Latest / Retail Fast Five / Does Going Smaller Actually Grow Best Buy? | Fast Five Shorts
Transcript
- 0:00Best Buy's incoming CEO Jason Bonfig, who takes over from Corey Berry on November 1, says his growth plan starts with opening smaller format stores in markets the retailer's traditional big box locations could never support.
- 0:15According to CNBC, Best Buy's new small format stores run 12,000 to 15,000 square feet compared to medium sized locations at 20,000 to 25,000 square feet and a traditional Best Buy footprint near 40,000 square feet.
- 0:30The company opened two examples this month.
- 0:33A return to Jonesboro, Arkansas after a tornado destroyed its location and a 28,000 square foot store in Cape Cod, Massachusetts.
- 0:42Bonfig was explicit that the smaller stores add to the fleet rather than replace it, describing them as a way to reach customers and markets.
- 0:50Best Buy simply wasn't in before.
- 0:53Jen, are you buying or selling best buys?
- 0:55New CEOs plans for growth via smaller.
- 0:59Format stores As a customer, I'm buying a hundred percent.
- 1:02So yes, 100%.
- 1:06I, I love a smaller format.
- 1:08As a customer, right.
- 1:10I think it's just more efficient when I walk through those big Best Buy locations and again, I'm only visiting my local stores, so this isn't representative of the entire nation, right.
- 1:20But I feel a ton of waste.
- 1:22Maybe it's the ops girl in me, but it just feels like our local Best Buy, like it's never popping with this unreal amount of foot traffic.
- 1:29You don't need that amount of aisle space there.
- 1:32There are so many different sections, right.
- 1:34And you have to have a specialist in each section because you can't even see the other corner of the store.
- 1:40I'm a fan of tech and electronics in a smaller format.
- 1:43So think of like an Apple Store, right?
- 1:46They're squeezing those into mall formats and that's not a huge space, but they're doing a ton out of those Apple Store locations and I think it's that hands on piece.
- 1:56So from a business perspective that's as a customer I just like to be more efficient.
- 2:02I like, like just tell me what I need, help me out.
- 2:05I don't need to see 37 aisles of cell phones, right.
- 2:09I just, I don't need it.
- 2:11But from a business perspective, I like it for a few reasons as well.
- 2:15I think getting in front of those markets that they haven't been able to is key because again, think of like the, the mid sized cities that haven't been serviced by a Best Buy in the past or maybe rural
- 2:28communities, right.
- 2:31Being in those locations and being able to say I have someone to consult with me about my new tech to help me Set it up to offer this Geek Squad service on the back end.
- 2:42I realize again, we're moving towards this digital customer and you can do all that in some cases, but to me,.
- 2:48Do it with Best Buy.
- 2:49But to me, those are compelling reasons to actually go into the store and have someone take care of my tech for me and have someone service my, my Geek Squad computer right in person.
- 3:03So I, I like that it will allow them to reach these new markets and I like that it could allow them to simplify.
- 3:11I think it's a cool test.
- 3:13Again, he didn't really announce it as a test.
- 3:15He said it's going to add to the fleet.
- 3:16But of course, everything is learn.
- 3:20I would be really interested to see if they can do more with less here.
- 3:24Wow.
- 3:24Wow, wow.
- 3:25Jen, I 100% have to disagree with you on this one.
- 3:29Right out of the B.
- 3:30You're right.
- 3:30You said we're gonna disagree today.
- 3:32Yeah, no, I, I, I, I mean, I think what you, what I heard you, I heard you say a couple things.
- 3:37One thing you're getting at was like, you think it's probably just a more productive box, which may, may in fact be the case.
- 3:42Like, they just don't need a box the same size that it once was.
- 3:44Probably because you're not selling DVDs and things anymore, you know, or video games even.
- 3:48So, like, that's probably true, but that's a scary thought when you think about it.
- 3:52And so, so I did some math.
- 3:53I did some math.
- 3:54I brought some math into today's podcast, Jim.
- 3:56According to Google's Gemini search, a search I did on Gemini, Best Buy's annual US volume is just shy of $42 billion.
- 4:05Best Buy operates approximately 1,000 stores in the US give or take.
- 4:10So the math is easy.
- 4:10You can assume $40 million, give or take, per average store.
- 4:14So now Best Buy is going to open stores that are 60% smaller than its typical box.
- 4:19So let's, let's take that 40 million down by, let's say half.
- 4:22And maybe you're right, Jen.
- 4:23Maybe they can still stay productive.
- 4:25But let's say $20 million per average store.
- 4:28So by that math, it's going to take 50 stores, 50 new stores a year to generate a billion dollars in revenue.
- 4:36That's a tough get.
- 4:37I was there when Target tried to do a very similar thing with smaller stores.
- 4:41They said smaller stores were there, but path to Growth, and look how that played out.
- 4:44They had to pull back because the math simply doesn't pencil like.
- 4:48It's just, it doesn't you can't put that many small stores throughout the country in places where best buys don't already exist.
- 4:54So there's going to be a cannibalization effect as you get to a higher store count.
- 4:59So for all that, all those reasons, I throw the caution flag out again on this one.
- 5:03I threw it out on the first headline, I'm throwing it out on this one.
- 5:06I'm back from vacation, everybody.
- 5:08I had time to think, I had time to do some maths.
- 5:11So.
- 5:11But to get meaningful growth out of stores from the long small stores that are long term, you've got to build a lot of them.
- 5:16And it's just, it's not going to work.
- 5:19And I feel like if you look back at the retail landscape, particularly as I have over the last 10 years, you're going to see a lot of people go in this direction and then end up pulling back.
- 5:27Like, Macy's was talking about this for a while.
- 5:29They're not talking about it anymore.
- 5:30Bloomingdale's was talking about it for a while, they're not doing it anymore.
- 5:33Target's not doing it anymore.
- 5:35It just doesn't work to the degree that you think it's going to when you're promising growth to the street.
- 5:40That's my take, Jen.
- 5:43Perhaps.
- 5:43And I like your math there.
- 5:44I think one of the things that could, and I'm just thinking about this now, as you mentioned Target and Macy's and some of the other examples, I wonder how much apparel and, and the type of inventory that just
- 5:56changes over seasonally and regularly is different than electronics.
- 6:01Right.
- 6:01Like once the new phones are out or laptops are out, like we don't have to keep the old ones around.
- 6:06We don't need seven sizes of that, we only need two.
- 6:09Like it is a different game.
- 6:11So I would be interested if any or any space inside of retail, if it could work in electronics and if we're playing with numbers here, again, I'm not a real estate expert, but there's a significant savings if you
- 6:24need to enter a market and you could build a 12,000 square foot location versus if.
- 6:29You need to enter a market.
- 6:30For sure, yeah, 100.
- 6:31Right.
- 6:32And so there's a, there's an upfront savings which I realize isn't huge comparatively to what a store could produce long term.
- 6:39But if you think about it like do they need to staff less?
- 6:42Do they have different utilities?
- 6:43Right.
- 6:44The cost of occupancy is different in smaller locations.
- 6:47So there could be some savings on the expense side as well.
- 6:51But I hear you on the thought of, like, more space to sell from.
- 6:54And I think that's what we do in retail.
- 6:56So it'll be really interesting to see.
- 6:58But I, for one, Best Buy, if you put one in my area, I'm going to be there.
- 7:02And I'm going to be so happy that you made it smaller.
- 7:04Because I'm like, what are we doing with this mall here?
- 7:07When I'm in a Best Buy Buy, I'm like, this is too, too big.
- 7:10Yeah.
- 7:10And you know, I want Best Buy to succeed there.
- 7:12You know, I'm in Minneapolis, local company, you know, But I'm skeptical of this one.
- 7:16But, hey, I guess, you know, Jen.
- 7:17Jen, Best Buy fan, folks, is one of your biggest fans right now.