Latest / Taylor Tailored / Britain’s Welfare State Just Crossed a Line: Why Starmer Owns the Fallout Now
Transcript
- 0:00Britain's welfare state just crossed a line.
- 0:02Why? Starmer owns the fallout now.
- 0:05Official forecasts now show UK Social Security spending edging
- 0:09above income tax receipts. That is more than a fiscal
- 0:13curiosity. It is a warning about
- 0:15stagnation, aging, sickness, political drift and a country
- 0:19asking too much of too few taxpayers.
- 0:22The number that should stop Westminster in its tracks.
- 0:25Britain has reached a symbolic and politically dangerous
- 0:28threshold. Official forecasts show UK
- 0:31Social Security spending at £334 billion in 202526, while income
- 0:39tax is projected to raise roughly £331 billion in the same
- 0:43year. In plain English, the state is
- 0:45now expected to spend slightly more on benefits and welfare
- 0:49than it raises from the single biggest tax most working people
- 0:52see on their pay slip. That matters because this is not
- 0:55some obscure Treasury quirk. Income tax is the emotional core
- 1:00of the tax system. It is the deduction millions of
- 1:03workers notice every month when welfare overtakes it.
- 1:07The country does not just get a new fiscal fact, it gets a new
- 1:11political story. And that story is combustible.
- 1:15Britain already expects public spending of £1.37 trillion in
- 1:19202526, with a deficit of around £138 billion in debt, near 95%
- 1:27of GDP. This means the welfare milestone
- 1:31lands in a country that is already borrowing heavily,
- 1:34already taxed hard and already short on obvious room for error.
- 1:38This is bigger than a headline friendly comparison.
- 1:41The easy version of this story is outrage.
- 1:44Handouts higher than income tax system, broken country gone mad.
- 1:49That reaction will be common because it feels intuitive, but
- 1:53the deeper truth is harsher. This is not just about welfare
- 1:57generosity. It is about a state and an
- 2:00economy that have both become structurally weaker.
- 2:03Welfare is rising because Britain is older, sicker, more
- 2:07housing stressed and less productive than it should be.
- 2:10Taxes are rising because governments keep squeezing A
- 2:13narrow tax base harder rather than building a faster growing
- 2:16economy. Labour did not invent all of
- 2:18those problems, but it now governs them, defends them and
- 2:22increasingly adds to them. That is why this moment matters.
- 2:26It signals not just higher spending, but a country drifting
- 2:30into a model where weak growth, rising dependency and political
- 2:34avoidance feed each other. The ranked reasons Britain got
- 2:37here are one an ageing country is driving welfare higher.
- 2:42The largest single force is demographic.
- 2:45Around 55% of Great Britain's Social Security spending goes to
- 2:49pensioners and the UK is forecast to spend £177.8 billion
- 2:55on pensioner benefits in Great Britain alone in 202526,
- 3:00including £146.1 billion on the state pension.
- 3:04The OBR says larger pensioner cohorts in the triple lock are
- 3:08major reasons welfare spending keeps rising.
- 3:11This is why the lazy line that welfare is simply money for
- 3:14people not working is incomplete.
- 3:17A huge share is pension spending.
- 3:20But politically that does not rescue labour.
- 3:23It actually sharpens the pressure because the tax burden
- 3:26falls on the working age population while the spending
- 3:29pressure increasingly comes from age-related commitments that
- 3:32governments are too frightened to touch.
- 3:34Two health related benefits have surged.
- 3:37The second driver is the post pandemic explosion in incapacity
- 3:42and disability spending. The OBR says incapacity
- 3:45caseloads are forecast to rise from 3.4 million to 4 million
- 3:50between 202425 and 2030 to 31, while disability caseloads rise
- 3:57from 6.5 million to 8.8 million. The Resolution Foundation says
- 4:02real term spending on working age, disability and incapacity
- 4:05benefits has already risen by 19 billion pounds since 20/19/20
- 4:10and is set to rise by a further £13 billion between 20/24/25 and
- 4:1620/29/30. That is not a marginal trend, it
- 4:20is a major shift in the shape of the state.
- 4:22Britain is carrying a larger population of people
- 4:25economically inactive through ill health, and governments
- 4:28still do not have a convincing answer to whether this is mainly
- 4:31a public health problem, a labor market problem, an incentives
- 4:34problem or all three at once. Three, Britain's growth model is
- 4:40too weak to outrun the bill. Public sector income is forecast
- 4:44at £1.232 trillion in 202526, but spending is forecast higher
- 4:51at £1.37 trillion. Taxes are rising, yet the state
- 4:56is still not catching up. That is the signature of a
- 4:59sluggish economy. The government keeps taking
- 5:02more, but the country is not generating enough productive
- 5:05growth to make the burden feel sustainable.
- 5:08This is where Labour is especially exposed.
- 5:12It's sold competence, stability and seriousness.
- 5:15But competence is not just keeping markets calm.
- 5:19Competence is creating enough growth so that higher welfare
- 5:23pressures do not immediately become a fairness crisis for
- 5:26workers and businesses. So far, that broader fix is
- 5:30still missing. 4 The tax base is being squeezed rather than
- 5:34broadened. The OBR expects the tax take to
- 5:37keep rising, with national accounts taxes reaching 38.5% of
- 5:42GDP by 203031, a historical high in its forecast.
- 5:47Much of that increase comes from personal taxes.
- 5:50In other words, Britain is not escaping its spending problem
- 5:54through prosperity. It is trying to grind through it
- 5:57by taking more from earnings and work.
- 5:59That makes the welfare over income tax comparison
- 6:02politically toxic. People can just about tolerate a
- 6:06large state when they believe work pays, taxes are fair, and
- 6:10dependency is tightly controlled.
- 6:12They become far angrier when the state looks expensive, punitive,
- 6:16and ineffective all at once. 5 successive governments ducked
- 6:21hard reforms. This did not begin in 2024.
- 6:25The roots run back years. Anemic productivity, demographic
- 6:29pressure, housing costs, poor health, afraid contributory
- 6:33principle and repeated political cowardice over pensions,
- 6:36worklessness and state efficiency.
- 6:39But the fact Labour inherited a mess does not let Labour off.
- 6:44Governing means owning the numbers in front of you, not
- 6:48just the ones you inherited. 6 Labour has made the politics
- 6:52harder for itself. Here is the uncomfortable part
- 6:55for Starmer. Labour is trying to cut some
- 6:58work disincentives at the margin by lowering the new Universal
- 7:01Credit health element for some claimants and pairing that with
- 7:04employment support. At the same time.
- 7:07It has also removed the two child limit from Universal
- 7:09Credit from April 6th 2026, a move it says will help lift
- 7:14hundreds of thousands of children out of poverty.
- 7:17Both positions can be morally arguable, but politically they
- 7:21pull in opposite directions. Labour wants to say it is
- 7:24tougher on welfare incentives and more generous on family
- 7:28poverty. At the same time, the public
- 7:30often hears something simpler. The bill is still going up, the
- 7:34lines are still blurry, and the government still cannot tell a
- 7:37clean story about limits. The problems this will cause a
- 7:41deeper fairness revolt among workers.
- 7:44This is the most immediate risk. Workers already see high
- 7:48deductions, weak wage growth, expensive housing and stretched
- 7:52services. If they increasingly conclude
- 7:54that the state takes heavily from work but rewards dependence
- 7:58too loosely, the legitimacy of the system starts to rot.
- 8:01That does not require the public to oppose all welfare.
- 8:05It just requires a growing number of taxpayers to believe
- 8:07the balance is wrong. A harsher battle between
- 8:10generations. Because so much welfare spending
- 8:13is pension related, Britain is drifting into a difficult
- 8:17political shape. Older voters are heavily
- 8:19protected, while younger working age taxpayers face high housing
- 8:23costs, frozen thresholds and weaker asset ownership That can
- 8:27become a slow burn generational grievance if growth does not
- 8:31improve. More pressure for tougher
- 8:33conditionality. As the bill rises, so will
- 8:36demands for sharper tests, stricter assessments, more work
- 8:40requirements and closer scrutiny of health related claims.
- 8:44Some of that may be justified, some of it may be crude, but the
- 8:48political pressure will intensify.
- 8:50Either way, Laboux's own reforms already reflect that reality.
- 8:54A stronger opening for reform and the populist right.
- 8:58This is exactly the kind of number insurgent parties love.
- 9:02Simple, symbolic and emotionally explosive.
- 9:06You pay in. They take out is politically
- 9:09potent even when the underlying system is more complex.
- 9:12If Labour cannot explain the bill or control it, others will
- 9:16weaponize it. A credibility problem for
- 9:18Labour's entire economic pitch. Labour came in promising
- 9:22seriousness, but if the public sees a government presiding over
- 9:26record tax pressure, expanding welfare commitments, stubborn
- 9:30inactivity and weak household improvement, seriousness starts
- 9:34to look like managed decline with better presentation.
- 9:37What media misses, What media misses?
- 9:40The real scandal is not merely that welfare is higher than
- 9:44income tax. The real scandal is that Britain
- 9:46can now simultaneously have very high welfare spending and a very
- 9:50high tax burden, while still leaving huge numbers of people
- 9:53feeling insecure, overtaxed, unhealthy, unproductive and
- 9:58badly served. That changes the meaning of the
- 10:01whole debate. This is not simply a fight
- 10:03between generosity and cruelty or compassion and austerity.
- 10:07It is a fight over whether the British state still turns vast
- 10:11spending into social strength. More and more voters suspect it
- 10:16does not. Public backlash is no longer
- 10:19hypothetical. The backdrop for this story is
- 10:22already ugly for Labour. By the end of 2025, You Gov
- 10:26found 72% of Britons had an unfavorable opinion of Keir
- 10:30Starmer and 71% had an unfavorable opinion of Rachel
- 10:34Reeves. That does not prove welfare
- 10:37spending alone is driving the backlash, but it tells you
- 10:40something important. Labour is entering this fight
- 10:42from a position of political weakness, not strength.
- 10:46That matters because numbers like this become lightning rods
- 10:49when governments are already distrusted.
- 10:52A government with political capital can ask voters for
- 10:55patience. A government low on trust gets
- 10:58accused of drift, unfairness and ideological evasiveness.
- 11:02What happens next? The most likely next phase is a
- 11:06nastier argument about who the welfare state is for not whether
- 11:10Britain should have one, but what it should protect first,
- 11:13what behaviour it should reward and who should carry the bill.
- 11:16The most dangerous next phase is that the debate gets flattened
- 11:20into slogans. Workers versus claimants,
- 11:23strivers versus skivers, pensioners versus the young.
- 11:27That would be politically useful for some, but intellectually
- 11:30lazy and socially corrosive. The most underestimated next
- 11:34phase is a legitimacy crisis around taxation itself.
- 11:38If people believe the state is too expensive to fund, too weak
- 11:41to reform and too unwilling to reward work, the anger will not
- 11:46stay confined to welfare. It will spread to tax,
- 11:49migration, housing, public services and the whole argument
- 11:53about what Britain now is. Laboux's problem is not that the
- 11:57number exists, it is that the number fits the mood.
- 12:01Starmer will say, with some justification, that many of
- 12:05these pressures were inherited. He will say Britain was left
- 12:08with an economy too weak, a welfare system too passive and
- 12:12social damage too deep to repair quickly.
- 12:14Some of that is true. But politics is not a seminar in
- 12:18inherited constraints. Politics is ownership, and right
- 12:23now Labour owns a country where welfare is above income tax, the
- 12:26tax burden is climbing, health related inactivity is high,
- 12:30pension pressure is rising and the public is losing patience.
- 12:34That is why this moment matters. Not because one line in the
- 12:38fiscal tables crossed another, but because it captures, in a
- 12:41single brutal comparison the fear that modern Britain is
- 12:45becoming a state that costs more, takes more, explains less
- 12:49and solves less. And once voters start to believe
- 12:52that the backlash does not stay on a spreadsheet, it turns into
- 12:56politics.