Latest / Newcomer Pod / Bobby Kotick's Call of Duty (w/Kirsten Grind)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome everybody, Welcome to Dead cat.
- 0:14This is Tom here joined by Eric and our guests Kirsten grind of
- 0:18the Wall Street Journal. Kirsten has been behind a number
- 0:21of very big stories in the business and gaming and Tech
- 0:26World about Activision. First detailing, the The
- 0:30cultural problems that the company had had related to a
- 0:34culture of sexual harassment and ultimately proving that it's
- 0:37CEO. Bobby kotick was very aware of
- 0:40it and did not inform the board of the cultural problem.
- 0:44And we've complained on this podcast, that story was amazing
- 0:48but wasn't at we thought I should be even more seismic.
- 0:51But given, you know, the gaming industry was a little bit.
- 0:55Wasn't, you know, it wasn't as if it was like an apple or
- 0:58something. But then thankfully, we have the
- 1:00Microsoft acquisition which is like, really put this at the
- 1:03Activision story at the center of culture right now.
- 1:07So it's an interesting anyway, sorry to interrupt but I just
- 1:11thought it was interesting that we'd sort of been like this ya
- 1:14yuge storyline. Yeah, it's a good point because
- 1:17yes, it was a huge story. You know, we were, I was fixated
- 1:20on it because I was one, you know, the details within it were
- 1:24just so unbelievable in a good way.
- 1:27But also the fact that it wasn't, you know, it Like if
- 1:30this were an apple, If This Were a Facebook and we were talking
- 1:32about this level of dysfunction that connected to the CEO, I
- 1:35thought it would have been way bigger story, so it's a lot to
- 1:37cover here. First of all, thanks for thanks
- 1:39for joining us. Kirsten a nice to meet you.
- 1:41We hadn't met before this. Thanks so much for having me.
- 1:43Yeah, haven't met you guys but happy to be here.
- 1:46So I guess, you know, before we started recording, we were kind
- 1:49of talking about how you even came to be on the story because
- 1:52you are not a video games reporter, you're, you know, not
- 1:55even really a tech reporter on in your day-to-day basis.
- 1:58But you kind of you're like a secret agent.
- 1:59Gets called into, like, you know, handle the big stuff.
- 2:02So what was your first like introduction to Activision and
- 2:06this piece that you, you know, ended up, you know, helping to
- 2:09break. Yeah, that's funny.
- 2:11You say, you make that comparison because I often think
- 2:14of my editor as my Handler, he is actually the one that will
- 2:19often say, oh my gosh, I think we need to go bigger on this.
- 2:23And that's exactly how I ended up at Activision.
- 2:27Kirsten doesn't get out of bed unless she's got at least.
- 2:29A chance at a lobe don't waste your time.
- 2:38Yeah. I just want to get one thing out
- 2:40of the way early, which is that I don't play video games and I
- 2:45had Eric. And Alicia, we can we can handle
- 2:48that part of the okay, good. So, yeah, that's that's
- 2:51definitely one of the challenges of my job is.
- 2:54I parachute into areas, but I don't know a lot about so II.
- 2:58Certainly realized how Killer Activision games where but I
- 3:02can't say, I play World of Warcraft.
- 3:05Unfortunately, there was a lawsuit or what was your entry
- 3:08point, the activation story. So, last last July, I actually
- 3:14happen to be on book, leave and the state Regulators in
- 3:18California filed. This very unusual lawsuit
- 3:22against Activision and it was salacious the details, you know,
- 3:27it describe this really awful. That boy, culture and
- 3:31Activision, which is based, by the way in Santa Monica.
- 3:34And it talked about all this gender pay disparity and sexual
- 3:38harassment allegations and it just kind of blew up and
- 3:43employees were so upset. They staged a walkout.
- 3:47They were upset with how the company kind of messaged around
- 3:51the lawsuit basically, like tossing it aside, right.
- 3:54Like these are untrue allegations.
- 3:56All of this stuff a couple months later.
- 3:59So In September, it would come out that the equal employment
- 4:03opportunity commission. Also had been investigating for
- 4:06a couple years but hadn't made it public, but they were
- 4:10investigating much of the same stuff like all these sexual
- 4:14harassment and assault allegations and and also we're
- 4:19looking into it. So it just kind of that is the
- 4:22moment when we were sort of like what is going on here.
- 4:26And I remember my editor said to me, you know, we should really
- 4:29Really look at like what the CEO.
- 4:32He's this the most highly paid CEO Lobby in America.
- 4:37Yeah, the Ecotech famously, you know, crazy compensation, even
- 4:41at CEO levels. Definitely had had built the
- 4:44company had been there more than 30 years, like what do you know
- 4:48about this? Like how did he handle the
- 4:50situation and that kind of sparked the whole thing for us?
- 4:54Right? Because that is always the
- 4:55question with these workplace culture.
- 4:57Yes, you know the thing. About these stories as you sort
- 5:01of know going into it, at some level, of course, the CEO rarely
- 5:06is there a case where the CEO doesn't know something?
- 5:10I think, but it's all about the details, right?
- 5:13And that's what's really hard to nail down.
- 5:16It's really hard to figure out exactly what was happening.
- 5:20Especially when a boardroom is involved, I find.
- 5:24So it was not easy reporting for sure.
- 5:27Did you go into it with the That these were acts and a culture
- 5:33that Bobby knew about. I mean, you always kind of to go
- 5:36into reporting with some sort of assumption, maybe it is improved
- 5:39out by it. But like, what was your gut
- 5:40instinct as you began talking to people?
- 5:43So I totally agree with you on that.
- 5:46I do have to say again going back to how I Tara shoot into
- 5:49things. I truly knew really nothing
- 5:52about Bobby kotick and so I actually had no assumptions.
- 5:58I remember Early on. I did sort of start to think he
- 6:02must have known because people were describing his management
- 6:06style as knowing definitely everything that's going on
- 6:11across his company even though and and controls, right?
- 6:14Yes, even though there's about 10,000 employees that Activision
- 6:19and all these different Studios and units and he definitely was
- 6:24not managing the culture of each of those units.
- 6:27But he knew, you know, what was going on.
- 6:29On there. And so I pretty early on started
- 6:33to thank. Yeah, he probably knew and I
- 6:37also pulled in, oh my gosh, we have this great reporter from
- 6:40the LA Times. He's now an editor been Frets
- 6:42but he and our video games. Reporter, Sarah, needleman we
- 6:46were all working on this for sure.
- 6:48So obviously, you know, it's a very Wall Street Journal story
- 6:51and that you get to a new paragraph and there's some new
- 6:53very specific, damning investigation.
- 6:55And but like, in the broadest Strokes, like, you know, if
- 6:59feels like, okay, A company that had a huge alcohol called sure
- 7:02that caused a lot of problems was, you know, the CEO is sort
- 7:06of helping people either slide out quietly without making a big
- 7:09deal about sexual harassment. Allegations, this was an angry
- 7:14CEO who with like his own assistants had allegations that
- 7:18he was mistreating them and had a sexual harassment, allegation
- 7:22tied to him too, and then there's the whole board level to
- 7:25it. So I, I've sort of given my
- 7:27effort, but how would you like some up this story?
- 7:29There are so many pieces to it. Like what's the central Hub of
- 7:34the issue at Activision? Well, I think one of the one of
- 7:38the main issues that we were kind of showing there was that
- 7:41he was part of the issue, right? He knew and it wasn't telling
- 7:47the board, right? We also have, you know, details
- 7:51in there about yes, and threatening his assistant and a
- 7:54voicemail to have her killed, you know, when he was trying to
- 7:58clean house after, July lawsuit. He made a bunch of changes,
- 8:02right? At the top.
- 8:03He put in a female executive. This woman Jen O'Neal.
- 8:07Yeah, I thought that was one of the most damning Parts.
- 8:09Yeah. And see.
- 8:10Immediately was like, well, he's part of the problem and this
- 8:14internal email, right? The top female executive right?
- 8:17She leads blizzard Cochise desert and then she asks is it
- 8:21doesn't believe in the company anymore either.
- 8:23Exactly. And so she points to this
- 8:26incident going back to 2007, basically.
- 8:29He saying, well, he went to this party with scantily clad women
- 8:34just just an indication of he was allowing this culture.
- 8:38So I mean that's what we were kind of saying in the story and
- 8:42and I should, of course, say that the company called her
- 8:44reporting misleading, we interviewed Bobby kotick for the
- 8:48story. He said he was transparent with
- 8:51the board. The board has stuck by him every
- 8:54inch of this way. The board part is funny.
- 8:57I mean, obviously it's all very Bleak, but If I were on the
- 9:00board, you know, hopefully I would be a good board member but
- 9:03on some level, it's like, yes, thank you for not telling me
- 9:06about these terrible things that would have implicated me.
- 9:09I was always a cop. I mean, just like in terms of,
- 9:12like, Sting way to look at it, I hadn't thought about it like
- 9:14that. Yeah, governance of companies,
- 9:16you know, like so many longtime CEOs, like Bobby kotick, like
- 9:20putting people who are super loyal to them, I don't know the
- 9:23Activision board specifically. But, you know, I've done, I did
- 9:28a story on Elon Musk. Ask allegedly like shoving one
- 9:32of his employees and the board, like investigated it.
- 9:34And that's another sort of loyalists board.
- 9:37So I'm just very attuned to how these the stories with the
- 9:41board. Because we have, I think you
- 9:43have this idea that like a board.
- 9:45They're responsible but like, I don't know.
- 9:48Well, what do you think? The significance of him, keeping
- 9:51it from the board? Like, do you think he would have
- 9:53been removed if the board would have been there, or I'm curious
- 9:56why you chose to focus on the board part of the zoo, Well, I
- 10:00think because and we also kind of make the point he didn't make
- 10:04things public either, right? Like the EEOC probe, for
- 10:08example, that's something that other companies may have chosen
- 10:11to could be mature, security is filing, right?
- 10:14But the board is an interesting one.
- 10:16I've thought a lot about this and we've written about this
- 10:19too. I mean, and shareholders have
- 10:21been complaining about this. I mean, listen, this is a board
- 10:24that many of them have known Bobby for a long time.
- 10:28The chairman has brought Been there over 20 years, the
- 10:32independent quote-unquote director has been there over 20
- 10:36years and this is something that like shareholders were
- 10:39complaining about two for sure. So one of the reasons we focused
- 10:43on the board is because we wanted to show what action Bobby
- 10:48had taken. And that is like one of the
- 10:50number one things that he should have done is inform the board.
- 10:54Right now, the question of, you know, what the board should have
- 10:58done or whether They were truly independent.
- 11:01I think that's still playing out, right?
- 11:04I think. I think they're still going to
- 11:06get scrutiny. For sure.
- 11:07What's interesting to me about this particular story especially
- 11:10as it ends up in in the sale to Microsoft which we can talk
- 11:14about in a second is the fact that Activision the business is
- 11:17doing well, yes they are missing money.
- 11:20I mean they are, I think maybe below EA and Ten Cent and I
- 11:24don't know how you want to categorize the gaming industry.
- 11:26Like one of the largest gaming companies their games maybe are
- 11:28slightly cool. In off their major titles, but
- 11:31they're still enormously profitable and you know, like
- 11:34Eric you covered Uber through its non-public but, you know,
- 11:38like it wasn't a public company yet but you know that that
- 11:40business also had issues right. Like, there were lots of
- 11:43questions about its losses and you could sort of see business
- 11:47problems, really cropping up with totally.
- 11:48There's an argument that at the time that the scandals at Uber
- 11:53only sort of dislodge, Callen it because there were business
- 11:56problems. So the board had an incentive to
- 11:58say, maybe we should change Leadership and Activision in
- 12:01some ways is the counter or proves the point, which is that
- 12:05even if there are lots of scandals.
- 12:06But if you have a very profitable company, you know,
- 12:08boards happy to keep the CEO and place.
- 12:12Exactly, and it's funny. Like, let's go back to that
- 12:15alcohol, issue and Activision, right?
- 12:17I mean, this is kind of case in point with that.
- 12:20At one point we had heard about how some people didn't want
- 12:25alcohol in the office, right? But they wanted to keep it
- 12:29because some of the game designers and developers really
- 12:32thought, it'd help them fill these games.
- 12:34And so, you can see, I mean, honestly, like at an executive
- 12:39level, you just want the game's right?
- 12:41Like you just huge. And so this was a truly a
- 12:45debate. A lot of people would say to me,
- 12:47I just don't understand why they're allowing alcohol in the
- 12:50office and it's because it was producing amazing product, you
- 12:56know, the so the argument went, I mean like, look the same Issue
- 13:00played out a couple years earlier in Hollywood and in that
- 13:03side of the entertainment industry, when finally enough
- 13:06people decided, yeah, the casting couch, the sexual
- 13:09harassment, the usage of power in order to cast favored people
- 13:13into roles is actually not an essential part of making TV
- 13:15shows and movies and actually is just textbook harassment and I
- 13:20really can clean these things up.
- 13:21So there is I mean maybe just again bring back to this idea
- 13:24that gaming has not entered the mainstream in the same way that
- 13:28other things have it was Allowed to happen for a couple more
- 13:31years in the gaming world when it's essentially the same issue,
- 13:34right? It's people claiming cultural
- 13:36necessities of mistreatment of people.
- 13:39When in fact it's just straight up immoral.
- 13:41That's the exactly right? Yeah, I agree.
- 13:44Okay. Katie, just dropped in.
- 13:46Now, Katie was working on a piece but she is now in the
- 13:49convo with Kirsten. I know, Katie and Eric, and I
- 13:52before you were doing like, in the days, leading up to this, we
- 13:54kept going on and on about Bobby as a character and we definitely
- 13:58want it to Talked about him already a bit.
- 14:01But I mean Katie you had a lot of thoughts about Bobby.
- 14:04Some not expressible on this podcast, right?
- 14:09What's interesting to him about me is that he's kind of a
- 14:11celebrity CEO, right? And it's, you know, he supported
- 14:15Sheryl Sandberg. He was always very out there, he
- 14:18loved being at conferences. He wanted everybody to know who
- 14:21he was. So I mean, I guess, one of the
- 14:24things we would love to know is what was it?
- 14:27Like one just to report on him. Especially somebody who would
- 14:30love the media so much and did any part of his response to the
- 14:35allegations that were happening in his own company, surprise,
- 14:38you. That's a really good question.
- 14:41So, Katie I was telling these guys earlier, I jump into story
- 14:45so I actually did not know that much about Bobby ahead of time
- 14:49but quickly realized. Yes he is a celebrity clearly
- 14:53although I would kind of argue he's like an understated
- 14:56celebrity like he's not like obviously.
- 14:59I think he wants to be but maybe not as well known as someone at
- 15:03one of the other day. He's not Mark Zuckerberg.
- 15:05Yeah, he's like he's like a b-list celebrities but he's
- 15:08friends with lots of alien - yeah.
- 15:12But what's his name? Like Robert Kraft, the owner of
- 15:18the Patriots, everyone in heart really goes out.
- 15:21Yeah, yeah, yeah. Like is he does he have a
- 15:27reality Distortion field? Are you at least?
- 15:29Like, wow, I can see why this guy runs the show.
- 15:32It's such a performance or what see, I could see that, you know,
- 15:37I finally got to interview him and I, to be honest, found him
- 15:43to be very charismatic and like, clearly knew his clearly is a
- 15:48brilliant businessman. That much is clear.
- 15:52I just think that he may be lost sight, for sure of the culture
- 15:57that was going on at his own company.
- 15:59So, um, which we've reported on. Yeah, the culture, obviously,
- 16:05terrible in that story is so everybody should go read.
- 16:08It is so thorough. It's hard, you tie so much to
- 16:11him in ways that would be impossible for most companies.
- 16:14The one thing I want to be and you're I don't think you've made
- 16:18this a big issue, but in the culture and we've sort of
- 16:20reference it, the, the compensation piece of it, like
- 16:23the complaint that he makes so much money.
- 16:26I'm curious. I mean, he basically built the
- 16:29company P'nay from like nothing, right?
- 16:31He bought it with some workers out of bankruptcy.
- 16:34I mean, it isn't some piece of his like, enormous compensation.
- 16:37Just tied to how much the company like lives or dies by
- 16:41this one was sort of willed it into being I don't feel like
- 16:45hmm, complaint. That's an interesting way to but
- 16:49that's a complaint. Yeah, I definitely see this.
- 16:52A lot of people in the gaming world.
- 16:53I think complain about playing. Yeah.
- 16:56So the funny thing about that will funny maybe is not the
- 16:59right Word. But as you can imagine our
- 17:02process for getting common is extensive and scrupulous at the
- 17:05journal. So these guys had quite a long
- 17:07time to respond. And so, in between that area.
- 17:11Well, after we went to them with a lot of questions, he told
- 17:14employees he was going to cut his salary, so now he is going
- 17:19to make 62 thousand dollars. So I barely spread out longer,
- 17:24right? Yeah.
- 17:25That I would say with him though, you know, in the story
- 17:28that you guys wrote, you know, detailing the acquisition, which
- 17:31I want to talk about in a sec. I think you said that, you know,
- 17:34and it's expected that he will leave the company after, like, a
- 17:37year at or after the deal with Microsoft closes and they're
- 17:40saying, you know, if he were to sell all of his shares, you
- 17:42know, the amount that he owns he's worth four hundred million
- 17:45dollars, which my first instinct was like, that's not that much
- 17:48actually no, it's not that much. You know I I have to say we're
- 17:52still like trying to wrap our heads around that.
- 17:55I'm gonna have to look into that because I think my suspicions
- 17:59Out knowing is that it's probably more but I think, I
- 18:03don't know for sure. Yeah.
- 18:05But he got something much bigger out of that deal than money,
- 18:08which is that he got to exit, a very bad situation for him and
- 18:12look amazing. Right?
- 18:15How did he manage to get that deal?
- 18:16And what do you think? Like, how did why was that deal
- 18:19given to him? How did the board?
- 18:21See it. Why does it benefit the company?
- 18:23Well, I I actually think it's a really beneficial deal to be
- 18:27honest. It with all the Crap to put it
- 18:31nicely, they are they have been dealing with.
- 18:35So as we kind of reported, like the deal came about.
- 18:39So we are story came out like mid-november.
- 18:42There was a huge outcry among employees shareholders, like
- 18:46they were under so much pressure.
- 18:49How much did the stock drop total?
- 18:51It had been down about 30% since the July lawsuit, I believe,
- 18:56after our story ran at drop like 20% in two weeks, There's
- 18:59something. Wow.
- 19:00And employees were calling for him to resign like twenty
- 19:04nineteen percent of employees or something.
- 19:06There was a walkout analysts were calling for him to step
- 19:11down shareholders. I mean, it was just like he was
- 19:14in a terrible position and Microsoft had been interested in
- 19:19Activision before, but Bobby is an acquirer.
- 19:23He is not someone that sells right?
- 19:26And I cannot overstate and Enough.
- 19:30How much Activision was like? His is like his, his child,
- 19:34like, this is a company that he grew.
- 19:37He loves this company. He's been at the home over 30
- 19:40years, but like he was in the situation and as we reported
- 19:46like board members, they, you know, had always supported him
- 19:50and they continue to support him publicly but they were starting
- 19:53to get a little anxious to write and Microsoft comes in with an
- 19:58offer. And it's a good offer, right?
- 20:01Well, the offers basically 45 percent above the current stock
- 20:06price, but in an acquisition, you're always going to stop
- 20:09right down, right? So it's like, of course, you
- 20:12have to give above the current price.
- 20:15But, you know, you're buying a company that's sort of
- 20:17artificially depressed. It's like, depressed and its
- 20:21current situation, but to an acquirer, you can getting rid of
- 20:24the perception that there are Bad actors and move on and
- 20:27apologize, and say that was the old guys.
- 20:29Then it's a valuable company to you because it doesn't have sort
- 20:32of those old problems. So you can slightly so wonderful
- 20:35acquisition. Absolutely.
- 20:37But the funny thing about Microsoft as the acquirer is
- 20:40that, they were also part of the reason that the stock was
- 20:43depressed because he because they came out right, bad?
- 20:48Like what the hell right right. And they make, you know, a major
- 20:51console that Activision sells games for and they told
- 20:55Activision like you guys better shape up because if you don't
- 20:58like we may consider taking Action.
- 21:00And that's like, I'm sure investors were like, well,
- 21:01that's not good. Yeah, exactly.
- 21:05And they weren't the only ones. I mean, Sony said that to and
- 21:08recently llego some that look well lay ago, you know, the
- 21:13real, the real world, I wouldn't take what I say seriously, but
- 21:18they were definitely getting business partner, pressure for
- 21:21sure. So, but the funny thing about
- 21:23this sale is that there are sort of two narratives right now.
- 21:25One that the company is trying to sell in the one that you guys
- 21:28are probably a Accurately reporting, that's my opinion and
- 21:31Activision's lion. Like I saw Bobby giving a couple
- 21:34interviews to you guys and to venturebeat is basically saying
- 21:37it's tough out here. You know, there are these
- 21:39trillion dollar companies and they have the AI, and we don't
- 21:42have the AI, and you need to have that in the machine
- 21:45learnings and the engineers. And you know, I mean, listen,
- 21:50just when you see that just keep reminding yourself how much
- 21:54Bobby loved this company and there was Microsoft had been in
- 21:59Before right and he never wanted to sell to them, right?
- 22:03So that we've seen that story line.
- 22:07Yeah. Right.
- 22:08Yeah. Just like the assessment on
- 22:10Microsoft like, on some way. They're like opportunistic here.
- 22:13There's been like just as they were criticizing Activision.
- 22:18They were talking through the deal.
- 22:20I don't know if I have an objection to that necessarily
- 22:22like as long as Microsoft does clean it up.
- 22:26I don't know if I care that they play games friendship.
- 22:28I don't know. Do you have a point of view on
- 22:30sort of Microsoft is like an actor here and whether they
- 22:34there's anything wrong with them sort of criticizing the company
- 22:38as they're trying to buy it. Or I don't know if you have a
- 22:40view or you talk to people as strong points of huh.
- 22:43No, I mean I think I have a strong point of view but I do
- 22:46think it. I mean Microsoft was pretty
- 22:48smart here. I mean 100%, you know, this is a
- 22:53great deal for them, I think. One thing that I that we haven't
- 22:58really touched on that. I still have it.
- 23:00The back of my head is I mean they still are facing.
- 23:03Activision is regulatory investigations right?
- 23:07I mean the Securities and Exchange Commission that just
- 23:11happened in the fall. The state Regulators, the
- 23:14California state Regulators. I mean that does clearly does
- 23:19not seem to be ending anytime soon and they tried to come to a
- 23:24deal with the EEOC that Go employment opportunity
- 23:27commission last fall still hasn't been approved.
- 23:31So I mean, this is all stuff that Microsoft I suppose is
- 23:36going to have to, you know, deal with right.
- 23:40But they can deal with that. That that I'm sure they thought
- 23:43about that. But it's all they had to do is
- 23:45Google it, right Kirsten. Do you think that the Microsoft
- 23:48deal and making the deal is, does Microsoft have a better
- 23:51chance of coming to settlements with these Regulators?
- 23:54Because they can say we're coming, In from the outside, we
- 23:57will bring accountability, we will bring in, you know, whether
- 24:00it's an outside Law Firm to do a full investigation.
- 24:03Whatever it is that they could more credibly make a promise.
- 24:05Like how do you think of Microsoft's acquisition could
- 24:08impact these investigations? Yeah, that's a really good
- 24:12question. I, I wish I knew more about that
- 24:15but I sort of think the deal definitely does help them.
- 24:20And one aspect of that, that probably helps at least and this
- 24:25is, I Want to be clear speculation with Bobby the SEC
- 24:31clearly seems to be after what, Bobby and other Executives knew
- 24:36about these cases. And so, Bobby not staying after
- 24:40the acquisition. I mean, I can't imagine that's
- 24:43not a point. Microsoft, is, is going to turn
- 24:46to, right? And also just to be clear like
- 24:49this acquisition, you know, if it closes knock on wood, it's
- 24:53going to be like a year over a year.
- 24:56Like it's still going to be those guys dealing with this.
- 25:00They told him. Activision told employees. 2023
- 25:02basically. Yeah.
- 25:03They think this will. Yes and I mean whatever hurdles
- 25:08they may face from antitrust Regulators.
- 25:11Whatever my point being Activision still going to be
- 25:15dealing with these investigations in the meantime,
- 25:17right? It's not really going to be
- 25:19Microsoft for a while, I think. I hope so.
- 25:22And kotick is not meant to stay at Microsoft at When is the
- 25:26conclusion or right? No, no, no.
- 25:29He is not someone who would work for someone else.
- 25:32No. Yeah, but I don't know if you
- 25:36guys read about Microsoft, press release.
- 25:40I mean, I read when the opposition first came out, I
- 25:44read it. I must admit.
- 25:45It was early in the morning. I had not had my coffee yet, but
- 25:48it clearly to me said he was staying.
- 25:51But if you look at the wording, we point this out in one of our
- 25:54stories. It's It's very like wishy-washy.
- 25:59All say about what is actually happening to him after the deal
- 26:04closes the line that companies always use with that is is
- 26:07staying on as an advisor. Yeah.
- 26:10But they didn't even say it even say that they definitely don't
- 26:13even want to look at it. It looks like he's going to be
- 26:21an employee of fell Spencer's and Microsoft, right?
- 26:24Like he's going to Port to happen when clearly that's not
- 26:28what if there's anything I feel like I've learned about this
- 26:30deal deal stuff, it's like sure, they'll negotiate, the actual
- 26:35like control which is like we get to decide whether you stay
- 26:38and then as part of the negotiation will negotiate the
- 26:40language, which is like irrelevant when you give someone
- 26:43else to control. So then the language is often
- 26:45just like meaningless relative to the actual disease.
- 26:48It's not a relevant to the people who they're talking
- 26:50about, that's all they care. They run, they get to feel like
- 26:53they won on language even though the Stay all the stories, say
- 26:57the opposite because like the leaks came out.
- 27:00That's exactly right, right. Exactly right.
- 27:03Well, the same thing happened, if you guys remember Crazy
- 27:06Summer of 2020, when Tick-Tock was going to be selling to
- 27:09Microsoft. I got.
- 27:27That was a weird summer. Yeah, but but part of in I had
- 27:33to write some of those stories and part of the craziest aspect
- 27:36when that deal, I mean like until the 11th Hour, felt like
- 27:39it was going to go through was that Kevin mayor?
- 27:42Who is this Disney executive that had hopped over to become
- 27:44the CEO of tick-tock, which was always an ill-fated marriage was
- 27:50like, well, this guy would never work for Microsoft.
- 27:53This comes to be a CEO. He left to become Come the CEO
- 27:56of tick-tock not like, you know, three ranks below Satya Nadella.
- 28:01So yeah guys can't they can't stomach that at all.
- 28:04It almost Bobby is like going to run Microsoft.
- 28:08Like he's not just going to run a division or like Dy like games
- 28:15officer. I don't know what they call it
- 28:17there. That's not that's not going to
- 28:19look good on Riya. He can't do that.
- 28:23I'm skeptical. This gets Derailed by antitrust
- 28:27Regulators. I feel like it's important
- 28:30story. Everybody's talking about it.
- 28:31Like, what is your, you think it well, or at?
- 28:34Well, I think I'll go through. I mean, first of all, I mean
- 28:37there's been a lot of reporting saying that, you know, Microsoft
- 28:40has a good relationship in Washington.
- 28:41They're not over the largest game company.
- 28:44I mean, it's sort of a competitive space idea.
- 28:48It's kind of like this isn't like to Airlines merging.
- 28:52We're right at the same time though like you know, Bobby
- 28:55going around Saying we couldn't hack it because we're only ass,
- 28:58you know, worth set, you know, sixty or seventy billion
- 29:01dollars. To Microsoft, we're not big
- 29:02enough. We need trillion dollar
- 29:04companies to run things these days.
- 29:06It doesn't exactly Inspire confidence in like the health of
- 29:08our business right now. It's like I don't say that's not
- 29:11necessarily it seems like Shameless antitrust positioning
- 29:14just like just yeah obviously, right after a deal.
- 29:17This guy of antitrust review, if the regulator stop this, I might
- 29:22be able to still run this exact. Yeah, sort of that little Poison
- 29:26pill. What's your view on the
- 29:27antitrust sort of situation? And I mean, this is actually
- 29:31based on very little, but we all sort of thought that Microsoft,
- 29:35I don't know. Like, it's not, it's not
- 29:38Facebook trying to buy them, right?
- 29:41I mean, could you imagine that deal going through, even even if
- 29:45they're not a gaming company? Technically, I just feel like,
- 29:48Microsoft hasn't been under the same scrutiny, some of the
- 29:52other, like, big Tech players, so it feels Feels like it has a
- 29:57better chance that said I mean clearly they've made and
- 30:01antitrust like huge on the agenda in Washington.
- 30:05So and you know as discussed it wouldn't be obviously the same
- 30:10Regulators looking into some of these harassment issues but they
- 30:15know that Regulators are looking into the harassment issues.
- 30:18I don't know if that comes into play somehow, who knows II.
- 30:22Really feel like it could go either way.
- 30:24I wouldn't be surprised either way.
- 30:26I just want to make one random point.
- 30:28I'm curious what you guys think this is the I have a podcast so
- 30:31I can make this look like the. I've always thought that it's,
- 30:37you know, like Apple and Google both control app stores, right?
- 30:41All the Gaming revenue that flows through their systems,
- 30:46they get 30%, but Microsoft has never been able to do this on
- 30:50the PC. Obviously, bz was born in sort
- 30:52of open, internet world and so steam is made of Fortune selling
- 30:57like video games on the PC where Microsoft has never been able to
- 31:01control the App Store. And so I do think there's an
- 31:04interesting like so Microsoft then tries to build a steaming
- 31:09streaming service, like sort of Netflix style, which would give
- 31:13them sort of more control. And I almost like do feel bad
- 31:16for Microsoft. It's like, you could be this
- 31:18great gaming Monopoly on the PC, but you just were like born too
- 31:22soon when it was, okay, to A rake and so you didn't get away
- 31:27with it. But if you've been born today,
- 31:30you'd be like, taking, basically all 30% of all revenue on
- 31:35gaming. So can they just like accumulate
- 31:37enough power that somehow they can like, figure out a way to do
- 31:41it? I don't know, right?
- 31:43I really don't know about that. I had it first.
- 31:49It seems like they could. Um, I it's funny about
- 31:53Microsoft, right? I always sort of feel like, They
- 31:56don't get as much scrutiny as they should, right?
- 31:59And they're so huge. Do you think that's like the
- 32:02boringness of the company is a real?
- 32:04Yeah, flak jacket for them, 100%.
- 32:08I mean, they make Enterprise software and cloud computing
- 32:10infrastructure, right? They have not platform Nazis and
- 32:14they, you know, aren't apple and and because of that.
- 32:19But you know, things like this will at least give them a little
- 32:21bit more. Public-facing image size is also
- 32:24kind of a nice guy. Which, you know seems to do well
- 32:28for him but I don't know. I mean I think if you were to
- 32:31ask most Americans who is the CEO of Microsoft, they would
- 32:36think it was a wait. Yeah.
- 32:38Yeah. You know, right?
- 32:39Right. Which is funny for many reasons
- 32:42but yeah, I mean, I don't want to go too much into the
- 32:46Microsoft of it although you know, their argument that
- 32:48they're going to build like a Netflix for games with
- 32:50Activision just seems pretty far-fetched.
- 32:54I mean it's not a great now that we've seen that Flexes earnings
- 32:56like maybe you will actually yeah, exactly.
- 32:59I mean if you're all into like, you know, destroying value
- 33:02through all-you-can-eat models, you know, go look over, you
- 33:05know, a few miles to the east in Hollywood from where
- 33:08Activision's headquarters are to see like what that's done to all
- 33:11those companies. So, best of luck to you
- 33:12Microsoft, I mean they can afford it because they have a
- 33:15extremely profitable Enterprise business.
- 33:17And anyway, that's a that's that's that's for another day
- 33:22for somebody who did not want to go into the, Microsoft of it
- 33:25all. That was a really Good summation
- 33:26of my cards. Yeah, I wanted to go back.
- 33:30I mean, just to the Activision story, like we focused really,
- 33:34and we always focus on like the corporate and, like, the money
- 33:38and the deals. But like how, what's the like,
- 33:40victim? Sort of the people who, like
- 33:42suffered through the Activision culture, like, what's their
- 33:47feeling at the moment, or like, have you been sort of catching
- 33:50up with the most or your focus on Deal reporting at the moment?
- 33:54Yeah, that's a really good question.
- 33:55I think a lot of employees well, 19 percent really wanted Bobby
- 34:01to resign, right? They felt like he should have
- 34:05his walk of shame basically, and they didn't get that.
- 34:09So, I think there is Disappointment about that for
- 34:13sure, among the employee ranks, but I would say, most of what
- 34:18I've heard is positive about Microsoft, right?
- 34:22Because so, I will say, Activision has already been
- 34:27cleaning house. Quite well since the summer they
- 34:30have this woman Francis Townsend there who is leading the charge
- 34:36about getting some of these Bad actors out.
- 34:38But when they get to Microsoft eventually, I mean Microsoft can
- 34:42just like do what it wants. Like this is one case where
- 34:47layoffs might actually not be terrible, right?
- 34:51They can, they can work even more on that workplace culture.
- 34:54So I think think it's, you know, they didn't quite get the
- 34:57outcome they wanted, but this isn't a terrible outcome either.
- 35:00I don't think that's my two cents anyway.
- 35:04I mean, it seemed like a big complaint or one of the
- 35:06complaints in the Activision story.
- 35:07Was that these Executives would get to leave with sort of a
- 35:11positive. Yeah, goodbye.
- 35:13And in some ways, Bobby kotick is also getting that because for
- 35:17Microsoft to get it, over the hill, I'm sure they couldn't
- 35:21Bobby wasn't going to be like, yeah.
- 35:22And you can also like, shit on say, whatever they are.
- 35:27Nice things about me. I know what Bobby is out there
- 35:29saying and I know what their storyline is and all of this.
- 35:33But I just know how hard it must have been for him to do this
- 35:37deal and that is not the outcome.
- 35:40He would have chosen even like a few months ago.
- 35:44So I just feel like, you know, it's not the outcome.
- 35:49These employees some of them necessarily wanted but I don't
- 35:52also believe it's the outcome. He necessarily Ali wanted at
- 35:57least in my opinion. So do you think there will be a
- 36:01lot of turnover in the employee ranks especially because it
- 36:05we've just been speaking about the people who wanted change at
- 36:08the company who are upset with Bobby and wanted him to leave.
- 36:11But there are probably as many if not more people at the
- 36:13company, who liked the way that it was who like the way that it
- 36:16ran, who did not see problems. So, will we see a lot of
- 36:21turnover? Do you think people will stick
- 36:22it out? Totally, I agree with you and
- 36:25I'm glad You brought that up. Because for sure, there are
- 36:27people that were happy there. I've spoken to many people who
- 36:32especially within blizzard their unit loved working there.
- 36:37Love the way it was run, they were already because of all
- 36:42this, you know, these public problems.
- 36:44Same like Facebook, right? They were already in these last
- 36:48six months, having trouble, keeping talent and losing
- 36:51people. They separately have this
- 36:53unionization effort going on. On.
- 36:56So I think that was already a problem, it might continue to be
- 37:01a problem. It seems like it probably will
- 37:03continue to be a problem, but it was definitely one they were
- 37:06already facing. I think, how much did Activision
- 37:09do to try to stop employees from talking to you guys?
- 37:13I know with Facebook which you've also reported on they go
- 37:17through cycles of intense leakage and then you know they
- 37:21button things down a bit. I mean this there was so much
- 37:24like legal action on the state's part I'm sure maybe freed people
- 37:27up a little bit to talk in certain capacities but you know
- 37:31what did you what sense did you get from people that were key
- 37:33sources? Were those do you mean sorry?
- 37:35Do you mean like getting sources to talk or what the company
- 37:39tried to do to get us? Not what you think the company
- 37:41mostly? I mean, how do they you know try
- 37:43to put the fear of God into employees from ever speaking to
- 37:46you guys? Yeah, we could talk another hour
- 37:51about that but unfortunately some of that is probably Oh
- 37:55Terry but they definitely. Yeah I would say the law is
- 38:00courage. People from the fucking tough
- 38:15to the journal, destroying our stock value.
- 38:19I mean, this is a guy who you reported like, what threatened
- 38:22to kill, allegedly, his assistant.
- 38:26Over doing something read, read from that.
- 38:30Yeah, I think you should just really that in.
- 38:33Yeah, yeah. Which by the way, he's he told
- 38:38us through spokeswoman that he deeply regrets.
- 38:41So I will just put that's better soon.
- 38:43So that's the one fact they didn't deny might be a message
- 38:47eternally, do employees. So, I want to.
- 38:51So you also worked with our friend Deepa on the Cambridge
- 38:55analytic historiography. Aries.
- 38:56And so, you spent some time in Facebook land, seeing all of
- 38:58the, you know, issues that that company had through that whole
- 39:01period. And Facebook is a company in
- 39:04which through that hole and ongoing crises Mark, Zuckerberg
- 39:08seems to have come out even stronger.
- 39:10He was not forced to sell his company.
- 39:13Its value has only increased substantially since that time.
- 39:16What's your take on that? Why does one CEO become even
- 39:20more of an emperor in the other one?
- 39:22You know, has to walk away with only four hundred million
- 39:24dollars. I I know this Mark Zuckerberg
- 39:29question. I, I find myself even though I'm
- 39:31not involved really in Facebook coverage anymore.
- 39:35I just, I don't understand it. I really don't.
- 39:39Um, I guess my speculation is that the thing that would really
- 39:44force him to make a change? Is maybe the advertisers?
- 39:49That's something we haven't really seen.
- 39:51Yet is the money, you know, right.
- 39:53People voting with the money. It just seems like they go in
- 39:58waves of these scandals and then a few months later it's sort of
- 40:02like did that even happen, you know.
- 40:04It's crazy. I just never seen anything like
- 40:07it. It's bizarre and even Cheryl is
- 40:11still there, right? Right.
- 40:13So right Mark has like the the structure of his shares.
- 40:18I think protects him a lot, but Cheryl doesn't have that
- 40:20protection, right? You did see a lot of people just
- 40:23under her leave the So I was always I always wondered was it
- 40:29because they felt like you know, having their former head of like
- 40:33Global policy leave and other people like that that would
- 40:37satisfy the board satisfied shareholder satisfy Regulators
- 40:40or if it's just because those people are fed up and couldn't
- 40:42just couldn't be there anymore. I did think that was interesting
- 40:45that at that level. You saw the departures?
- 40:48Yeah, I would just be so interested to about the board.
- 40:51They're like, are they question of what I mean?
- 40:55I just don't know. Oh, I really have.
- 40:57It's just a fully outside of what you saw, you know, Mark
- 41:00just put Tony the CEO of doordash on the board, which is,
- 41:06I mean, I know Tony, he is a Founder first.
- 41:11He definitely is someone who believes in like Founders
- 41:14running out of these and so, you know, I like Tony, but you know,
- 41:18if you're Mark Zuckerberg and you're looking for someone to
- 41:21put on your board, who believes that a Founders should continue
- 41:24to control the company. Tony shoe is a good pic.
- 41:28So that was, that was a strong signal to me.
- 41:30No, he, which isn't said that board member, right?
- 41:33He's there for the beneficence of the shareholders.
- 41:38I don't, and so is Drew Houston for that matter.
- 41:41I mean, I always Drew also stored in Dropbox.
- 41:45Yeah, yeah. Oh yeah, exactly.
- 41:47Deep Silicon Valley, people believe in sort of the culture
- 41:52of yeah. Who knew that we would look to
- 41:54the gaming industry as like a pair of Agon of independent
- 41:56coordinates. Well one of the really
- 41:59interesting things is. I mean Activision had not faced
- 42:03basically any scrutiny, really? Until that July lawsuit.
- 42:07I mean, not not any serious scrutiny.
- 42:10Were Facebook. I mean they've been weathering.
- 42:13This kind of dad reporting for how many years now has it been?
- 42:18I mean so long. They've got it down right?
- 42:22They know how to handle right where Activision was having a
- 42:25kind of Your it out as they went along.
- 42:28Wait. Yeah.
- 42:29I mean that's what it raises a question that we've asked on
- 42:31this podcast before, I mean, and you're in an interesting
- 42:34position, having written about tech not being a gamer yourself.
- 42:37Like, Hollywood's a huge thing covered by the business press
- 42:41Tex a big thing, gaming is now a huge industry and there are lots
- 42:46of people that play them in. Are invested in them.
- 42:50What's your answer for? Why like Activision wasn't sort
- 42:54of a closely covered company. Before like what's what's going
- 42:57on with the media? And we sort of elite culture
- 43:00that we're not as like usually focused on the games business.
- 43:05Yeah it's so funny. I actually asked this question
- 43:08internally at one point and didn't really get a good answer
- 43:11if you're like, I feel like sometimes the media just broadly
- 43:16especially at like these big newspapers has like I don't want
- 43:21to say gaps in coverage. I mean we certainly have a very
- 43:24good like video. To report our, but it's not up
- 43:27to her. What goes on the front page, or
- 43:30what's covered a lot, right? So, I just don't know, it's
- 43:33almost like there's coverage areas where it doesn't get
- 43:38attention, until there's a scandal, and then it suddenly
- 43:41like, oh wait a minute, like we should have been covering that
- 43:45more or something like that and I feel like for some reason
- 43:48video games, got into that category.
- 43:52It does feel partially like generational to me.
- 43:54I mean, it's yeah, Yeah, big Call of Duty hits are a
- 43:58relatively new phenomenon so I don't know.
- 44:01So it's like, it just feels like, yeah, the Masthead level
- 44:04editors don't quite see how big some of these games are.
- 44:08I don't, I mean, it's also just like how Hollywood I mean Tom
- 44:11was Tom. You think it's about like just
- 44:14like cultural impact and like video games?
- 44:16No, I think I mean I yeah it's I still think this is going to go
- 44:20way down like the video gaming around.
- 44:22I'm sure. Kirsten doesn't want to stick
- 44:23around for that. I do think games are derivative
- 44:27of Hollywood culture and so, you know, it's easier for people to
- 44:30identify with, you know, the the the more Upstream part of the
- 44:35culture than the stuff that's a little bit more derivative
- 44:37Downstream which isn't to say games or fully derivative.
- 44:40It's just that, you know, you talk about what people are
- 44:42interested in. As a broad topic, you know, the
- 44:47movies and TV shows, we watch just happens to be more
- 44:49interesting, definitely to editors, but I do Eric, you and
- 44:52I have both been in a situation where we've gotten really you
- 44:54were both you. More than me but Gamers and you
- 44:58get into Esports and you recognize how big of a deal
- 45:00sport is terrible story. So hard to write about.
- 45:03I try to write about it so many times, it's not a great
- 45:06business. I mean, that's part of the
- 45:07problem. Everybody wants to take from the
- 45:09enterprise software. Yes, James, yes.
- 45:12Right there so much spin. Is it like just Esports exist as
- 45:15marketing, is it like its own Revenue line?
- 45:17Like Esports is just, it's like it's easy for them to sort of
- 45:21shift around what it's even about and like, I don't know,
- 45:24it's yeah. I think it's also like going
- 45:27back to Bobby kotick slike be - or a - Celebrity Status whatever
- 45:32we decided that was like there's not really a celebrity like who
- 45:38are the celebrities and gaining, right?
- 45:40Part of the reason we're all over Facebook is because Mark
- 45:43Zuckerberg and like Sheryl Sandberg are just such
- 45:46interesting. Like right.
- 45:47You need a character is basically like Twitter.
- 45:51I actually don't think anyone cares about Twitter except the
- 45:54media but Jack Percy was like such a cool cover of Everything
- 45:59I can and it was an awesome. Yeah.
- 46:03And so I just think there hasn't been anyone like that in gaming
- 46:08will also what happens frequently with gaming CEOs.
- 46:11I actually don't know the status with Bobby, but a lot of them
- 46:14are not Gamers and this is a real Pride attention in The
- 46:17Gaming Community. When they'll bring up that,
- 46:18like, oh the CEO of EA, not even a gamer.
- 46:21And a lot of times they have to prove their, you know, gaming
- 46:24Bona fides to like, Over an audience but it's yeah, I think,
- 46:28you know, as we're talking what I think, also, the issue is that
- 46:31Gamers, the people that do care about it, which is a huge number
- 46:33of people are not necessarily Wall Street Journal readers and
- 46:37your time writers they have their outlay right?
- 46:40And they're not interested in the business or also
- 46:42generational to. Yeah.
- 46:43You think about the age of the people running newsrooms right
- 46:47now? They they grew up at a time when
- 46:50video games were basically Atari and Nintendo when it was still
- 46:55considered kind of Even more Niche activity to do alongside
- 46:59playing with dolls or playing with trucks.
- 47:01And I think that as that generation of Newsroom leader
- 47:04starts to phase out and younger people.
- 47:07Come in, there will be a sort of a shift in attitude toward
- 47:10whether or not gaming is an important part of like, yes of
- 47:15the business ecosystem. Yes.
- 47:17Well anyway, it was an incredible story, an incredible
- 47:19feat of reporting and you know these stories have results.
- 47:23So thank you. So, Much for having me.
- 47:26You guys. Well, thank you.
- 47:27Thanks a lot for joining, goodbye.
- 47:41Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 47:43Goodbye. Goodbye.