Latest / I’m Too Busy! / Too Dressed Up? The Hidden Bias Behind Dress Codes
Transcript
- 0:00For example, um, in the early 20th
- 0:02century, women could be arrested in some
- 0:05American and European cities for wearing
- 0:07pants. Um, and not tight pants or
- 0:10see-through trousers or anything, but
- 0:12just regular men's clothing was seen as
- 0:15a real provocation. And so, it's just a
- 0:17new dress code, um, in a different form.
- 0:21But, I do think that it has implications
- 0:25for gender equality because that kind of
- 0:29dressed-down aesthetic really works best
- 0:32for men, [music]
- 0:33and women I think struggle with that.
- 0:36So, on the one hand, if they dress up
- 0:37too much, they're going to be ridiculed
- 0:38as vain and superficial. But, if they
- 0:41don't, I don't think they're going to
- 0:42get the same benefit of the doubt that a
- 0:44man does wearing a t-shirt and
- 0:46flip-flops.
- 0:49>> Hello, and welcome to another [snorts]
- 0:50episode of I'm Too Busy TV, where we
- 0:53dive into the lives [music] of aspiring
- 0:54entrepreneurs and industry professionals
- 0:57who are making waves despite [music]
- 0:59their packed schedules. I am your host,
- 1:02Christina Black, and [music] today I am
- 1:03so excited to have a very special guest.
- 1:06Please join me in welcoming Richard
- 1:08Thompson Ford.
- 1:09>> And as it turned out, I did get that
- 1:11offer from Stanford, um, and I've been
- 1:15at Stanford ever since.
- 1:16>> So, your latest book, Dress Codes,
- 1:19explores the intersection of fashion and
- 1:21law. What sparked your interest in this
- 1:23particular subject?
- 1:25>> Uh, well, there two reasons. One's
- 1:26professional and one's personal.
- 1:28Professional reason is that there are a
- 1:31lot of disputes involving clothing and
- 1:35grooming codes and dress codes in
- 1:38American
- 1:40law. Uh, there are workplace dress codes
- 1:42that are challenged by employees as
- 1:45either, um, a form of race
- 1:47discrimination, a form of sex
- 1:48discrimination, um,
- 1:50a type of religious intolerance. Um,
- 1:53there dress codes in high school that
- 1:55are challenged by students as a
- 1:57restriction on their rights to free
- 2:00speech or is just plain up tight. Uh
- 2:03there's widely dis-
- 2:06wide disparities in enforcement in high
- 2:09school dress codes. Uh most of it's
- 2:11directed at girls and that raises um
- 2:14equality issues. And one of the things I
- 2:17found in reading the legal literature
- 2:20and the case law was that oh when the
- 2:23case when the courts would address some
- 2:26of these disputes
- 2:27they did so in a way that I always found
- 2:29unsatisfying. It seemed as if Uh yeah,
- 2:33well I it seemed as if the
- 2:36typical approach was to say fashion and
- 2:39dress are trivial.
- 2:41And for the most part would be beneath
- 2:43the attention of the law. But um perhaps
- 2:47they've touched on some important value
- 2:49like race or sex discrimination or first
- 2:54amendment concerns. Um
- 2:56But by beginning the analysis by saying
- 2:58that what the people were arguing about
- 3:01is basically trivial.
- 3:03Uh it seemed to me that they missed a
- 3:05lot of the point of these disputes. And
- 3:07so in many ways the analysis were
- 3:09somewhat unsatisfying. And I think
- 3:12sometimes the courts missed a lot of
- 3:14what was important and sometimes came to
- 3:17the wrong conclusions.
- 3:19So I wanted to look at why clothing and
- 3:23fashion is important to people. So much
- 3:26so that they would sue about it. That um
- 3:29employees would risk losing a job. That
- 3:31employers would risk losing a good
- 3:33employee. That people would lose time at
- 3:37school. And that schools would send
- 3:40students home. That they had an
- 3:42obligation to teach over what they were
- 3:44wearing.
- 3:45Uh so that was the professional reason.
- 3:49The personal reason is that I've always
- 3:51been kind of interested in fashion. It's
- 3:52been a way for me to, you know, not only
- 3:56express myself but kind of navigate the
- 3:59world and
- 4:02um
- 4:02deal with
- 4:04sometimes new or difficult social
- 4:07environments that, you know, clothing
- 4:09seemed important to me.
- 4:11I think I learned that from my father
- 4:12who was the first African-American in
- 4:15many circumstances that he
- 4:18found himself in in his professional
- 4:20career. And he always took great pride
- 4:23in his appearance and his dress. And he
- 4:26It was clear that he thought it was
- 4:27important more than just as a matter of
- 4:30vanity but as a matter of dignity. And
- 4:35that stuck with me.
- 4:37>> And what did your father do?
- 4:39>> Well, he's he's no longer with us but he
- 4:42used to be the dean of the School of
- 4:45Health and Social Work at Cal State
- 4:47Fresno.
- 4:48>> Oh, wow.
- 4:48>> And
- 4:49he was the first black administrator at
- 4:51that school and
- 4:53we moved from New York to California for
- 4:56that job and he held that position for
- 4:58many years.
- 5:00>> That's incredible.
- 5:01I personally feel like with dress, I
- 5:04mean, and you know, I'm a makeup artist
- 5:06in my other world besides doing this,
- 5:08but I always feel that
- 5:10it's you should always try and look your
- 5:12personal best. But, you know, regardless
- 5:15of the situation. I just think it's less
- 5:18distracting when you feel that you look
- 5:20in and are dressed appropriately because
- 5:23you can just focus on like what we're
- 5:24discussing right now other than, oh my
- 5:26god, do I
- 5:28my eyes? Is my shirt? Like am I in
- 5:30pajamas? And I also do think it is a
- 5:32form of respect to you that I come,
- 5:36you know, to you meeting with you or
- 5:37whomever
- 5:39looking like the best version of myself.
- 5:41I mean, don't you think that's
- 5:42important? Because I know in the tech
- 5:44world, you know, there's CEOs that wear
- 5:46t-shirts and flip-flops and that set the
- 5:48tone for the industry that you know,
- 5:50women wearing I'm quoting you here.
- 5:52Women wearing fashionable dresses or
- 5:54high heels face ridicule in the tech
- 5:56world and some venture capitalists
- 5:58refuse to invest in a company run by
- 6:00someone wearing a suit. Do you find that
- 6:02to be really true?
- 6:03>> Uh yes, yes. There was a quote from the
- 6:07the entrepreneur Peter Thiel who's
- 6:10kind of famous now as a conservative
- 6:13political activist as well, but
- 6:15you know, he was a big deal in the tech
- 6:16world and once said never invest in a
- 6:18company where the CEO wears a suit. Um
- 6:22when Marissa Mayer who was the
- 6:25CEO of Yahoo appeared in a Vogue fashion
- 6:28spread,
- 6:30she was ridiculed and one person said
- 6:33and I think this kind of encapsulates
- 6:34the attitude,
- 6:36she looks like she's on vacation or
- 6:38going to a party while everyone else is
- 6:40working. So, her fashionable clothing
- 6:43was seen as distracting from her
- 6:46work ethic almost that you know,
- 6:48demonstrated that she was superficial
- 6:51and you know, everyone else is working
- 6:52while she's out worried about what she's
- 6:54going to wear.
- 6:55>> But I mean, don't you find that
- 6:56discriminatory as well? I mean,
- 6:59I mean, I find that offensive you know,
- 7:02because I do work in the fashion world
- 7:03as well and it's like, why is someone
- 7:05making that presumption that you because
- 7:07someone dresses well that they have a
- 7:08poor work ethic? I mean, if you would
- 7:11look at it from a different perspective,
- 7:12someone wearing a t-shirt and flip-flops
- 7:14would look like they're on holiday,
- 7:15right?
- 7:16>> Yes, no, absolutely. That's what's so
- 7:18ironic about it that this dressed down
- 7:21aesthetic
- 7:22has come to symbolize the work ethic in
- 7:26Silicon Valley. So, I mean, Mark
- 7:29Zuckerberg once said, you know, the
- 7:30reason I wear a gray t-shirt, I'm
- 7:31paraphrasing, but the reason I wear a
- 7:33gray t-shirt is because if I wasted time
- 7:36on trivial things like what to wear, I
- 7:38wouldn't be doing my job
- 7:41um, make Facebook the best company it
- 7:43can be. And so, right there, now the
- 7:45t-shirt's not a matter of indifference.
- 7:47You know, he didn't say, "Who cares what
- 7:49I'm wearing? What's important is the
- 7:50quality of my work." Instead, the
- 7:52t-shirt became a symbol of the work
- 7:54ethic. And so, it's just a new dress
- 7:56code, um, in a different form.
- 7:59But, I do think that it has implications
- 8:03for gender equality because that kind of
- 8:07dressed down aesthetic really works best
- 8:10for men, and women I think struggle with
- 8:13that. So, on the one hand, if they dress
- 8:15up too much, they're going to be
- 8:16ridiculed as vain and superficial. But,
- 8:18if they don't, I don't think they're
- 8:20going to get the same benefit of the
- 8:22doubt that a man does wearing a t-shirt
- 8:24and flip-flops.
- 8:25>> I completely agree. On a separate note,
- 8:27I was hired by Fox to do, um,
- 8:30the the grooming for Mark Zuckerberg,
- 8:32um, Dana Perino, and Tucker Carlson, and
- 8:35he declined my services. And I'm like,
- 8:37>> Mhm.
- 8:38>> I'm getting paid, okay? I I you're not
- 8:40So, it for me it was kind of weird like,
- 8:44I'm hired to do my job and you're
- 8:45declining even though I'm just going to
- 8:47make you look a little bit better.
- 8:49>> Right.
- 8:50>> So, I found that kind of offensive,
- 8:52actually.
- 8:53>> Yeah. And it's it's kind of it's really
- 8:55surprising as well because
- 8:57the way you look on the camera is very
- 8:58different than the way you look in
- 9:00person. You know, when I first had my
- 9:02big TV, my first like TV appearance
- 9:05where I was actually in front of like
- 9:06lots of lights and cameras, um, and they
- 9:09had someone come in to make me up and
- 9:11said, "A lot of people look washed out
- 9:13on camera." And I said, "Well, I don't
- 9:15think that's going to be my problem."
- 9:17But, um, she said, "Trust me, you know."
- 9:19And and for sure, like
- 9:22in the absence of that, you know, every
- 9:24tiny imperfection shows up, every
- 9:26wrinkle, every weird thing. Um,
- 9:29it it's it's a real skill you have.
- 9:31>> It really Well, and it's also when
- 9:33you're doing the grooming for a man on
- 9:35TV,
- 9:36a good groomer, and I consider myself
- 9:38one, you no one would even know you have
- 9:41anything on. You just look like a little
- 9:43bit fresher and on and not shiny and
- 9:46just a better version of you.
- 9:48>> Yeah.
- 9:48>> You've So, speaking of your television
- 9:50appearances, you've appeared on the
- 9:51Colbert Report. How do you translate
- 9:54complex legal concepts for broader
- 9:56audiences?
- 9:57>> Yeah, that is a challenge and it's one
- 10:00of the things that I've spent a lot of
- 10:02time thinking about. You know, the
- 10:03Colbert Report was the first big
- 10:05television show I was on and I was you
- 10:08know, just
- 10:09as nervous as you could possibly be. Um
- 10:12but I'd gotten a lot of advice from
- 10:14people who'd either watched it or um
- 10:17been on the show about when you're one,
- 10:19keeping your answers short, having that
- 10:21kind of elevator pitch statement of your
- 10:24idea. That's hard for academics to do,
- 10:26you know, we're used to having a captive
- 10:28audience for an hour where you know, we
- 10:30can go on and on. No, you need to have
- 10:32something very short so the people don't
- 10:34turn off the television. And um so
- 10:37that's one thing. I found telling
- 10:39stories is a
- 10:42great way to translate complicated ideas
- 10:45to a general audience. Um
- 10:48and if I can find a good story that
- 10:51illustrates my point, then I don't have
- 10:54to spend very much time explaining it in
- 10:56abstract terms that start to become
- 10:58boring.
- 11:00>> So, you've been on You were also a
- 11:02featured uh TED Talk speaker. And you've
- 11:05appeared on the Rachel Maddow Show and
- 11:07you've been um a former host on SiriusXM
- 11:10Stanford Legal. Tell me about that. Did
- 11:13you enjoy that and and it Did you find
- 11:16that to be something that came naturally
- 11:18or did you kind of have to learn how to
- 11:21you know,
- 11:22speak to people in a different way? I
- 11:23mean, you mentioned earlier that you
- 11:25have to be a little more concise with
- 11:27your answers, but what else you learn
- 11:28about
- 11:30you know, being on these shows?
- 11:32>> Oh, yeah. And
- 11:33>> maybe
- 11:33>> how you teach your courses.
- 11:35>> Oh, actually, yes. I think it has
- 11:37affected the way I teach my courses and
- 11:40um the TED in particular puts you
- 11:44through a very rigorous training before
- 11:48you give the TED Talk. And so, what's
- 11:51interesting is that these TED Talks look
- 11:53like they're someone just having a
- 11:54conversation, but in fact, they're
- 11:56really, really, really well rehearsed.
- 11:58They're really well thought out um down
- 12:01to, you know, the seconds of time. Like,
- 12:04you know, your talk is going to be 9
- 12:06minutes and 32 seconds. Um
- 12:08and here's how you're going to make
- 12:10these transitions. And so, it taught me
- 12:12a lot about precision and the way um
- 12:15small differences can make the
- 12:17difference between, you know, keeping
- 12:19your audience and losing it their
- 12:21attention.
- 12:22Um they were great at coaching me on how
- 12:26to pack a complicated set of ideas into
- 12:29a very short period of time. So, you
- 12:31know, they're like, you've got 10
- 12:32minutes, no more.
- 12:34How do you get your point across in 10
- 12:35minutes?
- 12:36Um so, it was that was a great
- 12:38experience. Um you know, it's a little
- 12:41different on a podcast like Stanford
- 12:44Legal, where we have a bit more time,
- 12:46but a lot of the same things apply. A
- 12:49lot's about trying to be more concise
- 12:53and find ways to tell a compelling story
- 12:57that will grab read or listeners'
- 13:00attention right away. So, yeah, I think
- 13:02I have brought that to the classroom in
- 13:05um a variety of ways. I'd like to think
- 13:07that my lecturing style, my teaching
- 13:09style is more engaging as a result.
- 13:12>> Oh, I'm sure it's done nothing but help,
- 13:14but I'm sure you were amazing
- 13:15regardless. You've written extensively
- 13:18about race and the law. How has your
- 13:20perspective evolved throughout your
- 13:22career?
- 13:24>> Well,
- 13:25in a few ways. I My earliest work about
- 13:29race and the law was designed to get at
- 13:31how
- 13:33um things that we overlook can cause
- 13:36racial inequalities. So, rather than
- 13:38looking at the you know stereotypical
- 13:40bigot who's deliberately trying to keep
- 13:43people of color down or something like
- 13:44that, I would wanted to look at the way
- 13:47um things like local government
- 13:49boundaries, things like the way
- 13:51government um
- 13:53operates differently in different
- 13:55neighborhoods can reproduce racial
- 13:57inequalities.
- 13:59Um and I guess that work got me thinking
- 14:03more about how
- 14:06um
- 14:07questions of race discrimination are
- 14:09often not simple. And we like to tell uh
- 14:13you know a simple story of a racist who
- 14:15is a morally evil person and deserves
- 14:18condemnation. And you know those people
- 14:20are out there, don't get me wrong.
- 14:23But
- 14:24a lot of what we're experiencing now
- 14:26doesn't involve that. It involves people
- 14:28who are um
- 14:30you know,
- 14:31decent people whose activities are just
- 14:35thoughtless with respect to um questions
- 14:38of social equality. And um or people who
- 14:41are in tough circumstances and are
- 14:44perpetuating racial equality because
- 14:46they're uh you know really busy trying
- 14:48to focus on something else that's also
- 14:50important. So, there're trade-offs. And
- 14:52I guess that's the way that it's has
- 14:55affected my thinking about it is to see
- 14:57these things as you know more
- 15:00complicated and um
- 15:02a little less black and white if you
- 15:04will than I may have thought at one
- 15:07time.
- 15:08>> Can you tell me a little about the
- 15:09research process behind dress codes and
- 15:12what surprised you along the way? And I
- 15:14love this quote from your book. One can
- 15:16make a gentleman from two yards of red
- 15:18cloth.
- 15:19>> Yes, right. Cosimo de Medici, the um
- 15:22great patriarch of Florence during the
- 15:25Renaissance, said this and it reflected
- 15:28the idea and an anxiety that
- 15:32um
- 15:32people were dressing above their
- 15:34station. And that in a society where a
- 15:38lot was communicated visually,
- 15:42um the ability to look like an
- 15:44aristocrat, to look like a gentleman,
- 15:46often was all there was to it. And so,
- 15:50there was a worry about changing social
- 15:51hierarchy and the power of fashion to
- 15:54affect those social hierarchies.
- 15:56The um
- 15:58you were asking about the research
- 16:00process and I mean, it's the most fun
- 16:04I've had doing any writing project. Uh
- 16:07but I spent a lot of time digging
- 16:10through
- 16:11um history articles
- 16:14and and books and going into archives
- 16:16trying to find examples of legal rules
- 16:20around clothing. Uh yeah, cuz I thought,
- 16:22well, I'm a lawyer and the way I can get
- 16:24at this is by looking at what laws were
- 16:27in place at the time. And I guess what
- 16:29surprised me is how many of them there
- 16:30were. I mean, yeah, I expected to find a
- 16:32few, but there were a vast number of
- 16:36rules and regulations from the late
- 16:38Middle Ages through about the early
- 16:401600s
- 16:42about dress, um regulating it in great
- 16:46detail. And so, this was not a small
- 16:49thing, it wasn't an isolated thing, it
- 16:51was something where, you know, in like a
- 16:53single year there could be two, three,
- 16:55four acts of apparel that were
- 16:58attempting to regulate clothing. There
- 17:00were law enforcement campaigns that
- 17:03involved, you know, people with lists of
- 17:06citizens or or or subjects at that time,
- 17:08they wouldn't wouldn't have been
- 17:09citizens, um according to their social
- 17:11rank to make sure that no one was
- 17:13wearing clothing that was above their
- 17:15station. You know, elaborate
- 17:16enforcement. Um it was quite surprising
- 17:20to me and um and and really fascinating.
- 17:23>> This is so interesting. I have never
- 17:25thought about this from
- 17:26this perspective at all. And to go back
- 17:29in time in history
- 17:31to think that this was such a a such an
- 17:33issue is is really remarkable to me. How
- 17:36far back did you go historically?
- 17:39>> Well, so I the book really begins in the
- 17:41late Middle Ages and that's a moment I
- 17:43talk a tiny bit about the ancient world
- 17:45but only in order to contrast this
- 17:47moment in the late Middle Ages um 1300s
- 17:51that uh some historians describe as the
- 17:53birth of fashion. And that's when
- 17:56clothing really begins to get varied and
- 18:00um expressive. You get uh tailoring
- 18:04techniques that create like bold shapes,
- 18:07big collars with big ruffs or puffy
- 18:10sleeves or puffy trousers, you know,
- 18:13things that are really become um
- 18:16uh
- 18:17you know, an art form and that
- 18:21leads fashion to become a new kind of
- 18:25status symbol
- 18:27but also a new way of exercising
- 18:29political power. And so you know, Queen
- 18:32Elizabeth for instance, a lot of
- 18:35her um clothing was designed to convey
- 18:40royal authority. It it people said that
- 18:42she almost looked otherworldly.
- 18:44And that was by design and it was an
- 18:47important part of the way she he
- 18:48exercised power and asserted her right
- 18:50to rule. So that's um
- 18:53you know, that that that birth of
- 18:55fashion is a way of conveying that kind
- 18:58of meaning that we're really familiar
- 18:59with today but wasn't always true. Um
- 19:02that's where I started and you know,
- 19:04then kind of
- 19:05and that's right when these laws started
- 19:07as well beginning to regulate what
- 19:09people could wear uh according to their
- 19:11social rank. And then I'd move forward
- 19:13into the present.
- 19:14>> So, could you tell me, and I don't know
- 19:15if
- 19:16if this is
- 19:18what you can quote me on here, but what
- 19:19what was like the first law? Like, who
- 19:22went to somewhere and decided, "We're
- 19:24going to make a law about fashion and
- 19:26about what people are wearing and their
- 19:28their rank and where they are in the
- 19:30world." I what I can't even imagine that
- 19:33happening.
- 19:33>> Yes. Uh
- 19:35so, this started I think one of the
- 19:37first ones was sometimes in actually in
- 19:39the late
- 19:401200s.
- 19:43But, they really got going in the 1300s
- 19:46and kind of kept accelerating all the
- 19:49way through the 1500s.
- 19:52Um and the first laws
- 19:56were
- 19:57designed to control consumption.
- 20:01And in particular, conspicuous
- 20:03consumption, according to wealth. So,
- 20:06um you had concerns that people were
- 20:08buying things they couldn't afford. Uh
- 20:11you had concerns that people were buying
- 20:13foreign products that were going to
- 20:15contribute to uh you know, a negative
- 20:17trade balance for various regimes. But,
- 20:20most of all, you had the concern that
- 20:22people were dressing above their
- 20:24station, putting on airs, um taking on
- 20:28the pretense to be of a higher social
- 20:31rank and importance than they, you know,
- 20:32really were according to the hierarchies
- 20:36of the time. And it became really clear
- 20:39that that was the biggest concern. That
- 20:41you you these kind of things coincided
- 20:44with um
- 20:45economic booms, where skilled
- 20:48tradespeople um
- 20:50and merchants were making a lot of
- 20:52money. So, now suddenly they could
- 20:54afford fancy and luxurious clothing. And
- 20:57they looked around at the aristocrats
- 20:59and said, "Well, if it's good for them,
- 21:01maybe it's good for us as well." But,
- 21:04they were kind of a a social class that
- 21:06was asserting itself, kind of flexing
- 21:08their muscles. Not so much that they
- 21:09wanted to pass themselves off as
- 21:11aristocrats, but maybe what was more
- 21:13subversive to say, "We're just as
- 21:15important as aristocrats. We deserve
- 21:18this
- 21:19um fine clothing as well." And I think
- 21:21that was really threatening.
- 21:23>> I It's so funny. It seems like the
- 21:25uh the government was very involved.
- 21:27>> Yes.
- 21:28>> And that's really surprising to me.
- 21:31>> Yes, the government was very involved.
- 21:34Some of these laws involved um the
- 21:37church and were regulations on modesty.
- 21:40So, um those were uh
- 21:44the those were often directed primarily
- 21:46at women, although not always, but a
- 21:48requirement that people behave modestly
- 21:51and therefore not adorn themselves with
- 21:52vanities. Uh but a lot of them were from
- 21:57um
- 21:57royal courts. I mean, again, Henry the
- 22:00VIII and then even more so Queen
- 22:02Elizabeth the First in England passed a
- 22:04lot of acts of apparel um or pro
- 22:08proclamations.
- 22:09Um
- 22:10Parliament passed acts of apparel and
- 22:13were involved with the concern that um
- 22:17people were
- 22:19acting above their rank and it was
- 22:21confusing to the general population and
- 22:24threatened to overturn the appropriate
- 22:27established order. These arguments were
- 22:30made openly. So, one of the things that
- 22:32was great for me as a scholar about
- 22:33reading about these early laws is that
- 22:36people were quite up front about the
- 22:39fact that, you know, we have a
- 22:40hierarchy, it needs to be maintained.
- 22:42It's not acceptable for people of lower
- 22:44orders to dress in the way that's
- 22:46appropriate for people of higher orders.
- 22:48We don't say that anymore today, even
- 22:50though we sometimes act like it, but
- 22:53back then they were perfectly fine with
- 22:54saying it.
- 22:56>> So, what would happen if someone was
- 22:58convicted of of such a crime back then?
- 23:00Like, what were the what would happen?
- 23:03>> The penalties
- 23:04One person
- 23:05One of the main penalties that you see
- 23:07is that they would have the offending
- 23:09clothing seized by the government. So,
- 23:11you're not supposed to have that. We are
- 23:13going to take it. Public humiliation was
- 23:16a common penalty. One person, for
- 23:19instance, was arrested on the streets of
- 23:22London for wearing what the authorities
- 23:24described as a monstrous and outrageous
- 23:26pair of trunk hose. And trunk hose are
- 23:28these big puffy trousers that you might
- 23:31associate with, you know, Sir Walter
- 23:33Raleigh or William Shakespeare. They
- 23:35were big men's fashion, and they could
- 23:37get very big and puffed up, and that was
- 23:38the fashion for
- 23:41the elite. So, this person who was a
- 23:44tailor or tailor's apprentice had these
- 23:48trunk hose and was
- 23:50arrested, and the linings of his trunk
- 23:53hose were torn out by the
- 23:56Yeah, yeah, ripped out while he was
- 23:58wearing them, and then he was marched
- 24:00through the streets of London with the
- 24:03lining trailing behind him for all to
- 24:05see
- 24:06back to his place of residence where the
- 24:09constables searched and found other
- 24:11offending garments that were likewise
- 24:14torn in front of him. So, that was one
- 24:18example.
- 24:19Another person had his offending garment
- 24:21seized and then posted in a public place
- 24:25as an example for everyone of his
- 24:28extreme folly. So, and then there were
- 24:31also monetary fines.
- 24:33>> Wow. So, between the 18th, 19th, and
- 24:3520th centuries, have has the changed
- 24:38these these laws or
- 24:41what Like what was different in the in
- 24:42those previous centuries?
- 24:44>> Yeah, the the laws kind of fell out of
- 24:47favor around the 1600s, and by the
- 24:491700s, most had either been repealed or
- 24:52simply were no longer enforced.
- 24:56Part of the reason this happened was
- 24:58that
- 24:59as fashion continued to mature and to
- 25:03advance,
- 25:05it became harder and harder for
- 25:06authorities to list the things that
- 25:10would convey high status. You know,
- 25:11fashion's just changing too quickly. You
- 25:13know, in fact, at one point in the late
- 25:151500s, the Venetian Senate passed a law
- 25:18that simply said all new fashions are
- 25:20hereby banned. Uh, because they clearly
- 25:23had been racing to catch up with the
- 25:24latest fashion and then now we have to
- 25:26ban this, now we have to you regulate
- 25:28that. Um, so they just put an end to all
- 25:30this. But of course, that didn't work.
- 25:33And so,
- 25:34status started to change. It started to
- 25:38change from something that was conveyed
- 25:40through flashy and ostentatious display
- 25:44to something that was conveyed through
- 25:46subtleties.
- 25:48Um, so by the
- 25:50time of, let's say, Beau Brummell in the
- 25:53early 1800s in England, in the Regency
- 25:55era in England, um, he's the avatar of
- 25:58masculine vanity, but he was known for
- 26:00his understatedness.
- 26:02Uh, that he didn't wear flashy clothing.
- 26:05Everything was subtle and subdued, but
- 26:08all of the details had to be perfect.
- 26:10And so, this new way of exhibiting
- 26:12fashion was something that didn't
- 26:13require the same type of overt
- 26:15regulation, but served some of the same
- 26:19functions. And you can read in periods
- 26:21of the time, like kind of handbooks that
- 26:22will advise about all the variety of
- 26:25details that the well-dressed gentleman
- 26:28or the um, fashionable lady would wear.
- 26:33And it gets quite elaborate. You wear
- 26:34this in the afternoon and this for tea
- 26:36and this in the evening, and you have to
- 26:38have five different outfits. Um, but
- 26:41they have to be of the appropriate cloth
- 26:43and cut and everything else. So, you it
- 26:44was about it was about know-how rather
- 26:46than about just money.
- 26:48>> Did you find most of these uh, laws
- 26:50applied more to men or women?
- 26:52>> Um the Well, the early laws applied to
- 26:56both men and women, although it was
- 26:58really men who had the most fashionable
- 27:00clothing up until
- 27:03sometime like the late 1700s. You know,
- 27:06all of the new innovations were
- 27:07masculine, and women borrowed them. Um
- 27:11all of the sexiest fashions were
- 27:13masculine. Women, for instance, were all
- 27:16required to be draped below the waist,
- 27:18whereas men had, you know, stockings
- 27:20that showed off their legs and things
- 27:21like that, and it was understood to be
- 27:23very sexy.
- 27:24Um but that changed in the 1700s, and
- 27:27then um it was women who were
- 27:30fashionable, and men were just well
- 27:32dressed. And so you had this stark shift
- 27:36in the
- 27:38way people thought about fashion. Now,
- 27:40it doesn't mean that men didn't care
- 27:42about the way they looked, but they
- 27:43didn't want to be seen as fashionable
- 27:45fashionable anymore. That was frivolous.
- 27:48Um Now, we're just well dressed. And so
- 27:50the rules then started to um apply more
- 27:54to women as well. The women needed to
- 27:57have five different outfits during the
- 27:58day, you know, if they were wealthy, of
- 28:00course, um and and lots of elaborate
- 28:03things. But for men, um the rules were
- 28:07often unstated,
- 28:09but very important. The importance of a
- 28:11suit that's well cut, um that fits
- 28:14properly, that's of the right refined
- 28:17fabric. Uh you know, those things became
- 28:19extremely important, and anyone who knew
- 28:21would be able to tell the difference
- 28:23between, you know, the well-dressed
- 28:25gentleman in a well-fitted suit and the,
- 28:28you know, upstart um or the wannabe
- 28:31wearing a poorly-fitted suit or wearing
- 28:34the wrong thing at the wrong time.
- 28:37>> So, was color ever a factor in the
- 28:40fabric?
- 28:41>> Uh yes, the color
- 28:43um uh
- 28:45at the time when men started to kind of
- 28:48renounce the flashier fashions
- 28:51and some
- 28:52one one historian described this as the
- 28:54great masculine renunciation where men
- 28:58cast off all of that. The colors became
- 29:01much more subdued and so
- 29:04you know first it was grays and beige
- 29:09type colors subdued
- 29:12but still somewhat colorful perhaps with
- 29:15a colorful waistcoat. Over time this
- 29:18matured into the black
- 29:22Brooks Brothers style business suit and
- 29:24the typical man was wearing this very
- 29:26somber
- 29:28outfit that kind of conveyed
- 29:30practicality
- 29:32and civic virtue and a lack of vanity.
- 29:36So there's kind of a direct line between
- 29:38that shift to dark colors and to you
- 29:41know Mark Zuckerberg's gray t-shirt. The
- 29:43same message is being conveyed.
- 29:45I have better things to think about than
- 29:47what I wear.
- 29:50>> So
- 29:51what about in the last 100 years? Has
- 29:54has any of these issues legal from a
- 29:56legal perspective arisen?
- 29:59>> Yes, there are still
- 30:03a variety of ways in which fashion and
- 30:05law intersect. In the early 20th century
- 30:08for instance, it was still unlawful in
- 30:11many American and European cities for
- 30:13women to wear pants. That was considered
- 30:16to be indecent.
- 30:18Yeah,
- 30:20early 20th century. There were lots of
- 30:23workplace dress codes prohibiting
- 30:26women from for instance showing their
- 30:28legs or showing their ankles. When the
- 30:30flapper fashions began to become popular
- 30:33in the 1920s one of the things that was
- 30:35most scandalous about them was that the
- 30:37skirts were for that period of time
- 30:39short in the sense that they were you
- 30:42know, just below the knee so that the
- 30:44entire leg could be showing and that was
- 30:46seen as a huge scandal and a
- 30:47provocation. Um the outfits were
- 30:50form-fitting rather than big drape
- 30:52skirts and that again was seen as quite
- 30:56um
- 30:56provocative. Uh some condemned it as not
- 31:00feminine enough, some as too sexy, but
- 31:02either way people didn't like it and
- 31:04they and and employers passed rules
- 31:06prohibiting women from wearing these
- 31:08kind of
- 31:15You right, your question was whether we
- 31:17had any of these um rules about clothing
- 31:21in the 20th century. Uh so yeah, where
- 31:23where should I pick it up?
- 31:25>> Go right there. Just start right there
- 31:26if you want to say that again.
- 31:28>> Uh okay.
- 31:30So we do still have rules about clothing
- 31:36even in the 20th century. For example,
- 31:39um
- 31:40in the early 20th century women could be
- 31:43arrested in some American and European
- 31:45cities for wearing pants. Um and not
- 31:48tight pants or see-through trousers or
- 31:50anything, but just regular men's
- 31:52clothing was seen as a real provocation.
- 31:56Um
- 31:57clothing that showed a woman's legs was
- 32:01considered quite scandalous and
- 32:03employers, for instance, passed laws
- 32:06against what were described as flapper
- 32:08fashions, which included the the newly
- 32:12for the times short skirts. They were
- 32:14still cut below the knee, but um that
- 32:17showed the woman's legs and that was a
- 32:19new thing and one considered to be quite
- 32:21um
- 32:22provocative.
- 32:24Um women, of course, many women liked
- 32:26these fashions and the fashions um
- 32:29managed to proliferate despite these
- 32:32rules, but there was a long period of
- 32:34time in which people suggested that
- 32:36women wearing flapper fashions should be
- 32:39subject to arrest for indecent exposure,
- 32:41that they were inviting sexual assault,
- 32:44and therefore had no cause to complain
- 32:46if they were assaulted given that they
- 32:48were dressed like this. Um, you know,
- 32:50all kinds of uh ideas. And of course,
- 32:52again, employers that outlawed the
- 32:54fashions as scandalous.
- 32:56Um, and then, you know, as you move
- 32:59through the 20th century,
- 33:01uh public indecency laws were used for
- 33:06um people who cross-dressed. So, you
- 33:09know, the one of the first examples was
- 33:11just
- 33:11>> If that was ever true in in historic,
- 33:14you know, history.
- 33:15>> Yes. Yes. So, I mean, one of the earlier
- 33:18examples were women wearing trousers was
- 33:20considered, you know, kind of a form of
- 33:22cross-dressing. That was a masculine
- 33:24style. Um, and it was seen as sexually
- 33:27provocative. You know, if you think of
- 33:28like Marlene Dietrich in Morocco with
- 33:31the tuxedo, you know, that's our sexy
- 33:34thing. And that's the way people looked
- 33:35at women wearing pants at that period of
- 33:37time.
- 33:38Because it suggested the woman was going
- 33:41to assert the social prerogatives of
- 33:44men.
- 33:45Um, and that, you know, meant to a
- 33:48certain sexual openness that women
- 33:51weren't expected to exhibit. Um, lack of
- 33:54modesty. But cross-dressing then, um you
- 33:57know, later, of course, involved um more
- 34:00concern about men dressing in women's
- 34:03clothing. And laws um prohibiting
- 34:07cross-dressing, usually under the rubric
- 34:10of indecent exposure or public
- 34:13indecency, continued in the United
- 34:15States through the 1970s.
- 34:18They, yes, through the night People In
- 34:20fact, there was some litigation around
- 34:23these laws in the 1970s where they were
- 34:26eventually challenged as, um
- 34:29interestingly, um unconstitutionally
- 34:32vague. So, the reason that they were
- 34:35objectionable is because they were too
- 34:37vague. One court said, "We don't you
- 34:40know, given the change in fashions, how
- 34:42do we know what's a masculine fashion
- 34:44and what's a feminine one?" Um, you
- 34:46know, men were wearing, you know, kind
- 34:48of the romantic look with the ruffled
- 34:51shirts and things like that. And so, the
- 34:53court said, "Well, how are we Is that a
- 34:54woman's blouse and subjects you to
- 34:57arrest for indecency or is that a man's
- 34:59fashion?" Um, "We can't tell, so this
- 35:01law is too vague to be enforced." Uh,
- 35:03and they kind of then fell into, um,
- 35:07uh, you were either invalidated or just
- 35:09no longer enforced, but that was quite
- 35:13recent.
- 35:14Even as recently as the early 21st
- 35:19century. Um, and maybe even today there
- 35:22laws about, um, that have been used
- 35:26about sagging pants, you know, the kind
- 35:28of hip-hop style.
- 35:29>> All right.
- 35:29>> And again, prosecuted as public
- 35:31indecency. You're showing your
- 35:32undergarments. That's the official,
- 35:35um, reason for
- 35:37arresting people. One person wearing
- 35:40sagging pants was actually thrown in
- 35:41jail for contempt of court,
- 35:43um, for because,
- 35:46uh, you know, the judge found it, um,
- 35:48contemptuous that someone would come
- 35:50into his courtroom wearing sagging
- 35:52pants.
- 35:54So, we still have some of these laws.
- 35:55>> indecent? Like almost like indecent
- 35:57exposure or how do you determine?
- 36:00>> Yes. Well, that's just it. That the
- 36:02claim is that it's indecent exposure
- 36:04because you're wearing these pants that
- 36:06show your underwear.
- 36:07Um,
- 36:08you know, I think realistically,
- 36:11the objections had more to do with the
- 36:14African-American subculture that that
- 36:16style is associated with. But, a lot of
- 36:19people felt that it conveyed a lack of
- 36:22respect. And you know, it's worth
- 36:24noting,
- 36:25there were many African-Americans who
- 36:27objected to the sagging pants, too.
- 36:28There was a whole group of
- 36:31almost a little movement in the
- 36:33early
- 36:352000s
- 36:36that was kind of called pull up your
- 36:39pants. Get a belt. Buy a belt. So, you
- 36:42people and these were sometimes, you
- 36:44know, African American churches, African
- 36:46American leaders saying, "Hey, you know,
- 36:48pull up your pants. Show some respect."
- 36:50So, that
- 36:53dovetailed with the enforcement, the
- 36:55legal enforcement in
- 36:57with some of these public indecency
- 36:59laws.
- 37:00>> To date, so is there anything in the
- 37:02last 50 years of any laws or any
- 37:05legal cases that one would say
- 37:09have affected fashion or or
- 37:12that someone's getting persecuted or
- 37:14something, not persecuted, but, you
- 37:15know, getting in having an issue with
- 37:17the law because of
- 37:18clothes?
- 37:19>> Yes, I mean, other than the sagging
- 37:21pants cases, which were recent,
- 37:23all braided hair styles were a subject
- 37:28of legal disputes since way back in the
- 37:301970s.
- 37:31There
- 37:32were There was a woman who was a flight
- 37:35airline, I believe a flight attendant,
- 37:37who had an all braided hairstyle and the
- 37:40airlines had a lot of rules about how
- 37:42the flight attendants could dress and
- 37:45said that that was not consistent with
- 37:47the dress code and she sued for race
- 37:49discrimination. Now, she lost that case,
- 37:52but the
- 37:55the the the
- 37:57conflicts involving all braided hair
- 37:58styles continued and now we're beginning
- 38:03to see legislation that prohibits
- 38:05employers from forbidding all braided
- 38:07hair styles. They're called the Crown
- 38:09Act.
- 38:10California and several other states have
- 38:12adopted it, but not every state. And so,
- 38:16there are still workplaces where locks
- 38:19or braids are prohibited by the employer
- 38:24and they lead to legal conflicts as to
- 38:27whether or not those rules are
- 38:29discrimination or sex discrimination or
- 38:31both.
- 38:34>> I'm going to switch to other subjects,
- 38:36but is there anything else that I've
- 38:37missed
- 38:39that you want to share about about your
- 38:41book or, you know, going back in history
- 38:43from a legal perspective with fashion?
- 38:46>> Oh, there's so many interesting
- 38:48incidents involving the complexities of
- 38:50the way fashion signifies things from
- 38:53dignified dress for African Americans to
- 38:56the variety of ways in which women have
- 38:59struggled with gendered expectations
- 39:02around clothing. And maybe the the
- 39:04biggest theme is that
- 39:06it's kind of that it's complicated in
- 39:08the sense that sometimes women embrace
- 39:10traditional femininity and feminine
- 39:12fashions
- 39:14and sometimes they resist them. And
- 39:17similarly with African Americans,
- 39:19there's a whole
- 39:21history in the civil rights movement of
- 39:22wearing one's Sunday best to protest
- 39:26unjust laws. Today that might seem
- 39:28strange, but at the time it was a
- 39:30powerful symbol of a demand for racial
- 39:33dignity. So looking back in history
- 39:36allows us to get a different perspective
- 39:37on a lot of
- 39:40or a variety of perspectives on the way
- 39:41that fashion signifies and why it's
- 39:44important to so many people.
- 39:46>> Are there any other cultures besides
- 39:48African-American cultures that have been
- 39:50affected by these laws?
- 39:52>> Yes. Yes, there are. In fact,
- 39:54the in
- 39:56the 1940s
- 39:58in Los Angeles, there were zoot suit
- 40:02riots. And the zoot suits were it was a
- 40:05fashion style that was worn in some
- 40:07places by African-Americans and some
- 40:09places by Italian-Americans, but in Los
- 40:12Angeles by
- 40:13Latinos. And the Latino
- 40:16community
- 40:18embraced a
- 40:19certain subculture of the Latino
- 40:22community. It wasn't everyone, but
- 40:23embraced this style of, you know, that
- 40:26kind of baggy trousers, long coats, and
- 40:30they were seen as insolent and
- 40:35unpatriotic
- 40:37and got into fights with American
- 40:40servicemen who had been, you know,
- 40:42stationed in Los Angeles and they were a
- 40:44series of these zoot suit riots in which
- 40:47the servicemen and the and the zoot
- 40:50suiters fought and um
- 40:53when when the servicemen won, they would
- 40:56take the zoot suits and burn them on a
- 40:58pyre.
- 41:00And so
- 41:02they they raged for several days.
- 41:05People suggested legislation.
- 41:07One California
- 41:09politician
- 41:11said, "You know, if we can arrest people
- 41:13for being underdressed, we can arrest
- 41:15them for being overdressed. So we should
- 41:17pass a law against the zoot suits and
- 41:20these crazy styles."
- 41:22So that's another ethnic group that had
- 41:24been targeted.
- 41:26Um
- 41:27Chinese Americans had at times been
- 41:29targeted for the braids that
- 41:31some used to wear in let's see the 1800s
- 41:37and that was, you know, outlawed as a
- 41:39way to target that population.
- 41:43>> Wow, that is amazing. I didn't realize
- 41:45the zoot suit was such an uh scandalous
- 41:48form of fashion.
- 41:50>> Yes, yes.
- 41:51>> Really interesting.
- 41:52So what does being named one of the 10
- 41:54100 most influential black lawyers mean
- 41:57to you professionally and personally?
- 42:00>> Oh,
- 42:01thank you. Um well, it's a great honor.
- 42:04I have tried throughout my career to do
- 42:08work that's important and um
- 42:12it times it has been unusual work. You
- 42:15know, I mean, a book about fashion for
- 42:17instance. But a lot of my work has taken
- 42:19a somewhat unconventional
- 42:21tack at looking at issues involving race
- 42:26and race discrimination. And so it's
- 42:27really gratifying to have that work
- 42:29recognized.
- 42:30>> No, that's such an accomplishment. How
- 42:32do you manage to balance your
- 42:33responsibilities as a professor, an
- 42:35author, a media personality, and board
- 42:38member of multiple organizations?
- 42:41>> Ah, um, I try to keep a careful Apple
- 42:44calendar.
- 42:46And I try to prioritize. It's
- 42:52the the thing that I focus on most is to
- 42:54ask each day, "What's the most important
- 42:57thing that I can do today? Um, what will
- 43:02have the most impact? And where can I
- 43:07make the biggest difference?" You know,
- 43:08those are two questions because
- 43:10sometimes
- 43:11there's an activity that a lot of other
- 43:13people could do. I could do it, but
- 43:16I'm not uniquely
- 43:19qualified or needed. And that may take a
- 43:21lower priority than something where I
- 43:22think, "If I don't do this, no one else
- 43:24will."
- 43:25>> Correct.
- 43:26So, what do you do when your day isn't
- 43:27flowing?
- 43:30Cuz we all have those days, right?
- 43:32>> Oh, absolutely. You know, well, I mean,
- 43:33I probably like most people sometimes I
- 43:35stare at the computer screen or
- 43:38you know, pace up and down and try to
- 43:40figure out what to do. But, um,
- 43:43my most effective strategy is to take a
- 43:46break and do something else. And so, one
- 43:49maybe one advantage of having a few
- 43:51different things going at one time is
- 43:54that if I'm feel like I'm hitting
- 43:56writer's block with one project, I can
- 43:57shift to another one. Or if I can't
- 43:59write that day for whatever reason, then
- 44:01maybe I can think about
- 44:04some other kind of advocacy or
- 44:06organizing I'm doing.
- 44:08>> Do you ever shut it down and just go,
- 44:09"I'm out of here. I'm going for a walk
- 44:11or I'm going to the gym or I'm going to
- 44:12do something else?" Does that
- 44:14>> Oh, yeah. Oh, definitely.
- 44:15>> What what do you do to escape when
- 44:17things are like that?
- 44:19>> Uh sometimes I go for a run
- 44:22um and that can clear my head.
- 44:26Sometimes
- 44:27I um just
- 44:30read a book, you know, about something
- 44:33else. Uh
- 44:34I'll have a novel going.
- 44:36>> yeah.
- 44:37>> Yeah, yeah, just to you know, clear my
- 44:38mind and get to think about something
- 44:40else for a little while.
- 44:42>> You've lectured in 12 countries
- 44:45um
- 44:46across five continents. How do you
- 44:48how do perspectives on law and race
- 44:50differ internationally?
- 44:52>> Well, they differ in fascinating ways.
- 44:55You I spent quite a bit of time in
- 44:57France as what was called an equality of
- 44:59opportunity fellow and the idea of the
- 45:01fellowship was for me to talk to people
- 45:04doing you were you know, civil rights
- 45:06work, equality law work in France. And
- 45:10one of the things I found was that um
- 45:13identical commitments, you know, a
- 45:15commitment to equality of opportunity,
- 45:17for instance, might be pursued in very
- 45:19different ways that made sense given
- 45:23national history and national culture.
- 45:26And so um
- 45:28that was a really fascinating thing to
- 45:31see, the way that things I took for
- 45:33granted as an American would be seen as
- 45:38uh uh
- 45:39um a
- 45:40the wrong approach in uh another
- 45:43country. So, for instance, in France,
- 45:45there is a great deal of resistance to
- 45:49collecting data about race or having
- 45:53official recognitions of race. And so, a
- 45:55lot of what we do in the American civil
- 45:57rights tradition is collect data to to
- 46:00where the disparities are and then we'll
- 46:01know where the problems are. That seems
- 46:03to be the way to do it. Um
- 46:05my experience in France was that there
- 46:08are,
- 46:09you know, committed, sincere people who
- 46:12believe very strongly that that's not
- 46:14the way to do it. Um that that
- 46:16reinforces ideas of racial division. And
- 46:19although that's a position that I um
- 46:22have been resistant to in the American
- 46:24context, I had to
- 46:28take it seriously and and respect it in
- 46:31the French context. And so it made me
- 46:32think that there are a lot of different
- 46:33ways to approach the same issue.
- 46:36>> As a founding member of the Academic
- 46:38Freedom Alliance, what do you see as the
- 46:40most pressing challenges to academic
- 46:42freedom today?
- 46:44>> Well, they're coming uh sadly, they're
- 46:46coming from many different directions
- 46:49today. Um when the Academic Freedom
- 46:52Alliance was started, I would have said
- 46:54that the main concern was a kind of
- 46:59group think on both the left and the
- 47:02right that made it difficult for
- 47:05um unorthodox or heterodox thinkers to
- 47:09find a place. Um that on many issues,
- 47:11there'd be an immediate kind of
- 47:13polarization and a crystallization of a
- 47:16position or set of positions, and it was
- 47:17really hard to break out of that. You
- 47:19know, if you're on the left, to tow this
- 47:21line. If you're on the right, tow that
- 47:23um that line.
- 47:25Today,
- 47:27I think the main threats to academic
- 47:29freedom, sadly, are coming from the
- 47:30government. Um we have, uh for the first
- 47:34time in my lifetime,
- 47:37uh government that has sent out lists of
- 47:40banned words to organizations that you
- 47:44are not to appear on
- 47:46um websites or proposals for grants
- 47:51um under the rubric of attacking what
- 47:54they describe as DEI, which is a very
- 47:57vague and undefined term. Um, we have
- 48:00the suggestion that, um, talking about
- 48:04the history of racial injustice, talking
- 48:06about the, um, prevalence of gender
- 48:10inequality, uh, is a is unlawful. Or
- 48:15will be met with the suspension of
- 48:18federal funding. And that, even if it
- 48:21doesn't
- 48:22have formal consequences, I mean, even
- 48:24if the government doesn't follow
- 48:26through, um, has a real chilling effect.
- 48:28And I've already seen that in, um, my
- 48:31own experience.
- 48:33>> That's interesting. Your books have been
- 48:35selected as notable books of the year by
- 48:37The New York Times multiple times.
- 48:39What's your writing process like?
- 48:42>> Well, um,
- 48:44I begin
- 48:47by developing a working hypothesis, and
- 48:52then I start to explore to test that
- 48:55hypothesis. Now, you know, not in the
- 48:57sense of statistical testing, because
- 48:59I'm not a
- 49:01I'm not a quantitative
- 49:03social scientist, but in the sense of
- 49:06looking broadly to see whether, um, the
- 49:09historical record, the sociological
- 49:12accounts, uh, and reported incidents
- 49:17line up with my intuitions about a
- 49:19particular social problem.
- 49:21>> Mhm.
- 49:21>> And then,
- 49:23um,
- 49:24start writing. So, I'll, uh, begin to
- 49:27I'll I'll map out, uh, you know, a vague
- 49:30idea where you think the book is going
- 49:31to go. Now, I have to admit it never
- 49:33goes exactly the way I think it's
- 49:35[laughter] going to when I start
- 49:36writing. I got a plan, and then, uh, one
- 49:39has to be flexible depending on where
- 49:41both the evidence and the most
- 49:43interesting,
- 49:45uh, material is. But, uh, that's that's
- 49:49my basic writing process. I'm almost
- 49:51always reading and writing at the same
- 49:53time. I have a bunch of books out and
- 49:55I'm, you know, checking sources and I'm
- 49:57looking at various things and then I'll
- 49:59write a little bit and then go back to
- 50:00the books and and um
- 50:03and for more inspiration and for uh more
- 50:05information.
- 50:07>> Are you currently look working on
- 50:08anything new or do you have an idea for
- 50:10your your next book?
- 50:11>> Uh I'm I am actually working on a new
- 50:14book and then in a way it was inspired
- 50:16by dress codes, but it's taking things
- 50:17in a slightly different direction. Um
- 50:19it's tentatively called The Virtues of
- 50:22Vice and the idea of this book is to
- 50:25look at activities that have
- 50:27historically been condemned as vices and
- 50:30I kind of got this from some of the
- 50:32issues around um
- 50:34modesty and dress and the way that was
- 50:36considered to be a sinful vanity or
- 50:39vice-type behavior, but to look at some
- 50:41of these activities and see why it is
- 50:43people are engaging in them. Um now, I
- 50:47don't want to argue in this book that
- 50:49it's good to engage in vices. That's not
- 50:51the point, but it is to try to figure
- 50:53out why it is, for instance, that
- 50:55someone might
- 50:57um
- 50:58uh want to use mind-altering substances.
- 51:01Why are people drawn to gambling? Why
- 51:04are people drawn to illicit sex and why
- 51:06how is illicit sex defined? Because of
- 51:09course for much of European and American
- 51:12history any sex outside of marriage was
- 51:14illicit. Certainly until very recently
- 51:18sex between people of the same sex was
- 51:20illicit um for a long time in American
- 51:23history
- 51:24sex between people of different races
- 51:26was illicit. So, looking at all of
- 51:28those, why did people why
- 51:30what what what were the the political
- 51:32consequences of having these kind of
- 51:34ideas about vice and who were the people
- 51:37who either resisted
- 51:40those ideas or transgressed and is there
- 51:45anything we can learn from those people?
- 51:47That's basically the idea. I mean, the
- 51:48very early stages.
- 51:50>> That's exciting. How long does it
- 51:51usually take? How long do you anticipate
- 51:53this taking?
- 51:54This next
- 51:55>> Um I I'm hoping this book takes a little
- 51:57bit less time than the last one. The
- 51:59last one probably took me about 5 years.
- 52:01>> Oh, wow.
- 52:02>> From concept to finished book. And I I
- 52:05and my editor are both hoping that it
- 52:07will take more like two or three years.
- 52:10I think I've learned something from the
- 52:12last book in terms of how to streamline
- 52:13the process a little bit. But, you know,
- 52:15again, you never know until you start to
- 52:17really dig into it.
- 52:19>> How has your experience practicing law
- 52:21and working with various city
- 52:22governments informed your academic work?
- 52:25>> Ah, it's given me One of the great
- 52:27things about the law and study of the
- 52:30law as compared to,
- 52:33let's say, the study of something like
- 52:34philosophy, which I've also all along
- 52:36been very interested in, is that you're
- 52:37really dealing with practical,
- 52:40on-the-ground issues all the time. And
- 52:42so, what is
- 52:44plausible
- 52:46world of tradeoffs and a world of
- 52:48practical constraints is very much in
- 52:51the foreground. And work in policy or
- 52:55with government is all about that.
- 52:58And so, that has informed my work in a
- 53:01variety of ways cuz it's made me always
- 53:04foreground the question
- 53:06of
- 53:07practical constraints, of real-world
- 53:10situations, and of the effects of ideas
- 53:14on real people in their day-to-day
- 53:16lives.
- 53:16>> What would you tell your 20-year-old
- 53:17self?
- 53:18>> What would I tell my 20-year-old self? I
- 53:21would probably tell him to spend a
- 53:24little bit less time at nightclubs and
- 53:29more time studying.
- 53:32And but also
- 53:34uh
- 53:35follow your passions.
- 53:37>> I think that's wise advice. What advice
- 53:39would you give to law students who
- 53:41aspire to make an impact beyond
- 53:43traditional legal practice?
- 53:44>> Ah, I would give them similar advice.
- 53:47Follow your passions, but um look to
- 53:51ask yourself why you decided to go to
- 53:53law school
- 53:54and keep that
- 53:57at the center of your focus.
- 54:00That's what I would say. It's very easy
- 54:01to get
- 54:03distracted
- 54:04by what everyone else is doing, with the
- 54:07direction that you think the legal
- 54:08profession is headed, um the jobs that
- 54:11are the most prestigious or that pay the
- 54:13most, and forget why you decided to go
- 54:16to law school in the first place as
- 54:17opposed to something else. But I think
- 54:19for people who can keep that initial
- 54:24passion
- 54:25in mind, um even if the way they get
- 54:29there changes or the means change, um
- 54:31that serves as a good lodestar.
- 54:34>> What is your favorite quote or motto?
- 54:37>> Oh.
- 54:38>> Or both.
- 54:39>> Huh. Let's see. There is um this may or
- 54:44may not be my favorite, but it's just
- 54:45popped into my mind, and it's one that I
- 54:47like quite a lot. Um and I wish I could
- 54:49remember the exact quote and exactly who
- 54:52said it, but it's it's it's it's
- 54:54something like um I'll send you the
- 54:56exact quote later. Um something like
- 54:59opinions are like watches.
- 55:02Everyone's
- 55:04reads something different, and yet
- 55:06everyone trusts their own.
- 55:08>> Oh, that's a good one.
- 55:10And what about a motto? Do you have one?
- 55:12>> A motto? Um I don't know if I have a
- 55:15motto. Let me
- 55:17>> You got to get back to me.
- 55:18>> back to you with that.
- 55:19>> another show on that.
- 55:20>> Yeah, okay.
- 55:21>> Is there anything that I've missed today
- 55:23that you want to share?
- 55:25>> Um
- 55:27No, I can't think of anything.
- 55:29>> I think we've covered everything.
- 55:30>> we've covered quite a lot. Yeah, you're
- 55:32a great interviewer. You asked me a lot
- 55:34of um probing questions.
- 55:37>> Well, thank you.
- 55:38Richard Thompson Ford, I cannot thank
- 55:40you enough for being here. It has been I
- 55:42could chat with you all day.
- 55:44I'm going to have all your information
- 55:46in the show notes. I wish you the best
- 55:48of luck. I can't wait to hear about your
- 55:50next book and I'm going to continue
- 55:52looking at the other book that you just
- 55:54finished. I think it's great.
- 55:57Thank you so much for being here today.
- 55:59I appreciate Thank you so much. It's
- 56:00been delightful to talk to you.
- 56:01>> Oh, thank you so much.