Latest / The Dokkcast / Innovations in Endoscopic Surgery with Professor Hesham Saleh
Transcript
- 0:00Hesham: Yeah, definitely. I mean, are things that have been useful for social media, like if you look at, there's a lot of websites, like online, I mean, I'm talking about the internet, from big institutes, institutions like the Mayo Clinic or Cleveland Clinic and so on, and The UK as well, that explains everything to the patient. ENT UK has so much stuff.
- 0:19Nara: So these
- 0:20Hesham: are really good for patients to get information. But for facial plastic and cosmetic surgery, it's completely opposite sometimes.
- 0:32Nara: So thank you very much, Hesham. It's lovely to see you.
- 0:37Hesham: You too.
- 0:38Nara: So Professor Saleh is one of the great leading lights of ENT surgery and a personal mentor and friend. So thank you so much for agreeing to this discussion today. Really lovely to see you.
- 0:50Hesham: Thanks for inviting me.
- 0:51Nara: Yeah. Tell me a little bit, perhaps if we start introduce who you are for those who don't know you. Obviously, within the field of ENT, there's no one who doesn't know you. But outside of that, who you are, where you work now, and and what you do.
- 1:04Hesham: So I'm consultant ENT, but the specialization is basically rhinology, which is sinus and facial plastic, but that's mainly septorhinal and nasal reconstruction. I work in the Imperial College. It's mainly Cheyenne Cross Hospital. So I'm really based in Cheyenne Cross, but I do some clinics in the Brompton, Royal Brompton. And because the Imperial also covered Saint Mary's and Hammersmith, we sort of oversee the the these parts of, you know, of of the Imperial as well.
- 1:31But, really, I'm all my sessions are Cheyenne Cross and the Brompton. So I would do sinus complex sinus studies, skull base, and septorhinoplasty. I also obviously do private practice. And a few years ago, I was given the title of professor of practice in radiology in the Imperial.
- 1:49Nara: Which is very prestigious.
- 1:51Hesham: Mean nice. Yes. It's takes I think it takes a lot of experience and a lot of, you know, things that you have to have done before you get it. And it's a long process of application and so on, which is quite nice because it helps me for teaching as well and for the presented Imperial internationally more. It's good for Imperial as well.
- 2:12It's good for me, of course.
- 2:14Nara: Yeah. I mean, you're an incredibly passionate teacher, aren't you? And I think you're very well known surgery in general and ENT, which is ear, nose and throat surgery in particular, is an incredibly dedicated passionate teacher of the practice. Obviously for those who don't know, Impera is probably one of the biggest trusts within The UK, certainly within London. It looks after a huge patch in North West Of London and under it fall a number of hospitals, which obviously you will cover the Royal Brompton, which is a specialist heart and lung centre being one of them.
- 2:49Tell me a little bit around how you journeyed into ENT. Where does, where does that sort of, you know, cause you're incredibly passionate about it, right? And you love it. You really, really do love it. You teach it, you research it, you operate on it, etcetera.
- 3:05How did you find yourself in ENT? How did that start and how did the medical journey start? And we might have to go back to the young Hashem and Yeah.
- 3:17Hesham: That's an interesting story, you know? So I actually did like ENT. So when I was a medical student, I really liked ENT. You know, you do, like, a short period, like, few weeks of ENT of every specialty anyway. So I thought, I like that specialty, but I didn't, like, decided anything.
- 3:33You're just a young student. Then I came to so I had graduated in Egypt. My parents had moved to England already anyway. So I moved. I followed my brother.
- 3:41You have to do the exam, the plan, and all that, which was quite tough. So we'll be allowed to work in The UK. And I hadn't decided what I'm gonna do yet. I thought I was just gonna be a surgeon, but I actually was looking at cardiac surgery.
- 3:53Nara: Okay.
- 3:53Hesham: Why? Because this professor, Madhya Kubo, was very famous then, and he was amazing Egyptian as well, and I wanna be like him.
- 4:01Nara: He's very inspirational.
- 4:03Hesham: He was very inspirational and I wanted to be a surgeon anyway. So to do any surgical specialty, you have to start with general surgery and then you have to do accident and emergency. It was like this at the time, completely different system. And then you go for the specialty you want, and then you can proceed until you do your exams, and then you apply for registrars and so on. So I applied for general surgery.
- 4:24That was my first job in The UK. I did it. It was in a remote place. And then I got a casualty job, and I was doing my exams and so on. And in the meantime, I was talking to various people about cardiac surgery and so on to see what I'm gonna do.
- 4:39And the the cardiac surgeons I saw were a bit too much for me, actually. And but also they worked too much. They worked they one of them said to me, yeah. You'll give you'll be 50 and you'll be on call and you go to the hospital at 3AM. That's just normal all the time.
- 4:54Said, I could imagine myself being 50 and just not sleeping and and so on. Then I was in the ward, keep thinking, oh, do I really wanna do cardiac surgery? And then there was this gentleman who keeps coming to the ward. I was doing general surgery, and everybody's talking to him. He's very smiley and very nice and relaxed.
- 5:13And then he goes away, and people just really like him. Then I said, who is that? He said, this is a d ENT consultant. He said, oh, he's very nice. They all like that.
- 5:22I said, really? Wow. He said, yeah. ENT, they all like this. He said, oh, I used to like ENT when I was when I was young.
- 5:28You know? Can I can I see him? So I went to see him. Oh, come and watch this. So I wow.
- 5:34There's a lot of surgery and interesting stuff on the variety. I like that. I wanna do that. So that was it. So I decided then no cardiac surgery, it's ENT.
- 5:41Nara: It's ENT. So you would have been the more sort of what was in old money called senior house officer?
- 5:47Hesham: I was SHO, senior house officer who had done surgery then, yeah, which
- 5:51Nara: Now you're done as core trainees, yes.
- 5:53Hesham: Had to do as a what you're called core trainee, wasn't so that time there was no structure, so you basically apply for jobs every six months. So you apply for general surgery and then you apply for accident emergency, And then you're supposed to apply for a specialty that you don't have to do, but relate it to the what you have to do in the future. For example, if you wanna do ENT, you would probably do neurosurgery or plastics. Yeah. But you didn't have to do that.
- 6:17So I actually added general surgery, accident emergency, then ENT. So I started
- 6:23Nara: my place where the guy
- 6:24Hesham: No. Different places. No. Because I'm not a local graduate. It wasn't that simple.
- 6:27So, basically, people told me, you really wanna do an ENT in The UK. Forget it. It's not gonna happen. It's impossible.
- 6:33Nara: Because it was hard to get into.
- 6:35Hesham: Because it's very hard to get into. I said, we'll see. You know? And so I applied. I I, like, I worked in New Yorkshire for the casualty for the sorry, for the general surgery job.
- 6:44And that was after twenty seventh of application, had one interview. So that was my first job. So I got that job. And after that job, I applied to casualty for a lot of job, but I can't remember how many. And I got interviewed in Middlesbrough and Wales.
- 7:00That was it. Not not even Yorkshire. So I went to Middlesbrough. Actually, I was offered the job. And the following day, I was offered the job also in in Wales, in South Wales, Abercabenny.
- 7:12And then people said to me, don't go to to Middlesbrough. The job is busy, and there's lots of problems, and you wanna study for your exam. So, sadly, I did apologize, which I I do regret to the consultant then. Yeah. But he had another person anyway.
- 7:25So I did the job there. I passed my exam while I was there and all that, which was very useful.
- 7:29Nara: This is the this is the this is the primaries, the FRCN.
- 7:31Hesham: Primary FRCS. The exams then was completely different from now. Primary FRCS
- 7:35Nara: very is difficult to pass. I think Yeah.
- 7:36Hesham: It has to bring a lot of anatomy, lot of physiology. Exactly. Lot of biochemistry. So did the exam, and I then got the ENT job in Boston, Lancashire, which people even didn't know. My consultants were great there, actually.
- 7:52And they told me, you need to proceed. You have to be in DG hospitals. And one of the registrars said to me, do you have any papers? He said, what papers? He said, you know I have to do recession.
- 8:01Okay. Why why didn't anybody tell me that?
- 8:04Nara: It's Yeah. Funny, you of find these things as you go along. Nobody tells me
- 8:09Hesham: what doing.
- 8:10Nara: There's no mentorship. Yeah.
- 8:12Hesham: Yeah. By then, yeah, so I I wrote the paper immediately. I did a case report, and then I got a job in Nottingham. While I was in Nottingham
- 8:22Nara: From ENT job this one now?
- 8:23Hesham: ENT now. Yeah. So SH SHL. I went I wanted advice from a senior that I thought maybe I should get an advice from some senior ENT. So then mister Omar Shahina was really well known consultant guys.
- 8:38He was a friend of a friend of my dad, so I went to see him. And he gave me a lot of advice. He said to continue working hard and so on. Yeah. It was very useful advice.
- 8:45And, yeah, from then onwards, I it was still actually not straightforward to get the registrar jobs because of my status as foreign graduate, also the visa status because it hadn't actually even though my family was living here, it was not that simple to get the permanent residency yet. So I couldn't apply straight away for numbers, so I had to do locums. So I did locum registrars, Liverpool, and then Plymouth and Turkey. And then I got my number training, which was in Scotland. So I traveled a lot.
- 9:17When I gave a lecture, yeah, when I gave the lecture of my the presidency president presidential address, they call it, in RSM ten years ago. So I put a map to see where I moved from. Like that. I got my number. Bandido was amazing job, brilliant training.
- 9:35And I think from then, I really liked the way they trained us, and I wanted to do the same because you felt the consultants were really just dedicated to look after us. They had the time, it was a different perspective from what we have here in London, you're busy, you're running around, do a lot more things here, but we had an amazing built department, it was designed to be contained in one unit, so everything is there. We had a lab. We had, like, area for dissections, for the trainees, everything. And I had a really nice training for two years, but then my wife wanted to move to London to work in the BBC.
- 10:11And then we moved to applied here and just moved to London. And, again, met amazing people, I was trained by the top rhinologist. By then, I've decided I'm I'm just gonna be a rhinologist because I when I actually was in Mudd's in Dundee, I worked with Paul White who was amazing rhinologist, and so this is my specialty. So that was after doing about two years of ENT as a reg, I liked that, and I thought this is it. So I worked then in in the, what I call, the North Thames rotation anyway, And I ended up working with Barryland, then Ian MacKay, where my dream, dream Yeah.
- 10:47Nara: I mean, Ian MacKay and Barryland are the other probably from from, you know, the last sort of fifty years are the leading lights of, right now. I mean, they are, they are sort of world famous and have been awarded that. So just to sort of, you know, dive into that a little deeper. So it's really interesting because, as you were talking, it reminds me of, or prompts me to think how different it is for the trainees today. Although you moved over the lot quite a few times and all over The UK, you had a lot of agency and decision over what you did with your life.
- 11:24And one of the issues for trainees today is that that choice is much more restricted. Everything is limited. Yeah, correct. It's everything is formalized and squeezed into set pathways, which they can't kind of almost get, get out of. And, know, we learn at different rates, don't we?
- 11:42And we decide what we want to do at different rates. So, you know, despite the fact that it was difficult, it sounds like, because you were so driven both once you've decided EMT is your chosen field and then to subspecialize in nasal surgery, rhinology, the next step, you could use that agency to go to places where you felt you had the best training, Right?
- 12:06Hesham: Yeah. Exactly. You're right. Yeah. Exactly.
- 12:09You had a bit more freedom. I mean, much more freedom to move around and choose where you wanna go, which in my situation, yeah, it gave me advantage because I moved around with work with with a lot of top people across the country anyway, but it took longer. That's one thing. So you would say the system new system was created to try to make it a bit shorter and and to make it organised so it's easier, but then it does restrict your choices. So you could go to an area that doesn't have the subspecialty in the level that you want, for example.
- 12:40So it definitely is. So there have to be solutions for this, which is the creation of fellowships because people have been doing training somewhere and they still wanna do more than the fellowships. And this is what we're doing now. And I think that's why the number of fellowships increased now. I created the first fellowship in The UK, which is 2,003.
- 12:58There was no fellowship Yeah. By Yeah. Was no fellowship.
- 13:01Nara: By knowledge fellowship. Yeah.
- 13:02Hesham: Yeah. And I fought to for the hospital to pay for it, but they won't. So I had it for free. So but the the fellows came anyway, and they got money from whatever until at some stage, it was a bit too much when my Australian fellow had a baby, and it was just too much. I said, okay.
- 13:16I'm not having any more fellows. So then the hospital said, okay, we're gonna pay them some.
- 13:20Nara: Because actually they contribute a lot. They're very, very senior in that, you know, very, very often they've got twenty years as a doctor. So yeah, it's a bit of a quirk, isn't it? Of medicine. I mean, until recently they used to be called junior doctors and now they're resident doctors, but you can't be in your forties, having done twenty years as a doctor, very senior in your training.
- 13:39And you're still called a resident doctor just because you haven't made that jump to be a consultant, which seems crazy.
- 13:44Hesham: Yeah. Because yeah. It's it's it's interesting, isn't it, that they changed that name because now they're probably getting older because they spend a long time. But yeah. Yeah.
- 13:53And doctors, they have families, you know, but they're still moving. Arasoq, my current fellow. He has two children. He had to move from the North to come down to London, and his family had to follow him. So Yeah.
- 14:05Still unsettling. The system in The UK, the training is great because people finish a training, are really experienced. But it is long, and it does affect your family. If you look at the system in Australia or The United States, it's quite intense. It's short.
- 14:21But they finish in a young age. Yeah. They finish in a young age. They have good enough experience as well. Yeah.
- 14:28I don't know how we can make our system like theirs is because it's all based in their like, for example, in Australia, the public system, how it works. Here, NHS is structured that way that the trainees are workers as well. They're not just providing they're not just there to actually learn, they're providing service, aren't they? So that's something
- 14:47Nara: that is a real problem because there is service provision on one side and the majority of what the NHS provides is actually provided by training grades, which I think is also bad. It doesn't quite capture the seniority, the experience and the level of training of this group of people, But then the second thing is training and that is for someone which will, which will come to later on as well, but it's probably just a high, good to highlight now for someone like yourself, when you say that one of the best units you worked in, think, would you say it was Newcastle Nottingham? Dundee. Sorry, Dundee. That, that they had, you had the wet lab there.
- 15:25You had, you know, ability to drill temporal bones, which is obviously for surgery of the ear. And you had really dedicated time with your trainers, with the consultants. And one of the things that, that, that we hear a lot from consultants now, particularly senior ones like yourself, is you just don't have as much time to teach as you would like.
- 15:46Hesham: Yeah. And
- 15:46Nara: that's, that's, that's not good. It's, you know, we, we don't have that space to, to, to, to teach and pass on that knowledge as well as we should.
- 15:54Hesham: Yeah. That's yeah. Sadly, it's the case, and it's reflected on the system itself, how it's run and so on. And you go more south, you go, you find the consultants are busy because they have to do more private practice and so on as well. So that's one of the advantages in Indeed that they didn't have to do that as well.
- 16:12So they had the time. But the way the department was structured, it it was modeled on a Canadian department because the head of department then, Robert Blair, he was a consultant in Canada for nine, ten years, and he modeled that system to to us in Dundee because, obviously, the residents they call the residents anyway in the in The United States and Canada. They're there just to learn. So they're basically students. They do the work as well by these students, so they supervise all the time.
- 16:40So that's how they did it. So I'm actually doing something in here, not exactly the same, but I run my clinic like this. I convince the manager that I lost. So I stand in the middle and every all the residents are in the rooms calling the patients. Every patient, they talk to a patient, get a history, then I go and join them.
- 17:02And I discuss the patient with them and examine the patient with them and move so I can see all the patients. And I think this is much better teaching way and much better for the patient, of course, because the consultant is there to consult, not just to sit in a room seeing a certain number of patients, not seeing the others. Yes. So this is what I'm trying
- 17:20Nara: to It's the old style consultant model, isn't it? That's what consultants need
- 17:24Hesham: be doing. And it works, it works, you know. But somehow, obviously, you know, NHS management has got settled that way that consultant is sitting in the room
- 17:35Nara: Yep.
- 17:35Hesham: And just calls the patient. But now with these all these computer things that you have to you you know, like, actually, we've done an audit. How much time you're spending putting information in the computer and how much time you're spending with the patient? It turned out that putting things in the
- 17:50Nara: Spend more time on the computer than a Yeah.
- 17:52Hesham: So but if you're a consultant, you know, use your skill, clinical skill that you accumulated for years and years and years to consult and let these things done by somebody else. You know? So this is what I'm doing.
- 18:04Nara: And They're I hope that everybody trying to make it like as if a consultant time is the same as any other, you know, as if doctors change changeable, then they're really not, you know, no, you're right. I'm going to take you back a little bit and ask you about what it was like, you know, as a, as somebody who wasn't a UK graduate, you know, it, you know, did you, how was that for you? And was that something that you felt, you needed to adjust anything for? Was it, you know, cause it was hard for everyone, To get into ENT to get it to the, it was difficult all around. So, but how did you find it?
- 18:39How was that transition? I know your parents had moved here already. And in some ways, do you reflect on some of the things that are going on now seeing that I think it's even over 40% of the core trainee level, the SHO grade is at the moment being provided for by non UK graduates. So one of the challenges, because I think you were, you know, whilst you weren't the only one, but there wasn't that many UK graduates at that point doing what you're doing, whereas now a huge amount of, of service delivery, you know, basically seeing and treating patients is delivered by non UK graduates, which is, which actually is one of the current issues that the BMA is talking about. What tell me how you sort of, how was it for you then?
- 19:22And what do you think has gone on since, since that time?
- 19:25Hesham: Yeah. It's maybe it was a bit different. It's interesting then because in the beginning I'll just give you an example of something. When I work at when I worked in the non teaching hospitals, there were some foreign graduates. Yeah.
- 19:41Not as much as now. Is you you wouldn't say 40%, maybe 10%. Yeah. When I worked in the teaching hospital, it was only me in the department from any level. I said I was only SHO, foreign graduate, nobody else when I got appointed in Nottingham.
- 20:00And, actually, I remember because my friend Mike Sonders sent me look. I found the rotator on call in July 1992.
- 20:07Nara: Oh, wow.
- 20:08Hesham: Yeah. And he sent it to me just like a couple of weeks ago. So so what happened in the foreign graduate found jobs in the district hospitals.
- 20:18Nara: Mhmm.
- 20:19Hesham: So they didn't found the training jobs as much is what happened unless they prove themselves with publications, exams, and everything else. So that was that was the hard thing then. I think now is a lot of The UK graduates are leaving, seem to be. So they're to Australia and so on. So that's why the there's more open for foreign graduates to come in as well.
- 20:41Yeah. So, obviously, when you study somewhere else, if you go back to your question again, it's a completely different system. But it actually, the plan did help me to understand the system, studying for the plan. Because then you know exactly what's it like here and just do, like, attachment in hospitals and so on. You're never actually the same as the local graduate knowledge wise and because they've been exposed to everything.
- 21:04So I'm not saying it's completely justified not to give the non local graduate jobs, because it was a bit of an extreme thing then, so don't get shortlisted if you're a non local graduate, to most jobs anyway at that time. Even if
- 21:17Nara: have a not right, right?
- 21:18Hesham: Mean Yeah, that's of course. I mean, there was a paper published, very famous. I was talking about this yesterday with my fellow, Sam Evington, I think, and they did the fake CVs and, like, with different names, like Indian names and and, like, Western names, and the percent of the the different shortlisting was staggering. Yeah. So things like this used to happen in my time anyway, and it happened to me across all the time until I got the consultant job and that's it.
- 21:48So it was like that, you know? I don't know what's it like now, but you know, like now there's so many procedures to prevent that, which is at the anonymize that there's no names and so on. Yeah, which is great. But I think things have changed a lot. And I think the system will always depend on non local graduates because you never have enough graduates from The UK medical schools anyway.
- 22:12And imagine now is a huge immigration from them. Like I see the medical students. I'm responsible for something we call this specialist placement in ENT, which I have a student for a month.
- 22:23Nara: These are medical students, right?
- 22:25Hesham: They're medical students. They come, they spend a month. The ones with really interest in ENT. So I've created that long time ago with the medical school because when I realized that students, they only come for a week, it was not enough. So if anybody's interested so so I have about four or five or six maybe students a year.
- 22:40So every time I ask them, what do you wanna do? I'm gonna go to Australia or something like that, or I'm going to go to US. So many of them say that now. Yeah. They don't want to stay.
- 22:49So sadly, the system has done something to these young doctors to to feel that there's just not hope for them to stay here, it's not like some good perspective, so they want to leave. So something wrong is happening. It needs to be fixed. Yeah.
- 23:04Nara: I think you're right. And the of so the tragedy that sort of is going to befall us, I think, will be more obvious in about five years. Yeah. When actually these students that you're hearing with the desire to move actually become doctors and then, and then do move if they don't see that their, their lot changes. So now I'm going to take you back to, again, to when you decided to do ENT.
- 23:30What was it about the rhinology bit and, you know, obviously you and I know what falls under rhinology, which is just noses, but you know, the man on the street, you know, what is it? What's rhinology? What, you know, do people see the end of your nose and you think, well, it's not, there can't be that much to do in there. Yeah. So, so what, what is rhinology?
- 23:49Hesham: Yeah. What do mean? I'll tell you why actually that I could really think of when I actually thought I'd like that. So rhinology, obviously, anything related to the nose. Yeah.
- 24:01But it starts with from inside and outside. So I gave my lecture. I call it the nose inside and out once, which is my RSM lecture because then talked about the inside. So the inside is the sinuses and allergies.
- 24:11Nara: That lecture up on the UDOC as well because that would be a very interesting one.
- 24:14Hesham: Yeah. This lecture, I do RSM have it as a saved lecture. I I I have it as well as video. Yeah. So and then so, basically so rhinology, obviously, dealing with sinusitis, which is so common.
- 24:26Yeah. And allergy really common.
- 24:28Nara: Sinuses. Yeah.
- 24:28Hesham: Yeah. Sinuses, you know, sinusitis is like, five percent of this at point, we're sitting here, five percent of The UK population has sinusitis. It's a lot. Millions. Yeah?
- 24:39So it's very common. And also allergies, but then it extends something that we worked on later on, you know, which extended sinus, which you deal with the brain because it's close and you can actually deal with that through the nose anyway. So that's one aspect of it. But then the outside, which is the shape of the nose, but also the septum, which is what you can block your breathing, it's broken or deviated or something. So then you could do a cosmetic part which you change the shape of the nose.
- 25:05So all this covers rhinology in a way. And the bit I liked in the beginning was the sinus surgery because what happened in the late eighties, early nineties, that this there was a revolution on sinus surgery. So it was basically coming from Austria interestingly that they studied how things work, the physiology of the sinuses, and realized the way they did it at that time was wrong. You have to use cameras and endoscopes and you target the areas to open which are where the drainage comes from naturally, not just make holes everywhere that they did in the past. So really changed, and the leaders of this were Ian MacKay, who was the first one to do this, and Valerie, who was his student later on, Valerie Lando, became professor of rhinology as well.
- 25:49And I saw
- 25:50Nara: this Valerie Lando.
- 25:51Hesham: Yeah. Dame Valerie. So I was working in Nottingham as a young senior house officer, and the new consultant start just started six months ago called Nick Jones. Professor Nick Jones was retired. Nick Jones had just been appointed after being working in London with Ian Mackay, And he started something called endoscopic sinus surgery that they've never heard of in Nottingham.
- 26:15And he was doing that.
- 26:16Nara: What year is this? What year
- 26:17Hesham: is That would be 1992.
- 26:20Nara: '92?
- 26:21Hesham: Yeah.
- 26:21Nara: So before '92, we're saying no sinus surgery, people literally just drilling holes into the
- 26:27Hesham: Exactly. Yeah. There was nobody
- 26:28Nara: for the best. Blind not blindly, but near blindly. Right? Just by the heel.
- 26:33Hesham: And it didn't work that well. That's why
- 26:35Nara: Oh, surprisingly. Yeah.
- 26:36Hesham: It was notoriously I had bad reputation. Gonna have a sinus operation. It's not gonna work. You know? It was like this.
- 26:41Yeah. So then he was holding the endoscope, and we look and we see all these things. That was fascinating. For me, that was like, this is the best thing ever. And that's why I like the rhinology then.
- 26:51So, obviously, I hadn't done it. I hadn't been able to do this, so I haven't touched it. So I still don't know until I was a registrar, then I was taught to do it, which is only a couple of years later anyway. When I did it, I thought, oh, my skill is very good in this. I love it.
- 27:03So that was how I I liked rhinology. So it was a developing specialty. It was a big revolution in it. Everything's like this, catch up slowly. So although it started in late 80s, by time other consultants learn it and catches up in UK in different regions, it takes ages.
- 27:20So there was a lot of hospitals still not doing this endoscopic sinus surgery until mid nineties, you know, across The UK. Ian McKay was the leader, and he was in London. He taught a lot of people in London. So in London, it was different then. But then across the area and Nick Jones moved from London to Nottingham.
- 27:40So, like, I remember when I went to Liverpool later on as a locum, nobody was doing it. And that was '94.
- 27:46Nara: If you think about it now. I mean, it's probably one of the commonest operations we do, you know, and sinus surgery of all different ones. You can get very simple, straightforward ones that you can get immensely complex ones that actually go into skull based surgery. Right. And everything in between.
- 28:00So there's a huge variety. It was probably one of the commonest other than tonsils and grommeting So like
- 28:06Hesham: some statistics, few years ago, twenty thousand sinus operations are done in The UK a year. So that is a lot. Yeah. So that was some older statistics, much more now probably. Yeah.
- 28:17Yeah. It is because sinusitis is common.
- 28:20Nara: Yeah. Yeah. And the difficulty with sinus operations is that you've got to be, you've got to have a brain that's very good at three dimensions because you're looking on a screen. So for people who don't know, there is a telescope, which you can look down with your eyes. And some people did do that, particularly initially, but now it's with a camera that's attached to a stack with a monitor.
- 28:39So you're looking at the monitor that projects the image seen through the endoscopes. It's two dimensions Yeah. Massively magnified. And then of course you've got the CT scan of the sinuses, right? Which essentially is like cuts through, through the face.
- 28:54So
- 28:54Hesham: you've got
- 28:55Nara: to put together what you see on the scan with what you see on the screen and then make it into three-dimensional in your head. Right?
- 29:04Hesham: Exactly. So not everybody can be good at it. Yeah. Although, you know, you could teach most ENT surgeons to do it. That's why people tend to like certain areas.
- 29:17That's why you find maybe your mental ability or something more suitable to certain areas. So for me, maybe it was that. There was some time though some time ago people said people are good at computer games are good at sinus surgery.
- 29:31Nara: Yeah. I can see that.
- 29:32Hesham: Maybe it is true. We we haven't proven this, but I need to get some people are really can
- 29:37Nara: do a study on roadblocks or something like Yeah.
- 29:42Hesham: If yeah. So it's eye hand coordination. Yeah? Between because you're looking straight, you're not looking down at the patient. You look at the screen and operating like this.
- 29:51Eye, hand coordination and mental building a three d image of what you're
- 29:55Nara: You're not actually looking at the patient, are you? I mean, you might do when you're grabbing an instrument to pop it inside
- 30:00Hesham: the Just when you're grabbing an instrument, but otherwise you're looking at the screen, which is straight on from your life.
- 30:05Nara: That discipline of rhinology, so sinuses is, as I say, goes from very simple, but goes all the way to the skull base, right?
- 30:12Hesham: Yeah.
- 30:13Nara: And it's the bit that anybody who's in rhinology, and I suppose I'd include myself in that, finds that the most exciting in some ways. But there's only so many, you know, anterior skull based surgeons we need in The UK, right? That's the bit I think people very often, that's also the scary bit, right. It's one of the things we consent people, you know, one of the, one of the dangers that we say to people who undergo sinus surgery, say, the bone between your sinus and the brain can crack when we do this operation unintentionally. Can fix it, of course, but that's what happened.
- 30:43How did you, how did you, how, what was your experience in that jump from, you know, just, you know, staying in our lane and staying in the nose to then ENT surgeons going, you know what, this is actually a pathway to the brain. And of course we work in certain units to do this closely with neurosurgeons, right? How can you recall your path into going actually, I'm going to go beyond the sinus and I'm actually going to use this as an approach to the brain?
- 31:08Hesham: Yeah, so Ian MacKay was already repairing CSF leaks, which is when there is a crack in the bone above the sinuses and the fluid
- 31:17Nara: is And the leak from around the brain, right? Yeah. The brain
- 31:20Hesham: Patients were referred to him because he did it with endoscope. Have either accident that caused that or maybe an operation caused this, or some people have it spontaneously, which is a bit of an unusual rare condition. So he was repairing this already, which I learned from him. But I saw the research that was coming, especially from a group in The USA. They were doing what we call joint surgery.
- 31:46They work with the neurosurgeon at the same time, and they openly take the pituitaries out, for example, like tumors or the pituitary gland up here or even meningiomas like other type of tumors they were doing that. And they had a big experience. I went there. I did the course, and I thought we have to do that. Nobody's doing this joint surgery in The UK yet.
- 32:06Although some people did the pituitaries in The UK then, but that was it. Nobody did anything more than that. And because you can access I mean, like the old you know, the ancient Egyptians did that, the mummification, they went through the nose anyway. The brain is
- 32:19Nara: It didn't say. That's how they shook the brain out through Exactly. Yeah. They took it out
- 32:22Hesham: of point. Yeah. I didn't think that because I'm Egyptian or anything like that. So I just thought yeah.
- 32:26Nara: You were tested. Yeah. You were tested.
- 32:28Hesham: Great, yeah, great area of surgery that we should be doing more in The UK. Yeah.
- 32:32Nara: And what year is this, Hesham? What year
- 32:33Hesham: is 2000 and 2002. And I so I did the I did the the course. I, you know, I saw what they're doing. I saw we can expand out. So I talked to neurosurgeons who were a bit reluctant in the beginning.
- 32:46I kept convincing them. Let me just show you. Let's just use the endoscope. We could show you that. And after I think maybe it took me six months to a year to so 2003, we did the first case, and then then he rose and saw the light, and he was like jumping.
- 33:00Nara: Endoscopic light.
- 33:02Hesham: Endoscopic light. And he said, oh, that's great. I could see much more. Said, let's do more. And we started doing more, and then we got the group from Pittsburgh to visit us in Cheyenne Cross Hospital to show how this is done and invited everyone in The UK who have interest in rhinology, everyone I know anyway, advertise everywhere.
- 33:24Anybody who wants to come and watch Skull Base, come and see that. And we had a lot of people who just did that like a a day of teaching on this area. And many people tell me that was the launch of skull base in The UK then.
- 33:37Nara: Yeah. That's amazing.
- 33:39Hesham: Yeah. So I I presume, like, maybe other people had the idea, but I started it, I think, that then but we we knew it's happening, but we need to launch it. Now there are lots of units that doing this joint skull base surgery, which is great. Our unit continues.
- 33:53Nara: Very, it's very altruistic and charitable of you to say, look, we now know how to do it. Let's share that knowledge because sometimes they can be sort of people who want to, right. But I think that spirit of sharing is, is how, you know,
- 34:10Hesham: like I know exactly what you're saying, Nora, because yeah, it's true. But I think like our time as surgeon is a certain time. You know? Okay. You you can prove yourself.
- 34:24You'll be good at all this, but you really it's all for the patient in end. So we have to spread the knowledge. Everybody has to know it. You can't just keep your knowledge for yourself because you are the only one who wanna do it. Everybody has to learn it because then you get access to the patients.
- 34:38And I think this is and I think a lot of doctors feel the same, to be honest. These guys from Pittsburgh were like that too. They they came. They were so generous with us and showed us everything. It was just great.
- 34:48And I think now we have very good units in The UK that do that. Yeah. And you know, like it's good. I want it to be more, but you know, but it is good now.
- 34:59Nara: It is, and it is specialised. I think that's a very good time to sort of start talking about the patients because I think the evolution of rhinology endoscopic sinus surgery, we'll come to facial plastics in a second, but certainly sort of the advances in sinus treatments meant medical treatment, the way, well, not just surgical, but surgical treatments of sinus surgery, skull base, etcetera. I mean, the benefit to the patient is immense.
- 35:24Hesham: You
- 35:24Nara: know, we've gone from having something that was not treated very well at all to now, you know, so I think, you know, so how do you feel, how do you think that the evolution of this surgery has benefited patients? You know, what's kind of what's in it for the reason why we're here, which is essentially to improve patients' life, right?
- 35:44Hesham: Yeah, so the great difference between doing things with endoscope and doing things with cuts and incisions is it's more targeted, but also quicker recovery because you're not creating big wounds. Like, in the past, examine, like, for example, the surgery that we often do with the neurosurgeons. Moving a meningioma, they had to create what called craniotomy. So they they actually had to drill through the skull and go through that route and then find where the tumor is mobilized or a lot of, like, you know, working a lot of tissue that can get swollen and damaged so that the patient take much longer to recover and the complication rate is much higher. I mean, like we call brain edema, hemorrhages, and so on, much higher with open surgery.
- 36:28So that closed surgery shorten the patient's stay for the hospital, has less complication, quicker recovery, you know, and probably ultimately better result from tumor because you could see exactly what you're doing closer with the cameras and endoscope. So that that is a great advantage for the patient. And that's why this surgery has taken over in a lot of areas. So obviously, it doesn't take everything from a neurosurgeon because a lot of other surgery that neurosurgeons have to do in different using different techniques anyway. But there are certain areas of skull, which are about areas are close to the nose.
- 36:59They can always access through the nose, smaller incisions from inside, and you remove whatever tumor is there and so on. So that's advantage. Is it.
- 37:08Nara: You from, you know, weeks recovery to days recovery, right? I mean, that's Yeah. The
- 37:13Hesham: weeks or even months to two days or weeks on. Yeah, exactly. Big, big difference.
- 37:18Nara: Yeah. Which, which is, which is an. Unbelievable advancement of modern surgery. I mean, you know, if you think that this, what we're talking about is less than 20 years old or just twenty years old, you know, that's, that's quite remarkable. And this obviously happened, you know, through you and by you.
- 37:35Let's go on to facial plastics because in some ways that's a, that's quite a different thing, right? Yeah. And how, and very often people are either on the sinus surgery side of things or on the facial side. And by the way, the facial plastic side, you know, that's an area we share with plastic surgeons, right? And maxillofacial surgeons.
- 37:55So it's not just the remit of ENT surgeons. So sometimes when people go, well, does the best, you know, rhinoplasties, nose jobs? And you think, well, whoever does the most actually. I might always say to them actually somebody who knows the inside of the nose is always very helpful because you almost have to rub the bottom up. But yeah, so how did you how did that piece come, you know, the facial plastic side of things?
- 38:15Hesham: So that was also happened because my mentors did both. So in The UK, had been traditionally like this at the time anyway, that a lot of the surgeons who did the sinus and the inside also did the outside. Yeah. That's in contrast to The United States, for example, where there are different specialties. The ones who do sinus completely separate from the ones who do the facial plastics, rhinoplasties, facelift, and so on.
- 38:38But in The UK, it's been like that traditionally at that time. So when I worked in Scotland in Dundee, so one of the bosses, he was doing a lot of rhinoplasties. He learned it from one of the leaders in Canada. So that exposed me to that, and I really liked that so a lot. So I learned that a lot from him then.
- 38:58But then again, when I came to London and I worked with Imica, Imica was one of the leading, maybe two of rhinoplasty in The UK, him and Tony Bu. And I just loved what he was doing because we do 50% sinus, 50% rhinoplasties. So I learned a lot from him as well. And when I worked with Valerie Land Valerie Landers Sinuses, and I'd already applied to do a fellowship post training in The States because I believed in that type of really intense specialization in sinus surgery. And she said to me, why do you wanna do that?
- 39:32You've done enough sinus with me and in Mackay. You know? You should go and do facial plastics. I said, but, know what, just write rhinoplasty. I said, no.
- 39:41But you should learn the whole face because it's useful. I said, okay.
- 39:45Nara: Good advice?
- 39:46Hesham: Yeah. So she perfect advice. So cancel that. She canceled the fellowship for me. This she called her friend who was my gonna be my boss in Johns Hopkins and was fine and helped me to do the fellowship the fellowship with European Academy of Facial Plastic in Amsterdam, part in Beverly Hills as well, actually.
- 40:04So I basically learned the whole face and and more rhinoplasty. So that's how so it was working in parallel. And I started working when I started working with who only retired a year after I started. He's already been doing this. So when he left, we already have a waiting list of patients for sinuses and a lot of septorhinos, like traumas and so on because of the NHS.
- 40:29And this I started doing them both, and I've always done hundreds of each every year since then. So you build your practice in parallel. The one thing that you realise at some stage after a few years, I realized it's impossible for me to do skull base rhinoplasty and sinus surgery at the same time. So I decreased the skull base a little bit. So I I don't do the joint surgery.
- 40:53I stopped doing the joint surgery with the neurosurgeons because my colleagues are doing it now, but I do the skull base things that are suitable for me to do by myself.
- 41:01Nara: Yeah. So there's a little bit of succession planning, because as you say, you know, these things all evolve, right? And you can't be at the forefront of every single thing for decades and decades. And it's absolutely right as a, as a team building, which I suppose is, is a really good way to saying, you know, is there any, do you think there's misunderstandings out and you're particularly now in the sort of social media world, there's so many things, particularly about facial plastics. Is there anything where, are there any sort of misunderstandings or sort of, questions that people come to you with that you have to go actually, you know, it isn't this way, you know, sort of, there are the misunderstandings or something that social media has talked about, that you have to go actually, you know, we need to correct that, whether it's about fillers or how hard or easy nose jobs are, or, you know, what to do for, you know, sinus infections.
- 41:52Are there sort of common things that come up where you feel actually social media hasn't been great in in in telling people about it?
- 42:00Hesham: Yeah. Yeah. Definitely. I mean, there are things that have been useful for social media. Like, if you look at there's a lot of websites like, online.
- 42:09Mean, I'm talking about the Internet from big institutes institutions like the Mayo Clinic or Cleveland Clinic and so on, you know, in The UK as well that explains everything to the patient. Our ENT UK has so much stuff. So these are really good for patients to get information. But for facial plastic and cosmetic surgery, completely opposite sometimes because there's nothing like that in in a big institution doing this. The information that patients get are a lot from Instagram, TikTok, and stuff like this, and some online patients or sorry, surgeons really wanna advertise themselves more than given that's my feeling anyway.
- 42:46I could be wrong sometimes, but maybe it's something. I haven't seen it, but what I've seen is a lot of young people get really influenced by social media. Yeah. And there's a lot of doctors who are putting images a lot, which represents some unusual like like shapes of noses and so on, and the kids believe that this is what it should be like. It's the unnatural looking nose that you call it the Disney noses and and so on.
- 43:11Yes. Scooped here and so on. So young people look at these things a lot, and they look at the fillers and look at this. They think they wanna have that. So you find so many young people who want to have fillers, for example, which is not right in that young age.
- 43:24You find a lot of young people have rhinoplasty. Many, many, many, many more young people want to have rhinoplasty nowadays because they get influenced.
- 43:31Nara: Think they're Before you think?
- 43:33Hesham: Yeah. Much, much more than before. And I'll tell you an example of a patient like some of the patients come and think, one of two patients told me the ones who have more followers in Instagram are the best, which is completely, you know, completely, obviously, unbalanced because how they actually you judge the doctor by followers or by peer, you know, peer judgment or, you know, academic, you know, abilities and so on. And there is a paper published, and actually, did a we're gonna publish that paper on social media soon. There was something published that said when you Google some some doctors nowadays, even Google puts the doctors on top who have more social media presence than their academic abilities or qualifications and so on.
- 44:23So that it's not very good for the patients. So And if you saw the news two days ago, Australia decided not to allow anybody below 16 to have Australia has been a leading, by the way. It's not only that. Last year, they completely changed the rules for doctors' social media posts and so on. The doctors will put pictures of patients.
- 44:46They have to have so much consent and so much proof that this has not been manipulated and so on. It's really, really good. Like so to make sure that patients are not deceived and so on. So that was done last year. UK has some system going on, but nothing yet.
- 45:01Yeah. So social media is good, but needs to be controlled a bit better because especially in facial plastic, it can be really deceiving.
- 45:09Nara: And it's very easy to manipulate images. I mean, to the point where it is impossible to tell whether an image has been, you know, manipulated. I mean, the sort of the face morphing has been along, has, has been around rather for some time. Most facial plastic surgeons actually didn't use them exactly because they felt it was giving, you know, cause it's not that you can do anything and everything with any nose. Right.
- 45:31There's only a certain amount.
- 45:33Hesham: There's lots of limits. Yeah.
- 45:35Nara: Yeah. There are limits to it's not plasticine.
- 45:39Hesham: So I use the facial, the software manipulation for twenty something years anyway, but I tell the patient this is just software. It's just to give you an idea that how we can try to change this, but it's not doesn't mean it's gonna look like this exactly because that's
- 45:53Nara: just Yes. But
- 45:55Hesham: you look I mean, like, I I gave a lecture in the European Academy. It's called the Joseph lecture last year, and I talked about particularly this. I showed pictures in the Internet that are impossible to be not my they they are manipulated because the person looks like a different person, even the angles, everything. Yeah. So and there's a lot of them in in in the social media, but the more people don't know.
- 46:17Nara: Difficulty will be it'll be more normalized. Yeah. And for and as as younger people come through, they won't have those antennae that know what is and isn't possible.
- 46:28Hesham: They know. They wouldn't know.
- 46:29Nara: Yeah. It's setting unrealistic expectations of beauty as well.
- 46:32Hesham: Exactly. So I hope there's some, more control that comes in, in general, in The UK as well, But it is hard to control it completely. And now with AI coming as movies as well, sometimes you look, is that real or is it AI as well, all these things? So we are an area of, you know, speculation. We don't know what's gonna happen, but something has to be done.
- 46:57At least Australia is doing something, which is good. I I respect that. I hope we can have something similar.
- 47:03Nara: Yeah. And maybe and maybe and there's one bit is regulation, and the other bit is actually sort of providing guidance, you know, you're mentioning
- 47:10Hesham: it in The
- 47:10Nara: UK, maybe it's something, you know, to say, look, you know, providing guidance that you mustn't, you know, if you have put on pictures that look manipulated, then you have to, you have to, you have to declare that. So very clear, A little bit like, you know, when you had social media influencers, they had to declare if they were being paid for an ad. Yeah. So they just love those shoes.
- 47:28Hesham: They're being paid
- 47:29Nara: to show love those shoes. Right?
- 47:31Hesham: Yeah. Something simple like that. You know, like there's something in The UK, I that was that was, like, announced last year or beginning of last year that they're gonna use a software to detect which pictures are manipulated. You know, this is gonna work or not. I don't know.
- 47:48So every ad by, you know, somebody that's shown some plastic procedure that supposed to be the AI software can detect which one has been played with, changed, or manipulated, so on.
- 48:01Nara: I mean, it's the new frontier, isn't it? I think it's been an era. I mean, it'd be interesting to see how the AI, will affect things like, you know, cause we've got the, you know, the sinus surgery mapping, for example, you know, the brain lab that allows you to look on the screen and in three d reconstructs the sinus images. Hopefully that can get a bit better because that instrument, that hardware is quite clunky. Right?
- 48:24Hesham: And
- 48:24Nara: very, very expensive.
- 48:25Hesham: So actually AI is amazing. I actually do a lot of research with AI group at the Imperial College.
- 48:35Nara: Oh, yeah.
- 48:35Hesham: So we've already got AI to teach AI to read the CT scans of the sinuses.
- 48:42Nara: Alright. So
- 48:43Hesham: areas, not all of it. Yeah. So it's like a beginning. So we've done some research in that. But ultimately, the human being has to look and make sure because who's responsible for the mistakes of the AI?
- 48:53Yeah. So they have to check it, but it would just make it more efficient and quicker. So that's one thing. And we we're now getting the AI to read the inside of the nose, the measurements of the breathing, the size of the nasal cavity, and all that. So I think it will help us a lot in Yeah.
- 49:08In various things, but we can't just completely depend on AI. I think the future of because always gonna be somebody who was gonna be responsible for this. So AI making a mistake, it's a big, big thing. You can't
- 49:21Nara: just mean, on that note, what do you think? So so you started your career in in ENT and let's call it early nineties. Is that that fair?
- 49:31Hesham: Yeah. Early nineties. Yeah, exactly.
- 49:32Nara: Early nineties. Yes. So, so thirty five years in ENT. What do you think? This is a really hard question because I think it's very difficult to predict where we are.
- 49:40Where do you think ENT will be in thirty five years? So that will, you know, that will take us to, you know, thousand sixty, which is quite obviously.
- 49:48Hesham: Yeah, it's difficult to predict, but I can predict a few things actually.
- 49:51Nara: Okay.
- 49:52Hesham: I predict, yeah, that a lot of the sinus problems are going be treated with medicines, not with surgery.
- 49:58Nara: Okay.
- 49:58Hesham: Because, for example, like, now we have what we call the biologics that you inject them, they target the exact inflammation, which causes polyps, and the polyps can disappear, for example. So we do a lot of sinus surgery for polyps. Actually, two thirds of endoscopic sinus surgery in The UK done for polyps. The other one third is of sinus infections. Yeah.
- 50:19So that's imagine these two thirds can go away at some stage. So a lot of these sinus surgeries may just be gone or just less. So I think that will happen. Thirty five years probably definitely that a lot of these conditions are treated with medicines or injections and so on. So that's one area.
- 50:35I think there'll be some robots. Robotic surgery has advanced a lot in other areas outside ENT, outside the nose and sinus and so on because the robots, they're a bit more bulky, you can use them in the abdomen and so on and the neck and so on. And they have improved a lot of areas. We need to create which the research has gone on. There'll be robots that are small enough to go through the nose to remove the tumors in the in the brain tumors and so on.
- 51:04I think that will happen. So I think maybe there will be some of that. It's not gonna be done by AI. I think the surgeons still have to
- 51:11Nara: do it. Yeah. And actually, just on that note, when people think about robotic surgery, some people think that it's little robots robots that are doing it and it isn't. It's just that it's a human controlling it.
- 51:20Hesham: Exactly. It's a control. A human
- 51:21Nara: sitting on the side. Yeah. So go ahead. Yeah.
- 51:23Hesham: So the human is holding the instruments in a console that's here and that's connected to arms. The arms just mimic exactly precisely the the human movements. So when they're stitching, it moves like the stitching. When they're holding a forceps, it moves like that, and it's very precise. It transfers the movement.
- 51:44Interestingly, it doesn't transfer tremors. Yep. Yeah. So it just cancels the tremors of any surgeon. Everybody has a bit of tremor anyway, but any tremor just gone.
- 51:53So it's such a stable equipment. It's really amazing.
- 51:56Nara: There's still a human doing the operation.
- 51:58Hesham: Just Human not doing it. Yeah. It's not a robot. Yeah. So for a robot to operate on a human being, I think that would take a long time.
- 52:05It may happen, but I think that will take a very long time. So it's nothing like this. I don't think there's any even technology coming that way anyway. So I think that's where the area of my area that would be like the robotic surgery. There'll be a lot of areas that are gonna be treated with surgery anymore, like sinus problems.
- 52:24Cosmetic surgery may probably continue the same actually, unless it changes the genetics of everybody.
- 52:31Nara: Yeah. And then the AI obviously is a part, right?
- 52:34Hesham: I mean,
- 52:35Nara: right now in the dictations, it's very complex. Exactly.
- 52:40Hesham: Yeah, so a lot of the things that will save a lot of time. When you're seeing patients talking to them, AI is listening, which we already use now. AI is listening and writing everything you said, and so all the reports have been written by that, which is available. It's nothing. That would be like everybody would use that thing.
- 52:55So hopefully we'll save our time and not using the computer like we are now. It will be done for us. And AI will help us to read the CT scans, the x rays, the pathology, any specimen that we take from patients. That AI will help us read it. Will be quicker and efficient, run a lot of the tasks that we don't wanna do that are, you know, not dangerous or anything like that, are just like managerial things.
- 53:19Yes. So I think this will be a commonplace. Yeah.
- 53:21Nara: Yeah. And so as we sort of wrap up, I mean, you know, you've gone, I mean, I think this is an amazing, amazing journey and, and, and the fact that you're, you know, I won't give away how old you are, but essentially, you know, you're very, very senior, senior surgeon, profit Imperial, and you continue giving back. I don't think you'll ever stop teaching. I don't think you'll ever stop research. Don't I think you'll ever stop writing.
- 53:44And I think it's, you've got this, on sort of quenchable thirst and curiosity. That means you're always doing something and looking for the, for the next improvement. How do you want people to remember you? Cause how, what would you like your legacy be? You know, when you actually hang up the, you know, your loops, for a final time, what, what do you want people to remember you as what do you want your legacy to be?
- 54:09Hesham: I think your legacy is comes from the people you taught, basically. So I think I want people to remember me. I just that I I wanted to teach. I wanted to improve all the time. I actually we're talking about this yesterday.
- 54:26I created a logo for the fellows, and I was thinking, what's my motto? So I said, always learning, forever humble. Yeah? So I put that in the back. So I want people to remember to me that I want that.
- 54:39That's an important thing. I just wanna develop. And I think curiosity you're talking about is really important. Always be curious and just keep improving. Yeah.
- 54:47So I want people to remember me that I was that. I just wanted to get better all the time, but I have to stay humble because that's how you learn. You always wanna be better. I think that's it.
- 55:00Nara: That, you know, that that that really is amazing. I mean, I think the, you know, the the that endless ability to learn and that, constant, I think humility, because, you know, it's, it's very, it's very inspiring to hear that from someone like yourself who essentially is at the, you know, at the top of it, you know, there's no, there's not many people that can teach you anything, but you're teaching yourself you're looking. So, so thank you, Hashem. And thank you personally, because you certainly are that teacher and mentor to me amongst many, many others. Thank
- 55:33Hesham: you.