Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #28: Week 2 in College Basketball, top teams and conferences and early season tournament time!
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, and welcome to episode number 28 of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank teams based on resume, not on expectations.
- 0:21This will be another college basketball episode, and I'll cover both the men and women's games this time.
- 0:26I'll recap the games that happened last week, pointing out games that were crucial to those conference head-to-heads.
- 0:31I'll introduce the new top 25 and what a theoretical bracket would look like using the CSR.
- 0:36I'll dive into the AP polls to see how the voters did, and finally, we'll look forward to some of those early season tournaments that are filling up the next two weeks.
- 0:46There were 382 men's college basketball games played, including a Division I team last Monday through Sunday, bringing our season total to 860 games.
- 0:55I said last week we'd have 30 games that were crucial to the Common Sense rankings, games defined by featuring teams from conferences that play just once or twice this season.
- 1:04But one early season tournament matchup changed that number to 29.
- 1:08Morgan State and Loyola, Maryland played in the consolation of the 410 Classic, pitting the MIAC and Patriot League against one another a third time this season.
- 1:17For the power conferences, Baylor defeated Yale early in the week, giving the Big 12 a two-zero series win over the Ivy League this season, improving the stock of the Big 12 in the CSR.
- 1:27Texas Tech played the first matchup the Big 12 has with the NEC this season, defeating Stonehill by 51 on Saturday.
- 1:35Kentucky managed a win in a nail-biter over Northern Arizona to allow the SEC to maintain hope of winning their season head-to-head with the Big Sky.
- 1:43In the first of two SEC Pac-12 games this season, LSU traveled out west to take on Gonzaga and came away with a one-point victory to give the SEC a one-zero edge in that season series.
- 1:54Finally, the Big Ten wrapped up their season series with the Southern Conference when Indiana took down Tennessee Tech on Thursday.
- 2:02At the end of the first week of the season, the Big 12 was atop college basketball, owning winning head-to-heads against 17 other conferences.
- 2:09The ACC and Big Ten were one step behind with 16 each, and the SEC was fourth with 14.
- 2:16Among the mid-major conferences, the Atlantic 10 was tops with 11 winning head-to-heads, sitting just one behind the Big East.
- 2:23At the end of week two, we have a tie at the top of the new CSR Conference Strength Rankings, with the Big Ten and Big 12 sitting at 19 conference head-to-heads at this point in the season.
- 2:33The ACC and SEC are hovering one behind with 18, and the final power conference, the Big East, is fifth at 15.
- 2:41Amongst the mid-majors, the A10 still leads.
- 2:43They're at 13 conference head-to-heads, but the American is just behind with 12, and the final conference that's over that 10 head-to-head number is the Pac-12, who owns 11 winning records against other conferences this season.
- 2:56Wins over those conferences will garner the most credit in the CSR, and the Big Sky is the lone conference that has yet to own a winning head-to-head against another league this season.
- 3:07The biggest movers in the conference strength rankings this past week were Conference USA, the Mid-American Conference in the Sun Belt, each of whom picked up an additional five head-to-heads throughout the week and moved into the top half of the conference hierarchy.
- 3:20There are several conference match-ups in which one league has already clinched that winning head-to-head.
- 3:25Enough early season match-ups for these conferences that they will own that winning conference record over the other, even if they were to lose the entirety of the remaining non-conference schedule.
- 3:34The Sun Belt leads with five head-to-heads already locked up.
- 3:37The ACC and Big 12 have four.
- 3:40With three are the A10, Big East, SEC, and West Coast Conference.
- 3:44Six more have two, including the American and Big Ten, and nine more have already clinched one winning head-to-head.
- 3:51The remaining 10 conferences still have work to do to raise their conference's floor this season.
- 3:57Next, I want to introduce the top 25 in this week's common sense rankings.
- 4:01Keep in mind that when teams have played more games early in the season, that will reflect in the CSR.
- 4:06We're not looking at the average of results.
- 4:08This is the totality of wins and losses.
- 4:11Number one is the Virginia Cavaliers.
- 4:13They have two power conference wins over Arkansas and Maryland and are one of just six teams with a five and O start.
- 4:19The value of their wins sits atop Division I college basketball, and the value of their opponents' wins sits sixth, which gives, Virginia that number one spot this week.
- 4:29Number two is another five and O team with five wins over Division I schools.
- 4:32It's the Santa Clara Broncos.
- 4:34While their resume lacks a power conference victory, they do have two high mid-major wins over North Texas and New Mexico on their resume.
- 4:42In addition to their quality of wins, their opponents also sport eight Division I victories, giving them the most impressive opponent win strength in the CSR formula.
- 4:51Ranked third for another week is High Point, the third straight five and O team atop this week's rankings.
- 4:56The Panthers are riding the quantity of wins to that number three spot right now, especially their most recent win over the A10's St.
- 5:02Louis.
- 5:03While their win value is on par with Santa Clara, the opponents they faced have only picked up four D-I wins so far this season, settling the Panthers behind the Broncos this week.
- 5:13Number four is Florida, who sport two ACC wins, which are two of the most impressive wins in the CSR formula right now due to the ACC's out-of-conference success.
- 5:22Florida also sits fourth in opponent win strength.
- 5:25Combine that with a four and O start, and the Gators have a top five resume.
- 5:29Number five is Connecticut.
- 5:30Two Big Ten wins and two wins over one-bid leagues combine to give them a better resume of wins than Florida above them, but the strength of UConn's opponent wins don't quite match up with the Gators.
- 5:41Number six is last week's number one team, the Pitt Panthers.
- 5:44They only played one game in week two, so it was almost assured that Pitt loses ground.
- 5:48So they dropped five spots as their game total continues to normalize.
- 5:52They're the second ACC teams in the rankings this week behind number one, Virginia.
- 5:57Number seven is the Rhode Island Rams from the A-10.
- 5:59They are another five and O team with five Division I wins, but the opponents they've defeated have all come from lower-tier conferences.
- 6:05Their best win right now is over Monmouth of the Coastal Athletic Conference.
- 6:10Eighth this week is Vanderbilt, a second SEC team at four and O.
- 6:14Vandy's wins come over Wake Forest and Memphis, who have a combined six wins, boosting the resume of the Commodores.
- 6:20Number nine is a second Big East team, the Georgetown Hoyas.
- 6:23Having beaten Maryland and Clemson, they get credit for a Big Ten and ACC win, but the value of their opponents' wins is what holds the Hoyas back through two weeks.
- 6:32To round out the top ten, we have the Alabama Crimson Tide.
- 6:35Their best win is over Seton Hall from the Big East, but the stronger starts by the Sun Belt, Conference USA, and Horizon are boosting their other three wins right now too.
- 6:45To continue down the top 25, number 11 is Michigan State, 12 is Wright State out of the Horizon League, 13 is DePaul, 14 USC, 15 BYU, 16 Nebraska, 17 Xavier, 18 Texas A&M, 19 Texas, 20 is San Diego State, a first Pac-12 team, 21 is Texas State, another team from the Pac-12, 22 Minnesota, 23 Virginia Tech, 24 Georgia, and Indiana is in the 25 spot this week.
- 7:14Still just undefeated teams in the top 25 of the CSR.
- 7:17The top one-loss team is Memphis, whose three wins over the Big 12, ACC, and A-10 put it at number 55 in this week's rankings.
- 7:26The first week's CSR was very well-rounded, with no conference getting more than three teams into the initial top 25.
- 7:32It is more top-heavy this week, as there are six SEC, five Big Ten, four Big East teams, three from the ACC, two Pac-12, and one each from the Atlantic Ten, Big 12, Big South, Horizon League, and West Coast Conference.
- 7:47The CSR will look drastically different than the AP poll early in the season, as losses are barely valued, seemingly, for the best teams, and who you beat doesn't seem to matter.
- 7:57The AP this week had seven SEC teams, one too many.
- 8:00Six Big Ten, also one too many.
- 8:02Five from the Big Twelve, when the CSR only has one.
- 8:05Four from the ACC, too many again.
- 8:07Two from the Big East, a conference the AP undervalued this week.
- 8:11And finally, one team from the Pac-12, albeit the wrong one, the two-in-one Gonzaga Bulldogs.
- 8:17If we put together a seventy-six team bracket based on the CSR, the SEC would lead the way with ten teams, followed by the Big Twelve with nine, and the ACC and Big Ten with eight.
- 8:27The Big East would get five bids, the A-10 and Pac-12 would each get four, the MAC would get three, and the Mountain West would settle for two.
- 8:35The play-in games would take place in the twelve to fourteen seed range, with West Virginia, Ole Miss, Rutgers, and Tennessee getting the last four spots in the field.
- 8:44The first four teams to miss out on an at-large bid right now would be Penn State, Oregon, Charleston, and Akron, a balanced two power conference teams with two mid-majors.
- 8:54The full theoretical bracket can be found at commonsensrankings.com.
- 8:59Looking at the top four seed lines in each quarter of the field, we'd see Virginia as the top seed in the East, with Rhode Island their two seed, Alabama the three, and DePaul the four.
- 9:08Out West, Santa Clara would be the one seed, Vanderbilt the two, Wright State on the three line, and USC at the four.
- 9:15In the Midwest, High Point is the one seed, UConn the two seed, Michigan State the three seed, and BYU is the four in what would likely be the hardest bracket based on those top four seed lines.
- 9:25Lastly, Florida would top the South region, followed by Pittsburgh at two, Georgetown as the three seed, and Nebraska would fill in as the four.
- 9:34Early in the season, there are some egregious ranking mistakes made by the AP poll voters.
- 9:38Let's look at two of their most head-scratching decisions.
- 9:42In blind resume test number one, we have team A who sits at two and one with wins over the Ohio Valley and the Southern Conference.
- 9:48Their loss is to a three and one American team.
- 9:51Their two wins are over teams with a combined two Division I victories.
- 9:55Team B, meanwhile, is four and O.
- 9:57They have wins over the Big Ten, the ACC, as well as two smaller conference wins, and those four victories are over teams with four Division I wins of their own.
- 10:06We're back to that critical early-season question: Do losses actually penalize teams in the minds of the voters, and do voters actually care about teams that surprisingly win their first handful of games?
- 10:17Team A is Louisville, who sits twenty-third in the AP poll with their two and one record, and Georgetown, team B, receives zero votes.
- 10:24In the CSR, the Hoyas are number nine, while the Cardinals are down at number one hundred thirty-six.
- 10:30In blind resume test number two, team A is four and O.
- 10:33They have wins over the Big Ten, the American Conference, the SWAC, and the UAC, and those four teams they've beaten have six Division I victories this season.
- 10:42Team B is three and one.
- 10:44They have wins over the Horizon League, the SWAC, and the UAC.
- 10:47Their loss is to an undefeated ACC team, and their three wins are over teams with one cumulative D1 victory.
- 10:54So both teams have a win over the SWAC and the UAC.
- 10:57Team A has a Big Ten and American win, which is favored over Team B's Horizon League win.
- 11:02The lack of loss should also work in Team A's favor, and the success of defeated opponents also favors Team A, right?
- 11:09Unfortunately, Team A does not have the pedigree.
- 11:12Team A is DePaul from the Big East, number seventeen in the CSR, but no votes in the AP poll.
- 11:17Team B is number twenty in the AP, Arkansas, who sits down at number ninety in this week's CSR.
- 11:25The AP voters this week got ten of the correct top twenty-five resumes, but just three of the top ten.
- 11:31The good stuff includes Virginia, who is number one in the CSR, and Florida, who is number four.
- 11:36The AP voters got it backward, but at least they are both top twenty-five.
- 11:40Santa Clara and High Point both got votes, which is a step in the right direction.
- 11:44Eight teams were included that have lost at least a quarter of their games.
- 11:48Seems like certain teams don't get penalized when it's shown they're not as good as another team.
- 11:52And Tennessee has wins over the Big South, Ohio Valley, and Southern Conference, yet they're a top fifteen team?
- 11:58The CSR does not see it that way.
- 12:01David Jablonsky will receive a shout-out for a second week in a row.
- 12:04He was the lone voter to not include two-and-one Michigan in his ballot, and he had the lone ballot that included CSR number two, Santa Clara.
- 12:12Percy Allen included nine one-loss teams on his ballot, including every spot from number nineteen to number twenty-five, so seemingly just stuffing that ballot box with undeserving teams there at the end.
- 12:25As we look forward to week three, early season tournaments are going to kick off in earnest.
- 12:29There are a handful more that aren't tournaments in the traditional sense, but there are destination games taking place with a couple of guaranteed matchups.
- 12:38The Players Era Eight will start on Tuesday.
- 12:41That includes seven power conference teams plus UNLV.
- 12:44It'll include AP number one Florida, Kansas, and Houston in its field, and that three-round tournament will finish on Thursday.
- 12:52The Baha Mar Hoops Bahamas Classic will be a four-team tournament on Thursday and Friday, with NC State, Seton Hall, Wisconsin, and Murray State all participating.
- 13:02The US Virgin Islands Paradise Jam will feature eight teams, including mostly mid-major schools.
- 13:07The highlights of that field are East Carolina and Temple from the American.
- 13:12Switching over to the women's game, we had 375 games played at the Division I level.
- 13:17That gives us 862 games through two weeks.
- 13:20There were 27 matchups that were between conferences only playing once or twice this season.
- 13:25Amongst the power conference teams, the favorite won all of those vital games, so any losses that a power conference team suffered in week two have room to be overcome in the CSR conference strength rankings.
- 13:37Coming into the week, it was the ACC that led all women's basketball conferences.
- 13:42They had a winning record over 20 other leagues through the first seven days.
- 13:45The Big 12 and SEC were tied with 18, followed by the Big Ten and Big East.
- 13:50Among the mid-major conferences, the Atlantic 10, American, and Pac-12 were tops.
- 13:55With another seven days of games, the SEC has matched the ACC, with both currently leading 23 head-to-heads over other conferences.
- 14:03The Big 12 and Big Ten are tied with 20 each, then a gap back to the Big East with 15.
- 14:09The American still sits sixth, but both the Ivy League and United Athletic Conference have made big gains in week two.
- 14:16As it currently stands, each conference is beating at least one other in head-to-head matchups this season.
- 14:21In the first two weeks of games, several head-to-heads between conferences are already clinched.
- 14:26The following numbers are the new floor for each conference if they were to lose every non-conference game the rest of the season.
- 14:33The Big East is guaranteed to have eight conference head-to-head victories this season.
- 14:37The ACC follows with seven.
- 14:39The Big Ten and Big 12 both have locked up six conference head-to-heads.
- 14:43The SEC has five, and then the American, MAC, Pac-12, and UAC all have three.
- 14:49Now that the preamble is over, let's dive into the top 25 resumes in women's college basketball through two weeks.
- 14:56Starting us off is the South Carolina Gamecocks, who also sit at number one in the AP poll.
- 15:01Even though South Carolina has played two fewer games than some teams around them, two wins over each of the ACC and Big Ten give them the best allotment of wins and the highest opponent win points in the formula this week.
- 15:12Number two is the Louisville Cardinals, fresh off their win over Connecticut on Sunday.
- 15:16They sit at six and O, with their second best win being Ball State in the MAC.
- 15:20But we look at the totality of the resume at the CSR, so they get credit for each of their six wins, even if only one of them is over a top conference.
- 15:28Three this week is TCU from the Big 12, another six and O team.
- 15:32TCU has beaten up on smaller conference teams and only sits so high because of the superior number of games played to this point.
- 15:39Their opponents only have four combined Division I victories, so the quality of their opponents' wins sits far behind the teams around them.
- 15:46Number four is West Virginia, a second Big 12 team.
- 15:49Similar to South Carolina, the Mountaineers have only played four games, but the conferences from which their opponents hailed are too impressive for the CSR formula to ignore.
- 15:58Two power conference wins and two wins over the Atlantic Ten, the eighth best conference, get the Mountaineers the number four spot this week.
- 16:05Number five is Kentucky, who sit five and O with a win over North Carolina State on their resume.
- 16:10That win is carrying them to this ranking, and they hope their opponents will keep winning so they can keep this spot because their next week of games are more fluff opponents.
- 16:19Six is Florida State, who most recently beat Florida, as well as three other schools from the Sunshine State.
- 16:24An SEC win is worth as much as any victory right now, so that rivalry win over the Gators looms large on the Seminoles' five-game resume so far.
- 16:32Seven is Virginia Tech.
- 16:34Two A-10 wins plus three more Division I victories put them on the same level as Florida State as far as who they've played, but the quality of their opponents' wins puts them just behind the Seminoles.
- 16:44The eighth-ranked team this week is the California Golden Bears, a fourth ACC team in the top eight.
- 16:50Cal sits in 10th place in both direct wins and opponent win points, a combo that gets them a little boost in this week's top 25.
- 16:57Ninth this week is the Indiana Hoosiers.
- 16:59Without a statement wins to their name quite yet, Indiana is taking advantage of their five wins in five games to have earned their spot in the rankings this week.
- 17:07Rounding out the top 10 is Virginia, a fifth ACC team.
- 17:11Similar to Indiana, no big wins on the Cavaliers' resume yet, and although the value of their wins is higher than the Hoosiers', those opponents only have five D1 wins compared to Indiana's seventh, putting them 10th and behind Indiana right now.
- 17:25To complete the top 25, 11 is Minnesota, 12 Georgia, 13 UCLA, 14 BYU, 15 is Missouri, 16 Iowa State, 17 Notre Dame, 18 is Butler, 19 is Baylor, number 20 is Princeton, the first one-loss team to make an appearance in the top 25.
- 17:4421 is Texas Tech, 22 Duke, 23 SMU, 24 Nebraska, and 25 Oklahoma.
- 17:51I want to mention number 26 just because it's another mid-major this week.
- 17:55Five and O Illinois State is the first team out of the top 25.
- 18:00The top 25 this week is starting to be dominated by the power conferences with eight ACC, six Big 12, five SEC, four Big Ten, one Big East, and one Ivy League team.
- 18:12The CSR didn't find much in common with the AP voters after week two.
- 18:16The AP had just four ACC compared with the CSR's eight.
- 18:20The Big 12 only had three in the AP compared to the CSR's six.
- 18:24The SEC was overvalued by the AP poll voters.
- 18:27Somehow, ten Big Ten teams made the AP top 25, six too many, but at least the four that deserved it were in there.
- 18:34And to round it out, two-loss UConn from the Big East was number seven this week in the Associated Press poll.
- 18:40If we were to slap together a 76-team bracket with our CSR formula this week, that would lead to an inhumane 14 ACC teams making the field.
- 18:49They'd be followed by the SEC with 12, the Big Ten and Big 12 with nine, the Big East with three, then the American and the MAC both with two.
- 18:57Similar to the men, the play-in games would take place between the 12 and 14 seed lines, the final play-in being adjusted from the 13 seed line to keep conference teams from playing each other too early in the tournament.
- 19:09The final four teams to receive at-large bids would be Iowa, Arkansas, Clemson, and Bowling Green.
- 19:15The first four out of the 76-team field would be South Florida, Washington, Oregon, and DePaul.
- 19:21If you head to commonsensrankings.com, you can see the full CSR bracket recommendation.
- 19:26As we snake through the top four seed lines, the Philadelphia one bracket would see South Carolina on the one line, California the two, Indiana the three, and Iowa State the four.
- 19:36In the second Philadelphia quarter, Louisville would be the top seed, followed by Virginia Tech on the two line, Virginia at the three, and Missouri the four.
- 19:45In the first Las Vegas bracket, TCU would be the one seed, Florida State at the two, Minnesota would be the three, and BYU the four seed.
- 19:53And in the final quarter of the bracket, West Virginia, Kentucky, Georgia, and UCLA would be the top four seed lines.
- 20:01Next, let's look at a few women's blind resume tests.
- 20:04Keep in mind, win margin does not matter in the CSR.
- 20:07The only question we ask is who won the game?
- 20:10In blind resume test number one, team A is five and O.
- 20:13They have a win over an SEC team, a team from the Metro, the SWAC, and two over the ASun.
- 20:18The teams they've defeated have six Division I victories.
- 20:22Team B is two and one with wins over the A-10 and Ivy League.
- 20:25Their loss is to an undefeated SEC team, and the teams they've defeated also have six Division I victories.
- 20:31So we have team A with three more wins, who also has an SEC win, zero losses compared to team B's one loss, and the quality of their opponents' wins is comparable, yet team B was the one in the AP Top 25 this week.
- 20:44That would be Maryland, who, uh, earned the 18th spot this week by AP voters, yet sit 107th in the CSR.
- 20:52Team A is Florida State, who received zero votes and sit sixth in this, week's Common Sense rankings.
- 20:59Blind resume test number two.
- 21:01Team A is five and O.
- 21:02They have wins over the Atlantic Sun, the MAAC, the Ohio Valley, the Southern Conference, and the Summit League.
- 21:07Five teams they've defeated have just two Division I victories.
- 21:11Team B is three and O, so two fewer wins.
- 21:14They have two wins over the Big West and one over the West Coast Conference, and their three opponents have three Division I wins.
- 21:20So success of opponents favors team B slightly, but the two additional wins would likely give team A the edge, right?
- 21:27To the AP voters, it vehemently does not.
- 21:30Washington is team B, 16th in the AP poll, 60th in the CSR.
- 21:35Team A was Butler, 18th in the Common Sense rankings, yet lacking a single vote from the 33 men and women who vote this week.
- 21:43The AP voters this week got 11 of the top 25 resumes correct, but just two of the top 10.
- 21:49West Virginia sits number four in the CSR, but down at number 21 in the AP poll.
- 21:54The highest any voter had the Mountaineers was 15, so a holler at Jeff Linder for his assessment of West Virginia.
- 22:01Southern Cal was fourth in the AP poll, but lack a statement win has them down at 85th in the CSR.
- 22:07There were four voters who put the Trojans as low as seventh in their ballots, so giving in to assumed peer pressure just a little bit.
- 22:13Angel Grey, Owen Sebring, Rebecca Lobo, and Alex Simon, consider yourselves complimented.
- 22:19On the other end of the ballot spectrum, I'll likely continue to call out the person who put two and two North Carolina the highest, at least until they have a half-decent win.
- 22:27With wins over just North Carolina Central and Penn, Gene Wang thinks they are the 14th best team in the country.
- 22:33Gene, you're just wrong.
- 22:36There were three voters who put a three and one team with wins over Utah State, UNLV, and Charleston all the way up at number two.
- 22:43Ethan Fuller, Maggie Vanoni, and Kelly Gramlik each put the Southern Cal Trojans that high, better than 41 teams who are at least four and O against Division I opponents.
- 22:54That'll wrap up another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 22:57If you want to give me a follow on the socials, you can do so@commonsenseranking.
- 23:02I'm consistently posting about the matchups each night that will swing the conference head-to-heads this season if you want more information.
- 23:08College basketball rankings will be updated nearly daily throughout the season at commonsenserankings.com.
- 23:13There's also bracket, conference, and blind resume information for each week of the season.
- 23:19I'm going to try to get out a college basketball weekly pod on Mondays or Tuesdays, then a college football pod on Wednesdays through the remainder of the season.
- 23:26After the CFP is announced, it'll be just one basketball podcast each week until Selection Sunday.
- 23:32And with that, please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense