Latest / Retail Fast Five / Sprouts’ New CEO, Costco Exits Its Marketplace & Ulta Is Told To Get The Flock Out | Fast Five
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, I am Chris Waltner, and welcome to this Week's Omnitalk Retail Fast 5, brought to you exclusively by the Omnitalk Retail Podcast network.
- 0:08This week, guest host Shelley Huff joins me and we get into a little bit of everything.
- 0:11Amazon, Costco, and even social media.
- 0:14Telling Ulta to get the flock out of here.
- 0:17Producer Ella let's cue the highlights.
- 0:21A retailer should not deploy technology like this unless they can actually explain it.
- 0:26Detection and prevention are two really different things.
- 0:30I ultimately think it's defensive for them.
- 0:33Yeah, survival of the fittest, no doubt.
- 0:35This is an example of really bad external and internal comms.
- 0:40Yeah.
- 0:40Costco does everything with conviction.
- 0:43I don't know that consumers are really going to be bothered by this.
- 0:45At the end of the day, do.
- 0:47You think any club should have a marketplace?
- 0:49The next generation of great brands won't just have customers, they'll have communities.
- 0:56Shelly Hoff, former Certus Simmons CEO and Walmart executive, and now CEO and co founder of the Interval.
- 1:02How have you been?
- 1:04Fantastic, Chris.
- 1:05I had a wonderful Labor Day weekend, got a lot accomplished, cleaned out my entire closet, went shopping and saw Zach Brian Live in Phoenix, which was fantastic.
- 1:17Oh, wow.
- 1:18That sounds like the absolute trifecta of a great Labor Day weekend.
- 1:21A little chores, a little shopping and a little concert going.
- 1:24Well done.
- 1:24It was perfect.
- 1:27So how are things going with the Interval?
- 1:28Let's start there.
- 1:29Like, you know, what's the four one, one on that?
- 1:30Where are things at?
- 1:32Yeah, so the Interval.
- 1:33We're gearing up to throw a lot host a lot of in person and online events all the way through the fall.
- 1:38So for those of you who don't know, the Interval is a community for C Suite executives and founders who are taking an intentional pause to design what's next.
- 1:47And it's a really great peer to peer community and you can find it attheintercommunity.com.
- 1:53The other exciting announcement we have is that we're launching our first six week experience called Design youn Next Chapter, which is led by two fantastic transition experts that we've partnered with to launch this coursework.
- 2:08So we're excited for that to kick off in the fall too.
- 2:11Oh, that's really it.
- 2:12Tell us more about that.
- 2:13So when you say transition experts, so like, what does that mean?
- 2:15What do you, what do you all get with that course?
- 2:17Yeah, so there we couldn't find anything that we really loved that was transition coursework directed at senior executives.
- 2:25So we used all the insights we've garnered from C Suite executives and founders over the last Two years and partnered with two excellent facilitator facilitators who have spent their life's work in transition.
- 2:38And we've designed a proprietary product for the interval members that we have.
- 2:43And it essentially takes everyone through the arc of this transition.
- 2:47And by the end, you have a really good plan of what you think your next chapter is going to look like.
- 2:53Wow.
- 2:53And so if people are listening and are like, wow, I want to learn more about that.
- 2:56Where do they go, Shelley?
- 2:57How do they find out more theintervalcommunity.com experiences and you can learn more there or reach out to me directly.
- 3:05Okay.
- 3:05Wow.
- 3:06Yeah, I imagine there's a lot of listeners that are going to be interested in that, especially with everything going on in retail right now.
- 3:10And to that point, Shelby, you know this is, we were joking before the show.
- 3:13This is your like 4th time co hosting with me.
- 3:16So I'm curious, like, you're close to the Five Timers jacket, the proverbial five Timers jacket.
- 3:20What's your approach for preparing for this show?
- 3:22Because I know it's early for you too because it's west coast time, you know where you are.
- 3:27So it's like 7:30 when we're recording this.
- 3:29So what's your approach?
- 3:31Well, I love coming on.
- 3:32So thanks for having me again.
- 3:33My fourth time, lots of coffee, early wake time, lots of coffee.
- 3:40And you know, I have to prepare for this and know that I'm going to defend all my points against you, a well known retail veteran.
- 3:48So I have, I've learned to evolve and like adapt as I'm prepared for each point.
- 3:53Yeah.
- 3:54And these headlines are pretty interesting this week.
- 3:56Do you have a favorite, you know, going in?
- 3:57Like, is there one that really caught your eye here before we get to it, before I give the full read down and rundown?
- 4:03Yeah, I really like the Sephora headline this week.
- 4:05I think it's interesting, I think it's future looking and I think it's thought provoking and it touches on multiple customer interaction points.
- 4:13So I'm excited to get to that one.
- 4:15Yeah, I think that's a really interesting one too.
- 4:17All right, Shelly, well, let's get to this week's Fast 5, which is of course brought to you with the help and support of the A and M consumer and retail group, Miracle Corso, Ocampo Capital, Veloc and RNS Logistics.
- 4:30In this week's Fast5, we've got news on Ulta getting dragged online this week over its use of controversial license plate surveillance technology.
- 4:38Costco quietly Shutting down its Costco Next Marketplace.
- 4:42Sephora piloting monthly drop storefronts on TikTok shop.
- 4:46We know Shelly's excited about that one.
- 4:48And sprouts farmers market naming a new CEO just as its comps turn negative.
- 4:52But we begin today with Amazon rolling out a one off grocery storefront this time for Labor Day.
- 4:58Headline number one is of course brought to you with the help and support of the A and M Consumer and Retail Group.
- 5:03The A and M Consumer and Retail Group is a management consulting firm that tackles the most complex challenges and advances its clients, people and communities toward their maximum potential.
- 5:12CRG brings the experience, tools and operator like pragmatism to help retailers and consumer products companies be on the right side of disruption.
- 5:20All right Shelly, let's get this party started.
- 5:22Headline number one.
- 5:23Amazon is running a limited time digital storefront.
- 5:27Top customers stock up for Labor Day, the latest in a growing string of its smaller occasion based online sales events.
- 5:33According to chainsaw age, Amazon ran a limited time online storefront offering discounts on select food items via a dedicated Labor Day grocery store timed to the federal holiday on an Monday, September not Sebastian deal categories included cookout essentials
- 5:51starting at $2.
- 5:51Think things like hot dogs and hamburger buns, summer produce under $4 and of course grilling proteins, all under $10.
- 5:59Every eligible item was backed by Amazon's freshness guarantee and prime members can get free same day delivery on eligible orders.
- 6:07This continues a pattern of smaller Amazon sales activations beyond its marquee events.
- 6:11Think prime day, big deal days, Black Friday week, including my personal favorite Shelley Pet days in May.
- 6:18So my question for you is Amazon keeps adding these smaller occasion based grocery storefronts to its calendar.
- 6:25Do you think these are smart, low cost, incremental share building moves in grocery or is it a gimmick that ultimately will not move the needle?
- 6:32Well, I think that this is ultimately defensive on Amazon's part.
- 6:35I think when they probably look, I think it's defensive and I'll share why?
- 6:41Okay, if they probably look at their market share, my hypothesis is if they look at their market share every week of the year, that they probably lose share during key holiday events like Labor Day.
- 6:51And that's because Walmart, Target, Kroger do it so well.
- 6:55When you walk into those stores, you see everything stacked out in bulk.
- 7:00Chips, meat, you know, beverages, all of these things.
- 7:04They actually remind you of everything you need to have a Labor Day gathering when you walk into these stores.
- 7:09And so I actually think during that time Amazon probably sees a dip in market share.
- 7:14This is defensive for them to try to get some of that back or not lose as much.
- 7:18And retail, more than ever, grocery, retail is becoming a share fight again.
- 7:23So you see Greg Faran is at the helm of Kroger just since he started.
- 7:28You see how many price drops I was in a Fry's three or four days ago.
- 7:32And you see how many price drops already are in the market putting a ton of pricing pressure on Walmart and Target and others.
- 7:38And then you've got Amazon, who doesn't have as much sharing grocery, and they're trying to fight for share during these key time frames.
- 7:46And so I ultimately think it's defensive for them.
- 7:49Wow.
- 7:49Okay.
- 7:49I didn't.
- 7:50I didn't even think about that angle.
- 7:51So defensive.
- 7:52Okay, let me ask you this.
- 7:53Can something be defensive and offensive at the same time?
- 7:56Not offensive, but offensive at the same time?
- 7:59I think that they would hope that's the case, that they would really have somebody new shopping them who hasn't before.
- 8:05That's.
- 8:06That enjoys the experience and may come back to them again.
- 8:10But ultimately, I think that they have a lot of work to do to build the awareness and the confidence that customers have to think of them for those key events.
- 8:18So I think they'll learn a lot and maybe they'll try something like this again.
- 8:23But I think that that's probably their.
- 8:26Their hope.
- 8:26Chris.
- 8:27Yeah, right.
- 8:28Right.
- 8:28Yeah.
- 8:28No, this is really.
- 8:29Oh, God.
- 8:29This is a really interesting conversation to start the show.
- 8:31I agree with you 100%.
- 8:33I don't think I can disagree with anything you said.
- 8:35I also think it is a little bit of an offensive move.
- 8:37So it's defensive and offensive.
- 8:39Like as I was answering the question myself, I think it's a floor wax and a dessert topic.
- 8:43If you remember that old 70s Saturday Night Live sketch, you know, with Dan aykroyd, because it's 100% a silly gimmick.
- 8:49Let's just call it what it is too.
- 8:50But, but the other part about it that makes it offensive in addition to defensive in the short run, in the long run, Amazon is playing the long game here.
- 8:58We've talked on the show a lot, probably even with you, Shelly, at times like Death by a Thousand Cuts.
- 9:02That's the strategy Amazon's taking here.
- 9:05And every time they can bait the hook, you even said it yourself, and they get somebody to bite, they end up triggering a grocery purchase and grocery recall around seasonal events, which are absolutely essential in grocery because of
- 9:18what you're basically alluding to is the basket size around these events.
- 9:22People go into the store and they get a lot of stuff.
- 9:25And so Amazon, if it keeps doing this, is going to slowly chip away at that and make it harder and harder for the average grocer to compete in the long run.
- 9:34So, and I think, you know, that's a good trick when you're talking about converting people to become more loyal to Amazon for grocery shopping.
- 9:42Of course, with that said, the part we didn't, neither one of us talked about too, Shelly.
- 9:46So I'm curious to get your last your thoughts here and give you the last word is Amazon's got to make good on the delivery, too.
- 9:51Like the product quality and the freshness has got to be there.
- 9:55Absolutely.
- 9:56And I think Amazon's gotten a lot better at that.
- 9:58And I think consumers, you know, tend to expect that from them at this point.
- 10:03So, yeah, if they can deliver on the promise, I think that they not only can maintain their market share, but chip away at some others.
- 10:10But I think it's going to be an interesting next 12 to 18 months in grocery in general to see where market share goes.
- 10:17Yeah, survival of the fittest, no doubt.
- 10:19All right, headline number two.
- 10:21This headline is brought to you by Miracle, the catalyst of Commerce.
- 10:24Over 450 retailers are opening new revenue streams with marketplaces, dropship and retail media and succeeding.
- 10:31With Miracle, you can unlock more products, more partners, and more profits without the heavy lifting.
- 10:36So what's holding you back?
- 10:37Visit miracle.com to learn more.
- 10:40All right, headline number two.
- 10:41Ulta Beauty is facing a social media backlash this week after an activist campaign went viral criticizing the retailer's use of Flock Safety's automated license plate reader technology at a small number of its stores.
- 10:54According to Retail Dive, social media users flooded Ulta's Instagram post this this week after a campaign by activist group Ultraviolet Cool Name went viral criticizing Ulta's relationship with surveillance tech provider Flock.
- 11:07The technology is deployed at fewer than 1% 1% of Alta's roughly 1500 store fleet nationwide, and a source told Retail Dive the cameras do not use facial recognition.
- 11:18Flock has faced growing public criticism and vandalism of its license plate readers in recent months, with some state and local governments reconsidering the technology's use.
- 11:28Flack's website also lists organized retail crime as a use case, and Ulta's director of organized retail crime has said the retailer sought the technology to help bridge the gap, end quote, with law enforcement after a rise in store
- 11:40violence following the pandemic.
- 11:42Neither Ulta nor Flack, however, responded to Retail Dive's detailed Questions about the relationship.
- 11:47Shelly Alta is framing this internally as an organized retail crime tool, but the online reaction is treating it as surveillance overreach.
- 11:56Is the viral backlash appropriate, or is ULTA just an easy target amid the broader anti surveillance movement?
- 12:03Well, this is an interesting topic today, and I'll probably say this very directly.
- 12:08Yeah, A retailer should not deploy technology like this unless they can actually explain it.
- 12:14And I think this is an example of really bad external and internal comms where there should have been a strategy around how to talk to consumers about this.
- 12:23And so what is even more interesting is they had an opportunity to start that discussion with Retail Dive, and then they refused to comment as well.
- 12:31So this is kind of leaving it very opaque for everybody to understand exactly what's happening.
- 12:37But a retailer does have a responsibility to protect not only the people that work at its retail locations, but also customers.
- 12:45And when we talk about surveillance, and I'd be curious about your perspective, Chris, is like, where do we draw the line?
- 12:50Because we've had cameras outside of malls during holiday times forever in order to protect people against theft.
- 12:57And so for me, this is not like a safety privacy question.
- 13:03It's what is being captured, what data is being captured, for how long?
- 13:08And how do you explain to your consumers and people shopping at your stores what is happening?
- 13:14And so, yeah, I think it's interesting because I think it's more of a communication problem than I think it is a surveillance problem.
- 13:24Yeah, and it's also.
- 13:24It's also.
- 13:25It's a tough communications problem too.
- 13:26Right, Shelly?
- 13:27Like, it's a hard one to know how to get out in front of from a communication standpoint, too.
- 13:31So my field goes out to the PR teams as well, because it's hard to know how to couch this.
- 13:36Like, I think of.
- 13:37We had a similar conversation.
- 13:39Ben Miller, on Grocery Talk, he talked about Sainsbury's use of facial recognition, which is going, you know, a step beyond because Flock doesn't apparently use facial recognition.
- 13:47It's just reading license plates.
- 13:49But, you know, Ben, you know, Ben was all for it for the reasons you said, because it was, you know, designed to help keep employees safer.
- 13:55But yet then they had a false positive where they accused somebody of shoplifting, and then social media blew up on it.
- 14:01And it was like one of those things where I was like, yeah, I personally, I don't know if I'd be.
- 14:05I'd be touching this.
- 14:07But then I come back on the flip side of it and go, yeah, but at the end of the day, I need to Protect my store employees.
- 14:12Like I need to do that.
- 14:14So I've got to figure out a way to do it.
- 14:16And so I think if you're going to deploy this type of tech, you either one, have to know your communication strategy to your point, or you've got to stand your ground and be ready for the backlash and give
- 14:28the rationale for why are you using it.
- 14:30But I think you have to tread cautiously still and dip your toe into it, which is my hunch.
- 14:37My hunch is that all these technologies are being deployed in this way.
- 14:43The question I have too is, are they really moving the needle and are they worth art?
- 14:48Is the juice, worth the squeeze on them?
- 14:51In terms of the social media backlash and the distraction for the comms teams internally in your organizations, I think those are the questions you have to ask because detection and prevention are two really different things.
- 15:02And I'm still not sure I've seen a silver bullet on how do you actually prevent versus how do you just detect?
- 15:08But I don't know.
- 15:09What do you think, Shelley?
- 15:10I think that's right.
- 15:11I think technology is going to be deployed at a faster rate than ever in the past in retail.
- 15:18So the point is be transparent about it and have a plan.
- 15:23In the age that we're living in now, we can't just deploy things and not communicate them and not be transparent about them because there's too many of our consumer bases that are now in communities talking to each other,
- 15:36picking up on things.
- 15:37And so if you don't create your own narrative, the basics, right?
- 15:41If you don't create your own narrative, somebody else is going to create it for you.
- 15:44So I think the punchline here is the technology could be great.
- 15:48It needs to be tested more.
- 15:49There have been misuses of it.
- 15:51It's great that they're trying it out in 1% of their stores.
- 15:54They need to get more data on it, but they didn't have a plan.
- 15:57And so I think that's the big lesson here for other retailers that may follow suit in deploying similar types of surveillance technology.
- 16:05But Shelly, at the same time, as a former CEO, I'm curious because I don't know the answer to this question either that I'm about to ask you is like, what does that mean for pilot implementations?
- 16:14Like, this is in 1% of stores.
- 16:16Like, the comps team's gotta be very dialed in on what the innovation teams or the tech teams are trying to learn by executing small tests in stores too, because it sounds like, you know, if you get that wrong,
- 16:29it can blow up.
- 16:30So are.
- 16:30So are you saying then that you know, the comps team's got to get more involved in innovation?
- 16:35I think one of the more most strategic roles that companies have to have now is communications and I think that those roles are starting to report directly to CEOs for that reason.
- 16:47Because you have two things kind of happening at once.
- 16:50You have a more rapid iteration of customer experiences which I think this falls into.
- 16:55Consumers are obviously experiencing this surveillance when they come into the parking lot.
- 16:59And then you also have a need for increased communication with your associates.
- 17:03So both internal and external comms have become so much more strategic, the need for those in recent years.
- 17:09And so I think that that role is so strategic, more and more reporting to the CEO and I think they absolutely have to be involved in every facet of the business and understand what's launching and if it's visible
- 17:21to a consumer, there should be a plan around it.
- 17:24That's a really good point too.
- 17:25Like for those listening too, especially people gravitated with like what's next in my career with the dawn of AI, that seems like in some ways an AI proof job too.
- 17:33And a job that would require more knowledge of the hands on operations of how the retailer works day in and day out.
- 17:40So it actually may be a good way to transition for a career too as you're thinking about it.
- 17:44Like, you know, hey, do I start going into comms if I've been in merchandising at some point, you know, because I, I have the chops that help me understand what's actually being talked about here.
- 17:53That, that's, that's a really interesting insight, Shelly.
- 17:56All right.
- 17:57Wow.
- 17:57We are cooking with gas today.
- 17:59Headline number three.
- 18:00Headline number three is brought to you by Corso.
- 18:02Your stores are full of data, but are your teams acting on it?
- 18:05Corso turns retail data into personalized daily to dos that drive sales, reduce waste and improve execution.
- 18:12No fluff, just action.
- 18:14Help your managers focus on what matters most.
- 18:16Visit corso.com to see Intelligent Management in Motion.
- 18:20Headline number three.
- 18:21Costco has quietly shut down Costco Next, its member only online marketplace without any advance notice to shoppers.
- 18:30Costco Next lets members buy products never or let, I should say Costco Next used to let members buy products never stocked in warehouses directly from vetted third party suppliers including brands like Priority Bicycles and Viking Culinary at exclusive
- 18:44member pricing with vendors handling shipping and returns.
- 18:47The program launched in 2017 and expanded over the years to dozens of partner brands as an asset.
- 18:53Light way for Costco to broaden its assortment without holding inventory.
- 18:57Costco's customer service page now displays a notice that access to Costco Next storefronts is no longer available, directing members to individual vendors for eligible returns and warranty inquiries.
- 19:09The shutdown reportedly came without warning.
- 19:12Regional outlets first reported the closure around September 1, and many members say they only learned the service existed as it was disappearing.
- 19:20Shelley, how should we read the tea leaves around Costco shutting down its online marketplace?
- 19:25Costco Next.
- 19:26Well, I think this is interesting, and it was a natural step for Costco to try a marketplace, because everyone was.
- 19:32And a lot of retailers thought marketplace is the future, and it still might be.
- 19:37And so it was natural for Costco to step into this space, and they did it relatively early.
- 19:41If you look back, I think it was.
- 19:43That's a good point.
- 19:442017.
- 19:45Yeah, 2017.
- 19:46At this point, they've captured a lot of data around it.
- 19:48And so Costco has one of the strongest trust relationships in retail.
- 19:53So this actually introduced a level of complexity and that relationship, and it may not have had the incremental improvement that they or assortment that they actually needed.
- 20:02And so online, Costco already has a broader first party assortment than they do in stores.
- 20:08So they're already capturing and trying different items in addition to, you know, their store assortment.
- 20:14But when you look at marketplace, somebody still has to vet all the suppliers, maintain quality standards.
- 20:19There's another what layer of, you know, customer service?
- 20:24You created a whole different ecosystem.
- 20:26And then even though the vendor, you know, marketplaces can be efficient because they own fulfillment and returns, you know, it still might not be efficient when you look at the entire Costco ecosystem because of all of those other
- 20:38things we just discussed before.
- 20:40So I think this is something Costco tried.
- 20:42It was probably like, if we delete it, who cares?
- 20:45And Costco is incredibly trusted and does what they do in a really excellent way.
- 20:51So I don't know that consumers are really going to be bothered by this at the end of the day.
- 20:55Yeah, Costco does everything with conviction.
- 20:57I'm curious, Shelley, I have an opinion on this, but I'm going to ask you first.
- 21:02Do you think any club should have a marketplace?
- 21:04When you look at the club business model, it doesn't necessarily make sense for them.
- 21:11And that.
- 21:12And so that's.
- 21:13If an item's big enough to be meaningful, it'll end up in a club anyway.
- 21:17I actually think the websites with broader assortment are great testing ground for what should be put in clubs.
- 21:23And so I think the business model doesn't necessarily yield itself to that being effective.
- 21:30For any club.
- 21:32I 100% agree with you.
- 21:35100% agree with you.
- 21:36Yes, I agree.
- 21:37I think the club business model is just different.
- 21:39And I say that, and I say that.
- 21:41Everybody listening.
- 21:42Like, I'm an advisor for Miracle.
- 21:43Miracle is a sponsor of this podcast.
- 21:45Their business is Marketplace.
- 21:47And Shelley, to your point, E Commerce overall, globally, is a marketplace business.
- 21:51Like, it's the bulk of the volume, it's the bulk of where growth is coming from.
- 21:54But I don't like marketplaces for clubs.
- 21:56I think if clubs want to, quote, unquote, extend the aisle, they should do it themselves by sourcing the same great value deals they would put into their stores, but just don't have the room to do so.
- 22:07And the big reason being, for me, is what you said, Shelley, it keeps the customer relationship start to finish because unlike other retailers, the trust that comes when I'm paying a membership fee to shop with that retailer is
- 22:21important.
- 22:21It puts a premium on the service and quality that I expect.
- 22:25Which, this is the other point I'd make sure.
- 22:26And I'm curious what you think on this.
- 22:28That psychological bond is different to me than a delivery membership like prime or Walmart.
- 22:34Plus, with those, I'm not paying for the privilege to shop like I am in a club.
- 22:39So while I generally espouse every vertical to have a marketplace strategy, I don't think clubs should look at it.
- 22:45I 100% agree with you.
- 22:46And I would also add, because I called on a lot of different retailers when I was a manufacturer and a supplier, I think Costco has the best, most customer focused merchants in the business and they do not make
- 22:59any decisions haphazardly.
- 23:01And every decision they make is to provide more value to consumers and to their members.
- 23:05And so I think that they're just world class in how they look at things like this and how they make those decisions.
- 23:10And I think trust is, you know, one of the highest in retail as a result of that.
- 23:14So I completely agree with you.
- 23:16Yeah, it's amazing how much benefit of the doubt we give the reputation of the retailer when talking about these headlines every week.
- 23:22But, you know, Costco, rightfully so, is, deserves that benefit of the doubt at the end of the day.
- 23:28So.
- 23:29All right, headline number four is brought to you by Ocampo Capital.
- 23:32Ocampo Capital is a venture capital firm founded by retail executives with the aim of helping early stage consumer businesses succeed through investment and operational support.
- 23:41You can learn more at Ocampo Capital.
- 23:43Com.
- 23:44All right, Shelley, this is the one you were excited about.
- 23:46Headline number four.
- 23:47Sephora is set to launch a pilot storefront on TikTok shop later this month featuring exclusive monthly product drops built around live stream shopping events.
- 23:57According to Chain Storage, Sephora will begin piloting a Sephora Drop shop storefront on TikTok shop in the US starting Saturday, September 19, offering exclusive monthly drops curated from Sephora brand partners.
- 24:10Producer Ella will crack up in the background knowing that TikTok shop is the hardest thing for me to say.
- 24:15Every week on this podcast.
- 24:16Each drop will include teasers, interactive experiences and creator led content building to an official TikTok live shopping event featuring a celebrity host, brand founders and creators unveiling products in real time.
- 24:28Sephora has partnered with TikTok since 2023 through the Sephora and TikTok Incubator Program and has continued layering on digital and social commerce bets including My Sephora Storefront which is an infrastructure influencer affiliate program that launched in fall of
- 24:422025 and a pilot inside chat GPT that began in March of 2026.
- 24:47Shelley why do you think brands are so much more open to experimenting with TikTok shop as opposed to Amazon?
- 24:53Is it because it's a social media platform?
- 24:55Is it the live shopping element?
- 24:57Because both at the end of the day are marketplaces, are they not?
- 25:02They are technically both marketplaces, but I would argue incredibly different marketplaces.
- 25:07Amazon captures demand, whereas TikTok can actually create it.
- 25:12And so this is why I love this and I think there's something even bigger happening here than social commerce.
- 25:18My prediction is the next generation of great brands won't just have customers, they'll have communities.
- 25:24And TikTok is amazing at creating communities.
- 25:27Consumers actually have dialogue, interact in chats, get to know the creators, learn about products, and those are all things that are so powerful, particularly in beauty.
- 25:36And TikTok has always over indexed in beauty so people aren't just scrolling past an ad, they're actually engaging.
- 25:43And I think that that's what is really powerful and I think Sephora is going to learn a ton from consumers as they start doing this.
- 25:49Sephora is actually just putting on a show here that happens to have a buy button which is quite different than how you would engage with an experience on Amazon.
- 25:59And so I think that again this is going to be a lesson in demand generation.
- 26:04I think that brands that aren't investing in community building are not going to have the outsized growth that brands that are investing in community building.
- 26:11And so I think that this is just a really great example of the future of brand building and potentially the future of the beauty category and how folks are engaging with it.
- 26:21Woo.
- 26:22Shots fired on that one.
- 26:23Wow, that was so great.
- 26:24I 100% agree with you again.
- 26:26I mean I started saying about God 10 years ago when I started Omnitok.
- 26:29I think we're going to see a world where the influencers are the new merchants.
- 26:33And that's, that's kind of what you're getting at here in the online space.
- 26:36Like the influencers are going to be the merchants, particularly with marketplaces as prevalent as they are and the access to products that they, they, that those influencers have to then promote and get behind.
- 26:48Right.
- 26:48Build a community around.
- 26:49So like TikTok shop enables that you're 100% right too.
- 26:52Shelley, like to answer my question too, it's, it's all of the above because one begets the other like it's the social media hook.
- 26:59That's why people are spending hours on hours on TikTok.
- 27:01They're seeking inspiration.
- 27:02They're doom scrolling Amazon's Amazon people go there because they, they want to buy something, not because they want to be entertained.
- 27:10So net net, this is the other point I was thinking about in, in this headline too.
- 27:14I would expect the conversion on seeing items for the very first time to be astronomically higher on TikTok shop than it ever would be on Amazon.
- 27:23Like how many times have you ever seen something for, how many times are you even ever seeing something for the first time on Amazon?
- 27:28I don't think, I don't think that's ever happened in the history of my, my purchasing something on Amazon.
- 27:33You know, like I'm looking for the category in and of itself when I start on Amazon.
- 27:37So I, so I think that's inherently what's here.
- 27:41And yeah, to your point, Shelly, that has ripple effects downstream.
- 27:45Well, I think what you just said is the really important point here is that you go to Amazon to search for something.
- 27:51You're not going there to be inspired or learn something.
- 27:53And that's where TikTok actually, and communities actually really help.
- 27:57If I want to be inspired or learn about the latest thing or the latest application of something, I go on TikTok because I'm going to, you know, be around a bunch of other people that are inspiring me and
- 28:08teaching me something.
- 28:10And that's just not the platform that Amazon is.
- 28:12Yeah.
- 28:13And meanwhile Amazon will do okay because they'll be fulfilling the orders on the back end for all these TikTok shop brands anyway.
- 28:19So who knows?
- 28:20But yeah, but it's great.
- 28:21It's, it's the first example we have of someone actually closing the line of social commerce to marketplace commerce.
- 28:27Right?
- 28:27That TikTok shop can own that relationship end to end.
- 28:31And the question now will become how do the ChatGPTs of the world, the AI engines of the world, come and insert themselves into that line?
- 28:39Because you know that, that, that idea didn't exist two or three years ago, but now that's a palpable thing that these companies have to think about.
- 28:47All right, last one.
- 28:48Headline number five is brought to you by Veloc.
- 28:51Veloc is a proven E grocery technology built by grocers for grocers.
- 28:55They unite proprietary software with right size automation to make same day delivery profitable.
- 29:01To learn more, visit Veloc.com that's V E L O Q.com Sprouts Farmers Market is turning the page on its leadership, with longtime CEO Jack Sinclair transitioning to executive chairman and president and COO and personal friend of mine, I
- 29:18might add, Nick Conant.
- 29:19Set to become CEO in January, Sprouts announced that CEO Jack Sinclair, who has led the company since 2019, will step down and become Executive chairman, with President and CEO Nick Conant becoming the CEO effective January 4, the first
- 29:33day of Sprout's 2027 fiscal year.
- 29:36Conant inherits choppy recent results.
- 29:38Comparable store sales growth peaked near 12% in the first quarter of 2025, slowed to 1.6% by the fourth quarter and has come in negative over the company's last two quarters, with executives citing underestimated customer softening.
- 29:53Priorities on Conant's plate include sharpening Sprout's value and affordability messaging, expanding into new markets like the Northeast and Upper Midwest while deepening its Texas presence and growing its self distribution network, including bringing more private label production in house.
- 30:08Investor reaction to the news, however, was muted.
- 30:12Sprouts Stock dipped about 2.5% before recovering much of that loss last week.
- 30:17Shelly, you're down there.
- 30:18You're really close to the ground here.
- 30:20With Sprouts being down in Arizona, what do you think Nick Conant's priority should be as he looks to take over as CEO of Sprouts?
- 30:27Well, I think Sprouts is fantastic.
- 30:29I'm a Sprouts customer.
- 30:30I'm in there at least once a week.
- 30:32Are you okay?
- 30:33Cool.
- 30:33I am.
- 30:34And their assortments are fantastic.
- 30:36You know, is this as the wellness trend continues to grow and most likely won't go away, Sprouts assortment is directly targeted at all of these fantastic items that, you know, help you stay on track And I think that
- 30:48they do a really great job and they still have a ton of room to grow.
- 30:51So definitely a loyal Sprouts customer.
- 30:55I think this is pretty straightforward.
- 30:56I had the opportunity to work with Jack at Walmart and he's a phenomenal and incredibly planful leader.
- 31:04So when I look at this transition, I don't think it's about a new strategy.
- 31:08And so for me, this is, you know, don't confuse a leadership transition with a strategy transition.
- 31:13And not every CEO needs a new strategy.
- 31:15And I think you highlighted all the reasons why they still have a ton of expansion opportunity.
- 31:20They can continue to highlight the value proposition.
- 31:23They have a lot of growth and tailwinds, you know, from an industry trend standpoint behind them.
- 31:28And so I think that this is a very strategic, planful transition.
- 31:33And kudos to Jack for having a succession plan in place.
- 31:37And I think when we take a look at this against the larger backdrop of retail transitions that are happening, this is on the heels of Doug McMillan's transition, target transition, their CEO.
- 31:49Now we've got Sprout's transition, Kroger transition.
- 31:52And so there's just a lot of change happening in grocery in general.
- 31:55And we know that the future of grocery looks a lot different and is more complex than it has in the past.
- 32:00So it's a really great time to have this inflection point of a new leader in place going against this competitive marketplace.
- 32:08That's a great point too.
- 32:09I never stepped back and thought about that yet.
- 32:11Man, we've seen a lot of leadership transition and everyone's handled them a little bit differently, to your point.
- 32:16And this one was very planned out and very methodical.
- 32:19I had the chance to interview Jackson Claire at Grocery Shop last year on the main stage.
- 32:23And yeah, I mean, the guy, the guy is super impressed, is super impressive, super charismatic.
- 32:28To your point, Shelley knows his stuff.
- 32:30Nick seems like the right succession option to, you know, when you look at his background at Target, at Petco, before that, a number of years at Sprouts, heading up their operations as they look to expand the marketplace.
- 32:41So, so my advice for my friend, who there is no one I want to succeed more in his job than Nick is, is kind of like you said, Shelly, it's.
- 32:49It's to ride out the storm.
- 32:50You know, they've got the roadmap, they've got the formula.
- 32:53Sprouts is dramatically under penetrated throughout the U.S.
- 32:56i think 24 states in total as of last year.
- 32:59If I remember right, Shelly, I think they've potentially expanded in more States this year.
- 33:02I mean, you go there once a week when.
- 33:04When somebody with that proclivity doesn't have that, you know, with people that want to have that proclivity, I should say don't have that opportunity nationally.
- 33:12That smells of opportunity to me.
- 33:14So stay pragmatic, stay methodical.
- 33:17Nick.
- 33:17Focus.
- 33:18The other thing I'd say, too, is focus.
- 33:19You know, the consumer.
- 33:21The consumer health right now is definitely probably impacting the business.
- 33:25So stay focused on your negotiations.
- 33:26Get back down to your buyer roots.
- 33:28You know, keep your.
- 33:29You know, put your negotiations top of mind with your suppliers so you can humiliate your margin pressures and keep your prices as low as possible so that doesn't get out of control.
- 33:37And I know they're doing that.
- 33:38I know they're thinking about that.
- 33:40So, you know, just build out what you know works.
- 33:43Basic blocking and tackling.
- 33:44You've got the plan, so just don't get distracted.
- 33:46But, Shelly, last word before we get to the lightning round.
- 33:49Now, these are the CEO roles you want to take, where you're following, right?
- 33:53Where the business is solid, where you get to continue to grow a wonderful brand.
- 33:58These are.
- 33:58These are the CEO roles that you want to come into.
- 34:01And there's not that many like that right now because almost everything's a turnaround.
- 34:05So good for Nick.
- 34:07Right.
- 34:07I was going to ask you which ones don't you want to take?
- 34:09But we'll leave that for another conversation, another day.
- 34:11But, yes, I would 100 agree.
- 34:13I mean, I think I wrote in Forbes yesterday, like, there is nothing but upside here for sprouts.
- 34:17But, you know, you say that, though, you just don't want to screw it up either, right?
- 34:21That's.
- 34:21That's the big risk.
- 34:22You never want to screw it up.
- 34:23All right, well, let's go to the lightning rod.
- 34:25Today's lightning round is brought to you with the help and support of RNS Logistics.
- 34:29Are you looking for a fulfillment and distribution partner that's just right?
- 34:33Well, RNS Logistics is smart enough to provide custom solutions and that personal touch while also boasting 2 million square feet across 10 locations in the Southeast.
- 34:42With technology that can scale your growing E commerce operations, visit rswarehousingsolutions.com all right, Shelley, I'm so excited about this first question.
- 34:51I watched Obsession twice over Labor Day weekend.
- 34:54Once by myself and then a second time with Mrs.
- 34:57Omni Talk.
- 34:58Have you seen it?
- 34:59Number one.
- 34:59And regardless, what wish would you make with the one wish?
- 35:03Willow.
- 35:05Yes, I had the opportunity to see this movie, and I don't know if I'd recommend it, but it was an interesting movie to see.
- 35:13And yeah, you really have to, after watching it, think about your wish.
- 35:16But so then, okay, so the obvious, like, beauty pageant answer would be world peace.
- 35:22Right?
- 35:23But then if I put world peace aside, I think I would want my dog to live as long as I do, but really healthy.
- 35:33Oh, wow.
- 35:33Okay.
- 35:34That's so nice.
- 35:34That's sort of.
- 35:35That reminds me of the old Steve Martin.
- 35:36Saturday live sit.
- 35:37His Christmas wishes.
- 35:38I'll have word.
- 35:39Peace.
- 35:39All the children of the world singing all that crap about the kids, you know, but yeah.
- 35:43Oh, my God, that's so.
- 35:44That's so good.
- 35:44And you just watch.
- 35:45I told you I was gonna ask you this question.
- 35:47And you.
- 35:47For those listening.
- 35:48You watched the movie last night, didn't you?
- 35:50I did.
- 35:51I was winding down and I was like, I'll watch this movie and it's not a wind down kind of movie, you know what I'm saying?
- 35:57Kind of sleep with one eye open afterwards.
- 35:59Yeah, no, I didn't sleep well after watching it.
- 36:01But I gotta tell you, it's even better the second time.
- 36:04Like, it's better on the second rewatch.
- 36:06Like, I picked up so much stuff I missed the first time around.
- 36:09Well, I might wait a couple days and try again, but it's not going to be a today thing.
- 36:15Don't watch it twice in 24 hours.
- 36:17Did you watch it on your own or with somebody?
- 36:19No, I watched it on my own.
- 36:21Oh, my God.
- 36:22With my dog.
- 36:23That I'd like to live as long as I do.
- 36:26So.
- 36:27Great.
- 36:28Okay, so first lightning round question for you is the NFL season starts tomorrow.
- 36:35You get one completely consequence free prediction.
- 36:38Who is winning the super bowl this year?
- 36:41Oh, God.
- 36:42I know I'm not picky.
- 36:43I know I'm not picking our shared hometown love of the Arizona Cardinals because they're going to be absolutely terrible this year.
- 36:51I think I'm going to go with the Rams, though.
- 36:53Same division.
- 36:54You know that line with Miles Garrett and Eric Donald, that's going to be unstoppable.
- 36:58So I think I'm going with the Rams.
- 36:59Shelly.
- 37:00Nice.
- 37:00Nice pick.
- 37:01Nice pick.
- 37:02I'm on the fence, but agree.
- 37:04Not the Cardinals.
- 37:05Yeah, the Cardinal.
- 37:05The Cardinals could be so bad this year.
- 37:07All right, next one.
- 37:08Barbara Eden of I Dream of Genie fame had to cancel a planned appearance at a festival after falling ill at age 95.
- 37:16Wow.
- 37:17I'm curious.
- 37:17Shelley, this is for all the Gen Xers out there.
- 37:20Who did you roll with more, Jeannie.
- 37:22Or Samantha from Bewitched, probably Samantha.
- 37:27And I don't have.
- 37:28Me too.
- 37:29Yeah.
- 37:29I don't have super strong reasons why, but just like, always really liked her in that.
- 37:34Yeah, yeah.
- 37:35If I was, I was always like, ah, Jeannie's on again, but Samantha.
- 37:37I'll tune in for Samantha.
- 37:39Yeah.
- 37:39100.
- 37:40When I was a kid.
- 37:40Yeah, I'm with you.
- 37:41Totally.
- 37:43Okay, next question for you.
- 37:45Since it's Adam Sandler's birthday today, if you could only keep one Adam Sandler movie forever, what's your pick?
- 37:53Oh, man.
- 37:53You know, I'm not.
- 37:54This is funny.
- 37:55This will surprise a lot of people.
- 37:57I'm not a big Adam Sandler guy.
- 37:59I just am not.
- 38:00So, like, God, if I had to think about his movie library, I think you'd go Happy Gilmore for sure.
- 38:07I actually like uncut gems, too, which is like, a different side of Adam Sandler.
- 38:11Are you a big Adam Sandler fan?
- 38:13Are you a Sandlerite or whatever the hell the phrase is?
- 38:15I definitely am not, but I will watch his movies and I enjoy them, but I'm not one to seek them out.
- 38:20But if they're on, I'll definitely watch it and laugh.
- 38:23Yeah, right.
- 38:24Yeah, it's one of those, like, if you're flipping through, you can watch it and you always get.
- 38:27You always get some kind of chuckle from them, so.
- 38:30All right.
- 38:30Well, what a great show.
- 38:31This was super fun.
- 38:32Today's podcast was, of course, produced with the help and support of Ella Siri.
- 38:37Ella, I want to bring you in here because I want to talk about this new thing we've debuted in our daily newsletter too, called Producer Ella's Product Picks.
- 38:44Talk about what inspired that.
- 38:46And also what this week's product pick is that you've got everyone on the Internet all a rage about.
- 38:51Yeah, no, I'm really excited about this.
- 38:53I feel like loyal omnitok fans would know I'm a marketer's dream.
- 38:57I fall for everything.
- 38:58But I also take a lot of pride in finding good products.
- 39:01I majored in product design, so finding a good design and something that has a long lifetime is really important to me.
- 39:07So anyways, I kind of want to leave it up to the viewers to find out what the pick is.
- 39:12Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 39:13You want to have them check out our website with our new products pick, Carousel.
- 39:17Ella, is that what you're telling them for sure.
- 39:19I mean, it's a pick that you don't think you would need, but once you have it, it's amazing.
- 39:25Yeah, that's right.
- 39:26And to give a little hit you should.
- 39:27Everyone should trolley on over to Omnitalk Blog, scroll down a little bit and see Ella's product picks for this week.
- 39:33All right, happy birthday today to Hugh Grant and totally coincidentally, Adam Sandler and to the women who made the woman who may just be pound for pound.
- 39:43And I actually do think, I think this pound for pound, the best actress out there, Michelle Williams.
- 39:49And remember, if you can only read or listen to one retail blog in the business, make it Omnitalk.
- 39:53Our Fast five podcast is the quickest, fastest rundown of all the week's top news in our daily newsletter.
- 39:58The Retail Daily Minute tells you all you need to know each day to stay on top of your game as a retail executive and also regularly feature special content that is exclusive to us and we take a ton
- 40:08of pride in doing just for you.
- 40:09And also be sure to check out our new podcast, Grocery Talk, hosted each week by Ben Miller.
- 40:15Thanks as always for listening and please remember to like and leave us a review wherever you happen to listen to your podcast or on YouTube.
- 40:21You can follow us today by simply going to YouTube.com omnitalkretail Shelly, if people want to get in touch with you before we let you go, what's the best way for them to do that.
- 40:32On LinkedIn, Shelley Huff or at my email S H E L l e y the intervalcommunity.com all right, well, on.
- 40:41Behalf of Shelley, producer, Ella, myself and all of us at Omnitalk Retail, thanks for listening in and as always, be careful out there.