Latest / Change My Relationship / All or Nothing Thinking Causes Problems in Your Life and Relationships
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to an audio recording
- 0:02by Change My Relationship, featuring licensed marriage
- 0:05and family therapist and author Karla Downing.
- 0:08These audios are designed to provide you
- 0:10with practical solutions based on biblical truths
- 0:13for all your relationships.
- 0:18I’m gonna talk to you about all or nothing.
- 0:20Thinking.
- 0:21This is often called black and white thinking.
- 0:24And I know you've had people that have done it with you.
- 0:27We all do it sometimes.
- 0:28Oh, that is a almost all or nothing.
- 0:32We all do it. That might be, might.
- 0:34Maybe there's somebody out
- 0:35here, out there who doesn't use black and white thinking. So.
- 0:40See how easy it is to say that.
- 0:42So how do you think about things?
- 0:46The thoughts that run through your mind.
- 0:47And they are all the time continual.
- 0:50Just when you get off this video, think.
- 0:53Pay attention to what you're thinking,
- 0:55the thoughts that run through your mind
- 0:56for even 15 minutes, and you'll be surprised how busy
- 1:00your mind is.
- 1:01So thoughts that run through your mind
- 1:03and they affect you.
- 1:05They affect how you feel.
- 1:07They affect how you see the world.
- 1:08They affect how you see other people.
- 1:10They affect whether or not you attempt to make changes,
- 1:14whether you make a decision
- 1:16to go do something, your thoughts have power.
- 1:20And the good thing is that you can change your thoughts,
- 1:25and changing your thoughts
- 1:26can actually change your life, because it can
- 1:29change your feelings and it can change your behavior.
- 1:31Just changing your thought about something will change
- 1:35how you feel about it,
- 1:36and then that can change what you want to do about it.
- 1:39So all or nothing thinking describes extremes.
- 1:44Extreme opposites, black and white.
- 1:48So it's both ends of the spectrum.
- 1:52Example of this is when somebody says you're always late.
- 1:57Now something that is in the middle is you're often late.
- 2:03You're late today or you're.
- 2:07That actually would be true if the person was late that day.
- 2:10But to say you're always late, the person can just come back
- 2:13and go, no, I'm not.
- 2:14I was on time last week.
- 2:18I was on time a month ago.
- 2:20I was on time to church this morning.
- 2:23I mean, it's just easily blown out of the water.
- 2:26So it's just kind of a statement that people will use
- 2:30to make a point that is in their favor.
- 2:34That is a point that is like to win an argument,
- 2:37to accuse somebody, to let them know how aggravated they are.
- 2:41But it's it's a it's an extreme and never
- 2:46is all also one of those you're never happy.
- 2:50You are never on my side.
- 2:52You never agree with me.
- 2:54You never clean your room.
- 2:56You never come home.
- 2:57When you say you're going to come home,
- 2:59all the person has to do is think, yeah, except I
- 3:05did it
- 3:05yesterday and your arguments blown out of the water.
- 3:08But it's just a it's not a good way
- 3:11to communicate what is going on.
- 3:14It's not a a way to look at things in a more balanced.
- 3:19We want to look for balance.
- 3:21Here's another way that people do this in the relationship
- 3:25they give, like you and someone else,
- 3:28all of the blame, but they take none of the credit.
- 3:32So it's like it's your fault for everything that goes wrong.
- 3:36But I'm not going to give you
- 3:37any credit for anything that goes right.
- 3:40That's not fair, right?
- 3:42So if
- 3:42I'm going to give you the blame for something
- 3:45when you don't make a good choice,
- 3:46then I got to give you the credit.
- 3:47When you make a
- 3:49when you do make a good choice, I can't just always blame
- 3:52you and always accuse you of doing the wrong thing.
- 3:55And what about passive aggressive
- 3:57people do this. They give you
- 3:58all of the responsibility, but none of the power.
- 4:02So it's basically you're responsible for
- 4:05everything that goes wrong,
- 4:06but you don't really have the power to make the decisions.
- 4:09But when they default to whatever it is
- 4:12that I allow to happen or cause you to have to choose,
- 4:16then I'm going to blame you and give you the responsibility.
- 4:19So all the responsibility, none of the power.
- 4:23And that's kind of all or nothing you get.
- 4:25You don't get responsibility
- 4:27for the things that you do decide or do choose to do,
- 4:31but you even get blamed for the things that I choose to do.
- 4:36And yet you don't ever.
- 4:38You don't have the power to make decisions, give
- 4:41somebody all the work, but none of them want money.
- 4:44So you do a garage sale and the person does all the work
- 4:48to set it up, all the work to sort everything out.
- 4:51And yet you keep all the money because it's your stuff.
- 4:55I mean, these
- 4:55these are just kind of fun examples to
- 4:57think about how you look at it's kind of this, these extremes,
- 5:01and then
- 5:02you make all of the decisions but take none
- 5:05of the responsibility.
- 5:06So maybe your husband or a parent
- 5:11makes all the decisions and yet they're never wrong.
- 5:15They they still blame someone else.
- 5:17And then in relationships often we see all of somebody's
- 5:21faults.
- 5:21We see
- 5:21everything bad about them, but we don't see anything good.
- 5:25They're all all bad or
- 5:29and nothing good, or somebody’s all good and nothing bad.
- 5:33Now oftentimes we do that out of defensiveness
- 5:36with ourselves, that because we are so fearful
- 5:40of having something bad about us, or admitting a fault,
- 5:43or having to admit that we did something that that was wrong
- 5:50or caused a problem, and we're it's so hard
- 5:53for us to admit that because when we do, we feel all bad.
- 5:57A healthy way is to be to say, yeah, I, I messed up.
- 6:01These are the responses.
- 6:03This is a responsibility
- 6:04I have for this relationship, for these relationship problems.
- 6:08This is my part being able to see that
- 6:10but then also see but I also did some good things
- 6:13and I'm not responsible for all of the problems.
- 6:16And then
- 6:16let give the other person the responsibility for their part,
- 6:21but not see that person as all bad and myself
- 6:25is all good, or see myself as all bad,
- 6:27and the other person is all good.
- 6:28This is an abnormal, unhealthy, I should say abnormal.
- 6:34It's actually pretty normal for a lot of people to do that
- 6:37that haven't worked on themselves,
- 6:39but it is a very unhealthy way of looking at yourself
- 6:43and admitting your faults, because we all have them.
- 6:48You can see yourself as always, right?
- 6:51And others is always wrong. It's not true.
- 6:53That's that's all or nothing thinking.
- 6:56And there are so many difficult to get along with people
- 6:58that see themselves as always right and you as always wrong.
- 7:03And having a conversation with them is painful
- 7:06and you know you're not going to get anywhere.
- 7:08That is very unhealthy.
- 7:10It is. Here's another all or nothing
- 7:13that it is impossible for you to always be right.
- 7:17Okay. Jesus was always right.
- 7:21That's the only person that's always been right.
- 7:24It's impossible.
- 7:26So taking that stance is an extreme.
- 7:28It polarizes the relationship.
- 7:30It causes there to not be good conversation,
- 7:34to not be good resolve, to not be able to
- 7:39work on the things and discuss what needs to be discussed.
- 7:43You could always see someone as someone who makes
- 7:47bad decisions and say to them, everything you do is wrong.
- 7:51Everything falls apart.
- 7:53Every decision is no good.
- 7:57That's not true.
- 7:59There's no way that that person
- 8:02makes every decision poorly in their entire life.
- 8:07No way.
- 8:08This is very discouraging to say to somebody.
- 8:11It's very hard,
- 8:12especially when the person like your parent or your spouse
- 8:16says this to you and that's their opinion of you.
- 8:19It can make people want to give up.
- 8:21It can make people feel like, forget it.
- 8:23I'm just no good. I'm never going to succeed.
- 8:26These kind of messages to you as a child will set you up
- 8:31to continue criticizing yourself in the same way as an adult,
- 8:35which means you're going to be have low self-esteem.
- 8:39You're going to keep putting yourself down.
- 8:40You're going to be afraid to start projects and try things.
- 8:44So if you have somebody that has used
- 8:47all or nothing thinking with you,
- 8:49you you want to recognize it as that.
- 8:52You want to recognize that someone is going to the extreme.
- 8:57You don't have to defend yourself by
- 9:01saying, bringing up a time and just starting
- 9:04that back and forth.
- 9:05But you can you can say that's all or nothing.
- 9:09That's not true, that I do that all the time.
- 9:13Or you could say, you could admit oftentimes
- 9:16when somebody has a criticism where something about
- 9:19it is true,
- 9:20admitting that kind of relaxes the conversation rather than
- 9:24defending yourself, saying, you know, you're right.
- 9:26I was late today.
- 9:29I, I did come late today
- 9:31and I do come late sometimes.
- 9:35Don't defend it. You don't have to go to the.
- 9:38Well, I was on time one time.
- 9:40No, it's like you're right.
- 9:41I'm, I'm, I was late and I apologize for that.
- 9:46And you don't have to explain it
- 9:47or make an excuse for it because you were late
- 9:49and, whether it's traffic
- 9:51or you left late or whatever it was, you were late.
- 9:56So you want to recognize
- 9:57when somebody is doing that, you want to respond to it.
- 10:00If somebody tells you and sticks to it
- 10:03and says something like, you're always wrong, you.
- 10:06Everything you do like messes up.
- 10:09Everything turns out bad.
- 10:11You can say, I don't see myself that way.
- 10:14I don't think that's true.
- 10:16I don't
- 10:19this this didn't turn out right, but I don't see myself as
- 10:23every decision.
- 10:24I see it differently, every decision going bad.
- 10:27Or you can just agree to disagree.
- 10:29Just say I have a different opinion.
- 10:31I. I see things differently than you do.
- 10:34Or you can, like I said,
- 10:38just say that's
- 10:40that's all or nothing and that's never true.
- 10:45Now you want to avoid all or nothing
- 10:47thinking when you're looking at other people
- 10:51to be healthy because
- 10:54you you want to stay balanced in your own life
- 10:57and you want to avoid all or nothing thinking.
- 11:01When you're looking at yourself,
- 11:02you do not need to see yourself as always a failure,
- 11:06always wrong, always rejected, always.
- 11:10And then have these messages about yourself.
- 11:13Or this I'll never succeed. I'll never fail.
- 11:15You need to look at that.
- 11:16They call that a cognitive distortion.
- 11:19Distortion meaning
- 11:20it's a thought distortion, something that is not true.
- 11:24Black or white thinking is an extreme.
- 11:27It is not true.
- 11:29Identify the black and white thinking that you have
- 11:32and replace it with something that is true.
- 11:35I make some decisions that don't turn out well,
- 11:41but I make other decisions that do turn out well.
- 11:44Just because I have failed in this decision
- 11:48or this decision didn't turn out right,
- 11:50doesn't mean every decision that I make or have made is
- 11:54going is wrong.
- 11:55Make sure that you correct that thought
- 11:58so that you can get rid of that thinking you want to have.
- 12:01Thinking that is accurate.
- 12:02Thinking that is healthy.
- 12:05The Ecclesiastes 7:16-18, which was King Solomon
- 12:09when he was trying to figure out what was important about life
- 12:12and getting that right perspective.
- 12:13He says, do not be over righteous, neither be over wise.
- 12:19Why destroy yourself?
- 12:20Do not be over wicked and do not be a fool.
- 12:24Why die before your time?
- 12:25It is good to grasp the one and not let go of the other.
- 12:29Whoever fears God will avoid all extremes.
- 12:32Such just a fun verse to put to that.
- 12:34So watch your black and white
- 12:36thinking and replace it with thinking that is accurate.
- 12:41Thank you for watching. God bless you.
- 12:44Thank you for listening to Change My Relationship.
- 12:47We hope you will subscribe to these podcasts
- 12:49and share them with your friends.
- 12:51Karla would love to hear from you.
- 12:53She welcomes
- 12:54ideas for a future podcast, as well as your feedback
- 12:57on how the podcasts have helped your life and relationships.
- 13:01You can email her at.
- 13:02karla@changemyrelationship.com
- 13:06For more information on
- 13:07Change My Relationship and Karla Downing's ministry,
- 13:10including her books, studies, devotionals, podcasts
- 13:14and YouTube videos visit changemyrelationship.com.