Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Cult 45
Transcript
- 0:01My sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to the cult favorite show.
- 0:12My sister's a therapist. My name's Virginia Jones.
- 0:15I'm a stand up comedian and I Co host this show with my amazing
- 0:19sister licensed marriage and family therapist Laura Ryan.
- 0:23Hello, I'm Laura Ryan, I'm a licensed marriage and family
- 0:25therapist but my main credit is sister to Sassy Slapstick
- 0:28Virginia Jones. That sounds almost like an
- 0:31exotic dancer. First name sassy second name
- 0:34Slapstick. Sassy Slapstick.
- 0:37You had a cat named Sassy and you grew up on slapstick.
- 0:40Slapstick Ave. you remember that?
- 0:43Absolutely. Remember that this is a show in
- 0:45which we talk about mental health, pop culture, TikTok, and
- 0:50just thoughts that we've been thinking.
- 0:52Every week on the show, 1 of us has a topic prepared and the
- 0:55other one of us get surprised. This week I get surprised.
- 0:59I like to occasionally check in and see where we're at with our
- 1:03listeners. USA is holding strong at #1.
- 1:05Turkey still holding strong at number.
- 1:08Rocking and rolling in Turkey. Hi, Turkey.
- 1:11We've got UK next. Thank you, UK, France in fourth
- 1:15position, Prathiol in fifth, Germany, Canada, Spain,
- 1:20Thailand, Italy, Bangladesh, Australia, Chile and a new one,
- 1:25the Seychelles, followed by Africa to.
- 1:29Everyone listening in Thailand, I would like to say Sawadika.
- 1:32To everyone listening in Australia, I'd like to say good
- 1:36day mate. Bob's your uncle to our UK
- 1:38listeners. Did you say anything to our
- 1:40German listeners? Guten tag 3 gates to our Turkish
- 1:44listeners, we'd like to say Merhaba Laura.
- 1:46This week I would like to talk about cults.
- 1:50Oh, nice. Last night and I were talking
- 1:53about the religions we grew up in and could they be considered
- 1:56cults? As you probably know, but our
- 1:58listeners might not, a gentleman named Stephen Hassan has
- 2:02developed a model to answer the question, is this a cult?
- 2:05The model is called BITE, and it means behavior, information,
- 2:09thought, and emotional control. If you go through it in detail,
- 2:14my religion does seem like it's a cult.
- 2:16It meets expectations, sometimes even exceeding.
- 2:20Behavior control tells you what to do, tells you where to be.
- 2:23It can be as extreme as sleep deprivation and beating and
- 2:28torture, but also control types of clothing and hairstyles.
- 2:32Rewards and punishment used to modify behaviors, discouraging
- 2:36individualism, encouraging group.
- 2:37Think. Is for information control.
- 2:40Deliberately withhold information, distort information
- 2:42to make it acceptable, or just lie.
- 2:44This is a big one for me. Minimize or discourage access to
- 2:47non cult source of information. Internet.
- 2:50If you came to anybody as a child with ideas or information
- 2:54about the church that was not flattering, you would be told
- 2:56that what you have been looking at was not godly.
- 2:59Even just information that wasn't necessarily negative
- 3:02towards the church, but other kids I know are drinking Diet
- 3:05Coke and it seems like it's OK. There's also compartmental
- 3:08realizing information into outsider versus insider
- 3:11doctrines, like how does the church look from the outside
- 3:13versus how does it look from the inside.
- 3:15And the idea that as you grew in the church, you would get more
- 3:18information, which definitely is something that happened with our
- 3:21dad because he came up the ranks a little bit.
- 3:23He was given additional information that we were not
- 3:26allowed to have. And then this one, it really
- 3:28struck me. Extensive use of cult generated
- 3:31information and propaganda including newsletters,
- 3:34magazines, journals, audiotapes, videotapes, YouTube, movies and
- 3:37other media. Our church was the king of this.
- 3:40So much weird film cassettes. We had records and cassettes.
- 3:45Yeah, and we had a musical. The next one is thought control,
- 3:56requiring members to internalize the group's doctrine is truth
- 4:00and organizing people into US versus them, insiders and
- 4:03outsiders. We had a whole name for
- 4:05outsiders, which was Gentiles, which now I know is not OK.
- 4:08You can't just use a Jewish people's word.
- 4:11I feel like in the Mormon church, all bets are off.
- 4:13You can kind of do whatever. You want right.
- 4:15It was very funny. There's a bit in this about
- 4:17confessions publicly and I said yeah, we would sometimes do that
- 4:21in the main meeting and we would call it testimonials.
- 4:24And I was like we call the. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
- 4:29I found this really interesting. Teachings thought stopping
- 4:31techniques which will shut down your reality.
- 4:34Testing, chanting, meditating, praying, speaking in tongues,
- 4:37singing, you're humming. We've talked about this as an
- 4:40individual. When you're having a negative
- 4:41thought, have a thing that you can go to.
- 4:45I don't use it as part of a cult.
- 4:47Yeah, like putting your tongue on the roof of your mouth if
- 4:49you're having a lot of negative thoughts.
- 4:51I have a secret word that I say to myself when I'm thinking
- 4:54something negative about. Myself, it is also something
- 4:58that calls dude, while we're talking, I like to do what if
- 5:01game. So I'm thinking Donald Trump is
- 5:03going to destroy our democracy and we're going to be in World
- 5:05War Three. Well, what if that does happen?
- 5:07And then I just sort of walk my way through it and then figure
- 5:10it out. What I keep coming back to on
- 5:12that topic is this will end, and I don't know when it will end,
- 5:16but it will end and I just have to survive until then.
- 5:19The good news is, and this is just my opinion and I do not
- 5:23have any sort of political science degree, but what I have
- 5:26seen is that when the culture moves way too far to One
- 5:31Direction, the response will be in the other direction.
- 5:35The fact that this is the Republican Party we've had means
- 5:38that we're not going to elect anybody in that party next.
- 5:42We're not going to elect anyone this extreme for a long time or
- 5:45until people forget, which is apparently five years.
- 5:48No one remembers January 6th, the last element of this, and
- 5:52I'm skipping through hitting the high points just to understand
- 5:55in general what this is. Emotional control.
- 5:57Promote feelings of guilt or unworthiness.
- 5:59Identity guilt. You're not living up to your
- 6:01potential. Your family is deficient.
- 6:03Your past is suspect. Manipulate a narrow range of
- 6:06feelings. Some emotions or needs are
- 6:08deemed as wrong, evil or selfish and still fear, such as fear of
- 6:12thinking independently, the outside world enemies losing 1's
- 6:16salvation, others disapproval. That's a lot of shame.
- 6:19The question I have today is, is MAGA a cult?
- 6:24I don't know if they're kidnapping people and beating
- 6:26them, not yet, but I think they're doing all the other
- 6:28things. When you were going through the
- 6:29list, I was thinking Scientology and Mega.
- 6:32I have another section about specifically political cults.
- 6:36This is a list of aspects. Of more political cults,
- 6:39especially cult of personality or charismatic cults.
- 6:42I do not find leader charismatic, but his followers
- 6:47seem to leadership structure. You've got a charismatic slash
- 6:51deified leader who demands absolute loyalty, who will
- 6:54punish you if you do not present absolute loyalty.
- 6:58You're not allowed to question. But what about this thing?
- 7:00Because he will sue you. He will try to sick the media on
- 7:05you. He will degrade your name in
- 7:06public. And he'll physically have people
- 7:09remove you from. Rooms and arrest you.
- 7:12Basically. There's people who have been
- 7:14very much on his side for a lot of the journey, but as soon as
- 7:17they say one thing, they're out. What you have is a lot of other
- 7:22conservatives operating in a very fearful way because they've
- 7:25seen that dissent is not tolerated.
- 7:27In a regular political party, it would be debated.
- 7:30It'd be internal processes, you know, democracy, information
- 7:33control, high control, isolation, limited exposure to
- 7:36alternatives. This is what I'm seeing most
- 7:39right now. Information is being narrowed
- 7:41and narrowed. And it reminds me, of course,
- 7:43Putin's Russia and Russia in communist rule and everything
- 7:47that came after. The people on the street are
- 7:49told a line of propaganda. They kind of know it's not true,
- 7:52but there's nothing they can do about it.
- 7:54So they're like, yeah, for sure. No, he's like the best horseman
- 7:56there is. I don't think they know that
- 7:58it's not true. I watched a whole TikTok about
- 8:01how people are using AI and using old footage and pumping it
- 8:06out to conservative folks. For example the LA riots.
- 8:10They. Used George Floyd riots, they're
- 8:13using that same footage and they're just saying it's
- 8:15happening now. He just put another caption over
- 8:17it. There was one way MO automated
- 8:19taxi that was burned and then that was just used over and
- 8:22over. And I saw somebody say like, how
- 8:24many times are they going to burn that one way MO?
- 8:26Why do they keep sending the way MO's out when they're setting
- 8:29them off on fire? That's what I see most in the
- 8:32mega world is a manipulation of information.
- 8:36Another TikTok, this woman was doing an impression of stuff she
- 8:39overheard Trump's birthday party.
- 8:41She said. There was one person who was on
- 8:43the bus to the rally and another person was at the rally and they
- 8:46were both talking about they were concerned that there were
- 8:49so many violent black people in DC.
- 8:52Where did they get that from? And the frustrating thing about
- 8:55the charismatic leader, he'll say whatever and people will
- 8:58immediately say, well, that is not true.
- 9:00That can be proved not to be true.
- 9:02We have documentation that that's not true, but he doesn't
- 9:05care and his followers don't care.
- 9:06That's a frustration for liberals because this is just BF
- 9:10because he doesn't care if it's true or not.
- 9:12Someone puts a microphone in front of him and then whatever
- 9:15comes out of his mouth comes out.
- 9:16Yeah, because I think he was lying about egg prices and he's
- 9:19just gaslighting the hell out of the American public.
- 9:22When you compare a political cult to a political party, low
- 9:25or no accountability leader is above scrutiny versus high
- 9:29accountability. Elections, media, legal
- 9:31frameworks, criticism. What he's been doing with
- 9:33journalism, saying, oh, this person can't come in the White
- 9:37House. Oh, I don't like this person
- 9:38anymore and that's not legal, but he doesn't care.
- 9:41Relationship with external society.
- 9:43In a political cult, you'll have insular US versus them
- 9:46mentality. It encourages isolation and in a
- 9:49political party it will be integrated with society.
- 9:51Seeks broader public support and information control.
- 9:54High control, isolation versus open information flow.
- 9:57Engagement with diverse media. The charismatic leader.
- 10:00This is someone with a tightly controlled public image.
- 10:03This deification often taps into a deeper psychological need
- 10:06among followers to quote, believe in something greater
- 10:09than themselves, transcending the mundane aspects of daily
- 10:12life. I've got my problems, I've got
- 10:14my struggles, but if I can put all my faith and hope and
- 10:17concentration on this one person, but I'm going to feel
- 10:20better. Something that I find really
- 10:21disturbing is that a lot of his followers seem to like that he
- 10:24is a bully. And a liar.
- 10:26They like that he's a liar. I was listening to a TikTok live
- 10:29with this guy who talks to mega people and fights them with
- 10:34knowledge and facts. It's kind of satisfying.
- 10:37He was talking to this one kid who was clearly like 18 or
- 10:40something. And the kid said, well, you
- 10:42know, you can't deny Donald Trump is a lot of fun.
- 10:45He's a rock and roller. He's a, he's wearing a diaper.
- 10:49Yeah, there's I saw a political rally poster that says Donald
- 10:52Trump poops his pants every day. He was saying, well, you can't
- 10:56deny he has this rock'n'roll sensibility.
- 10:59No, he doesn't. He says 79 year old man who
- 11:02poops his pants and eats McDonald's every day and he's
- 11:05mad at Taylor Swift. There's nothing rock'n'roll
- 11:08about a man who wears an oversized suit all the time and
- 11:10has a comb over. That's not rock'n'roll.
- 11:13So here's a list of charismatic leaders through history.
- 11:15Historical examples include ancient Pharaohs and Roman
- 11:18emperors who declared themselves gods and the British royalty
- 11:22they speak to that this has been designated by a higher power.
- 11:25I'm here because I'm supposed to be here, not just because a long
- 11:28time ago someone stabbed someone else.
- 11:30I'm here because God ordained me in this role.
- 11:34In the 20th century, you've got figures like Benito Mussolini,
- 11:36Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin pioneering the model of a
- 11:40dictator as cult figure. More recently, you've got Juan
- 11:43and Ava Peron in Argentina. Don't cry for her.
- 11:46Sheikh Mujibur Rahman in Bangladesh and DT Big DT are
- 11:50demonstrating how charismatic authority, even when erratic or
- 11:55transgressive, can be reinterpreted by followers as
- 11:57strong leadership. Trump's claim of a God-given
- 12:00mandate following an assassination attempt
- 12:02exemplifies this deification. He's saying God meant me to be
- 12:06here, a God he does not worship and does not believe in.
- 12:09Loves all the Bible, he says. I can't really find a passage
- 12:13that I really like. I just, you know, I just love
- 12:15the whole thing. More characteristics, absolute
- 12:17loyalty. So speaking more to this, the
- 12:19demand for absolute loyalty is underpinned by a critical
- 12:22psychological phenomenon known as closure.
- 12:25This concept describes a deep seated resistance to
- 12:28contradictory information and an act of refusal to adjust
- 12:31perspectives even in the face of compelling evidence.
- 12:33So This is why when you talk to a friend, a loved 1A family
- 12:37member who's MAGA, it makes you feel like you're going crazy
- 12:41because they can't take any information in and anything you
- 12:43say, they'll just shut it down. It's because of this cognitive
- 12:46closure. What I find is usually it's
- 12:48immediately followed by a straw man argument.
- 12:51I'll say Donald Trump is a felon.
- 12:53They'll say, Oh, well, we've all done things that we don't feel
- 12:57good about. That's not what I'm saying.
- 12:59I'm saying that this person, this elected official is a felon
- 13:02and we're OK with that. So I.
- 13:04Guess you're so perfect you'd never have done anything bad.
- 13:06Right. Maybe we've.
- 13:07All committed crimes or you'll say.
- 13:10I'm really concerned that ICE is a gang of thugs who have 100%
- 13:16permission to do whatever they want, especially after George
- 13:19Floyd protests and every Police Department saying, OK, we're not
- 13:22going to shoot people directly with rubber bullets anymore, OK,
- 13:25we're not going to tear gas innocent crowds anymore.
- 13:27And then that's just out the window.
- 13:28It's like it never happened. But then they'll go, well, worse
- 13:31things are happening in Palestine, Chechnya.
- 13:34I'm not. Talking about that right now,
- 13:36I'm talking about what's happening in Estadios Unidos.
- 13:39Oh, so you like criminals murdering your grandma?
- 13:42I didn't say that. I did like that.
- 13:45So you think it's OK that a group of children should just be
- 13:49rounded up and no. I didn't say.
- 13:51That, and that's not what we're talking about.
- 13:53In a political cult, the leader and the ideology provide
- 13:56definite answers to complex issues.
- 13:58This relates back to the religion thing, because I think
- 14:02when people get heavy, heavy into church, sometimes it's
- 14:06because they want to have the answers and it makes them feel
- 14:09better to have the answers. And I think that this cult is
- 14:12doing the same thing for people. I was having this conversation
- 14:14recently with a friend about our mother.
- 14:17I was saying it's crazy to me that our mother just jumped feet
- 14:21first into this weird religion. But it makes sense to me because
- 14:24our mother does want clear black and white answers.
- 14:28Yeah, surety. And she got it with the Mormon
- 14:31church. They gave it to her 100%.
- 14:33There's no deviation. It's just here's the rules,
- 14:35follow the rules and you'll do great.
- 14:36So any. Challenge to the cult's answers
- 14:39is perceived as a direct threat to the members certainty and
- 14:42sense of belonging. This psychological rigidity
- 14:45creates a a self reinforcing loop where a loyalty is
- 14:47maintained by actively shutting down external information and
- 14:50internal doubt. This is what I've seen when I
- 14:52talk to formerly reasonable people who have drunk the
- 14:56kool-aid. In this cult, when you challenge
- 14:58something that the cult leader has done or said or something
- 15:02the cult is doing, it is perceived as an attack on their
- 15:06personhood, on their individual freedom, certainty, belonging.
- 15:11And they will attack you in that manner is if I've said something
- 15:15to you about something you've done wrong.
- 15:17Because I am Trump. Trump is me.
- 15:19It's like that joke about a woman walks in on her husband in
- 15:24flagrante with, let's say, a lady that he met at the Bikini
- 15:28Coffee place. Is that a place in small towns
- 15:32in Oregon? You will not have a fancy
- 15:35barista coffee shop. You may not even have a
- 15:37Starbucks. And so sometimes what you have
- 15:40is a kiosk with young ladies in lingerie and bikinis making the
- 15:45worst espresso coffee that you've ever had.
- 15:48It's really cold in Portland. Why yes?
- 15:51Why? It's the Hooters of coffee and I
- 15:53don't understand it. So lady walks in on her husband
- 15:56and she says John, you're cheating on me.
- 15:59And he says no, I'm not. Yes, I can see that you are.
- 16:02And he says are you going to believe your eyes or what?
- 16:04I'm telling you? This is the logic.
- 16:06You can only believe what you get from the teat of
- 16:09information. There is an important song of
- 16:11our generation. It wasn't me.
- 16:14Saw you banging in the corner. It wasn't me.
- 16:17Saw you threatening Iran with missiles.
- 16:19It wasn't me. Saw you saying a lady.
- 16:22It wasn't me. Saw you pooping in your
- 16:24underpants. Coming from that, the important
- 16:27thing about a cult is the cultivation of an US versus them
- 16:30mentality, but fosters loyalty and eliminates dissent by
- 16:33constructing clear enemies. Whether racial, national or
- 16:36ideological is seen in fascist regimes or cult members.
- 16:40There is calling other people unenlightened or evil or
- 16:43gentiles. This next part in my research is
- 16:45about social isolation. And this is the danger of
- 16:49knowing MAGA people and doing what I think we we're all
- 16:53tempted to do, which is cut them off entirely, never speak to
- 16:55them again, wear AT shirt that say I'm no longer friends with
- 16:58so and so. The problem is that that
- 17:00isolates them further, and that's what MAGA wants, because
- 17:04the more they can get these people isolated, the more
- 17:06control they have over them. I remember learning that about
- 17:10Fox News. I saw an interview with Roseanne
- 17:12Barr talking with, I think Tucker Carlson about the fact
- 17:15that. My whole family don't talk to
- 17:17me. Right, and he was praising her
- 17:20for it. They want that because they want
- 17:22you to have fewer inputs. The temptation is to say never
- 17:25again. But by doing that you're going
- 17:27to further just push them down the rabbit hole.
- 17:29Both fascist. Regimes and cults employ social
- 17:33separation to create quote, an echo chamber UN quote that
- 17:37reinforces loyalty and suppresses dissent.
- 17:40Members are frequently encouraged to cut ties with
- 17:42their family and friends, severing external support
- 17:45systems. This makes it easier for them to
- 17:47be manipulated. I think it's.
- 17:48Sort of the same as an abusive relationship.
- 17:50What does an abusive person do? The first thing they do is cut
- 17:53you off from everyone in your life.
- 17:55Those thoughts were from the article explaining the Trump
- 17:58loyalty cult phenomenon. So it doesn't matter how
- 18:01partisan we're getting how much Democrats and Republicans hate
- 18:04each other. Yes it does by David Andreatta.
- 18:06How has Republican partisan friendship led to violence?
- 18:10Research suggests that both Republicans and Democrats who
- 18:12are highly polarized or express strong aversion towards the
- 18:15opposing party are more likely to support using violence for
- 18:19political purposes. When you are pushed way out to
- 18:21the extremes, you start to believe that violence is OK and
- 18:25violence is a way to move forward.
- 18:27And I think this is really important in this discussion.
- 18:30Effective partisan polarization can lead to the dehumanization
- 18:33of opposing partisans because then you can treat them however
- 18:35you want. Trump has called migrants
- 18:37animals. I think the simple act of
- 18:40referring to a human being as an illegal that makes it OK to
- 18:44deport them without due process to kidnap them in the middle of
- 18:48a work day or in the middle of the street to.
- 18:50Take a four year old with cancer.
- 18:51Send her to Mexico without any. Support other language that has
- 18:55been used poisoning the blood of our country has been used by
- 18:58trump to describe undocumented immigrants.
- 19:01He also says that immigrants who murder might have quote bad
- 19:05genes, suggesting sub humanity and supporting eugenics.
- 19:09I know we don't like to talk. About it's reminding me of
- 19:12something. It reminds me of something.
- 19:14It's like ringing a bell. Plato talked about selective
- 19:18breathing for the ruling class. That's something we all talk
- 19:20about. That's a favorite.
- 19:22Aristotle encouraged abortion infanticide for children with
- 19:25deformities. Why?
- 19:26Did they listen to these people? You know what?
- 19:28They have a lot of good ideas as well.
- 19:31Not all their ideas were. Bad and Trump has said Dungeons
- 19:34of the Third World, describing the places where some migrants
- 19:37are coming from. He will call his political
- 19:40opponents vermin. Disgusting rat and rodent
- 19:43infested mess was used to describe Baltimore.
- 19:45Look, even if it's true Baltimore, you're still Charm
- 19:48City to me. I remember he was saying S hole
- 19:50countries about places that have a lot of BIPOC folk in them.
- 19:55When you use this language, it softens boundaries.
- 19:59It makes it OK to treat people in a way that they should not be
- 20:03treated. Yeah, there was a man found
- 20:05hanging from a tree recently in New York City.
- 20:08Many pundits pointed out that Trump's 2024 RE election bid
- 20:11became a carnival of misogyny and racism.
- 20:14But that's his selling point. That's not a bug, that's a
- 20:17feature. When he says the stuff in
- 20:19public, it gives everybody permission to come out with
- 20:23their dark feelings and dark thoughts.
- 20:25Maybe I should hang someone from a tree.
- 20:26Maybe I should assassinate a political opponent in the middle
- 20:29of the night. His rhetoric, characterized by
- 20:31violent language and attacks on opponents, is cited as a factor
- 20:35that may contribute to violent actions.
- 20:37His use of terms like bloodbath and references to murderers,
- 20:39rapists and thugs can heighten anxiety among his supporters
- 20:42talking specifically about polarization.
- 20:45Social media gets a lot of stick for polarization and for
- 20:48creating an echo chamber. Effective polarization started
- 20:51growing before the Internet in radio, talk shows and cable
- 20:54news. You got your Rush Limbaugh and
- 20:56your Fox News. It's also growing more swiftly
- 20:58among Americans over 65 years old, a demographic that uses the
- 21:02Internet less but watches television and listens to talk
- 21:04radio far more. The findings suggest that all
- 21:07media, not just social media, are playing a role in this
- 21:11phenomenon. And I'm not saying that social
- 21:13media isn't an echo chamber. It 100.
- 21:15Is my TikTok is very different than MAGA kid TikTok?
- 21:18I don't see anything and I hope that they don't see me because I
- 21:22don't want them to. I remember when I was in high
- 21:24school, my government teacher had us listen to Rush Limbaugh
- 21:28every morning. And I remember this dumb girl in
- 21:32my class crying and saying, what am I going to do?
- 21:36My children see a gay couple holding hands.
- 21:40And I said, you're going to tell your children that those are two
- 21:43people in love? When?
- 21:44It has nothing to do with you, Yeah.
- 21:46What is wrong with you? And I got kicked out of.
- 21:49Class Ah, Texas. The normalization of violence by
- 21:52political leaders in particular may provide a sense that acting
- 21:55violently will be permitted. Or you could be a hero like Kyle
- 21:58Rittenhouse. Was he a hero?
- 22:00Was he maybe the voice of our generation?
- 22:03What do you do if you're loved? 1 is in any cult.
- 22:05Here's the list that I found. You can tell me what you think.
- 22:08As a therapist, maintain positive contact even though
- 22:12it's tempting to say I'm just not going to talk to them
- 22:14anymore. This is for my mental health.
- 22:16This is for my own sanity. Even if it's minimal birthdays
- 22:18and holidays, keep an open door to let the person know there's
- 22:22still a place for them in the group.
- 22:24Former members often report that close family bonds outside the
- 22:27movement were important in their eventual departure from the
- 22:31cult. Avoid shaming or belittling.
- 22:33Do not tell the person they have been brainwashed.
- 22:35This language can make them feel alienated and further entrench
- 22:38their beliefs. How to reduce partisanship and
- 22:41polarization. Gently correct misconceptions
- 22:44about the other party. Correct misperceptions based on
- 22:47identities. Democrats tend to think
- 22:48Republicans are all evangelical old white men.
- 22:52For instance, Democrats have believed that over 1/3 of
- 22:54Republicans earned over 250 KA year, when the reality is that's
- 22:58about 2%. What?
- 23:002% There's so sad, yes, it's so sad because everything the party
- 23:06is doing is for people much richer than that level.
- 23:10They're doing everything they can to destabilize everyone who
- 23:13isn't that. Rich and that's 98% of the party
- 23:16is doing things that actively hurt them.
- 23:19Republicans think Democrats are often members of unions and are
- 23:22more likely to be atheist, sexual minorities, or people of
- 23:25color. They can believe that nearly 1/3
- 23:27of Democrats are members of the LGBT community when the reality
- 23:30is 6%, which is standard percentage.
- 23:32Like ideological misperceptions, these demographic misbeliefs are
- 23:36strongest among those who are more politically informed
- 23:39because we're getting these messages even from our own
- 23:42people that cannot be trusted. In fact, the modal member of the
- 23:46average person in both parties is a middle-aged white, non
- 23:49evangelical Christian. But we're all the same guys.
- 23:52In one set of lab experiments, scholars found that when
- 23:54respondents misperceptions of the demographics of the other
- 23:57party were corrected, polarization decreased.
- 23:59We're all Americans, we're all one people.
- 24:02I was eavesdropping on a conversation recently where a
- 24:05woman said I think all Democrats should be arrested.
- 24:09Agreed. Because she has been fed this
- 24:12line that woke is a terrible thing.
- 24:14It's awful to think about other people and be concerned about
- 24:17their health and safety. It's the worst thing you can be
- 24:20and that all Democrats are just out here drinking baby's blood
- 24:26and committing tax fraud and being welfare Queens.
- 24:30They're getting all this information that they then lump
- 24:33into an incorrect assessment of everybody in the party.
- 24:36And you don't have to be a Democrat to dislike MAGA.
- 24:39OK, feel free. The next step is correct
- 24:41misperceptions based on policies.
- 24:43People who are effectively polarized may dislike each other
- 24:46and be unaware that their policy beliefs may overlap.
- 24:49Sometimes. Multiple studies found that when
- 24:51parties were made aware that they shared beliefs across
- 24:53parties, their polarization declined.
- 24:55Communicate that we're not as different as these two extremes
- 24:59are making us out to be, Right. I actually did this in real life
- 25:03because I got into a conflict with a loved one about the Elon
- 25:08Musk doge situation. You mean how a bunch of
- 25:12unelected drug addicts were being allowed to form policy?
- 25:16And raid our Social Security. I was telling this person that I
- 25:20was heading to a rally and they they said, well, why?
- 25:24Because we're here to celebrate what doge is doing.
- 25:28And then we had a long conversation where I talked
- 25:30about here are the things that I believe that the world should be
- 25:34doing. I feel like what America should
- 25:36be doing. And I want to hear what you
- 25:39believe America should be doing. What do you think we should be
- 25:42spending our time and energy on? And as you said, we had so much
- 25:45overlap. This is why I love you and This
- 25:48is why you're in my life because we do actually have a lot of
- 25:50really similar beliefs. I feel like some of us or
- 25:53drinking from the poison well and.
- 25:55You have to be gentle in these conversations, even though it
- 25:58feels really good when you fight with someone on the Internet.
- 26:01I spent a whole day this week fighting with someone on TikTok
- 26:05about feminism. A lot.
- 26:08I know I should block and delete.
- 26:10I know that this person was just getting my goat.
- 26:12And finally I went and looked at their page and it was all about
- 26:15Roblox and I had been fighting with a 12 year old.
- 26:17But when you're doing it in the moment, you get filled with
- 26:21righteous anger and adrenaline and endorphins and you spend
- 26:25your whole day refreshing your phone.
- 26:26What are you going to say? What are you going to say now
- 26:28and then typing something with your thumbs?
- 26:29And did you know that life is finite and we cannot spend the
- 26:32whole day arguing with a 12 year old?
- 26:34I mean you. Can, but it's going to make your
- 26:37life miserable and I don't believe the whole thing about we
- 26:40can have different politics and still agree.
- 26:42Well, no, I'm not going to sign off that it's OK to deport
- 26:46people and kill people. I am going to maintain a
- 26:49relationship with you because I want to be someone that you can
- 26:53and say well not all Democrats are totally garbage.
- 26:55I know 1 friend. We look at Scientology, this is
- 26:58most of the stories. It was always family members
- 27:02that helped to keep this person in reality a little bit and help
- 27:06to get them out of the cult. Because when?
- 27:08Everyone around you has the same belief as you do, and you feel
- 27:13very safe and you're just echoing it back to each other
- 27:16and then someone else says something that disagrees with
- 27:19it. It feels like you are being
- 27:21attacked, like it's an attack on your personhood, an attack on
- 27:24your individuality. It's important to go into these
- 27:27conversations with a little bit of grace and a lot of patience,
- 27:31and I'm talking to myself as much as anybody else.
- 27:34And I think also love. I feel like love does conquer
- 27:37all. If I approach you with love,
- 27:39it's going to go a lot further than with malice, because malice
- 27:43just. Confirms everything that they've
- 27:45been told about you. I have a lot of clients who are
- 27:47struggling with this particular topic and what they say is,
- 27:51well, I just want to tell the person that they're crazy.
- 27:53And I tell them, just think about something that you believe
- 27:55in very, very strongly. How would you feel if someone
- 27:57just walked up to you on the street and said, wow, you're
- 28:00crazy, you don't know what you're talking about.
- 28:01You would be incredibly offended.
- 28:03So just assume that the strength of your conviction is the same
- 28:06as theirs. Anytime that I have tried to
- 28:10offer my opinion, the first reaction is always
- 28:13defensiveness. And the same with me.
- 28:15When someone has corrected something that I've said or
- 28:17done, my first reaction out-of-the-box is just
- 28:20defensiveness and screw you and screw those people over there
- 28:23and screw everybody you guys hang out with.
- 28:24Later I might reflect and say, OK, well this wasn't totally
- 28:27wrong. In my office, there's another
- 28:30business, and I overheard the receptionist recently saying
- 28:34stuff on a speakerphone that you really shouldn't say.
- 28:36I came in and smiled, and I said, hey, I don't think that
- 28:40you probably know this, but that's breaking the rules of
- 28:43HIPAA and you should stop. And she gave me one of those
- 28:46smiles that contained daggers. But I thought if I had come in
- 28:51really aggressively it would have gone way worse than that.
- 28:53What other good advice is there for people who are managing
- 28:57loved ones who are part of a political cult?
- 29:00I think sticking to the facts is really important before I.
- 29:04I enter into one of these conversations.
- 29:06I try to do my research and verify everything before I say
- 29:10it because sometimes I have flippantly said something and
- 29:13gotten in trouble because there was.
- 29:15They'll look it up and they're like, well, that's not exactly.
- 29:17True. OK.
- 29:18There was a rumor that JD Vance was suggesting that women should
- 29:22have pregnancy tests before they get on an airplane.
- 29:25That was going to become a policy.
- 29:27And it turned out that that was actually not actually based.
- 29:29We all make mistakes. And the person corrected me.
- 29:32And we all have just information.
- 29:34Presented to us all the time and when someone says where did you
- 29:38read that? It's sometimes hard to remember.
- 29:40Was it the New York Times or was it just a Facebook post?
- 29:42Go back in the memory. Was it was it a tic tac or was
- 29:45it a reporter who's paid money in a professional way to report
- 29:49on these things. I just think we're all
- 29:51susceptible to stuff Make sure your facts are right and also
- 29:55check their facts. I had a client who was full Q
- 29:59Anon. I met them during the
- 30:01pandemonium and they were full Q Anon and they really were into
- 30:05this idea about Hillary Clinton selling children in the
- 30:10furniture. And I was like Wayfair.
- 30:12Yeah, we. Order something named Tyler
- 30:14because a child will come to you in a box.
- 30:16I said, OK, let's sit down and let's break it down and see if
- 30:21this is actually true. So we put it into Snopes.
- 30:25It was not true. I wasn't being mean.
- 30:27I was just saying, hey, I know that you've heard this a lot and
- 30:30I know that you're using this as one of your founding beliefs.
- 30:33It's not true. And when you talk about pedos in
- 30:37the political system, let me assure you, hardly any of them
- 30:40are women. OK?
- 30:41When you're saying, oh, Hillary Clinton and all of her child sex
- 30:47slave swapping, let me assure you that women have not
- 30:51traditionally been strong in that area.
- 30:53And in my experience, I've been doing this work for almost 20
- 30:57years, and I probably hear a childhood sexual abuse story
- 31:01probably a couple times a week in my entire career.
- 31:04Two of those stories were women. When we talk about so many
- 31:08people became crazy, indoctrinated and changed
- 31:12personalities during the panda mineral.
- 31:14And why is that? Because we were isolated?
- 31:17Because we were just at home looking at the Internet all day.
- 31:20We were terrified. And that's when they get you.
- 31:23This is something I don't like about either party.
- 31:25Every time we are coming up on a national election, both of the
- 31:28parties try to whip you up into a frenzy of believing that if
- 31:33the other party wins, the world will end.
- 31:36I believe this is just a way to get donations and to scare you
- 31:40into going to the polls. I'm always going to go to the
- 31:42polls, OK? I'm never not going to go.
- 31:45I think that the polarization that results from this kind of
- 31:49rhetoric curses rather than helps us.
- 31:52Absolutely. I hate my phone when any
- 31:54election is coming up. Hey, did you hear the Republican
- 31:57Party is just murdering people? Straight up murder you guys.
- 32:02That's just how political parties operate.
- 32:04Everything is click bait and everything is turned out to the
- 32:07NTH degree. And I think your exercise you
- 32:09mentioned earlier about just following it to the end is very
- 32:13helpful. What if this was 100% true?
- 32:16What's the next thing? How does it affect me?
- 32:18How am I going to get out of it? What does that look like in
- 32:20general? What it looks like to me is
- 32:22there will come a point where we're not going to put up with
- 32:24this anymore. I would have thought it would
- 32:26been long ago, but I'm not always.
- 32:28Right. Laura, you've had some great
- 32:30thoughts and input on this, but what are your final thoughts on
- 32:33this topic of political cults? My understanding with any cult
- 32:37is that you need to have a period where you are
- 32:40deprogramming the person maybe has to have a willingness to at
- 32:45least separate temporarily from the cult.
- 32:48And that's when you get a motel room and you lock them in there
- 32:51and you just make them watch video footage, have information
- 32:54that they have been told not to believe.
- 32:56And then after that, for a couple days, then you can go get
- 32:59McDonald's and all will be well. Ad hoc deprogramming.
- 33:02What an exciting concept. Well, the human mind is so
- 33:06primitive and I really do think malleable.
- 33:10I think that this has been a strength for us somehow
- 33:13genetically over time, to be very easily influenced.
- 33:17I think it helps us to stick in groups and keep ourselves alive.
- 33:21You're talking about the text from these political parties.
- 33:24We are very motivated by fear. The human brain is very
- 33:28motivated by fear. And fear can really rock us to
- 33:31the point where it makes us take action.
- 33:33That's what everyone is counting on, is your fear and your anger.
- 33:36And I think this woman talking about Trump's birthday, birthday
- 33:39party, everybody out there is talking about their fear of
- 33:42BIPOC folks in DC. That's how they're being
- 33:46controlled because they're being told, you know what, this out
- 33:49group, this one that you're not a part of, they're very violent,
- 33:51very dangerous. And I think about Jane Elliott,
- 33:54who did the blue eye experiment where they took children and the
- 33:59children with the blue eyes were treated poorly and the children
- 34:02with the brown eyes were treated well.
- 34:04And it was only a couple of days before the kids really shot in
- 34:08lockstep. Yes.
- 34:09And it works on adults too. We're very, very easily
- 34:13influenced. And I think you just have to
- 34:15watch out for that in yourself and in others.
- 34:17If you have a person in your life that you care about and you
- 34:20can see them kind of going the wrong path, I think just trying
- 34:23to be a consistent part of their life and trying to show them
- 34:27that the stories that they're told about the group that you're
- 34:29a part of, maybe you're not true the.
- 34:32Interesting thing to me. Interesting slash terrifying
- 34:35about directing fears towards immigrants, minorities is that
- 34:41the real danger in this country, at least economically, is from
- 34:46rich people and the 1%. Taking that and redirecting it
- 34:50towards minorities and people from other countries who just
- 34:54want to work a job is a fiendishly clever way of doing
- 34:58it. Putting all that fear onto a
- 35:01group of people who are innocent in order to divert it away from,
- 35:05say, South African billionaires is a great move.
- 35:10Congratulations, what do you think they did on every season
- 35:13of scooby-doo? You take the the real bad guy
- 35:16and just slap a mask on it and make that mask a group of people
- 35:20that you already didn't like. So Virginia, what are your final
- 35:22thoughts on this topic? It's interesting when you were
- 35:24talking earlier about our caveman brains and how we are
- 35:29super motivated by fear and anger.
- 35:32At the core, we're very simple. You sent me a TikTok that I
- 35:35haven't discussed with you, but I'm going to discuss it now.
- 35:37It was about E Jean Carroll and about her trial, which she won
- 35:40and got a settlement for, I think, $84 million.
- 35:43What was the trial about? It was about essay by the
- 35:46sitting president. Oh, so wait a minute, he was a
- 35:49convicted essayer. Yeah, weird.
- 35:51So what the TikTok you sent me was about was because Eugene is
- 35:55older than she was in the 90s when this happened.
- 35:59She had to do a little trick because she had to look effable,
- 36:03because otherwise their monkey brains in the jury are going to
- 36:05look at her and go, well, she's an old woman who would want to
- 36:08sexually assault her. Because sexual assault is all
- 36:10about how attractive someone is. Our brains are simple.
- 36:14We look at one thing, we're like, well, that doesn't make
- 36:16sense to me. She had to use old footage and
- 36:19dress exactly like she did in that footage.
- 36:21So people are like, oh, OK, I see how someone would want to
- 36:24assault her in a dressing room in public.
- 36:27My final thoughts are, are as difficult as it is, try to have
- 36:30patience with loved ones who have gotten in a political realm
- 36:34you don't agree with and don't appreciate.
- 36:36And try to understand that they are attracted to a feeling of
- 36:41safety and security and surety that this party is demonstrating
- 36:45that they have for them. It's all not true, but they've
- 36:48been told we're going to keep you safe from the minorities,
- 36:51from the drag Queens, from the trans women in bathrooms.
- 36:55We're going to keep you safe. Everything that's changing in
- 36:57this society that you're scared of, minorities in Marvel movies,
- 37:01we're going to keep you safe from that.
- 37:02We're going to go back to a suburban world of just smiling
- 37:07white guys in suits. Where everything is predictable
- 37:10and makes sense to you, don't. Worry.
- 37:12Try to have some empathy for that and try to hold some space
- 37:15for that, as difficult as it is. If somebody could give me a
- 37:19sense of certainty about the world and how things are going
- 37:23to go, I would love that. No one's been able to
- 37:25successfully do it, but if anyone has a cult for me to join
- 37:29I would love that. Honestly, when I was 13 years
- 37:31old and I left the church that we grew up in, that was the
- 37:35first thought that I had. I thought I really am going to
- 37:38miss and I'm already missing the sense of surety and confidence
- 37:43that I knew what was going on. I knew what to do in my life.
- 37:47That's going to be a lack for me.
- 37:49But I had already taken the red pill and there was no going
- 37:52back. It was hard for me too, because
- 37:54I remember thinking in the Mormon religion, as long as you
- 37:56follow the rules and you do what you're told, everything's going
- 37:59to work out great in this life and in the afterlife.
- 38:02We had all the answers. It's hard to lose all the
- 38:05answers. It's very challenging.
- 38:06It's hard to go from having a very black and white, simplified
- 38:10way of thinking about the world to looking at nuance and
- 38:12complexity. It is very hard because
- 38:14sometimes it really does hurt your brain because we are just
- 38:17little Cavemen. We want everything to be very
- 38:19simple. It's good or it's bad, it's
- 38:21right or it's wrong. It's the in Group or the out
- 38:23group. In the information that I have
- 38:25acquired in the last month, I don't think there's anything
- 38:27that has left me as angry and confused as the fact that Donald
- 38:30Trump's favorite musical is Les Miserables.
- 38:34Talking about your freaking Gray area.
- 38:36He went with Melania. It was his favorite musical
- 38:39because it was big in the 80s and he hasn't thought about what
- 38:42it means when a man is stealing bread to feed his children and
- 38:45goes to jail. He hasn't thought about what
- 38:48kind of society that is or what the French Revolution is.
- 38:50We don't even know. That he ever thought about that
- 38:53even back then, that's just the statement of a man who has never
- 38:57thought about anything for two seconds and in his entire life.
- 39:01Laura, where can people? Find you on the Internet.
- 39:04If they would like to they can find me at lauraryan.org my
- 39:08professional website. If you'd like to do therapy with
- 39:10me feel free to check me out there and if you're in the state
- 39:13of Texas, if you're not in the state of Texas, so sorry my
- 39:16license does not allow me to work with people outside of the
- 39:19state. If you would like to follow my
- 39:21TikTok, I now have 816 followers at I am Laura Ryan.
- 39:25If you'd like to follow the show on Instagram, you can find Visit
- 39:28My Sisters a Therapist Instagram.
- 39:29You can also go to our website, mysistersatherapist.com.
- 39:33What if people have a question or a show idea or just a comment
- 39:37that they want to send to the show?
- 39:38Well, they can send us an e-mail,
- 39:40hello@mysistersatherapist.com. Perhaps many of your favorite
- 39:43episodes have been provided by other listeners, and you too can
- 39:47be one of those listeners at Virginia.
- 39:49If somebody wants to give us money or pay us to advertise on
- 39:53the show, how would they go about doing that?
- 39:55You could hit us up at Hire us at my Sister's asatherapist.com.
- 39:59We are always open to your ideas.
- 40:02We're ready. We're ready.
- 40:04We will help promote your car, wash your dog, wash your face,
- 40:09wash anything that you want to wash.
- 40:10We're there for it. Virginia, if somebody wanted to
- 40:13follow your comedy career, how would they go about?
- 40:15Doing that, you can find me at my website,
- 40:18wahwahwah.badinia.com. I keep a calendar there, so if
- 40:22you're interested in seeing a show and you're in the Portland
- 40:24area or on the West Coast, you can probably do that.
- 40:27You can also follow my Instagram, which is Vidinia and
- 40:29my TikTok, which is also Vidinia.
- 40:31I want to get a shout out to everybody who has found us from
- 40:34me talking about it on stage. I talked to a young lady in the
- 40:37audience just this week who found us from me talking about
- 40:41how I had a show with my sister, the therapist.
- 40:42We would like to encourage anybody who listens to leave us
- 40:46a positive comment on Apple or on Spotify or anywhere else you
- 40:50can find that says hey, you can leave a comment here.
- 40:52We would like it. It would be appreciated by us
- 40:54if. It is on the wall of a women's
- 40:56bathroom. Anything you want to do, but
- 40:59especially if it's on Apple or Spotify because that's what gets
- 41:01us more listeners like you. Speaking of Laura, sometimes you
- 41:04like to share a nice comment, review, or e-mail that someone
- 41:08has sent to us. Do you have one this week?
- 41:09In fact, I do. I have an e-mail that somebody
- 41:12sent to hello@mysisterstherapist.com and
- 41:15it is from KDK. Hello.
- 41:17I was just listening to your It's Not About You episode.
- 41:20And buddy, oh boy, what is the timing?
- 41:22Spot on for me. I run a very small business with
- 41:25fewer than 10 employees, and this week one of them asked for
- 41:28fewer hours over the summer for reasons that, after the reality
- 41:31check of the episode, no longer make any sense.
- 41:33This felt very personal, and I'm embarrassed to admit my feelings
- 41:37were hurt. But it's not about me.
- 41:39I know. Duh bro.
- 41:40Didn't quit, had no negative feedback, just wanted some extra
- 41:43home time. Thank you for helping me remove
- 41:45my head from my own bottom. It helped.
- 41:48Thank you Katie. You're so welcome, Katie.
- 41:50I'm so glad that that was helpful.
- 41:52It's certainly a concept that has been helpful for me many,
- 41:55many times. Hence, the episode was created.
- 41:58It all leads to one thing, which is take your head out of your
- 42:01butt hole. And also, while we're on that
- 42:03topic, if you have a friend who you think could really benefit
- 42:07from our podcast, shoot them over to my sisters,
- 42:10thetherapist.com. Do you have a friend who could
- 42:14benefit from some honestly free and pretty good mental health
- 42:17advice? Free and pretty good.
- 42:20If they've only seen Lucy up to now from the Peanuts gang who
- 42:24gives 5 cent psychological support in her booth, then maybe
- 42:28they might like this better. And it costs less.
- 42:31It's zero cents. And in the words of someone
- 42:33who's inspired us very much, Billy Ray Valentine, Capricorn,
- 42:37we can make it baby, me and you. Bye.
- 42:41Bye.