Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / AI and Intellectual Property in Film and Television: Ownership, Rights, and Risk Management Across Greece, the UK, and the US
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to AI and Intellectual Property in Film
- 0:05and Television. Ownership, rights, and risk management
- 0:09across Greece, the UK, and the US. I'm David
- 0:12Shraga, a member of the executive leadership
- 0:14team of the Beverly Hills Bar Associations Entertainment
- 0:17Law Section, and I have the privilege of introducing
- 0:19this fantastic program today. Before getting
- 0:21into today's excellent seminar, we'd like to
- 0:23acknowledge the continuing support of our friends
- 0:25at Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company, who is a
- 0:29valued sponsor of the entertainment law section,
- 0:31helps enable so much of what we bring to our
- 0:32membership and the community. For five decades,
- 0:36Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company has been the
- 0:38only California -based company to continuously
- 0:40provide lawyers throughout the state with professional
- 0:42liability insurance coverage. Their experience
- 0:45and expertise are complemented by the fact that
- 0:47LMIC is directed by a group of dedicated lawyers.
- 0:51They offer special rates with competitive premiums
- 0:53for a wide range of areas of practice, including
- 0:55entertainment law. We know these individuals,
- 0:58and you will find that their team has unique
- 1:00expertise in the entertainment industry and a
- 1:02particular familiarity with the complex issues
- 1:04that entertainment lawyers navigate in their
- 1:06practices. So learn more about them at lawyersmutual
- 1:09.com. We have a great program for you today with
- 1:12a panel of three speakers that hail from around
- 1:15the globe and offer a truly international and
- 1:17expert perspective on today's topic. Thanos Leontaris
- 1:22is the managing partner at Ratio Legal Services
- 1:24in Thessaloniki, Greece. He specializes in IP
- 1:28and entertainment law with extensive experience
- 1:31drafting financing and distribution agreements.
- 1:33cash rebate and production contracts, and advising
- 1:36producers and distributors on commercial and
- 1:38regulatory matters. His practice also spans blockchain
- 1:41and commercial technology, and he is duly licensed
- 1:43in Greece and Cyprus. Sarah Kundl is a senior
- 1:47associate at Lee & Thompson LLP in London. Since
- 1:50joining the firm in 2017, she has advised producers
- 1:53and financiers on all aspects of the development,
- 1:56production, financing, and exploitation of scripted
- 1:59and unscripted content with a particular focus
- 2:01on film and television financing. Michael Peters
- 2:05is an attorney at Ramo Law here in Los Angeles,
- 2:07whose practice focuses on the intersection of
- 2:09media, entertainment, and emerging technologies.
- 2:12He specializes in music rights management, media
- 2:15financing, and dispute resolution, advising artists,
- 2:19content creators, and entrepreneurs on building
- 2:21and protecting their media presence. And now
- 2:24let's get started. Thank you, David. Thank you
- 2:27all for joining us. This panel will be more of
- 2:31a conversational kind of sharing of ideas, perspectives,
- 2:35compare and contrast. We welcome questions as
- 2:38they come up. So please put them in the channel
- 2:41and we will look at them as often as we can and
- 2:44respond to them in real time. If it's fluent.
- 2:48I'd like to start with hearing from Sarah and
- 2:52Thanos on the kind of state of the nation as
- 2:54far as copyright and intellectual property as
- 2:57it relates to AI. And so I'll start with Sarah.
- 3:01Great Anna, pleasure to be here. So in the UK
- 3:05it's I imagine similar to everywhere in terms
- 3:08of the general consensus is excitement and trepidation.
- 3:12It's trying to find the balance between encouraging
- 3:15technological innovation but also protecting
- 3:18those rights holders and copyrighted works. This
- 3:22webinar has actually come at quite a good time
- 3:24because the UK government issued some guidance
- 3:27in the last couple of weeks about how the ownership
- 3:32of copyrighted works and also how AI training
- 3:37data can use copyrighted works. Last year, the
- 3:43UK government was floating the idea of having
- 3:46an opt -out mechanism, so that automatically
- 3:50copyright holders would need to opt out from
- 3:54having their copyrighted works used to train
- 3:57AI. this decision at that step back from this,
- 4:00which is what the guidance this month has done,
- 4:03has been welcomed by the creative industries.
- 4:06Meaning that any AI platform that wishes to use
- 4:10Copyrighted Works for its training data will
- 4:12need to specifically license it in the usual
- 4:14way. So that has generally been positive, positive
- 4:18thing for creative industries. The sort of other
- 4:21main topical thing in the UK at the moment is
- 4:25the ongoing negotiations between PACT, which
- 4:27is our producers guild, and Equity, our on -screen
- 4:31performers guild. Negotiations are ongoing in
- 4:35respect of AI. They have different views in that
- 4:39PACT believes that rigid restrictions would impede
- 4:42and hamper a producer's job and making it even
- 4:44more difficult to make content in a time where
- 4:47it's already pretty hard to find financing. And
- 4:52equity believe though that the technology has
- 4:57changed sufficient to warrant revisiting the
- 5:00pact agreement and specifically in respect to
- 5:03things like digital replicas, which whilst there
- 5:06was always some level of digital replicas in
- 5:08the last few years in terms of the sort that
- 5:11you see in the effects, et cetera, the technology
- 5:14has advanced to an extent where it's definitely
- 5:16worth revisiting and they are pushing for more
- 5:19rigid restrictions to protect their members.
- 5:23Just so for anyone that's not familiar with UK
- 5:27customs, can you distinguish PACT and equity
- 5:29really quickly? Yeah, so PACT is the Producers
- 5:34Alliance for Cinema and Television. So they are
- 5:37probably one of the most vocal groups in the
- 5:39UK from the creative industries. We do obviously
- 5:41have writer's guilds and things like WGGB, but
- 5:44generally PACT kind of leads the charge in terms
- 5:46of issues that crop up commercial ones such as
- 5:50AI. and equity is our on -screen performers.
- 5:54So it's actors, stunt performers, et cetera.
- 5:58Thank you. Thanos. Sure. Thank you. Look, I mean,
- 6:05my intention is here to also bring the European
- 6:08perspective to this conversation. So I will just
- 6:12get started on some of the legal items here.
- 6:16Obviously, the European Union is until since
- 6:21last year, one of the first jurisdictions that
- 6:24has its own artificial intelligence act. So we
- 6:28have a uniform legal instrument that regulates
- 6:31a number of things around artificial intelligence,
- 6:34generative AI as well, and content created with
- 6:39the use of AI. Specifically, one of the things
- 6:42that interests us, obviously, is the fact that
- 6:44we will need to have specific banners. and making
- 6:49sure that content created with generative AI
- 6:51has to be properly noted as such wherever it
- 6:55is being distributed. Right now, I guess the
- 6:58state of play is that people are realizing more
- 7:02and more in the industry that generative AI is
- 7:07not only text, obviously. Now we can use AI for
- 7:11a number of things in the entertainment industry
- 7:15and creating, like you said, digital replicas,
- 7:17Sarah, and creating twins and creating any number
- 7:21of things in the entertainment space. What we're
- 7:25seeing the past year is that there is a big push
- 7:28by the equivalent of European unions, such as
- 7:35the equivalent of SAG, which is the Euro FIA,
- 7:40to have more regulation within the AI Act in
- 7:45regard to copyright and some of the creations
- 7:49that AI will. create so on and so forth. However,
- 7:53Europe had since 2021, which is interesting,
- 7:57a copyright directive, which was very specific
- 8:00in regard to an opt out that was machine readable.
- 8:03So essentially, if you have any content online,
- 8:07even let's say in my law firms website, where
- 8:09we post articles, we can put an opt out on our
- 8:13terms and conditions that would disallow machine
- 8:18learning and AI to read our content and learn
- 8:22from it. So this has existed since 2021. In light
- 8:28of this, yeah, it's very interesting. Of course,
- 8:31this is not very pertinent, I would say to...
- 8:35of the entertainment sector in the sense that
- 8:37we are creating moving pictures. But it can be
- 8:42relevant when we're talking about scripts, obviously.
- 8:45So in that regard, depositories that might be
- 8:49machine readable, meaning that that's the term
- 8:53that is being used in the regulation, actually,
- 8:56in the directive, I'm sorry. Depositories that
- 8:59you post your ideas on, your potential scripts
- 9:03or whatever those may be, Unless you have an
- 9:06opt -out, it creates this issue. An AEI generative
- 9:11tool can use it to learn from it and create a
- 9:15new IP from it without you getting anything at
- 9:18all. Another component to the unions such as
- 9:24UFIA, which is the equivalent of SAG for Europe,
- 9:27is the European film agencies and the European
- 9:30Film Academy, which are also taking steps to
- 9:33push the European Union towards a uniform way
- 9:37that we will treat copyright in the AI era. And
- 9:42of course, making sure that creators' rights
- 9:47and the rights of the performers, obviously,
- 9:50they're being protected. Remember, of course,
- 9:54that we have a very peculiar situation in Europe
- 9:57in the sense that we are not allowed to waive
- 10:00all rights in a similar manner that in the UK
- 10:03and the US, you're able to waive most rights,
- 10:05I guess, based on my understanding in copyright
- 10:08law. That doesn't exist technically in Europe.
- 10:12We have the droit moral, which is really important
- 10:16for European creators. And essentially, you're
- 10:21licensing everything. Nothing is actually being
- 10:24transferred, legally speaking. So for us, that
- 10:27also shapes how we're going to treat AI creations
- 10:31and how we're going to treat the uses of AI in
- 10:37performances. The one thing that I've seen, which
- 10:40is interesting to me, just in terms of monetization,
- 10:44And I think this probably has come up for you
- 10:47guys as well, is the fact that a lot of libraries
- 10:51are now being given from producers to AI training
- 10:56tools, and they're creating a new revenue stream
- 10:58for them. And that's really interesting for me.
- 11:01Because in Europe, because we have this issue
- 11:04with licensing, essentially you have to license
- 11:08everything. There's no, technically you can't
- 11:11do a catch -all. So you have to be proper in
- 11:14terms of how you license everything. So unless
- 11:16we have properly licensed the material for training
- 11:19of AI, I'm in the gray. I mean, I'm not feeling
- 11:22comfortable providing the advice that you're
- 11:24OK to give it out for training. And we can then
- 11:28use it to monetize. So this will create an interesting
- 11:31issue. And it has already created this issue,
- 11:33I guess, in terms of whether we're able to actually
- 11:36give this material for training or not. because
- 11:40the industry being what it is right now, you
- 11:43want to create new revenue streams for your clients
- 11:46and you want to be able to help them monetize
- 11:48some very old libraries that they have. It's
- 11:52not like they're doing anything with it anyway.
- 11:55I think that's also really interesting. I'm sure
- 12:01that's something that has come up for you guys
- 12:02as well is making sure that you're able to fix
- 12:05performances. making sure that you're able to
- 12:09use AI when necessary to create some intimacy
- 12:14scenes as well, which has also been an issue
- 12:16in Greece specifically. I guess that's the state
- 12:21of play where we are right now. It's interesting
- 12:26that both the territories have played with the
- 12:30opt -out thing, but neither of you have mentioned
- 12:32fair use or something similar to that. the law
- 12:36in the US, a lot of it seems to be centered around
- 12:41training and whether what types of training are
- 12:44fair use or not. And you know, we have we've
- 12:48had some I mean, case law can kind of be seen
- 12:51as anecdotal in some ways, because it's like
- 12:53until there's a wealth of case law that covers
- 12:56a very variety of different situations, you kind
- 12:59of have like in this specific situation, this
- 13:02was the law. And then that can be analogized
- 13:04to other things. So we have things like in one
- 13:07instance, it was found that copies of bought
- 13:11copies of books were fair use for training. But
- 13:16pirated copies of books were not fair use of
- 13:17training. Things like that. And so we're kind
- 13:20of patching together this kind of philosophical
- 13:22approach of what is and is not. But even in certain
- 13:26instances, the judge just really called out defense
- 13:29counsel for not raising an argument that that
- 13:32judge feel may have prevailed. But the argument
- 13:35wasn't raised. So the judge's hands were tied.
- 13:38Is that true? Did that actually happen? i'm trying
- 13:41to avoid specifics because i don't i there are
- 13:44other panels that can speak better to this and
- 13:46with more specificity so i'm kind of keeping
- 13:47it general but that was my understanding of of
- 13:50where it left off and of course with any judge's
- 13:53decision there's going to be a lot more nuance
- 13:54and detail to it but that's kind of where where
- 13:58we're sitting of um you know it's it's looked
- 14:03at how it's copied there's you know categories
- 14:06of fair use and i kind of wanted was curious
- 14:07is there any similarity of or similar concept
- 14:10in UK or Europe as far as fair use of copyright
- 14:14and has that been part of the conversation as
- 14:17far as training LLMs? It hasn't really been part
- 14:23of the conversation. A couple of potential solutions
- 14:26in absence of this opt -out provision are just
- 14:29looking at licensing requirements and credit
- 14:31requirements as well, like can content be used
- 14:34as long as it's sufficiently credited? But the
- 14:37one thing the UK is desperately in need of is
- 14:41A, the pace law, because there really hasn't
- 14:43been any so far. I mean, we can say how we can
- 14:46interpret statute, the relevant one being in
- 14:50the UK, the Copyright Designs and Painting Act
- 14:53from 1988, which until Thanos was talking about
- 14:56how there are AI statutes, I thought was actually
- 15:01pretty ahead of its time in that it anticipated
- 15:03computer generated works. I'm sorry, excuse.
- 15:09We do actually have a provision in the Copyright
- 15:13Designs and Patents Act, which anticipates computer
- 15:18-generated works. It needs to have human involvement.
- 15:21But as far as the human needs to make the arrangements
- 15:25necessary for the creation of that work that
- 15:28computer generates, but that can be anything.
- 15:31I mean, AI wasn't a thing at the time in 1988,
- 15:34which is when the statute dates back to and it's
- 15:36now you look at it with a new lens and it's whether
- 15:39or not that means the human putting the prompts
- 15:42into AI software. Is it the person who designed
- 15:45the AI software? It's just so up in the air.
- 15:53Yeah The other I mean the other big thing was
- 15:56kind of the more immediate response in our laws
- 16:00and and customs I guess was the guild strikes
- 16:03large a lot of them were a long time coming AI
- 16:06was not the only aspect of them, but it kind
- 16:10of Accelerated the conversations a bit more than
- 16:14a bit especially on the sag and WGA side Sag
- 16:17being screen actors guild and WGA being writers
- 16:20guild um and you know largely focused on safety
- 16:25of labor uh like securing of jobs um and that's
- 16:30largely how those strikes got resolved there
- 16:33was a bit of um like nothing was resolved with
- 16:36any specificity or not a lot of specificity at
- 16:39least but they kind of found themselves in a
- 16:44in the lane of you know you can't there's a few
- 16:46rules we established that you can't replace writer
- 16:49jobs So if one writer works on a WGA project
- 16:53and the rest is written by generative AI, that
- 16:56writer, that one writer that worked on it is
- 16:58basically deemed the writer of the whole thing,
- 17:01things like that. And then SAG did a lot of work
- 17:04with the California legislature to do a, and
- 17:08that's actually now a law that relates to digital
- 17:12replicas. And now we have You know, I can get
- 17:15in a little bit later. We have a law in California
- 17:18that has a number of requirements that if they're
- 17:21not met, then the contract is unenforceable,
- 17:24at least with regard to use of digital replicas
- 17:26and generative AI. And then SAG, that was kind
- 17:29of mirrored the SAG contract as it relates to
- 17:34that. The SAG one being a little bit more inclusive
- 17:37and the state law being a little more one of
- 17:41the One of them has to be met versus all of them
- 17:43in the SAG deal. It's interesting you mentioned
- 17:48the strikes, actually, because that is something
- 17:50that could potentially happen in the UK with
- 17:52equity. In December, I believe it was, I think
- 17:5899 % of equity members indicated that they'd
- 18:02be open to some form of industrial action, which
- 18:05is quite a big percentage. So it's clearly at
- 18:07the forefront of a lot of members' minds. there
- 18:11was an open letter as well with about 1500 signatures
- 18:14of really prominent British talent, all championing
- 18:19more rigid requirements. Whether or not that
- 18:25is going to result in full industrial action
- 18:28and actors refusing to turn up to set or whether
- 18:31it's going to be something more small scale,
- 18:36i .e. refusing just to do body scans if required.
- 18:40that remains to be seen, but that is unfortunate
- 18:42at the moment. It does feel like that could be
- 18:44a possibility if equity and PACT can't meet somewhere
- 18:48in the middle. I think that just, sorry, just
- 18:52going back a little bit to the fair use point
- 18:55that you were making before. We do have a very
- 18:58small carve out for fair use, but it's not for
- 19:02AI. It's only for educational purposes and non
- 19:04-commercial purposes. So for us, fair use is
- 19:07not really something that you can used to license
- 19:11stuff for AI. I think that in regard to what
- 19:14you're saying now, Sarah, I think that wasn't
- 19:16Elton John one of the people who was part of
- 19:19that? I mean, I remember listening to his interview
- 19:22on that. I mean, it was, I think that at least
- 19:26on our end in Europe, I think that the one way
- 19:29that people will be pushed to make changes, I
- 19:34don't know if they're going to be good, bad,
- 19:36or whatever those may be, but I think that the
- 19:38the agencies who are financing the film production
- 19:43industry in Europe will take a bigger part in
- 19:47formulating some of this policy. Because like
- 19:50BFI in the UK, and for us, I come in the Greek
- 19:54rebate agency or the Center for Cinema in France
- 19:57and the equivalent in Germany, they hold a lot
- 20:00of sway in terms of how policy is determined
- 20:04and how the legislation evolves. And I think
- 20:07that if you, for example, take out of the eligible
- 20:12spend stuff that has to do with AI, I think that
- 20:15everybody will get the message that some stuff
- 20:18you can't do with AI or with the AI tools. So
- 20:20if we're not going to finance you for it, you
- 20:23should probably be doing it, even if the law
- 20:25delays to do something like this. Especially,
- 20:29I think, that if the French unions of actors,
- 20:33producers, and If they are taking some initiative,
- 20:37I think that in a similar manner that the Germans
- 20:40had actually last year, produced a report on
- 20:43it, the equivalent German Union of Actors, I
- 20:48think that Europe will be pushed to create some
- 20:51legislation. Because for us in Europe, film agencies,
- 20:55because we're very much reliant on rebates, be
- 20:59it tax credit or cash rebates, they hold a lot
- 21:02of sway in terms of how the industry will progress
- 21:07in that regard. And with the Greek rebate, Panos,
- 21:12are AI costs, would they typically be qualifying
- 21:15expenditure? See, that's a good question. It's
- 21:18not, it doesn't say it's not. So if you were
- 21:22doing it in post, I would say, I think that I
- 21:25would call it a post reduction expense. So in
- 21:27my opinion, it should be, yes. Unless, you know,
- 21:30otherwise, you know, noted as such. Yeah. Yeah,
- 21:33it's similar in the UK. I mean, most of the instances
- 21:36would be imposed anyway, and there's not been
- 21:39any guidance issued as to that being excluded.
- 21:41It would qualify for our tax credit. Yeah. Yeah,
- 21:46I mean, yeah, I guess that's why we're different
- 21:48with the US so much, right? I mean, the US, I
- 21:51don't think that you care so much about rebates
- 21:54internally in the US, right? I mean, except,
- 21:56I don't know. Oh, we do. The innovative film
- 21:59market. Okay, really what where someone's shooting
- 22:01is heavily reliant or dependent on on the tax
- 22:04credit a lot of the times But I don't think I
- 22:07kind of agree. I think it would kind of pan out
- 22:09the same way unless someone actually decided
- 22:10to take a stance And it would be like a state
- 22:13-level tax credit We would kind of have a federal
- 22:16tax credit that kind of comes in and out called
- 22:18the one in one section there's like it's it's
- 22:21more of a tax break than a tax credit, but I
- 22:25think that's going to be something that people
- 22:27will just have to like decide to make a deal
- 22:29out of because it largely is a post cost. Although
- 22:33I have seen we can talk a little more about implementation
- 22:36and creative or cultural responses and applications
- 22:38later. But there's been some interesting case
- 22:41studies of like real time visualizations on set.
- 22:45So you so instead of a green screen, you can
- 22:47kind of see like what is actually going to look
- 22:49like while you're filming, which is I think is
- 22:52very exciting. um but we're uh we're close to
- 22:56the halfway mark already so let's keep this this
- 22:58going through our topics um we've talked we've
- 23:01touched on authorship a bit also side note we
- 23:03could do a whole other panel just comparing creative
- 23:07like uh community cultural exchange concepts
- 23:10with or without fair use as a commercial as a
- 23:13with a like commercial possibly commercial applicability
- 23:17of fair use because commercial application is
- 23:20kind of one of our our standards but it's interesting
- 23:22that neither has it, really, because it's a very
- 23:26fundamental concept for us in a lot of ways.
- 23:30Like most independent films have a fair use opinion
- 23:33on materials used, especially documentaries.
- 23:37But let's talk quickly on authorship. How are
- 23:41you guys defining authorship versus when JNA
- 23:45is involved? I think I probably already covered
- 23:49the UK stance on this. So maybe Sanos, if you
- 23:52want to talk about Europe. In summary, it's a
- 23:56human author. But in terms of computer generated,
- 23:59it's who that human author is. It's really unclear
- 24:02until there's some case law. Yeah. I would say
- 24:07the same in Europe. But let me ask this because
- 24:11we're all attorneys here. And I just want to
- 24:13have this discussion with someone. So look, let's
- 24:16say that you use ChatGBT. professionally, like
- 24:20you have an actual subscription and a proper
- 24:22data processing agreement that we have to have
- 24:24in Europe and terms and conditions and so on
- 24:27and so forth. You pay for it properly and all
- 24:28is well. I'm wondering, since you have a service
- 24:34agreement with that tool, isn't it defined in
- 24:38the terms and conditions, what's the IP? Kind
- 24:42of. This is exactly what I wanted to talk about.
- 24:45You know what I mean? We have a service agreement
- 24:48with them. Particularly, Suno, I've read their
- 24:51terms of service multiple times now and from
- 24:54multiple different angles of problems to solve.
- 24:58Why are you reading terms and conditions? You're
- 25:01a lawyer. You're not supposed to be doing that.
- 25:04Because either a client makes something and says,
- 25:06what rights do I have here? Or a client is receiving
- 25:09rights from someone that used Suno. And then
- 25:12I kind of have to look at, OK, it's kind of a
- 25:15contract, right? So there's a contractual right
- 25:17of Is is one party going to be a problem for
- 25:21the other for exploiting this and then there's
- 25:23the concept of authorship which is a much more
- 25:27Intangible but much more meaningful concept and
- 25:30copyright is like you are the author as I understand
- 25:33like in a lot of European territories that the
- 25:37authorship and joint morale like our heavily,
- 25:41heavily entwined, we have some kind of thing
- 25:44like that, where we have a termination right
- 25:46for an author, if they if they will assign their
- 25:49their copyright, they can they can take it back
- 25:51years later. It was kind of our response to the
- 25:54renewables being alienable. And so this is not.
- 25:58But the problem in my mind is kind of shifted
- 26:01to, is it protectable? not as it is do you have
- 26:06the rights to use it because if it was just prompt
- 26:09to output right now copyright law says no one
- 26:12owns that that is just it is immediately public
- 26:15domain because there is no human author until
- 26:19our law changes i think that's how it sits yeah
- 26:22so with prompts in the uk they are technically
- 26:25copyrightable um it would be it would qualify
- 26:28as a literary work which i agree depending what
- 26:31the prompt is i agree um but the thing in order
- 26:34to, again I don't think this has ever been through
- 26:36the course, but technically that's what the statute
- 26:38is, I would say that you'd have more likelihood
- 26:42of it if you wanted to test it, of it qualifying
- 26:45as a copyrighted, a copyrightable work, a literary
- 26:48work would be to, in the prompt, would be talk
- 26:52about creative character development and set
- 26:56out something that's really I hate to repeat
- 27:00myself again, but creative, yeah. Character stories,
- 27:04a setting, like a world in which this, if you
- 27:07wanted to get AI to write a forest -based fantasy
- 27:15or something, if you go to great detail and set
- 27:18out those sort of prompts that you want it to
- 27:20take into account, then it's more likely to be
- 27:23a copyrightable work because it in itself is
- 27:26a literary piece. So my understanding, and how
- 27:30I've kind of approaching the problem is that,
- 27:33you know, the copyright office will look at,
- 27:36okay, tell us the human intervention, tell us
- 27:38what humans did, tell us what a robot did. And
- 27:40then they'll, they'll protect what a human did.
- 27:42So if you have like a sketch, like a kind of
- 27:44a crude sketch, then the AI then makes into like
- 27:46a polished looking album cover or something,
- 27:49they will protect the crude sketch will protect
- 27:51the elements of the crude sketch that show up
- 27:52in the final product. So to your point, Sarah,
- 27:56if in I think there's a common misconception
- 27:58that a lot of generative AI use on the professional
- 28:01level is just prompt to final product. And it's
- 28:05really a nauseating web of different generative
- 28:12AI platforms, different workflows. Laura's and
- 28:16all these other things often custom -built Laura's
- 28:19and things like that So there is actually even
- 28:22if it's just heavily every output was made completely
- 28:25by generative AI There's a lot of human direction
- 28:27in all of it and so the the guidance I'm I'm
- 28:31leaning towards is you know documenting everything
- 28:33and I have some clients that actually implement
- 28:36Software or I don't know if they've actually
- 28:38finished it yet, but they've been working on
- 28:40software that will track Everything that their
- 28:43people are doing in their workstations so that
- 28:46they actually have a record of everything a human
- 28:48did. So when it comes to protecting the output,
- 28:52they actually have as much data as possible to
- 28:54show that this was not just, you know, write
- 28:58me a forest story about some elves. It's like,
- 29:01you know, they actually the humans to dictate
- 29:03the characters, the humans dictate the pacing,
- 29:05the humans dictate the plot points. It's just
- 29:08generally, I was kind of filling out a structure.
- 29:10But I feel like our laws need to kind of catch
- 29:13up to that. I think that it's different when
- 29:17you ask Chad GPT to write you a joke about a
- 29:21Greek, a US, and a UK attorney participating
- 29:25at the BHBA. And it's different to, like Sarah
- 29:30said, to give it so much prompt that it just,
- 29:34again, like you said, like polishes something.
- 29:36And we have a default in our copyright law that
- 29:42says that by default, salaried employees, any
- 29:46creation that they make during their work, by
- 29:51default goes to the employer. So whatever, be
- 29:54it software, literally works, whatever that may
- 29:57be, so long as it's part of their work, because
- 29:59they're salaried employees and not work for hire,
- 30:02by default, all rights go to the employer. To
- 30:06that regard, what I'm trying to say is essentially
- 30:10what the legislator has recognized here is the
- 30:12fact that this employee probably is getting input
- 30:14from someone to create. So while it is a human
- 30:19being creating, it is obviously getting input
- 30:21and guidance from someone else. And that's why,
- 30:25in my opinion, the copyright law in Greece, and
- 30:27I think it's the same in France and Germany,
- 30:28because we basically have the same copyright
- 30:31laws. It's because it's being recognized that
- 30:34the employee is acting under someone's supervision
- 30:37and guidance to create. In a similar manner,
- 30:41if you're giving guidance, supervision to an
- 30:45AI tool, I don't see a reason why the authorship
- 30:49couldn't go by default to the person essentially
- 30:51licensing it. You know what I mean? I'm inclined
- 30:54to agree. And just for context, the case law
- 30:57that we're working with in the US is a monkey
- 31:00or a gorilla or some kind of primate that that
- 31:04got his hands on a camera, then press the button
- 31:08to open the shutter. And then that photo was
- 31:11taken. I think it was a kind of like a selfie
- 31:13of a monkey or something like that. And then
- 31:16there was a copyright issue of the camera, the
- 31:19person that owned the camera said, like, I set
- 31:21up the camera, like, I dialed in the settings,
- 31:25it's my camera, the monkey just took it and took
- 31:26the picture. And the court was like, No, that's
- 31:30A non -human took the picture, so there's no
- 31:33copyright granted to that picture. And that's
- 31:36what's being applied to generative AI. You and
- 31:42I both teach at the university. So one of the
- 31:46things that I was teaching at the University
- 31:48of Nicosia, and we were talking about it for
- 31:50smart contracts and blockchain, was that some
- 31:54of these technological issues were dealing with
- 31:57right now, the legal issues around them, will
- 31:59take us down to the fundamentals of law. And
- 32:03it will either require reinterpretation of what
- 32:05we're doing on existing legislation or whatever
- 32:07it is that we're doing now. We'll have to go
- 32:09to the fundamentals of the monkey, like you correctly
- 32:11point out. Or we're going to create something
- 32:15completely new to accommodate all of this. And
- 32:18I think this will be really interesting what
- 32:21approaches each jurisdiction will take. Europe
- 32:24is over -regulated, so we know what we're doing.
- 32:27We're creating new things all the time for whatever
- 32:30reason. But hopefully we'll get some case law
- 32:35soon enough to give us some more guidance on
- 32:38how to do some of these things. But sorry, let
- 32:46me go back to what you were saying before. You
- 32:49mentioned the Copyright Office in the US. Now,
- 32:52me and you, we actually had this discussion before
- 32:54and Sarah separately for another project that
- 32:56we did together. You both have copyright offices.
- 33:00I mean, in Europe, we don't really use them,
- 33:02to be completely honest with you. The registration
- 33:04of copyright, I know it's not necessary for legal
- 33:07purposes for you guys as well, but it obviously,
- 33:09it helps. As you explained to me back in November,
- 33:12it helps you for, I guess, to be able to sue
- 33:15someone. For damages, for standing. For damages,
- 33:17right. I think it was 2019 Supreme there was
- 33:25there was a split between the West Coast and
- 33:28an East Coast ninth and second, I believe Circuits
- 33:32as to whether you needed a valid registration
- 33:34to get damages for copyright infringement And
- 33:38that's now been solidified across the nation.
- 33:41You do need a valid registration and that's why
- 33:44it's really consequential what the Copyright
- 33:47Office says about these like registering a work
- 33:52that has generative AI included, or that has
- 33:56contributions from generative AI, because if
- 33:59you're gonna put a commercial project out, you
- 34:01wanna be protected. And if someone's going to
- 34:04infringe on your market space or just steal your
- 34:07work, you wanna be able to enforce that. And
- 34:10enforcement is very expensive and having a healthy
- 34:13six figure, up to six figure. um, punitive damages
- 34:16or statutory damages is a really meaningful thing
- 34:19for being able to actually enforce your copyright.
- 34:22DMCA is helpful, um, in a lot of ways. Um, but
- 34:26sometimes someone made a bunch of money off of
- 34:28your stuff and you want to like, you have people
- 34:30to answer to for that. So having, I would say
- 34:34it's very necessary for us. Um, even though in
- 34:37an abstract, it is protected. You can always
- 34:39prove it's yours with the right evidence, but
- 34:43yeah. No, but I'm just asking, this doesn't really
- 34:46sound like just registration because we do have
- 34:50a copyright office in Greece, for example, and
- 34:52in France and in Germany and so on and so forth.
- 34:56But they only act as record keepers, so to speak.
- 35:00They don't go into the substance. But what you're
- 35:02saying is that in the US it goes into the substance
- 35:05of whether this is actually copyrightable content.
- 35:08Is it the same in the UK? No. And this is kind
- 35:14of more from a chain of title perspective, but
- 35:16a CP or a conditions precedent to a lot of financing
- 35:19in the UK would be evidence that the screenplay
- 35:23of a film or TV or script from a TV show had
- 35:26been registered with the US Copyright Office.
- 35:29We care more about that. The reason why I'm asking
- 35:34is because when we're talking about it for the
- 35:36UK for one of the projects we did together for
- 35:38your CPs, you told me you were asking for the
- 35:40US and not for the UK. Which was interesting
- 35:42to me as well. Yeah, I've run into that too.
- 35:48Sorry, go. I was just going to say, I think that
- 35:51security works a little bit differently in the
- 35:53US as well. Michael, is that right? So you can,
- 35:56the copyright mortgage, for example, is registered
- 35:59separately. Whereas in, and it can be more as
- 36:02more securities assigned to the, the actual work
- 36:05run the owner. Whereas in the UK, we can only
- 36:08really take registered security over a company.
- 36:12So it's what it's the owner of that asset as
- 36:15well. So I think that's why it's. Yeah, it's
- 36:19a it's a state versus federal distinction and
- 36:22federal supersede. So that's why federal is copyright.
- 36:28So we take a copyright mortgage filed out with
- 36:31the Copyright Office and we take a UCC, which
- 36:33is state level overall, the UCC level. you know
- 36:37properties like you know chattel equipment bank
- 36:40notes and things like that accounts receivable
- 36:42etc but we we have to do both in the states because
- 36:46there's a chance there's a likelihood that um
- 36:49if challenged without the copyright mortgage
- 36:52you may have copyright law supersede the ucc
- 36:54state level lien so let's A little bit of a tangent
- 37:01into film production stuff. No, it's good. It's
- 37:04fun. I find it interesting too. I just spent
- 37:07a lot of time with this. It's a very critical
- 37:09thing because look at this. Like you mentioned,
- 37:12Copyright Office in the US says it goes into
- 37:15substance, whereas in the UK, it doesn't go to
- 37:18substance. So if you want to, if you're not sure
- 37:20about your AI stuff, you will go to the UK just
- 37:22to be on the safe side that at least you have
- 37:24something registered somewhere. Yeah, he said
- 37:26something that you kind of look at them as their
- 37:29own independent body, you know, they're not a
- 37:31court. They're not legislation. But people do
- 37:34look to them for guidance. And every time I file
- 37:37a new work that has some generative AI element
- 37:43to it. You know, sometimes, though, the explanation
- 37:47is, you know, sufficient for whoever's looking
- 37:49at it, sometimes it's not. And they'll email
- 37:51me and say, Hey, can you get more information?
- 37:53That's how Gen I was us versus human authorship.
- 37:56So they are actually looking at it a lot of copyrights.
- 38:00They won't unless they find it like a objective
- 38:02problem. And then it's just kind of that's the
- 38:05record you put into the system. And that's what's
- 38:08challenged when you sue on it. Because back to
- 38:11the point of, you know, you need a valid registration
- 38:13to sue for damages. The first thing to defend
- 38:15it does in a copyright suit is attack the registration
- 38:18to try to invalidate it. One of the first things.
- 38:21Yeah. Copyright protection in the UK is automatic.
- 38:29So we don't need to register it. And so if we
- 38:32do, the reason we care more about the US is,
- 38:35I mean, generally, because that tends to be the
- 38:37biggest distribution deal as well. It's chain
- 38:41of title distributors going to want to check
- 38:42it. For us, it was interesting. The fact that
- 38:46it was one of the things that the EU film agencies
- 38:51you know, super union, let's call it. One of
- 38:54the recommendations they were making to the European
- 38:56Parliament was to have the EU IPO, which is the
- 39:01European Intellectual Property Office, where
- 39:03we register trademarks and designs throughout
- 39:08the EU to have a role in this sort of thing for
- 39:12copyright now in AI. And it's possible that in
- 39:16the coming years, if that actually if that proposal
- 39:19actually does go through, that the UIPO, which
- 39:23already exists since the 1980s, will actually
- 39:26get a role in registering copyright to that effect
- 39:29as well. So that was interesting for us, too.
- 39:31It hasn't happened yet, but the fact that we
- 39:34could go there probably takes a cue from the
- 39:36US on that. So we touched on inputs and outputs.
- 39:42And I think the current guidance is that an input
- 39:46is not a prompt. is not necessarily is not in
- 39:50and of itself copyrightable. But we're all operating
- 39:53on, you know, fixed original expression as the
- 39:56key magical keywords for copyrightability. And
- 40:00maybe if you just put a prompt in and you don't
- 40:03actually save it anywhere, is it fixed or not?
- 40:05That's a more of a philosophical question. But
- 40:08I think if it's rises to a level of original
- 40:10expression, I think I'm kind of expecting in
- 40:14the future, some decisions to come down. that
- 40:17would grant protectability for a prompt. But
- 40:22the problem is that if any of you use image or
- 40:25video generators with AI, there's a lot of different
- 40:30things that a generative AI platform can do with
- 40:34a singular prompt, even a detailed prompt. And
- 40:38then that kind of raises the more philosophical
- 40:41copyright question of even a detail prompt, if
- 40:45it can make a variety of very different images
- 40:49or videos, would that be, you know, is that actually
- 40:54expression at that point, or are you just protecting
- 40:56the prompt? And if someone wants to use the prompt
- 40:58for whatever they want to use, but the actual
- 41:01generations are not actual human expression.
- 41:04They're just, you know, the hallucinations of
- 41:06a machine based on what, based on actual human
- 41:09expression. That's kind of what I'm struggling
- 41:13with right now, as far as the prompt versus output
- 41:17protections and stuff like that. Because I think
- 41:19it's going to be dangerous to say, OK, anything
- 41:22that this prompt creates can be protected. What
- 41:25do you think? This sounds difficult. Sarah should
- 41:28answer first. I completely agree. But again,
- 41:34we just don't have any guidance on this in the
- 41:37UK. It's gonna be yeah, I mean it's kind of a
- 41:42wait -and -see thing Yeah, it's gonna be interesting
- 41:46to see how it how it figures out How's the the
- 41:51cultural response I mean, there's a lot of doomerism
- 41:53in the United States But I feel like it's kind
- 41:56of shifting as people kind of figure out like,
- 41:59you know y2k or the internet or you know Everything
- 42:02else that's happened before everyone kind of
- 42:04like goes the worst -case scenario with a new
- 42:05technology I do think that this is scarier than
- 42:10Most technologies the humans have ever created
- 42:13It's also just more uncertain like of what it
- 42:16can do or what it will do But you know, how's
- 42:19the how's the temperature over there? It's again
- 42:24sort of excitement mix with reputation but and
- 42:27certain types of AI that we're seeing especially
- 42:29in film and TV so it's kind of more limited to
- 42:31film and TV than AI in general is It's exciting,
- 42:36like dubbing, for example, like being able to
- 42:38sort of almost AI a foreign speaker onto the
- 42:43body of an English speaker, a well -known actor
- 42:46is really exciting. And a lot of people are hoping
- 42:49to be able to have a play with all these new
- 42:51tools. But that also does come with the law needs
- 42:56to catch up with how quick that this technology
- 43:00is advancing because it's just not over here.
- 43:03flagging behind and I think with the uncertainty
- 43:06it's what makes people quite nervous. I think
- 43:12that there hasn't been, how can I say this, we
- 43:18don't have such a huge industry in Europe right
- 43:22now to have such big issues in terms of how we're
- 43:27utilizing most of these AI tools, but only because
- 43:31I don't think that people in the creator specifically
- 43:33have realized how producers can monetize what
- 43:37they already have from them to use AI tools.
- 43:43For example, like I said before, being able to
- 43:46monetize entire libraries without any compensation
- 43:52to any creator or creative participant. is an
- 43:59issue. I mean, we do have two clients right now
- 44:02that had very good offers to buy out libraries
- 44:08for AI training. And the advice from us was not
- 44:12only was it a legal risk because we're in the
- 44:15gray for sure, but it was also a reputational
- 44:20risk. Because if you're in the gray and Say you
- 44:25take a chance and you say, you know what, we're
- 44:26going to take the chance. We're going to give
- 44:27you the advice that, you know, we believe that
- 44:30based on X, Y, and Z contracts that you have
- 44:32to, you can give over this library and have it
- 44:35have them train off of everyone's performance
- 44:38and so on and so forth. You are jeopardizing
- 44:41your relationships with the creators because.
- 44:45You know, if if they figure out that you're doing
- 44:48this, you're not compensating them. They will
- 44:51never trust you with your projects again. And
- 44:53especially if our clients are doing high quality
- 44:56stuff that you're relying on good creators and
- 45:00good performers to be in them, you're not going
- 45:03to get them again. It's a relationship type of
- 45:06world where we provide our services. People know
- 45:09each other. They want to be able to trust each
- 45:11other. And their creativity is what makes them
- 45:15money. Similarly to how we make our money by
- 45:19creating and drafting contracts and doing intellectual
- 45:23work. So again, it's a legal issue as much as
- 45:28it becomes a legal reputational risk. If this
- 45:32is not resolved in terms of if we're able to
- 45:36use AI in some of these instances. Yeah, kind
- 45:43of another client kind of thing. I know some
- 45:48areas of the industry are kind of clamoring to
- 45:51get what they can now as far as seeing AI as
- 45:57a major market threat. And so they're kind of
- 46:00welcoming these licensing opportunities because
- 46:04it's kind of might as well get something out
- 46:08of it because they see the writing on the wall
- 46:09that like a lot of the kind of faster licensing
- 46:12models. um, for content are going to be likely
- 46:17replaced. Um, not necessarily, but it's, you
- 46:21know, I think it's kind of an inevitability that,
- 46:23you know, if people can just create custom stuff
- 46:26very cheaply, that's duty free. Um, the more
- 46:30bulk licensing content is not going to be as
- 46:33lucrative as it was before. Um, as far as there's
- 46:37also this interesting concept that I've talked
- 46:39to some people about, um, attribution and like
- 46:42using AI. to analyze AI, generative AI material
- 46:47to attribute to existing people. And if something
- 46:52like that works, then you can kind of have a
- 46:56continuing revenue stream related to training
- 46:59AI and licensing it for training AI, because
- 47:02then there's a way of it coming back to you.
- 47:04But that's to be seen, whether or not something
- 47:07like that will ever be embraced. I mean, I think
- 47:10it'd be a good thing if it did. But it's kind
- 47:15of a buyout right now. If you if you license
- 47:17for training, then you're not that I don't really
- 47:21see a direct way of guaranteeing you're ever
- 47:23going to get any more money from that unless
- 47:25except maybe there's like it's a multitude of
- 47:28LLMs or, you know, digital brains that can be
- 47:30trained. And each one of those is a new license.
- 47:33But eventually, we've seen everything consolidates
- 47:36over time. I think that the only way that you
- 47:40can do something like this, if the AI tools that
- 47:43are being used in our industry are required,
- 47:47contractually or otherwise, to give us a list
- 47:51of the works that they used. That's the only
- 47:53way. Yeah. I mean, the only way is provenance,
- 47:59making sure that we know where it's coming from.
- 48:01That'd be a hell of a list, though. I mean, it
- 48:05will be sure, but at the same time, Like, you
- 48:08know, you have residuals being paid to actors,
- 48:10to writers, you know, so on and so forth. You
- 48:12have, you know, all these rights that we were
- 48:14paying to creators. You know, they're also huge
- 48:20lists, you know, when we have to pay residuals,
- 48:23for example. Of course, but, you know, huge or
- 48:27otherwise, we have to know what was being used.
- 48:30And of course, you're writing something on on
- 48:33Claude or on Chad's UBD or Copilot and it gives
- 48:36you all its reasoning behind it. Why can it not
- 48:40give you the references it used and cite what
- 48:47sources it used? I don't see a problem with that.
- 48:50It's supposed to be smart, so it should be able
- 48:52to do that. Yeah, the reality is that might be
- 48:55so so bulky that only an AI could actually utilize
- 48:58it. Listen, let me ask you another question.
- 49:01I mean you you also do music if I'm not mistaken,
- 49:03right? Mm -hmm I mean you take it on trust that
- 49:06you know Apple music Actually pays what it's
- 49:09supposed to pay right? Well after the um, we
- 49:13could also another panel on this but we a few
- 49:14years ago We had the MMA the music modernization
- 49:16act which which basically precluded a bunch of
- 49:20pending lawsuits in favor of a blanket license
- 49:24And I'm I'm If I had to predict something that
- 49:29related to all the training lawsuits in the US,
- 49:33I think something like that would would be a
- 49:35solution. And I wouldn't be surprised if they
- 49:38kind of defaulted to that. Because we had a similar
- 49:41situation, just everyone was suing Spotify and
- 49:43Apple and everyone else. Because nothing was
- 49:46it was too much to license to, you know, kind
- 49:49of their credit. But also, like, I don't think
- 49:52they were that motivated to if they were getting
- 49:54away with it. So then you just had like, okay,
- 49:56everyone's doing the same deal. Here's the blanket
- 49:59license, mechanicals get paid to the MLC, and
- 50:04the lawsuits are gone. And that, I mean, people
- 50:10will gripe about anything and people have valid
- 50:12gripes about it. But to a large extent, it did
- 50:15work. So we could do something similar. Yeah,
- 50:18see, that's what I'm getting at though. We were
- 50:20basing it off trust that this would happen. So
- 50:22I don't see a reason why we can't do it again.
- 50:28By analogy, that would kind of put war and peace
- 50:30in the same valuation as a random local magazine.
- 50:38And so having some kind of attribution or analysis
- 50:41on the back end of what was utilized in the product.
- 50:46Might be more fair but that just adds an entire
- 50:49new dimension of of work and complication and
- 50:52Maybe the society would be satisfied with just
- 50:54like okay Everyone that got you every every piece
- 50:57of work that got used by this LLM can get a fractional
- 51:00of a fraction of a fraction of the economic Upside
- 51:05of whatever anything that that LLM creates and
- 51:08they basically just make like a Spotify type
- 51:10royalty pool of This chunk of your income goes
- 51:13to pay out all of these people in perpetuity
- 51:16It's possible. I feel like it would be more symbolically
- 51:24satisfactory than economically. I mean, we're
- 51:29creating all these tools. somebody has to find
- 51:33a way to utilize them to make them work for everyone.
- 51:36You know what I mean? Like at some point it's
- 51:37like, I get it. I mean, I get it. You're right.
- 51:40It's complicated, but you know, they need to
- 51:42figure this out. If they're taking advantage
- 51:44of everyone's work. Right. I mean, it's only
- 51:48fair. There's also a possibility that the United
- 51:50States courts will lean towards, you know, as
- 51:52long as you had a valid copy, then it's, you
- 51:56know, it's a transformative use and it's fair
- 51:58use and we'll see. Wow. You never know. No offense,
- 52:04but to me, that sounds crazy. I mean, honestly,
- 52:07the fact that I bought, I don't have a book right
- 52:09now, I bought a book to hold and read, to love
- 52:14and to cherish, to essentially be a license to
- 52:20train AI. I mean, it doesn't make sense. A bit
- 52:25of a devil's advocate there is I don't see it
- 52:27being that much different than how a human brain
- 52:30Interprets in stores and transforms the wealth
- 52:33of material. It's it's ever read but then we're
- 52:36talking of speed and and and and you know Volume
- 52:40yeah magnet. I was gonna say but yeah volume
- 52:42to be scoreboard done I didn't want to because
- 52:45we have a kind of right of privacy issue in the
- 52:49United States that's being Pushed through legislation
- 52:52as a federal right of privacy, which is new for
- 52:54us very much sparked by AI and the capabilities,
- 53:00rather nefarious capabilities of AI to create
- 53:02defects, to create fake political ads, to create
- 53:05knockoffs of very convincing knockoffs of artists
- 53:08work, and things like that. And currently, we
- 53:11have everything state level, and we're pushing
- 53:13through a federal. Well, hopefully, soon we'll
- 53:17have a federal right of publicity or privacy,
- 53:22or, you know, general name and likeness rights.
- 53:26If I was to guess, I'd say Europe was ahead of
- 53:28us on that, but I'm actually not sure. So do
- 53:31you know where you guys stand on? Is that a thing?
- 53:35Is deepfakes a cultural hot button right now
- 53:38for you guys? Actually, it's weird. We did write
- 53:41an article on our website two or three weeks
- 53:43ago for deepfake nudes and what you can do criminally
- 53:49and civilly. to litigate. It is becoming a huge
- 53:55problem, weirdly, for underage persons. It is
- 54:00such a huge issue. And there have been a lot
- 54:04of criminal cases and litigation. And of course,
- 54:11it has to do with personal data as well and the
- 54:14right to privacy. But it's not what you would
- 54:18call the right to publicity or the right to likeness,
- 54:20like you guys You guys have that right, I guess,
- 54:24in the US, where you can license it out and so
- 54:26on and so forth. It's not that per se, but we
- 54:29mostly tie it to personal data, to be honest.
- 54:33Yeah. We see it as a personal data violation.
- 54:37Yeah. Yeah, it's similar in the UK. And again,
- 54:41this is kind of verging out of my media bubble,
- 54:44but it's more online safety. Thanos says like
- 54:47sexual deepfakes are really the thing that statutes
- 54:50trying to protect against at the moment, rather
- 54:52than sort of the non funny memes that don't have
- 55:00a sort of dark side. But similarly to Thanos
- 55:05in terms of data protection, the UK's got quite
- 55:07stringent rules, not quite as strict as the EU,
- 55:10I understand. But that's one of the main concerns
- 55:13with with AI and things like body scanning and
- 55:17stuff, like that's special category data under
- 55:20UK law, the data protection regs. They need to
- 55:25be processed in a particular way. There needs
- 55:28to be encryption and it needs to be absolutely
- 55:31necessary. So it's contractual necessity. So
- 55:36you couldn't just say, can we do this whole body
- 55:39scan? of someone who appears in the background
- 55:43of a scene, an extra just in case we need to
- 55:46use it in the future. Like it's not contractually
- 55:49necessary for that in order to create the original
- 55:52film and stuff. So it's a real minefield, especially
- 55:56in the UK with data protection and that special
- 56:00category data, which would include things like
- 56:01voice recordings and stuff. It's really heavily
- 56:05protected. For us, it's all about proportionality,
- 56:10actually. I guess it's the same thing to what
- 56:12Sarah is saying, basically. If it's not absolutely
- 56:15necessary for the services to be provided, you
- 56:17can't have a blanket license to do something
- 56:21like this. Yeah, it's basically how it is here
- 56:24too. That's, I mean, it's not dissimilar to the
- 56:32SAG rules or the California law on digital. California
- 56:37has its own privacy law, right? the cpa most
- 56:42states do like all states kind of have a different
- 56:45like right of publicity right of privacy um but
- 56:48the problem is like um dina lapolzo eloquently
- 56:52uh um illustrated the last time i saw her on
- 56:55a panel it's like one of her clients got there
- 56:57was a video of or a song that came out with like
- 57:01a collaboration fake collaboration between one
- 57:03of her clients another huge celebrity and it
- 57:06took like a week in like a village of all the
- 57:08interested parties to come together to find some
- 57:10way of getting it down. Whereas like, wow, if
- 57:14it's so obviously designed to be a fake of a
- 57:17celebrity or a very famous singer, one would
- 57:21hope that there would be a more direct way. I
- 57:24think eventually are taken down just by relationships.
- 57:26It wasn't like an actual mechanical legal mechanism
- 57:29that redundant but there was an actual legal
- 57:33mechanism that took it down. It was the label
- 57:36and Spotify had a relationship so they're like
- 57:38okay we'll take it down. Yeah again slightly
- 57:41out of my wheelhouse but we have the online safety
- 57:44act in the UK which would probably be used in
- 57:46that case and also Ofcom which is our broadcast
- 57:51regulator that also can regulate certain social
- 57:55media stuff as well. They would be the people
- 57:59probably in the UK that would do that and be
- 58:02able to get content taken down. No, we actually
- 58:07have that covered in our Digital Services Act.
- 58:11Now there is a proper legal regulation which
- 58:17is uniform throughout the EU that regulates all
- 58:20platforms like YouTube, Facebook, Instagram,
- 58:23and so on and so forth in terms of how they put
- 58:25our content and they have to have a a good process
- 58:30in terms of how we can request takedowns. They
- 58:33have to have a proper person that we have to
- 58:34serve with legal documents to take stuff down.
- 58:39Yeah, we do have that since a year and a half
- 58:42ago, something like that. Yeah, we haven't had
- 58:45to use it just yet, but there is a process on
- 58:48how you do that. Interesting. Well, we're just
- 58:53about out of time. Do you guys have any? Closing
- 58:56thoughts or statements? I think I've been checking
- 59:01the channel. I don't think we have any questions
- 59:03in the audience. We have some questions from
- 59:06the audience. Oh, then I don't see it on my phone.
- 59:09So if one of you can lead that. I need to drop
- 59:14off imminently, but there's probably only one
- 59:17for me in terms of the UK. If the script is registered
- 59:22in the US, for the UK then is that just evidence?
- 59:25Does the UK registration achieve the same goal
- 59:27in UK courts as it does in the US? Meaning does
- 59:30that get to you? Does that get you the same damages?
- 59:34So yeah, there isn't a, you don't have to register
- 59:38the copyright in the UK, and I think this was
- 59:41probably answered after this question actually,
- 59:42so apologies for repeating, but so the reason
- 59:46why most in the UK in the UK world we'd ask for
- 59:50US copyright is more just a complete chain of
- 59:52title thing and obviously like the US deal is
- 59:56going to be one of the most valuable and US distributors
- 1:00:01are more likely to check chain of title etc so
- 1:00:03that's kind of why we want to see that and because
- 1:00:06it is the only sort of registration available.
- 1:00:17Michael, one for you is, with regard to US copyright
- 1:00:19law, has there been any discussion about the
- 1:00:22risks of prompts being considered collections
- 1:00:24of unprotectable ideas rather than protectable
- 1:00:27expressions? Unprotectable ideas? I mean, I would
- 1:00:33see a prompt just as any other work, which, you
- 1:00:37know, everything's derivative. If you literally
- 1:00:40take someone else's work and put it into a prompt,
- 1:00:44I could see a very good argument for copyright
- 1:00:46infringement there. If you were telling an AI
- 1:00:49to replicate something copyrightable, like a
- 1:00:55character, a well -known Star Wars character
- 1:00:56or Disney character or something, then you are
- 1:00:59basically intentionally making the generative
- 1:01:02AI infringe on someone else's copyright. I think
- 1:01:08that answers the question as I understood it,
- 1:01:09but I may not be understanding the question.
- 1:01:13Does that sound right? Can you read it again?
- 1:01:16Yeah, sure. Actually, it seems to have disappeared.
- 1:01:20So I imagine you have answered. I guess I'll
- 1:01:22take that as answered. We answered it. One for
- 1:01:26you, Thanos. In the US, for performers, one of
- 1:01:29the protections for outputs used is a right of
- 1:01:32publicity, which is a protection of the ability
- 1:01:34to monetize one's image. Those laws are state
- 1:01:37by state. Are there equivalent laws in the EU?
- 1:01:40Well, we don't have equivalent laws in the EU
- 1:01:43uniformly, but in continental law, we would probably
- 1:01:46call it the right to personality. So essentially
- 1:01:49it's kind of the right of publicity, but we call
- 1:01:53it the right of personality. So it's kind of
- 1:01:55the same thing. Is only the prompt, the literary
- 1:02:03work in the UK and EU, or is the output based
- 1:02:06on a detailed prompt also protectable? It kind
- 1:02:11of depends what the output is, to be honest,
- 1:02:13in the UK. Yes, probably. Again, kind of depends
- 1:02:19on the human involvement in creating that prompt.
- 1:02:24I think that the over under on giving a response
- 1:02:29that included it depends by lawyers is, you know,
- 1:02:32it's off the charts. No, but it does depend.
- 1:02:37Obviously, yes. I mean, I agree. I mean, at the
- 1:02:39same time, I think I don't know how much prompts
- 1:02:42can be, unless it's something like Michael said,
- 1:02:45where you've given a prompt that is so long and
- 1:02:48it includes very detailed instructions and so
- 1:02:50on and so forth to be protected. But again, like
- 1:02:54I said in my previous point, I think you always
- 1:02:56have to take a look at what is the license agreement
- 1:02:59that you have with that tool. I think that's
- 1:03:02what's really, really important. We keep forgetting
- 1:03:04that we have a license agreement with the other
- 1:03:07party utilizing the AI tool. We keep going to
- 1:03:10the defaults of the law, but we're not seeing
- 1:03:12what we've actually agreed with them. I think
- 1:03:14that's really important, too. On the other side
- 1:03:17of that is, you know, the license dictates the
- 1:03:20rights to whatever exists. The law dictates what
- 1:03:22exists. As far as you're right. Of course. Yeah.
- 1:03:26And so it sounds like in the United States, I'm
- 1:03:28balancing that a little bit more than you have
- 1:03:30to because in the EU so much of it's just licensing
- 1:03:33based anyway. But, you know, talking about, you
- 1:03:36know, are there any moral rights? with regard
- 1:03:40to something created by generative AI or the
- 1:03:42generative AI touched. Because sometimes the
- 1:03:44prompt is an entire draft. Sometimes the screenplay
- 1:03:47is the entire draft and the prompt is just, you
- 1:03:49know, polish this or give me some ideas of how
- 1:03:52to restructure this or how to streamline it.
- 1:03:54In which case, absolutely the prompt is original
- 1:03:58expression. unless they just copied it. But if
- 1:04:02it's a genuine original screenplay, then yeah,
- 1:04:05then just because it got put into AI as a prompt
- 1:04:07doesn't change the character of what it was or
- 1:04:11what it is. I only have one more minute, but
- 1:04:16there is one here that's actually really interesting.
- 1:04:19Are there any regulations anywhere that require
- 1:04:21disclosure that an image is AI generated so that
- 1:04:23the user viewer can see it? In the UK, not so
- 1:04:27much regulations, but that is one thing that
- 1:04:30the government's potentially reviewing as part
- 1:04:33of the report I mentioned earlier. But that is
- 1:04:37one thing that we're increasingly seeing errors
- 1:04:40and omissions insurers asking for as a condition
- 1:04:43to grant E &O insurances disclosure of what AI
- 1:04:47tools have been used and how. And if content's
- 1:04:50generated, then have they been separately cleared
- 1:04:53and gone through NEC checks, et cetera? So as
- 1:04:57kind of not answering the question in terms of
- 1:04:58regulations, but it's definitely something that's
- 1:05:01at the forefront of film and TV, I think. We
- 1:05:04do have that regulation in the EU, actually.
- 1:05:07Nice. We do have that. Yeah, it's the AI Act
- 1:05:10requires you to flag AI generated content. So
- 1:05:14if you visit Europe and you're using Instagram,
- 1:05:16there has to be a tag that something is AI created.
- 1:05:21Of course, it's voluntary. I mean, there's no
- 1:05:24automatic you know AI tagging but you are legally
- 1:05:28required to do so yes I think there is I think
- 1:05:31there is something similar um to that in the
- 1:05:34UK in terms of social media with the advertising
- 1:05:37standards agency um that's slightly again out
- 1:05:41of my wheelhouse but film and tv no but you know
- 1:05:44it's it's a very interesting question because
- 1:05:46look technically speaking youtube is is kind
- 1:05:49of a social media space in terms of video content
- 1:05:51so if you're posting content on YouTube, at least
- 1:05:56under the Digital Services Act and the AI Act
- 1:05:58in Europe, you would probably have to disclose
- 1:06:00the use of AI on some level. So I think that's
- 1:06:04interesting to point out. Yeah. I'm actually
- 1:06:09not sure it's on my way to the house either.
- 1:06:10I don't know if FTC requires it in the United
- 1:06:12States, but so much of the internet is global.
- 1:06:15So largely why a lot of US companies will use
- 1:06:20the European standards for data privacy as because
- 1:06:25of the most stringent, so that if you're good
- 1:06:27there, you're good pretty much everywhere else.
- 1:06:29That might be why I'm seeing it on the state
- 1:06:30side. I'm seeing a lot of disclosures, but I
- 1:06:33don't know to the extent they're actually required
- 1:06:35here. I'm so sorry. I'm going to need to shoot
- 1:06:41off. I don't know if Michael and Fanos can stay
- 1:06:45on. We got seven extra minutes, so I appreciate
- 1:06:48it. This is a good time to wrap anyway. We're
- 1:06:50over time. Thank you both. This has been great.
- 1:06:55Very stimulating conversation. Thank you for
- 1:06:57having us. Of course.