Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Indicates CAMEL Codes Keep Getting Worse
Transcript
- 0:00Todd H: This sudden rise may be startling for some, but
- 0:02it should have been expected.
- 0:04After all the continued high levels of interest rate risk have increased credit
- 0:08union liquidity risks contributed to asset quality deterioration and capital
- 0:12erosion and placed pressure on earnings.
- 0:15What is more concerning for me, however, is the rapid rise in total
- 0:19assets for composite Campbell's code 3 billion plus credit unions.
- 0:23If not addressed quickly by the credit union management.
- 0:26These problems could escalate into CamelScope 4 and 5
- 0:31ratings and even failures.
- 0:33And it's the billion dollar plus credit unions that pose the greatest
- 0:36risks to the shared insurance fund.
- 1:13Microphone (USB PnP Audio Device)-1: Hey, everyone.
- 1:14This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:17That voice before the intro to the podcast, which normally
- 1:23starts an episode, is that of NCUA Board Chairman Todd Harper.
- 1:29He did not appear on the show.
- 1:30Let me clarify that right out of the gate, especially if anybody at NCUA
- 1:35is listening and by the way, people at NCUA do listen, I have a separate
- 1:39episode on that, but I digress.
- 1:41All right.
- 1:42So that snippet came from the NCUA board meeting, and chairman
- 1:46Harper was being briefed on the state of the chair insurance fund.
- 1:51the.
- 1:52board presentation on the shared insurance fund.
- 1:55, it's one of my favorite, , quarterly events that happens at NCUA.
- 1:59And you might ask why?
- 2:00The reason why is that it's the only time they publicly do any type of disclosure on
- 2:06what's happening in Campbell code trends.
- 2:10Now I put a post , on LinkedIn.
- 2:12Let me pull it up here.
- 2:14Indicating , that if you took the amount of dollars in, in complex credit unions,
- 2:20, and as a reminder, complex credit unions are those over 500 million dollars
- 2:24in assets based on NCUA's definition.
- 2:27If you took the dollars in code 3s, they increased from 47.
- 2:327 billion, with a B, in June to 80.
- 2:378 billion.
- 2:38That's an increase annualized.
- 2:40If you take the results, multiply it by 4 and divide by what you had coming into
- 2:46the quarter, that's an increase of 277%.
- 2:51Now, if you go back and look at the number a year ago, they actually
- 2:54made reference to that in The budget briefing, which happened later in
- 2:59the day, and when they made reference to that, they indicated there were
- 3:02like 11 or 12 and now there are 51.
- 3:05So that was like a 500 percent increase in the number of large
- 3:09credit unions with a code 3.
- 3:12Now, that impacts the insurance fund, which we'll get to a little bit later.
- 3:15And the reality is N.
- 3:17C.
- 3:17U.
- 3:17A.
- 3:18Is nervous about the economy.
- 3:20They.
- 3:21That is trickling into camel codes, and I'm going to now go back to NCUA Board
- 3:27Chairman Todd Harper with some questions and answers that he also poses to Chief
- 3:35Financial Officer Eugene Sheed at NCUA.
- 3:39Todd: The Share Insurance Fund's performance in the third quarter of
- 3:422023 mirrors the industry's financial performance over the last year.
- 3:47Like the credit union system, the Share Insurance Fund is performing well overall.
- 3:51But there are some flashing cautionary lights that we
- 3:54should all heed and act upon.
- 3:56For several months, the NCUA has reported signs of growing liquidity,
- 4:00interest rate, and credit risks within the credit union system.
- 4:03In today's report, we see that stress firsthand, especially in
- 4:07large, complex credit unions with more than 500 million in assets.
- 4:12In fact, as shown on slide 9, the number of large, complex credit unions I'm
- 4:18going to talk a little bit about credit unions with composite Camel's Code three
- 4:21rating increased by nine credit unions to a total of 51 credit unions in the
- 4:26third quarter assets in the Camel's Code three group for credit unions
- 4:30of all sizes also increased to 131.
- 4:337 billion dollars as shown in the bottom right hand corner of slide nine.
- 4:39That is nearly 45 percent higher than the previous quarter's results.
- 4:44The rising risks within the credit union system also demonstrate why
- 4:48the NCUA Board must ensure the agency's 2024 budget has sufficient
- 4:53resources to examine, supervise, and mitigate these growing risks.
- 4:57Some may not like the size of the increase proposed in the staff draft
- 5:00budget, but it is our job to protect credit union members and the system.
- 5:05Other issues, including the reinstatement of federal student loan repayments,
- 5:09rising costs for property and casualty insurance, and consumers drawing down
- 5:13the last of their pandemic era savings will also affect already strained
- 5:17household finances going forward.
- 5:19And those household level issues could eventually roll on to the credit union's
- 5:24books as delinquencies and charge offs.
- 5:26So the NCUA Credit unions and the public should be prepared for further
- 5:31impact on the asset distribution of the system's CAMEL's ratings.
- 5:36It will get worse before it gets better.
- 5:38That brings me to my first question, Eugene.
- 5:40On slide 8, we see a 275 basis point increase in the percentage of insured
- 5:47shares held in PASA CAMEL 3 code credit unions since the end of 2022.
- 5:53This brisk pace of increase concerns me.
- 5:57How rapid is the growth of insured shares in Camel's Code 3 credit
- 6:00unions compared to what we have experienced in prior business cycles?
- 6:04So as
- 6:05Eugene: compared to prior business cycles, we first went back and took
- 6:08a look at the last 10 years, which would include the taxicab period.
- 6:13And we found no evidence of any cycle that saw this kind of increase.
- 6:18So then we went back a bit further, and you have to go back to the Great Recession
- 6:23in the 2010, 2007 to 2010 period.
- 6:27Where we did see instances of quarter over quarter increases that were larger
- 6:31than what we've seen this quarter.
- 6:32But again, you have to go back to the Great Recession.
- 6:36Todd: Thank you, Eugene.
- 6:37That's a bit sobering to hear.
- 6:39The NCOA will continue to monitor credit union performance and mitigate risk
- 6:43in the examination process, off site monitoring, and tailored supervision.
- 6:46The NCOA board will also closely watch credit union and share insurance fund
- 6:51performance in the quarters ahead and act to protect the system as needed.
- 6:55Additionally, and I cannot emphasize this enough, credit union executives,
- 7:01supervisors, and boards of directors must remain diligent in managing the
- 7:05potential risks on their balance sheet and when monitoring economic conditions
- 7:09and the interest rate environment.
- 7:11Today's economic environment requires active, not passive, management by all.
- 7:17Additionally, the NCUA must ensure the share insurance fund remains healthy
- 7:21and fortify the system's defenses.
- 7:23For potential risks ahead with the rising camel code three credit unions,
- 7:28the share insurance funds general reserve balance increased by 10.
- 7:322 million in the third quarter, as shown on slide for at the end of the quarter,
- 7:37the reserve balance total of 214.
- 7:403 million with 7.
- 7:413 million set aside for specific reserves and 207 million set
- 7:45aside for general reserves.
- 7:47Eugene, when you look at the number of credit union failures and the cost
- 7:50to the share insurance fund, as we saw on slide five, the actual cash
- 7:54losses have been small, about 1.
- 7:574 million a year to date.
- 7:59Would you elaborate on why general reserves are high when actual
- 8:03cash losses have been so small?
- 8:05And please discuss the NCUA's methodology for reserving for potential
- 8:09losses for the share insurance fund.
- 8:11For example, I've long had concerns that the share insurance fund's
- 8:14current reserving methodology.
- 8:16does not consider black swan events.
- 8:19Eugene: Okay.
- 8:19So thank you for that question and I would guess there's several parts
- 8:22to that and I'd start with the part about the black swan events where
- 8:26the methodology as I've mentioned in my statement includes two parts.
- 8:31There's a specific reserve and a general reserve.
- 8:34The general reserve really is there to ensure that we've got sufficient
- 8:37funds to cover probable losses.
- 8:40At any given time.
- 8:41And the modeling that we do for the general reserve does attempt to take into
- 8:47consideration the totality of the current situation that we see within the industry.
- 8:51It does not, I would say, unlike some modeling that we sometimes
- 8:54talk about, it does not exclude, per se, black swan events.
- 8:58The modeling kind of takes into account.
- 9:01The current state of the credit unions same, similar factors to the CAML
- 9:05ratings, which is why they often move in tandem with each other as well as
- 9:09macroeconomic data that we're seeing.
- 9:11And again the purpose of that is to get a systemic look at essentially
- 9:16a financial risk to the SIF based on current economic performance
- 9:20of credit unions in the industry.
- 9:22And then we have the specific reserves where when we know something...
- 9:25More particular is probable estimable.
- 9:28We can value it then we create that specific reserve.
- 9:32Looking at slide I think you mentioned slide five.
- 9:35I did.
- 9:35So let's take a one thing I want to point out on slide five, if we can bring that
- 9:38one up is this discrepancy that you see in actual cash losses in any particular year.
- 9:44So on slide five, that this is a five year.
- 9:47I just actually, we got six years of data up there.
- 9:50In 2018 there were $784 million, $785 million of losses.
- 9:56Whereas in the, two years later we're down to a million 0.6 in was so huge
- 10:02variability in terms of what happens.
- 10:04In terms of actual losses in any particular year.
- 10:07So the general reserve model is trying to guess where you're going to be
- 10:11between some events that are, extreme at one end and extreme at the other end.
- 10:14You're generally not going to nail the upper and the lower ends perfectly.
- 10:18What you want is to have a model that as conditions start to deteriorate, the
- 10:23reserve starts to go up in anticipation of those potential cash payouts.
- 10:27And then as economic conditions improve the reserve income's down because the
- 10:31general reserve model goes both ways.
- 10:33It goes up some quarters, it comes down in others.
- 10:36Todd: We're trying to get to that proverbial just right.
- 10:39Correct.
- 10:39Yeah.
- 10:40Microphone (USB PnP Audio Device)-2: Okay, you heard a little bit there from
- 10:42Chief Financial Officer Eugene Sheed.
- 10:44There's a lot to unpack here.
- 10:46We haven't seen this big of increases in camel code velocity of camel code threes
- 10:51increasing, particularly large camel code threes since the Great Recession.
- 10:56Chairman Harper found that sobering, and he said if management does not act quickly
- 11:00and boards do not act quickly, you could become a code four and you could become
- 11:04a code five, which could lead to failure.
- 11:07And then they go on with a big discussion about the insurance fund and how the
- 11:11essentially the equivalent of Cecil for credit unions is the allowance for
- 11:17credit union losses at the NCUSIF level.
- 11:21And they have a general reserve, they have a specific reserve.
- 11:24And when the specific reserve is, is code fours and code fives where they
- 11:31expect that they're shopping a credit union and they might have a loss.
- 11:34The general reserve is, is.
- 11:37Essentially, , materially based upon the camel codes and credit unions.
- 11:41So when you have camel code threes going up, pick a number, , quite a bit,
- 11:46, substantially, , increasing velocity, you're going to see increases in what
- 11:50needs to be set aside, , for losses.
- 11:53And they indicated they set aside 10 million, during the quarter.
- 11:57If you annualize that 10 million, that's 40 million on a base.
- 12:02Of 21 million.
- 12:03So that's about a 20 percent increase as this number keeps going up.
- 12:08If it keeps going up.
- 12:09And oh, by the way, Chairman Harper predicts that it will go up.
- 12:12What does that mean?
- 12:13That means that they're probably are aware of some other large
- 12:15credit unions that became code 3s during the month of October.
- 12:20We're in November as I sit here speaking, it's November 18th on a Saturday.
- 12:25And yeah, so camel code 3s are going to go up.
- 12:29So, what happens when you become a Code 3?
- 12:31NCUA comes and visits you at least twice as often, every six months.
- 12:36I've said this before, and I'll say it again.
- 12:38Best way to stay out of NCUA's crosshairs is to never become a Code 3.
- 12:44They have the authority when they come back at that six month, , visit
- 12:49to upgrade you back to a Code 3.
- 12:52But they don't very frequently do that.
- 12:56Sometimes they don't do it because they don't bring enough resources to
- 12:59do something closer to a full exam.
- 13:02Sometimes they don't do it because they don't feel the credit union
- 13:05has done enough to be upgraded.
- 13:08And even if you're squeaky clean, oftentimes they'll just
- 13:11say, Hey, you're doing great.
- 13:13If you keep doing it, when we come back in another six months
- 13:16we will do, quote, a full exam.
- 13:18And we will upgrade you at that point in time.
- 13:20So you become a code three, you're stuck in their crosshairs 99 times out
- 13:26of a hundred for, , the next full year.
- 13:28And you'll see them, they, they depart.
- 13:31Let's say they depart in January.
- 13:32You'll see them again in July and you'll see them again the following January.
- 13:37Gets worse.
- 13:37If you become a code four, you'll see them every four months.
- 13:40And it's almost as if they never leave.
- 13:43, which reminds me, , of a funny, , A funny country western song.
- 13:48How can I miss you if you don't go away?
- 13:49Well, if you're a code 4, NSUA tends to not go away, and it's a constant drip,
- 13:55a constant reminder, , that you need to manage a little bit towards what
- 13:59the insurer, what the regulator wants.
- 14:01And again, your goal should be to stay out of being a code
- 14:034, stay out of being a code 3.
- 14:06, and I've seen a lot of code 3s downgrades.
- 14:09We've, , assisted in some credit unions getting upgrades, But it's a
- 14:13challenging time out there nonetheless.
- 14:15So one other thing that's brought up in the budget briefing, I did a separate
- 14:18podcast on their budget document, the staff budget document, which is
- 14:22about 60 page, a lot of transparency.
- 14:25, they just did a budget briefing Thursday at two o'clock testifying it.
- 14:29That was NASCS, the Virginia league, the Washington, Oregon league, which
- 14:34I believe is now called go west CUNA and NAFCU, , who've now decided to
- 14:38merge into America's credit unions.
- 14:40So there were five, 5 organizations, 5 trade associations, they're making
- 14:46statements to NCUA, they generally every year come up with some
- 14:49broad statements that the budget's getting too high, and that, , NCUA,
- 14:53should, should reduce the budget.
- 14:55But they did provide some constructive criticism.
- 14:59Now, one thing that, Chairman Harper and I disagree on quite a bit.
- 15:03And I've talked about it here in the podcast.
- 15:04He's actually referenced the podcast statements I've made
- 15:07on this is that it's not a zero sum game to move something from.
- 15:11Tip to move resources from safety and soundness to consumer compliance, implying
- 15:16that there is a nexus between the 2.
- 15:19there is somewhat of a nexus between the 2.
- 15:21however, when they are not increasing.
- 15:25Full time equivalence, but they are taking staff from.
- 15:29regular examinations from safety and soundness exams, and they are
- 15:34turning them into specialists that deal only with consumer compliance.
- 15:38That's a reduction in resources that go to safety and soundness at the same time
- 15:43as they're saying, we think there's going to be more problem in credit unions.
- 15:47So, , quite frankly, I think it would be more appropriate for them to ask for
- 15:51more staff, keep the examiner staff.
- 15:54And add these consumer compliance folks, but to pretend that,
- 15:58when you move resources, from.
- 16:01From 1 area into another area that the area that you took them from, , is not.
- 16:07Position.
- 16:07More poorly, , it's just not accurate in my opinion.
- 16:11So I disagree with him on that.
- 16:13I, I do in general, I think their budget is reasonable.
- 16:16Yes, they've got some pay increases, but yes, so have
- 16:19credit unions had pay increases.
- 16:21So have other people in industry had pay increases.
- 16:24And one thing that you'll never hear NCUA or have not yet heard NCUA say publicly
- 16:30is if you take the combined payments that credit union make to trade associations.
- 16:35The cost of those is more than the cost of NCUA in its entirety.
- 16:40So, and both of them are immaterial.
- 16:42I'm not saying that you shouldn't join a trade association, but, the
- 16:45trade associations like to make a big issue about NCUA's budget.
- 16:49And the reality is.
- 16:50, a similar size credit union sees less hours spent on them than a
- 16:55similar size bank, meaning NCUA is more efficient and NCUA, I believe,
- 16:59has a very prudent budget process.
- 17:01All right.
- 17:02So, , in summary, , NCUA is, , nervous about the economy.
- 17:06They're nervous that the insurance fund.
- 17:09may need more increases in the future for their allowance for loan losses for or
- 17:14their allowance for credit union failures.
- 17:16Why?
- 17:16Because camel codes are getting worse and they predict more to come.
- 17:20That means when they come in they're going to be more aggressive as opposed
- 17:24to less aggressive and that's something that I've seen from my conversations
- 17:29with credit unions out there.
- 17:31So you need to be ready for that.
- 17:33You need to be ready for them to be Pushing harder on your camel codes and
- 17:37pushing harder on your asset quality and pushing harder on your liquidity
- 17:41and pushing harder on your capital.
- 17:43Uh, you name it.
- 17:44They are going to push on it.
- 17:47Again, and again and again over these next years exams.
- 17:51All right.
- 17:51That's it.
- 17:52I appreciate, , your listening today.
- 17:55Hope you'll listen again in the future, and I hope you have a fabulous
- 17:57Thanksgiving with your family.
- 17:59One of my favorite, , holidays of the year is Thanksgiving, and we will be
- 18:03spending it with family this year as well.
- 18:06, Mark Treichel, signing off with Flying Colors.