Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / A Tale of Two Cities (1936)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. And I'm Ryan. And we are talking more
- 0:23literature today. That's right. Yep. And while
- 0:26we're talking literature, we actually didn't
- 0:28plan this, so this works out very nicely. I just
- 0:29want to go ahead and say. O -U -T -A -O podcast
- 0:32at gmail .com. Good lord. Maybe this is why you
- 0:36should do it from now on. Maybe you should continue
- 0:38to do it. You can reach us there with any questions,
- 0:42thoughts, concerns. We take them all. Also, you
- 0:46can find our Patreon exclusive benefits by joining
- 0:49the Patreon, including early episodes and our
- 0:53exclusive episodes such as Horror the Overlooked
- 0:56and, of course, our Discord access. Yeah. But
- 0:59the reason that I wanted to talk about literature.
- 1:02On this one is I wanted to kind of go ahead and
- 1:04open up with some somber news and talk about
- 1:08some of the people that we've lost recently.
- 1:10So obviously in the news, we're a little delayed
- 1:14because we record these early. Sure. Dolly Parton
- 1:17and Tim Curry had passed. Kind of a one -two
- 1:21right after each other, both 80 years old. I
- 1:25found out about this when I was in Pittsburgh
- 1:26for work. Um, and it was devastating because
- 1:29I was with two of my coworkers and we were talking
- 1:32about Dolly Parton and the importance of her
- 1:33music, but also the importance of literature
- 1:36and how important, uh, of a figure she was for
- 1:39like children's literacy. Obviously worth important
- 1:42or worth mentioning on this podcast, not alone
- 1:44for those things. Uh, but also she was a prominent
- 1:48figure in movies. Um, nine to five best little
- 1:51whorehouse in Texas, steel magnolias. Like these
- 1:53were very big pictures. Um, For a second when
- 1:58I first heard this news, I don't know why I was
- 1:59thinking Best Little Whorehouse in Texas was
- 2:01nominated for Best Picture. I don't believe it
- 2:03was. Keanu Lorber did just release a copy of
- 2:07it. I've heard it looks beautiful. I'm excited
- 2:10to pick it up. I imagine now it's going to be
- 2:11a little more difficult. But I wanted to see
- 2:13your thoughts not only on Dolly Parton, but also
- 2:16another prominent figure, maybe not so much to
- 2:18the Academy, but to us at least in how much we
- 2:21love movies, Tim Curry. Clue, Legend, Home Alone
- 2:252, Rocky Horror Picture Show. I mean, that's
- 2:28like the top of the list. Muppet Treasure Island.
- 2:30Oh my God, I have a poster not 10 feet away from
- 2:33you of this. It's not in this room. It's in the
- 2:36other room. It's just, if I do the math, it's
- 2:3810 feet. Just broke my neck. For no reason. But
- 2:41yeah, so I want to give you a chance to talk
- 2:44about how you felt about that. Yeah, it's obviously
- 2:48devastating news. Yeah, you're going to be like,
- 2:50good. Yeah. So long. No, it's pretty awful. You
- 2:56know, I try to always look at people that reach
- 3:01that age and have lived like that caliber of
- 3:05life. I try to look at their passing with more
- 3:09optimism and like celebration, I guess, than
- 3:12really sadness. Both of them, like you said,
- 3:16were 80. Dolly Parton had an incredible career
- 3:19that spanned, God, what? five or six decades
- 3:22which is wild insane and like you said music
- 3:27movies um uh just aid to people across the world
- 3:32television show for both dollywood is cool as
- 3:35hell like she did so much and she she's always
- 3:39come off as just like a good person and i think
- 3:42it's so rare in this world to find genuinely
- 3:45good people uh i i can't think of a single news
- 3:48story i've ever heard where it's like You know,
- 3:51she's always been great. So I've tried to just
- 3:54look more at both of their passings like as a
- 3:57celebration and Tim Curry as well. Like, I don't
- 4:00know if he has ever been an actor that like I
- 4:04remember I love as much as I do. But then when
- 4:07I do list his movies, I'm like, are you kidding
- 4:10me? It's insane what he's done. And, you know,
- 4:14he stopped acting. He hadn't been acting for
- 4:18a while due to a stroke he suffered. And even
- 4:22then he was going to conventions and stuff and
- 4:24talking with fans. And he just always seemed
- 4:26like somebody who was very grateful of the life
- 4:30he led and the career he led. And so many of
- 4:35those movies, like, I do revisit and I will revisit
- 4:38and just... monumental people really i mean rocky
- 4:42horror picture show plays i'm sure in many places
- 4:45especially in atlanta but uh the plaza at midnight
- 4:48every friday and i just cannot imagine uh what
- 4:51kind of celebrations are going to be like are
- 4:53going to be like now yeah following Tim's passing.
- 4:58Just wanted to make sure I shouted those out
- 5:00because very prominent figures, A, in general,
- 5:03but B, to movies. So I wanted to make sure we
- 5:06made some time for them here. So I appreciate
- 5:09you giving me the natural segue from literature
- 5:11to talk about Dolly Parton a bit. But it's fitting
- 5:15because you really can't talk about the movie
- 5:17that we're talking about today without talking
- 5:18about literature. Charles Dickens, to be specific.
- 5:21Today we're covering the Charles Dickens adaptation,
- 5:23or rather the... adaptation of Charles Dickens'
- 5:26novel, A Tale of Two Cities. Yes. And this is
- 5:30like a title that I am so familiar with and a
- 5:35story that I knew nothing about. Well, it's easy
- 5:39to be extremely familiar with it because just
- 5:41let's, you know. Time warp ourselves to 1936
- 5:44in honor of Tim Curry. There have been four adaptations
- 5:47at this point for A Tale of Two Cities, three
- 5:51of them before the talkies, 1911, 1917, and 1922.
- 5:56So we're seeing a 14 -year gap from the last
- 5:59adaptation to now. Yeah. And it almost feels
- 6:02like they've been waiting for someone like Ronald
- 6:04Coleman to do this. I feel like the actors that
- 6:08we've seen at this time that feel like they could
- 6:10play the role. uh specifically of either or uh
- 6:14sydney carton and uh charles dick nope wrong
- 6:17charles darnay i saw charles d and i was like
- 6:21yeah that's my guy charles darnay i think frederick
- 6:23march could uh fit the bill pretty well um i
- 6:27think oh we just saw him as uh romeo and romeo
- 6:29and juliet this is gonna hurt leslie howard thank
- 6:31you leslie howard could have done this very well
- 6:34yeah i think even um Is it Lionel Barrymore or
- 6:38John Barrymore who's more of the leading man?
- 6:42Why do I forget? I get them confused so often.
- 6:45I think Lionel Barrymore is from Grand Hotel.
- 6:49Well, they're both from Grand Hotel. Bad example.
- 6:51Yeah, there's no good way to do this. One of
- 6:54them would be great. One of them would be great.
- 6:56The Barrymores would do well here. I think that
- 6:59Ronald Coleman has a very stoic... nature to
- 7:04him yes and i think he's very handsome and he
- 7:06kind of has like a more modern feel to his look
- 7:10i would say before we we get too far into who's
- 7:14in this well i'll tell you who's in it right
- 7:16now this was directed by jack conway and ronald
- 7:19coleman did play sydney carton And this also
- 7:22starred Elizabeth Allen. Edna Mae Oliver returns.
- 7:25We remember her from another adaptation of classic
- 7:28literature, David Copperfield. Blanche Yerka
- 7:32is a big character here. Probably my favorite
- 7:35performance as Madame de... Oh, Defarge. Defarge,
- 7:40thank you. This was written by W .P. Lipscomb
- 7:43and S .N. Berman, based on the Charles Dickens
- 7:47novel from 1859. That's right. I should also
- 7:51have started with the nominations. My apologies.
- 7:53No, that's okay. Two nominations for A Tale of
- 7:56Two Cities. Look at what we're doing. Isn't that
- 7:58weird? Three nominations for Three Smart Girls,
- 7:59two for A Tale of Two Cities. We'll see what
- 8:02San Francisco has for us. Film editing was the
- 8:06first nomination for Conrad A. Nervig. An outstanding
- 8:09production on behalf of MGM Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer.
- 8:13Yes. I did want to point out, you mentioned this
- 8:15was directed by Jack Conway. It was. It was also
- 8:19Robert Z. Leonard as a fill -in director. Okay.
- 8:23And we'll talk a little bit about Robert Z. Leonard
- 8:25here a little bit, but that is off the bat, the
- 8:27two directors who contributed. Yeah, and we've
- 8:30seen two other movies from Jack Conway now, Libel
- 8:33Lady this year, but also Viva Via with... wallace
- 8:38berry as well it's also we'll talk about it a
- 8:41little bit later here but there's technically
- 8:42four people who directed this movie oh really
- 8:45um i mean who oversaw the whole thing jack conway
- 8:48sure robert z linder is a fill -in director and
- 8:50then two directors who kind of stepped in um
- 8:53for one specific sequence that we'll talk about
- 8:56later yeah but uh for anyone who hasn't read
- 8:59the book how would you break down a quick two
- 9:03-sentence synopsis of uh a tale of two cities
- 9:07A Tale of Two Cities is the story of the catalyst
- 9:11of the French Revolution that also tells the
- 9:15story of love and sacrifice, I would say. There
- 9:20you go. Yeah. It feels kind of like sometimes,
- 9:24I don't know if you've noticed this, every once
- 9:26in a while, maybe every year, but at least once
- 9:29in a while, there will be two films that come
- 9:32out in the same year that you're like, did no
- 9:34one speak to each other? about these yeah i'll
- 9:37give you some examples the prestige and the illusionist
- 9:39came out in the same year sure there was no strings
- 9:43attached friends with benefits uh wasn't armageddon
- 9:46and deep impact the same year there you go so
- 9:49and another current example uh paw patrol the
- 9:53dino movie and end of oak street came out on
- 9:56the same day Big day for dino lovers. Big day.
- 10:01Big day for my niece, who's a huge dinosaur fan.
- 10:04There you go. She's not seeing End of Oak Street
- 10:05anytime soon. That's good. And I'm not seeing
- 10:09Paw Patrol dino movie anytime soon, which is
- 10:11also good. Your loss. Ash will be the first to
- 10:14tell me that. That's what this feels like, where
- 10:17it feels like, hey, did the people who adapted
- 10:20Les Mis not talk with people who adapted A Tale
- 10:23of Two Cities? Because so much of this feels
- 10:26so similar. And don't get me wrong. I'm well
- 10:29aware that Charles Dickens wrote this a while
- 10:32ago. And the adaptation of Les Mis has been from
- 10:34a while ago. Victor Hugo. Correct. Yeah. So this
- 10:38isn't like this was Jack Conway's fault, by any
- 10:40means. Or not even a fault, but like the doing
- 10:43of Jack Conway. It's just like, I just saw Les
- 10:46Mis. I was like, oh, I really liked it. And then
- 10:48I watched this. I was like, this is writing me
- 10:50a lot of Les Mis. In terms of, like, love and
- 10:52sacrifice and, like, the French Revolution. Yeah.
- 10:55That's interesting to even bring up because it
- 10:58feels like that's what they do in Hollywood.
- 11:00They're like, oh, this was successful. Let's
- 11:02make this one, too. Let's just do this one. Yeah.
- 11:03And, you know, these are two massive entries
- 11:07in, like, classic literature. Yes. So it makes
- 11:09sense that they would adapt both of them. Yeah.
- 11:12I bet if you sat down and watched— It was year
- 11:13after year. Yeah, yeah. I don't know. It just
- 11:16makes sense to me. I think if this would have
- 11:18been a Hunchback of Notre Dame, you wouldn't
- 11:20have been like, Guys, we just did Les Mis. Do
- 11:22we really need another Victor Hugo? And you're
- 11:25right, because that's also love and sacrifice.
- 11:27So that's a good point. Maybe it's because, you
- 11:29know what? The problem with this movie, he's
- 11:31not a hunchback. Yeah, yeah, you're right. Nor
- 11:33do gargoyles speak to him. So maybe that's the
- 11:36problem. This is true. Now, it does have some
- 11:38spooky characters. Do you think I should talk
- 11:42to Charles Dickens and be like, hey, man, more
- 11:43explosions? Yeah, yeah. A Tale of Two Cities
- 11:47by Michael Bay. Where's the car chase, bro? And
- 11:50he's like, what's a car? It's like, that happened.
- 11:52Don't you remember the horse and the child? Oh,
- 11:55no. Oh, no. That did happen. Yeah, this is...
- 12:00This is one of those movies, similar to David
- 12:02Copperfield, I feel, that is kind of split in
- 12:05half, where the first half you are introduced
- 12:08to your players, and it's a very, very slow buildup,
- 12:13an introduction to the world. I don't know a
- 12:15whole lot about France during this time period,
- 12:18so I can't speak like historically accurate or
- 12:21politically accurate, but it's basically the
- 12:24wealthy are in power and they are not taking
- 12:27care of... the the everyday citizen yes uh it's
- 12:32also it i think the other thing that was just
- 12:35an interesting interesting parallel for me for
- 12:37me yeah is the purpose of identity in both of
- 12:41these movies uh les mis and tale two cities right
- 12:44in the sense of jean valjean Nailed it. Jean
- 12:47Valjean kind of battling the identity and trying
- 12:51to go under a different name. And of course,
- 12:53in this one, something that's so well known for
- 12:55A Tale of Two Cities is that we generally have
- 12:57one actor portraying both Sidney Carton and Charles
- 13:02Darnay. What's interesting about this adaptation,
- 13:05Jack Conway's A Tale of Two Cities, actually
- 13:07wasn't Jack Conway's call at all. This was Ronald
- 13:11Coleman. Ronald Coleman had specifically said
- 13:14that he would lead the film, but only on one
- 13:16condition. And that's where he would not have
- 13:19to portray Charles Dornay and instead would just
- 13:21play Sidney Carton. And this is what ended up
- 13:24having Donald Woods cast as Charles Dornay. And
- 13:28this was kind of against custom at the time.
- 13:30Right. Plays previous adaptations. We have seen
- 13:33the actor portraying Coleman also portray Coleman
- 13:37portray Carton also portraying Darnay. So this
- 13:41was a new thing. That's very interesting for
- 13:43us to see. I had heard that like this was a dream
- 13:46for Ronald Coleman to play Carton specifically.
- 13:49What's interesting is that he saw Carton, not
- 13:52Darnay, and said, no, that's my role. And maybe
- 13:57he wanted to like have this be standing out in
- 13:59that sense. I'm not sure. Now, with that said,
- 14:01I did have some problems with this movie because
- 14:04they do not look that alike. No, they don't.
- 14:08And the importance of them looking alike is that...
- 14:12It's less of they're brothers and it's more there's
- 14:15something later on. But yes, go ahead. Are they
- 14:17brothers? No, no, no. They absolutely aren't.
- 14:19It's not like they have to look like they're
- 14:21brothers. Oh, no, no, no. It's more of a... Carton
- 14:25disguises himself as Darnay at multiple points
- 14:28in the movie to kind of... get him out of trouble.
- 14:31So it is important in the story that they look
- 14:33similar. I didn't know that they were normally
- 14:35played by the same actor. That's very interesting
- 14:37and makes a chloroform sequence probably very
- 14:41difficult to pull off on a stage. I think there's
- 14:44a lot of hands in a tight close -up. Is it like
- 14:47the making out in the hallway at high school?
- 14:51Yeah, except the chloroform, which is probably
- 14:53how all scenes of people making out themselves
- 14:55in the hallway should go in high schools. One
- 14:57time when I was on set, I had to play a thug
- 15:00that chloroformed a girl and kidnapped her. Did
- 15:05I tell this story? No. Are you familiar with
- 15:06this? I think I would have heard you talking
- 15:08about chloroforming a girl. So, yes, please continue.
- 15:10It was pretty wild to hear the director be like,
- 15:13all right, here's what you're going to do. You're
- 15:14going to come up behind her and you're going
- 15:15to put this over her mouth. Was it real chloroform?
- 15:18No, no. Thank God. I was about to say. It was
- 15:20a dry piece of whatever paper. But, yeah, anytime
- 15:26I'm on set. It just feels like everybody is so
- 15:29okay with everything and ready to go. And I'm
- 15:32the one that's like, hello, ma 'am. My name is
- 15:35Kyle. I am going to be doing this to you today.
- 15:38I just want to make sure that you're okay with
- 15:40it. And she's like, can we go? We've got to film.
- 15:42I'm like, all right. I got five more chloroform
- 15:45scenes to go. It's just always so funny. But
- 15:48unfortunately, you do have a name that's very
- 15:50good for alliteration with chloroform. So I'm
- 15:51really glad that didn't stick. Yeah. Well, not
- 15:54yet. Well, let's hope not ever. I mean, there's
- 15:59a sequel coming, so we'll see. They cut that
- 16:02scene. They might need you. You'll never see
- 16:04it. But anyway. Yeah. But I was saying that this
- 16:09movie is kind of split into two. And the first
- 16:11half is honestly, for me, it was a little boring
- 16:15and it felt like it dragged a lot. And I was
- 16:17fascinated by the world and kind of the seeing
- 16:21the conditions that the people of France were
- 16:24having to deal with. The dirty, just disgusting
- 16:28streets that they had to survive in. The way
- 16:31that the, is it Basil Rathbone that plays the
- 16:35Marquis? Marquis Saint -Evermond. Yes, he's kind
- 16:41of the political figure in this section here
- 16:45of France. And he is so almost comedically villainous
- 16:50where it's so over the top. There's a sequence
- 16:53where he is. riding in his carriage his horse
- 16:57-drawn carriage into the city and it's going
- 16:59fast and a little kid kind of stumbles into the
- 17:03street and ends up having to run from this horse
- 17:05and carriage and he gets run over and killed
- 17:07and when rathbone's character gets out of this
- 17:11carriage and he's like why why is this child
- 17:13playing in the street you you people it's no
- 17:16wonder more of you don't die every day and oh
- 17:18you look hungry tough like just so on the nose
- 17:22villainous um I don't know where I was going
- 17:25with that, other than the buildup here is so
- 17:29just hand -fisted, I think. It is. I think the
- 17:35villainous thing is heightened because of how
- 17:39we see anyone in poverty reacting to things.
- 17:44Not just that incident you're talking about,
- 17:46but also there's a scene in which a barrel of
- 17:48wine falls over. Right. And everyone clamors
- 17:51to get as much wine as they can because it's
- 17:53fair game. Even a child is given like wine with
- 17:57like mud in it because it's like, you know, get
- 17:59your nutrients, I think is what his father says.
- 18:02So also what's interesting is this is two movies
- 18:06in a row we'll talk about where wine is publicly
- 18:08ingested through like a fountain or spilling.
- 18:11Yes. Interesting little like, you know, finding
- 18:14the connections between movies. Doesn't matter.
- 18:16Anyways, in this you see like how hard times
- 18:20are. And I think the reason that this got interesting
- 18:24for me is solely in the second half. So I agree
- 18:27with you on the first half. It's a lot of setup,
- 18:28a lot of meeting people, a lot of, hey, this
- 18:31happened, can you help out? And you're just kind
- 18:33of like, who is who? What's happening here? What's
- 18:35the importance of these characters? And maybe
- 18:38it's because of the production code, or the Hays
- 18:42Code, rather. At the time, this character of
- 18:46Sidney Carton is... Meant to be an alcoholic.
- 18:51Yeah. And that's a very large part of the story
- 18:54here. And you will see him like sometimes having
- 18:56a beverage, but like you don't see him incapacitated
- 18:59from this at all. No. But he does come off as
- 19:04like a functional alcoholic. Yes. For sure. Yes.
- 19:06And that is important to the story. You just
- 19:09don't see it very heavily in this. You're kind
- 19:13of lost in some details of it. But the second
- 19:15half, I think, is much more interesting for a
- 19:17number of reasons. But the one I'll cite right
- 19:19now is you see a lot more of the sense of how
- 19:25the lower class has taken over after the the
- 19:29uprising. Right. Right. Right. You see like the
- 19:33sparks of the revolution itself. Absolutely.
- 19:35And you see them like now they're in charge of
- 19:38the court systems and now they place like, you
- 19:40know, the. sentences to these people and more
- 19:44often than not they are beheadings yeah yeah
- 19:47famously guillotine beheadings yes um yeah that's
- 19:52i i think that's why the second half is is more
- 19:54interesting and exciting because things actually
- 19:57start to happen uh the the whole lead up in the
- 20:01first half of the movie really is that uh carton
- 20:06is recruited to rescue darnay by her his love
- 20:12interest he has been captured and he's about
- 20:17to be sentenced to death for treason and it's
- 20:20it's all a misunderstanding really so carton
- 20:24shows up and goes on trial to say hey the man
- 20:29who who called this guy out as the the treasoner
- 20:32what what's the word for that reason the man
- 20:35of treason i don't know we'll call it man of
- 20:37treason yeah uh you know look at me he shows
- 20:40up wearing a wig or whatever to look more like
- 20:42him and he's like are you sure mr heavy drinker
- 20:46that it wasn't me you saw and and gets him off
- 20:49on on that technicality like oh you're right
- 20:51it could have been anybody i guess well the thing
- 20:53that i like about and that's kind of the lone
- 20:55scene in the first act that i actually really
- 20:57enjoy is uh it's not only that he kind of catches
- 21:01him and like ah you may have confused me with
- 21:03him but he has a scene where he kind of like
- 21:06is that functional alcoholic that you talked
- 21:08about and he has that like um moment with that
- 21:11guy and he has him admit to him that like yeah
- 21:15i kind of framed this guy like it wasn't really
- 21:17him so then when he turns around in court and
- 21:20shows himself and like winks at him he knows
- 21:22oh well this guy can out me right now right and
- 21:25say that he heard me say that i framed this guy
- 21:27so in reality let me just say yeah you know what
- 21:30you're right it could have been anyone and let
- 21:32this go yeah so it's almost like He is doing
- 21:34him a favor of, hey, I know you lied. You know
- 21:37you lied. Why don't we just get this out of court
- 21:39and not show that you're going to be arrested
- 21:41for this? Yeah, it's like a two -part scheme
- 21:42by Carton. Yes. Where he's like, I'm going to
- 21:45make this a legitimate reason for the courts
- 21:48to believe. Like, oh, yeah, that makes sense.
- 21:51But I'm also going to sneakily kind of blackmail
- 21:54this guy. Yes. Another reason that this got really
- 21:57confusing for me is that, and hang with us here,
- 22:00any literary folks out there. are going to know
- 22:04this pretty quickly. But Lucy Manette is the
- 22:08individual, the love interest you were talking
- 22:09about. Love interests were both Carton and Darnay.
- 22:14Played by Elizabeth Allen. Correct. And eventually,
- 22:18Lucy and Charles Darnay do get together. They
- 22:22have a child together and they have a daughter.
- 22:24And they name that daughter Lucy. So there are
- 22:27now two characters named Lucy and not Lucy Jr.
- 22:31It's confusing when they mention Lucy and you're
- 22:33like, who are we talking about here? And those
- 22:36are all completely fine things, but in a movie
- 22:38that you were just not very focused on, it's
- 22:43a difficult beat. And we haven't really started
- 22:45with this, so I guess I'll dive into this aspect.
- 22:49I didn't love this. Okay. It was one of those
- 22:53where I think on the end, towards the end of
- 22:56it, it won me back over a little bit more. But
- 22:58it was just such a difficult thing to get through
- 23:01for the first half. And then the second half,
- 23:03there was a lot more that I was interested in,
- 23:05but it still felt uneven. Yeah. So it was difficult
- 23:10for me to get into. Definitely not like... unenjoyable
- 23:13by any means but difficult to like really get
- 23:16into it it was so similar to david copperfield
- 23:19for me but on the reverse where the first half
- 23:22of david copperfield i was like this is great
- 23:24i hope that this all pays off and then it didn't
- 23:27there was no exploration of Copperfield as an
- 23:30adult really for me. Do you think you prefer
- 23:32that or the alternative? Where the first half
- 23:36is more interesting than the second half? I would
- 23:38rather the second half be more interesting, I
- 23:41think. I agree. Because it's rare that I quit
- 23:44watching a movie. I will go all the way through
- 23:46and I'd rather walk away from it remembering
- 23:49the better part. Do you think the closest you've
- 23:52gotten to not finishing a movie recently with
- 23:55the pod has been Midsummer Night's Dream? I was
- 23:57never not going to finish that. Okay. Like, I'll
- 23:59finish everything. That's the closest I ever
- 24:02got to, like, jumping out my window. Do you think
- 24:05that counts? No, because I probably would have
- 24:08waited until it was over. And then jump out?
- 24:10Yeah. Okay. I'm just making sure it's like, no,
- 24:12no, no. It's not that I didn't stop the movie.
- 24:14It's that I stopped my life. It's different.
- 24:16I'm on the first floor, to be clear. I just think
- 24:20it would have been dramatic. Yeah. It's not even
- 24:21remotely a chance of, like, a sprained ankle.
- 24:23Yeah. If you jump out your window. That's great,
- 24:26my elbow. If anything, you're just going to maybe
- 24:28land on a chicken. Yeah. My neighbors have chickens.
- 24:31They're always in my yard. Get out of here. I'm
- 24:34sorry that we're recording at my place and not
- 24:36your place. I did have a laptop outside playing
- 24:40chicken noises. Oh, yeah. I hope that's coming
- 24:42through. It does make me feel more at home, for
- 24:44sure. But every five minutes, it plays an ad
- 24:47for a Lidl. right yeah so i i hope that's uh
- 24:51not a bothersome thing for which is very bothersome
- 24:53for the chickens actually yeah because they're
- 24:54like chicken breast on sale for 59 cents a pound
- 24:57they're like eggs half off and they're like what
- 24:59yeah stop everyone stop playing oh um yeah sorry
- 25:05about that you know it's kind of similar to uh
- 25:07tale of two cities really that's oh well hold
- 25:10on now see see what we got going well look at
- 25:13you so the that first half right ends really
- 25:17with the the trial and the disguise plot to save
- 25:21charles darnay and i even that trial section
- 25:26i know you said you enjoyed it quite a bit at
- 25:29least up to that point i was like but what why
- 25:31why are we doing this what is the point here
- 25:33and then you fast forward a few years because
- 25:36you do have darnay and lucy married and they
- 25:39have the daughter and i'm like well what did
- 25:40we gain other than this man did not die yes That
- 25:44is when the subplot of the child who was run
- 25:49over by the horse and carriage starts to take
- 25:51hold. And I think that is when the movie really
- 25:53starts to get interesting. For me, and I think
- 25:57we're saying the same thing here, it got really
- 25:58interesting for me during the storming of the
- 26:02Bastille. Yes, which is a result. Of the child
- 26:07death. Yes. Really. The storming of the Bastille
- 26:10is really where I think the movie turns around
- 26:12for me. You mentioned that this is a result of
- 26:15the child being ran over by the carriage and
- 26:18the horses. And this is where I want to talk
- 26:21about the two other directors. So we mentioned
- 26:23Robert Z. Leonard taking over for Jack Conway
- 26:26at some point. But here we actually saw Jacques
- 26:30Tournier take over along with Val Luton. Val
- 26:35Luton. Val Luton of Cat People. Oh, yeah. I think
- 26:41Body Snatchers. Okay. Many horror films. RKO
- 26:45Radio, obviously a very big name. But Val Luton,
- 26:49a big name for horror. Now, here's what's interesting.
- 26:52You wouldn't expect that in a Charles Dickens
- 26:55adaptation, but the Storming of the Bastille
- 26:57scene is really where I think it earns its film
- 27:00editing nomination. Yes. Conrad A. Nervig, as
- 27:03I mentioned previously, edited this film. And
- 27:06it's this sequence of the storming the Bastille
- 27:08that is terrifying of watching. Pretty much everyone
- 27:14can get it. Like we were just watching a complete
- 27:17uprising, the revolution that we talked about.
- 27:19I think in previous films that tackle the revolution,
- 27:22it's handled in a little bit more of a. How do
- 27:27I want to put that sanitized way? And in this
- 27:30one, you really do see there are murders. Yes.
- 27:34There are murders. There are people trampled
- 27:37by horses. Yeah, it's very graphic. Very graphic.
- 27:40And it's upsetting. And I won't say it terrified
- 27:45me, but it was upsetting to see. And it did not
- 27:49feel like that movie in a good way. Because they've
- 27:52been talking about how they need to rise up against
- 27:55the... Is it autocrats? I am the last person
- 28:02to know. They need to stand up to the rich elite.
- 28:05They need to turn over everything and make sure
- 28:07they gain the power that is being kept from them.
- 28:10And whether it be financial resources, whatever
- 28:14it may be. And you're seeing that come to a fever
- 28:18pitch. And I thought this was an exceptional
- 28:22piece, an exceptional sequence in the movie itself.
- 28:26And I think it really welcomed the tone of the
- 28:28rest of the movie. And it's interesting. I didn't
- 28:32pair it with this. I probably should have. The
- 28:34second half of this felt a lot like The Dark
- 28:37Knight Rises to me. And obviously so much of
- 28:39The Dark Knight Rises is taking from A Tale of
- 28:40Two Cities. But the People's Court, essentially,
- 28:44being ran by Scarecrow. That felt very similar
- 28:47to the People's Court where they were just justifiably
- 28:50sentencing everyone to beheading. Right. What
- 28:56did you think of this sequence of the storming?
- 28:59It's so impressive. There are so many extras.
- 29:02The set pieces are monumentally large. And this
- 29:08is kind of the first time I almost wanted to
- 29:12credit what we see here and in the next movie
- 29:15we're going to talk about to King Kong, where
- 29:18I think that was such a popular like action adventure
- 29:22movie that. Included so many special effects,
- 29:26but also stunt work that people were kind of
- 29:28hungry for more of that. And while we've dealt
- 29:30with like pirate movies and things with Mutiny
- 29:32on the Bounty and Captain Blood, there are stunts
- 29:36there. But this really felt like a lot. There's
- 29:40a scene where the French pull up the drawbridge
- 29:44and... Two citizens like run as it's going up
- 29:48and they jump and hang on to the bridge and they're
- 29:51dangling off and one of them falls into the moat
- 29:54below. But then they start scaling the fortress
- 29:57walls to break the chains free of the drawbridge.
- 30:02And in addition to that, like they're firing
- 30:05cannons, they're firing guns and people are falling
- 30:07off things. And it really felt like. Hey, here
- 30:10are stunt actors. You haven't seen a lot of this
- 30:13in Academy -nominated films. Not to say that
- 30:15it didn't exist in other movies. But I think
- 30:18this kind of ushers in a new type of filmmaking
- 30:22that really, I say this a lot, is super comparable
- 30:26to like what we see in the modern day. We want
- 30:29big action. We want stunts. We want special effects
- 30:32and things like that. It's so exciting. And to
- 30:35talk about the editing as well. In movies like
- 30:38Cavalcade and what's another good example? Maybe
- 30:44Lives of a Bengal Lancer, perhaps? Anytime war
- 30:49is shown or battles, it feels more, you're more
- 30:53distanced from those moments. You don't really
- 30:57see the characters that you've been watching
- 30:59have a role in those battles. So it's almost
- 31:04like a compilation of, hey, just get some stock
- 31:06footage of the war, which is unfortunate. Viva
- 31:09Via does that as well, another Jack Conway movie.
- 31:12This feels like if you see a wide of the background
- 31:16actors of France like storming the keep, you
- 31:20will eventually see all of them either killed
- 31:23or individually taking – having purpose in this
- 31:28fight. And I love that. It feels real. It feels
- 31:32– Like, you are in it. That is such a huge element
- 31:36of the editing that I think makes this work and
- 31:39makes this movie stand out. It's the... The fact
- 31:42that the cinematography, and maybe this is where
- 31:44Val Luton comes into play, the cinematography
- 31:47puts you really close to this. This is not a
- 31:50wide shot of many people, like, you know, endgame,
- 31:52like, clashing at each other. This is very up
- 31:55close. This is, like, faces, you know, down on
- 31:58the ground looking at a horse, like, coming down
- 32:00and then seeing, like, the trampling very up
- 32:02close. All this feels so personal. and that kind
- 32:05of lends to what you're saying of like it is
- 32:07a pov like you are there you are in it yes and
- 32:10this was such a smart idea to bring in uh some
- 32:13directors i can't say i'm familiar with jock
- 32:16uh and what he did previously but val luton when
- 32:19he goes on to do it's unmistakable the stamp
- 32:21that you can feel on this for you know cat people
- 32:24and the horror movies he goes on to make so I
- 32:28thought this was a really smart idea for them
- 32:29to kind of pull in and say, well, this is going
- 32:31to be a different kind of sequence. So why don't
- 32:32we bring in these individuals to oversee that?
- 32:36Very smart. And I almost wish there was a crediting
- 32:40for them of like, you know, their names were
- 32:42also listed along with the assistant director
- 32:45here, Robert Z. Leonard. But I will take the
- 32:49sequence being as effective as it is. And it
- 32:51gets my attention more so than. really anything
- 32:54we've seen previously in this movie, and then
- 32:56holds it for the remainder of the movie. Because
- 32:58now, I think it's kind of safe to say that this
- 33:02sequence has shown us that no one is safe. Right.
- 33:05And this is an unpredictable event of what's
- 33:08going to happen, or series of events to come.
- 33:11Yeah, and it feels like there is a motivation
- 33:14in the movie now. You're actually following a
- 33:16plot that you care about. The revolution has
- 33:18started, and you want to know how that's going
- 33:20to affect people. I think that this was the moment
- 33:25that kind of drew you back into the movie. And
- 33:26I mentioned it was a little prior to this where
- 33:29the father of the boy that was trampled sneaks
- 33:33into Marquise's room, the comically evil villain
- 33:38of the movie. Basil Rathbone. Yes, Basil Rathbone,
- 33:41and kills him in his sleep. And that sparks the
- 33:44outrage. And I think that's the beginning of
- 33:46the Val Luton sequence because everything is
- 33:48just shadowed. And you see like the knife really
- 33:52come up and then come down really hard. Yeah.
- 33:54And it just feels, it's shocking when you see
- 33:57this. Now you don't see him being stabbed. You
- 33:59just see the knife coming down. Right. And they,
- 34:02this is what's kind of interesting to me. They
- 34:05expertly get through the production code on that
- 34:07sense, but it's the next sequence of like the
- 34:11trampling and everyone like rioting that. You're
- 34:14like, well, hold on. This feels like it completely
- 34:16goes in the face of everything we just saw of
- 34:18like the subtlety. Right. Subtlety is out the
- 34:20window with this sequence. Yeah. Well, there's
- 34:23a sequence, too, where everyone is charging the
- 34:26cannons and the cannon fires like you're behind
- 34:29the cannon. The camera is and it fires and it
- 34:33leaves a line of fallen people. It's it's pretty
- 34:38crazy. It's pretty wild. But. There is like an
- 34:41element of violence here that feels so defiant
- 34:44of the production code. And I think it is because
- 34:47like the villains aren't winning for one thing.
- 34:50Like it is a historical. Exactly. Do you think
- 34:53that gets a pass? I think so. I think because
- 34:55we've seen that here, we'll actually see it in
- 34:58our next movie as well. There's a pretty hefty
- 35:00amount of violence, really horrific violence
- 35:03in the next movie. Not that the horse trampling
- 35:06scene didn't make my jaw drop here. I think that's
- 35:11where we start to see, hey, the production code
- 35:14is here and you do have to follow it unless,
- 35:17and there's a lot of unless in this movie. It
- 35:21was an interesting, I don't want to say gamble,
- 35:24but move from David O. Selznick, of course, the
- 35:28head of MGM at the time. I thought this was interesting.
- 35:31This was the last film that he did under MGM
- 35:33before he started his own production company.
- 35:36Yeah. And it's interesting because we talked
- 35:39about Selznick before saying, like, we really
- 35:41want to get in the business of biopics. And adaptations
- 35:44were very popular at this time. And they wanted
- 35:47to see more of the Shakespeare adaptations, more
- 35:49of the Dickens adaptations. And this being the
- 35:53final movie of his MGM career kind of feels like
- 35:57they've continued that effort. But then, of course,
- 36:00he has the money to go on and create his own
- 36:02production company and do what he wants to do.
- 36:04So I thought it was an interesting. I think sometimes
- 36:07when you see a final movie out with a head like
- 36:09that, they're like, I don't know, whatever is
- 36:11going to make money. But with this, it feels
- 36:13like there is an actual desire to make something
- 36:15like this, which I thought was cool. I also think
- 36:18there's a lot of really good subtlety, not subtlety,
- 36:20but symbolism in the movie. You talked about
- 36:25your favorite performance. I forget the actress's
- 36:28name. Blanche Yerka. She plays Madame Defarge.
- 36:32Yes. I thought she was really interesting because
- 36:35the camera loves to sit on her, to just rest
- 36:40on her and watch her work on her yarn in her
- 36:43crafting. Yeah. She's like crochetings. needlework
- 36:47exactly so i thought this was interesting because
- 36:49it's like a tapestry that she's creating and
- 36:53the movie does create this sense actually the
- 36:56camera creates this sense of a metaphor of two
- 37:00things one i saw that there was like the fates
- 37:03of like greek mythology of the way she's overseeing
- 37:05this but also um of like old english uh like
- 37:09the the weird sisters um it It sounds like weird,
- 37:13but like the W -Y -R -D. Yes. Yeah. So the idea
- 37:17was like her having the crocheting that she's
- 37:20doing throughout the movie. Really, I think just
- 37:23about any time that she's on screen, except for
- 37:25like the very end sequence of her moments, she
- 37:28is crocheting. Yeah. And the idea is that like
- 37:31it's the Grand Tapestry of Death. Right. And
- 37:35that this is all like sealed. The fates are sealed.
- 37:37Like everyone's fate in this movie is determined
- 37:39and it's going to go out the way it's supposed
- 37:41to go. And I thought this was interesting because
- 37:44it's not in the performance that she gives, although
- 37:46she gives a good performance, I agree with you,
- 37:48but it's more in the actions of what she's doing.
- 37:51And she's kind of like, it's a foreboding thing
- 37:53of her weaving the entire movie. And I thought
- 37:57that was really interesting. I liked a lot of
- 37:59the out loud things that were being said, whether
- 38:02it be that storming of Bastille or the quiet
- 38:05parts. That's more her performance and the subtlety
- 38:08of that. And then she gets really loud towards
- 38:11the end when she gets to like speak in a court
- 38:13and everything. Yeah. Well, and even after that.
- 38:15Yeah. But I thought she was the best performance
- 38:19in this movie. I would have been OK seeing. a
- 38:23supporting actress nomination for her because
- 38:25she's the voice of the revolution throughout
- 38:27the entire movie. She is. She is the one that
- 38:30gives the father of the young boy the line that
- 38:34he leaves on the chest of Marquis when he's killed
- 38:37that says, drive him fast to his tomb, which
- 38:42I think is what the Marquis hinted at, like,
- 38:45oh, I'm going to drive even faster. And then
- 38:46she said, drive him fast to his tomb, hinting
- 38:49that's where he belongs. And I love that. She's
- 38:53always like, don't worry. Don't worry. Our time
- 38:55will come. Our day will come. And then when it
- 38:59does, when the revolution starts, when the siege
- 39:01on Bastille starts, she is there at the forefront.
- 39:04And she inspires everybody to come out of their
- 39:08homes and take part in this revolution. And that
- 39:12leads into an interesting part of the movie as
- 39:14well where there are a lot of – title cards in
- 39:17this movie. There are. And I thought that was
- 39:20a unique approach as well. We've talked about
- 39:23how movies such as David Copperfield or Anthony
- 39:27Adverse have the title cards kind of separating
- 39:31the moments in his life. This feels like taking
- 39:36a paragraph out of the book and overlaying it
- 39:39over what's happening on the screen. Yes. That's
- 39:42most evident, I think, in the Bastille. uh the
- 39:45storm of the best deal what did you think of
- 39:48that overall did it take you out of the movie
- 39:49not nearly as much as it did in anthony adverse
- 39:51yeah i think first off there's more in anthony
- 39:54adverse and in this it felt more like and maybe
- 39:58this is a damnation of the movie itself it should
- 40:01i don't mean it this way but it felt more like
- 40:04hey here are the themes in which you're going
- 40:06to see the the following scene tackle It's more
- 40:10like, yeah, here's some context, but mostly you
- 40:12don't need this. It's just going to be in the
- 40:13next scene. With anything adverse, it was kind
- 40:16of like, yeah, so he goes to Cuba or something.
- 40:18Anyways, we skip past that. Now he's in Jamaica.
- 40:21You're like, wait, what? What did we miss? Right.
- 40:25And it feels like it's more like skipping over
- 40:27stories. to like get you to the scene whereas
- 40:30in a tale of two cities like you said it's just
- 40:32a paragraph it's kind of like yep and then that
- 40:35led to this and here's this scene and it moves
- 40:37on it moves forward with it so not nearly as
- 40:40much and it was more setting the scene than it
- 40:42was like replacing filming anything right so
- 40:45i i like that use of title cards much better
- 40:47what was the word that that kept popping up on
- 40:50screen they did it stylistically where it was
- 40:53the word either help Or, or. Oh, what was it?
- 40:57You know what it reminded me of? It reminded
- 40:58me of Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory with
- 41:00the Oompa Loompa scenes when it would like warp
- 41:02onto the screen during their song. Yeah. Oh man.
- 41:06What was it? Was it Help? I can't remember if
- 41:09it was Help, but it was, it was. I always wanted
- 41:11to say it was Hark. It's not Hark. It was them
- 41:13getting, spurring on the revolution more, you
- 41:16know, getting people out of their homes and all
- 41:18of that. And. The way they did it was such a
- 41:21stylistic choice because they had the word pop
- 41:23up on screen in normal font and text, and then
- 41:26it got bigger and bigger every time, and it showed
- 41:28more people opening their windows to see what
- 41:30was going on. That whole sequence is almost like
- 41:35a silent film in a way because the music is playing,
- 41:38and then there's sound effects playing that don't
- 41:41always necessarily line up with the actions going
- 41:43on screen, but you'll see people moving their
- 41:45lips as well, but there's no dialogue. It is
- 41:48all overlaid with these title cards, and I thought
- 41:51that was very interesting. Well, I think this
- 41:54leads us to the natural conclusion of the movie.
- 41:57One thing we haven't mentioned is that Charles
- 42:00Darnay, I'll say it's revealed. It's not revealed.
- 42:04You kind of know it up front. He is the nephew
- 42:07of the sinister Marquise that we mentioned, and
- 42:11de Overmont. Sorry, Zink. Wake is the word. Wake.
- 42:17Wake. That's it. Yes. As to like, you know, get
- 42:20everyone aware of the situation and to wake up
- 42:22from what they've been doing their entire life.
- 42:26So the Marquis St. Overmont is the uncle to Darnay.
- 42:31Right. And this comes out. And now everyone is
- 42:35in this public court after the revolution. They're
- 42:40condemning all of the rich elite in this sense,
- 42:43the aristocrats. And they ask him about this.
- 42:48And he tells them what I think is a pretty clear,
- 42:50like, you know, hey, I've actually condemned
- 42:51that side of my family and have not wanted to
- 42:54be a part of them for so long. And then they
- 42:57start getting some really interesting thoughts
- 42:58of like, well, just because you've condemned
- 43:00that, does that make you exempt? Right. Like,
- 43:02does that mean that you've not benefited from
- 43:04that lifestyle? Does that mean that you are not
- 43:07where you are now because of that? And this shows
- 43:10the ugly side of both. both examples right of
- 43:13both the rich and then of the lower class of
- 43:16now they have the power are they any different
- 43:18are they treating that any differently and it's
- 43:20they're really interesting questions in that
- 43:22um i thought the the the theming of this was
- 43:25done very well especially in the second half
- 43:27uh the second half of the movie did much better
- 43:30for me and then the first did And that's solely
- 43:32just because there's a lot of setup that's needed.
- 43:34Yeah. I still think there's a lot of confusion
- 43:36in who's who in this. You mentioned in Three
- 43:39Smart Girls that there's a couple moments where
- 43:41there's men in suits and you're like, which one
- 43:43of you is which? Yeah, who's who here? And that's
- 43:45kind of how I feel in this. The costuming is
- 43:47better. uh in this than it is in three smart
- 43:50girls and of course they're fitting to the time
- 43:52of charles dickens i like ronald coleman's style
- 43:54a lot in this i think i need to start rocking
- 43:57a scarf to be honest with you shout out to adrian
- 43:58as well that's right yeah mgm so we've got the
- 44:02regulars douglas shearer cedric gibbons adrian
- 44:04that's right yeah um But I think that was a major
- 44:07issue that I had where I do like this. And I
- 44:10think this kind of leads naturally to the title
- 44:11cards you're talking about is that this leads
- 44:14to adult Lucy finding carton. Yes. Yes. Finding
- 44:17carton again, Sydney carton and telling him of
- 44:20the situation. My husband has been arrested and
- 44:24they are going to hang him or they're going to
- 44:26behead him. Yeah. And it's in 24 hours. He's
- 44:29like, hey, don't worry. We'll find a way to get
- 44:30him out. And the way that they get him out. is
- 44:34that Carton determines, and this is all in the
- 44:36book, so spoilers for a book that I'm sure we've
- 44:38all had to read for AP English. But just in case
- 44:41you haven't. Not me. Or just, you know, general
- 44:43English like I took. Not me. Carton then decides
- 44:48that he will use the similarities in appearance
- 44:52from him and Darnay to take his place. He is
- 44:56a man who cannot have the love of his life because
- 44:58she has chosen another man. And he is an alcoholic.
- 45:04He feels like he can give this man a better shot
- 45:07at a life. And he deserves that more than he
- 45:09does. So he decides to take his place, chloroform,
- 45:13popping up again, putting him to sleep, and then
- 45:17replacing his body with his own, and giving him
- 45:20his clothes so he can live his life as, I assume,
- 45:25Sidney Carton, and Sidney Carton die as Charles
- 45:29Darnay. Right. And I thought that there's a scene
- 45:32where he is waiting to be tried. just executed
- 45:37executed right and uh a woman walks up to him
- 45:40and recognizes him it's like why would you do
- 45:42this for him and i think this is where ronald
- 45:45coleman sells like the movie he sells his entire
- 45:48performance on this i thought he was incredible
- 45:50but then there's a great sequence where they're
- 45:52all walking up line by line to this um to the
- 45:55gallows the guillotine yeah and This is where
- 45:58we see our final title card in that he is about
- 46:02to put his head in. But instead of seeing this
- 46:04grotesque scene, the camera pans up and shows
- 46:07the sky. And that's where we have our final title
- 46:09card, which is generally said by Carton just
- 46:14before the beheading. Yeah. But this was another
- 46:17decision that I thought was a little not controversial,
- 46:19but an interesting choice to have that line be
- 46:24at the end of the movie in the title card. Yeah.
- 46:26You know how. In the classic Disney movies, it
- 46:29starts with a storybook and opens up. So it's
- 46:32like the first page you're always reading. Yes.
- 46:34I feel like this was trying to keep you reminded
- 46:39that this is a novel, you know? So the title
- 46:44cards popping up so frequently, it's almost playing
- 46:46on that a little bit. And I really like the end
- 46:49sequence here. Everything from when he's discovered
- 46:52by the seamstress who's been sentenced to death
- 46:54wrongfully. Because she's terrified. She's a
- 46:58young girl. She's terrified. And when she discovers
- 47:01what he's done to save Darnay, she's like, I
- 47:04was terrified until this moment because you are
- 47:07brave and I'll be brave as well. And them choosing
- 47:11to show him walking up to the guillotine block
- 47:15and then panning the camera up. So good. That
- 47:19was the moment I was like, okay, I'm bumping
- 47:21up my rating because I really like this. And
- 47:23I know the line is obviously from the book. The
- 47:27opening, it was the best of times. It was the
- 47:30worst of times. I've heard that a lot. And when
- 47:33I was watching the movie, I was like, I think
- 47:34it was the worst of times. I don't know if it
- 47:37was the best for anybody, really. Well, I guess
- 47:40a Rathbone was doing pretty well. I guess that's
- 47:42the whole thing. It's like the tale of two cities.
- 47:44There's the high life and the other life. But
- 47:48this line really, really stuck with me. And it
- 47:51is a far, far better thing that I do than I have
- 47:55ever done. It is a far, far better rest that
- 47:58I go to than I have ever known. And it just adds
- 48:02so much weight to the sacrifice he's chosen for
- 48:07himself. I love the ending of this movie. The
- 48:10ending is fantastic. I mean, I think that the
- 48:13second half... of this movie redeems a lot of
- 48:17the first half and i don't know if that's like
- 48:20if that's ultimately a good thing like oh the
- 48:23movie is better because of that second ending
- 48:25and i'm gonna like rate it properly the way i
- 48:26should have the whole time or if it's just in
- 48:29the story itself the second half benefits a lot
- 48:31more or the story benefits a lot more from the
- 48:33second half but i agree that the Second half
- 48:37is great, but also specifically that scene, I
- 48:40think it was a really smart call to have that
- 48:42final line be a title card rather than Ronald
- 48:45Coleman read it. Because at times I think it
- 48:48can be a little too performative of like, well,
- 48:50I'm going to stop in monologue real quick. Yes.
- 48:53The dialogue, they do a really good job of it
- 48:55not feeling like they're just reciting exactly
- 48:57what's... Romeo and Juliet's a great example
- 48:59of like, you guys are just reading what's on
- 49:00there. And it doesn't feel very like you're older
- 49:03than they were. This doesn't feel very authentic.
- 49:06This feels authentic. And I think if he would
- 49:09have stopped just before the beheading and said
- 49:11this, it would have been a little like, yeah,
- 49:12that's the last line. Okay. But for it to be
- 49:15like more, that's his thoughts. Because for the
- 49:17camera to pan up and then that up here is more
- 49:19kind of like the consciousness of him, I think.
- 49:22Yes. Than it is the movie telling you this. And
- 49:24I thought that was really well done. I think
- 49:26it would have been a little too performative
- 49:28if he just recited this line like in tears. This
- 49:30was much better. I think that the image of him
- 49:33walking up to the guillotine. And just the somber
- 49:38look on his face. But also, like, there's no
- 49:40fear there. It's such a unique emotion to have
- 49:44to capture. It's a complacency in what he's decided.
- 49:46Yeah. I feel like that's a very difficult emotion
- 49:49to capture as an actor and an artist. And he
- 49:53does it so perfectly. That's why I think Ronald
- 49:55Coleman is doing something that, like, Frederick
- 49:59March probably could have done. I don't know.
- 50:02Like, they're all great actors. His face specifically
- 50:06in that moment is so iconic now in my brain,
- 50:10even if the rest of the movie was not as iconic
- 50:14to me as that moment. I'm not sure if this is
- 50:17the first time we've seen him since then, but
- 50:19this was Aerosmith, right? Ronald Coleman? Yes.
- 50:23Yeah, and I really liked him in both this and
- 50:26Aerosmith. So I'm starting to like him a lot.
- 50:29He's becoming a little bit more of a reliable
- 50:31figure in the podcast for us. I thought he was
- 50:35excellent in this. I'm not sure if you want to
- 50:38get right into ratings or if there's anything
- 50:40else you want to talk about before we discuss
- 50:41it. So there is one thing I want to talk about.
- 50:44In the group of the main resistance members,
- 50:47the father, Blanche Yurka, and then there is
- 50:50the cackling witch woman. Yes. And I say cackling
- 50:55witch because of the connection she has. That
- 50:58is Lucille Laverne. And you might recognize that
- 51:02laugh, do you? Did you recognize it? It was very
- 51:06noticeable, but I don't think I recognized it.
- 51:08You didn't recognize it? That is the Evil Queen
- 51:10in Snow White. Oh, I did see this. Yeah. Oh,
- 51:13that's cool. So I thought that was very cool.
- 51:16We've talked about, I think Snow White herself
- 51:18appeared in another one of these movies that
- 51:20we mentioned briefly, and that was kind of a
- 51:22rare thing for her. It's cool now that we've
- 51:24seen Snow White and the Evil Queen. So that is
- 51:27interesting. I'm excited to watch that next month.
- 51:31We won't talk about it for the nominations, but
- 51:34we will talk about the ceremony. Yeah. So I'm
- 51:36really excited to watch that and maybe hear her
- 51:39a little bit in this. She is a they did not go
- 51:42very far off from the figure because she is she's
- 51:45got the robe on and everything. Yes. Yeah. That's
- 51:48why she's not like a witch in this movie, but
- 51:51she is in Snow White. And that laugh is very
- 51:54witchy. You're right. Yeah. I do want to, one
- 51:57more thing. You mentioned her at the top. Edna
- 51:59Mae Oliver. Oh, yeah. Just a little miscast in
- 52:03this movie. Not really. She's very good. But
- 52:05I think she provides, in David Copperfield, certainly
- 52:08she did this. She provides a lot of comic relief
- 52:11in her own personality. Yes. It's not that she
- 52:14has lines or anything or she does anything really
- 52:16funny. It's just more her presentation is very
- 52:20soothing. And I'm trying to think of the comp
- 52:23here. She's almost like the best friend, but
- 52:27to everyone. Yeah. And I thought she was really
- 52:30good in this, in that role. And it was just a
- 52:33little bit of levity that this movie needed.
- 52:35So whenever she's on screen, you're always kind
- 52:36of like, oh, I like her. Yeah. I do think that
- 52:40you're right, though. She's such a lighthearted
- 52:43actress, I feel. And that's based on the two
- 52:46movies now I've seen her in. She has this huge
- 52:49finale at the end with... Madame LaForge, is
- 52:53that it? They end up in a feud together and they're
- 52:56rolling around and trying to take each other
- 52:58out. Because LaForge is trying to get child Lucy.
- 53:02Yes. And ultimately this ends with LaForge pulling
- 53:07a pistol out and Edna Mae Oliver somehow manages
- 53:11to like turn her hands so that she shoots herself.
- 53:15and kills her and then they her the whole family
- 53:18flees after that so miss pross is really like
- 53:21the hero of this story in addition to carton
- 53:24just i didn't expect that from her edna may oliver
- 53:27feels odd to me specifically in that part yeah
- 53:31no it's it's a strange decision i think she does
- 53:35well in it but um I kind of appreciate it because,
- 53:39again, it's just a little bit of levity that
- 53:40I kind of needed. Yeah. And not even in the characterization,
- 53:43but just more in, oh, that's Edna Mae Oliver.
- 53:45But either way, she's really good in it. Let's
- 53:48get into ratings. Yeah, let's do it. So you and
- 53:51I are matched here. Okay. We went three stars.
- 53:53absolutely i was originally two and a half uh
- 53:55i did bump this up to a three two and a half
- 53:58i think i was putting a lot of weight on that
- 53:59first half of the movie and looking at the second
- 54:03half and seeing how effective it is seeing the
- 54:05performances kind of like cultivate or culminate
- 54:07into what they become i think it requires the
- 54:11first half to be a little bit more of a setup
- 54:13um I still think that creates some unevenness
- 54:16in the movie, and that's why I can't go much
- 54:19higher than where I'm at. Ronald Coleman's performance
- 54:22is fantastic. It's very subtle. I feel like the
- 54:27decision to separate Carton and Darnay creates
- 54:32some complications in the way that these two
- 54:34characters have meaning together, and that makes
- 54:38the movie feel a little uneven to me, too. Those
- 54:41reasons, I can't go much higher than a three,
- 54:44but you can't deny the siege scene that you talked
- 54:49about from Val Luton and Jacques. That was done
- 54:52so well. Ron Coleman's performance, I think the
- 54:55direction is fantastic. And I thought this, overall,
- 55:00this was enjoyable. It was just, you feel the
- 55:02length. After a while, you really do. Yeah, and
- 55:05that is a consequence, I think, of the first
- 55:09half of the movie, unfortunately. But again,
- 55:12I am grateful that the latter half was more interesting.
- 55:16I'd rather that than what we got with David Copperfield.
- 55:19Definitely. For double feature, I went with a
- 55:22movie that is also about a period piece that
- 55:27is also about war, that is about uprising, but
- 55:31specifically about condemning the wrong man just
- 55:35for instead of an elite reason, although that's
- 55:38kind of affected too, mostly just at a selfish
- 55:40choice. And I went with the 2007 Joe Wright film
- 55:44Atonement. Atonement. I thought there's a top
- 55:48review on Letterboxd that I completely agree
- 55:50with that said Saoirse Ronan was robbed in this
- 55:54movie from not getting a nomination for playing
- 55:56the literal devil. Have you ever seen Atonement?
- 55:58I have not. Anyone who's seen that movie is going
- 56:00to understand why she is so reviled in this movie.
- 56:04She accuses, read between the lines with me on
- 56:08this, she accuses James McAvoy of doing something
- 56:12to her just because she is in love with him.
- 56:15But he is actually in love and in a relationship
- 56:17with her older sister, Keira Knightley. Gotcha.
- 56:20And then that drives him to be sent away and
- 56:23go to war where he ultimately meets a demise.
- 56:26Gotcha. Very, very troublesome movie. Very difficult.
- 56:30Not necessarily French. More set in England.
- 56:33But this is something that the ties between falsely
- 56:38condemning a man for something and watching him
- 56:41have to like... suffer this was like kind of
- 56:43the alternative uh the yin to the yang of tale
- 56:46of two cities of how this can end up for someone
- 56:48that you can't have a savior or ultimately you
- 56:51could pay the price for something you never did
- 56:53um that would be joe wright's atonement joe wright
- 56:55someone who i think gets a dogged on a little
- 56:57bit now i think he had a great run of movies
- 57:00for a while uh hannah is a movie that i have
- 57:03a lot of time for i also like anna karenina a
- 57:06good bit uh and then there's pan I've never seen
- 57:10any of those movies. I'll leave that where it
- 57:12is. You should see Anna Karenina. I think you
- 57:14would really like Hannah. Yeah, I think I'll
- 57:17have to see Anna Karenina. I want to say it was
- 57:19nominated. At least one version of it was nominated.
- 57:21I don't know if his version was. Hannah should
- 57:23have been nominated for a score, which I don't
- 57:25think it was. But yeah, Hannah, well worth your
- 57:28time out of all those. And very different than
- 57:30everything else I mentioned. I'll definitely
- 57:32check it out when I can. Oh, he did it. So that's
- 57:37such a better. double feature than what i'm going
- 57:40with i i think my double feature kind of like
- 57:43skirts some of the themes of like classism and
- 57:47like guilt and sacrifice and i i went with the
- 57:52uh whatever year it came out the remake of 310
- 57:55to yuma oh i love that movie i really really
- 57:58like that movie a lot and it's it's so different
- 58:01i don't even know in my brain like what the comparison
- 58:04is But without spoiling the movie, I think the
- 58:08ending feels very similar to me in a way of what
- 58:13A Tale of Two Cities is. And that might be just
- 58:17like the most vague, simple comparison overall.
- 58:21But for whatever reason, that's the movie that
- 58:23was in my head while I was watching this one.
- 58:25What I like about our double features is that
- 58:27sometimes, most times, we provide context of
- 58:30like, here's why I picked this. Other times,
- 58:32it's like you just said, but I think it would
- 58:33just be like vibes. Yeah. Just vibes. Yeah, it
- 58:36is kind of just vibes. It is. Also, if you put
- 58:38Ben Foster in a ugly mustache, a big old ugly
- 58:42mustache, I'm going to watch it. Yeah. He's in
- 58:44that movie. Who are the two? It's Christian Bale
- 58:47and who? Russell Crowe. That's it. Man. You know
- 58:51what I sing at work all the time from that movie?
- 58:53And I think people look at me like, are you good?
- 58:56When Russell Crowe's sitting by the campfire.
- 59:00The night before he's delivered for hanging,
- 59:02and he's like, they're going to hang me in the
- 59:04morning. Before the morning comes, hang me in
- 59:07the morning, and I'll never see the sun. I'm
- 59:10sorry, so you're saying that you sing that at
- 59:13your new job, that you go in at 6 a .m., that
- 59:16they've just met you. I sing that at every job,
- 59:18but yes, it continues today. See, I think it's
- 59:21more fitting at the haunt that you work at seasonally.
- 59:24I think it's a little more concerning when people
- 59:27at 6 a .m. hear the new guy sing that. Well,
- 59:30you know. It's like, I think this guy has a false
- 59:32expectation of what's going to happen to this
- 59:35office. Or he thinks he's going to be here really
- 59:37late. But, which, hopefully not. Also, Dawn has
- 59:41already happened. Right. At that point. So it's
- 59:43like the next Dawn. Exactly. Yeah. I need to
- 59:47rewatch that movie. It's been a minute. It's
- 59:49so good. We're going to talk about the original,
- 59:51though. We are. Yeah, yeah. Which is one of the
- 59:53rare examples where I'm like, I like the remake
- 59:56more. Yeah. No, I have a feeling I agree with
- 59:58you. I need to see it, though. Yeah. But that's
- 1:00:01going to do it for A Tale of Two Cities. Hope
- 1:00:05you enjoyed that one. We let in with all of the
- 1:00:08info, the Patreon and shooting us an email and
- 1:00:10all of that. We have one more movie left to cover
- 1:00:12for the ninth Academy year, and then we'll be
- 1:00:15moving on to our ceremony. That movie is going
- 1:00:17to be San Francisco, which I got to tell you.
- 1:00:21was not what I expected it to be. No, it certainly
- 1:00:23wasn't. I'm very excited to get into it. Not
- 1:00:26what I would have expected from a Clark Gable,
- 1:00:29Jeanette McDonald movie. Not at all. And if you
- 1:00:33wonder what we mean... This movie has everything.
- 1:00:37I was just about to name everything, but I kind
- 1:00:38of don't want to give it away. If you're wondering
- 1:00:40what we mean by that, check in the next episode.
- 1:00:42Absolutely. But that's going to do it for today.
- 1:00:45As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 1:00:48you at the movies.