Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / The Habsburg Jaw: Why the Empire That Ruled the World Couldn't Chew
Transcript
- 0:00When they finally opened him up, the autopsy found a heart, the.
- 0:03Size of a. Peppercorn and almost no blood
- 0:06left in the body. This was a man who couldn't
- 0:09chew, who hadn't been able to walk until he was 8.
- 0:12Years old. And whose own physicians had
- 0:15decided the only real explanation was witchcraft and
- 0:19he was the king of Spain most history books.
- 0:22Look at that. And it reads today's tragedy.
- 0:26But on this channel, we're going to read it more like a balance
- 0:28sheet. The usual story blames
- 0:31ignorance, a family so. Closed off it couldn't see.
- 0:34What it was doing to? Itself, but that's.
- 0:37Not quite what happened. The Hapsburgs.
- 0:39Had a motto bellow gherant. Ali 2 Phallics.
- 0:43Austria nube, let others. Wage war, you happy, Austria?
- 0:47Marry. And that wasn't.
- 0:49Poetry it was. Closer to an operating manual
- 0:52for an entire family every marriage.
- 0:54Was really a piece. Of land acquired and every union
- 0:58locked in a line of succession before anyone had to.
- 1:00Draw a sword. By 1519 that.
- 1:03Approach had built the. First genuinely global empire
- 1:07stretching across Spain, the Americas, the Netherlands,
- 1:10Austria and the Kingdom of Naples.
- 1:13And they done it without armies, using bloodlines and wedding
- 1:16contracts instead. They didn't so much conquer an
- 1:19empire as merry into one. And then they found they
- 1:23couldn't stop. By the time we're done here, you
- 1:26won't just understand while Charles the second jaw.
- 1:29Wouldn't close. You'll start to recognize almost
- 1:32any institution, whether it's financial or political or
- 1:36dynastic, that seals. Itself so tightly.
- 1:39Around its own bloodline that it eventually starts producing its
- 1:42own bewitched kings. Welcome back to Hidden forces in
- 2:04history. I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan.
- 2:06Slate CEO. Of command your brand and you
- 2:10could check us out over at commandyourbrand.com so getting.
- 2:14Back to the Hapsburgs. Before any of that mattered.
- 2:17Though the Hapsburgs were. Nobody in particular, and I
- 2:21don't mean that as an insult. Because that's actually.
- 2:24Where this whole thing begins in 1273, a Swiss count named.
- 2:28Rudolph got himself elected. Holy Roman Emperor by a group of
- 2:32German Princess who specifically wanted a weak king, someone they
- 2:35could control, someone with no real power base of his own, and
- 2:39they chose about as wrong as. They possibly could have.
- 2:43Rudolph didn't have an army big enough to just take.
- 2:45Territory by force and. Didn't have the money.
- 2:48To buy it outright either. What he did have was daughters.
- 2:52Along with a very clear sense that in medieval Europe, a
- 2:55marriage contract worked. Like a property deed, so he
- 2:59spent his. Whole reign, arranging marriages
- 3:01that quietly moved land and title and legal claim into
- 3:05Habsburg hands, and he managed about fighting a single battle.
- 3:09By the time he died in 1291, his family controlled Austria, and
- 3:13again, they hadn't conquered it, they'd married into it.
- 3:17That one move is basically the entire.
- 3:19Hapsburg story. In miniature, every generation
- 3:22that came after ran the same play.
- 3:25More daughters, more deals, more territory.
- 3:28Picked up at the. Altar instead of the
- 3:30battlefield, and for 200 years it.
- 3:32Worked without really ever. Failing the one who truly.
- 3:35Perfected this. Was Maximilian the first?
- 3:38He took what had been a regional tactic and turned it into a.
- 3:42Strategy that covered the. Whole continent.
- 3:44Maximilian was born in 1459, and when he took control of the
- 3:48Hapsburg lands back in the 1480s, he was working with
- 3:51Austria, some parts of what's now Switzerland, and honestly,
- 3:56not much else. By the time he died in 1519,
- 3:59though, his grandchildren were positioned to inherit Spain, the
- 4:03Netherlands, Burgundy, the Kingdom of Naples, and the
- 4:07entire Western Hemisphere. He hadn't fought for any of it.
- 4:12He'd arranged it. The first deal was.
- 4:14The one that really mattered. In 1477, the Duke of Burgundy
- 4:18died in battle, leaving no male heir.
- 4:21One daughter and half of Western Europe already circling the
- 4:25estate. France wanted Burgundy, but
- 4:28Maximilian simply moved faster. He married Mary of Burgundy
- 4:32within four months of. His father's death.
- 4:35And just like that, the Netherlands, Flanders,
- 4:38Luxembourg and the richest trading corridor in Europe all
- 4:42transferred to hapsbourgs in a single ceremony.
- 4:46That marriage only lasted five years before Mary died in a
- 4:49riding accident, but by then the.
- 4:51Territory is already. Locked in the Hapsbourg hands
- 4:55and Maximilian didn't spend long morning because he was already
- 4:58negotiating for Spain. The Spanish deal is the one that
- 5:02changed everything. Ferdinand and.
- 5:05Isabella the same. Monarchs who funded Columbus.
- 5:09Had a daughter. Named Joanna, and Maximilian had
- 5:12a son named Philip, so the arrangement was pretty simple.
- 5:16Philip marries Joanna and the Spanish inheritance comes over.
- 5:21To the hapsborgs. Then Philip died young and
- 5:24Joanna went through a mental collapse serious enough that her
- 5:29family. Locked her away she.
- 5:31Spent the last 50 years of her life confined to a tower and
- 5:34tortoiseia, and history remembers her as Joanna la Loca,
- 5:39Joanna the Mad, the Spanish crown.
- 5:41Never. Actually passed to either of
- 5:42them. It went straight to their son.
- 5:44Charles Charles the 1st. Of Spain.
- 5:48Who is also Charles the 5th? As Holy Roman Emperor came into
- 5:51his titles at 17 years old and he controlled Spain, the
- 5:55Americas, the Netherlands. Austria.
- 5:58The Kingdom of Naples and big stretches of North Africa on top
- 6:02of that. No single ruler in the whole
- 6:05European history had ever held this much territory at one time.
- 6:09Not Charlemagne, not Caesar. Nobody.
- 6:12He built the entire thing on his grandfather's marriage formula
- 6:16and right at the peak at the moment of maximum.
- 6:19Success. The flaw?
- 6:20Buried inside that formula started to.
- 6:22Show for the first. Time, the deepest problem.
- 6:25Here was really the. Question of succession.
- 6:28What had to happen once? All that territory was.
- 6:30Assembled, holding the land was never the hard.
- 6:33Part. There's a document from 1549
- 6:35called the Pragmatic Sanction and most people have never heard
- 6:39of it. What it did was bind the 17
- 6:42provinces of the Habsburg Netherlands.
- 6:44Together, so they'd. Pass intact and undivided to a
- 6:48single heir, and it became a kind of template for how the
- 6:51family thought about inheritance everywhere else.
- 6:54No splitting things up, no subdividing.
- 6:57The whole patrimony stays in one piece.
- 7:00Now, on the surface that sounds like responsible governance, but
- 7:04in practice it turned to a slow motion.
- 7:06Catastrophe because of the. Territory couldn't be divided
- 7:10then, the air had to come from within the bloodline, and a
- 7:13bloodline only holds so many eligible candidates, and by this
- 7:17point most of them were already hapsborgs anyway.
- 7:21Charles actually understood this arithmetic himself before he
- 7:24abdicated in 1556. So he split the empire
- 7:28administratively, giving his son Philip Spain and the western
- 7:32territories, and handing his brother Ferdinand of Austria and
- 7:36the East. So now you've got 2 branches,
- 7:39both of them Habsburg, both of them still running the exact
- 7:43same marriage. Strategy.
- 7:45Which meant that whenever either branch needed their heirs strong
- 7:48enough. To hold it together.
- 7:49There was an obvious solution sitting right there.
- 7:52They could just marry. Each other, the word.
- 7:55For this in genetics is consequinity, which means blood
- 7:59relation, Every one of us. Carries 2 copies.
- 8:02Of each gene from each parent, and when those two parents are
- 8:06closely related, the. Odds go up that both copies are.
- 8:10Carrying the same mutation. Most mutations are harmless, but
- 8:15some of them aren't, and the harmful ones usually stay hidden
- 8:18as long as you've got two different versions of a gene,
- 8:21one working and one faulty the working.
- 8:24Copy just covers. For the damage but once both
- 8:27parents are carrying the same faulty version.
- 8:30Which is exactly what? Happens when they share the same
- 8:33ancestry. Both copies can switch on at the
- 8:37same time, and at that point there's nothing left to cover.
- 8:40For it, that's really what produces.
- 8:42Inbreeding and health problems. There's nothing mysterious.
- 8:45About it, it's just probability. Running in the wrong direction
- 8:49for long enough, and the hapsborgs ran that probability
- 8:52in the wrong direction for two full centuries.
- 8:56The jaw itself showed up early. Maximilian the First already had
- 9:00it and if you. Look at his portraits.
- 9:02You can see that slightly extended lower jaw that would go
- 9:07on to become the family's visual signature across 6 generations
- 9:11of official painting in him. It was still subtle, A mild
- 9:15protrusion that gave his face a certain set.
- 9:18To it. His physicians noticed it, and
- 9:20his artists mostly painted around it.
- 9:23By Philip the 1st. It was more pronounced and by
- 9:26Philip the second it had gotten severe enough.
- 9:29That he needed specific. Accommodations just to get
- 9:31through a meal. The Hapsborg jaw, which?
- 9:34Technically gets called a Manda blur prognosticism.
- 9:39It's basically the lower jaw growing out past the.
- 9:41Upper. And it doesn't only change the
- 9:43face. Once it gets severe enough, the
- 9:47upper and lower teeth stop meeting altogether, so chewing
- 9:51becomes inefficient, swallowing gets harder, and eating ends up
- 9:56taking longer while giving you less nutrition for the effort.
- 9:59The thing the portrait painters were treating as a charming
- 10:02little family quirk was really a metabolic problem building up
- 10:06across generations. And that's going to matter a
- 10:09great deal when we get to Charles the Second.
- 10:12Philip the Second is the hinge point of the whole story.
- 10:15He inherits Spain in 1556 and then ruled for. 42 years.
- 10:19And he was genuinely competent, a careful and deliberate kind of
- 10:23ruler. He built the Escorial.
- 10:26This palace and monastery up in the mountains outside Madrid,
- 10:30sealed off from the outside world and organized entirely
- 10:33around 1 premise that power flows from God down to the King
- 10:39and then through the institutions that he controls.
- 10:42And the design of the place wasn't accidental.
- 10:45The Escorial was a physical statement that the system was
- 10:48closed, that it was complete, and that it needed no input from
- 10:53anywhere. Outside itself.
- 10:55Philip understood the empire as a closed system and he governed
- 10:59it. Exactly that way.
- 11:00He also married his own niece, his fourth wife, Anna.
- 11:04Of Austria was the daughter of his sister.
- 11:08That marriage needed a formal papal dispensation, which was
- 11:11basically written permission from Rome admitting the union
- 11:14was technically incestuous, but treating it as strategically
- 11:19necessary. To keep the Catholic.
- 11:21Hapsburg line going and the church granted it.
- 11:24The way it always did. Because from Rome's point of
- 11:27view, the alternative Hapsburg lands slipping to a Protestant
- 11:31line was far worse of an outcome.
- 11:34Philip. Genuinely.
- 11:35Believed that he was. Protecting the bloodline, and in
- 11:38a sense. He was.
- 11:40He was also concentrating a whole set of genetic risks.
- 11:44That wouldn't fully. Show themselves for another 2
- 11:46generations. Spain under Philip the Second
- 11:49was the dominant power on earth and the silver coming out of the
- 11:53Americas. Pulled through a forced labor.
- 11:56System called the Misha is what financed the European wars that
- 12:00kept the whole empire. Held together.
- 12:02The system was producing and then in 1588 the Armada sailed
- 12:06for England and never came back. That's.
- 12:08Roughly 130 ships and 30,000 men.
- 12:12And in the end, the storms off the Irish coast did more damage
- 12:16to them than the English cannons ever did.
- 12:18Philip got the news. Back at the Escorial.
- 12:21And he reportedly said I sent my ships against men, not against
- 12:26the winds and the. Waves of God.
- 12:28And then he shut the door and just kept on governing.
- 12:31He left the Empire strategic position exactly where it was
- 12:35and he never touched the marriage.
- 12:37Policy. In his mind, the system was
- 12:39sound and the Armada. Had just been a fluke.
- 12:43The Dutch Revolt, meanwhile, had already been grinding on for 20
- 12:47years at that point, the northern provinces.
- 12:50Which were the? Richest trading territories in
- 12:53the whole empire. We're well into what would
- 12:55eventually stretch out into an. 80 year war.
- 12:58Of independence and years before Phillips answer.
- 13:02To all of it. Had been to send.
- 13:03The Duke of Alba. In with a standing army and a
- 13:07policy of public executions, which really only accelerated
- 13:11the rebellion. So now it's more silver coming
- 13:13out of the Americas. To pay for the.
- 13:14Crackdown. More money poured into.
- 13:16Wars that force what? Was never going to win.
- 13:20This is more or less what Paul Kennedy called imperial
- 13:23overstretch, the point where a great powers commitments start
- 13:27to outrun the economy underneath them and it begins spending its
- 13:30own. Future just to.
- 13:32Defend the present. The Empire had been built on
- 13:34contracts and now it was trying to hold itself together with
- 13:38armies. Instead, that's.
- 13:39More than a tactical. Shift.
- 13:41It's a system quietly admitting that its own.
- 13:43Logic has stopped working. Philip the Second died in 1598
- 13:48and left Spain to his son Philip the Third, who was 20 years old,
- 13:52fond of ceremony and almost completely uninterested in the
- 13:56actual work of governing. He appointed a man named
- 13:59Francisco Gomez de Sandoval as his chief minister, and this was
- 14:03the. First of the great Vallidos.
- 14:06A volado was essentially. A royal favorite.
- 14:09Who got handed real? Executive.
- 14:10Power. The King would sign the
- 14:12documents and the Volado would actually run the state.
- 14:16And you shouldn't read this. As.
- 14:17Occupation in the modern sense. It's more like the system
- 14:21quietly adapting to a problem it couldn't.
- 14:23Say out loud. The bloodline had to sit on the
- 14:26throne because the entire legal and religious foundation of the
- 14:30Empire depended on it, but the actual man on the throne was
- 14:33less and less capable of governing.
- 14:36So the capacity to. Govern just migrated somewhere.
- 14:38Else the. Bloodline kept the title and the
- 14:41valido. Held the real power.
- 14:44And that gap between who? Legally held the authority.
- 14:47And who actually? Exercised it.
- 14:49Kept widening with every generation that came after.
- 14:53Philip the third son was Philip the 4th and Philip the. 4th had
- 14:57a valido. Of his own named Gaspar de
- 14:59Guzman, the Count Duke of Olivar, and Olivar was probably
- 15:04the most capable administrator Spain ever produced in the
- 15:08entire 17th century. JH Elliott, whose biography of
- 15:12him is still the standard account, frames him more or less
- 15:16in that way as a reformer who saw a painful clarity.
- 15:20With exactly what was. Wrong with the empire and still
- 15:23couldn't budget the institutions standing in his way.
- 15:26He understood that his empire. Was overstretched.
- 15:29And badly under financed and he spent something like 20 years
- 15:33trying to reform it. He proposed.
- 15:35Spreading the tax burden. Across the Hapsburg territories.
- 15:38Instead of dumping it on Castile.
- 15:40And he wanted an army in every region that would pay into it
- 15:44proportionally. Beyond that, he was trying to
- 15:47centralized. The bureaucracy.
- 15:48Just enough that you could actually.
- 15:50Govern a continent with it and every single proposal.
- 15:53Failed. The regional nobility blocked
- 15:56him, the Church blocked him and the whole institutional.
- 15:59Layer the Habsburg had. Originally used to build the
- 16:01empire, the councils and the church courts and the structures
- 16:05of noble privilege had hardened into veto powers that no reform
- 16:10could get passed. Olivar fell from power in 1643,
- 16:14disgraced and exiled and pretty much broken, and Philip the 4th
- 16:18spent the last 20 years of his reign just watching the whole
- 16:21thing come apart. The 30 Years War.
- 16:23Ended in 1640. 8 With the Peace of Westfalia.
- 16:27And Spain was still standing at the end of it.
- 16:30But it wasn't the same thing it had been back in 1550.
- 16:33Six it was. Smaller, now poorer, running on
- 16:37debt and sitting on top of territories that increasingly
- 16:40wanted out and the man who was going to inherit.
- 16:43All of that. Had already been born.
- 16:45Charles the Second was born November 6th, 1661.
- 16:49To Philip the. 4th of Spain and Mariana of Austria, and Mariana
- 16:54was Philip's own niece and the daughter.
- 16:56Of his sister. So this is the same close
- 16:59relation move that Philip the Second had already made with
- 17:01Anna of Austria a generation. Before, except that by. 1661 The
- 17:07family tree had been folding back on itself through four
- 17:09straight generations of deliberate cousin and uncle
- 17:13niece marriages, the term geneticists use for this.
- 17:16Is the. Coefficient of the inbreeding it
- 17:19measures. What share of a?
- 17:20Person's genes trace back to a common ancestor who show up on
- 17:23both sides of the family tree at once.
- 17:26For two completely unrelated people, that number.
- 17:29Is basically 0. For first cousins it's about
- 17:316.25% and for full sibling union it's around 25%.
- 17:36So Charles the Second's coefficient came out to 25.4%.
- 17:41Which is actually higher. Than you'd get from siblings and
- 17:44no single marriage. Produced that it built up.
- 17:47Across 9 generations of strategic marriages, all folding
- 17:51back to the same small family pool.
- 17:53That number, by the way, comes from a Spanish geneticist named
- 17:57Gonzalo Alvarez and his team at the University of Santiago de
- 18:01Compostela. Who published?
- 18:03The full analysis back in 2009 they traced.
- 18:06All of Charles the. 2nd ancestral lines back across 16
- 18:10generations and more than 3000 relatives in total and the same
- 18:14individuals kept turning up on both sides of the family tree
- 18:17over and over Philip the. 1st. The man whose Castile marriage
- 18:22had kicked off the entire empire appears in Charles the Second's
- 18:26ancestry again and again. So by the end the shape of it
- 18:30stops looking like a tree and starts looking a lot more.
- 18:33Like a closed loop. Charles wasn't expected to
- 18:36survive infancy at all. He was born premature and so
- 18:40physically. Fragile that they.
- 18:42Baptized him immediately after delivery on the assumption that
- 18:46he wouldn't last the week. But he did survive.
- 18:49And the life that. Followed was basically a.
- 18:51Catalog of everything that. Closed loop had produced, he
- 18:55couldn't. Walk until he was 8 years old.
- 18:58He didn't speak clearly until about 10, and his head was
- 19:02noticeably too. Large for the rest of his body.
- 19:05His tongue was enlarged enough that both eating and speaking.
- 19:09Took visible, labored effort. And his lower jaw.
- 19:12Extended so far past the. Upper one that his teeth never
- 19:16actually made contact, which meant he couldn't.
- 19:18Chew solid food at all. So he was.
- 19:21Kept on a near liquid diet for most of his.
- 19:23Life. Taking in less nutrition in a
- 19:26day than an ordinary working class Spaniard.
- 19:29He had frequent seizures. His physicians wrote down that
- 19:32he vomited. Habitually his digestive system.
- 19:35Unable to fully handle even that little that he did manage to get
- 19:39down, he went bald before his mid. 30s and he was.
- 19:42Tired in this deep, constant way that no amount of rest ever
- 19:46seemed to fix. So by the time he was a
- 19:49teenager, the most powerful empire in the Western world was
- 19:53being run on behalf of a king who couldn't physically get
- 19:56through a meal without help. And the court had no real way to
- 19:59acknowledge any of this. The divine right of kings.
- 20:03The religious. Idea that justified absolute.
- 20:05Monarchy in the 1st. Place.
- 20:07Demanded that the king actually be the king.
- 20:10He had to be the. Person genuinely ruling, not a
- 20:13symbol and not a figurehead, but in reality, Charles the Second's
- 20:18mother, Mariana. Served.
- 20:20As Regent all through his minority and a rotating.
- 20:23Set of volados. And court favorites made the
- 20:26actual executive decisions. The whole court organized itself
- 20:31around working around his incapacity without ever naming
- 20:34it aloud, because to name it, you'd have to name the cause,
- 20:38and naming the cause would mean admitting that the marriage.
- 20:41Strategy the very. Thing that had built the empire
- 20:45was also the thing that had produced the king who couldn't
- 20:47rule it. And that wasn't just a
- 20:49conversation about the court was willing to have so instead.
- 20:53They called it. Witchcraft.
- 20:55Serious investigations actually got commissioned over it, and
- 20:59two separate exorcisms were performed on the King of Spain
- 21:02himself, the Inquisition, whose entire job was to identify and
- 21:07root out. Threats to the Catholic order
- 21:09got brought. In to investigate whether
- 21:11supernatural forces were behind the King's condition, and they
- 21:14concluded that he'd been bewitched.
- 21:16Through a a cup of. Chocolate that somebody given
- 21:19him as a child. The explanation they landed on
- 21:22demonic affliction was in some way exactly the explanation they
- 21:26needed. It placed the cause.
- 21:28Somewhere outside the system, which meant the system never had
- 21:32to turn around and examine itself.
- 21:35Charles the Second married. Twice over his life. 1st to
- 21:38Marie Louise of Orlean in 1679, and then after her death to
- 21:43Mariana of Neuberg in 1689. But he was impotent, and neither
- 21:48marriage ever produced a. Child.
- 21:50And this was the final consequence of the whole
- 21:53operating system. The marriage strategy had been
- 21:56built specifically to generate airs and lock in territorial
- 21:59continuity. And now it had delivered a king
- 22:02who couldn't generate an air at. All.
- 22:04The exact same. The system existed to prevent
- 22:07the line ending in the territory breaking apart, and the empire
- 22:10dissolving was now basically guaranteed.
- 22:13Every major power in Europe knew Charles the Second was going to
- 22:17die without an heir they'd honestly known it for.
- 22:20Years. And they were already
- 22:22negotiating what came next long before he was anywhere near the
- 22:26grave. So the succession crisis when it
- 22:29finally came. Caught nobody off guard.
- 22:32In a sense, it had been on the calendar.
- 22:34For years. Both France and.
- 22:37Austria had legal. Claims to the Spanish throne
- 22:40running through the Hapsburg women who'd married out of the
- 22:43Direct Line in earlier generations.
- 22:46Louis the 14th of France was married to the Spanish Infanta
- 22:49Maria Teresa. The daughter of Philip the 4th.
- 22:53And the Austrian hapsborgs had a candidate of their own coming
- 22:56through a separate branch. So you've got 2 great powers.
- 22:59And one dying empire sitting between them.
- 23:02And the negotiations were happening while Charles the
- 23:05Second was still alive, still technically raining there.
- 23:08Were a series of. Partition treaties that carved
- 23:11up the Spanish inheritance like an estate inventory taken before
- 23:15the owner had ever stopped breathing.
- 23:17England and the Dutch. Republic were part of these
- 23:20talks to. The working assumption behind
- 23:22all of it was that the Empire. Would have to be distributed.
- 23:26And no single power could inherit the whole thing and tip
- 23:29the balance of the continent. Then Charles the Second found
- 23:32out about the partition treaties and it made him.
- 23:35Furious, he could live with the idea of.
- 23:37Succession planning in the abstract.
- 23:39What he couldn't stand was that they'd arranged the entire thing
- 23:43behind his back without ever consulting him.
- 23:46So in the final months of his. Life.
- 23:48Knowing that he was dying and determined to preserve the thing
- 23:52the system had always demanded, which was territorial integrity,
- 23:56he signed a will naming Philip of Anjou, the grandson of.
- 24:00Louis the 14th, his sole heir. And Philip was a Borbin, not a
- 24:04Hapsburg. At all.
- 24:06Which meant that with one signature, the Hapsburg line in
- 24:09Spain had come to an end. Charles the Second died on
- 24:13November 1st, 1700 at. 38 years old.
- 24:17And the autopsy his court physicians carried out?
- 24:19Recorded exactly what I described at the very start.
- 24:22They found a heart. About the size of.
- 24:24Peppercorn. Corroded lungs, Intestines.
- 24:27Full of putrid water. And a brain that, in their
- 24:31notes, had been reduced. To a liquid state, the body of
- 24:35the lapse Hapsborg. King of Spain was, in a real
- 24:38sense, the whole system's balance sheet laid open on the.
- 24:42Table The war that broke out after his death lasted. 13 years
- 24:47The War of Spanish Succession pulled in England.
- 24:49The Dutch Republic. The Austrian Hapsborg.
- 24:52Portugal, Savoy and. Eventually, most of the
- 24:56continent in one form or another, it produced some of
- 24:59the. Bloodiest set pieces, battles
- 25:01that Europe had ever. Seen to that point.
- 25:03At places. Like Blenheim and Malpaquet,
- 25:06names that basically became. Bywords for slaughter.
- 25:10And it ended with the trees of 1713 and 1714.
- 25:14Utrecht first, then Rolfstadt and Baden, redistributing
- 25:18whatever was left of the Spanish Empire and confirming the new
- 25:21order in Europe. Spain but keep its monarchy, and
- 25:25Philip of Anjou became Philip the 5th of Spain.
- 25:28But the Empire itself lost the Netherlands, Naples, Sardinia
- 25:32and Milan to Austria, and Gibraltar went to Britain, and
- 25:35the empire that Maximilian the First had assembled in two
- 25:38centuries of marriage contracts got legally taken apart in about
- 25:4218 months of treaty negotiations.
- 25:45The thing that had taken 2. 100 years to build.
- 25:47Had needed only about two generations to rot from the
- 25:50inside and nothing outside it really did the damage the
- 25:55system. Did it to itself.
- 25:57So this pattern is sending underneath.
- 25:59All of it. The hapsborgs built an empire by
- 26:02turning the bloodline itself into the asset every marriage.
- 26:05Was a piece of. Territory acquired and every air
- 26:08was a guarantee that the whole thing would continue.
- 26:11And that logic actually held up fine as long as the bloodline
- 26:15was still expanding, still taking in new families, new
- 26:18genetics, new administrative capacity from outside.
- 26:22But empires don't expand forever.
- 26:24Rome showed us that. There's a passage from Iban
- 26:27Khaldoon writing all the way back in the 14th century, long
- 26:31before anyone had a word like genetics, where he puts the
- 26:35natural lifespan of ruling dynasty at roughly 3
- 26:38generations. You get the ones who built it,
- 26:41the ones who imitate. The builders.
- 26:43And finally the ones who inherit the whole thing, and quietly.
- 26:47Let it fall apart. He was, really.
- 26:49Describing the loss of what he. Called solidarity, but the shape
- 26:53he's. Sketching there is the same
- 26:54shape we're watching play out. With the hapsborgs.
- 26:57At a certain. Scale the appetite for.
- 26:59Acquisition. Just reverses the priority.
- 27:02Quietly shifts from expanding to preserving, and for a system
- 27:05built on a bloodline, preserving means keeping the asset locked
- 27:09inside the line. No outside blood coming in, no
- 27:13dilution, no loss of. Control.
- 27:15So the very. Same logic that assembled the
- 27:17empire turned into the logic. That destroyed it because.
- 27:21Once you close a system off this tightly once, self continuity
- 27:25becomes the main thing it's optimizing for.
- 27:28You lose the ability. To take an information.
- 27:30From the outside the loop. You stop being able to respond.
- 27:33To the world is actually. Doing out there and you start
- 27:36producing administrators who can't administer, kings who
- 27:39can't rule, and eventually jaws that won't even close.
- 27:44And this really isn't only a Hapsborg problem, it's any
- 27:47institution that's been running too long and ask the same basic
- 27:51question about it. Who it is actually built?
- 27:53To serve at this point. You've got the corporate.
- 27:56Board that fills every vacancy of the same social circle, the
- 28:00same alumni pool, the same 20 or so families that have built
- 28:04rotating through the same. Seats for 30 years.
- 28:07You've got the political. Dynasty that keeps recycling the
- 28:09same handful of surnames across 4 generations.
- 28:12Of elected office. Getting a little more insulated
- 28:15from the. People it supposedly.
- 28:16Represents with each cycle you've got the financial firm
- 28:20that keeps promoting from within the people.
- 28:22Who? Protect how things already.
- 28:24Work. And never really the ones who
- 28:26point out where it's failing. And you got the central bank
- 28:30that's run for more than a century.
- 28:32Without a full public. Audit of its monetary
- 28:34operations. There'd be plenty to find, if
- 28:37anyone. Actually looked it stays that
- 28:40way. Because the institution's first
- 28:42obligation, the one that quietly outranks its official mandate,
- 28:46is to the whole network of institutions that depend on it
- 28:50staying. Exactly as is.
- 28:52None of these are cartoonish villains sitting around running
- 28:55some deliberate conspiracy. They're closed systems just
- 28:59following their own survival. Logic.
- 29:01Every closed system eventually starts optimizing for its own.
- 29:04Survival over, actually. Doing its job, and any closed
- 29:08system that runs long enough without correction from the
- 29:10outside will at some point produce its own version.
- 29:14Of Charles the Second. It won't always be a king with a
- 29:17jaw that won't close. Sometimes it's a central bank
- 29:20policy that can't adapt to the very conditions that its own
- 29:24models. Predicted.
- 29:25Sometimes it's a political. Class that.
- 29:27Keeps getting the same signal from the population and keeps
- 29:30holding back the same non response.
- 29:33And sometimes it's a currency system that just keeps issuing
- 29:35debt against collateral. It doesn't really exist anymore
- 29:38at the values being claimed for it.
- 29:41Because to correct the. Valuation would mean admitting
- 29:43the. Collateral was always.
- 29:45Just the inner circle and the inner circle.
- 29:47Can't audit itself. It's really the same playbook,
- 29:51just running in a different century.
- 29:53The Habsburg jaw is such a. Famous deformity mainly.
- 29:56Because it's visible. You can, literally.
- 29:58Trace it through the portraits. Watching Maximilian's Subtle.
- 30:01Little. Protrusion around 1500.
- 30:04Turn into Philip the Second's accommodated underbite and then
- 30:07into Charles the Second's severe extension, the kind that forced
- 30:11him into a liquid. Diet just to stay alive it's
- 30:13the. System closing in on itself,
- 30:16painted in oil generation after generation, sitting right there
- 30:20for anyone to look at the whole sequence as a sequence instead
- 30:25of a set of. Separate portraits, but the jaw
- 30:27itself. Was only ever the output the
- 30:30visible symptom? The actual disease was the.
- 30:33Operating principle behind it Bella Garant, Ali to Felix
- 30:37Austrian nube let. Others wage war.
- 30:40You happy Austria? Marry It worked for 200.
- 30:44Years because it was a. System that could outmaneuver.
- 30:47Raw force. Using contracts and it failed in
- 30:50the 3rd century for a very simple reason, which is that
- 30:54contracts. Require two parties.
- 30:56Once the only acceptable parties were already inside your own
- 30:59bloodline, the contract stops being in agreement.
- 31:02With the outside world. And turns into a document the
- 31:05system is just issuing. To itself, it's a loop dressed
- 31:09up as a policy, a closed circuit.
- 31:12Still calling itself an empire, so in the end.
- 31:16The Habsburg jaw was a lot. More than a genetic.
- 31:19Curiosity. It was the state itself.
- 31:22Becoming physically unable to. Feed the very.
- 31:24Population, it ruled. This has been hidden forces in
- 31:27history. I'm Jeremy Ryan.
- 31:28Slate, please Like this video? Leave us a comment and smash the
- 31:33subscribe button if you want more hidden forces in history.