Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 2 - Urban elections, Title IX, and Religious Charters
Transcript
- 0:01Jed: Hey Andy.
- 0:01Andy: Hey Jed.
- 0:02Jed: Hey, good to try number two here at WonkyFolk.
- 0:06Andy: I know number one went okay, so we're back.
- 0:09Jed: We're back, and family members were giving me a hard time that we
- 0:15didn't even introduce ourselves at all.
- 0:17So maybe like, okay, 10 seconds each or 15.
- 0:21You want to go first?
- 0:22Just give a little background about yourself.
- 0:24Andy: Yeah, sure.
- 0:24It's entirely possible somebody might have watched that first
- 0:27episode and concluded, "these guys aren't professional podcasters".
- 0:33Jed: Maybe we're just impersonating the Muppets, the guys in the orchestra, a
- 0:38big orchestra or something like that.
- 0:40But I guess we need a little intro, so give us, give me a little bit here.
- 0:45Andy: Yeah, we just jumped right in last time.
- 0:46So I'm Andy Rotherham.
- 0:47I'm a co-founder and partner at Bellweather.
- 0:50So I've been there since 2010.
- 0:52My background is Think Tanks policy, some research work, a lot of media
- 0:58work and I'm a state board member.
- 1:02I'm actually in the middle of my second stint on the Virginia Board of Education,
- 1:07and I write the blog Eduwonk.com and do some other media stuff, and I lead
- 1:12external relations at Bellwether, and I work on our policy team as well.
- 1:17So, Jed,what about you?
- 1:19Who are you?
- 1:20Jed: So, I just come from a family of public school educators.
- 1:24I spent seven years in the classroom in Los Angeles, ended up authorizing
- 1:28for a couple years in San Diego.
- 1:29I Had a chance to work at High Tech High for five years,
- 1:31just a great five year run.
- 1:33And then I led the Charter School Association of California for ten years,
- 1:38left about a little over four years ago and have been really working to help
- 1:42however I can on national advocacy for charter schools -- and that's included
- 1:46my service project to the movement, which is this thing, CharterFolk.
- 1:50But what I love most about the work is it gives me excuse to stay in contact
- 1:54with great people, and Andy, you've been an incredible supporter of everything
- 1:57we've been doing, so thank you.
- 1:58And then it becomes natural to try something new.
- 2:00So this is fun.
- 2:02I'll just also, my, my last part of my introduction is I am obsessed with the
- 2:07Sacramento Kings and this baby light the beam, maybe this town is going crazy.
- 2:12So my obsessions continue to grow as I get older here.
- 2:16Yeah.
- 2:17I mean, the playoffs, they have started our communications and marketing
- 2:22director Andy Jacobs, a huge NBA fan.
- 2:26So I've already sort of seen productivity drop here over the last couple of days and
- 2:30because the NBA playoffs sort of seemingly never end, like what they, when do they
- 2:34end like around Thanksgiving or something?
- 2:36And so this will continue for a while.
- 2:39Well, listen, let's go back to where we left things, or one of the topics
- 2:43that we addressed last week in a big NBA city is Chicago, and we recorded
- 2:51on the day before the election, and I think we made a mental note.
- 2:56Let's come back and just make some observations about whatever
- 2:58may have most surprised us.
- 3:00How are you processing the Chicago results.
- 3:05Andy: Yeah, I can't even remember if we made predictions.
- 3:07I think we both said it was going to be close and it was close
- 3:09and it was a little hard to tell.
- 3:12Neither of us are a Chicago expert, and honestly, when you talked to people
- 3:16out there, you heard there were people who were quote unquote in the know,
- 3:20connected politically who had different takes on which way it was going to
- 3:24go, and I think that's reflected.
- 3:25It was tight.
- 3:26So, I mean, look if obviously Vallas losing does send a message, a lot
- 3:33of the race turned on issues besides education policing and so forth but
- 3:37clearly if that brand of politics had been overwhelmingly popular,
- 3:41it wouldn't have been a close race.
- 3:44And so clearly there's some thinking to do there, on the other hand, you
- 3:48have seen this happen elsewhere.
- 3:49So I guess my bottom line is when I look at a race that's that close, I'm
- 3:53cautious to read too much into it, and if, say Vallas had one and it by the
- 3:59same margin that Brandon Johnson did, I think it would've been a mistake for
- 4:02reformers to suddenly assume they had a mandate and sort of charge forward.
- 4:06They would've needed to listen the message the voters were sending.
- 4:09And I think the message the voters are sending is they, they have conflicting
- 4:12priorities they want different things.
- 4:14And there was a bunch of dynamics in the Chicago race, including
- 4:17obviously race that played out.
- 4:21So I think we'll have to see which direction it goes.
- 4:24Brandon Johnson probably has an opportunity to pull some Nixon into
- 4:27China, moves to improve quality of life in that city and schooling.
- 4:30But we'll see kind of how that happens with the coalition he's put together.
- 4:33What's your read on it?
- 4:35Jed: Yeah, I don't, I, I wouldn't extrapolate anything
- 4:38out from the results themselves.
- 4:39I think there were so many idiosyncratic things to the race itself, but what I do
- 4:43think is worth focusing on is just some of the changes to the political coalitions
- 4:49that seem to be coming together that I think are likely to sustain themselves
- 4:53and are becoming national trends.
- 4:55I've been writing a lot at Charter folk about how the Los Angeles Teacher
- 4:58Union and the Chicago Teacher Union have really come together and been
- 5:02articulating a new vision for what a teacher union political strength could be.
- 5:07And I think we've seen now in Los Angeles and in Chicago, that
- 5:10race be run on political fronts.
- 5:13One of the things most interesting to me is how SEIU and the teacher union,
- 5:17came together to win races and came together to do a strike in Los Angeles.
- 5:23And now we've seen SEIU and the Teacher's Union in Chicago,
- 5:26which had previously been at odds together in the very same way.
- 5:29So that is something that I would imagine we're going to see people
- 5:32attempt to bring to other cities.
- 5:34It's not as easy as you might first assume, that's one thing.
- 5:39And then the other one is just, I found it very striking how the youth vote
- 5:42really broke strongly for Johnson in the general rather than in the primary.
- 5:49And that's just what I find perplexing or potentially very interesting.
- 5:55What is it that is resonating, especially with some of our young folk.
- 6:00I we can chalk it up to simple progressivity of youth, but I think
- 6:05there's a lot more in it than that and worth us, you know, diving into
- 6:09when we have a chance to really see what the election results are.
- 6:12Andy: Yeah, I think so, and look, obviously like reforms, particularly
- 6:16reformers of a certain generation, have not figured out yet how to
- 6:19talk to energized young people.
- 6:21And you and I have talked about sort of some of the quote unquote progressive
- 6:26positions are on education, are actually like decidedly conservative, right?
- 6:30And reactionary, but reformers haven't sort of figured out
- 6:33how to pick that lock yet.
- 6:35And there's a bunch of work to do than we're going to know we're going to talk
- 6:38about Denver and that's an example where that might be happening we'll have to see.
- 6:43The other interesting thing about Chicago that I think we can't like
- 6:47move on from, is just the scale of sort of violence in Chicago and
- 6:51gun violence is just unbelievable.
- 6:53When you talk to school leaders out there, just the presence of
- 6:56particularly handguns just in the life of schools and the number of incidents
- 7:01where they're finding the kids are bringing them to school and so forth.
- 7:04It's unbelievable and it just sort of happens day to day and it's sort of
- 7:09background noise and there's almost this attitude of like case sura surah and then
- 7:14something happens like we talked about last time about covenant and so forth,
- 7:17there's obviously that horrifying school shooting and it galvanizes the attention,
- 7:21but like the sort of just routine violence just does not garner the same attention.
- 7:28It's really, it is in terms of the numbers just catastrophic.
- 7:31And it's going to be interesting to see in Chicago what can be done about that
- 7:36and if there is, or if it just this just turns into sort of again, sort of just you
- 7:41get, end up getting a backlash cause we'll feel like it's t's not being handled.
- 7:45And then the other thing in Chicago I do, and you sort of alluded to this,
- 7:48If I were a charter school leader out there, I'd be preparing for pressure,
- 7:52that may not be like pressure that's going to get headlines, but it seems
- 7:55the unionization efforts will certainly step up and there's going to be
- 7:59more pressure on those schools, and that's gonna be how that community
- 8:03responds out there and, and navigates that will be interesting to watch.
- 8:07Jed: Yeah, my pessimism comes through in my saying that I don't think that those
- 8:15that are coming into power in Chicago right now have a vision for making
- 8:21traditional public schools any better.
- 8:23And I think we're going to see a lot more doubling down and I think we're
- 8:27going to see a lot more of adult benefit being the focus of most of the
- 8:32EF policy efforts there, which is only going to result in some parents having
- 8:38greater desperation for something else.
- 8:40And it's how do you remain a strong and vibrant, the charter school community,
- 8:46wanting to be growing when the overall environment seems so hostile, but
- 8:50yet the needs for what you offer has never been higher than right now.
- 8:55It's a real tough dichotomy for people to deal with right now.
- 8:59Andy: Yeah, I think that's right.
- 9:00And then one that we can move on to Denver.
- 9:02One other thing is, it is just worth noting, I think on Chicago's, all Vallas's
- 9:06concession speech, that was a classy concession speech, that's becoming all
- 9:10too rare, where you and I are sort of a generation where you have elections,
- 9:15they decide things and then you move on, and then you have another election
- 9:19down the road rather than this sort of just constant acrimony and conflict
- 9:25that never stops and nothing gets done.
- 9:27And if it doesn't go your way, you just show up and argue in a
- 9:31different, often more disruptive way.
- 9:34And I feel like, Vallas just one thing I think that the older
- 9:38generation of politics has right is just that degree of just civility.
- 9:43And the way he sort of even chatted people who were starting to complain about about
- 9:48Johnson was classy and it was sad that it was like, it felt like such a throw back.
- 9:54Jed: Yeah, well you leave the door open for one last
- 9:57conversation or comment on Chicago.
- 9:59Sorry.
- 9:59We're going to go to my hometown Denver.
- 10:01I'm excited to talk about that too.
- 10:02But, because Vallas, yes, I agree with you in terms of the concession speech.
- 10:07The other thing though, I think from an education policy standpoint, is
- 10:10what strike you to be is he's basically saying the same thing now that he
- 10:14was saying in 2005, 2006, 2008, 2011.
- 10:19There's very little evolution in what the reformers are bringing to places
- 10:24like Chicago, and I think that Ballas' defeated, being defeated here is if
- 10:30there's any consolation, it gives the charter school world and the reform world
- 10:37to refresh what we're bringing forward.
- 10:40And I think we absolutely have to, because if we're going to win that
- 10:43youth vote, we're not going to simply win it by better political machinery,
- 10:49but we've have to have a better policy agenda to attract these people.
- 10:52Andy: Yeah.
- 10:52That's probably a whole future episode because I half agree.
- 10:56I mean, look you and I talked about this, I think Vallas is a guy who you don't
- 11:03bring him in to a super high functioning school system that just needs some nudges
- 11:08to even take it to the next level, there's a reason, the kind of places where he is
- 11:12been a school leader, you bring him in to really dysfunctional situations where
- 11:16sort of governance, teaching and learning, it's all kind of broken and he gives it
- 11:22a jolt, and that's kind of his skillset.
- 11:24And I think we do need that, there are places like that, then
- 11:27there's other places that need different kinds of leadership.
- 11:30So I have agree with you, but I also think so to some of these fundamentals.
- 11:33Like, we're not going to tolerate low performing schools.
- 11:36We're going to right size school systems, that dollars
- 11:38are aligned with effectiveness.
- 11:40Like those things we also have to figure out a way to talk about them
- 11:44so those ideas don't go out of style.
- 11:46And I'm worried like that part of what we have to meet the new meet a different
- 11:51generation, a different set of demands.
- 11:53I'm hearing conversations now about all this emphasis on grades
- 11:57and academics and kids learning and so forth is that's a problem.
- 12:01We need to have a new area of emphasis and focus and that terrifies me.
- 12:08It's easy to see how that can be a fashionable.
- 12:11And then you walk away from a focus on accountability for results,
- 12:17student learning, all of those things.
- 12:18And the unions are smart about this.
- 12:20They've started to wrap their demands in the language of equity, which
- 12:24has a very seductive appeal and people aren't sort of parsing like,
- 12:29what are they actually saying here?
- 12:31And what would be the actual effect of this.
- 12:36Jed: Well, a place that's interesting along these lines is Denver.
- 12:38It's where we've been wanting to get to.
- 12:40And it's fascinating how we have two strong charter school supporters
- 12:45who are now in the mayoral general election and speaks to Denver being,
- 12:53well again, maybe it's not right to extrapolate too much, because
- 12:58there could be some I idiosyncratic things that have led to this.
- 13:01For example, was it nine, nine progressives and two moderates,
- 13:06in the primary, get me started.
- 13:11What are your thoughts about and also, we know Johnston very well and obviously
- 13:17someone that a lot of charter folk have a great deal of respect for, but where
- 13:21would you go first in coming on Denver.
- 13:24Andy: We need like a ritual set of dis of disclosures here on this one.
- 13:28I sent money to Mike.
- 13:31I've known him a long time.
- 13:32I think he'd be a great mayor.
- 13:34He was good when he was an elected office before.
- 13:37So I'm not coming at this.
- 13:40Both candidates seem great.
- 13:42They're both supporters of charters and so forth, but I don't want
- 13:45to, but I'm coming to this with a certain, obviously perspective.
- 13:49The big thing that my general take on Denver has been this idea that
- 13:55reformers are actually pretty good at winning when they get focused
- 13:58and there's resources and so forth.
- 14:00And so what happened in Denver with the changes there, and this is under
- 14:03Michael Bennett and Bosberg and so forth, was pretty remarkable.
- 14:07And the school board and those were obviously really some contentious
- 14:09school board races and so forth.
- 14:12The problem was there was just, it wasn't sustained.
- 14:14It was a classic "okay, mission accomplished", and
- 14:16everybody kind of moved on.
- 14:18And the folks who didn't like reform and the teachers unions and all of this, and
- 14:23people who didn't like charters, they all sort of didn't get that memo that
- 14:26it was over and they just kept coming.
- 14:28And so it's it unraveled Denver.
- 14:31So that's my critique is basically the reformers got
- 14:35a little fat and comfortable.
- 14:37But it seems that shoe may be on the other foot, I guess, mix metaphors, the fat
- 14:43shoe maybe on the other foot or something.
- 14:46What seems have happened is the progressives just got caught sleeping and
- 14:51we're not organized, because you're right, he did that and so now, as opposed to
- 14:55Chicago, were coming out of the primary, the progressives could be like, "yeah.
- 14:59here is our person, we're all going to rally behind."
- 15:02Yeah.
- 15:05Listening to progressives in Denver, they don't like either of these choices.
- 15:08They're sort of stuck.
- 15:11And I think that's an interesting dynamic and obviously, Mike has proven
- 15:17to be a reformer over the years, in public office on a number of fronts.
- 15:21And so I think there's a potential that Denver once again becomes
- 15:24a really interesting place on ED reform as it has been.
- 15:28But as you said, this is like your hometown.
- 15:32So I'm giving the outsider view.
- 15:34You tell me that's actually really going on there.
- 15:37Jed: Well, I can't say it at that level, but I can provide just the
- 15:40historical context and my parents did not teach in Denver, they taught
- 15:45in Jeffco, which is right next door.
- 15:47And the striking thing for us, for me is just how much better public
- 15:52education is in Denver 25 years later and how little it's really
- 15:58appreciated that is in fact the case.
- 16:00And it's, despite that great track record of success, the changing political
- 16:05dynamics has led the Denver School Board to go in a completely different direction.
- 16:09I, for a long term time, have said that the reform world and especially
- 16:13the charter school world, needed to be more proactive in the creating
- 16:16of C4 political infrastructure to defend the wins that we had.
- 16:21And I think there's been a longstanding kind of distaste, for
- 16:24political activity from the charter school world, and a belief that
- 16:28things were going to be all right.
- 16:29This blanche oi, depending upon the kindness of strangers,
- 16:32somebody else will do it for us.
- 16:33And I think that Denver is one of the great cautionary tales for us.
- 16:39What I really love about either mayoral candidate winning, but especially
- 16:45Johnston, would be something of a feeling of like, charter folk it's okay to
- 16:50come out of the woodwork again, right?
- 16:52What really is our vision?
- 16:54Because we're still going to have a zero seven school board that
- 16:57all this charter school operators are going to be concerned about.
- 17:01But to have a person at the mayoral level, be able to drive a conversation.
- 17:07I think it could create some really interesting dynamics in Denver and
- 17:12Colorado is one of the leaders now in the national charter school movement
- 17:15in terms of percentage of kids served, all sorts of really cool.
- 17:18Jared Pollis, obviously a big charter school supporter, on the Denver side.
- 17:22This could really be a really positive sign that charters could
- 17:31regain momentum in the west.
- 17:33Andy: Yeah.
- 17:33And you mentioned Pollis.
- 17:34I've always struck.
- 17:36Jared's an interesting politician, interesting person, and I've always
- 17:40like whenever the sort of mentioning starts of if either Biden doesn't
- 17:44run or who will ultimately succeed Biden on the Democratic side.
- 17:47I'm always surprised that Pollis' name doesn't come up more.
- 17:52He's like a libertarian democrat, how he handled Covid, I think
- 17:56was very popular and effective.
- 17:58He supports charters in some kinds of school choice and just
- 18:02has a really interesting profile.
- 18:04And I'm always struck like, why the people he's using not the top
- 18:09of the list, in my view, he should be, he's an interesting politician.
- 18:14Interesting leader.
- 18:15Jed: I think that, something I've been writing about since 16, the history I've
- 18:21been writing about is 2016 and 2017.
- 18:242016 was the election in Massachusetts against question two, 2017 is the
- 18:31NE's new policy on charter schools.
- 18:34And basically what they said in that moment was, it is not
- 18:37possible to be a Democrat and also be supportive of charter schools.
- 18:40And so Jerry Brown was really the last, well almost the last, I think that
- 18:45Pollis still was under, had already set his political relationships before
- 18:52the change in the NEA policy happened.
- 18:54So I think that Pollis' story here is one that's very important to stay focused on.
- 19:00Andy: I think so too.
- 19:00Also, I would throw on that list, like you got, I think Josh Shapiro in
- 19:04Pennsylvania will be interesting to watch.
- 19:07It's be interesting to see what they do in Massachusetts, but I can't
- 19:11argue the fundamental point that like that was the sign winter is coming.
- 19:17And the Democrats have sort of seeded that issue and seeded
- 19:20the choice issue in general.
- 19:22In some ways I think it can approve, over time to be really
- 19:25unhelpful to their politics.
- 19:27Jed: But if we look at the West Colorado, New Mexico, Arizona, Texas, Utah, Idaho,
- 19:34these are all places where charter schools support charter school momentum, reform
- 19:38momentum, is very positive right now.
- 19:41And I think it's possible for us to hitch these wagons together to use my
- 19:45western metaphors here and perhaps drive a whole new narrative for the movement.
- 19:51So we'll see how that plays out.
- 19:52Andy: Yeah, and I think also, look, there's some really
- 19:55interesting stuff happen on rural charter schools in the west.
- 19:57And there's some folks, Rob Celine he's a political science professor university
- 20:01of Montana's, doing a lot of work on sort how Democrats can win with rural
- 20:04voters again, and re-energize that coalition and, I don't see how you do
- 20:09it without a real economic opportunity agenda and schools and things like
- 20:13rural charter schools and school choice being true, being a part of that.
- 20:16Again, not speaking of things that Democrats have seeded.
- 20:18They've just seeded the rural vote and that's a mistake.
- 20:23And it there may be some sort of signs of life in the mountain west
- 20:26around some of that over time.
- 20:29Jed: Well, we focus a lot on Denver, but in Colorado, I mean we've got charter
- 20:32schools in Grand Junction and Durango and Fort Collins, up and down the front range.
- 20:37So it's one of these places where we've really seen a broad distribution
- 20:41of charter schools and it creates a political circumstance, very different
- 20:44from if you have all of your schools only concentrated in urban areas.
- 20:48But hey, I know I've known that you've wanted to like get to Title IX and some
- 20:52really interesting decisions coming out of the Biden administration this last week.
- 20:55Do you mind if we pivot over there?
- 20:57Andy: Yeah, let's do that, before we do that though, I do want one
- 20:59other Denver thing, I just want to, cause it's our podcast and
- 21:02so we can say whatever we want.
- 21:04A really gutsy thing that happened in Denver.
- 21:06I don't know how close you follow the Rockies, they have a reliever.
- 21:09He is a guy named Daniel Bard, used to be the setup guy for the Boston Red
- 21:13Sox, he was out of baseball for a few years and then came back and has had
- 21:18sort of a miraculous comeback with the Rockies and it's just a great story.
- 21:24What was really interesting at the beginning of this season, we talk a lot
- 21:27about mental health in schools and this is a big issue, but there's still sort
- 21:32of some stigma sometimes and so forth.
- 21:34And he was having some issues with anxiety and he put himself on the
- 21:38injured list, the 15 day list.
- 21:41And you, I love baseball, people see lots of heroics and you're like, oh
- 21:45my god, gutsy plays and all that.
- 21:47But that was honestly one of the gutsiest things I've ever seen a
- 21:51player do, especially given some of the aspects of the culture in that game.
- 21:54And then not too long afterwards, the guy from the Tigers did a similar thing
- 21:59and I am someone who believes that sort of, those kinds of things have a
- 22:02queuing effect and they change, again, I wish more influencers talked about
- 22:09ED reform and charter schools, but just on the mental health front, sort of
- 22:11seeing that and if you had to sort of have a play of the week or a gutsy move.
- 22:17I just think what Daniel Barr did is just really impressive and commendable
- 22:22as we try to get more attention on these issues in mental health.
- 22:26Jed: Well, my wife being a clinical psychologist, this
- 22:28is our wheelhouse for sure.
- 22:30And I think sometimes, blue left-leaning charter folk don't always pick up
- 22:39things that are happening elsewhere.
- 22:41It's the stigma in, especially in red context, against getting yourself
- 22:46some psychological assistance.
- 22:48And then also the stigma, the feeling that conservative folk aren't going to
- 22:53find a psychologist who is, resonates with them across all these cultural issues.
- 22:58It just creates this structural barrier, right?
- 23:01And so any high profile person that is just going to be courageous and
- 23:05be upfront about what their struggles are, I think really, really helps.
- 23:09So I appreciate you pointing that out.
- 23:12Andy: Yeah.
- 23:12So on Title IX an interesting thing happened, and I think it's interesting in
- 23:18part because the administration, they've had some hard challenges, obviously around
- 23:24the economy, some foreign policy things.
- 23:27But they've also had some relatively straightforward things in education.
- 23:30I think a lot of people would argue that they have potentially fumbled
- 23:33aspects of the recovery dollars.
- 23:37This third party servicing process that they just went
- 23:40through, just a number of things.
- 23:44Maybe, a lot of people think the student loan and how that, that's been handled
- 23:47and the entire process of the student loan issue, not just the case that
- 23:52is at the Supreme Court right now.
- 23:54And some of those issues actually weren't super complicated and
- 23:58they still managed to fumble them.
- 24:00But then you've got this 109 issue of transgender athletes and sports and they
- 24:07parsed it in a really interesting way that I'm favorably disposed to myself because
- 24:15I think, it gets at some of the nuance, where they basically, They're going to
- 24:19put it out for comment, but that they, you can't have blanket bans on participation,
- 24:24but where you have to balance fairness and safety with inclusion, you can do that.
- 24:30And so some restrictions are going to be okay.
- 24:32And I think this is the kind of thing, a lot of people look and are like, certain
- 24:35things seem fair, certain things don't all that, and then it matters a lot by things
- 24:39like age level, level of competition.
- 24:42Is this an elite sort of zero sum or just some other kind
- 24:45of like recreational league.
- 24:47All of these sort of nuanced things and in this sort of debate Yes/No, this sort
- 24:52of macro debate to sort of get lost.
- 24:55And they have a policy that sort of parsed it.
- 24:57And what's interesting is, look, some people think okay, they're just
- 25:00playing possum and they're saying they're going to parse it, but they'll
- 25:03reject every single plane that comes.
- 25:06I don't think that wouldn't be a smart strategy for them, politically.
- 25:11And I think they know that, and wouldn't be a smart strategy,
- 25:15with Congress and so forth.
- 25:16So I actually take them at their word that they're going to recognize there's
- 25:21probably differences between some sports, this really only matters when you get to
- 25:25zero sum levels where you know, only a certain number of people could advance.
- 25:29That's varsity level, elite level, sports, and then, college and, and so forth.
- 25:35And then people are going to take them with their word, that they're
- 25:37actually going to parse those.
- 25:39And what they may be doing, and this is me inferring, they saw the Obama policy
- 25:46on Title IX and colleges just ended up in court constantly and lost constantly.
- 25:52Right?
- 25:53And so it was just one of these things, it was, it just became almost sort of
- 25:57a farce, and what they may be doing here is recognizing this issue is also
- 26:02in the courts, it's in federal courts.
- 26:05And recognizing that's going to sort of play this issue will ultimately
- 26:09be decided in the courts, and so they're just creating some space.
- 26:12But I just thought it was on acomplicated issue where there is a awful lot of
- 26:16activist capture, and it would've been easy for them just to sort of
- 26:20just do the thing that, that everybody would've just do a real straight
- 26:25down the line sort of red blue thing.
- 26:26Instead, they sort of parse some nuance and I thought that was interesting.
- 26:30And I don't know if that means sort of signs of life on interesting policymaking.
- 26:35I don't know if they're going to walk it back.
- 26:37I watched one interview with the secretary who he didn't.
- 26:40Like totally in love with the policy, so who knows?
- 26:43That may have just been, people give lots of interviews and that may have been
- 26:47an impression he didn't mean to convey.
- 26:50So who knows?
- 26:51But, I think it's going to be an interesting one to
- 26:55watch to watch going forward.
- 26:57Jed: One of the byproducts of working on charterfolk, I've got subscriptions now to
- 27:0325 or 30 newspapers, across the country.
- 27:07And I just try and screen them out, but the headlines keep coming through, right?
- 27:12And it was fascinating to see that first day.
- 27:15I think in the first like four hours or six hours, all the headlines were
- 27:18about, hey, the new guidance bands any kind of discrimination, right?
- 27:28And then later, before even the end of the day, and certainly thereafter
- 27:32it started to get into the nuance.
- 27:33Wait a second.
- 27:34Yeah.
- 27:34Blanket things.
- 27:35They will, be opposed by the feds, but here are some, here's some areas where
- 27:41clearly we should be more flexible.
- 27:44Andy: The total fog of culture, that first few was right.
- 27:48It was like complete fog of culture war.
- 27:51What was interesting is the guidance, the proposed regulation, the way that
- 27:55the department's materials described to you was actually pretty straightforward.
- 27:58The key, you could sort of see the key graphs.
- 28:00Yeah.
- 28:00So there was a lot of like confusion, but it's one of these things we
- 28:05try to teach this to since you learned this in elementary school,
- 28:08like primary documents, right?
- 28:11And everybody was sort of keying off this other stuff rather than just like the
- 28:14plain letter of what this guidance said.
- 28:18Jed: What I like about the guidance is that it doesn't necessarily erase a more
- 28:24agency across all of the public education.
- 28:28It can be that the political environment is so toxic in all these different
- 28:33situations that we really don't want to be talking about some of these issues
- 28:36and if somebody took these issues off the table, Maybe there'd be a value in that.
- 28:40Generally, that's terrible.
- 28:42Generally we want decision making and discussion and
- 28:46nuance created at local levels.
- 28:49And generally what I've seen in terms of guidance coming out of Washington.
- 28:54Or guidance coming out of state capitals from across the country right now is
- 28:58state taking agency away from local school districts, from charter schools, from
- 29:02school, from any operators of schools.
- 29:06And generally that's just not set up for long-term thoughtful decision making.
- 29:12And so I would say this guidance is probably a breath
- 29:15of fresh air along those lines.
- 29:16Andy: Well, look, as society evolves, you get these complicated
- 29:20questions and necessarily, there's nuance and they're complicated
- 29:26and the devil is in the details.
- 29:28And that's where you have to get and hopefully what we're seeing on
- 29:32some of this stuff is blunt force sort of culture war stuff will give
- 29:38way to just more texture and nuance.
- 29:42I live to some extent, I think you've got 10 to 15% of people on either
- 29:49side who just are really struggling to live in community with others.
- 29:53And everybody else is sort of like an unwilling combatant in the,
- 29:57health wars sees the areas of gray, sees the nuance and wants us to
- 30:02parse through that as best we can.
- 30:05But the media fixates on those loudest voices, and they obviously
- 30:08are what drives politics.
- 30:11So this was interesting.
- 30:13And again, we'll have to see how it plays out a year from now.
- 30:15It could look totally different depending how they do it.
- 30:18And they could look, we keep calling it a guidance it's a
- 30:21the proposed change to Title IX.
- 30:23We'll go through a comment process, they'll issue a final version.
- 30:28That could change as well.
- 30:31But it was an interesting sign of life because it came on such a politic
- 30:38political hothouse issue where they can all thumbs on some more basic stuff.
- 30:44And this one they really tried to find some nuance.
- 30:48So I thought it was interesting.
- 30:50Speaking of all this stuff.
- 30:52The last thing I know we wanted to talk about is rel there's
- 30:56Supreme Court cases coming on.
- 30:58Religious charter schools.
- 30:59There was a case out of Washington state on religion and schools I think surprised
- 31:05a lot of people, the Kennedy case.
- 31:07Last year it's like there's a lot happening here and yet no one seems
- 31:11to be paying very close attention.
- 31:13It's potentially like very precedent setting.
- 31:16Walk us through, there's been a couple, there's been a couple
- 31:20cases now there's one up.
- 31:22Walk us through, what's going on and what do people need to know?
- 31:26Jed: Well, I think that there are a couple cases that are working their way through
- 31:31the courts right now, and there's this North Carolina case where a dress code
- 31:37and requiring girls to wear skirts in a charter school has now come all the
- 31:43way up and it, we'll see if the Supreme Court decides to take that case or not.
- 31:48The argument of those who say that charter schools should be able to impose
- 31:53this kind of dress code is that charter schools are not public schools and so they
- 31:57have greater freedoms to discriminate or whatever it may be because of that status.
- 32:03That's one wing of things.
- 32:04There are other things where we've had a main case and other things where
- 32:07it's questions like, could a religious institution directly hold a charter.
- 32:13And where that's being tested right now, first is in Oklahoma.
- 32:17And and this is one where, just this last week again, monitoring the headlines the
- 32:24authorizer turned down the charter school application from the Catholic diocese.
- 32:32But said, why don't you bring it back again in a month, and we'll see if
- 32:36you can address some of our concerns.
- 32:39But the thing that's just really interesting from my contacts in
- 32:42Oklahoma and elsewhere, it seems as though the operators who are proposing
- 32:47this charter aren't that deeply connect, committed to charterness.
- 32:53They really are people motivated around issues of religious liberty.
- 32:57And so what we see then is that the charter school canvas really just
- 33:00becomes something that the religious liberty advocates can paint a picture on.
- 33:05And my own sense is that from a just an actual impact on school options for
- 33:13people, religious charter schools, I don't think is going to make that big of
- 33:18a difference because I don't think that many religious institutions are going to
- 33:22be willing to deal with all the challenges and hassles of operating a charter school.
- 33:27And so really this issue in Oklahoma is going to remain one
- 33:31that is presidential for these broader religious liberty issues.
- 33:37But what it does in terms of the core of the charter school movement, unless
- 33:41there's blowback, from those precedents that like harm us from a political
- 33:45standpoint, I don't think it's going to profoundly change the profile of
- 33:49schools that, you know are operating within the charter school space.
- 33:54Andy: So, let me push on that a little bit.
- 33:55One of the things I've always like,19 good charter schools
- 34:00get clobbered by that 20th.
- 34:03That's terrible.
- 34:04Right?
- 34:04And you live some of this in California when you're running the association,
- 34:07you get these sort of high profile cases and look, it's a natural instinct.
- 34:11No one reports on all the planes that take off and land every day just fine.
- 34:15Right?
- 34:15But when you know something goes wrong, we all hear about it.
- 34:19It's a natural thing.
- 34:20Do you worry that with this push in, it will blur the lines on what
- 34:25actually is a charter school, and then you'll get some outlier examples,
- 34:28which will be used, particularly used by people in the advocacy world
- 34:32to sort of paint a broad brush.
- 34:33It just does seem to me like, like there's some, when people are still
- 34:37actually learning what a charter school is and is not, and all of that there
- 34:41is just some the reputational and political risk almost regardless of the
- 34:46scale that this happens at, seems real.
- 34:50Jed: Yeah, so I think that the likely collateral damage is in blue context
- 34:56when we've got establishment aligned, policy makers looking for the next
- 35:02excuse to sunset their charter school law or moratorium or whatever it may be.
- 35:08And we can see that if the Supreme Court and the Oklahoma case, confirms that
- 35:15religious institutions must be allowed to operate a charter, if you choose to have a
- 35:19charter law, there're going to be several blue contexts where people are going
- 35:22to use that as the precipitating event for the next round of moratorium call.
- 35:27I definitely do worry about that.
- 35:30But I also think that A key thing is how does the charter school world,
- 35:36the operators and our funders and our policies supporters, how do we
- 35:40orient ourselves to this reality?
- 35:43And how much do we end up like taking pot shots at one another such that it becomes
- 35:48easier to set us back with a policy loss?
- 35:53And that's why I think it would be better if we were having more
- 35:55proactive conversations about what are the likely results of these cases
- 36:00and what are ways for us to orient ourselves that are consistent with our
- 36:04values such that we can stay together.
- 36:07Whether or not that'll be enough to withstand the attack that
- 36:10comes against us, I don't know, but we'll be stronger than if we
- 36:13haven't had the conversation at all.
- 36:15Andy: Something we said at the top of this episode, we're obviously amateur
- 36:19podcasters, so I don't know if we actually even have show notes, but if
- 36:22we do, I wrote a piece last year on the main case and its potential impact that
- 36:28we could include, because I guess I'm a little more concerned than you, that
- 36:34as you bring religious institutions into closer contact with charters,
- 36:39that the potential, particularly for political risk there, is real.
- 36:44And I'm, this isn't something I'm completely against, I actually during
- 36:47the Clinton administration, wrote a guidance on how religious institutions
- 36:54can do more to interact with charters and support their educational mission.
- 37:00But the lines have become more blurry, the church state lines over the last 20 years.
- 37:07And so I do think there's some risk there.
- 37:09And then the other thing that just is interesting is, I've always assumed
- 37:14when you start to do this, one of the fascinating things about homeschoolers,
- 37:18and I'm not like a one of these reflexive critics of homeschooling, I've spent lots
- 37:23of time, I wrote a article for the Well of Time a few years ago on homeschooling.
- 37:27I think like it's actually just a really fascinating part of the ED sector.
- 37:31But one of the things that you often find is people have this vision of
- 37:34homeschooling is these individual kids or families, but they often
- 37:37homeschoolers work together in co-ops and they pool resources, and
- 37:41they're very strategic about sort of taking advantage of different
- 37:44assets that exist in their community.
- 37:46And so one of the things I've always wondered is if you make chartering loose
- 37:49enough, you've got these groups of, you'll go in, you'll see like 15 kids, and
- 37:54they'll be all working and doing stuff.
- 37:56And if you say, this looks like a school, you'll get a lot of pushback,
- 37:59but it looks off not a lot like in a school or an alternative school, in
- 38:03practice, and if that's gonna be an attractive place, because if you can
- 38:07then get all the public money to that same stuff, like what's the difference
- 38:11between that and sort of a small, scrappy or startup kind of charter school.
- 38:16So that's always been a place I've watched and I've wondered if these decisions
- 38:19the past few years might fuel that and create more intersections there.
- 38:25And why I think all this matters is we're obviously having
- 38:27a big evolution on choice.
- 38:29Like the quiet story during the pandemic was just this
- 38:31explosion in choice policies.
- 38:34The rhetoric about school choice, it's not happening, it's being rejected.
- 38:39And the actual like reality, I could not have been more sort of discordant.
- 38:43It was crazy.
- 38:45And this is a piece of that we're going to start to redefine what choice
- 38:50looks like in these various choice options, ESAs have become very popular.
- 38:54We've also got tax credits and other kinds of choice schemes.
- 39:00And that as this redefinition goes on, where charter schools end up living
- 39:05in that new ecosystem politically, is an important question to where
- 39:11their support comes from and so forth.
- 39:12I think we've talked about, I don't know if it is on the podcast or just you
- 39:16and me, like it does seem like there's a scenario here when the music stops.
- 39:19Charters will be alone without the chair.
- 39:21Jed: Yeah, I think, there's a lot more to dive into here.
- 39:24I'll just end with this thought, which is, to some extent my value in at CCSA after
- 39:3210 years on the road, just visiting all these schools and knowing all these people
- 39:35was having a fairly good assessment.
- 39:39What are folk going to think about this?
- 39:41Can we keep the movement together on this?
- 39:43Will it splinter on that?
- 39:45And by the time I left, I was right, maybe 70% of the time.
- 39:49Right?
- 39:49I just don't think my intuition is nearly as good on national issues at this point.
- 39:55But I know that a schism that we cannot cross is if somehow we ask charter
- 40:03folk to accept the idea that charter schools can exclude kids for whatever
- 40:08reason, whether they're gay or trans status, they're religious status.
- 40:13And I think the same thing around employees too.
- 40:15If we can kick you out and you can't work here, that is going to be a definition of
- 40:19charterness that we just cannot endure.
- 40:22So my hope is that ultimately these court cases play out such that remains an
- 40:27option for us to try to gravitate around.
- 40:30We'll see whether or not what draws us together is strong
- 40:33enough to hold us together.
- 40:34Andy: I think that there are so many interesting issues
- 40:37percolating up to the courts.
- 40:39I've been following very close, there's some issues on teacher free speech rights
- 40:42that can be hugely precedent setting.
- 40:44There's just a lot, a lot of this stuff is being redefined as being redefined
- 40:50in the courts in ways that I think bear more watching and scrutiny it
- 40:56will have big, big effects what you're talking about in terms of how political
- 41:01coalitions hold together or don't.
- 41:03Jed: Well, lots to talk about two weeks from now when we get together again.
- 41:06Andy: Yeah.
- 41:06Looking forward to it.
- 41:07Continue to enjoy spring.
- 41:08Enjoy the playoffs.
- 41:10Jed: Alright.
- 41:10Light the beam baby.
- 41:11Light that beam.
- 41:13See you Andy.
- 41:14Andy: See you Jed.