Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mechanic's Lien Fraud and How to Clear a Clouded Title
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Mechanics, Lean, Fraud, and How to Clear a Clouded
- 0:10Title. I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of Education
- 0:13and Professional Development at Beverly Hills
- 0:15Bar Association. And today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speaker, Pooja Nair. Pooja is a partner and
- 0:23chair of the Food, Beverage, and Hospitality
- 0:25Department at Irwin, Cohen, and Jessup. She serves
- 0:29as a business litigator handling high stakes
- 0:31disputes, internal investigations, and complex
- 0:34legal challenges for the middle market companies
- 0:37across the consumer products, real estate, and
- 0:40consumer packaged goods industries. A recognized
- 0:43thought leader, she has been published in Law
- 0:45360, Eater, and Bloomberg BNA, quoted by the
- 0:49New York Times and Reuters, just to name a few,
- 0:52and named a Litigator and Trial Attorney of Influence
- 0:55by the Los Angeles Business Journal. Beyond the
- 0:58legal practice, Pooja is an active community
- 1:01leader and history enthusiast who has appeared
- 1:03as a legal historian on the Travel Channel's
- 1:06Lost Secrets. We're so excited to hear what she
- 1:09has to share with us today, so I'm now going
- 1:10to turn it over to her. Thanks for the kind introduction
- 1:13and thanks to BHBA for having me. I'm going to
- 1:17share my screen now. So today I'm talking about
- 1:20clearing a clouded title. And what prompted this
- 1:23presentation was a couple of articles that I
- 1:25wrote for the Beverly Hills Courier about this
- 1:28widespread mechanics lien fraud that had rocked
- 1:34kind of the Benedict Canyon area of the west
- 1:36side. So think about this situation. About three
- 1:40years ago, someone filed paperwork for a $98
- 1:45million mechanics lien with the LA County recorder's
- 1:49office. This person had no contractor's license,
- 1:54no contract with the property owners, and no
- 1:57connection to the property. The clerk recorded
- 2:00that $98 million mechanics lien anyway because
- 2:03the form was in order. And that happened with
- 2:06the same individual on her LLC. 35 times. By
- 2:12the time that enough people were aware of this
- 2:15and anything was done to stop it, she had already
- 2:19clouded title to more than half a billion dollars
- 2:22of real estate on the west side, primarily in
- 2:24Benedict Canyon. So today I want to go through
- 2:29essentially three questions. How does a fraudulent
- 2:32mechanics lien get on title? And if you're from
- 2:36the perspective of a property owner or the attorney
- 2:39for the property owner, how do you get it off?
- 2:41And how does that process work? And how are you
- 2:44able to catch this before it costs your client
- 2:47a sale or refinance? So as part of this presentation,
- 2:51I'm going to talk about these recent incidences
- 2:53of fraud. I'm going to discuss the nuts and bolts
- 2:57a little bit of the mechanics in process because
- 2:59I think you have to understand that to know what
- 3:02the property owners options are. And then I'll
- 3:05talk about a little bit about deed fraud, which
- 3:08is also on the rise. And the Q &A is available
- 3:14here. And I will try to get to questions. But
- 3:16I also have quite a bit to cover. So if I don't
- 3:18get to your question now, I'm happy to kind of
- 3:20reach out over email and follow up later. Alright,
- 3:24so let's talk specifically a little bit more
- 3:27about this Benedict Canyon mechanics liens fraud.
- 3:31So this started in 2023. So this woman whose
- 3:35name was Rita Ortiz, she had a company called
- 3:39Ortiz Consulting LLC. Starting in 2023, she recorded
- 3:44liens against homes in Beverly Hills, Los Angeles
- 3:48and in Riverside County. The face value of those
- 3:51liens exceeded $500 million cumulatively, and
- 3:55each lien ranged from $800 ,000 to $98 million.
- 4:00There's just one small stretch of Benedict Canyon
- 4:03that in that stretch, there was about $320 million
- 4:07of liens across 10 different properties. So in
- 4:11a lot of these circumstances, the owners were
- 4:15older homeowners, many of whom had their homes
- 4:19already paid off. So there was no kind of mortgage
- 4:23company looking over the current status or the
- 4:27title of the property. So in some circumstances,
- 4:30within this three -year period, they didn't realize
- 4:32right away that a mechanics lien had even been
- 4:35put on the property. And so the mechanics liens
- 4:43forms essentially that were submitted stated
- 4:46that the services were for cleaning and consulting.
- 4:49And the property owners stated that they had
- 4:52never met this woman, let alone hired her to
- 4:54do anything for their property. So the scheme
- 4:59ran for about three years and three years into
- 5:01it in February, 2026. LAPD's real estate fraud
- 5:08unit arrested Ms. Ortiz. On March 3rd, the DA's
- 5:14office charged her with 25 felony counts of knowingly
- 5:20causing a false instrument to be recorded. And
- 5:25that holds like, they've just... indicted her
- 5:35in March of 2026, so the case is still ongoing,
- 5:37but if she were to be convicted as charged, that
- 5:40would be about a 24 -year prison sentence. Interestingly,
- 5:46even though this person has been indicted, the
- 5:52mechanics liens are still on the property. There's
- 5:56one homeowner who had about a hundred million
- 5:58dollars in liens who was able to get that removed,
- 6:01but she had to file a court action to do that.
- 6:03The DA's office has said that once they get a
- 6:06conviction, they'll seek an order to clear title,
- 6:10but given the nature of the court system. Alright,
- 6:14and separate from this, another recent example
- 6:16that's come up because of the Palisades and Eaton
- 6:18fires is that people that have lost their homes
- 6:23to wildfires or even had damage to wildfires
- 6:26are extremely vulnerable to mechanics and fraud.
- 6:33So in general, the American Institute of CPAs
- 6:37said that more than one third of people impacted
- 6:40by a disaster experienced some kind of fraud.
- 6:43And about 15 % of that circumstances that can
- 6:45be contractor fraud. An example that came up
- 6:51of this was in restoration services. People would
- 6:56come to the homeowners and tell them that they
- 7:01wanted to provide cleaning and restoration post
- 7:04wildfire, and that this would all be covered
- 7:06by insurance. They would proceed to start doing
- 7:10work, sometimes causing damage to the house.
- 7:18They would then charged the homeowner and this
- 7:22was not approved by insurance but when the homeowner
- 7:25refused to pay they would put a mechanic's lien
- 7:27on the property. And then the company that provided
- 7:35the restoration services then filed a mechanics
- 7:38lien and filed an action to foreclose on the
- 7:43mechanics lien. So this is ongoing. There's several
- 7:47of these cases in Ventura County back from the
- 7:50Camarillo fires and now in Los Angeles County
- 7:53from the Eden and Palisades fires in which there
- 7:56are fraudulent mechanics liens tied somehow to
- 8:00wildfire restoration, and this puts pressure
- 8:03on homeowners who may not be able to handle one
- 8:07other legal issue and be on top of kind of all
- 8:10the specific processes. So the reporting system,
- 8:14meaning the system in which the LA County or
- 8:17any county recorder's office looks at a mechanic's
- 8:20lien, is pretty vulnerable to fraud and abuse.
- 8:24That's because as in California, The clerk really
- 8:28checks mostly formatting, signatures, and that
- 8:32the form has the required statutory language
- 8:35and notary signature. The clerk doesn't check.
- 8:40There's no process in place when you're recording
- 8:43a mechanics lien to check that an actual contract
- 8:46exists between the purported contractor and the
- 8:49homeowner, that work was actually performed.
- 8:52that the claimant is actually licensed, that
- 8:55the amount makes sense, and for deed fraud that
- 8:59the person signing a grant deed is the actual
- 9:00owner. So none of that stuff is part of the process,
- 9:04which can be extremely frustrating for property
- 9:07owners. And there's no, it doesn't matter whether
- 9:11the lien is for $50 ,000 or $90 million, the
- 9:15clerk kind of goes through the same process and
- 9:19doesn't confirm It doesn't confirm whether this
- 9:23information is true or not. I want to talk a
- 9:27little bit about the history of mechanics liens
- 9:32in general. So California is the only state with
- 9:37a mechanics lien provision enshrined in the state
- 9:40constitution that was added to the California
- 9:43constitution in 1879. The first mechanics liens
- 9:48on the book in California date back to 1850,
- 9:52which was the very first legislative session
- 9:55in California. And the mechanics lien statute
- 9:59has been amended more than 70 times, and there's
- 10:03150 different bills passed in the California
- 10:06legislature that somehow deal with mechanics
- 10:08lien. It's been a big part of California law.
- 10:13And what was the purpose of mechanics liens,
- 10:16particularly in 1850? So the idea behind them
- 10:20is that a person who provides labor and materials
- 10:26to improve private property, right, to do a private
- 10:29improvement, they're contributing to the value
- 10:33of the property and the work that they do should
- 10:37be secured. by an interest in the real estate
- 10:40that they're improving. That's kind of the legislative
- 10:43purpose of it. But over time, that constitutional
- 10:50and statutory framework has essentially changed
- 10:54as the kind of things that contractors do and
- 10:56the way that these agreements work has changed
- 10:59as well. So I want to talk through essentially
- 11:04the basics of what a mechanics lien, how a mechanics
- 11:12lien works. So this is kind of separate from
- 11:15the issue of fraud, but I think to understand
- 11:18what a property owner could do to clear a clouded
- 11:24title, it's important to understand what the
- 11:28civil code requires from mechanics liens because
- 11:32one of the most important things that you can
- 11:35be aware of as an attorney representing a property
- 11:38owner or you know on the flip side an attorney
- 11:41representing a contract owner is that these these
- 11:46kind of technical requirements under the statute
- 11:48are strict and if if the contractor hasn't contractor
- 11:53or subcontractor hasn't properly met the requirements
- 11:57that that they need to meet then the property
- 12:01owner has a good ability to ultimately get the
- 12:08lien removed. And on the other side, if all of
- 12:12the requirements are met, then it's going to
- 12:14be kind of a drawn out fight to deal with the
- 12:19lien. And a lot of times it may make sense for
- 12:22the property owner and contractor to discuss
- 12:26this and come to a settlement. In most cases,
- 12:32what I deal with in my practice with real estate
- 12:36law is not so much these fraudulent loans where
- 12:41you have no idea who the contractor is. It's
- 12:46much more an issue of the homeowner and contractor
- 12:50disagreeing about the value of the work. Just
- 12:53give me one second. I'm just going to get some
- 12:54water. Sorry about that. The more common scenario
- 13:10is you have the property owner, you have the
- 13:13contractor, some point in the beginning of the
- 13:15work they were on the same page, they signed
- 13:16the contract, and then they disagree. The owner
- 13:20may think the contractor didn't do a good job,
- 13:22there were delays, the scope of work exceeded,
- 13:26they didn't like the change orders. So that is
- 13:28the most common type of issue with mechanics
- 13:31liens. But whether you're dealing with that kind
- 13:36of issue or dealing with an issue in which there's
- 13:40a complete fraud that clouds title, the statutory
- 13:43steps are the same. So I think it's very important
- 13:45to understand that because that gives both the
- 13:49contractor and the owner have to be aware of
- 13:54what the civil code requires. So first, a claimant
- 14:01who doesn't have a direct contract with the owner.
- 14:05That means that any subcontractor who did work
- 14:09on the property needs to serve what's called
- 14:11a 20 -day preliminary notice. The direct contractor,
- 14:15so the general contractor, does not need to serve
- 14:17a preliminary notice and someone who performs
- 14:20labor doesn't need to serve a preliminary notice.
- 14:27There's a recording deadline. This is very strict
- 14:30So the recording deadline has to be the deadline
- 14:34in which the contractor can record a mechanics
- 14:38lien is within 90 days of a product of general
- 14:43contractor direct contractor completing the contract
- 14:46or 60 days after the owner records a notice of
- 14:53completion or cessation the subcontractor or
- 14:57supplier records after it stops working on the
- 15:01project and before the earlier of either 90 days
- 15:04after completion or 30 days after the owner records
- 15:08a notice of completion. And this is very important.
- 15:12There's a foreclosure deadline, meaning that
- 15:15once a contractor files a mechanics lien, it
- 15:19must sue within 90 days of recording mechanics
- 15:23lien. If they fail to file If they fail to file
- 15:29an action to foreclose on the mechanics lien,
- 15:32that's untimely and the lien is invalid. But
- 15:39an invalid lien will still show up on the property.
- 15:46And so that can still cloud title, it can still
- 15:48be an issue for the sale. But if that lien is
- 15:50challenged and you don't have a court action
- 15:54to foreclose on the lien, within 90 days of recording,
- 15:58it's going to be found to be invalid. So in that
- 16:01circumstance, it often makes sense for the owner
- 16:08to take further action to ensure that, whether
- 16:12it's filing an action for a debt relief, but
- 16:15to somehow make clear that that that that lien
- 16:21has expired because the contractor failed to
- 16:24file within the 90 days. So that is the most
- 16:27critical deadline to be aware of. So the lien
- 16:31becomes unenforceable, but while it could still
- 16:34be sitting on title. So in those circumstances,
- 16:38you can submit a letter demanding the contractor
- 16:43remove the lien voluntarily, because if you,
- 16:47as the owner or the owner's counsel, have to
- 16:50go to court to get the lien removed, you would
- 16:54be entitled to your attorney's fees. So the statute
- 16:59throughout for each of these steps, the civil
- 17:01code demands strict compliance. And so every
- 17:06missed step or missed deadline is something that
- 17:09could be armored or something that could be weaponized
- 17:12by the property owner and something that could
- 17:14be is something that the contractor needs to
- 17:16be very aware of. This whole concept of recording
- 17:22a notice of completion. within 15 days of the
- 17:26project being finished or a notice of cessation
- 17:29is really important also to be aware of if the
- 17:32property owner is going through that process
- 17:34and suspects that there may be mechanics liens,
- 17:37that limits the amount of time that a contractor
- 17:39may have to go forward and cuts the recording
- 17:44window essentially from 90 days to 30 days in
- 17:46most circumstances. looking kind of through each
- 17:59of these steps as a checklist. If you have a
- 18:02client that has a mechanics lien or a threatened
- 18:05mechanics lien is pretty important. And on the
- 18:09preliminary notice, that's only for subcontractors,
- 18:13but it's a non -wavable condition. And so if
- 18:16a subcontractor records a lien, but they never
- 18:19provided the property owner with preliminary
- 18:22notice, they're not then able to go ahead and
- 18:29file a lien. So that is something that's important
- 18:33for you to be aware of. you know, in a lot of
- 18:38circumstances, this preliminary notice may get
- 18:41missed. What I've found now is that, especially
- 18:45with AI, there's more mechanics leans recorded
- 18:50than there used to be. And I think people are
- 18:56aware that it's essentially an easy thing to
- 19:00record, that there's significant leverage because
- 19:02the consequence to the owner of having a lien
- 19:07on their property is significant, right, especially
- 19:10if an owner is trying to sell or refinance. And
- 19:13so there's not, there's a perception that there's
- 19:17not much downside from the point of view of the
- 19:21contractor to go ahead and record or at the very
- 19:24least threaten the mechanics lien, but As people
- 19:27are using these tools more and more, what I'm
- 19:29finding is that the preliminary notice for subcontractors
- 19:33can often be missed, and it's an important tool
- 19:35to be aware of. And for the preliminary notice,
- 19:40it only reaches back 20 days. So the timing is
- 19:45also something to be well aware of in terms of
- 19:47what work was done within the 20 -day notice
- 19:51period. So running through a checklist of was
- 19:55preliminary notice required, and if so, was it
- 19:58served? Was the lien recorded within the statutory
- 20:01window? And that'll be either from civil code
- 20:04section 8412 or 8414. And then the lien also
- 20:10requires that the owner be that there be a completed
- 20:13proof of service under 8416. And then was the
- 20:18amount actually the contract price or a reasonable
- 20:22value that the amount of the mechanics lien is
- 20:26bound by section 8430. And then was the work
- 20:31actually authorized? This can be a major issue,
- 20:33I'll talk about that a little bit more. And then
- 20:35was the action to foreclose on the mechanics
- 20:38lien filed within 90 days? So And also to just
- 20:45keep in mind, if you have the same contractor
- 20:47working on multiple properties, they can record
- 20:51a blanket lien. For example, if they're working
- 20:53on a development, which has a few different addresses,
- 20:56they can record one blanket lien, but they have
- 20:59to allocate the amount of work that was completed
- 21:01for each property. Each separate residential
- 21:04unit would require its own lien. and would also
- 21:09require their own contract with the property.
- 21:21So when does a clock start running after a lien
- 21:25is recorded? So between days 1 and 90, the claimant
- 21:32can sue to foreclose on the mechanics lien, and
- 21:35the owner's options at that point are either
- 21:37to demand a voluntary release from the contractor
- 21:39or to get a release bond, which I'll talk about
- 21:44a little bit more later. After 90 days, if 90
- 21:48days have passed and the contractor hasn't filed
- 21:53a foreclosure action, the owner then has the
- 21:59ability to file a petition to release the mechanics
- 22:02lien in court, and they can recover their attorney's
- 22:06fees if they prevail. The date of the recording
- 22:10controls what remedy applies. So one thing to
- 22:15keep in mind, I get this question a lot from
- 22:17my clients about mechanics liens, right? Because
- 22:20they, particularly if there's a dispute, between
- 22:27the owner and the contractor about whether the
- 22:30work was done properly, whether it exceeded the
- 22:32scope of what was authorized, and, you know,
- 22:36whether the contractor is actually bringing this
- 22:40mechanics lien in good faith. A lot of times
- 22:42the property owner wants to punish the contractor
- 22:47for bringing the mechanics lien in the first
- 22:48place. They may say that, you know, this is causing
- 22:52me a lot of harm, it could be causing emotional
- 22:54distress. It's like the fact of having a lien
- 22:58adds a lot of stress and also makes the property,
- 23:01it ties up the property, right? And so there
- 23:04can be a lot of desire to do something within
- 23:10the law to try to penalize the contractor for
- 23:14filing the mechanics lien. But under the recent
- 23:20authority and the antislapped statute essentially,
- 23:23there's clear California appellate authority
- 23:26that the litigation privilege applies to the
- 23:30filing of a mechanics lien. That's the RGC gas
- 23:33lamp case that came out in 2020 and the takeaway
- 23:37of that case is that the filing of a mechanics
- 23:40lien constitutes protected activity for purposes
- 23:44of the litigation privilege and the anti -SLAPP
- 23:46statute, even if the lien was invalid or otherwise
- 23:50improper. So in this case, this RGC gas lamp
- 23:57case, the subcontractor recorded a mechanics
- 24:01lien on a San Diego hotel construction project
- 24:05for sheet metal work. The owner then obtained
- 24:09a lien release bond and then After the owner
- 24:13bonded the lien, the subcontractor then recorded
- 24:17three more identical liens. So the owner sued
- 24:23for quiet title, slander of title, and deck relief
- 24:28and injunctive relief. The subcontractor moved
- 24:31to strike under the anti -slap statute, arguing
- 24:36that recording the liens was protected litigation
- 24:41activity and the trial court granted this anti
- 24:44-slap motion and the court of appeal affirmed.
- 24:47So in that and in discussing the outcome of that
- 24:51case and coming up with the holding the court
- 24:53specifically talked about how the evidence in
- 24:56this particular case supported the owner's theory
- 25:00that the the subcontractor was improperly filing
- 25:05or recording invalid liens for kind of an improper
- 25:09purpose, but said that didn't matter. It was
- 25:11still protected by the litigation privilege.
- 25:15So that's an important case to be aware of because
- 25:19the owner's options are somewhat limited in terms
- 25:25of trying to use slander of title as a basis
- 25:30to sue for the act of recording mechanics lien.
- 25:35So I want to talk about a few options that owners
- 25:41have immediately after a mechanics lien has been
- 25:45recorded against the property. So the release
- 25:48bond is within the statute, and that is the fastest
- 25:53remedy. So you essentially bond the lien at 125
- 25:57% premium. and it is the fastest way to get the
- 26:03to get the lien off an owner's property. But
- 26:06there is a premium and the collateral requirement
- 26:09and that can put it out of reach. So essentially
- 26:12the contractor is able to set the price of the
- 26:14bond because they choose the number on the lien.
- 26:17So in in some cases it makes sense. we've had
- 26:22cases in which, you know, when you have a legitimate
- 26:26dispute with a contractor and the lien is set
- 26:30at the amount that you originally contracted
- 26:32for, it can make sense to get the bond, especially
- 26:35if the owner has plans to try to sell a refinance.
- 26:38So that can be the quickest way to do this. And
- 26:44that's under civil code 8424. So the Anyone,
- 26:51either the owner or anyone with an interest in
- 26:53the property, including a construction lender
- 26:56or an affected direct contractor, can record
- 27:01a lien release bond and the bond will replace
- 27:04the property as security. The bond has to come
- 27:08from an admitted surety insurer and the bond
- 27:13has to equal 125 % of the lien amount. And the
- 27:18bond can be recorded even after a foreclosure
- 27:22suit has been filed so even if you're in if it's
- 27:25been over 90 days and the contractor has filed
- 27:29a lawsuit to foreclose on the lien, the owner
- 27:34would still have the option of going to one of
- 27:39the admitted sureties and getting a bond. After
- 27:43the owner records the bond, the owner has to
- 27:49notify the claimant and include a copy of the
- 27:51bond. And from that point on, the contractor's
- 27:55remedies are limited to the surety and bond instead
- 28:00of the property itself. So the bond is kind of
- 28:05the fastest remedy and if the amount makes sense,
- 28:08it obviously doesn't make sense if we're talking
- 28:10about pure fraud, but if there's a legitimate
- 28:12dispute about the amount that's owed but it's
- 28:17kind of within reason, sometimes the bond will
- 28:20make sense rather than using other remedies.
- 28:26The big issue is a lot of times where the dispute
- 28:31is about inflated amounts on the lien and whether
- 28:36those amounts were authorized. And sometimes
- 28:39if the contractor puts in a significantly inflated
- 28:43amount, then it doesn't make sense for the owner
- 28:47to pay 125 % premium. for the release bond. So
- 28:54it's really about kind of the amount. So a scenario
- 28:58that came up recently for one of our clients
- 29:01is with a... trust dispute we had, there was
- 29:07a mechanics lien of about $200 ,000. And at that
- 29:12point, the property was in escrow, the property
- 29:15was worth about $7 million. And so in that circumstance,
- 29:21the title company declined to bond it, but the
- 29:25client went to an admitted surety and got a bond
- 29:30at 125 % of the lien. So in that circumstance,
- 29:34because of the potential sale of $7 million,
- 29:37getting a bond of $250 ,000 even with the 125
- 29:40% premium made sense for Escrow to close on schedule.
- 29:45So that works. If the amount is proportionate,
- 29:48it's important to know who the admitted charities
- 29:50are and to be able to kind of consider what the
- 29:53cost of that will be to the client over time,
- 29:55but it is something that may make sense and is
- 29:58within the statute. So within the 90 -day window,
- 30:08what a property owner can do if there is a mechanics
- 30:14lien recorded against their property is first
- 30:17send a demand that the claimant either recorder
- 30:23release if there's something deficient about
- 30:29the mechanics lien or actually bring the suit
- 30:32to foreclose and then advise the claimant in
- 30:36writing that if they don't actually file that
- 30:39the owner would be entitled to an attorney's
- 30:43fees award and to file the petition after 90
- 30:46days. If there's a pending transaction, Sometimes
- 30:51the thing that really will make the most sense
- 30:53is to get the release bond because, of course,
- 30:56even though mechanics liens move faster than
- 30:59other types of civil cases, it can still be a
- 31:03delay that would impact a potential sale or refinancing.
- 31:10So what can an owner do after the 90 days? This
- 31:17is, I put a lot of civil code sections here kind
- 31:22of for reference and you have this in the material
- 31:24so I'm not going to go through the entire, you
- 31:27know, I'm not going to go through each of these
- 31:29in super detail but it's really important to
- 31:32just note that the mechanics lean statute is
- 31:35super technical and so it's important to be aware
- 31:41of all of the statutory requirements both for
- 31:47the contractor and the owner. So after 90 days
- 31:51has passed, so like on day 91, the owner can
- 31:54petition the court for an order to release the
- 31:57property from the lien on the grounds that the
- 32:00claimant has failed to file a foreclosure action.
- 32:04So 10 days before filing that petition, the owner
- 32:08has to provide notice. So if you wanted to do
- 32:13it immediately after the 90 days has passed and
- 32:18file on day 91, you would need to provide notice
- 32:22to the contractor. on day 81 that a formal notice
- 32:27requiring demanding that they execute and report
- 32:29a release. That's really important because if
- 32:32they fail to foreclose and you have to file a
- 32:37petition, you want to get prevailing party attorney's
- 32:40fees under the statute and you won't get those
- 32:43fees if you don't provide the required notice.
- 32:47The petition that you file in court has to be
- 32:53verified and there's some technical requirements
- 32:55laid out by 8484. And then the hearing will be
- 33:00set quickly. It will be set within 30 days after
- 33:04the petition is filed and you have to serve the
- 33:08petition at least 15 days before the hearing.
- 33:10And the burden of proof, once you file that petition,
- 33:15The burden of proof goes to the contractor. It's
- 33:18not on the property owner. And if the property
- 33:22owner and petitioner prevails, the court orders
- 33:26the property released from the lien and the prevailing
- 33:29party gets attorney's views back. And if the
- 33:34claimant has other causes of action, which are
- 33:36most commonly breach of contract. The release
- 33:39order as to the lien doesn't bar other causes
- 33:43of action, so the contractor would be able to
- 33:46bring a breach of contract claim within the statutory
- 33:49deadline. The fact that the owner prevails on
- 33:53the petition and gets their fees back doesn't
- 33:58have any bearing on potentially other causes
- 34:01of action. So one thing that's come up is in
- 34:09these circumstances that we talked about earlier,
- 34:11right, with retail or tease and the the wildfire
- 34:15victims that have purely fraudulent mechanics
- 34:20liens. This doesn't come up too often in my practice,
- 34:23but I think it has been more and more common.
- 34:26And so one thing that you can one option is to
- 34:31report to LAPD's commercial crimes division.
- 34:34the real estate fraud unit and to the DA's office
- 34:37as well. Penal code 115, which is what the Ortiz
- 34:46Consulting and Rita Ortiz were charged under,
- 34:50makes it a crime to knowingly procure or offer
- 34:53a false or forged instrument for recording. And
- 34:56each different instrument that's fraudulent and
- 35:00that's recorded is a separate offense. After
- 35:04the defendant has been convicted, the court can
- 35:08declare the false instrument to be void. This
- 35:10would require the prosecutor to notify interested
- 35:14parties and then the prosecutor's office can
- 35:16record a list penance. So in practice, I will
- 35:22say that the LAPD's real estate fraud unit has
- 35:27been more I'd say in recent years has been more
- 35:32attuned to this because there are a lot more
- 35:34instances of fraud and particularly they're aware
- 35:38that victims of natural disasters can be susceptible
- 35:43to this. So I think it is worth the owner doing,
- 35:49but it's very selective in terms of what they'll
- 35:54prosecute, especially if it's a single owner.
- 35:57Dealing with dealing with the lien. So I think
- 36:01it's important to use this. It's very important
- 36:03for if it's if there's a pure fraudulent lien.
- 36:08On a property, it's very important to file a
- 36:10police report and to try to escalate this to
- 36:13the LAPD and to the to the DA's office. But there's
- 36:18no guarantee that they'll take this action. And
- 36:24the because the prosecutor's office won't. Do
- 36:30anything in terms of getting the instrument voided
- 36:34until after they. Until after the. conviction,
- 36:39it means that you're basically slowed to the
- 36:42property owner is not going to be the priority
- 36:45until after the conviction is obtained. So that's
- 36:47why in the Rito or Teeth case, one homeowner
- 36:50that had $100 million of liens recorded against
- 36:53the property took action on their own because
- 36:56they didn't want to wait for the legal process
- 36:58and the conviction to take place. I wanted to
- 37:03also touch on deed fraud here. So The Alta, which
- 37:11is the title association, recently issued a report
- 37:17on deed fraud and the 59 % of title firms reported
- 37:23a seller impersonation attempt in 2025, which
- 37:26was up from 28 % in 2023. 87 % encountered spoof
- 37:32contact information. 58 % encountered manipulated
- 37:37voice or image technology. So in deed fraud takes
- 37:44place when the fraudster essentially impersonates
- 37:50the owner of the property and then signs a deed
- 37:53to a buyer entity that they control, records
- 37:57the deed, and then either sells the property
- 37:59or more commonly borrows against the property.
- 38:03This happens most frequently when no one is washing
- 38:07the title. So the common targets where this happens
- 38:11is if you have either vacant land or land that's
- 38:15owned for purposes of like a vacation home or
- 38:18rental property and very commonly now for older
- 38:22homeowners with where they've paid off the mortgage
- 38:26or properties where the owner has passed away.
- 38:30So if no one is watching what's kind of happening
- 38:36then someone records, you know, they record a
- 38:41fraudulent deed and then they either sell the
- 38:44property or they borrow a lot of money against
- 38:47the property using the property as collateral.
- 38:50If no one's kind of seeing what's happening,
- 38:53you don't automatically get a notification. And
- 38:56so it can take a long period of time before you
- 38:59become aware that this has happened. And then
- 39:00by that time, particularly if they're borrowing
- 39:04money against the property, they've already taken
- 39:07out the money. So there's a debt owed and the
- 39:10security of the debt is the property itself.
- 39:13But the real legitimate property owner has no
- 39:17idea. For clients that where this has come up
- 39:21in my practice, we've had it come up where the
- 39:26property owner doesn't live in the same county
- 39:27or just doesn't see the property all the time,
- 39:30and they own the property outright, so there's
- 39:32no bank kind of watching it. And so this is a
- 39:36huge problem throughout the country. It's been
- 39:41kind of a public policy priority. And I think
- 39:44that with deed of fraud, There is a lot of technology
- 39:49that this whole manipulated voice or image technology
- 39:54and spoof contact information, it's all being
- 39:57kind of exacerbated by the different tools that
- 40:04now someone who's trying to do these kind of
- 40:07fraudulent transactions may have and a lack of
- 40:09checks and balances. And so This is kind of a
- 40:15rising area that government agencies both on
- 40:18a federal and state level are looking at. So
- 40:22as I'm sure everyone on the call knows, a forged
- 40:25deed is void from the beginning, right? It's
- 40:28void by law. So a forged deed can pass no title,
- 40:32even if there's a bona fide lender or purchaser
- 40:35who paid value without notice. The bona fide
- 40:38purchaser protection protection extends only
- 40:42to a party who took from someone holding good
- 40:44legal title. If someone forged a deed, they have
- 40:47nothing to convey, but a void deed can stay in
- 40:51the public record until their support order.
- 40:56So if you have, if you have, if you become aware
- 41:10of a forged deed on a property, These are a couple
- 41:14of the remedies that the property owner would
- 41:18have. So record a list pendants, sue to cancel
- 41:22the instrument, sue to quiet title, apply for
- 41:27a TRO, It's helpful in many cases, the title
- 41:34insurance can assist with this. And so that's
- 41:37the first thing I advise clients to do, tender
- 41:40to the title insurance and see if they can take
- 41:43over dealing with the forged deed. And then file
- 41:46a police report and try to make a criminal referral
- 41:49under this session of the penal code. So to date,
- 41:53about 10 states, including California, have passed
- 41:57laws aimed at title fraud. And a lot of those
- 42:03laws, including the one recently passed in California,
- 42:07focus on notification to homeowners. There's
- 42:11not been a lot of reform or talk of reform as
- 42:15to an overarching process for ensuring that liens
- 42:20and deeds are limited or that the county recorder's
- 42:25office do more of a QC before actually reporting
- 42:28the deed. In terms of in the context of liens
- 42:34in the automotive industry, there was recently
- 42:35a reform because there was such rampant fraud
- 42:38on auto liens that now the kind of the number
- 42:43of the people that can bring the they can record
- 42:48those types of liens has the categories have
- 42:50been more narrowed. And I do think that there's
- 42:53some discussion about doing a more widespread
- 42:56reform, but I don't think there's been a lot
- 42:58of legislative traction there. And there's this,
- 43:01this kind of rising deed fraud, there's a lot
- 43:06of there's a lot of homeowners that may be vulnerable
- 43:11to this, and then there's very limited things
- 43:14that currently the state or the reporter's office
- 43:17does. So, I mean, from my perspective, I think
- 43:20legislative reform here, or at least creating
- 43:24more of a process so that the, so the recorder
- 43:29is doing some kind of checks. to see that the
- 43:33contractor issuing a lien is actually a licensed
- 43:37contractor or requiring that a contract be provided
- 43:41in addition to just the form. There's a lot of
- 43:43things that would make sense that aren't currently
- 43:48required. They would also add kind of more paperwork
- 43:51to the process for legitimate contractors, but
- 43:55I think that there has been There's been a little
- 43:59bit of talk about it, but there's nothing that's
- 44:01currently pending. But I think if there is enough
- 44:04of a push for it, it may be something that would
- 44:06be considered. Some other states have a more
- 44:11rigorous process before a mechanics lien can
- 44:14be recorded on their property. And there are
- 44:16some states... that, particularly on the East
- 44:18Coast, where if it's a lean over a certain amount,
- 44:20it's automatically subject to higher scrutiny
- 44:23before it can be recorded. But California has
- 44:25such a low bar that there is no process like
- 44:29that. And so it's something that we can maybe
- 44:34think about from other states here. So what we
- 44:38did, what California did pass is this early warning
- 44:42system. So I'll talk more about the statewide
- 44:45reform that just passed, but in LA, there is
- 44:49a homeowner notification program that all property
- 44:54owners can sign up for. So that gives you an
- 44:57email. The day that any document is recorded,
- 45:00but you have to affirmatively sign up for it
- 45:02with your email address for the property owner.
- 45:05There is and you can, you can opt in for. Those
- 45:11emails through the assessors portal. There's
- 45:14also a homeowners notification program that mails
- 45:17copies of recorded documents, including grant
- 45:20deeds, notice of default, notice of trustee sale.
- 45:24That's automatic, the mailed copies of the recorded
- 45:29documents. But owners can opt into getting electronic
- 45:32notice instead, or in addition to getting the
- 45:34mailed documents at the property. So I think
- 45:37that's very important if you know property owners
- 45:39who may not be physically near the property and
- 45:43may not be getting notices that are mailed to
- 45:45the property. Because that early notice, if you're
- 45:49aware of particularly of deeds or liens being
- 45:53recorded, it shortens the timeline for when the
- 45:57property owner could take action. And particularly
- 46:01if a deed is being recorded and then that kind
- 46:08of ownership of the property is being used to
- 46:11secure a huge loan, Knowing that the deed has
- 46:14been recorded and it wasn't authorized can limit
- 46:17the damages significantly. So California just
- 46:22passed in this legislative session SB 255 that
- 46:26requires every California county except for Los
- 46:29Angeles to establish its own reporter notification
- 46:32program. The reason LA was excluded is as I said
- 46:35before LA already had that early warning system
- 46:38and so LA's was found to be sufficient without
- 46:41needing any additional work on LA County's part.
- 46:47So under the statewide law effective January
- 46:511st, 2027, any parties to a deed, quit claim
- 46:55deed, mortgage, or deed of trust will receive
- 46:58notice from the recorder's office in their county
- 47:00within 30 days of reporting. That SB255 does
- 47:05not provide early notice of mechanics liens.
- 47:10And while SB255 provides notice, it doesn't stop
- 47:14a fraudulent document from being recorded. That's
- 47:16all subject to the the protocols in the recorder's
- 47:20office. So that was kind of the bulk of my presentation.
- 47:25We've got about 10 minutes for questions if anyone
- 47:27has them. Otherwise, I can give a few examples
- 47:31of some of the mechanics lens issues that we're
- 47:35dealing with. So let me see, I've got a couple
- 47:38of questions here. Okay. So we got one question
- 47:46on the RCG gas lamp case. So the question was,
- 47:51once the anti -slap was granted, did the lien
- 47:53remain in place throughout the entire litigation?
- 47:57So I don't know what happened in that particular
- 47:59case, but in general, because the anti -slap
- 48:04was granted, essentially the court voided the
- 48:08cause of action for slander of title because
- 48:11it was solely based on the recording of the mechanics
- 48:17liens. So I think that that kind of the takeaway
- 48:21there because that was only cause of action in
- 48:23the complaint. So the the when the motion to
- 48:27strike was granted there. there wasn't like a
- 48:31separate case for the mechanics lien. So I don't
- 48:34know if another action was formed, but what had
- 48:38happened was that there was one lien that was
- 48:40recorded and then the owner filed a release bond,
- 48:44right? So they paid the 125 % premium and got
- 48:46that lien released. And then when the two other
- 48:49liens were formed, when the two other liens were
- 48:52recorded, 90 days hadn't passed at that time.
- 48:54And so they went ahead and filed a quiet title
- 49:00and slander of title action. And the basis of
- 49:03that was that the subcontractor had recorded
- 49:07duplicative mechanics liens improperly for an
- 49:13improper purpose and that it was essentially
- 49:15forcing them to either file a petition for release
- 49:18or to pay the release bond. I'm not entirely
- 49:25sure what happened next, but the lien would remain
- 49:30in place throughout any kind of other litigation.
- 49:33But at that time, there was no pending petition
- 49:37to release the lien. The purpose of the action
- 49:40was a slander of title and quiet title action,
- 49:44and that was subject to the motion to strike.
- 49:52And then the other question was really a comment
- 49:55as to other reform which I think is actually
- 50:00worth discussing. So this comment from Matt here
- 50:07says, I would question the efficacy of imposing
- 50:10higher paperwork burdens at the filing level
- 50:12because someone sufficiently dishonest to file
- 50:15an untrue mechanics lien could just as easily
- 50:17create a fraudulent contract and invoice. And
- 50:20that could be used as a barrier. for contractors
- 50:25who are genuinely filing, and that another reform
- 50:30would be requiring criminal courts to require
- 50:34convicted fraudsters to sign and deliver withdrawals,
- 50:37which would relieve the innocent landowner of
- 50:40the obligation to clear title. So I think that
- 50:42this whole issue as to needing to wait for a
- 50:47conviction before the... prosecutor's office
- 50:52takes any action to try to relieve the homeowners.
- 50:57I think that's a prosecutor's policy decision
- 50:59as opposed to a requirement under the statute.
- 51:03So I think there could be reform in there that
- 51:05wouldn't need to come from the law or from the
- 51:08recorder's office. But right now, the way it
- 51:10sits is as the criminal cases ongoing, the prosecutor's
- 51:16office just doesn't do anything related to clearing
- 51:18title. They wait for the conviction to come out.
- 51:23But I think at a minimum, I mean, this whole
- 51:25idea of there's all this protection for, there
- 51:32are all these requirements, right, that only
- 51:35licensed contractors should be able to do work
- 51:38in California. There's protection, homeowners
- 51:44are able to speak to the contractor's licensing
- 51:46board, and if unlicensed contractors do work
- 51:51that is supposed to be done by licensed contractors,
- 51:55there's remedies there for the owners, but there
- 51:59isn't that simple check. There's just no connection
- 52:02between the recorder's office and the contractor's
- 52:05licensing board, and that does seem like something
- 52:07that could be a fairly easy reform. So if anyone
- 52:12on the call has connections with generating that,
- 52:15because I do think that there is a significant,
- 52:18from at least what I've seen in the pure fraud
- 52:20cases, which haven't frankly been all that many,
- 52:23but there's been the kind of pure fraud where
- 52:30there's mechanics and then there hasn't actually
- 52:32been work done, that's not coming from licensed
- 52:34contractors, that's coming from people that don't
- 52:36have the license. And so if there were something
- 52:39for if there were something that was checked
- 52:43there that I think that could catch at least
- 52:45some significant amount of this this type of
- 52:47fraud. So I think that's we've got about five
- 52:52minutes left. Does anyone have any other questions
- 52:54that they want to put in the chat? Otherwise
- 53:01I'll just kind of share that in general the cases
- 53:04that I've been seeing for mechanics liens are
- 53:07primarily really the Owners' complaint is the
- 53:13amount of fees and whether that exceeds the permitted
- 53:16scope of work. So there's a lot of disputes that
- 53:19are related to change orders, whether they're
- 53:21unsigned or authorized. And there are a lot of
- 53:27kind of substantive issues about the quality
- 53:31of the work that get litigated in these mechanics
- 53:34liens type of cases. So where the parties are
- 53:39seriously You know where we couldn't come in
- 53:42normally is if there's a significant dispute
- 53:45as to not necessarily that the contractor provided
- 53:49some work, but whether the amount of the lien
- 53:51is reasonable and whether the scope of work was
- 53:56actually within what was authorized by the contract.
- 53:58And so the mechanics liens cases tend to not
- 54:01be as simple as an action to foreclose or a petition
- 54:04to release the lien. They tend to be kind of
- 54:08caught, especially for larger liens, they tend
- 54:10to kind of then involve breach of contract and
- 54:14construction defect type cases. And so while
- 54:18the statute is kind of designed with a simple
- 54:21process in mind, simple as kind of statutes go
- 54:26for having the contractor puts their lien in
- 54:31and then within 90 days forecloses it. And then
- 54:33if they don't do that, the homeowner has that
- 54:36petition to release option. What ends up happening
- 54:38is if the dispute is larger than just if there's
- 54:41complications to dispute and then almost always
- 54:44are right as to whether the um as to whether
- 54:48that amount was authorized and if the work was
- 54:51done satisfactorily, that all gets kind of litigated
- 54:54into one big case. And so that's why, even though
- 54:57there's this requirement on the petition to release,
- 55:00that that be heard within 30 days, most of the
- 55:04time these cases kind of become a lot more complicated
- 55:07because there's at least a breach of contract
- 55:09and potentially construction defect cause of
- 55:11action that will also be litigated in the same
- 55:14case. they tend to not be all that simple, even
- 55:20though I think in 1850 when they were first passing
- 55:24the initial Mechanic Sleem Statute, that was
- 55:26the idea. And the fact that California so enshrines
- 55:34Mechanic Sleem that they're in the state constitution,
- 55:39and the process that has been developed over
- 55:42these kind of 70... to 150 different iterations
- 55:45of the Mechanics Lean Statute means that it's
- 55:47really important to be on top of the detailed
- 55:51procedure of mechanics liens and so i'm open
- 55:54if anyone has any questions now or wants to email
- 55:57me my contact information is here but i think
- 55:59the number one thing that you can do on behalf
- 56:01of either a property owner or a contractor if
- 56:05you're dealing with mechanics liens is to be
- 56:06really well aware of the technicalities of the
- 56:10civil code on mechanics lien it's one where courts
- 56:13will enforce it to the letter because it's so
- 56:16specific and if windows are missed on either
- 56:19side it can have serious consequences because
- 56:22while mechanics leans can range from, you know,
- 56:26there's cases in which mechanics leans are only
- 56:29for you know, 20 -25 ,000 dollars, there's also
- 56:33mechanics liens cases that are worth hundreds
- 56:35of millions of dollars for large -scale construction
- 56:38contracts or projects, but the same technical
- 56:42rules and timing rules apply to both. And because
- 56:47the mechanics liens statute has a prevailing
- 56:50parties fees cause that's statutory. If you're
- 56:54on the wrong side of it, right, if you end up
- 56:57having a mechanics lien that's overinflated and
- 57:00you're filing on behalf of the contractor or
- 57:02you don't follow all the kind of the timing requirements
- 57:05and you're not the prevailing party on either
- 57:06side, you'll be responsible for the fees. So
- 57:10super important to consider all the technical
- 57:12aspects of the statute. All right, if there's
- 57:19no more questions, I think that's... I think
- 57:23that's my time. And I appreciate your attention
- 57:27to this and appreciate you logging on. Please
- 57:32let me know. Feel free to connect with me on
- 57:33LinkedIn or email me if you have any questions
- 57:36or want to talk about this. There's been, I don't
- 57:39think it's been a huge uptick, but there's been
- 57:41a steady uptick in mechanics liens that seem
- 57:44to be filed, at least in my practice. And I think
- 57:46that the amount of of private improvements that
- 57:51take place in LA and particularly us having two
- 57:53natural disasters to recover from means that
- 57:56we're going to be looking at more of these. And
- 57:58so knowing the mechanics in statute and being
- 58:00on the lookout for potential fraud is very important
- 58:05for anyone who deals with clients that touch
- 58:08real estate, either on the contractor or owner
- 58:11side. Thanks everyone for attending. Thank you,
- 58:17Pooja, for presenting. Thank you.