Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Law of Scarcity in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, you ever notice how the thing you ignore on your desk suddenly seems urgent the moment someone else asks for it? Luna: All the time. It's like the second I decide to clean out that pile, someone needs the exact document I was about to recycle. Lucas: Right. That's the scarcity principle at work — we assign higher value to things that are limited or hard to get. And in office politics, you can use that same dynamic to raise the perceived value of your contributions. Luna: So you're saying we should deliberately make ourselves less available? That feels risky. Lucas: It's not about playing hard to get in a petty way. It's about recognizing that when you're always available, always saying yes, your contributions start to feel like a utility — like running water. People don't appreciate running water until the pipe bursts. Luna: Okay, I'm listening. Give me a concrete example. Lucas: Let's use a real situation. I know a product manager, Sarah, at a mid-size tech company. She had this feature that kept getting deprioritized in sprint planning. Every quarter, the engineering lead would say 'we'll get to it next time,' and they never did. Sarah was frustrated because she'd done all the research, the customer requests were piling up, but she had no formal authority to force it up the list. Luna: Classic problem. How did she use scarcity? Lucas: She stopped pitching the feature in every planning meeting. Instead, she let the request backlog grow. She also quietly mentioned to a senior sales director that two major prospects had asked about that specific capability — but that the engineering team had indicated it wouldn't be available until Q4 at the earliest. Luna: So she created a perceived shortage — the feature was scarce because it wasn't going to be ready soon. Lucas: Exactly. And because the sales director heard it from a prospect, not from Sarah, it had more weight. Suddenly, that feature went from 'nice to have' to 'we're losing deals without it.' The engineering lead reprioritized it in the next sprint. Luna: But isn't that a little manipulative? I mean, she was framing a timeline that was accurate — Q4 was the real estimate — but she let the sales director draw his own conclusion. Lucas: That's the line. As long as you're not lying or fabricating demand, you're just surfacing information that already exists. The scarcity was real — the feature was limited by engineering capacity. Sarah didn't create a fake deadline; she made the existing scarcity visible to someone who could act on it. Luna: Okay, so the first rule: the scarcity has to be genuine. What else? Lucas: Second rule: scarcity works best when it's tied to a specific, legitimate constraint. Time, access, expertise, or data. If you're the only person who knows how to run a certain analytics query, that's genuine scarcity — and you can use it to get a seat at the table for projects that matter. Luna: But if you overuse that, you become a bottleneck. And bottlenecks get replaced or automated. Lucas: Absolutely. That's the third rule: scarcity needs to be renewable. If you're the only person who knows a process, your goal should be to eventually share that knowledge on your terms — after you've gotten the political capital you need. Otherwise, you're just a single point of failure, not a strategic asset. Luna: So it's about timing. You leverage scarcity at a key moment, then you transition to being a collaborator. Lucas: Bingo. There's a classic study in negotiation — people who showed up late to a negotiation but had a legitimate excuse actually got better deals than those who were on time. Why? Because their time felt scarce. The other party assumed that if they're late, they must be busy and valuable. Luna: But that only works if the excuse is legitimate. If you're always late, you're just rude. Lucas: Right. And that's the risk with the scarcity principle in office politics — if you cry wolf, you lose credibility. You can only pull the 'I'm fully booked' card a few times before people start thinking you're just bad at managing your calendar. Luna: So how do you calibrate? How do you know when to be scarce and when to be available? Lucas: Think of it as a rhythm. For most of your day-to-day, be helpful and accessible. That builds social capital. But when you have a specific ask — a project you want to lead, a promotion you're angling for — you temporarily tighten your availability. You become a little harder to book, you let a few non-critical requests wait an extra day. Luna: And the contrast makes people pay attention. Lucas: Exactly. There's research on the contrast principle — if you're normally very responsive and then you take a day to reply, people notice. They assume you're busy with something important. That gives you an opening to say, 'I'm focused on the X project, which is why I was slower to respond.' Now X project sounds important. Luna: I've seen that work. A colleague of mine once said, 'I can't make that meeting because I'm preparing the quarterly review for the CEO.' Suddenly everyone wanted to know what was in that review. Lucas: That's a perfect example. The scarcity was real — access to the CEO is limited. But by naming it, she raised the perceived value of her own work. She didn't even have to say 'my review is important.' She just let the scarcity speak. Luna: One thing I wonder about: does this work differently for people at different levels? Like, if you're an intern, being scarce might just get you ignored. Lucas: Great point. Scarcity only works if you already have some baseline of perceived value. If you're new or junior, you need to build some credibility first — be generous with your time, show competence. Then, once people know you're good, you can start being selective. Luna: So it's a two-stage process. First, build the reputation. Then, leverage scarcity to increase perceived value. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the political savvy comes in — knowing when you've built enough capital to start being scarce. Jump too soon, and you look arrogant. Wait too long, and you're taken for granted. Luna: Speaking of being taken for granted — I think a lot of people in support roles struggle with this. Their whole job is to be available. Lucas: That's a tough one. But even in support roles, you can create scarcity around your deepest expertise. If you're an IT support person who's the only one who can fix a legacy system, that's leverage. You can use it to negotiate for training opportunities or a better schedule. Luna: But again, you have to be careful not to become a bottleneck. The goal is to use scarcity as a lever, not a permanent state. Lucas: Right. The most politically skilled people I've seen use scarcity as a surgical tool — a few well-timed moves per quarter. They're not constantly playing hard to get. They're generous most of the time, and then they dial it up when it matters. Luna: If today was actually useful to you — and I feel like this is one of those episodes where you might want to try the technique — the way these stay ad-free is listener support. A quick coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps keep us going. Lucas: Yeah, we don't do sponsors, and we like it that way. If you've gotten value from a past episode or this one, that's the place. No pressure, but it genuinely helps us keep the lights on. Now, back to scarcity — one more thing I want to touch on. Luna: What's that? Lucas: The flip side: when someone else uses scarcity on you. If a stakeholder says, 'I need this by Friday or the deal falls through,' that's a classic scarcity play. The best defense is to ask for the underlying constraint. 'What specifically about Friday? What happens Saturday?' Often, the urgency is manufactured. Luna: So you call the bluff, but politely. Lucas: Exactly. 'Help me understand the timeline so I can prioritize correctly.' That forces them to either reveal the real reason or back off. And if the scarcity is real, you know you need to act. Luna: Good defense. I'll remember that. Lucas: So to wrap up: scarcity is a tool. Use it sparingly, with genuine constraints, and always with an eye toward building long-term credibility, not short-term wins. Luna: And if you misuse it, you lose the one thing that makes it work — trust. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for listening, everyone.