Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Therapy Recording Sessions - "Anna", part 2/6
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Curious mind podcast and the second part of
- 0:03my first session with my client. Anna.
- 0:06If you haven't listened to the first part, please go to the
- 0:09description below where I left a link to it in the first part and
- 0:13it has described how the US doesn't feel like home anymore.
- 0:17She also has based on her experience from childhood on
- 0:21developed the habit of moving every few years.
- 0:24I encouraged honored to question this habit and to see if she
- 0:27still needs it, or if it's time to could come portable with
- 0:30staying longer in one place. When it comes to decisions like
- 0:35these, I point out that we shouldn't just hope for our gut
- 0:39feeling to tell us what to do. Instead, we also need to take
- 0:43cues from our environment. The people around us Korea, and
- 0:48our age as well, in order to make life decisions that are
- 0:50meaningful for us. We now, jump back into the
- 0:55conversation, we're on a describes, how uprooted she is
- 0:58from a life in the US and how this disconnect is met with
- 1:02incomprehension by her family of origin.
- 1:07They would say things like, why do you why aren't you smiling or
- 1:12in a good mood? Like you should should smile
- 1:14more. Don't be like, you know, like
- 1:17them and Central Europe, not smiling and smile much, right?
- 1:23No. And I heard this term recently
- 1:26called toxic positivity and I felt, yeah, I know.
- 1:32And I'm like, okay, because we always hear about, you know,
- 1:35toxic negativity but It's where it's just like, people are just
- 1:38so overtly positive that it just collapses on you and that's how
- 1:44America can be at times. Yeah, I I got defensive at this
- 1:54woman at the store when I was living there.
- 1:59I went to to the cashier and I was paying for my items and the
- 2:05woman she was so friendly. She said, oh, I like your jacket
- 2:09and I said what? Why?
- 2:11Like I got so defensive of this poor woman and then and then I
- 2:17realized like, oh yeah, she's just trying to be nice.
- 2:19Like that happens. There's customer service skills
- 2:23here. So I work, you know, but there
- 2:27are moments like that where I was just like what?
- 2:30And I felt like God, I'm not acting in the correct way.
- 2:36Yes. And just as a side note for
- 2:38might be some some people in the audience, who don't know, but in
- 2:42contrast to what we get from movies and series from the US,
- 2:47the normal experience in the public in the u.s. is that
- 2:50people are very, very friendly. Let me see that.
- 2:53And I'm from the Midwest. Yes, even when I was in New
- 2:59York, people said oh New York is super friendly most of them.
- 3:03Yeah. Yeah.
- 3:05Compared to here. It's like what It's no problem.
- 3:09This is weird. It's considered weird and of
- 3:11this America. Yeah.
- 3:12Way of just commenting on something love.
- 3:15Nice. Goal is nice.
- 3:16This is nice that you casual chitchat in a very friendly way
- 3:21and I don't and I don't behave like that here in public.
- 3:25Like when you like right now I'm out, of course, I'm being open
- 3:28with you smiling, whatever. But outside I catch myself not,
- 3:33I'm so much part of the yes, the environment.
- 3:38Yeah, I don't see. This is a normal process that we
- 3:40do, right? We would blend in with Tom.
- 3:44So let us get go a little bit back to what we had before.
- 3:49So, if I cannot rely on, you know, on a common sense because
- 3:55the common sense does not apply to me.
- 3:57I'm, I'm an immigrant living in another country.
- 4:00I have a different background, so then not many signs that tell
- 4:04me automatically how to behave. Which means I have to build my
- 4:08life and you write words in the past maybe in school maybe at
- 4:13University there would have been some markers that tell me which
- 4:17person to engage with with and which not, you know, so that
- 4:22it's kind of pre-prepared a little bit in which direction to
- 4:27go when I'm away when I'm outside, it's it's all up to me.
- 4:33I can connect with anyone with anyone I like I can I can have
- 4:38my life as much as I in the way that I like I can I can change
- 4:44jobs and so on. So this is one of the advantages
- 4:48but you know that I'm not in a family system or a kind of tried
- 4:53Unity where I would go in a more specific Direction.
- 4:57It's up to me so that is freedom but that is also of course
- 5:01complexity but that is I think the situation that you are in
- 5:07Which means when you think about who you are or who you want to
- 5:11be in the next year's and which person you want to develop in, I
- 5:17think that you're faced with kind of the obvious situation
- 5:23that you have to decide that more or less.
- 5:26Yeah, in the decision making progress while you go To sense
- 5:33the resonance within, if, this is, if this feels right, if it
- 5:36encourages you to move on in that direction or if you want to
- 5:40change. So, it's a lot of freedom that
- 5:43you are confronted with, if you could choose Just, you know, the
- 5:50way that you reflect nowadays. And which direction would you
- 5:54take your life if you forgot about, you know, the habits that
- 5:57you have acquired also, now abroad and you look at your next
- 6:0110 years and as a Clean Plate, like, how do I, how do I want to
- 6:13behave? You mean, or like my goals Row
- 6:18in terms of identity? Right.
- 6:19This is one of the questions that you had in the beginning
- 6:22terms. Of identity.
- 6:24Where would I like to settle as what kind of person would I like
- 6:27to settle? Where do I take my motherhood.
- 6:30My relationship my work and so on.
- 6:34Yeah. I think I think staying here
- 6:37being with my partner because we makes me very, very happy and
- 6:41just building a life with him because we'll have to like, I'll
- 6:45have to rebuild once again, you know, if we decide to take it
- 6:50further, which I think we want to then, I'll have to Adjust my
- 6:57identity again but it's for something positive.
- 7:00It's like okay we're going somewhere.
- 7:03Good but still scary. And I think if we stay like a
- 7:10team, like a little family, it doesn't really matter so much
- 7:12where we live? It'll be fine.
- 7:15That's what I'm hoping. Okay, I'll have that.
- 7:19Let's relate that to the other questions that you had.
- 7:22How should I deal with my by now a little bit?
- 7:25Estranged family and here to forget that there are scripts
- 7:29now they believe that there is a script and the normal script is
- 7:34the one that moves away is responsible for keeping up the
- 7:37connection. Yes, yes that is the script for
- 7:40the people who stay right? Mmm-hmm, this is not yours.
- 7:44Now, if you forget about that this is their perspective, how
- 7:47would you like to frame the connection between you and your
- 7:51family? And also, and maybe Is easier to
- 7:56reflect. How would you like the
- 7:58relationship of your son to your family in the US?
- 8:01Yeah, I want I want them to be more connected because they're,
- 8:07they're great people, you know, and my son loves them and I
- 8:14would like them to be involved more, I'd love.
- 8:16I would love for them to come and visit me, you know I've gone
- 8:21back many a times as a single mom traveling alone with a kid.
- 8:25Did to go see them but they've never done that for me and they
- 8:31always have some excuses but in the end it's like come on, you
- 8:34know I've been here for you in terms of health or fine.
- 8:39No. Restrictions that would keep
- 8:40maybe some Financial ones at times but then they have money
- 8:45for other things and you're like, well, you know, that could
- 8:49have I could have been a trip to here and yes.
- 8:53So I went I That they are scared to come here because they don't
- 8:58want to see that. It looks good.
- 9:02I think that they want to feel that they're right.
- 9:07I should never have left and where I'm living now.
- 9:12This is just, you know, temporary and it's, you know,
- 9:14not a perfect life for me. Yes.
- 9:19That is interesting because so when we come to the topic of how
- 9:23to deal with them, right, how to relate how to communicate and so
- 9:27on. So it brings up the question for
- 9:32me, how Frank, how open do you want to be in your communication
- 9:37with them? Because again we keep in mind
- 9:39that, you know, you're approaching your forties.
- 9:43It is you're not, you know, teenager you're not Amid 20,
- 9:50someone who is trying new things and then right back and so on,
- 9:56you know, that you have settled for different way of life.
- 10:00And then, for sure, you will not just move into years back to the
- 10:04US and then settled. So, you know, these things and
- 10:08biographically you are in the position with a new partner and
- 10:11a stability in life where you could represent that.
- 10:15I think much more actively than maybe you have done in the past.
- 10:20Is that you think that is possible with your family?
- 10:24I think so. I think it's going to be very
- 10:26hard though. They, we don't really talk about
- 10:29these types of things, emotional things.
- 10:34Like they, for example, my after I separated from my husband,
- 10:41which was crazy, you know, emotional roller coaster my We
- 10:49assumed that I would just naturally move back with them.
- 10:52And at that time, I wasn't prepared for that.
- 10:55And I said, I'm sorry, I'm going to stay.
- 10:58And my mom was so angry with me. She didn't talk to me for three
- 11:01months. No, you disappointed?
- 11:06Yeah, which is, of course, weird.
- 11:10Right. You do something.
- 11:12You make difficult decisions and then someone else, like, you
- 11:15didn't call, you didn't come You did.
- 11:18Yeah, our expectations. Yep, because I'm supposed to be
- 11:24the responsible one and, and do you know, I never went against
- 11:27my family. You know, for most of my
- 11:29childhood I was always at really, really like a pleasing
- 11:34kid, like whatever Mom and Dad said I did it.
- 11:37I never like I was never trouble for them.
- 11:40Yes. And and then when I became an
- 11:43adult and I start to have my own voice, I was just, I'm just like
- 11:48an anomaly, they don't get me. All right.
- 11:51So how does it make you feel that such important topics have
- 11:55not been discussed? You know the way that you change
- 11:59the decisions that you make that they should or have to accept
- 12:04who you are now and not dwell so much in the past of the image
- 12:08that they have of nice of a teenager you were.
- 12:11Yeah it's gosh. I wish I wish I could have this
- 12:16conversation with them. I really do.
- 12:19I don't know if I'm prepared for it.
- 12:20I don't know if They're prepared for it.
- 12:23Do they still make jokes? Like, oh, you were such a.
- 12:26You were so cute and then he stopped being cute at the age of
- 12:2921. Because that's the age I got
- 12:31married. Yeah, yeah.
- 12:34Like, well, in my mom cried on the day, I got married, she
- 12:38didn't, she doesn't know that. I know, but I saw her out the
- 12:40window and she was crying. And so I know like I was a
- 12:46disappointment, So that is it makes relatively clear.
- 12:55I think what the expectation and what their view of you is what
- 12:59would you like to know to do? Because it's for my
- 13:04sensibilities about, you know, what they think, or what you
- 13:08should do. And so on, what would you like
- 13:09to do? What would you like to say to
- 13:11them to them that, you know, that I want you to just feel
- 13:16happy for me to finally admit that, I'm I'm in a place that I
- 13:21feel good and I'm with a partner who makes me feel really good,
- 13:26and it's is a great person that I'm trying really hard.
- 13:30That I work hard Because sometimes I feel that they don't
- 13:36think that I do work hard another aspect of that because I
- 13:42do the work, the type of work that they're not familiar with
- 13:46so they don't understand what goes into that.
- 13:49Yes. And and to not compare me to my
- 13:54sister who's she's wonderful and I love her but she and I have
- 13:59different family situation. She's With kids house and she
- 14:04does work that they understand and they always compare the two
- 14:10of us. Yeah, so I would want them to
- 14:16know it. It hurts my feelings.
- 14:18Yes. What is interesting to me.
- 14:20Is that what you said right now it's It sounds like you would
- 14:26like this message to be received.
- 14:28It doesn't sound like, A kind of a discussion in the sense that
- 14:35would like to hear what they think about you.
- 14:37It sounds like I want you to know this.
- 14:40You how do you feel about just the idea of maybe sending them a
- 14:45letter or an email? Or I don't know how they, how
- 14:49they? Yeah, because that would be a
- 14:52statement. That would not be a pseudo
- 14:54conversation. That's Jazz.
- 14:58I want to talk to you. That's something that you could
- 15:00imagine what you have done. Does.
- 15:02Does it resume? I mean that.
- 15:04Yeah, that is something I think I could do in the future.
- 15:08Maybe not now. But yeah, I'll warm up to it.
- 15:11But yeah, I could do something like that.
- 15:14I mean, I, I generally try to be as open as I can with people and
- 15:19I don't want them to feel like I'm being dishonest or whatever.
- 15:24I'm trying to be very forthright, and I think that if
- 15:30they knew this stuff, Maybe our conversations would be easier,
- 15:34you know? Because every conversation we
- 15:38have a kind of imply that they'd like me to move back or
- 15:42something and I think that's why I kind of stopped on my end of
- 15:48reaching out to them like hey let's let's talk or like let's
- 15:51have a Skype. Date.
- 15:55But they also don't reach out to me and then I know and I know
- 16:00the next time I talk to them they'll say like you never send
- 16:04messages anymore. You never contact us and legal
- 16:09because you're responsible yours.
- 16:11Yeah, it's always on me and it's 50/50.
- 16:16I feel It is yes partly. But also they have to also yes
- 16:22put forth. Its they're angry that they have
- 16:24to do that. They're angry at me.
- 16:26I think. Yes.
- 16:27And this is something there is something important that they
- 16:31don't understand which is your perspective.
- 16:33And this is probably due to the lack of having that experience,
- 16:38right? Of being the one that moved away
- 16:41and then being confronted by people who stayed and ask them,
- 16:44hey, why don't you call, why don't you visit as if you
- 16:48Nothing else to do. And yeah, the only vacation that
- 16:51you have is to have in order to plan pleasantry trips to satisfy
- 16:57the family's expectations. So they probably have not made
- 17:01to this extent, the experience that you've made and maybe this
- 17:06is something they need to learn from you.
- 17:10Yeah. Now that is I would love to have
- 17:13a conversation with them. I would love to have a
- 17:15conversation with my brother. I haven't spoken to my brother.
- 17:18Either a year, maybe longer at least, we don't, we have no, I
- 17:23don't have a brother sister connection with him and there's
- 17:27no, again, we didn't have a falling out.
- 17:30He's an easygoing guy, we could completely have that but he just
- 17:36feels like, well, this is gone. So that's it.
- 17:38You know, we have so much modern technology and ways to
- 17:42communicate. Why is this a problem in my
- 17:45family? Other families.
- 17:47I see that they can do ooh, this they, you know, They can
- 17:50communicate and mind cannot yes. So I mean, we speak for now and
- 18:00very brief terms about of course there's a lot of complexity to
- 18:03that but what would I would like to convey is I think that you
- 18:10are in a position that many people have that many people are
- 18:14and which is in similar circumstances that we have not
- 18:18given ourselves the permission to grow up from the age that we
- 18:23were in when we for example left or when we dealt with family,
- 18:28which means that I think from the outside you have a position
- 18:34that is would be more adequate for a Ray, you know, someone
- 18:41that the 20s or and 28 or something like that.
- 18:47And in connection to what we spoke about before, right?
- 18:51That someone in your situation, someone who's an expert who
- 18:55builds their life abroad, right? You are constantly in a position
- 19:00of figuring out of overcoming, the alienation of a coming, the
- 19:05lack of integration in the country where you live in.
- 19:08So, So you are in constructing mode, right?
- 19:11Yeah. And this is what you do because
- 19:13you have to, but you don't apply this to the family.
- 19:21And I think because we're somewhat stuck in a time when we
- 19:26felt that there wasn't one more organic give-and-take between
- 19:31family members and this is just not happening anymore.
- 19:34So it's somewhat Frozen at a time that I'm or were it Frozen
- 19:43in, in a place that I'm not at anymore.
- 19:48Yeah. And the, of course, the risks,
- 19:52but in general, I think it's more healthy to think in terms
- 19:56of let me shape this. Just as I constructed the
- 20:00relationships with the friends and people around me here and
- 20:04the new partner that I found, let me take this approach.
- 20:08Also to my family, they have to see that.
- 20:11I'm a different person now and Let me create that relationship
- 20:14as a different person. Not the daughter that said
- 20:17goodbye and we'll come back as the same daughter that she was.
- 20:21Yeah, yeah. It's a good way to put that, you
- 20:25know, that I have to like be a more active with my who I am and
- 20:33my role in relation to my family to let them know.
- 20:35Like this is who I am now and for them to accept that what
- 20:42does for you and the way to take such a more active stand because
- 20:45I know it's not easy, it doesn't feel right.
- 20:47No. What what is, how would you put
- 20:49it? I don't know, like I feel like
- 20:54well first off I you know, I definitely need to go and visit
- 20:58them. It's been long enough.
- 21:00I need to take my son of course I'm waiting for this pandemic
- 21:05situation did but after that I would like to go back and just
- 21:12have these talks with them. I think that they need to hear
- 21:17that. I would love for them to meet my
- 21:19my partner so that they can see. And they can trust like, oh
- 21:23yeah, you are with a good person.
- 21:26Yes. Because again, I personally I'm
- 21:30a fan of sometimes writing messages, emails, or letters
- 21:35because I think that if in such a situation, you would open up
- 21:44in a form of a conversation and direct conversation.
- 21:48I think they're not prepared, they would not be prepared and
- 21:51they would not know what to say and then there would be this
- 21:55kind of awkward the defensive. Yeah.
- 21:58Okay let's have lunch something so yeah and possibly the
- 22:05advantage of a could be that they can sit with it with them
- 22:11or while and they have discussions about it at home.
- 22:16And they could reflect on it and integrate it and process it to a
- 22:21certain extent. And if ideally, you know, this
- 22:27letter is kind of worded in a kind way so that it's not
- 22:32doesn't have to make them defensive or so.
- 22:35I think that there's a chance that they win the conversation
- 22:38happens when the visit happens that they could be prepared
- 22:43emotionally. But also with words, you know,
- 22:46Because they have thought about it.
- 22:47In words they have communicated to each other your parents, for
- 22:51example, or your siblings with words.
- 22:54So there is a pathway to a communication know, it's a good
- 22:59idea, you know, it's fair to them as well.
- 23:02Gives them their gives them time and space to kind of understand
- 23:07by throwing their way. Yeah, I think you know that that
- 23:13would be a smart thing to do. To let them know.
- 23:18I don't know if I'm ready just yet to do it but yeah, I don't
- 23:21know. I get nervous with it.
- 23:23Yeah. Just because I like I said I am
- 23:26most of my life. It's always been like well don't
- 23:29challenge what Mom and Dad say whatever and is.
- 23:35Yeah, it's different now. Okay so we have with we've gone
- 23:40into this topic of. I mean we started from the topic
- 23:44of identity and where do I belong?
- 23:46And where do I stay? I mean some comments and you
- 23:50made some comments on that and then we came to the family
- 23:53family topic. That as far as I remember in our
- 23:57pre conversation, you mentioned that you have not thought about
- 24:01it deeply or you have not read kind of Just your position on
- 24:06this for longer time. Yeah.
- 24:09So how was it for you to have a conversation like that?
- 24:14Let's it's this is the first time I've ever done anything
- 24:18like this and it's It's good. I feel like some weight is
- 24:28lifted off but I'm still a bit like hesitant like nervous
- 24:33because I'm not used to it. Also I'm also not used to the
- 24:36focus being completely about myself, you know?
- 24:41Like if I was with a friend right now at some point that the
- 24:45conversation then with end up like little let's hear about
- 24:48your story and then yeah so this has been a Range experience.
- 24:55But in a good way, I should like feel comfortable talking about
- 25:01these things and that's part of my identity.
- 25:04It's who I am. So yes.
- 25:09Yeah. What I often say to clients.
- 25:11Especially in the beginning when they have not done any sort of
- 25:14consultation counseling therapy or anything is that?
- 25:17It's their time where they can give themselves permission to be
- 25:20selfish and just to think about themselves and yeah.
- 25:24I often make suggestions obviously just as in this
- 25:27conversation but it's just meant as a I'm throwing something out.
- 25:31There, it doesn't come from an authoritative position because
- 25:35frankly, I don't know you well enough, right.
- 25:37I know situations that resemble yours from my perspective.
- 25:42So this is where we kind of throw in something that from
- 25:46experience has worked for other people.
- 25:49So, this aspect changes with time, you know, when I get to
- 25:52know someone deeper than, Certainly my comments also more
- 25:56adjusted and the beginning is just what it is.
- 26:01You know, it's a way of getting to know each other for me to
- 26:05probe and to make suggestions and see how you react to that.
- 26:10But that is my impression as well that it's that you're not
- 26:18completely comfortable with this position of this attention.
- 26:24I feel like you want to be more dialogical.
- 26:29Last kind of self-revealing or self self kind of yeah.
- 26:34Expressing right. Exactly like I've I've never had
- 26:40therapy before. So I've always had to analyze
- 26:43things myself and you know Psychology videos or whatever.
- 26:49And then you know, creating this this narrative, but I, you know,
- 26:55to just to like let go and or even just to cry about
- 26:59something, it's really like I if I feel like I'm going to start
- 27:05opening up too much and you probably can't see it, but I'm
- 27:09like, I'm rubbing my fingers together and trying to, like not
- 27:13like, like, go too much, because I'm so used to keeping it.
- 27:17Get inside. Hmm, right?
- 27:19So this is a strange experience. Yeah there is no fine modulation
- 27:24of the knob. Like how much would evolve of
- 27:26how much to open it up? How does it work?
- 27:28The fine-tuning. Yeah, exactly.
- 27:31Yeah. So so this is a great way.
- 27:35Also with entrusted friends and maybe the partner, when you
- 27:39discover that there is a possibility that with practice,
- 27:43there is some sort of a skill, the skill of a healthy opening
- 27:48up that is not threatened, or don't feel that I lose control,
- 27:53or I put things in such an awkward way.
- 27:56That Eileen 8, those clothes people around me because that
- 28:02gives me just An additional layer of dealing in a trusted
- 28:09way with people around me, when I develop that skill, more and
- 28:13more, and there is an understanding of how much is
- 28:16adequate right now and that situation.
- 28:18Yeah, reading the signs asking if things are, okay?
- 28:21So for example, with, you know, partner or friend, Jessica is
- 28:26it, is it okay if I talk for 20 minutes and I just use you as a
- 28:31resonance board? Sounding board for our
- 28:35conversation and is it okay? If you only ask you, no
- 28:40questions to clarify but kind of keep back your position and then
- 28:45when I'm done, I would love to hear your your your position,
- 28:49and your understanding your interpretation.
- 28:51So, you know, it's kind of, it's a little bit of an artificial
- 28:55space, but it allows me to again, to develop a field in my
- 29:00immediate surrounding where I can't develop my own thoughts
- 29:06which is I think such a healthy thing to do and it's not so
- 29:11common because mostly we are in the mode of give-and-take.
- 29:16What do you think about this or this one?
- 29:17And then I immediately I withdraw again because it's game
- 29:21as it is played is you know, is the ball is on the other side
- 29:25and then they have to say something then I have to say
- 29:27something so that kind of I make those connections in my mind.
- 29:34That I think, oh, what the other person said made me realize
- 29:37something about myself, but it's not my time to speak, so I hold
- 29:41it back. So, yes.
- 29:43So this is just a general, kind of recommendation to open up
- 29:47those spaces. And to give myself permission to
- 29:50go in that direction outside of those, you know, highly highly
- 29:55artificial context as counseling or therapy sessions.
- 30:00Well, this would be it for today.
- 30:03I Thank you so much for opening up about your topic and your
- 30:10glimpses into your world. You just committed a little bit
- 30:17in those past sentences on how what your impression is.
- 30:21Can you can use sum it up for us and the audience, what the
- 30:25process was for you. It was it's like having like you
- 30:31said, like the spotlight is completely on you.
- 30:34So it's I feel bit more vulnerable but at the same time
- 30:39Comfort to know that like, well, you know, you're guiding me
- 30:44through it and that that helped because I am not used to these
- 30:50types of conversations and for such a long period of time and
- 30:57it was It's really refreshing to have something different like
- 31:02that to look at things in a different way, to not always
- 31:07keep everything hidden and surprise to kind of like, let it
- 31:10out. It's nice.
- 31:12I think more and more people should have those moments.
- 31:17Can you describe what is good about that?
- 31:19Why is it? It's a press is already a
- 31:20negative term, but why is it you just to let it out to speak
- 31:25about if you talk about Something that you have
- 31:30ownership over it. Right.
- 31:32But it's not scary anymore or I don't know some crazy monster,
- 31:38whatever. Like it's your accepting it and
- 31:41there's something really healthy about that.
- 31:44Yeah, I just think it's really good and I want to keep going
- 31:49further with exploring some of these issues about myself.
- 31:55Please join us for the next episode where continue to
- 31:58explore with an amp. The topics of isolation
- 32:01re-establishing a closer connection with your family
- 32:04self-identity and developing a new feeling of home within
- 32:08herself. Please join us for the next
- 31:57episode where continue to explore with an amp.
- 31:59The topics of isolation re-establishing a closer
- 32:02connection with your family self-identity and developing a
- 32:06new feeling of home within herself.