Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Monday, July 8, 2024
Transcript
- 0:25Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network. You
- 0:30are surrounded radio turned on from the studio of w v RC Media and the
- 0:41Metro News Radio Network, the voice of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio
- 0:47show in West Virginia. This this is Metro News Talk Live with Happy Kerchible.
- 0:54Uptivated switch network control from Charles Jared. Bye you, Hoppy. You're
- 1:00on Metro News. Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you by Encovia
- 1:04Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit
- 1:10in covid dot com to learn more. Good morning, Welcome to talk Line
- 1:12on the Metro News Radio Network, all across the great state of West Virginia.
- 1:17Broadcasting from the Encovia Insurance studios. Hoppy Kerchival with you back from a
- 1:21week off. Thank you Dave Wilson for filling in ably last week. A
- 1:25lot of Biden talk coming up this morning, but first let's talk taxes.
- 1:29While I was gone, the governor said, look, with the surplus,
- 1:34the tax rates in West Virginia, which is all which has already been reduced
- 1:38by twenty one and a half percent according to the formula are probably going to
- 1:44be reduced another three or four percent when all the numbers are in, So
- 1:48you would take the current marginal rate and reduce them by three or four percent.
- 1:53Justice has thrown a bit of a curveball in there and says, why
- 1:55don't we tackle on another five percent onto that? So if that happens,
- 2:00you're talking about a rate reduction, a rate reduction of about nine percent of
- 2:06about nine percent off of the current rates, A couple hundred million dollars there
- 2:09that West Virginia taxpayers would say. But the question is can West Virginia afford
- 2:15to do this? Let me bring in House financi Committee Chairman Vernon Chris Republican,
- 2:20Wood County joint us on Metro News Talk one, Vernon, Good morning,
- 2:22Good you talk to you. How are you, sir? Good morning,
- 2:24sir, How are you well? Thank you good to talk with you.
- 2:27Do you support or oppose the Governor's suggestion that, in addition to what
- 2:31will probably be a three or four percent reduction of marginal rates, that you
- 2:36tackle on under five percent reduction. Agree or disagree? Well, I think
- 2:40we need to look at it, definitely. I think it's an option that
- 2:44we need to look at, because in the rural world, when you look
- 2:46at our surrounding states, the state income tax in Pennsylvania is just over three
- 2:53percent. The estate of Ohio where I'm in Pergersburg and we deal with its
- 2:58employees from the state of West or state of Eye as part of our employment
- 3:02situation here in Pergersburg, is at three point seventy five, and they're going
- 3:07to go to three and a half well right now, even with the changes
- 3:13that we are going to see with the automatic reduction and the possibility of looking
- 3:20at for an additional drop, we're going to be at four point five.
- 3:23So we're still in the outside the range in our market conditions for our employees
- 3:30to be able to be competitive with somebody from the living conditions in West Virginia
- 3:37versus Ohio, especially in our area, and for the things that are happening
- 3:42along the High River as we know, and we're and down at below Point
- 3:46Pleasant for instance, and at Ravens would a lot of those employees traditionally have
- 3:51come from the other side of the river, and so their tax base,
- 3:57their salaries are based upon three point seventy five right now, which we'll go
- 4:02to three and a half. So I think it's definitely something we need to
- 4:06look at. He's the governor's goal is that we would have cut our state
- 4:13income tax by thirty percent in the top rates. So I definitely think it's
- 4:20something to explore. But again, we want to make sure that we're,
- 4:25as he said, minding the store. I want to make sure that we
- 4:30do not invade any cash flow problems to be able to pay our bills,
- 4:34because I was there in the late eighties in the early nineties when we couldn't
- 4:40pay the electric bills, and so cash flow and being able to pay my
- 4:45bills and our bills is a state are definitely in the fourth front. Well,
- 4:49it sounds like House Finance Committee Chairman Vernon crisis with us, and I
- 4:54hear the layered response by you, but it sounds like you want to try
- 4:59to get there most definitely okay, but as you also said, again,
- 5:04you have to be concerned about the future. I mean, there's a big
- 5:08surplus, but about half of that eight hundred million has already committed to various
- 5:11spending. Every state agency has says, wow, we you know, we
- 5:15need more money for this, We need more money for that. We have
- 5:18road issues, we have childcare issues, we have infrastructure issues on and on.
- 5:24Plus if you do this and you end up with what amounts to a
- 5:28thirty percent reduction of rates over the last two years, then that's that's forever
- 5:32more, as the governor would say. So you got to think about the
- 5:34out years. And you were there, as you said, when tough time.
- 5:39So how much concern you have about well, okay, we can it's
- 5:42going to bit flushed now. You could cut it now, but what about
- 5:44three years from now or five years from now. By the other thing you
- 5:48got to remember too, is as you've cut rates, revenues continue to grow.
- 5:55And we've seen that with the twenty one and a half percent that are
- 5:59actual reductions in revenues. Was not twenty one and a half percent, it's
- 6:03something very much less than that. So we're actually seeing growth in our revenue
- 6:08for tax for taxes coming from personal income tax. So as you cut you
- 6:14will see additional revenues down the road. Now you may not see it up
- 6:18front. So that's the other problem. The short term that you have here
- 6:24could be a problem, So we need to take a look at that.
- 6:28But when you go to look at the out years, it appears that when
- 6:31you do reductions in taxes that your revenues actually go up. Vernon, do
- 6:36you support the government the government wants to do this now like August September,
- 6:41do you, as the Finance chair and anything like this would have to go
- 6:44through Finance, do you support having a special session to deal with this proposed
- 6:49additional five percent or do you think, well, I better wait till the
- 6:54new administrations in a couple of months and see what they want to do.
- 6:58Now, I think it's proven to it now I do. I think we
- 7:01need along with the other things of the surplus dollars that we continue to have
- 7:06left over that we need to take a look at. We have traditionally looked
- 7:12at those surplus dollars to do one time infrastructure projects. We want to continue
- 7:16to do water and sewer and highways and the internet services that we need to
- 7:23provide to our people so they have access. You know, It's funny that
- 7:28I had a lady in my office two weeks ago from Richie County and they
- 7:33were here to pick up some limestone, and she was telling us about their
- 7:38water problem problems in Richie County. And I'm sitting here and I'm amazed that
- 7:43here we are in the twenty fourth year of the twenty first century, and
- 7:48we still have homes in West Virginia without running water. Now that's just totally
- 7:54uncomfortable, and that we should have running water every home in this state of
- 7:59Way Virginia. Well, you still probably also have some. You still probably
- 8:03have some locations in parts of West Virginia where people are straight piping their sewer
- 8:05into the creek. That's exactly right. And you know, and I know
- 8:11where that most of that is. Yeah, so so having and that's the
- 8:15same thing. So having having said that again, it's about it's about balance.
- 8:20Uh. And you're the financi cheer. You hear all these requests,
- 8:24is you get pulled back the other way then and say, well, you
- 8:26know, gosh, we have all these needs. We better really fix that
- 8:28stuff before we cut taxes another couple of million dollars. But I still think
- 8:35giving back the people their money so they can do what they want to do
- 8:39with it actually increases the economy and we'll and will boost revenues down the ray.
- 8:45So the dollars that we still have left over from the excess, it
- 8:50is still proven to use towards one time infrastructure all right. House Finance Committee
- 8:56Chairman Vernon Chris, Republican, Wood County, Vernon, good to speak with
- 8:58you. Thank you coming on today. Much appreciate it. All right,
- 9:01sir, thank you. Thank you. When we come back on Metronews,
- 9:05talk on John Decker. How long have members of the White House Press Corps
- 9:09been asking about access to this current president? And if there had been more
- 9:15access, would there have been more stories, more attention to Biden's apparent cognitive
- 9:22decline prior to the debate. We'll be right back. In today's fast paced
- 9:24world, staying ahead in business means staying on top of technology, but managing
- 9:30it infrastructure can be overwhelming. That's where city net comes in. Our team
- 9:33of experts takes the hassle out of it so you can focus on what you
- 9:37do best, running and growing your business. From network management, cybersecurity,
- 9:43remote work solutions, and more, We've got you covered. Visit us at
- 9:46citynet dot net today. City net connects, protects, and perfects. We
- 9:56are there for you, do care for you. The the whole plan.
- 10:01The health plan is still growing, giving you a large network of doctors,
- 10:05friendly and helpful customer service representatives, and competitive flexible pricing plans that meet your
- 10:09needs. Log on to health plan dot org for more information for you to
- 10:16care for you and plan. We are here. Winning the lottery would be
- 10:26the start of my race dream. Hitting the open road at top speeds,
- 10:28hugging turns. It's intense. What are you dreaming of racing again? Not
- 10:39dreaming? I'm practicing and I'm checking my tickets. It's a mower, It's
- 10:45a dream. West Virginia Lottery. What if it could happen to you?
- 10:52Please play responsively. You're listening to talk Line on Metro News. The Voice
- 10:56of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain state's only hook and bullet
- 11:03radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state.
- 11:09Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for
- 11:13more than twenty five years. I shot him. He ran over to the
- 11:16edge of the field. He made it about five ten yards out of the
- 11:20edge of the field and fell over there. Whether it's hunting and fishing news
- 11:24or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. He stuck his
- 11:28head through the blind into where you were. Yeah, Yeah, well,
- 11:33he had jumped, he leaked over the blonde. Oh gosh, yeah,
- 11:37he had. His whole body was in the air for a couple of seconds
- 11:41and is the only man that landed in the blind was of course his head
- 11:45in his front leg. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven
- 11:50oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and
- 11:52a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning
- 11:56on Metro News the Voice of West Virginia. Hey everybody, it's Tony Courritty.
- 12:01I'm Greg Hunter and I'm Brad Howe, and we invite you to join
- 12:05us Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro News radio network. It's the
- 12:09city Nets Statewide sports Line. We talk West Virginia University football, basketball,
- 12:15baseball, you name it. If it's got anything to do with the Golden
- 12:18Blue, we're on it. And don't forget the text line available every night.
- 12:22So we invite you to join us. The Senator coach Hunter and me
- 12:24Tony Coritti. It's the city Net state wide sports Line on Metro News News
- 12:30in the Mountain State. Happens quick and for decades, you have depended on
- 12:33Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep
- 12:39your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become a Metro
- 12:43News hawk by texting News to three five sixty five to one. If you
- 12:46take a picture or video of what you see, submit that as well.
- 12:50Text the word news to three five sixty five one to submit your tip or
- 12:54story. Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive. Metro News
- 13:13Talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you by Incoca Insurance, encircling you
- 13:18with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in Coca dot com
- 13:22to learn more broadcasting from me and COVID Insurance Studios. One of the observations
- 13:26since the debate has been, well, wait a minute, this has been
- 13:30going on for a while, this cognitive decline, and where it was the
- 13:35White House Press Corps, those who cover Biden and was this not obvious?
- 13:39Were they not reporting on it? And John Decker is a senior editor in
- 13:43White House correspondent for Great Television in West Virginia's WSAZWTAPWDTV and WVVA has covered presents
- 13:50for many years, and he sent me a clip. This is from April
- 13:54twenty twenty three. This is more than a year ago where Decker and others
- 13:58in the press corps we're raising questions about Biden's availability to take questions. And
- 14:05this is Decker's exchange with Carin Jean Pierre, the White House Press Secretary,
- 14:09runs about two minutes. Let's listen. The second question has to do with
- 14:13the lack of a press conference during the president's upcoming trip and the lack of
- 14:16press conference that we see in general from this White House. I represent a
- 14:22news organization that owns one hundred and thirteen television stations and a question that I'm
- 14:26often asked and I don't know the answer to. So I'll ask you that
- 14:30question. Is the administration trying to protect the president from our questions? Please?
- 14:37I answer absolutely not, absolutely not. The lack of any interaction in
- 14:41a formal setting to have a press conference, I mean, the president takes
- 14:46shouty questions. I understand, John, I understand. I understand. I
- 14:50have dealt with this question about three times already. I understand it is it
- 14:54is the job of you all to ask this question to me totally get that,
- 14:58and that's not a problem at all. But certainly the president many times
- 15:05has stood in front of all of you has taken questions on his own because
- 15:11he wanted to see what was all on your minds. He wanted to see
- 15:15what the questions you all were going to ask him, and he wanted to
- 15:16answer them directly. That has happened multiple times, many times during this administration,
- 15:22and that will certainly continue to be when it comes to a formal press
- 15:26conference, they don't have anything to share it with you at the time.
- 15:28It's just one last thing. You recognize that as it relates to prior administrations,
- 15:35the president's predecessor, President Obama, President George W. Bush. I've
- 15:39been here long enough to have covered President Bill Clinton. This is not the
- 15:43norm. The norm is we do get an opportunity have asked the questions to
- 15:50the president about domestic and foreign policy issues in a formal setting at some point,
- 15:54and you choose that point, right, But we haven't had that opportunity
- 15:58in quite some time. So I'll say this. It is also unprecedented that
- 16:02a president takes as many shouted questions as this president has, and he has
- 16:07Okay, okay, well we'll get well, we'll certainly, we'll certainly get
- 16:14the data and share that with all of you. All Right, that's green
- 16:17Jean Pierre April of last year. In an exchange with John Decker, John
- 16:21joins us on Metro News Talk one. John, as you reflect on that,
- 16:23considering the debate, the interview with George Stefanoppois, what are your thoughts
- 16:26today, Well, my thoughts are the White House counted on news cycles overwhelming
- 16:33these questions, and they have to a certain extent. But now we're closer
- 16:37to the November election, and after that disastrous debate performance, you can't rely
- 16:45on news cycles just clearing out all of this bad news for President Biden.
- 16:49It's going to continue. The attention is only going to increase on President Biden
- 16:55with everything he says, everything he does. This week, interestingly enough,
- 16:59he does have a press conference on the schedule, a solo press conference,
- 17:03hoppy, and that will take place Thursday of this week at five thirty pm
- 17:07Eastern time, and so much attention is going to be focused on that to
- 17:11see how he handles himself tough questions posed to him during the course of that
- 17:15press conference on Thursday, John, Look, you were on this obviously pretty
- 17:21early. Was this always there? Was there always grumbling among the White House
- 17:25press corps about access to this president and also questions, whether overt questions or
- 17:30just questions among you all in the hallways about his capacity to handle these questions.
- 17:37Oh yes, you know. And I can think of various episodes over
- 17:41the course of the president's three and a half plus years in office in which
- 17:45we all talk amongst ourselves after a particular event, you know, raising our
- 17:52eyebrows. Did you see that? Boy? He handled that pretty poorly.
- 17:56I mean, even a simple event, hoppy like take you your child to
- 18:00work day, did not go well for President Biden. And that took place
- 18:04within the past year. So yes, these topics have been on our minds
- 18:11for quite some time. And now after that debate performance, you know,
- 18:15you have a larger segment of the American population talking about it as well.
- 18:19John the President called into Morning Joe. I caught just the end of it,
- 18:23and he sounded I think some of his answers were still kind of convoluted,
- 18:27but he certainly had a lot more energy than he did during the debate.
- 18:32He says, he's he's I think his quote was I'm not letting up.
- 18:36So do you get any indication from the White House that they are at
- 18:40least aware of what is going on and that you are they are they even
- 18:48considering whether he should step aside? Or is it just like double down,
- 18:51dig in pushback. Yeah, it's it's the latter. It's doubled down,
- 18:56dig in pushback. And the reason why you had the President call in the
- 19:00morning Joe today, and the reason why you had the President sending a letter,
- 19:07a single space, two page letter to a fellow Democrats about why he's
- 19:11staying in this race is because this week is different than last week. This
- 19:15week you have Congress back from its July fourth recess. That means that all
- 19:21of these Democrats are now back in the nation's capital and they can't avoid questions
- 19:26that are posed to them from reporters about whether or not they still support Joe
- 19:30Biden as the Democratic presidential nominee, or at least the presumptive nominee. And
- 19:37I think that what you see from the White House with the Morning Joe call
- 19:38on the letter is trying to go on the offensive, trying to make certain
- 19:42that they're in front of this rather than reacting to what Democrats may stay or
- 19:49potentially do at some point during the course of this week. John, Finally,
- 19:55and you've been around a long time, and you know how stories are,
- 19:57And there is a loop, and there's a giant, gantic loop now
- 20:00involving the president's cognitive ability, whether he will stay in the race, how
- 20:03many Democrats call for him to step aside, on and on, and it
- 20:07will be a story until it's not a story until something else happened. So
- 20:11it's not a one off. I mean, how long is this going to
- 20:14How long? How do you think this plays out in terms of the media,
- 20:17in terms of coverage, Well, I think it plays out as long
- 20:21as you have Democratic donors publicly saying they're not going to support their presumptive nominee.
- 20:26As long as you have Democratic lawmakers making statements or putting out statements indicating
- 20:33that they would like to see Joe Biden bow out, this will continue to
- 20:37be a story for the president. In addition to that is, if you
- 20:41have further episodes that do not put the president in a flattering light, then
- 20:47you will have further stories about the president and his physical mental abilities to do
- 20:52the job, not only now but also over the course of the next four
- 20:56years if he were to win reelection. All right. John Decker, Senior
- 21:00editor, White House correspondent for Great Television in West Virginia then includes WSAZWTAPWDTV,
- 21:07and WVVA. John, always a pleasure, appreciate you coming on. Thank
- 21:11you, Hotpy, you have a great day. Thanky, thank you,
- 21:12Tex three or four talk three or four, Hoppy. Here we go again,
- 21:15another day of beating up on Biden. Get over it. He's the
- 21:18dominee. People have been voting. You want to throw away the will of
- 21:22the voters. Where's the call for Trump to step aside for January six felony
- 21:26convictions inm world behavior, sexual perversions. Trump should be the one asked to
- 21:30step aside. He's unfit to be president. I don't think you can switch
- 21:34the narrative like that. I mean, Trump has been the narrative for years,
- 21:40and for January sixth, and for continuing to deny the results of the
- 21:44twenty twenty election, on and on. I mean, hardly a day goes
- 21:47by that that has not been the narrative. However, you cannot change what
- 21:52happened with that debate, and you cannot change what happened in that ABC interview.
- 21:56Which really wasn't much better. So that is a story that frankly,
- 22:00that's a story that's been brewing and really is just now come to surface.
- 22:06So and as I said, there is a loop. There is a loop,
- 22:10and right now it's a gigantic loop. And it is about Biden.
- 22:11It is about his performance, It is about his cognitive ability or lack thereof,
- 22:15and it is about what Democrats are saying are doing. So you can't
- 22:19just say, wow, I'll get over it. No, it's bigger than
- 22:22that. And I think one of the reasons that it is as big as
- 22:26it is is that there had been some protection of Biden that had taken place,
- 22:33and there had been limited access of Biden. And when you watch that
- 22:37debate, and I think I said this before I went on break, was
- 22:42that what many of us saw was we saw a parent or grandparent, a
- 22:49spouse, a friend, maybe even some of the characteristics in ourselves of just
- 22:55not being as sharp as we once were, or that father or mother having
- 23:00cognitive declinent. We saw that, and so we initially so we've had experience
- 23:07with that. You don't have to be you do not have to be a
- 23:11neurosurgeon to look at that and go wow that I remember my dad being like
- 23:17that, I remember my mom being like that, I remember my uncle being
- 23:19like that. That's why I think it really resonated with people. And now
- 23:23when that happens, now you are alert to it. You're alert to it.
- 23:27So anytime the president is speaking or in an appearance, frankly, you're
- 23:32on the lookout for it. All right, We're gonna take a break and
- 23:34come back on Metro News talk Line. We'll get a democratic perspective from a
- 23:40longtime Democrat and Biden's supporter in West Virginia, Michael Tamaski, on this story.
- 23:45When talk line continues on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of
- 23:48West Virginia. It's ten thirty. Let's get a news update, checking with
- 23:53the Metro News Radio Network. Final. What's happening statewide this hour, all
- 23:57across the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News design Kerrie Hooda
- 24:04sec Changes are coming on the West Virginia Turnpike beginning today. The turnpike is
- 24:08closing the Bluestone Travel Plaza, which is located northbound in Mercer County. The
- 24:14plaza itself is being rebuilt, but now, the fuel and parking areas will
- 24:17be closed to allow for completion. The same thing will happen at the southbound
- 24:21travel Plaza at Beckley beginning August first. The new mayor of Beckley is ready
- 24:25to get to work as the city transitions to a city manager form of government.
- 24:27Ryan Neil was sworn in last week following the retirement of Rob Rappold.
- 24:32Neil says he'll be part of the discussions with selecting a permanent city manager.
- 24:36He explains how the change will work. The mayor will be more of a
- 24:38ceremonial mayor, run the city council meetings, you know, be the eyes
- 24:44and ears of the people, you know that live in the city, work
- 24:48in the city, owned businesses in the city. And then my job is
- 24:51to kind of steer the city manager to get things done that the people want
- 24:56done. City Treasurer Recorder Billy Trump is serving as the interim city manager during
- 25:00the next few months. One of the last events of this year's Charleston Stern
- 25:03will Vergata was the Classic Car Show. Organizer Terry Godby says they couldn't have
- 25:07done it without the city's help. It's a great event, you know,
- 25:11the mayors helped us get this together and you know, to have something for
- 25:15a car show, so we're excited. Hopefully we're going to grow and get
- 25:18it bigger. More than one hundred cars line the street Sunday. There was
- 25:21also a large crowd Saturday night for the I Love the Nineties Tour concert featuring
- 25:25Vanilla Ice. You're listening to Metro News the Voice of West Virginia. A
- 25:30new episode of Live Healthy West Virginia is now posted on the podcast center of
- 25:34wv metronews dot com and the metro News TV app coming soon. The Elkins
- 25:38Corridor Medical Center a hospital without beds. When you think of probably ninety percent
- 25:45of the healthcare that we all need, it can all be accomplished in this
- 25:48building because we don't always need surgeries. Listen to Live Healthy West Virginia for
- 25:52candid conversations with insights for improving your health and well being. Live Healthy West
- 25:57Virginia is presented by WU Medicine. As a veteran, I live with health
- 26:02impacts from my service. VA Healthcare means you're in one hundred percent control of
- 26:07your own medical care, your own benefits, and it only takes minutes to
- 26:11set up a veteran should enroll in VIA Healthcare because it ensures that they get
- 26:17quality, high level care for the rest of their lives. My service was
- 26:22then my benefits are now get what you were Visit choose dot Va dot gov.
- 26:27Not all vetterans are eligible for the hyper amount of benefits mentioned it.
- 26:30Miss Agriculture USA is from West Virginia. Taylor County Native Grace Austin Roibovich has
- 26:36been advocating for women in agriculture and working to show people where the food they're
- 26:40buying is coming from. We go to Walmart, we get a gallon of
- 26:42milk, get a pickerburger. That's it. I want them to know the
- 26:45hard work and the dedication that it actually took to get to that shelf.
- 26:49It didn't just magically appear. She's been representing West Virginia for the last year
- 26:53and says she grew up on a farm which has been in her family for
- 26:56generations. From the Metro News anchor desk, I'm carrying you to talkling from
- 27:15me and co Insurance Studios. What's in a number? If you matched his
- 27:18six of twenty five correctly playing cash twenty five from the West Virginia Lottery will
- 27:22take him a top prize of twenty five thousand dollars. Drawings are held Mondays,
- 27:26Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays. It only costs a dollar to play,
- 27:30with four drawings each week. The od's pretty good. You're gonna have
- 27:32fun playing cash twenty five text topy. The evidence that Donald Trump has lost
- 27:37his fastball is every bit as strong as the evidence that Joe Biden has lost
- 27:40his. Until you are ready to look at both of them, you should
- 27:44shut up, the texter says to me. Michael Tamaski is a progressive commentator,
- 27:49author editor of The New Republic, is most recent book, If We
- 27:53Can Keep It, How the Republic Collapsed, How It Might Be Saved.
- 27:56He's at Morgantown, West Virginia, Native and I promised him that I would
- 28:00announce whenever his band was playing in the region. So go ahead. Are
- 28:04you playing in the region? We have no plans to reveal at this point,
- 28:08sir, are you dodging the question? Yeah, the last time we
- 28:17played, we had a bad night. You see. Oh yeah, I
- 28:19got it understood. You wrote here's the headline. I don't think you wrote
- 28:25the headline, but it's eight thirty PM. Do you know where your president
- 28:29is? And this was your lead, Tamaski's lead. I buried my head
- 28:33in my hands Thursday when I read that Joe Biden privately told a group of
- 28:37Democratic governors that he needed to get more sleep and do fewer events after eight
- 28:41pm, as if that was supposed to be reassuring. That's how you started
- 28:45your piece. How you feel today, Michael not good. I did write
- 28:48that headline. You know, this is a this is a very exasperating situation.
- 28:56To put it mildly, I mean, I think he's been a good
- 29:00president. I think that, you know, if he were seventy five,
- 29:07I think he'd be ahead by five or six points, and I think he'd
- 29:11be on his way to re election, and I think he'd deserve it.
- 29:18I know listeners don't agree with all that, but that's my take. But
- 29:22he's not seventy five, and that debate was you know, if you're a
- 29:30Democrat and that debate wasn't a serious wake up call, then I don't really
- 29:36know what you're thinking. Now. I'm not saying the only logical position is
- 29:40that he has to go. I have some friends who think he should stay,
- 29:42and they have their reasons, and you know, maybe you know,
- 29:48I mean a lot of America doesn't like Donald Trump either, and he's going
- 29:51to do a couple of crazy things between now and November fifth. But you
- 29:56know, the chances of Biden winning certainly went down, and I would just
- 30:00say this, then I'll yield the floor. The Democrats have always been looking
- 30:06at three risky options. Option one is to stick with Biden, even at
- 30:11his age. Option two was to ditch him for Harris, and option three
- 30:15was to open up the primary. I think, on balance, option one
- 30:23has been the least risky for most people until that debate, and now you
- 30:32know, Harris seems less risky, and open process, however abbreviated, also
- 30:37seems less risky. Do you think there should be Do you think you should
- 30:40set aside? I do? I mean, I'm not, I'm not in
- 30:44the I'm an independent, and I didn't plan to vote for I don't plan
- 30:47to vote for either or all three quitting ORFK But do you think you should
- 30:51set aside? I do? I do? I do, yeah, And
- 30:53I think I think if he did that, he could be very gracious.
- 30:59First of all, very people in history have renounced power that they had George
- 31:06Washington, George Washington, George Washington, the most famous of all Cincinnatis back
- 31:11in Rome, and then George Washington in Annapolish and that's that's really about it.
- 31:17So he would join a pretty select group of people who said, you
- 31:21know what, I could stay. I think I'd win, but I think
- 31:25what's right for the country is for me to turn this over to others,
- 31:29to the next generation. I think he'd get tremendous applause for that from Democrats
- 31:36and independence and probably some anti Trump Republicans too. It would it would have
- 31:40been it would have been more effective if he had done it a year ago
- 31:44and said I was elected and just summarize, I was elected because you wanted
- 31:48to stop Donald Trump. We did that. Now I'll turn it over to
- 31:52the next generation. Period exclamation point. Yeah, yeah, now you know
- 31:56he Yeah, he should have done it last summer, last September. I
- 32:01think once October seventh happened, Hamas he was going to stay. But yeah,
- 32:08it would have been great if he'd done it last Labor Day, say
- 32:14and let there be a process, and he could have said something like,
- 32:17you know, I love my vice president, I'm I'm for her, but
- 32:22we have a lot of talent in this party, so let's let's let people
- 32:25get out there and see what they've got. And that would have been that
- 32:30would have just taken so much pressure off the situation. Do you believe and
- 32:36look, you are well connected in democratic circles? Do you believe that a
- 32:39lot of Democrats and I don't know how well connected you are with people inside
- 32:43the administration? Were they for the last year or two? Were they just
- 32:45holding their breaths? I kind of think so, yeah, I mean that's
- 32:51what a lot of reporting says. I mean, I do know people in
- 32:52the in the West wing, but I'm not a beat reporter there, so
- 32:57I don't you know, I don't I don't take their temperature every day or
- 33:00a week. But yeah, I mean, we've seen a lot of reporting
- 33:06in the last few days that it was kind of like that, And it
- 33:10sounds like he really started to slip last summer when he literally did slip at
- 33:17the Air Force Academy graduation in June of twenty twenty three. And I think
- 33:23from there, I just remember feeling, just as somebody who watched his press
- 33:28conferences on cable news that you know, back in February of twenty twenty three.
- 33:36I wasn't nervous when I was watching him speak. You know, it
- 33:38was February twenty twenty three when he took that ten hour train ride from Poland
- 33:43to Keith and gave that I thought, really good speech with Zelenski standing next
- 33:49to him. So that was February twenty twenty three. I think it was
- 33:51okay then. So I think it set in like last summer, and yeah,
- 33:54I think the White House has been yeah, as you say, holding
- 34:00their breast, it could win. But Michael Timaski's with his progressive commentator,
- 34:02author editor of The New Republic. How does this play out this morning?
- 34:07On morning Joe, President Biden called in and said, I am not letting
- 34:13up. We know that eight Democrats have come forward so far, and look,
- 34:16the Congress is back in Washington, and everybody who gets new a microphone's
- 34:21going to be asked to you at least a Democrat should Biden step aside?
- 34:23So how does this play out over this week next week? Do you think?
- 34:29Well, first of all, this is going to be one of those
- 34:30rare weeks when politicians avoid a microphone. I you know, I mean my
- 34:40assessment changes from day to day. You know, Saturday, I thought it
- 34:45was headed toward Harris or open process, but I think probably Harris out of
- 34:50those two. And then you know, this morning it feels like Biden all
- 34:55the way. What will it take? He has a press conference Thursday,
- 35:01but well, Wednesday, he's going to the AFL CIO and they're going to
- 35:05have his back. You know, he walked a picket line. That's the
- 35:09power of the presidency. Thursday, NATO summit, He's going to give a
- 35:15press conference. We'll see how he does. You know, it's just going
- 35:21to come down to senators and Schumer Keem Jefferies. I've written also about Barack
- 35:30Obama. Where are you? Where are you to do what? Well,
- 35:37you know, I gather there's a little bit of tension between Biden and Obama
- 35:43because of twenty sixteen when Obama was all in for Hillary. But still they
- 35:46did work together eight years. Obama made him his vice president, put him
- 35:50in a position where he was able to have the stature to run for president.
- 35:53And when Obama is the one leader I think more so than Bill Clinton,
- 35:59who's you know, it's a long time since he was president, but
- 36:04Obama is the one leader who I think can pull the party together and say
- 36:09this is what we're going to do, folks, this is what we need
- 36:12to do to win this election. I think he has that juice, he
- 36:17doesn't seem to me to be interested in using it. He was he never
- 36:23liked the rough and tumble of politics. I mean, you know, he
- 36:28really didn't. I mean, and this is this is a time for the
- 36:30nitty gritty of politics, and he never liked that. In my opinion,
- 36:34I no, no, he always was a little to be above the fray.
- 36:38Can I give you here's here's my scenario. And I do not know
- 36:44the intricacies of all the rules, whatever they may be, for a democratic
- 36:50convention or delegates, et cetera, et cetera. Is Biden steps aside and
- 36:55says, you know, I've heard you. There are things that more important
- 37:00than what I want to do, and it's stopping Donald Trump, it's the
- 37:02country, et cetera. And open it up, and you have a convenient
- 37:07and you have a convention, and you have you know, four or five
- 37:10six potential candidates speak, have their people, try to round up delegates,
- 37:15have a true convention, and maybe have Barack Obama there to kind of get
- 37:21people routed up and on the last night before the nominee speaks, have Biden
- 37:24speak and says goodbyes. He gets a big round of applause and then and
- 37:29then probably the nature of conventions are whoever came out there would have some enthusiasm,
- 37:36which right now there's none for Biden. How about that? Yeah,
- 37:38No, I mean that would be great, that would be great. I'm
- 37:43not sure anyone would even take Harris on because I think the way these people
- 37:51think is like, well, do I want to alienate the black voters in
- 37:55the Democratic Party? And I've got my eye on twenty twenty eight And you
- 38:01know that's I think that's sort of how they think. But that's a problem
- 38:05for the Democrats. That's a problem, is it is. Yeah, it's
- 38:07a big problem. But if that's wrong, and if I have four or
- 38:13five of these governors get in and then a couple of senators, then there
- 38:16are a lot of plausible choices for the party. And just word of mouth
- 38:22and just my conversations over these last few months, the person who would have
- 38:28the most interest would be Gretchen Whitmer, the governor of Michigan. A lot
- 38:34of people are very impressed by her, now she has to rise to the
- 38:37occasion and command a presidential stage and so forth, and not everybody can do
- 38:43that. You know, Ron Since didn't do it, so a lot of
- 38:45big state governors can't do it. But there's a lot of interest in her.
- 38:50But there's there's interest in Pritzker of Illinois that Shapiro Pennsylvania knew some I
- 38:55think feelings that are more mixed about with more of Maryland. But he's just
- 39:01brand new senators. I would say Chris Murphy of Connecticut, maybe Corey Booker
- 39:07of New Jersey. I mean, these are all plausible presidential timber and it
- 39:15would be really exciting to see a genuinely contested convention yep, with all these
- 39:22people offering their wares. I just think the chances of it happening are pretty
- 39:28low. Michael Tamaski, progressive commentator, author, editor of The New Republic.
- 39:31His most recent book is If We Can Keep It, How the Republic
- 39:35Collapsed and How it Might be saved. Also a band member who refuses to
- 39:38reveal. I mean, they are so hip, they are so edgy,
- 39:44they do not tell people when they play. Right. Yeah, yeah,
- 39:47we posted on Instagram ten minutes before It's like before the Rolling Stones go on
- 39:54tour, they show up somewhere, right, yeah, right, right,
- 39:57right, yeah, it's exactly like that, Michael to talk to you.
- 40:00Thank you, my friend. All right, We'll be right back. Were
- 40:04there for you to care for you at the health Plan. The health Plan
- 40:09is still growing, giving you a large network of doctors, friendly and helpful
- 40:14customer service representatives, and competitive, flexible pricing plans that meet your needs.
- 40:19Log on to health plan dot org for more information. We are to care
- 40:24for you plan. We are here. Winning the lottery would be the start
- 40:34of my race dream. Hitting the open road at top speeds, hugging turns.
- 40:37It's intense. What are you dreaming of racing again? Not dreaming.
- 40:49I'm practicing and I'm checking my tickets. It's a mower, It's a dream.
- 40:58West Virginia Lottery. If it can happen to you, please pay responsibly.
- 41:02This is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia wvmetronews
- 41:09dot com the only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain State.
- 41:14Get the latest news and sports story, information on the great outdoors, and
- 41:17never miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs. And podcast including Talkline,
- 41:23Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a
- 41:27bookmark now and visit do wv metronews dot com First Thing every morning to find
- 41:31out what's happening all across the state. Wvmetronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors
- 41:38is the Mountain State's only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than
- 41:43quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has
- 41:47been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. Stockfish
- 41:52for repatriation purposes to that's reintroduction, reestablishment of Brooks trout, and two of
- 41:58those streams the oldest we have worked on, the earliest ones that we started
- 42:01putting fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in both of those streams, whether
- 42:07it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great
- 42:10outdoors. It was a pretty good fight. It takes me about ten minutes
- 42:15to get it in. My dad actually had to run to the truck and
- 42:19grab a NAT because there's my way I could list him up over top of
- 42:22the rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six
- 42:27am and for your daily fix. Outdoors Today brings you two and a half
- 42:30minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro
- 42:35News of Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap
- 42:39up your weekend. It's the City that Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey,
- 42:43this is Travis Joes joined myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh
- 42:46six until eight o'clock as we wrap up the sports weekend. We talked Mountaineers,
- 42:51High School, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national scene.
- 42:53The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text the
- 42:58show at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend sports
- 43:01wrap up on your favorite Metro News affilia or watch the show at wb Metronews
- 43:06dot com. Metro News Talkline with Hoppykerchible is brought to you by Incovia Insurance,
- 43:23encircling you with coverage to protect what do you care about most? Visiting
- 43:28Coca dot com to learn more. Talkline from me in Co Insurance Studios.
- 43:31Vandelja Health has exciting career opportunities across all their hospitals and now patient locations.
- 43:37You will also find conference of benefits, as well as training and educational assistance
- 43:40programs. Learn more about Vendeia Health locations, services and career opportunities at Vandelia
- 43:46health dot org. Vandelia Health dot org. Let me do some texts at
- 43:50three oh four talk three oh four, Happy fake news. You made your
- 43:54bed, Now lie in a Conservatives have been saying this since his presidential campaign,
- 44:00when he stayed in the basement but somehow got more votes than anyone in
- 44:02history. Not buying it, well, the fact is he did get more
- 44:07votes. Hoppy. Can you picture Biden one on one with Chinese or Russian
- 44:13leaders? This is reminiscent of the old SNL skits where the Soviets propped up
- 44:16their leaders surrounded by associates holding them up. The answer is no, I
- 44:20can't, No, I cannot. And even when I caught about two minutes
- 44:25of him on Morning Joe this morning, and even then it felt like he
- 44:29was reading off cards, which that's what it felt like, Hoppy. I
- 44:37guess it's more politically expedient to allow you know what, to flow into streams
- 44:43and rivers, to not have a tax cut. What type of people are
- 44:46we anymore? We'll see what happens with this tax cut plan. I mean,
- 44:53I get the idea that Governor Justice being Governor Justice rolled in one day
- 44:59and said, look, let's add another five percent cut in here. I
- 45:06don't believe he consulted with legislative If he did, maybe he did, I
- 45:12don't know, but it doesn't sound like it. While I was gone,
- 45:15Eric Tarr, the chairman of the powerful Sin of Finance Committee, said he
- 45:19was not consulted. I know that he and the governor don't get along very
- 45:22well, but Tar was not consulted. So that's kind of Justice rolls in
- 45:25one day and says, let's add another five percent cut onto what will probably
- 45:31be about a three or four percent cut. So now you're talking about a
- 45:34nine percent reduction in rates, and which would get you to since West Virginia
- 45:40started, this tax reduction will gets you to about a thirty percent reduction in
- 45:45rates from the original rates, which what six point five percent, six percent,
- 45:51five something, four something, three something, So it would be a
- 45:55thirty percent reduction, roughly thirty percent reduction, but we'll see. Yeah,
- 46:00you'd have to have a special session you'd have to have wallmakers agree to it.
- 46:05So we'll see. Keep an eye on that. But it did sound
- 46:07like that, you know, Eric Tarr has concerns about it. Chairman Chris
- 46:13of the Finance Committe on the House sounds like he wants to find a way
- 46:15to support it. Happy my observation. My observation is the press ignored Biden's
- 46:21decline until they couldn't after the debate Hoppy. The campaign has looked at the
- 46:27numbers. It won't make any difference if it's Harris or Biden. He's not
- 46:31going to get out. There are two candidate. These are the two candidates
- 46:35we have. This is the choice. I don't well. I think that
- 46:40Michael made a great point about if Biden got out, would Democrats be willing
- 46:45to look at somebody other than Harris? And if you do, and you
- 46:50bypass Harris, then the upset the black votes. Do you upset the female
- 46:53vote because she's a black woman? I don't know. Are you trying to
- 46:58win? Are you trying to win because her numbers are about as bad as
- 47:02Joe Biden's. I don't know. Where I don't know. It doesn't seem
- 47:07like if if Biden stepped aside, and it was Harris. I'm not sure
- 47:12what that does for the enthusiasm gap as it exists, because again, her
- 47:17numbers aren't very good. I think if you had a convention, had to
- 47:22think why, I mean, roll the dice. Have a convention, see
- 47:25what comes out of it? Generates some enthusiasm and excitement. Do you think
- 47:30if Biden, if they continue on this course, what's that? What's that
- 47:34convention gonna be like? It's gonna be like a wake? Well it won't.
- 47:38I mean, they'll put on a show, but it's gonna feel like
- 47:43a wake. I'd mean, why No. Examples of Trump's cognitive decline when
- 47:47he's unaware of what city or state he's in, confuses NICKI Haley with Nancy
- 47:52Pelosi. Those again, I don't you can't. I don't think you can
- 47:57equate those things. I don't think you can say what about it in this
- 48:00is that? Because when he does it, when he did conflate those two,
- 48:05it was a story. But the debate was so bad, it was
- 48:10so bad it's it's hard to justify it. Well, yeah, but I
- 48:15mean Trump lied fifty times. Well, yeah, he did, whatever the
- 48:19number is. But what stood out What stood out about that was the cognitive
- 48:23decline. And you can't you can't approach this saying, look, instead of
- 48:28the cognitive decline of Biden, let's talk about the cognitive cline of Trump.
- 48:32I mean, maybe Trump has cognitive decline, but it clearly when you if
- 48:37you watch the debate objectively, who had more trouble formulating answers. It was
- 48:44Joe Biden. It really is not that there's not a debate about that part
- 48:47of the debate. We'll be right back. Our joints are complex structures.
- 48:52For joint replacements to function properly, the implants must be placed with accuracy and
- 48:58precision WU METUS since Board certified orthopedic surgeons utilize the latest technologies in robotic assisted
- 49:05joint replacement surgery to ensure that the implants are in the exact spot they should
- 49:08be. If you have a joint problem in West Virginia, there's no reason
- 49:13to go anywhere else but WVU Medicine. Visit Wvumedicine dot org slash joint.
- 49:20If you love sports, you'll love the Bridge. The Bridge Sports Complex and
- 49:23Bridgeport is West Virginia's largest sports and recreation destination. At the Bridge you'll find
- 49:29one hundred and fifty six thousand square feet for volleyball, basketball, swimming,
- 49:34soccer, climbing, running, and fitness the bridge One reason Bridgeport is the
- 49:38perfect pot or a fun and memorable weekend getaway. Learn more about travel,
- 49:43dining, events, and things to do in the beautiful city of Bridgeports,
- 49:46West Virginia at Greater Dash Bridgeport dot com. Winning the lottery would be the
- 49:52start of my race dream, hitting the open road at top speeds, hugging
- 49:54turns. It's intents. What are you dreaming of racing again? Not dreaming,
- 50:07I'm practicing and I'm checking my tickets. It's a mower, It's a
- 50:12dream. West Virginia Lottery. What if it could happen to you? Please
- 50:19pay responsibly. You're listening to talk Line on Metro News, The Voice of
- 50:22West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio
- 50:30show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state.
- 50:35Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more
- 50:39than twenty five years. I shot him, he ran over to the edge
- 50:43of the field. He made it about five ten yards out of the edge
- 50:46of the field and fell over there. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or
- 50:51just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. He stuck his head
- 50:54through the blind into where you were. Yeah, yeah, well he had
- 51:00jump. He leaked oka the blonde. Oh gosh, yeah, he had.
- 51:05His whole body was in the air for a couple of seconds and is
- 51:07the only thing that landed in the blonde was you know? Of course at
- 51:12Bartley, West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am
- 51:16and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes
- 51:20of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News
- 51:24of Voice of West Virginia. Hey everybody, it's Tony Courritty, I'm Greg
- 51:29Hunter, and I'm Brad Howe, and we invite you to join us Sunday
- 51:32through Fridays right here on the Metro News Radio network. It's the City Nets
- 51:36Statewide Sports Line. We talk West Virginia University football, basketball, baseball,
- 51:42you name it. If it's got anything to do with the Golden Blue,
- 51:45We're on it. And don't forget the text line available every night, so
- 51:47we invite you to join us. The Senator Coach Hunter and me Tony Coritti.
- 51:52It's the city net state wide sports line on Metro News. News in
- 51:55the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you depended on Metro News for accurate
- 52:01news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians
- 52:07informed. If you see news happening, become a Metro News hawk by texting
- 52:10News to three five sixty five to one. If you take a picture or
- 52:14video of what you see, submit that as well. Text the word news
- 52:17to three five sixty five one to submit your tip or story. Standard texting
- 52:22rates apply. Please don't text and drive talk line on Metro News. I
- 52:45am pleased to announce that our two week long nightmare in Parkersburg is over.
- 52:52We are back on the air in Parkersburg WVAM AM fourteen fifty eight point one
- 53:00and FM one oh seven point nine. So that's w VAM AM fourteen point
- 53:07fifty and FM ninety eight point one and FM one oh seven point nine.
- 53:15So glad to be back on in Parkersburg. We had a station switched there.
- 53:19The station we were on switched formats. So we welcome our friends in
- 53:22Parkersburg once again able to listen to talk line and loul Metro News programming on
- 53:28WVAM AM fourteen fifty FM ninety eight point one FM one oh seven point nine.
- 53:34It's great to have you on the Metro News team back in six minutes.
- 53:37This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia.
- 54:00Already our number two talk line on the Metro News radio network all across the
- 54:04great state of West Virginia. So while I was gone, the US Supreme
- 54:07Court issued a seminal decision, a huge decision which kind of got lost in
- 54:13all the Biden stuff. And also it's had complicated, so it's not the
- 54:16sexiest thing. But talk about a decision that will have significant impact on how
- 54:22the government does things or doesn't do things. This is it the Chevron case.
- 54:27U Supreme Court reversed a forty year old ruling it had been effect for
- 54:31forty years, called the Chevron Decision that when it was issued forty years ago,
- 54:37it made it easier for government agencies like the EPA or public health organization's
- 54:44workplace safety consumer protection associations or organizations within government to issue regulations, and the
- 54:51essence of the ruling was forty years ago that said, look, if the
- 54:54statute passed by Congress is ambiguous, it's unclean, then you give deference to
- 55:01the agency like the EPA to decide what that means, which really empowers those
- 55:07agencies. At the time, it was actually a decision favored by conservatives.
- 55:12I'll get to that. So this is a decision it could have far reaching
- 55:16impact. Joining US is West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey, also Republican nominee
- 55:22for Governor. Patrick. Good morning, Good to talk to you again.
- 55:23How are you, sir, Good morning, Appy. I'm glad you're spending
- 55:28time on this case. It's a pretty significant one, especially when you combine
- 55:31it with West Virginia EPA and a lot of the other bigger cases out there.
- 55:37We've been able to make a pretty huge debt in the administrative state in
- 55:42Washington, and we're very pleased to have led a lot of these efforts.
- 55:45A lot of what you and others have done have been a pushback against regulatory
- 55:50agencies, saying they are exceeding their authority. Now, with this decision by
- 55:54the Spreme Court, do you and others have greater authority to push back to
- 55:58what are regulatory agency you may or may not may try to do well.
- 56:02I think there's some additional tools, and that's been ongoing over the last number
- 56:08of years as the Supreme Court is really recognized that the deference that was given
- 56:15to these agencies over a prolonged stretch of time, it's not proper, it's
- 56:19not consistent with the Constitution and the role that the federal government plays in it.
- 56:24So I do think that there will be some additional opportunities to go after
- 56:29the excesses of the administrative state, and we should welcome that because this decision
- 56:34at its heart is reflecting proper constitutional governance from the beginning of time. From
- 56:40the beginning, when you go back to Marbury v. Madison, it was
- 56:45always envisioned that the courts are going to make the decisions with respect to the
- 56:50correct interpretations of law. When you started to give more and more power to
- 56:55these federal agencies who are largely unaccountable, then you started to see the growth
- 57:01of the federal government, and you see these federal bureaucrats inventing power that didn't
- 57:06belong to them. Far better to have correct interpretations of law consistent with the
- 57:12Constitution, as opposed to simply deferring to a bureaucrat because they exist. Patrick
- 57:16and I do get that argument. I understand that argument philosophically and practically.
- 57:21However, it is impossible for Congress to pass a law let's say, let's
- 57:25just stick with the environment, say concerning the environment, and understand or articulate
- 57:30or all the minutia that may be involved in environmental protection. Therefore, it
- 57:37does give latitude to agencies to decide what that should be, using presumably expert
- 57:45opinion. And wouldn't those who work at those agencies have more information and more
- 57:51expertise than Congress or a judge and courts. Look, I think no one
- 57:58is questioning that Congress can delegate specific grants of authority to a particular agency.
- 58:06But what's been happening over a prolonged period of time is that these agencies have
- 58:09effectively been seizing power for themselves. Certainly, the onus falls back to Congress
- 58:15to make the big decisions of the day. That was actually the heart of
- 58:19the West Virginia VPA case as well. When you have these vast economic or
- 58:22political decisions, you look to whether Congress issued a clear statement, are they
- 58:28making the decisions? Ultimately, when you're looking at our constitution, all these
- 58:32federal agencies are just creatures, the creations of Congress, So you have to
- 58:37be very clear what the rules of the road are. And what we've seen,
- 58:42unfortunately over many decades, is that these agencies have grown bigger and bigger.
- 58:46Not only have they received so much funding, but they've been inventing power
- 58:52for themselves. So I think copy you can still delegate to these agencies,
- 58:57but the courts are probably going to be in interpreting whether the delegation is correct
- 59:01and clear for themselves, rather than blindly deferring to an agency that might have
- 59:07some expertise but might be completely wrong in the interpretation of the law. And
- 59:13when we're talking with about our constitution and the laws, you've got to get
- 59:16the law right. There are no shortcuts when it comes to complying with our
- 59:22constitution. Patrick Marsy is with US West Virginia Attorney General, republican nominee for
- 59:25Governor. Patrick There is an irony here, and that is when this case
- 59:30was decided first time forty years ago. It was a six to zero decision.
- 59:34Three judges recused, but the judges said the judges should play a limited
- 59:38and deferential role when evaluating the actions of agency experts in a case that was
- 59:44brought by environmental groups challenging the Reagan administration. So at the time when the
- 59:49court initially ruled on this forty years ago, in the Chevron case, it
- 59:52was viewed by the Reagan administration and by conservatives as a victory because it's because
- 59:59it it held in check what these rather gave deference to these agencies like the
- 1:00:07EPA. And therefore, if you had a conservative administration like the Reagan administration,
- 1:00:12and like, Okay, this is what we can do, and we
- 1:00:15won't have presidents here instead of a court telling us what to do. So
- 1:00:19do you see the irony in this? Well, certainly, people's positions sometimes
- 1:00:24change over time. But I think what you're pointing out really reinforces the greater
- 1:00:30principle, which is when you have a constitutional republic, the price that you
- 1:00:35pay is you have to be eternally vigilant. You have to make sure that
- 1:00:38no part of the federal government or the states, or that there's always a
- 1:00:43balance in separation of powers. And you see, since I started in twenty
- 1:00:47thirteen. We've been focusing extensively on the separation of powers between the federal agencies,
- 1:00:53between the federal agencies and the states, and so I think what you're
- 1:00:59seeing is anytime the pendulum starts to swing too far over, there's a natural
- 1:01:04correction. I think that's what you're seeing here. Hoppyan. Remember there's nothing
- 1:01:07in this case law getting rid of Chevron that doesn't allow courts to show respect
- 1:01:14for an agency decision. That's certainly appropriate, especially if they're correct on the
- 1:01:19law. It's not engaging in the blind difference that's binding in the past under
- 1:01:25Chevron that was binding difference. That's a huge problem, and I think that's
- 1:01:30what we were able to get rid of. And after many cases that this
- 1:01:34office has been involved in, you know, we were fortunate to lead the
- 1:01:37way on the state amarchus on this case, and we really have been trying
- 1:01:39to build on our West Virginia VPA precedent. So I think it's a good
- 1:01:44decision. Obviously, like any issue, you're going to have to implement it
- 1:01:47the right way to make sure it doesn't get abused, and we're certainly going
- 1:01:52to be consistently focusing on that. Let me try to put a face on
- 1:01:55this. Patrick, for the other side, Let's say that you're the next
- 1:01:59gup of the state and you say, you know what, we really need
- 1:02:01to build a pipeline from here to there, and the regulatory agencies approve it,
- 1:02:09and then everybody who's against a pipeline comes out. The would work and
- 1:02:13file suit everywhere they can to find a sympathetic federal judge to side with them.
- 1:02:19I mean, could that happen and could this end up having things being
- 1:02:22endlessly bogged down in the courts? Well, look, I am hopeful that
- 1:02:27there would be effort. If we want to have authority to allow a particular
- 1:02:31activity to happen, then most certainly I would want to work with the legislature
- 1:02:36to get it right. In the first instance, if you were to create
- 1:02:38ambiguous language, even on the state level, that's not something that should get
- 1:02:44the broad deference. So I want to be consistent about this as it applies.
- 1:02:47But there's a way to fix it. It's to work with people at
- 1:02:51the outset to make sure that there's clarity. Hoppy, what's happened over a
- 1:02:54long period of time with these federal agencies is that they used to get this
- 1:02:59language from Congress in some cases was wildly ambiguous. And how do you know
- 1:03:04why they did that? Because a lot of times there'd be worrying factions in
- 1:03:07Congress. Congress wouldn't want to be clear because they'd anger one side or the
- 1:03:12other. So they decided to be ambiguous, toss the political problem over to
- 1:03:15the agency, and then say, see it could be resolved in one of
- 1:03:20two ways, and therefore they get the votes. But that's not consistent with
- 1:03:23our constitutional process. You have to do it the right way. There are
- 1:03:27no shortcuts in proper constitutional governments. And I would say the same type of
- 1:03:31principles would apply for state government as well. And I'm excited to actually be
- 1:03:37part of that because I envision a good working relationship with the legislature when we
- 1:03:43have to make changes of law, that there is clarity, and it'll be
- 1:03:45clear for the courts. It's going to be clear for the people to understand.
- 1:03:50It's not just you say one thing and then do another. Patrick Marcy,
- 1:03:52Attorney General, Republican Kende for Governor. Patrick, appreciate your insights.
- 1:03:55Thank you for coming on today. Hey so much, howp you appreciate it
- 1:04:00all right? Talk soon. A new episode of Live Healthy West Virginia is
- 1:04:02now posted on the podcast center of wb metronews dot com and the Metro News
- 1:04:06TV app coming soon. The Elkins Corridor Medical Center a hospital without beds.
- 1:04:13When you think of probably ninety percent of the healthcare that we all need,
- 1:04:16it can all be accomplished in this building because we don't always need surgeries.
- 1:04:21Listen to Live Healthy West Virginia for candid conversations with insights for improving your health
- 1:04:26and well being. Live Healthy West Virginia is presented by WU Medicine. As
- 1:04:30Governor Justice always says, West Virginia is a diamond in the rough. That
- 1:04:35diamond just got a bit shinier with the state being named one of the top
- 1:04:40travel destinations in the world. Our scenic beauty, natural wonder and unique culture
- 1:04:45are unsurpassed, and it's no surprise people are catching on. And for those
- 1:04:49visiting, we hope you'll decide to stay in West Virginia. Job opportunities abound,
- 1:04:54especially in the coal industry. Coal mining is a high tech, high
- 1:04:58growth industry that exist side by side with exceptional hiking, biking, climbing,
- 1:05:02kayaking, hunting, fishing, and so much more. With state of the
- 1:05:06art mining operations. West Virginia's coal industry is recognized as the best in the
- 1:05:12world. We produce the coal that makes the steel that built this great country
- 1:05:16while continuing to power America today, Join one of America's most honorable professions while
- 1:05:21living in one of the top travel destinations in the world. Join us in
- 1:05:27almost Heaven, West Virginia. A message from the friends of Coal. This
- 1:05:30is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Wvmetronews dot
- 1:05:38com the only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain State. Get
- 1:05:43the latest news and sports story, information on the great outdoors, and never
- 1:05:46miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcasts, including Talkline,
- 1:05:51Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a bookmark
- 1:05:56now and visit do WV metronews dot com first Thing every every morning to find
- 1:06:00out what's happening all across the state. Wvmetronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors
- 1:06:06is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than
- 1:06:11quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has
- 1:06:15been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years stockfish for
- 1:06:20repatriation purposes to that's reintroduction, re establishment of Brookschrout and two of those streams,
- 1:06:27the oldest that we have worked on, the earliest ones that we started
- 1:06:30putting fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in both of those streams, whether
- 1:06:34it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great
- 1:06:39outdoors. It was a pretty good flight. It takes me about ten minutes
- 1:06:43to get it in. My dad actually had to run to the truck and
- 1:06:46grab antclus. There's my way. I could list him up over top of
- 1:06:50the rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six
- 1:06:55am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half
- 1:06:59minutes of news notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News,
- 1:07:03the Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap
- 1:07:08up your weekend. It's the City Net Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey,
- 1:07:11this is Travis Jowes joining myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh
- 1:07:15six until eight o'clock. As we wrap up the sports weekend, we talk
- 1:07:17Mountaineers, High School, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national
- 1:07:21scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text
- 1:07:26the show at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend
- 1:07:30sports wrap up on your favorite Metro news Apphili, or watch the show at
- 1:07:33wv Metronews dot com. Metro News talk Line with Hoppykerchibal is brought to you
- 1:07:50by Incovia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 1:07:57Visit in Covia dot com to learn more Talkline from me and in studios.
- 1:08:00And I'm back after a week off, and once again I'm going to
- 1:08:04talk about homeschooling. And I want to clarify as always, this is not
- 1:08:09an attack on homeschooling. I support the concept of homeschooling. I know that
- 1:08:13many people do it right and do it well, and I've met students who've
- 1:08:15come out of the homeschooling system or systems and it's been very, very impressive.
- 1:08:20But there are issues associated with homeschooling, and that is that have come
- 1:08:25out from the deproblement of education, like about the fact that only about a
- 1:08:29third of the reports that are supposed to be filed by the parents four times
- 1:08:38over the course of twelve years are being done. The fact that a lot
- 1:08:42of the students, many of most of the students who end up in homeschool,
- 1:08:45were chronically absent before, so there are some accountability issues. Center.
- 1:08:49Michael Laverio, Republican, Montague County, Montage and Marion is a member of
- 1:08:54the Senate Education Committee joint us in studio. Michael, good to see you.
- 1:08:57How are you, sir, Hey, good hobby, Thanks for coming
- 1:08:59in. Happy to come on and talk with you about this subject. And
- 1:09:01I think both of us love our West Virginia children and see every reason that
- 1:09:06we should be taking to care for them and protect them. Your care and
- 1:09:11empathy is demonstrated by you continuing to be on this issue. And I think
- 1:09:15a slice of my care and empathy is based on legislation that I sponsored back
- 1:09:20in nineteen ninety seven that created a criminal statute that spelled out child neglect resulting
- 1:09:28in death because we worried about that, and sure enough, that is in
- 1:09:31fact the criminal statute that's being used to prosecute this mother and grandparents. Yeah,
- 1:09:38We've seen this issue for a long time, and the purpose of that
- 1:09:43legislation more than twenty five years ago, was to create a deterrent that we
- 1:09:47don't neglect children and to punish those who do. So let me just start
- 1:09:51with that. This whole issue of homeschool and children. We have so many
- 1:09:58successes within them homeschool area, and our job in state government is to find
- 1:10:04some balance between those legislators who want to overly regulate homeschoolers and those who want
- 1:10:11to be completely laissez fair. Do you believe there is an accountability issue?
- 1:10:16I think there should be an accountability issue with all children in West Virginia.
- 1:10:20You know, we have a responsibility as a state to provide a thorough and
- 1:10:25free public education to our children, and with that comes compulsory attendance requirements.
- 1:10:31And so when a family says, hey, we think we can do it
- 1:10:34better ourselves, and they want to step out and do that, there has
- 1:10:39to be some accountability. The lion's share of the accountability has to be with
- 1:10:44the parent, But at the same time, there should be some level of
- 1:10:46accountability of the state of saying, hey, these requirements have to be turned
- 1:10:51in, you know, four times during the child's education, the third grade,
- 1:10:56the fifth grade, the eighth grade, the eleventh grade, are those
- 1:10:59in fact being turned in? Is satisfactory progress being made? And if not,
- 1:11:02why not? And if we ask that question, why not and we
- 1:11:08dig into that, there might be that very rare occasion where we find a
- 1:11:12Kennedy Miller that is not being properly cared for. You mentioned the interview we
- 1:11:16did here with Michelle Blatt, Superintendent of Schools, and she supports homeschooling as
- 1:11:19well, but she said, look, the numbers that they have so far
- 1:11:24indicate that only a third of these reports are being turned in or at least
- 1:11:29accounted for. And what we don't know, maybe they know by now from
- 1:11:31the data, is that whether are these reports not being turned in? Are
- 1:11:35they turned in but nobody reviews them? Are they reviewed but nobody accounts them,
- 1:11:40accounts for them? I mean, does that raise alarm bells to you?
- 1:11:45When I first heard her say thirty seven percent of these reports are being
- 1:11:48turned in, I was concerned. What we've asked the state Department of Education
- 1:11:55to do is let's take a little deeper dive into that and see are all
- 1:11:59fifty five county school systems receiving those reports and transmitting those to the state board,
- 1:12:05and if some of those are not, then clearly that's going to skew
- 1:12:09the numbers sure and create what looks like a big disparity. I know many
- 1:12:13families at homeschool and they're proud to turn those reports in. You know,
- 1:12:16when that child's in the eighth grade and that child's making progress, those families
- 1:12:20are proud to put that report together and send it in. So I was
- 1:12:25surprised by that number. I'm not gonna say it's wrong. I don't have
- 1:12:28any way of knowing it's wrong, but but I'm surprised by it and think
- 1:12:30that with greater accountability we might learn that that number is not correct. It
- 1:12:35may not be. I thought it was just an early indicator that there is
- 1:12:39an issue there. There is an issue there either with parents, some parents
- 1:12:43not turning into reports, of the reports not being documented, or not making
- 1:12:46their way to the state or whatever. So you're again on the Education Committee
- 1:12:54in the Senate. Amy Grady is the chair of that committee. Have you
- 1:12:58talked among other members? Is there any interest in dealing with these issues at
- 1:13:01some point? There's been a lot of interest in general child welfare throughout just
- 1:13:08even this legislative session. The session began by Senator Charlie Trump from Morgan County
- 1:13:15standing up and saying, hey, we don't have a child Protective Service investigator
- 1:13:20in Morgan County, a county of eighteen twenty thousand people. And part of
- 1:13:26the issue, he thought was related to pay that you get over there in
- 1:13:30the eastern Panhandle counties, the growth counties like Montengeia. You need some kind
- 1:13:33of locality pay or something to be able to pay somebody to take the job
- 1:13:38and stay in the job. And so we have these pockets around our state
- 1:13:43where we're not being able to have the proper CPS work done when there are
- 1:13:47so there's CPS, there are CPS issues as well as child protective services issues
- 1:13:51as well. Taught to this, I mean the you know, so what
- 1:13:56you end up with is you end up in that case with a report and
- 1:14:00maybe it shows a quarter let's say, three months in a row, and
- 1:14:02it says there were no instances of child abuse or neglect in Morgan County from
- 1:14:09July, August and September. Well, certainly that's not true, right,
- 1:14:13Yeah, What is true is there was nobody there to investigate those reports that
- 1:14:17had been made by mandatory reporters, whether it was school personnel or law enforcement
- 1:14:24or others in human services. And so I think we desperately need more child
- 1:14:29protective service workers and we need a level of accountability such that those folks are
- 1:14:34out there and they're following up on these leads. And you know, all
- 1:14:39of us as citizens have a responsibility beyond just mandatory reporters. All of us
- 1:14:45as West Virginians who care about children have a responsibility to say something if we
- 1:14:49see something. And that's what's missing, no question. Can I tell you
- 1:14:54what I think. And again, big supporter of homeschooling, I've seen a
- 1:14:59lot of the great results. I also believe and two things can be true.
- 1:15:01I think there are instances, and the question is how many instances where
- 1:15:05that a child, for whatever reason, is chronically absent and then there is
- 1:15:10a follow up, and maybe CPS is following up, following up, and
- 1:15:13in order to avoid any follow up, a parent or guardian or whomever takes
- 1:15:18that child out of school and says, I'm homeschooling them. And it's a
- 1:15:23way to get around a way to avoid CPS and a way to get around
- 1:15:28the whole truancy issue. I think that's happening. How much I don't know,
- 1:15:31but I guarantee it's happening. Your Greer disagree Bigger than that. I
- 1:15:34think we have child welfare issues that need to be addressed in those instances where
- 1:15:40a family doesn't believe they can meet the compulsory education attendance requirements they do that
- 1:15:47if they're not providing education to the child, that's wrong and that should show
- 1:15:51up when these reports are due. And if we're not tracking the reports,
- 1:15:56then we have no accountability at all. And really, an issue that involves
- 1:16:00abuse or the intent to harm children I think should be it should be addressed
- 1:16:05in the courthouse and not in the schoolhouse. So let's not put all this
- 1:16:11additional pressure on our public school system to be responsible for the health and welfare
- 1:16:15of all these children they just don't have in school or not. Yeah,
- 1:16:18and they say they don't have the personnel of the time to followup on the
- 1:16:20homeschool kids, So that's true, they don't. I think I think we
- 1:16:25can do more with our you know, as we've reconfigured DHHR now with the
- 1:16:30focus on the Department of Human Services, I think we can do more with
- 1:16:32child protective service, folks, And that's and that's where we should focus our
- 1:16:38time and effort. Yes, we should ask our state Department of Education and
- 1:16:42our county boards of education to try to get a handle on these reports so
- 1:16:45that we know what's going on. But again, we can't. We can't
- 1:16:47expect the school system to monitor all these issues of abuse and neglect across the
- 1:16:54state. To the extent that they see something, we want them to say
- 1:16:57something, But beyond that, we need child protective service. Senator Mike Alaverio,
- 1:17:00Republican, Montaglia and Marion County. He's a member of the Senate Education
- 1:17:05Committee, and whenever the wallmakers get together, probably in regular session, you
- 1:17:10would expect that some of these issues will be coming up. Mike, good
- 1:17:12to see you, Thanks for coming in. Thank you, Hobby all.
- 1:17:14I appreciate it. We're gonna take a break and come back. When you
- 1:17:15come back, We're going to do open phones, open texts for the rest
- 1:17:17of the way. One one hundred seven sixty five eight two five five text
- 1:17:23meet three oh four talk three oh four, three oh four talk three oh
- 1:17:26four, or one one hundred seven sixty five eight two five five open phones.
- 1:17:30This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia.
- 1:17:33At eleven thirty. Let's get a news update. Check in with the Metro
- 1:17:35News Radio Network. Final What's happening statewide this hour, all across the great
- 1:17:40State of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News. I'm Jeff Jenkins. State
- 1:17:45Transportation Secretary Jimmy Risten says it's time to do something about driving behavior in West
- 1:17:50Virginia. Ristin says new initiatives will soon come from the DOT aimed at teaching
- 1:17:56young people proper ways to drive in the years leading up to them getting their
- 1:18:00license. Ristin says he has a lofty goal that's worth going after, really
- 1:18:03focused on safety, particularly in our work zones. Now we are committed and
- 1:18:09we're going to We're going to get We're going to get results. We're going
- 1:18:12to take fatalities on our roads to zero. We're going to make sure that
- 1:18:15when accidents happen, when crashes happen, that people have a better chance to
- 1:18:21survive. Riskden making those comments on a recent edition of The Agencies on the
- 1:18:25podcast. There are several summer construction projects taking place on or about to take
- 1:18:30place on the eighty eight miles West Virginia Turnpike. West Virginia Parkway's Authority Executive
- 1:18:34Director Jeff Miller says the northern end of the turnpike needs some work. And
- 1:18:38then also before full facility, see at Shillion you'll see some work. It's
- 1:18:43being done right there for a staging area, and we've got to replace those
- 1:18:45bridge decks on the Catman Creek bridges. Also today on the Turnpike, the
- 1:18:49Bluestone Travel Plaza is totally closed. It's been open for fuel and parking in
- 1:18:54recent months as construction on a travel plaza headquarters gets underway. Now Cruise need
- 1:18:59all of that to finish the job. State Board of Education meeting today in
- 1:19:02Charleston. Board getting an update home work it's been doing to help improve operations
- 1:19:06in Logan Upshore in Hampshire Counties. You're listening to Metro News, the Voice
- 1:19:11of West Virginia. I was able to buy my first home using the VIA
- 1:19:15Home Loan Guarantee without having to put down a down payment. I was able
- 1:19:19to graduate from college using the post nine to eleven GI bill debt free.
- 1:19:25I was able to enroll in VIA healthcare, and I know that VIA is
- 1:19:31going to be there for me when I need it. My services then and
- 1:19:34my benefits are now. Get what you are visit choose dot Va dot gov.
- 1:19:39Not all veterans are eligible for the hyper amount of benefits mentioned it.
- 1:19:42The high school football season is fast approaching and you can get ready with video
- 1:19:45previews of your favorite teams now on the new Metro News TV app. Jo
- 1:19:49Percado will visit all fifty five collies this summer to get the latest on the
- 1:19:53upcoming season. Check out the free Season high and get all your favorite Metro
- 1:19:57News shows like Talk Line with Hobby Gurgibold, Sports Line with Tony and three
- 1:20:00Guys Before the Game free by downloading the new Metro News TV app on your
- 1:20:03smart TV or streaming device. You can now watch the Voice of West Virginia
- 1:20:08on the new Metro News TV app downloaded today. The City of Charleston's Rules
- 1:20:13and Ordnance Committee has a meeting schedule for this evening. Up for discussion two
- 1:20:16proposed ordinances that would lessen the penalties for a simple possession of marijuana. We
- 1:20:23are heading into the mid nineties today in many Mountain State communities. It looks
- 1:20:27like the current track of what's left of Hurricane Barrel will pass to our northwest
- 1:20:30on Wednesday. West Virginia could get some rain from the outer bands of that
- 1:20:35system. From the Metro News anchor desk, I'm Jeff Jenkins talk line from
- 1:20:58the in Cove Insurance Studios. It's in a number. If you match just
- 1:21:00six of twenty five correctly playing Cash twenty five from the West Virginia Lottery,
- 1:21:04you'll take them a top prize of twenty five thousand dollars. Drawings held Monday's,
- 1:21:08Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays. It only costs a dollar to play.
- 1:21:12With four drawings each week, the odds are pretty good. You're gonna
- 1:21:14have fun playing Cash twenty five. Once again. Happy to be back on
- 1:21:16in Parkersburg station switch there. We're now on WVAMAM fourteen fifty FM ninety eight
- 1:21:25point one in FM one oh seven point nine. Thanks to Sam Joho and
- 1:21:29Tom Taggart. Sam and Tom, thank you for joining the Metro News team.
- 1:21:33It's great to be on with you guys in Parkersburg. Open phones,
- 1:21:38open texts the rest of the way one one hundred and seven sixty five eight
- 1:21:41two five five text me three oh four talk three oh four, whatever you'd
- 1:21:45like to get into. You know what the issues of the day are.
- 1:21:47Jack, Good morning, What do you have for us? Good morning?
- 1:21:50Hell? You're talking about who the Democrats are gonna put in there to run
- 1:21:56for president. I believe it will be a black woman, and it won't
- 1:22:02be Paris. It'll be Michelle Obama and Hillary Clinton will be her VP.
- 1:22:11Why do you think that is? That? Is that who you want or
- 1:22:13that's as who you think it's going to be. No, I'd say Mark
- 1:22:17dis Dale. That's what's gonna happen. They gotta have the black vote,
- 1:22:20the woman vote, and I think that's who they'll put in Michelle Obama and
- 1:22:27Hillary Clinton. Got it. Appreciate the call. I have no idea if
- 1:22:31Biden steps aside, who would be there. You'd have to think you would
- 1:22:36start with Kamala Harri simply because she's the vice president female black? Do you
- 1:22:41want to kick her off the ticket? So you'd have to start there.
- 1:22:45In terms of a Hillary Clinton Michelle Obama, I don't see that for a
- 1:22:47couple of reasons. One is that I know that Michelle Obama might, as
- 1:22:50they say, win the press conference, but I mean she's certainly smart,
- 1:22:56but never held office before. So there's that and Hillary Clinton. If you're
- 1:23:02talking about the future and you're moving on from Biden, if you do that,
- 1:23:10then you need to think about you need to be oriented toward the future,
- 1:23:14and Hillary Clinton reminds you of the past. So I wouldn't think I
- 1:23:19understand what you're saying. I know there's people talk about all kinds of names.
- 1:23:24I would not think either one of those would be would be the choices
- 1:23:27if in fact Biden steps aside hobby A. I would like to see what
- 1:23:34in world these people are living in who think that Trump has the same cognitive
- 1:23:39decline as Joe Biden. Every day Trump is out in front of crowds of
- 1:23:43tens of thousands of people. At times, we're not seeing him lose train
- 1:23:45of thought randomly spounding out incorrect numbers. Weh he does that? I mean,
- 1:23:50or get lost trying to leave the stage. Yeah, the difference in
- 1:23:59cognitive abilities. Does Trump make mistakes? Yeah? But the difference in cognitive
- 1:24:05abilities was so blatant in the debate, just very very obvious. I mean,
- 1:24:14there's only three years difference between those two men. It looked like thirty
- 1:24:21um hoppy the media hiding the cognitive decline of the president proved what we always
- 1:24:28knew fake news. Where's the fact check on this? Says the texture Ibby.
- 1:24:35Welcome back the band from West Middle School in Morgantown on the way to
- 1:24:40play the national anthem at the Pirate game today at twelve thirty five, So
- 1:24:45proud says this father, well done. Hoppy. Has John Decker whined about
- 1:24:51not getting access to Trump or covered any of Trump's recent lunacy. Let's see,
- 1:25:02that's wepy. Every Democratic president has used the EPA as a tool to
- 1:25:10make law. Congress has given up the power and not wanting to upset their
- 1:25:15constituentsy the well. I have many times, particularly with the EPA, have
- 1:25:24argued that the EPA was exceeding its authority. And I think that Patrick Morrissey
- 1:25:30I don't think. I know that Patrick Morrissey prove that in court with the
- 1:25:35West Virginia versus EPA case about the Clean Power Plant rule. So I believe
- 1:25:41there have been many instances of that. And when you have a giant bureaucracy,
- 1:25:45when you have Congress writing laws that are at times ambiguous or as Morrissey
- 1:25:50said, may be written purposely in an ambiguous way so they don't get held
- 1:25:56accountable and leaving up to agencies. But again, there's another side to that
- 1:26:00coin, and the coin may be when a conservative, pro business administration is
- 1:26:08in and it pulls back on what regulatory agencies do. Then because this Chevron
- 1:26:15decision says it's going to be up to the courts, then are you inviting
- 1:26:20just mass and litigation three or four? Talk three or four. Let's see.
- 1:26:33I mean there are huge accountability issues with education in state of West Virginia,
- 1:26:36and many of them are at the public schools not held accountable for any
- 1:26:40of their actions either. The statistics that keep coming out are coming from board
- 1:26:45offices who financially benefit from destroying homeschooling in our state. This is not a
- 1:26:48fair representation of homeschooling in West Virginia. You don't ask competing radio stations what
- 1:26:54are your ratings? The oh, I'd be interested in what other rates.
- 1:27:00But okay, there is something wrong here. There is something wrong here,
- 1:27:10and I think that homeschoolers would acknowledge that if there are parents families who are
- 1:27:23really not operating in the best interests education of their children, that you wouldn't
- 1:27:28want them homeschooling, right, So there's something there. There is an issue
- 1:27:33there. I have no doubt there's an issue there, and I believe it
- 1:27:36has to do with accountability, and I think the state has a responsibility to
- 1:27:41hold homeschoolers accountable. Like Cindra A. Lavario say, it's a great point.
- 1:27:45Look, you're doing the job. You've separated yourself from the public schools.
- 1:27:50Maybe you're doing better into public schools. Here's our report. Just want
- 1:27:54to let you know everything's good here. Okay, fine, fine, but
- 1:27:59I will I will guarantee you. Now, I usually don't like to guarantee.
- 1:28:03I will guarantee you. There are instances, and the question is how
- 1:28:10many, So you need data. It's not one, it's not twenty thousand.
- 1:28:16Don't know what it is. There are many instances where children are being
- 1:28:21taken out of the public school to say they're going to be homeschooled. They're
- 1:28:27not part of any organization, not part of any group that's doing homeschooling the
- 1:28:30right way. They're just taking the kid out of school and not doing the
- 1:28:33job, not filing the reports, or if they're filing the reports, just
- 1:28:38getting a rubber stamp from the school system that that's happening, and that is
- 1:28:45then when that happens, because the state has a constitutional obligation to provide for
- 1:28:49a thorough, efficient free schools. When that happens, the state has an
- 1:28:54obligation to intercede. It does, and by the way, by law,
- 1:29:00an obligation to intercede. Although that law needs to be tightened up because right
- 1:29:03now the county if a if the standard's not met, then it just says
- 1:29:10that the superintendent may may follow Why may it should be? Shall it should
- 1:29:15be? Shall follow up? And I don't look. I know there's issues
- 1:29:25with public hid too, and we talk about that all the time too,
- 1:29:27every time test scores come out, or when we talk about attendance issues when
- 1:29:32you have you know, a third of kids are chronically absent, when you
- 1:29:36talk about teacher vacancy. So it's not as though we don't talk about those
- 1:29:41things. We do, and we we highlight them all the time. But
- 1:29:46we should not take our eye off of issues associated with quote unquote homeschooling.
- 1:29:53That's not being done right or there's no accountability by saying, well, the
- 1:29:56public schools are failing. That's not that again, and that's what about ism
- 1:30:00that I think undermines the ability to focus attention on issues associated with and I
- 1:30:08always hate to stay homeschooling because they're not getting any schooling up in there.
- 1:30:12Those who are not doing homeschooling in the best interest of their children Text three
- 1:30:21oh four Talk three oh four Iby. Before last week's vacation, you'd written
- 1:30:28that immigrants were not in West Virginia come to Morefield in Petersburg, where they're
- 1:30:31indentured servants. In my opinion, Pilgrim's Pride pays them to work but holds
- 1:30:35their money to pay their rent. I did point out that in that area
- 1:30:44is one of the areas of the state where there are a lot of immigrants
- 1:30:46comparatively speaking, and presumably they're working in the poultry industry there. Let's see
- 1:31:00i' BWAJR News reported hundreds of kids starved, abused physically and sexually. Big,
- 1:31:08I don't know that story. I kept up with the news. I
- 1:31:11don't know that story. I'py public schools do not have the personnel to address
- 1:31:16these homeschool issues. I support homeschooling, but as a public educator, it
- 1:31:19wouldn't be fair to blame us for these issues. I hope our legislators will
- 1:31:23listen to Mike. Well we end up. Here's what we end up with.
- 1:31:28The reports are supposed to be filed. Well, according to the early
- 1:31:30data, in most cases the reports aren't filed. So is that the parent
- 1:31:36is not submitting the report. Is that it's getting submitted but it's not being
- 1:31:42accounted for? Is it it's a state board office, they're not getting an
- 1:31:45accurate record of the report. Don't know, don't know. But it is
- 1:31:50legitimate to ask for accurate data. So if there, in fact there is
- 1:31:56an issue, which I suspect there is, that it can be addressed based
- 1:31:59on the data. I'll be right back. Stay with us. We can
- 1:32:02all agree that hearing aids are expensive. No more. Fruit Pharmacy now offers
- 1:32:06hearing aids at affordable pricing. You can find the perfect over the counter Nuva
- 1:32:11met hearing aid and you'll have money left over to go to a concert and
- 1:32:14put that new aid to the test. Choose from the digiear plus max Pro
- 1:32:18or Life. Not only are you saving hundreds of dollars, but you also
- 1:32:21get a one year warranty and Nuvomed has a forty five day money back guarantee.
- 1:32:27Visit your local fruth today for your next hearing, aid your hometown family
- 1:32:30pharmacy for over seventy years. Are you ready to make a difference in your
- 1:32:35community? Let ZOM Architects and engineers be your partner in progress, innovative designs
- 1:32:43and a collaborative approach. We're committed to creating inspiring spaces and improving the communities
- 1:32:48we serve, from cutting edge educational facilities to community centric gathering spaces. Together,
- 1:32:55we can design better environments for future generations. Because it's ZOLM, it's
- 1:33:00more than architecture. It's about building your legacy. You're listening to talk Line
- 1:33:04on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the
- 1:33:12Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million
- 1:33:16hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking
- 1:33:21down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. I show him
- 1:33:26he ran over to the edge of the field, and he made it about
- 1:33:29five ten yards out of the edge of the field and fell over there.
- 1:33:32Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the
- 1:33:36great outdoors. He stuck his head through the blind into where you were.
- 1:33:42Yeah. Yeah, well he had jumped, he leaped in okay the blinde
- 1:33:45Oh gosh, yeah, so he had his whole body was in the air
- 1:33:49for a couple of seconds and is the only thing that landed in the blind
- 1:33:54was, of course his head in his part leg. West Virginia Outdoors covers
- 1:33:58it all Saturday mornings at seven am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today
- 1:34:02brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and
- 1:34:05water every weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Hey
- 1:34:11everybody, it's Tony Courritti. I'm Greg Hunter and I'm Brad Howe, and
- 1:34:14we invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro News
- 1:34:17radio network. It's the City Net Statewide sports Line. We talk West Virginia
- 1:34:23University football, basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's got anything
- 1:34:27to do with the Golden Blue, we're on it. And don't forget the
- 1:34:30text line available every night. So we invite you to join us. The
- 1:34:32Senator Coach Hunter and me Tony Courritti it's the city net state wide sports line
- 1:34:38on Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you
- 1:34:43have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance
- 1:34:47to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening,
- 1:34:51become a Metro News hawk by texting news too three five sixty five to one.
- 1:34:56If you take a picture or video of what you see, submit that
- 1:35:00as well. Text the word news two three five sixty five one to submit
- 1:35:03your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive.
- 1:35:21Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by Incoca Insurance,
- 1:35:26encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in
- 1:35:30Coca dot com to learn more. Talk on from me in co Insurance studios.
- 1:35:33Mon Health's Heart Team covers every beat. Mon Health Medical Center is nationally
- 1:35:39recognized by the American College of Cardiology as the first and only hospital in West
- 1:35:43Virginia to be accredited for electrophysiology, the first in West Virginia, the twenty
- 1:35:48fourth in the country to receive the Heartcare Center National Distinction of Excellence among more
- 1:35:54awards. You know where to go for expert heartcare mon Health three h four
- 1:36:00talk three or four phone call one hundred and seven to sixty five eight two
- 1:36:03five five text hop you hope you had a good week. Glad to have
- 1:36:05you back in the big chair. Had a great week. We visited our
- 1:36:11son and his wife in Texas. They live outside of Austin in a about
- 1:36:16thirty minutes outside of Austin, a community of Bastrop. Nice little town and
- 1:36:21uh, you know if you want. I was teasing the rental car person.
- 1:36:26They said, oh, what's the purpose of your visit? And I
- 1:36:29said, well, we come to Texas in July for the weather. It
- 1:36:32was one hundred degrees and just brutally, brutally hot. I know it's hot
- 1:36:40here, but Texas hot is you know, it's hot, and there's a
- 1:36:44difference there. I know it's hot here. We've had a hot summer.
- 1:36:47Is that at least in West Virginia and doesn't get as hot as Texas.
- 1:36:51When you go outside in the morning, oh it's a little cool, you
- 1:36:55know, I mean there's some relief from the heat. I get up,
- 1:36:59like you know, six thirty or something, walk outside, it's hot.
- 1:37:02It's hot, like, oh my gosh, it's hot. So it was
- 1:37:09I mean, good visit with family, very nice, but it's brutally hot.
- 1:37:15Here's but I tell what we did. They were both my son and
- 1:37:17his wife. Our son and his wife were working some so one day we
- 1:37:21went to Austin went to the art museum. And I'm not a big art
- 1:37:29officionado. I mean, I like going to museums. I'm fine with going
- 1:37:34to art museums. My attention spans about two hours. But when it's unbearably
- 1:37:40hot, what a great place to go during the week. Not many people
- 1:37:45there, clean bathrooms and great air conditioning. Oh yeah, and there's also
- 1:37:49art you can look at. Not very crowded, clean bathrooms, always great
- 1:37:57air conditioning. My endorsement of art museums. Happy Michelle Obauma and Hillary.
- 1:38:04What was that guy smoking? I think he was offering up what maybe some
- 1:38:08people think might happen. I certainly don't think that would happen. Happy.
- 1:38:13The three letter agencies all use experts that have conflicts of interest. It is
- 1:38:17hard to take advice from an expert that gets their funding from the company that
- 1:38:21they're giving you information on hoppy you're educated. You know darn well that Trump
- 1:38:29has no clue about anything he talks about or any questions that's asked of him.
- 1:38:35Of him not fit to be president. Well, I've said, just
- 1:38:41for the record, I do not believe that he is qualified or fit to
- 1:38:45be president because of his continued denial of the legitimate outcome of the twenty twenty
- 1:38:48election, and because that he inspired the events of January sixth, which I
- 1:38:56think is one of the darkest days in her country's history. Frankly so,
- 1:39:00for that and other reasons, I do not believe he is qualified. I
- 1:39:03think he is disqualified from being the president of the United States again. But
- 1:39:09that's that's just my opinion. This isn't about the focus now has been on
- 1:39:13Biden, which I think is legitimate. This isn't about well, why aren't
- 1:39:16you talking about Trump? Well, that's pretty well established. Okay. This
- 1:39:21is relatively new with Biden. I know some of you you're saying, where
- 1:39:26have you been for the last four years or whatever. Biden now isn't like
- 1:39:30Biden twenty twenty. Biden twenty twenty was like the uncle that sometimes got a
- 1:39:34little confused. This is different. This is different. I think if you
- 1:39:39look at it objectively, you acknowledge that this is different Hopy. I wish
- 1:39:45everybody would quit calling for President Biden step aside. The way it is now
- 1:39:48Trump has him beat hands down. That's when a Trump supporter. Look,
- 1:39:55the Trump supporter says, happy of homes school families do not want government oversight.
- 1:40:00They should not receive government funding through the Hope Scholarship. I believe the
- 1:40:04government has Look what is the government. The government is the people. The
- 1:40:10people then are the government. That's us. It really to me isn't separate.
- 1:40:15And there there is a net benefit in having an educated populace. It
- 1:40:26is better for the state. It is better for the people of the state
- 1:40:30if we have an educated populace. And therefore, as per the Constitution,
- 1:40:35the state has a responsibility to ensure that we have an educated populace. I
- 1:40:42don't care whether they're homeschooled or in the public schools. And critically, we
- 1:40:46have issues in the public schools as well, that we have a responsibility to
- 1:40:50ensure that we're doing a good job on that front. Hobbies that do we
- 1:40:58have homeschool kids playing sports with no grade checks, I don't know. I
- 1:41:02can't micro down to that level. I really don't know. I mean,
- 1:41:05I'm trying to stick with the data that I've received on this and hope that
- 1:41:12lawmakers are interested as well, and we'll take a close look at it.
- 1:41:18HAPI, You and Michael Tamaski failed to mention that in between the glory of
- 1:41:23Rome and Biden, there was Trump and Johnson, Truman and Johnson. Happy.
- 1:41:30You're spot on with the homeschooling issues. It's all the above that you
- 1:41:34just mentioned that would help with accountability. Happy lots of talk about winning the
- 1:41:45election, but I think there is a national security problem right in front of
- 1:41:48us. Appy. I think a no vote for anyone is not good for
- 1:41:57either party. Is there someone they could put in that you'd vote for,
- 1:42:00I don't know, without just I don't know who is it. I don't
- 1:42:04know, and I reserve the right. Look, my vote candidly isn't going
- 1:42:13to make a bit of difference in West Virginia. It will not make a
- 1:42:15bit of It might make a difference in the county commission race, but the
- 1:42:19local deliate race not gonna make a bit of difference in the president's race.
- 1:42:23Therefore, it represents a philosophical view on my part, and therefore I reserve
- 1:42:29the right not to vote for any of the above in the race for president.
- 1:42:32We'll be right back. Stay with us. Winning the lottery would be
- 1:42:35the start of my race dream. Hitting the open road at top speeds,
- 1:42:39hugging turns. It's intense. Are you dreaming of racing again? Not dreaming?
- 1:42:50I'm practicing and I'm checking my tickets. It's a lower, It's a
- 1:42:55dream. West Virginia Lottery. What if it could happen to you? Please
- 1:43:02pay responsibly. The high school football season is fast approaching, and you can
- 1:43:06get ready with video previews of your favorite teams now on the new Metro News
- 1:43:12TV app. Joe Percado will visit all fifty five Collies this summer to get
- 1:43:15the latest on the upcoming season. Check out the preseason height and get all
- 1:43:18your favorite Metro News shows like Talkline with Hopy Kerchivall, sports Line with Tony
- 1:43:21Coredi and three Guys Before the Game free by downloading the new Metro News TV
- 1:43:26app on your smart TV or streaming device. You can now watch the Voice
- 1:43:30of West Virginia on the new Metro News TV app. Download it today.
- 1:43:34This is talk Line on Metro News The voice of West Virginia. Wv metronews
- 1:43:42dot com the only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain State.
- 1:43:45Get the latest news and sports story, information on the great outdoors, and
- 1:43:49never miss an episode of your favorite Metro news programs and podcast including Talkline,
- 1:43:56Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a book
- 1:44:00now and visit dou WV metronews dot com first thing every morning to find out
- 1:44:03what's happening all across the state. WV metronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors
- 1:44:11is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than
- 1:44:15quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has
- 1:44:19been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years stockfish for
- 1:44:25repatriation purposes. So that's reintroduction, re establishment of Brookshrout and two of those
- 1:44:30streams, the oldest that we have worked on, the earliest ones that we
- 1:44:33started putting fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in both of those streams,
- 1:44:38whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the
- 1:44:43great outdoors. It was a pretty good flight. It taked me about ten
- 1:44:45minutes to get it in. My dad actually had to run to the truck
- 1:44:50and grab a Natclus there's my way. I could list him up over top
- 1:44:54of the rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh
- 1:44:58six am, your daily fix. Outdoors Today brings you two and a half
- 1:45:01minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro
- 1:45:06News, the Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to
- 1:45:11wrap up your weekend. It's the City Net Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey,
- 1:45:15this is Travis Joes joining myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six
- 1:45:17oh six until eight o'clock. As we wrap up the sports weekend, we
- 1:45:20talk Mountaineers, high school, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the
- 1:45:25national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or
- 1:45:29text the show at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect
- 1:45:32weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro News affiliate, or watch the show
- 1:45:36at wv metronews dot com. This reminder, your employees are your frontline heroes
- 1:45:55and cybersecurity. Get with citty net and get them started on regular training to
- 1:46:00spot and stop those bad guys. Remember sitting that connects, protects perfects.
- 1:46:02Learn more at sittynet dot net. Time is time. Let me get Dave
- 1:46:05in here. Hey, Dave, only got a minute, but take your
- 1:46:08best shot. I'm listening David Walmsley here, Yeah, listen. I've been
- 1:46:12a school psychologist all over West Virginia. A lot of people that do homeschool
- 1:46:15don't understand that sometimes children have learning deficits. And I'll give you some free
- 1:46:19advice. If your job's struggling with something, go back to a lower level
- 1:46:25so that they can have approximately seventy percent chance of success. And there are
- 1:46:29a lot of people who do a great job with homeschooling, but there are
- 1:46:31a lot of people who do it to take their kid out of school because
- 1:46:34they don't want to deal with the stress of school. Their kid may not
- 1:46:38be achieving, or they have personal problems. And you've done a great forum
- 1:46:44for this topic. We need much more discussion and more investigation and data.
- 1:46:48So I appreciate you taking my call and keep up doing a good job.
- 1:46:51Thank you, Dave. I appreciate that. And Dave listening in our new
- 1:46:55stations in Parkersburg WVAMAM fourteen fifty ninety eight point one FM one oh seven point
- 1:47:01nine the leadership there of Sam Joho and Tom Taggart. Thank you guys for
- 1:47:06being part of the Metro News team, and thank you Dave for the call.
- 1:47:12We will regroup tomorrow morning at ten oh six. See you then.
- 1:47:15Keep up with the news of the day at our website at wv metronews dot
- 1:47:17com. This has been talk line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia.