Latest / Bloomberg Law / High Court Seems Divided on Shield for Religious Schools
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: You're listening to Bloomberg Law with June Grasso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:06Speaker 1: The relationship between church and state was before the Supreme
- 0:09Speaker 1: Court once again on Monday, as the Justice is considered
- 0:12Speaker 1: calls by religious schools for a broader exemption from employment
- 0:16Speaker 1: discrimination lawsuits. The justices appeared divided along ideological lines. Here
- 0:21Speaker 1: are Justices Sonya Soto, Mayor and Neil Gorst's you're asking
- 0:26Speaker 1: for an exception to law that's broader than the ministerial
- 0:30Speaker 1: exception generally, and broader than is necessary to protect the church.
- 0:37Speaker 1: Why couldn't we just simply say that sincerely held religious
- 0:42Speaker 1: belief about who is a minister should control just like
- 0:44Speaker 1: we do everywhere else in the First Amendment. And joining
- 0:47Speaker 1: me is Richard Garnett, a professor at Notre Dame Law School.
- 0:50Speaker 1: Rick explain what the ministerial exception is and when the
- 0:53Speaker 1: Supreme Court recognized it. Sure, so, lower courts went first
- 0:58Speaker 1: on this issue. Lower courts recognized what they called a
- 1:01Speaker 1: ministrail exception about forty years ago, and the idea here
- 1:04Speaker 1: was that for certain classes of employees, employment discrimination lawsuits
- 1:09Speaker 1: couldn't go forward because if they did, it would get
- 1:12Speaker 1: courts involved and you know, what they thought was kind
- 1:14Speaker 1: of the tricky business of having to interfere with religious
- 1:18Speaker 1: decisions between ministers and religious institutions. And so this doctrine
- 1:22Speaker 1: would have been around for a long time. And the
- 1:24Speaker 1: reason the Supreme Court never addressed it was because all
- 1:26Speaker 1: the lower courts agreed that there was such a doctrine,
- 1:29Speaker 1: and there were there were disputes about details in particular cases,
- 1:32Speaker 1: but the basic idea that if the separation of church
- 1:34Speaker 1: and State needs anything, it means that the government can't
- 1:37Speaker 1: tell churches who hires their ministers. That there was a
- 1:39Speaker 1: lot of consensus on that point. Then the Supreme Court
- 1:42Speaker 1: weighed in in two thousand and twelve, they finally did
- 1:44Speaker 1: take a case, and they were ruled unanimously that yes,
- 1:47Speaker 1: there is a ministerial exception that the First Amendment does
- 1:51Speaker 1: not permit some employment discrimination lawsuits to go forward. So
- 1:55Speaker 1: you know, it would be illegal for Walmart to refuse
- 1:57Speaker 1: to hire a woman, but the government doesn't have a
- 2:00Speaker 1: power to tell an Orthodox Jewish congregation that it has
- 2:03Speaker 1: to hire a woman to be its rabbi, and so on.
- 2:05Speaker 1: The disagreement has been not so much about the principle
- 2:08Speaker 1: of the thing I mean, I think everybody has kind
- 2:11Speaker 1: of an instinct. The government can't make the Catholic Church
- 2:13Speaker 1: ordained women priests. But it's more about the shape of
- 2:16Speaker 1: the doctrine, right who count has a religious institution, who
- 2:20Speaker 1: counts as a ministerial employee. And there's been a lot
- 2:23Speaker 1: of cases that have been pretty easy. If a church
- 2:26Speaker 1: fires its pastor, that's pretty obviously a minister. So what
- 2:30Speaker 1: was the main issue in these cases which involved teachers
- 2:33Speaker 1: and Catholic schools who were not ordained ministers, who had
- 2:36Speaker 1: a mix of job duties religious and secular, And so
- 2:40Speaker 1: the issue was how do you decide who counts as
- 2:43Speaker 1: a ministerial employee? And in these two cases, the lower
- 2:47Speaker 1: courts had taken a narrower review than most courts had.
- 2:52Speaker 1: Most courts had taken a pretty deferential approach, you know,
- 2:55Speaker 1: not wanting to kind of get involved in wading into
- 2:57Speaker 1: the weeds about you know, counting up how many minute
- 3:00Speaker 1: the teachers is doing religious subjects or what have you.
- 3:03Speaker 1: And what the justices were wrestling with was not whether
- 3:05Speaker 1: there should be a ministry or exception. I think all
- 3:07Speaker 1: the justices agreed there should be one. The question they
- 3:10Speaker 1: were wrestling with those kind of how far should it reach?
- 3:13Speaker 1: Should courts be kind of second guessing religious institutions designations
- 3:18Speaker 1: of their own ministers they leave up to them, and
- 3:20Speaker 1: so on? And how did the justices way the competing
- 3:22Speaker 1: considerations the justices, you know, we're asking lawyers on both sides, well,
- 3:27Speaker 1: you know, what about this kind of case, or you
- 3:28Speaker 1: know what if you have a teacher who does religion
- 3:31Speaker 1: for two hours a day but is also a gym coach,
- 3:33Speaker 1: or what if you have somebody who's a they're a
- 3:35Speaker 1: Lutheran person at a Catholic school who says grace before meals.
- 3:40Speaker 1: You know, I think for one side of the case,
- 3:42Speaker 1: they wanted to show these hypothecles like, look, this thing
- 3:44Speaker 1: could sweep really broadly, and would that undermine the importance
- 3:47Speaker 1: of antidiscrimination law. The other side was trying to make
- 3:50Speaker 1: the point. I think that, look, we don't want secular
- 3:53Speaker 1: courts getting in the business of making these kind of
- 3:56Speaker 1: fine grain distinctions based on how many minutes a day
- 4:00Speaker 1: person might spend teaching math versus teaching catechisess and theology.
- 4:05Speaker 1: And you know, at a lot of schools the math
- 4:06Speaker 1: teacher does play an important religious role and you can't
- 4:09Speaker 1: make it just depend on the label. The arguments at
- 4:12Speaker 1: the end of the day were really about the difficulty
- 4:14Speaker 1: of line drawing. There was a lot of consensus at
- 4:17Speaker 1: the level of high principle right religious freedom is important.
- 4:21Speaker 1: Religious institutions should get to govern themselves and decides who
- 4:23Speaker 1: their ministers are. We don't want secular courts involved in
- 4:26Speaker 1: these decisions. There seemed to be a fair bit of
- 4:28Speaker 1: agreement on those points, but the argument was more about
- 4:31Speaker 1: where do you draw the line? So Rick, what's your
- 4:33Speaker 1: sense of how the justices might line up in the case.
- 4:37Speaker 1: My read of the situation was that maybe it won't
- 4:41Speaker 1: be unanimous this time, but that you'll still have a
- 4:43Speaker 1: majority of the justices saying, look, this doctrine is important,
- 4:47Speaker 1: and it really should prevent courts from getting involved in
- 4:53Speaker 1: um sort of second guessing the employment decisions that religious
- 4:56Speaker 1: institutions make about people who they regard as having an
- 5:01Speaker 1: important ministerial or religious role. Justice course, it's said that
- 5:06Speaker 1: we don't second guess these sincerely held religious beliefs in
- 5:09Speaker 1: First Amendment cases? Why should we hear so? Do you
- 5:12Speaker 1: think that enough justice will come down and say we
- 5:16Speaker 1: shouldn't second guesses at all. Whoever religious institution says is
- 5:20Speaker 1: a minister, that's a minister. Well, uh, he used. He
- 5:24Speaker 1: was making an analogy to what we do in free
- 5:26Speaker 1: exercise cases around the sincerely held belief issue, And that
- 5:30Speaker 1: comes up in RIFRA cases obviously, and it comes up
- 5:33Speaker 1: in free exercise cases. UM courts do inquire in those
- 5:38Speaker 1: kind of cases into whether a claim about religion is sincere.
- 5:42Speaker 1: I mean, if a court thinks that the that the
- 5:44Speaker 1: party is typically not telling the truth about their religious beliefs,
- 5:48Speaker 1: then they don't have to give credence to that. But
- 5:51Speaker 1: I think what justice course it was alluding to was
- 5:54Speaker 1: the idea that, look, we take a pretty we take
- 5:57Speaker 1: a pretty light touch when it comes to um second
- 6:01Speaker 1: guessing somebody who tells us what their religious beliefs are.
- 6:04Speaker 1: And similarly, it makes sense in this context to take
- 6:08Speaker 1: a pretty light touch to the question of if a
- 6:10Speaker 1: religious community tells us and tells the world that they
- 6:15Speaker 1: regard a particular position as important to the religious mission,
- 6:19Speaker 1: it's not really our job to second guess that. Again,
- 6:22Speaker 1: if we're going to take this kind of church state
- 6:24Speaker 1: separation idea seriously, I mean, and again looking in the background,
- 6:29Speaker 1: and I think this is something that Justice Kagan was
- 6:32Speaker 1: particularly concerned with. Justice Thomas also, there's a there's a
- 6:37Speaker 1: worry about the potential for discrimination against kind of unfamiliar religions,
- 6:43Speaker 1: or minority religions, or just small institutions. Um. You know,
- 6:48Speaker 1: in these cases involved kind of Catholic parochial schools, and
- 6:51Speaker 1: everybody is kind of familiar with that set up. But
- 6:55Speaker 1: as some of the justices pointed out, there's a whole
- 6:57Speaker 1: lot of religious institutions in this country where people wear
- 6:59Speaker 1: a a lot of different hats and where the roles
- 7:03Speaker 1: that they're asked to play might be unfamiliar to your
- 7:06Speaker 1: typical again kind of um, white Anglo Saxon Protestant jurists,
- 7:13Speaker 1: And so they don't want to come up with doctrines
- 7:15Speaker 1: that run the risk that unfamiliar religions will not get
- 7:20Speaker 1: the same protection as religions that are more kind of
- 7:24Speaker 1: structured and formal and familiar. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg did
- 7:29Speaker 1: she seem to be the justice who was most most
- 7:33Speaker 1: on the side of the teachers. Yeah, I think jeffics
- 7:36Speaker 1: Ginsburg's current ser and again again, Justice Ginsburg joined the
- 7:39Speaker 1: opinion eight years ago which endorsed a pretty robust version
- 7:44Speaker 1: of the ministry exception. But I think what her concern
- 7:48Speaker 1: was was that, you know, because the ministerial exception applies
- 7:54Speaker 1: even in cases where the employer's reasons for firing the
- 7:58Speaker 1: person are not explicitly religious, she was worried about the
- 8:03Speaker 1: exemption being too broad. Now, again, my view would be
- 8:07Speaker 1: that that was what Josanna Tabor said eight years ago,
- 8:10Speaker 1: and she signed onto that. But I think her questions
- 8:14Speaker 1: indicated a concern that you that the ministry exception might
- 8:19Speaker 1: have the effect, of um, of blocking a lot of
- 8:24Speaker 1: employment discrimination lawsuits in cases that, at least in her view,
- 8:30Speaker 1: don't have a lot to do with actual religious teaching
- 8:34Speaker 1: and instruction. Do you see them drawing a line? What
- 8:37Speaker 1: do you see them doing? No? I don't. I just
- 8:41Speaker 1: really just don't think there's a line to be drawn.
- 8:43Speaker 1: I mean, they declined to draw one in the Posanna
- 8:46Speaker 1: Tabor case eight years ago, and I don't think they'll
- 8:49Speaker 1: draw one now. Um, It'll be it's more a question
- 8:53Speaker 1: of kind of the um, the vibe of the approach,
- 8:57Speaker 1: And I think the real what's really in play is
- 9:00Speaker 1: just how much difference we tell lower courts that they're
- 9:04Speaker 1: supposed to be extending to the religious employers, and the
- 9:07Speaker 1: subsite is I mean, it's you know, the people who
- 9:10Speaker 1: want a narrower version of the ministry exception. They want
- 9:14Speaker 1: to put out certain markers, you know, like you you
- 9:18Speaker 1: have to have a certain title, you have to have
- 9:19Speaker 1: a certain kind of training, or you have to have
- 9:21Speaker 1: a certain kind of certification, or you have to spend
- 9:24Speaker 1: a certain amount of time teaching religious subjects. And I
- 9:28Speaker 1: just don't think the court is going to want to
- 9:31Speaker 1: do that because with respect to any of those bright lines,
- 9:35Speaker 1: you could think of cases that wouldn't satisfy them. So
- 9:38Speaker 1: I suspect we're going to end up, frankly, probably where
- 9:42Speaker 1: we were after Josiana Tabor, which is just that there's
- 9:45Speaker 1: a lot of factors to be considered. We don't want
- 9:48Speaker 1: to have a one size fits all things because we
- 9:50Speaker 1: have religious diversity in this country, but that the basic
- 9:53Speaker 1: principle is one that respects both free exercise values that
- 9:58Speaker 1: as we think religious communit these have a free exercise
- 10:01Speaker 1: of religion, right to pick their own ministers. And also
- 10:05Speaker 1: this kind of church state separation comes around where we
- 10:08Speaker 1: really don't want um employment discrimination lawsuits to become a
- 10:13Speaker 1: a mechanism where secular courts are kind of digging into
- 10:19Speaker 1: um internal religious decisions about who should be a minister
- 10:22Speaker 1: and who won't. So it'll be, you know, for for
- 10:25Speaker 1: a certain kind of lawyer. Frankly, I'm offer in this
- 10:29Speaker 1: way myself, who likes kind of bright line rules. I
- 10:33Speaker 1: suspect we won't get one here. Um. I think instead
- 10:37Speaker 1: what we'll get as kind of a a general principle
- 10:40Speaker 1: that's important, right, respecting religious autonomy, and then we'll get
- 10:44Speaker 1: kind of a pretty deferential approach to religious employers. But
- 10:49Speaker 1: like Justice course has said, and I think you're right
- 10:51Speaker 1: to pick up on that, there's always it's always possible
- 10:55Speaker 1: to ask about kind of the sincerity of a claim
- 10:59Speaker 1: that it puts a sular employee is a is a minister.
- 11:03Speaker 1: So let me ask you this then, Rick, looking at
- 11:06Speaker 1: this from another side, does that mean that if someone
- 11:10Speaker 1: fits the ministerial exception, let's just say you're a l
- 11:13Speaker 1: a teacher teaches religion, does that mean that the school
- 11:17Speaker 1: can then fire her because she has cancer or because
- 11:22Speaker 1: they don't like the way she dresses, That they can
- 11:24Speaker 1: fire her for any reason and not be held to account. Right, So,
- 11:28Speaker 1: if the ministerial exception applies. It's it's absolutely. Um Uh.
- 11:34Speaker 1: This is separate from there's a separate rule in the
- 11:38Speaker 1: Title seven and employment discrimination laws which give kind of
- 11:42Speaker 1: broad protections to religious institutions to hire and two favorite
- 11:47Speaker 1: co religionists. Right, so you're a Catholic institution is allowed
- 11:51Speaker 1: to prefer Catholic but that just kind of that's already
- 11:53Speaker 1: at rule. The minister exception is separate. The minister exception
- 11:56Speaker 1: does not care about the reasons of the employment decision.
- 12:01Speaker 1: It's attached to the position and the relationship between that
- 12:04Speaker 1: position and the religious institution. And this is again I
- 12:07Speaker 1: think this is one of the things that had Justice
- 12:08Speaker 1: Ginsburg hesitants and sort of nervous about this is that
- 12:13Speaker 1: when the ministry exception applies, it's absolute. And so it
- 12:18Speaker 1: does mean that sometimes the ministry exception will protect religious
- 12:25Speaker 1: institutions that behave badly. Um. There's there's there's no way
- 12:29Speaker 1: around that, right. It's kind of like the freedom of
- 12:31Speaker 1: speech protects people who say some really offensive things. Sometimes. Um,
- 12:35Speaker 1: the minister exception can be misused in some circumstances by
- 12:39Speaker 1: religious institutions two to shield employment decisions that are that
- 12:45Speaker 1: are bad and that's just a fact of life. And
- 12:49Speaker 1: I don't I don't think, I don't think advocates for
- 12:51Speaker 1: the ministry of exception would would deny that. It's just
- 12:55Speaker 1: that's an inevitable result of the fact that we have
- 12:58Speaker 1: a principle of church autonomy and church state separation. And
- 13:02Speaker 1: of course then it just raises the question, well, religious
- 13:06Speaker 1: communities and those who are parts of religious institutions um,
- 13:10Speaker 1: need to be asking themselves to be outside the context
- 13:14Speaker 1: of litigation. Um, how well there they're treating their their members,
- 13:19Speaker 1: their employees, their leaders and so on. And it raises
- 13:22Speaker 1: all kinds of questions about how you structure employment contracts
- 13:25Speaker 1: and um, employee guide books and handbooks and all that
- 13:29Speaker 1: kind of thing. But your question is an important one
- 13:31Speaker 1: because nobody should nobody should pretend otherwise. The ministry exception
- 13:36Speaker 1: does mean that, when it applies, religious institutions can fire
- 13:43Speaker 1: some people without having to give an account of that
- 13:47Speaker 1: in the secular court. So now, how do you see
- 13:51Speaker 1: that the justices lining up, Well, all nine of the
- 13:54Speaker 1: justices believe that there is a ministry or exception um,
- 13:58Speaker 1: and so at a high level of reality, they will
- 14:00Speaker 1: all agree um with respect to this particular case. I'm
- 14:05Speaker 1: not sure. If I had to guess, I would I
- 14:07Speaker 1: would have been Again, it's so risky, you know, making
- 14:10Speaker 1: these kind of predictions on the basis of argument. But
- 14:14Speaker 1: I thought there was enough skepticism on the part of
- 14:16Speaker 1: Justices Ginsburg and so do my or that maybe they
- 14:19Speaker 1: would side with these particular teachers in this particular case. Um,
- 14:24Speaker 1: But I would I would think that even in this case, um,
- 14:27Speaker 1: since you know, this wasn't the case involving like a
- 14:30Speaker 1: really marginal employee like sometimes the cases you hear about
- 14:34Speaker 1: our you know, what about the janitor or the school
- 14:37Speaker 1: bus driver or what have you. These are still teachers
- 14:40Speaker 1: who were teaching religion sometimes. And so I I guess
- 14:43Speaker 1: I expect that you'll see at least seven justices siding
- 14:46Speaker 1: with the religious school. Thanks for being on Bloomberg Law. Rick,
- 14:49Speaker 1: That's Richard Garnett, a professor at Notre Dame Law School.
- 14:52Speaker 1: And that's it for the sedition of Bloomberg Law. Remember
- 14:55Speaker 1: you can always get the latest legal news by going
- 14:57Speaker 1: to our Bloomberg Law podcast. You can find them on iTunes, SoundCloud,
- 15:01Speaker 1: or Bloomberg dot com Slash podcast Slash Law. I'm June Grosso,
- 15:05Speaker 1: Thanks so much for listening, and remember to tune to
- 15:08Speaker 1: The Bloomberg Law Show weeknights at ten pm Eastern, right
- 15:11Speaker 1: here on Bloomberg Radio. Than