Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Los Angeles' New Requirements for CCP 170.6 Peremptory Challenges
Transcript
- 0:03We are really pleased for all of you to join
- 0:05us. We are discussing Los Angeles's new requirements
- 0:09for CCP 170 .6, peremptory challenges. My name
- 0:13is Natasagafi. I'm vice chair of BHBA's litigation
- 0:17section and a personal injury attorney at Panache
- 0:21Raviputi. I am so pleased to introduce Judge
- 0:26Riff today and moderate this discussion. Judge
- 0:28Riff has a great Many accolades, but I'll introduce
- 0:32him with just a few. He is supervising judge
- 0:35of the civil division for the Los Angeles Superior
- 0:37Court. Judge Riff was appointed to the Los Angeles
- 0:41Superior Court in 2015. His civil assignments
- 0:45have included complex civil, IC, and dedicated
- 0:48trial court. He also served in the family law
- 0:52division as supervising judge, dedicated trial
- 0:55court, and home court. Before judicial service,
- 0:58Judge Riff was a partner of the international
- 1:00law firm Steptoe and Johnson, where he served
- 1:03as the firm's managing partner for its Los Angeles
- 1:06office for 17 years and practice group leader
- 1:10for the firm's US toxic tort and environmental
- 1:13litigation practice group. So we're going to
- 1:17get straight into things, Judge Riff. And again,
- 1:19thank you for joining us. Judge Riff, I want
- 1:22to talk about the JO versus Superior Court of
- 1:25San Joaquin County decision, which changed the
- 1:28landscape for CCP Section 170 .6 challenges.
- 1:32For those listeners today who have not read the
- 1:36decision, can you give us a high level summary
- 1:39of the decision and explain how it changed the
- 1:42landscape? I can, and thank you for having me.
- 1:45It's always a pleasure to talk to my friends
- 1:48of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. So the
- 1:52subject matter of today's discussion and of the
- 1:56J .O. decision is bad faith blanket challenges
- 2:02made under 170 .6. Bad faith blanket. Those are
- 2:08two conditions. So before I get into the decision,
- 2:11let me tell you what is not a topic of discussion
- 2:15today and what has not changed. 170 .6 challenges.
- 2:20The statute itself, I should say, remains constitutional,
- 2:24remains operative. And if counsel or a party
- 2:29is willing to sign under penalty of perjury that
- 2:32he, she, or it has a good faith belief that the
- 2:35judge is prejudiced, then without further question
- 2:38or inquiry that assuming the 170 .6 is timely,
- 2:44the case will be reassigned. OK, so. And I will
- 2:49just tell you, in the civil division and in the
- 2:53family law division, that is going to be almost
- 2:56all 170 .6s. Nothing about JO or our new general
- 3:02order touches and concerns most 170 .6s. That's
- 3:10number one. Number two, nothing I'm going to
- 3:12talk about today effects or changes or touches
- 3:17and concerns, 170 .3 slash 170 .1 challenges
- 3:23for cause, statements of disqualification for
- 3:27cause. What we are talking about is when there
- 3:35appears to be or may be a 170 .6 challenge, which
- 3:39is part of a bad faith blanket challenge policy.
- 3:46Now, we've had 170 .6s for roughly 50 years in
- 3:53California. And for roughly 50 years, it has
- 3:56been the law, good faith, bad faith, blanket
- 3:59or not, the law has been that no judge may look
- 4:03behind the 170 .6 challenge to find out if it's
- 4:08really made in good faith, if somebody really
- 4:10believes the judge is prejudiced, or is it really
- 4:13just a matter of I don't want to drive to Pomona
- 4:17for my trial, so I'm going to file paper on a
- 4:20judge out there. That rule was a Supreme Court
- 4:25case called Solberg, and it's a 48, 49 -year
- 4:30-old precedent. You know, there's really been
- 4:37no inquiry into 170 .6s. Now, let me tell you
- 4:41what happened in the J .O. case, which changed
- 4:44that. There was a judge up in San Joaquin County,
- 4:48Judge Guy Castillo, who's sitting in a probate
- 4:52assignment and hearing conservatorship matters.
- 4:56And County Council is a party in conservatorship
- 5:00matters. Well, according to the allegations in
- 5:02the J .O. case, Judge Guy Castillo had publicly
- 5:06admonished a member of the county council's office
- 5:11for doing something apparently wrong or bad.
- 5:15And in a retaliatory concerted action, every
- 5:22county council lawyer who had a conservatorship
- 5:27case assigned to Judge Guy Castillo papered her.
- 5:30So, in the course of four months, she received
- 5:33325 peremptory challenges. Now, she accepted
- 5:39the challenge in J .O. because under Solberg,
- 5:43she had no choice. It was timely presented, so
- 5:46she accepted it. The case got reassigned to another
- 5:52judge, Judge Eagle, up there in San Joaquin County.
- 5:56while in Judge Eagle's hands, the petitioner,
- 6:00J .O., himself, filed an objection. It said,
- 6:06I object to County Council's 170 .6 challenge
- 6:10against Judge Guy Castillo. I object because
- 6:14it is in bad faith and it is a violation of the
- 6:19separation of powers under the California Constitution.
- 6:22Judge Eagle, relying on Solberg said, well, that's
- 6:28very interesting. Your objection is denied, overruled,
- 6:31because I'm not permitted to inspect that. Well,
- 6:35up it went on appeal, and the Supreme Court in
- 6:39the J .O. decision on May 28 changed the law.
- 6:44It overruled Solberg in part such that now, When
- 6:52there is evidence, or appears to be evidence,
- 6:56that a challenge is part of a bad faith blanket
- 7:01policy, the court is, as the Supreme Court said,
- 7:06no longer helpless, no longer helpless to inquire
- 7:10into the merits of the challenge, whether it
- 7:15is in good faith and bad faith. Solberg got overruled
- 7:20to that extent. The other thing that the California
- 7:23Supreme Court did, or another thing, is it created
- 7:26a whole new process that it likened to a Batson
- 7:33Wheeler -like challenge. Batson Wheeler, Batson
- 7:37refers to the 1986 U .S. Supreme Court case,
- 7:41which permitted examination of peremptory challenges
- 7:46to trial jurors that are apparently based on
- 7:50race, ethnicity, or some other immutable characteristic.
- 7:54And as you may remember from Batson and Wheeler
- 7:57in our state, it's a three -part process. Step
- 8:04one is, is there a prima facie showing? Let me
- 8:08make it about 170 .6. under the J -O three -part
- 8:14new process, the first step, step one is, is
- 8:21there evidence sufficient to create a prima facie
- 8:25showing, prima facie showing that the challenge
- 8:29is or may be part of a bad faith blanket challenge?
- 8:32If so, then it goes to step two. Now, Another
- 8:39judge, not the challenge judge, another judge
- 8:42holds a merits hearing where the burden of proof
- 8:46has now shifted to the party filing the paper,
- 8:49making the challenge to articulate a good faith
- 8:54basis for the 170 .6. And if that judge determines,
- 9:02yes, that is a good faith challenge, well, then
- 9:05the 170 .6 is valid. The case is reassigned.
- 9:08and life goes on. If the judge decides, no, it
- 9:12is a bad faith challenge under JO, well, then
- 9:17the 170 .6 is stricken and the case remains with
- 9:21the challenge judge. So that is a high level
- 9:27overview of what happened in JO. Now, just a
- 9:32couple of things I want to mention now before
- 9:34going further. I guess the question comes up,
- 9:42well, who can make the objection? In J .O. it
- 9:47was the other party. The other party raised their
- 9:50hand and said, I object to the other side's 170
- 9:53.6. Well, as you know, in civil, for example,
- 9:57there is no other side for a very long time.
- 10:00You know, plaintiff files the complaint, the
- 10:02case gets assigned, plaintiff's office files
- 10:05a one. 170 .6, the defendant hasn't been served.
- 10:10The defendant may not be served for weeks, months,
- 10:12or even years down the road. So there is no other
- 10:16side really to make an objection at the front
- 10:20end. So the question arose, well, can the challenged
- 10:25judge make the objection? Or can a supervisory
- 10:30judge? Like a supervising judge or a or an arraignment
- 10:35calendar judge can hear she make the objection
- 10:37I just want to point out that the California
- 10:40Supreme Court Explicitly in paragraph 10 of the
- 10:45decision said we are not going to decide We are
- 10:48not going to reach the question whether a judge
- 10:51may Sue Espante Raise an objection or make an
- 10:55inquiry, but I do want our listeners to understand
- 10:59that the Superior Court of LA County has a point
- 11:02of view on this question. And it is that, yes,
- 11:06the challenged judge or a supervisory judge may
- 11:11in the first instance make an objection or commence
- 11:21the inquiry as to whether there is or is not
- 11:24a prima facie showing. On July 28, the Superior
- 11:30Court of Los Angeles issued a new general order
- 11:34relating to 170 .6 challenges following the J
- 11:39.O. decision. Tell us about that. Yes, we did.
- 11:42We did do that. And I urge all to read it. I
- 11:47forwarded that as some material for this webinar.
- 11:51And I think the bar will be making it available
- 11:54to you all. who have signed up. But look, the
- 12:00general order, I'm going to give you the guts
- 12:04of the general order, then I will tell you a
- 12:06little bit of the policy behind it. The general
- 12:09order requires that when a party is exercising
- 12:13a 170 .6 now, after July 28, that the party supply
- 12:19contemporaneously some additional information.
- 12:23And the additional information to be supplied
- 12:26along with the 170 .6 is the number of cases,
- 12:32not only the number, but the name and case number
- 12:35of any other case in the preceding 12 months
- 12:40where that law firm or that party has exercised
- 12:44a challenge against this same judge. You got
- 12:49it? So let me say it again. The party exercising
- 12:55the 170 .6, normally a law firm and civil, needs
- 12:59to supply contemporaneously a listing of other
- 13:07cases where that law firm or that party has challenged
- 13:13that same judge in the preceding 12 months. Now,
- 13:17why are we doing that? We're doing that because
- 13:20we're concerned about blanket challenges. We're
- 13:23not concerned about one -offs. We're concerned
- 13:26about blanket challenges. Now, we'll talk maybe
- 13:29in a minute about how to define blanket. But
- 13:32I want to tell you that our general order has
- 13:36an exemption, which I think is going to apply
- 13:39to almost everybody in the community. The exemption
- 13:43is if If the law firm or the party has filed
- 13:48two or fewer 170s against that judge, they're
- 13:53exempt from the general order requirement. And
- 13:56two or fewer within what duration? 12 months.
- 14:00Within 12 months. Okay. Now, what happens if
- 14:07a party does not supply that information under
- 14:10the general order? Several things could happen.
- 14:14Let me tell you what won't happen and what can't
- 14:17happen. The general order is very explicit. The
- 14:21170 .6 is not deemed ineffective or denied or
- 14:26stricken for non -compliance with the general
- 14:30order. So like any other order, if a party doesn't
- 14:35comply, I suppose there are remedies for non
- 14:38-compliance with a court order. But what's far
- 14:41more likely to happen is the party is going to
- 14:46be given additional time to comply, okay? So
- 14:51that is what the general order says. You need
- 14:55to supply additional information so that, well,
- 15:00period, paragraph. Why do we want the additional
- 15:03information? Because we are interested in knowing
- 15:08whether this is part of a blanket challenge or
- 15:12not. Let me just cover what a blanket challenge
- 15:15is in our opinion here in the court. It is not
- 15:18a categorical challenge. It is not this law firm,
- 15:23no matter what kind of case, no matter what,
- 15:27we're going to challenge this judge every single
- 15:29time. A blanket challenge, according to J .O.,
- 15:34according to our California Supreme Court, is
- 15:37a challenge to all or a substantial portion of
- 15:44cases assigned to a particular judge period.
- 15:49So substantial portion, in our view, could mean
- 15:53certain kinds of cases. Say you have an IC judge
- 15:59and an office says, well, I'm perfectly happy
- 16:02with Judge Riff on lemon law cases, but I cannot
- 16:06tolerate Judge Riff on employment cases. So we're
- 16:10going to challenge him in every employment case
- 16:13there is. That's a blanket challenge. And if
- 16:16it's, I mean, frankly, if it's three, four, five
- 16:20out of six or seven such cases, it's probably
- 16:25going to be seen as a blanket challenge. So that
- 16:30is what the general order provides. That's really
- 16:35helpful context and I know earlier you gave us
- 16:38this overview of the J .O. decision and you provided
- 16:41kind of the three -step analysis. Can you go
- 16:44over those moving pieces for us one more time?
- 16:46Yeah, let me do that because this is new stuff
- 16:49for everybody including judges on our court.
- 16:53Okay so when a 170 .6 come, let me back up and
- 16:59say the following, think about civil. When When
- 17:04is a 170 .6 exercised? Well, frequently it's
- 17:09right at the case assignment. Somebody files
- 17:12a complaint, and the case is assigned, and that's
- 17:17when plaintiffs' counsel learn, oh, it's assigned
- 17:20to Judge Riff. I'm going to file a paper on Judge
- 17:25Riff. That's one place it can occur. The other
- 17:29place that another place that can occur. So when
- 17:31a case gets reassigned judge riff retires now
- 17:35the case goes near the inventory goes to judge
- 17:39jessner and Council are so advised it's two years
- 17:44into the case Parties have appeared everybody's
- 17:47been litigating. It's like oh this case is now
- 17:49with jessner one if A party can file paper at
- 17:54that point, too. The third place it can happen
- 17:57in civil is on assignment of the case to trial,
- 18:02right? So, you know, in normally, I see courts
- 18:07are handling their own trials. We all know that.
- 18:10But from time to time, and I see court may send
- 18:13the case down to Department 534, my department,
- 18:17what we used to call Department 1. uh for a trial
- 18:20assignment so everybody's standing in front of
- 18:22me and i say okay i'm assigning your case to
- 18:27trial to judge shaller or you know judge fracius
- 18:31or judge harwin or and somebody says well you
- 18:34know i want to exercise i 170 .6 okay so whenever
- 18:40the 170 .6 is is made the challenge is made either
- 18:51the opponent can raise an objection or the challenge
- 18:56judge or a supervising judge or the arraignment
- 18:59judge or the master calendar judge can initiate
- 19:02an inquiry and say, you know what? I think this
- 19:06might be part of a bad faith blanket challenge
- 19:10policy. And now I'm looking at the declaration
- 19:13filed with the 170 .6 and you know what? I see
- 19:17that this law firm has filed 170 .6 is against
- 19:22Judge Jessner in the past 12 months. And based
- 19:26on that, I think there is a prima facie showing
- 19:30that this is or may be part of a bad faith blanket
- 19:35challenge policy. So step one, Netta, is a determination
- 19:42that there is a prima facie showing. Now the
- 19:46case has to go somewhere else. to step two. Now,
- 19:51in the civil division, the place it goes is to
- 19:56me. It goes to department 534, at least for the
- 20:00time being, as supervising judge, I'm holding
- 20:03all the merits hearings for the entire division
- 20:07county -wide. So the matter gets set on my calendar
- 20:11two court days later, and counsel are directed
- 20:14to show up in my department for a hearing, a
- 20:18merits -based hearing. Normally, it's only plaintiff's
- 20:21counsel, right? Because normally, this is all
- 20:27arising upon assignment of the case. So plaintiff's
- 20:31counsel comes in, and I hold a hearing. And the
- 20:34ultimate question is, so counsel, now is the
- 20:38time for you to articulate to me. the good faith
- 20:42basis for this 170 .6 to demonstrate that Judge
- 20:47Jessner is in fact prejudiced against you or
- 20:49your client. Tell me what it is. Tell me the
- 20:53JO compliant reason. And then step three is I
- 20:59make a decision. I decide yes, it is in good
- 21:03faith or no, it is not in good faith. In the
- 21:06family law division, I believe It's the same
- 21:11process. Judge Kaufman, as supervising judge,
- 21:16is going to be hearing the merits -based step
- 21:20two part of this. In the criminal division, because
- 21:26of its vastness, there is a different process.
- 21:33There, the supervising judge of the districts
- 21:36are holding the merits -based hearing. So if
- 21:40all of this is happening down in Long Beach or
- 21:44Pomona, rather than the SJ of criminal, Judge
- 21:48Verestegui, bringing everybody downtown for the
- 21:51merits hearing, the merits hearing is being handled
- 21:54in the district. So that's the answer to your
- 21:58question. That's the overview. Well, and you've
- 22:02addressed part of this, but I just want to reiterate
- 22:07that when there is the primary objection to the
- 22:11170 .6, Sue Esponte, the judge who is being objected
- 22:17to or the supervising judge, at least in L .A.
- 22:21County, can also make an objection. Is that right?
- 22:25Yes, that's our view of the law. And now I acknowledge
- 22:29that the California Supreme Court has not addressed
- 22:33that question explicitly. Footnote 10. But again,
- 22:38our view of the reason for the JO decision requires
- 22:45the conclusion that yes, the challenge judge
- 22:48or a supervising judge can make the objection
- 22:51and commence the inquiry. Now, I do want to say
- 22:54there is a risk of embroilment, and we judges
- 22:59know that. So some judges may well decide, you
- 23:06know, I don't want to hold. I don't want to make
- 23:10the prima facie showing determination. I'm going
- 23:13to ask a different judge to do that. And if a
- 23:16judge so decides they can send it to me and I
- 23:19will do both the prima facie and the merits.
- 23:22And we know you explained that in L .A. County
- 23:26for civil, at least you will do the merits hearing.
- 23:30Yeah. Are there any other judges? right now who
- 23:34are assigned to Merit's hearing. Let's say there
- 23:37is an objection to you. Yeah, well, I mean, that's
- 23:42a hypothetical that I cannot get my mind around.
- 23:45Who would object to me? But all right, for the
- 23:48academic purposes, we'll assume that could happen
- 23:51somehow. In that circumstance, We have thought
- 23:56about that, by the way. The presiding judge is
- 23:58going to assign it to somebody. It's not going
- 24:02to be to the assistant supervising judge. That
- 24:05wouldn't look so good. So it probably would be
- 24:08the supervising judge of criminal, Judge Verastegui.
- 24:12When she got challenged, it was assigned to me
- 24:17rather than staying in that division. Now, look,
- 24:20you know, we are so short on time. There's something
- 24:22I really need to say to whoever is listening
- 24:25out there, because this is like a revolution
- 24:33in thought for many of us, for many practitioners.
- 24:39Let me tell you what is a bad faith basis under
- 24:43J .O., a bad faith basis. under J .O. is to challenge
- 24:50the judge because of the judge's rulings on a
- 24:56question of law. And I know most people connect
- 25:00with their mind around that, so let me be clear.
- 25:03I need to challenge Judge Riff, many lawyers
- 25:07might say, because that guy always sustains.
- 25:11a demurrer without leave to amend in my lemon
- 25:14law case, striking my fraud claim. And I know
- 25:18that's what he's going to do in this case. That's
- 25:20bad for me. That's bad for my client. That's
- 25:24prejudice. And so I'm striking Judge Riff because
- 25:27I don't like the way he rules on demurrers in
- 25:30lemon law cases. That is not a lawful basis for
- 25:36a challenge. And I know many people For some
- 25:41decades have thought otherwise So when counsel
- 25:45come down to me for this For the merits hearing
- 25:50and I finally say so why is it? What is your
- 25:54good faith basis? And they said well, you know
- 25:56this judge Just lets too many cases go to the
- 26:00jury this judge Let's you know punitive damages
- 26:04go to the jury too much and that's really bad
- 26:06for my client or this judge As I say, he sustains
- 26:10Demers with leave to amend on something. That
- 26:13is textbook bad faith under J .O. This, I'll
- 26:19give you some other examples now. You know, I
- 26:22have hearings with this judge. This judge lets
- 26:24my opponent just go on and on and on. When it's
- 26:27my turn, she's shutting me down all the time.
- 26:29I can't get a word out edgewise. And you know,
- 26:33I don't like that. And my client doesn't like
- 26:36it. And I think it's prejudicial to me. I mean,
- 26:38respectfully, unless that is some entrenched
- 26:44personal prejudice, a judge's determination as
- 26:49to how much time to give an argument to one side
- 26:52or another is a classic example of judicial discretion.
- 26:58And the jail court says, exercise of judicial
- 27:02discretion is not the basis for a 170 .6. So,
- 27:08Judge Riff, it's really helpful that you gave
- 27:09those examples, because there are a lot of questions
- 27:12that I am staying with respect to what constitutes
- 27:15good faith versus bad faith. And I think this
- 27:18question will help address some of those questions
- 27:21that we may not get time to address. But I think
- 27:26we'll get to the heart of the matter. which is
- 27:28that if counsel believes in their heart of hearts
- 27:31that the judge is prejudiced, is that subjective
- 27:35opinion sufficient for what is considered a good
- 27:38faith challenge? I don't think so, and let me
- 27:42comment on that. Look, I've held 44 merits hearings
- 27:47under J .O. since all of this, and this is only
- 27:50August 14th, right? And our general order only
- 27:54came out on July 28th, so the last two and a
- 27:57half weeks. I've had counsel in front of me say,
- 28:00you know, Judge Riff, I genuinely believe this.
- 28:04I mean, there's no silly business here. I'm not
- 28:07trying to get out of driving to Pomona. I really
- 28:10think this judge is prejudiced against me. I
- 28:13genuinely believe it. And that's and I read 170
- 28:16.6 and that's all it takes is my genuine good
- 28:20faith, subjective belief. Now, Neda, if that
- 28:25were true, then we would not need the JO decision
- 28:29if that were enough. My view is that, well, let
- 28:34me say this, I never question counsel's representation
- 28:38to me that they genuinely believe it. If they
- 28:41believe it, they believe it. And who am I to
- 28:43say they don't believe it? But that entirely
- 28:48subjective belief needs to be tethered, in my
- 28:53view, to something objective in the real world
- 28:57that they can articulate. It's not enough just
- 29:01to say, I believe it in my heart, but I really
- 29:03can't say why. They need to say why and the say
- 29:07why part needs to have a subjective truth to
- 29:12it in the real world. And if the subjective truth
- 29:16to it in the real world is, I don't like the
- 29:19way this judge rules on 11 law cases where in
- 29:22class action matters. That is not a JO -compliant
- 29:29reason. Now you might ask, well, what is a JO
- 29:32-compliant reason? I can give you several examples.
- 29:38I do see we have now gone all the way to our
- 29:4130 minutes. We have, and for those of you who
- 29:44can join us, maybe, and Judge Riff, if you have
- 29:47the extra time, if we can do an extra five minutes
- 29:49and we can address some more questions. Sure.
- 29:52Great. I have time, but let me just say, so let's
- 29:58say counsel come in and say, your honor, this
- 30:03judge has made public statements indicating prejudgment
- 30:08on a point of law, a prejudgment that is prejudicial
- 30:14to my client's point of view. And that is the
- 30:18reason I exercise a 170 .6. Hey, that's righteous.
- 30:23That is a righteous, 170 points, J .O. challenge,
- 30:27I should say. You know, really, when you start
- 30:32making a list of what are good faith bases, it
- 30:36looks very much like the things that would be
- 30:40appropriate for a statement of disqualification.
- 30:44You know, a close personal relationship, financial.
- 30:48interest in the outcome in some fashion. But,
- 30:53you know, or even, you know, some very rare things
- 30:56like, well, judge, you know, the judge, the challenge
- 31:02judge, Judge Jeffner in my case, and my client
- 31:06are members of the same homeowners association,
- 31:08and they've really gotten into it in some of
- 31:10these meetings. I think they hate each other.
- 31:12Okay, you know. I'll buy that if then you should
- 31:17not be in front of judge jessner that is a righteous
- 31:19170 .6 in my view but i don't like the way judge
- 31:23jessner rules on class action certification motions
- 31:26no okay So there are some questions with respect
- 31:32to timing and if defendant has also appeared
- 31:35in a matter. So I'll go ahead and read this one.
- 31:38It may address several others. We have recently
- 31:41seen certain judges contesting 170 .6 challenges
- 31:44unprompted by the opposing council or party with
- 31:48no prima facie challenge raised by the opposing
- 31:51council party, which in LA County we. we discussed
- 31:54they can do that. Is the sua sponte consideration
- 31:56of 170 .6 challenges when all parties have appeared
- 32:00appropriate? And I think we know the answer to
- 32:04that question, but I'll go ahead and let you
- 32:05answer. Well, I think the answer to that is yes.
- 32:10I think the question implies, well, if there
- 32:12is an opponent in the case and the opponent doesn't
- 32:16raise the point, maybe the question is implying,
- 32:20well, why is the judge at that point Sue Espante
- 32:24doing anything and I think the answer I'll just
- 32:26speak for myself on this It's because when you
- 32:29look to see in the jail opinion who is the victim
- 32:33of a bad faith blanket challenge. It's the court
- 32:36system It's the court system. So if the opponent
- 32:40for some reason, I mean the opponent might say
- 32:42well, you know what? I don't like judge Chester
- 32:43either So it's okay with me if my opponent papered
- 32:47judge Chester, but the court has a stake in the
- 32:51outcome here as well. So I would say, yes, it
- 32:55would be appropriate for the challenge judge
- 32:58to Sue Espante act, even in the presence of an
- 33:02opponent. Here's an interesting one to clarify.
- 33:06Is there no opportunity to object to the 170
- 33:09.6 challenge if the firm bringing the 170 .6
- 33:13has brought two or fewer 170 .6 is against that
- 33:17judge in the prior 12 months? Well, I would say
- 33:22that's an open question of law that the JO opinion
- 33:25does not address, because remember, JO is dealing
- 33:31with two conditions precedent. It's gotta be
- 33:34bad faith, it's gotta be blanket, okay? So by
- 33:38the way, a blanket policy that's based on good
- 33:42faith is completely lawful. So far, a bad faith
- 33:49challenge that is not part of a blanket policy?
- 33:54Well, that's just how it's been for the last
- 33:5650 years. We are not permitted to look behind
- 34:01that challenge if it's not a blanket or apparently
- 34:06a blanket challenge. So I think the specific
- 34:09answer to the question is no, there is not an
- 34:12opportunity to object if the challenge is thought
- 34:17to be brought in bad faith, but it's not part
- 34:20of a blanket challenge policy. Interesting. Lena
- 34:26said the J .O. decision recognizes that there's
- 34:29such a thing as a good faith blanket challenge,
- 34:33which can interfere with court operations, but
- 34:35is nevertheless valid and is critical for guarding
- 34:38against cases where a litigant may sincerely
- 34:40believe a judge is prejudiced, but would struggle
- 34:44to come into court. of that prejudice? What,
- 34:47if anything, would establish that a blanket challenge
- 34:49is in good faith in your view? Well, the kind
- 34:52of thing I was just mentioning. First of all,
- 34:54the point of that, the first part of that question
- 34:57is exactly what I had just said, that a good
- 35:01faith blanket challenge policy is not unlawful.
- 35:06No problem. So let me give you a hypothetical.
- 35:10Let's say, hypothetically, You've got a judge
- 35:14out there who wrote an article, it was published
- 35:18in, you know, the Daily Journal, and the judge
- 35:24is sitting in a UD assignment, unlawful detainer
- 35:27assignment, and the judge says, I think that
- 35:31the UD laws way favor tenants too much, and I
- 35:37think landlords are really getting harmed by
- 35:40this crazy policy that the legislature has created
- 35:43for unlawful detainers, okay? That is a statement
- 35:48of prejudgment. And I think that if you are a
- 35:53UD lawyer representing landlords, you could blanket
- 35:57challenge that judge forever with it being a
- 36:05good faith blanket challenge. Because it's a
- 36:10statement of prejudgment. probably that would
- 36:13also be sufficient to disqualify the judge under
- 36:16170 .3 and 170 .1. I think those, you know, the
- 36:21answer to those questions kind of addressed a
- 36:24lot of the inquiries that I'm seeing. And Judge
- 36:26Ripso, you know, a lot is kind of this seemingly
- 36:31perplexion or confusion about what's good faith
- 36:34versus bad faith. And, you know, I think this
- 36:37will become clear as well. these challenges become
- 36:40more apparent and become more like ubiquitous.
- 36:45The last thing that I've seen a bit is with respect
- 36:49to trauma informed judges. So people practicing
- 36:53in areas where trauma is high, if they have seen
- 36:58judges be quote unquote overly harsh, towards
- 37:03litigants. Would that be a sufficient basis?
- 37:06Because I've seen a few of those questions. It's
- 37:08hard to know. I mean, you know, I would I would
- 37:13urge people at the merits hearing to, you know,
- 37:17make the presentation of evidence to support
- 37:21that. But let me say this. Let me just say this.
- 37:26Look, I am not in favor withdrawn. Let me say
- 37:30this. There are remedies for judges who are over
- 37:35the top, who are violating the canons of judicial
- 37:38ethics, including Canon 3, which requires judges
- 37:41to be patient, dignified, and courteous at all
- 37:44times. There are remedies for that. There is
- 37:47a complaint mechanism where the presiding judge
- 37:51will institute a formal investigation of a complaint
- 37:55if a lawyer is willing to put it in writing.
- 37:59There is the Commission on Judicial Performance,
- 38:04which will likewise investigate these kinds of
- 38:07complaints. With respect to, you know, conduct
- 38:13kinds of things. With respect to, you know, I
- 38:17hate the way this judge rules on Class action
- 38:21certification because the judge gets it wrong
- 38:23every time and that's why I want to challenge
- 38:25the judge. The remedy is not a 170 .6. It's an
- 38:28appeal or a writ. That's why the Court of Appeal
- 38:32exists. So. You know, one of the things that
- 38:38the jail court specifically called out as not
- 38:41a good faith basis is the personality of the
- 38:45judge. So is this judge? Kind of being overly
- 38:51harsh because this judge is that is this judge's
- 38:53personality or is this judge violating Canon
- 38:56three by not being patient dignified and courteous?
- 39:01It's uh areas of gray Areas of great Well judge
- 39:07riff. Thank you so much and thank you all for
- 39:10joining. You know, we really appreciate everyone's
- 39:13time Thank you for having me invite me again
- 39:16sometime. Of course. Thank you all Bye. Bye bye,
- 39:20Nana.