Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Leveraged ETFs Explained: Mechanics, Risks, and Volatility Decay
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. So you've clearly been curious
- 0:02about some, well, let's call them exciting, maybe even
- 0:05dangerous post to the market leveraged ETFs.
- 0:08That's right, we're looking at lets today, and specifically the
- 0:12ones people ask about most. TQQQ and sex QQQ.
- 0:15They promised big returns fast. OK, let's unpack this then.
- 0:19Our goal here is to cut through that hype, understand how they
- 0:23actually work, what the real risks are.
- 0:25We really need to focus on why trading these is completely
- 0:28different from investing in them.
- 0:30And look, if you remember just one thing, make it this.
- 0:34These are built to amplify returns for one single day.
- 0:38That word daily. It changes everything.
- 0:40It's the absolute key to why they behave the way they do,
- 0:43especially over longer periods. Daily.
- 0:45Got it. So our sources break them down
- 0:46into a few types, right? Yeah.
- 0:47Broadly 3, you've got your leveraged ones, the bull funds
- 0:50like TQQQ aiming for 2X or 3X the daily move, then the inverse
- 0:55or bear funds doing magus 1X so the opposite of the index daily.
- 0:59And finally, the leveraged inverse, the ultra short ones,
- 1:02that's SQQQQ it targets -3 times Medicaid 3X the daily return to
- 1:08the NASDAQ 100. -3 times, OK, how on earth do they get that
- 1:12kind of exposure, like instantly?
- 1:13It's not like they can buy and sell three times the NASDAQ
- 1:16every day. No, exactly.
- 1:17And that's the first big thing to understand.
- 1:19Your normal ETF, say QQQ, it holds the actual stocks, Apple,
- 1:24Microsoft, etcetera. Leveraged ETFs.
- 1:27They don't. They use financial derivatives,
- 1:29mostly things called swap agreements and futures
- 1:32contracts. Swap agreements?
- 1:33What are the exactly? Think of it like a contract,
- 1:35usually with a big bank, say Goldman Sachs or Barclays.
- 1:39The fund pays the bank a fee OK, and in return the bank promises
- 1:43to pay the funds, say, three times the return of the index
- 1:46for that day. So the funds money that the AUM
- 1:49isn't actually buying stocks? Nope.
- 1:50Most of it is just sitting there as collateral, usually safe
- 1:53stuff like U.S. Treasury bills.
- 1:54It's back in the promise made in that swap contract.
- 1:57That's how they get huge notional exposure, way bigger
- 1:59than their actual assets. OK, that structure based on
- 2:03derivatives and these daily promises, it leads us to the
- 2:08really crucial mechanic, doesn't it?
- 2:10The daily reset. Precisely the daily rebalancing.
- 2:13It has to happen every single day.
- 2:14Why mandatory though if it's just a contract?
- 2:17Because the fund promised 3X leverage for the day, so at the
- 2:20end of the day its value has changed.
- 2:22Let's say the index went up 1%. The Three X Fund goes up 3%.
- 2:25Right. It's AUM is now bigger.
- 2:28To maintain that 3X leverage promise for tomorrow based on
- 2:31this new larger asset base, the manager must buy more exposure,
- 2:36more swaps or futures. So if the markets going up,
- 2:38they're forced to buy more each night, buying high.
- 2:41Effectively, yes. Buying into strength?
- 2:43Well, wait, isn't that just compounding working for you?
- 2:45If the markets in a strong uptrend, why is it necessarily
- 2:47bad? It's great in the strong, smooth
- 2:49uptrend. That's the ideal scenario.
- 2:51The problem comes when the market isn't smooth, when it's
- 2:54choppy. OK, the other side of the coin.
- 2:56Exactly what happens if the index falls 1%?
- 2:59The 3X fund drops 3%, it's AUM shrinks.
- 3:02So to maintain 3X on that smaller Bay.
- 3:04They are forced to sell exposure, sell derivatives, they
- 3:07have to reduce their bets to avoid becoming over leveraged
- 3:10relative to their now smaller pool of assets.
- 3:13Those are forced to sell low, buy high, sell low, baked into
- 3:17the structure if the market with sauce.
- 3:19That's the pro cyclical nature. It amplifies trends both up and
- 3:22down, but it gets destroyed by volatility.
- 3:24And that forced buying and selling in a choppy market that
- 3:28takes us straight to the biggest danger for anyone thinking long
- 3:31term right volatility decay. Volatility decay or variance
- 3:33string. Yeah.
- 3:34And critically, this isn't a fee the fund charges you.
- 3:37It's just math. An unavoidable consequence of
- 3:41compounding leverage returns day after day, especially volatile
- 3:44ones. OK, the math helps here.
- 3:45The sources had a pretty clear example.
- 3:47Walk us through it. Sure.
- 3:48Let's keep it simple, 2 days, very volatile market.
- 3:51Yeah, you start with $100 and three things, OK.
- 3:54One, a standard 1X ETF, let's call it QQQ, 2, our 3X
- 3:58bullfriend TQQQ. And three, the NACA 3X Bear Skew
- 4:02QQ. $100 in each. Got it.
- 4:04Day one the index jumps plus 10%.
- 4:06Pretty big move. So QQQ goes to $110 TQQQQ.
- 4:09TQQQ jumps 30%, so it's $130.00. This says QQQ.
- 4:13The Bear 1 drops 30% so it's down to $70.
- 4:16Everything's working as expected.
- 4:17OK, makes sense so far. Day 2 Now the mark reverses.
- 4:20The index falls 99.09%. Why that specific number Nan is
- 4:249.09%? Because a 9.09% fall from $110
- 4:29brings the index exactly back to $100.
- 4:31OK, so over the two days the index is perfectly flat.
- 4:34Started at 100, ended at 100. Zero return.
- 4:37Exactly. Now what happened to our ETFs?
- 4:39QQQ, the standard one. It lost 9.09% from $110.00, so
- 4:43it ends right back at $100. Zero return, just like the
- 4:46index. Perfect.
- 4:47OK, that's logical. But the leveraged ones, yeah,
- 4:49this is where the daily reset bites, right?
- 4:51This is the. Punchline TQQQ started day 2 at
- 4:53$130.00. The index fell 9.09%.
- 4:55TQQQ falls three times that, so it loses 27.27%.
- 4:59OK. So $130.00 - 27.27.
- 5:02Percent. It ends at $94.55.
- 5:04It lost nearly 5.5% even though the underlying index was
- 5:07perfectly flat. Wow.
- 5:08OK. And SEC QQQ, the bear fund, it
- 5:10started day two at 7%. Right, the index fell 9.09%.
- 5:13This QQQ is designed to do the opposite.
- 5:15It times 3 so we go up 27.27 on day 2.
- 5:18So $70.00 + 27.27. Percent.
- 5:20That comes out to $89.09. It also lost money, down over
- 5:2410% from the initial $100. That's incredible.
- 5:28The market goes nowhere over 2 days, just up then down and both
- 5:32the 3X bowl and the 3X bear funds lose significant money.
- 5:35That's volatility decay. It eats away at value in choppy
- 5:39sideways markets and it completely demolishes the idea
- 5:42some people have of oh I'll just hold both TQQQ and TQQ long term
- 5:46to head. Yeah, because if the market just
- 5:48churns, you're losing on both ends.
- 5:50Guaranteed losses on both sides in that scenario.
- 5:52Yeah, trying the paddle of canoe and swirling water.
- 5:55Every correction just drags you down lower overall, even if you
- 5:59end up pointing the right way eventually.
- 6:00Good analogy. The energy is lost to the
- 6:03churning, the volatility, not the net direction.
- 6:06But we have to be fair, it's not always decay.
- 6:08There's the flip side. For compounding boost you call.
- 6:10It right when the market is trending strongly and crucially
- 6:13smoothly with low volatility day-to-day, that force buying
- 6:17high actually works wonders. How so?
- 6:19Will the sources show an example if an index goes up, say 10% one
- 6:23day and 10% the next, a smooth 21% total gain?
- 6:26A 2X leveraged ETF wouldn't just be up 42% because of the
- 6:30compounding on the daily gains, it would actually be up 44%.
- 6:34You get more than double the return in a strong, smooth
- 6:36trend. I see, so the daily reset
- 6:39supercharges gains in the right condition.
- 6:41Exactly, and TQQQ's history shows both sides perfectly.
- 6:44Pro Shares Ultra Pro QQQ launched in 2010.
- 6:48Right into the teeth of a massive tech bull run.
- 6:51Talk about timing. Couldn't have planned it better
- 6:53for a 3X bull fund and the result results were well eye
- 6:56watering. The sources cited numbers like
- 6:58over 4000%. Yeah.
- 7:00One period showed a 10 year return for TQQQ of plus 4395%
- 7:05over the same time the underlying QQQ did about plus
- 7:08447%. 447% is amazing on its own, 4000% is.
- 7:13That's the siren song, isn't? It that's the dream they saw,
- 7:15yeah. Then came 2022, the bear market.
- 7:18OK. Reality check time Q2 Q itself
- 7:19had a nasty draw down to 2. Q Lost about 32.58% peak to
- 7:23through bad but recoverable for a long term investor.
- 7:25And TQ being 3X leveraged. TQ suffered a maximum drawdown
- 7:29of Nakity 1.65%. 81% just. Gone, wiped out, and a loss that
- 7:34deep is incredibly hard to come back from.
- 7:36Yeah, the math on that is brutal.
- 7:38To get back to even from an 81% loss, you need.
- 7:42What is it? You need a + 444% gain just to
- 7:45break even? It shows how disconnected these
- 7:47can become from the underlying index over the long run it.
- 7:50Takes way, way longer to climb out of that hole than it took to
- 7:53fall in. Exponentially longer.
- 7:55Now let's flip this QQQ, the Nega 3X bear fund.
- 8:00What if someone thought, OK, I'll hold this long term as
- 8:02portfolio insurance? Based on what we've seen, I'm
- 8:05guessing that's a bad idea. Catastrophic.
- 8:07The five year total return for Skew QQ is something like
- 8:10-97.37%. -97% it's basically 0A guaranteed path to losing almost
- 8:17everything. Pretty much, and it's not just
- 8:19one thing causing that. What's the lethal combo there?
- 8:212 main drivers First, simple positive market drift Over the
- 8:25long haul. The stock market, especially
- 8:27tech via the NASDAQ 100, tends to go up.
- 8:29A permanent, not a 3X short, is fighting a powerful rising tide.
- 8:32You're constantly betting against the house edge,
- 8:34basically. Exactly.
- 8:36And 2nd, even when the market does dip, you have that
- 8:38relentless volatility decay we calculated earlier because
- 8:42markets rarely fall in a straight line.
- 8:44The chop just erodes SQQ shoes value constantly.
- 8:47So decay plus the market's upward bias just grinds it down.
- 8:51Relentlessly. Plus there are other drags too
- 8:53that we haven't even focused on yet.
- 8:55Right, the structural disadvantages like fees.
- 8:57Yeah, they aren't cheap index funds.
- 8:59TQQQ's expense ratio is close to 1% year, somewhere between .82%
- 9:03and .97%. SQQQ is similar, around .95%.
- 9:07That's way higher than a standard QQQ tracker.
- 9:10Much higher, and that fee comes right off the top every day,
- 9:13compounding the drag from decay. And the other big one you
- 9:16mentioned counterparty risk. Remind us what that is again?
- 9:18OK. Remember, these funds use swaps
- 9:20contracts with big banks. Right, They don't own the
- 9:22stocks, they own the banks promise to pay the index return.
- 9:26Exactly. So you don't own the stocks, you
- 9:28own that promise. What happens if the bank making
- 9:31the promise gets into serious trouble, like in a 2008 stall
- 9:34crisis? The promise might not be good.
- 9:37That's the risk. If a major counterparty bank
- 9:39were to fail, the fund could suffer massive sudden losses
- 9:43because those swap agreements could become worthless.
- 9:45It's a systemic risk baked into the structure.
- 9:48You own IOU's, not assets. OK.
- 9:51So given all this, the decay, the fees, the counterparty risk,
- 9:56let's tackle that common question head on.
- 9:59Can I just buy both TQQ and Scoo QQ and hold them to kind of
- 10:03smooth things out? Get market exposure but hedged?
- 10:06That's the big hedging conundrum.
- 10:08And the short answer is no, not strategically.
- 10:10Why not? Look, an inverse ETF like CQQQ
- 10:13can be useful. Maybe as a tactical head for a
- 10:15very short period, a few days perhaps.
- 10:17It's capital efficient. You get a lot of short exposure
- 10:19for your money quickly. But not for months, not as
- 10:21portfolio insurance. Absolutely not.
- 10:23As we saw, if you hold Scoo QQ for months, the decay is likely
- 10:26to just chew through. Its value becomes a depreciating
- 10:28asset. Source material even highlighted
- 10:30a study where a leveraged inverse ETF actually lost 21%
- 10:34during time when the index it was tracking also fell.
- 10:36Wait, the index went down and the inverse font also went down
- 10:39the hedge? Made things worse.
- 10:41Exactly. It compounded the losses because
- 10:43the decay was more powerful than the short term inverse
- 10:46correlation. That's how damaging decay can be
- 10:50over time. That explains why the regulators
- 10:52are so wary of these for retail investors.
- 10:55Absolutely. The SEC fine array, they've put
- 10:58out specific warnings, investor alerts.
- 11:01And what do they say? They state very clearly that
- 11:03these products are unsuitable for most retail investors,
- 11:07especially anyone planning to hold them for longer than one
- 11:10single trading session. One day.
- 11:12That's the intended holding period.
- 11:13That's what they're built for, ultra short term tactical use.
- 11:17They call them specialized tools, not long term investment
- 11:19vehicles. Think Formula One car versus
- 11:22family sedan. OK.
- 11:23So if investing is clearly out, what is the scenario where
- 11:27trading these make sense? Who are they actually for?
- 11:30Right there is a specific, though narrow use case, but it
- 11:33requires several things to line up perfectly.
- 11:35What are the conditions? One, you need a high conviction
- 11:38short term directional call, you have to be very sure about where
- 11:41the markets going in the next say 24 to 72 hours I guess isn't
- 11:45enough. OK, strong conviction, very
- 11:47short term. What else?
- 11:48Two, you need a strongly trending market, high momentum.
- 11:54The daily reset needs to be working for you, compounding
- 11:57gains, not fighting whipsaws needs.
- 11:59To be moving smoothly and not chopping around.
- 12:02Which leads to #3 you ideally want a low volatility regime.
- 12:06Avoid those choppy periods like the plague, because that's when
- 12:09the decay really bites hardest. Strong trend, low chop.
- 12:13High conviction, strong trend, low volatility.
- 12:15That sounds like a rare combination to nail perfectly.
- 12:18It is, which defines the user profile.
- 12:21This isn't for your average passive investor, or even most
- 12:23active investors. So she can use these
- 12:25appropriately. A sophisticated, highly active
- 12:28and extremely disciplined trader.
- 12:30Someone who understands the math inside out.
- 12:32The daily reset. The decay.
- 12:33And someone watching the screen constantly.
- 12:35Pretty much they need the ability and the discipline to
- 12:38monitor positions very closely, maybe even hourly, and get out
- 12:42quickly if conditions change. The fees the structural risks
- 12:45buy and hold is just too dangerous.
- 12:48It really comes back to that TQQ drawdown, doesn't it?
- 12:51That -81.65% loss in a single year.
- 12:55It crystallizes the risk. You look at the potential
- 12:58upside, that plus 4000% number, and it's incredibly tempting,
- 13:02but then you weigh it against an 81% loss that requires a + 444%
- 13:07gain just to get your money back.
- 13:09And remember that loss can happen because the structure
- 13:11itself forces losses during choppy periods, which are
- 13:15inevitable. It really makes you think, is
- 13:17that potential reward worth that specific structurally embedded
- 13:21risk? Something for you to definitely
- 13:22consider very carefully when deciding if tools like these
- 13:24have any place in your own strategy.