Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use Reciprocity Without Looking Transactional
Transcript
- Lucas: There's a moment in every workplace relationship where you wonder — if I do this person a favor, am I building goodwill or just creating a tab they'll feel obligated to repay? Luna: Right, and the difference is huge. One builds trust, the other builds awkwardness. Lucas: Exactly. And I think a lot of us have been on both sides. You do something nice for a colleague, and then a week later they're doing something for you — but it feels oddly transactional, like you're both keeping a mental ledger. Luna: Or worse — you do a favor and the person never reciprocates, and you start feeling resentful. So you stop helping. And the relationship stagnates. Lucas: That's the classic 'matching' behavior that Adam Grant talks about in his book Give and Take. He categorizes people into givers, takers, and matchers. Matchers keep score — they'll help you, but they expect you to help them back in roughly equal measure. Luna: And that's most of us, I think. We're socialized to reciprocate, so we do. But the problem is, when reciprocity feels like a transaction, it actually undermines trust. Lucas: Yes. Grant's research shows that the most effective networkers aren't the matchers — they're the givers. People who help without expecting anything in return. But here's the catch: they're also the most likely to burn out if they're not strategic about it. Luna: So how do you be a giver without getting taken advantage of? That's the million-dollar question. Lucas: Well, let's look at a concrete case. I was talking to a product manager at a mid-size SaaS company — let's call her Priya. She was trying to get buy-in from the engineering team for a feature that required extra work on their end. Instead of going in with a request, she started by doing small, unsolicited favors for the engineering leads. Luna: Like what kind of favors? Lucas: She'd noticed that one of the lead engineers was struggling with the documentation for a third-party API they were integrating. So she spent an afternoon writing a clear, concise guide and shared it with him — no strings attached. For another engineer, she found a bug in the user interface and flagged it before it hit the backlog. Simple stuff, but genuinely helpful. Luna: So she built a reciprocity loop before she needed anything. That's smart. Lucas: Exactly. And when she did finally ask for the extra engineering hours, the leads were much more receptive. Not because they felt obligated, but because they already saw her as someone who had their back. The reciprocity was social, not transactional. Luna: I think there's a subtle art to that. If you do a favor and then immediately ask for something, it feels like a trade. But if you space it out — and especially if the favor is something the other person didn't even ask for — it builds genuine goodwill. Lucas: Right. The key is that the favor has to be valuable to them, not just convenient for you. Priya didn't just offer to grab coffee — she solved a real pain point. That signals that you pay attention to what people actually need. Luna: So what about the danger of creating obligation? I've been on the receiving end of a favor where I felt like I owed someone, and it made me uncomfortable. That can backfire. Lucas: Absolutely. That's what some researchers call 'obligation reciprocity' — when the favor is so big or so unsolicited that the recipient feels trapped. The trick is to make the favor small enough that it's easy to accept without feeling indebted, but meaningful enough that it's memorable. Luna: So like, share a useful article with a note about why you thought of them. Or introduce them to someone you know they'd benefit from meeting. Not, say, cover for them on a major project. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're on the receiving end of a favor you didn't ask for, the best response is gratitude, not immediate repayment. That's actually what builds the relationship — acknowledging that you saw the gesture. Luna: Okay, so what's your practical framework for this? How does someone start building reciprocity loops at work tomorrow? Lucas: I'd break it into three steps. First, identify a few key people you want to build better relationships with — people you collaborate with regularly or whose support you might need down the line. Second, pay attention to their work long enough to notice a genuine pain point or interest. Third, offer help that directly addresses that pain point, and do it without any mention of a future ask. Luna: And what if you don't have the time or expertise to help? Like, what if you can't solve their problem? Lucas: Then you can still offer a resource — a book, a podcast episode, a connection to someone who can help. The gesture still signals that you're thinking about them. And that's often enough to start the loop. Luna: I've seen this work really well in cross-functional teams. When I was in marketing, I used to share early data from our campaigns with the product team before they asked for it. Just a simple email saying, 'Hey, here's what we're seeing on the latest launch — thought you might find it useful.' And over time, they started sharing their roadmap early with me. Lucas: That's a perfect example. You gave them information they didn't know they needed, and it made them more likely to reciprocate with something valuable to you. And because it was unsolicited, it felt generous rather than transactional. Luna: Right. And I think that's the core insight: the most effective reciprocity is the kind that doesn't look like reciprocity at all. It just looks like being a helpful colleague. Lucas: That's worth repeating. If the other person feels like you're keeping score, you've already lost. The goal is to be someone who helps — and then, because of that, people want to help you back. Not because they have to, but because they want to. Luna: And that's really the difference between a strong professional network and a transactional one. Lucas: Yeah. And speaking of the value of these conversations — you know, if we've helped you think through a career move or a tricky workplace situation, it genuinely means a lot to hear that. A couple of dollars a month is what keeps these shows going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Luna: Yeah, and it's a small thing that makes a big difference. We keep the podcast ad-free because of listeners like that. Lucas: Alright, back to the framework. So step one: identify key people. Step two: notice their pain points. Step three: offer help with no strings attached. But there's a fourth step that's easy to miss — and that's accepting help graciously when it comes your way. Luna: Oh, that's a good point. A lot of people are terrible at receiving help. They say 'oh, no, I'm fine' and brush it off. Lucas: And that actually breaks the reciprocity loop. If someone offers to help you, and you reject it, they feel like you don't trust them or don't value their contribution. So accepting help — with genuine thanks — is part of building the relationship. Luna: So you're saying that being a good receiver is just as important as being a good giver? Lucas: Absolutely. And it's harder than it sounds. Especially for high-achievers who are used to being self-sufficient. But if you want to build a culture of reciprocity around you, you have to model both sides. Luna: Let's talk about one more pitfall: the favor that's actually a burden. I've had people offer to 'help' me by taking over a task I didn't want to delegate — because I needed to maintain quality control. Their offer felt more like a critique than a gift. Lucas: That's a great point. The favor has to be genuinely wanted. That's why step two — paying attention — is so critical. You can't just assume you know what someone needs. You have to observe, or even ask, 'What's on your plate that's frustrating you right now?' Luna: Exactly. And if they say 'nothing,' then you don't force it. You wait for a real opportunity. Lucas: Right. And sometimes the best favor isn't doing something for them — it's doing something with them. Collaborating on a problem can feel more like a partnership than a handout. Luna: Okay, so let's imagine someone listening to this who's in a new job and wants to build reciprocity loops fast. Where do they start? Lucas: I'd say pick one person in a role you'll need to work with closely — maybe a peer in a different department. Then find one small way to make their life easier this week. It could be as simple as sending them a template you created that saved you time. The key is to do it without expecting anything back. Luna: And then what? Wait for them to reciprocate? Lucas: Don't wait. Don't watch. Just keep being helpful. Over time, you'll notice that they start offering you information or support without being asked. That's when you know the loop is working — when it becomes mutual and natural. Luna: I think that's the mark of really effective office politics: you build such a strong reputation for generosity that people want to be on your side. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a much better long-term strategy than transactional networking. So to sum up: identify, observe, help, accept. And do it all with genuine intent, not as a manipulation tactic. Luna: Because people can smell a setup from a mile away. Lucas: They really can. So keep it real, keep it small, and keep it consistent. That's how you build reciprocity that lasts.