Latest / Sunlight Matters / How LED Lighting Is Harming Humans With Professor Glen Jeffery
Transcript
- 0:00Dave Wallace: You've just published a paper in Nature, and it really caught my eye.
- 0:04Dave Wallace: Could you just start by briefly introducing what the paper was about?
- 0:10Speaker: There has been concern for quite a while now that the lighting that we experience in the built environment at home and at work is affecting our health.
- 0:21Speaker: And I think a lot of that concern has been around light emitting diodes, LEDs.
- 0:26Speaker: LEDs now take over our world.
- 0:29Speaker: So what we did in a study was we went to University College London to a horrible building that had no windows that let in normal daylight.
- 0:39Speaker: Incredibly harsh LEDs and people working there eight hours a day.
- 0:44Speaker: And we tested their colour vision and then we walked back into that environment and we gave them old incandescent light bulbs that we left sitting around on their desks.
- 0:55Speaker: Now, old incandescent light bulbs are like sunlight, vast amount of infrared.
- 1:00Speaker: But we came back and we tested their vision, and there was a highly significant improvement in their vision.
- 1:07Speaker: Um, it really surprised us.
- 1:10Speaker: I mean, we were very surprised by the magnitude of the effect.
- 1:13Speaker: There's a package for health that is very obvious.
- 1:16Speaker: And it is public health, and it's small modifications that lead to improvements in public health improvements in health span.
- 1:26Speaker: I want to be 80 and still knocking around and having.
- 1:29Speaker: I'm not sure I care that much when I die, but I want to make sure that at least until that last five minutes before they put me in the coffin, I have a high quality of life.
- 1:39Speaker: That is, you know, that's paramount.
- 1:44Speaker: Welcome to Sunlight Matters, the podcast that reconnects us with the sun.
- 1:49Speaker: Join us as we explore the power and influence of our star, the force at the heart of everything.
- 1:55Speaker: Each episode, we speak with leading experts to uncover the ways sunlight shapes our world.
- 2:02Dave Wallace: So, welcome back to the podcast, Glenn.
- 2:05Dave Wallace: Thank you so much.
- 2:06Dave Wallace: Uh, very short notice for coming on.
- 2:10Dave Wallace: Uh, you've just published a paper in Nature, and it really caught my eye, and I thought actually, it might be a great opportunity to kind of grab you while the ink is still fresh on the paper, so to speak, uh, and get you to just talk about the the the study that it talks about and some of the conclusions that that you reach from it.
- 2:34Dave Wallace: So I wonder, could you just start by briefly um introducing what the the the paper was about and and and the sort of headlines on the study, and and I guess what the hypothesis was that you were were trying to prove through through the work that you did.
- 2:51Glen Jeffery: Sure.
- 2:51Glen Jeffery: Thanks, Dave.
- 2:52Glen Jeffery: And and it's always a pleasure to come back to this site.
- 2:55Glen Jeffery: Um there has been concern for um quite a while now that the lighting that we experience um in the built environment at home and at work um is affecting our health.
- 3:09Glen Jeffery: And and it's been something that people have been very susceptible to and talked about, but not much has gone on about it.
- 3:16Glen Jeffery: And I think a lot of that concern has been around light-emitting diodes, LEDs.
- 3:22Glen Jeffery: LEDs now take over our world.
- 3:24Glen Jeffery: Um, and they're peculiar because they only give off light that we can see.
- 3:30Glen Jeffery: Yet there are other parts of light that we don't see, particularly towards the infrared, that have a profound role in health, including our blood sugars, our life expectancy, a whole range of things.
- 3:43Glen Jeffery: So, what we did in a study was we went to part of UCL, University College London, to a horrible building that had no windows that let in normal daylight.
- 3:57Glen Jeffery: In fact, we went to deep in the building and all they had was incredibly harsh LEDs and people working there, you know, eight hours a day, very often in winter, not going out for lunch.
- 4:10Glen Jeffery: And we tested their colour vision and looked fine.
- 4:14Glen Jeffery: And then we walked back into that environment and we gave them old incandescent light bulbs that we left sitting around on their desks.
- 4:23Glen Jeffery: Now, old incandescent light bulbs are like sunlight, they've got a vast amount of light in them that we don't see, a vast amount of infrared, and they are very much like daylight.
- 4:36Glen Jeffery: So we left these there and we said to people, you don't have to look at them, just move around them, go do what you want to do, go to the loo, have your lunch, just leave them as part of your world.
- 4:47Glen Jeffery: And we came back and we tested their vision, and there was a highly significant improvement in their vision.
- 4:55Glen Jeffery: Um, it really surprised us.
- 4:58Glen Jeffery: I mean, we were, I mean, we walked into that environment, we all agreed the environment, the light environment, was awful.
- 5:04Glen Jeffery: It looked awful.
- 5:06Glen Jeffery: Um, but we were very surprised by the magnitude of the effects.
- 5:10Glen Jeffery: And then what we did, we took the light bulbs away and we went back and tested them subsequently.
- 5:17Glen Jeffery: And the improvements that we got lasted much longer than we thought that they should do.
- 5:23Glen Jeffery: In fact, they lasted for getting on for a couple of months.
- 5:26Glen Jeffery: And the study stopped and came to an end because we hit Christmas and everybody went, everybody left, everybody went home, everybody had then had a very different light experience, everybody had too much to eat and too much to drink, so we stopped the study there.
- 5:41Glen Jeffery: So the key implication of this study is what we thought, perhaps going back previously, which is LED lighting is suppressing your metabolism, it is suppressing your physiology.
- 5:58Glen Jeffery: We chose the retina or visual system because it's easy to assess.
- 6:02Glen Jeffery: We can say, we can say, can you see this now?
- 6:04Glen Jeffery: Can you see this tomorrow?
- 6:05Glen Jeffery: Could you see this in the past?
- 6:07Glen Jeffery: We get hard numbers out of it.
- 6:09Glen Jeffery: But the same metrics we have there, other people have used with these lightings and said, Well, actually, look, this this lighting is shifting your blood sugars.
- 6:16Glen Jeffery: So it is a pretty hardcore, I think, well-controlled study that shows that LED lighting is having a damaging effect in suppressing, in this case specifically, suppressing your colour vision.
- 6:33Glen Jeffery: How many people have we got in the world where their ability to perceive colours correctly is critical to the functions that they perform in life?
- 6:44Glen Jeffery: Um, people who sit in worlds with no natural daylight.
- 6:49Glen Jeffery: I mean, the great thing about this building, uh, which I'll go on about because it's a most horrible building I've been in for ages, is the limited amount of glass it had, which was not in the environment where we worked, blocked all light that you couldn't see.
- 7:06Glen Jeffery: So the glass, it's not only the lighting that is our problem, it is the glass in buildings, because glass now blocks that infrared light that is critical for metabolic health.
- 7:21Glen Jeffery: If we take animals that have short lifespans, and we take them from an environment where they've got LEDs, because nearly all animals are in LED light environments as well, in animal houses, and we give them long-wave light, they live longer.
- 7:36Glen Jeffery: Their blood sugars are better, they have health, they're much greater health span.
- 7:40Glen Jeffery: So it's really important for the built environment that we have a wider spectrum of light.
- 7:48Glen Jeffery: And I must say, the people have really picked this up and are concerned are the architects and the lighting engineers.
- 7:55Glen Jeffery: They are sitting there thinking, are we going to get prosecuted for putting up a building which has been unhealthy and made you pre-diabetic?
- 8:04Glen Jeffery: That's a realistic question.
- 8:07Glen Jeffery: And it's interesting, they responded much faster than the medical profession.
- 8:11Glen Jeffery: Medical profession still has not really responded.
- 8:15Glen Jeffery: New Moorefield's Eye Hospital, you would think a great centre for light and looking after people's eyes.
- 8:22Glen Jeffery: All harsh white LEDs going in and all infrared blocking glass in the building.
- 8:30Glen Jeffery: So we're still not there yet.
- 8:34Dave Wallace: No, I mean, and and can I just quickly going back to I guess the the the um research itself, you were trying to make it much like a kind of working environment.
- 8:46Dave Wallace: Now, obviously, it was in in a basement, but it wasn't dressed up like a it was where people went to work, wasn't it?
- 8:54Glen Jeffery: It was the real world.
- 8:55Glen Jeffery: It was the real world.
- 8:56Glen Jeffery: So you could argue that the problem with this experiment was that um it wasn't super tightly controlled, but I don't want to do super tightly controlled experiments anymore.
- 9:05Glen Jeffery: I want to do experiments in the real world, real life experience.
- 9:10Glen Jeffery: And yeah, you're right.
- 9:11Glen Jeffery: We didn't say you've got to sit down in front of this light bulb for your working day.
- 9:15Glen Jeffery: It was just part of your world.
- 9:18Glen Jeffery: The LEDs were still there, but what we'd done was we'd put wavelengths of light in to counterbalance the negative effects of those LEDs.
- 9:28Glen Jeffery: So, real world, that's important, real world experience.
- 9:32Dave Wallace: So, and I mean, again, just uh, because I I noticed in the paper you mentioned that people's sort of access to sunlight was pretty limited as well, because you know, they were inside, like if they could go out, it was like for 15 minutes at lunchtime and things like that.
- 9:49Dave Wallace: So you kind of there was a degree of control around what you uh in terms of what you were sort of seeing from the participants as well.
- 10:00Glen Jeffery: Yeah, it was uh you could say it was a worst case scenario.
- 10:03Glen Jeffery: Um, it was an environment where, and we did this in in in early winter months, so the daylight was fairly restricted, but then it was a real-world experience.
- 10:14Glen Jeffery: So I said to them, how'd you get to work?
- 10:16Glen Jeffery: Well, you know, we get public transport.
- 10:18Glen Jeffery: Check the public transport, it's all LED lit.
- 10:21Glen Jeffery: Um they weren't getting a break from this, and I was then saying to them, what time are you leaving?
- 10:27Glen Jeffery: Oh, about 5.30.
- 10:28Glen Jeffery: And we checked all the weather reports.
- 10:30Glen Jeffery: They were leaving actually when it was dark.
- 10:33Glen Jeffery: So they got a bit of light in the mornings, um, but and I I actually I actually quantified the cloud cover.
- 10:41Glen Jeffery: Um they they were getting a little bit of light in the mornings, but it wasn't great.
- 10:47Glen Jeffery: But how many of us are like that?
- 10:49Glen Jeffery: In in winter months in the northern hemisphere, that's our life.
- 10:54Glen Jeffery: You know, the building yeah, the building I am in, okay, my office I've got, I don't have dominant LED lighting, but the majority of the building I am in is lit with harsh LED lighting because it's economic.
- 11:09Dave Wallace: Well, I I I think, I mean, what what the importance of of the reason, I mean, the result is is is I mean, in a way, when you talk about things being significant, it really makes me think, well, this is you know, you demonstrating in a kind of controlled way that this is very problematic.
- 11:31Dave Wallace: But I like the fact that you did it in kind of people's working days as well.
- 11:36Dave Wallace: Because as you say, like the majority of the working world uh across the world now sits in like poorly lit offices, and you know, we're I'm here at home, and actually I I've got a shouldn't say to you, but I've got a hue system here with so I'm under LED light behind uh IR blocking glass in front of me, and um, you know, I'll be going off for uh incandescent my incandescent sort of hit in the bit.
- 12:06Dave Wallace: You've got incandescent bulbs in the house.
- 12:09Dave Wallace: But the major this is the majority of people's lives now, isn't it?
- 12:14Glen Jeffery: Definitely, definitely.
- 12:15Glen Jeffery: Try and find uh try and you know, when you go to the shopping, uh, you know, when you when you go to shopping somewhere in the house, in your work environment, it is all LED lit.
- 12:28Glen Jeffery: And what I think we need to move towards ultimately is uh determining how much LED light you should be exposed to.
- 12:38Glen Jeffery: Now, this is not an insurmountable problem because looking at that study, what we did show was we showed that the LED was damaging your visual health, but at the same time, we brought something in to counterbalance it.
- 12:54Glen Jeffery: So that doesn't mean necessarily that we've got to go into an environment and strip out all the LEDs.
- 13:00Glen Jeffery: We don't have to do that.
- 13:03Glen Jeffery: We have to be very careful in how many LEDs we use, and then we have to introduce other lighting systems that balance it.
- 13:11Glen Jeffery: So we are not talking about rewiring buildings, but we're talking about very careful consideration of the quality of light that we have in there.
- 13:22Glen Jeffery: And maybe we can bring that in by just having just what I have got, an angle poise lamp with an old incandescent light bulb in it.
- 13:30Glen Jeffery: That's good enough.
- 13:32Dave Wallace: But I I mean, at the same token, you've got incandescents, you know, we can still buy them.
- 13:37Dave Wallace: There's places around the world where you can't buy them.
- 13:39Dave Wallace: And I think in some countries they're even illegal to own incandescent bulbs.
- 13:44Dave Wallace: So, um, but but there is you, you know, here in the UK, we're kind of like using up reserves.
- 13:50Dave Wallace: There isn't people manufacturing incandescent bulbs, and that feels like that might be something that has to be rethought, you know, because um, like you say, the the maybe what you go for is a kind of mixture of lighting between LED and incandescence.
- 14:08Dave Wallace: But but it just requires a wholesale rethinking of lighting, doesn't it, from a kind of policy level, I guess.
- 14:16Glen Jeffery: Absolutely.
- 14:16Glen Jeffery: And, you know, we do have a few meetings coming up with policy makers in this field.
- 14:23Glen Jeffery: Um and then, you know, there are ways around this if you think about things.
- 14:27Glen Jeffery: So everyone goes, the first reaction is we can't go back to incandescent, it uses too much energy.
- 14:33Glen Jeffery: Well, actually, if you take an old incandescent light bulb and you take a dimmer switch, which costs $9.95 off Amazon, um, if you turn the light down, you're turning the visual light down, but you're not turning the infrared light down anywhere near as much.
- 14:54Glen Jeffery: So you can just turn it down and you're not going to increase your electricity bills that much.
- 15:01Glen Jeffery: There are intelligent, intelligent ways around this.
- 15:04Glen Jeffery: So we mustn't take polar views about it.
- 15:07Glen Jeffery: We mustn't say strip it all out.
- 15:09Glen Jeffery: Um there's an intelligent approach that we can get.
- 15:13Glen Jeffery: Now, we also got positive effects by taking old old LED light bulbs, pulling them apart, and putting an infrared um LED into it.
- 15:26Glen Jeffery: Right.
- 15:27Glen Jeffery: Now, that produced an improvement, but the improvement was nowhere near as good as the improvement with a full spectrum incandescent light bulb.
- 15:39Glen Jeffery: And I think people should also be very aware because there is a lot of adverts out there for full spectrum lighting, and I've yet to test one that is full spectrum lighting.
- 15:50Glen Jeffery: Um, it depends how you define it, but it's not sunlight.
- 15:53Glen Jeffery: So just an incandescent light bulb.
- 15:56Glen Jeffery: We can still buy them, as you say.
- 15:58Glen Jeffery: Um, we're not allowed to put them in new builds.
- 16:01Glen Jeffery: Um they're still they're still out there um under the name of either incandescent or halogen bulbs.
- 16:08Glen Jeffery: Right.
- 16:09Glen Jeffery: Um, but America is banning them.
- 16:11Glen Jeffery: And there is a campaign now in America to try and try and change that.
- 16:16Glen Jeffery: I'm not sure it's got a lot of traction at the moment.
- 16:19Glen Jeffery: I hope our research can contribute towards that, but we're lucky here.
- 16:24Glen Jeffery: European legislation is definitely moving towards a complete ban.
- 16:28Glen Jeffery: So it's a fight that it's a fight I think we'll win.
- 16:33Glen Jeffery: It's just going to take a bit of energy to get there.
- 16:36Dave Wallace: But I but I think, you know, the I mean, just not to sort of I guess skate over the consequences of this.
- 16:44Dave Wallace: So, you know, to in my head, actually spending a bit of money on an incandescent bulb and the energy used for it is a fraction of the healthcare costs of looking for someone with after someone with diabetes or you know, some other metabolic disease or you you know macular degeneration or whatever it is, you know.
- 17:05Dave Wallace: So the preventative side of all of this stuff is I I think far outweighs the costs of um of the damage that could be done.
- 17:16Dave Wallace: If you're enjoying Sunlight Matters, make sure to subscribe and leave us a review on your favourite podcast platform.
- 17:24Dave Wallace: You can also search Sunlight Matters on Google to find more episodes, guest information, and further insights about sunlight analysis, solar exposure, and the way light shapes our spaces.
- 17:38Glen Jeffery: Completely, totally agree with you, but you need a politician to sit back and grab the big picture.
- 17:45Glen Jeffery: These problems are not the problems for today's politicians, they're the problems that will be generated for tomorrow's politicians.
- 17:52Glen Jeffery: And you know, most politicians just care about what's going to be on the front page of the Daily Mail tomorrow.
- 17:58Glen Jeffery: They don't see the long the longer run.
- 18:00Glen Jeffery: But you know, the one I really love and I go back to a lot, which is go back to your older hospital that didn't have infrared blocking glass.
- 18:09Glen Jeffery: Everybody knew that you got patients out of bed earlier if their bed was by a window.
- 18:18Glen Jeffery: That's telling you something about daylight.
- 18:21Glen Jeffery: Now think about bed blocking.
- 18:23Glen Jeffery: I mean, we're talking to critical care units.
- 18:26Glen Jeffery: How much does it cost to keep someone in a critical care unit for 24 hours?
- 18:33Glen Jeffery: It's thousands.
- 18:35Glen Jeffery: So that it's costing the taxpayer thousands.
- 18:38Glen Jeffery: And at the same time, the person, the person, we could get that person out of that bed earlier.
- 18:44Glen Jeffery: Do we really care about the price of a light bulb?
- 18:47Glen Jeffery: You know, let's get let's get the big picture here.
- 18:50Glen Jeffery: Um and you know, I think people have people have started to listen, but they need direction from those that establish standards.
- 19:02Glen Jeffery: They need direction.
- 19:03Glen Jeffery: So, you know, I raised this point where I work partly at Moorefield's Eye Hospital, and they're saying, well, the um the system doesn't allow this.
- 19:14Glen Jeffery: You know, that the standards state A, B, and C.
- 19:18Glen Jeffery: They do not state D.
- 19:19Glen Jeffery: So we have to influence policymakers.
- 19:22Glen Jeffery: That's that's a real big issue.
- 19:25Dave Wallace: I mean, uh you we've talked about this before, like scurvy, I guess you've got smoking.
- 19:31Dave Wallace: You recently mentioned asbestos as well.
- 19:34Dave Wallace: And I think, you know, what do they all have in common is it took a long time for you know, the the science was there and obvious.
- 19:42Dave Wallace: It just took a long time for policymakers to kind of catch up with all of this stuff.
- 19:47Dave Wallace: I I think in in this instance, what I just sort of beggars belief, why can't the why can't people learn from these mistakes?
- 19:56Dave Wallace: You know, I mean I mentioned to you that I unfortunately I had personal experience.
- 19:59Dave Wallace: Experience of asbestos because my mum died of mesothelioma.
- 20:04Dave Wallace: I mean, she lived the healthiest life ever, but somewhere along the line, she got a small particle of asbestos in her lungs, and that caused cancer.
- 20:15Dave Wallace: And um, you know, so I I know from personal that if you get this stuff wrong, it ends up with ill and frankly dead people.
- 20:25Dave Wallace: And you know, as a society, like I think you mention it specifically in your paper about care homes and people at the you know who need kind of looking after, like giving them sort of light as a nutrition, like with incandescence will probably improve their sort of health and you know, probably improve their well-being as well, won't it?
- 20:51Glen Jeffery: Yeah.
- 20:52Glen Jeffery: I have, and I'm not the only one, I have been banging my head against the wall regarding care homes.
- 20:58Glen Jeffery: Really banging my head against the wall.
- 21:01Glen Jeffery: We can all the animal studies show us that older debilitated animals, we can get them moving much more efficiently if we give them the right spectra of light.
- 21:14Glen Jeffery: So we've got these people who, you know, when they're in a care home, they have limited mobility, which means they have a chance that they might fall and break their hip, which in many cases that becomes fatal because they're put flat in a bed and they get pneumonia and they die.
- 21:29Glen Jeffery: Their quality of life is absolutely rock bottom and they lose control of their blood sugars.
- 21:35Glen Jeffery: What is it all about?
- 21:37Glen Jeffery: Well, a big fraction of this is about light.
- 21:41Glen Jeffery: We can walk into environments, all the science is there, we can put a light bulb in, and we can improve the quality of people's lives.
- 21:54Glen Jeffery: It is, as I say, I'm I am not the only one.
- 21:59Glen Jeffery: Many of us are banging our heads against a wall.
- 22:03Glen Jeffery: You know, if my if my mother were in a nursing home, I would be, I would be in there.
- 22:09Glen Jeffery: So, you know, I do with an angle poise lamp and an incandescent bar.
- 22:14Glen Jeffery: Yeah, well, actually, you don't even have to have an angle poise.
- 22:18Glen Jeffery: You can go to IKEA and buy one of these cheap little bendy things, right?
- 22:21Glen Jeffery: Just, you know, something's like 10 10 pounds and put an incandescent, which is what I've done with my aging aunts and my aging uncles.
- 22:30Dave Wallace: That's amazing.
- 22:31Dave Wallace: Well, I I I did it for my son.
- 22:33Dave Wallace: I sent him off to university with an incandescent bulb.
- 22:36Dave Wallace: And I am pleased to report, like, his health seems to be like he's not a sports person, he's not outside, but he seems to be on a level.
- 22:45Dave Wallace: So, you know, I'm I'm seeing the positive results of just like, you know, we've replaced a lot of our bulbs with incandescence.
- 22:54Dave Wallace: The amount of illness in the family uh has kind of dropped off.
- 22:59Dave Wallace: So there's something going on, which I think is really interesting.
- 23:03Dave Wallace: Yeah.
- 23:03Dave Wallace: I have to ask a question like you, because you talk about LED suppressing metabolic health.
- 23:11Dave Wallace: If I did I did I get that right, or is that sort of No, no, that that that that is right.
- 23:15Glen Jeffery: So if we if we take the wavelengths of light in LEDs and we put animals under those wavelengths, they become pre-diabetic.
- 23:26Glen Jeffery: That's a metabolic thing.
- 23:28Glen Jeffery: So that is that is clear.
- 23:30Glen Jeffery: And if you dig through the evidence, it is clear that you get a similar pattern in humans.
- 23:37Glen Jeffery: All right?
- 23:38Glen Jeffery: Now, what's that costing the NHS?
- 23:40Glen Jeffery: It's costing us fortune.
- 23:42Glen Jeffery: Absolute fortune.
- 23:44Glen Jeffery: This time of year, people are spending more time inside, they become relatively sedentary.
- 23:50Glen Jeffery: Um, you know, over the Christmas period, they've consumed too much.
- 23:54Glen Jeffery: This is just this is just ridiculous.
- 23:57Glen Jeffery: You know, I it is it seems to me to be ridiculous that we we're not getting traction on it.
- 24:04Dave Wallace: So I mean, I think it's all up to all of us to kind of do what we can in terms of sort of banging the drum around this thing.
- 24:11Glen Jeffery: Yeah.
- 24:11Glen Jeffery: Yeah, definitely.
- 24:12Glen Jeffery: Definitely.
- 24:14Dave Wallace: I and I I sort of puzzle over it because I like we do I I think we we sort of talked briefly, and I know on the Huberman podcast you talked about the the the people getting dogs.
- 24:26Dave Wallace: I mean, I think like getting outside, like walking, all of this other stuff, but yeah, yeah, you know, is kind of super critical as well.
- 24:34Dave Wallace: Because I I guess the thing with incandescence, and I get going back to LED being narrow spectrum, that incandescents create light from heat.
- 24:44Dave Wallace: So what you then end up with broad spectrum.
- 24:46Dave Wallace: And I what one of the questions is is do you understand is it wavelengths in the incandescent, or is it the because you got and you've kind of mentioned this because of the uh infrared LEDs, but is it do you understand the sort of what's going on from a broad spectrum perspective in terms of the impact it might be having?
- 25:07Glen Jeffery: I I think from the science perspective, we're we're we're pretty much there now.
- 25:12Glen Jeffery: Sort of, you know, we're we're dealing with we're dealing with entities called mitochondria that generate energy, and the right kind of light improves the energy you produce, wrong kind of light reduces the energy.
- 25:25Glen Jeffery: I think we're pretty much there now.
- 25:27Glen Jeffery: So when we talk, and and I know you've spoken to Bob Fosbury, who's a big pusher in the physics of this, um, when we talk, we're all sitting there saying, okay, we know enough.
- 25:38Glen Jeffery: We know enough to feel that we're not idiots.
- 25:41Glen Jeffery: We know enough to say, now's the time to talk.
- 25:45Glen Jeffery: Now's the time.
- 25:46Glen Jeffery: So I'm hoping that somewhere out in the world there is some senior civil servant in the Department of Health who's who's watching this, who will then stroll into work and say, how many millions can we save by changing lighting?
- 26:03Glen Jeffery: He can think about money.
- 26:05Glen Jeffery: I'm thinking about quality of life.
- 26:08Glen Jeffery: Um, that is the kind of person we need to get hold of.
- 26:12Glen Jeffery: The science is there, and it's been driven by Bob Fosbury, an atmospheric physicist.
- 26:19Glen Jeffery: Um, so why are we waiting?
- 26:23Dave Wallace: Yeah, I mean, I think you're absolutely I mean, you know, if any MPs end up listening to this, I mean, you could you could make a name for yourself by actually taking up this taking up this cause.
- 26:34Dave Wallace: Because I mean, what better thing is there to sort of actually change the health of a nation by Yeah, yeah.
- 26:43Glen Jeffery: I I don't want to make a name for myself.
- 26:44Glen Jeffery: I quite like to drift to the back.
- 26:46Glen Jeffery: Um, but I do I must end up.
- 26:49Dave Wallace: Sorry, you shouldn't then be appearing on Huberman's podcast.
- 26:54Glen Jeffery: Fortunately, I'm not recognized walking down the street.
- 26:57Glen Jeffery: Um, but I do have a meeting with an MP next week.
- 27:01Dave Wallace: Great, great, great, great.
- 27:02Glen Jeffery: Um, so so just crawl up that wall.
- 27:06Glen Jeffery: Just crawl up that wall until someone notices you.
- 27:09Glen Jeffery: That's what that's the philosophy.
- 27:12Dave Wallace: So, I mean, one question on like I think you again you mentioned about the industry, and there's lots of people with IR panels and IR light.
- 27:23Dave Wallace: And have you got any thoughts on dosage at all?
- 27:28Glen Jeffery: Like well, dosage, dosage was a conversation with Bob Fosbury at about nine o'clock this morning because we're talking about it all the time.
- 27:37Glen Jeffery: Uh, these panels are producing far too much light, far too much light.
- 27:42Glen Jeffery: And we're sitting here thinking this is going to cause a problem in the end.
- 27:48Glen Jeffery: Why is it with all these panels that, okay, you sit there, let's just say, for argument's sake, the first 10 minutes is okay.
- 27:56Glen Jeffery: But we know from the research that if you sit in front of that panel too much, the effect goes.
- 28:03Glen Jeffery: Right?
- 28:03Glen Jeffery: It just it just goes.
- 28:05Glen Jeffery: And what we know is got pretty sure is going on is that the metabolic system is getting clogged up with too much energy.
- 28:12Glen Jeffery: So, particularly these face masks and these big whole body panels, um, of which we pulled apart a few.
- 28:21Glen Jeffery: First of all, they're unbelievably overpriced for what they are.
- 28:25Glen Jeffery: Uh, you know, a a thousand pounds worth of panel has probably gotten 15 pounds worth of product in it.
- 28:31Glen Jeffery: Um, but they're producing too much energy.
- 28:35Glen Jeffery: Your body is not used to getting a vast wall of energy, that deep red energy.
- 28:44Glen Jeffery: The the first the first couple of minutes may be really good, um, but after that, no, you are challenging your metabolism um by overloading it.
- 28:56Dave Wallace: That's really interesting because again, this was why I wanted to talk to you about the research that you've done, because it's proper science.
- 29:06Dave Wallace: And I sort of feel like when you look at a lot of what's out there, people are not being led by science, they're being led by commercial opportunities.
- 29:17Glen Jeffery: Definitely, definitely.
- 29:19Glen Jeffery: I I deal with I I had said we'll I'll answer emails.
- 29:24Glen Jeffery: I deal with walls of emails from people who say, I've got this device, is it gonna work?
- 29:29Glen Jeffery: Well, I can't answer.
- 29:32Glen Jeffery: Um, because unless I have that device in the lab and we pull it apart and spend a day looking at it, um, I can't really answer.
- 29:39Glen Jeffery: But the vast majority of devices that we have looked at are of extremely poor quality and very high price.
- 29:50Glen Jeffery: Um, and you know, and the you say to people, well, actually, it's kicking out too much energy.
- 29:55Glen Jeffery: And then a manufacturer will say, Well, if I've got a device with a dim red light and a device with a bright red light, everybody's gonna buy the bright red light.
- 30:03Glen Jeffery: No one's gonna buy the dim.
- 30:04Glen Jeffery: And I get that, I understand that, I understand the sales pitch.
- 30:09Glen Jeffery: But the point is they're producing too much energy.
- 30:12Glen Jeffery: What happens to, and I don't know the answer to this, what happens to the lady who buys a face mask, uses it quite heavily?
- 30:21Glen Jeffery: What happens in five years' time?
- 30:23Glen Jeffery: I don't know.
- 30:25Glen Jeffery: I just don't know.
- 30:26Glen Jeffery: But I am cautious enough to say, I know you're jet that's generating too much energy, and I know that your metabolism is going to struggle to cope with that.
- 30:36Glen Jeffery: I do not know what the consequences are.
- 30:40Dave Wallace: It's again, I mean, great.
- 30:43Dave Wallace: I mean, it's great to what I love about you, Glenn, is you're uh you speak the truth as you as you see it, you know, and I think uh you know it's in it's great to kind of have that, and I'll be telling my wife to take that face mask off later because uh she got one for Christmas.
- 31:03Dave Wallace: So um, no, it's it's it's it's really, really interesting.
- 31:08Dave Wallace: I I mean one thing that I wanted to ask you was about sunlight.
- 31:14Dave Wallace: Um and you know, one of the things I did last year was to try and get out a bit more in the mornings, and you know, and I I really do feel it kind of made a difference to me.
- 31:28Dave Wallace: So decided to try and go a bit more hardcore this year and and follow the sun's pattern if I can, just to you know, and I need to kind of think about what could I measure in order to sort of see what impact that would have.
- 31:44Dave Wallace: So, you know, I'm talking about like four, four in the morning, I could I guess in the middle of summer getting up and getting the dogs out.
- 31:52Dave Wallace: Um for for me, just as a sort of citizen scientist, is there anything that I could do just to kind of measure um simply like the impact that might have on me?
- 32:05Glen Jeffery: No, and but it's a really important question.
- 32:08Glen Jeffery: So people will say, How do I know?
- 32:10Glen Jeffery: How do I know?
- 32:11Glen Jeffery: And I'm struggling to find a metric that you yourself have access to.
- 32:17Glen Jeffery: So I can I can improve all your blood sugars, right, with light, but you're unaware of it.
- 32:23Glen Jeffery: You know, you don't, okay, when you're when your blood sugars crash, you're aware of that, but you're not aware of when your blood sugars reach dangerous levels.
- 32:32Glen Jeffery: Much of what I think we do has a prophylactic angle.
- 32:36Glen Jeffery: It's preventing things happening that's negative in the future.
- 32:40Glen Jeffery: Um I know that there are some people, um, I mean some people at Westminster University who are looking at a whole load of markers in the blood.
- 32:50Glen Jeffery: Um will there be a time when, for instance, you can prick your finger and go, oh look, something's a hell of a lot better here?
- 32:58Glen Jeffery: Um that will come, but I don't know what the I don't know what it is.
- 33:03Glen Jeffery: So with the with the red light or the incandescent light and improving vision.
- 33:09Glen Jeffery: Most people come away from that and they can't really tell the difference.
- 33:14Glen Jeffery: When when I'm when I test them, I can see the difference.
- 33:18Glen Jeffery: Right.
- 33:19Glen Jeffery: A few people come along and say, oh, you know, the curtain's moving in a slightly different way.
- 33:24Glen Jeffery: I think Bob Fosbury did that.
- 33:26Glen Jeffery: Um, but it's there when you test it.
- 33:29Glen Jeffery: It's there when you test it.
- 33:31Glen Jeffery: And I've got big advantages of working with vision, but I've also got big negatives.
- 33:35Glen Jeffery: So you can lose vast amounts of your vision, say, for instance, in glaucoma, where you lose your peripheral vision, you don't even know it's gone.
- 33:45Glen Jeffery: You start to register you've got a problem when you bump into the coffee table when you walk past it.
- 33:51Glen Jeffery: And that's because whatever is happening in your eye, your brain is constantly recorrecting it to take things back to where they were before.
- 34:00Glen Jeffery: You can test it and you say, I know, I know that's better, I know that's worse.
- 34:04Glen Jeffery: But for the person, very often they're largely unaware.
- 34:10Glen Jeffery: If I can find that, if I can find that thing that says, you now tie up your shoelaces three seconds faster, I'll find it and and and I'll tell people about it.
- 34:20Dave Wallace: No, it's it's it's really interesting.
- 34:23Dave Wallace: I mean, I I think one of the things is just to kind of check inside yourself and say, like, do I feel better?
- 34:30Dave Wallace: Like, I think feeling better is a it's quite a difficult thing though to measure, isn't it?
- 34:36Glen Jeffery: Exactly.
- 34:36Glen Jeffery: And we and and the the the reason why I did the study that we did in changing the light bulbs is it's hard science.
- 34:47Dave Wallace: Yes.
- 34:47Glen Jeffery: You know, it's a number.
- 34:49Glen Jeffery: Here is a number, and it's different on this day after this experience than it was before.
- 34:54Glen Jeffery: And if we're going to get people to believe hard-nosed civil servants, people in charge, they've got to they can't have the I feel better phenomena.
- 35:05Glen Jeffery: Whether that's true or not true, they can't have it.
- 35:08Dave Wallace: Yeah, I I I totally, totally agree.
- 35:10Dave Wallace: I think it's really, it's really interesting.
- 35:13Dave Wallace: So, so what's next?
- 35:14Dave Wallace: I mean, you you've this is a kind of I feel a groundbreaking piece of research, which I think proves a lot of what you've been thinking and hypothesizing, and you know, you and Bob sort of chatting about.
- 35:28Dave Wallace: So uh have you got anything that you're kind of lining up for future research as well?
- 35:33Glen Jeffery: Well, we you know, the the the the the kettle is still the kettle's still on.
- 35:37Glen Jeffery: Um, so we've got a whole load of stuff looking at, for instance, how long does it take for that incandescent light bulb to improve your vision?
- 35:48Glen Jeffery: Uh, what's the time course?
- 35:50Glen Jeffery: And actually, I have to say, it's shockingly brief.
- 35:54Glen Jeffery: We put light bulbs in for a couple of weeks.
- 35:57Glen Jeffery: We're now seeing changes in people um uh within an hour of introducing different lighting into the room.
- 36:06Dave Wallace: Wow.
- 36:06Glen Jeffery: And I've gone out and I've gone out and said to uh uh this is this is a guy called Mark Mark Robinson, who's a graduate student in the lab.
- 36:13Glen Jeffery: And I said, Mark, can you do all this again, please?
- 36:16Glen Jeffery: Um let's let's let's make sure we get this one right.
- 36:20Glen Jeffery: But it is it is clear the effect can be corrected relatively easily, and the effect can be corrected relatively quickly.
- 36:32Glen Jeffery: Okay, so what about that person when that person comes out of the operating theater after a big operation?
- 36:38Glen Jeffery: Could it be the case that they only need an hour of an incandescent light bulb to support their metabolism, right?
- 36:46Glen Jeffery: One of the worst light environments on the planet is an operating theatre, right?
- 36:52Glen Jeffery: Very rarely have they got windows, they've all got harsh LED lighting.
- 36:56Glen Jeffery: You walk in there and you think, oh God, it's like being on a stage in a plant.
- 37:00Glen Jeffery: Where did all this come from?
- 37:02Glen Jeffery: And those people in that environment are there, you know, they can be there for hours and hours and hours.
- 37:09Glen Jeffery: And you know, the great thing about our NHS NHS is it's fantastic.
- 37:14Glen Jeffery: People are dedicated to it.
- 37:16Glen Jeffery: And I know of some surgeons that sit in that environment a hell of a lot longer than eight hours a day.
- 37:22Glen Jeffery: Um, so yeah, maybe just an incandescent light bulb in the recovery room might be enough.
- 37:31Glen Jeffery: You know, as as as I say, as I say all the time, if this is a load of rubbish, okay, I'm an idiot, but it hasn't cost you any money.
- 37:41Glen Jeffery: You know?
- 37:42Glen Jeffery: Um I like.
- 37:44Dave Wallace: But I I think what you're proving is that there is uh this isn't a load of rubbish.
- 37:49Dave Wallace: And I I mean when you actually I I guess what I've sort of done is I've sort of sat back and thought about it and you go, well, it's obvious, isn't it?
- 37:58Dave Wallace: Of course we've kind of got a connection to to light and sunlight and broad spectrum light because we've lived most of our histories outside, haven't we?
- 38:08Dave Wallace: So um you know, it would be almost surprising that we have.
- 38:13Dave Wallace: I guess the big surprise is we haven't really thought about this until fairly recently.
- 38:18Glen Jeffery: No, I you know, this is the thing that is really striking and is a problem about resistance.
- 38:24Glen Jeffery: People are saying, well, hang on, we've we've we've we've had these uh LEDs, you know, since 2000, 2005.
- 38:31Glen Jeffery: We're not dropping dead.
- 38:32Glen Jeffery: What's the problem?
- 38:33Glen Jeffery: Yeah, and and and and and and then where are you coming from with these odd comments about LEDs?
- 38:40Glen Jeffery: You know, we're all we're all happy.
- 38:42Glen Jeffery: Um that's quite something to try and overcome, you know, um resistance.
- 38:49Glen Jeffery: And that's not only resistance from the industry, it's resistance from public perception.
- 38:54Glen Jeffery: The public aren't really aware.
- 38:57Glen Jeffery: Um, the consequences are not here yet.
- 39:01Dave Wallace: I'm uh actually chatting to Anne Levine, who wrote a book Incandescent next week.
- 39:06Dave Wallace: And you know, she's fascinating because she kind of lays out what happened in the lighting industry um and that move to sort of LED LEDs and away from incandescence.
- 39:18Dave Wallace: And at no point did anyone think about the kind of health consequences of all of this stuff.
- 39:24Dave Wallace: It wasn't even factored in.
- 39:26Glen Jeffery: No.
- 39:26Glen Jeffery: No.
- 39:27Glen Jeffery: And superficially, why should it be?
- 39:29Glen Jeffery: Yes, superficially, you know, it you know, it do even, you know, vast majority of the scientists.
- 39:36Glen Jeffery: Why should it be?
- 39:37Glen Jeffery: We've got more light and it's cheaper.
- 39:39Glen Jeffery: It's not costing us anything when we move to an LED.
- 39:42Glen Jeffery: But we just didn't understand the light we don't see, but our bodies in different ways perceive.
- 39:51Glen Jeffery: My uh my mitochondria in my body are aware of of.
- 39:59Glen Jeffery: Long wavelength, deep infrared light.
- 40:02Glen Jeffery: That light goes through your body.
- 40:04Glen Jeffery: I can measure it coming out the other side.
- 40:07Glen Jeffery: And it influences them even at very, very low concentrations.
- 40:12Glen Jeffery: So yeah.
- 40:14Glen Jeffery: How do we get across public perception?
- 40:17Dave Wallace: No, I well, I look, I think it's like one of those problems you go back to asbestos and scurvy and smoking is because the problems don't come for a little while.
- 40:27Dave Wallace: So you know, the problem with the LED thing is it's sort of, you know, we're we're only a decade into the journey, really, or a couple of decades into the journey.
- 40:37Dave Wallace: What are we seeing is where we're seeing metabolic diseases increasing, you know, and certain cancers increasing.
- 40:44Dave Wallace: And I I mean, like we talk places like the Middle East, they have diabetes rates which are absolutely astronomical.
- 40:53Dave Wallace: Yeah, yeah.
- 40:54Dave Wallace: You know, and what's the common, what's the common kind of denominator across all of this?
- 41:01Dave Wallace: Inside time, behind glass, under LED light.
- 41:06Dave Wallace: Yeah.
- 41:06Dave Wallace: Eating probably ultra pro you know, so yeah.
- 41:10Dave Wallace: I mean, all of this stuff must be kind of work.
- 41:12Dave Wallace: I mean, you you I I do wonder if you could ask a mitochondria what's going on, they'd go, none of it's good, is it?
- 41:21Glen Jeffery: There's um there's a great study uh undertaken in Papua New Guinea where um the diets of the people are almost pure carbohydrate.
- 41:32Glen Jeffery: Um, you know, so you look at them and you think, well, you know, diabetes should be rampant.
- 41:37Glen Jeffery: These people live fundamentally outside.
- 41:40Dave Wallace: Yeah.
- 41:40Glen Jeffery: There is no significant history of diabetes in that population.
- 41:44Glen Jeffery: You know, they they they have firelight, they live outside.
- 41:49Glen Jeffery: Um it's telling you something.
- 41:52Glen Jeffery: I mean, you can argue, well, maybe they're all genetically different.
- 41:55Glen Jeffery: Well, that's possible, but then let's stack up the evidence.
- 41:58Glen Jeffery: Where's all this different evidence coming from?
- 42:00Glen Jeffery: And that is great.
- 42:01Glen Jeffery: And then on the on the alternative side, you look at the Gulf, you look at Saudi Arabia, highest incidence of diabetes.
- 42:09Glen Jeffery: They never go out in sunlight.
- 42:12Glen Jeffery: They have got artificial lighting, they've got infrared blocking glass to keep their wind to keep their environment cool.
- 42:19Glen Jeffery: Uh, let's look at those two extremes.
- 42:21Glen Jeffery: There's something going on there.
- 42:23Glen Jeffery: Um, and the whole of the Gulf has got that problem.
- 42:26Glen Jeffery: Kuwait's got that problem.
- 42:27Glen Jeffery: We've been out there talking to them about it.
- 42:29Glen Jeffery: Uh, all of the Gulf.
- 42:30Dave Wallace: Isn't it 40% or something like the rate of diabetes in Kuwait?
- 42:34Glen Jeffery: I mean, it's yeah, it's something like that.
- 42:36Glen Jeffery: Pre-diabetes isn't, they've got this massive, massive diabetes research institute.
- 42:41Glen Jeffery: There's not a lot going on in it yet, but the government acknowledge that they've got a ticking time bomb with diabetes, and they are not sure what to grab hold of.
- 42:53Glen Jeffery: There's one or two very smart scientists there that are actually raising the flag about light.
- 42:58Glen Jeffery: Um, and I know, I know one of them is in the medical school, and she's got one, uh she's got one lecture theatre for one group of students with incandescent light bulbs in it, and another lecture theatre with the LEDs.
- 43:12Glen Jeffery: And I'm looking forward to seeing the results.
- 43:15Dave Wallace: Amazing.
- 43:16Dave Wallace: No, that sounds great.
- 43:17Dave Wallace: I mean, and I think, you know, obviously your focus is on, you know, eyes because of your background, but I guess anyone from the scientific community who's listening to this who I mean, to me it would make sense to like take the work you've done and then maybe look at Dart.
- 43:36Dave Wallace: So do you sort of feed people Big Macs for uh as part of the process?
- 43:42Dave Wallace: I mean, and I know that's not eyes, you're probably looking at blood blood glucose levels and things like that, but you you know, there's obvious things that you could do to build on this, to kind of basically look at the real relationship between light, food, and all of these other bits and pieces, isn't there?
- 43:58Dave Wallace: Yeah, yeah, and and yes, I completely agree.
- 44:03Glen Jeffery: There's a package for health that is very obvious, and it is public health.
- 44:08Glen Jeffery: And it's small modifications that lead to improvements in public health improvements in health span.
- 44:16Glen Jeffery: I I want, you know, I want to be 80 and still knocking around and having, I'm not sure I care that much when I die, but I want to make sure that at least until that last five minutes before they put me in the coffin, I have a high quality of life.
- 44:31Glen Jeffery: That is, you know, that that's paramount.
- 44:35Dave Wallace: Well, and I think you so, you know, was it Alistair Nunn talking about morbidity, compression, and all that whole notion of okay, we're living longer, but we're not living healthier lives.
- 44:45Glen Jeffery: We're not.
- 44:45Glen Jeffery: We are not.
- 44:47Dave Wallace: That thought makes me very depressed, you know.
- 44:50Dave Wallace: So um, I mean, so anyway, well, listen, thank you so much because I think we've covered a lot of ground.
- 44:57Dave Wallace: I feel like you've completely demystified the research paper.
- 45:01Dave Wallace: I mean, I would encourage people to actually read it.
- 45:04Dave Wallace: Um, you know, now they could probably start with listening to the podcast, then have a look at the paper because I think it kind of really brings it to life.
- 45:12Dave Wallace: But it's a very impressive piece of work.
- 45:15Glen Jeffery: I want, I wrote certainly the abstract and the introduction of that paper with the idea in mind, could my mum get it?
- 45:25Dave Wallace: Yeah.
- 45:25Glen Jeffery: Right?
- 45:25Glen Jeffery: My mum's my mum's just a housewife.
- 45:29Glen Jeffery: Could my mum get it?
- 45:31Glen Jeffery: Because as I've said before, it's all about communication now.
- 45:35Glen Jeffery: Everything is about communication.
- 45:37Glen Jeffery: Um, hopefully they'll get the abstract, hopefully they'll get the introduction.
- 45:43Glen Jeffery: That's good enough.
- 45:45Dave Wallace: I think they will.
- 45:45Dave Wallace: I think they will.
- 45:46Dave Wallace: But it's I love the protocol, I love the descriptions of how you went about it.
- 45:51Dave Wallace: There's some very interesting photos as well.
- 45:54Dave Wallace: So, you know, I think it's brilliant.
- 45:56Dave Wallace: So thank you so much, and uh look forward to seeing what your next project is as well.
- 46:01Dave Wallace: Thank you, Dave.
- 46:03Glen Jeffery: Thank you for helping to publicise it.
- 46:08Dave Wallace: Thanks for listening to Sunlight Matters, brought to you by Shadow Man, where we explore how sunlight influences the way we build, design, and live each day.
- 46:18Dave Wallace: If you like what you heard today, be sure to subscribe, follow, and leave a review on your preferred streaming platform.
- 46:25Dave Wallace: You can also search Sunlight Matters on Google to find all our episodes, guest information and resources about sunlight analysis, solar exposure, and the best home orientation for natural light.
- 46:38Dave Wallace: You can also head over to shadowmap.org where you can download our iOS app for free today to visualize how sun is currently impacting your life.
- 46:49Dave Wallace: We appreciate you being part of the conversation, and we'll see you next time, where you can keep exploring the world through the lens of light.