Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 164. Rethinks: Using "Pre-suasion" to Influence Others
Transcript
- 0:00Matt Abrahams: Hi, Matt here.
- 0:01If you think about it, most of our communication attempts to influence and persuade others to our point of view.
- 0:08We're opening up our archive to bring you a best of episode, where I speak with world renowned persuasion researcher Robert Cialdini, who discussed with me how we can be more effective in both our persuasion and pre-suasion.
- 0:23Listen in to help you get your point of view across better.
- 0:29Regardless of if you're pitching or presenting, teaching or sharing, at its core, communication is often about influencing and motivating others.
- 0:39Yet we don't often take time to think about how to hone and improve our persuasive practices.
- 0:45Today, we will dive deeply into the intricacies of influence.
- 0:50I am Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:55Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 1:03Today, I am super excited to get a chance to chat with Robert Cialdini.
- 1:06Bob is the Regents Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Marketing at Arizona State University.
- 1:13His research and coaching focus on persuasion and social influence.
- 1:18He's the author of two amazingly popular and impactful books, Influence and Pre-Suasion.
- 1:25And I have to admit, Bob is one of my academic heroes.
- 1:29As an undergrad, Bob was a guest lecturer in Phil Zimbardo's popular class, The Psychology of Mind Control.
- 1:36And after hearing Bob's lecture, I chose a graduate school program where I could do research into social influence.
- 1:43Welcome, Bob.
- 1:44And thanks for pointing me to a field of study that I have continued to be fascinated by.
- 1:48Robert Cialdini: Well, I'm looking forward to our interaction, Matt, and look forward to spending some time with you and your listeners.
- 1:56Matt Abrahams: Great, let's jump right in.
- 1:58To get started, can you define and distinguish between persuasion and what you call pre-suasion?
- 2:07And what role does attention and motivation play in these concepts?
- 2:12Robert Cialdini: Oh, good question.
- 2:13Let's start with motivation first, which is the functional component of persuasion.
- 2:20Persuasion involves putting into a message factors that motivate people to say yes.
- 2:27Such as the quality of an item or its attractive price or its fit with the recipient's values or self image or the fact that it's the most popular choice among their peers.
- 2:40Those kinds of things, if you put those into a message, they motivate people toward assent.
- 2:48Tension, on the other hand, is the functional component of pre-suasion.
- 2:54It involves focusing people on, that is, putting them in mind of, one of those motivators before they encounter it in the communicator's message.
- 3:07Let's take an example.
- 3:09There was a study done with a furniture store that had its specialty sofas.
- 3:17And for half of the visitors to the store, researchers arranged for them to go to a landing page that had as its background fluffy clouds.
- 3:28The other half of the visitors went to a different landing page.
- 3:33The content was identical, but its background was small coins, pennies.
- 3:40Then the researchers gave the visitors options of various sofas to choose.
- 3:47What they found was that those who encountered fluffy clouds were more likely to choose for purchase comfortable furniture.
- 4:00Whereas those who were exposed to pennies were more likely to prefer for purchase inexpensive furniture.
- 4:09So whichever motivator of behavior, in this case, quality or price, was made salient, was brought to consciousness before they ever encountered the request to choose one or another of the kinds of sofas directed the visitors to the one that was high in consciousness, was most accessible to them at the time.
- 4:39And there's an interesting mediator of all of this.
- 4:42And that is that not only did these visitors choose more high quality furniture or less expensive furniture, depending on which landing page they saw.
- 4:56Those people who saw clouds rated comfort as more important to them in deciding what to choose in a sofa.
- 5:07Whereas those who saw the pennies rated cost as more important to them in their decisions.
- 5:17Matt Abrahams: This is absolutely fascinating to me.
- 5:20So what you can do in advance of actually even issuing your message can influence people by managing their attention.
- 5:32In some ways it's priming and framing, isn't it?
- 5:36Robert Cialdini: It is.
- 5:37It's what I call using an opener, bringing people's focus of attention onto something that is nested in the message that is yet to come before that message is delivered.
- 5:51So they have been readied for the concept, it's become more cognitively accessible and more important in their minds.
- 6:02Here's an example that reinforced this idea.
- 6:05There was a study of a wine shop in which the proprietor played either German or French music on the music system as visitors came in.
- 6:20Those who heard French music were more likely to buy a French vintage.
- 6:25Those who heard German music were more likely to buy A bottle of German wine.
- 6:33Because things German or things French had been made more accessible in consciousness and made to seem more significant or to have greater import for their decision.
- 6:47Because it was high in consciousness at the time.
- 6:52Matt Abrahams: This to me really expands what we as communicators should be thinking about when we are crafting our influential messages.
- 7:03So I'm thinking things like the room in which we speak, how we organize it.
- 7:08The images we put on the slides that we might use.
- 7:13Are these the sort of things you're thinking about that can really influence people before the messages arrive?
- 7:20Robert Cialdini: Exactly.
- 7:20Let's say you have a meeting of people who are on your team and you're trying to break through with a problem that's just has just resisted your attempts to solve it.
- 7:32You need to think about broadly about it.
- 7:34You need to think expansively about this topic rather than stay located in the frames of the approach you were taking.
- 7:43It turns out if you go into a room with high ceilings and big windows, that expanse of the environment causes people to think more expansively and creatively.
- 7:58Matt Abrahams: That's great.
- 7:59I wonder now that we're all virtual or many of us are still virtual, if the background image we put behind us might be influential.
- 8:08I think there's just so many things that we could play with now.
- 8:11And you've opened up a sandbox here that we can be thinking about these things.
- 8:15Wonderful.
- 8:16That's great.
- 8:17Pre-suasion is really, really fascinating to me, and I appreciate you illuminating that for us.
- 8:24You know, I shared that you had a big impact on my choice when I went to graduate school, but my interest in persuasion actually started when I was a young boy.
- 8:33I vividly remember my father reading a newspaper back in the day when people actually read newspapers in paper.
- 8:40And he was laughing from behind the paper, and I asked him what he was laughing at.
- 8:43And he showed me a comic strip.
- 8:45And in the comic strip, there was a picture of a father with his arm around his son, pointing at a store that the father clearly owned.
- 8:52And across the store was the sign, going out of business sale.
- 8:57And the caption read, someday son, this will all be yours.
- 9:02And I was befuddled.
- 9:03I didn't understand why my father found that so funny.
- 9:06And he explained it to me that the store was perpetually going out of business, that it was a marketing ploy to get people to come in.
- 9:13And that was my first introduction to the idea of scarcity.
- 9:18And in your book, Influence, you identify scarcity as a technique among others.
- 9:23And I'm wondering if you can take a moment to explain how that technique works and how you've seen it used today.
- 9:30Robert Cialdini: People want more of those things they can have less of.
- 9:33A thing that is scarce, rare, dwindling in availability becomes more attractive.
- 9:40And one major reason is loss aversion.
- 9:43The prospects of losing something of value are twice as potent in motivating action then the prospects of gaining that very same resource.
- 9:59So in the case of loss, loss is the ultimate form of scarcity.
- 10:08It means you can't have it anymore.
- 10:10So people want those things that are dwindling in availability or scarcer, or, you know, the acronym FOMO, fear of missing out.
- 10:20That's essentially what I think is a major part of why scarcity works as powerfully as it does.
- 10:27Matt Abrahams: So people can manufacture scarcity to motivate action in the direction that they want, uh, and companies can as well.
- 10:37I mean, if you look at eBay, most of the exciting action happens as those auctions are coming closer and closer to ending.
- 10:45Is that all correct?
- 10:47Robert Cialdini: That's exactly right.
- 10:48Matt Abrahams: In addition to scarcity, you highlight six other principles of persuasion.
- 10:54Reciprocation, commitment and consistency, social proof, liking, authority, and unity.
- 11:00And we'll provide some links in our show notes to help everybody explore those in more detail.
- 11:06But I'd like to ask you to talk more about unity, which is the newest of your principles, and one that I think is particularly salient in our current cultural and political climate.
- 11:17What is the unity principle and how does it work exactly?
- 11:22Robert Cialdini: People say yes to you if you can show them that you share with them an important personal or social identity.
- 11:31That is, that you're a member of one of their "we" group.
- 11:36The groups that they use the term "we" to describe, or to characterize.
- 11:43In other words, that you're not just like them, that is similar, but you're of them, you're one of them.
- 11:53And in the boundaries of those "we" groups, all resistance to influence declines.
- 12:02Let me give you an example.
- 12:03There was a study done on a university campus, researchers took a young woman who was about college age, dressed like a college student, asked her to set up a table for the United Way on a heavily trafficked area of campus.
- 12:20And request people who were walking by to donate to the United Way.
- 12:26And because she looked similar to them, she was getting some contributions.
- 12:31But if she added one sentence to her request, she got four and a half times as many contributions.
- 12:42So what was the sentence?
- 12:44It was, I'm a student here too.
- 12:47I'm one of you.
- 12:49And people don't say no.
- 12:51They don't.
- 12:52They don't reject the people who are of them nearly as much as the people who are outside of those boundaries.
- 13:01And I'll tell you, these categories, these personal or social identities can be ethnic, shared ethnic, or political, or religious, or community, or workplace, or even athletic team identities.
- 13:22I'll give you a personal example.
- 13:23I grew up in the state of Wisconsin where the NFL football team there is the Green Bay Packers.
- 13:31So I grew up a Green Bay Packer fan.
- 13:33And a while ago, I saw an article in the newspaper that said two musical artists, uh, Justin Timberlake and Lil Wayne were avid Green Day Packer fans.
- 13:52And Matt, I immediately thought better of their music.
- 13:59More importantly, I wanted them to succeed more.
- 14:04Matt Abrahams: I'd like to move on, and I have always loved your creative research methodologies that you've used.
- 14:11Can you explain for our listeners how studying hotel towel use and stealing from national parks helped you identify how social norms can be used to influence people?
- 14:24Robert Cialdini: Let's take the hotel study first.
- 14:26I remember being in a hotel room, this is several years ago, and seeing one of these cards that asked us to reuse our towels and linen, right?
- 14:38It's a hanging card usually in the bathroom somewhere on a doorknob or a towel rack.
- 14:44And it often has a picture of some endangered woodland species, snow owls, or something like this, and asking us to reuse our towels for the sake of the environment.
- 14:59And you know, I'm a persuasion researcher, I'm a social influence researcher, and I'm always looking for places to study social influence.
- 15:08And I remember looking at this card and saying to myself, you know how there are these signs you see that say this space available for rent or this space available for lease on buildings and so on.
- 15:23I looked at that card and I said to myself, this space available for test.
- 15:31What could we say on the card?
- 15:33We can include all kinds of appeals besides do this for the environment and to see which was most powerful.
- 15:43And so we did this with various hotels, we had the cooperation of the managers and we went into hotel rooms and randomly assigned various kinds of cards that were the same, except for the recommendation, please do this for, right?
- 16:02And the environment was one, please do this for future generations was another.
- 16:08But the one that made the most difference was, the majority of guests who stay in this hotel have reused their towels.
- 16:20And that produced a significant increase in the willingness of people to reuse their towels.
- 16:29But even more interesting, we got a more significant effect if we said, not just the majority of visitors to our hotel have reused their towels.
- 16:43The majority of visitors who've stayed in this room every year have reused their towels.
- 16:49We got significantly more now because one, the principle we're talking about is the principle of social proof, that if a lot of other people are doing something, it validates the behavior, makes it more correct.
- 17:04But if those people are comparable to us staying in the same room, now that's not unity.
- 17:10That's just similarity here.
- 17:12They're comparable.
- 17:12They're like us, right?
- 17:15Well, that makes their behavior even more, um, diagnostic of what we should do.
- 17:23Matt Abrahams: I have seen those signs in hotel rooms, in fact, just recently.
- 17:27And every time I think of you in that research, every time I put my towel back up, rather than put it on the floor to go out, I think of that research.
- 17:36And how is this related to work you did in the petrified forests in Arizona?
- 17:42Robert Cialdini: So the petrified forest that is in Arizona, it's a national treasure.
- 17:48Um, there's a big sign that appears as you would enter the forest that uses this principle of social proof in an entirely wrong headed way.
- 17:59It says, so many people have been stealing petrified wood from the forest floor that's endangering the integrity of the forest.
- 18:09I know what the generators, the producers of that sign, were intending, but they made a serious mistake in telling people that all of their peers steal.
- 18:21So, what we did was to go into the park at different pathways and put up a sign that essentially said, so many people have been doing this, it's problematic for the forest.
- 18:34Please don't be one of them.
- 18:35And on the sign, there were a picture of three people stealing wood, picking up wood from the forest.
- 18:41That sign nearly tripled theft.
- 18:46Matt Abrahams: You were teaching them how to steal?
- 18:48Robert Cialdini: That's right.
- 18:49That it was a legitimate thing to do.
- 18:52It was okay, everybody does this, right?
- 18:55We had another sign that instead of normalizing theft, marginalized it.
- 19:02That sign said, if even one person steals from the forest, it undermines the integrity of the park.
- 19:11And we showed a single person picking up, uh, petrified wood.
- 19:17That sign halved theft compared to a control group.
- 19:24Matt Abrahams: I find both those studies very fascinating and they highlight how we can leverage social proof and norms to increase the likelihood of our persuasive success.
- 19:38It leads me to my next question because in essence the manipulations you were doing in both of those studies was changing wording and images.
- 19:48I'm curious to learn your thoughts about the role of language and wording and how they play out in persuasion.
- 19:55Does word choice really matter?
- 19:59Robert Cialdini: Let's begin with language.
- 20:02Um, it worked for persuasion.
- 20:06Let's say you have an idea that you would like to move up the ladder in your organization because you think it's a terrific initiative that would help all concerned.
- 20:19But to do that, you need to get the buy in of your colleagues before you the ladder.
- 20:26And what you often will do is show them a summary of your idea or a blueprint and ask for their opinion on it to get their input.
- 20:37Getting their input is very important, it's the right thing to do.
- 20:41The wrong thing to do is to ask for their opinion.
- 20:44Because when you ask for opinion, you get a critic.
- 20:49You get someone who steps back from you and goes inside introspects to examine the pros and cons and the critique that he or she can deliver for your idea.
- 21:05If instead you activate the principle of unity by changing one word, instead of asking for that person's opinion, you ask for that person's advice on your idea.
- 21:20Now instead of getting a critic, you get a partner, you get somebody who's in it with you.
- 21:27You get somebody who's a collaborator.
- 21:31And research shows that if you use the word advice rather than opinion, not only do you get more favorable evaluations of your idea, you get better input from them as to how to modify and improve your idea.
- 21:52Matt Abrahams: Just by simply changing one word,
- 21:56Robert Cialdini: One word
- 21:57Matt Abrahams: You change the entire interaction and actually get more of what you were really looking for.
- 22:05That is,
- 22:06Robert Cialdini: Exactly.
- 22:07Matt Abrahams: Fascinating.
- 22:09Robert Cialdini: And it all has to do with the associations to that word.
- 22:13The associations to opinion are critique.
- 22:17The associations to advice are partnership based.
- 22:23Matt Abrahams: So we really do have to be mindful of the words we choose to help drive in the direction we are trying to achieve with our persuasion or our influence.
- 22:35So before we end, Bob, I'd like to ask you the same three questions I ask everyone who joins me.
- 22:41Are you up for that?
- 22:43Robert Cialdini: Sure.
- 22:44Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 22:44Okay.
- 22:45If you were to capture the best communication advice you have ever received as a five to seven word presentation slide title, what would it be?
- 22:59Robert Cialdini: Don't have a favorite, go-to persuasive approach.
- 23:06Don't think, oh, scarcity, I'm always going to use, or don't think, oh, I'm always going to use social proof, no, no.
- 23:11You use the one that's in there.
- 23:15It's a fool's game to think that this, the same approach will be optimal across settings and circumstances and populations.
- 23:25No, it won't.
- 23:27The way to be ethical and effective is to say, is there truly scarcity here?
- 23:32Then I get to use it.
- 23:34Is there true authority here or science based information that I have, bring that to the surface.
- 23:40Is there true popularity or social proof involved?
- 23:44Mention that inside your message.
- 23:48Matt Abrahams: So there's several components of what I heard you say.
- 23:51One is be aware of your circumstance and adjust to it.
- 23:54So understand which of these tools is available to you ethically in the moment, and then don't rigidly lock into just one way of doing it.
- 24:04So part of it is awareness.
- 24:05And then part of it is it making use of what is available to you there.
- 24:11So let me move on to my second question.
- 24:13Who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 24:18Robert Cialdini: Right now, I'd say Greta Thunberg.
- 24:22She's overcome certain cognitive and affective abnormalities, Asperger's, depression, to become a powerful communicator for the environment.
- 24:35And she lives her commitment to it, leading by example.
- 24:40Matt Abrahams: And her messages are very clear and moving as well.
- 24:46Robert Cialdini: Right.
- 24:47She really understands what gets through by stripping away the message to its purest form.
- 24:56Matt Abrahams: And my final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 25:05Robert Cialdini: Credibility, ethics, and application.
- 25:13Matt Abrahams: Credibility, ethics, and application.
- 25:17Can you give us a sentence or two on each of those?
- 25:20Because those seem so foundational and important.
- 25:23Robert Cialdini: You know, credibility.
- 25:24You have to be seen as someone who knows what he or she is doing.
- 25:29Has the background, experience, credentials to be somebody to listen to.
- 25:38Secondly, to maintain the ethics of the communication, and the durability of the relationship.
- 25:48You can't fool people, they won't come back.
- 25:52Have you ever been, have you ever found yourself being tricked into something by someone or product service, communicator, politician, whatever.
- 26:01And then would you ever listen to that person again?
- 26:06Matt Abrahams: Absolutely not.
- 26:07I, and in fact, I'd actively warned people against it.
- 26:10Robert Cialdini: Yeah, so part of a successful communication recipe is not just in the moment, but in the long term.
- 26:18How do we maintain relationships in which people are willing to listen to us and follow our recommendations?
- 26:27And then finally, application.
- 26:29We have to give people a reason to listen to us, that there's something that they can now do with this piece of information that we've given them or this product or service that will be of benefit to them, will lead to positive outcomes for them.
- 26:46We have to show them that.
- 26:49Matt Abrahams: Well, thank you, Bob.
- 26:50It has been a great pleasure to chat with you and to learn from you and receive your advice.
- 26:57And thank you again for the influence you've had personally on my academic career and for helping all of us to become better at understanding the elements that go into successful persuasion and pre-suasion.
- 27:11It has been a true pleasure to chat with you.
- 27:13Robert Cialdini: I enjoyed it, Matt.
- 27:16Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 27:21To learn more about influence, please listen to episode 11 with Zak Tormala, and episode 142, where several Stanford professors share their thoughts on power and persuasion.
- 27:33This episode was produced by Jenny Luna, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 27:39Our music is by Floyd Wonder.
- 27:41With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 27:44Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 27:48Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 27:51Also, follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 27:53And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.