Latest / Before you say yes / EP 8. BONUS: This episode is different. Let's talk about financial abuse.
Transcript
- 0:00This episode is different.
- 0:0230 years ago, I met a woman named Anne O'Neill, and she had suffered what most of us can't even imagine.
- 0:11Her ex-husband committed an unthinkable crime.
- 0:15I was a young journalist and the first one to ever interview her.
- 0:19And I said to her, what did you do?
- 0:21And she looked at me and with incredible grace, she said, Catherine, it wasn't what I did.
- 0:29And that conversation affected me profoundly.
- 0:33It was the start of lifelong learning about domestic abuse.
- 0:38I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick, and for more than a decade, I've led change inside big banks.
- 0:44And now I work with business industry, governments, and regulators to expose how domestic and financial abusers exploit the products we use every day and how to close the loopholes.
- 0:58Anne is why this podcast exists.
- 1:03Not everyone is familiar with the term financial abuse, so I want to start there.
- 1:08Financial abuse is a form of domestic abuse.
- 1:12It's where money is used to control, manipulate, track and trap someone you love or once did.
- 1:20Well, I think it shows up in many guises, but I think it's
- 1:27If we got down to the fundamental of any abuse, it's changing your behavior or your interaction with money because you're frightened or you don't have access to it.
- 1:43Do you know what I mean?
- 1:45So abuse is typified by the presence of fear and then somebody changes their behavior.
- 1:51So in a financial context, you might stop asking about
- 1:56what money have we got, where's this going, what's happening?
- 1:59Because every time you ask, you know, it ends up in a big argument or, you know,
- 2:06You get called names or put down, you're stupid, you don't understand, I'm not going to tell you.
- 2:12It could be taking money out and spending it on what the other person wants, that privilege and entitlement that I can do what I want and you're not going to have a say.
- 2:20In my experience, I was actually responsible for managing the finances, but I went into a relationship very early.
- 2:29And I didn't know there was such a thing as a bank statement.
- 2:32So I'd sit and balance all the books and know how much was coming in.
- 2:35And then it was so long ago there were checks.
- 2:38And really, as much as money, the be it and end it of everything, for many, many people –
- 2:52when you have access to enough of it.
- 2:55You know, you don't need to have a mammoth amount of it, but enough for your basic life.
- 3:01And many, many people who experience domestic and family violence are trapped in those relationships because they don't have a financial pathway out.
- 3:12If any of this sounds familiar, the next part is for you.
- 3:15The first thing you need to know is you don't have to tell your whole story to get help.
- 3:22You don't need to use the words domestic abuse or financial abuse.
- 3:28You don't have to explain everything to a stranger on a phone line.
- 3:32Moo Bolch has spent decades in this work.
- 3:35You know, she may be calling her bank and saying, I'd like to set up a safe account.
- 3:40I think my credit cards have been compromised.
- 3:43There may be a range of different things that relate to those actual products that she's disclosing without saying, I'm thinking about getting out of this relationship.
- 3:51What can you do for me?
- 3:54Similarly, with phone companies, it could be, I need to change my number, but I want to be able to continue doing this and this and this, or I need to be able to change my address.
- 4:08What would that look like?
- 4:09So it might be that you're getting those contemplative questions.
- 4:14With utilities companies and with organisations where you might have a membership and a joint membership, it might be making those inquiries about what would it look like, what would the consequences be, will my partner know if...
- 4:31I need to change my details on this particular, you know, for this particular product or service.
- 4:37So just having the confidence to ask that extra question often will bypass the need for her to disclose lots and lots.
- 4:45So who can actually sit beside you and help you work it out?
- 4:50Rebecca Glenn founded the Centre for Women's Economic Safety.
- 4:53Our biggest initiative is our money clinics, which provides direct one-to-one support, free, confidential, independent support for women who are concerned about their finances in the context of domestic violence.
- 5:05We also publish the financial safety website, which is a great resource for people who are looking to secure their finances, thinking about their next steps, concerned about all the things that they're doing.
- 5:15what is happening in their relationship when it comes to the money and finances.
- 5:19What is interesting, and I'm really encouraged by this, is we are seeing women who come to us thinking about leaving an abusive partner.
- 5:30And I think that's important because we know that point of separation is not only physically dangerous, it is the point at which so much can go horribly wrong really quickly with the finances.
- 5:44And so seeing women taking those proactive steps to say,
- 5:49I no longer believe he has my best interests at heart.
- 5:53This relationship is over.
- 5:55And what can I do to protect myself?
- 5:58But the number one thing is to have a way to communicate with service providers, product providers, that is not going to be intercepted or monitored by the person doing you harm.
- 6:11And so setting up an email address that they're not aware of, that's not connected to the cloud, that's completely separate from the life that you've otherwise built together is the starting point.
- 6:22Of course, that has to be done on a device that that person can't access, that you don't usually use and so on.
- 6:29Once you've got those kind of those building blocks in place, you wanna be sure that you have, if you don't already have,
- 6:36a bank account that's in your name only, that sits separate from all of the joint products and so on.
- 6:43Sue Fraser has spent a career helping people disentangle.
- 6:46And if all of this feels like too much to face in one go, Sue says you don't have to know the first step.
- 6:54You just have to know how you want it to end.
- 6:57I mean, people don't actually know often what they need to do first, but they'll know how they want it to end.
- 7:03So that if they can identify they want safe, affordable housing in an environment where they're not known, where they can start a career or change a career, where their kids can have safety and security in a new school environment, if they know how they want that to occur...
- 7:21or what the end game should be.
- 7:23You can work backwards with them about what steps they need to take are.
- 7:27If what we're talking about sounds familiar and you're starting to recognise yourself, not as the person who's being harmed, but as the one who controls the money and the decisions, you'll be interested in what Dave Kramer has to say.
- 7:43Yeah, my name is Dave Kramer.
- 7:44I'm a facilitator of conversations around respect and respectful relationships in school, in high school.
- 7:50And I also am an advocate for safer men within society.
- 7:54And I do that because I believe that all men and all boys can play a role in contributing to a safer culture for all people.
- 8:00I asked Dave whether there's a difference between people who set out to control and people who are simply buckling under that pressure and reaching for control as a way to cope.
- 8:11I think you raised a really good point that there's certainly people out there with real intentions behind their behaviours in terms of coercively controlling, financially controlling someone and the financial control might be another contribution to the way they control this other person, not necessarily the whole thing, sometimes it is, but
- 8:28There are also people I would acknowledge in our society who struggle with the pressure to make money and the pressure to provide and therefore then choose.
- 8:39And this is not one causing the other, but they do choose to also then control the other person, the way they spend and even the money they earn.
- 8:49So it's really hard to hold that conversation in two things, right?
- 8:52Because two things are happening.
- 8:53I think it's a really tricky one to navigate.
- 8:56And not many people understand what financial abuse is, even if they're in it.
- 9:01But when you said choice, it's always a choice about the way you behave, even if it doesn't feel like it's a choice.
- 9:07When I started doing this work over a decade ago and I met Rosie Batty and over many years, we've had a really great conversation and she's taught me so much.
- 9:19But I still remember her saying, you know, when she was able to manage her own money, she might have made some choices that were probably not great choices with the way she spent her money.
- 9:32Mm-hmm.
- 9:33but they were hers to make.
- 9:35And that's always really stuck with me that you don't have to control somebody else through their access to money.
- 9:43To me, it's about talking about what does safe feel like in a relationship?
- 9:46Does it feel like I get no autonomy over my own decisions?
- 9:49Does it feel like that no matter how much money I make, if it's less than you, you're in control and in charge of me?
- 9:55Do you want to be in control and in charge of me?
- 9:57Or do you just struggle with some things sometimes and think that control is the only way to deal with whatever that struggle is?
- 10:04And is there another way to deal with that struggle?
- 10:05Right?
- 10:05And there is.
- 10:06There always is.
- 10:07There's communication, there's counseling, there's financial counseling.
- 10:11There's lots of ways we can manage this.
- 10:13So maybe the whole time you've been listening, you've been thinking about someone else, a sister, a friend, colleague you see every day.
- 10:24So how do you step into that?
- 10:26I asked Anne and what she told me is backed by the research, that the single most powerful thing a bystander can do isn't to fix it, it's to walk alongside.
- 10:36Research tells us that the pathways out of abusive situations, the most pivotal action that helped people extract themselves was having somebody to walk with them and,
- 10:52to that first contact point, be it that they picked up the phone and rang together, that they took them to the doctor for the examination, that they went to the police when they reported, that they went to the bank and, you know, froze the account.
- 11:07But it's that person to go with and be beside, not to do it for you and not to take control, but to do with, that really helps.
- 11:19I think...
- 11:21It can be quite confronting because you don't want to isolate people.
- 11:25You don't want them to feel shame or, you know, embarrassed and, you know, you're a bit worried.
- 11:33If you say too much, then, you know, they'll stop seeing you and then they'll be really isolated.
- 11:39But I think in reality it's about going, look –
- 11:43I'm not sure how to say this right, and I might be clumsy, but I've just noticed, you know, you seem a bit concerned.
- 11:55You're not having access to this or, you know, you've not got enough money for the food for the kids.
- 12:05You're scrimping, you're working two jobs, and yet,
- 12:11It appears that going to the footy every week and, you know, I'm being very stereotypical, but, you know, I've noticed that your partner's got all the things they want.
- 12:22And I'm just wondering, you know, how do you feel about that?
- 12:26Angelique Wan teaches young people how to have hard conversations for a living.
- 12:31The thing I would say is do it in private.
- 12:34Don't do it publicly.
- 12:36Obviously, don't do it in front of the partner that might be in question.
- 12:40And go really gently.
- 12:43Again, it's coming in with a sense of empathy and curiosity, and you never want to make someone feel happy.
- 12:51shamed or you never want to make that person feel isolated.
- 12:57And she's clear eyed about why staying connected is everything, because leaving is rarely a single moment.
- 13:05You know, I think the reality in instances of
- 13:09domestic violence, which is a little bit different, but can sometimes be related to economic abuse or financial abuse, is that it can take someone, you know, up to seven tries to leave a partner.
- 13:20And what you really don't want to see in that situation is that individual isolated from their friends and family.
- 13:26And here's the part I most want you to hear, what to do when they're not ready, because they might not be, not today.
- 13:34You ultimately want to see what they're not ready
- 13:36You want that person to feel like they have agency to make their own decisions and that if they don't immediately agree with you or they don't immediately leave their partner, they know that your relationship is still intact and that you're still a trusted person that they can come to and speak to.
- 13:56if they have any issues down the track.
- 13:58Sue Fraser put it even more simply, that sometimes the entire job is to make sure the door stays open.
- 14:06Whether I knew them well or not, I'd say, from what you've said or the way you look, I'm really concerned about you.
- 14:11And I'd wait.
- 14:14And they would then say, yeah, life's shit.
- 14:16Or yes, this has happened.
- 14:18Or none of your business.
- 14:21I'd say, that's okay, I'm just wanting to let you know.
- 14:24Something's telling me something's not right.
- 14:26I don't know what that is and I'm available to you if you'd like to talk about it.
- 14:31So it's not forcing help on people but giving them the opportunity to take it if they want it.
- 14:37And when they're ready, being useful can be very concrete.
- 14:41Anne describes it as helping someone to seek help without taking it over.
- 14:46Like saying, look, I know it's really personal.
- 14:48I'm your friend.
- 14:49I want to stay your friend.
- 14:50I don't want you to have to...
- 14:52Show me all your personal stuff.
- 14:55But I'm really happy to find a financial counsellor for you.
- 14:59We can go.
- 15:00We can talk to the bank.
- 15:01They have people.
- 15:02We can talk to your insurance company, whatever it might be.
- 15:06Let's go and find someone.
- 15:08Just stay in their life.
- 15:10It's the most important thing.
- 15:12You don't have to solve it.
- 15:13You just have to be the person who's there when they're still ready.
- 15:18Most people who share their financial lives do it well.
- 15:21They argue about money sometimes.
- 15:24They muddle through.
- 15:25They figure it out.
- 15:27This episode exists so that if ever that changes for you or for someone you love, someone you care about, you know what to ask, what to say.
- 15:38You don't have to have it all figured out before you reach out.
- 15:42You just have to reach out when you're ready.
- 15:45If you or someone you know needs support, 1-800-RESPECT is available 24 hours a day and in an emergency, call triple zero.
- 15:55This episode started 30 years ago with Anne and a sentence I've never forgotten.
- 16:01It wasn't what she did.
- 16:04And everything you've heard since has circled back to that same truth.
- 16:09That financial abuse is rarely about money.
- 16:12It's about fear and control and the slow narrowing of someone's choices.
- 16:19And that recognising it in your own life or in someone else's is where everything starts to change.
- 16:26Because love shouldn't cost you freedom.