Latest / Deep Thoughts About Stupid Sh*t: A Pop-Culture Comedy Podcast / Sex and the City: Deep Thoughts About Feminism, Female Friendship, and Funky Spunk
Transcript
- 0:00Emily: As feminist as this show is in so many ways, it ends up being very regressive.
- 0:10SPEAKER_01: My sister, Emily Guy Birkin, no hyphen, is an overthinker.
- 0:15Emily: And my sister, Tracy Guy Decker, yes hyphen, is an overthinker.
- 0:20Emily: And we both love pop culture, a well-crafted story, and eminently quotable movie lines.
- 0:26SPEAKER_01: Each week, with the help of Feminism, Our Super Smart Brains, and each other, we uncover the lessons lurking behind the nostalgia of our favorite comedies, dramas, science fiction, and horror.
- 0:38Emily: Because pop culture is still culture, and shouldn't you know what's in your head?
- 0:45Emily: I'm Emily Guy Birkin, and you're listening to Deep Thoughts About Stupid Shit.
- 0:49Emily: Because pop culture is still culture, and shouldn't you know what's in your head?
- 0:53Emily: On today's episode, I will be sharing my deep thoughts about the TV show Sex in the City with my sister, Tracy Guy Decker, and with you.
- 1:02Emily: Let's dive in.
- 1:04Emily: So, Tracy, I don't know if you have seen an episode of this, if you know anything about it.
- 1:08Emily: I mean, it was impossible to avoid it.
- 1:10Emily: It was such a cultural juggernaut.
- 1:13Emily: But uh tell me what's in your head about Sex in the City.
- 1:16SPEAKER_01: Yeah, Sex in the City was never one of my regular shows.
- 1:20SPEAKER_01: Um, so I've seen a few episodes, but just a few.
- 1:23SPEAKER_01: But that said, those episodes really stayed with me, the ones that I did see.
- 1:29SPEAKER_01: So I saw one episode where one of the women, maybe it was Carrie, I don't know.
- 1:36SPEAKER_01: One of the women gave advice to the redhead that sometimes he's just not that into you.
- 1:43SPEAKER_01: Like, and that's okay.
- 1:45SPEAKER_01: And I took that to heart.
- 1:48SPEAKER_01: Like that was like a mantra that I would repeat to myself.
- 1:51SPEAKER_01: Sometimes he's just not that into you, and that's okay.
- 1:54SPEAKER_01: And that saved me some heartache, probably.
- 1:57SPEAKER_01: But it also caused problems where, whether platonic or romantic, people were interested in me.
- 2:03SPEAKER_01: They were that into me.
- 2:05SPEAKER_01: Like I just was oblivious because I just assumed everybody was just not that into me.
- 2:09SPEAKER_01: Not that they hated me, they just weren't that into me.
- 2:11SPEAKER_01: And so I've had multiple like platonic friends be like, Tracy, I am trying to be your friend here.
- 2:19SPEAKER_01: What?
- 2:20SPEAKER_01: You know, and and other times like advances like in the wild, not on the apps, because on the apps you know what they're doing, but like in the wild where, you know, men might be interested in me.
- 2:30SPEAKER_01: And I just was oblivious.
- 2:31SPEAKER_01: And I think it's in part because for whatever reason, this episode of this one TV show that I didn't even watch, like resonated with me in a way.
- 2:41SPEAKER_01: The other one that I remember really well, I again I've seen maybe these only two, is the one where the brunette wants to convert to Judaism and the rabbi says no three times.
- 2:53SPEAKER_01: And then she like shows up at his door during dinner, and he's like, it's the third time now.
- 2:57SPEAKER_01: I can.
- 2:58SPEAKER_01: And um, for whatever reason, it really tickled me that this like broadcast mainstream TV show would include that little facet of Jewish culture that, you know, someone who's looking to join the faith is traditionally turned down three times to make sure that it's not an impulse.
- 3:19SPEAKER_01: So those are the things that my direct interaction with it.
- 3:23SPEAKER_01: From the zeitgeist, I know it's about a group of female friends who gossip about their dating lives and dress really nicely.
- 3:33SPEAKER_01: And I know that uh John Corbett, who we talked about in our last episode, because he was in my my Big Fat Greek Wedding.
- 3:40SPEAKER_01: I know he's in that too, Chris in the morning.
- 3:42SPEAKER_01: Still Chris in the morning in my Big Fat Greek Greek wedding, and still Chris in the morning on Sex in the City.
- 3:47SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 3:48SPEAKER_01: Anyway, that's what I know.
- 3:50SPEAKER_01: That's what's in my head about Sex in the City.
- 3:52SPEAKER_01: I know this TV show is really important to you, but articulate it for me.
- 3:55SPEAKER_01: Like, what's at stake for you in Sex in the City?
- 3:58SPEAKER_01: Why are we bringing the deep thoughts treatment to it?
- 4:01Emily: So Sex in the City debuted in 1998 when I was 19.
- 4:04Emily: As I remember, I watched from the very beginning.
- 4:07Emily: I can't really recall exactly, but I from the very beginning, because it is a phenomenally funny show.
- 4:14Emily: I mean, it is very, very funny.
- 4:16Emily: But for me, as a 19-year-old, because these are about women in their 30s, one of them is in her early 40s, who are single and who have created a family of each other.
- 4:28Emily: And the idea that I and my three best girlfriends would be each other's thick and thin was so compelling to me.
- 4:40Emily: These are very intelligent, go-getting women who, you know, had these phenomenal lives.
- 4:46Emily: Dating was a pain in the ass for them, but they got each other through all of the hard times.
- 4:52Emily: And there are a lot of hard times through the six years that this show went on.
- 4:56Emily: And there is one point where Mr.
- 5:00Emily: Big says to Carrie's three friends, you three are the loves of her life.
- 5:05Emily: And any man would be a distant fourth.
- 5:09Emily: And I loved that.
- 5:11Emily: I loved that depiction of adult female friendship that is just steady and unwavering.
- 5:20Emily: And yes, they have arguments, yes, they get mad at each other, they give each other silent treatment.
- 5:24Emily: There, there's they are selfish and, you know, because they're human.
- 5:28Emily: But ultimately, the most important relationships for all four of these women is each other.
- 5:36Emily: Even as two of them get married and, you know, different things happen in their lives where they do pair off.
- 5:42Emily: But it filled something deep within me to see this important relationship that is friendship rather than romantic relationship.
- 5:55SPEAKER_01: And it's also very, very funny.
- 5:58SPEAKER_01: Since his debuted in 98, it makes sense why I never was really into it.
- 6:01SPEAKER_01: That's the year I graduated from college.
- 6:03SPEAKER_01: And so I was like off trying to figure out how to be an adult.
- 6:06Emily: Yeah.
- 6:07SPEAKER_01: Still, still trying to figure that out.
- 6:09Emily: Well, and I was watching it on, you know, parents HBO.
- 6:12SPEAKER_01: Right, right.
- 6:13SPEAKER_01: I definitely did not have cable that year.
- 6:15Emily: Yeah.
- 6:16Emily: And by the time I was on my own in 2001, I wasn't able to watch it as it came out.
- 6:21Emily: I would go to the library to get the DVDs.
- 6:24Emily: Uh-huh.
- 6:24Emily: So I could I could watch it.
- 6:26Emily: Got it.
- 6:28SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 6:28SPEAKER_01: Well, give me some postcards from the destination.
- 6:30Emily: What are we going to talk about?
- 6:32Emily: So, as I mentioned, since female friendship was so important to me, that is something I really want to spend some time on.
- 6:37Emily: Also, I've kind of mentioned this in previous episodes, but explain why I will not watch the reboot and just like that, because I feel like it has betrayed the friendship that was at the core of this.
- 6:53Emily: I want to talk about women and sexuality because I'm very glad I had that in those formative years, you know, those like very, very early adulthood.
- 7:01Emily: But I also want to talk about some ways that the show kind of falls down on the job.
- 7:05Emily: Specifically, I want to talk about Samantha's character and how she was treated throughout the show because in some ways she's the most progressive character, but the show, in some ways, the way it treats her, is very regressive.
- 7:17Emily: Is that the Kim Catrol character?
- 7:18Emily: That is Kim Catrol's character.
- 7:20Emily: I want to talk about um race and privilege.
- 7:23Emily: Also, uh, there's there's some um biphobia within the show as well.
- 7:27Emily: And I want to talk about that.
- 7:29Emily: Um, the show is very much a time capsule, which I think is generally true of, you know, of anything that you make.
- 7:37Emily: Popular culture in particular.
- 7:39Emily: Yeah.
- 7:40Emily: But I I kind of want to talk a little bit about the things that felt liberal and progressive at the time, which now you look back and go, oh God.
- 7:51Emily: So I want to talk about the way that it presents feminism as part of that.
- 7:55Emily: And then I need to talk about Chris Knoff, the actor who played Mr.
- 7:59Emily: Big.
- 8:00Emily: He has been credibly accused of rape, which did not come out until and just like that came out.
- 8:08Emily: And it colors the way that I watch the show now.
- 8:11Emily: I'm probably not going to get to it, but fashion and New York City, kind of as a character, are both important.
- 8:18Emily: And we might get to that and shit we forgot to say.
- 8:48SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 8:48SPEAKER_01: Well, since I never watched the show, like Catch Me Up, like I I have this vague sense that there are four women.
- 8:55SPEAKER_01: I you heard me, I referred to them as like the redhead and the brunette.
- 8:59SPEAKER_01: Like, catch me up.
- 9:00SPEAKER_01: Who are these women and what do I need to know about them?
- 9:04Emily: The show is actually based on um, it was a column that was turned into a book by Candace Bushnell called Sex in the City.
- 9:12Emily: In 1994 is when she started Column.
- 9:13Emily: She was 35 at the time, uh single woman in New York.
- 9:17Emily: Uh, and she would go around and like interview people about their sex lives in New York City.
- 9:24Emily: And there were some recurring characters.
- 9:26Emily: She created a composite character who was her named Carrie Bradshaw.
- 9:31Emily: So Candace Bushnell, Carrie Bradshaw.
- 9:33Emily: And her Carrie Bradshaw had an on-again, off-again relationship with someone she referred to in the column as Mr.
- 9:40Emily: Big, although it's known who that was.
- 9:43Emily: Darren Starr, who was a um TV showrunner, he had uh worked on Beverly Hills 90210, Melrose Place with Aaron Spelling, he was trying to make a show by himself.
- 9:54Emily: And he was friends with Candace Bushnell, and he loved the idea of making a TV show based on her columns.
- 10:01Emily: So while the characters in the show, some of them are kind of composite characters of the recurring characters in her column, in uh Bushnell's columns, based on our friends, a lot of it is just kind of fictionalized and draws inspiration from her column.
- 10:18Emily: So we have Carrie Bradshaw, who is a columnist writing a column called Sex in the City for New York magazine.
- 10:25Emily: She is in her early 30s and she has three best friends.
- 10:30Emily: There is Miranda Hobbs, who is a lawyer.
- 10:33Emily: She is the redhead that you remember.
- 10:35Emily: She's a Harvard-educated lawyer.
- 10:37Emily: She is very cynical and takes no shit and is cynical about love.
- 10:43Emily: She's not very optimistic.
- 10:44Emily: So she's okay, like with hookups and things like that, but she's not really looking for a romantic connection.
- 10:51Emily: There is Charlotte York, who works in an art gallery, who is the like starry-eyed romantic who believes in happily ever after and is waiting for a prince to come.
- 11:03Emily: She also has like these difficult dates, but she is very much trying to make her dating life lead to a real connection where they they fall in love and get married.
- 11:16Emily: And then there is Samantha Jones, who owns her own PR firm.
- 11:21Emily: She is played by uh Kim Catrol.
- 11:23Emily: Kim Catrol was 41 at the time when they started uh filming.
- 11:27Emily: Miranda Hobbs is played by Cynthia Nixon, and Charlotte York is played by Kristen Davis, and they were all in their early 30s, like 31 to 33.
- 11:36Emily: And so Samantha is completely cynical.
- 11:40Emily: Well, not even not so much even cynical because she's joyful about it.
- 11:44Emily: She has no interest in romance.
- 11:46Emily: She just wants sex and is just straight up about it and is consistently flirting with men and and and meeting men and doing all kinds of depraved sexual things that are just amazing.
- 12:01Emily: She also got some of the funniest lines.
- 12:06Emily: So that's our our our our foesome.
- 12:09Emily: Then there's some recurring characters.
- 12:11Emily: Carrie, as of the very first episode, she meets someone she ends up calling Mr.
- 12:15Emily: Big, played by Chris Noth, who is in his early 40s.
- 12:19Emily: He is a very handsome businessman, lots of money, perpetual bachelor.
- 12:24Emily: Married once before when they meet.
- 12:27Emily: And the six years is basically their on-again, off again.
- 12:31Emily: And honestly, they are kind of toxic for each other if you take it all in.
- 12:35Emily: Miranda has an on-again, off again love interest named Steve, who is a bartender.
- 12:41Emily: And so she kind of dismisses him early on because she sees herself as different from him because of her job versus his job.
- 12:50Emily: They end up having a baby together.
- 12:52Emily: It's an accidental pregnancy.
- 12:55Emily: Charlotte, using, if you remember the rules.
- 12:59Emily: Yeah, vaguely, I do remember that.
- 13:01Emily: Yeah.
- 13:01Emily: It's not actually the rules, but they they create something like the rules.
- 13:05Emily: Yeah.
- 13:06Emily: Using that, she tries to meet a man and she ends up because of that, accidentally meeting Trey McDougall, who is played by Conway Coughlin, who is impotent, but she doesn't find that out because they're saving themselves from marriage.
- 13:19SPEAKER_01: Oh God.
- 13:20Emily: And that's why he's willing to do that.
- 13:22Emily: Even though they both like, she's had plenty of sex.
- 13:26Emily: So we've seen it.
- 13:26Emily: So she ends up marrying Trey McDougall.
- 13:29Emily: They are infertile in addition to him being impotent.
- 13:33Emily: And so their marriage ends up ending over that.
- 13:37Emily: Her divorce lawyer is named Harry, who's played by Evan.
- 13:44Emily: I'm forgetting his last name.
- 13:47Emily: But her uh her divorce lawyer, who is someone she's not attracted to, because uh Evan Handler, that's his name.
- 13:53Emily: He's bald.
- 13:53Emily: He's not conventionally attractive the way that uh Kyle McLachlan is.
- 13:57Emily: And so she ends up meeting him and she converts to Judaism for him.
- 14:02Emily: That's what she remember.
- 14:03Emily: And they they end up getting married.
- 14:04Emily: And Samantha, in the way that X-Files had a uh monster of the week, Samantha has a has a dude of the week for most of it.
- 14:12Emily: Towards the end of the show, she ends up getting involved with a young actor/slash model whose name was Jerry Jared, and she she uh changes it to Smith, Smith Jared.
- 14:24Emily: And so he's much younger than her, and they they end up together at the end of the show, although she has no interest in getting married.
- 14:33Emily: Okay.
- 14:34Emily: There are a couple other recurring characters.
- 14:36Emily: One of Carrie's closest friends is a man named Stanford, Stanford Blatch, who is gay, and I have forgotten the name of the actor who plays him, who it turns out was straight, which blew my mind because I've only ever seen him play very over the top characters.
- 14:53Emily: Yeah.
- 14:53Emily: Um, in a way that just felt very natural.
- 14:55Emily: Charlotte has a gay friend named Anthony, and I could not tell you who the actor is.
- 15:01Emily: And Stanford and Anthony hate each other on site, but they end up getting married.
- 15:06Emily: Stanford and Anthony do?
- 15:08Emily: Yes.
- 15:09Emily: Oh.
- 15:10Emily: And uh, I had a problem with that even when it was airing.
- 15:15SPEAKER_01: So we'll get to that.
- 15:19SPEAKER_01: So let me talk about it But you didn't oh you have to quickly.
- 15:22SPEAKER_01: John Corbett plays a guy named Aiden.
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 15:25Emily: Yes, yes, yes, yes.
- 15:26Emily: Okay.
- 15:27Emily: Another one of Ferry's on-again, off again relationships is with John Corbett's Aiden Shaw.
- 15:32Emily: And uh, he is a fan favorite.
- 15:34Emily: People love him because he seems to be like such a perfect boyfriend.
- 15:37Emily: I hated him.
- 15:38Emily: I hated his character.
- 15:40Emily: Carrie is a smoker.
- 15:41Emily: She smokes all throughout.
- 15:43Emily: It's really gross to watch now.
- 15:46Emily: But when Aiden meets her, he shames her for smoking in a way that feels like he doesn't recognize that it's an addiction.
- 15:55Emily: You don't want to date a smoker.
- 15:57Emily: I don't want to date a smoker.
- 15:58Emily: That's fine.
- 15:59Emily: But you meet someone you really like and turns out they're a smoker, you need to have grace for the fact that this is an addiction.
- 16:06Emily: Right.
- 16:08Emily: And then there is another episode where when Miranda finds out she's pregnant, she's considering having an abortion.
- 16:16Emily: And it's it's actually an amazing episode because at the same time, Charlotte is dealing with infertility.
- 16:22Emily: And so this is a really difficult time for these four friends.
- 16:26Emily: And so they they talk openly about it.
- 16:28Emily: And uh, Samantha says, you know, let's talk about it.
- 16:30Emily: I've had two, and thank God.
- 16:34Emily: Carrie had an abortion.
- 16:37Emily: Uh she'd had a one-night stand with a guy, and she's like, Well, I never told him because that was the other aspect of it.
- 16:43Emily: Miranda hasn't told Steve yet that she's pregnant.
- 16:47Emily: And so when Carrie is talking to Aiden about it, about the fact that Miranda's considering this, he's like, You would never do something like that, right?
- 16:59Emily: And then when she comes back and tells him, like, actually I did, and he's he's kind about it, like, I'm still not okay with that being his initial response.
- 17:11Emily: I'm still not okay with that.
- 17:14Emily: Like, it's it's not okay that his immediate reaction was like, You wouldn't have to do something like that, would you?
- 17:19Emily: Like, no, stop.
- 17:24Emily: I could see him saying, like, wait, she's not gonna tell Steve and she's gonna have an abortion.
- 17:29Emily: Wow, I really hope that if you were ever in that situation with me, you would talk to me.
- 17:34Emily: Not you would never do that, would you?
- 17:37Emily: So thank you for reminding me.
- 17:39Emily: I hate Aiden.
- 17:40Emily: I am I am very rare of Sex in the City fans to hate Aiden, but I hate him.
- 17:47SPEAKER_00: I find him manipulative and gross.
- 17:51SPEAKER_00: So I want to talk about the female friendship.
- 17:54SPEAKER_00: I I took such joy in the depiction of this friendship.
- 18:00Emily: There is one scene, it's an early episode, I think it's the fourth episode.
- 18:05Emily: Carrie's met Mr.
- 18:06Emily: Big and they've been trying to have a date, and it it keeps not happening, and she is running late for it when she gets a call, a panicked call from Charlotte, saying, I'm going on a date with this guy she's been seeing for three weeks.
- 18:20Emily: And he he said, you know, tomorrow night I'd really love it if we could, you know, have a nice dinner, have some wine, and then have anal sex.
- 18:28Emily: Yeah.
- 18:29Emily: And Charlotte is like, and so as soon as she tells Carrie that, Carrie's on the phone, like, I got two minutes, I gotta be out the door, I'm gonna be late.
- 18:37Emily: And as soon as she says that, Carrie says, Meet me outside your apartment in 10 minutes.
- 18:42Emily: And she gets a clap.
- 18:44Emily: And then they it starts with Carrie and Charlotte talking, and then they go, they pick up Miranda, and then they pick up Samantha, and all four of them are talking.
- 18:52Emily: The cab driver, who I think is Sikh because he's he's wearing a turban, keeps turning around looking at them because of what they're talking about.
- 19:00Emily: Because um, Charlotte's like, I don't want to be the off the butt girl, because nobody becomes Mrs.
- 19:04Emily: Off the Butt.
- 19:06Emily: Oh my God.
- 19:09Emily: Whereas and Samantha's like, you should try it.
- 19:12Emily: It can be fun.
- 19:13Emily: Like, it's hilarious.
- 19:16Emily: That scene is just, it makes my heart sing because immediately she drops her plans and goes to help her friend.
- 19:27Emily: Because, yeah, this needs to be discussed.
- 19:29Emily: And then they they all four of them they get together and they they talk about this.
- 19:33Emily: And so it's a very funny, early moment that truly like encapsulates who these women are to each other.
- 19:42Emily: And it's also just I'm dying laughing watching this yesterday, even though I have seen it many times.
- 19:50Emily: So that that is something that I just really love about it, and the fact that it's funny too is I think amazing.
- 19:58Emily: And there is a scene that lives rent-free in my brain and is the reason, and just like that is dead to me.
- 20:11Emily: So Carrie is with Aiden.
- 20:14Emily: Mr.
- 20:14Emily: Big has, like, they've they've been off and on, off and on, and he has left her and married a model who is younger than her, a woman named Natasha.
- 20:23Emily: And Mr.
- 20:24Emily: Big, who's also pretty toxic, runs into Carrie and tells her, like, it's not working.
- 20:30Emily: I'm going to get out of the marriage.
- 20:31Emily: And and Carrie's like, I'm, and she's with Aiden at the time.
- 20:34Emily: She's like, I'm I'm dating someone.
- 20:37Emily: This is no information I want to know.
- 20:39Emily: But he keeps pursuing her until they end up having an affair.
- 20:43Emily: So she's cheating on Aiden and he's cheating on Natasha.
- 20:48Emily: And Carrie feels awful about it.
- 20:52Emily: She goes to Samantha, she has a new apartment.
- 20:56Emily: So they go to a housewarming, like it's just the four of them, it's a new apartment.
- 21:00Emily: And she sticks around after the other two have left and she tells Samantha.
- 21:06Emily: And Samantha is amazing because she says, like the first thing she says, okay, how was the sex?
- 21:16Emily: And they they they talk about it, and Carrie at the end of it finally says to Samantha, don't you want to judge me just a little?
- 21:25Emily: And Samantha says, It's not my style.
- 21:29SPEAKER_00: I get teary-eyed thinking about it.
- 21:31Emily: Just that unconditional love that makes room for her to feel what she needs to feel about it because she feels terrible about it herself, that doesn't judge, that makes her laugh, that is just there for her.
- 21:50Emily: And for and just like that, they couldn't get Kim Catrol to sign on.
- 21:55Emily: That happens.
- 21:57Emily: So they wrote her out of the show by saying that Samantha got angry at Carrie because Carrie wouldn't use her PR firm or something like that.
- 22:06Emily: So she stopped being her friend.
- 22:09Emily: And I'm sorry.
- 22:11Emily: Not my style.
- 22:12Emily: Would never do that.
- 22:15Emily: Never.
- 22:16Emily: So the show is dead to me.
- 22:17Emily: I like I I refuse to acknowledge that it exists.
- 22:21Emily: When they very easily could have written her out by saying like she was in.
- 22:27Emily: England during COVID and got stuck there.
- 22:30Emily: And now that's where she lives.
- 22:33SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 22:34Emily: It's it wouldn't be perfect.
- 22:36Emily: But it would be just killed her in character.
- 22:39Emily: They could have killed her.
- 22:42Emily: I would prefer she's living her best life, you know.
- 22:45Emily: In London.
- 22:46Emily: In London.
- 22:47Emily: I would I would prefer that.
- 22:50Emily: So that actually brings me to something about the character of Samantha.
- 22:56Emily: Samantha is hilarious.
- 22:58Emily: She's amazing.
- 23:00Emily: There is a scene in one of the episodes I watched to prepare for this where the four of them are at brunch, because that's what they do.
- 23:11Emily: Like every every Saturday they have brunch together.
- 23:13Emily: They're at brunch.
- 23:14Emily: And they're all quiet.
- 23:16Emily: And out of nowhere, Samantha says, I'm dating a guy with the funkiest tasting spunk.
- 23:24Emily: Charlotte picks up her purse, gets up, and walks out.
- 23:31SPEAKER_00: Just leaves.
- 23:33Emily: And Randall's like, and she's never coming back.
- 23:37Emily: Because Charlotte and Samantha have friction because of their very opposing views of the way the world works.
- 23:43Emily: And Samantha just is just free.
- 23:47Emily: She's just free to say these things and do these things.
- 23:50Emily: And I loved that.
- 23:53Emily: But the show kept then wanting to make fun of her, have her be the butt of the joke, which felt very regressive.
- 24:03Emily: So there was another episode that I saw to prepare for this.
- 24:07Emily: And this happened over and over again.
- 24:08Emily: This was not the only time this happened.
- 24:11Emily: Where Carrie, because she's kind of a minor celebrity, she's asked to judge like a firefighting, like firefighters stripping.
- 24:20Emily: And they're going to be making a firefighter calendar and all of that.
- 24:25Emily: And so Samantha ends up meeting one of the firefighters, and uh she was like, Oh, you know, this is a fantasy.
- 24:31Emily: And then she shows up at the firehouse thinking all the men are gonna look like him, and they do not.
- 24:37Emily: And she and her firefighter have sex on the truck, the fire truck.
- 24:42Emily: And afterwards, she's just wearing panties and she's looking at the gear, and she's like, Why are why are you leaving the boots and everything out like this?
- 24:49Emily: And she puts on the boots and and like pulls it up and has it cover her breasts that way when the bell goes off.
- 24:57Emily: And so all the firefighters are rushing in, and the guy whose gear it is starts screaming at her, get the fuck out of my gear.
- 25:03Emily: There's a fire.
- 25:04Emily: And so she's left basically naked.
- 25:08Emily: And then the firetruck leaves and the door is open, and so people pass by and can see her and are laughing.
- 25:17Emily: And it feels like the show wanted to have its cake and eat it too with Samantha.
- 25:24Emily: They wanted her to be this commanding, unashamed, amazing woman who just owns her sexuality.
- 25:33SPEAKER_01: But they also wanted to be a- And then they had the slut shamer.
- 25:35Emily: Yeah.
- 25:36Emily: Yeah.
- 25:38Emily: And again, that not my style moment, Samantha does not fucking deserve that.
- 25:45SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 25:46Emily: Did is that why Kim Cotral didn't come back?
- 25:49Emily: It's hard to say if it's true or not, but there have been mentions that Sarah Jessica Parker and Kim Catrall had some friction.
- 25:57Emily: Oh.
- 25:58Emily: And that's in part because people loved Samantha.
- 26:02Emily: And she got a lot of the best lines, and she was very, very funny.
- 26:07Emily: And that Sarah Jessica Parker, for whatever reason, was jealous.
- 26:12Emily: That's what's reported.
- 26:14Emily: I don't know.
- 26:15Emily: Doesn't sound likely, frankly.
- 26:17Emily: I think also Kim Catrol had to be talked into doing this.
- 26:23Emily: She was early 40s, and she was just like, I don't know if this is the kind of character I want to play anymore.
- 26:29Emily: Not that she'd ever played that character, but like a bombshell.
- 26:31Emily: That I think had something to do with her, like, you know what, I'm I'm done.
- 26:34Emily: I don't want to come back anymore.
- 26:35Emily: I'm I'm in my 60s now.
- 26:37Emily: Like, which, you know, fair enough.
- 26:42Emily: So that aspect of it, that like progressive-regressive aspect of women and sexuality.
- 26:50Emily: Samantha in particular.
- 26:51Emily: Samantha in particular, but it's not just Samantha.
- 26:55Emily: There's an episode where Carrie has a lot of like acquaintances and friends.
- 27:00Emily: And she runs into Amelita, who she says most people would describe her as Euro trash.
- 27:05Emily: I thought her of her as fun.
- 27:07Emily: So she's like a professional girlfriend.
- 27:09Emily: Like that's what she does.
- 27:10Emily: She's Italian and Carrie runs into her while Carrie's buying shoes, and her heart has declined.
- 27:15Emily: And the sales salesman like cuts it in half.
- 27:18Emily: And so Amelita says, like, ah, I will buy them.
- 27:21Emily: And Carrie's like, I can't let you do that.
- 27:23Emily: And he's just like, well, it's not really me, it's Pedro, her current boyfriend.
- 27:27Emily: So Carrie ends up going out with Amelita and meets this unbelievably handsome French architect who's only in town for the weekend.
- 27:36Emily: They have a wonderful day together.
- 27:38Emily: She goes with him to his his hotel and sleeps with him.
- 27:41Emily: Um, he leaves and says, I have to go.
- 27:43Emily: I'm flying out to Peru.
- 27:45Emily: I don't even remember.
- 27:47Emily: And um, you know, I'll call you.
- 27:49Emily: And then after he leaves, she realizes, like, well, he doesn't have my number.
- 27:52Emily: But then she sees he's left an envelope on the on the table for her.
- 27:56Emily: It's got a thousand dollars in it.
- 27:58Emily: He thought she was a prostitute.
- 28:00Emily: It's not so much that, it's more like that's who that's how Amelita lives.
- 28:06Emily: It's not like, but basically, yes.
- 28:10Emily: And so, but he she had said, I'll get up and go with you because she's in this hotel.
- 28:13Emily: He's like, No, no, no, stay, order room service.
- 28:16Emily: And so she has Samantha and Miranda come over and they're all ordering room service together.
- 28:22Emily: And like they're saying, like, well, it's one thing to order room service, it's another to accept the cash.
- 28:29Emily: And Carrie actually says, like, my morals wouldn't accept this.
- 28:35Emily: And there's there's there's this judgment of sex work that feels regressive that I I know I didn't catch on to at the time.
- 28:47Emily: But it it's also like, you know, she's judging Amelita in a way that is just like, and one of the things I love about Samantha is she says women can use whatever tool they have in their toolbox to get power.
- 29:06Emily: And she says, sex is power, money is power.
- 29:08Emily: You're just exchanging power for power.
- 29:11Emily: Mm-hmm.
- 29:13SPEAKER_00: But then the show has to slut shame Samantha over and over and over again.
- 29:21Emily: So it's it's very difficult to like kind of tease those apart because again, uh in in a lot of ways, this movie, there this movie, this show is very feminist, passes Beckdale Flying Colors.
- 29:34Emily: Now, the four of them talk about men all the time.
- 29:36Emily: And there's actually one episode where Miranda she's trying to show them her palm pilot because they're all three are uh talking about men, and she finds just like, enough.
- 29:45Emily: Can we talk about something other than men?
- 29:48Emily: And leaves.
- 29:50Emily: But they talk about all kinds of stuff.
- 29:53Emily: I mean, like everything, all the time.
- 29:56Emily: You know, they they they are each other's supports.
- 29:59Emily: They are, they, they love each other.
- 30:02Emily: But that same episode where Samantha says, Not my style, she's just gotten this new apartment.
- 30:07Emily: She has bought it, and then she gets sick.
- 30:11Emily: So she is um, like she's trying to pull the curtains closed because she's got the flu and the curtain rod falls.
- 30:18Emily: And she then starts trying to call all of her old hookups to see if anyone will come to help take care of her, and none of them will.
- 30:25Emily: And like the thing that irritates me and irritated me at the time, was like, you call Charlotte and Carrie and Miranda, because Carrie does end up coming over and taking care of her.
- 30:38Emily: But at the time when they had the uh housewarming, she opened the window and shouted out the out the door, like, I have it all.
- 30:46Emily: I'm a woman and I can have it all.
- 30:48Emily: And they immediately take it away from her.
- 30:51Emily: Um, where she's saying, like, oh, you know, it doesn't mean anything if there's no one to take care of you when she's sick.
- 30:58Emily: And then in a little bit after that, when she's healthy again, Carrie says, like, you were saying that.
- 31:04Emily: She's like, Oh, it was delirious.
- 31:06Emily: But it's still like this this pushback, like, no, you can't really have it all.
- 31:12Emily: And like, okay, no, you can't.
- 31:14Emily: I mean, first of all, what's it all?
- 31:15Emily: And uh, you know, we're human.
- 31:19Emily: But at the same time, she has three dear friends who would drop everything to come take care of her.
- 31:29Emily: And so this this episode goes through that just to poke fun at the most sexually liberated of the four women.
- 31:39Emily: It's it's really tough to watch.
- 31:41Emily: And I remember hating that at the time, when it aired, I remember being like, that's that's not appropriate.
- 31:47Emily: That's not who Samantha is.
- 31:52Emily: The show is very white.
- 31:55Emily: It's very privileged.
- 31:57Emily: You know, all four of these women are straight, white, cishet, thin, attractive, well-paid.
- 32:07Emily: Yes, fairly affluent, I think.
- 32:09Emily: Yeah.
- 32:09Emily: Yeah.
- 32:11Emily: And so hearing some of their complaints can feel irritating.
- 32:21Emily: Although even with that, like there was a a show that was supposed to be like the gay version of Sex in the City that came out, I don't know, about four or five years ago, that had um Doogie Hauser.
- 32:33Emily: Um Neil Patrick Harris was the main character in it.
- 32:38Emily: And I think it was also Darren Starr was uh was the showrunner.
- 32:42Emily: Uh, and I tried to watch the first episode and like their the privilege was reeking.
- 32:47Emily: And I was like, I cannot watch this.
- 32:49Emily: These people, like, do you know what the world is out there?
- 32:53Emily: And I don't think it was just because Neil Patrick Harris is a white man.
- 32:57Emily: I think some of it was just that it was just such the upper echelons of privilege financially.
- 33:04Emily: Whereas Carrie is consistently having financial difficulties.
- 33:09Emily: She she's not very good with money.
- 33:11Emily: She spends her money on shoes and doesn't really think ahead, you know, plan ahead for financial stuff.
- 33:18Emily: So there's there's that aspect of it.
- 33:20Emily: And I just, I also just think there's there's a little less, but the show does not understand intersectionality at all.
- 33:31Emily: There is uh an early episode where Samantha dates a black man and they end up breaking up because his sister has a problem with it, and it really leans into the angry black woman trope.
- 33:46Emily: It's very ugly to revisit.
- 33:49Emily: Another episode that I that I watched, a relatively early one, Carrie's dating a younger man.
- 33:55Emily: And so he asks her like about previous relationships, and she tells him a little bit about Mr.
- 33:59Emily: Big.
- 33:59Emily: And then he's he says, Well, I've had three.
- 34:02Emily: You know, there's Layla, whatever her name was.
- 34:04Emily: There's Susan, whatever her name was, and then Mark.
- 34:07Emily: He asks, the the boyfriend asks, is that a problem?
- 34:11Emily: And she's like, No, but she's lying.
- 34:14Emily: Then at brunch with the with the other women, she no, uh, the boyfriend is younger than her.
- 34:22Emily: Um, so he's in.
- 34:24Emily: And so they talk about like, God, it's a different generation.
- 34:27Emily: They're a different letter than us, because it would, he would have been millennial gen Y.
- 34:32Emily: They're still calling it that.
- 34:34Emily: And she's like, I don't believe in bisexuality.
- 34:37Emily: It's just a um stop on the on the way to gay town.
- 34:42Emily: What?
- 34:43SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 34:45SPEAKER_00: Carrie said it.
- 34:47SPEAKER_00: Carrie says that.
- 34:50Emily: And there's it's this very regressive, like, women are women, men are men.
- 34:55Emily: And uh Samantha has a great line.
- 34:58Emily: She's like, I consider myself trisexual.
- 35:00Emily: I'll try anything once.
- 35:02Emily: It's very binary.
- 35:04Emily: It is.
- 35:06Emily: And this episode ends with um Carrie goes to um a party with the boyfriend that's hosted by Mark, the ex.
- 35:14Emily: And uh all of the people there are younger than her.
- 35:17Emily: And Carrie is like overwhelmed by the back and forth because the ex is now with, now married to a man whose ex-girlfriend or ex-wife, played by Alanis Morset, just got married to a woman.
- 35:32Emily: And Carrie's like, I can't keep this straight.
- 35:34Emily: There's so many, and it's just like it's really not that complicated.
- 35:38Emily: And they end up playing Spin the Bottle, and bottle lands on um uh Alanis Morset spins it, and bottle lands on uh, like there's already been two spins, and both times it was a male-female pairing, but the bottle ends at Carrie, and Carrie's like, oh, whoops, I'm a girl, got to spin again.
- 35:57Emily: And Alanis Morset's like, no, you really don't have to.
- 36:00Emily: And so she kisses Carrie, and Carrie gets up and leaves.
- 36:06Emily: She's like, Yeah, I'm I'm not for me, but in a kind of judgmental way.
- 36:14Emily: So she gets up and leaves, and she never sees Sean.
- 36:16Emily: Sean is the name of the boyfriend, never sees the boyfriend again.
- 36:21Emily: And boy, is that a time capsule.
- 36:24Emily: Like that kind of biphobia, just being okay.
- 36:29SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 36:30Emily: By erasure, that same episode, because they generally the the episodes had a theme, and like all four women are experiencing some aspect of that theme.
- 36:43Emily: And so Charlotte is exhibiting a new artist, a photographer, who dresses uh women up in in male drag, basically.
- 36:52Emily: And so it's photos of these women dressed as men who look very much like men.
- 36:57Emily: And the uh artist says, Well, there's feminine in every man, there's masculine in every woman, you know, I I like exploring that.
- 37:04Emily: And he asks Charlotte to pose for him as a man, and she's like, I'm a girly girl.
- 37:08Emily: Like, I can't do that.
- 37:09Emily: And one of the things that she talks about is the artist who does these photographs has indicated interest in her but hasn't asked her out.
- 37:19Emily: And so they were like, You should ask him out.
- 37:21Emily: And she's like, Oh, I can't do that.
- 37:23Emily: So when she's dressed as a man for the photograph, and he's like, he he talks her up, like you're you're like this powerful man.
- 37:33Emily: You you dominate boardrooms.
- 37:35Emily: And so when she's feeling like that, and she actually when he like he talks her up and she's like, I think I need a bigger sock to you know, stuff in her pants, and then she kisses him.
- 37:45SPEAKER_00: But that's only because she's dressed like a man.
- 37:49SPEAKER_00: Mm-hmm.
- 37:50SPEAKER_00: Mm-hmm.
- 37:52SPEAKER_00: It's a very bizarre binary that I why I mean it protects the status quo, is why.
- 38:04Emily: Yeah, yeah.
- 38:05Emily: And then I I do want to talk about like the Stanford and Anthony, the two gay characters.
- 38:13Emily: They're both fabulous characters.
- 38:15Emily: Like they really are.
- 38:16Emily: Um, I love Stanford.
- 38:17Emily: He's he's a longtime excellent friend to Carrie, and he's hilarious.
- 38:22Emily: There's there's one point that I say this all the time, I can't remember what she's doing, but she's saying something like kind of catty about someone, and he goes, Judgy Wudgy was a bear.
- 38:34Emily: And Anthony is this kind of um flamboyant and mean kind of man.
- 38:45SPEAKER_00: And they they hate each other.
- 38:48Emily: And they never explain why they get together.
- 38:53SPEAKER_01: Oh, you don't see the enemies to lovers happen.
- 38:57Emily: No.
- 38:57SPEAKER_01: You just know they hate each other and then all of a sudden they're married?
- 39:00Emily: It's not quite that fast.
- 39:02Emily: You see them like they hook up sometimes and and stuff like that.
- 39:04Emily: But again, it's just because like they're both there.
- 39:08Emily: Like you don't see any like there, there's there's nothing there.
- 39:13SPEAKER_01: And uh sort of like um to me, it sounds like we we just recently had an episode about Star Wars, and you were like, when Luke finds out he has a sister, he's like, of course it's Leia.
- 39:22SPEAKER_01: She's the only other woman in the in the universe, right?
- 39:24SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 39:25SPEAKER_01: So it sounds almost like that.
- 39:26SPEAKER_01: Like, of course, Stanford and Anthony end up together because they're the only two gay characters in the whole show in all of New York.
- 39:32Emily: Yeah.
- 39:34Emily: And it it really, like, again, because this show does such a good job with characterization and making even the most outlandish character feel like a real person.
- 39:45SPEAKER_01: This just felt stands out that because it missed, it missed the mark.
- 39:51Emily: Yeah, so badly.
- 39:53Emily: I mean, remember, even at the time, because Anthony yells at Charlotte, because Charlotte is the one who tries to first um put them together, tries to get them to um to get together.
- 40:04Emily: Willie Garson is the name of the actor who plays Stanford.
- 40:07Emily: Willie Garson is bald and like kind of dapper, like the way that they dress him.
- 40:14Emily: And Anthony is much more conventionally handsome.
- 40:18Emily: And so Anthony asks Charlotte, uh, he asks about what he what he looks like.
- 40:23Emily: And she's like, ah, and he's like, Well, what what actor would play him in a movie or something like that?
- 40:27Emily: And she goes, Ed Harris.
- 40:29Emily: And so when he meets him, he comes back to Charlotte and he's like, I am a fine-looking piece of goods, something along those lines.
- 40:39Emily: Like, this is no, you you can't just assume because we're both gay that we're gonna get along.
- 40:45Emily: So he was like, he's not attracted to Stanford and thinks that he's and that this is this is in character.
- 40:52Emily: This is in character for Anthony.
- 40:53Emily: He he would be like, No, I'm I'm an eight, he's a five, you know, he would like do something like that.
- 41:00SPEAKER_00: Mm-hmm.
- 41:02Emily: But uh he he makes it clear that it's not okay to assume that they'll like each other just because they are both gay.
- 41:13SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 41:14Emily: And yet the show still takes them together.
- 41:18Emily: And up together.
- 41:21Emily: And I know that is something that they are trying to improve upon with and just like that.
- 41:28Emily: They have a much more diverse cast in terms of both um race and sexuality and and and body type.
- 41:37Emily: But for a show that was so good and so character-driven, these were like, these were mistakes from the beginning.
- 41:45Emily: Uh so those are, you know, those are the things that like I noticed even at the time.
- 41:52Emily: What has come out so uh in spoiler alert, but in the reboot on just like that, at that point Carrie and Mr.
- 42:02Emily: Big are are married.
- 42:04Emily: The very first episode.
- 42:05Emily: I thought he died.
- 42:06Emily: He doesn't die.
- 42:07Emily: He dies in the very first episode.
- 42:09Emily: Oh.
- 42:10SPEAKER_01: That's what I'm yeah.
- 42:12SPEAKER_01: That was the spoiler alert, I see.
- 42:13SPEAKER_01: That was a spoiler alert, yes.
- 42:15SPEAKER_01: I wasn't that biggest spoiler since I knew.
- 42:17SPEAKER_01: I don't know anything.
- 42:18SPEAKER_01: And again, Samantha doesn't show up for the funeral.
- 42:23Emily: Which not my style.
- 42:25Emily: Does not fit.
- 42:27Emily: Yeah, yeah.
- 42:28Emily: They should have just made her dead.
- 42:30Emily: Uh and they have like they have she sends a flower floral tribute.
- 42:36Emily: But it's still just like, that's no.
- 42:39Emily: No.
- 42:39Emily: Yeah.
- 42:40Emily: Anyway, Ryan Reynolds, because he dies on a Peloton.
- 42:45Emily: Ryan Reynolds somehow got involved and made a Peloton commercial showing Chris Noth with the uh I think the Peloton instructor who, you know, was was on that when he died.
- 43:00Emily: Um, and the the commercial ends with, it's okay, guys, he's he's fine.
- 43:05Emily: And it was almost immediately after that that I multiple women came forward with incredible accusations of just horrific, horrific sexual assault.
- 43:21SPEAKER_00: And I, you know, obviously I don't know Chris Noss.
- 43:28Emily: But the way that his character is portrayed even feels like it fits with that in that he is commanding.
- 43:41Emily: And when he and Carrie end up having that affair, he keeps bothering her.
- 43:48Emily: He keeps showing up where he knows she'll be.
- 43:50Emily: And uh, and in fact, Aidan is fixing the floors in her apartment, so she leaves and goes to a hotel.
- 43:57Emily: And Mr.
- 43:58Emily: Big finds her there, calls her, and asks her to come down to the lobby, and then he like pursues her back into the elevator, and she keeps saying, Fuck you, fuck you.
- 44:11Emily: And then like he grabs her and he starts to kiss her, and then she goes, Oh, fuck me.
- 44:16Emily: So, like in that like an invitation.
- 44:22SPEAKER_01: I got it.
- 44:23SPEAKER_01: That's really shitty writing.
- 44:27Emily: So that story arc I think is fascinating, and I appreciate the story arc.
- 44:35Emily: The fact that Mr.
- 44:37Emily: Big is forcing himself on her.
- 44:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that it that she was coerced into it.
- 44:45SPEAKER_01: Now we know And then they write it so that she actually really wanted it.
- 44:48SPEAKER_01: We all know she actually wanted it.
- 44:49Emily: Well, the thing is, we know because of her voiceover.
- 44:53Emily: We know from her voiceover.
- 44:55Emily: Well, the t the showrunners made sure we knew she actually wanted it.
- 44:58Emily: But yeah, that's a choice.
- 45:00Emily: Yes.
- 45:02Emily: I remember watching this episode when it aired.
- 45:06Emily: And she's going, fuck you, fuck you.
- 45:08Emily: And I'm waiting for her to push him out of the elevator.
- 45:10Emily: And when she then goes, fuck me, I remember being like, What the fuck am I watching?
- 45:17SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 45:18SPEAKER_01: That's I mean that's like a a commanding man's wet dream.
- 45:26SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 45:27SPEAKER_01: When she says no, she means yes.
- 45:29Emily: Yeah.
- 45:30Emily: I remember seeing some behind-the-scenes stuff where um Chris Knoff, they they would interview Chris Knoff, and some of the things that he said, I remember kind of dicking me out at the time.
- 45:41Emily: The show is known for its sex scenes.
- 45:44Emily: And Sarah Jessica Parker was not comfortable doing any nudity.
- 45:48Emily: Um, but the other three main actresses were.
- 45:51Emily: And so even though there were sex scenes that involved Carrie, they were fewer and farther between.
- 45:58Emily: And so there was an interview with Chris Knoth where he was saying, like, uh, oh, you're wondering how we shoot the sex scenes?
- 46:04Emily: Well, Sarah Jessica and I just have sex and they they film it.
- 46:07Emily: Like, ha ha ha ha ha, I'm kidding.
- 46:09Emily: And I remember being like, ew, at the time.
- 46:14Emily: That's really gross.
- 46:16Emily: Yeah.
- 46:17Emily: As feminist as this show is in so many ways, it ends up being very regressive.
- 46:26Emily: You know, the these four women, they're so important to each other, and they show that single women in the city can thrive.
- 46:34Emily: Uh while also showing the um insecurities and and the doubts and the difficulties of being a single woman in a world made for married couples.
- 46:43Emily: And also like the the like, do I want to have children?
- 46:49Emily: You know, the reason why Miranda ends up having the the baby is she's like, what if this is my baby?
- 46:56Emily: And the the difficulty of infertility.
- 46:58Emily: Um, Samantha gets breast cancer in the sixth season.
- 47:02Emily: All of these things are are just amazing.
- 47:06Emily: It's amazing to see that and to see these strong, powerful women support each other and love each other through all of this without needing no man.
- 47:17Emily: But by the end of the sixth season, all four of them are paired up.
- 47:22Emily: Even Samantha?
- 47:23Emily: Even Samantha, she's with Smith with the with the model.
- 47:27Emily: Now it's on her terms and they end up breaking up uh because there's there are two movies, and I believe it's in the the first movie, they end up breaking up because he moves to Los Angeles um because he he has like makes it as an actor and model, and so she moves with him and it's not working.
- 47:49Emily: And she she breaks up with him and he says, like, I thought I thought you loved me.
- 47:54Emily: And she's like, I do love you, but I love me more, which is fantastic.
- 48:00Emily: Yeah.
- 48:02Emily: But the pairing up it just it feels odd.
- 48:07Emily: Now I'm glad that they did that.
- 48:09Emily: They did not do that.
- 48:10Emily: So um Samantha's breast cancer is at the end of the sixth season and the chemotherapy and going through all of that, she loses her libido.
- 48:18Emily: And it's very difficult for her because who is she if she's not a sexual being?
- 48:26Emily: And there is a like one of the things that's great about Smith is that he supports her through that and basically reassures her that she is Samantha, whether or not they're having sex.
- 48:40Emily: So like he is in a lot of ways really great for her.
- 48:44Emily: But there is this core of conservatism that runs throughout the show.
- 48:52SPEAKER_00: And it's hard to it's hard to live with that.
- 48:59Emily: I'm starry-eyed romantic, like you know, when people would say, like, which one of the four are you?
- 49:03Emily: Like, I'm Charlotte.
- 49:05Emily: Um and actually people used to tell me I look like her, especially when I wear my hair like I am right now with it tied in a ponytail because Kristen Davis would often wear her hair in a ponytail like this.
- 49:16Emily: While I was watching it when it was coming out, I liked that the these romantic interests worked out for them.
- 49:24Emily: Except for Big and Carrie.
- 49:26Emily: They they were just so toxic.
- 49:27Emily: They gave her someone even more toxic for him to look better by comparison.
- 49:33Emily: Yeah.
- 49:34Emily: But it still makes Coupledum the end goal.
- 49:38SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 49:39SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 49:41SPEAKER_01: We, I think, are running short on time.
- 49:44SPEAKER_01: So I know you have more that you want to say.
- 49:47SPEAKER_01: So we will definitely stick around for our shit we forgot to say about sex in the city, which is a patron exclusive.
- 49:53SPEAKER_01: So, listener, if you're not yet one of our patrons, head over to our Patreon.
- 49:58SPEAKER_01: The link will be in the show notes, and you can actually watch the video, not just listen to uh the extra thoughts that Emily has about Sex in the City.
- 50:08SPEAKER_01: But before we wrap up, let me see if I can reflect back to what I heard about Sex in the City, all the sort of lessons that are lurking behind the nostalgia.
- 50:19SPEAKER_01: So on the pros list, I heard this as a model of female friendship that really gave you hope almost, like as a young teen, early 20s, about what life could be like.
- 50:34SPEAKER_01: And the idea that a found family of, you know, beloved friends who would see each other through thick and thin, like that was something that really spoke to you and felt really important.
- 50:45SPEAKER_01: So much so, actually, that when Canon kind of breaks that, you say, fuck you, to Canon and won't accept it.
- 50:55SPEAKER_01: You demonstrated the nature of that friendship by telling me the story of the episode when Carrie admits to Samantha that she's having an affair and says, Don't you want to judge me just a little?
- 51:09SPEAKER_01: And Samantha says, That's not my style.
- 51:12SPEAKER_01: And that moment for you was the true Samantha.
- 51:18SPEAKER_01: And then the other moments where, you know, she's caught basically naked at the firehouse, or when she has the flu and she's calling her former hookups rather than her three best friends, that's not the real Samantha, as you understand it.
- 51:33SPEAKER_01: That's like the writer's room getting it wrong.
- 51:37SPEAKER_01: And especially the writer's room for just like that, who suggests that Samantha and Carrie would allow a professional disagreement to end their friendship.
- 51:49SPEAKER_01: Speaking of Samantha and the ways that, like the kernel that of not my style, which you sort of identify as the true core of that character and the and the way that the show then treated her, in some ways she was the most progressive.
- 52:05SPEAKER_01: You know, she's the most, she's she's trisexual, she'll try anything.
- 52:09SPEAKER_01: So she's the most sexually liberated.
- 52:11SPEAKER_01: She talks about having had abortions, she talks about like having tridental sex, like all of these things that she's just no inhibitions.
- 52:20SPEAKER_01: And yet she slut-shamed for it.
- 52:22SPEAKER_01: The show wanted to have its cake and eat it too.
- 52:25SPEAKER_01: So they wanted to have Samantha with all of her like flamboyance and hilarity, but then they slut shame her for it.
- 52:33Emily: I just want to mention my other favorite Samantha moment is again towards uh, I think season season five or six, she's with Smith.
- 52:42Emily: She had been completely shaving her genitalia, and Smith asks her to grow it out again because he he likes it.
- 52:49Emily: But when she does, there's gray hairs in there.
- 52:53Emily: And so she and Carrie are on their way to the first birthday party for Miranda's baby, no, no, toddler, Brady.
- 53:04Emily: She corners Carrie at this party, and she's tried to dye, dye her hair hair, and it comes out orange.
- 53:14Emily: And so she she pulls Carrie into the bathroom and she she says, No one wants to fuck grandma's pussy.
- 53:22Emily: Carrie's like, Oh my god, we are at a child's birthday party.
- 53:27Emily: Oh my god.
- 53:29Emily: Just that that that runs through my head at least once a year.
- 53:34Emily: Oh my god.
- 53:35Emily: Oh my god.
- 53:37Emily: I mean, particularly when I'm finding gray hairs.
- 53:40SPEAKER_01: Oh my god.
- 53:40SPEAKER_01: Oh my god.
- 53:42SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 53:42SPEAKER_01: So you also named the fact that this show has like the characters, there's a lot of financial privilege in addition to other identity privileges.
- 53:52SPEAKER_01: Like everyone in the show is able-bodied, cis, het, white, straight.
- 53:59SPEAKER_01: And so there's a slender with affluence and slender, thank you.
- 54:03SPEAKER_01: And so there's a lot of privilege in the show that is unacknowledged.
- 54:06SPEAKER_01: And the way you said it to me is that the showrunners have zero understanding of intersectionality.
- 54:12SPEAKER_01: There's also like bi-erasure, where one of Carrie's boyfriends is bisexual and she opts out as a result.
- 54:21SPEAKER_01: And there are ways in which that constellation of the privilege and the lack of intersectionality and the bi-erasure and the also like forcing the only two gay central characters into a coupling, you named it as sort of a times capsule, which I think is true of all popular culture because it's it's reflecting the time it's in.
- 54:43SPEAKER_01: That's what makes us like it.
- 54:45SPEAKER_01: But it really shows up in Rewatch on those sorts of things.
- 54:50SPEAKER_01: You also named the accusations against the actor Chris Chris Snop and the ways in which those credible allegations color the way you look at this show and his character.
- 55:08SPEAKER_01: And you talked about even the arc with him and Carrie, where he was, just from what you told me, coercive about their sexual relationship that then is actually extra colored by the actor's behavior.
- 55:22SPEAKER_01: I think that you named that, despite the fact that this show is progressive in a lot of ways, it has this core of conservatism.
- 55:30SPEAKER_01: And to me, that is representative of that core of conservatism, which is honestly like a core of like rape culture and misogyny.
- 55:40SPEAKER_01: And I don't think I'm overstating it to say that if the show had us know through her voiceover that when she said no, she meant yes, that is contributing to rape culture.
- 55:50SPEAKER_01: I will just say it outright.
- 55:52SPEAKER_01: So despite the fact that you came in saying you loved this show, that this was like one of the shows that was super formative, like there's some really icky stuff kind of lurking behind the nostalgia here.
- 56:04SPEAKER_01: So I'm I'm glad that we had the chance to unpack it.
- 56:07SPEAKER_01: Is there anything you want to add to my synopsis?
- 56:11Emily: Just the the what it got right resonated with not just women, but primarily women around the world.
- 56:23SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 56:23Emily: Which I know the showrunners were surprised by.
- 56:28Emily: And so there's a reason why I loved it.
- 56:31Emily: There's a reason why that I mean, I think there's still Sex in the City, like uh tours of New York that you can go on.
- 56:37Emily: Yeah.
- 56:38Emily: There there was something that really spoke to women's experience, especially in the late 20th, very early 21st century, of what it means to be a single woman, a professional woman in the world.
- 56:58Emily: Yeah.
- 56:59Emily: And I appreciate that.
- 57:01Emily: I really appreciate that.
- 57:02Emily: Um, and I will say the fact that the showrunners of and just like that are trying to fix some of the mistakes of the original is also something I appreciate.
- 57:14SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 57:14Emily: Yeah.
- 57:16SPEAKER_01: Well, our project is always about not throwing out the baby with the bathwater, but we don't have to let the baby keep drinking that shit water either.
- 57:23SPEAKER_01: So Yeah, yeah, definitely.
- 57:26SPEAKER_01: So next week, I'm gonna change the vibe a little bit.
- 57:29SPEAKER_01: I'm gonna bring you my deep thoughts about Monsters Inc.
- 57:32SPEAKER_01: That is a very different vibe.
- 57:34SPEAKER_01: Very different vibe.
- 57:36SPEAKER_01: But until then, we're gonna end recording here and start recording right away so that we can talk about the shit you forgot to say.
- 57:43SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 57:44SPEAKER_01: This show is a labor of love, but that doesn't make it free to produce.
- 57:48SPEAKER_01: If you enjoy it even half as much as we do, please consider helping to keep us overthinking.
- 57:54SPEAKER_01: You can support us at our Patreon.
- 57:56SPEAKER_01: There's a link in the show notes, or leave a positive review so others can find us.
- 58:01SPEAKER_01: And of course, share the show with your people.
- 58:04SPEAKER_01: Our theme music is Professor Umlaut by Kevin McLeod from Incompotech.com.
- 58:10SPEAKER_01: Find full music credits in the show notes.
- 58:12SPEAKER_01: Until next time, remember pop culture is still culture.
- 58:17SPEAKER_01: And shouldn't you know what's in your head?