Latest / Newcomer Pod / Jeremy Levine on AI Hype, Market Cycles & Playing the Long Game
Transcript
- 0:00And if, as an investor in venture capital, you're looking
- 0:03for returns every quarter or every year, you're in the wrong
- 0:05asset class. This is a patient person's game.
- 0:07How does one of the best software investment firms in the
- 0:10world feel about the SAS pocalypse?
- 0:12Today's guest is Jeremy Levine of Bessemer Venture Partners.
- 0:15He has a long history of early prescient investments in
- 0:18companies like LinkedIn, Pinterest, Yelp, and Shopify.
- 0:21We sit down to discuss his firm's over 100 year history,
- 0:24how he lives in reality and keeps his principles amidst
- 0:27everything happening in AI. He's the guy I turn to when the
- 0:30world is losing its mind. This is the NEWCOMER PODCAST.
- 0:41Jeremy Levine, welcome to the NEWCOMER PODCAST.
- 0:44Thank you for having me. Let's let's start big picture.
- 0:46You know, you see it all at Bessemer and have watched a
- 0:50number of hype cycles, you know, in venture capital, you know, it
- 0:55feels like the haves and have nots.
- 0:57You know, there's the story of obviously all the AI mania, but
- 1:02then there also sort of has quietly been this downturn, the
- 1:06recovery from 2021 that's hit, you know, some venture fund
- 1:10managers and then also a bunch of start-ups.
- 1:12I think we talked a couple years ago now in light of that 2021
- 1:18euphoria and the recovery, what how do you see where are we
- 1:21right now in sort of the venture capital cycle?
- 1:25I mean, it's hard to know exactly where we are until we
- 1:27have perspective of being able to step back and look at it a
- 1:30number of years later. But that said, I now I think
- 1:34it's pretty clear that 2021 was kind of the the culmination of
- 1:37this incredible period of growth in SAS software as a service.
- 1:43The companies grew, the industry grew, the investors around the
- 1:46companies grew like everything went up into the right for many,
- 1:49many years, more than a decade. And then all of a sudden the
- 1:53market thought for a minute, maybe these really nice
- 1:57businesses aren't quite as valuable as as as we thought
- 2:00they were. And that was the adjustment that
- 2:03we went through from 2021 to 22 or 23.
- 2:07And I think that's generally in the rearview mirror, say for the
- 2:10SAS occur that has recently happened, which we should talk
- 2:12about it in a minute. But I think the, the industry,
- 2:16the venture industry, the entrepreneurial, like I said,
- 2:19all shifted to AI obviously. And, and the growth of these AI
- 2:24businesses is making the SAS stuff look like child's play.
- 2:29It's extraordinary. And so before software as a
- 2:32service, when a company had to roll out software, it had to
- 2:34build infrastructure servers and, and, and run all the stuff
- 2:37on premise. And SAS made it so much easier
- 2:40that you saw SAS companies go from zero to 100 million of
- 2:44revenue in five years, whereas traditional software companies
- 2:47took 10 or more years. And that was this massive
- 2:49compression and acceleration. And now with AI, what used to
- 2:52take five years is now taking one year.
- 2:55And so it's an incredible speeding up of everything which
- 2:58I think has the the industry wildly excited and it's fun to
- 3:01watch all. Right.
- 3:01SAS occur a word I cannot turn away from.
- 3:05I mean, you know, you're a firm that had what the Cloud 100 has
- 3:09been very loud on software. A big believer vertical SAS in
- 3:12particular. You guys were extremely strong.
- 3:16Yeah. What do you make of the public
- 3:18market's total turn away from software as a service?
- 3:22Yeah, I so. At a high level, it's
- 3:24complicated and nuanced and you really have to think about it on
- 3:27a, on a name by name basis. But I'll I'll nonetheless get
- 3:30myself in trouble by generalizing.
- 3:32And that is to say, I think the public markets have overreacted
- 3:37very significantly in some cases, but there's also probably
- 3:41a little bit of valuation or price compression that's was
- 3:45meant to be. And So what do I mean by that?
- 3:47So for starters, I, I think the meme, if you will, is that with
- 3:52AI, anyone can create software. You don't need to be an
- 3:56engineer, let alone a really good engineer.
- 3:58And that drives the cost of creating software to near 0.
- 4:01And so why as a company or a customer, should I pay SAS
- 4:06company to provide software for me when I can just build it
- 4:09myself almost for free? And I think that oversimplifies
- 4:14a lot of what a SAS company does.
- 4:16But even if you take all that at face value, I think that's not
- 4:20what makes the most valuable SAS companies really valuable.
- 4:24What the software itself, that is what makes the most valuable
- 4:27SAS companies really valuable is the fact that they grew a
- 4:30network effect. And so I'll give you a couple of
- 4:33examples. And and the reason why the
- 4:35network effect is so important is because you can't replace it
- 4:38just by building the same piece of software for free.
- 4:42Perhaps my favorite example of Shopify was a Alex Ferrara at
- 4:45Bessemer led the investment for us about 15 years ago.
- 4:49And at first, the software that Shopify made was just really
- 4:53good software and that was their competitive edge.
- 4:56If that were their only competitive edge, I would be
- 4:58nervous for Shopify in this Assiger.
- 5:00I'm not. The reason why I'm not is
- 5:02because along the way Shopify built multiple network effects
- 5:06that insulate its business from someone else just building the
- 5:09same software and giving it away for free at a cheaper price.
- 5:12Right. But Shopify, yeah, feels like a
- 5:15unique company. When I think of software
- 5:17companies, yeah, I think of them as sort of more than the
- 5:19aberration than the representative case.
- 5:22Like do you have a view on Salesforce or a more classic
- 5:26software company? So, so I think that the the way
- 5:28I would analyze any given name and we can go through a whole
- 5:31bunch of them, but Salesforce for starters is like, is there a
- 5:34real network effect there? And I think in Salesforce's
- 5:37case, there are real network effects.
- 5:40I don't think they're quite as strong as the, the shop pay
- 5:42thing I was, I was about to share with you, but they're
- 5:45real. And so a couple examples.
- 5:47One is Salesforce has built or an entire ecosystem has been
- 5:50built around Salesforce of third party consultants and
- 5:54integrators who've built products that plug into
- 5:57Salesforce. And so you can't just replicate
- 6:00Salesforce itself to get the value of Salesforce.
- 6:03You then have to replicate all the third party capabilities
- 6:06that exist around Salesforce. And the reason why they exist
- 6:08around Salesforce and not other platforms is because Salesforce
- 6:12is by far the biggest. And so that's a situation where
- 6:15the the the first player, the the first mover has the massive
- 6:18advantage because the ecosystem develops around it.
- 6:21I think the second potential network effect around Salesforce
- 6:24is among its users, its users are so familiar with it.
- 6:29And to the extent human salespeople remain a thing,
- 6:33that's that's a second, a second source of value for Salesforce.
- 6:37There's there's so much comfort with it.
- 6:39Absolutely. Then it makes them less
- 6:41efficient. It makes them less happy.
- 6:43Now, that said, that is a network effect that could easily
- 6:46disappear if in fact, salespeople writ large or
- 6:49replaced by AI, because AI doesn't care what the interface
- 6:52looks like. But I think that's what you have
- 6:54to do for each of these companies, understand, is it
- 6:57just good software or in some cases mediocre software?
- 7:00Or is there something else going on?
- 7:02And if you ignore the something else, I think you're going to
- 7:04make the wrong call. Do you have a view on what the
- 7:07valuation multiple of software companies should be?
- 7:11I know that's like a market derived.
- 7:13Yeah. And it really depends company by
- 7:14company, but I think ultimately, you know, companies are worth
- 7:20some some aggregation of their future cash flows.
- 7:24And so when these companies that have no profits are being traded
- 7:28for say, 10 times revenue, I think what someone is really
- 7:32saying is I believe this company will become profitable or quite
- 7:36profitable. And when I discount those future
- 7:38cash flows back to today, it happens to equal 10 times
- 7:41today's revenue. But I don't think they're saying
- 7:43there's something inherently valuable about the revenue
- 7:46itself that they're willing to pay 10 times for it.
- 7:48I think the map is implicit. And then people get lazy and
- 7:51they stop thinking about the future cash flows and just start
- 7:54thinking about revenue multiples.
- 7:56But I think as we, you know, in 2021, we saw fast growing
- 8:00software companies regularly trading for 40 and 50 times
- 8:03revenue, which implied extraordinary future growth and
- 8:07high profit margins. In some cases that actually
- 8:10materialized, in some cases it didn't.
- 8:12I think today people are willing to be a little less bullish
- 8:15about the future and therefore that translates just to a lower
- 8:19revenue multiple. Are you still investing in
- 8:21software companies at early stages, or is that thesis out
- 8:25the door now? No, no, absolutely.
- 8:27And in fact, one of the reasons why is because what you're able
- 8:32to do now with AI embedded in your software is just so
- 8:35powerful. The functionality is, is
- 8:38fantastic and I'll give you some examples.
- 8:39So we invested them. It's probably been about 18
- 8:42months now in a company called Relevance.
- 8:45Relevance is essentially a software platform for managing
- 8:48AI agents. And so as companies adopt or try
- 8:52to adopt AI and and want agents to do the work of often times
- 8:58the grunt work that humans don't want to do, or supplement humans
- 9:01with additional capability where these agents can run in the
- 9:04background 24/7 doing work to to make people more productive.
- 9:10They need a platform to manage all this.
- 9:12And, and so that's what relevance builds.
- 9:14I'd say they were a little bit ahead of their their time in
- 9:16that most people weren't really talking about AI agents 18
- 9:19months ago or even 36 months ago when the company first got
- 9:22started. And today they are, and they're
- 9:24looking for solutions. And companies like Databricks
- 9:27and Confluent, as they try to embrace AI in their internal
- 9:30business operations, are all using relevance for it.
- 9:33And so, yeah, there's certainly opportunities for software.
- 9:36Most of them are, I think in today's world about leveraging
- 9:40AI and making it productive in the enterprise.
- 9:43And to what extent are those like, oh, we're going to have
- 9:45sort of a chat bot feature or like where, where do you see
- 9:48them? I mean, there are a bunch of
- 9:49different strategies for replacing a software category
- 9:53with AI. Or do you have buckets that
- 9:55you're starting to see where it's like, OK, there's this
- 9:58approach, this approach, and this approach?
- 10:00So we are seeing folks simply try to staple a chat bot feature
- 10:04onto a product. It's not going to work because
- 10:06the the the, the foundation labs, the foundation model
- 10:09companies, they have really great chat bots and you don't
- 10:11need much else. You can just append them or open
- 10:14them in another browser. So I call that a very thin value
- 10:17proposition. The thicker propositions are
- 10:19ones that builds real capabilities into the software.
- 10:23And so for, for example, we have another portfolio company,
- 10:27Hockey Stack. Hockey Stack is a software
- 10:29company, also a relatively new investment, maybe 18 months old
- 10:32for us now. And Hockey Stack started off by
- 10:35building a data platform that you can use as a marketer to
- 10:40understand where your better leads are coming from, your
- 10:43worst leads are coming from. And they, when they first
- 10:45started the company, I don't think they had thought a whole
- 10:47lot about AI. Today, the entire company is
- 10:51geared around AI and, and in in many ways, it's sort of back to
- 10:54our Salesforce conversation flipped Salesforce on his head.
- 10:57And so you can think of Salesforce as a tool to make
- 11:00human salespeople more productive, where the human
- 11:03salesperson is the the engine or the brain of the operation.
- 11:07And it's the that human is leveraging tools like Salesforce
- 11:09to make their job better. Hockey Stack has flipped the
- 11:12thing upside down. And Hockey stack is saying,
- 11:14well, actually there's so much data in sales and marketing that
- 11:17it's hard for a human to intuit. And so wouldn't it be better if
- 11:21AI were the brain sifting through all the data to make
- 11:24decisions? And then when helpful, it will
- 11:27ask a human to do something. So the AI is researching the
- 11:30prospects, evaluating which prospects are the most ripe for
- 11:34potential sale, and then deciding what's the action that
- 11:38my company should take with respect to this prospect.
- 11:41And if it's reach out with an e-mail, it will draft the e-mail
- 11:45and at the human center, maybe even send the e-mail itself if
- 11:48it's have a conversation or make a phone call, it will tell the
- 11:52human like, hey, this is a good phone call to make.
- 11:54And so the AI essentially becomes the quarterback and the
- 11:57human is a tool that the AI is using to, to further the
- 12:00initiative. And so I think there's so many
- 12:03categories of software that need to be rethought or re imagined
- 12:06because when they were designed, these AI capabilities didn't
- 12:08exist. And now they're they're wildly
- 12:10powerful. What's what's your view on the
- 12:13big foundation model companies today?
- 12:15I have sort of conflicting intuitions.
- 12:17On the one hand, feels like they keep doing better than we
- 12:21expect, like the revenue is growing more.
- 12:24I think investors keep marking them up more and more the the
- 12:27sense that wow, they're really dominant and highly valuable.
- 12:31I think that sentiment has continued to accelerate.
- 12:34I think people have seen some progress, you, your investors, I
- 12:38think in Anthropic. And then on the other hand, I
- 12:42don't know, it feels very like thin and tenuous.
- 12:45You know, it's like, can open AI get all the money that it wants?
- 12:48It seems sort of desperate for more money.
- 12:50We saw XAI sort of clumsily merged into SpaceX in a way that
- 12:55didn't make me feel from the outside, I guess, as optimistic
- 12:58about how that business was doing.
- 13:00What's your read? And I know they're all
- 13:01particular businesses with different strategies, but what's
- 13:04your read on sort of the value of foundation models and how
- 13:07much of the sort of the business opportunity here they're going
- 13:10to gobble up versus leave to other companies?
- 13:13So I think that it's an interesting conundrum because on
- 13:16the one hand, I heard somebody describe a foundation model as
- 13:20the fastest depreciating asset in human history.
- 13:23It goes down in value faster than a new car that's driven off
- 13:26of a new car dealership lot, which would suggest it's a
- 13:30really rapidly moving treadmill on your as a model builder,
- 13:34you're sort of pissing money down the drain building today's
- 13:37model when you know it's going to be outdated in a minute.
- 13:39And I think that's largely true. However, and kind of amazingly,
- 13:45I also believe these the good foundation model companies, of
- 13:50course, Anthropic among them. And you know, admittedly talking
- 13:52my, my own book or own book a little bit on it is going to be
- 13:55one of the most valuable companies in the world because
- 13:58the stuff is so damn powerful. And, and you know, credit to my,
- 14:03my partners who invested in Anthropic for us first a couple
- 14:06of years ago. And obviously that investment
- 14:09has improved in value more than our very recent investment.
- 14:13But I actually think the best investment in Anthropic on a
- 14:16risk adjusted basis is the one that just recently happened at a
- 14:19$350 billion valuation. Because it's become even more
- 14:23clear or wildly more clear today how successful this company has
- 14:27become and how much momentum there is for it to grow because
- 14:31people just can't get enough of this stuff.
- 14:32And it's I'd say it's meaningfully penetrated certain
- 14:35sectors like software development, but it's barely
- 14:38scratching the surface of dozens of massive other sectors of the
- 14:41economy, including sales and marketing or, or, or market
- 14:45research or frankly, a lot of white collar, you know, behind a
- 14:50computer office labour where people are using it a little
- 14:53bit. But there's just so far for it
- 14:56to go and, and you can just see that, I mean, I, I can't
- 14:59remember what's public and what I know in my head as as private,
- 15:02so I won't share the data. But the financial performance
- 15:06of, of Anthropic is just, it's astounding.
- 15:09And so it turns out that while yes, yesterday's model is much
- 15:16less valuable today than it was yesterday, a very small number
- 15:20of companies have proven the capability with the talent
- 15:25required to keep innovating and coming up with the next model.
- 15:29And it turns out that there actually are some pretty good
- 15:31uses for yesterday's model. It's maybe a little bit cheaper
- 15:35and a little bit less capable, but there's still plenty of
- 15:38people who are happy to use the slightly cheaper model for
- 15:40slightly less capability. And it's a, it's a really great
- 15:43business. In terms of venture strategy and
- 15:46portfolio construction, like I have you said how much money you
- 15:50invested in Anthropic? I mean, there are firms I know
- 15:53like the Menlo story a little bit better where it feels like
- 15:55they put a huge percentage of their fund into Anthropic.
- 15:59Like how have you thought about how much to say, all right, this
- 16:02is the thing like put a bunch of money in it.
- 16:05Now we're gross stage investors by old school standards versus
- 16:09saying no, we're we believe in portfolio theory and we should
- 16:12have a bunch of different bets. So we, so we, we invest in the
- 16:16full across the full spectrum of, of companies.
- 16:21So we, we sometimes we write $100,000 check in a person with
- 16:24an ID on a napkin and sometimes you write $100 million or even a
- 16:28$200 million check in what's obviously already a really
- 16:32compelling business. But what's in common across both
- 16:35is that we think the company that either barely exists or
- 16:39exists meaningfully can be 10 to 100 times larger in the future.
- 16:43And so, you know, one can debate is it easier to go from a
- 16:48million of revenue to 100 million of revenue or to go from
- 16:52100 million of revenue to whatever that would be 10
- 16:56billion of revenue, Is that right, 100 * 100?
- 16:59I think that's right. I think that's debatable.
- 17:03And so and and in fact $100 million revenue business
- 17:06actually looks like an early stage company relative to a $10
- 17:09billion revenue business. And so we think it's pretty much
- 17:11the same skill or the same puzzle that we're trying to
- 17:14solve. But if we're much less likely to
- 17:17invest in a, a quote, UN quote growth stage company, which may
- 17:21be $100 million or even a billion dollar revenue business,
- 17:24if we don't think it can go 10 to 100 times bigger, we're not
- 17:27looking to make, you know, a AA2X return.
- 17:30That's that's much less compelling.
- 17:32And so I think what's remarkable about Anthropic in particular is
- 17:37that it's already at a very significant scale and still
- 17:40growing as fast or faster than any company we've ever seen.
- 17:44And so these things don't come around all that often.
- 17:46And so hats off to Menlo for making what I think was a a very
- 17:50prescient early stage investment, but also I think a
- 17:53really smart later stage investment because I don't see
- 17:56the ceiling on Anthropic even remotely on the horizon.
- 17:59Which is part of why I think actually it's a better risk
- 18:01adjusted bet at a $350 billion valuation, given all they've
- 18:04accomplished and all the risks that have been eliminated than
- 18:07it was even a year ago when the price was much lower, but it had
- 18:11achieved much less. But I want to talk about agent
- 18:14marketplaces, like are you bullish on the idea that we
- 18:18should be building marketplace businesses for agents to
- 18:20interact with each other? We saw what the malt book sort
- 18:24of thing, which seems somewhat fake, somewhat real, somewhat
- 18:29fake, I don't know, still still to be seen.
- 18:30But I don't know what are you betting on.
- 18:32Any companies that are building like purely on a sort of agent
- 18:35marketplace thesis? No.
- 18:38Well, I mean, I mentioned relevance.
- 18:40Relevance is helping enterprises deploy agents to do white collar
- 18:43work. And so yes, but a system for
- 18:47agents to talk to each other, we haven't invested in any pureplay
- 18:51companies doing that, but we see it happening in some of our
- 18:54companies. And so for example, if you want
- 18:56to buy a ticket to an event, you, you probably find your way
- 19:00to StubHub at some point. And StubHub historically found
- 19:05that most people who were starting the event search
- 19:06process would start it on Google or maybe on StubHub directly.
- 19:11And increasingly they may start that process on Claude or on
- 19:15ChatGPT. And so they want to allow third
- 19:21party agents to complete transactions.
- 19:23Same thing for Shopify across all its stores.
- 19:25If you're, if you're starting your shopping search process
- 19:30with a bot, you every retailer wants to make sure its inventory
- 19:36is known to the bot. That said, I think it's going to
- 19:39depend a lot on what kind of transaction you're looking to do
- 19:43because humans like choosing that.
- 19:46You know, while I might prefer to have a bot reorder my paper
- 19:51towels and toilet paper, I'm not really shopping around when I
- 19:54make that purchase. If I'm trying to decide which
- 19:58seat I might want to sit in in the stadium, I want to see like
- 20:01what are the views? And I want to, I want to make
- 20:03the choice myself. And so I think depending on the
- 20:06category, we're going to find that in some instances.
- 20:09We have the agents go all the way, and it's literally an agent
- 20:12to an agent transaction. And I think a purveyor of
- 20:16commodity goods like Amazon is going to find Asian commerce
- 20:19really important. But in other places where taste
- 20:23and choice matters much more to the human, I think we'll have
- 20:26the agents do a bunch of work for us.
- 20:28But ultimately, we're going to be the one who clicks the final.
- 20:30Like, yes, that's what I want. I think these things are all
- 20:33emerging. I'll give you one other example,
- 20:36not to take this conversation in a random direction, but we
- 20:40invested in, I won't talk too much about it.
- 20:42It's a stealth investment and a wildly talented entrepreneur
- 20:46who's reimagining travel. And, and, and so in the way he
- 20:52described to me, the, the pitch was so compelling because he
- 20:55said, you know, the Internet when it came along that reformed
- 20:58travel and it basically eliminated hundreds of thousands
- 21:03of people whose jobs were as a travel agent.
- 21:07But the Internet didn't actually come up with a new travel agent.
- 21:10It just made you and me into travel agents.
- 21:12And we're now the ones checking what the flight options are,
- 21:15checking what the hotel options are, and kind of orchestrating
- 21:17it as a travel agent, which kind of sucks.
- 21:20But AI has the promise to actually be the travel agent and
- 21:25maybe live up to the original moniker, right?
- 21:28You know, the Expedia and the bookings of the world, they're
- 21:30called OTAs. That's the moniker which stands
- 21:33for online travel agent. But in fact, they aren't online
- 21:35travel agents. They're booking engines.
- 21:37And maybe with AI, we can actually build an online travel
- 21:39agent. So I think the other thing
- 21:40that's interesting about all these these sort of consumer
- 21:42agent technologies in particular is that the interfaces right now
- 21:46are all chat bots. But I think that's likely to be
- 21:49step one. And we're going to see wildly
- 21:52more creative interfaces that almost certainly will
- 21:55incorporate typing to a bot or even speaking to a bot, but also
- 21:59other elements that we're not yet seeing.
- 22:01It will be amazing if they can build actual brands for
- 22:03delivering, you know, the service successfully.
- 22:06Because I think right now a lot of this agent stuff, it feels
- 22:09like, OK, it's going to put this in your checkout box and then
- 22:14you're going to check out and say yes.
- 22:15And it's still like, maybe it gets you closer to the final
- 22:17decision, but you're still like pulling the trigger When we get
- 22:20to an era where like, okay, I've trusted this travel bot, It's
- 22:24booked it now. I'm willing to just sort of show
- 22:25up at the places it says. And I have a level of deference
- 22:28to it. I think that yeah, will be.
- 22:31It's sort of an amazing. Maybe, although it depends, like
- 22:32if it's a business trip and I know I need to be in, you know,
- 22:35San Francisco at 2:00 PM on Thursday, like, sure, let the
- 22:38agent do the whole thing. But if it's a vacation, like
- 22:40part of the fun view is like is looking at the photos and
- 22:43deciding where to go. And, and so like I said, I think
- 22:46the use cases are going to vary a lot.
- 22:47I think the simplistic idea that I'm going to do everything
- 22:50inside of a chat bot and I'm never going to go to a, a
- 22:52website anymore. That's ridiculous.
- 22:55But there will be definitely gradations.
- 22:57All right. Is this a consumer company like
- 22:59it's for? It is, yeah.
- 23:00Yeah. What what is the state of
- 23:02consumer today? I know that's another big
- 23:04question, but obviously the foundation models, you know, we
- 23:08sort of just talk through how in some ways, maybe you're going to
- 23:11anthropic or Chachibuti Claude and talking through the problem.
- 23:16And then they have to, you know, have a relationship with StubHub
- 23:18or something and you're the consumer experiences all in the
- 23:22chat bot. Is that the world you see or you
- 23:23see? Do you see opportunity for AI
- 23:26businesses that build sort of direct relationships with
- 23:29consumers themselves? I definitely see the
- 23:31opportunity. So I so to step back, I would
- 23:33say there was an explosion of compelling new consumer
- 23:38companies between 1996 and 2005. The first couple generations of
- 23:43the Internet and companies like Google and Pinterest and
- 23:46Facebook and and the like all emerged.
- 23:48And then there was a second slightly smaller but still
- 23:51significant explosion of companies that happened around
- 23:54the development of the Internet in your pocket on mobile phones
- 23:58and, and, and companies like Uber and and DoorDash all
- 24:03emerged. People want a platform shift.
- 24:06Some new things happen. It's not that they want it.
- 24:08It's not that they want. It's that once a platform is
- 24:10established, the incumbents amass the power and it becomes
- 24:14very difficult to get distribution.
- 24:16And so I think what when people think about consumer, they
- 24:18assume it was like some new whiz bang capability that built or
- 24:23was the foundation for a company.
- 24:25But in fact, while there often is a new whiz bang capability
- 24:29like being able to summon a car to you anywhere you are in your
- 24:32phone that that's Uber. What actually is much more
- 24:35important is how do you get that capability into the hands of
- 24:39millions or hundreds of millions or even today billions of
- 24:42consumers without having to pay to market to each one.
- 24:45Because if you need to pay to market to each one, your company
- 24:48will never be worth anything. But Google who controls the
- 24:52Internet platform alongside Facebook or or Apple, who
- 24:56controls the mobile platform, they'll make all the money and,
- 25:00and you'll be stuck. And in fact, you'll have to
- 25:01raise tons and tons of money. And so if you, if you, I think
- 25:06most of those early generation Internet companies, Facebook
- 25:09printers, Google, they never spent any money to acquire
- 25:11consumers. They got all the consumers for
- 25:13free. The second generation around
- 25:15mobile, it was a mix. Some did spend a lot of money.
- 25:19But actually I also think that they got a little lucky 'cause
- 25:22they were built in this zerp era, the the zero interest rate
- 25:27policy era where they were able to get and raise billions of
- 25:30dollars very cheaply. If that hadn't existed, I think
- 25:33many of those companies wouldn't exist, but they do and they did
- 25:36and they took advantage of it, which was quite smart.
- 25:40And and maybe the best and last example of a consumer platform
- 25:44that grew in the United States was TikTok.
- 25:48And they did it with billions of dollars of financing from a
- 25:51Chinese parent. They spent the money, but most
- 25:53start-ups can't realistically access that capital.
- 25:56And so what's consumer becomes interesting when there's a new
- 26:00platform, because a new platform means there's a new distribution
- 26:02technique. And so I think right now there's
- 26:06a confluence of two things happening at once that make me
- 26:08quite optimistic that we will see some new consumer companies
- 26:11for the first time in a decade, maybe more.
- 26:14And those two things are one, the way people are starting
- 26:18their Internet experience was almost exclusively on Google or
- 26:25one of the Meta properties. And now there's like a new front
- 26:29door and the new front door is Claude or ChatGPT or Gemini, the
- 26:34AI portion of Google search. And, and so the companies that
- 26:37had massively infiltrated the old front doors of the Internet,
- 26:43like in travel, as an example, it was booking like if you do
- 26:45any search on Google, like you see booking all over the
- 26:47results, 'cause they optimized the platform and it, they became
- 26:51$100 billion company that really dominates consumer travel.
- 26:54But for this new front door of the Internet, which is a
- 26:57chatbot, it's like open seasoned.
- 26:59And so I'm sure there's a team at booking trying to figure out
- 27:02aggressively like how do we make sure Booking is as present in
- 27:05these chat bot results as we as they are in the Google search
- 27:09results. But it's like a brand new game.
- 27:11Who? And are start-ups doing well at
- 27:13that or what's even the strategy?
- 27:15Well, and so, you know, in the early days of, of, of search
- 27:18engines, it was how do we manipulate the search engines to
- 27:21show our stuff high up in the results.
- 27:24And there were companies like Yelp, which did it really well.
- 27:26And anytime you search for a restaurant in any city, the Yelp
- 27:29results were among the 1st results.
- 27:31That was essentially the Kickstarter for how, how Yelp
- 27:33grew. And so, and, and it became an
- 27:38entire art or almost a discipline called search engine
- 27:41optimization. And there's an equivalent of
- 27:43that discipline now emerging for this new platform.
- 27:45And like I said, we've seen lots of people trying to innovate or
- 27:50reverse engineer or think about how to build their business in
- 27:54media. It's like one of the things that
- 27:56does well, I think in these spots is media.
- 27:59So yeah, happy to have that leverage, I guess at this.
- 28:02Point, yeah, but it the point is it's a new channel and it's very
- 28:05immature and it's a Sprint to go figure out how to crack this new
- 28:08distribution channel. So that's one.
- 28:11The second and compounding force is that there are new
- 28:15capabilities that you can build with AI that get consumers
- 28:19interested. And so now just that the latter
- 28:23is sort of more exciting from a principled perspective because
- 28:26like do we need another travel booking engine?
- 28:31We don't. They work just fine, but there
- 28:33may be an opportunity for one just by by dint of this new
- 28:38front door on the Internet. If you can be the one who is
- 28:40right behind the new front door of the Internet, you can build a
- 28:42replacement travel booking engine for booking.
- 28:44But the idea that you can build this wildly compelling new
- 28:47functionality because of AI makes it exciting.
- 28:50So now the consumers are also, in addition to discovering
- 28:53what's behind this new front door, are bumping into these new
- 28:56capabilities that I think will be sort of, you know, eye
- 28:59opening or potentially jaw-dropping.
- 29:01And when you put those two things together, I think you
- 29:03have the conditions for new consumer companies.
- 29:07The manipulation of the chat bots to produce sort of a, a
- 29:11company. I mean, it sounds somewhat
- 29:14depressing, right? I mean, I think what's great
- 29:16about the chat bots is like, if I'm like, I want the best pan,
- 29:19like what's the best pan? Sort of like, well, here's the
- 29:21best expensive one, Here's the best sort of medium, you know,
- 29:25price one. Obviously it's rooted in reviews
- 29:28and sort of different websites that trust probably Reddit to a
- 29:31large degree. How much do you see these
- 29:33businesses as needing to sort of manipulate the chat bots versus
- 29:38accept sort of a paradigm where they're thinking about things in
- 29:41sort of a different way? I mean, we sort of saw the
- 29:44degradation of search over time, which has allowed some of this
- 29:47opportunity, which is just over time it got more and more sort
- 29:50of games and, and sort of, I don't know, degraded in my view.
- 29:54If you want to think about it cynically, you can get pretty
- 29:56far just manipulating someone else's front door, and there are
- 29:59a lot of SEO companies that did that.
- 30:01I can't remember the the the name of the one that was.
- 30:05It was just like a massive farm of crappy content that would
- 30:07show up. It was called demand something,
- 30:10demand media. Eventually the the the front
- 30:13door the search engine. One day they're like, no.
- 30:15More figured it out. I'm like, this is crap and they
- 30:17just killed it. So you can get pretty far, but
- 30:19you probably can't build a great business.
- 30:21What makes it great business is that you, you, you, you may do
- 30:25some manipulation, if you will, these front doors to get get
- 30:29your product in front of consumers, millions of them or
- 30:31billions of them for free. But then what makes your
- 30:34business special is that the product is awesome and the
- 30:37consumer's like, wow, this is great.
- 30:39And next time when they want that experience, they don't go
- 30:42back through the front door. They come directly to your
- 30:44service. And that's that's like the Holy
- 30:46Grail of consumer and so. Are there any early businesses
- 30:49that have had success? I mean, I, I think Guillermo and
- 30:52Versal tweeted at one point, you know, that's not a broad
- 30:55consumer business, but tweeted that he was getting a fair bit
- 30:57of his business through people sort of deciding what to build
- 31:00in, in the foundation model zone.
- 31:02Are you seeing companies where they're getting a lot of
- 31:05customers through through these chat bots?
- 31:07It's just beginning, but we are and we're just trying to invest
- 31:12in them. So I'm not going to share the
- 31:13names with you because the last thing I need is even more
- 31:16competitors in a competitive world.
- 31:18But I'll give you an example of a company that we we haven't
- 31:19invested in that I think has done this.
- 31:22It's a business called Suno. I don't know if you know Suno
- 31:24and. Music Creation.
- 31:26Exactly. And so like there, the product
- 31:28is wildly compelling and it allows you to do things that you
- 31:31could never do before, or at least most people couldn't do
- 31:33before. And and I think they're also
- 31:36getting distribution through some of these chat bots.
- 31:39I think they're probably getting more distribution now because
- 31:41the product is so compelling, people are telling each other
- 31:43about it within the music world. But as an example, like you have
- 31:46to build something that's good or you end up going the ways of
- 31:49of demand media. But like I said, if you have to
- 31:53buy all your consumers one at a time, you need to have a, a
- 31:57massive sugar daddy with billions of dollars to to fund
- 31:59you or you're never going to get there.
- 32:00And that's that's tough to do. One, you know, investor craze
- 32:04and honestly, I, I can't remember if you made a bet in
- 32:07this category, they'll like QVC, you know, the online shopping
- 32:12for video category. Did you make a bet in that
- 32:15space? If we did, it was really small
- 32:19material. I don't know is that over or
- 32:21TikTok wanted to the extent exists, I guess what not is
- 32:23still sort of fighting it out. Do you ever read on that space?
- 32:27Because that was such like a hot category?
- 32:29Yeah, You know, it's funny because I think that, that I'm
- 32:32not a expert on the Chinese Internet, but, but my sense is
- 32:37that that's a much bigger, it's, it's much bigger thing for
- 32:43Chinese consumers than it has been for consumers in the West.
- 32:46And there I essentially think of there being 2 internets, There's
- 32:49a Chinese Internet and then there's the, the rest of the
- 32:51Internet and they don't mix very much.
- 32:54And so, and I don't know why, for whatever reason, no one has
- 32:58been able to, to quite make it work.
- 33:01But I, I, I wouldn't rule it out yet.
- 33:02I think we've seen a bunch of people try.
- 33:05Nothing has really stuck. I think Whatnot is interesting.
- 33:09I think it's a scaled business. My sense is a lot of what's
- 33:12happening on Whatnot are people buying things speculatively so
- 33:16they can resell them and and as opposed to buying things they
- 33:21necessarily want for themselves. So that's like a different, a
- 33:23different phenomenon altogether. But but you know, I haven't
- 33:27given up on it. But you're right to point out it
- 33:29hasn't happened yet. Yeah, I guess the gambling
- 33:32economy thesis, are you staying away from that?
- 33:34I mean, it's clearly, I mean, prediction markets loom super
- 33:38large. I mean, yeah, I think you're
- 33:40correct that what not is fuelled in part by some of that same
- 33:44behavior. Yeah.
- 33:46Yeah. Is that a thesis you've embraced
- 33:48so? I think there are a lot of, if
- 33:51you're setting out to build a company, there's lots of
- 33:53companies you could set up to build.
- 33:55If you're setting out to invest in a company, there's a giant
- 33:57menu of companies you can invest in.
- 33:59And I think one of the criteria that I apply that not everybody
- 34:02does is I want to be proud of my association with the company.
- 34:06And and so I'll give you like a classic example of a company
- 34:09that I admire the financial metrics on, but would never
- 34:13invest in because I just didn't want to be associated.
- 34:16And that was a company called Jewel.
- 34:18You may remember that, you know, they made they made vaping pens
- 34:20by the way people invest in it really made phenomenal returns.
- 34:24It it wasn't for me. And I think that when we look
- 34:29back on some of these prediction markets or gambling sites, there
- 34:33are a bunch of parallels that make me somewhat uncomfortable.
- 34:36That's not to say they aren't great businesses, and that's not
- 34:37to say someone else may not be a genius for investing in them,
- 34:41but but they're not for me. And, and, and by the way, I
- 34:43happen to have three teenage kids, two boys and one girl.
- 34:47And I can see among particularly my sons and their friends, it,
- 34:53it sort of reminds me of Jewel. It's like Jewel is purportedly
- 34:57an aunt a, a smoking cessation device for adults, but he
- 35:00actually looked at who was actually using Jewel with all
- 35:02its various flavors. It was like teenage kids.
- 35:04They're essentially introducing teenage kids to a new form of
- 35:07smoking, which was not good for those kids.
- 35:10And I think in many respects these new prediction markets
- 35:14which are allowing betting on anything all the time, I suspect
- 35:19one of their big customer bases are teenage kids who are
- 35:23particularly susceptible to the interesting characteristics
- 35:26about the. Children angle.
- 35:28Yeah, they're not like gating it.
- 35:30They, so they, I think very recently they've introduced some
- 35:33KYC things, but which require you to prove that you're of a
- 35:37certain age. But you know, if you ask any
- 35:40teenager about, you know, some restriction that was imposed on
- 35:43them by someone or something, I can pretty pretty much guarantee
- 35:46they have like three ways around it.
- 35:49And so I'm not sure how effective the KYC stuff is.
- 35:51I I, I confess to my ignorance. I haven't looked into it
- 35:53carefully, but even if it's a modest percentage of their
- 35:56business, it's just not something I would necessarily
- 35:58want to be associated with. So you're staying away from like
- 36:01the whole theme? I mean, I'm watching it and and
- 36:03by the way, maybe they find a way to eliminate that stuff
- 36:06entirely. And, you know, like if there
- 36:08were a jewel. You agree prediction markets,
- 36:11which I agree in sort of quotes, which are becoming sort of
- 36:15sports gambling sites are one of the major sort of consumer
- 36:19themes of the. Year oh it it's they've grown
- 36:21enormously yes no question about it I mean they they I mean I
- 36:24think what what held gambling back was all the regulation and
- 36:29a couple of really sharp entrepreneurs found a loophole
- 36:32around the regulation where they can make it available to
- 36:34everybody instantly without having to go through any of the
- 36:36regulatory processes or reviews and like lo and behold it's huge
- 36:39so yeah not surprising do. You think gambling was always in
- 36:42the crosshairs? I guess they did a good job of
- 36:44making it seem like, you know, elections and everything before
- 36:47it became about gambling. It I mean, sorry, I mean sports,
- 36:53sports in particular, yeah. I mean, look, the difference, of
- 36:56course, as I understand it is that there's they they don't
- 36:59take a side of the bet. It's it's you know, they're just
- 37:01matching better. So it's it's a marketplace and
- 37:03that you're going to. See the utility of like
- 37:06predictions in a way that predictions of sports don't?
- 37:10It doesn't feel. Like there's any utility like.
- 37:12What repricing the Vegas line, you know?
- 37:15Yeah, I, I, I'm, I, I suppose in in certain instances,
- 37:19understanding what the world thinks on average about
- 37:22something is useful, but to whom?
- 37:25Other than a speculator, maybe not so clear.
- 37:30Any any other categories or theses that you guys are really
- 37:33chasing at the moment within consumer specifically or no
- 37:38consumer or more? Broadly.
- 37:41So the other one that I'm really excited about is robotics.
- 37:45And so we, as I've talked about with you and others in the past,
- 37:51like we tend to be very road map oriented where we try to build a
- 37:53hypothesis and test the hypothesis through experts about
- 37:57some change happening in the world.
- 37:59And often times the most compelling ones are the simplest
- 38:01ones. And so, you know, by way of
- 38:04example, 20 years ago, as we saw the consumer Internet emerging,
- 38:08we thought like, oh, consumers are going to contribute content
- 38:11to media properties online, where the media properties have
- 38:14the benefit of being media companies without having to
- 38:16actually spend money on content. And that led to investments like
- 38:18Yelp and LinkedIn and Pinterest. And it was like a really basic
- 38:21idea. And once you have the basic
- 38:24idea, often an insight shared with an entrepreneur, you try to
- 38:26go find all the companies that are not competing with each
- 38:28other that are consistent with this idea.
- 38:30A really simple minded, like one sentence view on robotics is
- 38:34that there will be probably 10,000 times, maybe even 100,000
- 38:39times more robots on planet Earth 5 to 10 years from now
- 38:42than there are today. And, and there are essentially 3
- 38:46big challenges in robotics. 1 is can you make hardware that
- 38:50functions as a robot. 2 is can you make the hardware move.
- 38:55They call that the locomotion problem.
- 38:57And three is can you make the hardware manipulate things in
- 39:00the real world and the hardware itself essentially works.
- 39:04There's tons of hardware. A lot of it is being made in
- 39:07China. Increasingly companies are
- 39:08trying to make it in the US. So that was problem one.
- 39:11Problem 2 is the locomotion problem.
- 39:13And now as evidenced by by Waymo, another recent Bessemer
- 39:16investment, like we can make hardware move without issue.
- 39:21It's it's solved. And you see it in robot dogs,
- 39:24you see it in autonomous cars in all categories.
- 39:28And that was a machine learning problem, which is essentially
- 39:30solved. It isn't perfect, but it's it's
- 39:32close enough that it's usable. And the unsolved problem for
- 39:36robotics is around manipulation. So we have these things in the
- 39:39real world, but we need them to interact with objects to perform
- 39:44functions that in today's world, many humans do.
- 39:48But they're pretty crappy functions.
- 39:50Fold laundry. Yeah.
- 39:51I mean that's the consumer one. But there there's an enormous
- 39:54number of, I mean there are many companies working on it and and
- 39:57they have very various approaches to it.
- 40:00And I'm quite convinced that the the ironically, the LLMS of
- 40:05today have solved a bunch of what I think of as white collar
- 40:09type jobs before they've solved the blue collar type jobs.
- 40:13And in fact, an MIT professor I met with said to me the the hard
- 40:17things are actually relatively easy in AI.
- 40:19Like AI can do PhD level statistics hell of a better than
- 40:23I can. Yeah, the easy things like
- 40:26picking up this glass, moving it here and moving it back without
- 40:28spilling the water, which is so easy for any human to do, is
- 40:31actually hard to do with AII believe it will be solved.
- 40:35And I, I I can't tell you exactly when and I can't tell
- 40:37you exactly what the path is and so.
- 40:39That is the basic thing. You know, I have a four month
- 40:41old right now and obviously babies spend so much time
- 40:44figuring out like, how do I hold on to something that I think
- 40:47experiencing the human brain form, you're like, Oh yeah,
- 40:50obviously it's it's a lot of work navigating the physical
- 40:53world. The Are you bullish on humanoid
- 40:56robotics? I think eventually.
- 41:00We wrote a little barricade, just you don't have to agree
- 41:03with it, but we were somewhat skeptical and newcomer about the
- 41:06humanoid form factor. So I think it's it's fun for
- 41:09humans because it reminds us of ourselves.
- 41:12I think the the the autonomy of robotic form factors will be
- 41:16wildly varied, and there may be certain instances where the
- 41:19humanoid form factor is particularly powerful.
- 41:21I think it will come later because there are a bunch of
- 41:24challenges with humanoids that don't exist and other form
- 41:25factors of robots, but that it's not going to get in the way of
- 41:29these robots being wildly helpful or productive for, for
- 41:32humankind. And so anyway, so, so then the
- 41:34question is like, how do you invest in it?
- 41:36And, and we, we've started, we made an investment in a company
- 41:39called Foxglove. And if you believe there will be
- 41:42100,000 times more robots, then we're going to need the same
- 41:45kind of infrastructure tooling for robots that we have for
- 41:48computer servers. And there's companies like
- 41:51Datadog that make some of the infrastructure tooling for
- 41:55computer servers, and we're going to want that same kind of
- 41:58capability for robots. And that's essentially what
- 42:00Foxglove does. Makes it very easy to.
- 42:02And so then you avoid the particulars of which robot
- 42:05format. Exactly, It doesn't matter which
- 42:07robot companies or, or how they work, but if if they have the
- 42:10leading solution for the underlying infrastructure so
- 42:12that the robotic makers don't have to go build this
- 42:16infrastructure software, they can just take it off the shelf.
- 42:19Boxcliff should be a winner. So that's exactly right.
- 42:21So that's one area of investing. And then the second one is, OK,
- 42:24how do we figure out how to solve this manipulation problem?
- 42:27Once manipulation is solved, these robots become wildly more
- 42:30valuable to all of us. And so those are generally even
- 42:34earlier stage investing often times in academicians or
- 42:39inventors who are trying to solve this, this unsolved
- 42:41problem and a bunch of companies who've raised billions of
- 42:44dollars. My general view is it is nice to
- 42:47have raised lots and lots of money so you can, you know, pay
- 42:50people in Mexico to, you know, mimic the behavior of a robot
- 42:54and record it and collect all this data.
- 42:56I suspect the winner will be much more innovative than these
- 43:01companies using brute force to collect data.
- 43:04But it's early. And obviously, I don't know for
- 43:07sure, but we're trying to find really smart innovators in this
- 43:09category. I want to talk about venture
- 43:12capital as an asset class for a second.
- 43:14Bessemer, you Bessemer as a firm has been investing for more than
- 43:18a century, right? Is that?
- 43:20Yes, we came out of a family office which which has been,
- 43:24it's now I think since 1911, so 115 years.
- 43:27I don't know, I think Andreessen Horowitz just published a piece
- 43:30like defending sort of the mega firm or scale and venture
- 43:33capital. What?
- 43:35Yeah. What is your sense of sort of, I
- 43:37don't know, the the rise of like the mega fund and how venture
- 43:40capital is being practiced today?
- 43:43Do you think there is just sort of, you know, you're a huge,
- 43:45you're a big multi stage fund yourself.
- 43:47Like how do you think about scale and venture capital?
- 43:50I think scale is critical in venture capital.
- 43:54Does that mean it's required to have a successful fund?
- 43:57No. Do I think it's required to have
- 43:59a successful firm and a collection of funds?
- 44:02Yes. A bunch of things have changed
- 44:05even since I've been doing it. So I've been doing venture
- 44:07capital for 25 years and 25 years ago, if you were an
- 44:11entrepreneur, you found out about venture capital and
- 44:14venture capital firms through word of mouth and some friends.
- 44:17And it was a little bit of an old boys network and it was
- 44:20literally boys at the time. We've gotten wildly more
- 44:24diverse, thankfully, although it's still the predominantly an
- 44:29old boys network. And and therefore having scale
- 44:33and, and building brand and marketing awareness and and
- 44:36content like none of that mattered back then because it
- 44:39was it. Was Now you're forced to come
- 44:40slum it on my podcast I. Mean so, so now there's the
- 44:45Internet and, and, and people discover and learn in so many
- 44:49ways. And, and if your, if your firm
- 44:52or your brand is only in the conversation 1% of the time and
- 44:57someone else's is in the conversation 10% of the time,
- 44:59that's an advantage. And, and so I think there's this
- 45:03counter narrative, which I think is wrong.
- 45:06And that is if you want to have a 10X fund, it has to be a small
- 45:10fund because it's virtually impossible to have a 10X fund on
- 45:12a $3 billion fund. But if it's a $200 million fund,
- 45:15you could actually end up with a 10X fund.
- 45:18I think that's right, except what it misses is all the $200
- 45:22million funds that are going to be a, you know, a .1 X fund.
- 45:26And that if you have somehow the luck or oppressions to invest in
- 45:30the $200 million fund, that does become a 10X fund.
- 45:33Good on you. But that's maybe as much luck as
- 45:36it is skill. Whereas if you want repeated
- 45:39sources of competitive advantage, you need scale and
- 45:42you need to be in the conversation all the time.
- 45:45And it's impossible to do that as a boutique firm with four or
- 45:48five people who who do all the work themselves.
- 45:52Or you're leaving money on the table, right?
- 45:54I mean, there's like I sort of recently gave Benchmark a hard
- 45:57time in a story, which is they sort of have the brand and
- 45:59they're, they're leaving it some of on the table by not investing
- 46:03these later stage rounds. Like you, there are a couple
- 46:05firms, you know, USV or whatever that have built brands that if,
- 46:09if it's if the reason you need scale is because you need to
- 46:13stand out in people's minds. There are firms that built
- 46:16brands that are smaller. They they, there are, but I
- 46:19would argue that the brands of the small boutique firms
- 46:23relative to the rest of the industry 20 years ago were much
- 46:25bigger and they're increasingly smaller, getting crowded out by
- 46:28by by larger firms. But that's just one reason why
- 46:31scale matters. The second reason why scale
- 46:33matters is because time frames to evaluate opportunities have
- 46:37shrunk substantially. 25 years ago, I might meet a company and
- 46:40we might get to know each other over months before they were
- 46:45ready to raise money or we were ready to invest in the company.
- 46:49Increasingly, that number of months is shrinking to days.
- 46:53And if you want to make good decisions, you have to arm
- 46:56yourself with meaningful data. And even for an early stage
- 46:59company that has 16 early trial customers, like that's the whole
- 47:05business. You want to talk to 10 of the 16
- 47:10to really know what's going on. And if you're in a small firm
- 47:14with limited resources, it's kind of impossible to do that in
- 47:18three days time. Whereas a a larger firm with
- 47:22more resources is going to have talked to every customer and ten
- 47:25others to understand like, is this an easy thing to sell and
- 47:28what a prospects think? And that's just an incredible
- 47:32information edge. And, and I've seen it recently
- 47:35and I don't want to name names, but there was one instance where
- 47:38we were looking at it was a classic Series A investment and
- 47:41I was working on it with several colleagues.
- 47:43And so we actually called every company that had its logo on the
- 47:48this prospect website and we found out that not a single one
- 47:52liked the product. And these were the logos of on
- 47:55the company's website. And another really well known
- 47:59respected firm at a, at a smaller scale than us end up
- 48:03investing in the company. Because I think it was
- 48:06impossible that they had to sort of go on more faith and to kind
- 48:09of make a judgement, a snap judgement.
- 48:11Like is this entrepreneur talented, truthful and so forth.
- 48:16And I think they made the wrong call.
- 48:18I think if they had the same data that we had, they would
- 48:20have made a different decision. And so I think there are other,
- 48:23it's not just brand and being in the conversation that's that
- 48:28scale gets you, it also gets you information.
- 48:31Does honesty still matter or I feel like there's a nihilism.
- 48:33I mean you, I mean, we're it came up sort of in the
- 48:37prediction market piece, but you know, you only recommend in my
- 48:41last podcast was sort of or in a recent podcast described venture
- 48:46capitalist as sort of amoral financiers.
- 48:48Like, I mean, I guess you could be amoral and still think sort
- 48:52of honesty matters, but how how much in this sort of world
- 48:55where, I don't know, people are playing pretty fast and loose.
- 48:58Do you think it matters to back honest founders?
- 49:01Hi. I mean, look, do you want to be
- 49:04friends with honest people? Do you want to be married to an
- 49:06honest person? Like that's a value judgement.
- 49:08I mean, I do, but like, you can have your own values there.
- 49:12That said, I think more people than not resonate with people
- 49:17who do what they say, say what they do, are honest.
- 49:19And so I think is it impossible to build a company as like a
- 49:22pathological liar? It's not impossible, but I think
- 49:25it's probably harder because it's harder to have loyalty and
- 49:29have people bought into the mission and so forth.
- 49:31But like I will say it can you, there's also this, this age-old
- 49:36Eddy in Silicon Valley of faking it till you make it.
- 49:38And so could you, could you fake it and have 15 fake ish
- 49:41customers raise a bunch of money and then with that money turn
- 49:44things around? It is possible.
- 49:46It has been done, but it's not the kind of gamble that I want
- 49:50to take. And so it may well work out for
- 49:53this company that we didn't invest in that now that they've
- 49:56raised money from a a really well known investor, they're
- 49:59going to use that to reform their ways and become a great
- 50:01company. But I'd bet against it.
- 50:04You know, one advantage you're saying you get with venture
- 50:07capital scales you have, you know, all these people running
- 50:09around and doing all this diligence, do do you still need
- 50:12all the people or how much are you relying on analysts today
- 50:15versus using? AII just published some research
- 50:20that Venture 5 had done, and they saw that analysts and
- 50:24venture capital firms saw their salary fall.
- 50:26Like, do you, do you think you're hiring fewer of them
- 50:28because of what AI can do? In the short term, no, but
- 50:34advantage three of a venture capital firm of scale is that we
- 50:37have the resources to invest substantially in AI tooling and
- 50:42AI tooling is both a source of data.
- 50:45As a, as a, as a silly example, imagine if you knew any time
- 50:50someone of a certain seniority level left Google and, and
- 50:54changed their LinkedIn profile to be, you know, stealth
- 50:56founder. That's really valuable
- 50:58information for a venture capital firm to have.
- 51:01We have tooling that tells us that for every single person.
- 51:04If you're a little boutique venture firm with no resources
- 51:08to spend on tech and innovation yourself, you're not going to
- 51:11have that information. You're depending on your network
- 51:15to get you close to those people at exactly the right time.
- 51:18That worked really well when that's what everybody was doing.
- 51:21But now when there's a group of of competitors who have access
- 51:24to this incredibly rich information generated by their
- 51:27own AI tools, you're at a disadvantage because they also
- 51:30have the same personal networks, but they have tooling on top.
- 51:33And so to date, we've used our tooling to make all of us more
- 51:37productive. And I would say we're in inning
- 51:40one or two in a nine inning baseball game that probably even
- 51:43goes into overtime. So it's still early, but I have
- 51:48a hard time imagining in the short term, the people in
- 51:51venture capital mattering less because fundamentally, companies
- 51:55are still run and founded by humans, and humans don't really
- 51:59want to interact with or build a partnership with an AI bot.
- 52:02They want another human. And so having people who are
- 52:06smart, ambitious, hard working and compelling as humans within
- 52:10our firm is really important because those are the people who
- 52:12have to build relationships with today's founders and the
- 52:16founders of the future. Because fundamentally what we do
- 52:18is we become, we become partners.
- 52:20Like it's why it's why it's in our name, Bessemer Venture
- 52:22Partners, not Bessemer Capital. Because we're looking to partner
- 52:26with these people in a very human partnership to help them
- 52:29through the UPS and the downs, solve problems along the way, be
- 52:33the shoulder to cry on, be the person to bring them back down a
- 52:36little bit when they're celebrating a little bit too
- 52:38much. And those are all very human
- 52:40things. If the venture capital industry
- 52:43is, you know, inevitably booms and busts over hype and under
- 52:48under hype sometimes, where do you think we are in sort of, I
- 52:52don't know the, the, I think we're still rooted in the.com
- 52:55story, but like, where do you think we are today in that sort
- 52:58of hype journey? I think we are, well, I mean it
- 53:02is cyclical and it the growth of AI and the emergence of these
- 53:08companies growing at faster rates and reaching bigger scale
- 53:11than anything we've ever seen before echoes to me the early
- 53:15days of the, the Internet, the consumer Internet.
- 53:18But the scale and speed is an order of magnitude or more
- 53:22bigger and faster. And so I think we are on our way
- 53:26up a a well justified hype curve now, much like in the early days
- 53:32of the Internet, there were hundreds if not thousands of
- 53:35Internet companies that failed. They had the wrong model, they
- 53:38had the wrong ideas, they were focused on the wrong things, but
- 53:41got funded in what was objectively a gold rush of
- 53:45sorts. We will see the same thing
- 53:47happening here, but I think much like some phenomenal companies
- 53:51emerged from the advent of the Internet like Google and Meta
- 53:57and many others, we will see massive companies emerge from
- 54:00this and I think they will be even bigger than the ones that
- 54:02we saw in the Internet. And so I think it's a great time
- 54:06to be investing. It's an amazing time to be
- 54:08alive. And I'm so curious what some of
- 54:09these things will actually evolve into.
- 54:13But but nonetheless, venture remains the same, which is that
- 54:17it's a long game. And when we make an early stage
- 54:19investment today in on an idea like there'll be 100,000 times
- 54:23more robots in the future than there are now, that may not
- 54:26fully come to fruition for 7-8 or nine years.
- 54:29And if as an investor in venture capital, you're looking for
- 54:32returns every quarter or every year, you're in the wrong asset
- 54:35class. This is a, this is a patient
- 54:36person's game, even with these incredible momentum ideas like
- 54:42AI emerging. And so there'll be some
- 54:44instances where things just work immediately and it goes up to
- 54:47the right and you can actually see and taste the value right
- 54:49away. Most of the time it's a slow
- 54:52burn process until suddenly something appears to be really
- 54:55large when in fact it was growing a little bit along the
- 54:57way and just no one was paying attention to it.
- 55:00Jeremy, thank you for coming on the Newcomer Podcast.
- 55:03My pleasure. Thanks for having me.
- 55:05Thanks so much for listening to the Newcomer Podcast.
- 55:08I'm Eric Newcomer. Follow us on Substack at
- 55:10newcomer.co. Hope you enjoyed the episode.
- 55:13See you next week.