Latest / Thrive In Five / Beyond The Performance
Transcript
- David Osgathorp: Okay, so I'm joined by Hugh Bird, who is head of vehicle suspension and trackside support at Oracle Red Bull Racing. We're going to talk through the debrief process within an F1 team and also personal debrief process that Hugh's put together. So Hugh, for someone that hasn't experienced Formula One, can you give us a little overview of what a race weekend debrief looks like and why it's a real crucial part of performance within the team? Yeah, so debriefing is something which we do in various different stages. you've probably all seen it on Drive to Survive where you have those big debriefs after a session and everyone's sat in the engineering office, headsets on, the driver's doing their bit and the engineers are doing their bit. But that's just one aspect of it. We're debriefing continuously through the weekend. So after every run, Carl will come back in the garage, the driver will give us a debrief of how that run went. We'll play them asking them suitable questions to provide what we're doing through the rest of that session. Then we go into a bigger debrief post-session, as you've seen on Drive to Survive, where the driver has their say, the engineers in the team have their say, have a bit of a round robin for urgent fault finding. And then it goes beyond that and we're having even bigger debriefs post-event. trying to look at the bigger picture of the whole performance. I suppose if we're focusing on those post-session debriefs, that's really critical in terms of getting everyone on the same page. We're in those sessions, they can be hugely busy, things get easily missed. A lot of the guys are listening to 10, 20 radio channels, they're not necessarily focused on the specifics of what's happening on one of the cars or the other car. So having that opportunity to sit down and hear first hand from the driver their experiences of that session is critical really to get everyone on the same page. suppose another aspect of it is it's a big team which is operating through a session, it's not just the driver. So typically we're there with 20 engineers or so at the track and another 20 or 30 back in the Oxfam. They're not all going to contribute in these debriefs. but they'll be feeding into some of the more senior members of the team. So everyone can contribute their relevant experiences of the session and everyone can also listen to what the driver and the rest of the team have to say about what's just happened. That's fascinating. I really like that Hugh. think what you've said about getting everyone on the same page. I think it's really easy for you, whatever role you're performing and whatever world you're operating on that we have focused solely on. the thing that we're doing and maybe not looking at the bigger picture there. So I think that's really valuable in terms of just, like you said, getting everyone on the same page. From your perspective, is there anything that comes out of it that you really feel helps to improve that team performance element from that? It's building a real focus. So there's always going to be issues with the car, issues with the performance areas for improvement, but what are the key areas to focus on? And then the team can work as one to address those challenges. Definitely. I'll just share that Hugh's just joined me for this today after a challenging race weekend and where I think inevitably emotions are high immediately after the race. And actually he just shared as he came in that it was a really productive team briefing. today when you remove the emotion a few days later. So again, probably that window of when those debriefs take place is possibly determines whether that's a positive or negative kind of outcome at times, I'm sure. Yeah, I think it's important to get both aspects of it. Immediately after the event when the emotions are high gives you one picture and then taking the time again a couple of days later when people have slept on it and can look at things a little bit more objectively with. slightly less emotion in it, gives another picture. And it's both equally insightful and valuable things to listen to. Yeah, definitely. So just taking that from the F1 world, if we were to kind of look at that in a more corporate environment, if you were advising like a senior leadership team on what lessons a Formula One debrief could teach, what would you advise on them to adopt from that perspective? I think there's probably... two things which really jumped out to me over my time here. Debriefing in and of itself is a skill, whether you're the person that is debriefing your experience of a session or whether you're someone that's in the room listening to someone's debrief and maybe trying to ask questions and probe it. Particularly in those more time-pressured situations where emotion might be high, it's all too easy for the person. who is debriefing their experiences to let that skew what they're saying. So it takes a real skill set to compose yourself and objectively look at what's just happened and what are the issues that actually need to be addressed before you go out for the next session, for the next run. And in that, you know, that emotional response is a fact of life. It's human beings which we're dealing with. And so that's then where... the people working with them have to have that skill set as well of, okay, I hear that emotion in your voice, but let's just take a step back and try and focus down on things which are particularly relevant. Yeah, and make slightly more calculated judgments rather than purely emotional ones. That's a really powerful skill, I think. Is that something that you've developed over your time here? Do you feel that you've always had that? Is that something that's coached or discussed? It's something which we discussed as a group of engineers when we post-season, when we had a bit more downtime, and we could look at the points through the season and perhaps where some drivers were doing a better job, not necessarily in driving, but in the bits around the driving and what skill set made a good driver. So I had two things. And then the other thing then was also... changing up, mixing up who speaks when within a debrief. One of the things which has jumped out to me over my time is perhaps when you've got someone who's slightly more experienced and someone who's slightly more junior, if the more experienced person speaks first, the more junior person might tend to be skewed towards saying something similar. if you flip it around and the more junior person speaks first, then they're more likely to give their actual first-hand experience. So that's something we do routinely and every week we change which driver, which engineering crew speak first and get very different results depending on how that goes. That's really powerful. think we all need routines and processes and I think it can just be the easy way that the same person leads and switches off and people follow suit. But I think you've shared a few of those stories with me over the years where it is very easy for someone to just go along with what's previously been said. But yeah, if you've got a lead and actually come up with your opinion first off, makes it a little bit different. When you're there and whoever's gone second in their debrief and they say something completely different from what they were saying in session, like, hang on, is that what you're truly believing? You've had time to reflect on things? It's always that. Because of some other influence. Well, that's probably ties in nicely. So we mentioned you being a head of vehicle suspension and trackside support at the moment, but in a previous life you were a race engineer here and you worked very closely with some of the drivers. So do you want to share a little bit around that sort of time and who you work with and how that works out for you? Good, bad and the ugly, so to speak? Yeah, so I've spent seven years trackside, so three years as performance engineer with Max and then four years as race engineer with TREKCO where I was the central engineer directly working with the driver. In the highest of highs and the lowest of lows it was a spectacular four years and we've won our fair share of races and we were on the other side of the garage when Max won more than his fair share of races. He probably deserved them, but yeah, not necessarily the easiest place to be when you're sat on the other side of the garage and not necessarily having the performances which you're seeing going on there. Yeah, so that period where maybe the results didn't always reflect the quality of work that you were doing. How did that experience change the way that you evaluated your own performance? Because I think it's easy from any kind of sporting perspective to determine the result. on whether things went well or not, but how did you reflect on that? Yeah, certainly you've got a fairly black and white evaluation of how the weekend's on Sunday evening. Before, this industry, there always seems to be a reason to have a beer on a Sunday night. You're either celebrating or you're commiserating. It's very rare that you have that grey weekend and you come away going, that was fine, nothing special one way or the other. But what I developed through my time track side was a way of trying to objectively analyse my personal performance in the context of the race weekend, whether we won or lost. Could I look back on my performance over the weekend when I'm on the plane on Sunday night with satisfaction that I had contributed all that I could to the performance of the car or if I had... fallen short in some areas, then giving me a bit of awareness of what I need to focus on and try and reflect on as to why I might have fallen short. So ultimately in the last couple of years when I was track side, I developed this tool where immediately after the, particularly the key sessions, qualifying and race sessions, I would rank myself just a one to five score on my performance personally. focused on really those key skills to do my job, whether that was sort technical management of the car, communication with the driver, with the engineers operationally, and try and really decouple my personal performance from the car's ultimate performance within that session so that I could look back on that session hopefully more often than not with pride that I knew that I had contributed what I could to to make it as successful as possible. I remember you sharing this with me a while ago and just thinking how powerful this was because I think you also shared that there was some pretty tough times there where you turn up and I think you share with me when Max won the championship and you basically take away all of Chekhov's points and he still would have won the Constructors' Championship with it and I think at the time when that... happened was a pretty brutal weekend. It's quite hard to walk away kind of feeling a sense of satisfaction because when we're always focused on the outcome and I think if you're looking at that in a corporate perspective there's always sales figures, end-of-year results, targets that are either met or missed. It's really difficult to remove yourself and I think this became something really powerful that you developed for yourself in that time. Yeah it wasn't always easy to take the emotion out of it that particular scenario you say even weekend in Japan when We won the Constructors' Championship and, yeah, Txeko, we had one of the toughest race weekends of our time together. Certainly the emotions were pretty high after that and not the, well, not in line with the rest of the team who were at the time celebrating the championship. Yeah, then that evening with a bit of time and space to reflect on my personal performance. Yeah, puts things into a bit of perspective and helps to to deal with Yeah, those perhaps more short-term highs and lows of driven by the result of the session Now brilliant I am I love that I love the whole you know, the the process that you've created there I think that when we've got structure you that you follow within an organization you've then developed something that really worked from your own perspective to understand your performance and how you can kind of continue to develop irrelevant of that outcome that's outside of your control. You created something that was fully within your control. If you were to kind of suggest one thing that any leader listening to this could take from Formula One and create a habit that would improve their performance or the performance of their team, what would you encourage them to start doing? Well, just I'm going to go with a couple of things again. Just in that, in the concept of what we've just been talking about, by having that objective assessment of my personal performance, ultimately that did give me the data to take a step back, look at my performance over a number of races over the season and try and draw some trends and work out what was important for me. Ultimately... I was there to... I took satisfaction from performing to my best on a Sunday and not necessarily the social side around the race weekend, which was a slightly different motivation from people up and down the pit lane. I'm sorry, for me, when there was the opportunity to go out for dinner on a Saturday night, I could tally that up with perhaps when I didn't perform to my best on a Sunday, and so that was a higher priority for me to... get good night's sleep, make sure I went through my routine and performed to my best on Sunday. Just one slight tangent then also which F1 has this wonderful habit which improves performance up and down the pit lane and should absolutely be encouraged and that is just the whole attitude to exercise. as I said, tangent for what we've been talking about today. throughout the weekend, we have this quite strict timetable of when we're allowed to work, when we're allowed to be at the track. Yeah, mandating that we have so many hours away from the track overnight to rest up in contrast to years gone by. One of the things that introduced a couple of years ago was these one hour slots, Wednesday evening, Thursday evening, dedicated to exercise period. It's become a real standard within the industry that people will go out, run, cycle, walk the track, get that bit of exercise in on that Thursday evening, Saturday evening, clearing the head after a potentially stressful day. You're not allowed to work within the confines of the track, you're just allowed to exercise or you have to go home. throughout the highs and lows of my time track side, yeah, never felt worse for that opportunity. Hugh, you've just touched on something that I didn't realise we were going to talk about now. I think we've opened up a whole other conversation. Maybe we can continue this with a second conversation later on. Is that all right with you? Yeah, absolutely. Perfect. Thank you for your time today.