Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 125 – Rethinking “Duty Sex”
Transcript
- 0:43Hello, and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage Podcast. My name is JD, and I blog over at UncoveringIntimacy.com, and I've had a lot of conversations with couples as well as husbands and wives individually lately about what often gets called duty sex or pity sex.
- 0:59For those who don't know, duty or pity sex is when one spouse gives into sex not because they desire it themselves, but because their spouse does.
- 1:07And they might have sex for many reasons, including feeling obligated, pressured, guilty to keep the peace, or just to get them off their back.
- 1:16And the problem is that these negative reasons are often the only ones considered, and so any situation in which one spouse wants sex and the other agrees to it without having an internal desire of their own is seen as unfavorable.
- 1:28And this belief is compounded by our society constantly telling people that they shouldn't have sex unless they are in the mood, which I think is a deliberate attack on monogamy.
- 1:39I mean, it's easy to say that to people who are using apps for hooking up, going to bars looking to have sex, and constantly jumping from one partner to the next.
- 1:47When all you know is infatuation, new relationship energy, or being able to find someone else who is in the mood whenever you are, then it's easy to abide by that.
- 1:56But what happens when you're in a long-term relationship?
- 1:59You know, when you have children, and the stresses of life, when your hormones shift, when you don't have the option to find someone else who happens to be in the mood at the same time you are because you're in a committed, monogamous relationship.
- 2:10When you can't just put your relationship in the closet until you're ready to take it out again because you're in the mood, like an outfit for clubbing.
- 2:19What about when you have a spouse who isn't in the mood when you are, or they're always in the mood, or maybe never?
- 2:24However, suddenly the don't have sex unless you're in the mood rule turns into a burden because it's not designed for relationships.
- 2:33It's designed for those who want to destroy the concept of relationships, and I think it's incompatible with the Christian worldview.
- 2:39And I think it's part of a larger move in our society to move us away from intentionality and consideration and towards being wholly focused on emotions, feelings, pleasure, and reactions.
- 2:50And this mindset should come as no surprise to those who read books like Brave New World by Aldous Huxley.
- 2:57This is a dystopian philosophical novel in which drugs and sex control society.
- 3:02Similarly, Juvenal, who is a Roman poet, criticized his society for their willingness to be distracted from serious concerns by simple distractions such as were held in the Colosseum.
- 3:14And the Bible also warns us to focus more on thoughts and choices and thoughtful decisions rather than emotional reactions.
- 3:21You know, in Proverbs 29, 11, we see a fool vents all his feelings, but a wise man holds them back.
- 3:27In James 1, verses 19 to 20, we read,
- 3:32Let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath, for the wrath of man does not produce the righteousness of God.
- 3:40And in Galatians 5, verses 22 to 23, we hear the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, long-suffering, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control.
- 3:53You know, against these things there is no law.
- 3:56You know, it consistently teaches us to act not in response to emotion, but in self-controlled love and intentional responses.
- 4:04And this push to make decisions based on feelings runs along these same lines.
- 4:09It's a systemic attack on thought, on marriage, on God, and more.
- 4:14And I don't think most who push this rule of don't have sex unless you're in the mood know that that's what they're doing, but it still ends with the same result.
- 4:24This push prioritizes personal desire and gratification over more thoughtful consideration.
- 4:29It rejects concepts like neuroplasticity, which we talked about a few weeks ago, willingness over desire, which I have a post on as well, sacrifice, and more.
- 4:39And don't get me wrong, there are definitely times when duty sex is not good, like those times I mentioned above, when it's coerced or pressured, when you do it out of guilt, when you feel like you have to,
- 4:51and when you are just trying to get them to shut up about sex for a while.
- 4:56Well, those are not good reasons.
- 4:59They point to a more significant issue in your marriage, your spouse, or yourself.
- 5:04And sometimes that issue is simply that you believed that you have to be in the mood to have sex.
- 5:10We, my wife and I, lived with this paradigm for years until we learned better.
- 5:15And do you know what happened?
- 5:17We were both waiting for her to magically be in the mood.
- 5:21And guess what?
- 5:22It never happened.
- 5:23You know what did happen, though?
- 5:24She would feel guilty about not being in the mood, and so we'd have sex.
- 5:28And it would be good for both of us.
- 5:30But then she'd feel guilty about not wanting it more often, for not knowing why she didn't want it,
- 5:35for only having sex when the guilt became too much to bear.
- 5:39She enjoyed sex and would say things like, why don't we do this more often?
- 5:43But the next time that I initiated by asking something like, hey, are you in the mood for sex?
- 5:47The answer was always no, because she had responsive desire and was never just randomly in the mood.
- 5:56So as a result, we had a clinically sexless marriage for years.
- 6:00That's sex less than once a month until we realized that this was a lie.
- 6:05So don't believe the lie.
- 6:08Have sex even when you aren't necessarily in the mood, and change your mindset from asking,
- 6:12am I in the mood to am I willing to be in the mood?
- 6:16And don't ask your responsive desire spouse if they're in the mood for sex.
- 6:20Instead, initiate precursors to sex, not sex itself.
- 6:23I have a post on that if you're interested.
- 6:25And there are links in the show notes for it.
- 6:27As for duty sex itself, often we just need to reframe what duty sex is.
- 6:34Because there are some excellent reasons for why we have what's commonly considered duty sex or pity sex.
- 6:41And often, the conflicts I see in marriage are not that it's because of those reasons I mentioned above,
- 6:46but instead about something positive and loving.
- 6:49Often, the lower drive spouse is trying to do something loving and caring.
- 6:53They recognize the need for sex in the relationship and the desire of their spouse,
- 6:57and want to meet that need.
- 6:59So, despite not feeling any particular desire themselves, they engage in a loving gesture.
- 7:04And in many cases, this leads to a good time for both spouses because,
- 7:08in many of these cases, the lower drive spouse experiences largely responsive desire.
- 7:13So even though they aren't in the mood for sex when it starts,
- 7:16they manage to get in the mood, enjoy themselves, and maybe even have an orgasm.
- 7:20Or maybe they don't, but they enjoy the closeness.
- 7:22Or maybe they just enjoy doing something loving for their husband or wife.
- 7:26In all these cases, there's nothing wrong with this.
- 7:30This is a loving gesture given to your spouse.
- 7:32And spouses who engage in this sort of loving gesture often get quite frustrated when it is then rejected.
- 7:38Their spouses will tell them that it's not good enough.
- 7:41That they need to have or initiate sex simply because they want it themselves.
- 7:46Not because their spouse wants it.
- 7:48And this view of needing to initiate sex or have sex only when you want it has this entire paradigm backwards.
- 7:56You know, why is it seen as loving if it's selfish, but not if it's selfless?
- 8:01You know, think about it.
- 8:02If you both want sex and then have sex, that's a lot of fun.
- 8:06But it's just both of you getting what you want out of it.
- 8:10While that can be lots of fun and pleasurable and indeed can be loving,
- 8:14there's nothing inherently loving in agreeing to do something that you want for yourself.
- 8:19On the other hand, if you, with a loving heart, agree to do something for your spouse
- 8:23and choose to do it happily because you know that they love it and you love them,
- 8:27that is a genuinely loving act.
- 8:30So why do we elevate the scenario where both spouses are meeting their own desires
- 8:34and denigrate the other where the spouse is being loving?
- 8:38Now, there are four reasons I think why this is the case.
- 8:41The first is that our society tells us that being in love means that you desire sex with that person.
- 8:48It doesn't matter if you're single or married.
- 8:50All the movies, TV shows, etc. out there tell us that the way to know that you're actually in love with someone
- 8:55is if you want to have sex with them.
- 8:57If you're single, that means you should be in a relationship.
- 9:00If you're in a relationship and you're attracted to someone else,
- 9:03that means that you should leave and start a new one with them.
- 9:05If you're in a relationship and not attracted to your partner, then you're no longer in love.
- 9:10Everything is based on the whim of attraction and feelings rather than choosing to love and commitment.
- 9:16And it is ingrained in us that we want sex with our spouse,
- 9:20but if they don't with us, then we love them and they don't love us.
- 9:24And if they have sex out of a choice of love and commitment as a gift rather than because of some internal desire,
- 9:32that that is then interpreted as not being loving.
- 9:36The second is that our egos want us to be attractive.
- 9:40We feel that if we're attractive, then people will want to have sex with us.
- 9:45Again, this is an unambiguous societal teaching.
- 9:48Many people make jokes or are serious about having a hall pass when it comes to celebrities.
- 9:54As in, if you ever get a chance to have sex with your celebrity crush, then it's not considered adultery.
- 9:59Of course, it still is, but that's the prevalent trope.
- 10:03So when your spouse doesn't want to have sex with you out of an internal desire,
- 10:08then it must mean that they're not attracted to you, which means that you aren't attractive to them.
- 10:14And we can handle not being appealing to the world, but generally we want our spouses to be attracted to us.
- 10:20And we gauge that by how much they want to have sex with us.
- 10:23It's not a good metric, but it is in the minds of many spouses.
- 10:27The third is that we don't want to be the weird sex addict.
- 10:31I think many of us fear that we're always, if we're always the one initiating sex,
- 10:36if we're the only one who ever wants it, does that make us a sex addict?
- 10:41And what if our spouse is the normal one and we're the weird ones?
- 10:45What if we're not supposed to enjoy sex as much?
- 10:48What if it's something I'm supposed to grow out of?
- 10:50What if there's something wrong with me psychologically?
- 10:53You know, if our spouse wants sex as much as we do, then we don't feel alone.
- 10:57We don't feel weird and we don't feel broken.
- 11:01And lastly, we remember them wanting to have sex with us.
- 11:05You know, for many in this dynamic, the higher drive spouse remembers the other one wanting to have sex more often,
- 11:11or at least being more interested in being physical.
- 11:14For many couples, things started off hot and heavy and then it changed.
- 11:18Similar to some of the ideas above, the worry is that this signals a loss of love.
- 11:23I mean, if they wanted sex all the time when things were great and amazing at the beginning of the relationship
- 11:28and now they don't, what does that mean?
- 11:31Doesn't that mean they don't feel the relationship is great anymore?
- 11:34You know, do they regret marrying you?
- 11:36These are all fears I hear from spouses who are introspective enough to look at their own frustrations and dissect them.
- 11:43And there's a simple answer, I think, to address all of these.
- 11:46And that is to honor the sacrificial love your spouse is offering.
- 11:51You know, you have to recognize that they are doing it out of love.
- 11:54And I won't say that they aren't doing it out of duty because there is a lot of overlap between these two concepts.
- 12:00If we love someone and we care about them, that comes with a sense of responsibility.
- 12:06For example, I love my kids and I feel responsible for them and I am duty bound to care for them.
- 12:12And when they're young and just starting to learn to play card games and want to play a game called War,
- 12:17which I find a very dull game because it's 100% set by the shuffle of the deck,
- 12:23you know, I'll play with them because it's fun for them, even if it's not challenging or that much fun for me.
- 12:28But I love to see them smile when they win a big stack of cards from a triple war.
- 12:33Or, you know, should they then reject my willingness to play War with them?
- 12:38Of course not.
- 12:39Now they're older and we play much better games.
- 12:41We have quite a few games, actually, that we all enjoy.
- 12:46And I've been enjoying playing one deck dungeon with my younger two ones
- 12:49because they're not quite ready to play Gloomhaven yet, which I play with my wife and the oldest two.
- 12:54Let me know if there's any other Gloomhaven fans out there.
- 12:57The point is there's nothing wrong with doing something for someone just because you enjoy being with them,
- 13:03seeing them enjoying it, and knowing that you will enjoy it as well once you get into it.
- 13:07And these days, I appreciate it when my wife is willing to invest time and energy into sex,
- 13:12even when she's not feeling it in the moment.
- 13:15I treat these as opportunities to get her aroused.
- 13:19Sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.
- 13:21When the opportunities are more frequent, it's much easier to cut a night short when it's just not working out.
- 13:27But just because you're willing to doesn't mean you're necessarily able to either.
- 13:33And so it becomes a team effort, both of us working to wake up her sex drive.
- 13:38Sometimes we win, sometimes we lose, but we win or lose as a team.
- 13:43And there have been many times when we say,
- 13:45like, let's just stop, go to sleep, and try again tomorrow.
- 13:48And sometimes tomorrow doesn't happen either because life has a way of changing our plans.
- 13:53And it's okay to be frustrated and disappointed by that change,
- 13:56so long as you're not frustrated and disappointed in your spouse.
- 14:00It is not okay to be frustrated and disappointed in not receiving a gift that they are giving out of love.
- 14:07So if you're having fights about duty sex, this is how you move forward.
- 14:12Share this podcast episode with your spouse.
- 14:14If they prefer to read, there's a link to the show notes.
- 14:17They can read the whole thing verbatim.
- 14:19Ask them what they think of it.
- 14:20Use it as a conversation starter.
- 14:22If you're having duty sex for the wrong reasons, work to change the reasons.
- 14:27Choose to have sex for your own reasons, even if that reason is to be loving and caring.
- 14:33Any situation where you feel like you have to do something due to external influences
- 14:37will make you feel bad about it.
- 14:39Less in control and less likely to lead to a positive outcome.
- 14:43In contrast, decisions you make yourself for internal reasons,
- 14:46whether that's due to an internal sex drive or simply because you're being loving,
- 14:50those are more likely to lead to positive outcomes and you're more likely to look back on it positively.
- 14:56And if you're frustrated because you've been getting what you've been calling duty sex or pity sex,
- 15:01but now you realize it's a loving gesture, apologize and work to change that mindset.
- 15:06And it can be hard to change that.
- 15:09Like I said, this is a simple answer, but it doesn't mean it's an easy one.
- 15:14If you need help, I do marriage coaching and we can help you get past it.
- 15:18We can talk through it, find a practical solution that fits your marriage and help you move forward.
- 15:23But often people just need that paradigm shift to see it from a new perspective.
- 15:27And I hope this helped give you that.
- 15:31And that's it for this week.
- 15:33I'll talk to you next time.