Latest / Newcomer Pod / Peering Over the Edge of Death (with Jon McNeill)
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to the third episode of newcomer.
- 0:03I'm Eric newcomer excited for you to listen to an interview.
- 0:07With John McNeil a former Chief Operating Officer lift and a
- 0:11former top executive at Tesla, he knows Elon Musk.
- 0:16Well, now he's an investor at DV X, which is a hatch investor.
- 0:21John is also on a bunch of boards.
- 0:24We talked about CrossFit Lululemon, so someone who really
- 0:28sees the breath of of the business world.
- 0:31So we talked a lot about management that he learned at
- 0:34lift and Tesla. I think he's a little spicier
- 0:37about lift and interesting to hear his thoughts on mosque, for
- 0:42sure. And then we talked a little bit
- 0:44about blitz-scaling and sort of the challenges of that model in
- 0:48a world where interest rates are higher.
- 0:51I thought it was interesting pretty girl in light of our
- 0:53first episode with Reid Hoffman, who has been a big proponent,
- 0:56give it a listen before we get there.
- 0:58I want to thank our launch sponsor vanta Newcomers brought
- 1:01to you by vanta to close and grow, major customers.
- 1:04You have to earn trust, but demonstrating your security and
- 1:07compliance can be time. Consuming tedious and expensive
- 1:10until you use vanta, vanta automates up to 90% of the work
- 1:14for the most sought-after, security, and privacy standards,
- 1:17save time and money on compliance with fantas
- 1:19enterprise-ready. Trust management platform for
- 1:22limited time. Newcomer listeners get $1000 off
- 1:25Fanta, go to VA en, ta.com newcomer to get started, It.
- 1:30And now here's our episode with John McNeil, welcome to the
- 1:33newcomer podcast. Thanks for coming on.
- 1:36John. Yeah, glad to be here.
- 1:38I feel like the first time we really spent time together.
- 1:41You were the Chief Operating Officer of lift and I was
- 1:44following you around in Las Vegas.
- 1:47Is you are setting up driver operation stuff there, right?
- 1:51Yeah, I think so. We got some quality time when I
- 1:53was in that role. Yeah, right 2018 2019.
- 1:56So yeah 34 years ago yeah so we're going to jump.
- 2:00On your story and there's so much I want to talk about.
- 2:02But I mean, you are at Tesla, very senior.
- 2:05They're obviously, I met you through the lift context.
- 2:08Now you're an investor with a strong thesis, we're going to
- 2:11talk about that. You're on a bunch of boards.
- 2:13You're on the what GM board are. You also CrossFit is that right?
- 2:18Or you have a lemon, how do you cross fit?
- 2:23I just I don't know the story at all.
- 2:25I don't know what I'm opening up, but what is the story with
- 2:27the CrossFit one? So it's kind of a fun.
- 2:30Tori. One of the guys that worked with
- 2:31my first job out of college, his life was changed by CrossFit and
- 2:36so much. So any such a good manager that
- 2:39we back in 2010. He and I were having a breakfast
- 2:42together and I said, you got to buy that company because you'd
- 2:46be just the right person to run it.
- 2:49And so, through a series of events, he got to know the
- 2:51founder and didn't go anywhere. It almost went somewhere, but
- 2:55didn't go anywhere and then in 2019 2020.
- 3:00The founder needed a buyer and so he reached back out to my
- 3:04friend and my friend ended up winning the deal and asked me to
- 3:10join the board. And I'm not a crossfitter but
- 3:13I've kind of become one. The process.
- 3:16You're like a all-purpose entrepreneur this way, right?
- 3:19I mean I'm, there's deep focus in Auto which like with Tesla
- 3:24lift, I think you have a company now sort of in, yeah, that space
- 3:29and GM board, obviously. Leslie.
- 3:30But like you really started with entrepreneurship first.
- 3:34My stuff is an entrepreneur, it kind of started as a kid.
- 3:37I grew up in this household, that was awesome, but we didn't
- 3:39have much money. So we had to figure out a buyer
- 3:41on clothes and shoes. And so I started this
- 3:43landscaping business when I was 8 years old.
- 3:46So I could buy a pair of shoes and that experience was seminal
- 3:50for me because I kept it all through high school and it paid
- 3:52for my first. Car, it paid for a big chunk of
- 3:56my college and I got to college and A new, the only things I
- 4:01learned about business were things that I had learned
- 4:03between 8 and 18, myself and reading a lot of stuff.
- 4:06So, my first job out of college was at Bain Consulting.
- 4:09And I happened to sit outside of the conference room, where Bain
- 4:14Capital was, and this little group called information
- 4:17Partners, which was basically, what is now being Ventures.
- 4:20And I started to work with them and do some of the guys very
- 4:23closely, and it was through that process, I discovered or
- 4:26rediscovered. I was entrepreneur.
- 4:28And so one of the guys handed me a business plan and said, I
- 4:33think this could be really interesting for you and it
- 4:35turned out it was. So I hopped out of venture
- 4:39capital in started. My first company with Bain
- 4:41Ventures as a backer which was awesome.
- 4:44And was that a, was it a start-up?
- 4:47It was. And then we start to use the
- 4:48word here are start. Okay.
- 4:49It was a software company that sold software that runs call
- 4:54centers, call centers Winter, a new thing in the early 90s and
- 4:58We haven't written much software to help run them.
- 5:00And so we did, we wrote the software and we were computer
- 5:04scientist. So we said to ourselves, we only
- 5:05want one set of code. We want to run off one server
- 5:08and we want to serve all these clients.
- 5:10So we want multi-tenant single set of code which today you know
- 5:13as SAS but we weren't smart enough right to bake a name out
- 5:16of it. And so we started this company
- 5:18was right place, right? Time it took off and it was
- 5:22called first notice systems or FNS, and 18 months later, we
- 5:26sold it to a public company. And then I started a second
- 5:29company that really came out of this experience.
- 5:31My wife had her car was hit by one of our neighbors.
- 5:34It was a terrible experience, get it fixed.
- 5:36And as I got to know the industry, I figured out that the
- 5:38Collision industry was a fifty billion dollar industry with
- 5:41like no modern manufacturing or supply chain Approach at that
- 5:46time. And so, we started a company
- 5:47that today is the largest collision repair company in the
- 5:50country. It's owned by Carlisle and it
- 5:52was another heck of a ride and that was bought by And auto
- 5:57insurance company, Allstate. And then I stayed at Allstate
- 6:00for two years and saw all kinds of opportunities to write
- 6:02software for insurance companies.
- 6:04So start at a third company out of that experience called in
- 6:07servio which was a SAS platform that serve the insurance
- 6:10companies. So yeah, you've sat at this
- 6:13intersection between sort of tech and the real world and I
- 6:17wanted to touch a couple just so people could get hurt him, get
- 6:20some flavors of that. And I want to just like frame
- 6:23this up with sort of a big question which is just Like do
- 6:27you believe in blitzscaling? You know I had Reid Hoffman on
- 6:32the podcast. He's been a big advocate of that
- 6:34you know like Lyft and Uber Wars which you know I wrote a ton
- 6:37about felt like all about blitz-scaling and certainly some
- 6:40of these electric car companies like a ravine or something.
- 6:44It's like okay we're going to raise so much money to compete
- 6:47with the likes of Tesla. You know, Tesla probably had a
- 6:51slower ramp up there in terms of spend.
- 6:54How do you think about it? Scaling and do you believe in it
- 6:58and did you ever do you now? Yeah.
- 7:00What do you think about? So I love read to and he's
- 7:04giving me some similar advice as a friend and as an investor over
- 7:07time I think blitzscaling is appropriate when interest rates
- 7:11are zero when Capital Street was that for an answer.
- 7:15You know, people are going to hand you free Capital.
- 7:18Then you make different decisions and there was an ERA,
- 7:21like you just described were Capital was free and so you
- 7:24could go out and burn. In capital to acquire customers
- 7:28in a business that didn't have its economics figured out yet.
- 7:30And right there was a good example of that and you could
- 7:33burn through a lot of investor Capital because basically, every
- 7:36time you raised, it didn't cost you it much in terms of
- 7:39valuation because just the way valuations work, when you value
- 7:42a terminal value and divide by 0, it's free money.
- 7:45Now when you divide by 5% or 6% or 20% depending on what the
- 7:48rate of capital is it would lead you to a different conclusion.
- 7:51So when interest rates are now nonzero I don't believe
- 7:55blitzscaling. Appropriate because you can't
- 7:57afford the cost of capital to go do that.
- 7:59So you actually have to make the business work in.
- 8:01One of the things that I loved about working with a lion was,
- 8:04because I had been an entrepreneur before we met.
- 8:06I had this mindset of like, really success.
- 8:09This had been burned in my brain by a mentor really successful
- 8:13entrepreneurs can run a business on minimal cash and be creative
- 8:20and you have to have the best people and you got to get a lot
- 8:22out of those people. But that was an ethos that I
- 8:25shared. When I joined Tesla and I
- 8:27totally got the culture because that was it.
- 8:30It was like minimal Capital, maximum Talent, applied to big
- 8:34problems, and get as much out of that Talent as you can.
- 8:38And therefore blitzscaling is an appropriate, do you think the
- 8:40companies that were blitzscaling?
- 8:42However, conjugating that worried do, you think they can
- 8:45make the transition to this interest rate environment?
- 8:47I mean, I guess what challenge with blitzscaling if it only
- 8:50works in a zero interest rate environment and you learn the
- 8:54wrong lessons, For any other interest rate environment and
- 8:58most of human Financial history. There are interest rates above
- 9:02zero then maybe it seems dangerous, even in that brief
- 9:06wonderful moment of free money that you're going to learn wrong
- 9:09lessons or can companies Escape blitzscaling.
- 9:12That's the question I mean. Yeah, they can and you have to
- 9:17have super talented leadership to do it.
- 9:19And so like let's use Uber and Lyft is a case study here.
- 9:23So you get this professional manager that comes in dhara.
- 9:25Ha and dark comes into Uber and is able to create a market cap
- 9:31above their amount of capital raised because starts to
- 9:36rationalize costs gets rid of all the cash burners that he
- 9:39can. So it gets rid of autonomous
- 9:41which is burning a ton of cash, gets rid of international
- 9:44markets, which are burning a ton of cash, turns those into
- 9:47Investments on the balance sheet that end up helping.
- 9:50The pl, is they get liquid. And so in contrast you've got
- 9:54lift, which is Raised far more Capital than its market cap.
- 9:58It raised somewhere between 50. How much is it where do I
- 10:01somewhere between 15 and 20 billion and its market cap today
- 10:04is less than 5 and you deduct the cash?
- 10:07That's on the balance sheet. It's way less than 5.
- 10:09And so, I think to have a successful business over time,
- 10:12you have to have really professional managers that come
- 10:14in, that are capable of taking a company from blitzscaling into
- 10:19positively free, cash flow, which door has got to read
- 10:22between the lines, a little bit on this for the listener, you
- 10:24were the chief operating officer.
- 10:25Sir of live for what a little under two years, the
- 10:29professional management. Like what would you have liked
- 10:33to see them do that? They haven't done since you've
- 10:36left. Yeah.
- 10:37Just if there were a number of at the time who are arguing,
- 10:39that we really needed to address the expense base, get pricing
- 10:43discipline. So you get more revenue on the
- 10:45top line. Address, the expense base on the
- 10:48bottom line, there are still more engineers at left than
- 10:51there are Tesla. Tesla is approaching a hundred
- 10:54billion dollars in a For revenue and hardware and then diversify
- 10:59into other lines of business that would leverage the driver
- 11:01base, like food delivery. And so you number of us lost
- 11:05those arguments and left as a result.
- 11:07And unfortunately, the scoreboard reflects the outcome.
- 11:11Yeah. Do you think anybody would buy
- 11:14lift or like? I think search notice it's a
- 11:17colleges, you've got. Yeah, it's very costly there.
- 11:20A lot of Bargains in the market today and in this case, you've
- 11:22got Founders was super voting shares, which is sort of a very
- 11:25difficult issue to get through and maybe a non-starter for most
- 11:29buyers. The founders have been at it so
- 11:31long, I don't know. I would think, at some point,
- 11:34they would be willing to relinquish power for.
- 11:37Yeah. Maybe they get tired at some
- 11:38point. Maybe we'll come back to Tesla,
- 11:41maybe a little bit more lift, but I wanted to talk about your
- 11:44investing firm dvx, like, it seems born out of this idea that
- 11:49we're not in a zero interest rate environment anymore, right?
- 11:52Or it, can you talk a little bit about sort of Firm and sort of
- 11:57your ideas behind create like, are you calling a venture firm?
- 12:00I guess that's like not really he's like it's not I call it a
- 12:05hatch platform. For this reason, we only work on
- 12:09her own ideas. We really, really research the
- 12:11heck out of these ideas and prove them out and then we take
- 12:15that idea and start with a little nugget, an MVP minimum
- 12:19viable product. Put that on the market, start to
- 12:21learn, start the feedback loop and we run these companies
- 12:24through series to Stage gate. It's the didn't once we've
- 12:27proven that they've got product Market fit and go to market fit
- 12:31that we really launched the scaling chapter.
- 12:33That company bringing a team and let them add it in terms of
- 12:36running the company. How many partners do you have?
- 12:38I have three other partners so therefore of us, we create
- 12:41companies, some people call it this adventure Studio, some
- 12:44people would call it an incubator.
- 12:46I just called a hatch platform in two years.
- 12:48We've launched seven companies and for externally funded it
- 12:51which is our validation point. With somebody else comes in and
- 12:54says, hey we think you've got something here.
- 12:55That's Worth investing in and how much Capital are you
- 12:58investing? We started with the first
- 13:00tranche of capital of 50 million to start these seven companies.
- 13:03So it gives you a sense of the capital efficiency is we're
- 13:06getting them to investable Quality because we're kind of
- 13:09applying what we've been talking about which is what's not Piper
- 13:12spend. Let's prove that we've got a
- 13:15business here and then we'll add Capital to the fire but not
- 13:18until. And as an investor, like a big
- 13:20advantage of this, is that you own a much larger percentage of
- 13:24the company. Going into series.
- 13:27A that's rights, were a seat, dry seed, investor or what are
- 13:31the diamonds, right? Yeah.
- 13:32When we start to company, we want 100% of it.
- 13:34And so, this is very different economics than Venture where
- 13:37you're trying to own somewhere between 5 and 20 percent.
- 13:40It gives us a lot of Leverage as we work through the funding
- 13:43cycle on these businesses. And how do you attract sort of a
- 13:47CEO in that situation where we obviously they haven't come up
- 13:51with the idea. So I imagine they're happy to
- 13:53have this great company, but what's the dance there?
- 13:56And in terms of attracting a CEO, it's a really good
- 13:59question. This was inspired by the as I
- 14:01was a CEO. I was in different CEO groups
- 14:03ran across a lot of CEOs who would say I'd love to start a
- 14:06company but I don't have an idea, right?
- 14:09And there are a lot of those people walking around in that
- 14:13are super talented. And so we come to people like
- 14:16With not only an idea than an idea that's been de-risked,
- 14:19because we've already done the work to prove product Market
- 14:21fit, go to market fit, make sure the unit Economics work, that
- 14:24we've got a big tan for them to go attack.
- 14:27And so then we can bring a CEO a really cool early stage company
- 14:32that if they're wired to start something early, but don't have
- 14:36an idea, we're coming to answer for that.
- 14:38And for all these companies, the goal still is to raise a series
- 14:41a from a venture fund. Is that right?
- 14:45Or are there some that will never need capital or other
- 14:48sources of capital? Well, no, the goal is for us to
- 14:51get the right investors and alongside us at series a and
- 14:55sometimes earlier, but generally it series a because we want to a
- 14:59prove that if we're not smoke it, our own product and think
- 15:02we've got a great company and keep pouring capital and but
- 15:05others are willing to. So this is a check for us.
- 15:08A check and balance to make sure that we've got something that
- 15:10other see value in two and that they're willing to validate that
- 15:14by writing a jacket and vest. These are generally Venture
- 15:18groups, all right, so which companies for this long?
- 15:21Are you said 74 of raise money? Yeah.
- 15:25Walk us through a couple of the faves.
- 15:28So we've got you'll see like how completely different these ideas
- 15:32are but they generally come out of experiences, we've had so
- 15:35alone is in cyber insurance and what we saw there was an
- 15:38opportunity in a very large Market.
- 15:40That's growing very fast to come at the problem very differently.
- 15:44Everybody else in the industry was focusing on the outside end.
- 15:47So mainly what they do is test a company's defenses and see how
- 15:50effectively our come from the outside.
- 15:53We wanted to start from the inside out and say what's the
- 15:55tech stack is it effectively configured?
- 15:58Is it turned on for all users Etc?
- 16:01And getting that data, we knew was going to be really hard, but
- 16:04a potentially in load. So we figured out how to get
- 16:06that data. How to price cyber insurance,
- 16:09and make it super easy for people to understand.
- 16:12So it's a little bit like car insurance you get today, you
- 16:15know, you put an app on your phone, you get a driver score,
- 16:16and Car insurance. In this case, you put our
- 16:19software in, you get a score, you get Cyber insurance.
- 16:22So let's company called root and we've got several VC's in
- 16:25alongside us. It's a huge Market when I'm
- 16:27really excited for something completely different in the auto
- 16:29space, we took the team that invented mobile service for cars
- 16:34at Tesla. One of the things we discovered
- 16:35at Tesla, was the 80% of what needed to be fixed on a car
- 16:39could be done in the customers driveway or in their office,
- 16:42parking lot. And one day, we woke up and said
- 16:45there's a much bigger market for this.
- 16:47Much bigger Tam, and that's all cars.
- 16:49So, why don't we take that team and apply that to all cars?
- 16:52So, this is a company called Kirby and it's in 29 markets
- 16:56right now, in Northern California and now it's moving
- 16:58into Arizona and State starting, its multi-state expansion.
- 17:01But what they do is they provide on-site Mechanical Services for
- 17:05cars you wanted to do that. A similar idea left to right.
- 17:08I mean this sort of mobile or there was an opportunity.
- 17:11You sir, we did you drivers cars right?
- 17:14Exactly. Because every time a driver's
- 17:15car is down there, not making money.
- 17:17So, the idea was, we could, we could send cars out to get these
- 17:21cars fixed. It was in service of a long-term
- 17:23Vision. We have this long-term vision
- 17:25for Kirby, which is autonomous vehicles are going to operate in
- 17:29cities. Cities have largely been gutted
- 17:32of places to get your car fixed and autonomous vehicles are
- 17:36going to largely be electric, so you don't want to drive them
- 17:38into a central Depot and waste charge to get them fixed or
- 17:43service. You want someone to come to
- 17:44them. And so the long range vision, Or
- 17:47Kirby is they become the service platform for autonomous fleets
- 17:52in cities. But along the way, we're serving
- 17:54regular consumers who need to get their cars fixed to mostly
- 17:57electric cars, or any kind of car.
- 18:01Any Cuddy cars? Yeah.
- 18:03Any kind of cars. What do most people need?
- 18:05It is like an oil change situation.
- 18:07Or yeah, you can do anything from an oil change to swap out.
- 18:10Some of these breaks, two belts and other things, in a
- 18:13customer's driveway. So anything you don't need to
- 18:16basically put a car up on a lift for, in good underneath.
- 18:19You can do in a customer's driveway, so literally Will Row
- 18:22trucks to take care of just about anything that needs to be
- 18:26fixed on a customer's car. When I launched my newsletter
- 18:28first, like, I feel like I had five ten You know, stories are
- 18:32really wanted to do, you know, I've been thinking about them
- 18:34for a long time and then you come out of the gate, eventually
- 18:38write the stories and then you're like oh man I have this
- 18:40story creation machine and I need to have more than just the
- 18:43ones that I had a couple years like stew about when I you know,
- 18:47didn't like, you know what, my boss is Bloomberg.
- 18:49Thought I'm sure he's some of these ideas clearly came out of
- 18:52learnings at Tesla and left and elsewhere.
- 18:55How do you get the confidence that you'll keep coming up with
- 18:58ideas? And do you have any sort of I
- 19:00don't know. Method or how do you generate a
- 19:03new business idea? If you have to keep pumping them
- 19:05out for new Founders, we have a total method around this.
- 19:08So we have a method around our entire process and at the
- 19:10beginning of the process is coming up with these ideas.
- 19:13And so we have an ideation session once a month at dvx.
- 19:18Or it's not just Partners, it's the whole firm that comes
- 19:21together and says, I got an idea.
- 19:23What do you think about this? And we literally will Riff on
- 19:26these ideas and that's one source and we've got 35 to 50
- 19:30ideas. Time, we're looking at basically
- 19:32are internally generated. There will also do some
- 19:35proactive work rules say hey there's a big theme happening in
- 19:39the economy, like electrification and what are
- 19:42some of the non-obvious things that are going to happen?
- 19:44Five to ten years from now. If we Electrify like big chunks
- 19:49of transportation, for instance, and then we'll go looking for
- 19:52ideas. Proactively within that theme in
- 19:55will research the themes and then, as I mentioned, will come
- 19:58up with an idea. If one comes to the Forefront as
- 20:00really, really Attractive, and it's got a big market.
- 20:03So three things, we look for a very large markets,
- 20:05profitability opportunity above 50%, gross margins, and a unique
- 20:10way for us to win like a moat and if we got all three things
- 20:14then we'll work into launching a company.
- 20:17And we run these companies through stage Gates and so far,
- 20:21we've launched 10 companies 7 have made it through all of the
- 20:25stage Gates. Three were killed along the
- 20:27process where we either couldn't get product Market, fit.
- 20:30We thought Was there. We thought we were going to be
- 20:32able to get it we couldn't or we couldn't get the Internet
- 20:35connects to work and we'll kill something.
- 20:37If we don't think it's going to work but it all starts at that
- 20:40first idea stage and we've got to have a very big robust,
- 20:42funnel of ideas. How do you figure out that the
- 20:45gross margins for something like, Kirby will be above 50?
- 20:48Getting the get into the business and you start to test
- 20:50it. So literally, we got into a few
- 20:51markets in the Bay Area. And the team's first goal was
- 20:55proof product Market, fit. And once we got to our metrics
- 20:59on product Market fit, then it was Ew.
- 21:01Gross margins. And when they were able to prove
- 21:04a path to gross margins then we said okay now let's prove the
- 21:08caxton. Ltd's let's prove our go to
- 21:10market economics and once they approve all three of those
- 21:13things, they're Off to the Races which Kirby did.
- 21:16But couple of our companies couldn't get through those stage
- 21:18Gates, we had to kill him. I mean, back to sort of the big
- 21:21blitz-scaling zoom out. So there is the blitzscaling,
- 21:24which is just, you know, we can put a lot of cash into something
- 21:27even if it's like an Airbnb or more clearly We're sort of
- 21:32platform business to make it work, but I think there's a
- 21:35related phenomenon to blitzscaling, which is also just
- 21:39we can do things in the real world, you know, it's like
- 21:41Travis it, Uber saying, you know, atoms instead of bits or
- 21:45whatever, right. It was sort of that idea that,
- 21:47like, you can make real world stuff work because you're
- 21:51willing to throw enough money at it.
- 21:53And I think some people now it's like, okay, there was too much
- 21:56money but there's also a questioning about sort of the
- 21:59real world. Peace.
- 22:01Piece of tech in a higher interest rate environment.
- 22:04You know, everybody's excited about AI.
- 22:06Now it's like the least, right? Are sort of tangible physical
- 22:09real-world thing. I mean, yeah.
- 22:12Do you think the Venture model can still sustain something like
- 22:16Kirby or something like, does that make sense is a venture
- 22:19business in this higher interest rate, environment or do you
- 22:23think VCS are going to move on from anything that really tries
- 22:26to move atoms? I think you know, you've got to
- 22:30have a Set that helps a business get started.
- 22:33They can deal in the world and those are generally operators
- 22:37that have been in the real world and maybe the best example of
- 22:40that is bio Tech biotech. You're moving molecules and
- 22:43you're getting molecules and proteins to do things that
- 22:46haven't been done in history. And that's real world science
- 22:50getting applied. And I don't think any of us
- 22:52would argue that like Moderno wasn't a good investment if I'm
- 22:55right. It was Flagship story, much like
- 22:57us. They start companies from
- 22:58scratch. They work them through a Series
- 23:01of stage Gates, and they do that in the physical world.
- 23:04Not all of our businesses move atoms, but we're not afraid of
- 23:07businesses that do move atoms because we've run these kind of
- 23:10real-world businesses in scale. And we know what good product
- 23:13looks like, what good teams look like, what could go to market
- 23:16looks like. And so we feel like we're
- 23:18uniquely kind of skilled to help in a business that like Kirby
- 23:21that could be very large annually.
- 23:23People spend more than 200 billion dollars getting their
- 23:26car fixed except very big market.
- 23:29So now I can attack a very large Market.
- 23:31With a high, gross margin model that people love.
- 23:34Yeah, that's pretty. That's investable.
- 23:36So Tesla, let's go back. How did you connect with Ilan in
- 23:40the first place? Or how did you get to Tesla?
- 23:43So it, as we talked about, I Was a Serial entrepreneur.
- 23:45I had just started my sixth company which was basically a
- 23:49software that powers all of the driver scores.
- 23:51You see, insurance companies now, talking about.
- 23:53So, if you see the State Bar map, or the Allstate app or the
- 23:57progressive a poor Geico app that scores you're driving.
- 24:00That's our Technology, that's driving that.
- 24:02So I just started that company. And through a series of crazy
- 24:05events Sheryl, Sandberg introduced Ilana night and we
- 24:10hit it off because I think our backgrounds is entrepreneurs but
- 24:14I had had experience in manufacturing.
- 24:16A lot of experience an auto and so we immediately just hit it
- 24:20off. We when we met each other.
- 24:21Ilan said, hey, I want your perspective on this problem, I'm
- 24:26having the factory. And so like I said I've seen
- 24:29that kind of problem before we broke down the It's it like here
- 24:32probably where you're going to find the constraints and then
- 24:35the solutions. And so we talked through it, he
- 24:38went and applied what we talked about it worked.
- 24:41So we got a second phone, call it similar thing but very
- 24:45different, he said here's problem of having in my in my
- 24:47distribution sales Channel. What do you think?
- 24:49And so we work through that problem together.
- 24:51We're you interviewing in your mind or you know it's like we
- 24:53were just getting to know each other.
- 24:55Like I was getting to know somebody and a true like, you
- 24:58know, his he's got a fascinating mind, he's got a super Super
- 25:01unique intellect and is very deeply involved in the business
- 25:06still. And so we are able to get into
- 25:08the depths of a problem, not at a theoretical level, but at a
- 25:11factual level because he had the facts because he was involved in
- 25:14the business and whether it was a manufacturing problem, a
- 25:17distribution problem, a marketing Problem, whatever.
- 25:20We just kind of started to brainstorm about these started
- 25:23to talk more often and then eventually he said, hey, would
- 25:25you join Tesla? And I said, what did you do?
- 25:28I haven't, I haven't had a boss in.
- 25:31Many years. Like it is good.
- 25:32I don't even know how to do this, but if you're willing to
- 25:35take the risk, like, I'm going to because I for me, I felt like
- 25:40I was gonna get a chance to learn from the best practitioner
- 25:44of my craft as an entrepreneur. You can't point to anybody in
- 25:50our space who is created as much value as Elon Musk.
- 25:54What was your title when you came in president?
- 25:57Yeah, and you were you were the number two basically, the time.
- 26:01Well, I was on a team of five or six people.
- 26:04Senior leadership team, all of which like we kind of joined
- 26:07arms and we really didn't treat each other.
- 26:10Like we had titles or roles. We are trying to solve big props
- 26:14and big opportunities and we did it together.
- 26:16So I didn't feel like a number 2, 3 4 5, I felt like I was on,
- 26:20I felt like I was on this team with Greg and joy.
- 26:23Jerome and Doug and Deepak and Franz Etc.
- 26:27And we were arm and arm trying to do the impossible.
- 26:31What was the impossible that time or while you were there?
- 26:33What was the 4chan? Well, when I joined the first
- 26:36challenge we had, was to make a corner.
- 26:37They hadn't really made a quarter since they've been
- 26:39public. And we were more than halfway
- 26:42through the quarter and half way through the sales goal, not even
- 26:45close to halfway through this right school.
- 26:47And so, the first challenge was like, how do we sell enough
- 26:50units to actually make plan? That was the first Challenge and
- 26:55business hadn't thought about a funnel before.
- 26:57So, I introduced this concept of a funnel sales funnel where we
- 27:01had to pull people, through the sales funnel, and really change
- 27:03our conversion rates. First of all, we had to know our
- 27:05conversion rates and then change them in an engineering
- 27:08environment. That went a long ways for
- 27:10credibility because people said, this is the first time we've had
- 27:13an executive. Look at the problem, break it
- 27:15down mathematically and show us how we can actually hit plan
- 27:20with math. And so we went out to the team
- 27:22worldwide and We made our first quarter and that was the big
- 27:25that was a big Challenge and then we made another quarter and
- 27:28then another quarter. But then we had to do things
- 27:30like introducing new models and doing that with no cash
- 27:36basically in creating manufacturing lines, out of
- 27:39tense. So we could get these cars out
- 27:42and get the cash generated to get where you there when Ilan
- 27:46said he looked back and said, we could have gone bankrupt.
- 27:49Were you there though? We were yeah.
- 27:51For more than two years we operated at And we just had a
- 27:54quarters worth of cash. So that was for real.
- 27:57Like we could have without the work of all the people who are
- 28:01Tesla and on the team at that time, for sure.
- 28:04Bankruptcy was reality and when your peering over the edge of
- 28:08death like creativity starts to happen and really unique ways.
- 28:13And we had a bunch of creative people that really helped us get
- 28:16through that time. You know.
- 28:17I'm clearly likes the sort of pressure cooker environment,
- 28:20right? Like, I don't know.
- 28:21It feels like, you know, For most CEOs, you wouldn't want a
- 28:25company that close to death, especially a public company that
- 28:29has some Goodwill. Like the company could have been
- 28:32run in a way that it wasn't as close to death, right.
- 28:35Or do you think it was intentional to motivate?
- 28:37Well, you're tough to capitalize a company completely that it has
- 28:39never shown positive cash flow and so there was only so much
- 28:44Capital. You could raise on the way to
- 28:46each new product launch, but each new product launch takes
- 28:49billions of dollars. So, there's only so much
- 28:51Capital, you can raise in. So it's a bit of Pressure cooker
- 28:54and it's a super hard business. I've never seen a business as
- 28:56hard as the car business car manufacturing business and it's
- 29:00why nobody's really created a new successful car company in
- 29:03almost 100 years. It's really hard and I almost
- 29:06have maniacal and crazy to attempt it and to get through
- 29:10it. So by its nature, it's a
- 29:12pressure cooker and their different ways.
- 29:14People manage to the pressure and elon's got his way and I had
- 29:17my way and that was a largely complementary in the rest of the
- 29:19people on the team to we had this melted kind of approach.
- 29:22It was somewhere in the tinium of for an attic and somewhere on
- 29:25the Continuum of calm and between calm and frenetic.
- 29:28We found a path through now. Super proud to be a part of
- 29:31that. Is he the CEO?
- 29:32Like you know he has SpaceX I mean now it's a but he was use
- 29:37you know doing most of the CEO things you'd expect and not.
- 29:41Yes absolutely public. Absolutely.
- 29:43Yep. I mean it's one of the most
- 29:45famous people in the world. Certainly the most, I think,
- 29:47famous business person. I mean, what is sort of the
- 29:50genius like inside the company? I think people see the sort of
- 29:53Salesman aspect instead of the be able to sort of cell
- 29:56division. But like, what's his sort of
- 29:59strength? Yeah, from inside a company,
- 30:01like, Tessa, I think people will read books about this someday
- 30:06but he's got a company that has an operating Cadence of seven
- 30:10days a weekly operating Cadence. And what I mean by that is, if
- 30:14you're an engineer working on a problem and there are several
- 30:17problems that really matter and they just presented this at
- 30:20their investor day. So manufacturing really matters
- 30:23energy, density. City per dollar really matters.
- 30:25And so there are a few of these big problems that if you're
- 30:28working on your in front of the CEO, every week showing
- 30:31progress. And if you're not showing
- 30:33progress, you know, there's obviously trouble in running a
- 30:36company on a weekly, Cadence like that.
- 30:38A weekly release in Hardware is very unique to the Auto
- 30:43industry. It's a software approach in
- 30:45hardware and maybe one of the toughest Hardware businesses in
- 30:48the world and that is a key part of the secret sauce where you've
- 30:53got to see. You're challenging, viewpoints
- 30:55challenging physics, challenging manufacturing theory on a weekly
- 30:59basis. And the whole company is getting
- 31:01better as a result of that Weekly.
- 31:04Do you borrow from that? Do you think many people can
- 31:06turn, you know, that Cadence requires sort of a lot of effort
- 31:10and it means that you turn more people.
- 31:14You are there three years? A lot of people do turn out of
- 31:18Tesla. Do you think like, I mean, the
- 31:20celebrity and sort of the mission, certainly the mission,
- 31:23the ability to recruit people. Yeah.
- 31:25Something, they believe in. Like, do you think like, I don't
- 31:29know, your average like software business can replicate sort of
- 31:33the Elan management style without others, really?
- 31:35Like, it's all of us as managers have a style, like we have a
- 31:38personal style, you got a communication style, you got a
- 31:41management style, and I believe everybody should really find
- 31:44their optimal style for the way they're wired.
- 31:47Ilan. Has that for him?
- 31:48I have that for me. It's different.
- 31:50If I try to replicate his, it wouldn't work.
- 31:52I don't think mine For him. But he's got a capability of
- 31:55doing this model with intensity in a really effective way and
- 32:01it's Unique to him and that's why he's uniquely successful.
- 32:03I think have I tried to apply it.
- 32:05Heck yeah. Like we run on a weekly, Cadence
- 32:08at edx and we run on a process and we're continually pushing
- 32:11that process and pushing each other.
- 32:13And when we recruited people into Tesla, we would use this
- 32:17analog that you're not getting recruited here for regular army,
- 32:22you're signing up for Special Forces.
- 32:23Isis. What does that mean?
- 32:25That means you're going to be on a small team of Highly capable
- 32:27people doing highly intense things.
- 32:30So there is not going to be much down time.
- 32:32There's going to be a lot of fun, task time, and your talk do
- 32:36ratio has to be way inverted from maybe where you've been
- 32:39before, you've got a double, but when you deliver, I guarantee
- 32:44you, you will be doing the best work of your life and that's
- 32:47what addictive about working at Tesla is because, you know, you
- 32:50can go other places in code, you go other places and in Are you
- 32:53can go other places in manage but you probably won't be doing
- 32:56the best work of your life because you're not going to be
- 32:58part of an organization that has that push and Cadence.
- 33:01But we try to do this at dvx to say if you're here, we want you
- 33:05to be all in and doing the best work your life.
- 33:08And this is a method that we use to get there.
- 33:10Do you think that story is still true today for Tesla?
- 33:15I do when I watch the investor day in which the guys that are
- 33:17on that team today, who were there?
- 33:19We're in more Junior when I was there, but I worked with all of
- 33:22them. I see that they are continuing.
- 33:25That raised the bar raised, the bar raised, the bar raised the
- 33:27bar. I mean, they're our aim is to
- 33:29take 50% of the cost of the manufacturing base, over the
- 33:32course of what I think is probably two years that is super
- 33:36intense, super hard to do. And nobody has done that in
- 33:38their industry and they're setting out to go do it.
- 33:41So, yeah, that process on that outcome is definitely
- 33:44perpetuating today, but they're going to need a new vehicle,
- 33:47right? Yeah.
- 33:48When you take 50% of the cost out, you're going to have a new
- 33:50vehicle. You're going to have a mass
- 33:51Market vehicle. That is Very different from the
- 33:54model 3 today. Oh you're saying sort of lower,
- 33:57the cost of the vehicles are selling a, they're going to have
- 34:00a slightly different design and different Mechanicals.
- 34:02Different engineering would probably different chemistry.
- 34:05I don't know if I mean, he Lon he's good at talking about these
- 34:08things for so long. I guess the media is so much
- 34:11expectations versus reality. So, on the one hand we're super
- 34:14complicit, it's like, oh, he's willing to set these super high
- 34:19expectations. We've been talking about
- 34:20self-driving, we've been talking about Chuck, you know, he has a
- 34:24real truck, you know, the semi like allegedly you know, it's
- 34:28all so the media you know gets and then we seem really - on
- 34:32Ilan also because he got us excited about those things early
- 34:36and we're like where are they? And then we see him sort of like
- 34:39scold. So I feel like we are
- 34:42unfortunately getting played by Elon sort of on both sides and
- 34:45that we're some of the biggest sort of boosters and then also
- 34:49get to be his foil by being overly - I don't know like Are
- 34:54there other it's Unique business in the how much they talk about?
- 34:59How much, the company talks about things?
- 35:01It hasn't delivered on yet? I mean, would you would you
- 35:04accept that that there's a lot of forward talk in terms of what
- 35:07the company can deliver? I think you're seeing in scale
- 35:11in a very public way, the way a lot of entrepreneurs work and
- 35:16that is entrepreneurs tend to set really ambitious targets,
- 35:21entrepreneurs by Nature optimistic, How about how long
- 35:25and how much capital is going to take to get to those targets?
- 35:27They always think it's going to be faster than it really is.
- 35:30But they're setting these ambitious targets out in front
- 35:32of an organization or maybe out in front of themselves and you
- 35:35sort of say if I hit 80 percent of that I'm going to be super
- 35:38sight but it probably not going to be on the time frame that I
- 35:41think it's going to be but I'm going to push for that
- 35:43entrepreneurs are doing this every day.
- 35:44I caught myself doing this in every one of my companies that I
- 35:47built and people would complain. They would say, you know, you
- 35:50were way too, ambitious, you're crazy to think we.
- 35:53This done this fast entrepreneur is here that constantly with
- 35:56Ilan. You're seeing this in a very
- 35:58public way but he is unique in that he's not dialing that back
- 36:03to please. The public markets, to please
- 36:05the Press excetera. He's very much just being an
- 36:07entrepreneur and so I think it's combination of setting these
- 36:11ambitious targets. But at the same time he's a
- 36:14rational business person. And he says, okay, here's how
- 36:18much cash flow I can get from these different products.
- 36:21Here's how much cash flow I can get from a model y.
- 36:23Versus the Cyber truck. So, guess what I'm going to
- 36:27choose to produce model y across as many factories as I can,
- 36:30because the cash flow profile of that is much higher than the
- 36:33Cyber truck, right? Pickups are largely a North
- 36:36American and South American product, you don't see big
- 36:39pickups in Europe, you don't see them in Asia, but you see,
- 36:42hatchback, crossover, SUVs, or SUVs in every market.
- 36:47So, he's just making rational decisions at the back.
- 36:49End of his business to I see maryborough doing this a GM,
- 36:54she's making very rational Is about the model lineup.
- 36:56Switch comes when balancing her PL and her cash flows and
- 37:01working with her team on vehicle lineup as well student, you
- 37:05know, very similar, really rational logical approach to
- 37:09managing a balance sheet which is the other aspect that you
- 37:12have to do. So sometimes the Press gets that
- 37:14and sometimes they don't, it wouldn't take much for the press
- 37:17to size the market for model, why sighs the market for cyber
- 37:20truck and figure out, this is exactly why he's delaying cyber
- 37:23truck, but I feel like the Press doesn't do their homework.
- 37:25Go go with what's work. The thing, you know, you can
- 37:28make money off. What do you do with the thing
- 37:30that has the larger Tam? And the larger cache free cash
- 37:32flow profile. And the thing that you're
- 37:34already producing and make it produce more at scale?
- 37:37Yeah, you're going to you're going to deliver a divot.
- 37:40Okay. I'll but are you a little bit
- 37:42with their questions about the used car market and this signal
- 37:44that that sending about Teslas Vehicles, right?
- 37:47I mean, do you worry about? I think what you're moving price
- 37:50around as much yet, one of the downsides of moving price around
- 37:53as much as Tesla has moved it around for the last few years.
- 37:56Is the used car impact of that or the just the value of the
- 38:00vehicle that somebody has taken a loan out on or somebody's
- 38:04taking a lease option? And, yeah, they're definitely
- 38:07Downstream effects to some of those decisions there are not
- 38:11positive for consumers, right? I mean, but you don't think it
- 38:14hurts Tesla. The company I would say it
- 38:16hasn't hurt demand so far, it may in the future but it hasn't
- 38:19hurt demand. So far, self-driving, cars.
- 38:21You experience them in some form of Tesla, you know, certainly at
- 38:25live If there were Partnerships and work, you're on the board of
- 38:29GM. You were saying, you know, for
- 38:31Kirby, still premise on a long-term self-driving.
- 38:34Future, what's your sense of the timeline?
- 38:36Now you know the timeline has been slower.
- 38:38I think than people thought and that's hurting times businesses
- 38:41you have a sense of I don't know how optimistic are you.
- 38:45That we're going to see real movement there.
- 38:48I think we're now in the precipice like GM is the
- 38:51majority shareholder. A cruise cruise is deployed.
- 38:55Driverless autonomous cars on the Streets of San Francisco
- 38:59through the whole city. One of the most difficult
- 39:01environments in the world. They've now deployed them in
- 39:03Austin in Phoenix and are deploying them across the
- 39:06country way. MO is doing something similar,
- 39:09and I think all of the solutions been a long time, coming and
- 39:11autonomy, now we're actually seeing the rollout of this
- 39:14technology and the commercialization of the
- 39:16technology. So now you can go take a driver,
- 39:19this ride in a number of cities in the US and it's as normal as
- 39:23hailing any other kind of rad share their the full Coverage of
- 39:26these cities or Cruz has full coverage of the cities that it's
- 39:28in. Yeah.
- 39:29So, including San Francisco. So it's, it's wall-to-wall in
- 39:33San Francisco. So I do think it's been a long
- 39:35time coming, but now we're on it and the rollout is happening and
- 39:39that's really exciting for me, I think a lot of people to see
- 39:43because the goal isn't just the magical experience of having
- 39:47nobody in the driver's seat. The goal is eliminating.
- 39:50The 50,000 deaths that happened as a result of car accidents
- 39:55that are Almost 90 95 % + caused by human error.
- 40:00So if we can get 50,000 families, not too experienced a
- 40:03tragedy like a death every year, right?
- 40:06The big deal. And that's, and that's just in
- 40:08the u.s. Our roads are safer than the
- 40:10rest of the rules and in the world.
- 40:11So if you could roll this out worldwide, you're talking about,
- 40:13saving a million and a half lives every year.
- 40:15It's a really big deal, right? I mean it's crazy to me that
- 40:19human be, I really do think there will be a time where we
- 40:21look back and it's crazy that we let ya human beings like drive
- 40:24around it. 70 miles per hour just like right next to each
- 40:27other and it will seem like right really?
- 40:29Yeah. All right.
- 40:29Yeah. Just for another loan while
- 40:31you're doing that excetera. Yeah.
- 40:32Totally. But we didn't have the
- 40:34technology and now we do. And so thank God, like some
- 40:38really creative people like I like Cruz some really effective
- 40:41technologists set out to solve this problem and they have I
- 40:45still feel like, I feel like I would feel it more.
- 40:48If it were so close or it feels like they're okay, they're
- 40:51deploying in cities. But most people, you know, I
- 40:53feel like my friends in San Francisco, doesn't sound like
- 40:55Taking autonomous vehicles all the time or like, what's the
- 40:58limiting factor for it to be a real like economic mover for
- 41:04those cities and forces? I think these, you know, these
- 41:06cities have literally just opened up over the past few
- 41:08months to this. And so I think right now you've
- 41:11got folks that were early adopter including it myself for
- 41:14doing this and now you'll see it moved to the mass Market.
- 41:17As you know let's say the next time you and I get together for
- 41:20a coffee and San Francisco and I say hey I'm going to have a
- 41:23cruise. How about you?
- 41:23He'll at Cruise. I'll meet you over here and That
- 41:25kind of morality is now just starting and so you'll now see
- 41:29this build over time. It's really like if you consider
- 41:32like when the first Tesla roadsters were produce, there's
- 41:36a handful of people in Silicon Valley, they had those.
- 41:39And these started to notice like oh cheese Steve jurvetson
- 41:42striving one of these things jurvetson.
- 41:44Why you driving this? It's a fantastic car.
- 41:46Hop in and let me show you how fast this thing accelerates and
- 41:48little by little you had this ver ality start but it starts
- 41:51from a small base and we're starting from the small base.
- 41:53So I think with autonomous right now and It will start to become
- 41:56a movement over time and I think it's not going to take nearly as
- 42:00long as it took for Rideshare and some other Technologies to.
- 42:03Well I do we were once an autonomous vehicle together.
- 42:06I think in that in in Las Vegas Vegas, I forgot which is a
- 42:10partner was, right? That's that's emotional car.
- 42:13It was a partner of lifts, but you still have the driver in the
- 42:16seat of that car. We were and this now would be a
- 42:19very different experience because now there's there's
- 42:21nobody in the front seats. Yeah.
- 42:24I mean, The ride-sharing phenomenal.
- 42:27I mean, I look back it to me like Lyft line, and pool.
- 42:31And then autonomous is some point where Sookie to the like
- 42:35technological vision of ride sharing in that they're, they're
- 42:38really would be these efficiency gains by building up the
- 42:43Network's. Yeah.
- 42:44That didn't happen, right? Why do you think carpooling
- 42:47didn't work and does that undermine sort of the case that
- 42:52you know, ride-sharing was a step change over?
- 42:55Any more than taxi with a phone. If you can't make the carpooling
- 43:00or autonomous features work, I think we were interrupted by
- 43:04this crazy externality, a pandemic.
- 43:07And so let's open the car pooling work until we had a
- 43:11pandemic. And then like this externality
- 43:14came in that nobody anticipated and wisely both Uber and Lyft
- 43:18killed their carpooling product, during the pandemic, because it
- 43:22would have been irresponsible to do anything else.
- 43:24And now they're building. It back but we were interrupted
- 43:27for like two years of adoption when the adoption was super high
- 43:30and those products because the economics are great and the
- 43:33social aspects are kind of cool too.
- 43:35But what happened during the pandemic was, you know,
- 43:38obviously we didn't want to be in cars with each other and so
- 43:41people went out and bought their own vehicle as kind of PPE.
- 43:45And so you remember that like, these were record years for car
- 43:49sales or the past two and a half three years because people were
- 43:53buying their own car. So they wouldn't have to be in a
- 43:54car of somebody. And I think the whole movement
- 43:57towards far, less cars and cities got setback.
- 44:01Maybe by a decade or more, and I say a decade, because the
- 44:04average car park is now 11 to 13 years old.
- 44:08So that means somebody bought a car this year.
- 44:10Probably not getting that car for another decade and therefore
- 44:14they're going to be in Rideshare lesson in carpooling Less in a
- 44:18public transit less because they have their own way to get around
- 44:21and they're on the hook for a 72 month loan on that thing.
- 44:25So, Yeah, I think that externality of the pandemic
- 44:28really set this Vision back, unfortunately, which also speaks
- 44:32why, you know, having a delivery business on top of your ride
- 44:36sharing business. I mean, hard to know that, that
- 44:38was a pandemic Hedge for Uber, but then that ends up really
- 44:41hurting subunit. Lived, I mean, I feel like you
- 44:44can get the message like, oh, you should focus on what you're
- 44:46good at and then it's like, oh, you should have like multiple
- 44:49lines of business. I don't how does not improve or
- 44:52likes or those are just two irreconcilable.
- 44:55Saleable piece of advice. Generally, I've found that if
- 44:58you have all your eggs in one basket, that is not a very sound
- 45:01strategy. So you need to have some other
- 45:04forms of income or Revenue because yeah things can
- 45:09sideswipe you like a pandemic that you'll you'll never see
- 45:12coming and that happens did that having little real world.
- 45:15So you need to have other products of the revenue streams
- 45:18that help you weather that storm and so like in Tesla's case
- 45:22today, if the car market goes suddenly sideways and they're
- 45:24selling a lot less. Cars they can fall back on their
- 45:27entire base. They're selling Insurance into
- 45:29that base. They're selling infotainment
- 45:31into that base. They have Diversified Revenue
- 45:34sources just beyond selling the car.
- 45:36An Uber did that too? Uber said, we need to have other
- 45:39Revenue sources because the world doesn't work straight up
- 45:43into the right. And so, if we're only having one
- 45:45egg in one basket, that's a vulnerable position to be in.
- 45:48As an entrepreneur, just related to the delivery in your general
- 45:52expertise, some of these Real World Tech businesses.
- 45:55I feel The cloud kitchens ghost kitchens thing is like falling
- 45:59out over the conversation a little bit.
- 46:01I mean, they operate more behind the scenes and I what?
- 46:04I think I saw Tick Tock the other day.
- 46:05Someone's like, oh, I'm ordering from Danny's, which has some
- 46:08Rebrand as something else. I didn't realize anyway, so
- 46:11they're clearly still going. But do you feel strongly about
- 46:14this sort of ghost, kitchen, Cloud, Kitchen business, or
- 46:18those companies doing well? I don't know, right?
- 46:20I don't know enough about like where they are today because
- 46:23they're pretty opaque in terms of You know, how large they are,
- 46:26what sort of Revenue they're generating was sort of profits,
- 46:28they're generating. So I just don't have enough
- 46:31fact-based even answer the question.
- 46:33Yeah, it's not just not enough to just yet.
- 46:35People just aren't divulging, kind of how the business is
- 46:37doing. Have you thought about anything
- 46:39in food in your sort of company, idea, generation or that's,
- 46:43that's not yet. Fruit is not hit the radar.
- 46:46Like we're helping young families with a company called
- 46:49Loop, that allows them to rent, baby gear, and it just had stuff
- 46:53that they need. So that, you know, in big
- 46:55cities. You don't have much room in an
- 46:56apartment. You can't fill the apartment
- 46:58with stuff. So we're working on problems
- 47:00like that. We're working on hi
- 47:01consideration shopping with a platform that we've gotten beta.
- 47:05We are working on hva sees High considerations shopping start so
- 47:09that's men hi consideration purchase so like say an
- 47:12expensive purchase. Like if you're going to go
- 47:14purchase a washer and dryer or a car, nobody's really attacked
- 47:18that problem in a unique way and so we've got a team.
- 47:20Is it about financing? Or is it a pill?
- 47:22It's mainly about Discovery and I'm like, okay, you compare
- 47:27washers and what really matters, it turns out percent of washers
- 47:32that break our front loaders, not top loaders.
- 47:35So if you knew that one's act, then that helps your Discovery
- 47:38process. It says, maybe I'm not going to
- 47:40look at front loaders. Maybe I should look at top
- 47:42loaders because they break down a lot less.
- 47:44We've got a business work in an h v, AC and commercial buildings
- 47:47and taking 50% of the energy cost those buildings out.
- 47:50And so we're working across like a lot of these different
- 47:52problems, but none food-related yet.
- 47:55Okay. Yeah.
- 47:57What is the business like is that a consumer report?
- 48:00Sort of like, wire isn't like a media publication?
- 48:03Or is it we're in beta on this? We haven't really talked about a
- 48:06lot of it but okay. Yeah.
- 48:07Like one of the things that led to this idea was a few of us
- 48:11were shopping for stuff like a washer and dryer and said isn't
- 48:16it interesting that like when you go on consumer reports that
- 48:19the products that they're recommending?
- 48:21When you go out to buy those products though?
- 48:23They have the lowest review scores It's like how could that
- 48:26be? And it turns out that it looks
- 48:29like the quality of the consumer reports research and
- 48:34recommendations is gone down precipitously over time.
- 48:37And so there is a vacuum in that space to go figure out like
- 48:42could somebody fill this in a different way and so a guy on
- 48:46our team, he's super talented Rich hung who was part of the
- 48:49early Google shopping effort. He and I kind of started to Riff
- 48:53on this idea and shared a vision and so He's built the platform
- 48:56and now, we're out working on the minimum viable product, and
- 49:00testing it out in the market. But yeah, it'll be some
- 49:02combination of media and comparison tools that haven't
- 49:05existed before and, and some magic that were thrown into your
- 49:09decision to get in this the hatching business.
- 49:11Did you think about sort of the more traditional Venture path
- 49:15and like, I'm curious what? Yeah, I mean, you clearly went
- 49:20this direction but do you think The Venture industry is going to
- 49:25be more more challenged now, our was there anything about the
- 49:29Venture side of things that turned you away from it?
- 49:32Or it was just the appeal, there were a couple of things.
- 49:35There's a there's there's a couple things that I thought
- 49:38were ready to be kind of modernized in Ventura like the
- 49:41current Venture model of searching for entrepreneurs
- 49:46raising you know Distributing capital on the part of LPS for a
- 49:502% management fee and a 20% Kerry has Has not changed in
- 49:55decades. And I thought there might
- 49:58sometimes they get three and thirty you know, that sometimes
- 50:00I get. Yeah, when you get really good
- 50:01at it, when you get really good at it like Sequoia and Benchmark
- 50:05and some others you can get 3 and 30 but I thought maybe the
- 50:08maybe there's a more systematic way to go about this.
- 50:11What if there was a systematic way that you could create
- 50:13companies out of great ideas and so for me it's just a different
- 50:16approach. I had some friends close friends
- 50:19who are in the music business and when I discovered like how
- 50:22the music business Kind of structured.
- 50:24This really made sense to me and apply to dvx.
- 50:27There are generally in the music business.
- 50:31There are songwriters who are generating the content.
- 50:33There are performers that proliferate that content and
- 50:36their distribution, that take that content, plus performers
- 50:40and distribute it. And there are these songwriters
- 50:43guilds where you have people that have this, like, awesome,
- 50:46songwriting disease, and they find each other, and they get
- 50:49together in places like La in Nashville, and Berlin and other
- 50:52places around the world. Old.
- 50:53And they generate, they have this gift of generating massive
- 50:57amounts of content songs. Then they're paired with
- 51:02performers. Most performers aren't selling
- 51:05writers, most performers need content, somebody else, writes
- 51:08hits that somebody else writes, right.
- 51:10And I felt like we were kind of a Song Writers Guild, but in the
- 51:15business sense, like we have this disease where we see
- 51:18opportunities, where other people don't and we kick out a
- 51:21lot of ideas. Some are good, some are bad.
- 51:23Add. But we keep holding the best
- 51:25ones and we've got the capability turning those into
- 51:27hits. So in that sense were a singer
- 51:29songwriter and that's an approach that works for us.
- 51:32It wouldn't work for every VC. I think it works for us because
- 51:35we've been both idea generators and we've been scaled operators.
- 51:39And so we're uniquely kind of skilled to attack a problem in a
- 51:42different way than most species are.
- 51:44Does that mean like they BC? 1.0 model is dead.
- 51:47No, it doesn't. But it's mean that there is a
- 51:49different way that will kind of proliferate.
- 51:51Now, I think so because you've Got folks like us you got
- 51:54Flagship to generating you know 75 companies like moderna and
- 51:57indigo Aggie, consider Hills generating companies like like
- 52:00prism and pure and snowflake. Exactly systematically did
- 52:05generating companies and I think there is another way that's
- 52:08being created and I would call that VC 2.0.
- 52:10Does it mean that's going to be 100 percent of the market know?
- 52:12But is it going to be a significant percent of the
- 52:14market? I'd say probably, isn't it
- 52:16decade from now it probably is a significant chunk of the early
- 52:19stage Market. Yeah.
- 52:21He's if you, if you have the idea, you should you get to keep
- 52:24the economics, if you don't, you don't.
- 52:28Yeah, it's you own 50% of that company at the end of the
- 52:30funding cycle, 50% beats a 20% carry every day that week.
- 52:34So I think just the capital rational Capital will follow
- 52:39down this path and you're much more invested in sort of seeing
- 52:43the company through and working. Well, yeah, in a way that if you
- 52:47don't, you're like, listen, I'm on to the next one.
- 52:50You? Good luck.
- 52:51You have my that's right. Yeah, that's right.
- 52:53And we're certainly seeing that the downturn where you know,
- 52:56people are sort of shrugging off their losses and some cases.
- 53:00Yeah, I think our co-investors know we're not walking away from
- 53:02this, we're going to make them work and so that gives investors
- 53:05that invest alongside of us. A lot of Comfort Suite.
- 53:08John this is great. Thanks so much for coming on the
- 53:10podcast. Pat, thanks for heavier, been
- 53:11fun to talk to you. Thanks a bunch.
- 53:14That was my interview with John McNeil investor at dvx former
- 53:18executive and lift, and Tesla. Thanks for Inning.
- 53:21Shout out our editor, Tommy Heron, my chief of staff.
- 53:24So, Riley kinsella. The wonderful music is brought
- 53:28to you by Young Chomsky. I'm Eric newcomer, like,
- 53:31comment, subscribe on YouTube. Subscribe to the newsletter
- 53:35newcomer dotco. See you next week.
- 53:37Thanks, goodbye. Goodbye.