Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / History of Psychology & Behaviorism: Origins of Learning Theories
Transcript
- 0:00So get this, in exactly 19 minutes, you are going
- 0:03to forget like 40 % of what we are about to discuss.
- 0:08Well, unless of course we figure out how your
- 0:09brain actually learns before that happens. Exactly.
- 0:13Welcome to the Psychology undergrad. We are so
- 0:15stoked you're here. Yeah, consider yourself the
- 0:17essential third member of our undergrad study
- 0:19group today. For sure. So today's deep dive is
- 0:23all about tracing the very roots of learning
- 0:25and behavior. We are basically prepping for this
- 0:29massive exam on how psychology became a science.
- 0:32Right. How it violently divorced itself from
- 0:34philosophy and biology to become its own standalone
- 0:37thing. And ultimately, we are trying to figure
- 0:39out why humans do what they do, which is a small
- 0:42question. Totally simple. But to beat that 19
- 0:45minute forgetting curve, which, by the way, was
- 0:48famously discovered by psychologist Herman Ebbinghaus.
- 0:51We need to understand the mechanics of what is
- 0:53happening in your brain right now. Because right
- 0:55now you, our listener, are attempting to learn.
- 0:58And learning isn't just like passively absorbing
- 1:00information, right? No, not at all. The textbook
- 1:03definition is that learning is a relatively permanent
- 1:06change in behavior due to experience and practice.
- 1:09Wait, relatively permanent? I mean, if I learn
- 1:11something, isn't it just locked in there? Well,
- 1:14that is the thing. The underlying mechanism of
- 1:16learning is plasticity. So what is learned? can
- 1:19actually be unlearned. Oh, wow. OK, give me an
- 1:22example. So take a baby who experiences this
- 1:24loud, terrifying noise every single time they're
- 1:28handed a white rat. The baby learns a covert
- 1:31internal behavior, which is fear, and an overt
- 1:35observable behavior, crying. Right, classical
- 1:38conditioning, basically. Exactly. But if you
- 1:40subsequently introduce the rat without the noise
- 1:42and maybe pair it with a reward, the brain rewrites
- 1:46the script. The fear is unlearned. Okay, but
- 1:48for that overriding to happen, the brain has
- 1:51to actually store the previous data. I mean,
- 1:53learning cannot exist without memory. You have
- 1:55the physical ability to retain and retrieve information.
- 1:58If the baby doesn't remember the noise, no association
- 2:01forms. So that storage and retrieval process
- 2:03is essentially the foundation of psychology,
- 2:06which is the scientific study of behavior and
- 2:08mental processes. Right. Overt and covert. And
- 2:11the key mechanism there is the scientific method.
- 2:14We aren't just guessing why the baby cries. We
- 2:17are measuring it. Okay, let's unpack this because
- 2:20that raises a massive question for me What's
- 2:22that if modern psychology requires the scientific
- 2:24method? How did early humans explain behavior
- 2:28before psychology existed? like before we had
- 2:31laboratories or brain scans. Oh, right. Before
- 2:34empiricism really took over. Yeah. What was the
- 2:36framework for understanding human action when
- 2:39the world was just pure chaos? Well, before scientists
- 2:43had labs, people relied heavily on religion and
- 2:46philosophy. The primary mechanisms were animism
- 2:49and anthropomorphism. Okay, animism. That is
- 2:52the idea that a spirit exists in everything,
- 2:54right? Like the wind, the rivers. The earth itself.
- 2:56Yeah, the early Greeks didn't see the physical
- 2:58world as dead matter. They saw it as alive. And
- 3:01then anthropomorphism takes it a step further
- 3:03by assigning human emotions and motives to those
- 3:07inanimate forces. Exactly. So a thunderstorm
- 3:10wasn't a meteorological event. It was a god throwing
- 3:12a temper tantrum. Right, like Zeus just having
- 3:15a bad day. But it was actually a vital coping
- 3:17mechanism. I mean if the world operates on the
- 3:20whims of human -like gods Then you can negotiate
- 3:23with oh, I see you can offer sacrifices for a
- 3:25better harvest or like pray for a safe childbirth
- 3:29Yeah, it transformed an unpredictable terrifying
- 3:31environment into a system where humans felt they
- 3:35had at least a sliver of control over their fate.
- 3:37But eventually human thought evolved. I mean,
- 3:39we realized that blaming Zeus for a bad crop
- 3:42wasn't actually solving anything. No, it wasn't
- 3:45yielding results. And that realization essentially
- 3:48birthed philosophy. And looking at the history
- 3:51for our exam, this is where things get really
- 3:53muddy. Because philosophy and modern psychology
- 3:56are constantly stepping on each other's toes.
- 3:58Oh, absolutely. Especially regarding morality.
- 4:01They share the exact same historical DNA. Because
- 4:03both disciplines are deeply invested in ethics.
- 4:06They both want to know what makes a good person
- 4:08and why people commit atrocious acts. Right.
- 4:11For example, in psychology, you have Lawrence
- 4:13Kohlberg dedicating his entire career to studying
- 4:16the stages of moral development in children.
- 4:18And Stanley Milgram, right, with his infamous
- 4:20obedience experiments. Yes. Trying to understand
- 4:24how everyday people could participate in the
- 4:26horrors of World War II just because an authority
- 4:29figure told them to. So the distinction between
- 4:32the two fields lies entirely in the approach.
- 4:34To help you memorize this for the exam, think
- 4:36of philosophy as asking the why and the ought.
- 4:41Like why does evil exist and what ought we do
- 4:44about it? Subjective speculation. Exactly. But
- 4:47psychology demands objective measurement. It
- 4:49asks the how and the what. How does the brain
- 4:53process an authoritative command and what is
- 4:55the physical behavioral response? And the thinker
- 4:58who first really built a bridge between those
- 5:00philosophical questions and physical reality
- 5:02was René Descartes. Ah, Descartes. 17th century.
- 5:06Right, through his concept of dualism. Before
- 5:08Descartes, the soul was considered responsible
- 5:11for literally everything. Movement, thought,
- 5:14digestion. Wait, they thought the soul digested
- 5:16your food. They did. But Descartes radically
- 5:19argued that the human body functions purely as
- 5:22an autonomous machine. It produces involuntary
- 5:25automatic reflexes to external stimuli without
- 5:28any input from the soul. So he effectively split
- 5:31the human in half. The body is just mechanical
- 5:34hardware responding to the environment, but the
- 5:36mind, the soul has free will. Yeah, the soul
- 5:39is the pilot sitting in the cockpit. Yeah. And
- 5:41he categorizes software running in that mind
- 5:43too. Right. Innate ideas versus derived ideas.
- 5:47Exactly. Innate ideas are built -in concepts
- 5:49we are born with, like the understanding of perfection
- 5:52or the concept of God. And derived ideas are
- 5:54acquired entirely through our sensory experiences
- 5:57in the physical world. You got it. OK. But I
- 5:59have a serious bone to pick with the date -carts
- 6:01dualism. If the mind is non -physical spirit
- 6:04and the body is physical machinery, how do they
- 6:07actually communicate? That is the million dollar
- 6:09question. Right. You can't use a ghost to turn
- 6:12a physical steering wheel. But Descartes claimed
- 6:15they interacted in exactly one tiny structure
- 6:17in the center of the brain, the pineal gland.
- 6:20Yeah, the pineal gland theory. It feels like
- 6:22he constructed this brilliant complex theory
- 6:25of human consciousness and then just slapped
- 6:28a random brain part on it to make the math work.
- 6:32I mean, it was deeply flawed, obviously, but
- 6:34look at the paradigm shift it caused. By localizing
- 6:38the soul's interaction to a specific gland, Descartes
- 6:41unintentionally permitted scientists to study
- 6:44the mind. Oh, because it was tethered to biology
- 6:46now. Exactly. He moved the conversation out of
- 6:48theology and into early physiology. OK, so if
- 6:51we accept Descartes' premise that the physical
- 6:53body is a machine, that leads us straight into
- 6:56the 17th century's obsession with mechanism.
- 6:59Right. Building off that mechanical body, thinkers
- 7:01began to view the entire universe as a giant
- 7:04incredibly precise clock. And if the universe
- 7:07is a clock, then every gear, every spring, operates
- 7:10on predictable physical laws. Which means if
- 7:13you can understand the gears, you can understand
- 7:14the whole. That is reductionism, right? Breaking
- 7:17things down to their basic parts. Yes. And it
- 7:19fundamentally altered how we viewed human behavior.
- 7:22Mechanism birthed determinism. Which is the terrifyingly
- 7:26logical conclusion that if the universe is a
- 7:28machine, then every single act, every thought
- 7:31you have is directly caused by a past physical
- 7:34event. It's heavy stuff. And it's solidified
- 7:37materialism, arguing that absolutely everything,
- 7:40including human consciousness, is just matter
- 7:42and energy in motion. So under this mechanical
- 7:45worldview, where does our personality actually
- 7:47come from? If we are just gears turning gears,
- 7:49how do we learn? Well, that specific question
- 7:52triggered the rise of empiricism. If we are material
- 7:55machines, we don't have Descartes' innate ideas.
- 7:58Oh, right. Enter John Locke and the tabula rasa?
- 8:01The blank slate. He argued our minds are entirely
- 8:03empty at birth, and the environment writes the
- 8:06script of our behavior through sensory input.
- 8:09OK, I use a modern analogy for this one. Think
- 8:11of your brain at birth as a brand new smartphone
- 8:14straight out of the box. Oh, I like that. Right.
- 8:15The operating system is running, but you have
- 8:17zero apps, zero photos, zero contacts. That is
- 8:21the tabula rasa. Every time you experience something,
- 8:24a sound, a face, a hot stove, you download a
- 8:27piece of data. But a pile of random data doesn't
- 8:29equal intelligence. To organize that data, empiricists
- 8:33like Aristotle and David Hume proposed the laws
- 8:36of association. The algorithms. Exactly. The
- 8:39algorithms that connect your experiences. So
- 8:41the phone needs a way to link the data. The law
- 8:43of contiguity links things that happen at the
- 8:46exact same time. The law of similarity groups
- 8:48things that look alike. And the law of cause
- 8:50and effect connects the action to the consequence.
- 8:53While the law of frequency dictates that the
- 8:55more often you experience two things together,
- 8:58the stronger the connection becomes. It is basically
- 9:01the mechanism behind habit formation. Your phone
- 9:04learns that every time you open your map app,
- 9:06you subsequently open your music app, so it begins
- 9:09suggesting them together. But humans are more
- 9:11than just predictive text algorithms, right?
- 9:14We invent things. We create art. If empiricism
- 9:16just views us as passive hard drives storing
- 9:19sensory data, how do we explain creativity? If
- 9:22we connect this to the bigger picture, John Stuart
- 9:25Mill addressed that exact gap with the concept
- 9:28of creative synthesis. Creative synthesis? Yeah.
- 9:32He recognized that when human minds combine simple
- 9:35ideas, they don't merely stack them like bricks.
- 9:38The mind actively fuses them to generate something
- 9:41entirely novel. Something greater than the sum
- 9:43of its parts. Exactly. If you mix red light and
- 9:46green light, you don't get reddish green, you
- 9:48get yellow. The mind is an active generator,
- 9:51not just a passive recording device. So philosophy
- 9:54gave us brilliant theories like creative synthesis
- 9:57and the tabula rasa, but we couldn't stay in
- 10:00the armchair forever. No, to become a true science,
- 10:03psychology needed proof. We had to figure out
- 10:05how to measure the invisible mind. And that task
- 10:08fell to the physiologists because they actually
- 10:11had the physical tools that philosophy lacked.
- 10:14Enter Hermann von Helmholtz. He achieved something
- 10:16unprecedented. He measured the speed of the neural
- 10:19impulse. Which is wild because before Helmholtz,
- 10:22people assumed thoughts were instantaneous, right?
- 10:24Like almost magical occurrences. Yeah, but he
- 10:26proved that a nerve impulse travels at about
- 10:2890 feet per second. 90 feet per second. Measuring
- 10:32the speed of a thought fundamentally changes
- 10:35the game. It proves that the mind is bound by
- 10:38time, space, and physical biology. And then Ernst
- 10:41Weber pushed that physical measurement even further
- 10:44by mapping the borders of human perception. Oh,
- 10:47with the two -point threshold and the just noticeable
- 10:50difference. Right. You can actually test the
- 10:52two -point threshold on yourself right now. Just
- 10:54take two fingers, press them tightly together,
- 10:57and press them onto your forearm. It really just
- 10:59registers as a single point of pressure. Yeah,
- 11:01but if you slowly spread your fingers apart,
- 11:03millimeter by millimeter, pressing down each
- 11:06time, your brain will suddenly detect two distinct
- 11:09points. Weber measured the exact physical distance
- 11:13required for the brain to update its reality.
- 11:15Which is incredible. And while physiologists
- 11:18mapped the nervous system, Charles Darwin provided
- 11:20the missing biological context. Evolution and
- 11:23natural selection. Yes. His theory of evolution
- 11:26introduced the continuity of mind. Remember,
- 11:29Descartes had argued that animals were basically
- 11:31soulless automatons, while humans possessed consciousness.
- 11:34But Darwin shattered that divide. He proved humans
- 11:38and animals exist on the same cognitive spectrum.
- 11:41Which suddenly meant animals were valid, vital
- 11:44subjects for psychological research. If a dog
- 11:47learns similarly to a human, we can test the
- 11:49dog. It opened the floodgates for animal testing,
- 11:52sure. But it also invited some terrible methodology,
- 11:56like George Romina's and his anecdotal method.
- 11:59Oh, Romanesia. Yeah, he collected stories from
- 12:01pet owners and attributed highly complex human
- 12:04-level reasoning to animals. Right. He assumed
- 12:07a dog opening a gate understood the physics of
- 12:10the latch, which is just absurd. So C. Lloyd
- 12:13Morgan had to step in with his law of parsimony.
- 12:15The ultimate filter for scientific reasoning.
- 12:17He argued that we cannot attribute behavior to
- 12:20higher cognitive processes if it can be explained
- 12:22by a lower, simpler mechanism. The dog didn't
- 12:25study physics. It just violently pawed at the
- 12:28gate until it accidentally popped open. And then
- 12:30associated the pawing with the reward of escape.
- 12:32So when you're trying to parse out complex behavior,
- 12:34just remember the classic kiss rule. Keep it
- 12:37simple, stupid. Exactly. Simple explanations
- 12:40usually suffice without implicating higher mental
- 12:43processes. OK, so by the late 19th century, the
- 12:45elements were finally in place. We had philosophical
- 12:49frameworks, physiological measurement tools,
- 12:52and the biological justification to study animals.
- 12:55And in 1879, Wilhelm Wundt established the first
- 12:59formal psychology laboratory in Germany. Psychology
- 13:02was officially born. And the very second they
- 13:04got their own science, the psychologists completely
- 13:07fractured and started arguing. They really did.
- 13:09They launched into what we call the great school
- 13:11wars of psychology. Okay, here is where it gets
- 13:13really interesting. Let's start with Wundt and
- 13:16E .B. Titchener, who championed structuralism.
- 13:19Right. They believe the goal of psychology was
- 13:22to break consciousness down into its most basic
- 13:24elements using systematic experimental introspection.
- 13:28But introspection is inherently subjective. You
- 13:30cannot verify what someone claims to be experiencing
- 13:32internally. Which is exactly why functionalism
- 13:35was born, spearheaded by thinkers like John Dewey.
- 13:38They discarded the search for elements entirely.
- 13:41They wanted applied science. They wanted to know
- 13:43how the mind functions to help an organism adapt
- 13:46to its environment. Dewey's reflex circle is
- 13:48a perfect example. If a child reaches out, touches
- 13:51a strange dog, and gets bitten, it is not just
- 13:54a linear stimulus and response. Right. The consequence
- 13:58permanently alters the child's future perception.
- 14:01The child's mind adapts to view dogs as threats.
- 14:05Exactly. Functionalism focused on survival. But
- 14:08concurrently, Gestalt psychology was forming
- 14:11in Germany as a direct rebellion against the
- 14:14reductionism of the structuralists. Founders
- 14:16like Wirtheimer, Kafka, and Kohler, they fiercely
- 14:19believe that the whole is greater than the sum
- 14:21of its parts. Kohler's work with chimpanzees
- 14:24beautifully illustrates this. He hung bananas
- 14:26from a ceiling out of reach and scattered boxes
- 14:29around the room. And the chimps didn't just randomly
- 14:31flail around in blind trial and error like a
- 14:34behaviorist might expect. No, they sat... surveyed
- 14:36the environment, mentally restructured the problem,
- 14:39and then suddenly stacked the boxes to reach
- 14:41the fruit. Kohler called it insight learning.
- 14:43The solution came as a unified whole. But then,
- 14:46in 1913, John B. Watson detonated a bomb in American
- 14:50psychology. He published the Behaviorist Manifesto.
- 14:54Behaviorism. Throwing out consciousness entirely.
- 14:57Watson argued that if psychology was going to
- 14:58be a hard science like physics, it had to abandon
- 15:02introspection. You cannot observe a feeling.
- 15:05Therefore, science must only study observable
- 15:08objective behavior, stimulus, response. and total
- 15:12environmental control. Okay, let's build a visual
- 15:15to sort out these warring schools for the exam.
- 15:17Yes, the house analogy. Imagine you are standing
- 15:20on a street looking at a brick house. The structuralists
- 15:23are the ones standing inches from the wall, obsessively
- 15:26counting every single brick and analyzing the
- 15:28mortar. Right, and the functionalists are ignoring
- 15:31the bricks entirely. They are inside the house
- 15:33checking the furnace and the insulation to see
- 15:35if the structure actually adapts to the winter
- 15:37and keeps you warm. While the Gestalt psychologists
- 15:40are standing back on the lawn, arguing that the
- 15:42bricks and the warmth collectively create the
- 15:44concept of a home, a unified whole that you miss
- 15:47if you just stare at individual bricks. And the
- 15:50behaviorists, they refuse to even look inside
- 15:53the house at all. They are just standing on the
- 15:55curb with a clipboard counting who walks in and
- 15:58out the front door. It's a perfect way to remember
- 16:00it. And the historical irony of these schools
- 16:02is just staggering. In the 1930s, the Gestalt
- 16:06psychologists fled the rise of Nazi Germany to
- 16:09the U .S. Fully armed and ready to wage academic
- 16:12war against the structuralists. Only to realize
- 16:15they were attacking an old version of psychology.
- 16:18By the time they arrived, structuralism was essentially
- 16:20extinct. Behaviorism had already taken over American
- 16:23universities completely. Yeah, it became an absolute
- 16:26juggernaut. It ruled for like 50 years. But eventually
- 16:28treating human beings strictly as mechanical
- 16:30vending machines, insert stimulus, dispense response
- 16:33hit a massive wall. It couldn't account for complex
- 16:36phenomena like language acquisition or memory
- 16:38processing. And that limitation triggered the
- 16:42cognitive revolution in the 1950s and 60s. Right,
- 16:45bringing the mind back into the fold. Pioneers
- 16:47like George Miller with his Magic Number 7 and
- 16:49Ulrich Neisser forced the field to study mental
- 16:52processes again. Even the behaviorists had to
- 16:54adapt. Albert Bandura. introduced socio -behaviorism,
- 16:59proving we don't only learn through direct physical
- 17:01rewards. We learn through social modeling and
- 17:04vicarious reinforcement. Like if you watch someone
- 17:06else touch a hot stove and burn their hand, your
- 17:10brain learns the danger without you ever feeling
- 17:12the pain. Bandura brilliantly bridged the gap
- 17:15between cognitive capacity and observable behavior.
- 17:18Which brings us to how the field operates today.
- 17:22We have pure basic science, like the experimental
- 17:25analysis of behavior represented by APA's Division
- 17:2725. And we have applied science, like applied
- 17:30behavior analysis. What's fascinating here is
- 17:32that modern mainstream psychology doesn't really
- 17:34fight these school wars anymore. Right. They
- 17:36are now complementary processes that help us
- 17:38understand the whole human. So what does this
- 17:40all mean for us? Well, understanding these historical
- 17:42pivots isn't just trivia. Exactly. It's how we
- 17:45diagnose modern issues. Like realizing a veteran's
- 17:48PTSD is a learned physical response to past trauma.
- 17:52We use behaviorism to understand the conditioned
- 17:54response and cognitive strategies to restructure
- 17:57the internal memory. We use the synthesis of
- 18:00our entire history. to actually save lives. So
- 18:03to wrap up, you just absolutely crushed the ultimate
- 18:06undergrad study session. We traveled from Greek
- 18:08gods controlling the weather to Helmholtz measuring
- 18:11nerve impulses right up to modern cognitive behavioral
- 18:15integration. We figured out the mechanisms behind
- 18:17why we do what we do. Although I do want to leave
- 18:19you with one final provocative question based
- 18:22on everything we covered. Oh, boy, lay it on
- 18:24us. If determinism argues. that our past physical
- 18:28events dictate our future actions. And behaviorism
- 18:31shows how thoroughly we are conditioned by our
- 18:34environments. When you make a deeply personal,
- 18:38complex moral decision today, how much of that
- 18:41is your actual free will? And how much is just
- 18:44the history of your learning disguised as a choice?
- 18:46Oh, man. That is going to fundamentally ruin
- 18:49how I view every decision I make today. Just
- 18:51some food for thought. Well, keep questioning
- 18:53your own behaviors, keep digging into the mechanisms
- 18:55behind your choices, and we will catch you on
- 18:57the next session of The Psychology Undergrad.