Latest / Politics with Paul / How Can We Restore Trust in Political Institutions? w/ Sherman Tylawsky | Politics with Paul #107
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08Today is another guest episode, and those always get a disclaimer that I do not take a
- 0:12stance for or against a guest's political views or people they support, but the topics are
- 0:17always something that anybody of any political persuasion can get something out of.
- 0:23Decreasing trust in our political institutions, which can include anything like entities such
- 0:28as the supreme court, rules like the legislative process, systems like how we vote,
- 0:33pose a major challenge to the legitimacy of our political system.
- 0:38And when you have declining trust, you have more apathy, anger, strife, sometimes even
- 0:44violence.
- 0:45And that faith in our political system's ability to solve problems may even be at the
- 0:50lowest it has ever been.
- 0:52So how do we restore that trust, and how do we get people to understand the importance of
- 0:57trust in political institutions, however flawed they may be?
- 1:02Well, that's what today's guest, Sherman Tylovsky, is here to discuss.
- 1:06Sherman is the founder of the George Washington Institute, which states that its mission is,
- 1:11quote, to provide hands on nonpartisan civic leadership skills for citizens, end quote, and
- 1:16the host of the Friends and Fellow Citizen Podcast, which moderates civil discussions
- 1:21about current events and connects American history with contemporary issues.
- 1:27And his experience also includes working on political campaigns, interning on Capitol Hill,
- 1:32and giving a TED talk.
- 1:33So let's get some insights on political institutions and how we can fix the broken
- 1:39trust we see today.
- 1:40Please welcome Sherman Tylofsky to the show.
- 1:43Sherman, thanks for coming on.
- 1:44How are you?
- 1:45Well, Paul, hello, everybody.
- 1:47Thank you so much for having me on the podcast today.
- 1:49Yeah.
- 1:50No.
- 1:50Absolutely.
- 1:51So I always start with guests by going back to the genesis of their work and involvement in
- 1:57the topic at hand.
- 1:58So before all of this with the institute and and what you're doing now, what initially got
- 2:03you into this arena of political institutions and the trust in them, and why is it so
- 2:08important to you?
- 2:10Of course.
- 2:11Well, I think with anything, there's always a series of events that occurred in your
- 2:17childhood growing up that influenced you, and it'll be the same for me.
- 2:23Growing up, my mother is a first generation immigrant from Taiwan.
- 2:28She came here to study music and met my dad.
- 2:32My dad is originally from New York.
- 2:33He was a sailor for many years.
- 2:36He was a ship captain often at sea, but then was able to become a maritime pilot.
- 2:42And growing up, I I was always interested in how institutions operate because in many ways,
- 2:50the way I grew up was a combination of very different institutions that produced who I
- 2:56would be later in life and up to today and beyond.
- 3:00And I'll I'll start with the fact that my mom is Buddhist.
- 3:04She's from Taiwan, as I mentioned.
- 3:06My dad is of Orthodox Christian faith and is, of course, from the East Coast and grew up in
- 3:13Florida and Upstate New York.
- 3:15And so, there there already, when I was a kid, I was exposed to a lot of internationalism, you
- 3:22could say.
- 3:22Growing up in San Francisco, and with a place like that, you know, there's all different
- 3:27kinds of ways you can interact with people.
- 3:31And, you know, when I started getting into politics, so that's when I really started
- 3:35getting myself exposed to institutions such as media.
- 3:38I remember when I was in high school, I had my first New York Times subscription and
- 3:44subscribed to The Wall Street Journal just to see what what was out there, see what it was
- 3:49like to report about the news and how I was consuming that, which, you know, in that
- 3:54development phase is you're still figuring out a lot of things.
- 3:57But I eventually really started getting into into politics because in part because of my
- 4:03background growing up to speaking in two or three different languages, and I wanted to see
- 4:09the world for a bit for myself.
- 4:11And so it's really a series of things, and I'm happy to get more into those, integrate those
- 4:15in the conversation as we go.
- 4:17But I was able to do things such as run a congressional campaign earlier this year for
- 4:24the 2nd Congressional District in Nevada.
- 4:27That's interning in congress a couple of times and as well as with for Think Tank.
- 4:32And, of course, myself, I'm currently a doctoral candidate at the University of Alabama
- 4:36studying political science, and it's all about institutions and foreign policy and all about
- 4:42China and Taiwan policy as well.
- 4:44So just a bit of introduction there.
- 4:46As you can tell, institutions have been a huge fascination for me since I was a kid, and
- 4:51looking forward to just talking more about this today.
- 4:54It's a very eclectic background, especially, you know, coming from your your mom being from
- 4:59Taiwan, and it it is interesting to get the obviously, when you grow up here and and you're
- 5:06so politically socialized here, it's it's one thing.
- 5:09But when you're coming from somewhere completely different and getting the the
- 5:13perspective from that has always been fascinating.
- 5:16I don't I don't quite have that.
- 5:17I think I'm I wanna say I'm like fourth or fifth generation, so I don't quite have that
- 5:21perspective, but it's still very interesting to see how people shape that, especially from
- 5:27countries like Taiwan.
- 5:28But you're the founder of the George Washington Institute, and I briefly described what it does
- 5:33in the intro, but I want you to talk about it in your own words.
- 5:36Why did you establish the institute?
- 5:39What does it do, and what can people get out of checking it out?
- 5:44First of all, I think George Washington is the best president.
- 5:47So I'm sorry to all the past, presidents, and current, and future presidents out there.
- 5:53They'll they'll never be number one in my mind.
- 5:55I think George Washington represents much of what America is, even what what it was back
- 6:00then and what it is today in many ways.
- 6:03So that's the first phase.
- 6:04So it's kinda more of a it's a bit of a fandom element there.
- 6:07But the the important part of George Washington Institute, as you stated, Paul, which is it's
- 6:13really about preparing civic skills.
- 6:16And, you know, mainly, it's a speaking platform.
- 6:18I call it civics platform because the main part, of course, is the podcast, friends and
- 6:22fellow citizens, which is the first four words of George Washington's farewell address when he
- 6:28departs the White House after two terms.
- 6:31And I I remember reading a book about it back in when I was at Texas a and m for my master's,
- 6:36and I was just really fascinated about the practicability and the applicability of that
- 6:43speech, given that it's not a legal document as we would understand with the constitution.
- 6:47Also, it was not something like the declaration of independence.
- 6:49It was more aspirational, kinda more of the the foundational principles.
- 6:53This was very much a speech that is based on Washington's successes, but also failures in a
- 7:00lot of ways of learning about the president.
- 7:02If you're the first president of The United States, you're bound to learn something about
- 7:05what the American presidency is, and that certainly helped define it too.
- 7:10That's what I wanted to do with the podcast and ultimately, with the George Washington
- 7:14Institute.
- 7:14So it's it's mainly, as I mentioned, speaking platform that is all about passing on skills
- 7:21and ideas, really developing that bridge between Washington, the the founding the
- 7:28founding fathers, and the farewell address, that era of American history, bridging that
- 7:34with today and with policy making and institutions.
- 7:37And so it's very much on what those critical fundamentals are, what we can learn from
- 7:44history, and how everyday citizens can participate.
- 7:47And so there there really is a specific element there.
- 7:50I I always highlight the farewell address, but we we're we're so incredibly blessed that we
- 7:56hit 200 episodes a few months ago, and it's a combination of interviews with people from all
- 8:02different backgrounds who are sharing how they can relate to the values of the farewell
- 8:08address, whether that be patriotism, civility, fiscal responsibility, and others.
- 8:14And just to have those those conversations at a time when I do think a lot of people are
- 8:20longing for authenticity, and they're longing for the these kinds of conversation, long form
- 8:26conversations that you, Paul, have done for many episodes.
- 8:29This is on how we get to a better place in our civics, and I'm just really blessed that there
- 8:35are these opportunities to to put together a a platform that can really benefit all kinds of
- 8:43people, and just looking forward to expand that in different ways in the future, and there's
- 8:48plans in the future.
- 8:50But the point is to always go back to the fundamentals of who we are as a nation and what
- 8:54we
- 8:54can do to improve our country.
- 8:57Well, congratulations on the 200 episodes, first of all.
- 9:00And I just eclipsed a 100 episodes on this podcast about well well, actually, right right
- 9:06around July 4.
- 9:07It was a very auspicious timing that I did not plan, but
- 9:11Congratulations.
- 9:13You'll hit two you can hit 200.
- 9:15Thank you.
- 9:15Thank you.
- 9:16But I I always, you know, I always appreciate any anything that's trying to improve civics in
- 9:21this country and from a nonpartisan standpoint.
- 9:25And I I think one of the big things with me, obviously, of course, the state of civics in
- 9:32this country.
- 9:32And in some ways, it's improving, but it still has a long way to go.
- 9:35And I think one of those things is that adult continuing education.
- 9:39You know, once people are out of school, all of a sudden, there's not there's not a whole lot,
- 9:44it feels like, for adults to really try to hone in on civics even if they really want to.
- 9:50So this is a neat resource to to to have for that and just any anything that's that's out to
- 9:58improve civics.
- 9:59And, you know, you talk about the fundamentals, and sometimes even those of us who are in this
- 10:03kind of work for a living, sometimes we forget the fundamentals, and we have to, you know, go
- 10:07back to it or like how I'm I'm a sports guy.
- 10:09A lot of times, you gotta practice the fundamentals in sports.
- 10:12It it's it's it's something that anything or something that anybody can get something out
- 10:17of.
- 10:18But now for the crux of this discussion.
- 10:20So let's dive into the specifics about what we're talk here to talk about today, this lack
- 10:24of trust in political institutions.
- 10:27How much of this lack of trust is understandable or maybe even justified in your
- 10:32view, and how much would you say is based on misunderstandings or a lack of knowledge about
- 10:36how these institutions work?
- 10:39That's a great question, Paul.
- 10:40Let me start with a sports analogy since you brought up sports.
- 10:44I love sports as well.
- 10:45I recently read this book.
- 10:47It was sometime last year.
- 10:49It was about coach Nick Saban, who is arguably the best college football coach in history of
- 10:56the sport.
- 10:57And he wrote a book about leadership.
- 10:59Gosh.
- 10:59It must have been twenty plus years ago of the back I mean, this was back in the time when he
- 11:04was coaching LSU.
- 11:05But he he talked a lot about the fundamentals, right, of the sport.
- 11:10And one of the things he often reiterated is you can't look at the scoreboard.
- 11:16Right?
- 11:16Because we like to I think, generally, like to think that is there a scoreboard of some kind
- 11:21that we can see, we can track, and see how our institutions are performing?
- 11:26Well, obviously, there's a range of ways you can measure an institution's effectiveness.
- 11:30So the fact that there isn't even one agreed scoreboard if you like, that is is gonna pose a
- 11:35challenge.
- 11:36So what is it that you have to to do?
- 11:38And so I think going to to what Seymour's talking about, he said he always told his team,
- 11:42he said, focus on getting that first down.
- 11:45You know?
- 11:46It doesn't matter what the last play was.
- 11:48You've got to focus on what you need to do, and you've got to advance that ball.
- 11:53It doesn't matter if you think your other teammates messed up or something.
- 11:58You you gotta just focus on what you need to do.
- 12:00And I think that's very much related to this question because I would say for the lack of
- 12:06trust element, it I would say it's a combination of both, but I was probably more on
- 12:12the side of the misunderstanding, the lack of knowledge among leaders and citizenry.
- 12:17I think it's important to know that just just to set aside the finger pointing that can be
- 12:22very, very prevalent in our society today, there there is a responsibility for everybody.
- 12:28I think that's the one of the core parts of civics, right, is that it really it's about the
- 12:33people.
- 12:33And, you know, James Madison once has said that the advancement and diffusion of knowledge is
- 12:41the only guardian of true liberty.
- 12:44And Jefferson also talked about the importance of an informed citizenry.
- 12:49And so I think education really is a big part of this, or lack of education is is really,
- 12:54really key.
- 12:55Well, one of the things Paul like to share is going back to the lack of trust element.
- 12:59I I think lack of trust does stem from the fact that there it misunderstands because there is
- 13:07an expectation that government or certain levels of government are supposed to solve
- 13:13every single problem out there.
- 13:15I'll give you an example with the campaign I ran for c D two.
- 13:19One of the things that is interesting is that you're not just running a campaign as a
- 13:24congressional candidate, as if congress is the only thing that was on the ballot.
- 13:29You're going to events where you have people who are running for district attorney, running
- 13:34for county commission, or for, you know, dog catcher, or whatever the position is.
- 13:39Right?
- 13:39There's there's a low bunch of local and state positions that people are running for.
- 13:45And one of the things I always emphasized in my campaign is, I always emphasized this idea,
- 13:51particularly when there were issues that related to institutions, so it could be like
- 13:56education, it could be civics, all is the willingness to work alongside people who are
- 14:02elected in local and state positions.
- 14:05I think it's so important to remind people that as part of civics education, we have this
- 14:10system of federalism in our country.
- 14:13And so, there education, when I say education, it's not just about what we learn in school
- 14:18about the textbooks and all.
- 14:20It's about what people who are in politics, how they're communicating to the people.
- 14:26And so, there really is that, going back to the advancement and diffusion of knowledge, I think
- 14:31that lack of trust really is is this lack of diffusion.
- 14:34Right?
- 14:34And I think you can go into areas like socialization.
- 14:39You know, what what does socialization look like, particularly nowadays with social media
- 14:44and all?
- 14:45So there's there's always a need, right, to question authority.
- 14:49I do think that lack of trust sometimes can mean that we we shouldn't have any we should
- 14:54have complete trust in institutions.
- 14:57Obviously, it's never gonna happen.
- 14:58It's not healthy.
- 14:59I think we we need to consistently question authority, but we do need to have those
- 15:05elements of civility, of respect, but also that energy too.
- 15:09Right?
- 15:09The energy to argue for your position and to and to have an open mind and to put yourself
- 15:17out there and realize that, you know what, part of maybe part of this misunderstanding, lack of
- 15:21knowledge is also on my part.
- 15:23And just having that humility, having that ability to go out there and to share with
- 15:27people that you have much more to learn, I do think is a virtue in and of itself.
- 15:32Yeah.
- 15:33I I usually take the approach of and and I I think a lot of those are very good points.
- 15:38I I think part of it is just or when it comes to these kinds of either or situations, they're
- 15:44always like, well Mhmm.
- 15:46We can take a little bit of both.
- 15:47I mean, some of this lack of trust is understandable just because of regardless of
- 15:52political views, people who have occupied these institutions have sometimes either overstepped
- 15:57their bounds or they've just not listened to outside voices.
- 16:01They've they've just thought they think that they've got everything figured out.
- 16:05And I think that goes to a an aspect that often gets overlooked, especially in international
- 16:13context is the people and the institution are not the same thing.
- 16:19The people who occupy these institutions is not the same thing as the institution.
- 16:23Like, everybody hates congress pretty much, it it feels like.
- 16:27And certainly, I have my own frustrations with them time and time again, but you need that
- 16:33institution.
- 16:34Or like how in the international context, you know, a lot of times people talk about how much
- 16:38they hate a specific country was no.
- 16:41It's the country's government that's the issue.
- 16:44Oh, and and a lot of times when you say that that that country's government can use that as
- 16:49some sort of propaganda to say, oh, see how much that they hate you because they the
- 16:53government tries to make the people think that they're one and the same with the government,
- 16:58and it's there needs to be some level of separation between those two things.
- 17:03But and and it's something else that you you touched on too is, you know, a lot of people
- 17:08aren't really going to the right places for info, and part of that is they just haven't
- 17:12been taught well where to find the info.
- 17:14Some of it is just people just want to find things that confirm what they already believe.
- 17:19And also, just government in general is unfortunately very opaque and inaccessible in
- 17:25this country, and there's just obviously, there's just so much that we can do to improve
- 17:30upon that.
- 17:31But something that also just to clear up some things that people may have a misunderstanding
- 17:39of is just this in politics, obviously, how you define words matters, and people can try to
- 17:45twist words to mean things that they want.
- 17:47But when it comes to political institutions specifically, do you think that there's a
- 17:51difference between respect and trust?
- 17:54Whether somebody can somebody respect an institution but not trust it or vice versa?
- 17:59And then there's so there's this disconnect where people aren't necessarily on the same
- 18:04page with somebody, like, one of us saying that we should have some level of respect of these
- 18:08institutions.
- 18:09Is is do you think there there's an disconnect there?
- 18:12That's a great question, Paul.
- 18:14And I wanna touch upon real quick what you said too about this difference between government
- 18:18and people.
- 18:19And it it's just written so clearly on the constitution, we the people, not we in this in
- 18:25the institutions.
- 18:26Obviously, the people are are going to be a a very big role for institutions, but I I think I
- 18:32agree with you.
- 18:32I think even as we talk about institutions, it does always go back to the people because that
- 18:38the people are the the ones whom institutions should be serving.
- 18:43So, I just wanna bring that point there.
- 18:46I I think that question about trust and respect is is really key because I I think the biggest
- 18:52thing difference there is not practical, but it's more on the emotional difference there.
- 18:57And and I I just think of, for example, on trust.
- 19:02Trust relies on some element of submission, if you like.
- 19:07Like, as as in you kinda give a part of yourself or some element of yourself to
- 19:13someone.
- 19:14I I just think, like, probably there's a reason why we say, in God we trust, not in God we
- 19:18respect.
- 19:19I think trust is a much stronger term in that that faith, right, in that that deep
- 19:25understanding and deep appreciation and love for for something.
- 19:30So I think trust is one aspect.
- 19:33Respect, on the other hand, I think is more on the practical side, and it it definitely is
- 19:38used a lot more loosely as a term as well, because you might see at times when people say,
- 19:43oh, I I respect the results, or I respect this.
- 19:45And sometimes people are genuine in that they they do respect.
- 19:49They they might not like it, but they they respect.
- 19:52They have some element of recognition, right, and of giving that person or that result or
- 19:58whatever credibility.
- 20:00And so, respecting can be thrown around.
- 20:02There's some people who might say they say it because they just they feel like they have to
- 20:05they have to say it, but they really, really don't like how something has occurred.
- 20:09So I I do think there's there's that emotional difference there.
- 20:12What I would also say though is, I guess, maybe it's a combination of these two, which is I do
- 20:18think both are much needed in institutions because trust is and again, I like I mentioned,
- 20:26more of the emotional tone there.
- 20:29I I don't think that it's entirely a good thing, and very much a good thing to trust an
- 20:36institution fully because you know that institutions can come and have people who come
- 20:41and go.
- 20:42Right?
- 20:42And so is there is is it does it really lend to the the emotional weight of it to to say you
- 20:50trust something trust something.
- 20:52I think we need to trust people who really who do believe in us, right, or people who are
- 20:58entities that really have that meaning, right, whether that be a higher power, that be family,
- 21:04friends.
- 21:04Right?
- 21:04Respect on the I I think is also important too, because there should be a lot of things that
- 21:09we're not going to like about institutions.
- 21:11Right?
- 21:12There you could be maybe someone who is a civil servant in administration.
- 21:17That's a good example.
- 21:18A civil servant, and you serve no matter who's in office.
- 21:22And you might not like the policy, you might not like the way that things are done, but if
- 21:29you have that respect for the institution, you're going to carry it out.
- 21:31You're gonna carry out to the best of your ability for the interest of who of the the
- 21:36country.
- 21:36So there there's that element too.
- 21:39I I always think too that, you know, a bit I remember going to when I go to these museums,
- 21:44you know, the museums always have interesting people there because they talk about artifacts
- 21:50and what they treasure as and they look at themselves as stewards, not owners of
- 21:55something.
- 21:55And I think that it really relates to institutions because when you're a steward,
- 21:59right, you might not like every single thing about an institution, but you understand the
- 22:06significance to posterity.
- 22:07You understand that you are temporarily there.
- 22:10You never can own an institution.
- 22:12You have to run like a relay race, and then to pass that on.
- 22:17So just combining trust and respect, I think having some element of those two is important
- 22:24for institutions, but I do think it does depend on how we relate to to them.
- 22:30And perhaps, maybe a bit more on to the ones who are closer to us, I think trust would be
- 22:36a better word for those.
- 22:39I you you've kinda touched on it several times already, but I I think it it bears repeating is
- 22:46this idea that we should never when it comes to anything in politics, you shouldn't I don't
- 22:52think you should ever be unthinkingly supportive of it.
- 22:56Or, I mean, if you at least if you do fully support it, at least, you know, think things
- 23:00through.
- 23:00But at the same time, if you're just constantly critical of it, then it might just also be a
- 23:06knee jerk reaction.
- 23:07But you you you touch on another thing, this difference between the emotional and the
- 23:15practical for lack of a better term.
- 23:17Just like with trust and respect, how you need both, you need both the emotional and the
- 23:23practicality.
- 23:24You you can't be governed too much by the emotional side or otherwise, you're know, it
- 23:29leads to not really well informed decisions.
- 23:31But also, if you don't have any sort of emotion, then it's just very cold and
- 23:36emotionless, and and and that's not some the way that politics should work either.
- 23:41There should be some level of that human element to it.
- 23:44So, of course, not every institution has the same level of trust or distrust.
- 23:50What are a couple of institutions that you think are still well regarded and a couple that
- 23:55are particularly maligned?
- 23:56And if if you have anything to add about why you think those are the case or what exactly
- 24:02they do to earn or maybe not earn those distinctions, what do you think about that?
- 24:09Absolutely.
- 24:10First of all, when you asked what a couple institutions are well regarded, the fact that
- 24:16the vast majority of Americans, including myself and perhaps yourself as well, Paul, the
- 24:20fact that we struggle to think about the institution, that I think has gotta be an
- 24:26indication of where we are in terms of the institutional decay that we see in many places,
- 24:32not everywhere.
- 24:33And I think you bring up a good point a good question to ask, which ones do do most
- 24:38Americans still regard very well?
- 24:40I I thought of a couple.
- 24:42The first is the military.
- 24:44I think the military as not just an institution for of service, of sacrifice.
- 24:50Obviously, you go to any military, cemetery, and it's it's really a a touching experience.
- 24:57Certainly, I I I don't have to describe it too much because everyone can feel it as part of
- 25:03our our country.
- 25:05And so, I think the military, particularly I'd obviously differ that from, say, the Department
- 25:12of Defense.
- 25:12Right?
- 25:13Because that that's that'd be, in many ways, a different institution in that sense, in terms
- 25:18of that's more on the policy making side.
- 25:20But I think military and veterans, those those those kinds of individuals really do have a lot
- 25:26of respect.
- 25:27The other I I thought of is civic nonprofits.
- 25:30There there are a number of civic organizations, and there's some of them do lean
- 25:34a different way.
- 25:35So I'm not really counting those.
- 25:37I'm talking about the the institutions that really promote some element of, you know,
- 25:43active citizenry.
- 25:44I'm thinking of the National Constitution Center in Philadelphia.
- 25:48I've I've seen some of their content and they and the people there, they they really would
- 25:53just want to promote understanding of the constitution.
- 25:57There's you can go to other museums or other places that are kind of within those lines
- 26:03there.
- 26:04There's even others that might not be explicitly about some element activists or
- 26:09civics, but more so just on providing information.
- 26:12So for example, I'm thinking USA Facts.
- 26:15USA Facts, I I've once had a former CEO of USA Facts on there or operating officer of of that,
- 26:22and it's just very reassuring that there are people who are providing something that isn't
- 26:30maybe the most famous thing out there on social media, but it's just essential.
- 26:34Right?
- 26:34It's essential to know the numbers so that a person in government or in business or wherever
- 26:41can use that data to make informed decisions.
- 26:44So I I'd say those are a couple of the well regarded institutions.
- 26:49I think I'm aligned well, obviously, this is this is more of, like, gosh, how much time do
- 26:53we have on on this podcast?
- 26:55But I'll I'll narrow it down to two that I think are very critical, and ones that
- 27:00desperately need repair.
- 27:02I'm I'm talking, like, five alarm fire kind of repair.
- 27:05The number one institution I'll name is political parties.
- 27:09We have a we have two parties who that really are struggling even among its within itself to
- 27:20to handle broad tent.
- 27:22I'm not saying that having a broad tent is an easy job for any institution, but there are
- 27:28just too many times in my personal experience, and with the experiences of friends and of
- 27:34colleagues of others who feel like is part of it.
- 27:37If you think of that social contract philosophy out there, people feel like they're not getting
- 27:42their money's worth.
- 27:43They feel like they want to be part of the process of voicing their opinions, of
- 27:50volunteering, or whatever it is, and the party's not giving much back.
- 27:53You know, it it goes back to this it's it's a bit like, you know, fans that of historically
- 27:59bad sports teams.
- 28:01It really does feel, and that's not some sense, where people when they see, oh, there's a new
- 28:05season coming up, they don't have high expectations, and they just expect that that's
- 28:10then they're gonna perform badly.
- 28:12And what's worse is that these people, what these sports fans, they imagine how they feel
- 28:17when a historically bad sports team raises ticket prices or ask them, say, come on to the
- 28:23game and come watch us.
- 28:24That's what it kinda feels like with a lot of these with our political parties these days.
- 28:29It does seem like fan bases that have teams that that just, for some reason, choke in very,
- 28:37very strange times.
- 28:40So think think of your think of whatever team it is and whatever sport you can think of who
- 28:45does that.
- 28:46But I I do think there is this inability to govern, inability to resolve factions,
- 28:52inability to relate to a broader electorate.
- 28:56I think that explains why there are numb many many Americans who are independent, who don't
- 29:01wanna be regarded as a party, and both parties don't seem to to get the message.
- 29:06And so that's the first part, first institution there.
- 29:09Second part is congress.
- 29:10There's a very large concern, and you can see that with whether it's be Gallup or other polls
- 29:16that show this low confidence in congress.
- 29:18The fact that congress is competing with cockroaches as in terms of popularity, I think
- 29:24that goes to show that there is a huge disconnect between those who are responsible to
- 29:30govern and those who and and people the people in congress, of course, doesn't seem like
- 29:37they're they're in very interested in government because that's the hardest thing
- 29:40compared to, say, you know, posting something bad about someone in social media, and, of
- 29:45course, that the people who rightly have the high expectations, we need to have high
- 29:50expectations, and yet, congress, it does seem like for many people, including myself and many
- 29:55others, are not immediate to the representation duties that they ought to uphold.
- 30:03And I
- 30:03think with congress in particular, it's it's eve it even more of a pronounced issue than
- 30:10compared to the White House or the supreme court.
- 30:13Because with the White House and supreme court, there's a lot fewer people, and there's and
- 30:18we'll definitely get to this in a moment.
- 30:20There's a partisan and ideological bent to people's perceptions of of those two
- 30:28institutions.
- 30:29Congress, regardless of who controls it, is always in the dumps when it comes to these
- 30:34these this level of respect, approval, trust, whatever word you wanna use to describe it
- 30:39where, you know, there's there's a lot of times, you can barely clear, like, 20%
- 30:46approval.
- 30:46Now whether approval is a little bit different than trust or or respect, it still seems to
- 30:54have a very unique place in terms of maligned institutions.
- 30:59And but you do bring up a good point that, you know, is the crux or part of the crux of this
- 31:04discussion is there are so many institutions that just have such little positive perceptions
- 31:16about them.
- 31:17And it's it's something that is well, I obviously, if if we could if it was easy to
- 31:24solve, we would have already solved it by now, we could solve it with this podcast.
- 31:28But it did something you did mention though is a lot of it is, I think, sometimes there's this
- 31:33lack of self awareness by some of those institutions and realizing, you know, the
- 31:38things that are wrong with them, or they realize that the the public perception, but,
- 31:44you know, the the people who are most active in politics, they're the ones that they're
- 31:48answering to because they're the ones who are having the most impact on elections and so on.
- 31:52But speaking of which, we see partisan and ideological politics permeate so much of our
- 31:58political discussions that it's sometimes hard to separate those genuine feelings about a
- 32:03political institution from what people think about the partisan affiliation of those that
- 32:09occupy the institution or at least the people who put those people in those institutions.
- 32:14So trust can completely flip based on whether that institution flips between being controlled
- 32:20by Democrats or Republicans or between Liberals and Conservatives.
- 32:25How do we deal with that problem of partisan and ideological perception when it comes to
- 32:30trying to restore trust and faith in these institutions?
- 32:33Or at least what's the first step in doing that?
- 32:37That's a great question, Paul.
- 32:38I'll start with what Washington mentioned in the farewell address.
- 32:43He warned about factions.
- 32:45It it is certainly something that anyone after Washington would have known, and then I've just
- 32:51seen the farewell address.
- 32:53So there there is the first step, I think, is to recognize that this is certainly nothing
- 32:57new.
- 32:57And then certainly what you're talking about, Paul, and that you look at take a look at I
- 33:01just looked at the Gallup poll for July of this year twenty twenty six showing that there the
- 33:06party difference on confidence in institutions are at a new high.
- 33:09So we are seeing this this this winding gap.
- 33:13Whether or not that is new is is hard to tell because of the fact that we didn't have Gallup
- 33:20and all those Napoleon or any indicate clear indicators in the early years of our country to
- 33:25show those indifferent as but we can kinda get some sense.
- 33:29I say the first real instance that we see a very, very contentious and huge partisan
- 33:36difference there is election of eighteen hundred, where Jefferson is running against
- 33:41Adams.
- 33:41It is a very, very brutal election, probably one of the most brutal, if not the most brutal
- 33:46election we had just a year after Washington dies.
- 33:49And it's just hard to believe that that there imagine there were a number of people back then
- 33:55who probably were sharing those kinds of concerns about whether or not these
- 33:59institutions could hold.
- 34:01We I can think of, for example, 1876, which was a very contentious election, and you had
- 34:07basically a bipartisan vote.
- 34:10That is how we get Rutherford Hayes as president.
- 34:14And so I just use a couple examples to show that the the first step is recognizing the
- 34:19history.
- 34:20Right?
- 34:20Recognizing that there are times when in in the present day, we we do often like to think think
- 34:27it's very justified for people to to to be scared because history can be very much an
- 34:33unknown.
- 34:33Right?
- 34:34It could be it's it's something that covers years and years, parts is sift through, but
- 34:41there's a responsibility, I think, of civic individuals to to to at least make aware of
- 34:47these these elements there.
- 34:49So I think there's that element there.
- 34:52In terms of dealing with the problem of partisanship, ideological perception, trust,
- 34:57faith, I'd like to highlight a couple things that I think we can at least recognize and
- 35:02perhaps come up with solutions, probably more on the socialization part.
- 35:07So the first thing that has been noticeably different in recent decades is this increase in
- 35:16partisan self selection, which basically means that people are are joining groups or forming
- 35:23these networks that are matching some partisanship, right, some partisan identity.
- 35:29And so you're seeing, for example, urban versus rural, you're seeing young versus old,
- 35:35education attainment, you know, college versus no college.
- 35:38So we're seeing these fault lines within partisanship that is something that really
- 35:45needs to be recognized.
- 35:46Right?
- 35:47And this is where the this is where it does come down to individual choices, but also
- 35:53perhaps within groups of people in across America.
- 35:56Right?
- 35:57Whether that be at in a neighborhood.
- 35:59Right?
- 35:59Instead of people just sorting themselves into Democrats and Republicans.
- 36:04Right?
- 36:04So how about, you know, going out to a baseball game together.
- 36:07Right?
- 36:07Or, you know, to to do the things that to socialize change behaviors that can erode some
- 36:14of these fault lines there and show that, no, people can actively talk about politics.
- 36:20I know that there's that saying that you don't talk about politics or religion and or sex, you
- 36:26know, with strangers, or at least with first encounters, or even just habitually.
- 36:32But I mean, I I do think there's a risk to that.
- 36:35I think there's a risk of people feeling like they're left out, and that they're left out,
- 36:39and they might even resort to more to more of this distrust in institutions.
- 36:44The other component, I think, is Parsons sorting, where the there's an alignment of of
- 36:51attitudes, of ideologies that are kinda coming together, and you get instead of having
- 36:58conservative more conservative Democrats, now you have way more liberal Democrats.
- 37:03And so all the conservatives are gonna probably go to the Republican party, and same with the
- 37:08Republican side.
- 37:09You might have more liberal Republicans or centrist Republicans who are now saying that
- 37:14I'm identifying more with the Democrat party.
- 37:17So that, I think, is gonna be a huge risk because even as political parties struggle,
- 37:22when you have this alignment, it kinda rewards parties for being partisan, if that makes
- 37:28sense.
- 37:28And so the the part of the solutions, I think, is to, first of all, realize that maybe
- 37:35ideology, at least in my opinion, ideology needs to have less importance there.
- 37:42I think we need do need to move towards how people can be involved in institutions.
- 37:47Right?
- 37:47Because ideology is very fixed.
- 37:49It is I mean, it's certainly important.
- 37:51Right?
- 37:51You have an ideology.
- 37:52I have an ideology.
- 37:53But the ideology component really, I don't think, extends very well with with how we talk
- 38:01politics, because people might not know what the difference between liberals and
- 38:05conservatives.
- 38:05People might not realize that you and me me we might have differences on how we see certain
- 38:12issues, and it's not fair to you or to me to categorize each other in certain boxes.
- 38:18So it's it's the combination of getting out of these fault lines here, and I say it really
- 38:25comes down to the fundamentals.
- 38:26It comes down to fundamentals on the local level on how you approach strangers, how you
- 38:32you communicate with, I don't know, fellow students in class, or how or maybe the fact
- 38:37that you need to, when you're with a partisan organization, maybe do something together with
- 38:44the other partisan organization as we've seen at times with college campuses.
- 38:48So lots lots to talk about there, but it really does come down to how we make those choices and
- 38:55how we decide to socialize and how we decide to under to spend time with our fellow citizens.
- 39:03Well, there's a lot to get there, but all definitely good points about about those
- 39:08things. I
- 39:09I and one of the things you brought up was and something that I try to bring up often whenever
- 39:14anything comes to polarization or any of my discussions come to polarization is that it has
- 39:20always been there.
- 39:21Like you said, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, Federalists and Democratic Republicans going at
- 39:27it in 1876, of course.
- 39:29And during Reconstruction or leading to the end of Reconstruction, we had a civil war that
- 39:34broke the country in two.
- 39:35Or you you mentioned the urban and rural divide.
- 39:38You you can arguably trace that back to 1896 with William McKinley and William Jennings
- 39:45Bryan going for the presidency.
- 39:48And it's a simultaneously depressing yet also strangely kind of heartwarming fact that is
- 39:56this that, jeez, we're always at odds, but at the same time is look how far we've come
- 40:01despite being at all these odds.
- 40:04But something you another thing you brought up was that that partisan sorting, and and there's
- 40:11some of that debate between people who think that it's more people are just becoming more
- 40:16polarized and isn't and some people are saying, no.
- 40:19It's not being polarized.
- 40:20It's just that they're being more sorted, but I feel like that's a little bit disingenuous.
- 40:25I think your sort sorting by definition becomes more ID or polarized.
- 40:30The parties are becoming more polarized.
- 40:32And like you said, we all have an ideology, and it's important.
- 40:35There's nothing wrong with having an ideology.
- 40:37It's that rigidity and the lack of being able to step outside that worldview is that problem.
- 40:44And you do need a place to talk about politics.
- 40:47There's obviously a time and a place for it.
- 40:49You shouldn't just be able to just you shouldn't just talk about it, like, at any
- 40:52point in time.
- 40:53But like you said, a lot of people do just generally feel left out because they feel like
- 40:59they're not supposed to say anything, and then it just leads them a lot of times to eventually
- 41:04lash out.
- 41:05So for the next question, how much of an impact would improving civics education have on
- 41:10respect and trust in our political institutions?
- 41:12And what are a few things about civics that would need to change to make that happen?
- 41:18And do you do you think that civics itself is a political institution that has a problem with
- 41:24trust and respect?
- 41:27I'll I'll start with a quote that is always wrongly attributed to Benjamin Franklin for
- 41:32some reason.
- 41:32It seems like a lot of quotes are wrongly attributed to Franklin.
- 41:35And so but I I found that it was it's actually from a Chinese philosopher.
- 41:40And the quote is, show me and I forget, teach me and I remember, involve me and I learn.
- 41:49Those three degrees of education, there there's a combination there that I think are important,
- 41:57but I I really wanna emphasize that last part.
- 41:59Involve me and I learn.
- 42:01And civics education really does play that huge role of respect and trust because it it is
- 42:08practical.
- 42:09You you can't can't really fake civics.
- 42:12I mean, of course, people can go around and say, oh, I know about civics or I'm very
- 42:16involved and all.
- 42:17But but in terms of civics, you you have to do a lot of things.
- 42:19Right?
- 42:20And and I think that's where civics needs to be more practical and more relatable to how
- 42:27politics changes as well.
- 42:28And I think there's there are times when we might feel like and and it's understandable
- 42:33that certain people have said, traditionally, it's always worked this way and all.
- 42:38And believe me, there are a lot of basic elements of just like, for example, talking
- 42:43about politics in person that that is a core element.
- 42:46But what are some other creative ways that we can make civics a bit more practical?
- 42:51I think part of it is, I think, podcasts.
- 42:53Right?
- 42:53Podcasts in recent years, I'm really glad that there's been an interest in podcast because
- 43:00it's long form content in the age of social media, which I think is really, really
- 43:05fascinating.
- 43:06And so bringing some of this creativity, right, involving people, I think is is the first step
- 43:11there.
- 43:12One of the things that I I I'm disturbed by on so with social media, it's not just the the
- 43:18algorithms and whatnot.
- 43:20I think it's the fact that social media is trying to undermine a lot of the the role of
- 43:25credentials.
- 43:26I I think, for example, so you just think of whatever it be.
- 43:29It could be right wing or left wing influencers, and what they often do is they
- 43:35they do this history lesson.
- 43:37You know?
- 43:37They're like, oh, let me tell you about the real history of this and that.
- 43:40And here's the problem, is that they have not done any sort of formal training or any sort
- 43:47have any sort of credentials to discuss these issues, and they certainly don't have the
- 43:53incentive to be impartial or to address both sides.
- 43:58And that, I think, is a real, really big problem.
- 44:00I do I do think in within civics education, we we do need to go back to credentials.
- 44:06Now it could be diff difficult because there's also lack of trust in education institutions.
- 44:11Right?
- 44:11And that that certainly is something there.
- 44:13But I I think in terms of, for example, the fact that we that if you were to be an airline
- 44:21pilot, you have to license.
- 44:23You have to have a certain number of flight hours.
- 44:27If you are to become a medical doctor, you need to have an MD, and you need to to show that you
- 44:33have experience.
- 44:34Right?
- 44:34I I think there's a lot of there are a lot of reasons why we need to have some element of
- 44:41credentials, and to and to start, you know, looking at our civics again, and impose impose
- 44:49some some high standards.
- 44:50Now, there's certain ways you can do that, but I think formal education is something where I
- 44:55don't think you can fake.
- 44:56I I mentioned that I'm in a doctoral program.
- 44:59You you can't fake this program.
- 45:00You've got to be able to demonstrate in in a in any sort of program with professors there that
- 45:07you know how to conduct social science.
- 45:10You know how to I get, you know, with some ways, have have a sense of humility as well,
- 45:15knowing that you're not there to change the world and, you know, trying to come up with
- 45:20Sherman's new theory about politics.
- 45:22It's about building on what people have done already, and just returning to this element in
- 45:29civics education, not having to reinvent the wheel, but to to make make that wheel operate
- 45:36indifferently, maybe, kinda instead of just how we maybe think about how something is
- 45:42traditionally used, why not experiment and try new ways to get people involved so that people
- 45:49can see.
- 45:49They can see results.
- 45:51They can see the the impact that they can have on the local community, and perhaps that might
- 45:57get us to a better place, and and perhaps get get people to be part of something again, and
- 46:05to not have to people don't feel like they have to give away their political identity or their
- 46:11votes or whatever to something that they might not care a whole lot about.
- 46:15And it's those those things that I think we need to get back to to get back to trust and
- 46:21respect, which are never received, they are earned.
- 46:26Going back to that quote, I can understand why somebody would say that was Benjamin Franklin.
- 46:30That that's it sounds like an incredibly prescient thing that he would say.
- 46:33But it also made me think of and anybody who's watched several of my previous interviews will
- 46:39be like, oh, goodness.
- 46:40He's gonna bring this up again.
- 46:41But previous guest I had, he talked about the trajectory of civics education because he he he
- 46:50collected a lot of civics or he likes collecting old civics textbooks.
- 46:54And and I'm I say this so much now, and I'm and sometimes I wonder, wait.
- 46:58Am I remembering what he said correctly?
- 47:00So I think think I am.
- 47:02But basically, the idea was that there's been a a a lot of there's been somewhat of a shift
- 47:08from, you know, teaching people their rights and duties as a citizen and involving them as
- 47:14part of our nation's civics and politics and more sort towards sort of simple, like, rote
- 47:20facts of this is how government works and not focusing so much on the citizen's role in
- 47:26politics.
- 47:26And, you know, you're talking about, you know, involving people in something, and they'll
- 47:31learn.
- 47:32I think that's such a you know, there's so much of it is learning by doing instead of just
- 47:38having facts thrown at you.
- 47:40Now, I mean, I love learning about some of these, you know, specific facts, but for a lot
- 47:44of people, there's only so much you can teach it before their eyes glaze over.
- 47:47You have to show them why they should get involved and what benefits they get from being
- 47:51involved and how the system benefits from them being involved.
- 47:55And to the last point you were talking about with these credentials and civics, it it it is
- 48:01something that is maybe one of the most frustrating aspects of political discussion is
- 48:07all these people who have deemed themselves as experts about how all of these things work, how
- 48:12these bills work.
- 48:13And and they and they might they might have some knowledge in those fields, but they're
- 48:18just so tunnel vision biased or they have a vested interest in painting how things work a
- 48:25certain way.
- 48:27And I think you see that not just from people who are regular citizens or, you know, quote
- 48:33unquote influencers or anything like that.
- 48:34I think you see that from government officials too who their idea of civics is like a specific
- 48:40vision that they have.
- 48:41And you see left and right both talk about the other one trying to teach people what to think
- 48:47or what not to think, but yet I think they are very guilty of the same things that they're
- 48:52complaining about.
- 48:53But it it is it is definitely something something I had thought about.
- 48:58I don't know how I'd go about it or if it's even possible.
- 49:01I kind of would like to create some sort of certificate that says like, you know, this
- 49:08person's certified in, you know, civics education or or they know what they're talking
- 49:13about in whatever aspects or division of civics curricula there would be.
- 49:19Now, of course, then it's like, well, what do you put in that curriculum?
- 49:22And then there's obviously that's a whole other discussion, but it it is something where again,
- 49:28it kinda goes back to that whole you know, we're not necessarily looking at people's
- 49:32credentials.
- 49:33We're just or too many people are looking at whether they're hearing something that they're
- 49:38predisposed to agree with as opposed to something that's is like, well, you know what?
- 49:43Let me verify that for myself.
- 49:44Let me let me see people who try to balance balance issues and and viewpoints.
- 49:51And I that's I think that's one of the most important things to address when it comes to
- 49:58improving civics.
- 50:00And so not talking about a specific institution, and it it might be hard to do
- 50:06this, but if you had to convince somebody that was highly distrustful about an institution
- 50:10about the importance of having faith in it, what would you say to them?
- 50:14Or is it not so simple and it's really just a case by case situation depending on what the
- 50:18institution is?
- 50:19You know, Paul, one of the things I always tell people, and some people might find that ironic
- 50:27because I'm studying political science, I've been involved in politics in all ways, but I
- 50:33always tell people that make sure politics is never everything in your life.
- 50:37I I think one of the tragedies of our society today is that we there there are people who
- 50:42have not only just built careers on just being in congress or just in government, but they
- 50:50they think they they are so reluctant to give any of that away because they have effectively
- 50:55made that as part of who they are and all.
- 50:58I I don't think that is a good thing for our society.
- 51:02I I think there's the founders knew that government is important, but there's a reason
- 51:06why they emphasize the belief in the people.
- 51:11Right?
- 51:11The belief belief in it's I I always say that when I was in The UK for for college, one
- 51:19parliament is sovereign over there.
- 51:20So the parliament basically do whatever it wants, and I always thought, gosh, if they were
- 51:25to have a constitution, it'd probably be we the parliament, and nothing against English tea or,
- 51:30you know, the great British people out there, but but that's just that's the parliamentary
- 51:34system.
- 51:34Right?
- 51:34And so I think about how when we say we the people and all, it may seem like a very cliche
- 51:41term, but I think the deeper meaning here is that there needs to be some element of distance
- 51:49between politics, institutions, and our our daily lives.
- 51:53I don't think our we should let institutions dominate everything about what we do.
- 51:59They are incredibly important, but I think that's the starting point because once we if we
- 52:03say, oh gosh, institutions are everything, or we have to get and then usually institutions,
- 52:07people mean, like, political institutions.
- 52:09They mean or government and all.
- 52:11But I think I don't think that's a good road, but I think that's the first thing.
- 52:14The the the second point is, I do think it is case by case, as you brought up with the the
- 52:20question.
- 52:23I go back to this is a really quick story about Washington.
- 52:26He one time, there were some people building something, and there was a corporal basically
- 52:30telling the soldiers, come on, you know, hurry up, you know.
- 52:34Tell basically, everyone but the corporal is doing anything.
- 52:37It and so Washington comes around, and he's like, what's going on?
- 52:41And the corporal's like, I'm just tell I'm telling him what to do.
- 52:43I'm the corporal.
- 52:44Right?
- 52:44This is the kinda way that it should be.
- 52:46And the workers are struggling there, and so Washington's like, okay.
- 52:49I I recognize that you're the corporal.
- 52:51And then he gets off his horse, goes and helps the workers, and they get the job done.
- 52:56And Washington goes back to the corporal and says, if your guys need any help, just let them
- 53:01know that Washington's gonna be there.
- 53:03Yeah.
- 53:04And and it it shows that, you know, with a part of the I think with institutions, we often
- 53:10think that it's all about control.
- 53:11Right?
- 53:12It's all about who's in charge.
- 53:13Right?
- 53:14But as we've seen over the years, every there's a number of people who can play a different
- 53:19role.
- 53:20It's not just the it's not just the president of The United States.
- 53:22It's not just the governor.
- 53:24It's it's the people who make up that institution.
- 53:27It's the culture.
- 53:28It's the it's the ways in which people can uphold really not it's not really the just the
- 53:36written laws, it's the unwritten rules, and it's the norms.
- 53:40And so I think if we look at institutions less as, okay, someone's in charge, so therefore, it
- 53:46kinda feels like it's a one person rule.
- 53:49And if you look at it as it's more of a continuation of unwritten rules and practices,
- 53:56then I think people can have some have a different view of it.
- 53:59And I think the people can realize that, you know what?
- 54:02May maybe there is a way to get involved, but it does take some element of humility, takes
- 54:07some takes a lot of learning.
- 54:09I I can tell you right now, Paul, that I I'm always learning all the time.
- 54:13I and there are times when you do feel like you feel like you don't know much about something.
- 54:17You're always learning about congress, it seems like, or or other institutions.
- 54:22That, I think, is a very key role here.
- 54:25And so I I just hope that if people are distrustful, just know that it certainly
- 54:31happened many times before, and you have an opportunity to maybe not change that
- 54:37institution right away, but you can have some faith in it.
- 54:42And maybe that starts not just faith in other people, but faith in yourself and faith in your
- 54:48the people.
- 54:49I do think that with any society, a society can only thrive if it believes in itself, and it
- 54:56believes in its capabilities.
- 54:57And that, I think, is something we need to remind ourselves, is that we have a lot more
- 55:02capabilities than we might like to think, but it really is within each and every single
- 55:07individual.
- 55:08And I think everyone from that story of of servant leadership, going out there to serve
- 55:15others and not just one ourselves, I think that can that can start something.
- 55:20You never know.
- 55:23Such critical points there, and and the first one you brought up about, you know, how much
- 55:28people's identity is tied up in politics.
- 55:30That was something I I meant to bring up in response to a question that or an answer that
- 55:34you had given before is just there is this disturbing amount of how much people it's not
- 55:41like I'm I'm Joe Schmo, and I happen to be a Republican or I happen to be a Democrat.
- 55:47It's I'm a Democrat, first and foremost.
- 55:49I'm a Republican, first and foremost.
- 55:51I'm an Independent, first and foremost.
- 55:53And it there was I think it was last year, and it might have been national governors Governors
- 55:58Association summit, but Michelle Lujan Grisham from New Mexico, the governor there, and then
- 56:05governor Cox of Utah, he or they both talked about that how, like and I don't I don't know
- 56:12how much of this is just romanticizing the past and how much of it is legit, but there is a
- 56:18certain truth to this idea that when it used to be a lot fewer people that were like their
- 56:26their politics was such a critical part of who they are.
- 56:28It was like, whether they were Republican or Democrat or whatever was maybe, like, item 10
- 56:34to 15 on a list of things they'd use to describe themselves.
- 56:37And now it's so often one or two, maybe three.
- 56:41And it's just not how things should be.
- 56:43It it's important to have that identity, and you shouldn't have that suppressed.
- 56:49It's a first amendment right after all, but at the same time, where it's just leading
- 56:54basically everything you do and you're you're getting in what the people you involve yourself
- 56:59with, whether it's who you're living with, whether who you're dating or getting married
- 57:03to, and and then and and how much of that is being driven by your political views is just
- 57:10it's just a crazy idea to me, and it's it's not how things should be.
- 57:14That's how we come up with all these silos that we never break out of.
- 57:18And the last thing you said about institutions not being about control, I think is a very
- 57:26poignant, for lack of a better term, idea to bring up because there is so much about
- 57:32politics is about winning at all costs.
- 57:34It's a very zero sum thing.
- 57:35But just because you don't control something or your your your people, quote unquote, aren't in
- 57:42control, it doesn't mean that there's nothing you can do.
- 57:44It doesn't mean that there's not some sort of impact you can have.
- 57:48You're not supposed to always win.
- 57:50That's it was deliberately designed this way so that no single faction overtook all of the
- 57:56others.
- 57:57There everybody has to give a little bit of something, and it's the same thing with these
- 58:03institutions.
- 58:04And if you push back enough on these institutions, even if you're not the ones who
- 58:08are running the show, you a lot of times can still make change happen.
- 58:14And, obviously, it's it's a little bit oversimplified, but there's just so much.
- 58:20And not even just in politics, just everywhere, just so much is about you have to win.
- 58:24You have to win.
- 58:25You have to win.
- 58:25And I'm not one to say like, oh, there's moral victories, but at the same time, we can't let
- 58:33our desire to win everything and to try to be successful at everything completely shatter our
- 58:42how we interact with people and to bog down the system and make it worse.
- 58:50And so I think that's a really great final point you brought up there.
- 58:53So we are running up on time, so I want to ask one final question for you.
- 58:59The every time I haven't for those who are new or returning, I always end guest interviews
- 59:04with a random question of the day.
- 59:06It's nonpolitical, or if it is political, it's it's it's still meant to be fun and not not
- 59:11super serious.
- 59:12So, Sherman, for you, today's random question of the day is, you get to ban one word from the
- 59:19English language.
- 59:20It can't ever be uttered again.
- 59:21Any attempts to say are just silent.
- 59:23What is that word you are banning?
- 59:26Or what is a word that you would ban?
- 59:29Ban.
- 59:29Oh, man.
- 59:30That's that that's a really good one.
- 59:32Gosh.
- 59:33I I I'd say gosh.
- 59:37I gotta say I don't I don't know.
- 59:39I I just have a pet peeve for this sword, but it's called it's surely.
- 59:44Like like, I don't know why, but, like, every time someone says, surely, you must know or
- 59:48surely this or that, and I'm like, maybe it's maybe I should ban it because I would think
- 59:54that after watching the movie airplane Surely can't be serious.
- 59:58Know, Shirley.
- 59:59It's like it's like maybe to all the Shirley's out there, we'll just ban that word, and that
- 1:00:03way Shirley is just a name.
- 1:00:05That's the only name out there.
- 1:00:07I I don't know.
- 1:00:08I I just think they're they're just sometimes words or phrases that people use, and it's
- 1:00:13like, I I don't I don't is that is that really necessary of a word?
- 1:00:17So I'll just I'll just leave that.
- 1:00:19So shout out to Airplane as the inspiration for that.
- 1:00:23To to just to just to resolve any confusion about the English language.
- 1:00:27That's all.
- 1:00:28I wouldn't say I use that word a whole lot, but it's hey.
- 1:00:31Some some words are just just annoying just because.
- 1:00:34There's not not necessarily a rhyme or reason.
- 1:00:35Now this one definitely has a reason.
- 1:00:37I would absolutely ban the word literally.
- 1:00:40I would literally ban the word literally.
- 1:00:42I and it it's it's it's not because people use it incorrectly.
- 1:00:47Like, a lot of that is on purpose.
- 1:00:49It's meant to be hyperbolic.
- 1:00:51My problem with it is not that.
- 1:00:54My problem is when people use it, and it's just completely unnecessary to use.
- 1:00:58Like when people say, I would I literally took two steps to do something like, why do you need
- 1:01:04to say that?
- 1:01:05There's no you that's a completely unnecessary amplifier, and it just gets thrown into
- 1:01:13basically, like, every conversation.
- 1:01:15I see it everywhere, and it just I I'm I'm so sick of the word.
- 1:01:20My first order of business become world dictator is to is the word literally cannot be
- 1:01:25uttered ever again.
- 1:01:27I mean, talk about talk about, like, a sort imagine politicians using that.
- 1:01:31It's like, I I literally did this.
- 1:01:33Oh my gosh.
- 1:01:34Like, talk about something that would erode trust in in an institution.
- 1:01:39Instantly never getting my vote if you do that.
- 1:01:42Never happening.
- 1:01:43I I don't care if I agree with 99% of your platform.
- 1:01:47If you say that word, I'm done with you.
- 1:01:49But thank you, Sherman, for so much for being on the show before we wrap up.
- 1:01:54Any other obviously, I'll put the George Washington Institute in the show notes.
- 1:01:57Any other links you'd like to share?
- 1:02:02Thank you so much again, Paul, for having me.
- 1:02:04Great conversation.
- 1:02:05I appreciate what you do with with the show, keeping it civil, keeping it active, and all.
- 1:02:10I'll also just say, look up friends and fellow citizens.
- 1:02:13It's available on any podcast app, and we're also on YouTube as well.
- 1:02:17So just just type in those four words, Washington's farewell address.
- 1:02:20You'll get the show.
- 1:02:22And, of course, georgewashingtoninstitute.org.
- 1:02:24We're also on Facebook as well for our Facebook page with updates and all.
- 1:02:29So, Paul, again, thank you so much for this opportunity.
- 1:02:32I really appreciated our conversation today.
- 1:02:34Absolutely.
- 1:02:34Thank you for being on here.
- 1:02:35So I will include all those links.
- 1:02:37I'll put those links in the show notes and then for my show notes, my other works, my five day
- 1:02:41educational email course about how we can better mitigate toxicity and polarization and
- 1:02:46and how the the five of the big mistakes that we make in that regard and how we can fix
- 1:02:51those.
- 1:02:51My book on Amazon about political independence and why they rarely win elections and how they
- 1:02:57might become more competitive.
- 1:02:59The my work on medium.com, which I write on from time to time, then my other links, my
- 1:03:04LinkedIn, facebook.com page, and my website, paulraider.org, and my email, Paul Raider
- 1:03:10writes at Gmail dot com.
- 1:03:12But that will end things here for today's episode.
- 1:03:15As always, thank you so much for listening and watching, and we'll see you next time.