Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / Nothing Adds Up | The Lindsey Clancy Case
Transcript
- Nicholle: January 24th, Zalle: January. Nicholle: 2023. For Susan Clancy, there was no reason to believe this Tuesday would become the dividing line between Zalle: Susan Clinton, there was no reason to believe this Tuesday will become the dividing between Nicholle: everything that came before and everything that came after. Susan knew her daughter-in-law was struggling. Zalle: And everything came after. Susan knew her daughter on the short thing. Nicholle: Lindsay wasn't simply Zalle: Lindsay wasn't simply Nicholle: the woman who married her son. She was the fellow labor and delivery nurse, the mother of Susan's Zalle: She was a fellow Lake Ryan Liverpool, the mother of Susan. Nicholle: three grandchildren. And according to Susan's eventual testimony, a woman who had been begging for help months earlier, Lindsay had reached out to Susan. She wasn't sleeping. She wasn't eating normally. She was anxious and depressed and increasingly afraid of what the medications she'd been prescribed were doing to her. On November 30th, Lindsay sent Susan a message. "I'm not okay and I'm terrified of taking meds tonight. She told Susan she had never been that depressed. She believed medication had brought it on. She worried she'd become dependent on Ativan and she was frustrated that she felt like medications kept being added while the underlying problem remained. Susan tried to help. She connected Lindsay with a perinatal behavioral health program. She listened, she reassured her, and she knew another version of Lindsay, the Lindsay she would eventually describe to a jury as nurturing, loving, a devoted mother, of three children, five year old Cora, three year old Dawson, and eight month old Callan. On January 24th, life inside the Clancy home still looked almost painfully ordinary. The doctors' appointments, children playing outside. Outside, a snowman, chicken nuggets, medicine that needed to be picked up and take out for dinner. And then, sometime after six o'clock that evening, Susan's world changed. Her son Patrick had returned home. Lindsay was outside beneath a second-story window, critically injured. Police and paramedics were coming, and inside the basement, Patrick had found his children: Cora, Dawson, Callan. Cora and Dawson would die that night. Callan would fight for his life for several more days. And eventually Susan would learn something almost impossible to reconcile with the women she knew. Police believe Lindsay had done it. And more than two years later, Zalle: And more than three years later. Nicholle: Lindsay Clancy sits in a Massachusetts courtroom. She isn't denying that she killed her children. Zalle: She isn't denying that she killed her children. Her attorney is a Nicholle: Her attorneys acknowledged that she did. The question is whether Lindsay understood what she was doing, or whether severe mental illness had taken her somewhere reality no longer operated normally. But outside that courtroom, another trial has been happening. TikTok, Instagram, Reddit, YouTube, and in that trial, people aren't only questioning Lindsay, they're questioning Patrick, his timeline, a 5:24 p.m. email, His new wife, the investigation, a former assistant district attorney buying the Clancy home, alleged family connections to police, a photograph supposedly showing Patrick boating with someone connected to the investigation, even a reconstruction involving Bratz dolls. Some of those questions begin with documented evidence, some begin with a real fact and make a very large leap, and some we simply cannot verify. Throughout this episode, we're separating four things documented, disputed, Unverified and theory, because questioning evidence is fair. Turning a question into an accusation isn't. And underneath every theory, every TikTok, and every courtroom argument are three children. Cora, Dawson, Callan They deserve for us to get this right. Welcome back to Coffee and Crying with Mom. I'm Nicholle, Mom. And I'm Zalle. Before Zalle: And I'm Zalle. Before we start, make sure you're subscribed or followed. If you appreciate coverage willing to examine uncomfortable questions without turning rumors into facts, share this episode Nicholle: we start, make sure you're subscribed or following wherever you're watching or listening. If you appreciate coverage where we're willing to examine uncomfortable questions without turning rumors into facts, share this episode. You can't understand this case without understanding the crime. And this trial is still developing as we're recording. So if something significant happens after recording, we'll update you in the description and on our Zalle: and the trial is still developing as you're recording. So if something significant happens after recording, you will update your in the version and on. Nicholle: socials. Lindsay and Patrick Clancy lived in Duxbury, Massachusetts. Lindsay worked as a labor and delivery nurse and Patrick worked in technology sales. They had three children. Zalle: Cora Marie Clancy was five. She loved princesses. And taking care of people. Dawson William Clancy was three. He loved firefighters, trucks, paw patrol. And then there was Callan Patrick Clancy, eight months old. Patrick described him simply as a happy baby. Nicholle: Patrick described him simply as a happy baby. Their nanny would later describe Lindsay as an attentive, safety conscious mother. That matters because the evidence does not describe years of Lindsay abusing these children. Whatever happened to her happened over a much shorter period. Zalle: Callan was born in May 2022. Patrick testified that initially things were good, but by the fall Lindsay was struggling. Anxiety became intense, insomnia became severe, she became increasingly focused on sleep. Then treatment began, and eventually a lot of medication. Over approximately four months Nicholle: Over approximately four months before the killings, Lindsay was issued more than 30 prescriptions involving thirteen psychiatric medications from multiple medical providers. Among the medications documented Zalle: Lincoln's issued more than 30 prescriptions involving 13 psychiatric medications from multiple medical providers. Among the medications documented in the record, Zowat, I here. Zowart, MA, Nicholle: in the records were Zoloft, Ativan, Prozac, Ambion, Remeron, Klonopin, Seroquel, Lamictal, Valium, and other medications used to address anxiety, depression, and sleep. Zalle: Prozac, amin, rhinom, fungerate, cerebral, lympical, valve, and other medications used to address anxiety, depression and sleep. My she had to just be out of it because Nicholle: yes. Zalle: that's entirely too much medication. Okay, so I need you to listen carefully to this part. 'Cause Lindsay was not necessarily taking 13 psychiatric drugs simultaneously. That is an important distinction. Doctors started medications, stopped medications, changed doses, substituted one for another, and the evidence also raises questions about whether Lindsay consistently took every medication exactly as prescribed. Nicholle: So when you hear someone Zalle: she was prescribed thirteen different psychiatric medications over roughly four months with more than thirty prescriptions or prescription changes. That's still extraordinary, but the accuracy does matter. That's so many prescriptions. So many very strong prescriptions. Very strong. And Lindsay herself is Nicholle: So many very strong prescriptions. Very strong. And Lindsay herself was worried about what was happening. She complained of feeling spacey, Zalle: She complained of feeling spaced. Nicholle: disoriented, forgetful, disconnected. Zalle: Forgetful, disconnected. Nicholle: She became particularly concerned about benzodiazepines, especially Ativan. On November 30th, she wrote Susan, I'm not okay and I'm terrified of taking meds tonight." She said she had never been that depressed. She believed medication had caused it, and she worried she had become dependent on Ativan. Zalle: She became particularly concerned about benzodiazepines. Especially Ativan. On November 30th, she wrote Susan, I'm not okay. I'm terrified of the humanist tonight. she said she had never been depressed. She believed medication caused it and she worried she had become dependent on Atavant. Seroquel also expressed resistance to other medications. Nicholle: Seroquel Zalle: becomes particularly important. At one point she wanted to stop taking it, and a provider warned her that stopping could worsen her mood or sleep. Lindsay still wanted off. The provider agreed to taper it and So this isn't a story where Lindsay simply swallowed whatever anybody handled her. She was questioning her treatment, questioning side effects, and questioning her dependency and asking for help the whole time. Susan Clancy eventually summarized it for the jury in four words. She was begging for help Nicholle: By late November and December, Lindsay's symptoms were becoming more frightening. In a message with psychiatric providers, she described intrusive thoughts I never had before. She described feeling completely hopeless. She expressed concerns about becoming addicted to medication. She reported suicidal thoughts and eventually thoughts involving harming Zalle: She described intrusive thoughts that had never had a before. She described them completely hopeless. She expressed concerns probably addicted to medication. She reported suicidal thoughts and eventually thoughts involving. Nicholle: the children. Zalle: Patrick knew about some of those thoughts. Her family knew she was struggling. And according to testimony, when Patrick specifically asked whether she felt unable to safely be alone with the children, Lindsay said no. And her family did not believe she would actually hurt them. Nobody ever believes that they're gonna actually hurt their kids. Lindsay's a Nicholle: Lindsay's attempts to get treatment escalated. Providers, emergency care, crisis evaluations, women and infants hospital, South Shore's Perinatal Behavioral Health Program, and eventually McLean Hospital. Lindsay admitted herself around New Year's, and this is one of the most important Zalle: Lindsay for settled around new trees. And this is what it calls Nicholle: moments in the medical timeline. Zalle: One psychiatrist who treated Lindsay at McLean was doctor Alia Goodheart. Doctor Goodheart testified that Lindsay was anxious, but she was appropriately dressed, her speech was normal, she was polite, cooperative. Doctor Goodheart did not observe psychosis. Lindsay was specifically asked whether she Nicholle: was specifically asked whether she had a plan to kill herself or harm anyone else. According to Dr. Goodheart, she denied it. Goodheart testified I did not have any concerns about her safety or a risk for anybody else. Lindsay was discharged on January Zalle: Good hard testify that I did not have any concerns about her safety or a risk anyone anybody else. Lindsay was discourse on Nicholle: 5th. She went home with the two-week supply of Ativan and Tresidone. Nineteen days later, all three children would be attacked. And then came cross-examination. Kevin Reddington stood up and he asked Dr. Goodheart a very simple question. How many women have you treated that are suffering from postpartum psychosis? Zalle: Nineteen days later, all the children would be attacked. And then came cross-examination. Kevin Reddington's letter, and he asked Dr. Goodheart a very simple question. How many women have you treated that are suffering from postpartum psychosis? Nicholle: There was a long pause and Goodheart answered, I haven't seen any. Zalle: There was a long pause, and Goodheart answered, I haven't seen any. That part. Right there. That part. So other than what Nicholle: Right there. So other than Zalle: you're reading in your textbooks, how do you know what you're looking for? Right. Nicholle: Right. How do you know what you need to be concerned about? You see. Zalle: You've seen none and you felt strong enough to get on the stand. You felt strong enough to even tell her that she didn't have it or she didn't seem like it. And psychosis is not the same for everybody. Yeah. Submitted herself. That's Now Nicholle: Right. And to just send her home. When she submitted herself. Yes. Submitted her. Now that does not automatically mean Dr. Goodhart's evaluation was wrong. She was a psychiatrist. She examined Lindsay. She did not observe psychosis. That is real evidence, and the prosecution is entitled to rely on it. But the defense is going to be good. If Lindsay was not proof. Zalle: But the defense's question is obvious. If Lindsay was suffering from a relatively uncommon and severe postpartum psychiatric illness, would the clinicians evaluating her have recognized it? The defense says they didn't, clearly. The prosecution says there wasn't anything there to recognize. Multiple medical professionals saw Lindsay and they didn't see psychosis. Here's my thing. How did you even if you didn't see psychosis, nobody looked back and saw that she had 32 prescriptions in a short amount of time and thought, Hey, maybe what we're doing isn't working. Maybe we should try something else. Clearly. Nicholle: Clearly not. But one of the people who discharged her had never personally treated postpartum psychosis. That's why Zalle: That's Nicholle: that exchange matters. Not because it proves Zalle: Let's Nicholle: malpractice, not because it proves Lindsay was psychotic, but because it gives the jury context for the experience level of one of the clinicians whose Zalle: But because it gets the direct concepts for the experience level of one of the clinicians Nicholle: evaluation is being used to say Lindsay wasn't psychotic. Zalle: There's another detail from McLean. Goodheart testified that she was monitoring Lindsay for possible bipolar disorder. Sleep was important. Sleep deprivation can contribute to hypomania. And Lindsay's sleep had been one of the most persistent problems throughout this entire period. Later experts would reach dramatically different diagnoses. Some would say major depressive disorder, some bipolar two. Defense experts would describe psychosis and that disagreement is gonna become the heart of this trial. Either way, major depressive disorder and bipolar two are extremely dangerous. Nicholle: Five days before the Zalle: They Nicholle: children died, Lindsay's phone searched for symptoms of postpartum psychosis. There were also searches involving hallucinations, mental illness, medication, suicide, sleep, depression, and other psychiatric symptoms. The prosecution sees some of that digital history as evidence of awareness. The defense sees a woman desperately trying to figure out what was happening to Zalle: Medication, suicide, sleep, depression, and other psychiatric symptoms. The prosecution sees some of that visual history as evidence of awareness. The defense sees a woman desperately trying to figure out what's happening. Nicholle: her. And there is some Zalle: And there is a complication. Some activity came from a shared household computer, Which means investigators can sometimes tell us this device did this. That isn't always the same thing. Lindsay did this. That distinction becomes very important later. By 24th. Nicholle: January 24th began surprisingly normal. Lindsay took Cora to a doctor's appointment. The children played outside, and Zalle: children played outside and Nicholle: Lindsay sent Patrick a photograph involving Zalle: Lindsay sent Patrick a photograph. Nicholle: the kids and a snowman. Patrick Zalle: Patrick Nicholle: replied, You're a good mama. There was no obvious crisis unfolding. Later that afternoon, Lindsay began arranging dinner. She looked up the restaurant, she checked directions. She contacted CVS about medication for one of the children. People who interacted. Zalle: replied, we were a mom. There was no coffee prices in folky. Later that night, Lindsay began to range again. She looked up Bree V restaurant, she checked directions, she contacted CPS about medication for one of the children. People who interacted Nicholle: with her by phone described nothing obviously abnormal. Zalle: with her had gone with Crabnethy and obviously had gone. Then she asked Patrick to make the pickups, and that seemingly ordinary request becomes critical because it changed who would be inside the house and when. Patrick testified that shortly after five he prepared to leave. Dawson was eating chicken baggage. Lindsay was holding Callie. Patrick kissed for her. He held Callan briefly. Then he left. That was the last time Patrick saw his children alive. Nicholle: Patrick testified that shortly after five he prepared to leave. Dawson was eating chicken nuggets. Lindsay was holding Callan. Patrick kissed Cora, He held Callan briefly. Then he left. That was the last time Patrick saw his children alive in what? Allegedly. Zalle: Allegedly. Nicholle: Allegedly. And now Zalle: And now we need to slow the clock down because these next minutes are where almost every theory involving Patrick begins. So Patrick Nicholle: So Patrick leaves the home at approximately 5:15. Then 5:24 p.m. a work email is sent. This email has become enormous online. People have claimed Patrick sent it from his Surface Pro. His Surface Pro inside the house. Therefore, Patrick was still home. Therefore, his timeline is false. Zalle: Therefore, Patrick is a proponent. Therefore, this online is false. The email is real and Patrick has acknowledged sending it, but the evidence presented does not establish that Patrick was sitting at the Surface Pro inside the home at 5:24. And we have independent evidence placing him elsewhere shortly afterward at approximately 5:32 surveillance captures Patrick entering C V S. So, I'm gonna say this right is the weirdest thing to me it's way that we answer some of Nicholle: So I'm gonna say this right here. the weirdest thing to me is the way that he answers some of the questions. How don't you know what you use to send an email? How don't you know? How don't you know that? If you remember. Zalle: How don't you know? How don't you know that? If you remember so hard, you like specifically remember what time you left the house, then you would remember whether or not you used your search with you would know. Nicholle: Right. Whether or not you would know what you walked out the house with. You would know if you had your phone and if you had your phone and you sent it at that time from the pro, Zalle: From the Nicholle: then it was from the pro. You know what you had in your hand when you sent Zalle: You know what you have in your hand. Nicholle: it. So here's what we're comfortable saying. What's documented? Zalle: So here's what we probably think. Let's document. Nicholle: Patrick sent a work email at 5:24. Also documented surveillance places him at CVS around 5:32. The question, where exactly was he during every minute between leaving the Zalle: Also document surveillance places him at CPS and not five thirty two. The question where exactly was he hearing everything between leaving Nicholle: house and arriving at CVS? Question Can the five twenty four email be definitively attributed to a particular device? What's not established is that the email proves Patrick was secretly inside the house. That is true. That is true. Those are true facts. Zalle: question can the five twenty four email be definitively attributed to a particular device? What's not established is that the email can be actually secretly inside the house. That is true. That is true. Those are true facts. Patrick enters CVS. He can't immediately find exactly what Lindsay requested. He calls her. She doesn't answer. Lindsay calls him back. The conversation is brief. Patrick asks whether the generic medication is okay. According to him, Lindsay says yes. He later described her as quiet, possibly distracted, maybe busy with the children. Patrick obtains the medication, which so everybody knows it was Pedia Lex. Patrick obtained the medication, then heads toward three V for dinner, which Lindsay called in their order ahead of time. So all he had to do was pick it up. Nicholle: Which should make his trip shorter. Surveillance and other Zalle: Should shouldn't should should. Mm-hmm. Surveillance. Nicholle: evidence support significant portions of his movements away from the home. That's important because whatever questions Zalle: Never quite. Nicholle: we have about his timeline, the evidence does not currently establish that Patrick killed these children. And we will keep saying that because we cannot tell you that he killed the children. We can say we don't feel like he was adequately investigated at this point Zalle: Right. We can say we don't feel like he had if we would investigate at this Nicholle: in the story. Yeah. Zalle: Yeah. that's politely. Yes. While Patrick is away, Lindsay kills all three children. That fact is not disputed by her defense. What is disputed is why. The prosecution says Lindsay deliberately created the opportunity, and during that window the children are killed. To prosecutors, that looks like planning. The defense says organization does not exclude psychosis. Nicholle: The defense says organization does not exclude psychosis. A person experienced psychosis can use the phone, order dinner, talk normally, perform complex tasks and still be acting inside a delusional reality. Zalle: We're gonna explain this without being graphic. All three children were strangled using exercise resistant bands. Cora and Callan were found near one another in the basement. Cora was found face down. Dawson was found separately in Patrick's basement office. When Patrick eventually reached them, the bands were still present. He removed them, claiming he was attempting to help his children. First responders continued life-saving efforts. Nicholle: Cora was five, Dawson was three, they died that night. Callan was eight months old. He was still alive when Zalle: They died then. Callan was eight time. He was still alive. Nicholle: emergency personnel transported him, and doctors Zalle: And that's Nicholle: were temporarily able to restore a heartbeat. But Callan had suffered catastrophic injury. He was transferred for specialized care, and several days later, he died too. It is so heartbeat. Zalle: That is so sad. All three children are dead. And I think that it is important to include that when the first responders arrived, they said that when they walked downstairs to the basement, he was sitting on the couch. He said that he was doing everything he could to save his children And then at one point he said that he tried to Nicholle: at one point he said that he tried to Zalle: untie the bands from their necks. He said that it was knotted. It was proven that they were never knotted. So that was not true. Now for me, I know this is a biased opinion, but I don't feel like you would forget what your children looked like the last time you saw them. With exercise it tied around their necks. Just principle. No Nicholle: I don't forget what your children look like like a standard results. With a exercise band tied around their neck, that would be just imprinted behind my eyelids on a constant basis. And he doesn't remember a lot. He doesn't remember where he sent his email from. He doesn't remember Zalle: on a constant basis. Yeah, and so he doesn't remember like you don't remember your ways and then email you. Nicholle: how the thing was tied on the children's neck. But we want to make sure that the children remain at the center of this case. Yes. They are people. Yes. So after the book, you alleged to do it herself. Head first. Well Zalle: Yes, yes, they are the reason why we chose to do this episode and this case. So after killing the children, Lindsay went through a second story bedroom window. Allegedly. She threw herself out of this window head first. Walked up the stairs from the basement after she killed all of her children Nicholle: But her throat. Zalle: and cut her wrist and then her throat. Nicholle: And then mind Zalle: And mind you, Nicholle: you. She's a nurse. She's a nurse. She would know Zalle: she's a nurse. Nicholle: how to do both of those things. And then to Headfirst. With a note. Zalle: And then threw herself out of the window head first. With no shoulder injuries, no arm injuries to indicate that she tried to catch herself. Nicholle: And blood's better on the outside of the house, correct? Yes, it's prepared. Indication. Zalle: on the house as fa yes, is blood spatter on the outside of the house, indicating that she would have had to have been dangled out of the window because it's no other way. Or if she wasn't just dangled, somebody threw her and her reflex was to try to grab like towards the house. But even then that's not Nicholle: Right. Well even Zalle: possible because if that was the option she still would have tried to save herself in some other way. Nicholle: Your body will naturally react. Zalle: Yeah. And it was none of that. The doctor said she had to have been unconscious when she was thrown from the window. But she survived. She suffered devastating spinal injuries and she is now paralyzed and uses a wheelchair. The first responder said when they got there she was leaking spinal fluid from her body and she was unable to speak. Nicholle: Right. Remember it. A defense Zalle: Remember that. Nicholle: forensic pathologist later testified that her cervical injury was consistent with the head first fall. Remember that also. Because we're gonna come back to it when we show you the brat's reconstruction. I'm excited to show you this. Zalle: Okay. So Patrick returns home shortly after six. The house is quiet. He calls out. Nothing. He goes upstairs. The bedroom door is locked. He gets inside. He sees blood. The window is open. He looks outside and sees Lindsay below. Nicholle: And then he runs outside, calls 911, and initially Patrick believes Zalle: And initially Patrick believes Nicholle: his wife has attempted suicide. Then comes the question, where are the kids? According to Patrick, Lindsay communicates that they're in the basement. He goes downstairs and discovers what happened. Zalle: then comes the question, where are the kids? According to Ashley, Lindsay communicates that they're in the basement. He goes downstairs and discovers what's happening. Nicholle: The 911 recording captures the moment. His understanding changes from my wife tried to kill herself to my children are dying. Patrick screams, she killed the kids. Zalle: Patrick Green. She killed the kittens. And here's another viral claim. People say first responders said Lindsay couldn't speak. Patrick says though, she told him where the children were. Therefore Patrick lied. Nicholle: So I just thought of something. If on the 911 call, you can hear him in the background screaming once he finds the children. You can hear it. I've heard the I've heard the clip. But the argument that I heard against the fact that you know she couldn't speak, it was saying we don't know that she didn't tell him that. Zalle: she didn't tell him that Nicholle: Because the first responder says she couldn't speak when they got there. But if he's on the 911 Zalle: because the first responder said she couldn't speak when they got here. But if he's on the night, Nicholle: call and that's supposed to be when she's telling him where the kids are because otherwise he would have already gone to them So then they would have heard her telling him because they were on the phone and it said in the 911 call that all you could hear was the moaning and what sounded like trying to speak. Zalle: And that gurgling would be she's telling them where the kids are because otherwise the basement. So then they would have heard her telling him because they were on the phone and it said in the 911 call that all you did here was moaning and crying like her crying. Nicholle: Exactly. Zalle: Exactly. So it would have been on recording. Right. On record. Unless they there's no way it would not have come out. If he finds the kids upon the 911 call, that's when she has that helping them. Because clearly he didn't think she committed suicide. That's her what happened. She tells him when he calls 91 money. Nicholle: Right. Unless there's some fact that we are missing, because that doesn't line up. If he finds the kids on the 911 call, that's when she had to have told him because clearly he didn't think she committed suicide. Asked her what happened, she tells him, then he calls 911 and then he goes to find his kid. Zalle: Then he goes to find And then he asks Nicholle: So Lindsay was severely injured. She was moaning Zalle: So Lindsay was the clearly injured. She was Nicholle: and she was struggling to communicate. She drifted in and Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: out. Zalle: Before Patrick took the stand, his attorney made a request, and this has been misrepresented online too. You probably heard Patrick wouldn't testify unless certain evidence was kept out of court. That is exactly what I heard. But that's not what happened. Patrick sought restrictions on the public dissemination of highly sensitive evidence involving his children. Okay, that's different. Yeah, that's a different situation. The request involved here. Nicholle: That's different. Yeah, that's a different situation. The request involved material including the 911 recording, photographs involving his deceased children, autopsy-related images, and highly personal physical evidence. Patrick argued that broadcasting or redistributing that material would inflict additional trauma on him and other family members. The judge granted restrictions involving some of that material, but the evidence was not hidden from the jury. The attorneys could use it, the jury could hear and see evidence. People physically inside the courtroom could experience it. The restriction concerned what could be broadcast or redistributed publicly. That distinction matters. And I understand why Zalle: The judge ran restrictions involving some of that material, but the evidence was not hidden from the jury. The attorneys could use it, the jury could hear it and see evidence. People inside the courtroom could experience it. The restriction concerned would be broadcast or redistributed publicly. That distinction matters. I can concur with that. The jury heard the 911 call. Patrick had to sit there while the moment he discovered his children was played in court. Lindsay was there too. Both showed emotion at different points during the trial. Nicholle: Jurors were also confronted Zalle: Jurors were also Nicholle: with extremely difficult evidence. We're not playing the 911 Zalle: Not playing the nine. Nicholle: recording. You do not need to hear a father discover his dying children to understand what happened. Zalle: Now let's talk about Patrick's demeanor because social media has analyzed this man's face frame by frame. And if we're gonna discuss moments people perceive as suspicious, we need to discuss the rest too. Patrick became physically a nobody describing Nicholle: Patrick became visibly emotional while describing his children. At times he struggled, at other times he was composed. There were pauses before answers, moments of Zalle: There were positive answers moments. Nicholle: apparent discomfort, moments of visible grief, and moments Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: people online have interpreted as defensiveness. Body language is not forensic evidence. Zalle: Body language is not going to get hands. That is probably Nicholle: is probably Zalle: our biggest question about the investigation. Saying police never investigated Patrick is too broad. Police interviewed him now. I don't give a damn about the interview because as long as you didn't do nothing on the interview, that doesn't mean anything, okay? They say that they examined his digital evidence and they did enough that they were able to reconstruct portions of his movements and collected surveillance. Even though they say that they investigated him, I feel like what they called investigation was not thorough enough for it to be the situation that it was. Nicholle: It was not or it's decision. A triple But here's the question I still have. As we said, was Patrick ever treated Zalle: But here's the question I still have. As I said, professional ever Nicholle: It as a genuine alternative homicide suspect and comprehensively eliminated through an independent investigation. From the publicly available record, I don't think we have enough information to confidently describe the full extent of that process. Zalle: treated as a genuine alternative homicide as I say and comprehensively eliminated through an independent investigation. From the publicly available record, I don't think we have enough information to confidently describe the full extent of that process. Digital evidence becomes complicated because the family used shared devices. Hmm. Investigators examined a Microsoft Surface Pro. During cross examination, the defense raised questions about who was actually using the device during certain activity. And that happens a locked in account isn't necessarily a human being. A timestamp can tell you something happened. It may not tell you who was being a device can establish location or activity under certain service instances, but sometimes it can't. That is why the fact that before email Nicholle: that matters. A logged in account isn't necessarily a human being. A timestamp tell you something happened. It may not tell you who pressed the key. A device can establish location or activity under certain circumstances, but sometimes it can't. That is why the 5:24 email question deserves a forensic answer rather than a TikTok assumption. Agreed. Zalle: Agreed. But I cannot believe we're saying this during an episode about three murdered children. But we need to discuss Brad's dolls. It's very important. I know that sounds I know it sounds ridiculous, but it is extremely important for this case. It is. It is. So a creator. Nicholle: Very important. Yes, here we go. Yes it is. So a creator online attempted to reconstruct aspects of Lindsay's fall from the window using dolls. And while that sounds ridiculous when I say it, the video Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: is actually useful for understanding the theory people are proposing. Zalle: It is also showing the people evidence and points not brought up by the defense that should have been brought up by the defense now. I rock with Reddington the long way. Not because of necessarily what he's doing for Lindsay, but when there is a issue or that somebody is treating her disrespectfully as a woman he speaks up for it. And I can respect Nicholle: He does. Zalle: the hell out of that. That's a man that speaks up for women's rights and they're not many men out there that do it it openly and strongly. Yeah. And he don't care that you don't like what he's saying. Nothing. Yeah. We're not gonna do. And no, I don't want your sidebar. I don't want it. No, thank you so much. I would not appreciate the sidebar. I would like to bar right here. Let's bar here. Let's not sidebar. Let's main bar. Nicholle: Yeah, do it openly and loudly. And he No, you don't give two shits about your emotions about it because what you're not gonna do is disrespect his client. That's what you're not finna do. No, I don't No, thank you. I don't want it. No, thank you. I would not like to be a part. Thank you for the invitation. I decline. Respectfully. Let's bar in the middle. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: And the judge was Zalle: He stood up and everything. Like who come on, Reddington what we doing here? I mean, I can't say you're wrong because this can we sidebar? Nicholle: just like Come on, Reggie. I know you're mad, sir. I mean I can say we're wrong. Zalle: Can we sidebar? Okay, anyway. That does not make it a forensic reconstruction The dolls do not reproduce human weight, muscle movement, momentum, exact dimensions, body mechanics, injury response or every physical variable in that bedroom, clearly because they're Bratz dolls. So Nicholle: So we're showing this because it demonstrates a question visually, not because it answers it. It does a very good job of leading you down the road Zalle: And just so y'all know we're not gonna be able to play the full reconstruction because it's clearly too long. We're gonna play a small clip of it. But if you do wanna go see it, look up @millie, I think that's how you say it. M I L L I E on TikTok. When you know we normally don't shout out all the creators, but Miss Millie, ma'am, you earned your shout out because that reconstruction f Nicholle: It was life. It did its job. and I hope. Zalle: It did its job. And I hope the defense saw it and that's part of the reason why they called for the recess on Friday Y'all saw the L? I seen it. And for those of you who took forensic science or watch Forensic Files, then you will know that it is no way possible for those two drops to have ended up under the leg of that nightstand without it taking the form of what it fell around. There are perfectly two drops of blood spatter. And there's no print in it. Like it would be the L or whatever if it was moved back when it was wet, meaning that it was moved wherever the L shape was, where the the night stand was moved, till the blood dried and then put back on top of it. been an indent in those prints. So I can definitely understand why people are talking about it and I hope that y'all can understand why we brought it up. Nicholle: Exactly. Now let's compare it to actual Zalle: Yeah, it's a bad. Nicholle: evidence. A forensic pathologist testified about Lindsay's injuries and said the cervical injury Zalle: So Nicholle: was consistent with the head first fall. That's evidence. The dolls are an illustration. There's a difference. Zalle: Now we're getting into the connections that have fueled conspiracy theories. You've probably heard the DA bought the Clancy house. That's inaccurate. The person who bought the home was Michael Phippen. Phippen had previously worked as an assistant district attorney in Plymouth County. He left the office years before the killings. He later purchased the Clancy property. During the trial, he objected to jurors visiting the home, though the judge ultimately allowed the jury view. So Nicholle: He left the office years before the game, whose leader first became Nancy Parker. During the trial, was the judge's meeting partner. allowed the jury to be. So again, documented Zalle: again Nicholle: a former Plymouth County assistant district attorney later purchased the house. Not documented, the prosecutor handling the Lindsay's murder case secretly bought the crime scene. Those are not the same statement. Zalle: Still unusual enough to ask about though. Definitely. Something can be unusual. Nicholle: Definitely. Something can be unusual without being evidence of a conspiracy. Zalle: Yes, that is true. And now we're gonna show you one of the clips that's circulating online. The creator presents what appears to be a photograph involving Patrick at a boating or yachting event. Then the creator identifies another person in the photograph as someone connected to the investigation. That claim has been folded into the broader theory involving Patrick, Law Enforcement, and the House. We're going to show Nicholle: We're going to show it, but look at the screen. Here's where verification Zalle: Here's where we Nicholle: stops for us. There are portions of the surrounding story we can document, but we have not Zalle: But we have Nicholle: independently established through reliable evidence that the person identified in this viral photo is who the creator claims he is or that the alleged connection means what social media says it means. Until we can, it's unverified. Zalle: is who the creator claims he is or that the connection means what social media said that he is. And so we can't it's unverified. Another claim circulating online involves Patrick's family and the Duxbury Police Department. Various versions have claimed a relative of Patrick's held a senior position with Duxbury Police, his uncle. Now we Nicholle: we need Zalle: need to talk about Patrick's life after the killings. Patrick eventually moved to Manhattan. He later began a relationship with Doctor Rachel Danis. Rachel is a physician specializing in reproductive medicine. They eventually lived together and in twenty twenty six they married. Nicholle: But then the internet investigators discovered Patrick Zalle: But yeah, Nicholle: had traveled to New York for work in November of 2022 before the children died. Rachel was also working in New York. And then the question became did Patrick Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: and Rachel know each other before January 2023? Here's the answer we can court currently Zalle: Is for current. Nicholle: support. We have not found reliable evidence establishing that they did. Zalle: That was even thank you. Nicholle: No verified messages, no documented meeting. No verified photograph together from that period, no phone records Zalle: Yeah from that year. Nope. Nicholle: establishing contact, no evidence of an affair that we've been able to substantiate. But that is very suspicious. Zalle: Yeah, Two people being in New York City at the same time doesn't establish they knew each other. Nicholle: Would you still let them watch? Definitely, because Zalle: Would you still like to know when they actually met? Definitely. Nicholle: a documented answer could either support or destroy an enormous online theory. Mm-hmm. But until we have it, it's a question. Zalle: Mm-hmm. But it's a we have it. It's a question. Nicholle: Then the theory gets much bigger. People began comparing Zalle: Then the dairy gets much bigger. People begin Nicholle: photographs of Rachel and Lindsay. Some people think they look alike. We are some people. We are some Zalle: Some people think they look alike. We are some people. We are some people because anybody who's like, No, they don't look alike, you're blind, you need to go get your eyeballs checked. Exactly. look like that limits within the lengthy descriptions. Nicholle: Exactly. That resemblance was then connected to Lindsay's descriptions of what she experienced during the killings. And eventually some creators theorize that Rachel herself was somehow physically involved. Zalle: And eventually some creators theorized that Rachel herself was somehow physically evolved. Which makes a lot of sense because what she was saying was that "I didn't want to do this. It felt like it was another entity that took over my body and I was watching myself do these things, but I couldn't control myself." Yeah. So maybe you couldn't control yourself because you were drugged? And you were watching yourself do these things because it R it was Rachel? Nicholle: It was Rachel Reagan. Just a theory. Zalle: We're gonna be very clear. There's no credible evidence we found placing Rachel Danis inside the Clancy home on January 24th, 2023. She has not been charged. Authorities have not identified her as a participant. Lindsay's defense is not arguing Rachel killed the children, so that theory currently has no established evidentiary foundation. Nicholle: Patrick's behavior Zalle: Actually, Nicholle: after the killings is also being analyzed. some people think he moved on too quickly. I don't consider that useful evidence. There isn't an approved grief Zalle: and some people did keep going too quickly. I don't consider that useful evidence there and then approved. Nicholle: timeline. We don't know what Zalle: We don't Nicholle: returning home and finding your three children dying does to someone's relationship with a house, a town, a marriage, Zalle: Here's the ritual for dying does to someone's relationship with the house, the town, a marriage. Nicholle: or the need to rebuild a life. But all of those things make for me, my personal opinion, give a lot of credence to the fact that he wanted to get Zalle: But all of those things make for me and my first group feed give a lot of credence to the fact that he wanted to. Nicholle: away. from his family. I don't I don't agree with people saying, that person didn't cry or they didn't look sad. I don't agree with that because we cannot say what we will Zalle: They just said enough. I don't agree with that because we cannot stay from Nicholle: do, how we will react until we ourselves are in that situation. But I think we can take people's action and we can put a picture together until somebody shows differently. Because I don't think that even in the trial they're Zalle: But I think we can take people's actions and we can put a picture together until somebody shows differently. Because I think that even in the trial there Nicholle: Doing a good job proving that she did this. No. Zalle: doing a good job proving that she did this. No, the because first of all there is no evidence. Nicholle: None. Zalle: that she did any of it. Lindsay's fingerprints were not found on the bands wrapped around the children's neck, Lindsay's fingerprints were not found anywhere in their bedroom where supposedly she tried to kill herself and then throw herself out of the window. Not one. Though her blood was everywhere in the room. Where does that make sense? You literally have no physical evidence proving that she did any of this other than the fact that she said that she did it Okay. Even though clearly she did because she stated she had a whole memory, there was whole thing. So I'm just saying it's fishy. It's fishy. It's fishy. Okay. Shortly after the killings, Patrick publicly asked people to forgive Lindsay. He described the Lindsay he knew as loving. At trial, he discussed her mental health decline. He acknowledged the medication problems. He testified about her suicidal statements and intrusive thoughts. And he has pursued civil claims involving her medical treatment. against multiple hospitals saying that they did not handle Lindsay's care properly. Then he set up a GoFundMe He got $1,000,000 off of that. Then he sold the house and allegedly he got rid of all of the kids' stuff. When he sold the house. Got like $600,000 from that house and doesn't have to split that with with Lindsay. Nicholle: But that doesn't Zalle: But Nicholle: answer every question about Patrick. But it doesn't fit neatly into a story where he spent years Zalle: But that it meeting into a story prince thing. Nicholle: trying to convince everyone Lindsay was simply an evil monster either. We include evidence Zalle: Okay. Nicholle: that hurts our theory too. Zalle: Now we get to the heart of Lindsay's insanity defense. Lindsay eventually described hearing a male voice. According to defense testimony, she said the voice commanded her to kill the children and herself, that she had no other choice. Forensic psychologist Dr. Paul Zeizel testified that he believed Lindsay was not faking her symptoms. Defense psychiatrist Dr. Philip Resnick concluded she was psychotic. His interpretation was that Lindsay believed killing her children was somehow an act of protection Nicholle: yes. Zalle: An altruistic killing inside a delusional belief system. Nicholle: The prosecution's experts disagree. Dr. Avram Mack testified that Lindsay suffered a serious depressive illness, but not psychosis. He believed she understood what she was doing and could control Zalle: Even if she understood what she was doing and the Nicholle: her behavior. Dr. Kirk Helibrun diagnosed bipolar two disorder and recognized Zalle: Two, just one. Nicholle: intrusive thoughts, but his findings regarding hallucinations differed from the defenses. So now we have highly Zalle: But it's fine that throughout the stations don't fit this so Nicholle: credentialed experts looking at essentially the same records and reaching dramatically Zalle: Same reference. Nicholle: different conclusions. And here's the moment because if I'm not a Zalle: And here's what's blowing me, because if I'm not mistaken, once again, like we say a thousand times, I'm not a professional, I've never been in a courtroom and went through a whole trial But I don't believe that psychiatrists, psychologists are supposed to interview a patient at the same time in a criminal defense case. Nicholle: psychiatrist, psychologist, or what could you do? Interview a patient at the same time in a company. Defense case. Mm-hmm. Both of the psychologist reviewing her. Did they interview at the same time? And then talk about their funding and then talk about that we're we're gonna be reporting all those things. And then talk on the phone and Zalle: Both the psychologist reviewing her did the interview at the same time and then talked about their findings and then talked about that what they were gonna be reporting all of this and then talked on the phone Nicholle: before they came to court. Granted, was on the you know, are you going tomorrow? Zalle: before they came to court. Now, granted, it was on the you know, are you going tomorrow? Nicholle: Yeah. That kind of basis. But all of that still is is FISHY. It's fishy. You're not supposed to be doing that. Zalle: that kind of basis but all of that still is fishy. It's fishy. You're not supposed to be doing that. Nicholle: This is still where struggle because we need notebooks. Zalle: This is still where I struggle because sending Patrick out looks planned. Nicholle: And that's powerful prosecution evidence. Lindsay, she looks up the restaurant, checks directions, Zalle: Right, right. Check. Nicholle: orders dinner, contacts CVS, adds a medication pickup. Patrick leaves, the children die while he's gone. That can absolutely look like creating an opportunity. Yes, it definitely can. But the defense section Zalle: Yes, it definitely can. But the defense says planning behavior does not automatically eliminate psychosis. A psychotic person can still organize actions. The question is whether that person's understanding of why they're performing those actions is rooted in reality. And that's the jury's problem. Nicholle: And regardless of what verdict you think is appropriate, I keep coming back here. Lindsay sought help again, again, and again. Severe insomnia, anxiety, depression, suicidal thinking, intrusive thoughts, thoughts involving the children, medication side effects. Fear of Zalle: Beer. Nicholle: benzodiazepine dependence, more than thirty prescriptions involving thirteen psychiatric medications, multiple providers, hospital evaluation, psychiatric hospitalization, a psychiatrist who discharged her nineteen days before the killings testified. She saw no psychosis Zalle: She saw this like Nicholle: and believed Lindsay wasn't a danger. So much. Then under crossing Zalle: It is so much failure. So much. Then under cross examination, that same psychiatrist was asked, How many women suffering from postpartum psychosis have you treated? Woo Whatever you think about Lindsay's criminal responsibility, that sequence deserves examination. It definitely does. How? Nicholle: So here's my thing about the medicine and all of that, and them saying she didn't have psychosis, she just suffered from general anxiety. It makes absolutely no sense that that is all any licensed practitioner Zalle: Right. Nicholle: would believe she had, and yet she has all of these medications for things that are different from what you're saying she suffered from. So either you're wrong. Zalle: She has all of these medications for things that are different from what you're saying. She suffered from. So if you're working Nicholle: and she has some psychosis or something much more extreme than just generalized Zalle: and she has some psychosis or something much more extra than just general. Nicholle: anxiety, or every doctor that saw her before that was wrong. So that doesn't make any sense. I've been through situations where the doctors are Zalle: So that is it as a bit through a situation where the back Nicholle: just throwing medicine at you. I've been there. I've never, not one time in all of the medical history that I've had, had somebody give me a medication that they did not think that I needed, that was a stronger medication than what they believed was going on for me, whatever that was. Zalle: that I've had. Had somebody have metation and they did not mean that I've been eating. That was I I had stronger medication than what family was going on for whatever that was. Nicholle: it makes no sense. No, it so let's put everything Zalle: No, it it doesn't. So Nicholle: on the board. Theory one: the prosecution. Lindsay deliberately created an opportunity to be alone with the children. She killed them, attempted suicide, and understood her actions were wrong. Mentally ill? Yes. Legally insane? No. Theory two. Zalle: Theory one, the prosecution. Lindsay has never been created not to be able to children. She killed them, admitted suicide, and understood right to the problem. Mentally ill? Yes. Legally insane? No. Theory two: The defense. Lindsay was experiencing severe postpartum psychiatric illness. Psychosis, hallucinations, possibly bipolar illness, medication and sleep problems compounded the crisis. She physically killed the children, but was not criminally responsible. Nicholle: He physically feels but was not completed. Theory three: Patrick was involved. This theory is enormous online. People cite the 5:24 email, timeline questions, computer evidence, Lindsay's courtroom reactions, Patrick's demeanor, and alleged inconsistencies. Current evidentiary status - No evidence presented Zalle: Current voted chair status. No open. Nicholle: at trial establishes that Patrick participated in killing his children. Neither prosecution Zalle: Neither. Nicholle: nor Lindsay's defense is advancing that theory. Theory Patrick and River. Well, for me. travel. Zalle: Theory four: Patrick and Rachel knew each other beforehand. Nicholle: The theory relies heavily on Patrick's earlier group travel and Rachel will be for working there. Current status is unverified. We have not evidence establishing a pre existing relationship. As Zalle: The theory relies heavily on Patrick's earlier New York travel and Rachel living or working there. Current status - it is unverified. We have not found evidence establishing a pre existing relationship. Nicholle: Okay, so Theory five: institutional connections or cover up. This combines the house cell, former ADA Michael Phippen, police family relationships, the viral boating photograph, questions about the investigation, but these components have different evidentiary statuses. Former assistant DA buys the house, documented. Zalle: These components have different evidentiary statuses. Former assistant EA buys the house document. Viral identification of someone in the yacht photograph. Unverified by us. Evidence these things combined to protect Patrick or alter the investigation. Not established. Nicholle: Theory six: Investigators correctly determine that Lindsay physically killed the children and still may have left questions inadequately answered. Those things can coexist. We don't have to believe Zalle: still may have left questions in adequate answer. Those things can't coexist. we don't Nicholle: Patrick committed murder to believe investigators should thoroughly eliminate every alternative. Correct. Zalle: Correct. So now we're going to show you another clip representing the broader theory circulating online. As you watch, I want you to mentally sort through each statement, fact, inference, unverified claim, and theory. Nicholle: When it's all presented together, it sounds like one giant body of evidence. Exactly. But it's it's multiple set of ponies and each has to stand upon its own evidence. Zalle: Exactly, but it isn't. It's multiple separate claims and each has to stand on its own evidence. Nicholle: I don't want to dismiss online investigators though. They identified legitimate questions, timelines matter. Device attribution matters. The 5:24 Zalle: The right attribution maps. The Nicholle: email deserves a precise explanation. Shared device activity needs careful Zalle: Explanation. Shared device carefully. Nicholle: attribution. Investigators should Zalle: Invest it. Nicholle: eliminate alternative suspects. Unusual Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: connections are worth verifying. Testimony should be compared against objective records. And those are good questions. And there's nothing wrong with asking. The problem again is when asking the good question becomes answering the without evidence. And that is not good. Zalle: And there's nothing wrong with asking them. The problem begins when asking a question becomes answering it without evidence. And that is not what we're trying to do. Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: As we're recording, the trial is approaching its conclusion and the defense attorney Zalle: And the defense Nicholle: requested a mistrial that was denied by the judge. He was requesting the mistrial Zalle: He was insane. Nicholle: because of the comments that were made both by the mom, I believe it was Patrick's mom was up there and the prosecution asked her if she was if she practiced, if she was still a Catholic or something like that, and then said, Did she believe killing was a mortal sin? Zalle: Digital killing was on board the same. Nicholle: So that was one thing. And then the was it the forensic investigator that the psychiatrist the psychiatrist. Mm-hmm. Where he was talking about kind of what what Lindsay Zalle: The psychiatrist we just talked about, Doctor Kirk. Mm-hmm. What was talking about? kind of what what with Nicholle: believed. So they were requesting a mistrial because of those things, but it was not just our people in both inst instances that they weren't allowed to put this with them. So we did it. Right. Zalle: So they're requesting mistrial because of those things. And the judge had already told them on both instances that they weren't allowed to bring that kind of stuff up in court. And so he did it again. Nicholle: So the defense has rested, the prosecution has presented rebuttal psychiatric testimony, and closing arguments are approaching. The jury Zalle: The jury will not be deciding whether Lindsay killed Nicholle: because Zalle: Cora Dawson and Callan. That's not the disputed issue. Which is crazy. Because it should be. It should. It should be. Because even though she confessed, what evidence do you have that she did that shit? You cannot convict her on her words. Do you know how often people admit to crimes they did not do? Nicholle: And there are people who Zalle: And there are people Nicholle: not even under influence admit. There are people who just show up and admit that they did some crime and it's the police's job to determine if they have actual evidence. You don't just go off of what that person Zalle: And the fact that w whoever that who put the charges on Lindsay did this while she was unconscious in the hospital Nicholle: says. And the fact that whoever Zalle: Put the charges on Lindsay, did this while she was unconscious in the hospital, had never talked to her, had never spoken to her, but already had charges against her. When she woke up, she was already charged with the murder of her kids. And then the judge said this case is not about trying to see if she's guilty. Actually, yes, the fuck it is, because you cannot just charge somebody for a murder because they said they did it and not investigate that she did it. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: Yeah. So you're still not investigating and getting down to the bottom of it, which is a problem. That is the problem in this case. Nicholle: And that's the problem. That is the problem with this case. That is why people have so many questions. That's why these detectives and everybody is is looking ridiculous. And we we Zalle: And we? Nicholle: try really hard on this podcast not to nitpick Zalle: N Nicholle: or come down on individual police officers or investigators or anything because we don't do that job. That has to be a difficult job. But we will call it out when we see it. And in this case, this is not a system problem. This is not a problem Zalle: investigator for anything because we don't do that job. That must be a difficult job. But we will call it out when we see it. And in this case, y'all did not do your job. This is not the Nicholle: the system alone this is about investigators not investigating and i don't know of a situation where a family everybody Zalle: system alone. This is about investigators not investigating. And I don't know of a situation where a family ever Nicholle: but one person is either dead or profoundly injured and that is not the person that you go hard on investigating i have not seen it right never Zalle: Person is either dead or profoundly injured, and that is not the person that you go hard on investigating. I have not seen. Right. Never heard of that. as long as you do a thorough investigation and it comes back that she did My only problem is that I feel like regardless, as of right now, she's not getting the trial that she deserves. And it matters because then we could tell who really did what to those babies. She needs to have a fair trial so that her children can get justice. Whether it was Patrick, whether it was her or it was the new wife, whoever did it, we need to figure it out. But we need to do our jobs to actually figure it out. Nicholle: that's having time that her people that their culture whether it was earth or it was the white whoever did it we need to figure it out but we need to work off to actually figure it out. That's right. And it's unacceptable that the room and yeah all of this stuff that has not been brought up and other than because it's not been there's really been no investigation that using Zalle: And it's unacceptable that the world's internet is figuring out all of this stuff and it has not been brought up at all. And other than y'all checking his little his IP, there's really been no investigation that us as the people know about towards Patrick whatsoever. Because he was cooperative and then he told you that she did it. But did you go back and cross reference what he said? Or the the police call? Nobody asked those questions that Nicholle: Well no one had afforded tax whatsoever. Because he was cooperating, he's investigated. But did you go back and confirm you said? And I just wonder why why nobody nobody asked some of the questions that people are asking, Zalle: Keep right. Nicholle: people who are not investigators by trade. I don't understand why they're not looking at that. different Zalle: That's why it makes it more fishy, 'cause why are you not asking these questions? Well who would step off and pass them and passing him something. Yeah. You know why why are they not they see they see more than we see and they're not. Yeah. So I don't know. Nicholle: Right. He did that. He well well who is that woman pass him past him, but you know why why are they not they see they see more than we see and they're not doing it. So I don't know. Zalle: I feel like it is fucked up that they're just deciding whether she was criminally responsible when she did it, instead of her getting a full trial and trying to figure out whether she did it or not. That's my problem. And the experts profoundly disagree, which I feel like the world is disagreeing on this. Yeah, so I think that we Nicholle: Yeah, so I think that we have we have kind of stated where we stand on this. so just your last say zae. What are you thinking? Zalle: I feel like it's important for us to do a thorough investigation one way or the other. All I can say is as of now, with all of the evidence, even through the trial Even with them saying that physically it had to have been Lindsay who did it because whatever the reasoning, I still don't feel like it was her. I don't feel like a mother who is planning to kill her kids would get up and take her child to a doctor's appointment. Have a regular Nicholle: a right. Zalle: day. There's no problem. Call and ask a store if they have Pedia Lax Nicholle: Then she called in the full order for you. So all you need to do is pick it up. Zalle: Then she called in the food order for you. So all you had to do was pick it up. If I'm planning to murder my kids, don't I want you to stay gone as long as possible so I could get the job done? Nicholle: planning to murder my kids. Don't I want you to stay gone as long as possible so I can get the job done. Why am I waiting for you to be in town? You just came back. All the time I want to do Zalle: Why? We were just I I just had to keep it by myself. Nicholle: it. Why am I waiting for you to be back and then calculating how far the restaurant is, you need to go pick up this medicine? Is none of it Zalle: All the time you're in Manhattan in that skin doing all of that from is you need to go pick up this medicine. Is not that Nicholle: makes any sense? Her calling CVS to ask about that doesn't make sense. She definitely shouldn't have had questions about if the children could take it because she just Zalle: Makes any sense. None of it does make sense. She definitely shouldn't Nicholle: came from the doctor. So none of that makes any sense. Zalle: came back from a doctor's appointment. Yeah. So none of that makes sense. None of it. And then let's bring it back to how she attempted to kill herself. She's a nurse. We keep saying it. If you are a nurse, you know you're not Nicholle: You know you're not. Zalle: going to cut your wrist sideways. Right. Nicholle: Okay, you're just not when it's the arteries in your throat. Right. Then also we encourage you to spell it wrong. Zalle: Okay, and you're definitely not gonna miss the arteries in your throat. That's right. Then you're also not going to when you search it spell it wrong. Nicholle: Spell it incorrectly like this is not something that i deal with on a regular with charting. Yes. Get it together. Zalle: spell it incorrectly like this is not something that I deal with on a regular in charting. Yes. Get it together. Come on. It does not make sense whatsoever. And then how she fell out of the window and the blood spatter. I need you guys to go and look at the Bratz doll reconstruction. Because the blood at the nightstand is one. That's number one where it's like, yeah, then there's no blood on any of the bed. Nicholle: Because the blood the nice thing is one. That's no reason. Yeah. Then there's blood on any of the bed. Mm-hmm. Or really anywhere else in that room, you seen the nightstand, there was no blood on it. If she was moving Zalle: Or really anywhere else in that room, you seen the nightstand, there was no blood on it. If she was moving around doing all this stuff, it would have been blood everywhere. And what Patrick said on the stand was that it was blood everywhere. Nicholle: either that was the truth, if you cleaned it up, the eager cleaned it up and now that's a regardless of nothing is making sense. The fact that her mean temperature was eighty what, seven or something like that? Something ridiculous for the Zalle: either that was the truth and you cleaned it up or whoever cleaned it up and now that's a cover up. Regardless, none of it is making sense. The fact that her body temperature was eighty what, 87.2 something like that. Nicholle: amount of time that she was out there. Zalle: the medical professionals of the world are speaking. Yeah. People who are dead, their body temperature does not lower that fast. So she had to have been out there for a long time. You know how you know how badly you have to be hurt in order for spinal fluid to be leaking out of your body? Yeah. And that's what I'm Yes. Nicholle: Yes. And that just made my heart hurt. Yeah. That she would just be laying out there. In the cold. me, so let's say it is the proof. That it was proven that we were home that night. Zalle: so let's say it is the truth that it was proven that you weren't home at 5:24 when you sent this email. she had twenty minutes, to go find all these bands, get all her kids to the basement, kill everybody, run up the stairs, slit my wrist, do all this stuff, then throw myself out of the window. Nicholle: So I've I've never been to the point where I've wanted to commit suicide. I will I will say that out loud. But I've heard many instances of people who have actually attempted suicide. I've heard of people successfully committing suicide. And what I don't ever Zalle: Successfully committing suicide. Nicholle: hear is that they find the most difficult, drawn out, ridiculous ways Zalle: low success Nicholle: Wanted to be Zalle: rate. Nicholle: quick right now. I want to be dead. They're not cutting their wrist. She didn't do that. I'm just gonna say that. She did not do that. She did not cut her wrist the wrong way, her throat the Zalle: She didn't do that. I'm just gonna she did not do that. She did not cut her wrist the wrong way. Nicholle: wrong way. Kill her children with bands Zalle: Kill poetry with Nicholle: that do not have her fingerprints on them, She did everything the hard way. Zalle: fingerprints on them, She did everything the hard way if she did this. And this everything ended up not dead. Nicholle: Goodness. And then she ended up not dead. Then and how can you Zalle: Then ended up not dead. And how can you explain the fingerprints not being in the room, but her blood is everywhere? Right. That makes absolutely zero sense. Nicholle: Right. Somebody was cleaning up. Zalle: Somebody was cleaning up. And then they're saying her last known heartrate before all this happens was fifty seven. You're not killing anybody. Who's killing who with the 57 beats per minute heart rate? Nicholle: You're not killed by problem. Who's killing fifty seven at heart? Zalle: you're barely here. Nicholle: Yeah. So I don't think Zalle: So I'm Nicholle: that we could be any more clear. I don't know who did it. I have my suspicions, but I don't believe it was Lindsay. Zalle: And we can't let all these theories make us forget the children. Exactly. Nicholle: Exactly. Because Lindsay has become a symbol. Patrick has become a suspect in the court of TikTok. Doctors are being sued. Creatives are analyzing emails minute by minute. People are reconstructing a window with dolls. And underneath all of that, there was a five year old girl who loved princesses. A three year old. Zalle: Three-year-old boy who loved firefighters and Paw Patrol, and an eight-month-old baby, his father described as happy. Nicholle: Cora, Dawson, Callan, whatever you believed happened in that house, start with them. And next time you Zalle: And next time you see a shocking claim about this case, ask Do I know this? Can I prove it? Or does this theory simply give me an answer to something I don't understand? Nicholle: Those are not the same thing. We're going to keep asking questions. Just don't turn the question mark into a period before the evidence does. And if you're bring receipts. Please, because we Zalle: And if you're coming into our comments please, because we love to see them. I knew you were gonna say that. Nicholle: I will be checking them. Tell Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: us in the comments which documented piece of evidence in this case do you think still needs a better explanation? And if you're following Zalle: And if you're following the trial with us, subscribe, follow and turn on those notifications because we'll be covering the verdict and what happens next. Nicholle: bring the verdict of what happened. Definitely. Zalle: Keep it easy breezy. Nicholle: with the easy group. Bye.