Latest / Systems and Power / Why Democrats WILL FLIP the House AND Senate, Democrat Sweep? - Jimmy Vacca | Systems and Power #18
Transcript
- Moses: Thank you so much, Jimmy, for coming back on the podcast. Thank you for having me. You know, I think it's very i i it's it's now coming back to full circle in a way. You called me back when I was at an Uber ride home, and then you said, Moses, you should start a podcast. And here we are again for the second time. You're doing great. I've watched them and I'm really I'm really interested, and you've taken on a bunch of topics and they're very informative. You've had you've had great guests and and you really facilitate the entire discussion well. I I I do my best and I think the best guest to kick all of that off was of course with you. And for of course the topics of today, the midterm elections. I think you're one of the best to be able to discuss about this. Yes. I think we're in for a major change. I know right now the the Democrats are at a s even a sixty six percent chance to control the Senate, as I'm looking on the Cal Shi the on Calci right now. And overall I think the Democrats are at an eleven point lead nationally and have a n an over ninety percent chance to take the House. What's your thoughts on the political climate right now? Is this largely a just a referendum on Trump or there's something bigger going on? no, I think it's a it's a referendum on the current administration. I don't think that people voting are committed to the Democratic Party per se. I think people are motivated to be against. What they see happening. The high prices, the Iran war, the corruption allegations. I think this is what's motivating people to vote. So I don't know if this is purely a pro-democratic vote, but I do think it's an it's an anti-incumbent vote. Now I will say that every off-ear election means basically that the party in power in the White House does lose seats in the House and the Senate. this one I think will be a much more significant loss than we've had in pr many of the previous off years. Do you think this is kind of like a one eighty on two thousand and ten, back with the whole Tea Party movement? I don't know if it's going to reach that much of a of a debacle. I think with the Tea Party movement there was very like like there was a significant change in the House. I think you're going to see twenty, twenty five seats in the House go. But understand that when you see a national figure, which you just alluded to, where the Democrats have a more favorable rating than the Republicans of 11%, if that's the case, it's going to trickle down to races that you and I never suspect. We're talking about the Republicans putting a lot of money in Mississippi and South Carolina, Kansas. These are very Republican states. And when you see that the Republican Party is putting money into those states, then you know that the national trend is evidencing itself in states where normally there would not have been a competitive race. I mean, we saw Donald Trump campaigning in Ohio just recently for Vivek and John. Well I think Vivek is not going to win. I think most people agree that the commercial will not only hurt him. it's a new low in politics. And I think it's going to hurt other Republicans, especially in Ohio. the Senate seat there is very seriously contested. and I think that it's going to hurt the party, especially in Ohio, and it may re reverberate elsewhere. Donald Trump has largely been, I guess people have said that he's largely just kind of caring about himself and The party is essentially just a vehicle for him to use. There's no real loyalty to the GOP on a national or state level, and that he's willing to take it down as even if he's the one kind of like commandeering the ship, if that makes any sense. Well, I would remind everyone that he has two more years in the presidency. I don't think that Donald Trump would prefer a democratic house and a democratic senate. I think people have to understand if there's a democratic House and Senate, or one or the other, there's going to be intensive oversight at minimum. There are going to be significant hearings. There are going to be significant investigations. I would think that for two years we probably would have government and gridlock in so much as Congress may pass bills, but when they pass the bills, the president will veto it, and then there will not be a two-thirds majority to override the veto. And that's what you need to override a presidential veto. So presidents always want their own party to control the House and the Senate. I don't think that's going to be the case. I think the House certainly will go Democrat. And I think the odds of the Senate going Democrat are increasing every day. Doesn't look good. Some of the polls are very tight. But again, if there's a national trend, it's going to trickle down to races that we never imagine. Speaking of the House right now the Democrats, it looks like Hakeem Jeffries will be the next speaker and not and Nancy Pelosi's retiring. Do you think that he will be able to rein in and control the Democ the Democratic majority and be able to be an effective gridlock, I guess, against the administration? Well, if I'm Hakeem Jeffries, I would like to have at least a twenty or thirty seat margin. when you have a three or four seat margin. And you can ask Mike Johnson, the current Republican speaker, this question, it becomes difficult because then any three or four members can block the caucus from doing what the majority wants to do. so if I were Hakeem Jeffries, I would be praying for a 20 to 30 seat majority, which would give him more flexibility in getting his agenda across. And it would not allow certain individual members to perhaps move him too far to the left or to get a consensus that he's not happy with. so I think the numbers in the House are something that we should be watching. It will tell us a lot about the latitude Speaker Jeffries would have. Do you think we w are looking at a twenty two, thirty seat majority for the Democrats right now? I think we're looking at around twenty seats. Hm. What is your thoughts on the I guess I mean we had the Democratic primaries recently and we saw the rise of a lot of the DSA candidates coming in, overthrowing relatively progressive incumbents. Do you think that they will have a good working relationship with this with Hakeem Jeffries, assuming he does become the speaker? I think some will and I think some won't. I think some will become more realistic. You know, it's one thing to run for office, but it's another thing to win. And then to be Governing in a collaborative way. I think that many of the democratic socialists will realize that they cannot go to the House of Representatives, make speeches, and be independent entities and do as they wish and say as they wish. They have to be part of an overall democratic caucus. Through that caucus, you can get laws passed, do effective oversight. There may be impeachments that occur of cabinet officers or others. So I I think many of them will have a reality check. some may not, but I think that they will be fewer and far between. I mean, a lot of people do like to talk about independence, but at the end of the day, politics is a team sport. Of course it's a team sport. you're gonna have priorities too, and you're going to want some legislation. You're going to want to tack on some priorities to legislation. So you have to work with the speaker of the body. in order to get those things done. I'll tell you something else that's interesting. So many of the Democrats who are running for Senate and Congress, they're running as moderates. Whether they're moderates or not, I don't know. Elected officials will be a moderate if that if that's if that what if that's what's what's gets them elected, they will be a progressive if that's what gets them elected. So I understand that. But in certain states you cannot run as a socialist in Montana in Kansas. And you have to run as more of a moderate. So many of these Democrats are running as moderates. Taller Rico, others are running as more moderate centrist Democrats. So they're going to have to govern in that respect. Because if people feel that the Democratic Party has shifted too far to the left. And that's a fear of many people nationally. If they see that, some people may not support the Democratic Party. So Understand that right now the Democratic Party is going to win a midterm victory, the the level of which we don't know yet. But they're their winning doesn't mean that they're going to win in two years the presidency or keep the Congress. I do think that if they govern correctly, if they fight for the issues they've articulated, prices. Peace around the world, things like that. And if they manage to get results, I think they'll be in a much better position in two years, to get the presidency and to keep the Congress. A lot of the political, I guess like uprising that you that we see right now, especially with people voicing their disagreements, I see that it's mostly affecting people who are living in red states, like farmers with the tariffs, for example. Do you think that we're going to see the most damage done by the Democrats to the Republicans in like those areas? I think that the Democrats have to concentrate in those states. I don't ever want to think that the Democrats can take New York and California for granted. No one should be taken for granted. But I will say that the rest of the country is not New York and California. Democrats are going to have to not get carried away On certain issues, as many of them have in the past, they're going to have to understand that this country is significantly the middle. The middle is the significant force in this country. Don't forget, we are at the behest of independence. You have many states where independents outnumber Democrats, outnumber Republicans. So it's the independent voter. Those independent voters are not aligned with either party and they tend to be very centrist. So therefore, that that great middle is where most people are are at, and I think the Democrats have to understand that and resist being pulled to the left. Just like I think the Republicans should understand that they have to resist being pushed to the extreme right because the Trump presidency is going to end. in two years and at that point what kind of r of a republican party will there be? And I think that this election in two weeks is going to determine a lot. going to determine the the answer to that question. I remember in our last episode that we did the the first one, you made a a statement saying that the you see that the Democrats are gonna be going more to the left in the future and the Republicans are going to be more going more to the right. And we see that for the Democrats largely in with DSA candid candidates that are overthrowing incumbents. But we also see a lot of the extremes going also on the Republican Party as well. Like if you look on the like the rise of Nick Fuentes and the and the Tucker Carlson wing of the the Republican Party. I don't know if you saw the Florida primary for the Republicans. James Fishback, who has said a lot of things I guess what people would say that are extremely far to the right, he he only got ten percent of the vote. But if we look at voters who were only voted who were under 35 years old, he wins a plurality of the majority. And it shows a at least an alarm that is this where our politics is going to be in in the future, especially as more people who are like millennials or Gen Z get into positions of power. Well, young people are voting more and more. And I think the social media plays a s significant role in how young people vote. think that we have to hope that young people will be more More able to delineate truth, good, and bad when they watch the constant reels of social media. I worry about that. I worry about the influence of social media. It can serve such a good purpose, but I think that social media has brought many people out of their obscurity. And perhaps they should have stayed obscure because they abdicate things that are not mainstream at all. Extreme and too many people are taken in by that and then they embellish that and it becomes a whole thing just on its own. So yes, that is a c a challenge we have. Yeah, one thing that a lot of people I guess don't necessarily realize is that social media isn't real life. Social media kind of gives certain political views and amplifies them by tenfold, and then when people see that rhetoric going on online, they start to think that, that's what the majority actually thinks when in fact it's not. Yes. Everybody has an opinion and everybody can go on social media and voice it. Some people voice their opinion in such I don't want to use the the correct words, not obscene, but I'll put I'll say vulgar. And they use such vulgarity on social media. And a couple of years ago I think people would have frowned on that vulgarity. Now it's very common. I think it's a sad commentary on what our politics has become. you know, I always tell my students, if you ever want to run for office, make sure you have no skeletons in your closet. Make sure you're honest and ethical. And then if you want to run for office, you you know, I urge you to. Now, it's you're almost irrelevant if you have skeletons in your closet. Go run, everybody else is running as long as you win. Do whatever you have to do to win. If you if you win, who cares? But We should care about who we're electing to office. We want people with integrity in office. The objective should not be to win at any cost or any price with anyone. We have to have people of credibility who have integrity and ethics and are who are honest. And people who do have integrity and are honest and have ethics. Those people, many of whom I know, are now saying, you think I would ever run for office? I'll never run for office. This is not for me. And we need good people in office. Too many good people are saying that based on what I see, this is not for me. I mean, for example, like Ken Ken Paxson, who was impeached by his own party, the the the Republicans, in the in the Republican controlled s Texas state legislation, and he's now running for Senate. It's one of the unbelievable candidacies. The the it's It's just that I and some people accept this and and the more and more it happens, the more we just say, Well, you know, that's what it is. No, that's not necessarily what it should be. We we should have quality people running for office. and people who have those issues should not win. you know, and I don't speak I don't know this gentleman of course, but from Texas, but I I I I think that too many people running for office today don't represent the the high mark that we should set. We always looked up to our elected officials. Remember how many elected officials use the term honorable in front of their name. The honorable Jimmy Bacon. Honorable. Well, honorable means something. Honorable means that you are in a respected position where people look up to you. And that's how we always refer to elected officials with that term. Unfortunately, I guess nowadays politics doesn't seem so o so honorable, especially with the whole Ev apparently everyone's getting into scandals these days like To Tony Gonzalez for for example and just doing the most heinous acts and then we and then they just keep getting elected. I mean th obviously now they they've been removed they're not in office anymore, but just like na name a couple. Well, I I make kind of light of it, you know, I see people in the supermarket still and I I'm out of office eight years, but people will see me in the supermarket in the Bronx. And they'll say, we recognize you. We just don't know your name. We recognize you. So I said, I'm Jimmy, how are you? I was your city council member, but I want you to know I didn't do it. And that's exactly what I and they crack up laughing just like you did. I have to have a denial in there. other people will say, Jimmy, but why didn't you run again? What what happened to you? I says, Nothing happened to me. I had term limits. I think in people's minds they say, Well, you no longer ran. Was there a A scandal or something. No, I had term limits and I clarify that with people because that's people have a different sense today of politicians. I mean the council you you could technically run again. Will we ever see Well I won't be. So I loved it. I mean I had to throw that question out there. yeah. No. You're like, okay, guys, I I I'm retired, I'm out of it. Yes, yes. I love that. Yeah. Speaking of the Senate races, I did want to cover a few key states. Don't mind the the Minecraft background, but let's go into the into the into the polymarket predictions right now. Just hold just bear with me for one second. Hold on. We have well right now the the the the Democrats are at a sixty six percent chance to take the to take the Senate. And before it used to be very much of a toss-up. With the Republicans in favor of keeping control over the Senate. Right now I believe it's a fifty two or fifty three to forty seven. Yes, that's what it is. So a year ago, no one thought the Democrats had a chance to win the Senate. Because some of the seats that are up in Kansas and Texas, Mississippi, South Carolina, Florida, these are very Republican states. So a lot of people said, you know Let's take those states off the map. And once we do, the Democrats really have a big hill to climb. Things have changed since a year ago, dramatically. I mean, right now on Polymarket, we have James Salarico at a sixty-three percent chance to win against Ken Patson. How do you see that race going? I mean it right now it's basically a toss of it at point. Well, I think that is a toss of Texas is a very difficult state. It's been always thought that they would go Democrat, that they would elect a Democrat. beta O'Rourke came very close to beating Ted Cruz. Ted Cruz, but close is not good enough. so that was right after January sixth. Yes. And that was I mean I I would have never thought that that would ever happen in my lifetime, January sixth, when I when I when I saw that on when I saw that like on the on on the news and all of that and the radio. I remember I was at the gym at the time and I see the you know the the TVs that they have on the gym. Me and my friend we were working out. And I thought like the Republicans were pretty much done there, but Ted Cruz was able to still pull out a win there with only a few percentage points. Yep. You know, in an off-year election, there's one variable that's consistent, and that is pulling out your vote. Pulling out your vote. So if Republicans let's say the Republicans are at 35% right now, which the polls indicate they're at 35% nationwide. But of that 35%, can the Republicans get 70% of the 35% to vote? Where the Democrats may be at 45%, but with their 45%, they only get 55 or 60% of those to vote. So it is a get out the vote effort. And I think that that's what Trump is doing. Trump is trying to rile up the base. He he may be at 35%, but The turnout among that thirty-five percent is crucial if they turn out at much higher levels. I think what we're seeing in early voting, however, is that Democrats are turning out significantly. the early voting state tabulations I've seen. And you'll get an indication of this, by the way, on election night early. Kentucky closes their polls very early. I think they close at six o'clock. And they have a congressional race that is in dispute between the Republican and the Democrat. And Kentucky's a very Republican state. I think that you'll start to see early, you may not get certain states till eight or nine o'clock, but in some of those early states you'll start to see based on what the state is and based on what the the the race involves with the candidates, I think you'll start to see indications pretty early election night. Do you think what about the your opinion on the Susan Collins versus Troy Jackson race? That one is very interesting. That one's very interesting. you know, Maine is a small state. They have a million people. Susan Collins has been around a long time. Sometimes that works to your benefit, sometimes it works to your detriment. People may know her, they may like her, they may have met her several times. this year. doesn't necessarily mean that they're going to vote for her. She's a Republican. She has voted with the party many times. She has said that she's been independent other times. That's what they all say. That's for people to judge at this point. Yeah. I mean I I think her vote for Brett Kavanaugh is definitely biting her in the back. That hurt. Of course. Yeah. Right now on polymarkets it's at Tro Troy Jackson's at a sixty five percent chance chance to win. Do you think that whole st I I know the they the Democrats in my opinion didn't run the best campaign over there. They had Graham Platner, which they should have been w in my opinion, with the the safer option, the governor. You both have two established names and but then they w the the Democrats went with Graham Platner. Well the Graham Platner situation is exactly what I referred to before. Here you had a deficient candidate. And I'm being nice. You had a deficient candidate, and the Democrats thought he could win, and some Democrats, and many Democrats stuck with him through thick and thin, even as more and more revelations came out. But they thought he could win. And I think that hit Troy Jackson, of course, makes a stronger candidate. in in in this case. But that's that's a that's a classic example of what I referred to before. Well he was the way how I I see it, he was a he was a liability, but he was a liability that was polling like eight plus nine points at the time. But then when his poll numbers started to dip, they they released a hit piece on him for the allegations that he had and they're like, Okay, we need him out. Yeah. And he they replaced him with Troy Jackson and do I think it's was it a little bit too late? I don't know. I I think they might end up just going with I guess the devil that they know. I I I don't know because again there's an you know Maine has been trending Democrat for many years now and there is a national trend. and I I I do think Susan Collins has a problem. yeah. Let's go to the and Amy Acton is at eighty three percent chance to win with Vivek at eighteen percent that's That's definitely not looking good. I think you can take that to the bank. I yeah. Amy Acton's winning that one. I think she's going to win. whoever advised or put up that ad that Mr. Ramashwani put up has made a a terrible mistake and and also it's not just a political mistake. I I think it's a a human mistake. I I think it I think the go that low is absolutely disgusting. I I I cringed when I saw that ad and I I thought it was just not something that belongs that kind of an ad does not belong in our politics. Yeah, it i it's sad to see like they they didn't even apologize for it. I mean you saw JD Vance and Donald Trump, they stuck by they stuck by the ad. I think that was a mistake. I think so too. And it's On many on many levels. yeah. E even on a human level, I think involving someone's family like that. in especially in a political attack ad and especially with Amy A Amy Acton's past with her stepfather and her mother, it it was d absolutely disgusting in my opinion. Well here we go again. years ago in politics it was very commonly said you can attack me all you want. Do not attack my family. I think there's nothing off limits at this point, in politics. It's like i if if if you have a wayward uncle from Alaska, I mean it's going to be it's going to be brought up and I I just think that you cannot be responsible for every wayward uncle or cousin or or whatever you have. But I think that nothing's off limits. Yeah, speaking of Alaska, let's see how that race is going on right now though. Like like what are they what are they polling at? Hold on one second, spare with me for a little bit. Let's see what are the other poll like what does Quinnipac have for Alaska? Hold on. Just bear with me for a little bit. Well, Alaska, if I can fill in. Yes. Alaska has a very strange situation. You have Senator Dan Sullivan, a Republican incumbent, and you have someone else named Dan Sullivan, who is also a candidate in that race. You have two Dan Sullivans. by the way, th this thing of having two people with the s almost the same name, it's happened before. and I and I I don't know what kind of bearing that has. You know, something else to watch, I don't know if this is true in Alaska, but it's true in many other states, including Mississippi, is that you have independents running, you have libertarians running, and when you have these minor candidates running, they may get two or three percent of the vote, but that two or three percent can be the difference. Libertarian candidates tend to draw voters who are more oriented to the Republican Party. Other independents may draw Democratic votes based on who they are. But when you have these close things, close races, these lines of other independent candidates. can very much influence the election. don't forget the role that Ralph Nader played in two thousand, where George Bush beat Al Gore by a very close margin in Florida. And it was the Ralph Nader votes as a third party candidate. That's black that's that made the difference. And most people historically agree that the Ralph Nader voter was predominantly a Democrat. So Yes, third parties do play a role. and people have to understand that when they go into that booth and it's really not always I I would never say don't vote for an independent candidate. most people today or a l or a plurality of voters are independent, but The reality remains that we are a two-party country and that one of the other most times there are exceptions, but most times the Republican or the Democrat will win. So perhaps as election day gets closer, many of those people will then decide that they like the independent candidate, but they will vote for the lesser of the evils among the two that are the major parties. You think that was kind of like the case with the the the mayor election in twenty twenty five? You had Andrew Cuomo the independent and then you had Curtis with who was the Republican nominee and Even though the the Republicans don't have any power or or anything in in New York City, it's largely usually the general election by then is a formality. But essentially you had Mamdani and Cuomo, and then you just saw all like the I guess the more conservative voters just kind of like build a coalition with the more liberal or s centrist democrats and tried to get Andrew Cuomo to beat Mamdani. They didn't necessarily have to like him but they're like, okay, I would rather prefer it him over Mamdani. Well I think in that situation, the way it turned out, I cannot say that Curtis Sleewa was a spoiler because Mes Mr. Mandani got fif over fifty percent of the vote. If he had gotten less than fifty percent of the vote, I think many people would have felt that Sleewa was a spoiler. But he did get more than fifty percent. Not by much, but he got more fifty point three percent. Yeah, so he got a majority of the vote. Yeah. And for the Alaska Senate winner right now they're Mary Mary Paltola s she is at a seventy three point eight percent to win that this Senate seed right now over Dan Sullivan. These markets are are great. I I I think that Alaska will d will go down to the end. I I think this will be one of the states that will the the counting will go down to the end. I think it will be very close. It's a usually Republican state. What what is your thoughts on prediction markets that are o open prediction markets that have been dominating electoral politics right now? No. Polls predict the outcome. polls, however, all have a margin of error. So if they give you a poll that shows one candidate forty eight, the other candidate forty-five, there's a margin of error of four percent. Well there's really no winner. There's a a poll that shows one person ahead, but the there's a margin of error. I think many of these prediction markets also have margins of error. yeah of course. And and I don't know how many people are are honest when they Answer a pollster's question. I don't know how many of them, and I think it's important when you look at a poll. Are they polling registered voters or are they polling most likely voters? I think that's very important. I think what's also important is the size of the sample. When was the poll taken? Certainly the polls in the Ohio governor race are different today than they were five days ago. events often dictate what polls will show. So I the only as as elected officials will o often say, the only poll that counts is election day. Fair enough. I mean that's when you actually learn who the winner i is. Yes, yes, yes. Cause I I remember in my previous conversations with with many people who also joined the podcast on on open prediction markets on how are they like on it for elections and how how do they compare compared to regular polling. It's largely about like who puts more money on the line. And because I guess like money's an actual money's the collateral here, you see that if people are putting real money on who they think is more likely going to win. So there's a lot less bias on it. But then also Who's also putting the money in? Is it a true insider who knows what's going on? Or is it a sucker who's just trying to win some easy cash? And then some pe there's also speculation that people might be pumping in money to make it look more favorable towards one candidate over another. Yes. That is also a factor that should be considered in it in my opinion. And people who give money to political campaigns often want to give money to the winner. yeah. And know, somebody who's way behind has a more difficult time raising money. But I will say, as much as we see a lot of millionaires and billionaires giving money to candidates, which we we see this year, money is not the only factor in determining who wins. issues determine it. Our turnout determines it. Money helps. You need money. There's no doubt it helps. But I think you're going to see many races where millions upon millions were spent and the candidate still loses. And that will be interesting. That will be the morning after conversation. That is like the Ohio governor's race right now. Vivek has spent about thirty two million dollars of his own campaign of his own personal money and about altogether more than a hundred and thirty million dollars in that race. And Elon Musk has been spending a lot of money in that race too. I think the Jeff Yas, George Soros and Elon Musk are the top three spenders in this year's midterms, with over hundreds of millions of dollars being poured into races right now. Well, you know what millionaires say, especially a millionaire who runs for office, many millionaires run for office. You know what they say? I'm spending my own money. I'm not taking money from lobbyists, I'm not taking money from special interest, I don't owe anyone anything. I'm taking my own money and I'm spending it on myself. So They give you that explanation that they are beholden to no one, where other candidates have to take money from corporations, rich people, influential companies, and the feeling is that they will then be beholden. Now, those people will tell you, we do everything on the merits. That's what they will say. Whether that's true or not, you know. make a judgment as once they take office. I mean we also did have Michael Bloomberg drop about millions of dollars into into the can into the midterms as well. Yes. Yeah. I think it's funny when a lot of people's day say we can't have billionaires running into like like being into a getting involved in our elections unless it's my own party. Well both And you say that you hear that on both the Democrats and the Republican side. Well that's what I get a kick when I see Bernie Sanders running around saying that he he's again he wants to take money out of no, the the y you'll get the Democrats are getting the money too, and the Republicans are they're all getting millionaires' money. I'm sure that they're not refusing these these allocations, okay. If someone's donating ten million dollars to your campaign, you're not gonna say no. I I I mean candidates will find a way to spend it, trust me. They'll find a way to spend it. They might publicly rebuke it, but then they'll say, hey, just donate that get give it to like don't to whatever third party channels or whatever and then make funnel it through that way. They have a pack, they have different vehicles, independent expenditures. But don't forget also some of the media markets especially especially are very expensive. The New York media market. I I mean these media markets are very expensive where you may not need as much money as you would in a in a Montana or things like that. So campaigns today are very expensive. And the more you spend and the more your opponent spends, it it drives more spending. It drives more spending and you've got to get money to fuel your campaign. Especially in a s in a state like New York where we are now. I think if you're running a congressional campaign, if you don't have it. least a million dollars in the bank, then what are you doing? Don't run. Like you have to have a million dollars or don't run and a million dollars is conservative. No, you have to have a million to run a congressional a congressional district has seven hundred thousand people. And forget it. In New York, the media market, whatever, you want to do mailings, you want to do outreach on the streets, you wanna do a get out the vote operation. You gotta pay staffers. You have to pay staffers, you have to often pay to get your petitions. So this is not an inexpensive proposition. So you're right, running for the house is is is expensive. Running for even local office is expensive as well. Yes. Well the the the other offices like the assembly I think maybe has a hundred and ten thousand city council a hundred and thirty thousand it's a it's it's smaller, it's a smaller district. And then don't don't forget, in New York City And now New York State, we have a matching funds program. So there is a program that incentivizes smaller contributions for city council, state assembly, and state senate for those offices. And also governor, controller, attorney general. So we do have a state and city matching funds program. On the federal level, there's no such program. And many incumbent elected officials on the federal level. probably don't want that program because they don't want their opposition getting that matching money. the House of Representatives is about incumbency, seniority, and they don't want opposition getting matching money? What? No. That's not something they would want, and that isn't that is not gonna happen. I get a laugh out of these people running for the House of Representatives. we favor term limits, and they're running in these states in the Midwest where it's very popular. Where for term limits? Hello. Congress is n Newt Gingrich, if you remember, his contract with America back in the nineties, he pledged term limits. Have you seen term limits in Washington? No. I haven't either. There are no term limits because they will not term limit themselves. At least Bernie Sanders was very honest when he says, No, I'm not for term limits. It's unconstitutional. There are some people who feel that the only term limit is when the person votes you out of office. That's what he says. Bernie Sanders is there a long time. So you know, but The the only way we got term limits in New York City is because people went to the polls and voted in a referendum for term limits. I don't think any legislator will ever vote to term limit themselves. And that's why we don't have term limits in New York State or in the federal government. Now, some states here and there have term limits around the country, but Here getting s legislators to limit themselves is not an easy proposition. I mean you d you definitely see a lot term limits on the governor level for a lot of states. Yes, a lot of states have I believe Virginia and you can correct me if I'm wrong on this, you can't run like back to back terms. Right. Like you serve one term. Virginia one term and then you have to sit out four years. Yes. Then you can come back. I think Alabama has term limits. Th there are a couple of states that have term limits. I think Michigan. I think that's why G Gretchen Whitmer is not running again. Speaking of speaking of the Sen Michigan, the Senate race is actually getting quite controversial. How do you see that that one going right? I cannot predict Mich Michigan. I don't know what's in people's minds when they vote. I I think Michigan has not elected a Republican senator in years. The last Republican senator was a guy named Spencer Abraham, who was there like in the nineties. Although they're a swing state in presidential elections, not in the Senate so so much. So but I I think this is gonna go down to the wire. I think that's one of I think that's one of the the seats that will be v very, very close, hard to predict. Yeah, they had a very tough Democratic primary as well, where I think Abdul El Sayyid only won by one point. Very close. On and the polls were wrong in that race. The polls said that he was going to win significantly. And there that's where the polls were wrong. That's one of the races where I have to say that that was the case. Mm-hmm. There's a few more there's the South Carolina, s s Senate seat. Lindsay Lindsey Graham's sister, she's at around an eighty percent chance to win right now on on Calchy. Well if she doesn't win the Republicans can hang it up. This is South Carolina. This is a very Republican state. She's had some pitfalls, but I I I they if they can't win South Carolina, Mississippi There's a Senate race there that they say is the gap is closing. Florida, where the Democratic candidate is struggling, but if those states go to the Democratic Party, that would that would indicate a a a wave, in in my opinion. Yeah. Iowa and Ohio are are are also being very competitive on the Senate level. Yes. Yeah, I think r right now, well we'll we'll see how th those ones go on. I know right now the Henson right now is at a fifty nine percent chance to win and Ohio is right now Brown is the is favorite. I I know he was the previous senator for quite some time and Yes. I heard some rumors that they're banking on like a lot people still thinking that he's running for re election 'cause he's just been there for some time. He's like, he's running again? Yeah, I'll vote for him. Yes. And there are people like that, by the way. There are people who may not have been paying attention for the last six years that he's out of office and they may say, I'm voting for Brown. I I always vote for Brown. They're like, I know who he is. Of course. I just haven't seen him seen him on the ballot in a minute, but he's running again. I'll I'll I'll I'll vote for him. Yes, yes. And I don't doubt it. I don't doubt it. Not everyone is so attentive to politics. Many people are not. you and I follow this and we're we're we're observers and and and we're interested in this, but some people don't pay as much attention and I think that some politicians count on that. They know that not everyone's paying attention. We are excited spectators. Yes. How does it feel to be a spectator now now that you're out of office? I love it. I love criticizing everyone else. It's just it's a wonderful thing. I w it's a you know th I think the only job that would be well that would be similar to what mu to my obs obs obs observatory status would be public advocate of New York City. Public advocate of New York City is a great job because you get the the you have you don't have a lot of responsibility under the city charter, but you can criticize everybody and say this should have been done and that should have been done. I I'm I'm I'm an I enjoy being an observer and I enjoy I I I enjoy with the knowledge I have, I I think that I I can judge situations maybe a little differently than people who may not have had the experience I've had. What's your thoughts on the current city charter right now? Well we have revisions. Again. Yes. I'm not happy proposals. I'm not happy with the entire process and I'm going to be voting no on the propositions. this I was on the city council I was on the Charter Revision Commission of 2019. That commission had representatives of the mayor, the city council, the borough presidents, the controller, and the public advocate. I was an appointee of the Bronx Borough President at that time, Ruben Diaz Jr. And we determined that we wanted to put forth ranked choice voting, which has become a reality. We did months of public education on ranked choice voting. We wanted voters to go to the I saw your videos on it. You did, right? I did. I did videos. I was out there. We all did. We had staff. We had commission members educating. Cutie also had your your videos on with a lot of other professors. Yes. We had forums and we talked about ranked choice voting. We did a lot of outreach. But we had a commission that was representative of multiple elected officials. What we have in the past year under Eric Adams and now under this mayor, we have charter revision commissions appointed solely by the mayor with no other input from the other elected officials. So these people on these commissions do as the mayor wants them to do. And they put forth referendums with very little discussion. This time These referendums on the ballot in November will reduce community input into so much that happens in their local community, into the the the bus routes, into the bicycle paths, into the sidewalk cafes. It's going to shorten the process of community input or modify what inputs are given as a part of the approval process. Totally against everything I've been for in my entire life. The community boards, and I was a community board district manager for 26 years before I became a city council member. The community boards are little city halls. That's how I always envision them. And they are advisory in everything they do. So why are we trying to circumvent or minimize the input of a board that gives local people input? And is truly advisory at the end of the day, anyway. It it they they say they want government to move faster. That's what this they want to get rid of red tape. They want to get rid of well, get rid of red tape that the city agencies impose. The red tape is not at a community board level. Community boards are given 60 days, 30 days. They have a clock on land use, a clock on all these improvements. They're given a clock. The bureaucracy is in the city agencies. And that's where the mayor can cut bureaucracy, okay? But to say that we have to limit the input of the council, limit the input of local people into their own neighborhoods, very parochial matters. I don't think it matters to the people down in in on the east side of Manhattan where a bus route goes in Throgsneck, New York. But you know what? It matters to people in Throgsneck, New York. That's why we have local community boards. That's why. I was a city council member. And I chaired the Transportation Committee, and we put into law many, many protections for local neighborhoods that gave them the right to weigh in. Now we're going in the reverse direction. And I I I do think that the powers that be now, under Mayor Adams and others, not just this mayor, they take it for granted that all these approved once you put it on the referendum. People will not know too much about it and they will vote yes. And you know, they may be right. People tend to vote yes on these things, and they have now all social media is gonna come out. This will shorten the city bureaucracy, which we're all in favor of. Look at the fine print, my friends. And the fine print means less input, different process. Look at the fine print. Councilmember Phil Wong at Community Board Five was telling everyone to vote no on all proposals. I'm glad. I'm voting no myself. I I know. But everyone wants to when when they see those proposals, they all at least from what I see online, they're always say, vote yes on all proposals. It's good for the to speed up bureaucracy, cut through the red tape and help out the mayor. Do we need a referendum to speed up bureaucracy? This is the first I've heard of that. I I don't think we govern by referendum. we are a representative democracy in this country, and in a representative democracy our representatives who we elect can shorten the bureaucracy. And that's the way that should work. Do you do you think that this people are gonna vote yes on all of them and then just pass it? Unfortunately that's what happened last time. That's what that's what that that's is what happens with charter amendments, unfortunately. Most of them tend to pass. Most of them tend to pass. I tend to vote a little bit more conservative when it comes to the like the the proposals that people do. I'm usually a bit more skeptical of all of it, so at least for me, I usually I like to read what's on the back of the ballot and see what goes on and I usually vote no on on largely everything. And the print is so small and people are not going to realise the impact because there's not been the outreach that that that there should have been all along. We we're being told right now, today's the first early day of voting. I will tell you if you go to a polling place and ask people what these referendums do, they will not know today. And this is the first day of early voting. Funny enough, I remember back when ranked choice voting came out and they were making a whole bunch CUNY was putting out a bunch of videos on it. And that's where I saw you for the first time. I was a s I was a student at Queens College. I just got there and they were pushing out like r rank choice voting and Because I think there was the the mayor's election for twenty twenty one was about to happen like right at right after COVID. And that's where I saw you the first time on those videos. We had public hearings. Hundreds of people showed up. These charter revision commissions lately, maybe six people show up. Nobody knows where the hearing is or when, but they they have it to cover their rear ends, you know, they have to have hearings. We had hundreds of people, we we did a lot of work because rank choice voting is such a crucial change for the city of New York and affects our our voting system. But what they what they're doing now, it may seem in it may seem insignificant. It's not insignificant. Believe me, this is this is slowly reducing local input on matters affecting our everyday lives. That's one thing about local go local politics is that you like how you said before, you could you you would never you're most likely never gonna meet Donald Trump or Barack Obama or Joe Biden or Kamala Harris. But you can always meet your local New York City Council member, state assembly member, state senate. You can just walk into their offices at any time during the week and they'll have to answer you. Yes. And I was an elected official. My neighborhood should hold me accountable. If I'm their councilman and we don't get good results, we don't get good improvements, hold me accountable. You know, I tell my students, they say, the MTA. They're always complaining about the MTA. The buses don't come, the trains don't come. And you know what my question is? Who's in charge of the MTA? Who runs the MTA? My students don't know. But the reality is that the MTA has a board of directors with appointments from the governor and the mayor. No one knows. So when the MTA does not work well, who do you hold accountable? It should be whoever the governor is and whoever the mayor is. But they have people on there and no one knows who they are. So therefore, who do you actually hold accountable? Some faceless bureaucrat who's on a board? You know, it it's very it's very frustrating. I somehow think that over the years, because the MTA was created back when, in the the 80s or 70s, I kind of think that that was done on purpose. The elected officials at that time probably did not want to be held accountable for when the buses don't come and the trains don't go. So kind of just keep people in the dark. Yes. I mean, who likes the MTA? Nobody likes the MTA. They complain about everything. The trains, the buses, the air conditioning doesn't work, the nobody's paying their fare. There's always going to be complaints. So the so there's this buffer, the MTA. and there are many bureaucracies like that. So if If our politicians want to cut the bureaucracy, I can give them a lot of ideas about how to cut the bureaucracy. But don't don't eliminate level level one, which is the the local neighborhoods, that have advisory power. Advisory power. That's what they're taking away. Advisory power. They're reducing the time you can give your advice. They're telling you we will not consider your advice on these issues because we want to move things through. Speaking of I guess keeping people in the dark, a lot of people have been talking about open primaries and I be I believe it's about over like about one third of registered voters in New York City and New York State are independent voters. So with most of these elections largely happening on a in a largely democratic area or in like whatever pockets that are like largely Republican in the state. Most of them are closed off to literally everyone else. And do you think that we should open up primaries to independents? Yes. How I think it's long overdue. I think that we should not be disenfranchising voters. By the time we vote in November in the city of New York, the election is over in ninety five percent of the cases. Whoever wins the Democratic primary will win in November. We are a seven to one democratic city. So whoever wins the primary in November, in in in June rather, will win in November. But that primary that selected that person is not open to independence or other voters. It's only open to registered Democrats to vote. So we should be understanding that we have a responsibility not to disenfranchise voters. That's the current situation. Other states are moving toward open primaries. Pennsylvania now is moving in that direction. Other states, most states in this country have open primaries. New York, of course, is behind the eight ball. And I think that people want to discuss this. I think we have an obligation to im to involve as many voters as we can from day one in the electoral process. I know that's one thing that Andrew Yang has also been bringing up a lot, especially with the forward party that that he created. Now I'm not the biggest fan of I guess like people trying to make a a thir a third party, but I do think that he brought up a lot of interesting points and that closed off primaries are disenfranchising voters because I don't think that you necessarily should have to show complete loyalty to one party and you always have to be a registered person of that party to be able to part partake in that election. Right. I think that keeping independence out of out of primaries, you're largely just make making sure that they just don't vote in that and it o only becomes to a select amount of people who get to decide who the election is. And usually by that the time the primary is done, the person who won that primary is already gonna be in office. The general election at that point is a formality. And many of our young people, students, young people are registered in no party. Yeah. And they reflect also the if you look at the numbers, who is the independent voter in New York, it reflects the diversity of our city. So the reason to keep people out of a primary, th that reason does not resonate with me at at this point. Whether it's w maybe well, I mean the Republicans right now are in power, but then they might think that, the Democrats are a bit too far to the left. Or if the Democrats are the ones in power, they'll say, I don't like the Republicans, they might I think they're kind of closed off and not don't represent my values. But it but having open primaries encourages more people to vote, and that's one thing that I think we should have. Yeah. And I also think that people are turned off with politics. So how do we involve them more? At least give them the right to vote. I think also especially immigrants that come into the i in in I mean, we have a city full of immigrants. And when they register to vote to vote, most of them, in my opinion, are all independent. I don't think they d they are enthusiastic to declare an allegiance to one party or the other. Right. I I I think it would help address the f the fact that many people are turned off to politics today. Many people are turned off. Many people see that this is a quest for power and it they kind of feel a a hoax on the Republicans and a hoax on the Democrats. Because both parties want power and they seem to be doing anything they can to get power. And now here as an independent voter, many of those independent voters are turned off with the two parties. But we tell them you can only go vote in November when the result is already predetermined. That's what we're telling them. Yeah. Do you do you think that we're looking at a Democrat sweep in this mid midterm's coming up? A sweep meaning that they the the Democrats get the House and the Senate? Yes. Well, the house for sh the house for sure I'll put my neck on the line, I think that you're going to see a d a democratic Senate. if I'm wrong, please don't it's okay. We got our predictions, guys. I I give you my prediction. I I think that there's too many close races. And I think that when you have a national situation that shows dissatisfaction with the status quo, I think that that favors the party out of power. We got our predictions, guys. Thank you. Thank you. Also I did want to get one your your thoughts on the on the debates that went on for the governor and and the attorney general. What was your thoughts on how it went? Well, I guess for New York at least. I know for New York I don't think most people saw them. I think that they were it was a limited audience. I think we should have more than just one debate for those offices. we have s other states have several debates. I think that every candidate made their points. I don't know. I don't think it's going to be that impactful. I I don't think that the debates will be too impactful. Yeah, 'cause I I don't think everyone is necessarily all like eyes glued on New York one. No, and then it it it was only one debate each and and and I I happened to catch watch most of the three debates, controller debate also with Tom Dinapoli and I I think that the Democrats are going to win in New York and I didn't show Tom Dinapley the first pod podcast episode that we that we did. did you? Yeah. He's a if I can say this he's a good guy. He's a good guy, and I know him for years. And well of course I know Tish James and I know Kathy Hokel, and I I think all of them are fine public servants. Okay. I I've never met Mr. Blakeman or the other candidates on the Republican side, but I I I know the Democrats. I've met I I think this is the first time I can say I've now met all six candidates who are running. really? I did. Okay. I I th I think it my my interactions with them were all largely all all pleasant. I I I did dumbtell t I when I when I saw Tish James, I saw I saw and I mentioned you. So that that that was able to help me break the ice a little bit. I met Saritha a while back way before she ran for ran for office r ran for attorney general because I was in I was interested in her background as as she is the current well well well she was the she was the former chief of staff to the DEA and she had a large history of being a prosecutor and was involved in a lot of cases that dealt with cybercrime and I have come from a cybersecurity background so that was one thing that we that we talked on a lot. Kathy Hochle Bruce Blakeman, my interactions were largely very, very limited. Tom Dinapley, I you you also came in clutch with the with with being able to break the ice with that one. So that one was funny. I remember when you made that that Instagram post where you endorsed Tom Di Napoli. Yes, and I really don't do it you know, I re but he's a friend. But I Tisha's a friend. I consider her a friend. she sat right behind me in the council. So we served together in the council, and Kathy Hochel Has been I've been with Kathy Holcomb on several occasions. 'Cause he a he had a primary this this year earlier and I went up to him and I said I voted for you because you had Jimmy Vaca's total and swift and swift and complete endorsement. He must have gotten a kick out of that. he he was laughing like crazy. We that that we had a funny con a fun conversation from that one. Jose Hernandez he's very well educated, but the way how I say it, he's a guy who's made a lot of money and is just giving his I guess He's giving a d a dabble in politics because he's made all of his money, he's doing what what he's now trying something new. That that that's how I largely see it. Well, there's no doubt that running as a Republican in New York State is daunting. and this is an especially daunting yeah Envy them, but I don't envy them. So well, thank you again for coming on the podcast. Thank you. It was an honor having you on. Thank you again. Thank you for having me. you are now everyone loved your first episode, and I hope we can do more in the future. I hope they like this one too. I don't know. I think they will. I think they will. Give me the ratings when they come out. Of course, of course. Of course. Thank you again for coming. Thank you, Moses. Nice seeing you again.