Latest / The Assistant Principal Podcast / How can I co-create today? With Dr. Lindsay Lyons
Transcript
- 0:00Frederick: Today's show begins with a 40, 000 foot view of student voice and
- 0:04then takes us right to ground level to break down implementation of a
- 0:08specific practice for elevating not only student voice but also teacher voice.
- 0:13Are you ready?
- 1:14Lindsay Lyons is an educational justice coach who helps schools and
- 1:18districts co create feminist anti racist curricula that challenges,
- 1:22affirms, and inspires all students.
- 1:25A former New York City public school teacher, she holds a PhD in leadership
- 1:30and change and is the founder of the blog and podcast, Time for Teachership.
- 1:36She believes a secret sauce of educational equity is student voice.
- 1:41Hello, Lindsay.
- 1:42Welcome to the show.
- 1:43Lindsay: /Hi, Frederick.
- 1:44I'm so excited to be here.
- 1:46Frederick: Yeah, this is going to be fun before we jump in.
- 1:50I'm really eager to do that.
- 1:51But before we jump in, tell me, what are you celebrating today?
- 1:54What
- 1:56Lindsay: a question.
- 1:57I love that.
- 1:57I am celebrating that.
- 2:00My kid loves bubbles so much that he was tantruming last night and we
- 2:05put bubbles in the bubble bath and he was just like, I'm a happy child.
- 2:09And it was like a miracle.
- 2:12Frederick: Wow.
- 2:12I will not tell you how many years it's been since we had kids
- 2:16taking bubble baths in our house.
- 2:21Oh, but you enjoy every stage, every stage has its special things
- 2:25and bubble baths are part of that.
- 2:27That's right.
- 2:29Lindsay, is there a story that would help listeners understand why
- 2:33you're doing the work you're doing?
- 2:36Lindsay: I think there's a lot of stories, so choosing one is hard, but I
- 2:38think that the reality of how I grew up.
- 2:43And what I did not experience, right?
- 2:46I think oftentimes we're looking for things that we didn't get
- 2:49as children, whether we're in an educator mindset or a parent mindset.
- 2:54We just want things different than how we had them.
- 2:58I did not experience.
- 3:00a curriculum, a student body, a teaching staff as a student in,
- 3:08in my K 12 experience that pushed me around questions of justice and
- 3:15injustice that enabled me to create.
- 3:19And specifically to create solutions to problems that I saw in the world.
- 3:25In fact, I was often silenced when I brought things up, and educators
- 3:30in my space were actually silenced, for lack of a better word, and
- 3:35kicked out of the district if they were to bring in content that
- 3:39questioned things like gender or race.
- 3:42I had one teacher that introduced books.
- 3:45Their eyes were watching God, there's a feminist text that he
- 3:48introduced and led those conversations around race and gender justice.
- 3:52Wasn't there like a year or two later, you know, it was just like
- 3:55a quick blip and then, then gone.
- 3:58And so being able to see what was possible, but not to really
- 4:01experience it as a student day to day, all the classes, every grade.
- 4:07Really made me seek it out.
- 4:09And so I got some of that in college.
- 4:10It was really exciting.
- 4:11I realized that I wanted to solve problems of the world, but I was too focused
- 4:15on once the problems had happened, I wanted to do something about it.
- 4:19So I wanted to be a domestic violence lawyer, for example.
- 4:22And then I was like, this is really hard.
- 4:24The bad things have happened.
- 4:26I want to prevent them from happening.
- 4:28Where do I do that with children?
- 4:30And so that's how I became an educator.
- 4:33Frederick: Wow.
- 4:33What a beautiful story.
- 4:36Thank you.
- 4:37. So we're going to talk about what you've termed pedagogy of student voice.
- 4:43So before we dive into it, let's define it.
- 4:46What is pedagogy of student voice?
- 4:49. Lindsay: So I have always used the phrase student voice in line with the
- 4:53field of student voice research that I'm part of, but I recently heard
- 4:57pedagogy of student voice in, I think 2020 the book street data came out
- 5:01from Shane Safir and Jamila Dugan.
- 5:03And I was like, running with it.
- 5:05So they have six rules of it.
- 5:07They say it's about having student talk time exceed teacher talk time.
- 5:14I think they use a Hamilton phrase.
- 5:15They say, talk less, smile more.
- 5:17And really they're talking about like at least 75 percent of class time.
- 5:21Students should be talking, or if not, literal speaking, like, you know,
- 5:25engaging in some sort of creation.
- 5:27Valuing questions over answers is their second rule.
- 5:30Ritualizing reflection and revision, which we often don't make time for,
- 5:35making learning public, and that's for educators and adults as well as children.
- 5:39Circle up as a specific practice, and I think about a lot of protocols
- 5:43or activities that you can do, so having those at the ready.
- 5:46to amplify student voice.
- 5:47And then the sixth one is feedback over grades.
- 5:50So that real focus on progress versus perfection and that idea of, you know,
- 5:56getting to be the best you can be versus that idea of hierarchy that is
- 6:00way too common in educational spaces.
- 6:04Frederick: I love this because it opens a lot of space for not only student
- 6:09voice, but I think for relationships.
- 6:10Relationships between students because In this kind of a venue, they're really
- 6:17going to get to know each other more.
- 6:19But also that relationship between teachers and students.
- 6:23I'm doing a lot of work right now focused on classroom culture,
- 6:28which I think has three components.
- 6:29The relationships piece, the management piece, and then how we keep students safe.
- 6:36And when I think about that relationships piece, I think about students and teachers
- 6:42having a relationship along two lines.
- 6:45One is kind of the learning centered relationship that is as a student.
- 6:50How do I relate to you Lindsay as a teacher of the subject of the content
- 6:56and then there's the other side of it, which is the Learner not learning
- 7:01the learner teacher relationship.
- 7:03So how do I experience you as?
- 7:06As another human being in this classroom.
- 7:08Right?
- 7:09And and so if I, if I have a strong relationship with you from a learning
- 7:14perspective, and from a learner perspective, then you're going to be able
- 7:19to reach me and support me in ways that are much stronger if we don't have those.
- 7:24So it seems like this really ties in to this idea of student voice.
- 7:29And I'd like to just Open that up and let you run with that a bit.
- 7:34Lindsay: Yeah, I think if I had to distill down that big definition of pedagogy
- 7:39of student voice, I like to think of it as a co creation which to co create
- 7:44with students in an authentic way, you need to be able to have that trust.
- 7:48and that human piece built and you need to know enough about your
- 7:51curriculum and instruction that you can flex with whatever it is that the
- 7:55student needs or is interested in.
- 7:56And so I think from a planning and curriculum perspective, there's
- 8:00definitely a lot to be said about that model, which I absolutely love.
- 8:03Thank you for sharing that model.
- 8:05And then I also think from a.
- 8:07practical sense of like, well, what does it look like to do something
- 8:10tomorrow that does both of those things?
- 8:13I would say my number one protocol to do and to do with staff, as well
- 8:18as teachers with their students.
- 8:20I think everyone benefits from this practice is circle or circle up.
- 8:24And so from indigenous communities, we've learned, you know, this practice of
- 8:28circling up, having a talking piece past.
- 8:31Sing it around and literally giving everyone this democratic space to share,
- 8:36sharing about self and stories and personal connections to material, and
- 8:41also sharing in response to content, but democratizing the space so you
- 8:44don't have the kid who's the loudest get the most say in the conversation.
- 8:52Frederick: This sounds like a powerful practice.
- 8:53And I think we're planning to kind of dive into this, right?
- 8:57Mm hmm.
- 8:58Here today.
- 8:59I, something just popped in my head though, as you were talking, when you said
- 9:02co create and, and needing to be flexible.
- 9:05And I'm thinking about what does that look like?
- 9:09How do we do that with students?
- 9:11And then it just hit me.
- 9:13Some of the things we've been talking about recently in the assistant
- 9:16principal podcast about working with veteran teachers are really.
- 9:20Any teachers and helping teachers grow, helping that professional development
- 9:25piece, and I'm a strong advocate that teachers should be in the lead with that.
- 9:30But that relationship really is a co creation relationship with teachers.
- 9:34So if I'm an assistant principal and I'm trying to support teacher growth.
- 9:39In some ways, I think that's going to mirror me as a teacher creating,
- 9:44you know, student voice, giving room for student voice in my classroom.
- 9:48Like it's the same, kind of the same relationship.
- 9:52Yes.
- 9:52Oh
- 9:53Lindsay: my gosh.
- 9:53Yes.
- 9:54It's the same thing, right?
- 9:55We always used to...
- 9:56to say in the school that I worked in, and they have a whole network.
- 9:59Their model is one learning model for all.
- 10:02So the same things we do with adults is the same things we do with students.
- 10:05And the students see that latch onto that, appreciate that.
- 10:10And it all works better that way.
- 10:13Frederick: I want to, as we move into the circle piece, I'm going to
- 10:18share with you, a version of this, but I am not claiming that it is.
- 10:22Correct in any way.
- 10:23In fact, I want to start with it because I suspect it's flawed,
- 10:27but it's something I can do.
- 10:28And I just started doing.
- 10:29And I think sometimes that's a good way for us to start these things.
- 10:33So I'm going to share what we do and then you can help guide me through
- 10:37it and improve and build on it.
- 10:40Sounds great.
- 10:42Okay, so I train a lot with nonprofit and governmental leaders and now
- 10:47we usually have small groups.
- 10:49So we're.
- 10:507 to 12 people and at the end of training sessions, we will circle up and these are
- 10:56groups that meet a total of four times.
- 11:00So after the first time we all know each other, right?
- 11:03So we'll circle up at the end.
- 11:05I provide three prompts and they are , what are you going to be
- 11:10thinking about on the drive home?
- 11:13Do you have a challenge for the group?
- 11:16Or is there a thank you that you would like to share and they,
- 11:20they're supposed to only do one of those because right, even with eight
- 11:24people that could take a long time.
- 11:25So we try to really keep it succinct.
- 11:27We circle up.
- 11:29I've had colleagues that have done that, that have said you're allowed to pass.
- 11:34You don't have to participate.
- 11:36I never put that out there.
- 11:38I just put it up.
- 11:38We have these three options.
- 11:40What are you thinking about on the drive home?
- 11:41Do you have a challenge for the group or do you want to say thank you to somebody?
- 11:46And then we go and I go last.
- 11:49Usually.
- 11:51All right.
- 11:51So tell me how to make that better.
- 11:53Where did I hit it?
- 11:54And where am I missing?
- 11:55Lindsay: I mean, I think that's beautiful, but I think the thing about
- 11:58circle is you can't really do it wrong.
- 12:00And so the one, the one thing that I think is important is the structure.
- 12:05So it sounds like you have that structure of the circle.
- 12:08I said one thing.
- 12:09I'm going to say like three things in the structure of the circle, the
- 12:12democratization and of the facilitator or the keeper of the circle sitting as well.
- 12:18And to have nothing in the middle, except maybe a centerpiece
- 12:21that's co constructed to do this.
- 12:22I actually love having index cards for everyone to fill out
- 12:26and they just write the name of a person that is important to them.
- 12:29It could be a young person if you're specifically, you know, thinking about
- 12:32education spaces, but then you immediately have something that, you know, is.
- 12:36is a centerpiece.
- 12:37And so that's the structure.
- 12:39The only other piece of the structure is there's an opening and a closing ceremony.
- 12:43And the reason as explained to me for this is that circle is a very different kind of
- 12:49conversation than a typical class, right?
- 12:52Where students can shout out or they can raise hands or interrupt or whatever,
- 12:55you know, and so just to preserve the sanctity of the circle space to open
- 13:00and close, but that opening closing could be, you know everyone make.
- 13:05A face or a movement based on how you're feeling right now.
- 13:09You know, it could be really quick.
- 13:10It could be I've done when the bell rings and we're wrapping up class real fast
- 13:14It's like group clap everyone clap at the exact same time, you know something
- 13:17quick but we're honoring the start and end and then literally any questions.
- 13:21So I love all of those questions I I think anything that connects with your
- 13:26group anything that enables choice like you give them choice and what
- 13:29they're selecting and that idea of you know, what is important to me?
- 13:34What am I still thinking about?
- 13:35What am I challenged by?
- 13:37You know, those kinds of questions are the best because they're not just
- 13:40academic in terms of what content did I just learn and what am I going
- 13:43to do action wise tomorrow, but how am I going to be feeling about it?
- 13:47I'm feeling overwhelmed, you know, like my challenge is there's so much
- 13:50good stuff and I can't do it all right.
- 13:52That's also like the human part.
- 13:54So to go back to your model, I think you have both there and
- 13:56those questions, which is great.
- 13:58Frederick: So one of the.
- 13:59Big things we're trying to do.
- 14:01We're, we're elevating student voice, but the way that works with circle
- 14:06is students are getting choice because most of the time when we do a circle, we
- 14:12are giving some kind of choice, right?
- 14:15So we're giving choice.
- 14:16It's something that.
- 14:18I think allows students to connect with whatever we're doing, but also allows
- 14:25human connection in general between students and teacher and everybody.
- 14:31And then if we're doing it right and we're getting the prompts right,
- 14:36the choices, then they're also connecting to their self, which means
- 14:41they're connecting to that voice.
- 14:42And that's where.
- 14:44That part of the win comes in.
- 14:46Lindsay: Absolutely.
- 14:47Yeah.
- 14:47And I think, I mean, I can give some concrete examples.
- 14:50I don't know how deep you want to go in terms
- 14:52Frederick: of what this looks like.
- 14:53Yeah, I do.
- 14:53Well, cause the other, the other question that popped into my head,
- 14:57I made an assumption like I always do it at the end of the training.
- 15:00But as I heard you talking, I think you said that maybe it
- 15:02can go into different places.
- 15:04So I need to step back just one sec and say, okay.
- 15:08From an overarching perspective, what is the role of circle in the
- 15:14classroom that promotes student
- 15:15Lindsay: voice?
- 15:17Oh, such a good question.
- 15:18Okay, so there's layers to this.
- 15:20One is you're building the foundational community and the foundational.
- 15:26A set of agreements, ways of interacting with one another to enable you to
- 15:31tackle things that might be challenging emotionally that might deal with
- 15:36justice or injustice that might personally impact a lot of students.
- 15:40And so you're kind of building that foundation to be able to have those
- 15:44hard conversations if that's what the student brings up or the student has a,
- 15:48you know, a personal connection that is fraught with emotion around those topics.
- 15:53So I do a lot of justice work.
- 15:55So I think that's, that's important to build that
- 15:56community, to be able to go there.
- 15:58You're also, I mean, usually one of my first ones.
- 16:00So just to give a concrete example, I think would, would best illuminate this.
- 16:03But one of my first circles is typically the story of your name.
- 16:08And so on that level, you're just building community.
- 16:11You're not really doing a lot of things academically, but you're just asking
- 16:14students, tell me about your name.
- 16:15And that's the prompt, right?
- 16:16You can give a lot of sentence starters and stuff, but some students
- 16:19will tell me, you know, their, about their last names and how they have
- 16:22both their mom and dad's last names.
- 16:24And this is cultural and, you know, or some people will be like, I hate my name.
- 16:28No one can pronounce it right.
- 16:29This is how you pronounce it.
- 16:30And they teach the class, you know, there's so many different
- 16:33directions you can head with that.
- 16:35And everyone has something to share.
- 16:37About their name.
- 16:39So I think that's that's a way that it's just pure human, not so much
- 16:43of the academic and instruction.
- 16:45But then from there, you know, you go to something about current events
- 16:49like this is a staff circle and I can I'll share these resources as well
- 16:53with your listeners so they can like literally just grab the slide deck.
- 16:56But We were in class or in, you know, in the year that Trump
- 17:02was elected to the presidency.
- 17:04We were, as a staff community, grappling with, we are at a school
- 17:08where we have all students who are newly immigrated to the country.
- 17:12How are they going to be feeling about this and how do
- 17:15we facilitate class, right?
- 17:17And so we're like, we need to first figure that out as a staff.
- 17:21Before we go teach class tomorrow, kind of thing, right?
- 17:23So, one of the things we did was talk about that.
- 17:26And so, it was like, literally, what is the word first word that comes
- 17:30to mind when you see, you know, and then like, a magazine title.
- 17:33So for that, for that would be like, newspaper headline of like, Trump winning
- 17:36the presidency or something, right?
- 17:37Whatever the current event is.
- 17:39So it's literally just word association at first.
- 17:41You could do this with students current events.
- 17:43You could do it with a, a reading assignment.
- 17:45Then maybe you give a couple minutes to read or listen to a podcast or
- 17:48hear, you know, commentary, whatever.
- 17:51And then the next prompt is literally make a connection.
- 17:54So it's not debating something, right?
- 17:56It's not saying here's what's right and here's what's wrong.
- 17:58And this is my position.
- 17:59I'm never moving.
- 18:00It's saying, what's a personal experience you have related to the
- 18:04word that you associated with this current event or something, right?
- 18:07Like, what's another story that you want to tell the community?
- 18:11What's another current event that's connected?
- 18:13What is a text that you read?
- 18:15A song that's coming to mind?
- 18:17You know, a, a class, a science class.
- 18:20We just did this thing and that reminds me of this thing.
- 18:22You know, any kind of connection and you open it wide up.
- 18:26And enabling people to almost storytell as a form of instruction, but they get
- 18:32to be the experts in their own lives and the experts of the content that
- 18:36they're bringing in is super cool and also depolarizing, especially when
- 18:41you're talking about hard topics.
- 18:43So there's kind of the human element of grappling with emotion in those
- 18:47conversations, getting to know everyone else's stories and experiences
- 18:51and the agency that students have.
- 18:54and adults have in conversations like this, to bring in their own wisdom
- 18:58to the conversation and feel listened to because no one can interrupt.
- 19:02And then usually what I'll do as a closing there might be, all right,
- 19:07I'm going to put up a bunch of words that are like skill words.
- 19:10So for example, vulnerability emotional regulation, like things that
- 19:14were required in this conversation.
- 19:17Like, which did you feel like you did really well in today?
- 19:20So everyone ends on a success.
- 19:22And then they can just share that one phrase as they go around to a close.
- 19:25Sorry, that was a lot of talking.
- 19:27Frederick: No, that's great.
- 19:28You mentioned depolarization, so one thing I can imagine some listeners are thinking
- 19:34as you're going through this is, Whoa, I'd be concerned about putting in a circle
- 19:38that's going to open up all this stuff.
- 19:41We live in this weird space where we have to deal with this stuff, but it's
- 19:46all become so red hot flammable as well.
- 19:48So we're kind of trapped.
- 19:50So in what ways is circle depolarizing?
- 19:54. Lindsay: So, oh my gosh, I love how you're asking this question.
- 19:57I think Anytime you can speak from the I, so I think about this
- 20:02even in just like interpersonal conflict resolution training.
- 20:06Anytime you can speak from the I, and to truly speak from the I, not like,
- 20:10I don't like what you just said, but like, I'm feeling X, you know, and
- 20:15here's the story that's behind that.
- 20:17I think the invitation to share a story.
- 20:21is immediately humanizing.
- 20:24So it kind of decreases this need to be right or wrong or
- 20:27put people into categories.
- 20:29It invites emotion.
- 20:31I'm thinking about Dr.
- 20:32Sheree Bridges Patrick and I published a framework for analyzing what types
- 20:36of discussion kind of are present.
- 20:39And you can have multiple types of these.
- 20:41So it's not like one or the other, but in generative mobilizing
- 20:46That's the type we want to have.
- 20:47We're open to the disequilibrium, kind of feeling a little bit of discomfort
- 20:53because it invites change and possibility, and it connects with our emotions.
- 20:59So one of the things that we see is polarizing discourse
- 21:02kind of entrenches us, right?
- 21:03We don't invite that disequilibrium or or We might feel a disequilibrium, but we
- 21:07don't invite the imagination possibility.
- 21:10But another thing that's very popular in especially white liberal
- 21:12spaces is we intellectualize.
- 21:15So we can academically say, I say this all the time, like, I heard a podcast
- 21:18that said blah, blah, blah, right?
- 21:21And I'm leaving it in the head space, but I don't have the heart space.
- 21:24I'm not, like, feeling any emotion, because I'm academically talking about
- 21:28something that's not my own story.
- 21:30I'm just repeating what I heard.
- 21:31And I think that's very common when we talk about issues of injustice,
- 21:35or really, like, anything, right?
- 21:36Any academic thing.
- 21:37It's like, well, I'm just regurgitating this information.
- 21:40But I'm not personally connecting to it, and so I'm less likely to remember it.
- 21:44less likely to actually impact my life and people are probably
- 21:47going to tune out when I speak.
- 21:48But if I have a story to share and I'm invited to make that connection
- 21:53and choose the type of connection and the degree of the connection that
- 21:56I make, people are going to be more engaged in listening and I'm going to
- 22:00feel better about sharing and we have that generative mobilizing discourse.
- 22:05Frederick: So when you and I kind of had a preliminary conversation about what this
- 22:09podcast might look like, and we were both excited about this idea of, of student
- 22:16voice, and I'd asked about, well, you know, I could see teachers wanting, yes,
- 22:23that sounds great, but that also sounds like one of those things that can get
- 22:26really messy and, and run off the rails.
- 22:29And, and you said, well, circle is one really safe.
- 22:34Space to start.
- 22:36And so we've started to unpack that.
- 22:38And then we talked about.
- 22:40We want to make sure that coming out of this assistant principals can kind of
- 22:44see how can I introduce this to teachers and it's not, Hey, I heard this circles
- 22:49thing and you need to go do that.
- 22:51This looks like, right?
- 22:54We don't even have to sell it.
- 22:55What we can do is let people experience it and then they can
- 22:59decide whether or not they want to take that back to their classrooms.
- 23:03I think that's a really key point.
- 23:05We're going to help assistant principals.
- 23:07Think about how to go do this with teachers, and I would suggest don't
- 23:12go do it with teachers because you want them to go do it with their kids.
- 23:16Go do this with teachers because you value teacher voice in the same
- 23:21way that you want your students to value student voice, right?
- 23:24So don't do this.
- 23:26Because you want the next generation effect, do it because you're going to
- 23:29value the immediate impact and so to, have and foster more teacher voice at
- 23:36the end of a professional development or at the end of some meeting that
- 23:40we have, whatever excuse I can have to get teachers together, I want to
- 23:45bring their voices and I know because I've been listening to Lindsay now,
- 23:50A simple way to do that is circle.
- 23:53So I'm the AP, I've got all these teachers there.
- 23:56We just finished whatever we finished and I'm going to, take a step out
- 24:01and we're going to do a circle.
- 24:03What should I do?
- 24:05Lindsay: Oh, such a good question.
- 24:06Okay.
- 24:06So in something, in a situation like that where you had your typical meeting and now
- 24:10we're reflecting, I might do a very quick.
- 24:14Circle.
- 24:14So it might be how are you all feeling in a pose?
- 24:19Right?
- 24:19And so that's another again, thinking about UDL is really important.
- 24:22Universal design for learning.
- 24:24So not everyone loves speaking.
- 24:26And so giving people different opportunities.
- 24:29It could be how are you feeling in a pose?
- 24:30It could be everyone.
- 24:32What am I trying to say?
- 24:33Oh, take an index card and draw, right?
- 24:35It could, it could be some other modality.
- 24:37It could be literally find a picture on your phone or a meme or something
- 24:42and hold it up to the group, right?
- 24:44Around like how you're feeling in this moment.
- 24:45But get that emotion.
- 24:47there.
- 24:47What's the emotion?
- 24:48Just do an emotion check.
- 24:49You can also do that at the beginning, especially if you're going to introduce
- 24:52a new pedagogical practice or some change that people might be a little averse to.
- 24:56Like, let's feel the temperature of the room right now, right?
- 24:58Like quick, quick circle.
- 24:59And then I would ask for like a next step or an experience that you.
- 25:05Either have had that connects to what we're learning or that you want
- 25:09to have kind of visioning what is possible With whatever it is you learn.
- 25:14Let's say you just learn a new tech tool or something, right?
- 25:17And it's like how might this bring joy to your students?
- 25:20For example might be the prompt and everyone will share like
- 25:23their ideal scenario barrier free.
- 25:25They're not thinking about the challenges They're just putting out
- 25:28there their wish and then you might end with something like a group clap or
- 25:32an inspiring quote to end the circle.
- 25:34I also would say you can do a circle as an entire PD.
- 25:39So especially if there's something to talk about, but also to
- 25:42just model quality practice.
- 25:44So I have a bunch of slides that are like, if you have an hour with
- 25:47staff, here's how to do a circle.
- 25:49for the entire hour.
- 25:51And here's how I would build.
- 25:52So there's like three in a row that I would do over time.
- 25:57Build community values and agreements first.
- 25:59Then you talk about circle practice story of name, and then you do something
- 26:03challenging like current events within the community or news item that we talk about.
- 26:09Frederick: But Lindsay, if I have everybody in a circle for the entire
- 26:12PD, how are teachers going to sit in the back row and grade their papers?
- 26:16Exactly.
- 26:18You mean I have to be engaged?
- 26:21Okay.
- 26:21I'm thinking through a lot of this and I can just see so many opportunities.
- 26:26I love the idea that let's just wait in and try this and see how this goes, right?
- 26:33Because that's another thing as leaders we need to do if we want.
- 26:37Teachers to grow and be willing to take risks.
- 26:40We need to be willing to do that too.
- 26:43, and again, instead of coming in and saying, Hey, there's this new tool
- 26:46for student voice, I can go in and say, I know that the wisdom is in
- 26:50the room and I need to be better about giving voice to that wisdom.
- 26:54So this is something I heard on this goofy podcast, two people talking about.
- 26:59Using a circle to promote teacher voice, and I want to try it out.
- 27:04Here's how it would work.
- 27:05Are you okay to do this?
- 27:06Hopefully enough people will nod their heads and you can claim permission.
- 27:10and then we can circle up and do that.
- 27:13Lindsay: One of the things that just came to mind as well as, as you're
- 27:15thinking about the human centered part of what you're talking about.
- 27:19I think sometimes When you were speaking, I was just thinking of the teacher who
- 27:22just wants to be heard, like maybe they're literally not heard in their classes
- 27:26and the students are disruptive and they just want to focus on them for a minute.
- 27:30It's nice to have that space for that reason.
- 27:32It's also nice for people to be appreciated.
- 27:35And so one of the other things that I can put in, in this link, I'll, I'll give
- 27:38for your audience is values in action.
- 27:41It's a resource.
- 27:42It's a website.
- 27:43They came up with like 20 or so values or strengths, character
- 27:47strengths, and it's a bunch of positive psychologists who were like, let's talk
- 27:51about positive strengths of people.
- 27:53And so I actually printed them all out and put them out
- 27:57on , the wall of my classroom.
- 27:58And we would do a circle where it was turned to your left and say something
- 28:03positive about the person next to you.
- 28:05And I tried this without the resource.
- 28:08Nothing.
- 28:09Or like, that person is nice.
- 28:11You know, something really generic.
- 28:13I like your shirt.
- 28:14Exactly.
- 28:16And then once we got the language up there, it was like, I appreciate
- 28:21your sense of humor because I was having a tough day and you
- 28:24made a joke and made me laugh.
- 28:25Thank you.
- 28:25You know, it gives voice and opportunity and specificity to those opportunities.
- 28:30And, and it gives the opportunity for each teacher to feel like someone sees
- 28:34me and they said something nice about me, even if I had the worst day, even if
- 28:38I had the best day, that's really cool.
- 28:40And I feel good about that.
- 28:41I don't think any teacher would rebel against that idea.
- 28:44, Frederick: I'm also thinking about the easiest ways maybe to try this out.
- 28:48So for me, it's been comfortable doing the way I close it, but , we
- 28:52always begin with celebrations.
- 28:54We're usually parked at our table or, you know, whatever our kind
- 28:58of workspace arrangement is to do that, but we could begin that in a
- 29:03circle that could be, isn't that the easiest, simplest circle to do right?
- 29:09Hey, before we get going, y'all, let's stay in a circle and go
- 29:13around and what are you celebrating?
- 29:14And again, you've got choice.
- 29:17Right.
- 29:17Cause I choose what I celebrate, but you're giving this opportunity
- 29:20for connections because as people celebrate, I'm going to hear parts of
- 29:24my own life, maybe reflected in that.
- 29:27And everybody's getting voice because it's their celebration.
- 29:31So you're hitting all three choice connection and self right in that.
- 29:35And it's so simple.
- 29:38Lindsay: Yeah.
- 29:38Oh, I love that.
- 29:39And there's more attention paid, I think, to one another sharing versus when you're
- 29:44at tables, because then people can be distracted by their phones or, you know,
- 29:47you can't hide a cell phone in your lap when there's no furniture in between you.
- 29:50So you're looking at the speaker.
- 29:52And I also think I used to work for Life is Good Foundation for the Playmakers.
- 29:58And they used to always do Positive News Ball as like the share out celebration.
- 30:02So I was thinking you could combine this with another circle practice
- 30:05I've seen where it's just where you pass a ball around the circle as
- 30:09like an imaginary talking piece.
- 30:11And you can make it like a really big ball and it's so heavy.
- 30:13And then the next person is like hitting it to the next person.
- 30:16So you could do like positive news ball or something, and then just have a
- 30:19little bit of movement in there too, to just make it, you used the word goofy.
- 30:22And I was like, yes, this is the ticket.
- 30:25Frederick: I love it.
- 30:26It sounds like something that's just so flexible.
- 30:29It's something that we can really should do with teachers, right?
- 30:33We should be elevating voice.
- 30:34And this is a really strong tool for doing that.
- 30:37And Oh, by the way.
- 30:38Teachers might also embrace it and then use that as a
- 30:41tool to elevate student voice.
- 30:43So kind of sounds like a win, win, win to me.
- 30:49, the only other thing I'm thinking about is to me, this
- 30:52seems like this is a procedure,?
- 30:55And I know after the second time we've done this with a group, they know
- 30:59at the end I put that slide up and everybody's getting up and we're going
- 31:02into our circle and, and we're doing it.
- 31:05So.
- 31:06As a classroom procedure, from a teacher perspective to students,
- 31:11are there teaching points that I need to lay out for them?
- 31:15And then how would that translate into me as an AP doing this with teachers?
- 31:20Lindsay: Yeah, I would do it the same, AP to staff and teacher to students.
- 31:24And I think really it is a shared agreement that you
- 31:29want to co create if you can.
- 31:31If this is the first time you're rolling it out, I would say use a couple
- 31:35standard agreements for the procedure.
- 31:37So for example, we will always you know, help create a circle with our chairs
- 31:43and move the desks out of the way.
- 31:45We will...
- 31:46We will put our index cards with all the important people's names on
- 31:48them in the center as a centerpiece.
- 31:50We will pass the talking piece, and I usually do have the caveat that
- 31:54they can say pass, but I, I have to require them to say the word pass
- 32:00to be able to engage in some way.
- 32:03Like, I'm making a choice.
- 32:04I'm, I'm choosing to pass.
- 32:06And we will, never interrupt.
- 32:09And that includes the circle keeper.
- 32:11So whether that's the AP facilitating the staff circle or the teacher facilitating
- 32:15students unless there's an emergency.
- 32:18And so that was really important for me because I was, you know, often as teachers
- 32:22and leaders were giving directions.
- 32:25Here, you need to comply to these things I'm telling you to do.
- 32:28And for this one, it's here's my commitment to you and the circle process.
- 32:33I'm not going to interrupt.
- 32:34If I see someone talking, I might try to give them eyes, you know, like, but
- 32:38I'm not going to speak because that's the commitment I made to you all.
- 32:42Unless someone's in imminent danger or someone's being, you know, really
- 32:45rude and screaming or something.
- 32:48Frederick: And so I can think of those agreements as kind of the.
- 32:51The bullet points of teaching, maybe I should call them piece points, given
- 32:55what we're talking about , but the main points we're agreeing to hold the circle.
- 33:00You can pass, but you need to say pass so that we know, and then
- 33:05we are going to hold the space for people and not interrupt.
- 33:09Lindsay: The only other thing I would add to that, which is
- 33:11actually something that I learned.
- 33:14Because this happened is when you create a space like this, even if you're not
- 33:20talking about something like, for example, gender based violence, there are some
- 33:26students who will feel so comfortable in that space and have not felt that comfort
- 33:30anywhere else that they will come up to you afterwards or they will share in the
- 33:34circle some sort of something happening in their lives that now as a mandated
- 33:39reporter, you have to now do this thing.
- 33:41So I have Decided to have that as one of my rules or like kind of like
- 33:46asterisk at the bottom of the rules like just so you know If you want to
- 33:51share anything that I need to report that includes harm to yourself or others
- 33:56I like need to do these next steps.
- 33:59Just know that You can absolutely share it, but I don't want to violate
- 34:02your trust by not telling you ahead of time So for teachers particularly I
- 34:06would include that and I like I said, I learned the hard way on that one
- 34:09Frederick: I'd never thought about that, but I know exactly what you're
- 34:13talking about when somebody opens up something that you were not ready for.
- 34:17And in a way it's a beautiful moment and in another way it is scary as hell.
- 34:23Lindsay: Absolutely.
- 34:24Frederick: Okay.
- 34:25Lindsay, this has been fun.
- 34:26Hopefully y'all listening are going to think about the next meeting
- 34:30you have and it doesn't need to be a room full of people, right?
- 34:33We could do this with five people.
- 34:35If you're not sure where to start, maybe just start with the
- 34:37celebration before you get going.
- 34:39Hey, let's stand in a circle and just go around and say what we're celebrating.
- 34:43And then it, you can also use it as closing, but then I think you've
- 34:48already given some insights into different ways that we could do this.
- 34:52And it seems another really easy tip is keeping your prompt kind
- 34:57of open ended and let people interpret that any way they want.
- 35:02And it's simple way that's going to play out is in celebration.
- 35:04Somebody's going to say, well, personal or professional.
- 35:08It's up to you, right?
- 35:10Absolutely.
- 35:11Ah, okay.
- 35:13I have a couple more questions for you.
- 35:16Yeah.
- 35:17Number one, what part of your own leadership are you still
- 35:20trying to get better at?
- 35:24Lindsay: So many parts to narrow it to one.
- 35:26Let's see.
- 35:27I want to be a better listener.
- 35:30I think Circle is actually, that's one of the reasons I gravitate to it.
- 35:33It's a, it's a growth area for me.
- 35:36So, I do a lot of talking when I give webinars or presentations, but, like,
- 35:41my joy, but also the gap in my skills is, like, being able to sit And truly,
- 35:47deeply listen when people are talking.
- 35:50And I think, like I said, it's joyful.
- 35:52And it's also an area where , I could be so much better.
- 35:55Frederick: Thank you.
- 35:56If listeners could take away just one thing from today's show, what would it be?
- 36:01Practically.
- 36:02Lindsay: I'm going to cheat.
- 36:03Practically the circle practice and doing that in any way.
- 36:08Mindset wise, I think what is more important, but it might be
- 36:12less tangible, is the idea and the question of how can I co create today?
- 36:17How can I invite voice today?
- 36:20Frederick: I think we just hit the title of this podcast show.
- 36:24Excellent.
- 36:24Lindsay: I love those moments.
- 36:26Frederick: That is such a great thing.
- 36:27And I think if there was only one thing I could say to a leader every
- 36:31morning, it would be be present, look for opportunities to be present.
- 36:38And I bring that up because I think that this idea of co creation
- 36:43and presence go hand in hand.
- 36:45If I'm fully present, we're co creating.
- 36:48And if we're not able to co create, it's because we're not
- 36:51present and they go together.
- 36:53So I just think that's so beautiful.
- 36:55And I thank you for giving us another, lens through which to view relationships
- 37:02and what creates a quality relationship.
- 37:05Lindsay: Thank you for the opportunity.
- 37:06This has been so fun.
- 37:08Frederick: Yes, it has.
- 37:09And Lindsay, where can people find out more about you and your work?
- 37:13Where can they?
- 37:14Tap into some of those resources and you're going to tell us, but I
- 37:18know you do a lot of tremendous work with schools and school districts
- 37:22and helping them, embrace and work through what can be really challenging.
- 37:28So necessary practices.
- 37:29So let's learn more about what you're
- 37:31Lindsay: doing.
- 37:32Thank you so much for the opportunity.
- 37:33So I am on lindsaybethlyons.
- 37:36com.
- 37:37That's my website and everything is there.
- 37:39So there's a podcast called Time for Teachership.
- 37:41Like the guests are amazing.
- 37:43Frederick's going to be on my podcast.
- 37:44So everyone tuned into that episode and.
- 37:47I have a lot of my, you know, offers on there.
- 37:49But primarily what I do are , two things.
- 37:51One is the pedagogy of student voice.
- 37:53So how do we literally build that up?
- 37:55How do we coach teachers and coach leadership teams to
- 37:58support teachers structurally?
- 38:00'cause that's important with those opportunities to co-create.
- 38:04And then the other piece, which is very closely related, is designing
- 38:07curriculum for justice and co-creation.
- 38:09And so that's really tough to grapple with all the choices that
- 38:14you need to make when you're.
- 38:15You're designing curriculum for intersectional justice, but then also
- 38:19when you're co creating, how do you design a curriculum ahead of time that
- 38:24gives flexibility and space for co creation with each new group of students
- 38:28that you teach the unit to, right?
- 38:30So it's, it's a real balance and it's definitely an art and
- 38:34I absolutely love working with departments to create some new units.
- 38:38Right now, I've had an influx of ideas and questions around US history.
- 38:44Unit revisions.
- 38:45And so that's been a big topic of conversation for folks lately, but,
- 38:49you know, also people who are like, I want to teach art for justice.
- 38:52And so what is that like?
- 38:54So there's been some really cool creation happening in that front.
- 38:58Frederick: That's great.
- 38:59Thank you for sharing.
- 39:00Lindsay, is there anything else before we leave that you would
- 39:04like to leave our listeners?
- 39:08Lindsay: I think just that Michael Fielding in the, in the student voice
- 39:12researcher space talks about this idea of radical collegiality, this idea of
- 39:18seeing students as colleagues and partners is just so profound to me and really
- 39:24speaks to what we've been talking about.
- 39:26About there's that idea of the intersection of, you know, in
- 39:29instruction and human ness, right?
- 39:32The learning and the human pieces that, that blend together when we're truly in
- 39:36partnership with students and what we end up co creating both in the classroom,
- 39:40pedagogically, instructionally, but also for the school community, right?
- 39:44When we partner with students in that kind of colleague way is just profound.
- 39:48So I guess I would just leave it with that concept.
- 39:51Frederick: Lindsay, thank you so much.
- 39:53This has been so much fun.
- 39:54You've brought so much for us to be able to enact in a concrete
- 39:58way, but I think also so much to think about on the drive home.
- 40:03Lindsay: Excellent.
- 40:03Thanks so much, Frederick.
- 40:05All right.
- 40:05Frederick: Take care, Lindsay.
- 40:06You too.
- 40:07Bye.
- 40:09This was one of those wonderful interviews where I experienced
- 40:12a couple of lightbulb moments.
- 40:14Lindsay and I had met previously to outline the show and agreed to focus on
- 40:18the circle practice as an example of a practice for enhancing student voice.
- 40:23Lindsay had suggested that APs could use this in their own work to model the
- 40:28practice, so I knew we were going there.
- 40:31It was only in the middle of the episode that the light bulb went off for me, and
- 40:35I realized that we were teaching you, my colleague, to empower teacher voice.
- 40:41And I love the term co creation.
- 40:43I advocate for teachers to lead their own growth, to lead in identifying
- 40:47their goals and the process for growing.
- 40:50I advocate that they lead, but not that they go it alone.
- 40:54And the word co creation captures what I haven't really
- 40:57been fully able to articulate.
- 41:01We need to work with our teachers, and in so doing, we provide choice, create
- 41:05connection, and lift up individual voices.
- 41:09I encourage you to try using a simple circle.
- 41:12If we want teachers to grow, then we also need to model our own efforts to grow.
- 41:17If this feels challenging, be transparent.
- 41:20You can say something like, I heard about this way to help me listen better to
- 41:24you, and I thought I would try it out.
- 41:26If it doesn't work, blame the podcast folks.
- 41:30And then go for it.
- 41:32A smaller group will be easier than a larger one.
- 41:34Maybe a team meeting or something similar.
- 41:37The important thing is to try it and see what happens.
- 41:41Remember there will be links to Lindsay and her resources in the show notes.
- 41:46If you want to learn more about me and my materials, you can go to frederickbuskey.
- 41:50com and that link is also in the show notes.
- 41:53I look forward to seeing you again on Friday when we recap the week's
- 41:56daily emails, please remember to subscribe and rate this podcast
- 42:01rating the show helps others find it.
- 42:02And if you want to be a super fan, consider leaving a review.
- 42:07I'm Frederick Buskey, and thank you again for joining me on this episode
- 42:11of the assistant principal podcast.
- 42:13Cheers.