Latest / Her Legacy: Female perspectives on life, culture & society / Leaving the Church That Raised Me: The Grief of Sacred Space | Her Legacy
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that falls when you walk out of a building that used to be your entire world, and it’s louder than any sermon ever was. You don’t just leave the pews; you leave the version of yourself that fit perfectly inside them. I want you to close your eyes for a second and picture the door. Not just any door, but heavy oak, or maybe stained glass, with a handle worn smooth by thousands of hands before yours. For years, that handle was the threshold between who you were on Tuesday and who you were supposed to be on Sunday. And then, one day, you turn it. You step through. And you don’t look back. Here’s the thing about leaving the church that raised you. We talk a lot about the theology of it. The doubts. The cognitive dissonance. The moment the hymns stopped sounding like comfort and started sounding like instructions. But we rarely talk about the physical sensation of separation. It feels like amputation. Because in many ways, it is. Your community, your routine, your moral compass, your understanding of grace and guilt—it was all housed in those walls. When you walk away, you aren’t just changing your weekend schedule. You are dismantling the architecture of your soul. Did you feel that too? That sudden vertigo? Like standing on the edge of a cliff where the ground used to be solid. I remember my first Sunday off. I woke up at seven AM, not because of an alarm, but because my body had been wired for worship since I was six years old. I sat in my kitchen, waiting for the call to prayer, or the chime, or the announcement. Nothing came. Just the hum of the refrigerator. And in that quiet, I felt terrifyingly alone. I thought, if God isn’t in that room, where is He? If He’s nowhere, am I abandoned? If He’s everywhere, why does it hurt so much to leave? Let’s sit with that ache for a moment. It’s okay to miss it. It’s okay to miss the certainty. Even if that certainty was suffocating, even if it demanded pieces of you that didn’t belong to you, it was familiar. Familiarity is a drug, and withdrawal is brutal. When you leave, you carry ghosts with you. Not the scary kind, though there can be plenty of those, but the comforting ones. The memory of Aunt Linda holding your hand during communion. The smell of incense mixing with floor wax. The way the light hit the dust motes dancing above the altar. These sensory details become anchors in your mind, pulling you back toward the shore you tried to swim away from. I’ve spoken to so many women who describe this as a form of grief. Real, raw, complicated grief. You mourn the loss of faith, yes. But you also mourn the loss of identity. Who am I if I’m not a faithful daughter? Who am I if I’m not part of the chosen? The labels peel off, and underneath, you’re left wondering if there’s anything real left. Or if you were just a reflection of their beliefs all along. This is where the shame creeps in. It whispers that you’re broken. That you failed. That you weren’t strong enough to hold onto what mattered. But I’m here to tell you, with every fiber of my journalistic heart and my personal experience, that you didn’t fail. You evolved. Growth often looks like betrayal to the systems that raised us. It’s not that the system was evil—though some were—but that it was small. And you became big. You outgrew the container. Think about the people you loved there. Do you still love them? Probably. Does that mean you have to stay? No. This is the hardest part of the equation. Loving someone doesn’t obligate you to share their worldview. It just means you honor the connection while honoring your own truth. It’s messy. It’s painful. It requires you to set boundaries with the very people who taught you how to pray. So, where do you go? Where does the sacredness live now? This is the question that keeps me up at night, and I know it keeps you up too. We spend decades being told that holiness resides in specific buildings, specific rituals, specific words. When you leave, you have to learn that holiness is portable. It’s not something they give you; it’s something you recognize. I found mine in nature. In the way the wind moves through trees without asking permission. In the way water finds its level. I found it in the quiet act of making coffee for myself, slowly, paying attention to the grind, the pour, the steam. There is ritual in these things. There is reverence. But it’s a reverence I choose, not one I’m coerced into. For some women, it’s art. For others, it’s service. For me, it’s storytelling. It’s sitting here, talking to you, weaving these threads of truth together. That is my liturgy. That is my communion. We have to teach ourselves to see the divine in the mundane. To stop looking for miracles in the sky and start finding them in the soil. Radical honesty about the female experience is itself a spiritual practice. To speak our truth, even when it shakes the foundations, is a holy act. Let’s challenge the idea that you need a roof to connect to the infinite. You don’t. You never did. They just made it convenient for you to believe otherwise. Now that the roof is gone, the sky is vast. And yes, it’s cold out there sometimes. But it’s also free. And freedom, however terrifying, is worth the chill. One of the biggest fears leaving brings is isolation. You worry that no one will understand. That you’ll be the odd one out, the prodigal who didn’t return. And initially, that loneliness is palpable. It sits in your chest like a stone. But over time, something shifts. You begin to attract a different kind of tribe. People who value questions over answers. People who find beauty in the cracks. These new connections are different. They’re less about conformity and more about resonance. You meet women who have also stepped away, who have also questioned, who have also grieved. And in their stories, you find mirrors. Not perfect reflections, but honest ones. You realize you’re not alone in your aloneness. There is a whole hidden network of women walking this path, carrying their own scars, their own wisdom. But even if you don’t find a group immediately, you must learn to be your own best companion. This is the radical work of solitude. Remember that episode we discussed recently, 'Why Your Brain Needs Dirt'? Well, this is that dirt. It’s grounding. It’s messy. It’s real. You have to learn to sit with yourself without trying to fix or perform. Just be. You might find that your capacity for empathy deepens. Having lost a community, you appreciate the fragile, fleeting moments of connection even more. You listen harder. You care deeper. You stop judging people for their beliefs and start listening to their hearts. Because you know what it costs to hold on, and you know what it costs to let go. Eventually, you build a new altar. Not made of stone or wood, but of choices. You choose to wake up when you’re rested, not when the bell rings. You choose to eat what nourishes you, not what is permitted. You choose to love who loves you back, not who fits the mold. Each choice is a brick. Each morning is a mortar. It takes time. Years, sometimes. But slowly, the structure rises. It might look different than the cathedral you left. It might be smaller, simpler. But it’s sturdy. It’s built on the bedrock of your own integrity, not the shifting sand of dogma. And when storms come—and they will—you won’t fear the collapse. Because you know you built it yourself. You know you can rebuild it again if needed. This isn’t about rejecting the past. It’s about integrating it. The lessons learned, the kindness received, the songs sung. Keep what serves you. Release what harms you. It’s a curation process. You are the editor of your own life now. No more ghostwriters. No more editors telling you what’s appropriate. Just you, writing the story as it unfolds. And isn’t that liberating? To write your own ending? To define your own virtue? To stand in your own power, unapologetically, imperfectly, beautifully? If you are in the thick of this right now, if you’re sitting in that silence, feeling the vertigo, I want to send you a virtual hug. A tight, warm, wordless hug. You are doing hard work. You are brave. And you are not alone. Take it one day at a time. One breath at a time. Don’t rush the healing. Let yourself grieve. Let yourself be angry. Let yourself be confused. All of it is valid. All of it is part of the journey. You are not losing your faith; you are finding your voice. And that voice, once it grows strong, will sing songs no one else has ever heard. Songs of survival. Songs of joy. Songs of truth. Keep going. Keep questioning. Keep loving. The world needs your unique light, even if it flickers differently now. Especially because it flickers differently. It’s authentic. And authenticity is the rarest gift of all. Thank you for letting me into your space today. Until next time, keep your ears open and your heart wide. I’ll be thinking of you. Bye for now.