Latest / Automotive State of The Union / GMs Non-Auto CMO, Carvana Spooks Then Soars, Activity Avalanche
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Yo, what's up? Welcome to Wednesday. Got a little bit of a, uh, I don't know, a stock rollercoaster to talk about, a new G- a CMO at GM, and an activity avalanche. We're gonna tell you what that means.
- 0:12[singing] Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know- Mm. Who I is and who I be- Activity avalanche- They ask me what they see... is a good, good phrase. I- I'm gonna keep- Yeah. I'm gonna keep- A band name...
- 0:19run up on me, watch how far we be [laughs] It is a great band name. It's also what I'm gonna say to my wife every time she's like, "How was today?" [laughs] I'll be like- Right? [laughs]...
- 0:27"It was an activity avalanche." Activity... That's why I should get a sticker on my door that just says, "Activity avalanche in progress." [laughs] "Caution." [laughs] Right? We're gonna do that.
- 0:36Caution: activity avalanche in progress. That actually could be in a SoTo theme, actually, now that I think about it. Activity avalanche. That's- What do you guys do?
- 0:42See- We're, we're a professional activity avalanche creators... activity avalanche. [laughs] I don't know. I don't know, man. Ah, that's so good.
- 0:48Oh, man, you never know what you're gonna come up with in a little pod time, you know? Oh, we got a, we got a new In The Dirt podcast released- Oh, yes... today.
- 0:56Um, if you don't know, In The Dirt is a podcast that we created just so we can capture moments when we are on the ground, like at a dealership or, you know, kind of with a frontline person.
- 1:07Sometimes it's at an event, but usually now it's in a store. So, uh, you did this interview, Kyle, so why don't you talk about it? Yeah, no, this is, this was really cool.
- 1:14I kinda alluded to this a couple days ago, but, uh, we talked to a 22-year salesperson at the same store, or a 27-year salesperson and a 22-year customer at the store.
- 1:27And they were at the store h- like randomly buying another car when we were there. So it was just cool to kinda hear- Oh, like they've been doing business together for that long is what you're saying. Yes. Yes.
- 1:37That's amazing. So the, the salesperson has been at that store for 27 years. They've been doing business at that store for 22 years with the same person. That's the cool part, man.
- 1:46And they just happened to be in the showroom while we were there. Unscripted. Unscripted. So good. Oh, that's amazing. You can get that by, um, going to any podcast platform.
- 1:54Spotify, Apple Music probably the best places to get it. In The Dirt with a SoTo, and, uh, it'll be the last episode. Are we releasing that? Or probably it's gonna be a video and stuff for that, too.
- 2:04You'll see it on- Yeah... social media. Good show. Or if you're not following along, uh, LinkedIn is kind of where- No... the most conversation happens. So follow the SoTo page on LinkedIn and we'll do a thing.
- 2:12There you go. Do a thing. All right, let's get into some news. Let's do it. So, um- Come on... General Motors has hired, uh, Norm DeGreve, the ch- as the new CMO.
- 2:21He was the CMO of CVS, so a non-auto person coming in, um, a- effective July 31st. So he's, uh, ramping up to start here in just about a week and a half.
- 2:30DeGreve, known for transforming CVS into the country's largest consumer healthcare company. So if you remember back in the day, it was like, "We're no longer a drugstore. We are now a healthcare company."
- 2:42Um, and there's... He's setting out to spearhead GM's marketing as they, you know, continue into this new territory of EVs.
- 2:48Um, so he was at CVS since 2015, and he really had this purpose, uh, they call it purpose-related marketing, and this was his initiative.
- 2:56So he did things like, um, you know, stopping using altered images of females specifically in advertisements, say, "Hey, we're gonna be real life here," uh, to combat image insecurity.
- 3:07They had a, they had a program called Role Model. He also stopped doing business with any agency that worked with a big tobacco company, right? Good for Norm.
- 3:16'Cause like, how can we be a healthcare company if we're selling cigarettes, you know? Well, uh, uh, whoa, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. That's what they said. Doesn't CVS sell c- cigarettes now? Not anymore, no.
- 3:25They stopped. Really? Oh, yeah, like back then when they made this decision, it was a big, it was a big deal. I totally... I've only, I- like Walgreens is- They stopped selling all tobacco products.
- 3:34Yeah, like Walgreens is definitely more popular here, so I just don't get into a CVS. Yeah. Yep. Um, so- No, they changed their logo... man, that's wild. They all did it.
- 3:41Like CVS, Rite Aid, they changed their logo and were like, "Oh, we're, we're health proponents now." Yep. Um, I don't know, there's still a lot of candy bars in that aisle. Um, though- Lots...
- 3:49[laughs] though he lacks extensive auto experience, he did have prior experience with GM's digital marketing, uh, when he was employed with the big agency Digitas from 2001 to 2014.
- 3:58So business is a little different than it was back then, but awesome, man. You know, I'm, I'm excited for them, you know. And, and I have seen, like GM do some, some unique things with, uh, with marketing over the past.
- 4:10I, you know, I follow some of their, their marketing team on LinkedIn, and so they, they do push the boundaries a bit. Um, you know, and so, I... it's always tough for me, like watching c- someone come from, you know...
- 4:23It's, it's basically consumer packaged goods rebranded as like an, an over company. Um, you know, and then the healthcare side of stuff. It's, it'll be interesting to see how that translates into the brand of GM. Mm-hmm.
- 4:36Like whether we see kind of a renewed vision or refreshed, a, a refreshed look and feel. Um, because when, when you're going from like healthcare to trucks- Yeah... that's a big difference, you know?
- 4:48Uh, but- I hear you...
- 4:49you know, in- innovative, innovative thought, innovative voices, thinking about, uh, uh, this vertical with the context of other verticals I think is important, especially as when you think about like EVs and software and the way that, that GM is, is positioning itself for the next seven years.
- 5:07It's, it's probably a strong move. I think it could also come in, like when you think of them moving into the home charging space- Mm... and then also like the, the power storage and power generation, like in the home.
- 5:19I thi- Yep... I can see that as kind of like a, a similar vein, like, "Hey, we're reintroducing GM as an energy company."
- 5:25I mean, I know that's like kind of like a far stretch, but they're starting to dip their toe in the water.
- 5:29So there's, there's some relevance there, but hey, wish, wishing him the best of luck, and GM obviously the best of luck.
- 5:35Um, when you get fresh thinking into an organization, shakes things up and, uh, you know, Mary, Mary's paying attention. Yeah, I mean, and, and I think, you know, you look at like the, the, the company overall.
- 5:48You know, it really is telling a story of they're, they're a, they're an electric company- Yeah... more than- Trying... a vehicle company. And so if he's set to rebrand something like that, that win.
- 6:00So speaking of winning. Stop. Uh-oh. Segway timeSo I have, I have a little personal journey- Rollercoaster...
- 6:07I have a personal journey with this story, because I started building the show last night, which is an odd thing. [laughs] I usually only build it in the morning, but it was late.
- 6:15I'm like, "Oh, I'm gonna like start put a couple things in."
- 6:18And so Carvana's stock at the time, last night [laughs] Carvana's stock had dropped over 9% after the online retailer startled investors by moving its quarterly results release up by two weeks.
- 6:31They were like, "We're gonna announce this two weeks early," and everyone's like, "Whoa, whoa, whoa, what's going on?" Whoa. Yeah.
- 6:36People started selling, um, despite, you know, seeing a big rally this year, actually over like 700%. I mean, they were pretty low at the beginning of the year. Um- Right... you know, it just- $3 to $24- Yeah... is a...
- 6:46Yeah. I'll take that though. That's amazing. I'll take that. Yeah. Anyway. If you bought at $3, you, you love every bit of that 700%. I mean, yeah.
- 6:51Um, and then I wake up this morning and open everything back up, and shares are up 25% [laughs]
- 6:57in pre-market trading because they announced, um, the, the actual announcement is they signed an agreement to really, uh, restructure their debt and cut 1 point billion, $1.2 billion, um, in debt and increase their cashflow.
- 7:12Um, their interest expense went down by a lot, and basically, ev- they were like, "We're restructuring things." And then now it's up 25%. Wow. Actually 20... I don't know what it is now.
- 7:22Like as of like 20 minutes ago- It's moving. Right... it was 27%. [laughs] Um, um, they, they- It's, it's wild. Like,
- 7:29th- there is, it's so strange that Carvana continues to trade on the voice of what they, like, on what they say and less of what they do. Absolutely. Um- It's a voting machine...
- 7:42it, it's just a f- pure voting machine still, which is just wild, especially after what we saw with them in the second half of last year. Um, you know,
- 7:52I, I'm, I'm, like, I was counting them down and out last November, but like- Well, it was three bucks a share, and everyone was like, "It's bankrupt or they're gonna make it." I heard a lot of people- Yeah...
- 8:00saying, "They're gonna go bankrupt or they're gonna make it." Yep. And so restructuring debt is a big deal to stay out of bankruptcy, for sure.
- 8:08Um, they, they are, uh, they, um, changed their second quarter adjusted earnings to one- 155 million. Um, a difference, uh, th- you know, a, a difference- Major swing...
- 8:19from a loss of 216 million the same period last year. And, uh, so, and, and what's crazy about that is they still have a 23% reduction in overall revenue. They've been cutting- So they've restructured expenses...
- 8:31and slicing over there. Oh, yeah. Slashing, getting everything in line.
- 8:36Um, you know, one of the, o- one of the interesting things that was noted is, like, there are people saying, "Hey, look, are you, are you going away from some of the things that you've always done?"
- 8:47Like, it, like where, where, where is all of this changing? Um, because it's, like, it doesn't look like anything's changed from the outside, right?
- 8:56But there's obviously a massive restructuring re- restructuring to accomplish those goals internally, so. Two things. Um, number one, this highlights the power of a strong brand. Yep. Right?
- 9:07They're trading on brand and tra- like, very literally trading on the exchange on brand, on things like that.
- 9:13A lot of the large analysts say, you know, their price has completely disconnected from the fundamentals of how you would grade a stock. And so- It's like wow... like, trading on brand, man.
- 9:25They are trading on brand, and you know what? From a public perception standpoint, a lot of people don't pay attention to the stock market. They don't care.
- 9:31They just want a good experience buying a car and wanna feel good about doing it. So, um, Carvana's obviously keeping that, uh, keeping that dream alive and, uh, I don't know, maybe the story will be different tomorrow.
- 9:41[laughs] So how are we gonna segue to this? [laughs] I have no clue. Keeping the dream alive, maybe. Speaking of keeping the dream alive. Okay. Segway time. [upbeat music] Oh.
- 9:53[laughs] If you've been ke- trying to keep that dream alive of somehow staying at your house to work for eternity, uh, Workday may have your solution in there from a little bit of data that they have.
- 10:03So Workday is a cloud-based software firm, uh, that, uh, manages a lot of the world's larger, uh, enterprise-grade companies like HR and staffing and, and work tools.
- 10:14They've noticed a boost in collaboration overall when employees returned to the office part-time last year at some of these enterprise, uh, level companies.
- 10:24Basically, hallway chats, meetings replaced email communication, so there was a lot more interpersonal re- uh, interaction. Good.
- 10:31However, with a 17% rise in Team Connections, which I don't even know how you measure that with a- Uh, they have, they- Okay... uh, it said it in the article.
- 10:39Like, you can go in and check, click the link and read the article. They have metrics, so I don't know. Right. They got, they got metrics, so. [laughs] Uh, there was this downside.
- 10:47Basically, those connections created a 24% increase in meeting time, leading to a whole bunch of work pile up and extra stress for employees and- The pendulum swung... time away from the activity of what you're doing.
- 11:02And so, um, the, all of the ideas that came from the interpersonal interaction, the water cooler, the hallway moments, actually led to this, like, overabundance of necessary activity to accomplish the goals that the company was created.
- 11:15Um- So you mean it, it sounds like this: it's like, "Hey, we got together. Hey, you know what we should try? We should do this. That's a great idea. Let's set another meeting," right? They got meetings for meetings.
- 11:25[laughs] Meetings on meetings. They got a meeting about a meeting. I know how it goes. Yeah.
- 11:28Uh, the, the way a social scientist, Michael Arena, coined it, as we talked about at the beginning of the show, was an activity avalanche.
- 11:37Uh, basically a sudden surge of connecti- hyperconnectivity can negatively impact a company. Mm. What is this world, Paul? Activity- What is this world?... activity avalanche. You know, I, I've, I've experienced this.
- 11:51Yeah. When, when, when, in, I live in New York, and our, you know, at the time Asotu didn't exist. I only had Agency Congruent.
- 11:58Everything shut down, and we went into the Zoom world, which was like this-You know, it was kind of, shook us up 'cause we only came in, like, we never operated remotely.
- 12:06And then after we got the hang of it, we got very efficient. It was like, "Oh my gosh, this is great. We're getting so much done." Right.
- 12:11And then it switched, and then you just spent all day on Zoom meetings, and then you're not efficient. We came back to the office, and we got this boost of efficiency back, right?
- 12:20'Cause there's no longer, "I gotta set up a meeting." And then little by little, mission creep happens, and all of a sudden you're back in meetings all the time again.
- 12:27And it's, I think this is a constant struggle of any business that is doing a lot of stuff.
- 12:32Um, I know that, that, um, from having a little experience with VaynerMedia, like being in the halls, Gary Vaynerchuk freaks out whenever he sees more than three people in a room together.
- 12:40[laughs] He's like, w- like, and James Orsini, his COO, will say, "Oh, if you have more than three people in a room and Gary's around, you better guarantee he's gonna pop his head in, and you better be able to tell him why everybody's in that room."
- 12:51[laughs] Why everyone's in that room having a meeting. Yeah. Yeah. It's interesting, yeah. I mean, you know, like, they, I, I, I feel this, right?
- 12:58Because sometimes I'll get to the, my end of the day, I'm like, "Golly, I was just meetinged out." Mm-hmm. I was on Zoom calls or Google Meets or something like that all day. Mm-hmm.
- 13:06And I don't feel like I ever produced- Yeah... what was discussed in the meeting.
- 13:10And so, um, especially i- you know, this is, I think at dealerships, this probably happens less just because the activity is the consumer or the customer right in front of you, and so- It happens less in the front lines, I think.
- 13:23Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Right? Because the, the customer's there in your face. Yep. Exactly.
- 13:27But I, I think definitely the management level, the executive level, um, certainly can happen in, like, the marketing department, right? It's easy to get sucked into this, whether it's somebody- Yes...
- 13:38on your team or vendors like Shopify. Uh, I think we talked about this story, but it's coming back around again. Shopify said all recurring meetings are done. Like, done. Yeah. They just scratched all the meetings.
- 13:49And they actually built a tool or integrated a tool, I don't know what it actually is, but now when you book a meeting, it shows you what the labor cost of that meeting is.
- 13:58So you can see, like, oh, and what was the quote? They said something like, "No one would expense a $500 dinner, but a $500 meeting could pop up just like that," and- Just like that... and seeing that number.
- 14:09Can you imagine, like, w- what would happen if that meeting metric was, like, finance director- [laughs]... general manager- At Shopify? [laughs]... executive director, and controller all in a room? Oh.
- 14:19Oh, you know what? Everyone would be like, "Fire alarm. Get 'em out." Yeah. "Get 'em out." "We got 30 seconds, boys, girls." [laughs] Right.
- 14:25[laughs] We're actually, we have a, we have a close friend who works, uh, in Shopify. We're gonna ask him. We're gonna ask him. Yeah. But, um- How that, how that feels, yeah.
- 14:32You know, so this activity avalanche, uh, what, what is the gentleman that, that we quote in this article? Mike Arena. Um, he's a smart guy, I guess we'll just say that. [laughs] He's a smart guy.
- 14:42And basically he said, uh, the best leaders he's ever worked with assess their meetings in a, more than anything else.
- 14:48So they pay more attention to how the meetings are running, what they're talking about, how efficient they are. Um, and because that's the sweet spot for collaboration.
- 14:56They use the word collaboration, got our attention on this article. There you go. But hey- I, th- for me-... could, could you collaborate too much?... this is where, like- Can over-collaborate... we talk about this.
- 15:04Like, the, the minute you go past a 20-minute meeting, you're hanging out. You're just visiting. Right? And so- Dave Meltzer, right? [laughs] You're just visiting. There you go. Ah, it's so good. Exactly.
- 15:11Well, we're not gonna go past 20 minutes on this meeting, 15 minutes and 42 seconds- Oh... to be exact. Thanks for spending time.
- 15:17We hope it helps you make your day more efficient, think more strategically, and above all else, care for people just a little bit more. [upbeat music] Keep running. Keep running. Keep running. It means a lot.
- 15:31Keep running. Keep running. Keep running. It means a lot.