Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Deconstructing Faith without Losing Hope
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on this episode of Together for Good, I want to
- 0:05talk about questions and why it's OK to question your faith.
- 0:10There's this movement about deconstructing faith, and I
- 0:12think that's actually a really wonderful thing.
- 0:15So I'm thinking that this episode is all about
- 0:18deconstructing faith without losing hope.
- 0:20Can't wait to share with you. Here we go.
- 0:22Welcome to the Together for Good podcast, a podcast created by
- 0:26Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co and
- 0:29hosted by me, Pastor Nate pricing on Together for Good.
- 0:33Our goal is to provide practical, engaging content that
- 0:37supports you without expectations.
- 0:39Whether you're feeling disconnected from traditional
- 0:42religion or simply exploring what faith means in your life,
- 0:45we are here to walk alongside you.
- 0:47No matter where you are on your journey of faith, we're glad
- 0:51you're here. Welcome to Together for good.
- 0:54So one thing that I've encountered a lot as a pastor is
- 0:57people who have walked away from their faith for a variety of
- 1:02different reasons. They may have grown up going to
- 1:05church, but then they started asking questions.
- 1:08They took a college religion course or they heard something
- 1:11from a friend who wasn't religious.
- 1:13And these little points along the way that caused them to
- 1:16question then had this effect of completely taking their faith
- 1:21out from under them. All of a sudden, one there's one
- 1:24crack in the pavement, it feels like the whole thing splinters
- 1:28and falls apart. I understand how that can
- 1:31happen, and I'm not here to judge anyone who may have found
- 1:34himself in this situation. But more than anything, what I
- 1:37want to help us understand is that asking questions,
- 1:41deconstructing our faith, right? Thinking about it from a
- 1:45critical lens really is an essential and important part of
- 1:51being a Christian. Questions are not something that
- 1:54need to be pushed aside or ignored.
- 1:57They're something that needs to be embraced and continually
- 2:00engaged if we are going to be a community of faithful people.
- 2:07Let's just start with the logical, shall we?
- 2:09If we are going to believe in an Almighty God, that in and of
- 2:16itself suggests that there are going to be parts of this God
- 2:20that we can never fully understand.
- 2:22Just think about just from the most logical part of your brain,
- 2:27you can never fully know God, otherwise you would be God you.
- 2:33You can never completely wrap your mind around everything that
- 2:37God is doing and everything that God has said.
- 2:40That is an impossibility for finite human beings like you and
- 2:45me. And it seems like churches often
- 2:47forget that baseline component, the the very first commandment.
- 2:51You shall have no other gods before me.
- 2:53It establishes God as supreme and ultimate and almighty, like
- 2:59I said. And we then though, we remember
- 3:03that commandment and and we use it to bash people over the head
- 3:06and to point out all the ways that they're being idolatrous.
- 3:09But in the same sense, never stop to consider our own
- 3:12idolatry when we are the types of people who claim to know
- 3:17everything that God is up to in the world.
- 3:21I think it's helpful for the church to try to at times be in
- 3:25authority on different subjects. People do look to pastors and
- 3:30priests and the church for direction and insight about how
- 3:34to live their life. It's an incredible
- 3:37responsibility. That's one of the things that
- 3:39still makes me so humbled to be in the position that I'm in,
- 3:45that people would come and ask me for guidance or prayer or
- 3:49life advice or anything like that, that you would listen to
- 3:52this podcast. And and yet one of the places
- 3:57that I always try and start off too is, is recognizing and
- 4:00admitting that I don't have all the answers.
- 4:04And wouldn't we be a lot better off if more pastors and churches
- 4:10admitted from the start that they don't have all the answers?
- 4:15That just creates a much more generous and a much more open
- 4:19and a much more curious type of community.
- 4:25If you have a church that says we have all the answers come to
- 4:28us and we will tell you exactly the way that it all works.
- 4:32That really closes off conversation in a lot of ways
- 4:35like, well, well, just tell me the answer.
- 4:36You know it. It's a very black and white way
- 4:40of understanding the world and how to live.
- 4:43And I don't know if your life's anything like mine.
- 4:45You know full well that life is a series of Gray areas all over
- 4:50the place. And, and it's hard to figure out
- 4:52on a daily basis exactly what you're supposed to do or be or
- 4:56say that day. And I think I need a faith, at
- 5:00least personally, that accounts for the fact that life can be
- 5:04really messy and that sometimes things are much more complicated
- 5:10than just a simple yes or no answer, right.
- 5:14And, and here's a great example. We're not computers.
- 5:18Computers are use the the binary system, right?
- 5:20It's a one or a zero. The switch is on or the switch
- 5:23is off. And and that's what a black and
- 5:26life world would be like. It just us moving along as
- 5:29computers. But human beings are so much
- 5:31more complex than computers. There's so much more to us than
- 5:36just is it right or is it wrong? Yes, in in a lot of things,
- 5:40there are rights and wrongs. I'm not trying to just advocate
- 5:44for a complete relativist state. What I am saying is that humans
- 5:51are composed of so many complicating factors.
- 5:56There is the family that you were raised in and how your
- 6:00childhood effects who you are today.
- 6:03And there are the books that you've read and the classes that
- 6:07you've taken and the friends that you have.
- 6:09There's also your biology, right?
- 6:12Is it nature or is it nurture is the age-old debate.
- 6:14And the answer is yes, it's both.
- 6:17It is not only in your DNA, but it's also how you've been raised
- 6:22and who you've spent the majority of your time with.
- 6:24It's the traumatic experiences that you've had and how you've
- 6:28decided to process them. All of this complicated soup
- 6:32adds up to the person that you are.
- 6:34And so you need a faith. Or I need a faith at least, that
- 6:37accounts for the fact that human beings are incredibly complex.
- 6:42And in the same moment of faith that accounts for the fact that
- 6:46God is so much bigger than I can understand.
- 6:51I hope you're seeing how these two factors lead to a faith that
- 6:56embraces questioning. If God is always bigger than I
- 7:00can understand and my life is always much more complicated
- 7:03than a simple answer, well then yes, of course a life of faith
- 7:07is going to include asking lots of questions and wondering.
- 7:13And as I said earlier, being curious about this life that
- 7:18we've been given, being curious about this God who created
- 7:23everything. But it goes so much further than
- 7:27that as well. If the church were to be a place
- 7:33where it felt safe to ask questions and to wonder
- 7:36together, think about how much more vibrant that community
- 7:42would be. Because when you have a nagging
- 7:45question in your life you want to talk about it.
- 7:49It's torture to keep that question locked up inside.
- 7:54It's torture to just be muddling it over in your head all the
- 7:56time, thinking that it's too risky to actually voice these
- 8:00concerns or these curiosities. What's so freeing is when you
- 8:05finally find that person who you feel safe to talk to and say
- 8:08like, hey, have you ever struggled with this?
- 8:12Have you ever wondered about that?
- 8:15You see, we need a faith that can create communities that are
- 8:19safe enough to ask our questions.
- 8:23It's not healthy, I don't think, for the church to just always be
- 8:26the place, just the answer machine.
- 8:28And if you have a nagging question like no, stop asking
- 8:31questions. This is the way it's supposed to
- 8:33be. That doesn't createspace for
- 8:36community. It it creates more robots.
- 8:39You know, people who just say this is the answer.
- 8:41This is what I will do. Stop asking questions.
- 8:44You have to have a place and people who can struggle with the
- 8:47nuance of it all, even if the church is to be giving clear
- 8:51answers and directions, which at times I think it should
- 8:54absolutely. But then within that, for people
- 8:57to still feel like it's safe enough to wonder about that
- 9:01because that'll actually make the answers stronger.
- 9:04If you've ever been a part of a group project, you know that
- 9:09they're really frustrating. So we probably should say first
- 9:13that that that they're really frustrating and that it's hard
- 9:16to work together with other people.
- 9:18And in the same sense, I hope you've had the experience at
- 9:21least of working in a group and creating something better than
- 9:25you ever could have created on your own.
- 9:28And so, yeah, what if the church could have better answers?
- 9:33Again, nothing against the church being a type of place
- 9:37that gives people answers and directions for their life.
- 9:39Of course. That's what we do on this
- 9:40podcast all the time. It's what I do in my sermons and
- 9:43in the devotionals that I write. Yes, And those answers get
- 9:48better when I talk about them with other people.
- 9:52Let me give you an example. When I write my sermons, it is a
- 9:56conversation with so many people before I stand up on Sunday
- 10:02morning and deliver my 10 minute homily.
- 10:06It starts with me reading a whole bunch of commentaries.
- 10:10I have this really great set of commentaries that I love, and I
- 10:14always go through the readings in the commentaries first.
- 10:17And so this is me, you know, getting input from scholars,
- 10:21people who have committed their life, their professional career,
- 10:24to studying the nuances of these ancient texts.
- 10:28And then I take that and I try and write my insights in my own
- 10:31words. So there's this first
- 10:33conversation happening between me and the scholars, and then I
- 10:36bring my notes to a Bible study that we do here at Bethany every
- 10:40week. If you're the preacher, you lead
- 10:42Tuesday morning Bible study. And so I show up on Tuesday
- 10:45morning with my notes with this conversation I've had with the
- 10:48scholars, and I share it with this group of 10 people or so
- 10:52that show up on a Tuesday morning to spend time with me.
- 10:55And we talk together about what this passage might mean.
- 10:59And I share with them the insights.
- 11:01And they had their own insights. So now the conversation has
- 11:03grown to be this collection of 10 people at least conversing
- 11:08with the conversation that I originally had with the
- 11:10scholars. And then I take all of that and
- 11:13I think about stories from my life and experiences that I've
- 11:16had and I talk through it maybe with my wife a little bit or
- 11:21with other pastors or colleagues that I have.
- 11:25And I also, obviously, I'm constantly thinking about the
- 11:28stories of the congregation where I serve, where I'll be
- 11:31delivering this sermon. And I think about all of the
- 11:34things going on in the lives of these people that I pray for
- 11:37everyday. And that I think about
- 11:39constantly and try to think about what do, what do they need
- 11:43to hear? What what is God calling me to
- 11:44say and speak into their life right now?
- 11:49All of this goes into then forming this 10 minute speech
- 11:54sermon that Ioffer on a Sunday morning.
- 11:58But notice how this is an evolving and a nuanced and a
- 12:04multi layered conversation. You see, if I was just about the
- 12:09answers, well then I would read the text and I would tell the
- 12:13people this is what it says, now go do it.
- 12:17And I feel like that would be so much less satisfying and
- 12:21ultimately helpful because there I'm not respecting the nuances
- 12:26of everyone's life, again, the complexity of human existence.
- 12:32And there I'm also not respecting the ways that God is
- 12:36always above and beyond our imagination and comprehension.
- 12:40I'm just saying these are black and light words on a page.
- 12:44This is what it will mean for you today.
- 12:47Amen. That's not how I want to do it,
- 12:49and that's not what I think our world needs.
- 12:51We need a faith that's open to questioning.
- 12:55We need a space where we can feel safe to deconstruct what
- 13:00we've learned to unlearn, and then to learn something new in
- 13:04its place. I'm not saying that we're
- 13:06throwing out all of tradition. I'm not saying that we're
- 13:09getting rid of everything that's ever been said.
- 13:12No, no, no. Notice how it's an ongoing
- 13:14conversation. It's more a spiral if you know
- 13:18anything about spiral dynamics, right?
- 13:20It's something that's continually evolving and
- 13:23changing, and it's being changed by what came beforehand.
- 13:26And I think our faith can be like that, not because God is
- 13:31changing, but because our conception of God is continually
- 13:36changing as we have more experiences.
- 13:40People often hear what I'm saying and they're like, yeah,
- 13:42how can you possibly say that God changes?
- 13:45God is eternal and always in forever.
- 13:47Yes, I fully agree with that and embrace that.
- 13:51Again, though, God is so far beyond our imagination that our
- 13:55understanding needs to change. And just think about it.
- 13:58You, you know that from your own life, what you thought about God
- 14:01as a child growing up, your Sunday school faith is probably
- 14:06vastly different today because of life experiences that you've
- 14:10had, because of study that you've done or sermons that
- 14:14you've heard or books that you've read.
- 14:17The spiral has grown and grown and grown.
- 14:21And So what you might have originally believed about God in
- 14:24Sunday school class, that God is this man with a big white beard
- 14:29sitting in the sky who watches over me.
- 14:32You know what? Most wonderful and comforting,
- 14:34especially for A5 year old who's going into kindergarten for the
- 14:38first time in this scared. What a comforting thought that
- 14:41there's this old man in the sky watching over me while I do this
- 14:46scary thing. But you know what?
- 14:48That needed to evolve. Just as you're thinking in
- 14:51kindergarten needed to evolve to where it is today, your life of
- 14:55faith needed to evolve. And so you, in your own little
- 14:58ways, deconstructed that idea and came to see God as something
- 15:03so much bigger than just a person because you realize that
- 15:07people are are are fallible and flawed.
- 15:10Even your grandfather, who looked a lot like God in your
- 15:13mind when you were in kindergarten, you learned as you
- 15:15grew older that he was a flawed person.
- 15:18And somehow it made you love him more because you realize that
- 15:21you don't need to be perfect because he wasn't perfect.
- 15:24But then that meant also that your understanding of God needed
- 15:27to evolve. And you start to come to see
- 15:29that God is a force. God is what makes the flowers
- 15:34grow and the trees bud and the clouds rain.
- 15:40God is this force that underlies the entire ground of all
- 15:44existence. And so everything you do is
- 15:48touched by the very presence of God, even when you don't realize
- 15:52it. Just notice in that little
- 15:55anecdote how the ideas evolved. Faith gets deconstructed, but
- 16:02then it gets rebuilt into something more generous, more
- 16:05beautiful, more helpful for what you're going through as a mature
- 16:11adult. Because that's what you need now
- 16:13is you need God to be with you in the scary and difficult
- 16:16things that you face today. And a kindergarten understanding
- 16:21won't suffice, but God is always trying to find a way to break in
- 16:27and to connect with you. And what I need us to hear is
- 16:31that one of the ways that God can break in is through our
- 16:34questioning, by deconstructing our faith.
- 16:38So long as we deconstruct also, then hopefully with allowing the
- 16:42Holy Spirit to build something new in that place.
- 16:45Your faith doesn't have to be stagnant.
- 16:48It shouldn't be stagnant. Your faith can handle the
- 16:51questions because the questions hopefully can lead you to a
- 16:54community where it's OK to be vulnerable and to admit your
- 16:57faults and your struggles and your doubts.
- 17:00But through the conversation, you can learn from someone
- 17:02else's experience. You can learn through someone
- 17:05else's insight how God still fits into your life, just
- 17:10differently than God used to fit before.
- 17:15This, I think, is a much more beautiful and a much more
- 17:19generous and a much more realistic understanding of what
- 17:23it means to be a person of faith.
- 17:26And so the question can I have faith even if I have questions?
- 17:34Can I be a Christian even if I have doubts?
- 17:38Yes. In fact, I think questions and
- 17:41doubts are necessary to be a person of faith.
- 17:46You see, faith and doubt are opposing forces.
- 17:51They are two sides of the same coin.
- 17:54When we say that we have faith, inherent in that word is a
- 18:00confession of doubt because we don't say that we have
- 18:05certainty. Certainty is the opposite of
- 18:08doubt. If you're certain of something,
- 18:11then you don't have doubts. But if you have faith, then
- 18:15that's saying that you're trusting in some way that there
- 18:20might be a part of you that doesn't quite understand what's
- 18:24going on here, and yet you're choosing to trust anyway.
- 18:28That's what we need. That's what faith is all about.
- 18:32Faith and doubt, questions and wonderings.
- 18:35They build community. They respect the nuance of human
- 18:39existence and most importantly, they respect the bigness and the
- 18:43grandness and the boldness of this God who has animated life
- 18:48and who has encouraged the curiosity of human beings for
- 18:53thousands of thousands of years. I hope that this is helpful,
- 18:58especially if you have been wondering if your questions have
- 19:01a place in the church. They absolutely do.
- 19:04They absolutely have a part of your life of faith.
- 19:07Please, if you've got questions or further wonderings, I'd love
- 19:10to hear from you to be a part of a conversation partner with you
- 19:14as we struggle through these things.
- 19:15Those are some of my favorite emails to get.
- 19:17Feel free to reach out to me, but thank you for listening.
- 19:20Please share this with a family member or a friend, someone who
- 19:22might be struggling with their doubts and questions, to help
- 19:24them know that it's OK that they're doing a good job if
- 19:28they're asking the questions. And as always, stay in peace,
- 19:31everyone. Thank you for listening to the
- 19:33Together for Good podcast. If you'd like more resources for
- 19:36your walk of faith, please visit our website bethany-denver.org
- 19:41or download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect in
- 19:45your phone's App Store.