Latest / Dispatches from the Race War Podcast / Episode 31: Reflections on Zionism on Indigenous Peoples’ Day
Transcript
- 0:00[music]
- 0:35SPEAKER_00: How the hell are y'all gonna heal, be made whole?
- 0:38SPEAKER_01: Well, it is Indigenous People's Day,
- 0:40SPEAKER_01: as you know,
- 0:41SPEAKER_01: and it seems like a good day to have a conversation about Zionism, because...
- 0:50SPEAKER_01: On a day like today,
- 0:52SPEAKER_01: those who defend Zionism will often use this concept of indigeneity
- 0:59SPEAKER_01: to justify Jewish not only return to the land of Palestine,
- 1:06SPEAKER_01: to Israel,
- 1:07SPEAKER_01: as they would have it,
- 1:09SPEAKER_01: but they will use the concept of indigeneity as the moral,
- 1:14SPEAKER_01: ethical,
- 1:16SPEAKER_01: and I guess even one might say legal basis of for the creation of the Jewish state
- 1:22SPEAKER_01: and the justification for that above and beyond the rights that any other peoples,
- 1:28SPEAKER_01: including Palestinians themselves, might possess.
- 1:33SPEAKER_01: They will say, well,
- 1:34SPEAKER_01: we are the indigenous peoples of that land,
- 1:38SPEAKER_01: stretching back thousands of years, we have the right to be there.
- 1:42SPEAKER_01: And they will use that argument to deflect,
- 1:46SPEAKER_01: for instance,
- 1:46SPEAKER_01: from the Reliance on biblical arguments because they realize,
- 1:52SPEAKER_01: at least the secular folks within the Jewish community,
- 1:55SPEAKER_01: they realize that to rely on scripture,
- 1:59SPEAKER_01: to rely on Torah,
- 2:01SPEAKER_01: is a pretty unseemly argument when you're trying to convince people that you are not
- 2:06SPEAKER_01: in fact setting up a theocracy.
- 2:09SPEAKER_01: And the fact is most of us in the Jewish community,
- 2:11SPEAKER_01: certainly in the United States, are pretty secular.
- 2:15SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 2:16SPEAKER_01: most of us in the American Jewish community are not particularly observant
- 2:21SPEAKER_01: and even those who are generally do not try to come across as overly reliant
- 2:32SPEAKER_01: on scriptural bases for the things that we do or justify in terms
- 2:39SPEAKER_01: of governmental policy because we know that it really sort of strikes
- 2:42SPEAKER_01: the certainly American ear as pretty untoward.
- 2:46SPEAKER_01: And so one way to get around that, right,
- 2:48SPEAKER_01: one way to get around sounding like you're setting up a theocracy or trying
- 2:53SPEAKER_01: to justify your state on the basis of what God did or did not say in an ancient book
- 2:59SPEAKER_01: as interpreted by your spiritual and religious leaders is to say,
- 3:04SPEAKER_01: well, we're not talking about the Bible.
- 3:06SPEAKER_01: We're not talking about the Torah.
- 3:08SPEAKER_01: We're not talking about a religious text at all.
- 3:12SPEAKER_01: We are talking about indigeneity.
- 3:14SPEAKER_01: It is an ancestral religion.
- 3:16SPEAKER_01: Lineage, it is an ancestral inheritance that we're talking about.
- 3:21SPEAKER_01: So I figured on Indigenous People's Day, it's a good day to talk about that.
- 3:26SPEAKER_01: So let's talk about it.
- 3:27SPEAKER_01: First of all,
- 3:29SPEAKER_01: it is worth noting that,
- 3:31SPEAKER_01: and I want to say this because there is a lot of misinformation bouncing around
- 3:38SPEAKER_01: the internet.
- 3:39SPEAKER_01: Imagine that.
- 3:41SPEAKER_01: I'm sure that'll shock you.
- 3:43SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 3:44SPEAKER_01: it is easy to spread bullshit on the internet,
- 3:48SPEAKER_01: memes and unsourced information or badly sourced information.
- 3:54SPEAKER_01: And it spreads very,
- 3:55SPEAKER_01: very quickly,
- 3:56SPEAKER_01: oftentimes because it, you know, sort of, I guess, you know, fits with our priors.
- 4:03SPEAKER_01: And if it fits with our prior assumptions and reinforces our prior assumptions,
- 4:07SPEAKER_01: we run with it, we spread it.
- 4:09SPEAKER_01: And before it can be corrected, it's out there and millions of people are seeing it.
- 4:12SPEAKER_00: So there's a lot of folks out there whose anti-Zionism has led them to spread
- 4:19SPEAKER_01: the idea that modern Jews,
- 4:24SPEAKER_01: particularly Ashkenazi Jews,
- 4:26SPEAKER_01: who are about half of all Jews in the world today,
- 4:31SPEAKER_01: and certainly the majority of American Jews,
- 4:34SPEAKER_01: have literally no or virtually no Genetic connection or biological connection
- 4:42SPEAKER_01: or ancestral connection at all to the Levant, to that region.
- 4:49SPEAKER_01: And they will base some of it on thoroughly unsourced or fabricated footnotes
- 4:57SPEAKER_01: that claim to be genetic research that say,
- 5:00SPEAKER_01: see, there's no genetic, modern Jews have no genes from the Levant.
- 5:04SPEAKER_01: And that's just not true.
- 5:08SPEAKER_01: Sometimes it's the guys who stand on the corners in New York City from
- 5:11SPEAKER_01: the black Hebrew Israelites and claim to be the real Jews and,
- 5:16SPEAKER_01: you know, scream at white folks and call them crackers and all that fun stuff.
- 5:22SPEAKER_01: And, you know, they're fun.
- 5:24SPEAKER_01: They're fun.
- 5:25SPEAKER_01: They're fun people.
- 5:27SPEAKER_01: They are entertaining, I have to say.
- 5:29SPEAKER_01: And
- 5:31SPEAKER_01: I just want to point out,
- 5:33SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 5:34SPEAKER_01: I'm anti-Zionist,
- 5:35SPEAKER_01: as you all know,
- 5:36SPEAKER_01: and I'm going to make that exceedingly clear here in a second
- 5:39SPEAKER_01: if you don't already know it.
- 5:40SPEAKER_01: But it is really important that in our desire to debunk the rationales for Zionism
- 5:50SPEAKER_01: and to critique Zionism and to invalidate Zionism,
- 5:54SPEAKER_01: that we don't make stupid fucking arguments.
- 5:58SPEAKER_00: Okay?
- 5:58SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 5:59SPEAKER_01: I mean, I don't mean to be an asshole, but just don't make stupid fucking arguments.
- 6:04SPEAKER_01: If your arguments rely on the whole Kajar conversion theory
- 6:12SPEAKER_01: that has principally been popularized by neo-Nazis,
- 6:18SPEAKER_01: you know, you're probably doing it wrong.
- 6:21SPEAKER_01: You're probably doing it wrong.
- 6:24SPEAKER_01: If your whole fucking basis...
- 6:27SPEAKER_01: Your anti-Zionism is about some Turkish conversion theory.
- 6:34SPEAKER_01: The Kajar conversion theory.
- 6:35SPEAKER_01: That's your whole fucking thing.
- 6:38SPEAKER_01: And that theory is principally been spread by Nazis.
- 6:42SPEAKER_01: Like literally by neo-Nazis and overt white supremacists.
- 6:45SPEAKER_01: And yes, I know Arthur Kessler, Shlomo Sand, please don't fucking waste my time.
- 6:50SPEAKER_01: I know.
- 6:52SPEAKER_01: But the people who have popularized it have been Nazis, and there's a reason for that.
- 6:58SPEAKER_01: And the genetic research has already debunked the two Jews who have said it, so whatever.
- 7:06SPEAKER_01: But it's been popularized by Nazis.
- 7:09SPEAKER_01: And you can always find a couple of Jews to hold up as the ones who have said it.
- 7:13SPEAKER_01: But when Nazis start pointing to Kessler and Sand and say,
- 7:17SPEAKER_01: look, we found Jews who believe it too, it doesn't...
- 7:20SPEAKER_01: That's not it.
- 7:21SPEAKER_01: That's not the way.
- 7:22SPEAKER_01: That's just not it, guys.
- 7:23SPEAKER_01: Okay?
- 7:25SPEAKER_01: You don't need to argue the Qajar shit to debunk Zionism.
- 7:31SPEAKER_01: You don't have to argue that the Jews are not really the Jews.
- 7:36SPEAKER_01: They're actually all Turkish converts in order to delegitimize Israel.
- 7:41SPEAKER_01: I don't know why some of y'all feel that you have to go out of your way
- 7:46SPEAKER_01: to make this stupid fucking argument to delegitimize what Israel is doing and
- 7:51SPEAKER_01: to delegitimize Zionism.
- 7:53SPEAKER_01: It seems...
- 7:54SPEAKER_01: Wacky to me.
- 7:56SPEAKER_01: It seems wacky to me.
- 7:57SPEAKER_01: And in fact,
- 7:58SPEAKER_01: the reason the Nazis do it is because they don't actually use that argument
- 8:03SPEAKER_01: to delegitimize Zionism.
- 8:05SPEAKER_01: You do realize the reason that they make that argument is because they're doing it
- 8:10SPEAKER_01: to attack Jews.
- 8:11SPEAKER_01: Like, they use that argument not even as an anti-Zionist argument.
- 8:16SPEAKER_01: They use that argument as a way to basically...
- 8:20SPEAKER_01: Do anti-Semitism, right?
- 8:22SPEAKER_01: That's basically a way to say the Jews are imposters.
- 8:25SPEAKER_01: They're liars.
- 8:26SPEAKER_01: They're evil.
- 8:28SPEAKER_01: That's who they are.
- 8:29SPEAKER_01: They're pretenders.
- 8:31SPEAKER_01: And you shouldn't trust them.
- 8:32SPEAKER_01: Like, do you see?
- 8:33SPEAKER_01: I know that's not Kessler's reason for doing it.
- 8:36SPEAKER_01: I know that's not Shlomo Sands' reason for doing it.
- 8:39SPEAKER_01: Like,
- 8:40SPEAKER_01: Shlomo Sands' motivation for doing it is he's secular and he was trying to debunk
- 8:46SPEAKER_01: The chosen people bullshit.
- 8:49SPEAKER_01: And I respect that because I never liked the chosen people shit like the biblical shit.
- 8:54SPEAKER_01: And so he's trying to say, like, we're not really these people.
- 8:57SPEAKER_01: And so we can, like, ignore all the God shit.
- 9:00SPEAKER_01: Like, I got respect for that.
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: Much love for that.
- 9:03SPEAKER_01: But, I mean,
- 9:04SPEAKER_01: do you really need to come up with a Kajar conversion theory to say that
- 9:09SPEAKER_01: an internally contradictory scripture is bullshit?
- 9:15SPEAKER_01: Really?
- 9:16SPEAKER_01: And the genetic research now proves that Sand is wrong.
- 9:20SPEAKER_01: And Arthur Kessler was wrong.
- 9:22SPEAKER_01: So, just stop making dumb arguments, alright?
- 9:25SPEAKER_01: Let's get back to the actual business at hand.
- 9:28SPEAKER_01: The fact is, there are...
- 9:32SPEAKER_01: Genetic and ancestral ties between modern Jews and the Levant.
- 9:38SPEAKER_01: They are not as strong as the Zionists indicate or argue,
- 9:43SPEAKER_01: and they are not relevant,
- 9:45SPEAKER_01: that's the more important point, to the debate about Zionism.
- 9:49SPEAKER_01: They are not relevant to the issue of Zionism and the state of Israel,
- 9:55SPEAKER_01: but they are real to some extent.
- 10:00SPEAKER_01: Currently, here's what the research says, by the way.
- 10:05SPEAKER_01: First off,
- 10:05SPEAKER_01: Ashkenazi Jews, again,
- 10:06SPEAKER_01: about half of all Jews in the world,
- 10:09SPEAKER_01: and certainly the majority of American Jews,
- 10:11SPEAKER_01: the overwhelming majority of American Jews,
- 10:15SPEAKER_01: descend from about 350 people,
- 10:18SPEAKER_01: according to the most recent research that has been done.
- 10:21SPEAKER_01: There was a bottleneck,
- 10:23SPEAKER_01: genetic bottleneck,
- 10:25SPEAKER_01: About 600 to 800 years ago,
- 10:29SPEAKER_01: and all modern Ashkenazi Jews descend from those 350 people.
- 10:35SPEAKER_01: Those 350 people lived in Europe.
- 10:40SPEAKER_01: Now that doesn't mean that Ashkenazi Jews don't have genetic material,
- 10:47SPEAKER_01: however, and ancestry dating back to the Levant.
- 10:51SPEAKER_01: It just means that the bottleneck Those 350 people,
- 10:55SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 10:56SPEAKER_01: carried DNA on both the paternal line and the mitochondrial line from the mother,
- 11:04SPEAKER_01: at least some of which did,
- 11:06SPEAKER_01: in fact, date back to the Middle East, quote-unquote, to the Levant.
- 11:12SPEAKER_01: And the DNA of those 350 people was indeed a mix of so-called Middle Eastern
- 11:19SPEAKER_01: and European genetic material.
- 11:23SPEAKER_01: What the research seems to indicate is that the male lines,
- 11:28SPEAKER_01: the male DNA of most modern Ashkenazi Jews appears to stretch back to that region.
- 11:41SPEAKER_01: But most of the mitochondrial DNA,
- 11:45SPEAKER_01: that is to say the female line,
- 11:50SPEAKER_01: a disproportionate share of that Appears to be from Europe.
- 11:54SPEAKER_01: And what that suggests is that when Jewish men left the Levant and came into Europe,
- 12:04SPEAKER_01: they intermingled with non-Jewish women who converted to Judaism so that
- 12:13SPEAKER_01: when they had children and then they had children and they had children,
- 12:16SPEAKER_01: there was genetic change.
- 12:19SPEAKER_01: Material being passed down that was not from the Levant, right?
- 12:22SPEAKER_01: So now you've got mixture, right?
- 12:24SPEAKER_01: So this is why we can say that there's connection to the Levant, but it is not exclusively that.
- 12:32SPEAKER_01: There is also European,
- 12:35SPEAKER_01: non- quote-unquote Middle Eastern,
- 12:37SPEAKER_01: if you will,
- 12:38SPEAKER_01: non-North African,
- 12:39SPEAKER_01: non-Asia Minor, whatever you want to call it, non-Levantine genetic ancestry.
- 12:46SPEAKER_01: I also want to point out, however...
- 12:48SPEAKER_01: That the extent of Levantine genetic admixture is also going to be dictated even on
- 12:57SPEAKER_01: the male line
- 13:01SPEAKER_01: by the extent to which you have four Jewish grandparents.
- 13:07SPEAKER_01: Because when these studies have been done,
- 13:12SPEAKER_01: they've usually been done in Jewish families With four Jewish grandparents.
- 13:18SPEAKER_01: And so, in other words,
- 13:21SPEAKER_01: if you're looking at Jewish families,
- 13:23SPEAKER_01: modern Jewish American,
- 13:24SPEAKER_01: American Jewish families that have four Jewish grandparents,
- 13:26SPEAKER_01: these are families that in all likelihood have not intermingled or intermarried
- 13:32SPEAKER_01: at any point going back,
- 13:34SPEAKER_01: or at least at very few points,
- 13:35SPEAKER_01: if any, going back generations, generations, generations, right?
- 13:39SPEAKER_01: Hundreds of years, perhaps ever.
- 13:42SPEAKER_01: And of course,
- 13:43SPEAKER_01: it's true that within the Jewish community,
- 13:46SPEAKER_01: there is not a lot historically until relatively recently,
- 13:50SPEAKER_01: there was not a lot of intermarriage.
- 13:53SPEAKER_01: It's really been a phenomenon that only begins to become common in the last,
- 13:58SPEAKER_01: let's say, 100 years.
- 14:01SPEAKER_01: Really, in the last century.
- 14:02SPEAKER_01: And so when you study Jewish families that have four Jewish grandparents,
- 14:07SPEAKER_01: that's when you have a significant likelihood of ancestry dating back to the Levant.
- 14:14SPEAKER_01: But the reality is that in this country today,
- 14:16SPEAKER_01: in the United States,
- 14:17SPEAKER_01: many of us, myself included, don't have four Jewish grandparents.
- 14:24SPEAKER_01: Many of us only have two.
- 14:26SPEAKER_01: And many of us only have one.
- 14:28SPEAKER_01: I only had one Jewish grandparent because my father married a non-Jewish woman
- 14:33SPEAKER_01: and his father married a non-Jewish woman.
- 14:36SPEAKER_01: And that is not a...
- 14:38SPEAKER_01: A rare story among American Jews born in the late 1960s,
- 14:43SPEAKER_01: let's say early 1970s, who are now in our mid to late 50s.
- 14:48SPEAKER_01: That's not a rare story.
- 14:50SPEAKER_01: And it probably became even more common throughout the 1970s
- 14:55SPEAKER_01: to have only perhaps one Jewish grandparent,
- 14:58SPEAKER_01: because you get a couple of generations of intermarriage.
- 15:00SPEAKER_01: And by the way, then I married a non-Jewish woman.
- 15:04SPEAKER_01: Now, we had daughters, so the male line ends there.
- 15:08SPEAKER_01: But if we had had a son, that would have been another example.
- 15:12SPEAKER_01: That would have been three generations of intermarriage,
- 15:15SPEAKER_01: which would have reduced even further, potentially, had he had a son.
- 15:19SPEAKER_01: You see what I'm saying?
- 15:20SPEAKER_01: There would have been even less of the...
- 15:23SPEAKER_01: Yes, Ashkenazi Jews can trace their DNA back to that region,
- 15:27SPEAKER_01: but for those who are trying to make a claim of indigeneity,
- 15:29SPEAKER_01: it is at best a claim of indigeneity.
- 15:45SPEAKER_01: That only exists on typically one side of the family, that is coming from the male line.
- 15:54SPEAKER_01: And in the modern era,
- 15:56SPEAKER_01: it is oftentimes going to be the case that a lot of modern American Ashkenazi Jews,
- 16:01SPEAKER_01: just for example...
- 16:03SPEAKER_01: Are only going to be able to claim any Jewish ancestry on one fourth of one's family
- 16:09SPEAKER_01: or one half.
- 16:10SPEAKER_01: So how do we determine just how indigenous we are when we're trying to say,
- 16:14SPEAKER_01: oh, you have a claim to the land.
- 16:16SPEAKER_01: Oh, Tim, you know, you have the right of return.
- 16:19SPEAKER_01: You're Jewish and you have the right to go back to Israel as an indigenous person.
- 16:23SPEAKER_01: How indigenous am I really?
- 16:25SPEAKER_01: I mean, one-fourth,
- 16:27SPEAKER_01: even if you say I am,
- 16:29SPEAKER_01: how am I more indigenous than a Palestinian whose family's been there
- 16:33SPEAKER_01: for generations, unbroken, and was never diasporan?
- 16:38SPEAKER_01: Whether or not,
- 16:39SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 16:40SPEAKER_01: it was just for my family at some point,
- 16:45SPEAKER_01: however long ago my ancestors to have been put into diaspora, assuming...
- 16:51SPEAKER_01: That we can trace them back that far.
- 16:52SPEAKER_01: And I don't know that we can.
- 16:54SPEAKER_01: I don't know that we can.
- 16:55SPEAKER_01: I haven't done the 23andMe to even find out.
- 17:00SPEAKER_01: But even if we can trace ourselves back to that general region,
- 17:04SPEAKER_01: to what extent can I,
- 17:07SPEAKER_01: for instance,
- 17:08SPEAKER_01: as a one-quarter Jewish person,
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: say, well, I am indigenous relative to someone who was never indigenous.
- 17:15SPEAKER_01: That seems to me a pretty sort of absurd argument.
- 17:17SPEAKER_01: And given the fact that Judaism traditionally confers
- 17:36SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 17:56SPEAKER_01: Because of intermarriage,
- 17:58SPEAKER_01: that would seem to suggest that in the way that is most likely to confer Jewishness,
- 18:03SPEAKER_01: there are an awful lot of quote-unquote Jewish people who wouldn't be Jewish by
- 18:06SPEAKER_01: that standard.
- 18:07SPEAKER_01: So then how do we figure out indigeneity, right?
- 18:09SPEAKER_01: Does that complicate the consideration at all?
- 18:12SPEAKER_01: You see, it's not as straightforward as one might think.
- 18:16SPEAKER_01: But I guess the bigger point is we're certainly not indigenous in any recent sense.
- 18:21SPEAKER_01: And if you're trying to say that our historic indigeneity going back thousands
- 18:26SPEAKER_01: of years somehow gives us some right to that land,
- 18:29SPEAKER_01: how do you weigh that against the right of indigenous Palestinians
- 18:35SPEAKER_01: who have also been there for at least as long,
- 18:37SPEAKER_01: if not longer, and more unbroken lives?
- 18:41SPEAKER_01: And by the way,
- 18:42SPEAKER_01: that genetic research that has been done also indicates
- 18:46SPEAKER_01: that we are closely related genetically.
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: Those of us who are Jews and can trace some of our ancestry back to the Levant,
- 18:55SPEAKER_01: those who can are in fact genetically very closely related genetically.
- 19:03SPEAKER_01: So if we are closely related to them,
- 19:06SPEAKER_01: such that we are in effect genetic cousins,
- 19:09SPEAKER_01: who the hell are we to treat them the way that we're treating them?
- 19:11SPEAKER_01: We're both then indigenous.
- 19:13SPEAKER_01: We both have the same claim in that regard.
- 19:16SPEAKER_01: So now we're just back to God.
- 19:18SPEAKER_01: Now see all those people that are trying to use the indigenous argument to get out
- 19:22SPEAKER_01: of the God argument, now you're just back to God again.
- 19:25SPEAKER_01: Now you just got to go back to God and you sound like a zealot again
- 19:28SPEAKER_01: because genetically, scientifically, right?
- 19:32SPEAKER_01: We got the same basic DNA.
- 19:34SPEAKER_01: Those of us who can trace ourselves back to the extent that we can are no more able
- 19:40SPEAKER_01: to do so than the Palestinians.
- 19:42SPEAKER_01: So that's a draw, in other words.
- 19:43SPEAKER_01: That's a wash.
- 19:45SPEAKER_01: To whatever extent we can make that argument,
- 19:47SPEAKER_01: it's a wash. And so now all you got is God again and you sound like a nut, right?
- 19:52SPEAKER_01: Next point.
- 19:53SPEAKER_01: Indigeneity,
- 19:54SPEAKER_01: even to the extent you can claim it,
- 19:56SPEAKER_01: even to the extent it's a real argument,
- 19:58SPEAKER_01: it still doesn't speak to whether you have the right to create a state.
- 20:03SPEAKER_01: That extends special rights to you above and beyond others who are also in that space.
- 20:09SPEAKER_01: Just because you're indigenous and have a right to be in
- 20:12SPEAKER_01: a particular space doesn't confer rights to create a governmental structure
- 20:18SPEAKER_01: that provides to you special rights above and beyond others.
- 20:22SPEAKER_01: The right to abuse and treat people like shit.
- 20:26SPEAKER_01: The right to take their land.
- 20:27SPEAKER_01: The right to take their property.
- 20:28SPEAKER_01: The right to abuse them.
- 20:30SPEAKER_01: That doesn't come from indigeneity.
- 20:33SPEAKER_01: So even if indigeneity would give you the right to say,
- 20:36SPEAKER_01: for instance, I have a right to come back to this space and to be on this space.
- 20:41SPEAKER_01: And Palestinians, as indigenous to that land, would also have that right.
- 20:45SPEAKER_01: It's a small area of land that would require these two indigenous peoples
- 20:51SPEAKER_01: to figure out a way to live on that land together.
- 20:54SPEAKER_01: And that would mean one state.
- 20:56SPEAKER_01: That would mean one bi-national state with rights, equal rights for everyone.
- 21:01SPEAKER_01: Just because you have indigenous claim...
- 21:05SPEAKER_01: And someone else has indigenous claim.
- 21:07SPEAKER_01: You don't have a right to set up a state then as an indigenous people that limits
- 21:11SPEAKER_01: the rights and claims of other indigenous people.
- 21:14SPEAKER_01: If you have multiple people who are indigenous to an area,
- 21:17SPEAKER_01: even if you're the only group that's indigenous to an area,
- 21:20SPEAKER_01: by the way,
- 21:20SPEAKER_01: you don't have the right to set up a governmental structure
- 21:23SPEAKER_01: that oppresses other people.
- 21:25SPEAKER_01: I don't think we would say,
- 21:26SPEAKER_01: for instance,
- 21:26SPEAKER_01: that indigenous Native North Americans who have obviously a right to this land
- 21:32SPEAKER_01: that we're on, They might claim the right to get land back, absolutely.
- 21:36SPEAKER_01: And that should happen.
- 21:39SPEAKER_01: They might claim the right to certain...
- 21:53SPEAKER_01: They wouldn't make an argument that because of their indigeneity,
- 21:57SPEAKER_01: they have the right to set up a governmental structure where they would run
- 22:00SPEAKER_01: the entire country and have the right to oppress and marginalize the rest of us.
- 22:05SPEAKER_01: They wouldn't think of doing that.
- 22:06SPEAKER_01: That's not their goal.
- 22:08SPEAKER_01: They wouldn't do that.
- 22:09SPEAKER_01: That's not what indigenous people clamor for.
- 22:12SPEAKER_01: Their rights do not confer upon them the right to marginalize and oppress others.
- 22:16SPEAKER_01: So even with a claim of indigeneity,
- 22:19SPEAKER_01: that doesn't say anything about the creation of the state structure
- 22:24SPEAKER_01: that Israel has created.
- 22:25SPEAKER_01: But here's the final argument, and I've saved it to the end.
- 22:31SPEAKER_01: This is the clencher, and I hope you've stayed with this.
- 22:35SPEAKER_01: This is the final argument because it really is the one that puts to bed any logic
- 22:42SPEAKER_01: of the indigeneity claim for Zionism.
- 22:46SPEAKER_01: If you're going to argue that Jews have a right to the land
- 22:51SPEAKER_01: of Palestine slash Israel because of our so-called indigeneity,
- 22:58SPEAKER_01: you're going to have to explain that How it is that the law of return and the way
- 23:08SPEAKER_01: that citizenship operates in Israel extends to converts.
- 23:14SPEAKER_01: Because keep in mind,
- 23:16SPEAKER_01: anyone who converts to Judaism,
- 23:19SPEAKER_01: it used to be you had to convert Consistent with Halakha,
- 23:23SPEAKER_01: which is to say you had to convert in line with Orthodox Judaism.
- 23:29SPEAKER_01: You had to convert under an Orthodox rabbi.
- 23:33SPEAKER_01: And there were very, very strict rules about that.
- 23:37SPEAKER_01: Now that has been loosened.
- 23:38SPEAKER_01: The Supreme Court of Israel loosened those rules and regulations.
- 23:44SPEAKER_01: So now anyone who converts to Judaism,
- 23:47SPEAKER_01: as long as you convert as part of some You can convert to Judaism in any
- 23:51SPEAKER_01: of those established communities.
- 23:52SPEAKER_01: And you will be covered under the law of return.
- 23:55SPEAKER_01: You will be able to go.
- 23:57SPEAKER_01: If you convert right now, you could convert in Des Moines, Iowa.
- 24:00SPEAKER_01: You could convert in Lincoln, Nebraska.
- 24:03SPEAKER_01: You could convert in Butte, Montana.
- 24:21SPEAKER_01: Casper, Wyoming,
- 24:22SPEAKER_01: you could convert to Judaism,
- 24:24SPEAKER_01: having no Jewish ancestry whatsoever, none,
- 24:28SPEAKER_01: nobody in your family going back ever who was Jewish,
- 24:32SPEAKER_01: and you could convert,
- 24:35SPEAKER_01: go through the process,
- 24:36SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 24:36SPEAKER_01: do all the things,
- 24:38SPEAKER_01: convert to Judaism,
- 24:39SPEAKER_01: and under the law of return,
- 24:41SPEAKER_01: you could go to Israel,
- 24:43SPEAKER_01: become a citizen,
- 24:44SPEAKER_01: and you would have all the rights and privileges to of a Jewish person
- 24:49SPEAKER_01: in Israel just as much as anyone else there,
- 24:52SPEAKER_01: including those whose entire family history and entire ancestry going back thousands
- 24:58SPEAKER_01: of years had been Jewish.
- 25:00SPEAKER_01: Meaning like Ivanka Trump,
- 25:02SPEAKER_01: for instance,
- 25:03SPEAKER_01: who converted when she married Jared Kushner,
- 25:06SPEAKER_01: is now covered under the law of return.
- 25:09SPEAKER_01: Now explain to me how conversion to a faith Confers indigeneity.
- 25:15SPEAKER_01: Please explain this to me like I'm five years old.
- 25:19SPEAKER_01: How in the hell does converting to a religion confer indigeneity?
- 25:25SPEAKER_01: Obviously, it does not.
- 25:27SPEAKER_01: Converting to a faith does not suddenly change your ancestry.
- 25:31SPEAKER_01: It does not change your lineage.
- 25:34SPEAKER_01: So now what we are left with is again a religion...
- 26:04SPEAKER_01: That is dictating the terms of what Jewishness is,
- 26:06SPEAKER_01: which is to say that it isn't about indigeneity.
- 26:09SPEAKER_01: It is about a faith, meaning that we are talking about a religious state.
- 26:14SPEAKER_01: We are talking about a state that is extending rights and privileges on the basis
- 26:20SPEAKER_01: of religious status,
- 26:21SPEAKER_01: thereby making it no different than a Christian nationalist state,
- 26:26SPEAKER_01: which no Jewish person would accept.
- 26:28SPEAKER_01: And rightly so.
- 26:30SPEAKER_01: Making it no different than an Islamic state,
- 26:33SPEAKER_01: which every Jewish person I know rejects and condemns.
- 26:37SPEAKER_01: I certainly don't like Islamic states,
- 26:39SPEAKER_01: I don't like Christian nationalist states,
- 26:41SPEAKER_01: and I cannot accept a Jewish nationalist one.
- 26:43SPEAKER_01: And it's not a secular state.
- 26:45SPEAKER_01: If you're going to allow converts to accept all those rights and you're going
- 26:48SPEAKER_01: to extend Jewishness to converts and claim
- 26:50SPEAKER_01: that they are now essentially indigenous people,
- 26:53SPEAKER_01: Then what you've done is you have conflated indigeneity with religion.
- 26:57SPEAKER_01: You are essentially operating on a theocratic basis.
- 27:00SPEAKER_01: You're operating on a basis of a religious determination.
- 27:03SPEAKER_01: You're operating on the basis of what you think God said.
- 27:08SPEAKER_01: And there's no legitimate secular basis for that.
- 27:10SPEAKER_01: You're just a zealot.
- 27:11SPEAKER_01: You're just an extremist.
- 27:12SPEAKER_01: This has nothing to do with indigeneity at all.
- 27:15SPEAKER_01: And on indigenous people's day, I hope that we can remember that.