Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP192: Killer Clown
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Hi Talia. Welcome back
- 0:38everybody to this week's episode of Crimes and Consequences. It is a story that
- 0:45I think a lot of people have heard, but it's kind of older and
- 0:48it's really interesting. But if you don't like clowns, oh you're not gonna
- 0:52like this. Oh great, I don't like clowns, like personally like diff
- 0:57I'm matter clown. It probably would be okay, but I don't know.
- 1:00It's only John Wayne Gacy though. Yeah. And Stephen King's it Nay,
- 1:07he was a little fucked up too. Yeah. Well, I hadn't hit
- 1:08the subscribe or foul button yet or like button or whatever the hell button it's
- 1:14going on these days. Please do it whatever helps us, please, And
- 1:18with that we're going to start. Let's do it, okay. So this
- 1:21is a story of Marlene May McKinnon Warren. She was born in Michigan.
- 1:26Really just like me, me, too in nineteen fifty and I was not
- 1:30born in nineteen fifteen. She was a middle child of some sisters, and
- 1:36I'm just going to give you a background. When she was a child,
- 1:38she spent most of her time at her grandfather's farm in a small town north
- 1:42of Detroit. The town is actually Mount Clements, which is where we go
- 1:47to court. Yes, the county courthouses in Mount Clements. Yeah, it's
- 1:49kind of strange. So she spent a long time into grandfather's farm, which
- 1:53there aren't any farms that I know of in Mount Clements, not anymore,
- 1:57not anymore. She was described by the people that loved her as outgoing.
- 2:04She was funny and really kind. Oh that's nice. I don't think people
- 2:07would call me outgoing. No, No, do you think I'm outgoing?
- 2:12No? Yeah, exactly. I think you're funny, and I think you're
- 2:14extremely kind. Thank you. I think you are too well. Thank you.
- 2:16I would you think you were outgoing? No? No, I fake
- 2:20it. I fake a lot, right, you kind of have to.
- 2:24I talk to people like co hurt and and then when I go home,
- 2:29I have to be alone because I need to decompress it. People would say
- 2:32she lit up the room. Oh, she lit up the room as so
- 2:37okay when she walked in. And she was a type of person that would
- 2:39do anything for anyone. I bet there's a lot of people that would say
- 2:44otherwise. I mean, there's always two sides of the story. And she
- 2:49really liked clowns really okay, good for her. That's kind of an understatement
- 2:54when I say really liked Unlike most people, she was obsessed with clowns.
- 3:00Really. She actually had a clown theme bedroom, stop it. Yeah she
- 3:05did. Oh my goodness, she really does like clowns. Yeah, and
- 3:07she painted portraits of clowns and she was actually pretty talented with They're supposed to
- 3:14make people happy. Yeah, that was their original. Yeah, still are
- 3:17I think now it's just everybody's creeped out because of it from the clown I
- 3:23don't know if people know what happened in Michigan, but clowns would just pop
- 3:28up places enact creepy mysterious Yes, yeah, scared people anyway. Her mother
- 3:36surely still has one painting in particular, which she'll never part with. And
- 3:39it's kind of strange to think that in the end, Marlene's life was taken
- 3:46by a clown. Oh, man, it's kind of ironic. Yeah.
- 3:51Marlene met her first husband. His name was John Aaron's and they were really
- 3:55young and they got married in the nineteen sixties when she was eighteen years old
- 4:00old. Soon after they got married, John and Marlene welcome to two boys,
- 4:04John Junior and Joseph. By the time Marlene was twenty years of age,
- 4:09she was a widow. John died tragically, so sad, and obviously
- 4:15she's just very close with her sons and they were all each other had once
- 4:19John passed away. I mean they're little. Yeah. She taught both of
- 4:26the boys how to grow up, how to be successful, how to be
- 4:30helpful, kind respective, she led her children into actually a very stable life,
- 4:38even though given the tragedy that they had. So now we're at nineteen
- 4:42eighty Marlene, she's a widow with two children. She met a guy named
- 4:46Michael Warren. The two had a two year age gap, which is nothing,
- 4:50right, not even really an age gap, No, not really,
- 4:54and they fell head over heels in love, of course they did. They
- 4:59got married pretty quickly and then they settled in Wellington, Florida. Oh and
- 5:03that's an exclusive community known as the Aero Club. I don't know. I
- 5:09don't know Wellington, what's up right next to the our lights? Okay,
- 5:13And it is considered to be one of the richest areas of Palm Beach County.
- 5:17Oh nice. The aero club was built around a grass airstrip so that
- 5:23the residents could land their plane. Oh stop it, they're that rich or
- 5:27they got money helicopters. Okay, So yes, hunts why it's a very
- 5:32nice. Yeah area to live. Just gonna find my helicopter like I did
- 5:38today to get ready. No, I didn't. Many of the homes around
- 5:44their head plane hangars, and the residents would keep their aircrafts and their hangers,
- 5:49you know right, Oh sure, I know all about it. Got
- 5:54a hanger in my backyard. While Marlene was on her second mirror. This
- 6:00was the first marriage for Michael. The two went matched really well together and
- 6:04they really built a great life for themselves and the blended family that they had.
- 6:11Marlene and Michael worked hard and it worked really well together. Michael owned
- 6:16and operated a used car dealership, and with the dealership, he also had
- 6:20a corontal service. Both of the businesses were under Marlene's name. I don't
- 6:28know exactly why, but They also bought and rented houses. They running them
- 6:33out to people across West Palm Beach. But the rental properties that they had,
- 6:40they weren't in the best area of town. Okay, they had roughly
- 6:45forty goodness, yes, that's a lot. And they were very successful,
- 6:53and Marlene was a part of it. She helped basically run the properties Michael
- 6:58owned. It was called Bargain Motors on North Dixie Highway and Lost Palm Beach
- 7:02and the run of properties worth were worth well over one or two million dollars
- 7:08for the married couple and the two boys. Everything was looking good. Yeah,
- 7:13you know, prosperous. They're living in Florida and nice that property making
- 7:17the money was all over her planes. But then something really sad happened.
- 7:25Marlene's oldest son, John Junior, he lost his life in a car accident
- 7:29when he was twenty two years Oh no, really, Oh my god,
- 7:32this poor woman, right right, Oh, that's so sad. Marlene became
- 7:39exceptionally close to Joseph after losing John Junior, but her relationship with Michael began
- 7:46deteriorating, and he started distancing himself from Marlene and Joseph. He was spending
- 7:51a lot more time at work, and work really took up most of his
- 7:56life, like that's all he was doing, was working, And their distance
- 8:01grew more and more, and she suspected that he was having an affair with
- 8:05maybe one of his employees, particularly Sheila Keene, who was in the repo
- 8:13business. Oh okay, Marlene thought about leaving Michael. She wondered if I
- 8:20left, would anything really legally be mine even though it's in her name.
- 8:24I think she was just afraid, right, Yeah, I can imagine.
- 8:28I mean, if the divorce ever happened, she knew it would be messy,
- 8:31it'd be difficulty, And at this point they've been married twenty years.
- 8:37Before Marlene could divorce Michael, something bad happened to her. Oh she was
- 8:43murdered. Oh no, it sounds kind of suspicious, but you think it's
- 8:48Michael, right, But Michael has an alibi. She was in Miami,
- 8:50Florida. Okay, Okay, then I will go back to thinking Michael's at
- 8:56least halfway decent. Maybe I made twenty six, nineteen ninety, Marlene was
- 9:03home with Joseph, who was then twenty two, and some of his friends
- 9:05were there. There was a knock at the door, and it was about
- 9:09ten forty five am. Marlene answered the door, and when she did,
- 9:13she was staring into the eyes of a clown. That's weird. Nobody was
- 9:20expecting this clown like that. No, no, no, no, no.
- 9:22It's ten forty five then, and you not if someone knocks on your
- 9:26door, you open it. There's a fucking clown. The clown was holding
- 9:31balloons and a basket of red and white carnations for Marlene. Okay, clowns,
- 9:37Oh yeah they did, right, did they? I've seen the I
- 9:39don't I don't know. Maybe like well, I don't think they do it
- 9:45now like a singing telegram. They don't do it. No, nobody wants
- 9:46a clown. No, I wouldn't even answer my fucking door. Are you
- 9:50kidding me? So, don't send me shit. So the clowns holding balloons
- 9:54a basket of red and white carnations, and when Marlene went to take the
- 9:58balloons and flower, the clown shot her on the head and then just walked
- 10:03away into a white sedan that was parked in the driveway of her home.
- 10:07What the fuck the car just drove off. Joseph got into his car and
- 10:13he tried to chase down the clown and the white sedan. He didn't give
- 10:16a fuck about using roads during the chase. He didn't give a fuck about
- 10:22speed limits. He was going through neighborhoods and his mother was shot in front
- 10:28of him and his friends. They were actually there by the door when she
- 10:31was shot. He could see that the clown was wearing an orange wig,
- 10:35a red nose. Sorry, this is ridiculous, A red nose, A
- 10:39clown two and I painted on happy face. The Warrens neighbors they all heard
- 10:46this and saw the commotion, and they acted quickly, and they would never
- 10:48forget that day, my bad. One of the neighbors heard a noise that
- 10:54sounded pretty close to a nail gun, that's what they thought it was.
- 10:58He was with his dog when he heard a pop, and he rushed over
- 11:03to where the sound came from, along with another neighbor who happened to be
- 11:07a doctor. The two men entered the house because she's in the entryway of
- 11:13the house, and they try to help Marlene. The doctor was instructing the
- 11:18fellow neighbor on how to make her as comfortable as possible, and so the
- 11:22ambulance arrived soon after the paramedics arrived, the two neighbors backed away and they
- 11:28let EMTs do their thing. Marlene must all lie when the mts got there,
- 11:33and she was gasping for air from the blow to her face. It's
- 11:39her head, but it's also like in her face, but not like in
- 11:43the middle of her face. I don't know, maybe like the forehead area.
- 11:46Okay, from the blow to the face, she had bone and metal
- 11:50embedded in her tongue. What When the police arrived on the scene, they
- 11:54immediately sent a blow out for that white sedan. The investigation started and witnesses
- 12:01at the home try to remember anything they could to help catch this killer clown.
- 12:09Marline was rushed to the hospital, but she died two days later.
- 12:13The white sedan was found in a local parking lot. Four days after the
- 12:16shooting, Michael was instantly broadening, but I'm in Miami, I'm in Miami.
- 12:24How could I do it in Miami? He was actually on his way
- 12:31to a racetrack in Miami when basically she was shot point blank in the face.
- 12:37But it was the upper face, as I said, And friends and
- 12:39family and Marline pointed police in the direction of Sheila Keene because everybody had heard
- 12:48the rumors. But Michael's like, again, zummy, but I don't think
- 12:54he said Sheila. But the two were both questioned and they denied the rumors
- 12:58about them having an a fair absolutely well yeah, I mean that's what people
- 13:03do. They like. I mean, I don't know. I don't have
- 13:05confirmation they're having a fear. But okay. So Sheila was twenty seven at
- 13:09the time this happened and was married, oh boy, married to a man
- 13:13named Richard. Both he and Sheila were in the repo business, and Michael
- 13:18hired them in nineteen ninety five, months before Marlene's murder, to help him
- 13:22out with his car business. People are a pan, go get it,
- 13:26go get it. One of the reasons the police really started looking into Sheila
- 13:31was because somebody, an anonymous woman, called about five hours after the death
- 13:37of Marlene and gave them a tip about Sheila, but they never found out
- 13:41who it was anonymous tip. Marlene's parents told the police that their daughter and
- 13:46Michael were having some marital problems, and that Marlene had told her family in
- 13:52the past quote anything happens to me, oh my husband did it? Oh
- 13:56shit, oh shit, I've never said that have you ever said that?
- 14:03No? Yeah, no, never never. A year prior to Marlene's death,
- 14:09Michael had been at Palm Beach County Courthouse with an attorney and he'd ask
- 14:13this lawyer, quote, if a husband were to kill his wife, oh,
- 14:16what would happen to her state? Oh? Really? Really? All
- 14:20come on him? I know, I know I called him girl, I
- 14:26did it on purpose. Really, you don't know what's going to happen to
- 14:28your dead wife's estate. Chris De Santis was the lawyer and he represented Marlene's
- 14:33son in an assault case I don't know from nineteen eighty six. Santa said
- 14:37to the police, quote, my first impression was, is this guy nuts?
- 14:41Exactly what are you saying this out loud for? Because why would you
- 14:48ask that question with your wife there? Then I looked around and his wife
- 14:52wasn't there? Does that? The lawyers spoke with Marlene often and figured that
- 14:58Michael question, which just you know, he's being curious, sure, just
- 15:03wondering. The attorney one on tell Michael that Florida law is kind of weird
- 15:09when it comes to things like that. It is the issue is not if
- 15:13a man killed his wife, it's the conviction that would stop the inheritance.
- 15:20What you only you only don't get it if you're convicted. Okay, but
- 15:26the charge is okay, don't charge, it's dismissed. But what if a
- 15:33man is convicted of a lesser charge, like the husband, he would inherit
- 15:39all of his wife's assets. Nice, So you have that great advice to
- 15:43give to your fucking client. Luck just get convicted, take a plea of
- 15:46a lesser charge, right, I mean, that's what I would say to
- 15:50Santa just continued quote. Not only that, but if he had a friend
- 15:54who did it, and they and he means law enforcement couldn't tie him as
- 16:00an accessory to the front, he would get away scott free. Perfect.
- 16:03I love lawyers like us. Wow, why we hate lawyers like us?
- 16:11Marlene's death had an immense impact. I think about Joseph. Oh my god,
- 16:15poor Joseph lost his brother, and then he witnesses and head. He's
- 16:22only twenty two at the time, He's just soul, just got ripped out.
- 16:27Joseph said, quote last words, I heard my mom say, we're
- 16:32oh, how pretty. Oh man, this story sucks, and then I
- 16:38heard a bang. Oh god. The fact that the investigators weren't able to
- 16:42identify the killer despite the many witnesses at the home, caused Joseph to really
- 16:49spiral downward. He was angry, and he felt a lot of animosity about
- 16:56life, like we just said, Yeah, that's normal, that's one of
- 16:59the stage. So he started drinking. Oh, Joseph, No, he
- 17:03was depressed. Yeah, I mean hello, self medicating fuck Yeah. Yeah,
- 17:11A fucking clown comes and kills your mom at your fucking house. Yeah,
- 17:15I'm a little depressed. I'm gonna have to have a fucking dream.
- 17:19This went on for years, but eventually he got rehabilitated and he worked through
- 17:26all the issues of his life. So that's good. Yeah good. And
- 17:29Joseph, like I said, his success and rehabilitation and all that, he
- 17:33found a purpose by working with people who struggle with addiction and similar issues that
- 17:37he went through. Joseph remembers the day his mother was killed very vividly.
- 17:42At first, the pop sound gave him the illusion that maybe a balloon he
- 17:47saw it had popped, But then his mom collapsed and he ran to his
- 17:51mom and she fell to the ground, and when he got to her,
- 17:53he looked the killer clown in the eyes. He recalled the eyes being brown,
- 17:59and Joseph said that the clown stepped away from the front door of the
- 18:03home and then climbed into those white Chrysler LeBaron, But the car had no
- 18:07plates. That kind of car was reported stolen from Michael's used car lot a
- 18:15month before the murder, really from his car line. But we'll talk about
- 18:19that clown drove away as if he or she or it or they hadn't shot.
- 18:26Somebody didn't care. It wasn't like the clown was in a rush.
- 18:30That's so weird. Joseph later stated on a local radio show that he thought
- 18:34that the person dressed as the clown was a male because the person seemed very
- 18:38large in stature and had large hands. But before I tell you more,
- 18:44we're going to take a quick break. Marlene's mother, Shirley and her stop
- 18:51father Bill, they were notified of Marlene's death and at the time in nineteen
- 18:56ninety, they were visiting some friends in Phoenix in Maricopa County, and the
- 19:00sheriff's deputy. They ended up leaving a business card at the friend's house saying
- 19:04please call us. That's never Yeah, Shirley, I already had this gut
- 19:10feeling about Marlene that something was wrong. Marlene had previously told them, as
- 19:15I told you, if something were to happen to me, Michael did it.
- 19:19When Shirley and Bill called the number in the business card, they were
- 19:23told that Marlene was in the hospital in Florida, but the police didn't tell
- 19:29them anything else, like she'd been shot or anything. Marlene's mom and stepdad
- 19:34they lived in Las Vegas, so they flew from Vegas to Arizona, packed
- 19:37a bag and got up early in the morning to go out to West Palm
- 19:42Beach. Shirley said that it was early afternoon when they arrived at the hospital.
- 19:48Marlene was on life support, and she said that everything with Marlene seemed
- 19:53normal, her pulse were breathing, but she just knew her daughter was gone.
- 20:00And then again on the second day after being shot, Marline surely had
- 20:04to make the decision to unplug Marline from life support. Marlene's funeral was held
- 20:11about a week later, on July first, in nineteen ninety. Investigators were
- 20:15there hiding, checking everybody out, taking pictures of all the attendees. They
- 20:21kept track of who was there and how each person was acting and what they
- 20:26were all doing. Usually when spouses are killed or when they just pass on,
- 20:33the surviving spouse, is you heartbroken right? Crushed? Right? Kind
- 20:40of struggling with things. As we know, everybody handles things and you can't
- 20:47judge people on their emotions. But Michael didn't seem very upset. As a
- 20:52matter of fact, they thought he seemed completely fine, really like another day
- 20:56at the funeral, Like it's not your wife of twenty years. Michael wasn't
- 21:04a very educated man, but he's a really good salesman. He was a
- 21:08smooth talker, he was confident, but friends and family members around him didn't
- 21:14consider these traits to be compliments he seemed to. I think it was more
- 21:19of an arrogance, narcissistic kind of thing. He seemed to always have bad
- 21:26luck, and those around him said that his bad luck just followed him everywhere
- 21:30he went. One time, his plane went missing but was found later.
- 21:37I don't know how a plane goes missing, but it was found later with
- 21:41a broken engine, and nobody ever knew what happened, So I don't know
- 21:45when somebody stole his plane and broke his engine. He also had race horses.
- 21:49They had some money, Damn they did. Fuck. Yeah, I
- 21:52mean I got I got two cats and two dogs. I don't got a
- 21:56plane, I don't have race horses. Yeah, and you know when you
- 22:00got a plane and some racehorses, damn, do you really have that bad
- 22:03luck? No? Shit right, I don't know. It seems like kind
- 22:07of some good luck. But one day before he had a race with his
- 22:11racehorses, one of his horses ended up dead. Oh yes, that's his
- 22:17bad luck. Yeah, it sounds like real bad luck there to the first
- 22:19world problem. Yeah, exactly, But I do feel bad for the horse.
- 22:22I do too. As mentioned earlier, Marlene ran the rental properties.
- 22:26She was very organized. She had a very smooth operation going. She collected
- 22:32rent from people, even in rougher neighborhoods. At one point, Marlene was
- 22:37in the process of evicting a tonant because they didn't pay the rent. So
- 22:41investigators looked into maybe this tonant hated Marlene so much that he or she killed
- 22:48her, bought flowers, balloons, a clown costume, and killed her.
- 22:53But they couldn't pay the goddamn rent. I don't know if that makes monsensel
- 22:59of effort. Yeah, they didn't really get fired with any of that.
- 23:03The Warrens had worked really hard for what they had, and Marlene took pride
- 23:07in her work. She wanted, like I said, she kept everything running
- 23:10smoothly. She wanted a family to comfortable life. But you can't really say
- 23:15the same thing for Michael. The white Chrysler LeBaron was found, as I
- 23:18told you, four days later, in a parking lot, and there's quite
- 23:22a story behind it, so you got to follow me on this, Okay.
- 23:25Michael owned Bargain Motors and there was a rival business called Payless Car Rental,
- 23:30a car company was duped by someone at Bargain Motors a few weeks before
- 23:36the murder. The LeBaron was actually rented from the rival business, pay Less,
- 23:42and not Bargain Motors, but the car ended up at Bargain Motors lot
- 23:48weeks earlier, which seems weird. So other people had run it, okay,
- 23:52Yeah, the Yellow Pages, the ads for the companies looked pretty much
- 23:57exactly alike the two car companies, so that customers would get confused from one
- 24:04company to the other. So when this couple had rented a LeBaron and they
- 24:10went to return it, they accidentally returned it to Bargain Motors instead of car
- 24:15rentals. Whoever it answered the phone when the couple called to say they were
- 24:18dropping the car back off at Palos car Rental at the gates, they were
- 24:22told to just leave the car unlocked with the keys in it and someone would
- 24:26come by and pick it up. Okay, So that's how it ended up
- 24:30on Bargained Motors. I wonder if they were close together. They probably were.
- 24:37Do you ever see that movie Used Cars with Kurt Russell? No,
- 24:40It kind of reminds me of this a little bit. I never saw it,
- 24:44Cult Classic. Okay, I'll have to see it. The couple had
- 24:47a plane to catch, so they laughed how they were told to, even
- 24:52though they did kind of think it was a little weird. The employee at
- 24:55Bargained Motors who was responsible for the mishap was caught, arrested and convicted,
- 25:00but Michael Tone the company was never charged nor was he held responsible in any
- 25:07way anyway. So that's kind of just really strange. Bargain Motors had been
- 25:11under police surveillance for a lot of their shady dealings, such as shit like
- 25:17that, really drop it off keys, We'll just take that pay less car.
- 25:22Police conducted a nighttime raid. Wow. Yeah, they got a search
- 25:26warrant and they took cabinets worth of files and documents. Michael was really worried
- 25:33he was going to lose his business. Well, yeah, the government doesn't
- 25:36come and raide your fucking place just on a whim. Yeah. So then
- 25:40after Marlen's murder, he was a little bit more concerned about that investigation.
- 25:45So now years go by, nobody's convicted. Wow, which is really really
- 25:51sad. Yeah, but Michael was arrested for sixty seven counts of racketeering,
- 25:56my grand theft and a dominant t breath Oh my god. We went to
- 26:02trial and one of the prosecutors, though, made the mistake of bringing up
- 26:06how he was a suspect in his wife's murder. Because of this, the
- 26:11trial seemed more maybe like a witch hunt than actually trying to convict him of
- 26:17you know what he was caught doing. The jury deliberated for eighteen hours,
- 26:22and Michael was found guilty still of racketeering, twenty one counts o'domino tampering oh
- 26:30shit, and eleven counts of grand theft auto wow. But he was acquitted
- 26:34of whatever other charges. He ended up serving three and a half years in
- 26:38prison, and he got out in nineteen ninety seven. He was supposed to
- 26:41get nine years. We're talking white collar, so that's nine years. It's
- 26:45a pretty decent amount considering we've done cases where people have raped and murdered people.
- 26:51Yeah, I got that much less. Michael ended up marrying Sheila.
- 26:56Oh, boys of the roars were probably true. No, they just when
- 27:00he got out of prison. It was fell in love. Yeah, it
- 27:03was sar. She was there for him. That was in twenty two.
- 27:08Okay, despite the rumors of the affair, it wasn't true. Sure.
- 27:14The two ended up relocating to Virginia. Oddly, Sheila went under a completely
- 27:21different name when she moved to Virginia. She changed her name to Debbie Warren.
- 27:26And she played the part of this outgoing, neighbor loving wife. And
- 27:32they bought a restaurant. They bought a restaurant, or she said she was
- 27:34a restaurant owner. While in Virginia, Michael and Sheila slash Debbie where we're
- 27:41gonna call her. Sheila made their home and it's called Abingdon. In fact,
- 27:48the home they bought was the oldest building in town. It dates back
- 27:52to seventeen seventy nine, and they made it into a restaurant. Their new
- 27:56life was quiet and quaint, lovely. Yeah, how sweet, I know,
- 28:03how fucking sweet. The neighbors around the newly married couple knew the Warrens
- 28:07as diligent, warm, and generous. Yeah, the great people. None
- 28:11all of the earth. Yes, none of them had a clue that either
- 28:15of them been married before, because they never mentioned that, or that they
- 28:18had originally been from Florida, or that Debby's real name was Sheila. Yeah,
- 28:22or that Michael's former wife was murdered by the Warrens. The new Warrens,
- 28:30Debbie Slash Sheila and Michael he went on a trip to Herman and on
- 28:33the return, which they had recently visited Sheila's mother, they were pulled over
- 28:38on September twenty six of two thousand and seventeen. Oh damn. This is
- 28:44fifthteen years after they got married. After they got married in twenty seventeen,
- 28:52that's twenty seven years after Marlene was murdered. Wow. Deputies from Washington County
- 28:57Sheriff's office said, Sheila what right on the side of the road, and
- 29:03they took her into custy for murder. Sheila, Well, he couldn't have
- 29:07been dressed as the clownies a fucking racetrack. Yeah, that's true. Sheila
- 29:11applied not guilty. She requested a trial by jury, and the prosecutors in
- 29:15Florida were seeking the death death penalty. She was held without bond because that's
- 29:22what happens. We want the death penalty. Yeah, really an option.
- 29:25You can't really just like just go home, it's okay, Well, we
- 29:29know you'll come back. So this was shocking to everybody in Virginia that knew
- 29:33her. Sheila and Michael would throw lavish parties for every birthday, and any
- 29:41of the neighbors like they would go to their parties, and they were just
- 29:45big into their neighborhood people who liked them. A woman named Brooke Levelnds,
- 29:49one of their neighbors, said, quote, how could somebody capable of something
- 29:53like that be so goodhearted and loving? Well, people are complicated. True,
- 30:00It's true. The Bevlins were really close to the Warrens, and they
- 30:04were like best buddies whatever couples that hung out and they even spent holidays together.
- 30:08Wow. Close. They saw Michael about thirty minutes after Sheila's arrest,
- 30:15and Michael apparently gave the levelins this pity really sad lost look, huh oh,
- 30:23poor Michael. Yeah, your wife got arrested. That's fucked up,
- 30:30dude. I don't know why. Yeah, I don't know. I'm lost
- 30:33without her. Whatever. So I'm gonna give you a little bit more about
- 30:37Sheila, okay, because you gotta be fucked up to dress as a fucking
- 30:41killed. She spent most of her life in her early childhood, at least
- 30:45in Florida. In nineteen ninety, she moved to Martin County, where she
- 30:49attended high school. Her dad was Robert. He worked in construction. He
- 30:53owned his own construction company, and she dated a boy named Butch Away.
- 31:00He became very close to the family and would eventually accompany them on vacations to
- 31:06Vermont because I said Sheila had family there. Puchlaw's content was Sheila years ago,
- 31:11and he was blown away to hear about the arrest. He said,
- 31:17if Sheila ever wanted anything, she always found a way to get it.
- 31:22She was arrested for shoplifting in nineteen eighty four. In nineteen eighty six,
- 31:26she was arrested again for theft and got a felony. Oh. She was
- 31:30given six months probation. She married a guy named Richard Keane when she was
- 31:36twenty three and they had a son named Charles. In nineteen ninety, Sheila
- 31:40filed domestic violence complain against her husband, Richard, and then she moved out
- 31:44of the house and moved near West Palm Beach. The place she moved into
- 31:48was owned, oh by Michael and Marlene. Really it's a very tangled web
- 31:56here. So after Sheila's arrest, Marlene's parents, Shirley and her stepdad Bill,
- 32:02they'd said they'd always suspected that Michael had a mistress, and they were
- 32:07really angry that Michael married Sheila. They were shocked that Sheila got away with
- 32:13murder for so long, and they said, there's just absolutely no way that
- 32:15Michael didn't know. And they said, if there's a hell, I hope
- 32:20they rot in it. Amen. So, as you said, it took
- 32:22twenty seven years, Yeah, twenty seven years. The only evidence of the
- 32:30house at the time the shooting were the balloons and the carnations. So how
- 32:32did they figure out what Sheila? They followed up the trail of where these
- 32:37things may have came from. The balloons the carnations, the clown cast down.
- 32:44They looked at local costume shops and they found one in particular, and
- 32:49they believed the information they got from their shop was credible. One of the
- 32:52employees didn't know who the customer was at the time and didn't really understand what
- 32:59they were being questioned about, had said that Sheila had came into the shop.
- 33:05Somebody he recognizes. Sheila came into the shop in the evening. The
- 33:08store was supposed to be closed already, but she kept getting the attention of
- 33:13the employee, who eventually unlocked the door and let her in. Yeah,
- 33:17so fucking important, and he told her, you know what, we're closed.
- 33:21Would come back the following day. She told the employee she had to
- 33:27have that costume that night. I needed this clown cost down. You have
- 33:32to sell it to me. It was urgent, but it was anything like
- 33:36your Halloween. She begged them to just please let her get that costume.
- 33:42So they did, and then they didn't give much thought. But something like
- 33:45that is going to stick out in your head. Are actually two employees when
- 33:50she came in, she just quickly picked it out, didn't waste their time,
- 33:53got the costume, and she was out within minutes. What she had
- 33:57purchased was a clown suit, an ragewig and Bob Kelly brand clown makeup,
- 34:02a kit, and a red sponge nose. One of the things the employees
- 34:07remembered is they said, well, you probably need some clown shoes too,
- 34:12and she was like, no, no, no, I'm good. And
- 34:15they're like, what you have this whole entire coastume, but you don't want
- 34:20the shoes and she's like, nah, I'm good. It's okay. I
- 34:24get some sneakers at home. It'll be fine. She ended up wearing military
- 34:30grade boots when she really The balloons that Sheila handed to Marlene, there were
- 34:36two of them. One of the two was silver and it was heart shaped
- 34:39and red You're the Greatest, and the other had a picture of snow White
- 34:44and the seven dwarfs. That's weird. It's just super weird. These were
- 34:46purchased at the local Public's supermarket near Sheila's apartment. They were able to trace
- 34:52that Sheila didn't know that that heart shaped balloon was only sold at Public's and
- 35:00only sold in that particular area, So investigators ended up talking to employees and
- 35:05found out that, yeah, she bought two balloons, and they found a
- 35:08receipt with a basket of Carnaesians. But why did it take yeah, so
- 35:15long? Because yeah, that's pretty circumstantial. It's not hard evidence, and
- 35:19yeah, people can be convicted on circumstantial evidence. But and the But at
- 35:22the time, they also got a search warrant for Sheila's apartment and found orange
- 35:29hair like fibers. So I still I don't know why it took so long.
- 35:32Michael has never once thought that Sheila could be the one. Really,
- 35:39somebody randomly dressed like a fucking clown and shot your wife just out of the
- 35:45blue, like, oh I woke up today, I'm gonna go shoot somebody.
- 35:46He was never arrested, oh Man, in connection for the murder Marlin.
- 35:52Sheila was deemed to be the original and only suspect. It was one
- 35:57year after Marlene's murder that they add this evidence. Okay, okay, so
- 36:01Sheila was deemed to be the original suspect, but there were just there wasn't
- 36:06enough evidence to charge her. So that's why the case went cold. I
- 36:09mean, you have to remember this is what nineteen Yeah, and DNA analysis
- 36:16in technology wasn't advanced like it is now. So eventually they reopened the case
- 36:22and that's how DNA was tested, and it just led prosecutors to the connection
- 36:29of Sheila, so she left a DNA. Sheila's trial date was postponed for
- 36:35six months because of COVID. Oh christ, this was recent. Yes,
- 36:38damn took that long to put her on trial years after her arrest. Well
- 36:44you know how that works. Yeah, I know. Joseph ended up testifying.
- 36:46Oh he did because he was there. Yes, he recalled in the
- 36:50morning of the murder that he was just discussing the plans for the day with
- 36:53his friends and his mom while they ate breakfast. It was just a regular
- 36:57morning. They were where the table was was relatively close to the front door,
- 37:01and then his mother answered it and he heard her say, oh,
- 37:07those are beautiful and then the bang. You know what's really sad as after
- 37:12Marlene died, Michael pretty much left Joseph. Really, that's just cold.
- 37:19He didn't say in his life, Wow, I told you he moved to
- 37:22Las Vegas. Oh that's right. I mean that's really sad because this kid
- 37:27spend in your life for like twenty years. Poor Joseph just breaks my heart,
- 37:31like he loses his mom, his brother. Eventually, all the records
- 37:37were released by the Palm Beach Prosecution Team and it just shed light on the
- 37:42arrest and then the eventual conviction of Sheila. Sheila had drunkenly bragged to a
- 37:47co worker how she about a clown costume, dressed up his clown and killed
- 37:52her lover's wife. Oh ha ha over drinks. The costume and the gun
- 37:59were never found. There were hairs that belonged to Sheila found in the white
- 38:02Chrysler. That was some of the DNA. I don't know if I mentioned
- 38:07it earlier, but Michael was a beneficiary Marlene's life insurance policy, which was
- 38:10worth fifty four thousand. Nice and the attorney to see into this I talked
- 38:15about earlier. Yeah, I was like, hey, you know you're gonna
- 38:20your wife gets killed? Yeah, what would he happen to her estate?
- 38:23Right? He made a joke that if someone were to dress up as a
- 38:28clown and kill somebody, they'd probably never get caught. He did, Yes,
- 38:32Okay, that's weird. In April of twenty twenty three, Oh,
- 38:37that was just a few months ago, She'll admitted to dressing up as a
- 38:39clown and shooting Marline at point blank range. She admitted it. She did.
- 38:45She pled guilty. This is how long it took. She pled guilty
- 38:49to secondary murder inside a Palm Beach Counting courtroom. This was part of a
- 38:52plea deal that was reached right before the trial started. So the testimony I
- 38:58was talking about before was eliminary examinations. Okay, she originally had plied not
- 39:02guilty, but she changed it. So in the plea deal, it meant
- 39:07that she had to spend at least twelve years behind bars. Twelve, but
- 39:13her attorney told reporters, I think she'll get about ten months. What the
- 39:19judge in the case said, he accepted her two thousand thirty nine days in
- 39:24jail as time served towards her sentence. Oh so six years, yeah,
- 39:30six years. Damn. Her attorney, his name was Rosenfeld, still maintains
- 39:35that his client is innocent and that she only accepted the plea deal because she
- 39:39just wanted to go home. Well. Yeah, in the state of Florida,
- 39:42if she was convicted of first screen murder would probably given her the death
- 39:45penalty. Yeah, he said, quote, it was an extremely hard decision
- 39:49for our client, saying you did something that you didn't do. Sure,
- 39:52there's nothing harder than that. Sure. So she looked at a total of
- 39:57twelve years, but she could be out as early as next year, which
- 40:00is why her attorney said she'll be out in ten months. Yeah, yeah,
- 40:05damn, so that'll be like seven years. That's fucking bullshit. That's
- 40:09fucking bullshit. She planned it, bought the fucking clown costume, shot this
- 40:15woman in the face, got to live her life. This bullshit. Well,
- 40:19the biggest part of the bullshit is Michael. Yeah, he fucking knew.
- 40:23Fuck yeah, he knew, he knew. That's bullshit. This makes
- 40:27me angry. And you think after them being together twenty seven years and she
- 40:30she already was drunk telling employees she did it. You think our friends or
- 40:35whatever it was, you think she didn't fucking get drunk and tell her husband.
- 40:37Of course she did, of course. This bullshit. This fucking makes
- 40:40me mad. Poor Marlene, Poor Marlene. She got the rod deal man.
- 40:44Why didn't he just fucking divorce her? Who had to give up money?
- 40:47Yeah, but they didn't have any minor children, so he didn't give
- 40:51up that much. Just half the same reason. People killed their spouses all
- 40:54the time, it's always fucking money. It's ridiculous they hadn't hit a lot
- 41:00or I mean, but yeah, I don't know. Whatever. It makes
- 41:01me mad you yeah, me, I'm pissed. I know it. So
- 41:08the justice system is fucked sometimes, but it's still the best. I guess
- 41:13there's out there where where's better. I know, Canada maybe maybe, No,
- 41:17Canada is not better. No where they let fucking killers go? Right?
- 41:22No, where I go? Where? North Korea not better? No?
- 41:28China, Yeah, I doubt it. I don't think so. I
- 41:30don't know much about their legal system, but I'm just I'm sure you know
- 41:34Russia, No, no, no, definitely, But we love all those
- 41:37countries and people from there. I'm strictly talking about the justice system there or
- 41:43the lack of ours is bad. No, ours is bad. But I
- 41:46don't know of any place. Yeah. Maybe maybe Switzerland, Yeah maybe maybe,
- 41:52I don't know. Well, Well, thanks for that to Leah.
- 41:55Yeah, well calmed me out today. I'm just a little on fire right
- 42:00now. Yeah, that's fine, Right now, that's fine. It's all
- 42:02right. We always are after we're done. Yeah, but I want to
- 42:06thank you all for taking the time to listen to us and this story and
- 42:10our hearts do go out to Marlene and our family and Joseph. And if
- 42:15you like our stories, subscribe like follow Beck for more. However, you
- 42:22got to do it. If you want more, you can tell Antanya.
- 42:25We have unreleased to the public episodes special special for our Patreon members or our
- 42:31Apple subscribers, So you can go to our website Crimes and Consequences dot com
- 42:36and you can find out a little bit more about that. They are the
- 42:38same episodes on Apple and Patreon, so just matter of how you listen.
- 42:44Yeah, it's Patreon dot com. Slash T and T like the dynamite and
- 42:47go to Paton. See all we got hundreds billions, yeah billions. Oh
- 42:52yeah, for sure you'll be entertained from here until the end of time something
- 42:58like that. Once again, thank you guys for joining us, and we
- 43:02appreciate it, as we tell our next that was on, don't get each other by