Latest / Stuff They Don't Want You To Know / CLASSIC: Can a President pardon himself?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Welcome back to fellow conspiracy realist. Tonight's classic episode is
- 0:04Speaker 1: I think a great window into unprecedented times hashtag no pun.
- 0:11Speaker 2: Left behind unprecedented presidential chaotic times. Yeah, can a president
- 0:18Speaker 2: pardon themselves? Is a question that you know, got a
- 0:22Speaker 2: lot more exploration when it became kind of a little
- 0:25Speaker 2: more of a possibility that it might happen. And then
- 0:29Speaker 2: this is really laying out the groundwork of the argument
- 0:32Speaker 2: you know, for and against this concept.
- 0:34Speaker 3: And the answer is that, yeah, obviously a president can
- 0:36Speaker 3: parton themselves. Right, we don't even need this episode. Let's
- 0:39Speaker 3: get out of here.
- 0:40Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah, it's not as simple, quite as simple as that.
- 0:43Speaker 2: It's just some nuance to this convom.
- 0:46Speaker 1: Yeah, we're speaking with Professor Brian C. Coult, who is
- 0:53Speaker 1: I would say, still the top legal mind on this
- 0:56Speaker 1: very specific question. And Professor profess us or called points
- 1:01Speaker 1: out several times things that just sound weird if you
- 1:04Speaker 1: weren't born in the US or live here where it's normalized,
- 1:08Speaker 1: Like talk to somebody from any other part of the
- 1:11Speaker 1: world and look at their reaction when you say, well, yeah,
- 1:16Speaker 1: kind of a US president can be a felon and
- 1:19Speaker 1: can run for office.
- 1:22Speaker 3: They just can't be from Austria.
- 1:24Speaker 1: They just can't be Arnold Schwarzenegger. Dang from UFOs to
- 1:32Speaker 1: psychic powers and government conspiracies. History is riddled with unexplained events.
- 1:37Speaker 1: You can turn back now or learn this stuff they
- 1:40Speaker 1: don't want you to know.
- 1:55Speaker 3: Welcome back to the show. My name is Matt, my
- 1:57Speaker 3: name is Nola.
- 1:58Speaker 1: They call me Ben. We are joined with our super
- 2:00Speaker 1: producer Paul, pardon me, decand and most importantly, you are here.
- 2:06Speaker 1: You are you, and that makes this stuff they don't
- 2:09Speaker 1: want you to know. This is a very special episode
- 2:12Speaker 1: for us today, friends and neighbors. In a way, it
- 2:15Speaker 1: is a follow up or I would see a spiritual
- 2:19Speaker 1: successor I love that to an earlier episode that we
- 2:23Speaker 1: did back in twenty seventeen, we explored the strange case
- 2:28Speaker 1: of Yellowstone's Zone of Death, a small area of land
- 2:32Speaker 1: in rural America where an odd loophole allows, what's the
- 2:36Speaker 1: best way to say, guys, allows in theory, someone to
- 2:38Speaker 1: commit a crime and avoid prosecut.
- 2:40Speaker 4: Yeah, sort of like a purge zone where you could
- 2:42Speaker 4: just you know, all bets are off billy nilly crime
- 2:45Speaker 4: down USA. But as it turns out, with today's as
- 2:48Speaker 4: with today's question not quite so simple. So maybe listen
- 2:50Speaker 4: back to that episode if you haven't heard it in
- 2:52Speaker 4: a minute.
- 2:52Speaker 1: Yes, and spoiler alert for all of you would be
- 2:55Speaker 1: super villains in the crowd today, it will not work
- 2:58Speaker 1: in practice. Do not attempt it. However, in this episode
- 3:03Speaker 1: we relied heavily on the work of Professor Brian c. Coult,
- 3:08Speaker 1: the man who discovered the loophole in the first place.
- 3:11Speaker 3: And he actually wrote back to us and gave us
- 3:14Speaker 3: a few what would you call them, just some feedback
- 3:18Speaker 3: on some of the things we discussed. One of the
- 3:19Speaker 3: major ones is it's definitely cult as insult cult.
- 3:23Speaker 1: Yes, and this when we received this email, we were
- 3:28Speaker 1: delighted because in the course of our research for the
- 3:31Speaker 1: Yellowstone episode, we learned more about the professor's work, not
- 3:36Speaker 1: just concerning the zone of death. We learned that for years,
- 3:40Speaker 1: Professor Cult has investigated a question increasingly important and relevant
- 3:46Speaker 1: in the realm of American politics. It is this, can
- 3:49Speaker 1: a president pardon him or herself? And that's what we're
- 3:53Speaker 1: looking at today. But today, you see, we are lucky
- 3:57Speaker 1: enough to go directly to the prime source. Friends and neighbors,
- 4:01Speaker 1: We would like to introduce you to Professor Brian Cault.
- 4:05Speaker 1: Thank you so much for joining us on the show today.
- 4:07Speaker 5: Professor, Oh, thanks guys, glad to be here.
- 4:10Speaker 3: First off, can you tell us, just in your own words,
- 4:13Speaker 3: what you do every day, What are you studying, what
- 4:15Speaker 3: are you teaching.
- 4:16Speaker 5: Well, I'm a law professor at Michigan State University and
- 4:20Speaker 5: I teach towrts and administrative law, but my research has
- 4:24Speaker 5: pretty much always focused on constitutional law and more recently
- 4:29Speaker 5: the constitutional law of the presidency, things like pardons, impeachment,
- 4:34Speaker 5: twenty fifth Amendment, that sort of stuff.
- 4:36Speaker 1: Fantastic, So first things first, Professor, I think what would
- 4:42Speaker 1: benefit everyone in our audience right now would be to know,
- 4:46Speaker 1: in approachable terms, what is a presidential pardon. We hear
- 4:51Speaker 1: the term thrown around a lot, and it seems like
- 4:54Speaker 1: occasionally there are also misconceptions about this.
- 4:57Speaker 5: Yeah, so there definitely are. Presidential pardon is actually a
- 5:03Speaker 5: range of possible things, but at its fullest extent of
- 5:07Speaker 5: pardon forgives an offender for the crime that they committed.
- 5:16Speaker 5: That's the most common way it's practice. It's usually someone
- 5:19Speaker 5: who's already served their sentence, but the pardon sort of
- 5:22Speaker 5: removes the conviction from his record removes any sort of
- 5:27Speaker 5: consequences that remain, so if he's still suffering from some
- 5:32Speaker 5: civil rights deprivations, like he can't own a gun or
- 5:36Speaker 5: can't get certain licenses, those go away along with the conviction.
- 5:40Speaker 5: The president can also pardon people before they've been convicted,
- 5:43Speaker 5: or even before they've been charged with anything. And if
- 5:47Speaker 5: he does that, then by getting rid of any sort
- 5:50Speaker 5: of criminal consequences for the person's actions, that can prevent
- 5:54Speaker 5: them from going to prison. And if the person is
- 5:57Speaker 5: in prison in the middle the sentence, the pardon would
- 6:01Speaker 5: free them. The pardon can also be something less than that.
- 6:06Speaker 5: It includes the power to commute a sentence, so you're
- 6:09Speaker 5: not overturning the conviction, but you are shortening the sentence,
- 6:13Speaker 5: maybe letting them go earlier or immediately. There's also the
- 6:18Speaker 5: power to remit fines. If you had to pay a fine,
- 6:21Speaker 5: they can the president can make them pay you back.
- 6:25Speaker 5: Important limits on this, though, are that the president only
- 6:28Speaker 5: has this power with regard to federal offenses, and it
- 6:33Speaker 5: has to be something you've already done, so the president
- 6:35Speaker 5: can't pardon you in advance and give you sort of
- 6:38Speaker 5: a free path to commit crimes. That then won't be crimes. Finally,
- 6:44Speaker 5: there is an exception for impeachment because the Constitution makes
- 6:48Speaker 5: the impeachment process separate from the criminal justice process. So
- 6:51Speaker 5: if someone's being impeached, the president can't do that. You
- 6:54Speaker 5: can't use the pardon to interfere with or overturn the
- 6:58Speaker 5: result of an impeachment.
- 7:00Speaker 3: Can you clear up for us just a little bit,
- 7:02Speaker 3: what exactly is the state of being impeached and how
- 7:07Speaker 3: does that relate to being fired from a job or
- 7:11Speaker 3: having a vote of no confidence?
- 7:15Speaker 5: Sure, So the impeachment process is People talk about impeachment
- 7:19Speaker 5: to refer to the whole process, but impeachment is just
- 7:22Speaker 5: the first part. So the House of Representatives, by a
- 7:24Speaker 5: simple majority vote, can impeach any executive or judicial officer
- 7:30Speaker 5: of the federal government, and that's kind of like indicting someone. Basically,
- 7:36Speaker 5: the impeachment is an accusation, and so if the majority
- 7:39Speaker 5: of the House votes to impeach, then you are impeached.
- 7:44Speaker 5: But that just means you're on trial in the Senate,
- 7:47Speaker 5: and the Senate is the decision maker. You're on trial
- 7:51Speaker 5: in the Senate. The vice president presides over the Senate.
- 7:54Speaker 5: But if the president is impeached and on trial, then
- 7:57Speaker 5: the Chief Justice of the United States presides, and if
- 8:02Speaker 5: a two thirds majority of the Senate boats a convict,
- 8:05Speaker 5: then you're convicted. You're removed from office at that point,
- 8:10Speaker 5: unless you are no longer in office. That's a whole
- 8:13Speaker 5: other that's a whole other chapter of my last book.
- 8:16Speaker 5: Can you impeach people after they've left office? But impeachment again,
- 8:21Speaker 5: just refers to the accusation. It's like the indictment.
- 8:25Speaker 1: Oh, I see, so not immediately in and of itself
- 8:30Speaker 1: a proven thing, just an accusation exactly.
- 8:35Speaker 4: It was like Clinton, for example, you know, did not
- 8:37Speaker 4: get removed from office, but was impeached. Correct Or is
- 8:41Speaker 4: am I misremembering that?
- 8:42Speaker 1: Censured?
- 8:43Speaker 5: I believe, yes, yeah, Clinton, Clinton was impeached, Andrew Johnson
- 8:46Speaker 5: was impeached. Neither of them were convicted. So it's a
- 8:50Speaker 5: it's a blight on the record. I don't know anyone
- 8:53Speaker 5: who would invite an indictment and say it's no big deal.
- 8:58Speaker 5: But without being convicted, he wasn't found responsible for whatever
- 9:05Speaker 5: it is he did.
- 9:05Speaker 4: Have we seen a successful full realization of the impeachment
- 9:09Speaker 4: process from a president. I can't think of.
- 9:11Speaker 5: One, not of a president. The only people convicted under
- 9:15Speaker 5: the federal system have been judges.
- 9:19Speaker 1: And going back to this concept of pardons, we're interested
- 9:25Speaker 1: in learning a little bit about your personal story. I
- 9:29Speaker 1: believe you were some of your first published work on
- 9:32Speaker 1: this concept occurred in nineteen ninety six during your time
- 9:37Speaker 1: with the Yale Law Journal, or you wrote for the
- 9:40Speaker 1: Yale Law Journal in this regard, when did you first
- 9:43Speaker 1: begin investigating this question and what originally inspired you to
- 9:47Speaker 1: do so.
- 9:48Speaker 5: So I was a law student at Yale and I
- 9:51Speaker 5: was taking a criminal procedure class. And people make fun
- 9:54Speaker 5: of Yale sometimes Yale Law School for being overly theoretical,
- 9:59Speaker 5: and sometimes that's that's a fair, uh fair accusation. But so,
- 10:05Speaker 5: for instance, in our criminal procedure class, we were talking
- 10:07Speaker 5: about presidential pardons, which is not really an important part
- 10:12Speaker 5: of criminal procedure in the ordinary course of things. But
- 10:15Speaker 5: the professor had some theories and we were talking about
- 10:17Speaker 5: the whole structure of the constitution. And you know, okay, great,
- 10:21Speaker 5: how that's how it works in practice, but how is
- 10:22Speaker 5: it in theory. That's what we really want to know.
- 10:24Speaker 5: So we're talking about pardons, and I raised my hand
- 10:27Speaker 5: and I said, can the president pardon himself, and Professor
- 10:31Speaker 5: thought about it for a second, said I don't know.
- 10:34Speaker 5: Why don't you look into that? So that weekend I
- 10:39Speaker 5: went to the library and I read a bunch of stuff.
- 10:42Speaker 5: And I came back on Monday and I said, well,
- 10:46Speaker 5: I did some research and can't say for sure, but
- 10:50Speaker 5: I think the better argument is that he can't. And
- 10:52Speaker 5: he said, well that sounds interesting. Why why don't you
- 10:55Speaker 5: write something up. I'll you know, I'll call it an
- 10:57Speaker 5: independent study. You get a couple of credits for it,
- 11:00Speaker 5: maybe you could get it published somewhere. So I spent
- 11:03Speaker 5: the next weekend doing a rough draft of that, submitted
- 11:06Speaker 5: it to the Yale Law Journal, got rejected. Asked the
- 11:11Speaker 5: professor olsh I sent it around to other places. He said, well,
- 11:14Speaker 5: you know law reviews. The way that works when he
- 11:17Speaker 5: publish is as a student, it's kind of hard to
- 11:20Speaker 5: get published. Send it out to a hundred places. You'll
- 11:23Speaker 5: probably get a hundred rejections, but who knows, maybe you'll
- 11:26Speaker 5: be lucky, you'll get ninety nine rejections. And before I
- 11:32Speaker 5: did that, I resubmitted it to the Yale Law Journal
- 11:35Speaker 5: and they decided to take it. On the second try.
- 11:40Speaker 5: One of the main concerns about publishing it was it
- 11:42Speaker 5: just it seemed like a ridiculous thing to even think about, right, like,
- 11:46Speaker 5: why would a president, how could that ever happen. This
- 11:50Speaker 5: was in the Clinton administration, It was before Whitewater really
- 11:55Speaker 5: got heated up. It was before people started asking about
- 12:00Speaker 5: the self pardon in the Clinton contexts. So my first
- 12:04Speaker 5: task was just sort of making it seem relevant. So
- 12:06Speaker 5: I talked about Nixon, and Nixon had asked his lawyer
- 12:09Speaker 5: about it, and his lawyer said that Nixon could if
- 12:14Speaker 5: he wanted, pardon himself, and some of the others in
- 12:16Speaker 5: the administration said he couldn't. So it was talked about then.
- 12:20Speaker 5: Some people speculated about it a little bit at the
- 12:23Speaker 5: end of the George H. W. Bush presidency, which back
- 12:26Speaker 5: then was not that far in the past, when he
- 12:30Speaker 5: pardoned all of the Iran contract defendants after he had
- 12:34Speaker 5: lost the election, and some people thought maybe he'll pardon himself.
- 12:40Speaker 5: But it was you know, they made fun of it,
- 12:42Speaker 5: they said, this is kind of kind of out there.
- 12:46Speaker 5: And what I think is most important about this, and
- 12:50Speaker 5: I continue to say this is the fact that it
- 12:54Speaker 5: seemed unlikely, the fact that it seemed out there is
- 12:57Speaker 5: exactly why it needed to be written about then, because
- 13:02Speaker 5: now you see this fast forward to twenty eighteen, President
- 13:07Speaker 5: Trump says he can pardon himself. Now everyone's talking about it,
- 13:10Speaker 5: and no one can make the arguments that they have
- 13:13Speaker 5: about self pardons without thinking about Trump. And if you
- 13:18Speaker 5: don't like Trump, you don't want him to be able
- 13:21Speaker 5: to pardon himself. And if you do like Trump, you
- 13:23Speaker 5: do want him to be able to pardon himself. And
- 13:25Speaker 5: the Constitution doesn't care if you like Trump or not.
- 13:28Speaker 5: Either presidents can pardon themselves or they can't. So really,
- 13:31Speaker 5: the only time you can get the real analysis, get
- 13:34Speaker 5: the real answer to the question is when it's purely hypothetical,
- 13:38Speaker 5: and at that time it was, and so I wrote
- 13:41Speaker 5: at the time what I thought was the best argument
- 13:43Speaker 5: against self pardons being constitutional. It was sort of a
- 13:51Speaker 5: curiosity out there for many years, and then a few
- 13:55Speaker 5: years ago, in twenty twelve, I wrote a book that
- 13:58Speaker 5: looked at a bunch of these sorts of questions. Can
- 14:01Speaker 5: the president be impeached while he's after he's president? Can
- 14:06Speaker 5: you prosecute a sitting president? Can the president pardon himself?
- 14:10Speaker 5: What about Section four of the twenty fifth Amendment for
- 14:12Speaker 5: disabled presidents. There's a loophole and term limits where where
- 14:16Speaker 5: Obama or George W. Bush could come back into office
- 14:20Speaker 5: looking at sort of crazy things like that, but again
- 14:23Speaker 5: with the idea of looking at it when it's not happening,
- 14:27Speaker 5: so that we can figure out what the right answer
- 14:29Speaker 5: is and not what the politically preferable one for us is.
- 14:36Speaker 5: And the book came out in twenty twelve, and the
- 14:40Speaker 5: argument about self pardons, I added some arguments against them.
- 14:43Speaker 5: I also looked at the other side, so the book
- 14:45Speaker 5: gives both sides of the argument on it. But again
- 14:48Speaker 5: in twenty twelve, it's still all seemed hypothetical. So I'm
- 14:53Speaker 5: glad that I said what I had to say before
- 14:56Speaker 5: I knew whether whether I wanted the p to partner
- 15:00Speaker 5: himself or not.
- 15:02Speaker 1: Absolutely, And that book is constitutional cliffhangers, a legal guide
- 15:06Speaker 1: for presidents and their enemies.
- 15:07Speaker 4: So it's interesting you spent so much time laying the
- 15:10Speaker 4: groundwork and answer asking these questions in a hypothetical bubble
- 15:13Speaker 4: kind of and now we're seeing maybe the first example
- 15:17Speaker 4: of a president where these questions are pretty relevant because
- 15:21Speaker 4: of potential dealings before he was president. With his very
- 15:26Speaker 4: complex business network and things like that that maybe haven't
- 15:29Speaker 4: quite been in play in the way that we're seeing now,
- 15:32Speaker 4: do you see it that way?
- 15:34Speaker 5: Yeah? And so the book tries to sketch out these
- 15:38Speaker 5: sort of hypothetical scenarios just to illustrate, just to make
- 15:41Speaker 5: it make it more lifelike, give some color to it.
- 15:47Speaker 5: And a lot of the things that I try to
- 15:50Speaker 5: put in there, I was thinking about, like if this happened,
- 15:52Speaker 5: what would have to what would have to happen before
- 15:55Speaker 5: a president would partner himself. But it have to be
- 15:57Speaker 5: a really weird situation. So that's part of the question
- 15:59Speaker 5: is when would it happen, what would it look like?
- 16:02Speaker 5: And I can't see the future, but I think that
- 16:08Speaker 5: the book holds up pretty well. In the chapter on
- 16:11Speaker 5: can you prosecute a sitting President? It sort of, I
- 16:15Speaker 5: don't know. It resonates a little bit with what's been
- 16:18Speaker 5: going on this last year and a half. The self
- 16:20Speaker 5: pardon chapter, similar things, the one on twenty fifth Amendment,
- 16:27Speaker 5: which people are talking about you. When I wrote this book,
- 16:29Speaker 5: I had to try to convince people one of these
- 16:31Speaker 5: things might happen someday. It would be good if we
- 16:34Speaker 5: thought about them now, and then within six months of
- 16:38Speaker 5: Trump coming in, we had three of the six chapters
- 16:40Speaker 5: in the news for if you count the people saying
- 16:43Speaker 5: that they should impeach Hillary Clinton, and so, yeah, I
- 16:50Speaker 5: didn't think any of this would be relevant anytime soon.
- 16:52Speaker 5: I didn't know we would elect a president who tried
- 16:54Speaker 5: to hit for the cycle based on my book.
- 16:57Speaker 1: And one thing that is fascinating about various conversations we've
- 17:03Speaker 1: seen regarding the concept of self pardoning is, well, I'd
- 17:08Speaker 1: like to go back to the earlier example you alluded
- 17:12Speaker 1: to with Nixon briefly in some work. It was surprising
- 17:18Speaker 1: to me and I think to many of us to
- 17:21Speaker 1: learn that Nixon had reportedly asked his own legal team
- 17:26Speaker 1: about this concept way back during his time in office.
- 17:30Speaker 1: Is that correct.
- 17:32Speaker 5: Yeah, I'm not sure if he asked the lawyers or
- 17:36Speaker 5: if he just said to the lawyers, what are my
- 17:38Speaker 5: options and they came up with that, But a pardon
- 17:43Speaker 5: was definitely something that was important, and so the question was,
- 17:47Speaker 5: if he's going to get a pardon, does he have
- 17:49Speaker 5: to wait and get it from Ford if he resigns,
- 17:52Speaker 5: or can he give it to himself, or you know,
- 17:54Speaker 5: maybe they wouldn't have even prosecuted him. We're not sure.
- 17:57Speaker 5: So it was even then, I know it was very real.
- 18:01Speaker 5: At the time, it was still hypothetical. And the lawyer said,
- 18:06Speaker 5: if you pardoned yourself. The option was presented as you
- 18:09Speaker 5: pardon yourself and then you resign, because just politically, there's
- 18:13Speaker 5: no way that you could do that and avoid impeachment.
- 18:18Speaker 5: Impeachment was already the process was already rolling. That would
- 18:21Speaker 5: have just accelerated it, and that would have been the end.
- 18:24Speaker 5: And he knew it. He knew it would have been
- 18:26Speaker 5: the end.
- 18:27Speaker 3: Can we jump back to Article two, Section two of
- 18:30Speaker 3: the Constitution just to really go over and lay the
- 18:32Speaker 3: groundwork of exactly what the Constitution says. A pardon is sure.
- 18:39Speaker 5: So I can pull up my little copy of the
- 18:43Speaker 5: Constitution here, awesome Article two. Article two talks about the presidency,
- 18:49Speaker 5: and here we go. Article two, Section two, Clause one,
- 18:53Speaker 5: the president dot dot dot shall have power to grant
- 18:57Speaker 5: reprieves and pardons for a against the United States, except
- 19:02Speaker 5: in cases of impeachment. And that's it. That's all it says.
- 19:06Speaker 3: So everything else is just us kind of deciding.
- 19:10Speaker 4: Pretty open and with that language, that pretty vague language,
- 19:14Speaker 4: you get what I've seen described as one of the
- 19:17Speaker 4: most king like powers of the presidency. That's how it appears,
- 19:20Speaker 4: and I think that's pretty accurate. I can't remember where
- 19:22Speaker 4: I saw that, but it just seems like a wave
- 19:24Speaker 4: of the hand and all your sins are wiped away.
- 19:27Speaker 5: Yes, and it is one of the most king like
- 19:30Speaker 5: and I think just sort of thinking about Trump and
- 19:33Speaker 5: the pardon power, it's it's easy to see why it's
- 19:37Speaker 5: very appealing to him because it's the most king like,
- 19:42Speaker 5: or you could say, the most CEO like. He just
- 19:44Speaker 5: sort of signs this paper and he doesn't have to
- 19:47Speaker 5: go through Congress. He doesn't really have any potential for
- 19:52Speaker 5: a court reviewing it because under the so called political
- 19:56Speaker 5: question doctrine, the courts will not look he had a
- 20:00Speaker 5: pardon and decide if it was warranted or not. So
- 20:03Speaker 5: it's unreviewable in court. And he just says it and
- 20:08Speaker 5: it happens. He doesn't even need a lot of people
- 20:12Speaker 5: to sort of follow along. It's not like something he
- 20:15Speaker 5: has to build support for. If he says, let this
- 20:17Speaker 5: guy out of prison, they let that guy out of prison.
- 20:21Speaker 5: So it's the closest thing, like you said, to what
- 20:26Speaker 5: a king could do, and it is it is very tempting.
- 20:32Speaker 5: I can imagine for presidents to look at that and
- 20:35Speaker 5: think about how they might use it.
- 20:38Speaker 1: And we know that traditionally presidents have not immediately entered
- 20:45Speaker 1: office and began exercising this ability to pardon people. But correctly,
- 20:52Speaker 1: if I'm wrong here, did the current president, Donald Trump,
- 20:55Speaker 1: as we record this, did he begin pardoning people earlier
- 21:00Speaker 1: than in his time in office than other presidents?
- 21:05Speaker 5: Well, in recent history there's been sort of a shift.
- 21:08Speaker 5: Presidents have pardoned less recently than they did in the past,
- 21:13Speaker 5: and they sort of waited till the end to do
- 21:19Speaker 5: many of them. But it wasn't the earliest in a
- 21:22Speaker 5: presidential term that a president had done it. It was unusual,
- 21:28Speaker 5: but it wasn't unheard of. And in a way that's
- 21:33Speaker 5: actually a good thing because the design of the part
- 21:35Speaker 5: and power. We talk about it being a king like power,
- 21:37Speaker 5: but remember the president's not a king. And the whole
- 21:40Speaker 5: reason to give the president this power instead of giving
- 21:42Speaker 5: it to say, Congress, by a congressional vote, you give
- 21:46Speaker 5: it to the president because the president is politically accountable.
- 21:50Speaker 5: He's always politically accountable, even though he doesn't run for
- 21:55Speaker 5: reelection for two more years, even if he's in his
- 21:58Speaker 5: second term and not going to be running for reelection.
- 21:59Speaker 5: He's politically accountable to the whole country all at once.
- 22:03Speaker 5: He's got political capital to spend, and that's where the
- 22:09Speaker 5: framers of the Constitution wanted the power to reside. So
- 22:12Speaker 5: if presidents do what President Obama did by waiting until
- 22:18Speaker 5: after the election to commute all of those sentences and
- 22:24Speaker 5: the disproportionate sentences for drug offenses, he'd been talking about it,
- 22:31Speaker 5: but he didn't do it until after the election, Or
- 22:34Speaker 5: President Clinton on his last day in office, pardoning Mark Rich,
- 22:39Speaker 5: pardoning Susan McDougall, pardoning Roger Clinton, his own brother, waiting
- 22:43Speaker 5: until after the election when he's not at all politically accountable.
- 22:48Speaker 5: Or President George H. W. Bush partnering the Iran counter
- 22:51Speaker 5: defendants again after the election. The president is supposed to
- 22:56Speaker 5: be politically accountable. It's sort of this little loop that
- 23:00Speaker 5: he still has the power even when he's not. But
- 23:02Speaker 5: that's not how it's supposed to work. So when president's
- 23:05Speaker 5: pardon early, that's good because then that means that Congress
- 23:09Speaker 5: can respond and the voters can respond in the term elections,
- 23:15Speaker 5: or in the presidential election.
- 23:17Speaker 4: All right, we're going to be right back with more
- 23:18Speaker 4: from Professor Called.
- 23:19Speaker 6: After a quick sponsor break, and we're back Professor Called.
- 23:30Speaker 3: Please correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm just going
- 23:31Speaker 3: to make a statement here that is what I believe
- 23:34Speaker 3: to be true. My understanding is that much of law
- 23:40Speaker 3: is based upon the previous findings and judgments that have occurred,
- 23:44Speaker 3: Like the guiding principles of what is now law is
- 23:49Speaker 3: from the past.
- 23:50Speaker 5: Right, Yes, to the extent that we have precedent, we
- 23:53Speaker 5: take those presidents seriously or are bound by them, depending
- 23:57Speaker 5: on what kind of precedent it is.
- 23:59Speaker 3: Is there any foundational case or president that has to
- 24:02Speaker 3: do with this at all? A president pardoning himself.
- 24:07Speaker 5: Well, we don't have any case law directly on point
- 24:11Speaker 5: on presidents pardoning themselves. The argument against self pardons relies
- 24:16Speaker 5: on a whole bunch of theories and doctrines that haven't
- 24:21Speaker 5: really been tested either. It really is fair to say
- 24:27Speaker 5: that if a president did this, it would be completely unprecedented.
- 24:32Speaker 5: Now I'll let me back up a little bit. There
- 24:34Speaker 5: are cases in the past of other people with pardon
- 24:37Speaker 5: powers purporting to pardon themselves. Mayors and governors, and those
- 24:45Speaker 5: cases are sort of obscure. They hadn't really been tested
- 24:51Speaker 5: in court, and so we don't have any precedent from
- 24:54Speaker 5: those either. But even if we did. The US Constitution
- 24:58Speaker 5: presidential pardon power is different, is distinct from any state
- 25:04Speaker 5: or local pardon power.
- 25:06Speaker 3: What was doctor Bonham's.
- 25:08Speaker 5: Case, So this was a British case back in the
- 25:14Speaker 5: seventeenth century, and the issue in that case is I
- 25:20Speaker 5: would say, the power of Parliament over the King and
- 25:28Speaker 5: the power of the common law over the parliament. So
- 25:36Speaker 5: I don't know, it's sort of a fundamental case for
- 25:39Speaker 5: judicial review. People think about it as looking at the
- 25:44Speaker 5: ability of courts to strike down statutes or not. I
- 25:50Speaker 5: haven't thought about it much in terms of the pardon power.
- 25:54Speaker 5: But basically the principle of Bonds case. What you'll see
- 25:57Speaker 5: it's cited for is people will say, if there's a
- 26:02Speaker 5: statute that Parliament passes, because this is an English case
- 26:07Speaker 5: and it's contrary to what have you natural law or
- 26:12Speaker 5: common right and reason was how they put in that case,
- 26:15Speaker 5: then then the judges have to they have to declare
- 26:20Speaker 5: it void. And so again this sort of spawned the
- 26:24Speaker 5: concept of judicial review. A court looking at something that
- 26:28Speaker 5: Congress has done or that a president has done. If
- 26:31Speaker 5: it's illegal, then the court has to say so. They
- 26:36Speaker 5: have to say what the law is. And if the
- 26:39Speaker 5: law is that this statute is unconstitutional, then they're supposed
- 26:43Speaker 5: to say so. The actual case was about, you know,
- 26:47Speaker 5: sort of a weird medical licensing issue back in seventeenth
- 26:52Speaker 5: century England. So I'm not I'm not real up to
- 26:56Speaker 5: date on what exactly was going on, doctor Bonham, and.
- 27:01Speaker 3: The Washington Post just cited it as a foundational case
- 27:04Speaker 3: for possibly this subject.
- 27:07Speaker 1: And as we're speaking about some popular sources of media
- 27:12Speaker 1: and news here in the US, Professor, earlier in May
- 27:18Speaker 1: of twenty seventeen, you wrote a piece for the Wall
- 27:21Speaker 1: Street Journal about the twenty fifth Amendment and specifically section four.
- 27:26Speaker 1: I believe we mentioned it briefly at the beginning of
- 27:31Speaker 1: our conversation today, but I was wondering if you could
- 27:35Speaker 1: tell us and the audience what the significance of Section
- 27:40Speaker 1: four of the twenty fifth Amendment is in this conversation.
- 27:46Speaker 5: Well, Section four of the twenty fifth Amendment is where
- 27:50Speaker 5: the sections three and four deal with presidential disability. If
- 27:54Speaker 5: the president is unable to discharge the powers and duties
- 27:57Speaker 5: of his office. Then Section three allows him to say
- 28:01Speaker 5: so and hand over power to the vice president, and
- 28:04Speaker 5: then when he's better, he says, okay, I'm better now
- 28:06Speaker 5: and he takes power back. Section four is thru when
- 28:09Speaker 5: the president can't declare that he's disabled or won't, and
- 28:13Speaker 5: it allows the vice president and a majority of the
- 28:16Speaker 5: cabinet to declare that the president is unable to discharge
- 28:20Speaker 5: the powers and duties of his office. Then the vice
- 28:23Speaker 5: president becomes acting president. It doesn't remove the president from office,
- 28:29Speaker 5: and the president is still in office. He just is
- 28:31Speaker 5: temporarily stripped of his powers and he can say I'm
- 28:34Speaker 5: not disabled either right then if there's a disagreement there
- 28:38Speaker 5: or if he's unconscious, once he regains consciousness, he can
- 28:41Speaker 5: say I'm fine. If the vice president and cabinet disagree,
- 28:47Speaker 5: then it goes to Congress and Congress has to decide.
- 28:49Speaker 5: But the deck is stacked very heavily in favor of
- 28:53Speaker 5: the president. There needs to be two thirds in the
- 28:55Speaker 5: House and two thirds in the Senate agreeing that he's
- 28:58Speaker 5: unable to his job before before he loses. So it's
- 29:05Speaker 5: it's really it's never been used. Section three has been used.
- 29:09Speaker 5: President's going in for Kolonoskoy, he's going to be unconscious
- 29:12Speaker 5: for a couple of hours. He hands over power to
- 29:15Speaker 5: the vice president. That's happened three times, but Section four
- 29:19Speaker 5: has never been used. And you know, a lot of
- 29:21Speaker 5: people look at it and think, oh, well, if the
- 29:25Speaker 5: president is nuts, then the vice president and cabinet should
- 29:28Speaker 5: say so, and then then that'll remove him from office.
- 29:31Speaker 5: But it won't. If he's loocid enough to contest the action,
- 29:36Speaker 5: it would probably result in him getting his powers back
- 29:39Speaker 5: within a few days, and now he'd be mad. So
- 29:43Speaker 5: it's not I'm not sure how it relates to self pardons,
- 29:48Speaker 5: other than the possibility that if they thought he was
- 29:51Speaker 5: about to try to pardon himself, maybe they could invoke
- 29:55Speaker 5: Section four. I went, I went and found the Washington
- 30:01Speaker 5: Post piece you're talking about. I had read it before
- 30:04Speaker 5: Lawrence Tribe normalize and it's one of these things and
- 30:08Speaker 5: I and I should say this in general, a lot
- 30:12Speaker 5: of the discussion about presidential self pardons gets these headlines,
- 30:18Speaker 5: and it's not always the authors that let's say this.
- 30:21Speaker 5: Sometimes it's just the headline oversimplifying. But the headline says, no,
- 30:25Speaker 5: Trump can't pardon himself. The Constitution tells us so, and
- 30:30Speaker 5: you can find things that are equally certain of people
- 30:33Speaker 5: saying yes, Trump can pardon himself. The Constitution tells us so,
- 30:38Speaker 5: and they're both wrong. The Constitution doesn't tell us one
- 30:41Speaker 5: way or the other. We've got it. It's Schrodinger's cat, right.
- 30:45Speaker 5: We won't know until there's an actual case and when
- 30:50Speaker 5: and if it happens a chortal rule on it, then
- 30:52Speaker 5: we'll know. All we can say at this point is
- 30:55Speaker 5: we don't know. The president can try. It might work,
- 30:58Speaker 5: it might not, and we can say, hey, here's what
- 31:00Speaker 5: I would say if I were a judge, and I
- 31:03Speaker 5: would agree with Tribe painter in Eisen in this Washington
- 31:08Speaker 5: Post piece saying, I think the best reading of the
- 31:12Speaker 5: Constitution is that the president can't pardon himself. But there
- 31:18Speaker 5: are good arguments on both sides. And I found where
- 31:23Speaker 5: they talked about Bonham versus College of Physicians. That was
- 31:27Speaker 5: their source for the notion that you can't be the
- 31:33Speaker 5: judge in your own case. I'm actually kind of proud
- 31:37Speaker 5: that it didn't occur to me to link Bonham's case
- 31:41Speaker 5: with self pardons, because I think that's a very roundabout
- 31:44Speaker 5: and obscure way to get to that point. One of
- 31:47Speaker 5: the main arguments that the president can't parton himself is
- 31:51Speaker 5: that you can't be the judge in your own case.
- 31:54Speaker 5: And remember I said that it was about some obscure
- 31:58Speaker 5: medical licensing issue. It turns out that's the part of
- 32:01Speaker 5: the case that they were drawing on, which is why
- 32:03Speaker 5: I didn't even occur to it. It didn't even occur
- 32:06Speaker 5: to me.
- 32:07Speaker 4: Isn't there also the notion that a pardon is inherently
- 32:09Speaker 4: the nature of it is that it's for someone else.
- 32:12Speaker 5: Yeah, So that was the main argument that I added
- 32:16Speaker 5: In twenty twelve. A friend of mine in law school,
- 32:20Speaker 5: when I was writing this original article was only thirty
- 32:23Speaker 5: pages long. I couldn't put in everything I wanted. He said,
- 32:25Speaker 5: you should argue a textual argument that the pardon is
- 32:29Speaker 5: something that's inherently bilateral. It's something you have to give
- 32:32Speaker 5: someone else, not something you give to yourself. And I said, now,
- 32:35Speaker 5: I don't know. I don't think so. I don't want
- 32:37Speaker 5: to make room for that. Then sixteen years later, when
- 32:41Speaker 5: I'm writing it, it occurs to me, I think about
- 32:43Speaker 5: it more that that's not actually worth including, that's not
- 32:47Speaker 5: just worth including that's actually the best argument there is.
- 32:51Speaker 5: All of this other stuff is sort of well, like
- 32:55Speaker 5: you can't be a judge in your own case. Of
- 32:57Speaker 5: courts will say you can't be the judge in your
- 32:59Speaker 5: own case when they're ruling against you being the judge
- 33:02Speaker 5: in your own case. But there are other instances where
- 33:04Speaker 5: they allow all kinds of self dealing, and they conveniently
- 33:06Speaker 5: forget to mention that. But if you can find something
- 33:09Speaker 5: in the text of the Constitution itself, that's the best
- 33:13Speaker 5: kind of argument for me. That's persuasive to me. So
- 33:17Speaker 5: with that argument, the idea is the argument that the
- 33:21Speaker 5: president can pardon himself is it doesn't say he can't.
- 33:23Speaker 5: It says he shall have power to grant pardons, and
- 33:26Speaker 5: it says there's an exception for impeachment. It doesn't have
- 33:28Speaker 5: any other exceptions. They say, well, if they wanted to
- 33:31Speaker 5: make an exception, then they would have said, and they didn't,
- 33:33Speaker 5: so he can. He can do it. But there are
- 33:37Speaker 5: limits inherent in what the definition of a pardon or
- 33:41Speaker 5: granting a pardon is in itself. So, for instance, I
- 33:46Speaker 5: mentioned before, you can't pardon someone for something he hasn't
- 33:49Speaker 5: done yet. You can only pardon past acts doesn't say
- 33:54Speaker 5: that anywhere in the Constitution. Where do they get that from. Well,
- 33:58Speaker 5: the courts are very clear that you can only pardon
- 34:00Speaker 5: things that have already happened. But it's inherent in the
- 34:04Speaker 5: notion of what a pardon is. So this argument is
- 34:06Speaker 5: the same thing that a pardon is just by definition,
- 34:10Speaker 5: something you give to someone else. And you can look
- 34:13Speaker 5: at other words that have the same Latin root paradonai,
- 34:18Speaker 5: like donate or condone. Like you wouldn't say I condone
- 34:23Speaker 5: my own actions. That doesn't make sense. You wouldn't say
- 34:26Speaker 5: I'm making a donation to myself. That doesn't make sense.
- 34:29Speaker 4: If you said pardon me, you're asking for others to
- 34:32Speaker 4: excuse something that you have done. In like a social situation.
- 34:34Speaker 4: If I say pardon me, Matt, or I have beltched
- 34:37Speaker 4: or something, Matt would say of course, yeah, good sir.
- 34:40Speaker 3: You know, and stop a builching in my direction.
- 34:44Speaker 5: Yes, that probably also has roots in Mary Old England too.
- 34:49Speaker 5: But I think in addition to the argument that a
- 34:54Speaker 5: pardon is inherently something you give to someone else, and
- 34:57Speaker 5: the notion that the courts prove of people being the
- 35:01Speaker 5: judge in their own case, there's also a historical argument
- 35:06Speaker 5: based on how the people debating the constitution the Constitutional
- 35:11Speaker 5: Convention talked about pardon powers. They were worried about giving
- 35:15Speaker 5: the pardon power to the president, and Edmund Randolph, one
- 35:19Speaker 5: of the delegates, proposed This is all recorded in James
- 35:22Speaker 5: Madison's notes. Edmund Randolph said, well, we need to make
- 35:27Speaker 5: an exception. We need to not allow presidents to pardon
- 35:30Speaker 5: people for treason. And the reason he said was the
- 35:32Speaker 5: president may himself be guilty. He said, the traders may
- 35:36Speaker 5: be his own instruments, and so we can't let the
- 35:39Speaker 5: president have the power to pardon these other traders that
- 35:43Speaker 5: he's a trader along with. And James Wilson, another delegate
- 35:50Speaker 5: later on the Supreme Court responded, he said, if the
- 35:53Speaker 5: president be himself a party to the guilt, he can
- 35:56Speaker 5: be impeached and prosecuted. And everyone said, oh, yeah, that's right,
- 36:00Speaker 5: And they voted and rejected Randolph's motion, and they didn't
- 36:04Speaker 5: restrict the pardon power for cases of treason, and they
- 36:08Speaker 5: didn't talk about self pardons. But what this tells us is,
- 36:12Speaker 5: first of all, if any of those people thought that
- 36:15Speaker 5: the president could pardon himself, the notion that, well, if
- 36:19Speaker 5: the president's guilty, we can just prosecute him. That wouldn't
- 36:22Speaker 5: have been persuasive at all, and no one said that,
- 36:25Speaker 5: so they must not have thought that the president can
- 36:28Speaker 5: pardon himself. Additionally, if anyone thought the president could pardon himself,
- 36:33Speaker 5: then they would have talked about restricting that, not saying
- 36:35Speaker 5: he couldn't pardon traders, but that he couldn't pardon himself.
- 36:38Speaker 5: But they didn't. They did they say the president can
- 36:42Speaker 5: pardon himself. No, but I think that that little piece
- 36:46Speaker 5: of evidence shows that they thought that. It literally went
- 36:49Speaker 5: without saying that a self pardon is not possible. I
- 36:53Speaker 5: think that there is an argument on the other side
- 36:56Speaker 5: of this, which is that the president is both the
- 37:01Speaker 5: sovereign and a person, and so he can pardon himself
- 37:06Speaker 5: because it's it would be Trump, the president giving a
- 37:09Speaker 5: pardon to Trump the person, and so it's inherently bilateral
- 37:13Speaker 5: that way. So you know, it's it's not a killer argument.
- 37:16Speaker 5: Like I said, there are good arguments on both sides,
- 37:18Speaker 5: but to me, it's a it's a pretty persuasive one.
- 37:21Speaker 5: I think it's the best argument against self pardons because again,
- 37:24Speaker 5: it's in the constitution it's inherent in the definition of
- 37:27Speaker 5: the word parton itself.
- 37:29Speaker 1: Absolutely, But where does this lead us? Will be back
- 37:33Speaker 1: after a word from our sponsor. Going off our hypothetical
- 37:42Speaker 1: pardon me example, let's go into the realm of speculation
- 37:49Speaker 1: just a bit. Let's imagine that the current president, or
- 37:56Speaker 1: just any president does some how successfully attempt this move,
- 38:06Speaker 1: they successfully pardon themselves. What would happen afterward? What sort
- 38:14Speaker 1: of impact would this have on the US government, on
- 38:20Speaker 1: the hearts and minds of the public. What kind of
- 38:24Speaker 1: consequences or implications could we possibly expect if something like
- 38:30Speaker 1: this were ever to occur.
- 38:32Speaker 5: Yeah, I think that ultimately that's the most important question, because,
- 38:38Speaker 5: just like impeachment, the pardon power exists in a political context.
- 38:43Speaker 5: If the president thinks it's a good idea to pardon someone,
- 38:46Speaker 5: then he does it, and that's why he has the power.
- 38:49Speaker 5: And so thinking about how it would look in my
- 38:54Speaker 5: own writing, I set up this hypothetical example of a
- 38:59Speaker 5: president and who has been accused of all these crimes,
- 39:04Speaker 5: and there's some questions whether you can prosecute him while
- 39:07Speaker 5: they're in office. So he's running for he's in a
- 39:11Speaker 5: second term, so there's there's an election going on and
- 39:14Speaker 5: it's very divisive, and the other party is saying the
- 39:18Speaker 5: president's a crook, and if I get elected, the Kennedy,
- 39:23Speaker 5: the other party says, if I get elected, I'm going
- 39:26Speaker 5: to appoint this guy as prosecutor and we're going to
- 39:28Speaker 5: go after the president, kind of like what Trump was
- 39:31Speaker 5: saying he would do about Hillary Clinton, although he didn't
- 39:35Speaker 5: end up doing it, and that person wins the election.
- 39:40Speaker 5: And the President has been saying all along, I didn't
- 39:43Speaker 5: do anything wrong, and my people in my administration haven't
- 39:47Speaker 5: done anything wrong. And so he waits until again he's
- 39:53Speaker 5: not politically accountable anymore, and he says, well, I'll just
- 39:58Speaker 5: read here. He says, for ten months, these scurreless accusations
- 40:01Speaker 5: have paralyzed the country. We've been unable to work on
- 40:04Speaker 5: the real problems Americans face. That problem was about to
- 40:07Speaker 5: get worse. Enough is enough with this pardon. I'm ending
- 40:10Speaker 5: this expensive distraction. Right. He has the power to do this,
- 40:15Speaker 5: and he's going to use it. So that's how the President,
- 40:19Speaker 5: i think most likely, would frame it. That he's not
- 40:23Speaker 5: forgiving himself for doing something wrong, he is preventing these
- 40:29Speaker 5: runaway prosecutors from doing an injustice to him. That's how
- 40:33Speaker 5: he would spin it, and a certain percentage of the
- 40:38Speaker 5: country would probably go along with that. So politically, the
- 40:42Speaker 5: question would be how many people would buy that line
- 40:46Speaker 5: of rhetoric. I think it would be a scandalous enough
- 40:51Speaker 5: act to enough people that the president would wait until
- 40:55Speaker 5: he was on his way out of office to do it,
- 40:58Speaker 5: especially if he couldn't be secuted while in office. That's
- 41:01Speaker 5: an open question too. But if you can't prosecute the
- 41:04Speaker 5: president while he's in office, and you can, if you're
- 41:07Speaker 5: the president, pardon someone who hasn't been charged with anything yet,
- 41:13Speaker 5: then that sets up this potential. So on his way
- 41:16Speaker 5: out of office he pardons himself. If he's on his
- 41:19Speaker 5: way out of office, then the political fallout as much less. So,
- 41:25Speaker 5: to answer your question, if the president's not on his
- 41:28Speaker 5: way out of office, if they're pursuing him and he
- 41:31Speaker 5: says I'm I'm just gonna pardon myself, I think the
- 41:33Speaker 5: political follow would be tremendous. I think the prosecutor who
- 41:38Speaker 5: was pursuing him would not just say, oh, I guess
- 41:41Speaker 5: I can't prosecute you. Then he would challenge it in
- 41:43Speaker 5: court because it's not clear that the president can pardon himself.
- 41:47Speaker 5: It would be swiftly appealed up to the Supreme Court,
- 41:51Speaker 5: I think, but it would. It would It would be
- 41:54Speaker 5: a divisive issue, and the people who agree with the
- 41:56Speaker 5: president that he didn't do anything wrong would think it's great,
- 42:00Speaker 5: and the people who disagree with the president and think
- 42:02Speaker 5: that he's a crook would think that it's terrible. And
- 42:07Speaker 5: I think there'd be a lot of people in the
- 42:08Speaker 5: middle who would say, I don't know what happened, if
- 42:10Speaker 5: he's a crook or not. But I don't think that
- 42:12Speaker 5: pardoning yourself is okay. I think, you know, you need
- 42:17Speaker 5: to not put yourself above the law. You need to
- 42:19Speaker 5: let other people make that decision. And that takes us
- 42:22Speaker 5: back to Nixon. I mean, talk about what would have
- 42:25Speaker 5: happened if Nixon had pardoned himself. We can only speculate,
- 42:28Speaker 5: but we do know what happened after Nixon resigned and
- 42:31Speaker 5: shortly thereafter Gerald Ford, who came into office untouched by
- 42:35Speaker 5: the whole Watergate scandal. He had very high approval ratings
- 42:39Speaker 5: and he decides he's going to pardon Nixon and immediately
- 42:44Speaker 5: very controversial decision. His approval ratings drop most of the
- 42:48Speaker 5: data that I've seen suggest it cost him the election
- 42:51Speaker 5: in nineteen seventy six. Two years later, he's running for reelection.
- 42:54Speaker 5: He are not reelection, but to stay in office for
- 43:00Speaker 5: more years, and he narrowly loses. He it was a
- 43:04Speaker 5: close election, and if you look at the data what
- 43:08Speaker 5: people thought about that part and that pardon cost him
- 43:10Speaker 5: the election. So you can only imagine how much worse
- 43:14Speaker 5: it would be if Nixon had done it himself. Ford said,
- 43:17Speaker 5: we've got to move on. This is the right thing
- 43:19Speaker 5: to do. If Nixon had said that, it wouldn't have
- 43:22Speaker 5: been convincing at all. So politically, if the president's still
- 43:28Speaker 5: in office, it would be a it would be throwing
- 43:31Speaker 5: a bomb. If he's on his way out of office,
- 43:36Speaker 5: it would be controversial, but he wouldn't be president anymore,
- 43:38Speaker 5: so it wouldn't It would be tabloid fodder, right, it
- 43:42Speaker 5: would be cable news fodder, but it wouldn't. It wouldn't
- 43:46Speaker 5: have the same sort of political impact. I think everyone
- 43:49Speaker 5: would just wait and see what the courts had to
- 43:50Speaker 5: say about it.
- 43:51Speaker 1: But then on the flip side of the speculative world,
- 43:56Speaker 1: we're exploring here, what if a standing president or president
- 44:01Speaker 1: on the way out attempts to self pardon, and that
- 44:05Speaker 1: attempt fails, wouldn't they still encounter the same enormous potential
- 44:13Speaker 1: for backlash because I imagine a lot of people who
- 44:16Speaker 1: were going back to what you said about the supporters
- 44:19Speaker 1: thinking it's a good idea, the opponent's thinking it's a
- 44:22Speaker 1: bad idea. Wouldn't a lot of people in the anti
- 44:27Speaker 1: administration side see that as a smoking gun, more or
- 44:34Speaker 1: less indicating some sort of truth to all the problems
- 44:38Speaker 1: they had with that administration.
- 44:40Speaker 5: Well, I think they could. They could look at that
- 44:42Speaker 5: and say, see, see what kind of person this is.
- 44:45Speaker 5: But I think that supporters would say what they've been
- 44:49Speaker 5: saying all along, if they if they have supported them
- 44:52Speaker 5: this long in saying that the accusations against him are fause,
- 44:56Speaker 5: they would probably go along for the ride there too.
- 45:00Speaker 5: And and that's an important thing about pardons that I
- 45:03Speaker 5: think has overlooked a lot. I had a piece. I
- 45:07Speaker 5: don't know if anyone saw it, but I I but
- 45:09Speaker 5: I liked it. It was in the New York Daily
- 45:11Speaker 5: News a few weeks ago, where you hear people say
- 45:16Speaker 5: this a lot, that a pardon is a declaration of guilt,
- 45:20Speaker 5: and that accepting a pardon is an admission of guilt,
- 45:24Speaker 5: and so you, yeah, you might. You might have people saying, uh, see,
- 45:29Speaker 5: he pardoned himself. That means he's admitting he was guilty.
- 45:32Speaker 5: But that's that's actually not right. That notion that a
- 45:36Speaker 5: pardon is an admission of guilt, accepting a pardon is
- 45:39Speaker 5: an admission of guilt is taking this one line from
- 45:44Speaker 5: this one Supreme Court case out of context and reading
- 45:49Speaker 5: it into a completely different one and and really missing
- 45:52Speaker 5: the point. Presidents almost always use pardons to forgive guilty
- 45:58Speaker 5: people who may don't deserve the punishment that they got,
- 46:03Speaker 5: but they can also Presidents can also use the pardon
- 46:07Speaker 5: power to exonerate people, and it's not the most usual
- 46:11Speaker 5: use of it, but sometimes they do. President Ford pardon
- 46:15Speaker 5: Nixon for giving someone who is guilty. He also pardoned
- 46:18Speaker 5: Tokyo Rose. She had been convicted of making propaganda broadcasts
- 46:25Speaker 5: during World War Two, and she was an American citizen
- 46:29Speaker 5: living in Japan, and they said, oh, she was broadcasting
- 46:33Speaker 5: these terrible things. Turns out sixty minutes does his story.
- 46:36Speaker 5: It turns out the case against her was based on
- 46:40Speaker 5: perjury and it was totally trumped up. Charges against her
- 46:45Speaker 5: and she was completely innocent, and sixty minutes had this
- 46:49Speaker 5: big story about it, and President Porziella, this is terrible.
- 46:53Speaker 5: Let's do what we can to pardon her, and he
- 46:55Speaker 5: did not because she was guilty. It wasn't a declaration
- 46:59Speaker 5: of guilt because she wasn't guilty. And when she accepted
- 47:02Speaker 5: the pardon, she wasn't admitting she was guilty. She was
- 47:05Speaker 5: accepting it because she wasn't. And Trump himself just pardoned
- 47:10Speaker 5: Jack Johnson posthumously, the boxer again, not because he was
- 47:15Speaker 5: guilty but should be forgiven, but because he wasn't guilty.
- 47:18Speaker 5: The case against him was bogus. So this notion that
- 47:24Speaker 5: he won't do it because it would require him to
- 47:26Speaker 5: admit guilt, I think is wrong, and people are missing
- 47:29Speaker 5: the potential for a president to put it in the
- 47:31Speaker 5: language that I had it in my book, where he says,
- 47:35Speaker 5: I'm not guilty, I'm innocent, and these people are coming
- 47:38Speaker 5: after me anyway even though I'm innocent. But I have
- 47:40Speaker 5: the power to stop that, so I'm going to use
- 47:42Speaker 5: that power. That's what he would say, and so any
- 47:45Speaker 5: political reaction would have to reflect that context. If the
- 47:51Speaker 5: president was saying I'm guilty, but Hey, it's good to
- 47:56Speaker 5: be the king and pardon himself. That would be much
- 47:59Speaker 5: more controversal, much more unacceptable, but I think also, as
- 48:03Speaker 5: a result, much less likely to happen.
- 48:05Speaker 3: So let's talk kind of an out there hypothetical strategy, Noel,
- 48:11Speaker 3: that you were talking about earlier. Would it be possible
- 48:15Speaker 3: for a sitting president to use one of the clauses
- 48:19Speaker 3: to step down as president temporarily accept a pardon from
- 48:23Speaker 3: the person who is then president in that momentary timeline,
- 48:29Speaker 3: and then step back in.
- 48:31Speaker 5: Yes, so, I guess that's what you were referring to
- 48:36Speaker 5: Section four and twenty fifth Amendment about Yes, the president
- 48:40Speaker 5: could do that. Now, it's important to make a distinction
- 48:44Speaker 5: about whether such a pardon would be valid and whether
- 48:48Speaker 5: such a pardon would be able to be done with impunity,
- 48:53Speaker 5: because if the president did that, and then presumably you know,
- 48:56Speaker 5: once he's back, he pardons the vice president quid pro quo,
- 49:03Speaker 5: those pardons would be valid. Right when you're the president
- 49:07Speaker 5: or when you're the acting president, you pardon someone that
- 49:09Speaker 5: that pardon sticks, But you also can be impeached for that,
- 49:15Speaker 5: and you can be prosecuted for it too, if it's
- 49:17Speaker 5: part of a criminal enterprise. So if if I give
- 49:21Speaker 5: the president a million dollars in exchange for pardon and
- 49:24Speaker 5: he pardons me, that pardon is valid, but we're both
- 49:27Speaker 5: going to go to prison for the bribe. And because
- 49:32Speaker 5: you can only pardon something that's already been done. If
- 49:35Speaker 5: the pardon is this criminal, you can't pardon yourself for
- 49:37Speaker 5: pardoning yourself, right the last one. They'll always get you
- 49:40Speaker 5: for the last one. So yeah, the president could could
- 49:45Speaker 5: hand over power to the vice president, the vice president
- 49:48Speaker 5: pardons him, hands power back, he returns the favor, or
- 49:52Speaker 5: he could resign. That's that's basically what Nixon and Ford did.
- 49:56Speaker 5: Nixon resign, Ford pardon Nixon for didn't need a pardon,
- 50:00Speaker 5: So there is no sort of quid pro quo there.
- 50:04Speaker 5: If it's part of a corrupt conspiracy, then it would
- 50:08Speaker 5: be punished as part of a corrupt conspiracy, even though
- 50:10Speaker 5: the pardons themselves would probably stick. I don't think there's
- 50:15Speaker 5: any question about that. There are some people who would
- 50:18Speaker 5: say that a court would refuse to honor such a pardon,
- 50:22Speaker 5: but I based on the case, I don't see that happening.
- 50:26Speaker 5: I think it's also worth mentioning how this would play
- 50:28Speaker 5: out if you have a pardon, it doesn't actually mean
- 50:31Speaker 5: anything unless someone tries to do something to you that
- 50:34Speaker 5: the pardon says they can't. So if you have a
- 50:36Speaker 5: pardon and they say, well, I'm going to prosecute you say,
- 50:39Speaker 5: well you can't because I have a pardon. Then they
- 50:41Speaker 5: try to prosecute you anyway, then the court has to
- 50:44Speaker 5: decide whether the pardon is valid or not. If no
- 50:47Speaker 5: one tries to pardon the president, he pardons himself, or
- 50:51Speaker 5: the vice president pardens him and no one tries to
- 50:53Speaker 5: prosecute him, then we don't know if it's valid or
- 50:56Speaker 5: not because it doesn't matter. It's only when he tries
- 50:59Speaker 5: to do something that would only be he'd only be
- 51:02Speaker 5: able to do if the pardon were valid, that we
- 51:04Speaker 5: would find out. There's there's you know, a lot of
- 51:09Speaker 5: a lot of things would have to happen before a
- 51:11Speaker 5: president would get prosecuted. It's not just the self pardon
- 51:15Speaker 5: being a remote hypothetical, it's it's also the prosecution itself
- 51:20Speaker 5: that was remote. So, you know, I love talking about
- 51:24Speaker 5: these hypotheticals, but it's it's also hard to imagine the
- 51:31Speaker 5: vice president wanting to get his hands dirty in that way.
- 51:36Speaker 5: I'm not saying that it would never happen. I'm just
- 51:38Speaker 5: saying that the more things you add in that make
- 51:41Speaker 5: it unlikely, the more hypothetical it is, the less instructive
- 51:46Speaker 5: it is. It's hard to draw lessons from it.
- 51:49Speaker 4: Ford Nixon. To me, that's like a backroom conversation where
- 51:52Speaker 4: Nixon is like, no, that's how I see it. Why
- 51:57Speaker 4: did Ford parton Nixon knowing there would be political fallout.
- 51:59Speaker 4: It seems like it was something he was like doing
- 52:00Speaker 4: a favor for for Nixon.
- 52:03Speaker 5: Yeah, there are there are a lot of people who
- 52:04Speaker 5: think that Nixon made a deal with Ford. I'll resign
- 52:08Speaker 5: and then you pardon me. And I think Ford was
- 52:11Speaker 5: inclined to pardon Nixon because that's just the kind of
- 52:14Speaker 5: guy that Ford was. He he didn't he didn't think
- 52:18Speaker 5: that we needed to continue beating up on Nixon. He
- 52:23Speaker 5: thought that losing the office was punishment enough, all that
- 52:27Speaker 5: sort of stuff. And I don't I don't think that
- 52:32Speaker 5: Nixon really had any leverage over Ford. Like if he says, well,
- 52:35Speaker 5: I'll resign, but only if you promised to pardon me. Ford,
- 52:40Speaker 5: if he was if he was answering honestly, he said, well,
- 52:42Speaker 5: I was going to pardon you anyway? Why are you
- 52:43Speaker 5: saying that? Or or he could say why I which
- 52:48Speaker 5: which he actually did say. This is all in in
- 52:51Speaker 5: his autobiography, and it's been reported and al Haig's book. Well,
- 53:00Speaker 5: Haigu came to Ford before Nixon resigned. Haigu was Nixon's
- 53:04Speaker 5: chief of staff and said will you will you commit
- 53:10Speaker 5: to pardoning Nixon? And Ford didn't say yes, and he
- 53:17Speaker 5: didn't say no. And when he told his people later,
- 53:19Speaker 5: they said, well, you need to be more clear. You're
- 53:21Speaker 5: not committing to anything. So he called up hag He said,
- 53:22Speaker 5: I'm not committing to anything. But Nixon didn't have any leverage.
- 53:26Speaker 5: He was going to get impeached and removed. He was
- 53:31Speaker 5: going to have to resign anyway, pardon or no pardon.
- 53:33Speaker 5: Did he really want to pardon? Sure? Was Ford going
- 53:35Speaker 5: to pardon him anyway? Sure? But was there a deal?
- 53:38Speaker 5: I don't think so.
- 53:39Speaker 4: I think what I was getting at was that it
- 53:40Speaker 4: was more of a courtesy. And I'm wondering why the
- 53:43Speaker 4: conversation now isn't like, well, of course, Pence will pardon Trump.
- 53:47Speaker 4: Why are we talking about Trump pardoning himself when the
- 53:50Speaker 4: president has kind of been that has a courtesy, your
- 53:53Speaker 4: VP will pardon you anyway.
- 53:56Speaker 5: Well, I think maybe Pence will look at what happened
- 53:59Speaker 5: to Ford when Ford pardon Nixon, and say, if I
- 54:02Speaker 5: want to get elected in twenty twenty or whatever the
- 54:07Speaker 5: next election is, if this happened, I would have to
- 54:10Speaker 5: think seriously about whether to do this or not. And
- 54:13Speaker 5: if whatever it is that he's partnering Trump for is
- 54:16Speaker 5: something that involves himself as well, then that would be
- 54:22Speaker 5: politically difficult for him to do. Ford had the political
- 54:25Speaker 5: space because he hadn't been mixed up in Watergate. He
- 54:29Speaker 5: had the space to do that and not have it
- 54:31Speaker 5: look like an inside deal. In the same way, when
- 54:38Speaker 5: Bush pardoned the Iran contract defendants, that was controversial for
- 54:43Speaker 5: that reason because Bush was one of them. It looked
- 54:45Speaker 5: like he was helping them out of a mess that
- 54:50Speaker 5: he was in. Two So, yeah, a lot would turn
- 54:54Speaker 5: on that is Pence involved in whatever he's partnering him
- 54:58Speaker 5: for or not As far as courtesy is concerned, you know,
- 55:01Speaker 5: it's it's a political question. He would he would look
- 55:04Speaker 5: at the polls and they would they would survey people
- 55:07Speaker 5: and he wouldn't have to decide right away. This all
- 55:12Speaker 5: turns on the notion that the president is being prosecuted
- 55:16Speaker 5: for something, though, and I think, yeah, that's that's possible
- 55:21Speaker 5: that a former president would be pursued by a prosecutor.
- 55:24Speaker 5: But without knowing exactly what the case is and exactly
- 55:29Speaker 5: what the what the dynamics of it all are, it's
- 55:31Speaker 5: hard to say what Pence would or wouldn't do in
- 55:33Speaker 5: that situation. Because if if there's a smoking gun and
- 55:36Speaker 5: he looks guilty and it looks bad, then a pardon
- 55:39Speaker 5: would look bad. And if it looks like it's some
- 55:44Speaker 5: technical thing or some disputable thing, and Pence wants the
- 55:47Speaker 5: country to move on and he thinks that he can
- 55:49Speaker 5: sell that idea that this is about moving on, then
- 55:52Speaker 5: maybe he would. But he would he would have to
- 55:55Speaker 5: look at what happened for it and and realize that
- 55:58Speaker 5: unless he has thirty points of approval ratings to the spare,
- 56:02Speaker 5: he probably has to be real careful about.
- 56:05Speaker 1: That, because it's tantamount to political suicide, or at least
- 56:09Speaker 1: it seems that's the That's the way the average voter
- 56:14Speaker 1: would would look at a vice president right there, would
- 56:17Speaker 1: gaze unfavorably upon that, regardless of the circumstances that led
- 56:22Speaker 1: to that decision.
- 56:24Speaker 5: Well, I think that's the main thing that's different between
- 56:25Speaker 5: now and Watergate. You can talk about an average voter
- 56:30Speaker 5: in the seventies, and we were still being governed from
- 56:34Speaker 5: the center at that point, and now things are so
- 56:37Speaker 5: polarized and we've got two sides that have completely irreconcilable
- 56:44Speaker 5: versions of reality, and so there isn't an average voter
- 56:48Speaker 5: really like there isn't anyone in the middle. So I'm
- 56:52Speaker 5: not sure that I'm not sure that the political suicide
- 56:57Speaker 5: notion is something that translates exactly from the seventies. I mean,
- 57:02Speaker 5: he would have to take that seriously, he'd have to
- 57:05Speaker 5: look at what the poles say, but it would it
- 57:08Speaker 5: would play out in a weirdly different way. The same
- 57:13Speaker 5: with impeachment. Nixon didn't go until the Republicans turned on him.
- 57:18Speaker 5: The Democrats were in control of Congress. It looked like
- 57:21Speaker 5: they were going to drive the impeachment forward, but it
- 57:24Speaker 5: wasn't going to be successful until and unless the Republicans
- 57:26Speaker 5: turned against him. Well, that's the same situation now. You
- 57:29Speaker 5: don't get two thirds to vote to convict in the
- 57:32Speaker 5: Senate unless both parties agree. But you don't have anyone
- 57:36Speaker 5: in the middle anymore, and the Republicans have to pay
- 57:40Speaker 5: attention to the Republican primary voters. And with that polarization,
- 57:46Speaker 5: it's harder to paint a picture where something happens and
- 57:51Speaker 5: everyone agrees that it's bad, like it was in the seventies.
- 57:56Speaker 1: And I, you know, I'm having a hard time emphasizing
- 58:01Speaker 1: how much I appreciate that point about polarization, because for
- 58:06Speaker 1: everyone listening, regardless where you find yourself falling in your
- 58:11Speaker 1: own personal, political or ideological stances, the fact of the
- 58:17Speaker 1: matter is that the public in general is increasingly polarized.
- 58:24Speaker 1: And although precedent does exist, Professor cult, I think you
- 58:28Speaker 1: make some fascinating, fantastic, and to some degrees disturbing points
- 58:35Speaker 1: about the differences between previous decades and the age in
- 58:40Speaker 1: which we live today. Before we conclude today's episode, Professor,
- 58:47Speaker 1: we have a question for you that we are certain
- 58:51Speaker 1: is on the minds of our fellow audience members here,
- 58:54Speaker 1: and that is this, where can where can listeners go
- 58:59Speaker 1: to learn more about your work and to learn more
- 59:02Speaker 1: about the concept of pardoning or self pardoning specifically, So.
- 59:09Speaker 5: I would recommend if people are interested in my book.
- 59:14Speaker 5: That Chapter two of the book is the most comprehensive
- 59:18Speaker 5: treatment that I've produced on the self pardon question. For
- 59:24Speaker 5: twenty years, I was the only person talking about it.
- 59:26Speaker 5: Most of the discussion in the last year and a
- 59:29Speaker 5: half has drawn on the things that I've said, whether
- 59:33Speaker 5: they cited them or not. I think the book is
- 59:35Speaker 5: the best place to go. Just go to Amazon, type
- 59:39Speaker 5: in my last name, Kalt and constitutional cliffhangers, and it
- 59:44Speaker 5: should come right up. I think they've sold out of
- 59:47Speaker 5: the hardcovers, but the paperbacks are still available, and the
- 59:51Speaker 5: ebook version is still there. If they want to read
- 59:55Speaker 5: the original article in the Yell Law Journal nineteen ninety six, again,
- 1:00:01Speaker 5: google my name Calt and pardon me and SSRN. It'll
- 1:00:11Speaker 5: come up there and you can download the original article.
- 1:00:15Speaker 3: Awesome, We'll get out there on Amazon. Find that book,
- 1:00:17Speaker 3: check it out. There's all by the way, Professor called
- 1:00:21Speaker 3: you are all over just the Washington Post and the Internet.
- 1:00:24Speaker 3: When people are talking about this subject, you get a
- 1:00:27Speaker 3: lot of calls, don't you.
- 1:00:29Speaker 5: I do. It's a nice change from twenty years of
- 1:00:33Speaker 5: people thinking that it was ridiculous to even be talking
- 1:00:36Speaker 5: about this. Probably my highlight was in the preface of
- 1:00:39Speaker 5: the book, I talk about how I'm writing this book,
- 1:00:42Speaker 5: and I'm at this reception and I'm talking to this
- 1:00:45Speaker 5: prominent legal thinker and he asked me what I'm writing about,
- 1:00:49Speaker 5: and I tell him, and he looked at me and says,
- 1:00:50Speaker 5: why are you writing about that? And fast forward to
- 1:00:54Speaker 5: twenty eighteen and he has a piece in the Washington
- 1:00:59Speaker 5: Post about out whether the president can part himself.
- 1:01:01Speaker 3: So, oh man, it's a little terrifying that you're you know,
- 1:01:07Speaker 3: you were on the right track.
- 1:01:09Speaker 1: But it's a prescient as well. And we would like
- 1:01:13Speaker 1: to thank you again for being so generous with your
- 1:01:18Speaker 1: time with us today and for correcting or clarifying some
- 1:01:22Speaker 1: of the misconceptions regarding pardons in general that are so
- 1:01:27Speaker 1: common in the US, and I would say in larger
- 1:01:31Speaker 1: international context as well. So ladies and gentlemen, thank you
- 1:01:36Speaker 1: for tuning in. Please let us know further questions that
- 1:01:41Speaker 1: you may have while you're listening to today's episode regarding
- 1:01:44Speaker 1: the concept of self pardoning. You can find Matt Nole
- 1:01:49Speaker 1: and I on Instagram. You can find us on Facebook,
- 1:01:52Speaker 1: you can find us on Twitter, you can find us
- 1:01:54Speaker 1: on our fan page. Here's where it gets crazy.
- 1:01:57Speaker 4: And boy does it ever get crazy.
- 1:01:59Speaker 3: In that fan page, Professor called do you have a
- 1:02:02Speaker 3: Twitter that you'd like to plug here?
- 1:02:05Speaker 5: Yes, I'm on Twitter. I'm at Profbrian Cault.
- 1:02:11Speaker 3: There you go, prepare yourself for a lot of inquisitive minds.
- 1:02:16Speaker 5: Well, you know Twitter brings out the best in people,
- 1:02:18Speaker 5: doesn't it.
- 1:02:19Speaker 3: Yes, that's what I hear. And that's the end of
- 1:02:22Speaker 3: this classic episode. If you have any thoughts or questions
- 1:02:27Speaker 3: about this episode, you can get into contact with us
- 1:02:30Speaker 3: in a number of different ways. One of the best
- 1:02:32Speaker 3: is to give us a call. Our number is one
- 1:02:34Speaker 3: eight three three STDWYTK. If you don't want to do that,
- 1:02:39Speaker 3: you can send us a good old fashioned email.
- 1:02:41Speaker 1: We are conspiracy at iHeartRadio dot com.
- 1:02:45Speaker 3: Stuff they don't want you to know is a production
- 1:02:48Speaker 3: of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app,
- 1:02:52Speaker 3: Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.