Latest / No Way Out / Constraints-Led Approach (CLA): Real OODA in Sports Coaching | Rob Gray, PhD
Transcript
- 0:20Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh, Professor Rob Gray.
- 0:21Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: He's at Arizona State University.
- 0:22Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Welcome to the show, Rob.
- 0:24Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: How are you doing?
- 0:24Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Good.
- 0:25Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Thanks for having me.
- 0:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Hopefully that wasn't too fast and furious.
- 0:28Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I just wanted to share some ideas with you on where we are and our line of thought.
- 0:32Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I do have a couple of things with me.
- 0:34Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I have uh your books, uh, two of your books.
- 0:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 0:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I have uh ecological coach, developing attuned and adaptable coaching skills.
- 0:41Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I also have uh how we learn to move.
- 0:44Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I highly recommend these books.
- 0:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And before I flip it over to you, I also have two props that I want to share.
- 0:49Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And maybe this will number one, Cones.
- 0:53Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 0:53Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And then number two.
- 0:55Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: No.
- 0:55Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 0:57Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I think this one, there's some history.
- 1:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: This is balance bike that we got in Germany when we lived there, and that's how my kids learn how to ride bikes.
- 1:06Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So with that being said, um, where do you want to go with this today, uh, Rob?
- 1:12Rob Gray, PhD: Well, I think just kind of how you can apply some of the ideas of ecological dynamics.
- 1:16Rob Gray, PhD: Your introduction to the OODA loop, I like the direction you're moving it.
- 1:19Rob Gray, PhD: The, you know, the the big contention we have in ecological dynamics is that those are discrete linear processes.
- 1:27Rob Gray, PhD: You decide, then act.
- 1:28Rob Gray, PhD: You perceive, decide, act, whereas they're really more linked.
- 1:32Rob Gray, PhD: Like you act to perceive sometimes.
- 1:34Rob Gray, PhD: You explore your environment to pick up information, not just so I think that's and settling is situating it in the environment, recognizing that skill is a is a relationship between your perception, how you pick up information and how you move.
- 1:47Rob Gray, PhD: I brought up Yeah.
- 1:50Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So I brought up that when I went through PCT with Warren, I'm like, wait a minute, this is kind of confusing.
- 1:55Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: This is not how I understand like active inference and predictive processing.
- 1:59Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But when you look at it from the the sketch that I showed, it's just saying action by or um is it action drives behaviors or our perception?
- 2:06Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Is that right?
- 2:06Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So you're right.
- 2:07Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's it's a continuous one.
- 2:08Rob Gray, PhD: So it's a yeah, and they can go the other direction too, yeah.
- 2:11Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 2:12Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 2:13unknown: Yeah.
- 2:13Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So and then with what I saw in the paper uh that you had out there with uh Dr.
- 2:17Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Hippolyto and Warren and others, and and and Carl Friston, by the way, is to me, everybody's looking at this from their own perspective.
- 2:24Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Nobody's right and nobody's wrong.
- 2:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's you're all right, correct?
- 2:27Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I mean, hopefully I said that correctly.
- 2:29Rob Gray, PhD: Well, we we disagree.
- 2:30Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, yeah.
- 2:31Rob Gray, PhD: Um, you know, in ecological, we would doubt the the argument really is what goes on between the perception and action, right?
- 2:37Rob Gray, PhD: How much the brain is processing and predicting and adding to the information that's coming in, right?
- 2:44Rob Gray, PhD: In the ecological psychology, Gibson's fundamental idea is you don't need to add anything at all.
- 2:49Rob Gray, PhD: No prediction, right?
- 2:50Rob Gray, PhD: No actually, no inferences, no hypotheses, right?
- 2:54Rob Gray, PhD: You just pick up the right information and you link your movement to it and you're done.
- 2:57Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So how do you do that?
- 2:59Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: How do you train for that then?
- 3:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's that's what we're getting at is how do you bypass that?
- 3:03Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um, and that again within the OOD loop, you don't have to go through those spaces, the predictive and planning side and simulation.
- 3:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 3:10Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You can go right up to that skill side.
- 3:12Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 3:12Rob Gray, PhD: So there in the ecological, there's kind of three processes you go through when you become skillful.
- 3:17Rob Gray, PhD: One we call education of attention, which is learning to pick up better information.
- 3:22Rob Gray, PhD: My main sport I work in in bait is baseball.
- 3:24Rob Gray, PhD: So when you're a new hitter, you learn I can start my swing when the ball's this distance from me.
- 3:30Rob Gray, PhD: That's not very effective information because what if I throw it faster, right?
- 3:34Rob Gray, PhD: Or even like crossing a street uh safely.
- 3:36Rob Gray, PhD: So you learn to pick up better information.
- 3:38Rob Gray, PhD: You can pick up the information that tells you when it's gonna arrive.
- 3:42Rob Gray, PhD: Uh that's called education of attention, education of intention, you learn to match your actions to your goals better and your abilities.
- 3:49Rob Gray, PhD: And then calibration, you learn to like when you get in a uh example I always give is you when you rent a car, right?
- 3:55Rob Gray, PhD: When you rent a car, you might get a spongier break.
- 3:58Rob Gray, PhD: So you have to learn how to calibrate your foot movements appropriately for the dynamics of that break.
- 4:04Rob Gray, PhD: So you're using the same information but from the stop sign and the environment, but you have to calibrate the two, link them to.
- 4:10Rob Gray, PhD: And we lose calibration very easily.
- 4:13Rob Gray, PhD: But uh yeah, so those are the kind of three posters.
- 4:15Rob Gray, PhD: So you want to give practice environments with kind of encourage people to learn to pick up their information through lots of lots of variability in environments, letting them explore, let them do let information that's relative to their abilities, right?
- 4:28Rob Gray, PhD: Um, like the example I always give in when I stand, I'm five foot nine, right?
- 4:33Rob Gray, PhD: When I stand in a b basketball court, I don't perceive the ability to, I don't have the ability to dunk basketball, right?
- 4:39Rob Gray, PhD: So that I have to learn to perceive kind of space and in with relative to what I can do.
- 4:45Rob Gray, PhD: So so that that so most of it, like a lot of it is keeping the inform always training with the information there that you're gonna have in right in the real situation.
- 4:56Rob Gray, PhD: That's my end of my podcast.
- 4:57Rob Gray, PhD: I always say keep them coupled, which I mean always have your actions driven by the information that you're gonna face in this scenario.
- 5:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 5:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So keep the system open, right?
- 5:06Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Keep keep the system open.
- 5:08Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, yeah, for sure.
- 5:09Rob Gray, PhD: This is like when you do typically what we do is we train skill by pulling things out of the environment.
- 5:17Rob Gray, PhD: You know, in you know, training someone to have firearms training, right?
- 5:21Rob Gray, PhD: We pull it out of the environment, shoot you on a range.
- 5:24Rob Gray, PhD: There's no information about whether you should be shooting that target, and information about whether a person has a gun where they are, right?
- 5:31Rob Gray, PhD: It's just a tar a target with nothing, no information there.
- 5:34Rob Gray, PhD: So we pull that skill out, and then that's what a uh that's what a balanced bike also tries to address, right?
- 5:40Rob Gray, PhD: We don't we pull in typical way to teach you to um ride a bike is we separate propelling the bike forward from balancing the bike.
- 5:49Rob Gray, PhD: Training wheels do, right?
- 5:50Rob Gray, PhD: They they take the problem of of balancing the bike away from the child.
- 5:54Rob Gray, PhD: So they have to relearn that later, put it all together.
- 5:57Rob Gray, PhD: So it takes longer.
- 5:58Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 5:59Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So there's a lot of coaches that that listen to this and coaches that I've talked to in the last couple of weeks that will say that they're already doing a lot of things that you say uh we should be doing or they should be doing in the ecological approach and constraints flight approach.
- 6:12Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So they have small side games.
- 6:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You know, I watch my girls and they do the weave in basketball, they'll dribble around cones.
- 6:19Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um and if I go back to what I did in aviation and what uh Moose did in the Marine Corps, uh going back to firing a weapon, it's you have to create the conditions that you're going to experience, right, in order to actually learn how to adapt in the future.
- 6:33Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And one of the fundamental questions I have with the basketball coaches now is, and and I think this is true with a lot of parents, is when do we see that transition from the awesome spin moves and Eurosteps and all that into a basketball game?
- 6:46Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I realized after I asked that, I'd say months after I asked it, I'm like, I know the answer to that.
- 6:50Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You have to train like that, you have to create the affordances or the context, the constraints um that are required to uh for for the individual to explore what they can and cannot do, right?
- 7:02Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So but for um the you know, the w wider coaching audience, when they hear this, they're like, what are you guys talking about?
- 7:12Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So how do you kind of show what the current state is um and and talk about that and what the evolution should look like when it comes to um an ecological approach?
- 7:24Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, so the like the weave in basketball is a good example.
- 7:27Rob Gray, PhD: The the weave is something we don't like, right?
- 7:29Rob Gray, PhD: The weave is you're moving down the floor, you're passing, you're doing actions, passing, dribbling, cutting with no information there.
- 7:37Rob Gray, PhD: Like, why are you passing it to that player?
- 7:39Rob Gray, PhD: You pass to that player because the defensive player is here, where you cut through gaps where there's no defense there, you're just playing on air, right?
- 7:47Rob Gray, PhD: It's the same way, you know, I do a lot of recent work in mar mixed martial arts, like punching, doing techniques when there's no opponent, right?
- 7:55Rob Gray, PhD: Why are you like a technique is action is driven by something you pick up from an opponent from the defense of basketball?
- 8:02Rob Gray, PhD: We want that there as much as possible.
- 8:04Rob Gray, PhD: It doesn't matter what we mean we have to play the full game every time.
- 8:07Rob Gray, PhD: We can like and the same thing with training in military and other things, right?
- 8:11Rob Gray, PhD: It doesn't mean we need to, we can't possibly create the full scenario in your situation, right?
- 8:16Rob Gray, PhD: There's no way it's too dangerous.
- 8:18Rob Gray, PhD: There's no we can't create the pressure, the chaos, right?
- 8:22Rob Gray, PhD: But we can kind of take a piece of it and right and keep have the key ingredients still there.
- 8:27Rob Gray, PhD: But we don't do that by going uh uh really isolating the skill.
- 8:30Rob Gray, PhD: We find that you know you're gonna get really poor transfer into that situation.
- 8:35Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh so there's a phrase I think it was in your book, uh, or it said, um, the game is not the best teacher, right?
- 8:40Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 8:41Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Is it you is that you?
- 8:42Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So, and that's what we want is we want to create the conditions and practice and training.
- 8:46Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So, and my my argument is we want to be in a flow state in performance.
- 8:50Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And just let me build on this some more.
- 8:51Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I got to fly air shows, right?
- 8:53Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So I spent a lot of time in front of millions of people flying the F-14 demonstration.
- 8:56Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And on demonstration days, those are the best performances because I got hate to say it, but we got feedback from everybody.
- 9:03Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We we're in the environment, there's people watching, things like that.
- 9:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Your performance goes up and everything kind of slows down in the cockpit, right?
- 9:10Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Everything just happens.
- 9:11Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It just kind of flows from you.
- 9:12Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: The same thing is true in a game.
- 9:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's what we want to pursue in sports, is flow, right?
- 9:19Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And if you watch the movie F1, that whole movie is about chasing flow, right?
- 9:23Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's pretty cool.
- 9:24Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So, but in order to do that, uh, you have to create those conditions.
- 9:29Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And again, this goes back to the fundamentals of what do you call it, task environment and individual, right?
- 9:34Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Maybe we could talk a little bit about that.
- 9:35Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Constraints.
- 9:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: The constraints, right?
- 9:37Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So we need to start with the external environment to help create the conditions so people can learn.
- 9:43Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So can you walk us through constraints and the three constraints that you guys talk about the most?
- 9:48Rob Gray, PhD: Sure.
- 9:48Rob Gray, PhD: And I think you're on a key point, right?
- 9:50Rob Gray, PhD: One of the key points of this is the main stimulus for how we're gonna get you to learn is the practice environment we create.
- 9:58Rob Gray, PhD: For what we set up for you to practice, not what we say, not just what we say.
- 10:03Rob Gray, PhD: We're not gonna overly technically instruct you, we're gonna create these environments.
- 10:07Rob Gray, PhD: Constraint.
- 10:09Rob Gray, PhD: Constraint is something in an environment that essentially a reason I call it a constraint is it takes away some uh a solution you could use, right?
- 10:20Rob Gray, PhD: So uh, you know, when you have a 10-foot rim in basketball, it takes away, I can't dunk to score.
- 10:25Rob Gray, PhD: If I lowered it to six feet, then that solution comes back in.
- 10:29Rob Gray, PhD: Um but so and there's three types.
- 10:31Rob Gray, PhD: There's uh individual constraints are constraints you bring.
- 10:34Rob Gray, PhD: So it's your height, your weight, your flexibility, how you handle pressure, all these kind of individual things, uh, your level of fatigue.
- 10:42Rob Gray, PhD: Those things, what those things are gonna take away some of the solutions you can use, depending on your your own capabilities.
- 10:48Rob Gray, PhD: And that's part of the reason we don't want to just instruct the ideal perfect technique for doing a skill.
- 10:54Rob Gray, PhD: We want to let you find one that works for you.
- 10:56Rob Gray, PhD: By prescribing everyone the same way to shoot a basketball that are different heights, different arm lengths, different is is not gonna work.
- 11:04Rob Gray, PhD: So that's an individual task, is something specific to the sport.
- 11:08Rob Gray, PhD: So the rules, the number of players, the equipment.
- 11:12Rob Gray, PhD: So in basketball, we could give you a heavy ball to shoot.
- 11:15Rob Gray, PhD: That's one of my favorite tools.
- 11:16Rob Gray, PhD: Pitching in baseball, we use different weight bats.
- 11:18Rob Gray, PhD: That's a really popular thing now.
- 11:20Rob Gray, PhD: Different length bats to practice with.
- 11:22Rob Gray, PhD: So they're very specific to the sport.
- 11:24Rob Gray, PhD: Environmental are kind of general things that would apply to anything you're doing, which are like gravity, light level, friction, weather, those kind of things.
- 11:32Rob Gray, PhD: So the biggest one that a coach has control over is the task constraints, right?
- 11:36Rob Gray, PhD: They can manipulate the rules, the size of the area playing and number of players, equipment.
- 11:40Rob Gray, PhD: Environment, you got to kind of take advantage of opportunities.
- 11:43Rob Gray, PhD: We can play a thing around with things like light level and things you can design.
- 11:47Rob Gray, PhD: There are some technology starting to design things like that.
- 11:50Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, those are the three ideas.
- 11:52Rob Gray, PhD: Well, the idea is that from the kind of interaction of these different constraints, you're gonna, you're gonna a movement solution, a way to perform your goal is going to emerge the word we use is emerge.
- 12:05Rob Gray, PhD: It's gonna come out of out of all that, right?
- 12:07Rob Gray, PhD: You're gonna find.
- 12:08Rob Gray, PhD: So in this approach, really, we're trying what we're trying to build is adaptable problem solvers, right?
- 12:14Rob Gray, PhD: So we want you to be find a solution for any set of constraints we give you, right?
- 12:20Rob Gray, PhD: Instead of you teaching one technique which will work, not work in all conditions, we want you to be able to like the famous quote from Bernstein is you know, being skillful is not about repeating a solution, it's repeating the process of finding a solution, right?
- 12:35Rob Gray, PhD: So you we want to teach you to find, be able to find a way, or if we go back to firearms, fire accurately in any condition, when you're running, when you're lying down, when you're on one knee, when you're you're you know you're tired.
- 12:46Rob Gray, PhD: So can you find a technique that's gonna work in that those different situations?
- 12:51Rob Gray, PhD: That's kind of the fundamental idea.
- 12:53Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So there's a lot of language associated with this.
- 12:55Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And and you know, we're we're you know, we know emergence, path dependency, all the the language of complex adaptive systems, self-organization, you get into affordances and attractors.
- 13:04Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And by this time, everybody's eyes are rolling back in their head, right?
- 13:07Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 13:08Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 13:08Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But that's the whole point about learning, is you have to push yourself, you have to reorient around what was known 20 years ago, 50 years ago, and learn what's going on today.
- 13:17Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And this seems to be one of the biggest challenges that Moose and I have when we go in and work with elite performers, elite leaders, CEOs, and so forth.
- 13:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: They're like, that's not what they're doing, right?
- 13:28Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That that other organization isn't doing this.
- 13:31Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So I've got to ask, um, what's it like on your end trying to get the front office, a coach that knows, you know, this is the way I was taught 20 years ago, 30 years ago?
- 13:40Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: How do you get them to see this differently?
- 13:42Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, that that that's a great point.
- 13:44Rob Gray, PhD: I think, you know, I kind of I think you can overwhelm people with language and and it could be so using it all the every term perfectly correctly all the time is made.
- 13:54Rob Gray, PhD: I do think there's a value in using things consistently.
- 13:56Rob Gray, PhD: Like the word constraint, so the coaches I work with, we always try to use that because then you understand why why am I adding this?
- 14:03Rob Gray, PhD: Why do why would I what is it gonna do when I give a person a longer bat?
- 14:07Rob Gray, PhD: Well, I'm gonna add more players on the basketball court.
- 14:10Rob Gray, PhD: So for example, I coach my son's basketball team this year, and we do like when instead of doing the standard layup lines where you just run in by yourself and do a black, I have one line of shooters and one line of chasers, right?
- 14:24Rob Gray, PhD: And so they're coming, they're gonna try to defend.
- 14:26Rob Gray, PhD: So that's a constraint I add.
- 14:28Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, so I think there is like there is some consistent of that in doing that.
- 14:35Rob Gray, PhD: Um the terminology you just kind of got to build on the idea slowly, I think.
- 14:40Rob Gray, PhD: I always uh the question I like to use, I like to meet when I work with coach, meet them where they are, right?
- 14:44Rob Gray, PhD: If they're a really traditionalist, I start with can't how can we make that a little more variable, a little more game-like, right?
- 14:51Rob Gray, PhD: For example, in my sport, the cones you showed earlier, baseball the equivalent of cones are batting tees, right?
- 14:57Rob Gray, PhD: You're hitting a ball sitting still off a getting ready to hit a pitch coming at you 100 miles an hour.
- 16:01Rob Gray, PhD: How do I don't know how you could think those would that's gonna help, but a lot of people still so if a coach is really wants to use those, I try to think can we change the height of the T, move it around, do it.
- 16:11Rob Gray, PhD: So I try to kind of move, pull them in this direction and introduce some of the concepts along the way.
- 16:17Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's great.
- 16:18Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna bring Moose in here because uh Moose is the big brain when it comes to connecting the John Boyd's uh destruction and creation, the strategic game, mission command.
- 16:27Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What's going on in your head there, Moose?
- 16:30Mark McGrath: A lot.
- 16:31Mark McGrath: I was just at lunch with someone, and we were talking about how do you teach this to the like he's like, I get it, but how do we teach this to my team?
- 16:39Mark McGrath: You know, how would we teach this to the rest of the people?
- 16:41Mark McGrath: And that was exactly my answer was you have to meet them where they're at, and everybody's gonna have a different way of receiving this.
- 16:46Mark McGrath: Inherently, everybody, I believe that everybody's capable of doing these things inherently, or they may already be doing these things, they just don't understand them.
- 16:55Mark McGrath: And where Boyd would come in is that if you understand these things explicitly, then your results would be they would become geometric, that you'd be able to improve at a rate where your competitors would never be able to even calculate what's happening to them as they as they unravel and uh and head into uh and head into defeat.
- 17:21Mark McGrath: That's kind of my that's that's kind of my initial big big picture thing because ultimately when I I'd read an article not long ago on my on my contra frame my my substack my other substack contra frame about the tyranny of the coaching tree.
- 17:35Mark McGrath: And the tyranny of the coaching tree is kind of what Ponch was alluding to, that you have all of these coaches that, you know, this is the way we did it, this is the Bill Walsh way of approaching this, this is how Mike Holmgrim taught me, and I'm just gonna stick to it.
- 17:46Mark McGrath: And in light of new information, nothing ever, nothing ever changes.
- 17:49Mark McGrath: In fact, I just restacked an article on The World about Mike Tomlin.
- 17:52Mark McGrath: I'm I'm from Pittsburgh, I'm a Pittsburgh Steelers fan, season ticket holder.
- 17:56Mark McGrath: And I get to renew this article every single year because Mike Tomlin does not change, and it just keeps progressively getting worse and nothing's changing.
- 18:06Mark McGrath: And you keep pointing it out, and and no one's gonna no one's gonna understand it until the whole entire thing just explodes.
- 18:12Mark McGrath: Then they'll then they'll make a change.
- 18:13Mark McGrath: Yeah, they're extreme.
- 18:14Rob Gray, PhD: What if they had three coaches and their history stealers?
- 18:17Mark McGrath: Yeah, and you know, generally it's not it's not bad if those consistent coaches are constantly revising and updating their their approach and they're changing with the the nature of the game.
- 18:29Mark McGrath: Um, you know, the Steelers, you know, just using the last couple, you know, the last whatever, 15 years that he's been there, 17 years he's been there, is they're always like this defense first.
- 18:38Mark McGrath: Well, they have the worst defense in the entire league right now.
- 18:41Mark McGrath: You know, they haven't adapted or adjusted to the game.
- 18:44Mark McGrath: He doesn't have one person in his coaching tree.
- 18:47Mark McGrath: No one, he hasn't, he hasn't uh produced a single a single uh uh file, you know, or you know, uh coach.
- 18:57Mark McGrath: Coordinator coordinator or anything.
- 18:59Mark McGrath: It's yeah, that's that's that's that's a bad that's bad orientation and and it's defeatable.
- 19:05Mark McGrath: And when you're it seems that that their cultural orientation is we need 500 or better.
- 19:11Mark McGrath: He's never had a losing season.
- 19:12Mark McGrath: But in that process, they've been they've had their asses kicked in playoff games.
- 19:17Mark McGrath: They they get into novel situations and they don't know what to do because they double triple down on what they think always always worked in the past, and they're not they're not adapting or changing with the game.
- 19:28Mark McGrath: So it's the opposite of destruction creation.
- 19:30Mark McGrath: They're not doing anything to improve their capacity for free and independent action.
- 19:33Mark McGrath: And that's how all of a sudden they're four and three with with no with no hope.
- 19:38Mark McGrath: Um, I I don't think.
- 19:41Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 19:42Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, the um the uh we have a another a new somewhere up there, a new football book that we just I wrote with a couple of guys applying these ideas to football practice.
- 19:51Rob Gray, PhD: But but yeah, no, I think there's uh there one of the reasons like you know I find really rewarding about this, like that you may show that article in the New York Times, the constraints.
- 20:00Rob Gray, PhD: I think that it's kind of catching fire.
- 20:02Rob Gray, PhD: Is I there's a lot of coach, it's not the I the methods aren't new.
- 20:05Rob Gray, PhD: Small sided games, people are doing that forever, right?
- 20:08Rob Gray, PhD: It's the kind of putting the theoretical wrapping on it.
- 20:12Rob Gray, PhD: I get so many coaches, they're like, I've been doing that for years.
- 20:15Rob Gray, PhD: Now I you kind of explained why it works.
- 20:18Rob Gray, PhD: And they get ideas for making little tweaks.
- 20:20Rob Gray, PhD: And they teach they could teach other people how to do how they came out with the tweaks, let's talk about those because I the coaches are right.
- 20:27Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I did a uh episode with a coach, local basketball coach, and I'm like, what he's doing is pretty good, really good.
- 20:33Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But with a little tweak, and let just start let me start with one intention.
- 20:37Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Why are we doing this, right?
- 20:38Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So um, you know, I one of my daughters a little bit on the spectrum, so we have to spend time and go, why?
- 20:43Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Here's a why, right?
- 20:44Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: This is why we're doing this.
- 20:46Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And and um that closed lip communication, right?
- 20:48Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Here's what we're trying to accomplish with this thing.
- 20:51Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um, when you put that in front of them, um, you know, why are we doing a shimmy in basketball?
- 20:55Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Well, she didn't know for years that it was trying to get inside the mind time space or inside the oodle loop of somebody else to get them to do something, right?
- 21:02Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: To create a mismatch or create surprise, right?
- 21:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And that's what we're getting at is uh through these little tweaks, and I think that's one of them, along with what you call it representative learning design.
- 21:12Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Is that another one?
- 21:13Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 21:13Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So can you walk us through some of these uh tweaks?
- 21:16Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Because people are doing this, but what are what are the little ones that you can give to coaches right now?
- 21:21Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, the so the kind of the so I wouldn't what I tell coaches, don't spend forever designing a drill or practice activity.
- 21:29Rob Gray, PhD: Get the basic, then try it, right?
- 21:31Rob Gray, PhD: You never know.
- 21:32Rob Gray, PhD: Um, a lot of these things people will find shortcuts, and you know, you could put a rule you have to pass five times before you shoot in basketball to make your players move with the ball.
- 21:41Rob Gray, PhD: Like who's your yeah, they'll just stand at the top and go one, two, three, four, five, and then they'll go play, right?
- 21:48Rob Gray, PhD: They'll shortcut your rule all the time.
- 21:49Rob Gray, PhD: So you kind of put it out there and you gotta adapt, right?
- 21:52Rob Gray, PhD: So think about you know, what can I change, what can I add.
- 21:55Rob Gray, PhD: But the intention one, I really that's a really critical.
- 21:58Rob Gray, PhD: Oftentimes we don't, you know, I'm a big believer in like the you know, Anders Erickson's idea, deliberate practice, right?
- 22:05Rob Gray, PhD: If you want to get better, you gotta work on something specific that you're not good at now, right?
- 22:09Rob Gray, PhD: And so I had the same thing with with my kids, uh my kids when they first started playing basketball, they were they never knew which side to send stand on to set a pick on a uh because they didn't understand what the purpose of it was.
- 22:22Rob Gray, PhD: No one ever explained it to them.
- 22:24Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, they would just go stand there by the fire, but they would always stand on the wrong side.
- 22:28Rob Gray, PhD: It wouldn't work, it was pretty funny.
- 22:30Rob Gray, PhD: But but yeah, they need to understand what their intention, what their how they know when they've done a good rep, right?
- 22:35Rob Gray, PhD: I think is it's clear.
- 22:36Rob Gray, PhD: So but yeah, the tweaks, you know, is you know, changing, adding a different rule, you know, adding another player, adding, you know, there's so it can add change the constraints.
- 22:45Rob Gray, PhD: Um, we could make it all easier sometimes, right?
- 22:49Rob Gray, PhD: So in my example I gave earlier, the layup lines, if I have a kid that's constantly missing the layup when someone's chasing them, what I'll do is I'll make the defending line further back, right?
- 23:00Rob Gray, PhD: So they have to run farther to get to the and so they have more time to get the shot off.
- 23:04Rob Gray, PhD: So I'm still there's still someone chasing them, but now they have more time to get.
- 23:08Rob Gray, PhD: So I I just make everything a little bit easier without pulling that out of the out of the right.
- 23:14Rob Gray, PhD: So so that kind of thing, I think you kind of get a feel for how to how to do those things.
- 23:19Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And the uh coach's role.
- 23:20Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh so there's something we we talk about, we talk about mission command, um, we talk about leadership because there's a nice connection to that with John Boyd's work.
- 23:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We often talk about leading like a gardener.
- 23:29Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about the coach's role and how and how all this comes together?
- 23:33Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, I think that's a a challenge for a lot of people.
- 23:36Rob Gray, PhD: Uh it's a fundamental shift from being the general, being the instructor, right?
- 23:42Rob Gray, PhD: I know how to do it.
- 23:44Rob Gray, PhD: You come to me and I'll tell you.
- 23:45Rob Gray, PhD: That's kind of like a Mike Tomlin approach.
- 23:48Rob Gray, PhD: I know how to play defense, I'm gonna tell you to a more of a guide, right?
- 23:53Rob Gray, PhD: I'm gonna help guide you and you you find a way to do it and help, you know, support you in you learn you learning how to do it yourself, right?
- 24:03Rob Gray, PhD: It it's more of a so it's more of a hand less, it's still like there's still a major role for the coach, right?
- 24:09Rob Gray, PhD: A lot of people misinterpret the constraints that approach is just let them play and don't say anything, don't do anything.
- 24:15Rob Gray, PhD: But you're still guiding them.
- 24:16Rob Gray, PhD: If a player like is, you know, doing something that you know won't work as an instructor, right?
- 24:23Rob Gray, PhD: Then then it's okay to step in and try to give them something to change that.
- 24:27Rob Gray, PhD: You can still have your expertise there.
- 24:29Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, you're more guiding and and pointing out things and creating practice, design designing practice than telling people explicitly, here's how you do it.
- 24:39Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So you you brought up an individual constraint.
- 24:42Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I think a lot of coaches that I've met in the past, again, I'm I'm a parent to a 16 and 14-year-old, two girls uh that play basketball and other sports.
- 24:49Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And what I've seen is, hey, this coach is gonna come in here and he's gonna do this framework, he's gonna do this thing.
- 24:54Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh and our working with organizations, they do the same thing.
- 24:57Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Hey, we're gonna do this thing, we're gonna do this framework, we're gonna follow that.
- 25:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: The the I hate to say the correct way, but a relative effective, more effective way to do things is to understand the strengths and weaknesses of who you have, right?
- 25:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And start there.
- 25:10Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And then you develop a team around those constraints, right?
- 25:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Rather than coming in with and throwing something on and doing it that way.
- 25:17Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And why do coaches one, do coaches still do that?
- 25:20Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Do they still come in and say, I'm gonna throw in this whatever, this this approach?
- 25:25Rob Gray, PhD: There's still a um, there's still, I think, uh draw to be in control, like in control uh in control to teach them my offense, right?
- 25:35Rob Gray, PhD: No matter if we have a good point guard on the team, I'm gonna play this offense.
- 25:39Rob Gray, PhD: Because it's worked for me in the past.
- 25:40Rob Gray, PhD: I know how to do it.
- 25:41Rob Gray, PhD: So be in control, I think there's a real pull for that.
- 25:44Rob Gray, PhD: There's also what I found like in coaching, the kind of pressures you get from parents and the things like the the this CLA approach compared to standing in perfect lines and dribbling, it looks messy, right?
- 25:58Rob Gray, PhD: Kids are making bad passes, they're throwing the ball.
- 26:00Rob Gray, PhD: Um, you know, there lots of things are happening.
- 26:02Rob Gray, PhD: It's kind of chaotic.
- 26:03Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: All you have to do is go to a real basketball game with your kids.
- 26:06Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You see that that happened, right?
- 26:07Rob Gray, PhD: That happens in the game.
- 26:09Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 26:09Rob Gray, PhD: So we're preparing, but yeah, but uh so parents like I've had people, and you're not saying as much, you're not giving as much technical instruction.
- 26:17Rob Gray, PhD: So it looks like it's not as what people expect to be learning, like what a practice is supposed to look like.
- 26:25Rob Gray, PhD: Nice neat lines, nice people making every shot, right?
- 26:28Rob Gray, PhD: It's more chaotic, it's more, you know, and I'm a big believer.
- 26:31Rob Gray, PhD: I emphasize, right?
- 26:32Rob Gray, PhD: We need fail, you need failure to learn, right?
- 26:35Rob Gray, PhD: Failure motivates you to learn, right?
- 26:37Rob Gray, PhD: We want you to fail.
- 26:39Rob Gray, PhD: We don't want you to fail in the game.
- 26:40Rob Gray, PhD: That's performing, right?
- 26:42Rob Gray, PhD: But we want learning, it kind of motivates you to try something different, to get better.
- 26:46Rob Gray, PhD: So, so we're gonna, it's gonna look a little less pretty than than a lot of practices.
- 26:52Rob Gray, PhD: So, so that's kind of a challenge.
- 26:53Rob Gray, PhD: And it's pull, and it's so easy kind of to pull back to the way that you were taught, and your coach taught you and they car coach, right?
- 27:01Rob Gray, PhD: That path dependency is start is a very strong pull.
- 27:05Rob Gray, PhD: And it's a real shift, I think, too, in how like you think of everything in life is taught this way, right?
- 27:10Rob Gray, PhD: You go to pottery class or you learn how to go to a cooking class, you go, person tells you the correct way to do it, and then you leave, right?
- 27:18Rob Gray, PhD: That's the way we that's the best way to live.
- 27:20Rob Gray, PhD: And then you practice repeating it over and over until you get it right.
- 27:23Rob Gray, PhD: So it's a it's a really big shift, I think.
- 27:26unknown: Yeah.
- 27:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So parents, uh, I will say right now, people are pushing back, and I'm telling my girls, don't push this on any coach.
- 27:31Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: This isn't something you just say, dad says we need to do it this way, dad coaches great organizations.
- 27:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: No, no, no, no.
- 27:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's not what we're saying here.
- 27:37Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We're saying there is a better way, and we invite you to come explore it with us.
- 27:42Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And if you don't want to, you're going to get your butt kicked, right?
- 27:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 27:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's that's that's what's going to happen.
- 27:47Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And and uh just some more insights.
- 27:49Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We learned, I don't, I may or may not know this for fact, but we learned about NBA teams that were doing this over the last couple of years, and they didn't want anybody to know about it, right?
- 27:59Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I'm not gonna reveal many names at the moment, and I don't think this is one of them, by the way, the one I'm wearing on my sh my t-shirt.
- 28:04Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I don't I don't think so.
- 28:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But but there are some players from Europe that are dominating here in the NBA, right?
- 28:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Because potentially they have constraints that we don't have over here.
- 28:13Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Let me let me just walk you through a typical parent in my neighborhood.
- 28:16Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh there's there's money that we can throw towards a coach that we're gonna spend, you know, two hours a week on to teach them technical skills, right?
- 28:24Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Is that the right approach?
- 28:25Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Are they using CLA?
- 28:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh, are they using the traditional methods?
- 28:28Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um, that that's up for debate, right?
- 28:30Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But that's what's going on here.
- 28:32Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Over in Europe, you may be playing on a on a sidewalk or whatever.
- 28:35Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You don't have the nice facilities, you don't have the the the you know, the relaxed atmosphere.
- 28:40Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You're playing outside, you're playing with uh, I don't know, but they have different constraints over there.
- 28:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And in a con in the conversation I had in the last couple of weeks, it was that pretty soon the NBA, the top 10 players are not going to be American, right?
- 28:53Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Because our AAU system doesn't follow this approach.
- 28:57Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's a business to get you to pay for parking on the weekends, right?
- 29:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's a business to get you to go watch your kids and learn, spend fifty to a hundred dollars to go watch your kids pass the ball to the other team.
- 29:07Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, for sure.
- 29:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So I think there's a yeah.
- 29:11Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh where where I'm going with this is just that um that difference between you know uh having the ability to go down to a coach that may or may not know what they're doing.
- 29:21Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We can all do that because we're keeping up with the Joneses, right?
- 29:24Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: My neighbors are doing it, my friends are doing it, I have to do it too.
- 29:27Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um we want to flip that script and go, hey, this is probably the most effective way to train anybody in business too, by the way, if you're gonna learn team teamwork skills, um, is to use a constraints-led approach, an ecological approach, something that's based off of complex adaptive systems thinking.
- 29:43Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But people don't want to take the time to invest.
- 29:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So uh going back to the NBA and teams that are doing that, um, it looks like it's picking up some steam in the last month.
- 29:52Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh, can you talk a little bit about that?
- 29:54Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, I think so.
- 29:55Rob Gray, PhD: I think, you know, I think teams are the general, they're moving away from less plays, right?
- 30:01Rob Gray, PhD: Less scripted plays and more towards kind of principles, right?
- 30:05Rob Gray, PhD: We want to create an imbalance, right?
- 30:08Rob Gray, PhD: That and and so I think there's definitely a movement towards that and how we, you know, how we train guys.
- 30:14Rob Gray, PhD: I think that that is growing for sure.
- 30:16Rob Gray, PhD: There's getting um, I think people are seeing benefits.
- 30:19Rob Gray, PhD: And the positionless basketball, right?
- 30:21Rob Gray, PhD: So there that's the one big thing with Europe.
- 30:23Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, the huge, well, Oemby is like shooting threes from he's seven foot four or whatever he is, he's shooting threes ten foot behind the line.
- 30:31Rob Gray, PhD: And he's he's all over the court, playing in every position pretty much.
- 30:34Rob Gray, PhD: So I think that's kind of getting losing some of the structure and allowing things to adapt and flow.
- 30:40Rob Gray, PhD: You mentioned flow, I think.
- 30:42Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 30:43Rob Gray, PhD: Allowing things to flow a bit better instead of everyone thinking, where should I be?
- 30:46Rob Gray, PhD: Where am I on the court?
- 30:48Rob Gray, PhD: Just teach them to pick up opportunities, right?
- 30:51Rob Gray, PhD: Oh, there's an opening there.
- 30:52Rob Gray, PhD: There's no one under the hoop, I'll cut there.
- 30:54Rob Gray, PhD: Have players, teammates recognize that.
- 30:57Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 30:57Rob Gray, PhD: So I think that I think it's definitely a movement there.
- 30:59Rob Gray, PhD: There's kind of different sports have different degrees of that.
- 31:02Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 31:03Mark McGrath: I wrote about that, I just put the link in the chat, but the title was How a Division III Basketball Team Cracked the Code on Adaptive Strategy, and it was St.
- 31:11Mark McGrath: Joseph's basketball team up in Maine.
- 31:13Mark McGrath: How they were doing basically what you were saying.
- 31:15Mark McGrath: They were doing positionless basketball.
- 31:18Mark McGrath: They you know, they didn't have any set plays and there was no pick and roll.
- 31:22Mark McGrath: And they were, you know, inherently doing pretty very good John Boyd type thinking and applying it to basketball.
- 31:28Mark McGrath: And of course, my argument would always be that if they understood it, if they actually understood went deeper on understanding like why all that was happening and why it was working so well, they'd get even better at it and become even more unstoppable.
- 31:40Mark McGrath: You know, most people, I think when you look at their differentials from where they were to where they got to, you know, the other teams constantly were were unraveling.
- 31:49Mark McGrath: They didn't know, they didn't know how to respond to these, you know, basically improvisation within the constraints, what I what I talk about in the article.
- 31:58Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, yeah.
- 31:59Rob Gray, PhD: No, that for sure.
- 32:00Rob Gray, PhD: I think that that's uh definitely we're seeing that happen.
- 32:03Rob Gray, PhD: And you know, I think um the uh you know teams adopting more of that, allowing for more of that, I think is it's going for sure.
- 32:11Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What about the front office?
- 32:12Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: How do you get them to buy off on this?
- 32:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um I mean, because going back to Moose's point about adaptive strategy, adaptive strategy to us is exactly the same thing you're trying to do at the teamwork or team level for team development, right?
- 32:23Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Create the conditions, look to the external environment, understand the context.
- 32:27Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's how we've developed strategy.
- 32:29Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So how do you get the front office to buy into this?
- 32:33Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I'm sure you have to do that from time to time.
- 32:35Rob Gray, PhD: For sure.
- 32:35Rob Gray, PhD: And I'll say first, you know, I've started working with police training and military.
- 32:40Rob Gray, PhD: I think if ever there's a scenario where this fits, it's you guys, right?
- 32:44Rob Gray, PhD: How could you possibly predict what scenarios you're going to be in?
- 32:48Rob Gray, PhD: You're performing in a completely unpredictable, chaotic environment.
- 32:52Rob Gray, PhD: You could possibly can't train someone.
- 32:54Rob Gray, PhD: If this happens, this is four million variables, right?
- 32:57Rob Gray, PhD: If this is here, this the shooter's here and there and there, you need a million options.
- 33:02Rob Gray, PhD: So so yeah, so I think the the the hard part, some of the challenges with like a front office is it's harder to demonstrate like simple linear improvements, right?
- 33:13Rob Gray, PhD: It kind of quantifying and showing improvements, showing easy numbers.
- 33:19Rob Gray, PhD: Oh, the person did a a sprint test and they were 10 seconds faster or whatever.
- 33:25Rob Gray, PhD: Um, even though that sprinting doesn't really, it's not skill, right?
- 33:29Rob Gray, PhD: You're just running in a straight line.
- 33:30Rob Gray, PhD: Um so those things are a little challenging.
- 33:33Rob Gray, PhD: So it's yeah, it's just convincing them.
- 33:35Rob Gray, PhD: Um and sometimes it's like I've had where can we just do a small part of the training this way and kind of gradually convince them and show, show by the the um the the outcomes.
- 33:47Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, so I think uh fundamentally, like I think uh you were mentioning the I think it's about coaching the outcomes, not coaching the technique, right?
- 33:56Rob Gray, PhD: So you want like that's what I really like on a team play, on a basketball team.
- 34:01Rob Gray, PhD: You want to we want to be aggressive on defense, we want to get we want to organize when we get, we want to create imbalances, we want to create numbers, right?
- 34:09Rob Gray, PhD: Those are outcomes, not we don't want to shoot with our high, like focusing on the technique of the shoot.
- 34:15Rob Gray, PhD: We don't want to pass here and do this when this happens, right?
- 34:19Rob Gray, PhD: So yeah, I think that's important.
- 34:21Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, I think I've been lucky.
- 34:22Rob Gray, PhD: The teams I've been working with already have people in place are kind of a believers and intrigued by these ideas.
- 34:29Rob Gray, PhD: I know some other people have had struggles gone back and forth, but yeah, I think demonstrating and how coming out I've I've had some ways where I've shown, you know, the there's a tool I use called representative practice assessment tool.
- 34:44Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 34:44Rob Gray, PhD: And basically showing the relationship between that and and I think on a surface level, a lot of this makes sense, right?
- 34:51Rob Gray, PhD: We when you show people 90% of the practice you do is not like the game at all.
- 34:55Rob Gray, PhD: They kind of like, no wonder why we have trouble making decisions and and things like that.
- 35:00Rob Gray, PhD: So how often like you get often like in basketball, like we don't have good decision makers on our team.
- 35:05Rob Gray, PhD: Well, how much time in practice do act people actually make a decision?
- 35:10Rob Gray, PhD: Or do they always do what you told them before, right?
- 35:13Rob Gray, PhD: So those kind of things, kind of pointing out those and showing us you start with an L.
- 35:17Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 35:18Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Is it like a rubric or something?
- 35:19Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Like does it show good behaviors and bad behaviors, or what what is it like?
- 35:22Rob Gray, PhD: It says in this tool, is is a there's a bunch of questions, right?
- 35:25Rob Gray, PhD: Is um and it's a scale.
- 35:27Rob Gray, PhD: The number and its stuff don't matter to me so much.
- 35:30Rob Gray, PhD: It just gets you to think about, right?
- 35:33Rob Gray, PhD: Uh are there decisions involved?
- 35:35Rob Gray, PhD: Are people do people have to adapt their movements?
- 35:37Rob Gray, PhD: Do people have to change their detentions based on the unfolding situation?
- 35:42Rob Gray, PhD: And you kind of get sudden, and so I I think it just gets people to think about how they can make little tweaks to make it the practice more representative.
- 35:51Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, you know, in teamwork training, we work on the non-technical skills.
- 35:53Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: There is a way to do that.
- 35:54Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So you get into something known as guided self-correction.
- 35:57Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So you and I've learned this from uh folks from JetBlue and then folks that were working up at Boeing and healthcare organizations and emergency rooms up in Seattle, where they identified that, hey, we got this from commercial aviation and fighter aviation.
- 36:10Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's basically you describe a positive behavior or a negative behavior.
- 36:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And we we did that in teaming, and I'm just wondering that's it's probably the same thing.
- 36:18Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's uh, you know, what is good look like, right?
- 36:21Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And it's hard to describe sometimes, but once you do that, you get into guided self-correction for coaches, and it might be something that uh could be worth exploring.
- 36:29Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I'm trying to remember the technical name of these, and I can't believe it's not the tip of my head.
- 36:33Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Or anyway, but yeah, that's that that works, right?
- 36:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Once people know where they are, you know.
- 36:39Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, for sure.
- 36:40Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And generally, if you were to do that with a a high school basketball coach, um, for example, they're gonna be, I'll say, far far left on the spectrum when it comes to are you doing things that you that make no sense, right?
- 36:52Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, yeah.
- 36:53Rob Gray, PhD: They're gonna do probably coach the way they were coached.
- 36:56Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Or or there's no coupling.
- 36:57Mark McGrath: There's also risk aversion too, right?
- 36:59Mark McGrath: They don't want to take the risk and be and be different.
- 37:02Mark McGrath: You know, they don't want to uh something could be phenomenal.
- 37:05Mark McGrath: I mean, it seems like it seems like anytime there's been a novelty innovation in a sport, any sport where it literally changed the game, that came at such considerable risk that somebody finally had the stones to do it.
- 37:16Mark McGrath: And for sure.
- 37:17Mark McGrath: Everybody was saying, you know, ruining the game, you're destroying their game, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 37:23Mark McGrath: But in reality, it it it changed it forever.
- 37:26Mark McGrath: Like, I think back to, you know, Gladwell's got that book, David and Goliath, and he talks about those the basketball team in Silicon Valley.
- 37:33Mark McGrath: Yeah, they just pressed the whole time.
- 37:36Mark McGrath: I just read that, yeah.
- 37:37Mark McGrath: Yeah, and it makes total sense.
- 37:38Mark McGrath: Like, why wouldn't you do that?
- 37:39Mark McGrath: But then, but then like they gave in to like the the sort of the herd saying, you know, this is destroying the game, you know, you're not playing basketball the right way.
- 37:48Mark McGrath: This is not how we used to do it.
- 37:50Mark McGrath: And then that when they when they violated their their innovation, when they violated their novelty, they lost.
- 37:56Rob Gray, PhD: Mm-hmm.
- 37:57Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 37:57Rob Gray, PhD: Oftentimes you get that a rule, like in the league we just played in, you couldn't press to the last two minutes of the half.
- 38:05Mark McGrath: But when Walter Camp invented the forward pass, you know, it was heresy, right?
- 38:09Mark McGrath: Or like, you know, run and shoot or West Coast offense.
- 38:12Mark McGrath: These things were heretical until they became so successful you couldn't argue with the results anymore.
- 38:19Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 38:19Rob Gray, PhD: For sure.
- 38:20Rob Gray, PhD: Lots of that's what yeah, the kind of the old school people complaining, you know.
- 38:25Rob Gray, PhD: So yeah.
- 38:26Mark McGrath: That was the article of the that's the article, the tyranny of the coaching tree.
- 38:29Mark McGrath: It's like the you know, the coaching tree, it's like, you know, they're not gonna violate off the orthodoxy, but the ones that do take the risks are the ones that those are the ones that ultimately get rewarded.
- 38:38Mark McGrath: Yeah, there's bad risks too.
- 38:40Mark McGrath: Like not not every, like we were saying, John Boyd terms, like not every not every snowmobile works, you know.
- 38:45Mark McGrath: Uh yeah.
- 38:47Rob Gray, PhD: But for sure.
- 38:47Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 38:48Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, and I think a lot of it is, you know, one of the things we uh we focus so much on what we're trying to develop coaches, like you're talking about coaching tree.
- 38:58Rob Gray, PhD: Like so many coaches focus on what to coach instead of how to do it, right?
- 39:03Rob Gray, PhD: Like what you you need to coach this defense, that, but how do you do it?
- 39:07Rob Gray, PhD: How do you when and how do you give feedback?
- 39:09Rob Gray, PhD: How do you use instruction?
- 39:10Rob Gray, PhD: How do you design practice, right?
- 39:12Rob Gray, PhD: So so I I think getting the experience, the really good guys that have the long, deep, tall trees, they develop how to coach.
- 39:18Rob Gray, PhD: They educate their people that work with them and they're well to that end.
- 39:22Mark McGrath: Anytime I've ever worked with a sports coach, they're always waiting for me to tell them what offensive drills to run or what do I need, what and and and when it never comes, they can't believe it because all I'm trying to do is get them to adjust their cognition, their cognitive software, and then what they need to do differently, it just becomes self-evident.
- 39:40Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I want to go back into some of the theory here.
- 39:41Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And when I read about Bernstein's degrees of freedom, and you brought up Bernstein earlier, uh, there's folks that come out of the military and say, we got to execute flawlessly.
- 39:49Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, well, after you read Bernstein's uh work, you're like, that's impossible, right?
- 39:53Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: The outcomes are important, but how you execute varies because of complexity, right?
- 39:59Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So can you walk us through and our listeners through what that is?
- 40:02Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What did Bernstein discover?
- 40:04Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, so Bern Bernstein's fundamental I'll go along.
- 40:07Rob Gray, PhD: Bernstein was a Russian physiologist early.
- 40:09Rob Gray, PhD: And I really like his story because he was not only a scientist, but he was assigned to apply it.
- 40:14Rob Gray, PhD: He got assigned a job in the of working with blacksmiths and trying to make them more productive.
- 40:19Rob Gray, PhD: And he, this typical assumption was, right, you want to consistently hit your piece on the metal when you hit with the hammer.
- 40:27Rob Gray, PhD: And the way that you do that is by doing the same hammer swing every time.
- 40:31Rob Gray, PhD: So you you repeat an outcome by repeating the movement perfectly, right?
- 40:35Rob Gray, PhD: Just like you said, you repeat that technique over and over.
- 40:38Rob Gray, PhD: That's where you become skillful.
- 40:40Rob Gray, PhD: Bernstein, luckily for everybody, didn't buy that and he measured it and he showed, no, he came up with this phrase, repetition without repetition.
- 40:48Rob Gray, PhD: So you repeat an outcome.
- 40:50Rob Gray, PhD: I repeat getting in a ball in the basket, but not by repeating the same shooting technique every time.
- 40:56Rob Gray, PhD: My favorite example of that, Steph Curry is the king of that, right?
- 41:00Rob Gray, PhD: He never takes the same shot twice.
- 41:02Rob Gray, PhD: He never, he never takes the exact same jump shot.
- 41:05Rob Gray, PhD: Um, but he consistently gets the ball on the hoop.
- 41:07Rob Gray, PhD: He repeats the outcome without repeating the movement.
- 41:09Rob Gray, PhD: So Bernstein identified that's kind of his phone.
- 41:12Rob Gray, PhD: And then he he kind of, for understanding how we achieve that, he came up with this idea that this is a degrees of freedom problem.
- 41:20Rob Gray, PhD: So a degree of freedom is think of a degree of freedom as like your your joints and your muscles, and you have all these options for moving, right?
- 41:30Rob Gray, PhD: So when I when I, you know, I example I use serving a volleyball, I could serve a volleyball just by swinging my arm and keeping my elbow locked and my wrist locked.
- 41:39Rob Gray, PhD: I could hit the ball underhand over the net, or I could bend my shoulder rotate around my shoulder, my elbow, and my wrist.
- 41:45Rob Gray, PhD: Each of those is what Bernstein called a degrees of freedom, right?
- 41:49Rob Gray, PhD: And he said he what he identified was the hard part is not is which how what do I do with all?
- 41:55Rob Gray, PhD: We have too many options, really, when you first start out learning a skill.
- 41:59Rob Gray, PhD: You have too many different ways you can perform an action.
- 42:02Rob Gray, PhD: Um so we need to take some of those away.
- 42:05Rob Gray, PhD: That's how we sold, and you know, human beings are terrible with options.
- 42:09Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 42:09Rob Gray, PhD: Um when we, you know, my favorite example is a microwave, right?
- 42:13Rob Gray, PhD: A microwave has 42 different buttons.
- 42:15Rob Gray, PhD: Most people use two popcorn and start, right?
- 42:19Rob Gray, PhD: Because people don't want a million options, right?
- 42:21Rob Gray, PhD: So there's too many different ways to throw a ball, hit a ball, or whatever.
- 42:25Rob Gray, PhD: So there's too many different, you think about all the what I need to, if I need to tell my wrist, shoulder, and elbow what to do when I'm serving a volleyball, that's a lot for kind of my so that he that he we argued that's the fundamental thing you have to solve.
- 42:40Rob Gray, PhD: It's also like a real strength, right?
- 42:42Rob Gray, PhD: I so I I I can serve in multiple different ways.
- 42:45Rob Gray, PhD: If I get tired, my elbow gets sore.
- 42:48Rob Gray, PhD: So I've got what we would call redundancy.
- 42:50Rob Gray, PhD: There's another term.
- 42:51Rob Gray, PhD: Redundancy means there's just multiple different ways to achieve their goal.
- 42:54Rob Gray, PhD: So that was his, he identified this problem and he thought of different ways.
- 42:58Rob Gray, PhD: And one of the typical ways when you're first learning a skill is we what do what is called freezing degrees of freedom.
- 43:04Rob Gray, PhD: So we essentially take one of those options away, right?
- 43:07Rob Gray, PhD: So it's very common for someone to first learn to serve a volleyball, right?
- 43:11Rob Gray, PhD: They lock their elbow.
- 43:12Rob Gray, PhD: They don't rotate around.
- 43:14Rob Gray, PhD: So now they don't need to figure out what to do with it, they just don't move it, right?
- 43:18Rob Gray, PhD: The problem is when you do that, the your solution doesn't have it's not going to be great.
- 43:22Rob Gray, PhD: You're not gonna be able to hit very hard ball.
- 43:25Rob Gray, PhD: So um, but you probably can get proficient and play.
- 43:28Rob Gray, PhD: So, but then you kind of over time you learn to unfreeze those things.
- 43:33Rob Gray, PhD: So, yeah, that was his.
- 43:34Rob Gray, PhD: So he is uh, you know, understanding motor control, understanding the role of variability and and adapting to different conditions and constraints.
- 43:42Rob Gray, PhD: He didn't use the word constraints, but uh he was talking about that at the time.
- 43:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Okay, no, thanks for that.
- 43:46Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 43:47Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Something else I want to pick your brain on, and I'll give you some examples.
- 43:50Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So, coaches' feedback.
- 43:51Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh, so we talk about debriefing and effective debriefing, but there's a different approach when you're in a training environment.
- 43:58Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And let me give you an example.
- 43:59Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So in fighter aviation, as an instructor, the way we would lead a debrief is we were trying to build, believe it or not, their, you know, what are they attuned to when they're flying?
- 44:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What altitude were you at?
- 44:10Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Where was the sun?
- 44:11Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh what side were you on?
- 44:12Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What was your heading?
- 44:13Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What was your airspeed?
- 44:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And we're trying to build that into their, I guess the way they look at the, you know, how they look at their cockpit and what they're looking at.
- 44:20Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So the next time they go out there, they can know what to pay attention to, right?
- 44:23Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I need to know this, I need to know that, I need to know these things.
- 44:25Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So what we're trying to do in that accelerated approach to performance in fighter aviation in that training environment is we're asking questions, right?
- 44:35Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We're not, we're not demanding them, tell us what this was.
- 44:39Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We're like, you know, usually you'll go, what side were you on?
- 44:41Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And they'll go, I was on the right, and you're like, no, you're on the left.
- 44:44Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You know?
- 44:44Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Just the basic things, right?
- 44:46Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 44:46Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So walk me through the coach's role in feedback in in CLA and an ecological approach.
- 44:53Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, the what you described is a great example of what we kind of promote.
- 44:57Rob Gray, PhD: And that's a perfect example of the term I mentioned, educating attention.
- 45:01Rob Gray, PhD: So you're by the you're giving kind of leading questions by where what they need to focus on, right?
- 45:08Rob Gray, PhD: You need to focus on the by asking them where was, you're encouraging them to focus on that next time because you know that's important what for information for the task as a coach.
- 45:18Rob Gray, PhD: So that's perfect, perfect example, coach using their knowledge to guide.
- 45:21Rob Gray, PhD: Questioning is is a great tool.
- 45:24Rob Gray, PhD: I like to um get people to kind of answer the questions by doing it, like getting them to actually show you instead of just saying, if if at all possible.
- 45:35Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, and also it gets the athlete engaged.
- 45:38Rob Gray, PhD: Um, one of the things we were hoping to get out of this is getting athlete more involved instead of just being a passive recipient of a coach ordering them what to do and pushing them around.
- 45:48Rob Gray, PhD: We want them to be involved in their own learning.
- 45:50Rob Gray, PhD: What's that look like?
- 45:51Rob Gray, PhD: What's that what's that look like?
- 45:53Rob Gray, PhD: I mean, um So how do how does that happen?
- 45:56Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, yeah so get letting them so there's a few different things.
- 45:59Rob Gray, PhD: Letting them feel like having uh some choice in how sometimes I'll I'll end practice like okay, what what constraint should we do now?
- 46:08Rob Gray, PhD: I'll ask them, I'll get their advice, and maybe it's something silly, but giving them how they're they they feel like they're involved, they're not just following orders.
- 46:16Rob Gray, PhD: Feeling like they're part of uh part of a team, really.
- 46:21Rob Gray, PhD: They want instead of having isolated drills where you're doing one-on-one, people really like the relatedness, feeling part of the dream, part of a team.
- 46:29Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, so that's that's it.
- 46:30Rob Gray, PhD: But the other thing with feedback, we want to give, try to not to talk so much while someone's doing something.
- 46:37Rob Gray, PhD: Do it after, right?
- 46:39Rob Gray, PhD: We will there's what we call terminal feedback is much more effective than saying, unless, right, there's certain constraints, you know.
- 46:46Rob Gray, PhD: I was just at a policing conference, we were talking about firearms, right?
- 46:50Rob Gray, PhD: There's certain constraints that are non-negotiable, like basic firearm safety, right?
- 46:54Rob Gray, PhD: Those things you want to stop.
- 46:56Rob Gray, PhD: It's okay to stop immediately, right?
- 46:58Rob Gray, PhD: If someone's has their finger on the trigger when they're running into a room, okay, stop.
- 47:02Rob Gray, PhD: Those are non-negotiable.
- 47:04Rob Gray, PhD: They're very strong, those are constraints we're giving on them, but we really want to emphasize when they're when they're buying, because they're pretty serious.
- 47:10Rob Gray, PhD: Same with you know, a martial arts class or something, if you punch someone when you're not supposed to, things like that.
- 47:16Rob Gray, PhD: So yeah, so but the for the most part, we want to let kind of them do their thing and then give them the feedback after.
- 47:22Rob Gray, PhD: Um and I and like I said, questioning is a big one.
- 47:26Rob Gray, PhD: I think that was a great example you gave.
- 47:28Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So one of the examples I was talking to a basketball coach the other day is in inbounding a ball, and you know, it's always getting intercepted.
- 47:33Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I think it was in your book where you or one of your books where you talk about that where you allow the athletes to fail, right?
- 47:42Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I mean, they're gonna throw the ball to the other team and then let them come up with a solution.
- 47:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Somebody on maybe is that stuff and I think the Marines did that quite a bit.
- 47:49Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh what do they call it?
- 47:50Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh, internal bias for action, or uh I forgot there's a technical term for it, but they it's a way to buy into it, right?
- 47:56Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So you talk a little bit more about that.
- 47:59Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, for sure.
- 47:59Rob Gray, PhD: I I like I said earlier, I think failure is like great.
- 48:03Rob Gray, PhD: Like, so yeah, letting you you can't get the ball in, then you learn to bounce pass or reach around someone, right?
- 48:09Rob Gray, PhD: Instead of doing something because a coach told me to, right?
- 48:14Rob Gray, PhD: Getting the person to do a bounce pass because it ends up getting that to getting I'm successful, just so much more powerful.
- 48:21Rob Gray, PhD: Then they understand.
- 48:22Rob Gray, PhD: I always say, let them understand the why themselves, right?
- 48:26Rob Gray, PhD: Why you're doing it.
- 48:28Rob Gray, PhD: Why do I want to do a bounce pass here?
- 48:29Rob Gray, PhD: Because it's harder for them to block, right?
- 48:31Rob Gray, PhD: Things like that.
- 48:32Rob Gray, PhD: So yeah, I think that's a that's a good example.
- 48:34Rob Gray, PhD: It's a really good or powerful way to learn.
- 48:37Rob Gray, PhD: Didn't uh as long as you don't have too much failure, right?
- 48:40Rob Gray, PhD: Too much failure is gonna demotivate them, feel confident.
- 48:43Rob Gray, PhD: So you you kind of have to balance it, right?
- 48:45Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 48:46Mark McGrath: What's that book uh about Vince Lombardi, like when when pride still mattered, didn't he, you know, he had gone to Jesuit schools, which were free thinking and open inquiry.
- 48:57Mark McGrath: And I and I'm biased, I'm a product of two Jesuit schools.
- 49:00Mark McGrath: But they they give you the constraints, but you're free to operate within them however you see fit, so long as you you know get the mission done, right?
- 49:08Mark McGrath: And and when he was teaching football, he says, even if the play calls to go to the two-hole and the four hole's open, the two-hole's not, go in the four hole.
- 49:15Mark McGrath: Like take make the decision to have the freedom and the autonomy within the constraints to to to make the decision to do something different.
- 49:23Mark McGrath: Don't just do it because the play, the play says so.
- 49:27Mark McGrath: The other thing I I about staying on Lombardi really quick though was that John Madden would tell the story that when he was a young coach, he went up, Lombardi would do this like coach's symposium or whatever, and he says there was eight hours on just the sweep.
- 49:44Mark McGrath: Like eight hours, eight hours, just the sweep.
- 49:48Mark McGrath: But Madden, but Mad Madden said the more that we got into it over and over and over, all of a sudden, all these different opportunities started to emerge.
- 49:59Mark McGrath: You started to see things differently, even though it was allegedly just a repetitive thing of just the the sweep, but it it was it was like the orientation is kind of like like you know, you don't you don't think of these things anymore, and and possibilities emerge when you get so attuned to something.
- 50:20Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, and that yeah, there's some there's been some reanalysis of John Wooden's coaching too, and he seemed to have a lot of that in there too.
- 50:27Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, the that's where here's another term, affordance, right?
- 50:30Rob Gray, PhD: What we want is our athletes to pick up affordance.
- 50:34Rob Gray, PhD: We want to pick up to opportunities in the moment.
- 50:37Rob Gray, PhD: So if the play calls for this, but you're right, the four holes wide open, go there, take that opportunity, right?
- 50:43Rob Gray, PhD: And don't just pre-plan a movement and do it.
- 50:47Rob Gray, PhD: We want and teamwork comes when two more one or more two or more teammates perceive that ordinance at the same time.
- 50:54Rob Gray, PhD: So they both perceive a wide receiver perceive that they're blitzing, and he goes, he cut changes the pattern and goes along.
- 51:01Rob Gray, PhD: The quarterback perceives at the same time, and boom, there's a touchdown, right?
- 51:05Rob Gray, PhD: So perceive allowing things happen in the moment instead of having by picking up the information instead of having everything pre-planned and scripted.
- 51:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So we train for adaptability, right?
- 51:16Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's what you're saying.
- 51:18Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 51:19Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 51:19Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Not not to follow a plan.
- 51:21Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And that's yeah.
- 51:23Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 51:23Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So the way we talk about planning, it's plans are something to deviate from.
- 51:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's not a rigid approach, but most people look at it as that's what I have to follow.
- 51:30Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Or like, no, no, it's just a starting point.
- 51:31Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 51:32Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So this is fact.
- 51:33Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: There's so much overlap between what you're doing, and again, I I I really believed um years ago that the elite coaching um community was doing this.
- 51:44Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But it sounds to me like it's just starting to, it's in pockets.
- 51:47Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's a weak signal right now, right?
- 51:49Rob Gray, PhD: It is, yeah.
- 51:50Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, I would agree.
- 51:50Rob Gray, PhD: There are some coaches that have been doing this very, very well, some sports more than others.
- 51:55Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, it it's still very traditional in a lot of ways.
- 52:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What would be a good path to do?
- 52:02Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I mean, looking at Alex, uh, I'm gonna get his name.
- 52:04Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Samara, am I saying his name?
- 52:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 52:06Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: This path is is very unique, right?
- 52:08Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: To coaching.
- 52:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 52:10Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What is the talking to my girls that you know, they're like, what are they gonna do in the future?
- 52:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And I'm saying, hey, AI is gonna be a big part of human performance.
- 52:17Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So is coaching.
- 52:18Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So just walk me through what a good path would be to get to do what Alex is doing with the or will be doing with the Portland Fire.
- 52:27Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, so I think, you know, Alex is because he was a coach, basketball coach first, and then he kind of I think he had an aha moment, like with I was doing some of this already, and then he came across this field that perfectly aligns with what he he felt work, and then he kind of kind of went from there and got his player development with the Cleveland Clavineers.
- 52:47Rob Gray, PhD: And then so yeah, I don't I think uh just getting getting involved, like start uh thinking about practice designs, get involved in uh in in communicating.
- 52:58Rob Gray, PhD: I think get out what what I tell people in my sport, get your stuff out there, right?
- 53:03Rob Gray, PhD: Start a blog or a podcast, talk about how you're implementing these stuff, what you learned.
- 53:08Rob Gray, PhD: Um, don't be afraid if not stuff works, talk about how you iterate on practice, right?
- 53:13Rob Gray, PhD: How you so I think getting in and a lot of teams I know kind of they're they're looking at those kind of things, um, looking for the next person and take any experience you opportunity you can to learn from other coaches, even if it's not in your sport, your main area.
- 53:31Rob Gray, PhD: I think there's so much you can learn from and even trying coaching other sports.
- 53:35Rob Gray, PhD: So yeah, I think obviously just doing it, right?
- 53:38Rob Gray, PhD: But doing it, having a mentor, having a group, one of the things I have a group that works with my podcast where we have a bunch of coaches and we just talk through problems and challenges people face doing this.
- 53:48Rob Gray, PhD: Everyone's in a different sport and stuff, but it's very, very so get a coaching group to discuss some of the things you're doing and trying and get ideas from other people.
- 53:57Rob Gray, PhD: I think that's really a great way to do it.
- 54:00Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Let me ask you this if a large corporation came to you and said, hey, how do we apply CLA to develop uh team skills or technical skills and in whatever it may be?
- 54:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What would your response be?
- 54:12Rob Gray, PhD: So, like if I there were if I were applying this to how to run a business, for example, or something like that.
- 54:18Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: To improve performance, uh human performance in an organization.
- 54:22Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, I think uh, you know, allow giving, identifying the, you know, I I think about I get people do I have a few exercises they do one constraints matrix, where I get people to think about what are the constraints in our activity or whatever we're working on?
- 54:36Rob Gray, PhD: Time, space.
- 54:37Rob Gray, PhD: And we work through them.
- 54:38Rob Gray, PhD: And I think what might adding one of these do?
- 54:41Rob Gray, PhD: Well, how might it change people's behavior?
- 54:43Rob Gray, PhD: So get people thinking through those things.
- 54:45Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, so get just get people thinking along the lines and and trying stuff and and and seeing writing, observing their experience, I think is the how I would do it.
- 54:55Rob Gray, PhD: And depending on the sport, I kind of well, I I work in a lot of different sports in the in now a beyond sport, some some of the things, but kind of doing I'd start with an analysis of what I think is involved in the typical way we train.
- 55:07Rob Gray, PhD: And usually if I'm trying to sell myself, I talk about you know, kind of the how I would the kind of low transfer we get from the type of training to the actual environment.
- 55:17Rob Gray, PhD: We see yeah.
- 55:19Rob Gray, PhD: Well, yeah, I think that I think that's kind of I would say it, you know.
- 55:22Rob Gray, PhD: I think it does apply.
- 55:24Rob Gray, PhD: You know, I'm using a lot now is you once you see this, you can't unsee it, right?
- 55:29Rob Gray, PhD: It applies to life, right?
- 55:30Rob Gray, PhD: Everything in your life, you're like, oh my god, so I I could think I think it would work for anything.
- 55:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um we've been talking about musicians and uh Yeah, Rob, I we'd have to agree with you because we come at this from a the lens of the Oodaloop, observe oriented side act, which is not just those four things.
- 55:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's it's much, much more, you know, cybernetics to physics to philosophy to warfare, right?
- 55:50Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That it just represents the tip of a massive iceberg, if we want to call it that.
- 55:54Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But once you see it, you can't unsee it.
- 55:56Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And it's very frustrating for us to, you know, because we we're Moose and I and our organization, we have to deal with people that go, well, that's not the way I was taught.
- 56:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's not what Mackenzie teach is teaching us.
- 56:08Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: That's not what they're doing over there.
- 56:09Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And you're like, they're wrong.
- 56:11Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 56:12Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But it doesn't work, it doesn't always work in our favor that way, right?
- 56:15Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 56:15Rob Gray, PhD: That's one thing that I like about this field that's complex, adapts, right?
- 56:20Rob Gray, PhD: It's not a special theory we develop for fighter pilots or humans.
- 56:24Rob Gray, PhD: It applies to everything.
- 56:26Rob Gray, PhD: See how sand dunes form, right?
- 56:28Rob Gray, PhD: How your heart works.
- 56:30Rob Gray, PhD: It's a dynamo, it's it's just it's a theory of everything.
- 56:33Rob Gray, PhD: It's not an easy theory, right?
- 56:34Rob Gray, PhD: It would also kind of recognize.
- 56:36Rob Gray, PhD: I th I like it, I think it's a bit more honest.
- 56:38Rob Gray, PhD: It's recognizing this is just messy and chaotic, and we just have to deal with that.
- 56:43Rob Gray, PhD: We're except we're dealing with the whole looking at the whole picture instead of trying trying to make things controllable and understandable by reducing reductionistic.
- 56:52Mark McGrath: The generalist will survive over the specialist.
- 56:55Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah.
- 56:57Mark McGrath: Interdisciplinary when we look at a lot of these thinkers like Boyd and McLuhan and even Vince Lombardi.
- 57:08Mark McGrath: I mean, Vince Lombardi was a classic example of a of a guy who was interdisciplined, like you know, very interdisciplinary training.
- 57:13Mark McGrath: I think that the generalist survives, not the specialist.
- 57:17Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Well, here's what I'm gonna do, Rob.
- 57:18Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Those people that are closest to me that that I want to influence, but I'm not gonna do it me.
- 57:23Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna ask them to look at your podcast and look at your work.
- 57:26Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So can you tell our audience where they can find more of what you're doing, what you're doing next, who you're working with, and and all that?
- 57:33Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Just so they because I don't want them coming to me because they're they're they're friends and family.
- 57:37Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: They're gonna go, Mr.
- 57:38Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Rivera's want wants this, or you know, Callan Carmen's dad wants this, we're gonna do it.
- 57:42Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: No, no, no.
- 57:43Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I'm just pointing to them and saying, you should probably look at this because this is what we do with organizations that win.
- 57:48Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's the same thing.
- 57:49Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So share with our audience what they where they can find your work.
- 57:52Rob Gray, PhD: So uh I have a website, perceptionaction.com.
- 57:55Rob Gray, PhD: That's my main website.
- 57:57Rob Gray, PhD: That kind of everything you mentioned.
- 57:59Rob Gray, PhD: I have a podcast where I get really down the nitty-gritty of all the the details of this, applying this to skill acquisition.
- 58:06Rob Gray, PhD: Um, and then I have a few books I've written and kind of the consulting uh opportunity with some do some workshops every once in a while if I'm doing a couple of police uh workshops in the in the new year.
- 58:17Rob Gray, PhD: Um yeah, so you can find everything in there, perception action doc.
- 58:21Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 58:21Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: And then uh I've come across several coaches over the last few years.
- 58:24Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Uh I'm gonna throw their names at uh at you on here, and you you you can go ahead and decline to uh respond to it.
- 58:30Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: But uh one of the ones I've been following is Joe Boylan over he used to be with Memphis Grizzlies.
- 58:36Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Um and he writes, I mean he's constantly throwing things out there.
- 58:39Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, but but I'm like, are all coaches like this?
- 58:43Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Because if they are, man, that's that's where everybody needs to be learning.
- 58:45Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So I believe he has a new company called uh I don't know what it's uh let me look it up, uh Cognition Coach.
- 58:51Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What a great name.
- 58:52Rob Gray, PhD: Um do you know Joe at all?
- 58:53Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, I do.
- 58:54Rob Gray, PhD: I met a great guy.
- 58:56Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, he he's an example.
- 58:58Rob Gray, PhD: I don't know, I don't think he would mind me saying this, but where the upper organized upper level management, he didn't have the quite the support in Memphis, I think, as I understand how things went.
- 59:10Rob Gray, PhD: Men with the play certain players and things, so it didn't it was working well, but he didn't quite have it.
- 59:16Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, I think it's I think it's it's fun for me.
- 59:19Rob Gray, PhD: I'm really I love helping people develop and help you know educate stuff.
- 59:24Rob Gray, PhD: So it's very exciting to me.
- 59:26Rob Gray, PhD: There are quite a few coaches that are really interested in in you know, upping their understanding of things, and that's really exciting.
- 59:33Rob Gray, PhD: But it's there are that that's he's an extreme example, right?
- 59:37Rob Gray, PhD: He's always posting reviews of papers he's reading and stuff.
- 59:40Rob Gray, PhD: So yeah.
- 59:40Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, he's a he's he's doing interesting things with decision making and all kind of ecological approach and stuff.
- 59:46Rob Gray, PhD: So yeah, it's cool.
- 59:47Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: What about in baseball?
- 59:49Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I mean, any any can you share with us any coaches or organizations that are really into this?
- 59:55Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, so the I've worked with two now.
- 59:57Rob Gray, PhD: I used to work with the Red Sox, now I work with the Cubs.
- 1:00:00Rob Gray, PhD: So, you know, people like Jason Ochart, who was with the Red Sox, he's he's uh a hitting coach.
- 1:00:07Rob Gray, PhD: He he's affiliated with Drive Line.
- 1:00:09Rob Gray, PhD: Drive Line's a private baseball training facility that has multiple locations.
- 1:00:13Rob Gray, PhD: They really buy into a lot of this stuff.
- 1:00:15Rob Gray, PhD: Some of the you know, the people I work with, the Cubs now, you know, Craig Counsel's our manager, he's got a lot of the you know uh these ideas in the way he coaches.
- 1:00:24Rob Gray, PhD: I like that.
- 1:00:24Rob Gray, PhD: So come to New York.
- 1:00:26Rob Gray, PhD: We need you, we need it here in New York.
- 1:00:28Rob Gray, PhD: The Yankees?
- 1:00:29Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 1:00:30Rob Gray, PhD: You had a guy, um, yeah, the there's a few guys that used I used to know there, but yeah, so it is expanding, and it's interesting to see uh because part of this is recreating the culture and the environment.
- 1:00:44Mark McGrath: I got a question, kind of a curveball here.
- 1:00:46Mark McGrath: So I was stationed in Japan for almost two years, and I fell in love with Japanese baseball.
- 1:00:53Mark McGrath: I think I think it's played completely differently than it is here in the United States.
- 1:00:59Mark McGrath: Right?
- 1:01:00Mark McGrath: I mean, the the crowds, the environment, it's absolutely insanity, like on the scale of European soccer.
- 1:01:05Mark McGrath: And I've noticed that the technical differences between a player that came up in the JBL versus the MLB, and then when they come over here, they either make it or they don't.
- 1:01:16Mark McGrath: But some of the ones that have been really successful, like Otani.
- 1:01:18Mark McGrath: And a Deonomo and Adeki Matsui and others.
- 1:01:21Mark McGrath: Have you ever looked into that?
- 1:01:22Mark McGrath: Like what's the what's what are the cultural differences between what goes on in baseball in Japan versus what goes on here in the United States by them?
- 1:01:30Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, I think there's cultural differences in terms of the workload and things like that.
- 1:01:37Rob Gray, PhD: One of the specific things I can point to is in Japan, in Korea as well, they actually they have they hire pitchers that didn't make it to the level to throw batting practice.
- 1:01:50Rob Gray, PhD: So where whereas in North America we use more machines, right?
- 1:01:53Rob Gray, PhD: You do batting practice with machines.
- 1:01:55Rob Gray, PhD: We would never have a we do some lot of batting against a pitcher in practice, but you can't do too much because you wear it, you're gonna wear out the pitcher.
- 1:02:03Rob Gray, PhD: So they have more realistic some ways more realistic training environments.
- 1:02:07Rob Gray, PhD: But I think um, yeah, I think that's there's there's some differences like that, how much they push the kind of uh the their uh no not following strict models, things like that.
- 1:02:19Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, I do I agree with you.
- 1:02:20Rob Gray, PhD: It's a fun, it's a fun environment.
- 1:02:22Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 1:02:23Mark McGrath: What are their gaps?
- 1:02:23Mark McGrath: Like what what do Americans do better than they than they don't, do you think?
- 1:02:27Mark McGrath: Like by again, generally speaking.
- 1:02:30Rob Gray, PhD: I don't know.
- 1:02:31Rob Gray, PhD: I think it's it's position, you know, it's specific specific.
- 1:02:34Rob Gray, PhD: Uh I think, you know, developing uh in the the having the develop the system minor league to major league systems better in America.
- 1:02:41Rob Gray, PhD: But I don't know if there's any specific things I could point to that are different.
- 1:02:45Rob Gray, PhD: I think there's you know, just we've had some extreme cases, like with the Ortho Tani, who's uh unbelievable, but I think so I don't know if they're they're kind of supposed to be.
- 1:02:56Mark McGrath: The last and probably the most natural question is just the cultural difference between Eastern culture versus Western, specifically Japanese, which is one of more respect and humility.
- 1:03:07Mark McGrath: There's there's less it's it seems like in in JBL there's less sort of highlight reel show boating, like there's less there's a lot less of the sort of fun and games that go on that take away from the actual sport.
- 1:03:22Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, for sure.
- 1:03:23Rob Gray, PhD: And there's more, yeah, there's some kind of you know, the respecting your elders, not questioning, is it is it it's a little bit actually goes against the theory.
- 1:03:32Rob Gray, PhD: We'd expect those to make people less skillful in the ecological dynamics.
- 1:03:36Mark McGrath: So so I it's not the best example for for for um So Pedro Martinez throwing Don Zimmer to the deck, that wouldn't happen in Japan, probably.
- 1:03:45Rob Gray, PhD: Probably not, no.
- 1:03:46Rob Gray, PhD: Or a player saying, Why are you making me do all these weird drills?
- 1:03:50Rob Gray, PhD: You know, yeah.
- 1:03:52Rob Gray, PhD: It probably wouldn't happen, yeah.
- 1:03:54Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, no, no, it's interesting.
- 1:03:56Rob Gray, PhD: There are some, I don't know if anyone's done a baseball one.
- 1:03:58Rob Gray, PhD: There's an interesting one in soccer, like you know, soccer, the like Brazil, their kind of culture and stuff, they reward flair and you doing all kinds of showy moves, and that's with how their players play, the million deceptive step over moves, and you know, like so it it there's definitely a culture.
- 1:04:17Rob Gray, PhD: Culture is kind of one of the environmental constraints we talk about, right?
- 1:04:21Rob Gray, PhD: I think as a coach, too, you create like, do you want to be a defensive team or you want to be an offensive team, right?
- 1:04:27Rob Gray, PhD: You have to kind of create a culture around what you think's important.
- 1:04:31Rob Gray, PhD: It can't go too strong, right?
- 1:04:33Rob Gray, PhD: Maybe in some of your years, how hard are those to how hard are those to overcome?
- 1:04:38Mark McGrath: Because I think when people think, say Pittsburgh Steelers, they think Blitzberg, and I think Jack Lambert and Greg Lloyd and James Harrison and they think of these Paul Amalo, they think of these fearsome Hall of Fame defensive players that would put guys into the hospital or in their careers, but that kind of regression thinking doesn't address the present of the way that the game is changing and evolving.
- 1:05:02Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah.
- 1:05:02Rob Gray, PhD: No, I think you get you get very stuck in your ways, and you're right, you're not adapting to the new players.
- 1:05:08Rob Gray, PhD: I was lucky enough to do a little bit of stuff with the Spurs, right?
- 1:05:11Rob Gray, PhD: When they drafted Wemby.
- 1:05:13Rob Gray, PhD: And I met Greg Popovich.
- 1:05:15Rob Gray, PhD: He actually he came up and shook my head after I did a present presentation.
- 1:05:19Rob Gray, PhD: He's like, hi, I'm Greg Popovich.
- 1:05:21Rob Gray, PhD: I'm like, I know who you are.
- 1:05:22Rob Gray, PhD: But he was like, we were talking about Wemby.
- 1:05:25Rob Gray, PhD: He's like, I'm not sure what I'm how we're gonna coach him yet, because I have to see.
- 1:05:28Rob Gray, PhD: Like I have to see what he has.
- 1:05:29Rob Gray, PhD: I'm not gonna coach him like Tim Duncan.
- 1:05:31Rob Gray, PhD: He's a completely different guy, right?
- 1:05:33Rob Gray, PhD: So I was really impressed by that.
- 1:05:35Rob Gray, PhD: I think if you get too structured into a culture, then you can't, you gotta and and then kind of copying a culture, like that.
- 1:05:43Rob Gray, PhD: You like copying, oh, we want to play like Tampa Bay or whatever.
- 1:05:46Rob Gray, PhD: And when you don't have the same people, the same environment, that's that can that's a bad one.
- 1:05:51Rob Gray, PhD: But yeah, even copying culture from team to team, I think, can be bad.
- 1:05:54Rob Gray, PhD: He would be an interesting guy.
- 1:05:55Rob Gray, PhD: You've got to adjust to what you have, what you have on your team.
- 1:05:59Mark McGrath: Greg Popovich would be an interesting guy to speak with because he's an Air Force Academy graduate and he was an intelligence officer in the Air Force, and it's it'd be interesting to see how much of his uh you know wiring as a as a former officer and as a cadet, you know, how did that have an effect on?
- 1:06:15Mark McGrath: Because you know, John Boyd was an Air Force officer.
- 1:06:17Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:06:18Mark McGrath: I wonder um what effect that had.
- 1:06:21Mark McGrath: He was a real Yeah.
- 1:06:23Mark McGrath: Same thing with like Shoshevsky.
- 1:06:25Rob Gray, PhD: Like Shoshevsky went to West Point, and he was a culture of how they play defense and emphasis with Duke.
- 1:06:36Mark McGrath: Bum Phillips of the Houston Oilers was a marine raider that fought in World War II.
- 1:06:40Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:06:41Mark McGrath: Gunfighter.
- 1:06:43Rob Gray, PhD: I'm sure it had an effect.
- 1:06:43Rob Gray, PhD: It's got a lot of skills.
- 1:06:45Mark McGrath: Tom Landry was a bomber pilot in the Eighth Air Force.
- 1:06:48Mark McGrath: A lot of these military guys, who knows?
- 1:06:51Mark McGrath: Maybe there's more than we realize.
- 1:06:53Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:06:54Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Well, hey, Rob, we really appreciate your time today, and thanks for coming on the show.
- 1:06:57Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: This has been fun.
- 1:06:59Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I definitely want to do this again with you know down the road because I think we're gonna see this evolve quite a bit.
- 1:07:05Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: At least that's our hope.
- 1:07:06Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Where sports goes should be where organizations go.
- 1:07:08Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: So thanks for what you're doing.
- 1:07:10Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: I'm looking forward to the Spurs playing the uh nuggets this year.
- 1:07:13Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: It's uh just something I want to see.
- 1:07:14Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: You got a couple of uh interesting characters on both teams.
- 1:07:17Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:07:18Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Again, thanks for your time.
- 1:07:19Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Any any questions to us?
- 1:07:20Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Any anything you may have for us?
- 1:07:22Rob Gray, PhD: No, that was great.
- 1:07:23Rob Gray, PhD: I really appreciate it.
- 1:07:23Rob Gray, PhD: It was a lot of fun.
- 1:07:24Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, I'd love to do this again.
- 1:07:25Rob Gray, PhD: And yeah, I agree with you.
- 1:07:26Rob Gray, PhD: High performance is high performance, whether it's sports, military, police.
- 1:07:31Rob Gray, PhD: I think the same principles can apply.
- 1:07:34Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 1:07:34Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: Thanks again.
- 1:07:35Brian 'Ponch" Rivera: We'll keep you on here for just uh one minute.
- 1:07:37Rob Gray, PhD: Yeah, thanks for that.
- 1:07:38Rob Gray, PhD: Okay.