Latest / No Way Out / The Top Gun Bird Strike Nobody Noticed: Intent-Based Leadership | Gareth Holebrook
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh thanks for being here.
- 0:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Been looking forward to this uh for quite a while now.
- 0:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh a lot of overlap in your career and my career, military background, Navy background, not necessarily in the US Navy, some familiarity with uh with Japanese, like the Toyota Production System, Kanban, things like that, and of course uh the Agile community.
- 0:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you have a couple books out there, or actually you have a second one uh that you're authoring right now, right?
- 0:42Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, that's right.
- 0:43Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 0:44Gareth Hoelbook: So I'm hoping that's gonna be on Lean Pub within about two weeks.
- 0:47Gareth Hoelbook: So I'm beavering away in the next few weeks to get it finished.
- 0:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and that is on uh the discipline of governed intent.
- 0:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And can you talk a little bit about that and your uh your first book too?
- 0:58Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, so I'll start with the first book, which is Issue the discipline of determined intent.
- 1:03Gareth Hoelbook: And what I've done is taken my experience as an endurance athlete over the last 20 years, predominantly Iron Man racers.
- 1:10Gareth Hoelbook: And the question is, how would you apply that mindset to the way we approach work?
- 1:15Gareth Hoelbook: Um but then when writing the first book, it became a behemoth.
- 1:19Gareth Hoelbook: So about a year ago I was up to about 120,000 words and needed to edit it down, so I cut out all of the organizational thinking.
- 1:28Gareth Hoelbook: And so the first book is really about how we govern ourselves.
- 1:31Gareth Hoelbook: So we make a decision and we go through the deliberate practice, but then when we persist, how do we govern that persistence?
- 1:38Gareth Hoelbook: And then the second book then takes the same model and applies it to organizations.
- 1:44Gareth Hoelbook: And the problem I see with organizations is how we govern decisions.
- 1:49Gareth Hoelbook: So we make a decision at the beginning, but who owns that decision when it's underway?
- 1:54Gareth Hoelbook: How do we manage the boundaries of it, and how do we abort?
- 1:58Gareth Hoelbook: And I see a lot of companies struggling to abort from a decision at the right time.
- 2:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I think this is a fantastic connection as uh when we talk about the OODA loop, Observer Decide Act, there's one that has an orientation that is designed for the individual agent.
- 2:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then John Boyd never finished up that that second one, you know, he passed away.
- 2:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But we have, you know, intent, was it harmony, agility in there that he was building towards to say that this is how an organization works.
- 2:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is a perfect way to talk about this.
- 2:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: By the way, Chet Richards, just in the last week, brought this up, and we've had conversations with him on this, that the orientation of an organization cannot include genetics, like like the genetics that you and I have for uh performance, individual performance, right?
- 2:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think there's a nice connection there.
- 2:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You did you also worked with uh somebody who may be familiar globally.
- 2:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh can you talk a little bit about that?
- 2:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then we'll we'll jump back into the issue.
- 2:48Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, so um that's David Marquet, uh Captain Marquet retired.
- 2:52Gareth Hoelbook: He was the captain of the Santa Fe, and he wrote the book Turn the Ship Around back in 2012.
- 2:58Gareth Hoelbook: And I met him in 2015 at a conference, and then during COVID, he wrote his second book, Leadership is Language, and I reached out to him saying, I'd love to work with you, ex-Navy myself, uh, and really like the idea of intense base leadership, uh, which is similar but not quite the same as Mission Command.
- 3:15Gareth Hoelbook: And so for the past five years I've been working with David, predominantly in Australia and New Zealand.
- 3:20Gareth Hoelbook: When he comes down here, I've shared a stage with him a few times and worked with clients in the fire service and police and tech startups implementing how we change uh the dynamic of the culture so it moves from permission-based to intent-based.
- 3:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm curious if we could talk about that, the difference between your view between Mission Command and IBL.
- 3:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just want to hear the difference.
- 3:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you notice and how can you show this?
- 3:43Gareth Hoelbook: Well I asked David about this because I I've read Stephen Bungay's book, obviously, and I really like Von Molke, and that made perfect sense to me.
- 3:50Gareth Hoelbook: And there's an overlap, obviously.
- 3:53Gareth Hoelbook: Um but the way David explained it to me is Mission Command talks about how the central command, so the Pentagon or Whitehall, then issues commands to the captains or or the group leaders, and then they execute it with their groups.
- 4:08Gareth Hoelbook: And uh so Nelson, Napoleon von Molke, that's exactly the model that uh Bungay was talking about.
- 4:14Gareth Hoelbook: What Marquet has done is taken it to within the organization.
- 4:18Gareth Hoelbook: So even if you looked at uh historically things like Nelson, he would say England expects every man to do his duty, there's a mission, and then tactically each captain would have autonomy to make the decision.
- 4:31Gareth Hoelbook: What Marquet has done is now taken that to the organization within the group.
- 4:35Gareth Hoelbook: So within the ship or within the platoon, there is intent-based leadership.
- 4:40Gareth Hoelbook: And I think that's emerged out both in the US and the UK in the last 20 years.
- 4:44Gareth Hoelbook: Um if you think of team of teams, yeah, uh the way we want to distribute the decision making.
- 4:49Gareth Hoelbook: But mission command was more at the command level rather than the operational level.
- 4:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: See, this is interesting because I and I'm glad I asked this because I didn't know there was a I always say there's a lot of overlap there.
- 4:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And my view has always been when I learned Mission Command, when I went through you know, fighter aviation's plan brief, execute debrief, the top gun approach, all that stuff.
- 5:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's a leadership apprenticeship program built around mission command.
- 5:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We ultimately become a mission commander, which is where we get the idea of a product owner inside of Agile, right?
- 5:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's the 51% vote there.
- 5:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So my view has always been uh when I read David Marquet's book, you know, it was very popular back in the uh what 2014, 2015, right about the time I punched out of the Navy, um, I looked at him like, I don't know if everybody knows, but we all know this stuff.
- 5:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is what we're trained on, right?
- 5:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But there's a knowing doing gap too, right?
- 5:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We all know how to do this, but we don't do it well.
- 5:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think David Marquet did it quite well.
- 5:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and then I I do want to bring up a few other things.
- 5:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you look at a high-performing organization, and if you're looking at nuclear power, uh it's there's a selection process for that.
- 5:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You go through Power School, there's there's they they have risk management in there, they have uh I forgot the name of it, but the but they have critiques, right?
- 6:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's kind of like the the plan brief, execute debrief process or scrum process framework, whatever you want to call it.
- 6:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They already have that built in there and they call it critiques.
- 6:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I mean it's it's it's a parallel thing to fighter aviation, carrier aviation, maybe a little bit more specific on that.
- 6:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So same um service in the U.S.
- 6:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Navy, being the U.S.
- 6:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Navy, just a different uh you know career field.
- 6:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's it's very powerful to hear a submarine commander talk about uh effective critiques or debriefing, uh, and then hear a uh you know a top gun instructor talk about that as well.
- 6:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I never saw a difference between the two, but I thank you for that.
- 6:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I kind of want to tease that out a little bit more.
- 6:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What what else is different about IBL that you could talk about or maybe you could share to clarify this?
- 6:47Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, so what what David has done as well is he he did a lot of research into Canneman's work on thinking fast and slow and clean language and at DC's self-determination theory.
- 7:00Gareth Hoelbook: So it talks about the psychology, and he and this is in his second book, which I believe is more impactful, uh Leadership is Language, is as leaders what we say impacts the way our team think.
- 7:12Gareth Hoelbook: So the kind of questions we ask if we create the safe environment for people to dissent and speak up, and he has case studies on board his submarine where he he went back on the control room and I think they were dropping some seals off so they were close to the coast, and the navigator said, ahead, and he said, No, no, we should be going astern, we're going to ground.
- 7:33Gareth Hoelbook: And the navig and I think the teleman said, Captain, you wrong, it's ahead.
- 7:38Gareth Hoelbook: And Marquet then looked again and went, Ah no, the boat's pointing the opposite direction.
- 7:43Gareth Hoelbook: So the fact that a junior rating could challenge the captain is an environment that we we want in all organizations.
- 7:51Gareth Hoelbook: Um so I think intent-based leadership enables descent, invites descent, and it enables divergent thinking.
- 7:58Gareth Hoelbook: And it's all through the language, it's the psychology of the language we use.
- 8:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is fascinating.
- 8:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Years ago I I reached out to David uh this is probably 2015, 2016.
- 8:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We were at the time we were looking at um Tactical Decision Making Under Stress, which came from the uh shootdown of the uh from the uh uh US Vincent's shootdown of the Airbus.
- 8:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What happened to the SWO community after that?
- 8:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is uh late 80s, early 90s.
- 8:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then uh I was asking about his connection with uh behavioral markers, uh, which we use from aviation crew resource management as connection to CRM.
- 8:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's he said he was he was exploring that.
- 8:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let me just kind of rephrase that.
- 8:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So aviation CRM is where we get a lot of team science from, right?
- 8:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So inside naval aviation, carrier aviation, we use it.
- 8:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not, as far as I know, it's not well used in the submarine community.
- 8:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not used in the surface warfare community, even though it emerged from there uh, if you want to make that connection to tactical decision making under stress, right?
- 8:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's it's interesting that even within our naval services and our U.S.
- 8:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Navy, our we don't talk to each other.
- 9:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Our our our Navy AV Naval Aviation doesn't necessarily teach anything over to our submarine community.
- 9:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: However, the SEALs have borrowed a lot from naval aviation over the years, which includes a team science, planned brief, execute debrief, and these things.
- 9:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I'm just pointing this out that uh having, you know, I'm a Navy retired U.S.
- 9:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Navy captain, my view is the same is hey, that's nice what he wrote, and we already know that over here.
- 9:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thank you, right?
- 9:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 9:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so I'm not trying to take anything away.
- 9:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm just saying, yes, and going back to Kahneman and all that, you know, that's that's where we get into red teaming.
- 9:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's when we get into things we may talk about here.
- 9:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I want to kind of move this along a little bit unless you have anything else you want to add to this point.
- 9:39Gareth Hoelbook: And just one thing.
- 9:40Gareth Hoelbook: Recently, we have both been talking to a civil aviation pilot trainer about CRM and how we could potentially include Inside Base leadership in CRM.
- 9:51Gareth Hoelbook: Um, because and this particular pilot trainer went through David's exact journey.
- 9:56Gareth Hoelbook: He was uh he was a Boeing pilot and then was advanced to become a captain, but it would have been on Airbus or the other way around.
- 10:04Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 10:04Gareth Hoelbook: And it's the same as the USS Olympia, USS Santa Fe, and he read David's book at the same time.
- 10:09Gareth Hoelbook: So he's really fascinated with it, and he's looking at how we can include intent-based leadership in CRM.
- 10:15Gareth Hoelbook: So maybe it's gone full circle.
- 10:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think we can I think we could do that here.
- 10:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In fact, the the next question I want to ask you is okay, uh, as an athlete, I I'm I'm certain you are familiar with you know, you you wrote a little note about finite games to me earlier.
- 10:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 10:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But this this is signaling to me that you're tracking what's going on in skill acquisition and sports, which is ecological dynamics, which is to me is intent-based leadership again, right?
- 10:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's setting the conditions.
- 10:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you familiar with this?
- 10:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you tracking this?
- 10:48Gareth Hoelbook: David wrote the foreword for my book, and he did say that what I've done is in my book, which talks a lot about autobiographically about endurance sports, is I've turned intent-based leadership on the self.
- 10:59Gareth Hoelbook: So I'm setting my own and setting my own boundaries and then giving my own my own abort criteria.
- 11:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's a little bit different to do, I mean, that knowing doing gap is we know how to coach others, we just have a uh, you know, how do you apply it to yourself?
- 11:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's and we can dive into that a little bit more.
- 11:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So where I'm going with this is if you're your story about Marquet and this captain who who understands aviation CRM, it's it's all kind of converging, right?
- 11:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's peak performance.
- 11:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we learn from other disciplines?
- 11:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because uh again, going through my experience and and reading Turn the Ship Around, and you know, at the time I was doing some other work with another organization on Plant Brief X debrief, uh we already are like, yeah, we get it, man.
- 11:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't understand why anybody else doesn't get it.
- 11:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the same thing we got out of team of teams.
- 11:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you get team of teams, you're like, uh secret, you're you're supposed to do this, right?
- 11:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 11:49Gareth Hoelbook: So but but the same thing about aviation is my wife is an emergency consultant and an attending physician in emergency medicine.
- 11:57Gareth Hoelbook: So we've both had the checklist manifesto, which comes straight from aviation.
- 12:01Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 12:02Gareth Hoelbook: But the medical sector initially were quite resistant to the idea of checklists.
- 12:06Gareth Hoelbook: You know, I'm a doctor, I'm a junior, why do I need to do this?
- 12:09Gareth Hoelbook: But Auckland Hospital was actually cited in the checklist manifesto, and checklists are now used in medicine.
- 12:15Gareth Hoelbook: And my argument we should do this.
- 12:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have mine next to me because I know you wrote about this.
- 12:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll we'll get to the I want to come back to the top gun connection here in a little bit, the Maverick one.
- 12:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 12:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But on this, this is fascinating.
- 12:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so I again, this is just kind of a meeting of the minds here, and that's why we like these, these, these conversations.
- 12:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here in in the US, when I first realized the value of CRM in organizations, it was a couple books out there uh that that were written.
- 12:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But more importantly, I was up in Seattle and I met a doctor, and he's been on the show, Dr.
- 12:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Dan Lowe, and he said, Hey, Ponch, I went to Japan.
- 12:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I sat down, went through TPS, I was very fired up about that, brought it back here.
- 12:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it, this is his words.
- 12:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In his experience as a uh Hem's crew member, uh, when he was on his way to becoming a doctor, he's flying around on a helicopter.
- 13:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He he sat down next to a former SAS pilot who did this, gave him the checklist and said, I'm gonna make you, I'm gonna help you learn this, and we're gonna learn aviation CRM.
- 13:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it was aviation crew resource management that he brought back into the hospital and he said, Hey, lean is insufficient here because we got to get this teaming thing down, which is what you just talked about, right?
- 13:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And yeah, so in healthcare here in the US, we have something known as Team Steps.
- 13:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, don't ask me what the acronym is.
- 13:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's it's it actually comes from the same folks that gave us uh Naval Aviation Crew Resource Management, so Team Science.
- 13:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's something there, and then you read the um checklist manifesto, and later on, I'm sure you're familiar with Kinevin framework and things like that, right?
- 13:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 13:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 13:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you can't use checklists everywhere.
- 13:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know that, right?
- 13:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 13:46Gareth Hoelbook: So check checklists are useful, but if you depend on them.
- 13:49Gareth Hoelbook: And I'm I'm actually met Dave Snowden a few weeks ago in Singapore.
- 13:51Gareth Hoelbook: And I'm I'm I'm for my next book, I'm I'm hoping to really uh bring in Kinevin and his his his new interpretation of it, he's actually refreshing it.
- 14:01Gareth Hoelbook: Because if you lock yourself in that domain where it's all known cause and effect, you're gonna get caught out by the the complexity of the unknowns.
- 14:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely.
- 14:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's a dynamic uh view of things, and I think most people look at it as a static thing.
- 14:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So team science to me, the things that we're talking about, where we're going to use a checklist approach here in a sec, because I want to come back to that Maverick thing, uh, because you pointed out something uh that I missed in the movie.
- 14:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But checklists are good when you know the relationship between cause and effect.
- 14:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh can can you walk us through what you sent me in in your notes about the uh the Maverick scene?
- 14:34Gareth Hoelbook: Yes.
- 14:35Gareth Hoelbook: So we we use this in the internet-based leadership training, uh and we we play a short clip on YouTube of the bird strike, so it's easy to search out.
- 14:44Gareth Hoelbook: And you'll know better than me actually what happens that they're in an FE8 scene.
- 14:48Gareth Hoelbook: Um she had a bird strike, Phoenix had a bird strike, Bob said um bird strike, bird strike, and Maverick was just behind her, and I think she lost the left engine, so she she turned it down and then restarted it, and then she was going through the whole sequence of events, which was all automated, and I'm guessing she was doing the the naming, the pointed and calling, the the Shisa Kanko.
- 15:11Gareth Hoelbook: So she went through the whole sequence, and you can tell that there was deliberate practice there, it was all system one, it was all automated, and she got to the point where the right engine fired out and she said it's still spinning, I'm going to restart it.
- 15:28Gareth Hoelbook: So she called what she was going to do, and then Maverick was behind her and he said that the engine's on fire, don't start up.
- 15:35Gareth Hoelbook: But he didn't have time because she just fired it straight away and then it blew and they had to eject.
- 15:40Gareth Hoelbook: And the point is, in point and call and deliberate action, is you call the action you're going to take, but you give a slight pause so you can be conscious about what you've said, but people around you can give you feedback.
- 15:54Gareth Hoelbook: Yep.
- 15:54Gareth Hoelbook: There's no point giving intent if there isn't an opportunity to challenge that intent.
- 15:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, that's a fantastic um call out from the movie, and here's why.
- 16:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I never picked up on that.
- 16:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I'm reading your notes, I'm like, wait a minute, she she does do that, and that's very deliberate in the movie.
- 16:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I don't know if you know this, but the technical advisor to that movie has been on this podcast.
- 16:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: His name is Yank Cummings.
- 16:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and so we've had him deliver uh keynotes with us to to organizations, and he talks about what's in the movie and what's in real life, uh, kind of kind of as a you know, hey, this is how leadership actually works.
- 16:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But that is a fantastic example of this.
- 16:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And having flown um and and seen other aircraft catch fire, their engines catch fire, and been in that position from another aircraft, I I tell you that man, I'd uh I can't believe I missed that.
- 16:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so thank you for that.
- 16:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a fantastic call out.
- 16:48Gareth Hoelbook: Cool.
- 16:48Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 16:48Gareth Hoelbook: Um and so that we we use lots of little clips from like Apollo 13 and Master and Commander, because it's obviously the most movies are really well researched, and you can look at the dynamic, and that's what intent-based leadership is, really, is noticing how people speak, how people respond, and the language that people use.
- 17:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I do want to bring up uh some of the concepts that you have in your actually not just your book, but some of the things you've written about recently.
- 17:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and make some connections to just the OODA loop and then of course uh yeah what we're talking about with elite sports skill acquisition.
- 17:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So perception.
- 17:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How how does that play into all this?
- 17:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh how do we perceive what's going on around us?
- 17:30Gareth Hoelbook: So I think the the phrase is you don't see the world as it is, you see it as you are.
- 17:35Gareth Hoelbook: And I I'm I'm not sure what your position is on most cognitive biases.
- 17:40Gareth Hoelbook: Um but I know that in in the calm in planning, when you make a decision about how you're going to act in the future, it would be different than when you make that decision in the moment.
- 17:51Gareth Hoelbook: So I know from experience when I'm in an Iron Man, um as my heart rate goes up, my IQ goes down.
- 17:58Gareth Hoelbook: It's like two X-wing crosses.
- 18:01Gareth Hoelbook: So I know in a race I cannot make an on-the-hoof decision because it will be a poor decision.
- 18:06Gareth Hoelbook: So I try and preload all of the decisions of what is predictable beforehand because I know and and the the lead story in my in my book, that the opening story is in Iron Man, Hawaii, that I was seven kilometres from the finish line and I collapsed, lost consciousness, it was hypernitremia, really, really dangerous.
- 18:26Gareth Hoelbook: The doctors came, but somebody gave me some salt water, now I should have still pulled out, because it is really, really dangerous, it can kill you.
- 18:33Gareth Hoelbook: But I managed to shake myself off, walk it out, then jog out and finish.
- 18:38Gareth Hoelbook: And when I first thought about this, I thought, great, heroic story, that's going in the book.
- 18:43Gareth Hoelbook: But the more I think about it is that I'm not self-governing because I was just so fixated on finishing the race that I put my own life in danger.
- 18:51Gareth Hoelbook: And I think what I should have done is have a boundary that if I lose consciousness and collapse on the floor, it's over.
- 18:57Gareth Hoelbook: Um and I I think that's I think your question was about self-perception.
- 19:02Gareth Hoelbook: I think in the moment we're very weak as it.
- 19:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so let me back up a little bit.
- 19:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So had you planned this, had you gone through this contingency, uh it sounds like you didn't, right?
- 19:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It sounds like you made a decision in a moment to get back up and and continue?
- 19:15Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, I did, yeah.
- 19:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, and you think that's the wrong decision?
- 19:19Gareth Hoelbook: I think in in retrospect, yeah, and the two lead females from ha Hawaii last year, so Lucy Charles Barclay and Taylor Nib, both collapsed and they both pulled out.
- 19:28Gareth Hoelbook: Now Lucy was in a real poor state, but uh Taylor Nib was only two 2K, so a mile and a half from the finish line, and she stopped, she had a few few minutes on the suite behind her, or the Norwegian behind her.
- 19:40Gareth Hoelbook: She could arguably have shaken off and got up and maybe finished in the top five.
- 19:44Gareth Hoelbook: Um, but she no, she stayed down.
- 19:47Gareth Hoelbook: And I think that was a wise decision as a pro tri triathlete, she would have done.
- 19:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I wasn't expecting to go there with you on this, and we'll come back to the perception here in a second.
- 19:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so in your situation, you made a decision and you had an outcome where you finished a race, correct?
- 20:01Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah.
- 20:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 20:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And now it was a bad decision, right?
- 20:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That yeah, based on what I'm hearing.
- 20:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, so here this is this is really important.
- 20:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Separating outcomes and decisions is absolutely critical in all everything we're talking about, right?
- 20:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the lesson learned from this is you are not going to do that again.
- 20:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what I'm hearing, right?
- 20:18Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 20:18Gareth Hoelbook: So and and it's yeah, it's called resulting, uh, you talked about where you connect the decision quality with the outcome quality, and they may disconnect.
- 20:26Gareth Hoelbook: And we that we and in reflection, we need to look at what's the decision sound irrespective of the outcome.
- 20:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There we go.
- 20:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, so now we're gonna back out of this.
- 20:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna go so uh you had the um hindsight available to you and all this.
- 20:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you looked at this.
- 20:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now let's go back to the beginning.
- 20:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So think of like a pre-mortem.
- 20:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, we know what that is.
- 20:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now we're gonna go back to the planning process.
- 20:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in the planning process, if I'm hearing you correctly, we have to look at contingencies in the process of planning.
- 20:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That way we know in situ what we're gonna do, what our go-no-go is, right?
- 20:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so that is absolutely critical in everything we do.
- 21:02Gareth Hoelbook: Exactly, yeah.
- 21:03Gareth Hoelbook: And and I'm guessing in pre-flight briefing, you do that all the time because the consequences are quite quite poor, right?
- 21:10Gareth Hoelbook: Right.
- 21:10Gareth Hoelbook: But I don't think we in in normal living in sport and in in organizations and in work, I don't think we do the same briefing with the the boundaries of this decision is only valid within these boundaries.
- 21:23Gareth Hoelbook: Right.
- 21:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so an effective plan is going to have contingencies against known and stratified risks or threats, right?
- 21:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or we'll call it expected free energy or risk, right?
- 21:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Risk management.
- 21:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It doesn't mean we can go over every single possibility.
- 21:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can't do that.
- 21:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh because we can't know, right?
- 21:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's a complex system, but we can go over the likely or probable things and have a way to get out of those unknown unknowns later on, which is again it's a planning process that you have to do live, right?
- 21:51Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, and it but it wasn't known known.
- 21:53Gareth Hoelbook: I mean, how can I train you?
- 21:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You knew about this.
- 21:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, there you go.
- 21:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So using Kinevin, it's a known known.
- 21:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's a domain of expertise, right?
- 21:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a it's a complicated situation.
- 22:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: By the way, teamwork is a known known too.
- 22:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's teamwork and teaming are well to make sure I get this right.
- 22:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The process of teamwork is a complicated thing.
- 22:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Teams are complex, right?
- 22:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, that's using the Kinevin framework to help explain this and so much more.
- 22:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Go back to perception.
- 22:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 22:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can't remember if I saw this uh in in something you wrote about or somewhere tangential to your work.
- 22:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well one of the things you're following in in perception training is um and this goes back to intent.
- 22:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's education of attention and education of intention.
- 22:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So education of attention is what we pay attention to, what's what the affordances in the environment.
- 22:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And intention would be those skills that we develop to to use in a situation.
- 22:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you tracking that?
- 22:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you are you I mean do you follow that type of thinking?
- 22:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That perception and and uh intention are are two different things or similar things.
- 23:01Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, this is uh I'm I'm not sure.
- 23:04Gareth Hoelbook: I'm not sure I understand.
- 23:05Gareth Hoelbook: So I think there's introsception and extraception, and we I I I think about internally what am I feeling, and externally what am I seeing, and we have to have a non-judgmental observation before applying reasoning to it.
- 23:20Gareth Hoelbook: I I'm not sure that answers the question well.
- 23:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well actually actually that goes a little bit deeper into it.
- 23:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So to me, interoception, hopefully I get this right, is is you're aware of your uh the things that are going on inside your body, right?
- 23:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 23:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're you're you're connected to the environment.
- 23:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's and there's research here in the US, and I think globally it says that's probably the most important skill to have in anything.
- 23:44Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, and and in endurance sport, it's all interception.
- 23:47Gareth Hoelbook: So I will I will be getting signals all the time.
- 23:50Gareth Hoelbook: Some of them not good, but I need to override some to say that's pain, but that's okay.
- 23:55Gareth Hoelbook: But then other things I need to listen to and go, okay, this means I need to adapt.
- 24:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I think this actually connects to your uh your internal intent thing.
- 24:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I was again, I'm I'm I'm learning as we go.
- 24:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the perception I was talking about was the perception, the things you pay attention to in the environment, the external things outside of you.
- 24:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you just went and said, Yes, and it's the things that are inside that are more important.
- 24:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think I think that's what you're saying.
- 24:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I agree I agree with you.
- 24:20Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 24:21Gareth Hoelbook: So I I remember I had I was having this conversation with a CEO uh six years ago, and I was trying to sell in intent-based leadership, and he he was he was quite confrontational straight away.
- 24:31Gareth Hoelbook: And he was saying, Well, what are your credentials?
- 24:32Gareth Hoelbook: What do you know, and all that kind of stuff?
- 24:33Gareth Hoelbook: And he put me right on the back foot.
- 24:35Gareth Hoelbook: And I remember saying out loud, I'm I'm I can actually feel the threat response now.
- 24:40Gareth Hoelbook: And so that was an external action, but I had an internal response and I could distinguish the two.
- 24:46Gareth Hoelbook: And I think um I think yeah, you need you need the awareness of what's happening because if you don't know you're in a threat response, then you're going to respond without control.
- 24:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 24:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and one of the big studies we we look here is I think it's Dan Coates who looked at the number one skill on Wall Street is interoception skills.
- 25:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and again, I I I wasn't expecting that that answer from you, but you just led me down to yeah, Ponch, and it's also the stuff that's inside of you that's important, um, which is fantastic.
- 25:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the uh educational attention would be uh the way I look at it when we're doing things in a training scenario is as you're as you're instructing a new aviator, you're helping them understand the things you need to pay attention to in the in the environment, the external environment.
- 25:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Same thing is true in sports, right?
- 25:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and that's what the the ecological dynamics and constraints led approach folks are doing is working on that uh education of uh attention.
- 25:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What what are you paying attention to in the environment?
- 25:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then it's the skills development piece that I want to go with you next.
- 25:46Gareth Hoelbook: So we could talk a little bit about so one thing I've been listening to quite a lot of your podcasts, and the the sports metaphor is quite common, but there's there's an interesting thing with the sport that I do, I don't have an adversary, I'm not there's no tactical engagement with anybody else, it's all internal, and it's not even mind over body, it's mind over mind.
- 26:10Gareth Hoelbook: So there's parts of the mind which seeks comfort and avoids threat, and there's a part of the mind which is less hedonistic, which knows that this is going to be painful, um, but there's good reason to do it, and so there's a debate within my own mind.
- 26:23Gareth Hoelbook: So the the when in in my concept of sport, because I don't really do the sport with the somebody I'm racing against, yeah, I'm just racing against myself.
- 26:33Gareth Hoelbook: And and it was a I was actually listening to the game theory podcast from a few weeks ago, and I was riding my bike listening to this, and I thought, yeah, well, I'm I'm not playing games with anyone, but internal in my own head.
- 26:45Gareth Hoelbook: It's not even with the body, because the body just responds to one part of the brain.
- 26:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's interesting.
- 26:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so okay, so we're taking away the unfolding circumstances from an opponent that you that doesn't exist, so but we're still leaving the outside information, which is the the weather, the conditions of the road, all that things, water temperature.
- 27:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh but then we're going into the internal constraints, which you're you're which really what you're competing against is your your genetics, your what you ate for dinner four weeks ago, how you worked out, all those things.
- 27:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's your key on it.
- 27:18Gareth Hoelbook: And actually, specifically my internal governor.
- 27:21Gareth Hoelbook: So Tim Nokes has done a lot of research on the central governor th theory, and that your brain will limit your body before it's too late.
- 27:29Gareth Hoelbook: So your brain will self-protect.
- 27:31Gareth Hoelbook: And the debate is with that governor, and can I push a little bit further?
- 27:35Gareth Hoelbook: And so your conscious brain, your executive function, needs to drive the governor to allow the body to go further.
- 27:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, how do you do that?
- 27:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you train for that?
- 27:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's talk about that because it that that's that's to me, that's an internal constraint that limits you from performing.
- 27:50Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, so it's homesis, you it's in training when you when you push the limits, when you know that you know I've done a six-hour bike quick ride before, this is easy, I can do it.
- 27:59Gareth Hoelbook: But then it's also it's the internal mental modelling, it's psychological, it's giving yourself micro rewards, it's reframing the pain signals in its and this is why I I got it wrong with a hypernatremia because I started to feel really I was losing consciousness, is that I'm I was overriding that central governor to say, no, this is fine, we're expecting it, carry on.
- 28:23Gareth Hoelbook: So that's an internal debate, and it's intent as well.
- 28:27Gareth Hoelbook: You need the purpose and why you're doing this.
- 28:29Gareth Hoelbook: So uh when I did a two-day iron distance race, on the second day in the morning, it was it was quite horrible actually.
- 28:38Gareth Hoelbook: But I had a reason to do it, and it was actually to write this book and to have a you know a keynote story.
- 28:44Gareth Hoelbook: Um, but it was really tough, but because I had that purpose, it gave me agency to carry on and kind of override that governor.
- 28:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so I was just this actually right before this, I was listening to a podcast, uh Alex West, he's a Navy SEAL.
- 28:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's on with uh Sean Ryan at the moment.
- 28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he talks about this.
- 28:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to break this down.
- 29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what you just said is you have a distal goal, which is important.
- 29:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um that's that's the uh the book, and then you have proximal goals.
- 29:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What Alex was talking about on the podcast is uh uh during Hell Week in Buds, what they would what he would do is just get to the next meal, whatever that get to the next tree, get to the next car, get to the next thing.
- 29:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that is that what you're doing as well?
- 29:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:21Gareth Hoelbook: Um so I treat myself every 20 minutes as a gel, which is a reward.
- 29:25Gareth Hoelbook: Um in the swimming, it's every boy, is every hundred meters.
- 29:28Gareth Hoelbook: And I'm just looking at the next kilometer, the next the next stage, um, and then I do the fractions, so I'm now a third the way through, now I'm a halfway through, and I'm just using the proportions to get to the end.
- 29:39Gareth Hoelbook: So at the start of an Iron Man, I'm not thinking of 11, 12 hours of racing, because that would be overwhelming.
- 29:45Gareth Hoelbook: I'm just thinking about the start, the position, and the next hundred meters.
- 29:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, so this is true in anything we do, and this is where we set goals.
- 29:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, same with organization.
- 29:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're gonna move into the organizational side here in a moment, but they still need some type of distal goal, and we know that from team science.
- 30:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You need some proximal goals, things that you can get done.
- 30:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So think about when you're doing agile software development, this you know, a scrum goal is proximal goal to get to the bigger picture.
- 30:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and that proximal goal should be in more focus.
- 30:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You should have more awareness of what you're trying to do than that distal goal.
- 30:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because that distal goal doesn't really give you a desired end state or a high definition destination or whatever you want to call it.
- 30:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a direction of travel, and then I'm using stuff from Kinevin to to make make sense of that.
- 30:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's we're going in that direction, but to get there, we got to get to this, right?
- 30:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can can you talk about this in the context of organizations and and how they can use what we're talking about to to how they you know they how they run?
- 30:43Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, this this is a I mean, this is my professional life now, and one thing I've been really big on for the past 10 years, and I was leading the Agile practice visa for a few years, or subsidiary visa, and we had 25 teams, and in each team were they were in groups, and it was really important to me that the team charters, so it goes through all of Lencione's five dysfunctions to build trust, but we also need the mission, why are we here, what we're trying to achieve, and then with that mission, then you cascade down into well, what are we aiming for this quarter?
- 31:15Gareth Hoelbook: So we had quarterly goals and weekly goals, and also the obviously the sprint goal.
- 31:20Gareth Hoelbook: And I think that's really important when when we're doing that daily coordination meeting, is that what I'm aiming to do today fits into what our objective is for the next two weeks, which then cascades all the way through.
- 31:34Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 31:34Gareth Hoelbook: And I I think with with that mission and that purpose, then it's easier to make those small micro tactical decisions without deferring back to the leader every time.
- 31:44Gareth Hoelbook: So in chartering teams, it was really important to me to set a really strong mission, vision, and the objectives.
- 31:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, absolutely.
- 31:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We uh so when I was doing the agile stuff too, it was uh same same thing.
- 31:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If uh first off, you don't have a team if you don't have a shared understanding of what you're trying to do.
- 32:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you can't have that.
- 32:01Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 32:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh generally people just apply the label team to a group of people and say that it's a team, they're doing this, they're doing scrum, they're doing whatever, and and you go in there and you're like, they don't even know each other's names.
- 32:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um they don't even know what they're trying to do as an organization yet.
- 32:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're you're forcing this framework on them.
- 32:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I just want to I want to be clear, a team has to have a shared and and uh shared goal, uh understanding the direction of travel they're going into.
- 32:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I want to ask you this, going back to intent-based leadership.
- 32:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Remember, we brought up in a complex environment, you can't have a clear entity.
- 32:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You don't know exactly what things look like.
- 32:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you can't work backwards from that.
- 32:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can do that in a complicated domain, but you can't do that in the in a complex domain.
- 32:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So how how does lead how does intent-based leadership fit in that complex domain?
- 32:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What is a leader supposed to be doing?
- 32:48Gareth Hoelbook: So the first thing is for the leader to be to build the clarity of what the end point is.
- 32:54Gareth Hoelbook: Now, that endpoint may shift as we progress through, as we learn things, but at least there needs to be a start point of this is where the direction of travel.
- 33:02Gareth Hoelbook: And then it's really once there's clarity in that, then it's to build the environment where the team can build the competence and the commitment so that they that the team themselves can drive forward to that next step.
- 33:16Gareth Hoelbook: So the the leader's role is predominantly to set the direction of travel and and build the environment.
- 33:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the way I've seen it done in the past, and and I'm I'm I don't like this, uh it's a bunch of vision and mission statements, it's a bunch of uh uh leadership by uh you know emails and and uh PowerPoint presentations.
- 33:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh can you talk a little bit about that and what why that's right for that?
- 33:38Gareth Hoelbook: So uh mission and mission statement are two different things, and and you I've all seen lots of value statements in organizations, and then you watch the behavior and it's there are odds.
- 33:48Gareth Hoelbook: So the the leader needs to be sure that everybody can see the same thing, and that's what a vision is, you can see it.
- 33:55Gareth Hoelbook: But and that doesn't mean PowerPoint, it means that if you were to ask anybody what are we trying to achieve here or why are we trying to achieve it, you get largely the same answer.
- 34:05Gareth Hoelbook: And and so when I facilitated the uh the the chartering, it's to get people to see the same thing, and so I use techniques that we all agree that this is what we're trying to achieve.
- 34:17Gareth Hoelbook: Once you've got that, then the smaller decisions become aligned, and it's easier to make those smaller decisions without deferring up to why we're trying to do this.
- 34:26Gareth Hoelbook: Well, let me ask you this.
- 34:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 34:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sorry, go ahead.
- 34:29Gareth Hoelbook: Sorry.
- 34:29Gareth Hoelbook: So that's the that's a fundamental role of the leader is to ensure that everyone else can see what he can see or she can see.
- 35:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in an and this is where I I'm gonna challenge you on this because I want to have a conversation on it.
- 35:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When a leader doesn't have a clear understanding of what they're trying to do.
- 35:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 35:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and what what should we what should they be doing?
- 35:53Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, and and I've seen this, and I've I've seen some leaders, product owners.
- 35:56Gareth Hoelbook: Um one of my first product owners in a sprint planning said, you know, I'd really like to work on this technology in this stack, but and you did this, you went, them upstairs want to work on this thing over here.
- 36:06Gareth Hoelbook: And you can see the shoulders drop, and and when it's like it's not an internal will, it's like a projected will from somebody else, that's that's not gonna inspire people.
- 36:17Gareth Hoelbook: I I think yeah, if you don't know the way forward, what you can say is, well, that we don't know.
- 36:23Gareth Hoelbook: And it's actually the best thing to say is we don't know, but the these these are the boundaries of the things that we do know, and then start asking it as an experiment, saying this is what we're going to probe to the Kinevin language.
- 36:36Gareth Hoelbook: We think this, so let's try this, and this will validate what we think.
- 36:41Gareth Hoelbook: So then we're being hypothetical, and that's the empirical process control.
- 36:45Gareth Hoelbook: In essence, that's what scrum is, is we don't know the future.
- 36:49Gareth Hoelbook: And so many companies, especially the larger companies, say, Yeah, we know the future, the market wants this, the world's gonna be like this in a year's time, so this is definitely what we're going to do.
- 36:58Gareth Hoelbook: And it's that false certainty which catches us out.
- 37:02Gareth Hoelbook: So it's actually better to say we don't know, but we think that this is something we can test.
- 37:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think I can't remember if David Marquet actually said those words, um, but leadership language, uh, if I got that right, I'd I I that book came uh five years ago, four years ago.
- 37:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 37:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the language we use matters, and this goes back to psychological safety.
- 37:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, psychological safety, um, when you show vulnerability, humility, that you don't know all the answers, that's actually a good thing, right?
- 37:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what you're you're saying here is in context, a leader may not know exactly what's going to go on going to happen, and they can't.
- 37:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh they need to rely on their team.
- 37:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Collectively, they can build an intent, and the the leadership's job is to make sure that's the direction they want to go, right?
- 37:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in order to do that, you the leaders have to actually relinquish control and say, I don't know, and that's a good thing, right?
- 37:47Gareth Hoelbook: So it yeah, you agree with that or anything else?
- 37:51Gareth Hoelbook: So the uh and and specifically so the language, and this isn't in his book, was a case study of a container ship that was it was it was moving from Jacksonville to Puerto Rico and it sank around um Bermuda or Barbados, old Bermuda Channel, and Bahamas, sorry.
- 38:09Gareth Hoelbook: And the point is, is the captain in all of the language because the um David went through the voice data recorder, and the captain was very assertive and and very we know which way we're going, it's only a small storm, we're gonna press ahead.
- 38:23Gareth Hoelbook: And then the captain went below decks, uh went to sleep, and while he was asleep, the storm deteriorated, and the crew didn't feel that they could challenge him to say we need to take an alternative route, because he'd set that absolutely we're carrying on this route, the escalation of commitment we're carrying on, and and then it was hard for him to back down to say he was wrong because he had already set himself up as no, we we're we're gonna be fine.
- 38:50Gareth Hoelbook: Um, but it also made it hard for the crew to challenge him to say, I think we should take this alternative route.
- 38:56Gareth Hoelbook: So, and there's loads of cases like that.
- 38:58Gareth Hoelbook: He had loads of case studies of the um the BP Deep Water Horizon where people laid um breaking the valve.
- 39:05Gareth Hoelbook: Um the 2017 Oscars where Warren Beattie felt that he couldn't stop the proceedings.
- 39:11Gareth Hoelbook: And so if we're in an environment where there is uncertainty and we know we don't know, then it's safer to say, yes, I was wrong, what do we now know?
- 39:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, that I'm glad you brought up the 2017 uh award show.
- 39:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That was I actually used that to explain to folks uh multiple perspectives and art and science debriefing years and years of years ago.
- 39:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's uh and of course we used Bacon Doell to explain to folks that after Macondo Well, oil and gas picked up on a uh crew resource management and started mandating it, uh that training.
- 39:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this goes back to what Dave Marquet, what you just described, and that is uh when you listen to the tapes in the cockpit, when you go back to the 70s and we get the uh black box, that's when we started to identify it's not a mechanical failure, it's a it's a failure of collaboration, coordination, communication, a hierarchy in the cockpit that's preventing or you know, uh contributing to these accidents and rate around 80% of them.
- 40:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh uh again, there's there's nothing new under the sun here.
- 40:05Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, so we just need to lower the power power gradient so the junior people can speak up.
- 40:10Gareth Hoelbook: And so the one of the patterns I do when I coach leaders is in meetings, speak last and speak least.
- 40:17Gareth Hoelbook: Because if a leader goes into a meeting saying, This is what I want as an outcome, this is what I think, there's gonna be compliance.
- 40:23Gareth Hoelbook: People are generally feeling coerced and going to agree to it.
- 40:27Gareth Hoelbook: So if we want divergent thinking, that the the leader says, Here's a problem we're looking at, I want to hear your ideas first before I share my ideas, it means the the leader can still make the final decision and could declare that, but at least we're getting divergent thinking.
- 40:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I want to go back to your exposure to Japanese success.
- 40:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So going back to when you came across like Kanban, and you how where was that and what was going on and the connection to the things we're talking about now?
- 40:58Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, so um so I left the Navy in 94 and was made redundant.
- 41:02Gareth Hoelbook: Strange little I applied for redundancy, and my postgrad before I got into work was in management.
- 41:09Gareth Hoelbook: So in the mid-90s in the UK, it was all about Japanese management theory.
- 41:13Gareth Hoelbook: So I I learned about Theory Z and Theory Y, and Toyota was a good case study because the UK car industry was not very good at the time.
- 41:21Gareth Hoelbook: Um, and then I managed to get a job at Sony.
- 41:25Gareth Hoelbook: So I was working in a factory, a TV factory, and learned how they created the Kanban system or Sony's approach to it.
- 41:32Gareth Hoelbook: And I learned a few other things about Sony.
- 41:34Gareth Hoelbook: It's going to be in my next book about decision making because and Gillian Tet talked about it in the silo effect.
- 41:40Gareth Hoelbook: Um Sony struggled because it got so big.
- 41:42Gareth Hoelbook: But my true exposure to Kanban was when I first came to New Zealand, a small manufacturing company called Navman, who were making GPS navigators and um marine instruments.
- 41:53Gareth Hoelbook: They had a true Kanban line.
- 41:56Gareth Hoelbook: So the COO was X Alpine, so he worked in Japan.
- 42:00Gareth Hoelbook: And so I learned Kanban and it made perfect sense to me.
- 42:03Gareth Hoelbook: So I'd learned about Kaizen and the TPS in the 90s, and then into 2000 in Navman, I was there where I was willing a Kanban line as a product engineer.
- 42:13Gareth Hoelbook: And and that way of thinking has then informed all of the rest of my career for the last 25 years.
- 42:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There is a lot of overlap there.
- 42:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when when John Boyd came across TPS, and I'll I'll share a story that I shared in the last few weeks on on social media, and it was, you know, John Boyd looked at the Western interpretation of TPS and said, terrible, don't call it that, don't do that, right?
- 42:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh what John Boyd was critiquing authors about during that time was they didn't read Ono or Shingo, they didn't understand it.
- 42:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and what some of the feedback I got from Professor Leicher, and this is fantastic, because Nigel's been trying to tell me this for years, Professor Leicher said that you know, lean is just about a lean body, a lean organism, you know?
- 42:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So think about the things we just talked about, a healthy, lean system.
- 42:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what they're trying to convey.
- 43:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I think and I agree with that.
- 43:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, if if it's a living organism interacting with its environment, that's TPS.
- 43:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's the that's what I I mean, I'll support that 1000%.
- 43:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, yeah, I'll get behind that any day.
- 43:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why is that?
- 43:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because that's what the the OOD loop is.
- 43:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just a shows an agent embedded with us, you know, it's its environment.
- 43:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Until you take it into the linear observorient decide act loop, and that's a linear closed system.
- 43:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's an open system that's interacting with this environment.
- 43:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that is what uh one of the one of the blockers I had was what I was exposed to um TPS and Lane, what I saw was none of that.
- 43:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, this doesn't make any sense to me.
- 43:44Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah, so I read Gold Rats the Goal, and the version I had out in the appendix that TPS, even in Japan, let fewer than 20% of industrial Japan use TPS.
- 43:56Gareth Hoelbook: And the case study I think was Hita Hitachi Tools, who tried TPS and failed.
- 44:01Gareth Hoelbook: And we know the story of Numi and General Motors, who didn't really succeed.
- 44:06Gareth Hoelbook: And and we see this, that we people look at the outcome and go, oh, okay, we just need to do the same thing.
- 44:12Gareth Hoelbook: And so I've but worked at loads of banks here in New Zealand who think that a Swedish video uh music streaming company is a good model, even though Neberg said this is what we're trying.
- 44:23Gareth Hoelbook: And so um, yeah, Spotify is great, and I've I've visited Spotify and I can I see what they did, and it's a great you can look at some of the patterns and try and and experiment with some of the patterns in your context.
- 44:35Gareth Hoelbook: But what's been happening is people just like cookie cutter cut and paste Spotify onto 20-year-old, 30-year-old banks, and it just doesn't work.
- 44:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so the context matters here, and I I think going back to and this is why I like using sports analogies and the things we talked about here is you you gave an example of a living system engaging with its environment.
- 44:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's you, right?
- 44:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's peak performance.
- 44:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, that's what we want.
- 44:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in context, we can't come in with prescriptive approach.
- 45:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can't go, here's exactly what you're gonna do.
- 45:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're gonna use a Spotify model, you're gonna do this, you're gonna do that.
- 45:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't know because we don't understand the context.
- 45:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we're there to co-create with you and go, okay, if we understand these first principles, um, we know the things that work and we can implement them.
- 45:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and by the way, that's that's what we try to do, and that's what we've been trying to do.
- 45:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: uh or at least I've been trying to do for years.
- 45:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um you know, I push back on Scrum uh as a panacea free.
- 45:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, Scrum works great when you have highly interdependent teams that have a tacit interdependent.
- 45:29Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 45:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But chances are you don't necessarily have that everywhere you go, right?
- 45:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you need to find another way.
- 45:35Gareth Hoelbook: And and um interestingly with Scrum, and this is going to be in my next book, that I I treat Scrum as a kata.
- 45:42Gareth Hoelbook: So I've I I also practice karate and and kata is deliberate steps where you rewire patterns of thinking and doing that become autumn automatic.
- 45:53Gareth Hoelbook: And but you can't if you're in a combat scene you wouldn't do a kata that you'd just be laughed at.
- 45:58Gareth Hoelbook: And I'd like how Mike Rother in Toyota Kata uses that metaphor for what Toyota do and and if you went to Toyota they don't call it kata.
- 46:07Gareth Hoelbook: It was his interpretation of what toy what Toyota did with cata.
- 46:11Gareth Hoelbook: And I actually so I've used Toyota Cata as well and a real fan of Mike Rother's work but then when I use scrum I use it as a cata to change the way people think.
- 46:24Gareth Hoelbook: So you you have those patterns so the events and the artifacts and the roles and they if you repeat them long enough it's going to change the way people think.
- 46:34Gareth Hoelbook: So Ahmed Sidke um talks of the four keystone habits of collaboration, slicing swarming and learning.
- 46:41Gareth Hoelbook: And I think if if you if you use scrum to the bite to the act to your way to new thinking you can then over a period of time be build those keystone habits and then when they're embedded just the same as Toyota Casa you can diverge your way and have your own bespoke practice.
- 46:58Gareth Hoelbook: I agree.
- 46:59Gareth Hoelbook: So I only use scrum as a cutter if I were to coach a scrum team and then two years later they're still doing the same patterns they've probably not learned anything.
- 47:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah yeah I would uh there's there's we can dive into that more if we go through cycles of destruction and creation you don't want teams to be uh working together for a long period of time either uh you still got to change out some things in there.
- 47:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah curious what what you know you've been looking at the OODA loop a little bit um any any concerns questions or challenges that you would throw at us or throw at me?
- 47:29Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah so um I really did look into Oodaloop and I've been using AI to really uh deep dive because when I created this model that I call the issue spiral uh there's four phases to it which is decide, forge, persist, reflect.
- 47:43Gareth Hoelbook: My thinking is there's a slight difference in the Oodaloop and I and so I was pitching to speak at a conference and somebody said is this not just Oodaloop with Japanese words because I use ishi shuggyo gaman and Hansei for the four phases and I was really sensitive to this because I know so many consultants create their own little mini framework and try and sell it and you know it's the going to be the next PDSA.
- 48:07Gareth Hoelbook: And and my thinking is and and I I'd like you to try and challenge me on this is that the decision and act the decide and act in UDA is an experiment and test.
- 48:18Gareth Hoelbook: So that's what Boyd was arguing I think.
- 48:21Gareth Hoelbook: And in in my model I think the decision is the commitment and then you set a commitment over the long arc.
- 48:28Gareth Hoelbook: So so issue is the issue spiral is slightly different because it's long arc endeavours where you want to govern that decision because as things change you may want to preset boundaries or give yourself the permission to abort or adjust the method as things emerge.
- 48:44Gareth Hoelbook: So through emergence that decision then is no longer valid.
- 48:48Gareth Hoelbook: And I think the the Hansei aligns with orientation but in UDA UDA isn't a sequence of four things and it isn't about a loop getting faster and faster because they all interact with one another and and my thinking with Hansei the reflect phase at the end is it doesn't happen at the end it happens concurrently throughout.
- 49:09Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 49:10Gareth Hoelbook: So my model decide forge persist reflect I'm absolutely so sensitive that it it isn't ooh the loop in in a kimono.
- 49:18Gareth Hoelbook: That's so from what you've read because I I I sent you some of the stuff so what how do you perceive it?
- 49:23Gareth Hoelbook: Do you see a difference?
- 49:25Gareth Hoelbook: What well I want to just ask you about forge uh what do you mean by that?
- 49:28Gareth Hoelbook: What does forge mean?
- 49:29Gareth Hoelbook: So that's uh deliberate practice that's Ericton's work and and actually I listened to the grit Angela Duckworth a few weeks ago she said in order to get the to be gritty you need the deliberate practice and I argue in my book that persist and forge are a pair.
- 49:45Gareth Hoelbook: You need to persist with a forge and that you can only persist with the right patterns so you need to have forged first.
- 49:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah so to me you could apply this directly so the the if you look at the Oodaloop as a living system engaging with the world uh just a blueprint the the deliberate practice would be the practice design that you put onto the system right so that would be like a if you use the constraints led approach thinking and I'm just borrowing this because it's top of mind a deliberate practice for an individual for you would be to make sure that everything you do represents the things that you're going to experience in in the Iron Man or for a basketball coach everything they're going to experience in the game.
- 50:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Don't do something um like cone drills or weaves that isn't represented in the game.
- 50:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So representative design would be deliberate practice.
- 50:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's that's that persistence is to me is flow.
- 50:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean that's that's uh persistory time is about living so to me that might be uh that might be a component of the oodaloop or something you put onto it.
- 50:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not really sure and reflection you know reflection is not in the oodaloop it's it doesn't show up there right it's you get feedback from the external environment so uh again I wouldn't try to say I don't think it's the I don't think what you're saying is you're replacing the oodaloop you're you're trying to describe how you would improve the the oodle you know like the way a living system interacts with the environment.
- 51:10Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah and there's absolutely no doubt that having read Oodleop and been a you know studied scrum it is informed my thinking when I created the uh the issue spiral and and I just want to be sure that I've I've added some I've added something to it I've not just rebranded it in terms of flow you right when you persist you want to be in flow but also you want to be able to um deliberately step out of flow.
- 51:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So deliberate practice is the opposite of flow because it it's not enjoyable it's difficult it's frustrating you've got the disruption yes and yeah I agree with you yeah yeah but why you can't but here let me challenge you on this the the reason we have deliberate practice is we're outside of a flow channel because we're challenging our skills so if you think about Mihai Chicksemihai's uh challenge skills balance right the environment skills you're you're outside of that comfort zone it's it's hard and you're not in flow you can't be because you're challenging yourself right yeah so I agree only just outside so it's that inverted you that you want to be slightly uh slightly challenged but not overly challenged that you can close that right right because if you're over the challenged uh what is it you get I forget you don't get bored that's under challenges you get bored so yeah yeah it's all there yeah so yeah so I've I've read Chicksend me how his work and I think the the flow state is yeah the persist when you get into that flow so like when I'm running a I'm doing an ultramarathon in a few months' time and there will be like an arrow in and between an arrow and six hours will kind of fly.
- 52:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 52:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so to me what you're describing is a way to improve the Oodaloop so again let's I hate to say you're not improving the OODA loop but you're improving the way a living system interacts with its environment.
- 52:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or another way to say that you're improving an OODA loop which is a living system interacting with its environment.
- 52:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let me give you another example.
- 52:58Gareth Hoelbook: Scrum is to the way I look at it is it is a team life cycle right all teams plan execute assessed and that's what a that scrum is the plan brief execute debrief process is a team life cycle you plan you brief you execute you debrief right it's it's it repeats over over you're not it it's not a replacement for the OODA loop it's helping that living organism improve the way it interacts with a changing environment it's a linear process applied to a not hate to say that to a non living uh nonlinear living system open system right because that's what we know it's it's a complicated domain thing that I believe you're saying is is uh with decide forge persist and reflect uh to me that's plan brief execute debrief it yeah of course it'll work yeah yeah it says and and the the essence is it's not a four-step sequence in time my my my thinking that they happen sequentially but they also happen concurrently yeah and it's who owns the governance at any one moment who who owns the authority to govern are are you practicing in this moment or are you persisting is it a reflection or are you making a conscious decision?
- 54:04Gareth Hoelbook: And so Marquet talks about the red and blue work.
- 54:07Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah uh red work being repeatable um doing work um industrial age thinking and blue work being the thinking and reflecting work and a loss of his and especially in leadership is language is how do you consciously switch between red and blue work?
- 54:22Gareth Hoelbook: Because if you're locked into red work that's when mistakes happen and if you're locked into blue work that's where you get analysis paralysis.
- 54:30Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah.
- 54:31Gareth Hoelbook: So the spiral is a conscious way to switch out of red and blue work.
- 54:35Gareth Hoelbook: So you're always uh oscillating between one or the other.
- 54:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so here's where I think you can go deeper.
- 54:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: First principles as so we've been exploring you know free energy principle, active inference, predictive processing, Bayesian inference and all that how how do we actually engage with the external world?
- 54:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To me those are going to be kind of first principle approaches that that uh tell us how we engage, right?
- 54:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and at a minimum I believe leaders need to know that because you can get into cognitive warfare.
- 55:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You get to understand that a little bit deeper.
- 55:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You get into leadership you get into teamwork.
- 55:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then you can start applying these um I I hate to call it a framework but uh plan brief ex debrief maybe a framework, scrum as a framework maybe.
- 55:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But and then you can start to explain how these things work in context, right?
- 55:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because uh if you don't have interdependent work or if you're only operating in the complicated domain and I hate to say that that way but that that is uh that kind of bounds as to which pathways we're on in the OODA loop.
- 55:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And let me give you another example.
- 55:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One of the things that uh we're learning from the ecological dynamics folks and skill um what do they call it skill acquisition constraints led approach is you know perception action coupling is everything uh because you're you're you're you're coupled to the environment perception and action are not independent things and then they add skills in there skills could include things like um intuition uh those things that we talked about earlier right could include interoception so you have to develop those through deliberate practice right that that's key I can't um and and that's what we're you know there's a lot of wasted motion in coaching here in the U.S.
- 56:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They do things from an industrial point of view which is I'm gonna do this because that's what I was trying to do 20, 30 years ago and I'm gonna mandate they do this.
- 56:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well that doesn't fit our first principle approach which is how does that living system engage with the environment?
- 56:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How's that perception action coupling there?
- 56:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How is that representative design working or is there any in what you're designing?
- 56:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah I do think it fits man I just I just think we need to get to the first principles first and explain that to folks and then let them go, I want to use this.
- 56:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because they can create their own stuff anytime they want, right?
- 56:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They can they can create their own approach as long as they understand how how those systems work together.
- 56:47Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah if if you understand the basic principles and and the objective yeah the the uh the the selection of practices is up to you.
- 56:55Gareth Hoelbook: And if you mandate practices without having an alignment with the underlying principles or you you you use the practices without understanding the principles then it's gonna be very hollow.
- 57:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah yeah and I think this is where where over years when I like when we created the flow learning lab we borrowed a constraint sled approach mindset or thinking behind that to you know years ago I used to come in and tell everybody here's how you're gonna plan I'm gonna give you five, six steps like a checklist and I'm gonna give you how to debrief I stepped away from that and now let them discover which works best for them.
- 57:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll nudge them in a direction I'm like hey uh what about optionality in here?
- 57:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where you where where's that in your planning process, right?
- 57:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or where's the part where you create uh a safe environment?
- 57:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where's that part in your debrief?
- 57:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and they they start to pick up on that and they create then they make their own approach right and now it becomes easier for them to uh incorporate it in their own business right rather than being told you got to follow this five-step debriefing approach.
- 57:52Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah and there's there is now a an adverse reaction to try and like prescribe an approach.
- 57:58Gareth Hoelbook: But I I guess it depends on the where that team is at because if the team has absolutely no idea then and this is where Rotha says you know when you first teach somebody to swim you have them hold the side and just learn how to kick.
- 58:12Gareth Hoelbook: And then over time then they can start doing laps but to begin with you have to be you kind of front foot it and give some practices because it's the it's the patterns and this is where Kata comes in the patterns rewire the thinking and then the principles emerge out of that thinking then when you understand the principles then you can ascend the practices and develop your own.
- 58:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um I'm gonna let you know this uh hopefully this works out but I have uh Andrew Sheep hopefully I say his name right Andrew Sheep coming on the show uh who is a uh swimming coach and he uses constraints led approach to explain swimming and he's worked with Keith David to to write some books and I think he's worked with uh Rob Gray.
- 58:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah I hadn't I have no idea how to do this for an individual to be honest with you.
- 58:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's why I'm kind of like like how do you improve swimming through constraints and and I'm looking forward to that conversation.
- 59:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to know if you have any thoughts.
- 59:04Gareth Hoelbook: So so I've yeah I've had quite a few swim coaches I'm not the best swimmer I I I don't drown which is looking like um but when I've had a swim coach they they will observe me they will show me they'll do video analysis and will show me the video then they'll say here's the problem you're in your rotation you're you're skewing your hips and shoulders aren't the same or your hands crossing over your elbows not up then the constraint is for the next four weeks we're just going to focus on this one pattern so every time you swim even if the rest of the squad is practicing something else I want you to think about this one pattern.
- 59:40Gareth Hoelbook: So we we look at patterns in isolation and it's exactly what my karate instructor does with me as well.
- 59:46Gareth Hoelbook: So again my hips are a problem so he will see if I'm not thrusting the hips in the right kind of way he will say yeah your foot placement is out your punch isn't fast but today I just want you to focus on your hips.
- 59:58Gareth Hoelbook: I guess a constraint is identifying one thing to fix.
- 1:00:01Gareth Hoelbook: Now they can see what I can't see so they give me direct instruction and I've I've always thought about this with my swim coach at squads we go there we have a whiteboard he says right today this is the plan this is what we're doing he doesn't do the business coach of what do you want to try today he just tells us this is what we're gonna do.
- 1:00:21Gareth Hoelbook: So he does front fuss it.
- 1:00:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay yeah uh curious uh you're still running a consultancy is is that correct?
- 1:00:28Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah yeah yeah most of my time now is I work on a farm I'm an athlete um but also yeah is is writing the books for the last year the big the big thing has been writing the book um but I do do leadership consulting mainly in Australia New Zealand sometimes in Singapore okay uh I'll I'll connect you to our our team down there uh I I think you met Doug Doug in the past and uh it was actually I was thinking about Doug the other day because it was Doug who inspired me to reach out to David Marquet because he when I first met Doug about 10 years ago he was delivering Dan Pink's material and I thought that's a great pattern.
- 1:01:05Gareth Hoelbook: So in around 2020 I started reaching out to authors and David was one of them and that's how I connected up and started working with him.
- 1:01:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah du Doug's uh uh really getting really proficient with the flow learning lab which is uh it's a blast I love doing it uh I don't want to do it all the time uh just because I'd much rather do these things yeah I'm like I'm yeah it's it's it's like being an instructor all over again.
- 1:01:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like I know what's going to happen here I know it you know but it's still a process and it's it's a good coaching thing that I think uh helps organizations really understand teaming skills and leadership.
- 1:01:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just looking at your notes here anything else you want to cover today?
- 1:01:40Gareth Hoelbook: Anything we're missing thank you Brian I've I've really enjoyed this you've kept me on my toes uh talking for it's been an hour but my my next book I'm really interested in I'd like to share with you when it comes out because it's it's about organizational decision making and my argument is few if any organization governs decisions as a first class object.
- 1:02:01Gareth Hoelbook: I think we may have decision locks and we record and register decisions but we don't govern them and the the the flagship case study is the Boeing 737 Max because the initial decision was is it was a derivative airframe but as things changed as new engines, new MCAS new cockpit procedures nobody thought to change that decision to make it a brand new airframe and that ultimately ended up in it crashing because the pilots were overwhelmed with the MCAS fighting them.
- 1:02:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's my case study and and so I'd I'd like to share with you what I've got so far and then maybe we can have another conversation so you know I lived in Seattle during that time ish 2014 and I worked at a uh you know I ended up going to the 737 line to see those these things you know being built and I remember uh I was there with an airline that I was working with at the time and uh having the conversation about the bigger engines and and noticing these things first off it's a it's it's a lean product I mean it's fantastic.
- 1:03:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean the the uh single uh what do you call it single piece flow all the way through in that in that line anyway you can see the production quality you're like this is exactly what you know lean should look like it's it's fantastic and then uh there is a concern about the size of the engine uh the acceleration of technology we were asking about where's this software being written who's writing it you know couldn't get an answer so it it was sad to see this thing unfold living in Seattle at the time but uh where I'm going with this is you go up to the 777 line seven eight seven line you know 60 70 miles north of there it looks like a completely different company I mean it you're like how did you not know that just right down in Renton I believe it is you can go see this this fantastic line and uh you know that story is uh sad.
- 1:03:50Gareth Hoelbook: Uh I mean it's it's it's you know you get into black line no judgment on the people it's the it's the system in the environment that how the environment emerged out like that.
- 1:03:59Gareth Hoelbook: And so and what we do about decision governance basically.
- 1:04:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah and I here's here's where I struggle with it.
- 1:04:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I remember talking to Boeing folks that were pushing scaled agile framework and yeah I'd ask them like have you ever considered can talking to the pilots that fly these aircraft to figure out how how teams work?
- 1:04:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And like why would we do that?
- 1:04:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like maybe that team science I don't know right and it would never occur to them that that's what matters because the whole agile community and this is this is my frustration with agile agile got fixated on the frameworks and they talked about the OODA loop and they talked about the linear OODA loop and I'm like I'm up there jumping up and down I'm like there's this high reliability organization um it's actually called HROs right and I I did a keynote in San Diego right across from the uh what's the name of the ship the Carl Vinson right uh the Carl you could see the Carl Vinson where I was you know go out the doors it's right there.
- 1:04:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: These the flat top where the lot of these concepts came from I'm talking about it and I remember going you know I was done with the keynote and and uh I heard some people over talking about teal organizations and how much more powerful a teal organization could ever be over a high reliability theory or high reliability organizing organization because that theory is made up.
- 1:05:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, oh my God the one that's made up is the teal organization man.
- 1:05:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh uh it's fascinating.
- 1:05:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm I'm so glad the Agile era is quote unquote over and we can move on from it and and actually take some of these lessons and go, uh to me it's always been team science.
- 1:05:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's been intent-based leadership if you don't mind me borrowing that.
- 1:05:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you coach this in an organization?
- 1:05:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's never been the frameworks man.
- 1:05:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and the whole Kanban versus scrum thing I'm like oh my God you know this is the dumbest conversation I've ever been part of is is fighting over something that is a tool and something that's a framework.
- 1:05:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know are you a Kanban team or a scrum team?
- 1:05:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like wow so so I'm so glad that's over.
- 1:05:47Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah well yeah I'm I'm glad it's over as well I mean the benefit was it was lucrative and it got me in front of yes clients and execs for me to have and really I was more interested in the intent based leadership and the systems theory and and the psychology.
- 1:06:02Gareth Hoelbook: So being being an agile practice lead meant that I could then practice all the stuff I really wanted to do.
- 1:06:08Gareth Hoelbook: So for me it was table stakes.
- 1:06:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I agree with you man I I I was lucky to have worked with uh Jeff Sutherland and and bring these you know the red teamy techniques and all these things in and and test them out you know I mean because I I had yeah I got to do all these things.
- 1:06:24Gareth Hoelbook: But back at Visa so this is 2018 I went to my boss who was a founder of this small company and said I want to change the name from agile practice to tactical delivery practice and I don't want scrum masters and agile coaches I'd like to rename them Kaisen coaches because our role is continuous improvement and coaching that that environment where things are constantly challenged and improved.
- 1:06:46Gareth Hoelbook: And I I achieved that I think it's gone back now because it's all fully Visa.
- 1:06:50Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah but that was 2018 I was trying to distance away from the the agile industrial complex and the big four and what I was seeing in in some of the large telcos and banks in New Zealand which was Spocify basically.
- 1:07:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:07:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah it was it was hard to bring in first principles.
- 1:07:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It was hard to bring in like hard sciences and go, this is what the science of teamwork says and they're like whatever.
- 1:07:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I'll tell you right now that's flipped uh people are starting to to look at this because artificial intelligence is borrowing a lot of these concepts from neuroscience right so how do living systems actually engage it is built that I just had a conversation earlier today about nodes and uh edges on the in the context of uh cognitive warfare right but if you're not familiar for those of you are listening to this the connection is to loop and uh graph engineering it's it's the same it's borrowed from um system dynamics or complex adaptive systems thinking so these things are emerging all around us that we ought to be using on our own systems our own human systems and and yeah hopefully organizations can pick up on that and coaches can pick up on that and start using it.
- 1:07:58Gareth Hoelbook: Yeah and I think with with AI, because I'm I'm a heavy user of it now as well you I need to be better at the interception of what am I thinking at the moment and how is that thinking being influenced by what I'm doing.
- 1:08:10Gareth Hoelbook: Big big and that's I think it's going to impact us all.
- 1:08:13Gareth Hoelbook: And we we can all thrive if we know how to think better.
- 1:08:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I imagine your your spiral that you created can work as a as a good looper a graph engineering approach too you know it's it's it has everything it needs, right?
- 1:08:25Gareth Hoelbook: Potentially it's still a hypothesis at the moment it's not tested and and the argument is is every element of that spiral I can defend with with research but the spiral as an integration is still a hypothesis.
- 1:08:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 1:08:37Gareth Hoelbook: So it works in my head I start enough.
- 1:08:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey I appreciate your time today I'll keep you on here for a moment but uh where can our listeners find your work right now?
- 1:08:47Gareth Hoelbook: So just check my name out Gareth Holbrook I'm really prolific on Substack and LinkedIn at the moment and my YouTube channel I'm doing lots of clips because I've been doing quite a few keynotes recently and I explain the issue spiral.
- 1:08:59Gareth Hoelbook: The book is available on Amazon and Lean Pub and my next book is out on Lean Pub which is Kaisen of the day which is a hundred small actions aligned with the issue spiral and then the next book is out on Lean Pub next month which is Kete the discipline of governed intent and that's going to be organizations and how do we govern intent in organizations oh great hey I appreciate your time today I know it's early in the morning for you or actually it's nine a now is that right?
- 1:09:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No yeah yeah okay the animals yeah well I appreciate your time we'll say uh bye for now to the uh the audience yeah thank you Brian cheers