Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / Nude beaches, explicit movies, lifestyle resorts: where’s the line for a Christian couple?
Transcript
- 0:43Hello and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. I'm Jay Dee from uncoveringintimacy.com and we help couples build intimacy that strengthens their marriage.
- 0:52And a reader wrote in a few weeks ago with a question. She had been married for over 20 years, says their sex life is better than it's ever been. They're both devout and involved in church and her husband keeps introducing things into their sex life that she isn't sure about.
- 1:06And she asked two questions. Number one is, are these things okay? And number two, how am I supposed to decide if they are? So I'm going to answer both because the second one will still matter long after this particular list is behind her.
- 1:20So here's her question as she wrote it, shared with her permission with all the identifying details kind of changed to protect your privacy.
- 1:27She writes, I ran across your podcast ministry and have been very grateful and I'm thankful. My husband and I have been married for 20+ years. Thankfully our love making has gotten more exciting than ever before as we continue to learn and grow together. We both really enjoy sex. The problem is that my husband wants to do things that I'm just not sure if it is okay. I have tried all of these things and do end up enjoying them and feel that is what has made sex more exciting, but part of me really wonders if it is honoring God.
- 1:57The following is a list of questionable things.
- 2:00One, going to a nude beach. Neither my husband or I look at others lustfully. We really just enjoy sunbathing in the nude and it's exciting being naked together somewhere other than our bedroom.
- 2:11Two, listening to sexy music with vulgar language in it. Definitely X-rated graphic songs, but we use them in the context of making love.
- 2:19Number three, watching sexy movies together that involve sex scenes showing naked bodies. Again, not in a lustful way, but in a way that we enjoy as a couple and heightens our intimacy.
- 2:28Four, this next one my husband planned without my knowledge and it just happened a few weeks ago. I was super hurt at first because we didn't talk about it, but we ended up having a lot of fun. We went to a clothing optional resort. We were naked a lot of the time in front of people or wore very sexy clothing, even lingerie type to a club at night.
- 2:49This was a new experience and as the week went on, we warmed up to it. Again, neither of us were lustful. It only enhanced our excitement for each other. At this resort, you could also have sex publicly.
- 3:00We had made some friends and ended up both having sex with our own partner next to each other. Many people at the resort were swingers. This couple and us were not okay with that. I did kiss the girl and touch her boobs, but not in a lustful slash attractive way, but rather as part of the sensuality to enhance the lovemaking with my husband.
- 3:19Sounds weird and hard to explain. I know homosexuality is wrong and I don't want to cross that line, but this is more about us being friendly type thing, not sexual towards each other.
- 3:30All of these activities have been recent, starting with the nude beach about five years ago. Obviously, things have intensified since the resort was another level. My husband and I are both devout Christians involved at church. My husband is always the one pushing all of these things. No, he does not look at pornography. I've often asked and believe him. I'm the one always hesitant. He talks me into it. He also justifies it saying we are not sinning because we aren't looking lustfully or having sex with other people.
- 3:58He's talking about booking a cruise and inviting this couple we met to come with us. I'd love to hear what your thoughts are about these activities, if they're wrong or how to make that decision and the scripture to back it up.
- 4:09All right. So you asked for my thoughts on each one. So here they are. The nude beach. If what you enjoy is the sun and the freedom, that's one conversation.
- 4:18But you said it's exciting being naked together somewhere other than your bedroom. And if part of that excitement is being seen or the chance of being seen, then other people have become part of your sex life.
- 4:29That's using them. Even if you never look back. I wouldn't put myself there, but I'll admit that this is an item on your list where sincere Christians land in different places, which is one reason I care more about how you decide than about public nudity in general.
- 4:48The explicit music. Honestly, I'm less sure here. I don't think the words themselves are the main issue. The attitude behind them matters more. Crude is one thing. Lyrics built on contempt for another person or another. And I'd steer clear of those.
- 5:02My practical concern is what you get used to in private can creep into how you talk elsewhere. Of the four, this is the one that concerns me the least, partly because nobody else is being brought into your bed. Still be careful.
- 5:15The explicit movies. When you say watching naked bodies on the screen heightens your intimacy, other people's bodies are doing some of the work in your sex life. If you're watching to get excited, I don't know how to call that anything other than lust. However much you love each other while it's happening.
- 5:31On the resort, I believe this crossed a line and it's the one I'm the most concerned about. Not mainly because of the nudity, but because of what happened there. Sex in front of other people and you kissing and touching another woman as part of it. And I'll come back to that.
- 5:47Now, I think we weren't lusting as is the wrong test. Every step has been justified in the same way. It isn't sin because we aren't lusting and we aren't having sex with somebody else.
- 5:58The trouble is how narrow that definition is. You've now actively involved other people into your sex life, whether or not you had quote unquote sex with them.
- 6:07I'd argue that kissing another woman and touching a breast constitutes as part of your sexual activity. You used it as foreplay. This is clearly sexual contact outside of your marriage.
- 6:17And that's my real problem with the not lusting argument. It doesn't actually draw a line. It moves the line wherever you subjectively feel you want it to be to justify your actions.
- 6:28So, how to decide? Here's three questions. You know, you asked how to make the decision and for scripture to back it up.
- 6:34So, that's the question I want to help the most with because I won't be there the next time and there will always be the next thing to say yes or no to.
- 6:42I've written before about the basic test for what Christians can do in the bedroom.
- 6:45One man and one woman within marriage, both consensual and non-harmful between the two of you.
- 6:51Those still hold and the resort strains those rules.
- 6:54Another woman became part of your sex life, which steps outside the one man and one woman.
- 7:02And it was a trip you didn't get a say in, which at least, very least, puts pressure on consensual.
- 7:08So, here are three questions to help flesh out that framework with Bible verses as requested.
- 7:13Number one, does it stay between just the two of you?
- 7:17Sex was designed as a closed circle. Two become one flesh.
- 7:20Proverbs 5 verses 15 to 19 say,
- 7:25Drink water from your own cistern, flowing water from your own well.
- 7:29Should your springs be scattered abroad, streams of water in the streets, let them be for yourself alone and not for strangers with you.
- 7:37Let your fountain be blessed and rejoice in the wife of your youth, a lovely deer, a graceful doe.
- 7:44Let her breasts fill you at all times with delight and be intoxicated always in her love.
- 7:50That passage isn't only a list of don'ts.
- 7:53It calls a husband to faithfulness and to delight in his own wife.
- 7:58And it presents that as something good, not something begrudging.
- 8:03But notice in verse 17,
- 8:05For yourself alone and not for strangers with you.
- 8:09Not don't have sex with strangers, don't share it with them.
- 8:12Paul makes the same point from the other side.
- 8:17For this is the will of God, your sanctification, that you abstain from sexual immorality, that each one of you know how to control his own body in holiness and honor, not in the passion of lust like the Gentiles who do not know God, that no one transgress and wrong his brother in the matter.
- 8:36That's 1 Thessalonians 4, verses 3-6.
- 8:40Sexual holiness for Paul includes not wronging other people with your sexuality.
- 8:46Another couple, another wife, a room of onlookers, those are all other people.
- 8:52And even if they consent and want to engage in immoral behaviors like watching someone else have sex, you shouldn't help them in that.
- 8:58Number two is, is it good for us or just exciting?
- 9:031 Corinthians 10, verses 23-24 say,
- 9:06All things are lawful, but not all things are helpful.
- 9:10All things are lawful, but not all things build up.
- 9:12Let no one seek his own good, but the good of his neighbor.
- 9:16All things are lawful.
- 9:17It was a slogan in the Corinthians that were using it to justify themselves.
- 9:22And Paul answers it rather than endorsing it.
- 9:24Even for things that aren't already ruled out, he says,
- 9:28The test isn't only is it allowed, but does it build up.
- 9:32And the person you're supposed to be looking out for isn't yourself.
- 9:35It's the other person.
- 9:37Not your own thrill.
- 9:38But your spouse's good.
- 9:40Number three is, can you do it without going against your own conscience?
- 9:45Romans 14, verses 22-23 says,
- 9:48The faith that you have, keep between yourself and God.
- 9:51Blessed is the one who has no reason to pass judgment on himself for what he approves.
- 9:56But whoever has doubts is condemned if he eats, because eating is not from faith.
- 10:00For whatever does not proceed from faith is sin.
- 10:04Now, Paul was writing about food in holy days, but this principle carries forward.
- 10:08Condemned there means in the wrong in the act, not to send to hell or for having a question.
- 10:14His point is that if you go ahead with something while your conscience is objecting,
- 10:19you've done wrong, even if the thing itself was neutral,
- 10:22because you had to overrule your conscience to get there.
- 10:27Now, your conscience isn't infallible.
- 10:29It can be too tender or too dull, but it's not something to talk yourself past,
- 10:33and it's not something that someone else gets to talk you past either.
- 10:37You wrote a long, careful email to a stranger, me, asking whether or not this honors God.
- 10:42That tells me your conscience has something to say, and it deserves to be heard.
- 10:47So, let's look at where this road ends up.
- 10:51Look at the direction of your list.
- 10:53It started with a nude beach about five years ago,
- 10:55and then by your own description, things have intensified since.
- 10:59Explicit music, explicit films, a resort where you had sex beside another couple,
- 11:03making out with another woman, and now a cruise with the same couple.
- 11:08Each step makes the next one feel smaller.
- 11:11That's the pattern I watched.
- 11:12I'd watch for it because what felt like a big step last year becomes the baseline for this year,
- 11:18and the next thing has to be bigger to feel the same.
- 11:22Your husband's rule says the line is intercourse with somebody else,
- 11:25but each step has already moved you closer to that line, not further from it.
- 11:30And a cruise with a couple you are already intimate beside,
- 11:33and arguably with, is a lot closer.
- 11:36You've already had sex in the presence of other people.
- 11:39I would be shocked if you don't progress to soft swapping next.
- 11:42That's manual or oral sex, basically anything but intercourse with each other's spouses.
- 11:47And I highly doubt that in a highly sexually charged situation,
- 11:51that you won't shift your boundary further,
- 11:53and it will move to no sex with other people unless we're both present,
- 11:57and then unless we both talk about it first,
- 12:00and then unless you tell me about it later,
- 12:01and then unless we've vetted the people.
- 12:04This is how the progression often goes in these situations.
- 12:08Now the part that I'm most worried about,
- 12:10and what stood out most in your email,
- 12:11is that you are being pushed further and further,
- 12:14and you just keep going along with it.
- 12:16Your husband planned that resort trip without your knowledge,
- 12:19and you were hurt that you hadn't talked about it.
- 12:20You described yourself as always the hesitant one,
- 12:24and him always as the one who talks you into it,
- 12:26with the same argument each time.
- 12:28This is the pattern, and the pattern will likely continue
- 12:31until one day the marriage is destroyed
- 12:33because your husband has been chasing a sexual high,
- 12:36and you don't have boundaries in place to stop it.
- 12:40Of the couples I've worked with who went down this particular road,
- 12:43only a handful came out the other side with their marriage intact.
- 12:46Most who believed they'd be the exception weren't.
- 12:51So, what I'd do?
- 12:52Don't book the cruise.
- 12:54Not, let's set some rules first.
- 12:56Just don't.
- 12:57You don't need to win a theological argument to say no.
- 13:00No, I don't want to do that is a complete sentence.
- 13:04You know, if you want something firmer,
- 13:07no, I'm not doing that again, but I do want to work on us.
- 13:10You don't have to re-argue it every time he raises it.
- 13:13Saying no to being persuaded isn't the same as refusing to talk.
- 13:17Then you have to have a talk together about where this is heading
- 13:20because you clearly are wrestling with it and uncomfortable with it,
- 13:23and the choice is up to you.
- 13:24But follow your convictions and do things intentionally.
- 13:28Don't just be led into something that one day you might regret.
- 13:31Now, some listeners will hear themselves in the husband here.
- 13:35A few men in our forum honestly did.
- 13:37But if your spouse only agrees after you've persuaded them,
- 13:43then stop.
- 13:44Make room for an answer they can give without pressure.
- 13:46And accept a no as readily as a yes.
- 13:48If your case for the next step is always, well, it's not technically sin,
- 13:52ask yourself whether you're building your marriage or arguing for a loophole.
- 13:57Now, this is very different from a spouse that is just generally uncomfortable with trying new things sexually
- 14:02and then realizing they like it after the fact.
- 14:04I'm not saying never be open to being persuaded to trying new things.
- 14:08But if it's a moral conviction, that's not something you should be persuaded to set aside.
- 14:13If you want to do a study together with the purpose of finding the truth,
- 14:16not winning an argument, then by all means, go ahead and do that.
- 14:20But if the words, it's not technically a sin, ever come out of your mouth,
- 14:24then your heart is not in the right place.
- 14:26Our goal as Christians should be to flee sexual immorality,
- 14:30not walk up to the line, look at God and say,
- 14:33I'm not touching it like a five-year-old does.
- 14:35So if you've been the hesitant one and you've been talked past it again and again,
- 14:40it would be easy to start treating that hesitation as a flaw,
- 14:44as being uptight, as the thing to get over.
- 14:47It isn't.
- 14:47It's worth listening to.
- 14:49And you're free to stop and take time with it before anything else happens.
- 14:54Now, if this post hit close to home,
- 14:55you might want to also check out our post called
- 14:58Do Spouses Have the Right to Specific Sexual Acts?
- 15:01And Is It Okay for a Christian Couple to Expand Their Sexual Circle?
- 15:04And Can Christians Have Threesomes?
- 15:06Because questions like this come up quite regularly,
- 15:09and I answer them when they do.
- 15:11If you have a question you'd like to have answered,
- 15:13you can email me at jay@uncoveringintimacy.com
- 15:16or you can head over to uncoveringintimacy.com,
- 15:20click on the Have a Question page at the top,
- 15:22and you can ask any question that you might have.
- 15:26There's a search there so you can see if somebody's already asked it
- 15:28and I've answered it.
- 15:29If not, you can submit a new one anonymously.
- 15:32And that's it for today.
- 15:33We'll talk to you next time.