Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q3] Netflix's Risky Sixty Billion Dollar Bet
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today, we're looking at a
- 0:02company that is, I mean, basically synonymous with
- 0:06entertainment itself. Netflix, Yeah.
- 0:08For years they really define streaming.
- 0:10I set the pace for everything. But you know, when you actually
- 0:13dig into this new financial research report from late 2025,
- 0:17you realize something fundamental is happening.
- 0:20We're not looking at the same company anymore.
- 0:22Not at all. And that's why we really need to
- 0:24do this deep dive. The Netflix we all thought we
- 0:27knew is making this monumental, almost shocking pivot.
- 0:32It's moving from being, you know, a pretty capital efficient
- 0:35Silicon Valley tech company. Right focused on innovation,
- 0:38profitable growth. Exactly.
- 0:40And now it's becoming this massive debt leveraged media
- 0:43conglomerate. The whole game has changed.
- 0:45The risk profile is completely different and for you, the
- 0:48listener, understanding the shift is just, it's essential.
- 0:51So OK, let's unpack this whole thing.
- 0:53Let's do it. You're really sitting at the
- 0:54collision point of these two massive forces.
- 0:57On one hand, you have Netflix's incredible operational maturity.
- 1:02Right. The years of scale, the
- 1:03efficiency. Yeah, it's finally printing
- 1:05cash. Massive cash flow, yeah.
- 1:07But on the other hand, you have this incredibly disruptive,
- 1:10incredibly risky $82.7 billion acquisition of Warner Bros
- 1:16Discovery, WBD, WBD. So our mission today is pretty
- 1:20simple, but it's critical. Using this research, we need to
- 1:24figure out if Netflix is still a wonderful company, which you
- 1:27know historically it has been, and if it's current stock price
- 1:30and this newly levered balance sheet, if they still justify
- 1:33that title, we have to weigh the quality of the business against
- 1:37the the cost and the new financial risk.
- 1:40Just to give everyone a sense of the scale here, let's start with
- 1:42a headline number from Q32025. Consolidated revenues hit an
- 1:46enormous $11.51 billion. Just massive.
- 1:50And that's not just, you know, marginal growth, that's a robust
- 1:5317% year over year increase. It tells you right away the core
- 1:57business is absolutely firing on all cylinders.
- 1:59It is. And before we dive into the
- 2:01fascinating details behind that number, a quick, but you know,
- 2:04very critical note. We're guiding you through a
- 2:06pretty detailed financial report today.
- 2:09All the analysis, all the figures we're talking about,
- 2:11they're derived from publicly available sources.
- 2:14And this is really just for educational purposes, right?
- 2:16So we have to be absolutely clear, this deep dive is not
- 2:20investment advice. We really urge you, the
- 2:22listener, to conduct your own due diligence.
- 2:25Talk to a licensed professional before you make any decisions.
- 2:28Of course. OK.
- 2:29Now let's talk about those revenues.
- 2:32Let's start with that operational story in Q3.
- 2:35Yeah, that 11.51 billion in revenue wasn't just a big
- 2:40number, it perfectly confirmed what management had been guiding
- 2:44for. Yeah, they nailed.
- 2:45It it signalled that their two big strategic moves, cracking
- 2:48down on page sharing and rolling out the advertising tier, are
- 2:51really working. They're diversifying away from
- 2:53just relying on premium subscriptions.
- 2:55And that is a fundamentally strong story.
- 2:58The top line is just, it's undeniable proof of their scale
- 3:01and their pricing power. But if we look at the bottom
- 3:04line, the profits, the quarter had this really fascinating
- 3:08piece of financial friction. The company reported diluted
- 3:12earnings per share, or EPS, of $5.87.
- 3:17OK. And that number fell a little
- 3:18short of the analyst consensus, which was 594.
- 3:21It did, but more critically, it missed the company's own
- 3:24internal forecast by about a dollar per share.
- 3:27A dollar. When a company the size of
- 3:29Netflix misses its own internal numbers by that much, the market
- 3:33usually freaks out. Usually, but in this case the
- 3:35reason for the miss was so specific and probably I'd
- 3:39imagine, very frustrating for management.
- 3:41Why? What was it?
- 3:42It was frustrating because it had nothing to do with
- 3:44operations. The entire shortfall was caused
- 3:47by a discreet, non operational $619 million tax charge.
- 3:52Wow, 619 million. Yeah, and it was all related to
- 3:56a historical dispute, A disagreement with Brazilian tax
- 3:59authorities that just finally came to a head in Q3. $619
- 4:03million just from 1:00 country on a single tax issue that's no
- 4:08that just vanished from their profit line.
- 4:11But hold on, if this was an ongoing dispute, doesn't missing
- 4:14their forecast by that much suggest they weren't on top of
- 4:17it? That's a completely fair
- 4:19question. I mean, why wasn't that baked
- 4:21into the guidance? Well, it really reflects the
- 4:23uncertainty you have with international tax law.
- 4:26So while the dispute was known, the timing of the settlement and
- 4:30the final amount, those things are often really opaque.
- 4:33They're subject to last minute negotiation.
- 4:36To just hit all at once. Abruptly.
- 4:38But what matters for our analysis is the implication this
- 4:41charge artificially pushed their reported operating margin down
- 4:44to 28.2%. And their guidance was for what,
- 4:48over 30? They guided for 31.5% so it
- 4:51pulled it down significantly. So if we just, you know,
- 4:54theoretically strip out that $619 million penalty.
- 4:58Which was a one time thing, yeah.
- 5:00Then the operational success is clear.
- 5:02The underlying margins would have actually shown continued
- 5:05expansion. Recisely, if you take away that
- 5:08specific regulatory hiccup, the inherent operational leverage,
- 5:12you know, growing revenue faster than costs would have been
- 5:15crystal clear. We would have seen robust margin
- 5:17growth. It really just shows their
- 5:18discipline on content costs and how well the new ad and sharing
- 5:21initiatives are scaling. Exactly.
- 5:23So the quarter was a massive operational success that just
- 5:26got kind of financially muddied by international tax friction.
- 5:29And that friction really speaks volumes about the headwinds
- 5:32these global digital giants are facing.
- 5:35OK, So moving from the bottom line to the strategic focus, the
- 5:39report details this critical shift in how Netflix even
- 5:42measures its own success for I mean, for decades, the metric
- 5:46was simple subscriber growth, growth at all costs.
- 5:49Yeah, that was the startup phase mindset, high growth, burn cash
- 5:52to get bigger. That era is definitively over
- 5:54now. Right.
- 5:55So Netflix took this crucial step earlier in the year to stop
- 5:58reporting quarterly net subscriber editions as a primary
- 6:01KPI. A move that initially raised a
- 6:04lot of eyebrows. Analysts, you know, they accuse
- 6:06them of a lack of transparency because their models relied on
- 6:10those raw numbers. But the company's reasoning For
- 6:14a mature business, it's pretty sound, isn't it?
- 6:16They're shifting focus to profitable engagement.
- 6:19That's the adult pivot. Exactly.
- 6:21When you've already conquered the market, just adding your 300
- 6:24and first millionth customer who cost you $100 to get and only
- 6:27pays you 7 bucks a month, that's less valuable than keeping the
- 6:31300 million you have and maximizing their lifetime value.
- 6:34So what's the total number now? They ended the period with an
- 6:37astronomical 301.6 million global paid memberships. 300
- 6:43million. That kind of scale just
- 6:44solidifies their position. They're not fighting for global
- 6:47dominance anymore. They have it.
- 6:49And the metrics they're pushing now, this profitable engagement,
- 6:52it shows why the shift makes sense.
- 6:55It's about mindshare, not just headcount.
- 6:57Exactly. The report sites Nielsen data
- 7:00that completely backs this up. Netflix's share of total USTV
- 7:03viewing time grew by 15% since the end of 2022. 15%.
- 7:08And even in the Super mature UK market, it grew by 22%.
- 7:13So they are penetrating existing viewing habits more and more
- 7:16deeply. They're not just selling a
- 7:18subscription anymore, they're capturing your time.
- 7:20And more engagement justifies higher prices and reduces churn.
- 7:25Which is infinitely more profitable than chasing, you
- 7:28know, low ARP subscribers and markets that are already
- 7:31saturated. Let's talk more about that
- 7:33revenue structure because the report really details a
- 7:36significant change. Netflix isn't A1 product company
- 7:39anymore. No, it's moving from being, you
- 7:42know, 100% reliant on monthly subscriptions to what the report
- 7:46calls a dual engine model. And that transition is happening
- 7:49very, very quickly. Historically, yeah, they were
- 7:51pureplay subscriptions. Now if we look at the estimated
- 7:54revenue mix for fiscal year 2025, subscriptions are still
- 7:58the big piece around 78%, still dominant, still dominant, but
- 8:02it's the non subscription parts that are driving the new growth
- 8:05and that diversification is the critical evolution here.
- 8:08And the most exciting part of that, the piece that really
- 8:11brings Netflix back into the growth conversation, is
- 8:14advertising revenue. Absolutely.
- 8:16The report projects it's going to be 12% of the total revenue
- 8:20mix for 2025. How did this happen so
- 8:23successfully? I mean, they were so reluctant
- 8:26to get into ads at first. It was a necessary and I'd say
- 8:29brilliantly executed U-turn. The AD supported tier is proving
- 8:34to be a highly effective funnel for them.
- 8:36A funnel? How so?
- 8:37Well, management reports that in the markets where it's
- 8:40available, the ad tier accounts for over 50% of all new sign
- 8:44ups. Over half, yeah.
- 8:46And that's crucial because it captures this huge group of
- 8:49price sensitive customers, the people who might have just been
- 8:51borrowers before or who were just never going to pay the
- 8:54premium ad free price. And they're monetizing this
- 8:57budget conscious audience incredibly well.
- 8:59I heard it's often more profitable than the standard
- 9:01plan. That's the counterintuitive
- 9:03genius of it. They're using their scale and
- 9:06all that unique data to command premium ad prices.
- 9:09They're seeing really high CPMS. That's the price advertisers pay
- 9:13per 1000 views in the range of 55 to $65.
- 9:17That's top tier pricing. It is only premium broadcast and
- 9:20streaming can get those rates and because of this the average
- 9:24revenue per member or ARM from the ad supported tier can often
- 9:28be higher than the ARM from their basic ad free
- 9:31subscriptions. Their cheapest tier might
- 9:34actually be one of their highest margin products.
- 9:36That's a phenomenal reversal. Yeah.
- 9:37Let's quickly touch on the scale again that 301.6 million global
- 9:41members, What do the regional dynamics look like?
- 9:44It's a complex footprint. You have North America or you
- 9:47can as the mature region 84,000,000 Subs growth there is
- 9:51basically flat. So it's all about raising
- 9:53prices. It's all about pricing power.
- 9:55That's why the average revenue per user, the ARPU is highest
- 9:57there, around $17.17. It's basically a utility in that
- 10:02region. And then EBA, Europe, Middle
- 10:05East and Africa, that's the biggest by volume, right?
- 10:0894,000,000 Subs. Correct for now, but the long
- 10:11term growth engine is still Asia Pacific, AIPAC, they're at 51
- 10:16million subscribers. But the revenue per user there
- 10:19is much lower. It is.
- 10:21You see the price sensitivity ARPU is around 7 to $8.
- 10:25So it's a completely different model in AIPAC.
- 10:28It's all about high volume, lower price points, often driven
- 10:33by mobile only plans. And before we get to their
- 10:35structural advantages, we have to talk about the page sharing
- 10:38crackdown. The report called it a hidden
- 10:41inventory boost. It's the perfect phrase for it.
- 10:43This was a brilliant high margin move.
- 10:45The report estimates they converted over 20 million
- 10:48borrower households into paid units. 20 million, yeah.
- 10:51Either through the extra member option or a brand new account.
- 10:54And think about it, these 20 million households were already
- 10:57using the service, consuming bandwidth but generating $0.00
- 11:01in revenue. So converting them didn't
- 11:03require any new content or marketing spend. 0 It's pure
- 11:07immediate profit leverage, a financial gift that just needed
- 11:11an enforcement mechanism. That perfectly sets up the
- 11:14conversation about their wide economic Moat.
- 11:17This is why it's so hard for rivals to compete.
- 11:19Yes, there are three pillars really to their structural
- 11:22advantage, and the first one is the most powerful economies of
- 11:25scale in content. Give us a sense of the scale of
- 11:29that spending. Netflix spends roughly $17
- 11:32billion a year on content, and that's before the WBD deal. 17
- 11:37billion. And to understand the Moat, you
- 11:39have to see that as a fixed cost.
- 11:41It's like building a multibillion dollar highway.
- 11:44The cost is fixed. Now imagine a competitor, say
- 11:47Paramount Plus, with half the subscribers to offer a library
- 11:51that can compete. They have to spend the same
- 11:53amount. They have to spend that same $17
- 11:54billion or customers will leave. And this is where the math just
- 11:58gets brutal for the competition, right?
- 12:00Because the competitor has half the subscriber base, their
- 12:03content cost per subscriber is double what Netflix's is.
- 12:07This leads to massive per subscriber losses for that
- 12:10smaller rival which they just can't sustain long term.
- 12:14So Netflix's scale lets them spread read.
- 12:15That cost out over 300 million customers.
- 12:18It's a barrier you almost can't breach.
- 12:20Exactly. And the second advantage is
- 12:23their invisible edge, the data-driven feedback loop.
- 12:26This is their secret weapon. Built up over 15 years.
- 12:30They don't just know what you watched.
- 12:32They know when you paused, what scene you rewatched, what you
- 12:34gave up on after three minutes. And what time of day you want a
- 12:37documentary versus an action movie?
- 12:39All of it. And this data can't be bought.
- 12:42It can't be easily replicated. It feeds their content green
- 12:45lighting process so they have fewer expensive flops, and it
- 12:48powers that percentage match algorithm.
- 12:51Which is really a retention tool.
- 12:52It's all about retention. It's surfaces niche content
- 12:55that's relevant to you, which reduces churn and increases
- 12:57customer lifetime value. They know you're viewing habits
- 13:00better than you do. What about the third advantage,
- 13:03the distribution network? The global distribution
- 13:06infrastructure. It's often overlooked, but it's
- 13:08critical. Netflix is unique in its ability
- 13:11to launch a show simultaneously in 190 countries with full
- 13:16localization, dubbing, subtitles, marketing on day one.
- 13:20Like with Squid gamer Lupin. Exactly.
- 13:22And that capability attracts the best global talent.
- 13:25Creators want that instant worldwide audience.
- 13:28It creates A virtuous cycle that strengthens their content
- 13:31pipeline. It's a massive logistical
- 13:33advantage that even Disney still struggles to fully replicate.
- 13:37So the report makes it clear that while Netflix had the Moat
- 13:40in distribution and scale, it always kind of lacked the
- 13:43intellectual property, the IP mode that Disney has, right.
- 13:47And that brings us to the monumental gamble they're making
- 13:50with WBD. This is the moment they try to
- 13:52close that gap. This is the moment they attempt
- 13:55to fundamentally redesign their entire corporate DNA.
- 13:58OK, this is where the story shifts completely from
- 14:01operational success to just massive strategic risk.
- 14:05The $82.7 billion acquisition of Warner Bros Discovery is this
- 14:09direct, audacious play to secure an unassailable content mode.
- 14:13Right. They aren't just buying more
- 14:15shows, they are buying forever franchises.
- 14:17Harry Potter, the entire DC Universe, and, crucially, the
- 14:21prestige brand of HBO. They're buying history.
- 14:24The strategic logic of getting that Evergreen content is sound.
- 14:28The financial mechanics of the deal, though, That's what should
- 14:31keep every observer up at night. This is the core transformation.
- 14:35It is The deal is structured with a staggering $60 billion
- 14:39cash component, and that is being financed almost entirely
- 14:43through new debt. So this completely transforms
- 14:46their capital structure overnight.
- 14:48It takes a conservative tech company and just leverages it up
- 14:51dramatically. Let's make that real for people.
- 14:53What was their leverage before this?
- 14:55Before the WBD deal, Netflix was very conservative, A leverage
- 14:58ratio of about 0.6 times debt to EBITDA.
- 15:02OK, so for every dollar of profit they owed $0.60?
- 15:05Basically, they were essentially debt free.
- 15:08It gave them enormous flexibility.
- 15:10And after the acquisition? That ratio balloons to a pro
- 15:12forma leverage of nearly 3.0 times.
- 15:16This is the birth of the debt monster. $3 of debt for every
- 15:19$1.00 of profit. Exactly.
- 15:22And that radically changes who's in charge.
- 15:24The debt holders now have a much louder voice in the boardroom.
- 15:28The immediate consequence is a painful increase in their
- 15:31sensitivity to interest rates and a forced immediate
- 15:33suspension of their massive share buyback program.
- 15:36For how long? For at least two to three years.
- 15:39Every spare dollar has to go to repairing the balance sheet.
- 15:42And the risk isn't just financial, it's political and
- 15:45regulatory. The report estimates there's a
- 15:47significant chance this whole deal could just collapse.
- 15:50That's a critical short term risk because the sheer size and
- 15:54the market concentration this creates, the deal faces intense
- 15:58scrutiny. The report notes that figures
- 16:01like President Trump and the DOJ have flagged concerns about
- 16:04media consolidation. So there's a higher regulatory
- 16:07hurdle than they might have expected.
- 16:08A much higher hurdle. The estimated risk of the deal
- 16:11being blocked is around 50%. It's basically a coin flip for
- 16:14an $83 billion gamble. And if that coin lands on the
- 16:17wrong side, if the deal is blocked, Netflix is still on the
- 16:21hook for a massive non productive loss.
- 16:24A huge $5.8 billion breakup fee. Wow.
- 16:29Just think about that number. That's more than half a year's
- 16:31worth of free cash flow gone instantly just to pay a penalty
- 16:35for a failed deal. It would severely restrict their
- 16:38cash flow and just damage market confidence.
- 16:40Beyond the money and the regulatory hurdles, the long
- 16:43term risks are often the most destructive in these mega
- 16:46mergers, right? I mean the integration, the
- 16:49culture clash. We all remember AOL Time Warner.
- 16:51The report specifically calls out the cultural clash risk.
- 16:55Mergers of this scale, especially between tech and
- 16:57legacy media, have a terrible track record.
- 17:00Because Netflix runs on that freedom and responsibility
- 17:02culture. Yeah, Silicon Valley style.
- 17:04Exactly. It's data-driven, fast moving,
- 17:07meritocratic, and that philosophy is in direct conflict
- 17:11with Warner Bros traditional Hollywood studio culture.
- 17:14Which is more relationship driven?
- 17:16Talent heavy relies on intuition.
- 17:18And moves much, much slower. If you bring the Netflix ethos
- 17:22where Data decides if a show gets renewed, into a legacy
- 17:25studio that runs on decades long relationships with writers and
- 17:28producers, you are creating massive friction.
- 17:31The talent retention risk must be enormous.
- 17:33Huge If high profile showrunners feel that Netflix's cost
- 17:37cutting, data-driven approach is stifling creativity, you could
- 17:41see an exodus from HBO and WBD. And if they lose that key
- 17:45creative talent, the very content mode they paid $83
- 17:49billion for just evaporates. And the report mentioned two
- 17:52other external headwinds that are just constantly there
- 17:55chipping away at margins. Yep.
- 17:57First, foreign exchange volatility a constant issue.
- 18:00Because 60% of their revenue is international.
- 18:02Right. They're paid in euros, yen,
- 18:04Brazilian, real. But most of their production
- 18:07costs, especially for these big Hollywood assets, are in U.S.
- 18:10dollars. So when the dollar strengthens,
- 18:12their international revenue translates into fewer dollars
- 18:15while their costs stay high. It's a constant margin
- 18:18compression. And 2nd, going back to that
- 18:20surprise Brazilian charge, the risk of global taxation is just
- 18:24always there. Yes, that Q3 charge was a loud
- 18:28warning shot. As these digital giants expand
- 18:31governments all over the world, India, France, Italy are
- 18:35actively looking to capture revenue through digital
- 18:38services, taxes and retroactive assessments.
- 18:40These are non operational, unpredictable charges that can
- 18:44just hammer your net income. To really appreciate this shift
- 18:47of debt, we have to understand how Netflix actually makes money
- 18:50in its current mature state. Their cost structure is the key.
- 18:54It's the key to their operating leverage.
- 18:56It's characterized by extremely high fixed costs but negligible
- 19:00variable costs, and that is the magic formula for generating
- 19:03exponential profit once you hit scale.
- 19:06OK, So let's break down the single biggest expense, content
- 19:08amortization. Why is a cost that totals
- 19:11billions of dollars considered fixed?
- 19:13Because it's a sunk cost. Once the show is produced and
- 19:15that check is cut, the cost is locked in.
- 19:18Whether The Witcher is watched by 10 million people or 100
- 19:20million people, the expenditure for that asset does not change.
- 19:24So the marginal cost of streaming it to one more person
- 19:26is almost 0. Exactly.
- 19:28The cost of building the highway is fixed.
- 19:30The cost of letting one more car drive on it is negligible.
- 19:34That's why scale is everything in this business.
- 19:37And, you know, the report also notes that Netflix uses an
- 19:40accelerated accounting schedule. What does that mean?
- 19:42It means they expense and recognize the cost of content
- 19:45over a pretty short period. Over 90% of a title's cost is
- 19:49accounted for within four years of its release.
- 19:52And why do they do that? It's just fiscally responsible.
- 19:55It matches the expense to the viewing curve.
- 19:57Most people watch a new show in its first few months so it makes
- 20:01sense to front load the cost. But historically, this made
- 20:04their margins look tight when they were spending heavily for
- 20:06growth. Now that content spending is
- 20:08growing slower than revenue, this schedule is actually
- 20:11starting to work for them. It's accelerating the margin
- 20:13expansion we're seeing. Precisely.
- 20:15And the platform itself, the tech, the cloud infrastructure,
- 20:19those costs are also largely fixed, right?
- 20:22For the most part, running the core platform R&D for better
- 20:26compression, those are high upfront costs.
- 20:30But as their user base scales, those costs grow much slower
- 20:34than the revenue. They're always finding new
- 20:37efficiencies. What about marketing?
- 20:39That seems like it would be more flexible.
- 20:40It's more. Flexible but also highly
- 20:42disciplined. Their marketing budget is
- 20:44remarkably stable, around 2.9 to 3.1 billion a year.
- 20:49Which is only about 7 to 8% of their total revenue.
- 20:51Exactly. You contrast that with legacy
- 20:54media companies who are often spending 1520% of revenue on
- 20:57marketing. Netflix is lean because they use
- 21:00their own platform for promotion.
- 21:02You know the autoplay trailers and they rely on viral social
- 21:05media buzz. Which keeps their customer
- 21:07acquisition costs low. And this whole discipline cost
- 21:10structure leads us to the financial maturity story, the
- 21:14margin expansion and the free cash flow flywheel.
- 21:16Yeah, the 10 year history chart in the research report is
- 21:19visually stunning. It shows the flywheel effect
- 21:21perfectly. Cost of revenue, that huge
- 21:23content cost, has compressed dramatically as a percentage of
- 21:26revenue. What are the numbers?
- 21:27In 2015, cost of revenues ate up about 68% of every dollar they
- 21:32earned. By 2025, that figure has
- 21:35compressed down to roughly 52%. That 16 point drop is pure
- 21:40operational leverage converting into profit.
- 21:42And that margin expansion is what powers this radical turn
- 21:46around in their ability to generate real, spendable cash.
- 21:50It's the ultimate measure of success for a mature company.
- 21:53I mean, the report highlights this incredible shift from
- 21:55burning massive amounts of cash just a few years ago.
- 21:57Right, like in 2019 they had -3.3 billion in free cash.
- 22:01Flow exactly during the peak of the content spending wars, and
- 22:05now they're trailing 12 months. Free cash flow in 2025 stands at
- 22:09an enormous $9.1 billion. From burning over 3 billion to
- 22:14making over 9 billion, That's an incredible turn around.
- 22:17And that 9.1 billion is hard proof that the model is scalable
- 22:21and has moved past the investment phase.
- 22:23The flywheel is spinning and it's printing cash.
- 22:26And that cash gives them a huge cushion to weather any economic
- 22:29storm. We've established that
- 22:31operationally the business business is a cash generating
- 22:34engine, but financially the balance sheet is about to
- 22:38undergo this terrifying stress test with the WBD merger.
- 22:43So now let's use the final framework, assessing Netflix
- 22:47through the rigorous lens of traditional value investing, the
- 22:50Buffett checklist. This is really crucial for
- 22:54separating the quality of the business from the quality of the
- 22:56stock. Exactly.
- 22:58We need to answer the two parts of our mission.
- 23:00So let's start with the qualitative tests, the criteria
- 23:03that define a truly durable, high quality business.
- 23:06A wonderful company, Yeah. First up.
- 23:09Profitability and efficiency. It's a pass.
- 23:11Their net profit margin is exceptional at 23.6%, but look
- 23:15at how efficiently they use shareholder money.
- 23:17Return on equity or Roe is at an eye watering 42.9%.
- 23:22And for context, anything over 15% is considered really good.
- 23:25Yeah, they're nearly three times that.
- 23:27The return on invested capital, ROIC is also incredibly strong
- 23:31at 29.9%. These numbers just scream high
- 23:33quality operation. OK, next cash generation pass.
- 23:38The free cash flow is robust at 9.1 billion and the report
- 23:42specifically says management has shown elite skill in capital
- 23:47reinvestment. A key Buffett principle.
- 23:50It's not enough to generate cash, you have to deploy it
- 23:53intelligently and Netflix has proven they can do that.
- 23:55And growth and predictability also a pass.
- 23:59Even with subscriber growth slowing, earnings per share has
- 24:01grown dramatically from just three cents in 2015 to $2.39 in
- 24:072025. The business is durable,
- 24:09predictable, and highly scalable.
- 24:11So qualitatively, there's no doubt Netflix is a wonderful
- 24:14company. But now for the quantitative
- 24:16tests, the ones that determine if it's a good investment at
- 24:18this price. And this is where it hits major
- 24:21headwinds. This is where price ruins
- 24:22perfection. First, valuation discipline
- 24:25fail. The price to earnings or PE
- 24:27ratio is around 40 times trailing earnings.
- 24:30So for our listeners, that means the market is willing to pay
- 24:32$40.00 for every $1.00 of profit the company made last year.
- 24:35A traditional value investor is looking for a P/E of 15 or less.
- 24:40The price to book is also around 18 times the valuation is
- 24:44pricing in years of massive, flawless growth.
- 24:47There's absolutely no margin of safety.
- 24:49And then we get to the second quantitative failure, which is
- 24:51the defining issue here, balance sheet safety fail.
- 24:55Big fail. The current debt to equity ratio
- 24:58of 0.6 is fine, but post WBD merger that ratio is projected
- 25:03to shoot past 2.5. It's a dramatic, dramatic shift.
- 25:07It violates the core tenet of value investing, which is to
- 25:10avoid excessive leverage. But wait, if they're generating
- 25:139 billion in free cash flow, can't they just pay that debt
- 25:16down quickly? That's the crucial distinction.
- 25:19While their current interest coverage is phenomenal, their
- 25:21income covers their interest expense almost 29 times.
- 25:25The pro forma interest expense with 60 billion in new debt will
- 25:28tighten that coverage significantly.
- 25:30And their flexibility disappears.
- 25:31Completely. They're now highly dependent on
- 25:34the stability of global debt markets.
- 25:36Any unforeseen economic shock could turn that manageable debt
- 25:40into a life threatening anchor. And that level of risk is just
- 25:43unacceptable under strict value investing principles.
- 25:46So the verdict is definitive. A wonderful company at an
- 25:51unattractive price facing a massive balance sheet event.
- 25:55And that financial shift immediately forces a change in
- 25:58capital allocation, that enormous $15 billion share
- 26:01repurchase program. Which saw 1.6 billion
- 26:05repurchased in Q2 alone. That's expected to be suspended
- 26:08or severely curtailed through 2026 and 2027.
- 26:11Their priority has to be servicing that 60 billion in
- 26:14debt share buybacks are off the table until the balance sheet is
- 26:17fixed. And the report highlighted a
- 26:18real split among institutional investors on this Some big names
- 26:22were buying heavily, while others were getting out.
- 26:24Yeah, the market was clearly divided on the WBD gamble.
- 26:27On one side, you have prominent investors like Bridgewater
- 26:30Associates, who increased their position by nearly 900% in Q3.
- 26:34900% Why? They see the 9 billion in FCF as
- 26:37defensive growth, a durable asset with pricing power that
- 26:41can weather a downturn, making the high price worth it.
- 26:44But the profit takers saw the risk coming.
- 26:45Absolutely. Funds like Sapient Capital were
- 26:48trimming their positions. They were likely reacting to the
- 26:51extremely high valuation and anticipating the debt risk.
- 26:55They took profits signaling caution about the market's
- 26:58enthusiasm for the merger. To bring all of this home, we
- 27:01have to determine what the company's actually worth its
- 27:04intrinsic value. And because the WBD deal creates
- 27:07so much uncertainty, the analysts modeled 3 distinct
- 27:10scenarios using ADCF analysis. Right.
- 27:13And we're using a discount rate, a WACC of 9.5% for all the
- 27:17models. That's intentionally a little
- 27:19higher than Netflix's historical rate just to reflect the new
- 27:22leverage risk. OK, so let's look at the most
- 27:24cautious scenario case one. This assumes the markets word
- 27:28fears come true. Case 1.
- 27:29The conservative case, this is where the WBD deal gets blocked.
- 27:33They have to pay that punitive $5.8 billion breakup fee and
- 27:37core growth slows down. Here we assume a moderate XCF
- 27:41growth of 8% for five years. The resulting intrinsic value is
- 27:46only $39.70 per share. Less than 40 bucks and with a
- 27:50margin of safety the buy price would be under 30.
- 27:53It just shows the catastrophic impact of the deal failing.
- 27:56OK. That's a huge gap from the
- 27:58current price. What about the middle of the
- 27:59road scenario? Case 2.
- 28:01The nominal case. This model assumes the WBD deal
- 28:04gets partial approval or stays in regulatory limbo, but the
- 28:08core Netflix business executes well.
- 28:10Margins go up toward 30%. Here we use a much healthier 14%
- 28:15FCF growth rate. And the intrinsic value.
- 28:17It rises to $51.55 per share with a safety margin.
- 28:21The buy price is 3866, so even in a really strong scenario for
- 28:25the core business, the stock is trading at almost double its
- 28:28fundamental value. Which brings us to the
- 28:30optimistic case. This has to be the scenario the
- 28:33market is pricing in right now. It has to be case 3, the
- 28:37optimistic case. This is the moon shot.
- 28:40The WBD deal closes. Florida State integration is
- 28:43perfect. They get all the synergies
- 28:45immediately. The combined company dominates.
- 28:47Global media ad revenue keeps doubling.
- 28:49The dream scenario. The Dream scenario This model
- 28:52uses a massive 22% FCF growth rate for five years, and even in
- 28:57this most bullish high growth model, the intrinsic value is
- 29:01only $88.50 per share. 8850 and the buy price would be around
- 29:06$66, right? So when we compare all of those
- 29:09intrinsic values to the real world market price, the final
- 29:12verdict seems unavoidable. The current stock price of
- 29:15Netflix is $96.71. 9671. This means Netflix is trading
- 29:20above even the most optimistic intrinsic value.
- 29:23The market is pricing in a level of growth that not only exceeds
- 29:26historical norms, but requires absolutely flawless execution of
- 29:30a monumental merger that we know is filled with risk.
- 29:33The conclusion is clear. The stock is currently
- 29:36overvalued and price for perfection.
- 29:38There is zero room for error built into that price.
- 29:40To synthesize the core findings of this deep dive one last time
- 29:43for you, Netflix is without a doubt a wonderful company.
- 29:47It has an incredible product, a powerful expanding Moat, and
- 29:51it's matured into a massive free cash flow generator, right?
- 29:54But that quality is completely outweighed by the current price.
- 29:58It trades at an unattractive price and it's facing this
- 30:02profound transformative balance sheet event of taking on 60
- 30:06billion in debt, which introduces unacceptable leverage
- 30:10risk. The quality is stellar, but the
- 30:13price is prohibitive. And that debt event really is
- 30:16the defining moment. You know, brings me back to that
- 30:18strategic shift we talked about at the beginning, management
- 30:21deciding to stop reporting quarterly subscriber numbers.
- 30:24That move was criticized as a lack of transparency when growth
- 30:27was slowing down. And, you know, this shift toward
- 30:30prioritizing free cash flow and engagement over raw subscriber
- 30:33numbers, that's a move toward true financial majority.
- 30:36It's what a media giant should do.
- 30:38But it raises this final provocative thought for you, the
- 30:41listener. Given everything we've analyzed
- 30:43today, where revenue and engagement are clearly stronger
- 30:46indicators of financial health, does the market's continued
- 30:50demand for transparency on that old unicount metric really
- 30:53justify the operational headache of reporting it, especially when
- 30:57management rightly sees it as secondary to long term
- 31:00profitability now? It's a real challenge to the
- 31:03traditions of Wall Street, isn't it?
- 31:04Demanding maturity when they still want to see adolescence?
- 31:07An excellent point to end on. We hope this deep dive into
- 31:10Netflix's crossroads has given you a much clearer picture.
- 31:14Thank you for joining us on The Deep Dive.
- 31:15And a final reminder on the nature of this analysis.
- 31:18All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 31:21may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 31:25The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 31:28constitute investment advice. Please conduct your own due
- 31:31diligence before making any investment decisions.