Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The United States Governments Brief In Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's Appeal Request (Part 10)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04This episode, we're picking right back up where we left
- 0:06off with the United States Government's brief and response to
- 0:10Glenn Maxwell's attempt to appeal her sentence. Maxwell's contrary view
- 0:16rests on extensive speculation about which flights and evidence the
- 0:20jury was referencing in the note. The trial included, among
- 0:23other evidence, testimony by Jane about taking numerous flights, both
- 0:27on Epstein's private planes and on commercial carriers. Maxwell ignores
- 0:32that evidence focusing on a specific trip referenced in the
- 0:36flight logs. Even if Maxwell correctly identified the flight at issue,
- 0:40it still betrayed no jury confusion. The origin of that
- 0:44trip was New York, and the jury's focus was on
- 0:46the return flight, which it could have inferred was a
- 0:49flight to New York where Maxwell intended Jane to engage
- 0:53in sexual activity. Her view also rests on adopting one
- 0:57specific reading of a note that, as Judge Nathan explained,
- 1:00was decidedly ambiguous as to the precise legal questioning being asked.
- 1:06CEE Romney five six ft three d at one twenty
- 1:10six District Court enjoys considerable discretion in construing the scope
- 1:15of a jury inquiry. Maxwell herself initially understood the note
- 1:20to be about aiding and abetting liability and whether sexual
- 1:23activity was a sufficiently significant or a motivating purpose for
- 1:28the travel see United States versus Kim four seventy one
- 1:32f Appendix eighty two eighty four Second Circuit, twenty twelve,
- 1:37affirming jury instructions that prostitution must be a significant or
- 1:41motivating purpose of the interstate transportation. Maxwell only came to
- 1:46the theory she now advances after a lengthy discussion spanning
- 1:50ten pages of the transcript, and that reading is far
- 1:53from clear. The jury's question does not ask whether certain
- 1:56facts are sufficient for guilt. It asks whether Maxwell can
- 2:00be found guilty if a certain fact is true. Maxwell
- 2:03can be found guilty based in part on sexual activity
- 2:06occurring in New Mexico, which is probative of Maxwell's intent
- 2:11and role in transporting Jane. That is perfectly sensible question
- 2:15for the jury to ask. Indeed, it was repeatedly raised
- 2:18by defense counsel to Judge Nathan at trial. Setting aside
- 2:23the jury note, Maxwell's positions require the jury to have
- 2:26reached a series of odd conclusions. Jane testified at length
- 2:31about her travel to New York and the ensuing sexual
- 2:34abuse there. It would make little sense for the jury
- 2:37to reject that testimony and then conclude that Maxwell arranged
- 2:40the unidentified commercial return flight Maxwell now emphasizes, for which
- 2:45there is no documentary evidence in the record, including no
- 2:49specific corroboration of Maxwell's role in arranging that flight. Compare
- 2:54BR seventy nine to eighty. The jury likely believed that
- 2:57if they found Maxwell had some role in a ranking
- 3:00Jane's return flight from New Mexico after the sexual abuse
- 3:03had already taken place, they could convict her on the
- 3:07transportation count with TR three one three three defense argument
- 3:13that there is no evidence Maxwell arranged a return flight
- 3:16from New Mexico. Maxwell suggests that the jury thought the
- 3:19flight records to be critical evidence, but the flight logs
- 3:22also demonstrate that Jane was flown to New York on
- 3:25Epstein's private jet, corroborating her testimony on that point. See
- 3:30BR seventy nine, citing GX six sixty two dash Are
- 3:34at forty four. The same is true regarding Maxwell's comparison
- 3:38of counts two to four. In Maxwell's view, the jury
- 3:41rejected nearly all of the evidence of Maxwell's enticement of
- 3:44Jane to New York for lack of corroboration, and then
- 3:47convicted her based on an unsupported speculative leap about rearranging
- 3:52an unidentified return flight from New Mexico that is not plausible,
- 3:57and it certainly is not a substantially likely inclusion that
- 4:01can be drawn from an inscrutable jury note. For similar reasons,
- 4:05no variance occurred. As discussed above, the proof of trial
- 4:09corresponded to the allegations in the indictment, namely evidenced and
- 4:13argument that Maxwell enticed and transported Jane to New York
- 4:18in order to facilitate sexual abuse there. Maxwell has also
- 4:22aware that the government's proof would include conduct in New Mexico.
- 4:26Maxwell therefore had fair adequate notice that the conspiracies included
- 4:30conduct at Epstein's New Mexico home, which is all that
- 4:34is required United States versus Solomones three point fifty two
- 4:38ft three D six eight six twenty two, Second Circuit
- 4:42two thousand and three. In any event, the government produced
- 4:45on November six, twenty twenty one, more than three weeks
- 4:48before trial, notes from an interview with Jane describing sexual
- 4:52abuse in New Mexico that is sufficient see lebdevev. Nine
- 4:57thirty two ft three d at fifty four, rejecting a
- 5:00prejudiced argument in part because the government disclosed the evidence
- 5:04and exhibits four weeks prior to trial. Point number five,
- 5:09the sentence was procedurally reasonable a applicable law, a district
- 5:13court commits procedural error if, among other things, it makes
- 5:17a mistake in its guidelines calculation, or fails adequately to
- 5:21explain its chosen sentence. United States versus Kavara, five point
- 5:25fifty f dot three d one eighty one ninety Second Circuit,
- 5:29two thousand and eight. This Court reviews a district court's
- 5:33application of the guidelines de novo, while factual determinations underlying
- 5:37a district court's guidelines calculations are reviewed for clear error.
- 5:42United States versus Kramer seven seven seven f Dot three
- 5:45d five ninety seven six oh one, Second Circuit twenty fifteen.
- 5:49In explaining the sentence, the district court must show that
- 5:53it has considered the party's arguments and that it has
- 5:55reason basis for exercising its own legal decision making authority.
- 6:00Cavera five point fifty ft three D at one ninety
- 6:04three B. The discussion, Maxwell argues that the district Court
- 6:09aired by applying a four level leadership enhancement under three
- 6:13B one dot one of the Sentencing Guidelines. That enhancement
- 6:16applies when a defendant was an organizer or leader of
- 6:20a criminal activity that was otherwise extensive, which must include
- 6:24the defendant's leadership of at least one other criminal participant
- 6:28USSG Section three B one dot one and CMT number two.
- 6:34Maxwell contests only whether the evidence showed that she led
- 6:37another criminal participant. On that point, Judge Nathan found that
- 6:41Maxwell led Sarah Kellen. Two witnesses, both pilots for Epstein,
- 6:46testified that Kellen was Maxwell's assistant. Judge Nathan found that
- 6:50testimony credible, in part because it was corroborated by other
- 6:54testimony that Maxwell was Epstein's number two and the lady
- 6:57of the house in Palm Beach, where how much of
- 7:00the abuse occurred and where Kellen worked. The trial evidence
- 7:03showed that Kellen scheduled sexualized massages and took nude photographs
- 7:08of Carolyn. Even after Kellen took over some of Maxwell's duties,
- 7:12Maxwell continued to manage her by virtue of her position
- 7:15in the house, a fact corroborated by a household manual
- 7:19directing staff to tend to the specific needs of Epstein, Maxwell,
- 7:23and their other guests, as well as flight records showing
- 7:26that Maxwell and Kellen flew together on Epstein's planes dozens
- 7:29of times. The clear inference from this record is that
- 7:33Maxwell instructed Kellen regarding how to schedule massages and run
- 7:37part of the scheme that Maxwell was previously handled, at
- 7:41which point Kellen switched to making phone calls to schedule
- 7:44appointments following Maxwell's directions. Maxwell argues that Judge Nathan heirred
- 7:49because the defense witness testified that she, rather than Kellen,
- 7:53was Maxwell's assistant. That uncorroborated testimony is not enough to
- 7:57render Judge Nathan's finding really erroneous. Moreover, what matters is
- 8:03whether Maxwell exercised supervisory authority over Kellen, not whether Kellen
- 8:08or another individual was formerly Maxwell's assistant. Maxwell also argues
- 8:13that when imposing the two hundred and forty month sentence,
- 8:16which was above the guidelines range of one eighty eight
- 8:19to two thirty five months imprisonment, Judge Nathan then failed
- 8:23to provide reasons for its upward variance. Maxwell's one sentence
- 8:27argument is so cursory and undeveloped that it should be
- 8:30deemed waived see United States versus Body seven to eleven
- 8:34f Dot three D two ninety nine, three thirteen, Second Circuit,
- 8:37twenty thirteen. It is settled Appellet rule that issues adverted
- 8:43to in a perfunctory manner, unaccompanied by some sort at
- 8:47developed argumentation are deem wave in any event, Judge Nathan
- 8:52engaged in a lengthy discussion of the sentencing factors when
- 8:55imposing sentence, including Maxwell's pivotal role in heinous and predator
- 9:00sexual abuse of minor girls. In describing the seriousness of
- 9:04the offense, Judge Nathan found that Maxwell's crimes to be
- 9:07both extensive and far reaching, and concluded that the damage
- 9:11done to these young girls was incalculable as a result
- 9:15of the painful, horrific, and lasting impact of the trauma
- 9:18that they endured. After an extensive discussion of Maxwell's horrifying crimes,
- 9:23Judge Nathan explained that this conduct demands a substantial sentence
- 9:28that meets the scope of the conduct and the scope
- 9:30of the harm, and that the sentence must send an
- 9:33unmistakable message of general deterrence to those who engage in
- 9:38and facilitate the sexual abuse and trafficking of underage victims,
- 9:43that nobody is above the law. Accordingly, Judge Nathan concluded
- 9:47that a very serious, a very significant sentence is necessary
- 9:51to achieve the purposes of punishment under US Code eighteen,
- 9:54section thirty five fifty three a say four sixty two.
- 9:59This discussion lies any claim that Judge Nathan inadequately explained
- 10:03the sentence conclusion. The judgment of conviction should be affirmed.
- 10:09Dated June twenty ninth, twenty twenty three, and this was
- 10:12signed by Damian Williams. All Right, So that concludes the
- 10:17United States government's brief in a response to Maxwell trying
- 10:21to get that appeal. And as you can tell from
- 10:24this brief, the United States Government is not convinced, and
- 10:28they shouldn't be. Maxwell had a fair trial, she was
- 10:31found guilty. Now she needs to sit in prison and rot.
- 10:35And when all is said and done with this process
- 10:37of her appealing, my guess is that's exactly what's going
- 10:40to occur. But until then we'll continue our journey through
- 10:44the dark ass disgusting sewers known as Jeffrey Epstein's Criminal Enterprise.
- 10:50All of the information that goes with this episode can
- 10:53be found in the description box