Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️95 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 8th Restoration & Landscape Sep 2026 Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:06Unknown: Welcome to the Save Our Sperrins campaign. Voices from the front line. I'm Marella fyffe, your host and a member of the Save Our Sperrins team. At the heart of this struggle are the voices of local people, farmers, families, and young campaigners, whose homes, work, and families are rooted in this
- 0:25place. Their voices are joined by supporters from across the world, standing in solidarity, from professors to artists, from those offering vast expertise to those whose presence alone is an act of support. All have stood with us. In this series, we share stories of resistance, resilience, and hopes from those
- 0:50determined to protect these mountains, their land, their rivers, the very air they breathe, and their community. Let's get started. Today we moved on to the restoration and visual impact, which, on the face of it, sounded as though it might be one of the slightly gentler days at the inquiry. Me
- 1:15imagining grass, heather, and planting, and what the place might eventually look like-that sort of thing, as you might imagine, it didn't quite stay as simple as that. Once people start asking how you actually restore something on the scale of the proposed dry stack mine waste facility, where the soil
- 1:34comes from, where you keep it in the meantime, how deep it needs to be, what grows in it, and what happens while the different parts of the facility are still being constructed? We found ourselves heading back into some of the same mine waste questions we've been discussing for the last few days, and we hadn't
- 1:58been going very long this morning before the commission ran into the first difficulty. As you know, there are various documents and tables dealing with the construction sequence of the dry stack, produced at different stages of this application, and there was some discussion about which one was
- 2:14the most recent, which one had been added to, which one could still be relied upon, and whether one of them should simply be discounted. Then we got onto the years. When does cell one actually get restored? And just so you know what I mean by cell one, the mine waste facility isn't built and filled
- 2:37as one enormous heap in one go. It's divided into sections called cells. Cell one is the first of those sections to be prepared and filled with the filtered mine waste before the operation moves progressively into the other cells. Anyways, I diverged slightly. There were two construction years before
- 3:00production begins, referred to as minus two and minus one, followed by years 1234, and so on. So when a document says year four, the question was, are we four years into the project or six? Eventually, we got there, but it took a surprisingly long time to establish the answer to what you would have thought was
- 3:26a fairly straightforward question. As I said before, there's enormous amount of documentation around this project, produced and amended over a period of years, and finding one clear answer can sometimes involve an expedition through several reports, appendices, tables, and
- 3:43drawings, at one point this afternoon, somebody in our group described it as debt by 1000 references, which I thought was apt. Once we'd established roughly when the restoration was supposed to happen. The next question was, what this restored dry stack is actually going to look like. The intention is that
- 4:09the facility is progressively restored as it develops. Lower areas are vegetated and begin to mature, while work continues elsewhere, and eventually the finished structure is supposed to carry mainly acidic grassland with both wet heat and dry heat species, so over time it greens over and the ecological
- 4:29community develops per se. John Ingham, giving landscape evidence for Fermanagnoma District Council, wasn't convinced by what had been presented. His concern was that the visualisation showed something which looked much more established than he believed was realistic. He talked about the
- 4:48planting medium, the amount of soil available, and the conditions on this engineering mound, and his view was that you could end up with a predominantly grassy, engineered-looking structure. Which wouldn't resemble the blanket bog landscape against which it would actually be seen,
- 5:05of course. Witnesses disagreed.
- 5:08Their position was that the proposed grass and heat species were suitable for the conditions, that they could tolerate periods of water stress, and that because the restoration would be progressive, vegetation on the lower slopes would have had much longer to mature by the time the
- 5:25upper parts were being completed. There was quite a bit of discussion about soil depth as well. Half a metre was mentioned, and mr. Ingham considered that completely inadequate for shrubs. The reading clarified that half a metre was effectively the general planting layer, with
- 5:43greater depths locally where required. We then moved on to the topic of heather. Sean Clark speaks from his own experience of The Sperrins, made what I thought was a very understandable point. Heather here is associated with blanket bog, a landscape which has developed over 1000s of years
- 6:03and holds an enormous amount of water. So his question was: How do you reproduce anything resembling that on top of an engineering structure designed to manage water and move it away? The ladies' answer was: They weren't trying to create a blanket bog on top of a dry stack. The target habitat is
- 6:20predominantly acid grassland with dry heat, and their witness said those species can establish in the conditions proposed. I spent quite a few years working in horticulture myself, so inevitably I ended up sticking my ore in as well. There were questions about the engineered cover beneath the planting
- 6:41medium, which includes a mixture containing bentonite, and what interaction there might eventually be between that and the vegetation above it. We also talked about trees because planting the vegetation you want is one thing; stopping nature planting the vegetation it wants over the next 50 or 100 years is
- 7:00another. Willow and other trees will self-seed. Some tree roots, such as willow, aggressively seek water and will penetrate the slightest cracks and weaknesses. Trees get larger, and we do occasionally have a bit of wind in The Sperrins. So, what happens if a tree establishes? Roots penetrate
- 7:18downwards, and eventually one of those trees comes over. It's all right, though. Dalradian considered that risk low. Their witness said the conditions would effectively limit the establishment of larger trees, while species such as willow tend to be relatively shallow-rooted. From many years'
- 7:37experience, I remain unconvinced. There is also to be monitoring after closure, now proposed for 15 years. All of that took us into another part of today's discussion, which I thought was particularly interesting: soil and a lot of it. At one stage, we were talking about something in the
- 7:56region of 90,000 cubic metres of soil requiring storage. That material has to be stripped, stored, and eventually used as part of the restoration. Somebody asked the obvious question: Where is where is it in the picture? Because we've all seen the visualisations of the proposed mine at various
- 8:17stages, showing what people are expected to see from different viewpoints around the site. The answer was that these temporary soil storage mounds hadn't been modelled into the visualisations because they weren't considered visible. They would largely be behind the starter berm. Now that caused a bit of discussion.
- 8:40The difficulty with hiding something behind a berm is that it works particularly well if everybody agrees to stand in the right place. People in The Sperrins have an awkward habit of travelling uphill; some have even been known to cross the valleys. mr. Ingham's evidence for the council was that from
- 8:59other locations and from higher ground, those storage areas would indeed be very visible, and given their scale, he thought they should have been represented. Dalradians landscape witness maintained they weren't considered visible from the assessed viewpoints, and also made the perfectly
- 9:18reasonable point that no visualisation can contain every single element of a development, and that really left the commission with a question of judgement: Do the visualisations give a sufficient representative picture of what people are actually likely to see during the development of this site?
- 9:38Because those storage mounds aren't just a couple of wheelbarrows of topsoil sitting behind the shed. We're talking about a very substantial amount of material being stripped from the site, stored, and moved again as restoration progresses, and by this stage the conversation about restoration
- 9:58must begin to wander back towards the construction.
- 10:00Of the mine waste facility itself, which was outside the remit of today's discussion, and that probably illustrates one of the difficulties with dividing an inquiry like this into separate topics. On a mine site, everything is connected. You can't really talk about restoring the dry stack without
- 10:18talking about the soil and peat being stripped, where it's stored, the sequencing of the cells, drainage and water management, and before long you're back into mine waste. I understand why the commission needs to break such a huge inquiry into manageable sections, but the development
- 10:36itself doesn't respect those boundaries, and today was a pretty good example of that. Let's talk about the cells. When we talk about filling the cells, the dry stack facility isn't filled as one enormous heap in one go. It's divided into three large sections called cells, which are progressively
- 10:57developed. Cell one is the first of those on the eastern side, and these are in small compartments. The three cells together are designed to provide about 4.8 million cubic metres of storage. If 4.8 million cubic metres of storage means absolutely nothing to you, and frankly, it didn't mean much to
- 11:20me either, you might think of Wembley Stadium. The entire volume enclosed inside Wembley is about 4 million cubic metres. The proposed capacity of these three cells is 4.8 million cubic metres. That might give you some idea of the scale of what we're dealing with. So, if cell one has been constructed and filled,
- 11:42while cell two still has peat and soil sitting on it. When exactly is cell two stripped, and where does that material go? How close is the operating tailings facility? How are the different cells lined and drained as construction progresses, and what happens if and when you actually start
- 12:05stripping the ground, you discover that there's a hell of a lot more peat or more soil than your calculations predicted. Dr. Stephen Emerman asked why that possibility didn't appear as a risk with an associated mitigation measure. There was also a lengthy discussion about the engineered
- 12:23systems beneath and above the tailings, and this produced more detail today about how parts of those systems would actually be installed. At one point, there was confusion about whether we were talking about one continuous liner being placed across the site. The explanation eventually given was that the
- 12:44HDPE liner comes in strips around 25 metres wide, which are heat welded together in the field as the work progresses. The way this was all explained was very unclear, and I know I was confused at the end of that explanation, and I'm quite sure I was not the only one, and this brings us straight back to
- 13:04sequencing again, because the evidence today was the tailings could be going into cell one while peat and soil were still being stripped from cell two. More questions followed about drainage, access, contamination between working areas, stability, and what exactly the site looks like while all these
- 13:27operations are taking place one alongside the other. Some of these questions were still being argued about late in the afternoon, and around this point, another little feature of the day began to emerge. Dalradians council was concerned they weren't getting a fair opportunity to respond to what
- 13:48they regarded as new information. However, our Niall had been keeping count, and he was on top of it. And this is what he has to say about it.
- 13:58The questions were posed by the commissioner. Dalradian got the first opportunity to speak on it. Maybe then the council. It then came to us, and we give our points. And before lunch, it was passed back to Dalread and the comment. And Scott Linus Casey, he said the order they had to speak in was mr. Spears, Miss
- 14:21Oxley, and Miss Rogers. So the commissioner then listened to everything mr. Spears had to say, and it was to go. Then we broke for lunch, and when we returned after lunch, they gave mr. Linus then returned to mr. Spears to have a third opportunity to speak prior to going to Miss Oxley and Miss
- 14:45Rogers, and that should have been picked up at the time by the commissioners. Frankly, that he already had his chance to respond to those questions. But anyway, it came back to us then, and we obviously responded. It was put in front of us again, and. At that point, it was touching 4o'clock. mr. Linus
- 15:05came back a fourth time, saying this was new information and they needed a right to respond to main waste. And again, they were facilitated, and then again, also things were permitted that would be talked again on peat and water.
- 15:20So there you are. By that stage, they had so many bites of the apple that there wasn't much apple left. We've talked before in this podcast about equality of arms and the difficulties third parties have had during this process. I think it's only fair to say that over the last couple of weeks things have
- 15:40improved. We've been able to ask questions. We've been allowed to follow answers through, and for and from where I've been sitting, it has felt like we've been getting a fairer hearing. What I did find a bit rich and a little difficult to swallow was the suggestion from Dalradians Council that it was the third
- 16:00parties who had somehow brought mine waste back into today's proceedings. We didn't arrive this morning planning to reopen mine waste. The questions came out of the evidence being given about restoration, the sequencing of the cells, the stripping and storage of peat and soil, the liner, and how all
- 16:18of this was actually going to be constructed. Some of the details only became clear as their own witness explained it today, and once that happened, third parties were bound to ask questions about it. That's part of the reason we're sitting here. So, if those questions exposed matters which hadn't
- 16:37been fully dealt with before, I don't think it's reasonable to blame the people who noticed them and asked about them. By late afternoon, we were still going. There were more questions about the stability of the stored peat and soil, whether the analysis dealt with the actual stockpile material or
- 16:56principally the berms containing it, how the different cells would be accessed and constructed, where the waste rock for the starter berm comes from, and whether potentially acid generating rock could be involved. Dr. Emmerman also raised another question, which I suspect we may hear more about.
- 17:17When cell two is eventually being constructed, cell one will already be quite high and contain mine waste. His questions concerned the stability of that arrangement and the people who would actually have to work below the threatening wall of mine waste. So a day which began with
- 17:38landscape and visual amenity had, by 4o'clock brought us right back into engineering and mine waste. I suppose I came away thinking about the even was just how much has to happen before you ever arrive at the finished green landscape picture in the visualisations. Peat and soil have to be stripped and
- 18:00stored, cells excavated and prepared, drainage and liners installed, tailings deposited, materials moved around the site, while completed areas are covered and vegetation is expected to establish. All of it happening progressively over many years, and eventually we may arrive at the green mound in
- 18:21the picture, but where does all the material go in the meantime? Will the vegetation actually establish and survive? What happens if there's more peat or soil than was predicted, and what happens when nature doesn't behave according to the landscape management plan? And do these visualisations give the
- 18:42commission and the people living around this proposed mine a reasonable idea of what they're going to be looking at while all of this is going on? It was just another ordinary day at the inquiry. See you all tomorrow. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the front line.
- 19:03Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or
- 19:21anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the
- 19:41water, the air, and the people who protect them.