Latest / Murder Files Unsealed / Gilgo Beach Serial Killings Timeline - Part 2
Transcript
- 0:00July fourteenth, twenty twenty three, during Huyman's arraignment for three counts of first
- 0:06degree murder and three counts of second degree murder, defense attorney Michael Brown entered
- 0:11a not guilty plea on his behalf. Hyman was remanded without bail. Four
- 0:19twenty twenty three, authorities reveal the identification of Jane Doe number seven as thirty
- 0:25four year old Karen Vagata, whose remains were discovered on Fire Island in nineteen
- 0:29ninety six and on Tobey Beach in twenty eleven. Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond
- 0:35Tierney states that there are currently no charges. June sixth, twenty twenty four,
- 0:43following extensive evidence collection from Hyman's family, residents, and searches in a
- 0:48wooded area in Manerville, he faces additional charges for two more murders. He
- 0:54is accused of the two thousand three murder of Taylor, whose remains were found
- 0:59in Gilgo Beach and Manerville, and the nineteen ninety three murder of Sandra Costilla,
- 1:04whose remains were discovered in north Sea, Long Island. Prosecutors have linked
- 1:08Houyman to both murders through DNA evidence. Including a hare found on a drape
- 1:15under Taylor's body. Initially, Costilla's murder was believed to be the doing of
- 1:21John Bittrolf, but recent DNA advancements have now implicated Hoyman. According to prosecutors,
- 1:29Rex Heyman, the suspect in the Gilgo Beach serial killings, has been
- 1:33charged with the deaths of six women over a span of three decades in various
- 1:38Long Island communities. He pleaded not guilty to the murder charges of Jessica Taylor
- 1:44in two thousand three and Sandra Costilla in nineteen ninety three. The sixty year
- 1:49old architect was surprised by the new charges and is currently in a difficult situation.
- 1:55According to his attorney, Michael Brown, Hyman has been real commanded without
- 2:00bail and is scheduled to appear in court on July thirtie. Suffolk County Prosecutor
- 2:07Nicholas Santa Martino shocked the court room by revealing disturbing content found on Heyerman's devices,
- 2:15including a document detailing plans for future killings. This includes instructions on disposing
- 2:22of bodies, avoiding detection, and preventing DNA evidence, as well as a
- 2:27list of supplies needed for serial murder. The document contained a section labeled Body
- 2:34Preparation, which outlined the steps for cleaning, dismembering, and transporting bodies.
- 2:40Additionally, a section titled post event seemed to be a checklist of tasks aimed
- 2:46at avoiding detection, such as having a pre planned story. As stated in
- 2:52the bail application. During a press conference following the court appearance, Suffolk County
- 2:57District Attorney Raymond tier He stated this document was used by Hyman to meticulously plan
- 3:05and strategize his killings with meticulous attention to detail. His goal was to specifically
- 3:12target these victims, track them down, bring them under his control, and
- 3:17ultimately end their lives. Further evidence presented in the bail application revealed Huyman's extensive
- 3:24collection of violent bondage and torture pornography dating back to nineteen ninety four. The
- 3:32remains of Taylor were discovered partially in Manerville in two thousand three, with additional
- 3:38remains found along Ocean Parkway on Gilgo Beach in twenty eleven. Manerville is located
- 3:45approximately forty five miles northeast of Gilgo and about forty miles east of Massapequa Park,
- 3:52Hoyerman's hometown. Taylor's remains were found decapitated, with her hands and arms
- 3:58severed below the elbows, lying face up. Additionally, a tattoo had been
- 4:03intentionally removed with a sharp object. According to Tierney, at the time of
- 4:09her disappearance, Taylor was working as a sex worker in New York City.
- 4:14Hoyerman was known to have been in the city on the last day Taylor was
- 4:17seen there. After Taylor failed to return home for her mother's birthday, her
- 4:25family contacted law enforcement, leading to the recovery of some of her remains the
- 4:30following day. Witnesses reported seeing a dark colored pickup truck near the location where
- 4:36her body was eventually found. As detailed in the bail application, Costilla's body
- 4:45was discovered in the North Sea in nineteen ninety three by two hunters in the
- 4:48forest. As stated in the bail request, she was found lying on her
- 4:54back with twenty five sharp force wounds suspected to have been inflicted after her death.
- 5:00Tierney reported hair strands found on or near the remains of both Taylor and
- 5:04Costilla underwent forensic testing, revealing that ninety nine point ninety six percent of the
- 5:12North American population could be ruled out as the hair source. However, Heyman
- 5:18could not be excluded. Heyman was taken into custody in July twenty twenty three
- 5:24and faced murder charges in connection to the deaths of four women whose bodies were
- 5:30found bound with belts or tape and wrapped in burlap along a section of Long
- 5:34Island's Gilgo Beach in twenty ten. The victims, identified as Melissa Barthelemy Megan
- 5:42Waterman, Amber Costello, and Maureen Brainered Barnes, were collectively referred to as
- 5:48the Gilgo Four. Heyerman entered a plea of not guilty to the charges involving
- 5:55all four victims. These women were part of a group of at least to
- 6:00eleven sets of remains uncovered near the shoreline in Suffolk County, Long Island since
- 6:05twenty ten. Authorities have alleged that Hoyerman lived a double life.