Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / Berke's Choice: Faith and Feud in the Mongol West
Transcript
- Lucas: We've talked a lot about how the Mongols split apart — succession crises, rival kurultais, the Toluid civil war. But there's one rupture that's often overlooked, and it's the one that made the split permanent: the feud between Berke and Hulegu. Lucas: These were cousins, both grandsons of Chinggis Khan. Berke ruled the Golden Horde in the north, Hulegu the Ilkhanate in Persia. And in 1262, they went to war with each other — the first open conflict between Mongol khans. It wasn't just about territory. It was about faith. Luna: Faith? I thought the Mongols were shamanists at that point. Lucas: Right, most of them still followed Tengri, the sky god. But Berke had converted to Islam — probably in the 1250s — and he was the first Mongol ruler to do so. That set him apart from Hulegu, who was leaning Buddhist, and from the Great Khan Khubilai in the east, who was more ecumenical. Lucas: Berke's conversion wasn't just a personal choice. It became a political weapon. When Hulegu sacked Baghdad in 1258 and executed the Abbasid caliph, Berke was furious. He saw it as an attack on Islam itself. He even said, 'He has destroyed all the cities of the Muslims. If God helps me, I will call him to account.' Luna: Wow. So this is personal. Lucas: It was. And it was strategic too. Berke started forging alliances with the Mamluks of Egypt — the very people who had just defeated Hulegu's army at Ayn Jalut in 1260. The Mongols and Mamluks had been enemies, but now Berke saw them as natural partners against Hulegu. Lucas: There were also economic reasons. The Golden Horde controlled the trade routes through the steppe, and Hulegu's conquests in Persia threatened that. So this was a mix of faith, politics, and profit — the classic Mongol cocktail. Lucas: The flashpoint came in 1262. Hulegu launched a campaign northward into the Caucasus, crossing the Terek River. Berke responded with a full army. The battle was brutal — both sides suffered heavy losses. The sources say the river ran red. Luna: It must have been a shock — Mongols fighting Mongols. Lucas: It was unprecedented. Up to that point, the Mongols had mostly turned on each other in succession disputes, but this was a full-scale war between two established khanates. It set a precedent. From then on, the Golden Horde and the Ilkhanate would be rivals for decades. Lucas: Neither side backed down. Berke even allied with the Mamluks to pressure Hulegu from the south. The Mamluks were happy to have a Mongol ally, and they sent gifts and embassies to Sarai, Berke's capital on the Volga. Luna: So the Mongols were now playing the same game of shifting alliances as everyone else. Lucas: Exactly. The unity of the empire was gone. You had the Golden Horde and the Ilkhanate at each other's throats, the Chagatai Khanate in Central Asia doing its own thing, and Khubilai in the east trying to hold the whole thing together as Great Khan. It was a mess. Lucas: Berke's faith also had a lasting impact. He encouraged the spread of Islam in the Golden Horde, even though he never forced it on his subjects. Over the next century, the Golden Horde gradually became a Muslim state. Lucas: And here's a strange twist — Berke never actually faced Hulegu in person. They both died within a few years. Berke died in 1266, probably of illness, and Hulegu died in 1265. But their successors carried on the feud. Luna: It's almost like the feud outlived them. Lucas: It did. And it helped cement the permanent division of the Mongol world. If you look at a map of the Mongol Empire in 1270, it's already split into four distinct khanates. The era of a single, unified Mongol realm was over. Lucas: That's why this episode matters — it's not just a battle story. It's about how faith and family can tear apart even the most powerful empire the world had ever seen. Lucas: And you know, thinking about that — how a personal conviction like Berke's faith could ripple across continents and change the course of history — it reminds me of why we do this show. We dig into these stories because they connect us to something bigger. If you've been following along with our series on the Mongols, or any of our other deep dives, we'd love to keep bringing you these conversations. A little support from listeners like you helps keep Fexingo History ad-free and going strong. If you'd like to help, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a thank you for being part of this journey. Luna: Yeah, it's a great way to keep the history flowing. And it really helps us keep the lights on. Lucas: So, back to the split. After Berke and Hulegu, the feud between the Golden Horde and the Ilkhanate continued for decades. They fought over the Caucasus, over trade routes, and over influence in the region. The Ilkhanate eventually collapsed in the 1330s, but the Golden Horde lasted longer, until the 15th century. Lucas: One of the most interesting consequences was the impact on the Silk Road. With the khanates at odds, the famous Pax Mongolica — the Mongol peace that had made trans-Eurasian travel safe — started to break down. Merchants and travelers had to navigate a more fragmented political landscape. Luna: So even the economy suffered because of this feud. Lucas: Definitely. And it paved the way for later powers like Timur to rise. The fractured Mongol world was easier to conquer piece by piece. Lucas: But I think the most tragic part is that it didn't have to happen. The Mongols had a tradition of resolving disputes through the kurultai — a great council of the nobility. But by Berke's time, the kurultai had lost its power to unite. Each khan wanted to be independent. Luna: So the very tool that had built the empire became the thing that tore it apart. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the lesson of the Mongol split — when a system of shared governance breaks down, even the strongest empire can fragment. It's a story that repeats throughout history. Lucas: Now, if you're curious about how the Mamluks fit into this, they were actually the big winners in the short term. They survived the Mongol onslaught, and by allying with Berke, they gained a powerful friend in the north. That alliance helped them remain a major power in the Middle East for centuries. Lucas: So, to sum up: Berke's choice to convert to Islam wasn't just a spiritual move — it was political, and it set the stage for a permanent split in the Mongol world. The feud with Hulegu defined the history of Central Asia for the next hundred years. Luna: And it all started with a family disagreement. Lucas: A family disagreement with millions of lives caught in the middle. That's the story of the Mongol Empire, really — a family that conquered the world, then couldn't even get along. Thanks for listening, and we'll catch you next time.