Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Self-Defense Rights in Your Home
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, joined as always by Barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers, with Legally Speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Good afternoon, michael Mulligan.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: How are you?
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: I'm doing great, always good to be here.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: Some interesting things on the agenda today.
- 0:16Adam Stirling: I'm reading here criminals suing for injuries and homeowners being charged for assaulting intruders.
- 0:22Adam Stirling: I know this was an item that was in the discourse recently and myself and callers were discussing it, but you, of course, being Criminal Defense Council, know exactly what is and is not allowed in these situations and it's come up a couple of times recently.
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: It has, and it's come up in a couple of different contexts.
- 0:38Michael Mulligan: Right, many listeners will be familiar with the controversial recent case out of Ontario where there's a homeowner who has been charged with assaulting a burglar who broke into his home with a crossbow and there was a physical altercation between the homeowner and the crossbow wielding intruder and both the intruder has been charged with the break and enter, but they've charged the homeowner with assaulting the intruder, and so that has produced some real controversy in terms of whether that should be so.
- 1:12Michael Mulligan: There's also been some recent involving a civil claim by a person who is attempting to steal a car, and I'll come to that in a moment because the two things have different sort of elements to them.
- 1:25Michael Mulligan: The Ontario case, of course, is concerned with the criminal code provisions dealing with self-defense.
- 1:32Michael Mulligan: The other case we'll come to in a few minutes involving a grocery store being charged with assaulting a thief, deals with civil liability, which is a provincial responsibility.
- 1:46Michael Mulligan: So what's happened federally is that back in 2012, there were amendments made to the self-defense provisions in the criminal code Prior to 2012,.
- 1:59Michael Mulligan: In fairness, there were multiple provisions and they were relatively complicated.
- 2:03Michael Mulligan: They could become challenging, for example, for a judge trying to explain them to a jury or how they're to be applied, because there were different provisions.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: But at that time, when you were dealing with sort of the upper end of seriousness in terms of the amount of self-defense required where a person believed they needed to defend themselves or someone else against death or serious bodily harm, that would likely be the crossbow-wielding intruder in your bedroom, right?
- 2:32Michael Mulligan: Hard to imagine what's much more serious than that, and it'd be easy to imagine how a person could legitimately have a concern that they're going to die or be seriously injured when you've got a burglar in your bedroom with a crossbow Prior to 2012,.
- 2:51Michael Mulligan: If that was so, there no longer needed to be any assessment as to sort of the degree of force you were using to save your life or save your family's life.
- 2:55Michael Mulligan: Right, you didn't need to worry about.
- 2:57Michael Mulligan: You know, should I use the kitchen knife here, or should I just hit him softly, or might I be able to get him in the leg?
- 3:02Michael Mulligan: The idea was well, once you're protecting your life or protect yourself from serious bodily harm, there was no more assessment of sort of reasonableness or weighing up with nicety the force used.
- 3:14Michael Mulligan: But what happened in 2012?
- 3:17Michael Mulligan: In that effort to try to make simpler and combine the different versions of self-defense that existed is we now have a version in the criminal code that provides that where somebody is acting in self-defense, that is to say, using force to protect themselves or someone else, whether it's a death, threat to their life or just being assaulted or bodily harm there is a requirement of an assessment of reasonableness.
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: Now, on one level, you might say, well, surely we should all strive to be reasonable.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: Fair enough, right.
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: But when you put yourself in the position of the homeowner, with the burglar in your bedroom, and the fact that you now need to engage in a consideration of the reasonableness of the force used, with a series of factors that a judge or jury must consider, labeled A through H, with things like the nature of the force used Was it imminent?
- 4:14Michael Mulligan: The relative size, age, gender and physical capabilities of the two parties, things of this sort, it can make it, even though, at the end of the day, you might well have a jury that says, yeah, you don't need to measure this with nicety, not guilty.
- 4:29Michael Mulligan: It is a very significant matter, of course, to be the homeowner charged and have to go through trial to sort out whether all of these factors led up to reasonableness, and so that's why there's some current political discussion about whether we should maintain that, particularly in circumstances where you've got like an intruder in somebody's heart in a home or where you're trying to save your life, should you really be having to weigh up, ultimately to trial, the reasonableness of it.
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: And you know, could you've got the guy in the leg, or you know how old were they and how big are you and various things.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: And so that's from a criminal code perspective, I think there is, I think, real good scope for debate about whether we should have that sort of weighing up reasonableness, particularly in cases of very serious threats or maybe even for things like you're in your home.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: Where else would he supposed to do, imagine waking up in your bedroom to that kind of intruder?
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: So that's the criminal side of it, but there's also a civil side of it, and there's a recent case out of Manitoba that raises that issue and the fact pattern.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: There was a person who describes himself as a career criminal and in some document he mentioned having dealt with something in the order of a million dollars and stole a property at various times, went into a small grocery store and stole a jacket that had a key fob in it, waited about half an hour and then came back using the car key fob and tried to steal a car from the parking lot using the stolen fob from the stolen jacket.
- 6:00Michael Mulligan: And the allegation is a bunch of the employees of the grocery store ran out, dragged them out of the car and beat them up, basically, or the police showed up.
- 6:09Michael Mulligan: None of the grocery store employees were charged with anything.
- 6:12Michael Mulligan: The thief obviously was.
- 6:14Michael Mulligan: But the thief is now suing the grocery store and all the employees, alleging that they used too much force in what they did to him when they dragged him out of the car that he was attempting to steal, and he's alleging that that's caused damage to his psychological state and had a negative impact on his self-esteem and how it's interfering with his ability to continue to earn a living.
- 6:43Michael Mulligan: Presumably he doesn't mean by continuing to steal things, but maybe that's what he was referring to, and so there's been some consternation about should that be permissible right Now I should say the law does permit people to use reasonable force to prevent an offense or to detain somebody for the police to show up.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: You're not permitted to beat somebody up to teach them a lesson, right, that's not allowed.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: Now, I should say one of the protections we have both in British Columbia and in Manitoba not all provinces have it, but we have it here and it exists there and it's important is we have a right to a civil jury.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: So if you're the grocery store employees, one of the things you could do there if the same thing happened in British Columbia you could elect to have a civil jury with regular members of the public who would then come in.
- 7:30Michael Mulligan: In BC's case, it's an eight-person jury.
- 7:33Michael Mulligan: In Manitoba it's a six-person jury who would try the case, and you might well imagine that the public values that that might bring to bear might influence whether the jury would be persuaded to grant financial compensation to the career criminal thief who was dragged out of the car by the grocery store employees.
- 7:56Michael Mulligan: Right, but that's not an isolated thing and other provinces have dealt with it in a bit of a different way, like in Alberta just a few years ago I think it was 2018, there was a rancher who came out and discovered that there was somebody rummaging through his vehicles to steal things, and the rancher had a shotgun and he fired a shot into the ground, I guess as a warning, but unfortunately one of the pellets deflected off the ground and hit the thief in the arm, and it resulted in the thief suing the rancher.
- 8:27Michael Mulligan: The Alberta response to that was to amend the legislation there.
- 8:33Michael Mulligan: It was called the Trespass Statute Protecting Law Abiding Property Owners Amendment Act in 2019.
- 8:39Michael Mulligan: Statute Protecting Law Abiding Property Owners Amendment Act in 2019.
- 8:51Michael Mulligan: And so, as a result of that, now in Alberta there is no cause of action if you're a quote criminal trespasser, unless the property owner used force that was grossly disproportionate in the circumstances.
- 9:05Michael Mulligan: So that's much more than reasonable, and that person must also have been convicted of a serious criminal offense prosecuted by indictment.
- 9:18Michael Mulligan: And so the effect of that is that you're not going to release the case of trespassing.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: When somebody is doing something to repel the criminal trespasser or scare them off, they're not going to be able, at the end of the day, to sue you, and so something like that would be the responsibility of each province, right?
- 9:33Michael Mulligan: And so that's something that perhaps should be considered in the context of that Alberta case and that current Manitoba case, whether that sort of a provision would be an appropriate one.
- 9:45Michael Mulligan: So there are two aspects to it the criminal code self-defense provisions and whether we ought to continue to have that requirement for reasonableness, weighing up of the force being used, with this long series of factors that must be considered in circumstances where somebody's in fear of their life, where you've got a you know, armed burglar in your home, or whether the law should be in those circumstances, maybe something equivalent to that civil law in Alberta.
- 10:14Michael Mulligan: You know, maybe you could use some language about grossly disproportionate force, or maybe we should return to what we have prior to 2012,.
- 10:21Michael Mulligan: Right, when you're fighting for your life or to save your children, you don't need to worry about weighing up the how old is this person and what is their gender, and how tall am I and how tall the person comes in with a gun or crossbow into your bedroom.
- 10:37Michael Mulligan: Maybe we shouldn't require that, even if, at the end of the day, a jury might not convict you.
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: Perhaps we shouldn't have a circumstance where you need to be concerned with that.
- 10:44Michael Mulligan: That might also, of course, have a deterrent effect.
- 10:47Michael Mulligan: You know, I suspect that in some places, you might have more careful thought about whether you want to be breaking into somebody's house if there isn't quite the sort of weighing up of the force that might be used to defend you, although I suppose, at the end of the day, as with many of these things, I doubt that there are a lot of homeowners, or indeed burglars, that are carefully weighing up the list of things in Section 34 of the Criminal Code when they're deciding what to do when faced with the intruder in their bedroom, and so perhaps we should just give some forethought to whether we want to have a circumstance where that weighing should occur after the fact, because I doubt a lot of people are doing that when faced with that sort of a frightening circumstance in their home.
- 11:33Michael Mulligan: So that's what's going on with self-defense, both civil and criminal, across the country right now.
- 11:40Adam Stirling: All right, we'll take our first break.
- 11:41Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers will continue right after this.
- 11:45Adam Stirling: We are back on the air here at CFAX 1070 with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 11:50Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking on CFAX.
- 11:52Adam Stirling: Michael, where were we?
- 11:54Adam Stirling: We covered the incident of injuries and whatnot with intruders.
- 11:57Adam Stirling: I see a couple of other stories here.
- 11:59Adam Stirling: We've got nine minutes left.
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: Sure.
- 12:02Michael Mulligan: The next story on the agenda is a case involving Uber and a human rights complaint in British Columbia, and the background of that is this when Uber was licensed to operate in British Columbia, one of the things that was contemplated by the provincial government was whether there should be some sort of a requirement that they provide wheelchair accessible vehicles.
- 12:30Michael Mulligan: Now that is required in another context.
- 12:34Michael Mulligan: It's required for taxi companies at least some taxi companies, right?
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: There's a requirement that there be a certain percentage of taxis that are accessible using a wheelchair.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: You'll see a taxi, a van, with a ramp that comes down to the back, for example, right Now for ride-hailing companies, including Uber, it was contemplated whether to require that.
- 12:57Michael Mulligan: Now it's a bit more complicated in the ride-hailing world because, of course, uber doesn't own any vehicles at all and anyone can sign up or not sign up to operate an Uber.
- 13:08Michael Mulligan: So it'd be a bit more challenging to try to ensure what particular kind of cars or what percentage of them are out there, given that any of the people who are Uber drivers can choose to turn on and off their app anytime they feel like it.
- 13:22Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 13:22Michael Mulligan: And what do you do if you're Uber, I guess, and all of the people with the vans just say, yeah, not interested in doing that right now.
- 13:29Michael Mulligan: Right, how do you make sure you've got some percentage of wheelchair accessible vehicles out there In any case?
- 13:35Michael Mulligan: The province considered that and, in the regulations, instead of requiring them to have a percentage of vehicles that were wheelchair accessible, instead the provincial government decided to require Uber to pay a fee to the provincial government of 90 cents for every passenger trip in which there is not a wheelchair accessible vehicle used.
- 13:58Michael Mulligan: So every time you get in an Uber unless a kid or so you're paying it right.
- 14:02Michael Mulligan: You're paying 90 cents to the government for that fee right Now.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: At right, you're paying 90 cents to the government for that fee right Now.
- 14:10Michael Mulligan: In that context, there's a fellow over in Vancouver who uses a wheelchair and he brought a human rights complaint, and his human rights complaint was either no way to call a wheelchair accessible vehicle using the Uber app and I don't know whether that's still the case, but at least that was the case at the time and so he brought a challenge and the Human Rights Tribunal had to sort out well, what's the meaning of this 90 cent charge?
- 14:32Michael Mulligan: And Uber's argument was well, hold on.
- 14:35Michael Mulligan: We had a whole bunch of hearings about this and the provincial government decided to impose this 90 cent trip fee that we pay for every single trip for a vehicle that's not wheelchair accessible, that that was an alternative to requiring us to somehow ensure that there were enough wheelchair accessible vehicles being used by Uber drivers at any given time.
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: What's going on?
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: Why should we?
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: We can't be also subject to a human rights complaint?
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: What's happening here?
- 15:02Michael Mulligan: Well, the Human Rights Tribunal disagreed and they said no, no, no, the 90 cents wasn't somehow an alternative, it was an effort to try to get them to use wheelchair accessible vehicles.
- 15:13Michael Mulligan: And so they awarded this fellow $35,000 and ordered them to stop doing this.
- 15:20Michael Mulligan: Well, that just wound up by way of a judicial review of that decision, and the BC Supreme Court judge that reviewed it reversed what the Human Rights Tribunal found and the judge reviewing it found there just was no evidentiary basis for the conclusion that that 90 cent fee was somehow intended to encourage Uber to use all vehicles that were wheelchair accessible.
- 15:48Michael Mulligan: It just is.
- 15:49Michael Mulligan: There's just no basis for that conclusion.
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: Found that it was just not a reasonable interpretation of what happened.
- 15:55Michael Mulligan: But, on the flip side, the judge said look, I don't.
- 15:58Michael Mulligan: The judge didn't go so far as to conclude that this was intended, clearly, to be an alternative choice.
- 16:05Michael Mulligan: Both things still applied, but the interpretation given to it by the Human Rights Tribunal was not an appropriate one or correct, and so they've got to go back and assess it again in light of that conclusion.
- 16:22Michael Mulligan: And the judge looked at things like the Hansard and the hansard and the debates about it and the hearings about it and all of this now.
- 16:29Michael Mulligan: So there'll be a new, there'll be a new hearing with the human rights tribunal, but I guess here's really the the rub of it all.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: Right, if you're the person who's uh, uses a wheelchair, um, paying 90 cents to the government doesn't do anything for you, right?
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: Yeah, um, I mean the.
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: The judge's conclusion was this $0.90 fee was to somehow allow for more other accessible options and to defray the government's cost of regulating ride-hailing companies.
- 16:58Michael Mulligan: But what good does that, do you if you're in a wheelchair, trying to get a vehicle?
- 17:02Michael Mulligan: And so the money just appears to be going into government revenue and not really achieving that goal at all.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: And so perhaps we'll see what happens on the redo of the Human Rights Tribunal hearing.
- 17:17Michael Mulligan: But you could imagine creative things that could be done with that money.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: Maybe the government can use that as an incentive to encourage people or subsidize wheelchair accessible cars for Uber drivers.
- 17:29Michael Mulligan: You can imagine doing things with that, even if it's not as simple as just saying I order you to have 10% of the cars wheelchair accessible, because that's very challenging.
- 17:38Michael Mulligan: You could imagine other things you could reasonably do with that money.
- 17:42Michael Mulligan: If you were the government.
- 17:43Michael Mulligan: That might help alleviate the underlying issue here, rather than just putting it in your pocket and allowing these things to sail on.
- 17:51Michael Mulligan: The other thing that'll happen if the Human Rights Tribunal, on some different basis, comes to the same conclusion the alternative argument made by Uber, and it wasn't addressed because the judge said I don't need to, given my finding on that Interpret First issue.
- 18:07Michael Mulligan: He said well, uber's other position was well, these things are just completely inconsistent.
- 18:11Michael Mulligan: You've got a regulatory scheme that seems to expressly contemplate not having vehicles that are wheelchair accessible and having to pay a certain fee for that reason.
- 18:22Michael Mulligan: And then if the Human Rights Code makes that unlawful, well, what are you supposed to do?
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: The two things just seem to be incompatible orders or incompatible legal requirements, and so if the thing's just allowed to sail on and go back, that may be where we wind up.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: You know, another year or two from now, and you know again, people that are using wheelchairs are no better off trying to get around, and so hopefully the government will take notice of this and perhaps do something with the 90 cents multiplied by the total number of Uber rides all over the province it's going to be a substantial amount of money and come up with a way to use that to solve the underlying problem rather than simply leaving it as a human rights matter.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: To come back once again, I also must say, as I read this thing, it was kind of buried.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: It buried this thing on page 25 of the decision.
- 19:18Michael Mulligan: It's hard to understand quite how the Human Rights Tribunal would have come to the conclusion that this fellow who brought the complaint would come up to the figure of awarding him $35,000.
- 19:31Michael Mulligan: It seems like a rather out of the cold blue sky when trying to determine what your you know proper compensation or loss would have been for this state of affairs, bearing in mind, of course, there are other alternatives.
- 19:44Michael Mulligan: Like you know, all the taxi, you know the taxi companies are required to have those vehicles, and so you know, maybe some consideration should be given as to whether that, whether this, that is to say leaving this as a human rights matter, is the right solution.
- 19:58Michael Mulligan: $35,000 to one person doesn't seem to get the job done, nor does having the government just collect up a bunch of 90 cent fees without doing anything seem to get the job done, and so hopefully this gets a little bit of attention so that there can be a proper solution and people can get around.
- 20:15Michael Mulligan: And you know, the money just doesn't go into general revenue.
- 20:18Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the BC Supreme Court, the Human Rights Tribunal and Uber.
- 20:24Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 20:29Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 20:30Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 20:31Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 20:32Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 20:33Adam Stirling: All right, quick break News is next.